RecordWell Data

BZA-SD Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of May 6, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – SITE DESIGN PUBLIC COMMENT MAY 6, 2026 A meeting of the BZA-SD will be held on Wednesday, May 6, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bza-sd. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 A. Review of Minutes and Deferred Applications from Previously Advertised BZA-SD Agendas 2. Murraywood Rd. Johns Island | Council District 3 | TMS# 312-00-00-071, 657 & 330 | Zoned: DR-6/SR-1 Request a variance from Sec 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 10 grand trees. Owner: Southeastern Recapitalization Group, LLC Applicant: Earthsource Engineering 6 Comments in Opposition • Jessica Snyder, 2860 Sweetleaf Ln, Johns Island, SC 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on May 4, 2026 3:36 PM I appreciate that the applicant made revisions in response to the Board’s direction, including preserving Trees #5 and #22 and reducing impacts to others. However, significant impacts remain that are not minor. Tree #27 still has over 40% critical root zone encroachment, and Tree #38 is also near that threshold. At this level, the concern is no longer short-term preservation, but long-term survivability of these trees. The fact that additional trees could be protected through design adjustments indicates that the remaining impacts are not unavoidable, but a result of design choices. For that reason, I respectfully request that the Board deny the variance and require a design that more fully protects the remaining significant trees. • Shirley Stowe, 2910 Sweetleaf Lane, Johns Island, SC 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on May 4, 2026 9:47 AM I respectfully request the Board to deny the variance and require a plan that better protects the trees. The ordinance is in place to protect the grand trees because of thier importance in protecting our precious sea island from flooding over the years. Building too close to the root systems puts the trees at risk of decline over time. The trees are part of a fragile ecosystem that must be protected. If they architectural design requires building too close to the root systems, I feel it should be reconsidered for redesign. Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | May 6, 2026 Page 2 • Glenn Broj, 2721 Calico Bass Ln Submitted to Innovate Site on May 4, 2026 9:53 PM As a homeowner in the Whitney Lakes community, I respectfully but strongly object to the proposed zoning change and associated variances requested under MS# 312-00- 00-071, 657 & 330. The developer is seeking approval to remove a total of nine (9) grand, mature trees—six through a variance and three through a special exception under Sec. 54-327—as well as permission under Sec. 54-330 to reduce required impervious surface setbacks near the bases of an additional ten (10) grand trees. Collectively, these requests would significantly impact the existing natural buffer that separates our community from the proposed townhome development, resulting in both the loss of mature trees and the encroachment of pavement in close proximity to those that remain posing a threat to their health. The trees slated for removal are well established, healthy, and form a critical natural buffer between Whitney Lakes and the neighboring property. They provide substantial environmental benefits, including shade, storm water absorption, improved air circulation, and wind mitigation during severe weather events. Equally important, these trees act as a sound and visual barrier from nearby roadways, helping preserve the quiet, residential character that Whitney Lakes residents value. Beyond their environmental function, these trees are central to the identity and appeal of Whitney Lakes. The forested entrance and park like landscape form the first impression for anyone entering the neighborhood, contributing to the premium, natural experience that defines our community. For residents, particularly those living on the island, this wooded backdrop is not merely decorative—it is an essential part of why residents find Johns Island a desirable place to live. The adjacent property is already proposed for dense townhome development, which will undoubtedly result in extensive clearing of existing vegetation. Forested areas have already seen significant loss in similar developments, such as the second phase of residences behind Food Lion, where the land was largely cleared of its original vegetation. Repeating this pattern risks permanently eroding the character of the surrounding area and diminishing the distinct boundary between established neighborhoods and new, high-density housing. There is no demonstrated benefit to the Whitney Lakes community in removing these trees or in allowing an access road or paved connection between the two developments. The proposed townhome project already has ample opportunity to establish entrances directly from Murraywood Road without encroaching further on adjacent neighborhoods or eliminating valuable natural buffers. The purpose and justification of the variances must be clearly and transparently explained to Whitney Lakes homeowners. Absent a compelling justification that directly benefits our community, approval of this zoning change should not be considered. Once mature trees are removed, their ecological, aesthetic, and protective value cannot be replaced for decades, if ever. I respectfully ask the zoning board to carefully weigh the long term environmental and community impacts of this request impacting 19 grand trees and to prioritize the preservation of the mature trees that protect and define Whitney Lakes. Thank you for your time and for considering the concerns of our community. • Anna Messinger, 2928 Sugarberry Lane Submitted to Innovate Site on May 4, 2026 11:14 AM I am writing to formally oppose the requested variance to reduce the required impervious surface setback around the bases of ten grand oak trees within our neighborhood. These trees are not incidental landscape features—they are critical natural assets that define the character, environmental health, and long-term stability of our community. The existing setback requirements are in place for a reason: to protect root systems, ensure adequate water infiltration, and preserve the structural integrity and lifespan of mature trees. Reducing these protections for the sake of Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | May 6, 2026 Page 3 development convenience undermines both the intent of the ordinance and the long- term interests of the neighborhood. Grand oaks are particularly sensitive to soil compaction and changes in drainage patterns. Encroachment by impervious surfaces— such as pavement or structures—can significantly restrict oxygen and water flow to the roots, leading to decline, instability, and eventual loss. The damage may not be immediate, but it is often irreversible. Approving this variance effectively trades short- term development gain for long-term environmental degradation. Beyond the ecological impact, these trees provide measurable community benefits, including stormwater management, shade that reduces urban heat, improved air quality, and increased property values. Their preservation is not just aesthetic; it is functional and economically sound. Weakening protections sets a concerning precedent that could erode tree conservation standards across future developments. It is also important to note that variances are intended for cases of genuine hardship, not for accommodating design preferences or maximizing buildable area. The developer had the opportunity to design the project in compliance with existing regulations. Granting a variance in this case suggests that adherence to established environmental safeguards is optional rather than required. For these reasons, I strongly urge the board to deny this variance request and uphold the existing setback requirements designed to protect these irreplaceable grand oak trees and the integrity of our neighborhood. Respectfully submitted, Anna Messinger • Martha Gaston, 1904 Brittlebush Lane Submitted to Innovate Site on May 4, 2026 12:13 PM Dear Board Members, I add my voice to the local Johns Island residents who are concerned about the overdevelopment and depletion of the natural environment. Specifically, I believe the grand trees located around and in the proposed Murrywood Road development by Southeastern be protected. Old growth trees are important for our ecosystem and the slowdown in townhome sales on JZI indicates demand is easing. Please do what’s right for the CURRENT residents and keep the trees (and scale down the development)! • Jon Burgess, 2860 Sweetleaf ln, Johns Island, SC 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on May 5, 2026 7:35 AM Thanks for the continued effort by the board in reviewing this request and preserving the grand trees that make Johns Island unique. Even with those changes presented, the level of impact on several trees remains concerning. When encroachment reaches or exceeds 40% of the critical root zone, it significantly reduces the likelihood that a tree will remain healthy over time. The fact that the developer moved some lines proves this isn't a hardship of the land, but a choice of the layout. I am asking the Board to hold them to a standard where NO Grand Tree faces more than 25% encroachment, as that is the only way to ensure the preservation the ordinance intends 3. 8 Poplar St. North Central | Council District 4 | TMS #463-12-01-003 | Zoned: DR-1F Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 1 grand tree. Owner: Nicholas Rembowski Applicant: April Magill, Root Down Designs, LLC No Comments Submitted Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | May 6, 2026 Page 4 4. Grand Oaks Boulevard West Ashley | Council District 10 | TMS #301-00-00-052 | Zoned GB/LB Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 30 grand trees. Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 6 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 10 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 10 protected trees. Owner: Bees Resources Applicant: Thomas and Hutton 60 Comments Submitted in Opposition See attached document. B. New Applications 1. 87 Folly Road Boulevard Old Windemere | Council District 11 | TMS# 421-11-00-002 | Zoned SR-2 Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 1 grand tree. Owner: SDM Express LLC Applicant: Wread Development, LLC No Comments Submitted 2. 1614 Grimball Road Extension James Island | Council District 12 | TMS# 427-00-00-021 & 022, 431-00-00-288 Zoned LB & PUD Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 4 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec. 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback from the base of 6 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of protected trees below 15 trees per acre. Owner: Charles Wilson Applicant: Nick Allport No Comments Submitted Other Comments • Donna McClain, 2475 Wensley Drive Submitted to Innovate Site on May 4, 2026 7:57 PM A mature tree can produce about 260 to 100,000 liters of oxygen per year, depending on the species and size. This amount can support approximately two humans for a year. Please do NOT cut down anymore trees. West Ashley has suffered enough over development and natural resource loss. BZA-SD Meeting | May 6, 2026 Item B-4: Grand Oaks Boulevard 60 Comments Submitted in Opposition First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/ Time Submitted Torrey Sanders 131 Spring Street May 5, 2026 Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design City of Charleston Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability 2 George Street Charleston, SC 29401 Re: Bees Resource Apartments – Grand Oaks Boulevard (West Ashley), TMS# 301-00-00-052; BZA-SD Application Requesting Variances and Special Exception Under Sections 54-327, 54-329, and 54-330 Dear Members of the Board: The Coastal Conservation League (CCL) submits these comments in opposition to the variance and special exception requests filed by Bees Resources (Adam Ricketts) through applicant Thomas & Hutton in connection with the proposed 382-unit Bees Resource Apartments development on Grand Oaks Boulevard in West Ashley. The revised application, submitted April 28, 2026 following a March 4, 2026 deferral, requests: A variance from Sec. 54-327 to allow the removal of 30 grand trees; A special exception from Sec. 54-329.b to allow the removal of 6 grand trees in categories III or IV; A variance from Sec. 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 7 grand trees; and A variance from Sec. 54-327 to allow the removal of 10 protected trees within 25 feet of the property line. For the reasons set forth below, CCL respectfully urges the Board to deny all four requests. The application fails to meet the legal standards for either a variance or a special exception under the City’s tree protection ordinance, and approval would undermine the purposes the ordinance was enacted to serve. I. The Variance Requests Fail to Satisfy the Required Four-Part Hardship Test To obtain a variance, an applicant must satisfy all four elements of the hardship test set forth in S.C. Code § 6-29- 800 and reflected in the Board’s application form. The applicant has not done so. A. The Phosphate Mining Claim Is Unsubstantiated The applicant’s primary claim of extraordinary site conditions rests entirely on the assertion that the property was previously used for phosphate mining, resulting in a network of large ditches that constrains site design. This claim appears in the applicant’s narrative letter but is supported by no documentation whatsoever. No historical maps, no environmental records, no soil or geotechnical reports, and no survey data identifying the location or extent of any such ditches. The Board cannot make a finding of extraordinary and exceptional site conditions based on an unverified assertion. The applicant bears the burden of proof, and that burden has not been met on this threshold issue. B. The “Effective Prohibition” Argument Is Not Credible as Applied to Healthy Trees Even accepting the site conditions argument at face value, the applicant’s claim that the property would be “undevelopable” without the proposed removals does not withstand scrutiny. A review of the applicant’s own tree health data reveals that a significant number of the trees requested for removal are May 5 2026 11:18AM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 2 of 16 rated B (good condition) under the applicant’s arborist assessment. These trees are not hazardous, not diseased, and not structurally compromised. Many are slated for removal to accommodate surface parking, drive aisles, and walkways — elements of a site design that reflects choices made by the applicant, not constraints imposed by the ordinance. The variance standard does not exist to relieve an applicant of the need to design around protected resources. A site design that could be reconfigured to retain healthy grand trees does not give rise to an unnecessary hardship. C. The Authorization of These Variances Would Be of Substantial Detriment to the Public Good The applicant asserts that granting the variances will not harm the character of the district or the public good. CCL disagrees. The subject property is one of the last large forested tracts remaining in this portion of West Ashley, a part of the city with documented stormwater and flooding challenges. The mature hardwoods proposed for removal, predominantly red oaks, laurel oaks, water oaks, and tulip poplars ranging from 24 to 44 inches DBH, provide stormwater interception, canopy cover, and filtration functions that replacement plantings at the ordinance’s required 2.5- inch caliper minimum cannot replicate on any meaningful timeline. The site also contains wetlands and wetland buffers, and the removal of upland tree canopy immediately adjacent to those wetlands will increase runoff volume and velocity into a system the buffers exist to protect. These are precisely the harms the tree protection ordinance was enacted to prevent. II. The Special Exception Request Is Procedurally and Substantively Deficient Section 54-329.b provides that removal of a grand tree via special exception, rather than variance, is available only for trees in Category III or Category IV under Sec. 54-331, and only where the Board affirmatively finds one of three conditions: (1) the tree is in poor health; (2) its removal would allow protection of a specimen tree that would otherwise be lost; or (3) the tree is located within a proposed building footprint, street, road, driveway, drainage way, or parking area and no other reasonable design or economically reasonable alternative exists. The applicant’s revised application states only that it seeks “a special exemption from Sec. 54-329.b to remove 6 grand trees in categories III or IV.” It does not identify which specific trees are the subject of this request, does not demonstrate that those trees fall within Category III or IV under the Sec. 54-331 species table, and provides no analysis of which of the three required findings the Board can make. The BZA application form itself instructs applicants to “include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements.” No such documentation has been provided. The Board cannot grant a special exception without making the required findings, and it cannot make those findings on this record. III. Conclusion The City’s tree protection ordinance reflects a deliberate policy choice to treat grand trees as irreplaceable community assets warranting meaningful protection. The BZA variance process is the mechanism through which that protection is enforced. Here, the applicant has submitted an application that relies on an unverified factual predicate, fails to demonstrate hardship as to the healthy trees on the removal list, and provides no legally sufficient basis for the special exception request. CCL respectfully urges the Board to deny all four BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 3 of 16 requests. Thank you for your consideration of these comments. Respectfully submitted, Torrey Sanders Conservation Program Manager Coastal Conservation League Hank Simon 1812 Gun Club Rd 29414 Grand Oak trees are one of the most important protections for the environment and the climate. These large trees each provide a canopy that protects the local microclimate, stabilizing temperature extremes. This is in significant contrast to concrete and other artificial surfaces that increase local climate temperatures. In addition, Oaks trees are the best moderators of fresh rainwater and flooding. When Oak trees are thoughtless removed without careful planning, catastrophic flooding occurs on the scales of what happened in Shadowmoss and Forest Lakes in the years from 2016 - 2018, when flooding resulting in millions of dollars of local damages. Some of this damage was handled by public tax dollars, and some by private funds. The damage done by removing the Oak trees from Grand Oaks will have the same impact, and we will have to repair the damage with tax dollars... to mitigate planning mistakes. May 3 2026 1:45PM Jennifer Jairdullo 1426 Pooshee Drive Please do not give permission to remove any trees in this area for any reason. We are losing too many in this area. And it’s our responsibility to protect them! They are why a lot of us moved here and love living near them. May 3 2026 1:50PM Darby Brass 1035 Ashley Gardens Blvd Charleston SC 29415 The removal of grand trees is prohibited per law, and this should stand with this property. We are losing way too many trees and grand oaks just are not that plentiful any longer due to high development. This property should leave the trees standing and have to work around them, decreasing the their planned footprint for this area. The developers should have done their homework prior to coming up with their plans for this area. Approval for tree removal definitely should have been key before implementing their construction plans. It is done backwards so asking for tree removal afterwards allow for them to show just cause due to the location of their proposed buildings . We are losing way too many trees, all sizes, but grand trees are protected for a reason and condos/townhomes/apartments are not a dire need in West Ashley and should not be used to allow the removal of grand trees. As a provate citizen, I had to work around one grand tree when building. One and they want many removed??? No, we have got to stop allowing developers to remove all our trees and green space just because they purchased land to put as many living spaces on it for their own fortune. Our wildlife is being displaced due to lack of habitats. Let these trees live so some of our wild life can continue to live in our area that they and we call home. May 3 2026 2:04PM Lorraine Woolf 1620 Verbena Lane Removal of the trees is a detriment to the community. These trees play a vital part in flood prevention and serve homes for birds abc animal species. Also there are available affordable houses right now. We don’t need additional homes that will put burden on roads and schools. Enough already. May 3 2026 2:16PM Michael Laskavy 509 Hainsworth Dr., Charleston SC 29414 We MUST stop the destruction of the remaining trees on Grand Oaks Blvd. behind Harris Teeter. The increase in traffic congestion will be bad enough, and the quality of life for those who've lived here for years is being ruined. But my main concern is the loss of habitat for wildlife in the area. We are already seeing an increase in dead animals killed May 3 2026 2:32PM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 4 of 16 by car hits on the surrounding roads, and with less and less space for them to survive in, wildlife will increasingly become a problem for homeowners as animals try to find food, water and shelter in the surrounding neighborhoods. Where do they go when there's no place left? This constant habitat destruction must stop. Developers see no value in a tree unless it can be cut down for lumber and land to be sold and developed. And it's the wildlife that suffer the most. Please do NOT approve any further tree removals or easements. This constant development is no longer sustainable. Betty Reed 1569 Ashley Garden Boulevard, Charleston SC 29414 ...removal of 30 "grand" trees; removal of 6 "grand" trees; removal of 10 "protected" trees! Our community is named "Grand Oaks" for a reason...we are surrounded by the beauty of nature, especially the numerous remaining grand oak trees. If anyone needs a reminder of the definition of "grand" and "protected", here you go: - "grand" meaning grand, magnificent, imposing, stately, majestic, grandiose mean large and impressive. - "protected" meaning preserved from harm, especially by means of formal or legal measures. Do the words "grand" and "protected" no longer carry their intended meaning? How can you even consider removal of "grand" or "protected" trees? We certainly don't need more housing in our community. We also don't have the roads to accommodate additional traffic in/out of our neighborhood. So, how can you justify this unnecessary development. Some say it was in the original master plan for our community which was over 20 years ago...so what? That is no justification. Please reconsider allowing this housing development in our beautiful neighborhood. Thank you! May 3 2026 3:49PM Susan Vigen 1939 Piper Dr I am not in favor of removing the grand trees! Trees are important for water absorption & helps prevent flooding. This ridiculous destruction of our beautiful trees is destroying our home. Stop this crazy development, please! May 3 2026 4:18PM Cynthia Smart 301 Steele Magnolia Please do not cut down all of trees for this project. It impacts the entire area unfavorably and removes habitat required for birds and other animals. We don’t need more housing in this area. This will create more traffic and stress the green spaces for no reason. May 3 2026 4:21PM Rachel Woods 2202 Doris drive, Charleston sc I wholeheartedly oppose the destruction of any grand trees. May 3 2026 4:36PM Eric Wilhelm 1706 North Elgin Ct. Charleston SC 29414 I oppose the general concept to this development. The area has ready overgrown with new housing developments without needed infrastructure improvements: Bees Ferry/Highway 17/Ashley River Rd. In addition, storms continue to strengthen due to climate change. Natural wetlands help to prevent another Church Creek type flood witnessed within a mile of this proposal nearly ten years ago. May 3 2026 4:54PM Jennifer Albert 400 Cabrill Dr From What’s happening in West Ashley. Please comment and show up! Speak up against this destruction. These developers need to learn how to work with the trees, not cut them all down. Their unwillingness to preserve a little nature does not constitute a hardship. Submit comments here https://innovate.charleston-sc.gov/comments/ Agenda info for commenting: 4. Grand Oaks Boulevard I do not support the removal of so many trees. Specifically, I Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 30 grand trees. Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 6 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec May 3 2026 5:13PM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 5 of 16 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 10 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 10 protected trees. Owner: Bees Resources Applicant: Thomas and Hutton Liz Munn 3631 Morse Avenue, Johns Island SC 29455 Removal of grand trees for development is a betrayal to nature and the environment. Eliminating something that took hundreds of years to grow can not be recovered in this lifetime. Consider the alternative of moving the trees or relocating the project. May 3 2026 5:27PM Malorie Igo 439 minim st, Charleston sc I do not approve of the removal of these trees. The grand trees aid in flooding. If we keep cutting down trees, we are going to have a serious problem during rain storms. They bring much needed shade when walking. We would also be ruining natural habits for wildlife. We have to stop removing trees for pointless reasons. Beautiful west Ashley will soon be the next North Charleston, Ashley phosphate/rivers Ave. we need to continue to preserve what’s beautiful. There is a reason those trees are protected, you should not exempt anyone from this rule, especially someone who just wants to build more apartments that’s going to bring more traffic jams. I ask we keep the grand trees for which our community is named after. May 3 2026 5:52PM Careen Jensen 904 Lansfaire Dr., Charleston, SC 29414 I do not approve of the submission for the request of the variances for the removal of protected trees. They are protected for a reason and I don't believe putting up more apartments in our neighborhood where we are already dealing with overwhelming traffic and congestion in this area. Please leave the trees and the green areas in our neighborhood. Our neighborhood is called Grand Oaks. May 3 2026 7:06PM Pamela Ingram 1036 Tyron Circle, Charleston, SC Please do not approve any of the variance requests related to the removal of additional trees, grand trees or to impervious surfaces. Enough is enough! Trees are positive for our health and reducing flooding (which this neighborhood has already had issues with). It’s bad enough that this project, that no one in the neighborhood wants, has been approved, but now they want to take even more trees? They can figure out how to design the unwanted complex without taking even more trees. May 3 2026 7:35PM Chelsea Phillips White Oleander Ct. Stop tearing down trees and quit building in this area. May 3 2026 7:46PM Bryan Evans 290 cabrill dr That area has a decent amount of grand trees that should be preserved because oxygen and nature are by far more important than stuffing as many people into shodily constructed townhomes and apartment complexes as possible. You wish to remove 56 Grand trees that are worth more than your entire company and valued more so. What worth does this development company bring to the area? I don't see anything from the plans for this development at all that is useful. We already have long Savannah which will have far too many people coming to the area why do we need this poorly located development that will just clog up traffic even more what are they adding to the local infrastructure to be useful? If they already have permission to build the site I don't see why we need to make their job easier for them by allowing them to cut down trees that are worth more than they are. Let them redesign and build around nature if they truly want to build in that lot so bad. May 3 2026 8:37PM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 6 of 16 Louis Friscoe 373 weeping Willow way, charleston sc 29414 The request to remove numerous protected trees in the Grand Oaks area for residential development should be denied due to the significant environmental, community, and long-term economic impacts associated with such action. Protected trees play a critical role in preserving local ecosystems by supporting wildlife habitats, improving air and water quality, and mitigating stormwater runoff—an especially important function in flood-prone coastal regions like ours. Additionally, mature tree canopies contribute to property values, neighborhood character, and overall quality of life for residents. Approving large-scale removal would set a concerning precedent that undermines established conservation ordinances designed to balance responsible growth with environmental stewardship. Sustainable development practices can and should be pursued without sacrificing irreplaceable natural assets that benefit both current residents and future generations. May 3 2026 8:39PM Susan Farrell 104 Battlewood Avenue I'm writing against this request. That is an unholy number of trees to remove. Please, let's keep West Ashley as green as possible. May 4 2026 1:12PM Nancy Huber 337 Weeping Willow way I moved to Grand Oaks just over 5 years ago and one of the reasons was the gorgeous entrance of all the trees. Now the property owner wants to cut them down. I am totally against this project. Where are all the animals supposed to go? Just because you own land doesn't mean you have to build on it. Stop the cutting down of the trees. May 4 2026 1:27PM Linda Westfall 351 Cabrill Dr, Charleston, SC, 29414 Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 30 grand trees. Request a special exception from Sec 54- 327 to allow the removal of 6 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 10 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 10 grand trees. May 4 2026 2:07PM LaDon Paige Hunt Club Run I strongly oppose the approval of special exceptions and variances to remove any grand or protected trees. It’s bad enough that we have to have this development in West Ashley that is already overcrowded and quickly losing its natural spaces. But it’s just one more thing to allow the destruction of these mature trees and displacement of wildlife, all for the sake of profit. These developers should come up with a plan that work around these trees. There is nothing that creates a hardship to warrant approval of removal of these trees. Both the city and the county are responsible for the overdevelopment of West Ashley. Taxpayers are continuously paying to bail out properties that flood that never should’ve been developed near the Church Creek basin. Likely this property will be the same scenario. We spent a lot of money on Dutch dialogues, and yet here we are continuing to cut down all of the trees and decimate the wetlands. This is irresponsible development. Removal of these trees should be denied. I appreciate what you do and know that it is challenging to say no to developers. But we must be better stewards of our resources. May 4 2026 4:04PM Richard Kazzi 862 Rue Drive I stand in opposition to this request for a variance and special exception to remove 30 Grand Trees. As stated, these trees are an essential natural resource. They must be protected. Thank you for your consideration in this matter. May 4 2026 4:16PM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 7 of 16 Stephanie Leopard 9 Studebaker Ct. Charleston, 29414 Please to not cut down the Grand Oaks. We Do Not want any more residential building in this area. The green spaces are what attracked most residents to this area. There is also too much traffic already, on Beesferry and the roads leading onto and off of it. May 4 2026 4:18PM Robert Frederick 110 Sugar Magnolia Way Please stop cutting down all of the actual Grand oaks on Grand oaks boulevard. Beazer homes already did a fabulous job of removing all of those trees in the entire area. We don't need to lose anymore. May 4 2026 4:58PM Elizabeth Taylor 312 Spikerush Circle Please consider this neighborhood’s quality of life before you vote to chop down these beautiful trees that spawned the whole entire name of our neighborhood. With Long Savannah, we will have hardly any trees left in this area and far too many construction vehicles. Why is the area being cleared? Who is the developer? What will be built in this area? When is construction set to begin? When will construction be completed? The signs for this meeting were placed along Grand Oaks Blvd a few days ago. Today is 5/4/26. What defines “adequate notice” and how would we go about getting that time period extended? Do you agree with me this is a poor display of good faith- just as they’re trying to break ground on a massive project? Grand Oaks Blvd already backs up so far during rush hour, it is extremely frustrating to exit the neighborhood. When you can actually exit the neighborhood, you’re immediately stopped on Bees Ferry due to the bottleneck of people trying to turn right onto Glen McConnell. Your options are to stop in the middle of the intersection or pull on up in the wrong lane to clear the intersection to then be forced to merge with people turning right onto Glenn McConnell who will not let you over because they’ve been waiting in line for 10 minutes to turn right onto Glenn McConnell. This development will immediately affect traffic in a negative way. We need to be able to leave our neighborhood at any time for any reason. Emergency vehicles must be able to leave and enter our neighborhood as much as they need to. With construction vehicles speeding and blocking roads (already dealing with this in Long Savannah in the back of the neighborhood), it could lengthen emergency response times no matter how close the station is located. Are these construction companies allowed to cut the trees down anyway and simply pay a fine? I understand none of you live in this neighborhood, but for once please place human life and nature above the almighty dollar. There are far too many loopholes these developers are using to take over our city. You know this. You’ve heard this same old tired argument. Now let’s see if you can muster the courage to do the right thing. Thank you. May 4 2026 6:23AM Stephanie Brooks 220 Hampton Bluff Dr Charleston 29414 My name is Stephanie Brooks, and I am a resident of Autumn Chase and Magnolia Lakes, within the Grand Oaks Plantation neighborhood. I am submitting these comments in advance of tomorrow evening's council meeting to respectfully but firmly oppose the granting of special permission to remove 46 grand oak trees from the proposed development site along the entry corridor to our neighborhood. What we are asking — urgently and respectfully — is that the council deny the special permission being requested for the removal of these trees, and instead require the developer to revise their plans in a manner that preserves the grand oak canopy that defines the entrance to May 4 2026 6:40PM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 8 of 16 Grand Oaks Plantation. These 46 trees are not incidental landscaping. They are the living foundation of an entryway that our neighborhood was named for. They represent decades — in some cases, generations — of natural growth that cannot be replicated within any reasonable timeframe. Their removal would not simply alter the appearance of this corridor; it would permanently and irreversibly eliminate the green canopy that residents of the Grand Oaks community have come to treasure as a defining feature of where we live. We respectfully ask each council member to visit the site in person before casting a vote. No report, rendering, or description can adequately convey what stands to be lost. A brief drive along the entry road will make immediately clear why this community is asking you to act on its behalf. Development and preservation are not mutually exclusive. We believe that with good-faith effort, the developer can revise site plans to accommodate their project while protecting these irreplaceable trees. We ask that the council send that message clearly by denying this special permission and requiring a revised approach. Thank you for your time, your service to this community, and your consideration of our concerns. Respectfully submitted, Stephanie Brooks Rita Rozier 422 Blue Jasmine Lane I strongly disagree with the approval of the trees removal. These are protected trees and should not be touched. Why should you even consider the variance for removal of protected trees? No one else is allowed to cut them, why should this be an exception? What are the diameter and height of these trees? It was passed in 2024 that a tree 24" in diameter and 4'5" in height has to have your approval for removal. Why is the Council allowed to be different than the average citizen? Non removal means non removal. Please consider what you are doing to the environment and the displacement of nature by allowing this. May 4 2026 7:14PM Madison Van Caugherty 828 colony drive Charleston SC Refuse to cut down the 30 grand oaks and the other 10! Oak trees are important to our environment, wild life, and flooding. May 4 2026 7:32AM Ana Orozco 414 sycamore shade St. Charleston sc 29414 Not in favor of removal of any trees on the neighborhood May 4 2026 8:08AM Barbara Newton 2111 Fife Ln, Charleston, SC 29414 Please VOTE NO to everything in this variance request about cutting SO many grand trees and imperiling several more for a new development project on Grand Oaks Blvd. It is an insult to all West Ashley residents because it is yet another attack on the natural environment we desperately need to preserve in this area for SO many reasons; among them is preventing more flooding, which is already an ongoing major problem. How can this variance be in line with the promises to residents, and the plans made to mitigate the flooding in West Ashley? Also, the infrastructure needed for the developments ALREADY completed, or in the process of being completed, are not in place to properly support all of it in our area! Our West Ashley Council members should be representing their constituents by voting NO on this variance and emphatically stating why, in order to hopefully convince a majority of the other Council members on the merits of saying NO too. Let me be clear, I am not against responsible May 4 2026 8:09PM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 9 of 16 growth in our area - there are many things we lack to be a well rounded area of the City - but I am against rampant growth that has not been thoughtfully planned and developed to protect and preserve the ecologically important natural environment, and does not include creating and completing the infrastructure in a timely manner, that is needed to support it. Developers should also help bear the expense of adding all the infrastructure needed. Of course, all this would cost developers more money and time before their developments become profitable, but if they can't, or are unwilling to follow this path to create a new development in this area, they should look elsewhere. Multi-family housing stresses so many facets of infrastructure, and the proliferation of multi-family developments outside 526 in West Ashley already has residents suffering from inadequate infrastructure. A moratorium on this type of development needs to be put in place for this area. I realize this commentary is long, but I believe all the contents are germane to this Agenda item. In conclusion, I would like to say to ALL Council Members - convince us voters that you are doing your jobs and working in the best interest of residents in all areas of Charleston, and NOT in the interest of the many Developers who apply for variances, and submit plans for developments to be created in such a way that will be profitable for them, but detrimental to the best interest of Charleston residents. Thank you for the opportunity for my comments to be presented to the Council. Kathy Daw 321 Stinson Dr Leave the trees and stop building without concern to the environmental impact for the West Ashley area as well as the neccessary infrastructure needs thru out West Ashley area this building site will impact May 4 2026 8:10PM Heather Moore 1028 Tyron Circle I am writing to strongly oppose the proposed removal of grand trees for this new development. Mature landscapes play a critical role in stormwater management, reducing flooding, and improving air quality. In a region already vulnerable to flooding, removing trees or the current landscape will have a lasting negative impacts on both the environment and surrounding properties. Beyond their environmental value, these trees contribute significantly to the character and beauty of our neighborhood. Once they are removed, it will take decades to restore what has been lost. Replanting smaller trees does not adequately replace the ecological and visual benefits of mature ones. I urge you to reconsider this proposal and explore alternatives that preserve these grand trees. Development and environmental stewardship do not have to be mutually exclusive. Thoughtful planning can and should incorporate existing natural features rather than eliminate them. At a minimum, there should be a requirement to reduce the number of trees removed and prioritize preservation wherever possible. May 4 2026 8:22PM Meg Adelmann 582 Carters Grove Road Charleston SC 29414 As a resident of Autumn Chase/Magnolia Lakes in the Grand Oaks development, I am opposed to removing the oaks as requested. Part of the reason we moved into the neighborhood right across from the street from the proposed development was because of the green space. These trees are protected and should be left there to preserve the beauty of this neighborhood you are trying to destroy. May 4 2026 8:44PM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 10 of 16 Tracy Galanda 1212 Harcourt Ln As a resident of Grand Oaks for over 15 years, I would like to express my opinion that is shared by many in this community. We are highly AGAINST the removal of so many PROTECTED GRAND OAKS! Ordinance were passed to PROTECT these GRAND trees. These rules for protection seem to work in the cases of people removing them from their own property, but they never seem to protect them from developers. Developers always seems to get a variance and then the lots are wiped clean of these beautiful protected, grand trees. Our local government always follows the money. How about our local government listen to the voices of their constituents and represent what the citizens want. These PROTECTED and GRAND trees cannot be replaced. They help to mitigate flooding naturally. They provide shade to prevent global warming. They covert carbon dioxide to oxygen, to help with air pollution. Planting little oaks in their place does nothing. Especially when they have grown here for many decades. A small replacement tree can be planted in its place, but it’s no replacement. If the new smaller tree dies, it won’t be replaced and there goes another tree and no one notices. Please listen to the voices of people for once. Do not allow the removal of these government PROTECT, GRAND trees. Follow the rules that our government created and the voices of the residents. Save these GRAND OAK/Trees and vote NO to the variance. May 4 2026 9:14PM Melaina Murray 1492 Roustabout Way, Charleston, SC 29414 Please strike down any efforts to eliminate grand trees as part of this project. Aside from beautification and heritage that these trees provide (both grand and protected), they’re also essential for the area’s watershed/ecosystem. It’s on the developer to be more creative in their initial designs and plans for the area. I also hope that if this effort is not approved, that Thomas & Hutton will not get away with still cutting them down and paying the fine(s). Charleston is not beautiful because of our sidewalks, roadways, and quick- build residential and commercial buildings; Charleston is beautiful because of the sustained empowerment and responsible stewardship set in place regarding nature. Thomas & Hutton’s bottom line should not be the priority of Charleston and its residents. Council members should bear in mind that sustainable, responsible decisions rest largely on their shoulders. May 4 2026 9:37AM Danielle Crawford 115 Brogun Lane Charleston, SC 29414 NO, NO, NO! The overdevelopment of this area is insane- this area cannot handle any more traffic with current infrastructure- and don’t kill all those beautiful, living trees. There are also flooding concerns. May 4 2026 9:41AM Susab Nial 1780 Chelwood Circle The request for permission to destroy 30 Grand Trees is appalling. The thought that such permission could be granted is even more so and evidence that developers know that what they want they usually get. The laws protecting grand tress wasn’t about pretty landscapes! It was about protecting our environment and supporting natural flood protection. Every time a developer is permitted to destroy natural flood protect we all suffer … some be cause they lose their homes and the rest of us have to deal with flooded roads and the cost of dealing with the flooding developers cause, enough is enough Protect the tree to protect the land and the people May 4 2026 9:59AM William Burckhalter 1205 Palustrine Ct Please stop all variances and exceptions to remove grand trees from the area. Why do you have to destroy the things that make this area so beautiful? The city's greed and May 4 2026 10:07AM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 11 of 16 Charleston SC 29414 corruption is literally taking everything that makes this place special and burning it to the ground in the name of development. Stop ruining the area!!! Mallory Ware 1235 Ashley Garden Blvd There is not a legitimate need to remove protected trees for the potential of any more commercial development/ or potential housing in the Grand Oaks area. There is already a couple thousand acres planned to be lost to the upcoming Long Savannah development, and us residents who already live here are trying to preserve as much wooded area as possible; since that's the whole appeal of living here. The upcoming Long Savannah development will definitely strain the 10+ yr old Grand Oaks neighborhood, so no more land disturbance is wanted especially here directly at the entrance/exit. Continuing to remove the very appeal of the area is not preserving the integrity or character of the area as we know it. Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 30 grand trees. Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 6 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 10 grand trees. I request a variance from Sec 54- 327 to allow the removal of 10 protected trees. Thank you, contact at mcamw16@gmail.com May 4 2026 11:24AM Rhonda Smith 1917 old Parsonage Road NO..Absolutely NOT. DO NOT remove these grand trees. They are for the protection of animals who are trying to survive in over populated areas with their natural habitat being destroyed. DO NOT remove these trees as they prevent flooding. DO NOT REMOVE TREES.....Remove the politicians that want them removed. Too much over population ruins wildlife, ruins the air we breath, as well as prevents flooding. May 4 2026 11:32AM Kathy Hood 2232 Forest Lakes Blvd. Charleston,SC 29414 The removal of this many grand and protected native trees seems excessive. These trees took years and years to grow. Laws have been put in place to protect these trees for a reason. It would not be honorable to grant these exceptions as if the laws don’t exist. Too much destruction of our woodlands is happening and changing our entire area. The things we love about West Ashley is being developed away. We live off of Glenn McConnell Parkway and we know how much flooding has increased due to clearcutting, construction and paving. Less trees equal more water runoff. The least you can do is honor the tree laws already in place and stop the destruction where it is possible to do so. Please don’t be railroaded by people that believe these trees are worthless or want to gain by monetarily by removing them. Enforce the laws. May 4 2026 11:41AM Linda Motley 2120 Coffey Ct Charleston SC 29414 Removal of any Grand Tree is cause for alarm. Removal of this many is changing our Lowcountry landscape forever. Nit only dies the beauty change instantly but then we are left with long term effects, such as storm water management, that must be paid for by the taxpayers. I absolutely DO NOT support the removal of ANYof these Grand Trees May 4 2026 11:59AM Stacey Sutherland 2020 Proximity Dr, Apt 1314 Charleston SC I request that permission to remove the grand oak trees be DENIED. These trees are an important part of Charleston heritage and are protected. This is disgraceful. May 5 2026 6:46AM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 12 of 16 David Scott 511 Carters Grove Rd, Charleston SC 29414 These laws and regulations exist for a reason. I assert their claim fails to qualify under any of the four variance requirements. There are no exceptional and extraordinary conditions pertaining to this piece of property. The claim that it was used for phosphorus mining doesn't justify the removal or degradation of over 50 trees. The conditions of the lot are the same as the conditions of nearby undeveloped lots. It is not an unreasonable prohibition to require someone to develop within the limits of the law. Finally, if variance is granted there will be substantial negative impacts on adjacent properties, the public good, and the character of the district. This area is prone to flooding, the removal of those trees will have a substantial impact on the severity and frequency of that flooding, as well as soil erosion caused by the removal of those trees leading to damage of nearby retention ponds. The areas is known as "Grand Oaks" not "Area where we chop down trees to allow overdevelopment." There is a reason why in their submission they have zero letters of petition from neighbors supporting their plans. The neighbors are strongly against it and would encourage this board to deny the variance request. May 5 2026 8:23AM Lindsey Gill 302 Steele Magnolia Ave Grand Oaks trees are protected for a reason. Cutting these beauties down to jam more homes where they are not wanted is irresponsible and disappointing. Have you seen the wildlife creeping where they were not before? Eagles displaced? Their homes are being destroyed. Money is not the driving factor to everything. We need nature if we are going to survive in this upside-down world. Please leave the trees. And build elsewhere. We’re full here. May 5 2026 9:39AM CHRISTY RULLIS 228 Brambling Lane, 29414 I have lived in Grand oaks for 10+ years now, and all of the recent growth along Bees Ferry has made the traffic dreadful. Bees Ferry Road has been a known bottleneck for years; the road wasn’t originally designed for the volume created by large-scale residential expansion (like Grand Oaks, West Ashley Circle, etc.), so new development often outpaces infrastructure upgrades. Unless a project includes meaningful road improvements (turn lanes, signal timing, widening, etc.), congestion and traffic will become UNBEARABLE! It can easily take 10 minutes to get out of Grand Oaks and onto Bees Ferry as it is now, without hundreds of apartments being built. I live on Brambling Ln, the first road behind the proposed development. That is all swamp land that floods during storms, if you take that away then the flooding will come into our neighborhood. When swamps get filled or built on, stormwater has to go somewhere—and it frequently ends up in nearby neighborhoods. In places like West Ashley, this has been a recurring problem as development expands into low-lying land. LAST BUT NOT LEAST- have to mention the obvious- We have enough apartments in the area that are all doing move-in specials because they have vacancies- why build more when the current apartments aren't full. May 5 2026 9:46AM Pamela Wike 793 Bent Hickory Road I am writing to oppose the approval of the variances to remove 30 grand trees, the reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 10 grand trees, the removal of 10 protected trees, and the special exception to remove 6 grand trees. It is inevitable that the 412 high density proposed multifamily development will happen, so residents are asking the BZA to at least give us in Grand May 5 2026 10:05AM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 13 of 16 Oaks and surrounding neighborhoods a say in this request and the courtesy of denying it. The applicant engineering firm, Thomas and Hutton, is well known and respected in the Lowcountry and they have the knowledge and skills to redesign the plans to avoid the grand trees and not increase the construction impervious surface requests. What is happening here is greed by the property owner, a real estate company with zero vested interest in preserving the Grand Oaks neighborhood, nor our current way of life. Our neighborhood is known for larger single family lots, tree preservation and is very walkable due to shade by what? Trees! This is why we all love living in Grand Oaks and we do not want that changed for a new multifamily apartment development along the main entrance. The zoning regulations are put in place for a reason, including controlling flooding. What is true, trees help with flooding, improve air quality, create cooler temperatures, provide habitats, and improve mental health. A 412 apartment unit can be redesigned to avoid the trees and reducing the impervious construction setback near the 10 grand tree bases. Also, has a traffic study been completed? Adding over 800 vehicles to our entrance roadway is going to be a nightmare. Is the developer adding lanes/a different entrance? My 8 year old asked about all the signs up this morning and after I described what was happening, the response was, "protect the trees they take in carbon dioxide leaving global temperatures to cool down." This is the BZA's chance to make a smart growth decision and deny all four variances and special exceptions. Thank you for your time. Jennifer Powell 156 Evening Shade Drive I am opposed to the removal of the 50 trees near Grand Oaks Boulevard for the following reasons: 1. Trees absorb atmospheric carbon dioxide, making them critical in combating climate change. 2. Trees filter airborne pollutants and improve air quality. 3. Tree roots anchor the soil, preventing erosion. 4. Trees often serve as habitats for a variety of species, some of which may be endangered. 5. Trees provide critical shade and cooling, mitigating the heat in developed areas. 6. Trees enhance the visual appeal of our neighborhood, contributing to residents' quality of life. 7. Trees act as sound barriers, reducing noise pollution in urban areas. I understand the expansion was approved more than 20 years ago, but Charleston has drastically changed over those 20 years. Please reconsider the removal of these trees! May 5 2026 10:11AM Jennifer Gardin 501 Haddon Hall Drive, Charleston SC 29414 The applicant is asking to remove 69 protected trees, claiming that the trees impede their development plans for the property. Did they not know they were purchasing a wooded lot with protected trees? Why should the community be made to suffer for their poor planning? I understand that these trees do not fit into the existing plans that the applicant has made but sometimes plans have to change. I also understand they have invested in this property and probably do not want to incur the additional cost it would take to work around existing protected trees. However, the community must not be made to suffer simply to protect the bank accounts of property developers. We should also not be punished for their failure to incorporate these trees in their original planning. The community will suffer if these trees are removed. We will be the ones dealing with the environmental fallout. The applicant claims that removing these trees "will May 5 2026 10:20AM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 14 of 16 not be of substantial detriment...to the public good". Conservation scientists say otherwise. These large trees are crucial to our well-being. Not only because of the oxygen they produce, but because of the impact they have on reducing flooding by improving water drainage. If this variance request is granted, the community will be left to deal with the impact while the applicant accrues more wealth at our expense and then moves on to another location. Justin Florek 432 Manorwood Lane, Charleston SC 29414 Overpopulation…Increased congestion would be a huge issue for emergency vehicles, school buses, and everyday commuters. Grand Oaks Boulevard has no room for more vehicles. The forest provides a much needed “green space” for wildlife as Bees Ferry continues to grow and overpopulate. May 5 2026 10:36AM Devin Moore 1028 Tyron Circle, Charleston, SC 29414 I'd like to go on record for being 100% AGAINST the proposed development and subsequent tree removal on Grand Oaks Boulevard. This proposed development will do nothing to enhance the quality of life for the residents of the Grand Oaks neighborhood, and will in fact be hugely detrimental. Several things I would like to point out: 1. I believe the timing of the posted notice was not in compliance with what the rules are. This posting went up on Friday afternoon 05/01/2026 for a meeting this week on Wednesday 05/06/2026. It is my understanding. This kind of hearing requires a two week notice. 2. The removal of 30- 40 trees could interfere with the Church Creek watershed and add to the already problematic existing flooding issues for this area. 3. There is massive construction of infrastructure near this project, which will not be complete until 2028. Additional housing developments will further strain an already-stressed system. 3. This area has been used historically for phosphorus mining. That process widespread wiped out trees. It has taken many decades for the tree growth to return to its current state. We do not need to lose these trees again. The phosphorus mining 100+ years ago ruined the original landscape. The area recovered over time. Did we learn nothing from the past if we allow this type of decimation in this area? 4. Congestion in the Grand Oaks neighborhood is already extremely high. Residents already have to wait through two and three traffic light cycles to exit the neighborhood. The addition of 600+ cars (more likely to be 700+) will be hugely detrimental to an already over- taxed road system as well as placing a heavier load on already over-worked fire, police, and EMS services. 5. If this development were proposed today, I do not believe it would meet many of the current requirements. Being "grandfathered in" from over 20 years ago is absurd. 6. At a bare minimum, If the owner/developer has been able to wait 20 years without developing this land, why can they not at least wait long enough for the upcoming infrastructure and road extensions (Glenn McConnell Extension) to help with traffic loads, access, etc.? Don't do it. Don't let the developers run over the residents. We are the ones that are supposed to be represented by our elected officials to help protect us from this kind of thing. Too often the elected officials bow to the developers and don't protect the interest of the citizens. Choose to do better. Thank you, Devin S. Moore May 5 2026 10:56AM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 15 of 16 Kathryn Wilson 225 Brambling Lane Charleston BZA should not allow for the destruction of grand and protected trees in the Grand Oaks development simply to make it easy for developers to mow the land for their ugl, ticky tacky projects. It’s disgraceful how developers clear cut rather than thoughtfully plan. And even more shameful if BZA allows it (again!). They are grand and protected for a reason. Let them be. May 5 2026 11:28AM Melissa Watson 105 Walnut Creek Rd. Charleston SC 29414 I am against cutting down grand oaks and other protected trees. The risk of flooding will increase and given all of the other developments going up on Bees Ferry this is a real concern. May 5 2026 11:35AM Betsy Rice 506 Blue Dragonfly Drive My husband and I object to the developer of this project receiving any variances for the removal of grand trees and protected trees. The laws are in place to protect us from the destruction of these beautiful old trees which will never be replaced in our lifetime. The displacement of all the wildlife is sad to witness. The developer knew the trees were there and the laws protecting them yet they bought the land anyways. Maybe the developers saw the most recent developments being built in West Ashley and saw how all the trees were cut down so they could cram as many buildings in as possible. Maybe these companies know our zoning board and council members see West Ashley as middle class and they don’t deserve to be treated and respected like those in the wealthier neighborhoods. I do not understand why you have these codes and yet you give every developer variances to clear cut all the trees. Or to build too close to the ones left standing so in a year or two they die. And then the homeowner has to pay to cut them down. Not the developer. Please for once do the right thing for our community. DENY this developer from destroying our beautiful woods. Build less buildings and save more trees and wildlife. May 5 2026 11:45AM Chelsea Bunch 758 Bent Hickory Rd Stop cutting down all of the oaks! This area is building up enough as it is with Long Savana. Grand oaks blvd is so congested as the main entrance to the neighborhoods. May 5 2026 11:46AM Kiley Decell 771 bent hickory road Charleston SC 29414 I urge every elected council to think of the community of grand oaks and our duty to preserve the beauty of Charleston. To cut down an additional 20 protected trees is something to take seriously. The ecosystem is already hurting in the area and the area has already had issues with flooding. That is a natural wetland that protects the surrounding homes and businesses from flooding. To removing it is just setting Charleston up for more flooding and issues ALONG with the traffic congestion. I beg for you all to reconsider not just for the people currently living there but also for the generations to come who deserve to enjoy the beautiful oaks and natural state of our area. I also encourage everyone to think on what happened with flooding a few short years ago and changing the natural landscape will just cause more of an issue May 5 2026 11:49AM Jena Wirth 434 Blue Jasmine Lane, Charleston, SC I am a West Ashley resident submitting strong opposition to the removal of more than 30 grand trees and 10 protected oaks for the proposed apartment complex at the entrance to our Grand Oaks Boulevard neighborhood. This tract sits within the Church Creek drainage basin (one of Charleston County's most chronically flooded areas) and functions as a natural wetland on a former phosphate mine. These trees are not decorative. They are living stormwater infrastructure actively absorbing rainfall and groundwater. Removing them May 5 2026 11:57AM BZA-SD Public Comment | Grand Oaks Boulevard Page 16 of 16 accelerates flooding for every downstream neighbor. This development will also be bordered by the Glenn McConnell Parkway extension and West Ashley Circle, adding enormous cumulative impervious surface to an already stressed watershed. I urge the Board to demand a full, independent stormwater impact study accounting for that cumulative load before any approval moves forward. Additionally, ten of the trees proposed for removal are protected oaks under Charleston County ordinance. I request public documentation confirming that all mitigation and permitting requirements have been fully satisfied, not waived. The Board must ask whether any site plan was seriously considered that preserves more of this canopy. These trees took generations to grow. They cannot be replaced. Once approved, this decision cannot be undone. I urge the Board to require the stormwater study, enforce the tree ordinance fully, and carefully weigh the long-term flood liability to this community before granting approval. Ripley Owermohle 501 haddon hall dr I am against the removal of grand trees to make room for more hasty development. New Construction has outpaced infrastructure, leading to heavily congested and deteriorating roads and neighborhoods, and the removal of forest, wetland, and other habitat for local wildlife is a detriment to the quality of life of this area. The removal of so many trees, and quick and cheap construction of new buildings, will inevitably contribute to the already bad flooding in the area as well as compounding already terrible traffic. May 5 2026 12:32AM

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.