RecordWell Data

_05142026-10910

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of May 14, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

HUMAN RESOURCES COMMITTEE May 14, 2026 A meeting of the Human Resources Committee was held virtually this date at 4:00 p.m. PRESENT Councilmember Stephen Bowden, Chair, Councilmember Karl L. Brady, Jr., Vice Chair, Councilmember Boyd Gregg, Councilmember William Tinkler, Councilmember Leslie S Skardon, and Mayor William S. Cogswell, Jr. . STAFF : Tammy O ’Berry, Director, Human Resources Director, Elizabeth Dieck, Chief of Staff, Shannon Elliot, Assistant Corporation Counsel, Hampton Logan, Special Advisor, Lindsay Mazell, Talent Acquisition Manager, April Slinkard, Benefits and Wellness Manager, Jennifer Strickland, HR Efficiency, and Lee Wilder, HR Manager The meeting was opened with a moment of silence. Approval of February 19 Minutes Councilmember Gregg moved for approval of the minutes. Councilmember Tinkler seconded the motion . The motion passed unanimously. New Business A. Talent and Onboarding Updates – Lindsay Mazell Government and Public Safety Turnover Statistics Ms. Mazell was having difficulty with her mi crophone . Ms. O ’Berry presented the report until Ms. Mazell was able to take over . Quarter 1 Turnover : Historical Comparison 2026  From 2026 compared to prior years, it was a little bit higher than fire in 2025 , lower on police and a fraction higher than the past two years on nonsworn, but trending down overall .  2026 Total Turnover Projection- Currently in quarter one, it shows a large dip because that was only one quarter of the year. In the projections for the rest of the year, she noted one would still see they were still overall at a downturn from where they were over the past few years. Ms. O ’Berry noted when one was looking at the dip in quarter one, that was just first quarter data. Quarter 1 Sworn Staffing Levels, Historical Comparison  This was the current percentage of staff, the current precent of actual positions that have been filled. Police was at 93% and fire was at 91%. Presently the City was running a good trend compared to prior years when there were some good years and some worse years but remained in the 90% field level.  Non-Sworn Vacancy (Turnover) Rates – With the turnover, there were some groups with numbers that might be higher. O ’Berry indicated HR could be one of those but as a small department, that could be one person. As one looked at the numbers, she said make sure to note that anything with a large number to think about the size of the department. Overall, the turnovers were looking good.  General Turnover Statistics – Ms. O ’Berry remarked this was the question that was asked at the previous Human Resources meeting. After seeing the turnover numbers, what does it compare to? Through some research, they found the national average for turnover across all industries was currently about 18% to 20%. Government was running 15% to 20% and specifically city/municipal government running 15% to 20%. Generally, government turnover was lower than the private sector due to pensions and stability. If one was looking for where Human Resources Committee May 14, 2026 Page 2 the city compared to that data, they were looking at 2025 actuals at about 10.6% and a project ed 2026 running about 12.24%, which was a projection based on first quarter data. Overall, it was better than the national average.  Public Safety Turnover Statics – Ms. Mazell said this was part of what they had been asked to present. Police and Fire were able to present to them the turnover rates, keeping in mind the key trend. Police hi gher during the earlier career years and with fire , more lower turnover within the municipalities workforce . She noted the major takeaway from this was nationally police were looking at 7% to 10%, the city was running 10%. Fire ran 5% to 8%. City fire was running somewhere between 6 ½ % and 8%. Therefore, with police and fire, the city appeared to be right at the national average. Quarter 1 Project Highlights – They wanted to also present a fraction from each pod in relation to first quarter project highlights.  CBIZ Architecture and Grade Review – CBIZ was the vendor they were working with the comp study looking at the city architect. They moved to a new pay grading system that started in March where they did an update for all of the positions. It as a big overhaul working through an electronic file they had to upload into the Workday HRS system to get updated across the board not only for the positions but all of the positions that were currently posted with the new grade and doing some audits to make sure everything was working correctly.  CBIZ Job Description Meetings - They were also working with CBIZ to review job descriptions from the JQ ’s that all employees throughout the city did earlier this year.  Summer Hiring – At this point, this pod and recruitment , t hey supported 120 summer hires. A summer hire orientation had already been underway. They had the aquatic division two weeks ago so they could get the pool s open . The summer camps would be starting with training right after Memorial Day. They were doing orientation for about 60 of them next Monday night.  Spring Job Fairs – To prepare for the summer hires, they do a number of spring job fairs through out the low country, especially targeting the high schools in the area.  Updating All Positions and Job Postings to New Pay Grade System B. Employment Relations and Employee Development – Lee Wilder Quarter 1 - Overview  Employee Cases o 3 Investigations – Within the first quarter, there were three employee relations investigations .  Terminations o There were 14 involuntary and 63 voluntary terminations.  Terminated Employees 7/1/2025 – 3/31/2026 – The breakdown of reasons why the City had involuntarily terminated employees since July, 2025 . This went through the first quarter of 2026 with the highest reasons being : o Poor perf ormance o Drug and alcohol policy violations o Tardi es and absenteeism  Drug Free Workplace Policies – Across Jurisdictions – The chart showed the agencies and their respective policies to zero tolerance versus second chance approach for drug and alcohol policy violations . Most of the jurisdictions listed (City of Charleston, Charleston County, Town of Mount Pleasant, City of Greenville, State of South Carolina) maintained a zero tolerance approach, which was what their recommendation was with continuing to offer Human Resources Committee May 14, 2026 Page 3 assistance to employees who come forward with substance abuse problems prior to any required testing being done.  Drug Free Workplace – Zero Tolerance Vs Second Chance Policies – This showed the difference between the zero tolerance approach and the second chance policies. The city currently follows the zero tolerance approach but a couple of things to point out with the second chance approach was employees were give n the opportunity to retain employment under certain strict conditions should that be considered.  Drug Free Workplace Policy Recommendations – They were asked to consider an alternative approach, which would be a hybrid of the two. Maintain zero-tolerance and continue to offer assistance to employees who come forward with substance abuse problems. They were asked to consider a n alternative approach, which would be a hybrid of the two: o Maintain ing zero -tolerance for :  S afety sensitive positions  On duty impairment  Employees who demonstrate a refusal to test  Situations where continued employment would create a risk for the City o And combine this with the second chance criteria:  First-time violators of the drug and alcohol policy in non-safety sensitive roles  Situations where continued employment do not pose an undue risk Ms. O ’Berry noted at the last meeting, Councilmembers asked what was their policy like compared to other agen cies. This document on Slide 14 showed that right now they were on track with most of the other local groups as far as zero tolerance. Their current recommendation was to maintain that . H owever, if they wanted to consider a more flexible approach, they have drafted what they might want to consider when looking at that. Councilmember Tinkler asked if there was a staff recommendation. He said it sounded like they were recommending they maintain. Ms. Berry said at this point , based on the research they have done, they were recommending the City to maintain. Chair Bowden asked was that because they felt like the policy was working or because the City was in line with what others were doing? Ms. O ’Berry said it was a couple of things: a.) The City was in line with what others were doing, which was the first thing they wanted to double check, and b.) T he zero tolerance approach was very common in local government and it was the safest policy for the City to ensure that they were doing their best to eliminate drug and alcohol use at the City. The other approach, which was similar to the County ’s approach where one was allow ed certain positions with first time violations to continue employment. It was a viable approach and while they weren ’t opposed to it, it was outside of the norm and it would be a change for the City . Councilmember Bowden said he felt like doing something because it ’s the way that things have always been done was the worse reason to continue doing something. These policies were developed at a time when you couldn ’t go down the street to get Delta 8 gummy and fail a drug test the next day. A lcohol have always been legal and you can ’t drink that at work. But with things that weren ’t alcohol, when they become legal you risk firing someone for something you can ’t prove they were Human Resources Committee May 14, 2026 Page 4 actively intoxicated by. Secondly, he didn ’t know they could really prove that it ought to be considered a safety risk. He didn ’t know what the evidence that it created a safety risk but he would like to know that. More importantly, it was probably in wider use and particularly marijuana, do those studies that existed prior to this that might prove their safety risk continue to hold up as more people were presumably using. Ms. O ’Berry said she had worked in both environments, one with drug free workplace policy recommendations and one with drug workplace policy alternative approach. In policy recommendations when they did have second chance in place for certain positions, there were a few instances where employees were tested positive after smoking, being around smok e or being around CBD (cannabidiol) . When given the opportunity to continue employment, some were able to get the help through drug rehab counselor and come back to work. The same was true for a couple of employees who were doing cocaine. There were some fewer instances where some would eventually make it back to work and many instances where they didn ’t. In her personal experiences, those employees who did come back to work used marijuana or CBD . They worked it through with a counselor and came back to work. It was a viable option. I co u ld save some employees and have them come back. It wouldn ’t totally solve the City ’s problem with the number of employees leaving, but some would choose to get help and come back. Chair Bowden said h e just wondered if they wanted a marijuana specific policy . If someone tested positive for cocaine use, he thought it was fair to question whether there was a deeper problem they needed to be concerned about. It was the same as someone showing up intoxicated by alcohol on the job. Th ese weren ’t things that stayed in your system for as long as marijuana would. Somebody who smokes marijuana in the evening, he thought it was fa ir to wonder whether they were a legitimate risk to anything the City was doing unless there was evidence that they were intoxicated on the job. As these things were used wider and as the legislature was considering how legal they should be right now, he wondered whether these were relics of a war on drugs we lost a long time ago and maybe should rethink some of those things. Ms. O ’Berry thought they had a clearer direction now and they could look into the specifics of a marijuana policy with regards to testing positive. Councilmember Tinkler said one of the issue s at the last meeting was about insurance and whether this was driven by our insurance policies or whether this was just a more general policy. He asked if this had been checked to make sure this alternative approach fits with our insurance coverage? Ms. O ’Berry said it doesn ’t relate to insurance coverage at all. Councilmember Tinkler concluded it doesn ’t relate in that the insurance doesn ’t have anything that would apply to this context. Ms. O ’Berry said it wouldn ’t from the heal th insurance perspective but it would like from a risk of any sort like driving insurance. She thought he might be speaking towards insurance with regards to general liability. They haven ’t found anything that said it would affect their insurance rates at all . If the Committee decided this was where they wanted to head, they needed to triple check with their particular insurance vendor. She asked Mr. Wilder to check with the vendor. Chair Bowden said it sounded as if more information was needed to figure out which direction would make sense to head in. Ms. O ’Berry said they would gather that information and get back in touch with him . Quarter 1 Projects Highlights  Performance Management Training – Mr. Wilder said some of the things they had been working on in employee relations and organizational development space were preparing the City for the first pay for performance structure. They completed 14 training sessions with approximately 350 supervisors and managers on effective performance Human Resources Committee May 14, 2026 Page 5 management practices, coaching and feedback conversations, connecti ng employee performance to the City ’s core values and d ocumentation expectations. They have also put another seven supervisors through another round of the local government supervisor training series within Q1. They provided training to the city ’s executive leadership team on executive leadership coaching techniques . They also held a quarterly service awards breakfast recognizing years of service retirees and ASUS nominations. C. Benefits and Wellness Updates – April Slinkard  MyCIGNA Application Usage – One of their big pushes for employees was to make sure they had access to care; they understood what there resources were. They felt that lent itself to preventative care and for them taking care of their health ahead of the game rather than waiting until there was a complicated issue or chronic illness that they were dealing with. One of the ways they tracked that was by tracking the Cigna app registration and usage to make sure employees were getting acquainted with that so they were more comfortable reaching out for care or resources should they need it. Many employees had registered on the app and were using the app regularly for care and understanding what their resources were.  MD Live Registration – Another area they were focusing on and looking at in terms of data was looking at MD Live Registration, which was important because they were offering employees virtual option for getting their health care: o This was an affordable option for people. There was a $10 copay with the standard health care plan. They wanted to make sure employees had as much access to care as possible. o It was more convenient - no travel, no extended time away from work, traffic – they could do all of the virtual care where they were without a lot of hassle . They hoped people would get the preventive care or ask questions during their appointments to prevent them resorting to an urgent care or an emergency room . o The trend line in the usage of MD Live was going up steadily. They had a campaign for some time and are increasing that campaign to assure people understood what MD Live was, what it meant to them and how it could be helpful. o MD Live does behavioral health care . The virtual option seemed to be the better option for many employees. o Employees could also get primary care, dermatological care and urgent care through MD Live.  Parental Leave Municipality Comparison – They looked at various local municipalities . T he City of Charleston had paid maternity and parental leave of four weeks , which was unusual. Charleston County was the only other local government entity that provided the same services. North Charleston and Mount Pleasant didn ’t have it. The difference was their employees in other municipalities had to depend upon Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), Short-Term Disability (STD) and Paid Time Off (PTO) or S ick L eave to cover their maternity and parental leave. Councilmember Skardon thought four weeks was unacceptable. It wasn ’t enough time that someone needs. She was glad they had an immediate landscape analysis here but she asked if they knew whom the City was competing against as they were hiring people. She asked if they could add in some private sector or federal government benefits . She thought the City should be at leas t at 12 weeks . She said she felt very strongly about that. Ms. O ’Berry said they would be happy to go back and add in some definite other representative groups so she could get a better idea of non-municipal locations and what the City was competing against. Quarter 1 Project Highlights Human Resources Committee May 14, 2026 Page 6  Copay reduction for Telehealth ($10) and Specialist Visits ($50) per visit to make it more accessible for employees.  They also added implemented an Employee Benefits Plan Comparison Tool . They used it for new employees as well as other employees to see the different plans that affects them personally and their families.  They created an onsite employee health coaching program . It was a specific individual that worked with employees to help them understand nutrition, exercise, guides to help them to live healthier lives  They implemented mental health and weight loss support programs  They began mandatory use of biosimilars of which was a cost savings to the City but allowed employees to have the same quality of medication Councilmember Gregg asked when you do the analysis on the maternity leave, could they get a count of people who have used maternity leave over the last few years to see how many employees they did have taking maternity leave. He also asked Ms. Slinkard if she could give more information regarding biosimilars as he had never heard that term before. Ms. Slinkard said biosimilars were equated to generic medications. They were the same formula, the same medication but they didn ’t come with the brand name label, which was usually where the cost was. They just made it accessible for people to use biosimilars, which was a choice. Councilmember Gregg concluded it was the equivalent of a generic. Ms. Slinkard said it was but they were for very expensive medications. Chair Bowden noted he filed lawsuits pretty consistently against another local government entity because of their health care choices. One of those recent choices was to categorically refused to provide a certain medication. There wasn ’t a generic for that but there were similar drugs in that class that worked in a different way that wasn ’t working for people. He wanted to make sure that biosimilars would be specifically limited to a generic of the same drug as opposed to any other drug s in a c ategory that might have different side effects or might worked differently and not provide the same benefit that a doctor said that someone needed by prescribing them a certain medication. Ms. Slinkard said if patients had the ability through their doctor to get the “brand name ” medications if they felt it was a better fit. Or if for some reason that the biosimilar didn ’t work for them or there were any other issue, there was a process they could go through to go with the other medication. They were not required to use the biosimilar. Ms. O ’Berry said they were going to start with the biosimilar then use step therapy is the biosimilar didn ’t work. Vice Chair Brady said if the biosimilar didn ’t work, did it cover something like a generic GLP-1 or were they still not covering that type of treatment. Ms. Slinkard said currently they weren ’t covering the GLP-1 treatment. That was an entire plan through Cigna, which was an all of nothing kind of situation. There wasn ’t much opportunity to add in piece parts to that so at this time, they weren ’t covering that. Ms. O ’Berry said they weren ’t covering GLP-1 ’s for weight loss, only for diabet ics . There were no biosimilars yet for the weight loss drugs out on the market. D. Efficiency, Effectiveness and Operations Updates – Ms. Jennifer Strickland PEX Tickets by Quarter Ms. Strickland noted these slides were new and asked everyone to keep in mind that these are total numbers so these are really citywide, not just a focus on HR.  PEX was people experience. PEX tickets live in Workday. These were totals across the City, not just HR. They wanted to emphasize the steady decline . They went line in the system Human Resources Committee May 14, 2026 Page 7 September of 2024. That was the reason for the large increase of PEX tickets at the beginning of 2025. One would see the steady decline in Q 1 of 2026. They were down to 26 total PEX tickets. Quarter 1 PEX Tickets by Type  The next slide was the breakdown of what encompassed the 26 tickets. She pointed out the top three – security, general and benefits combined totaled slightly over half of the 26 tickets. Ms. Strickland want ed to talk about what was meant by security and general. The security PEX tickets were anything from someone who needed access on the finance end to be able to input an invoice. S omeone needed access to do some sort of function in HR. These were some of the security tickets. Maybe they got a promotion, they moved into a new role and their security needed to change. General encompassed HR and just as it states a general HR question. They were usually low level, very simple tickets that could be answered in a matter of minutes. Benefits spoke for itself and live d in HR. Quarter 1 – CVS Hours  CVS hours were fairly new, something the y reported for the first time last quarter. T his was their consulting hours that they have and utilized for Workday. These would be the higher level tickets. This represented of citywide totals. This wasn ’t just HR. It looked at Q4 2025 versus Q1 2026.  Referring to the chart below, Ms. Strickland noted HCM core was high in comparison to citywide. What stood out to her as in why it was so high in Q4 of 2025 was they had open enrollment. It wasn ’t just about a benefit specific question but maybe they needed to get in the depth of HCM. In Q1 2026, they built out a performance management system within Workday , which was another reason for the increase in Q1 of 2026.  In reference to integrations, on the HR side they have vendors on the benefits side, like Cigna and Afflack, who received files every week. The difference in the extensive influx in 2025, Q4 versus Q1 2026, was due to open enrollment. Those file feeds needed to go out on the regular and they had some higher tier questions, errors and issues that happened in Q4. Quarter 1 Project Highlights  They built out performance in Workday .  They were working on a security audit in Workday. Ms. Strickland thought w ithout that foundation of the system they were doing it backward s . She was excited about the audit to lay the foundation and from there they could really look at the processes within the system.  SOP and Job Aids – Really focusing on not just from Workday but in general that cross traini ng so not one person holds all of the knowledge.  They worked on updating military leave and the workflow in process for that. E. HR Active Projects Ms. O ’Berry noted what they were in the second quarter:  A lot of effort was going into helping managers complete their performance reviews to do their first citywide performance review process .  They were also at the tail end of the comp study and updating all of the job descriptions. They had a semi-final product in December-January. They have gone back in to review everything so that by June they will have all of the jobs in the right grades.  Ms. Strickland mentioned the citywide workday security analysis where they had been spending their time currently. Human Resources Committee May 14, 2026 Page 8  A big retiree data audit on the benefit side. They had different vendors involved with retirees and they were ascertaining they had the data where it needed to be for retirees. F. Future Projects  Talent Acquisition and Onboarding : NEO Rebuild - They were doing a complete rebuild of new employee orientation wherein the first day of employment was focused on the City and its mission, vision and values versus watching videos and doing paperwork that could be done ahead of time.  Employee Relations and Employee Development o Implementation of the pay for performance incentive plan – This will be rolled out once reviews were completed o Development of certification tracking process in Workday for different employee certifications o Hosting the i mplementation of required annual training program through Workday, which would include harassment, discrimination, ethics, etc.  Benefits and Wellness o Virtual Physical Therapy Platform – Ms. O ’Berry showed a video on virtual physical therapy (PT) . It was a vendor example but not necessarily the vendor the y were going to select. Muscular skeletal issues (MSK) were one of the top cost drivers in the city. It was in the top three to five every year. This program is important to help curb some of those costs. While people will go to PT, what they won ’t do are those exercises when they get home. These programs help to hold them accountable to working virtually with PT. They should be ready to move in the next quarter with a virtual PT environment being made available to City employees. o They were working on the dependent audit to verify all dependents on the plan were eligible dependents  Efficiency, Effectiveness and Operations o More focusing on HR SOP ’s to get those finalized o Working on list of updated areas where Workday suggested things they could do to improve the HR side of Workday G. Discussion regarding MUSC/Cigna Contract Councilmember Gregg wanted an update as to if they had discussions with Cigna and if they thought this was going to get worked out. MUSC was one of the biggest healthcare providers for city staff. They met last year and had a productive meeting regarding what he called the “self-referral ” t he hospitals systems used to self-refer themselves procedures, which was up the cost of insurance although that wasn ’t the biggest concern. He noted Ms. O ’Berry had great ideas to potentially combat some of that. He asked what had they heard from Cigna and MUSC regarding the contract negotiation? Ms. O ’Berry said she spoke to Cigna and Ms. Slinkard spoke with MUSC. They were actively in negotiation s . In the past, in the benefit s ’ world this was kind of similar to cable TV . A message states you ’re no longer going to have a particular TV station and to contact your local cable company. That was similar to what they were going through here. They were in contract negotiations. She had no way of knowing whether it would work itself out or not. What she did know was 98% to 99% of the time, it worked itself out. She knew they were both actively in negotiations. They both had their opinion of who was right and who was wrong in this situation. HR hoped they were going to continue to move forward because it was in the best interests of the employees that they d o . Many of the employees uses MUSC services. Human Resources Committee May 14, 2026 Page 9 HR were actively in communication , talking daily. As of today, there was no resolution but they did know how important it was to the City and to each other. Ms. O ’Berry hoped this would resolve itself. Councilmember Gregg said his other request would be given that they were dealing with all of this, maybe now is a good time to refresh those ideas for trying to reduce some of the cost through self- referrals. He thought they could meet on that again or if there was a way to try to move it into another project. He said she had some great thoughts in the memo that circulated about how one might be able to reduce cost through self-referrals. He had been trying to shop around for procedures. He was constantly shocked at the markup MUSC and Roper St. Francis place on standard procedures. You might pay 10x at MUSC or Roper St. Francis versus an independent medical provider. The hospital systems were buying up all of the independent medical providers. Soon we would be left with no options. He wanted to see the City to use its position to try to bring costs down, not just for city employees. If they could do that within the whole hospital system he thought it would be something they could do for good using the City ’s power of the purse. Ms. O ’Berry ’s said the letter they talked about broke that down into a strategic plan. That strategic plan had 10 items they hoped to accomplish this year to help address that very issue. The first two of those items they just saw in the presentations, the MSK referrals and the dependent audit , assured that people who were on the plan were actually eligible to be on the plan and tried to refer people to the other provider for mu scular skeletal health . Ms. O ’Berry said they could provide them with some numbers as soon as they chose a vendor but as a general assessment, going to hospital for PT versus going to a provider or using this app for PT, you saw a drastic decline in cost. The vendors they were looking at not only showed a drastic decline in cost for the employee and the City, it also showed tends toward higher compliance as employees were required to do their exercises at home as part of the app. Since this meeting was running into another scheduled City Council Standing Committee meeting, Councilmember Gregg suggested this issue be placed on the agenda for the next Human Resources Committee meeting when they had a little more time. The meeting was adjourned at 5:01 p.m. Marcia L. Grant Administrative Assistant II

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.