010720 COUNCIL MINUTES
City of Darlington · Darlington County · meeting of May 6, 2020 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Darlington
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
CITY OF DARLINGTON
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING AT 6:30 PM
TUESDAY –JANUARY 7, 2020
PRESENT AT MEETING:
Mayor-Elect Curtis Boyd, Councilpersons: John Segars, Sheila Baccus,
Bryant Gardner, Elaine Reed, Councilman Howard Nettles and John
Milling. Also, present: City Manager, Mr. Howard Garland, Mrs. Lisa
Rock, City Attorney Kevin Etheridge, Building Official Alex Gainey, W&S
Superintendent Mr. Kinsaul, Fire Chief Pat Cavanaugh, Police Chief Kelvin
Washington, Ms. Karen Carroll, Ms. Jonna Carter, Mr. Todd Hardee, Mr.
Steve Abbott, Mr. Linwood Epps, Mrs. Betty Jackson, Ms. Harriett Hobbs,
Mr. A.D. Jordan, Mr. Danny Watson, Mrs. Rosena James, Ms. Jannie
Lathan, Mr. Bill Hancock with The Brittingham Group, Mrs. Andrea Knapp,
Ms. Antoinette Muldrow, Ms. Wanda Wingate, Mrs. Anna DeWitt, Ms.
Gloria Hines, Ms. Ronda Brown, Mr. Roosevelt Scott, Mr. Ernest Boston,
Mrs. Linda Brunson, Ms. Carolyn Bruce, Ms. Jamie Steen, Ms. Gladys
Jules, Mr. Brantley Jett, and other visitors.
NEWS REPORTERS
Also present was Mr. Bobby Bryant, News Reporter from the News & Press.
ADMINISTATION OF OATH OF OFFICE FOR MAYOR & CITY
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Coroner Mr. Todd Hardee welcomed everyone to the first City Council
meeting of 2020. Mr. Hardee said he thought it would be appropriate if we
took just a moment and spoke about the seat, he is sitting in tonight which
was occupied by our friend Daniel B. Causey, III. Mr. Hardee said Judge
Causey went to be with the Lord on Sunday and he served our community
for three decades. He said he was a pillar to this community, and he served
this bench with the utmost professionalism and he was a mountain of a man.
Mr. Hardee offered his congratulations to Mayor Elect Curtis Boyd and
Councilman Elect Howard Nettles. He also thanked those who continue to
serve on council-Councilpersons, Sheila Baccus, Elaine Reed, Bryant
Gardner, John Milling and John Segars. Mr. Hardee extended his profound
appreciation to his friend Carolyn Bruce for her many years of distinguished
service to our town and also to his friend Gloria Hines for her hard work,
never ending drive, her persistence, her guidance and most of all her
2
friendship. Mr. Hardee said, “You have been a great advocate for
Darlington on many levels and a pioneer on many more”. “You will go
down in history as not only the first woman to serve as our Mayor and not
only the first person of color to serve as our Mayor, but as a leader and the
rebuilding and the transformation of a little southern town and birthing it
into a new day”. Mr. Hardee said before you can actually see your future,
you really need to know a little about your past. He said before he
administer the Oath of Office to the new Mayor, but before he does he
would like to read the names of those persons that have served before him:
Starting in 1836, Edgar W. Charles, Dr. T.J.K. Dargan, Dr. Theodore
Dargan, Moses Andrew Huggins, A.C. Spain, E.K. Dargan, John Gregg
McCall, John Floyd, Hiram Himes, George W. Dargan, John Jay Ward,
Berriman W. Edward, John Woods, James Carter Wilcox, M.D., William F.
Dargan, W.M. Haynesworth, George E. Dargan, Charles S. McCullough,
C.B. Edwards, Edward Colgate Dennis, Edwin Cox, J. Alexander McLeod,
Edwin Fountain, G.H. Brown, Dr. O.H. Alexander, Dr. G.B. Edwards,
Claude Vaughan, Fred B. Stem, Cecil E. Harper, Tom Buchanan, John Jay
Ward, Mr. Frank Wells, Albert P. Coggeshall, J. Ronald Ward, Tony
Watkins, and Ms. Gloria Hines. Mr. Todd Hardee administered the Oath of
Office to Mayor-Elect Curtis Boyd and to newly elected Councilman-Mr.
Howard Nettles. Mr. Hardee then administered the Oath of Office to
Councilman Bryant Gardner and Councilman John Milling.
ELECTION OF MAYOR PRO-TEM
Councilwoman Elaine Reed made a motion to nominate Councilman
John Segars for Mayor Pro-Tem. Councilman John Milling seconded
the motion. Councilpersons Bryant Gardner, Sheila Baccus, Howard
Nettles, Elaine Reed, John Milling, John Segars and Mayor Curtis Boyd
approved the motion.
INVOCATION & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Mayor Boyd said, “I do things a little different, so I asked that at each City
Council meeting we have a Pastor to come pray for us and tonight he asked
Pastor Kyle Myers to pray for us and then we will have the Pledge of
Allegiance”.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Upon motion of Councilman Bryant Gardner, Seconded by
Councilwoman Elaine Reed to approve the minutes of the December 3,
3
2019 Council Meeting. Mayor Boyd and Councilpersons Gardner,
Nettles, Baccus, Reed, Milling and Segars voted in favor of the motion.
APPROVAL OF MEETING AGENDA
Councilwoman Elaine Reed made a motion to approve the meeting
agenda, which was seconded by Councilman Bryant Gardner.
Councilpersons John Segars, John Millings, Elaine Reed, Howard
Nettles, Sheila Baccus, Bryant Gardner and Mayor Curtis Boyd voted
in favor of the motion.
REPORT OF STANDING COMMITTEES
A) DARLINGTON DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION
ASSOCIATION – MRS. LISA ROCK
Mrs. Rock said the DDRA Board has selected its new Leadership Team for
2020. Mr. Pete Dennis will serve as President and Mrs. Nancy Matthews
will serve as Vice-President. Mrs. Rock said they had a successful “Shop
Darlington Contest” during the holiday with more than $12,000 being spent
in connection with the contest. (This only includes those people that sent in
receipts) She said the three winners will be announced later this week and
they will appear in the News & Press. Mrs. Rock said they welcome people
to be members of DDRA; businesses, individuals, civic groups and churches
are invited to join as members by calling her at (843) 992-1561 or send an
email to info@buildupdarlington.org. She said they can feature their news,
employee recognitions, sales, new products, special hours and events for
people interested in Darlington as well as TV stations, radio stations and
newspapers through their text/email news alert system. Mrs. Rock said this
year they are offering a special member referral bonus for all new paid
memberships for 2020 the member who referred them will get a ticket to the
“2020 Taste of Darlington” and the member with the most referrals will get
a packet of tickets to the Southern 500 Race. She said another benefit of the
DDRA comes each month with a breakfast invitation for businesses to
network and learn about the DDRA programs and give feedback for future
projects at their monthly members breakfast at 8:00 AM on the last
Wednesday of the month at Takis Diner. Breakfast is provided for Members
Businesses at no charge; nonmembers are welcome to attend for a nominal
donation of $5.00 per person. The DDRA will be presenting an award
chosen by its members at the Chamber Annual Banquet. Wednesday April
8, 2020 will be the DDRA Annual Golf Tournament at Darlington Country
Club; Thursday April 23, 2020 will be the “Taste of Darlington at
4
Darlington Raceway. A new event they will be adding this year will be a
“Food Truck Festival at Darlington Raceway on Saturday June 6, 2020.
B) GREATER DARLINGTON CHAMBER OF COMMERCE – MS.
HARRIETT HOBBS
Ms. Hobbs said the Greater Darlington Chamber of Commerce is still taking
nominations for its annual award presentations in the following categories:
Lifetime Achievement, Citizen of the Year, Community Pride, Educator of
the Year, Business of the Year & Legacy Award. Ms. Hobbs said they will
be accepting nominations until January 15th, with the Awards Banquet being
held on Thursday February 6, 2020 at the Darlington Country Club. Ms.
Hobbs said this year they will not have the traditional sit-down dinner but
rather a party-type atmosphere with heavy hors d’oeuvres, a sangria type
punch will be available as well as tea, coffee and a cash bar. Ms. Hobbs said
they are asking everyone to don their best jeans and sweater. She said ladies
can put on a strand of pearls. She said they are going to celebrate the 2020
with what Darlington has done in the past and what they look forward to in
the future. Ms. Hobbs said they will network, talk with friends, mingle and
then they will have their awards presentations, so this will not be the
traditional banquet. Ms. Hobbs said they have a Ribbon Cutting coming up
on January 30th at the Healing Place. They are planning the dates for two
other Ribbon Cuttings coming up in February. The Chamber has five new
members in the month of January. She said a new business contacted her
yesterday with plans to come to Darlington and they want to join the
Chamber and they will also be looking for an office space.
CITIZENS WISHING TO SPEAK BEFORE COUNCIL (5 MINUTES
PER PERSON
Mr. Linwood Epps said he has two things he wants to talk about. First,
there are red cones that sits on Camelia Court. He said, “Why don’t you all
pull that line from one end, which is a cul-de-sac all the way down to Blue
Street and fix those water lines”? He said, “you patch them all the time, why
don’t you fix them”? He said the second thing is the Recreation
Department. He said, “I’ve sat in here and heard you all discuss ballfield,
ballfield, ballfield”. He said, “You buy land, you sell land”. He said, “I
don’t even know who you sold it to; who did you sell it to”? Mr. Epps said,
“And now you’ve got it on the agenda for tonight. When are you going to
tell us something? Tell us what you’re doing; tell us that we’re getting ready
to buy land at 109 Camelia Court. Why is that a secret where you going to
buy land and then when you get ready to sell it, why don’t you tell us”? Mr.
5
Epps asked that Council keep them informed of what’s going on because
there’s a lot of them that want to see Darlington do good. Mr. Epps said,
“There’s a lot of us old people that don’t have too much to do that don’t
mind getting involved, if you’ll let us know”. Mr. Epps said, “Tell us what
you’re doing about the ballfields. I’ve heard this for umpteen years, that
we’re going to do something about the ballfields; you haven’t done nothing
yet”?
Mrs. Diane Pruitt said she her husband Scott Pruitt own the home at 368
W. Broad Street in the historic district. She said they have been working for
a couple of years now on the renovation and restoration of the home to the
best of their ability. To the best of what the architecture and the
neighborhood and history of that home requires. Mrs. Pruitt said she
appreciate greatly for the last time that I spoke before Council, and Mayor
Hines, thank you with the deepest of respect for addressing issues of the
water drains. It took one week to resolve the issues on W. Broad Street &
Edwards Street. we haven’t had any flooding issues since and I thank you all
sincerely for addressing that problem. She said she is here tonight to speak
on the Historic District. Mrs. Pruitt said she is proud that they are working
on the home because this is a very important pillar of the community built in
1890 by Lawrence Reese. She said one of the things she has a concern
about is the inconsistency in renovations in the new construction in the area,
the rules and regulations and the ordinances that are on the books and where
the guidelines are specifically and who is to maintain the adherence to the
ordinances when there is new construction or when there is renovations to an
existing structure. Mrs. Pruitt said we have a beautiful opportunity in front
of us with the growth of this City and I would love to see this entire area
grow as it was structed originally. She said I would love to see the integrity
of the Historic District on W. Broad Street maintained. She said she has
some concerns about where the integrity in the City in the maintenance of
those guidelines lie. She said she knows we have a Historic Landmark
Commission and she knows we have ordinances on the books. Mrs. Pruitt
said historic home has propositions for renovations. When there’s new
construction there’s guidelines for that as well, but I’m afraid that
somewhere down the line that’s gone by the wayside. She said, “I’m afraid
that our Zoning and Planning Office is a little overwhelmed and burdened
with the majority of the decisions that needs to be made”. She said I think
it’s being passed forward to them and at some point, the ball is being
dropped and our historic district does not have the integrity that the
ordinance has required. Mrs. Pruitt asked Council today and going forward
6
to please take a look at the ordinances regarding the historic preservation of
W. Broad Street district. She said you did an outstanding job of making sure
that the flooding stopped so that we have the opportunity to restore these
homes without further damage. Mrs. Pruitt asked Mayor & Council again to
please review that and make a decision about how they are going to move
forward from today into the future, not only in the W. Broad Street historic
but in the City of Darlington as a whole.
Ms. Jamie Steen, Executive Director for the Housing Authority said on the
agenda tonight Council is going to be discussing a playground that’s going
to be very near to their property at Bowen Manor. Ms. Steen said she
wanted to let them know that they have fifty-five kids under the age of 12 at
Bowen Manor. She said the closest playground to them is their main office
which is across Main Street. She said they have two playgrounds in that are
but none on the other side of town. Ms. Steen said as the Housing Authority
Executive Director she is willing to help the City by providing security
cameras that the police will have access to so that it will be a secure area.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
None
NEW BUSINESS
A) 2018-2019 – AUDIT PRESENTATION – THE BRITTINGHAM
GROUP – MR. BILL HANCOCK
Mr. Hancock said his firm was engaged to audit the books of the City of
Darlington for 2018-2019 …Mr. Hancock said probably the number one
thing that every municipality looks for is, what’s the opinion. He said the
City received an unmodified also known as an “unqualified” or clean
opinion for the year which is good. Mr. Hancock said this letter is also an
opinion from your independent audit where they comment on the City’s
compliance on grants, agreements, contracts and other things that are legally
binding to the City. They also comment and offer opinions on our structure
and internal controls. Mr. Hancock said when they tested to see if the City
made their payroll tax deposits on time and for the right amount, they didn’t
find any errors. When they tested the municipal court system to see if fines
had been calculated correctly and sent to the State Treasurer for the right
amount, they didn’t find any errors. When they tested the water & sewer
bills that go out, they didn’t find any errors in the calculation, billing, receipt
or recording of those funds. Mr. Hancock said this was the second year of
7
their agreement with the City for their audit services and now that he has
two years of information readily available, he wanted to bring their attention
to a few things; mainly the general fund and the water & sewer fund. He
said on page 6 of the audit, looking at the cash and cash equivalent in the
general fund in the amount of $2,377,000, that amount is down about
$325,000 from last fiscal year. Mr. Hancock said that’s neither good nor
bad, but it’s information for the governing body to have and then discuss
with management at a time it deems appropriate. Mr. Hancock then went to
page 10 and went over the budget to actual for the general fund. He said the
deficit of revenues under expenditures was $293,000 this year. He said it is
no big deal, and this is for information, but it is worthy to note that 2018 had
a budget deficit of $221,000 so when you couple those you’ve had a budget
deficit of a half million dollars in the general fund in the past two years. Mr.
Hancock said, “What does that mean”? He said that means ask questions,
give directives, have management figure out solutions if there’s something
you want to change. He told Council they have the financial information
available to them now so going into your upcoming budget you can do
something about this. He told Council they haven’t always had this
information upfront in a timely manner. On page 11 under cash & cash
equivalent in the water and sewer fund it shows we have $1,001,000. This
time the year before we had $1,400,000 which is a $235,000 in cash in the
water & sewer department. Mr. Hancock said, “There’s no good or bad in
that it’s just information for this body”. He then went on to page 12 and
drew their attention to the line “Loss before capital contributions and
transfers”. He said this is the income statement for our water & sewer fund
and stormwater fund. These are supported by user fees. He said the page
shows the operating service revenues less your operating service expenses
and you take from that your interest expense on the outstanding debt which
is basically what you need to run your system. The water & sewer fund
showed a loss of $410,000 and the stormwater fund showed a loss before
capital contributions and transfers, so for the year that’s a $430,000 loss in
those user fee revenue generated funds. Mr. Hancock said it’s not a big deal,
just for information but let’s put it in context and compare that and add it to
the numbers we had for last year. He said last year’s number was a
$505,000 loss in water and sewer and $122,000 loss in stormwater which is
a combined $628,000 loss for those two enterprises which means if you
combine these two funds for the two years, it showed $1,058,000 loss. Mr.
Hancock said, “What does that mean”? “Is that bad and if it is what do you
want to do about it”? Mr. Hancock said he would encourage the City to
engage to do a Rate Study. He said there are several organizations in the
8
Southeast that do these, and we will be able to compare what our rates are
for water, sewer, for solid waste pickup in the Pee Dee Region as well as
municipalities close by. Mr. Hancock said the City needs to know whether
we are charging enough or if we are charging too much. Just so we know
are expenses are in line with what our peers are; are they too much or are
they not enough. He said the only way we can make decision is to get the
information. Mayor Boyd asked, “Over the two-year period there’s over
$1,058,000 loss, if that what you’re saying”? Mr. Hancock said, “Yes”.
Mayor Boyd said, “It could be that there were more expenses this year or
those two years or it could be that we didn’t raise our rates enough; it could
be a number of factors”? Mr. Hancock said most likely it’s a combination.
Mr. Hancock then went over pages 34-38 which covered long-term debt for
the general fund and water and sewer fund. Mr. Hancock said something
happened this year that had never happened before, so he had them turn to
page 43 of the audit. He said page 43 is a detailed schedule where they
compile and report court fines, fees & assessments and surcharges involved
with criminal tickets that have been written and processed through the
municipal court. He said the State Treasurer’s Office is always on the
lookout for what they consider to be their share of those fines. He said one
item in particular is the amount that’s segregated out for victim’s assistance.
He said the amount that’s levied for fines and fees for victim’s assistance has
very narrow uses and the City of Darlington has done a really good job of
getting those funds and putting them to the narrow uses that they are allowed
for. Mr. Hancock said this statement may not affect us because we are doing
a good job of managing victim’s funds, but he has another client that has
been accumulating funds on a larger scale for several years and the money
was sitting in the bank account and they had not used the funds for any
victim’s assistance purposes. He said the State Office of Victim’s Advocacy
came and took the money from the City because they had not spent it. Mr.
Hancock said if you collect it, you have to spend it, if not they will make
you forfeit it. He said he is not worried about that with the City of
Darlington because Chief seems to be on top of this. Mr. Hancock asked
Council if they had questions. Mayor Boyd asked Mr. Hancock if he’s
available for sit-down time? Mr. Hancock said he’s available for sit-down
time and he can be reached by phone. Mr. Garland told council they needed
to vote to accept the audit. Councilman Milling made a motion to accept the
2018-2019 audit presentation that Mr. Hancock has given on behalf of the
Brittingham Group. Councilman Howard Nettles seconded the motion.
Councilpersons Bryant Gardner, Sheila Baccus, Howard Nettles, Elaine
9
Reed, John Milling, John Segars and Mayor Boyd all voted in favor of
the motion.
B) APPROVAL 2020 CITY COUNCIL MEETING SCHEDULE
Councilwoman Elaine Reed made a motion to approve the 2020 City
Council Meeting schedule. Councilman Bryant Gardner seconded the
motion. Councilman Howard Nettles seconded the motion.
Councilpersons Bryant Gardner, Sheila Baccus, Howard Nettles, Elaine
Reed, John Milling, John Segars and Mayor Boyd all voted in favor of
the motion.
C) PLAYGROUND EQUIPMENT LOAN FOR BOWEN MANOR
Mr. Lee Andrews said this is the loan they talked about in December to fund
the playground at Bowen Manor for $41,162.83. The loan is coming from
Pee Dee Electric through their outreach program. The City will pay it back
at 1%. Mr. Andrews said we had to order the equipment before the end of
last year in order to get the pricing that we got which was about 50% off.
He said the equipment is here already and they are just waiting on the person
to come and install it. Councilman Milling said the note form does not set a
particular payment schedule. Mr. Andrews said Mr. Garland has the
payment schedule and he thinks that payment is around $507.00 for seven
years. Councilman Milling wanted to know how the payment has been
amortized out. Mr. Garland said the 1% charge is on top of each monthly
payment so they way it’s going to break out is we’ll take it out of the
“athletic equipment” line item and it will come out of the regular budget.
Mayor Boyd asked would this be split between the rec department and
another department? Mr. Garland said, as of right now, it’s just the
recreation department for the rest of this budget year, but then when we get
to the new budget year, we can split it. Councilman Milling asked if we
have the $507 and Mr. Andrews said he thinks they can swing it for the rest
of the budget cycle. Councilman Milling said this will be the same amount
until the year 2026. Councilman Reed said, “But he was saying you’ve got
enough money just to go to June of this year and from there, how would you
pay for it”? Mr. Andrews said he would have to cut some things in his
budget to make it work for the next six years. Councilwoman Reed said,
“Because of our earlier conversation, can we just clear up the reason that
we’re doing this because we thought all this kind of stuff could be done
through our hospitality”. Mr. Andrews said, “We sold the property that we
bought for the ballfields out there. He said, it’s kind of landlocked that
ballfield where it is and there’s no clear path to get it involved with
10
Hampton Street unless we went way around. Councilwoman Baccus said,
“when you say, “Way around” what do you mean”? “Are you saying you
can’t tie it into the trail”? She said I don’t agree with that. I can’t understand
why you can’t tie it in with the trail, but you’re saying it’s more feasible to
do it this way”? Mr. Andrews said, “Yes ma’am”. Councilman Milling said
this eliminates any question of whether or not it’s the proper use. Mr.
Andrews said, “If we can afford it, it’s a 1% loan and it’s basically costing
us about $450 for the loan and instead of taking a chance of paying $41,000
back because it was illegal, and we pay it out of this budget, we don’t have
to worry about it and we get a playground out there”. Mr. Andrews said it’s
sitting at the rec department right now waiting to be installed. Mayor Boyd
asked, “When do you expect for it to be installed”? Mr. Andrews said, “As
soon as the installer is done where he is, he is coming to Darlington to put
the playground equipment up”. Councilwoman Elaine Reed made a
motion to approve the playground equipment for Bowen Manor.
Councilwoman Baccus seconded the motion. Councilpersons Bryant
Gardner, Sheila Baccus, Howard Nettles, Elaine Reed, John Milling,
John Segars and Mayor Boyd all voted in favor of the motion.
Councilman John Milling said, “We had approved benches, tables,
etc…..Before he finished, Mr. Andrews said, “I’m glad you asked about
that”. He said they are going to start the install for Terrence Carraway on
tomorrow and four benches will be put there, and two picnic tables will be
put together. Hopefully, weather permitting they will get to the other park,
if not this week hopefully by midweek next week. Councilwoman Baccus
asked if there were four benches and tables at that park. Mr. Andrews said
four benches, two tables. Councilwoman Baccus wanted to know when the
one table and two benches would be installed at the pool? Mr. Andrews said
they are going to wait until the pool opens back up before they put them
back out.
D) HVAC BIDS FOR BALDWIN GYM & STANLEY GYM
Mr. Andrews said they have been a moisture issue at A.W. Stanley
whenever it is humid outside and it’s twice as humid inside and the floor
gets slick so it’s a safety issue as well. Mr. Andrews said they had someone
from Kentco come in a take a look and they determined it was a HVAC
issue. He said it’s just not pushing enough over there right now with the
couple of units they have. While that was going on, they lost one unit
completely at the Harmon Baldwin Center. The case for the motor cracked
and went everywhere. The unit on one end is working; the unit above the
door at the office is making an awful noise. He said they took parts off the
11
unit that went completely out and fixed the two units for the time being, so
they are in dire need of HVAC units at both places. Councilman Segars
asked how old the units at Stanley Gym are. Mr. Andrews and Mr. Garland
said they are ten years old and these were residential units that were put in.
Mayor Curtis Boyd said, “So you have four units at one location and five at
another location” and Mr. Andrews said, “Yes”. He asked did they give a
warranty for any period of time? Mr. Garland said it’s 10-year warranty that
they give on the compressor and the main parts and another five-year
warranty on labor. Councilwoman Reed said, “But you’re making a point
that these are residential even though we have a warranty and it’s ten years”.
Mr. Andrews said the ones we are getting are not residential. Mayor Curtis
Boyd said, “I’m not one to put things on hold, but aren’t we required to get
three bids”? Mr. Andrews said this was the contractor that we got to come
in to show us what the problem was, and this is the pricing that he gave, and
he would be glad to go out and get two more bids to bring back to them.
Mayor Boyd said, “But aren’t we required to have three bids”? Mr.
Andrews said, “Yes”. Councilman Bryant Gardner made a motion to
approve going after two more bids for the HVAC bids for Baldwin Gym
and Stanley Gym. Councilwoman Elaine Reed seconded the motion.
Councilman Milling asked Mr. Andrews if he has specifications that
everybody’s bidding on, they’re know that they’re going to have “apples
and apples”. Mr. Andrews said he has this information available for the
new bidders. Councilman Milling told Mr. Andrews to let Kentco know that
we are not divulging their information. Councilpersons Bryant Gardner,
Sheila Baccus, Howard Nettles, Elaine Reed, John Milling, John Segars
and Mayor Boyd all voted in favor of the motion.
E) NEW FLOOR BIDS FOR BALDWIN GYM & STANLEY GYM
Mr. Andrews said the flooring at A.W. Stanley was installed ten years ago
and it has been well used. He said the flooring at Harmon Baldwin Gym is
twenty-five years old. He said there are dead spots on the floor. They have
tried to do pickleball at both gyms but are unable to because they ball won’t
bounce. Mr. Andrews said they got a quote for flooring and for both gyms
with a 20-year warranty for approximately $125,000. He said they also want
to buy wall pads to put in both gyms to make it safer and a volleyball
expansion so they can start playing volleyball inside the gym at A.W.
Stanley. Also included in this bid is a floor cleaner which is what they are
supposed to be using on both floors now. He said it’s what you see at Sam’s
Club. He said this is not one that you ride on top of, this is one that you
walk behind and it’s specifically for these types of sports floors. Mr.
12
Andrews said even if we don’t get the new floors, he would suggest that we
buy a floor cleaner for the gyms so they can take care of what they have a lot
better than what they are doing. Councilman Segars asked if this type floor
would be serviced better than a wood floor. Mr. Andrews said, “Yes,
because on a wood floor you have to wear certain shoes and if they have a
dance, they would have to buy a cover for both floors to make sure they are
not damaging it. Councilman Milling said, “There’s certain exclusions that
does not include trimming doors, does not include major floor prep, leveling,
cleaning, etc. Mr. Andrews said floors don’t need doors right now. He said
the foyer at A.W. Stanley might need attention when they do the floor
because there is about a six-inch step down there. He said they can do a
ramp down into the foyer to make it safer or if they just include coming on
out with something else to make it even. Mayor Boyd asked if they have
one anywhere else that they can look at. Mr. Andrews said this is the one
they just put down in Wilmington, NC, but he has some pictures. He said
they are out of Charlotte but he’s sure he’ll be glad to let them know. Mr.
Andrews said they can take a road trip and go look at some floors. Mayor
Boyd asked if $5,600 is for the cleaner package to be able to clean the floors.
Mr. Andrews said, “Yes”. Mr. Andrews said they would have to go out and
find somebody else, but he was told to get prices. He said if they are going
to bid it out, he would like a chance to bid it out and see if there’s something
competitive. Mr. Garland asked what the useful life of the current gym
floors? Mr. Andrews said, “The Baldwin Gym is at the end of it’s life
cycle”. The Stanley Gym floor still plays good, it just doesn’t’ look as good
as it should and it’s from wear and tear. He said he would hate to do one
and not do the other so they can have everything for the next twenty-five
years in great working condition. Councilman Milling asked if they have the
funding to do this? Mr. Andrews said they have the funding, but he doesn’t
know if they would want to use the funding that he’s thinking about. It
would definitely fall under the hospitality tax with the Mayo Alumni using
the gyms, basketball teams from all over play there. Councilman Milling
made a motion to authorize Mr. Andrews on behalf of the recreation
department to get bids for the new floors at the Baldwin Gym and at the
Stanley Gym. Councilwoman Elaine Reed seconded the motion.
Councilpersons Bryant Gardner, Sheila Baccus, Howard Nettles, Elaine
Reed, John Milling, John Segars and Mayor Boyd all voted in favor of
the motion.
F) DARLINGTON MULTI-USE TRAIL MAP
13
Mayor Boyd said Councilman Gardner asked him two and a half years ago if
he would be interested in helping him with a trail. Two and a half years
later, they have it on the agenda. Mayor Boyd said Florence has a trail,
Hartsville is working on a trail and to make sure everybody is clear that we
need to get rid of the “cone City” and we need to fix our drains and repair
our streets, and to bring businesses in we need to show that we can progress
forth. He said in government there’s certain money in certain pockets that
you can only use for certain things. Mayor Boyd said, “I’m here because of
this trail and I’m Mayor because of this trail”. He said when you have a
video to show what you are looking to try to do and then be able to walk the
area and see a 1,400 -1,500-foot section, which is what they are asking for
today to start the trail. Mayor Boyd said they have the funds to do and they
have the funds to start it. He said Councilman Gardner has been asking for
this for over four years and it’s on the schedule today to see if we can get it
started. Mayor Boyd said he was going to show a 5-minute long video
which was recorded by drone. He said parts of it you can’t get to and they
don’t have 100% permission on every little spot yet, but that’s what they are
working on. He said they have permissions for all of it but one section. This
is approximately a 3-mile loop that would take us through town and that
would be Phase 1 once they get it all done. He said that’s not what they are
asking for right now, just a small section of Phase one. Phase 1 will go
through town and it’s going to be partly on the sidewalk, partly through the
woods, it will be cleaned up and carried around the town and once that’s
done, they will actually be able to spread out and it will be able to take you
out past the Racetrack all the way over toward Walmart; toward Bowens
Manor, toward that direction if we can finally get some easements there.
Mayor Boyd said they don’t have easements or 100% sure they can go that
direction, but they are looking to see how many different directions they can
take it out. He said the trails need to be connected to the playgrounds. As
they go out, they will try to add more playgrounds, more activities, and more
things for people to do so the residents will want to stay and want to come
and live in our city. Mayor Boyd showed a video and was explaining areas
as he went along. They are asking permission to start in the area on Cashua
Street near Dedicated Community Bank to the old railroad bed which goes
behind the Voter Registration office; going on behind the historical society
on to the library which is where it would stop. He said parts of it goes over
to Bristow property, then cut through the woods to Spring Street to
Williamson Park (this part of the trail is already done); come out to the left
of the newly renovated apartments on Cashua Street, cut through the woods
and come up behind Diamond Hill Plywood cutting through their property
14
on the left and this will take you to the City’s property where the railroad
bed is which cuts back and takes you back to Hampton Street Park. Mayor
Boyd asked Councilman Gardner if he wanted to tell Council anything.
Councilman Gardner said, “That covered it all”. He said, “Council today
just wanted them to test the trail from Hampton Street to Fountain Street and
the technical end of the property line which is directly butting up to the
library and that’s all this bid for today is just to do that one section”. He said
they are asking for a 10-foot-wide path that will be packed with crush and
run and will pave it in the future if we get the rail trail grants and the other
grants to help fund it. Mayor Boyd said they got two proposals, but one
added extra stuff to it which they didn’t really care for. Councilwoman
Baccus asked, “So the video that you just showed, this trail is only going to
run that area and that’s the entire trail”? Councilman Gardner said, “The
video that you just saw would be the first phase, but “No, that’s not the
entire trail”. Councilwoman Baccus asked Councilman Gardner, “So how
long are you estimating that first phase of the trail is going to take and how
long to get it fixed and the cost”? Councilman Gardner said, I don’t have a
cost or time estimate because I haven’t gotten permission from Council to go
forward with it, so I wouldn’t have those answers”. He said they have three
property owners that they’ve got to get permission from but everybody else
has said they are ok with it. Councilman Gardner said, “We would have to
get the properties surveyed and an actual trail line laid out”. Councilwoman
Baccus said, “So the area that you just showed on this video showed this
trail running strictly through North Darlington. Why there is nothing in
South Darlington included in this million-dollar trail”? Mayor Boyd said,
“This is the first phase that connects it to Hampton Street Park. The trail
that we’re asking for at this moment is approximately 1,400 feet and will
cost approximately $10,000. He said a lot of this trail that we just showed
you is already done because it connects to Williamson Park. He said that’s
the three-mile loop, but they are not asking to do the whole trail at this
moment. To start with they want to show people what they are planning on
doing. Their ultimate goal is to try and figure out a way to get it all the way
to Bowen Manor, all the way to Walmart, back down Smith Avenue; back
over to the other side if the Race Track down by May Flower where the trail
would actually connect the hometown. Mayor Boyd said Phase 1 is only
1,400 feet. He said once they get that, they will be working on getting a
grant, so we don’t have to spend money out of hospitality tax funds. If we
have to spend money out hospitality tax funds, but if we have to spend
hospitality tax funds then we can try to get this phase done and start working
on the next phase and get other companies to start helping us with trying to
15
progress it out into the whole town. Mr. John Gardner spoke out and said, I
want to point out one thing. Back when I was on the Highway Commission
thirty-five years ago, they used highway safety funds to put in the sidewalk
from the top of Cashua out to the Country Club”. He said it is used by the
entire community. Mr. Gardner said that 1,400 feet connects to probably ten
miles of sidewalk going through the entire town. He said people like to walk
and walk a long distance. That one section connects to so many miles of
already done sidewalk. Mayor Boyd said, “And the purpose of starting here,
his understanding was, there’s an actual railroad bed there so they are trying
to start to the bed and be able to move out”. Ms. Jannie Lathan spoke from
the audience and asked, “Isn’t there a public hearing required for a project
like this”? Mayor Boyd said, “No ma’am”. Ms. Lathan said, “I think so”.
Ms. Lathan then asked, “Have we gotten three bids that’s required”? Mayor
Boyd said, “We’ve gotten two bids so far”. Ms. Lathan asked if we were
going to get three and Mayor Boyd said, “yes ma’am”. Ms. Glady Jules
spoke from the audience and asked, “So this is an open forum meeting”?
She said, “This is not being conducted like regular city council meeting, you
just raise your hand and talk”? Mayor Boyd said, “Until I get too many, yes
ma’am”. He said if you have a question, I’ll be glad to take it.
Councilwoman Baccus said, I’m going to say this and I’m going to leave it
alone until I see a showing of where this trail is going to go through S.
Darlington because if we’re spending millions of dollars of taxpayers money
and grants that we have to match and whatever the case may be, then it
should affect all citizens and it should go somewhere through S. Darlington.
Councilman Gardner said, “Half of the circle in the first phase is all in your
district”. He said, “We’ve got a couple of other lines going through your
district and if you’d like to help us out with the African American Cemetery
beside the city property, they can access S. Darlington”. Councilwoman
Baccus said the diagram showed Diamond Hill and they were five feet from
Bowen Manor. Mayor Boyd said that was phase 1 and that he and
Councilman Gardner drove to Bowen Manor to figure out a way to get to the
property. Councilwoman Baccus said it will be 10 or 15 years…Mayor
Boyd interjected and said, “No ma’am. In the old process, yes ma’am.
Councilman Bryant Gardner made a motion to approve 1,400 feet, and the
$10,000 bid for the trail. Mayor Boyd said we will get a third bid before we
do anything. Councilman Milling said, “I guess what we would be
approving at this time would be a third bid for the 1,400 feet”. Councilman
Bryant Gardner amended his motion to approve a third bid for the
Darlington Multi-Use Trail map for the 1,400-foot trail. Councilman
Milling seconded the motion. Councilpersons Bryant Gardner, Sheila
16
Baccus, Howard Nettles, Elaine Reed, John Milling, John Segars and
Mayor Boyd all voted in favor of the motion.
DISCUSSION OF CITY ADMINISTRATION BUILDING USE AS
GREATER DARLINGTON CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
HEADQUARTERS (HOSPITALITY FUNDS
Mrs. Anna Dewitt said they were approached by the City for the Chamber of
Commerce about a proposal to relocate into the white house where Mr.
Garland’s office is in order to open up space on the Square for new
businesses. Mrs. Dewitt said she thinks the City’s thought process is, if the
Chamber moves into the white house, then they will be able to use
hospitality tax funds to fix the white house. She said the Chamber is not
doing a formal statement because they have not gotten anything in writing
from the City. She said Mr. Garland and Mayor Boyd would have to make
the proposal to the Chamber. Mayor Boyd told Mrs. Dewitt from their
meeting the other day, you and Nancy were going to discuss with the Board
if they were willing to do this and bring it to Council. Mrs. Dewitt said they
will entertain a proposal in writing from the City. Mayor Boyd asked
Council if they had any discussion on this. Councilman Milling asked, “Do
we have anything to discuss at this point and time”? Councilman Milling
said, they’ve got to have Council as a meeting, get some proposal sent to
us”. Mrs. Dewitt said, “They, as the Chamber cannot do anything until they
are given something in writing from the City”. Councilwoman Reed asked,
“But is this something the Chamber want”? Mrs. Dewitt said, “No ma’am.
This is something that we were approached by the City, by Mr. Garland.
Councilwoman Reed said, “See, we didn’t know anything about that”. Ms.
Harriett Hobbs spoke up and said she can comment on this. Ms. Hobbs said
the Executive Committee met with her this week and apparently Anna,
Mayor Boyd, Howard Garland and Nancy Matthews met earlier this week
and have come up with a proposal to use hospitality funds to move the
Chamber of Commerce into the Admin Building. She said the executive
committee said they would be willing to entertain such a proposal in writing
and then the Chamber of Commerce Executive committee would then
respond back in writing. Ms. Hobbs said they were the ones that were
approached and apparently, it’s for hospitality funds to be sued to fix the
Admin Building. Councilman Milling said, “You know more than I do”.
Councilman Milling said, “We need a presentation from Mr. Garland”. Ms.
Hobbs said, “They didn’t approach me, they approached Anna, Mr. Garland
and Mayor Boyd and they were the three that were in the discussions.
Councilman Milling said, “My position is if the City is going to act on
17
something and make a proposal to you, it needs to be presented to City
Council and the Mayor prior to an agenda item where they are discussing
something that they don’t have any information on. Councilman Milling
made a motion to table Item 9G until the City receives a report from the
City Administration as to this proposed use, funding, space, etc. as to
how it would be proposed that it be presented to the Chamber.
Councilwoman Reed seconded the motion. Mayor Boyd said the purpose
of them putting this on the agenda was to bring it to everybody’s attention
for them to discuss. Councilman Milling said, “We don’t have anything to
discuss”. Councilwoman Reed said, “What I’m getting out of it is it’s a
proposal to try to see how we can fix up the Admin Building. And you’re
going to another City department to solve a problem and you’re not giving
us any input here, you’ve already decided how you want this building done”.
Councilwoman Reed said, “What I’m understanding is the reason for this is
for you to be able to repair the admin building using hospitality money and
you’re using the Chamber so you can do it”. Councilman Milling said right
now there’s a motion to table Item 9G. Mayor Boyd wanted to give Mr.
Garland a chance to explain. Mr. Garland said last summer the Chamber
building had mold issues for about two to three months and an offer was
made at that time to the Chamber for them to use part of the admin building
as their headquarters until they got the mold issue fixed. Mr. Garland said
out of that came the idea of them using the conference room next to his
office or possibly upstairs. He said if they had DDRA and the Chamber in
one building they could have a visitor’s center which they could promote on
I-95 and help draw people into one place. Councilpersons Bryant
Gardner, Sheila Baccus, Howard Nettles, Elaine Reed, John Milling,
John Segars and Mayor Boyd all voted in favor of the motion.
RECEIVE AS INFORMATION (DEPARTMENT HEAD REPORTS
(GIVEN IN PERSON)
Council reports were given in person and they gave a summary of what was
included in their handwritten reports. Council had an opportunity to ask
them questions.
Ms. Jonna Carter gave her report for the Municipal Court Office. (No
questions asked)
Ms. Karen Carroll gave her report for the Street & Sanitation Departments.
Mayor Boyd said there were three locations that had mattresses and tv’s and
wanted to know the policy on that. Ms. Carroll said, “Code says that we
18
pick up tree limbs, grass cuttings and leaves. She said the City does not pick
up furniture and she convey that to the citizens.
Police Chief Kelvin Washington & Fire Chief Pat Cavanaugh. Chief
Washington said Council has a copy of his handwritten report and he would
entertain any questions. Mayor Boyd asked about the number of offenses
for speeding and what the policy is for inspecting fire extinguishers,
emergency lighting, etc. throughout the town. Mayor Boyd said in other
area that he has businesses, they come in each year and inspect the facility.
Mayor Boyd asked if we do annual inspections each year. Chief Cavanaugh
said, “Yes, they have two fulltime Fire Marshalls (He and Assistant Chief
Bailey) and they try their best to get to every business every year. He said
they send some of their staff into different store and different businesses and
do what they call “company inspections” and they preplan every business in
town. Chief Cavanaugh said they look for emergency lighting and fire
extinguishers and the biggest thing they look for is clearance around panel
boxes and people using excessive power strips or extension cords.
Codes Enforcement Officer Mr. Alex Gainey went over his handout and
told Council about some of the flooded areas that they worked on.
Recreation Department Head Mr. Lee Andrews went over his department
report.
W&S Superintendent Mr. Freddie Kinsaul said as far as leaks, they had a
leak at a six-inch water main on Pearl Street and other than that, there were a
few minor issues. Mr. Kinsaul said this gave them an opportunity to work
on Circle Drive fire hydrant. He said whoever put it together originally, they
ran three pipes together at that fire hydrant. Last Thursday they put a new
fire hydrant in. They did a repair on the one that was broken on the Square.
Mayor Boyd asked Mr. Kinsaul if he’s already worked on a rate study
comparing our rates to others? Mr. Kinsaul said he’s looked at it, but we’ve
got to program what you want to do. Mayor Boyd asked Mr. Kinsaul if he
can get a list of the fire hydrants that are broken? Mr. Kinsaul said a hydrant
on Broad Street is broken and one on Main Street is broken. Mr. Kinsaul
said he’ll have to get a list from Chief Cavanaugh of the ones that are not
broken, but they are the old two-prong fire hydrants. Mayor Boyd asked Mr.
Kinsaul if he could get a list by next month of how many are broken? Mr.
Kinsaul said as far as physically broken, there’s only two. Councilman
Gardner said his understanding is, the Fire Chief already has that list.
Councilwoman Baccus said, “So, do you have a plan now or working on a
19
plan to fix the underground leaks that we’re having and permanently solve
the problem”? Mr. Kinsaul said, If the council and Mayor would give him
money, we can replace the pipes”. Councilwoman Baccus said, “Do you
have an estimate of what it’s going to cost to fix the ones that we know
that’s broken that’s leaking”? Mr. Kinsaul said, “I’m not trying to be smart,
but that’s probably every line in Darlington that has had a leak on it”.
Councilwoman Reed said she was listening when Alex gave his report and
he’s mapping areas as he goes along. Mr. Kinsaul said Circle Drive has
three pipes going to the hydrant, but it only showed one. He said when you
dig, that’s the true locate. Councilwoman Reed said, “We’re doing so much
digging and we’ve got so many cones all over the City. Do we have some
kind of plan that we’re putting together to help us be able to identify what’s
along the line”? Mr. Kinsaul said, “Not with GPS”. He said they’ve got to
locate the lines in the ground and GPS. Councilwoman Baccus said, “So, if
I remember maybe eight or nine months ago, Councilman Milling wasn’t it
you that said or asked that we look at getting a GPS System in place and the
cost of it so we can start mapping out all of these things, so we’ll know
where everything is at”? Mr. Kinsaul said we can get an estimate, but
you’ve got to have an engineer, or GPS mapper, your software and
computer. Councilwoman Baccus said, “I think we asked that you check
into that and get us a cost on it, so we’ll know where we’re going with this”.
Mr. Kinsaul said we discussed this in a budget meeting. Councilwoman
Reed asked Mr. Kinsaul what his suggestions were as to what we can do and
if the only way to resolve this is when we have a problem. In other words, is
there a way for us to be proactive. Mr. Kinsaul said the only way to be
proactive is to replace the pipe. Councilman Milling asked if we can do a
study to determine what needs to be replaced because it sounds like
everything needs to be replaced. Mr. Kinsaul said Russell Street is probably
one of the ones that’s undersized. He said there’s a small line that runs
down Russell, Ward and part of Exchange Streets. Councilman Milling
asked if anybody has taken a look to identify other areas and what it’s going
to cost to replace a one-inch line or whatever is an acceptable size? Mr.
Kinsaul said the only way to do it is to engineer toward grants. Councilman
Milling said we need to develop a list of priorities. Mr. Kinsaul said they are
working on that now. Councilman Milling asked when would they see the
list of priorities? Mr. Kinsaul said by the time we start the budget
workshops. Councilman Milling said if we start the budget workshop
without knowing what the priorities are, how are we going to budget for it”?
Councilman Milling said it would be good to have some of that before we
begin discussions. Mayor Boyd asked, “Does Davis & Brown have a
20
mapping system that we can use”? Mr. Kinsaul said, “Yes they can
contract”. Mayor Boyd said he would like to see a list of all fire hydrants,
all the water lines in priority and possibly have it by next month.
For Info Only
Mr. Garland said on Thursday January 16, 2020 at 6:00 PM there will be a
workshop for Mayor and Council with Mr. Charlie Barrineau who is from
the Municipal Association. Mr. Barrineau will make a presentation on
“Now I’ve Been Elected, What’s Next”.
Mr. Garland said he just put out a request for qualifications for engineering
for the sewer lift station project which includes lift stations at Verizon, Joe
Louis Blvd., the old waste treatment plant on Old Florence Highway and the
Hampton Street Plant. They will open bids on Monday February 3, 2020 at
10:00 AM. Mr. Garland said they need two Councilmembers to help them
score the projects along with him and Mr. Kinsaul.
COUNCIL COMMENTS
None
EXECUTIVE SESSION – OPTION TO PURCHASE LAND FOR
BALLFIELDS (THE CITY OF DARLINGTON WILL VOTE AFTER
EXECUTIVE SESSION
Councilman Bryant Gardner made a motion to go into executive session
at 8:55 Pm to discuss option to purchase land for ballfields. Mayor Boyd
said he wanted to show the video of the property they were going to be
discussing in executive session to the audience. Councilwoman Elaine Reed
seconded the motion. (5-minute break)
Councilman Bryant Gardner made a motion to go out of executive
session at 9:35 PM. Councilman Milling seconded the motion.
Councilman Milling made a motion that the City of Darlington enter into
an option agreement with Mr. Olin Kirven to purchase 111 acres of land
which he owns at 1755 Harry Byrd Highway; Darlington County Tax
Parcel 126-00-02-063. This option will contain as contingencies that we
get free and clear title to the property and we have the ability to enter into
agreements with Darlington County, NASCAR, Darlington Raceway and
the Ramsey Family to obtain a strip of land that would be attached to the
111 acres and go back to the City Limits so that this piece of property
would become City property within the city limits of Darlington and not
21
property owned by the City outside of the city limits of Darlington; and
that we do sufficient geological and other surveys to ensure that we have
out of the 111 acres along with another piece of property some 70 acres of
buildable land to use for recreational fields for a purchase price of
$600,000. Councilwoman Elaine Reed seconded the motion.
Councilpersons Bryant Gardner, Sheila Baccus, Howard Nettles, Elaine
Reed, John Milling, John Segars and Mayor Boyd all voted in favor of
the motion.
Councilman Milling made a motion that the City enter into an option to
purchase from Keith Evans at 1785 Harry Byrd Highway Parcels 126-00-
02-091 and 126-00-02-092 for the sum of $55,000. Property is adjacent to
the first tract that was described under the same terms and conditions with
these exceptions that it has to have clear title that we can get annexed into
the City and that there is suitable land in combination with the 111 acres
and between the two that we can get 70 acres of buildable land for
recreational facilities. Councilman Segars seconded the motion.
Councilpersons Bryant Gardner, Sheila Baccus, Howard Nettles, Elaine
Reed, John Milling, John Segars and Mayor Boyd all voted in favor of
the motion.
Councilman Milling proposed that in connection with the offer to Mr.
Kirven in connection with the option, that we propose a $2,500 option
price and for Mr. Evans a $1,000 option price. Councilwoman Elaine
Reed seconded the motion. Councilpersons Bryant Gardner, Sheila
Baccus, Howard Nettles, Elaine Reed, John Milling, John Segars and
Mayor Boyd all voted in favor of the motion.
REMINDERS
January 20, 2020 Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Holiday – All City Office
Closed
February 11, 2020 at 6:30 PM - Regular Monthly Meeting Darlington City
Council
ADJOURNMENT
Upon motion of Councilman Bryant Gardner, seconded by Councilwoman
Elaine Reed, the meeting adjourned at 9:41 PM.
22
Mayor
ATTEST:
Clerk & Treasurer
Source: City of Darlington website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.