RecordWell Data

BZA-Z Staff Reports

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of May 5, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 184 Broad St. VARIANCE CASE SUMMARY May 5, 2026 | 5:15pm Case Number: BZA2026-002339 Subject Property: 184 Broad St. / TMS# 457-12-01-103 Zoning District: STR Property Owner: Naomie Olindo Applicant: Julia F. Martin Architects Requested Action: Request variance from Sec. 54-301 to construct 2-story addition with a 3’ rear setback and a detached 2-story accessory building with a 25’ front setback, 3’ side setback, and 3’ rear setback (60’, 25’, and 6’ required). Project Description: The applicant is requesting a variance to construct an addition with a 3’ rear setback. The addition is comprised of a first-floor dining room and porch, and a second-floor master bedroom closet and en-suite bathroom. Additionally the applicant is requesting a variance from the front, side, and rear setbacks to replace the existing nonconforming 1-story garage with a new 2-story garage. The new garage is comprised of a first floor garage, and a second-story living room, bedroom, and bathroom. Case History: The applicant previously requested a special exception to extend the nonconforming 4.5’ rear setback to construct the proposed addition. The special exception was granted during the 12/5/2023 BZA-Z meeting. The applicant also received an extension of this special exception approval during the 2/17/2026 BZA-Z meeting. Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-301 Height, area and setback regulations The setbacks for the STR Zoning District are as follows: Accessory Buildings to Residences Setback Required Front: 25’ Rear: 25’ South/West Side: 12’ North/East Side: 6’ Variance Test/ Findings of Fact: The following is excerpted from Section 54-924 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. This test is based on S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-800. A variance may be granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 184 Broad St. Page 2 Applicant Responses: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; The existing building's history & configuration clearly comprise extraordinary and exceptional conditions. The current dwelling is a remnant (rear extension) of the original 3-story dwelling that once faced Rutledge Avenue. (See history/diagrams, sheets A-003 and A-004). Mid-century alterations effectively reoriented the front of the home to the south resulting in an uncharacteristically shallow and wide lot. 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; There is no other dwelling that we know of with these conditions and parameters. The current structure is awkward both inside and out, and it doesn't function well as a home. 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and Application of the ordinance results in a narrow (approx. 3' wide) swath of buildable area in the center of the lot (see illustration, sheet A-004). Re: the addition, BZA-Z permission has already been granted for a similarly scaled addition - our request pertains to a very small area as a result of simplifying the previous design + rooflines (as highlighted on site plan and floor plans). Re: the garage, our design would likely comply as an accessory structure if the historic Rutledge Avenue address were still in use. As is, we must ask permission to place it 'behind' the original house, most of which has been lost to time. 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. The proposed modifications will not adversely affect either the property or the district. The addition will allow for the current 'fragment' of a house to provide a more appropriate/stately presence on the west end (rutledge avenue). The garage location is similar to the two previous garage structures on the lot and its replacement will result in improved proportions/quality. The proposed setbacks are typical of accessory structures relative to neighboring properties (3' @ north, 3' @ east), and by shifting the footprint slightly to the south as proposed, more clearance is given to the roots of an adjacent grand tree. Staff Recommendation: Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: Staff are recommending approval of the variance request due to the shallowness of the lot, existing configuration of the historic home, and the presence of additional structures in the past demonstrating an extraordinary and exceptional condition that unreasonably restricts the use of the lot. Attachments: • Zoning Map • Site Map • Application Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 184 Broad St. Page 3 Staff Contact: Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov 50.49' 117.93' CP CONC.S/WCP CP CPCO 9.6'1.4'16.3'15.8'10.4'21.7'18.5'14.0'2.1'2.2'14.9'15.2'9.6'7.6'17.5'BUSHES BUSHESWALLBUSHES BUSHES A/CA/C BRICK BORDER BRICK BORDER BRICK BORDER BRICK BORDER BRICK S/WWOOD FENCEXXXX XXX XXXXXX XXXX XX XX X XXXXXXX FENCEWOODFENCEWOOD XX IPF1"11"P25"O 8"MAG BRICK S/WBRICK S/W 13"P13"P 11"P12"P10"P 17"SB15"P 20"G WALL GATEWOODXX WALL ON LINE WALLWALLWALL WALL CONC. D/WCONC. D/W IRON GATEIRON GATE GARAGE FFE 4.31 TBM-MAG NAIL 75.53' 58.00' NAOMIE I. OLINDOTMS 457-12-01-103184 BROAD STREET6,583 SQ. FT.0.15 ACRE 54.00' WOOD FENCE METAL GATE 21.7' SETBACK (FROMPREVIOUS BZA-Z. APPROVAL) 4.5' SETBACK (FROMPREVIOUS BZA-Z. APPROVAL) 12' SETBACKGARAGE(POST-1955)RESIDENCE PORCH PORCH XXFFE 7.38 CPCP CPCO XXX XXXXXX XXXX X XXXXXXX XX 11"P25"O 13"P13"P 11"P12"P10"P 17"SB15"P 20"G WALL ON LINE CONC. D/W 12' SETBACK4.5' SETBACK (FROMPREVIOUS BZA-Z. APPROVAL) 21.7' SETBACK (FROMPREVIOUS BZA-Z. APPROVAL) NEW GARAGE A/CA/C DW LA CORNUEFRANCE LA CORNUEFRANCE PREVIOUS GARAGE FOOTPRINT 3' SETBACK (NEW APPROVAL REQUESTED) VARIANCE REQUESTED TOREPLACE EXISTINGNON-CONFORMINGGARAGE WITH NEWNON-CONFORMINGGARAGE(CANNOT MEET SETBACKS) 3'-0"3'-0"25'-11"CHECKED BY:DRAWN BY:DATE:PROJECT NO.:All designs represented on this sheet are theproperty of JULIA F. MARTIN, Architects,LLC. Any unauthorized use or reproduction issubject to legal action. Possession in any formconstitutes acceptance of these conditions.J.F.M.2025-2320.MARCH.2026E.F./J.F.M.J.F.M. RENOVATION +ADDITION @184 BROADSTREETCHARLESTON SC 29401 EXISTING +PROPOSED SITELAYOUTA-005 EXISTING SITE PLAN3/16" = 1'-0" (3/32" IF HALF-SIZED) PROPOSED SITE PLAN3/16" = 1'-0" (3/32" IF HALF-SIZED) Instructions – Submit this application , along with the required information and fee, to the Zoning Division office at 75 Calhoun Street. Applications are due by 12 Noon on the deadline date and must be complete to be accepted and placed on an age nda. A sign will be posted on the property, and a public hearing will be conducted by the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning. Permits authorized by the Board cannot be issued during a five (5) business day appeal period following the decision of the Board , except for use variances, the appeal period shall be fifteen (15) calendar days. An appeal to the Board during this appeal period stays all further action on the application. THE APPLICANT HEREBY REQUESTS:  A Variance and/or Special Exception as indicated on page 2 of this application.  Reconsideration of a decision of the Board or action of a zoning official (attach Appeal form).  Extension of an unexpired Variance and/or Special Exception approval. MEETING DATE REQUESTED: ___________________________ Property Address ________________________________________________ TMS # _________________________ Property Owner ______________________________________________ Daytime Phone _____________________ Applicant ____________________________________________________Daytime Phone _____________________ Applicant’s Mailing Address ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________ E-mail Address____________________ Relationship of applicant to owner (same, representative, prospective buyer, other) ________________________ Zoning of property __________________________ Information required with application: (check information submitted)  Scaled plans or plats, including elevations, showing the variance(s) or special exception(s) being requested (3 sets)  For new construction or additions within a flood zone, show HVAC units and platform on scaled plans  Scaled floor plans with rooms labeled and the total floor area for each dwelling unit noted are required for all density variances and building additions, unless exempted by the Zoning staff (3 sets)  Plans or documents necessary to show compliance with special exception requirements (3 sets)  Check, credit card or cash (make checks payable to the City of Charleston)  Pursuant to Section 6 -29-1145 of the South Carolina Code of Laws, is this Property, which is the subject of this Application, restricted by any recorded covenant, restriction, easement or other document that is contrary to, conflicts with or prohibits the proposed land use encompassed in this permit application? YES _____ NO ______ Optional but very helpful information:  Photographs  Letters or petitions from neighbors or organizations directly affected by your request I certify that the information on this application and any attachments is correct, that the proposed improvement(s) comply with private neighborhood covenants, if there are any, and that I am the owner of the subject property or th e authorized representative of the owner. I authorize the subject property to be posted with a notice of the Board hearing and inspected. Applicant _________________________________________________________________ Date__________________ For office use only Date application received ____________________________ Time application received ____________ Staffperson _____________________ Fee $ ______________ Receipt # __________________ Application for Variance, Special Exception, Reconsideration, or Extension Page 1 of 2 to the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning (BZA-Z) City of Charleston BZA-Z Application (continued) Page 2 of 2 For Variance requests, applicants should list the specific variance(s) being requested and , if possible, explain how the variance test that follows is met (add as an attachment if necessary): _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Variance Test: The Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning is authorized to approve a variance from the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of su bstantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws Section 6-29-800) For Special Exception requests, applicants should list the specific approval (s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as Sec. 54-110, Sec. 54-206, or sections in Article 5 (add as an attachment if necessary): _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ All approvals of the Board shall remain valid for two (2) years from the approval date, unless extended in accordance with the provisions of Article 9, Part 5 of the zoning ordinance. Applicants may not apply for the same request that has been denied by the Board until a period of six (6) months has lapsed. Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability 75 Calhoun Street, Third Floor Charleston, South Carolina 29401 (843) 724-3781 FAX (843) 724-3772 www.charleston-sc.gov 4/11 CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 44 State St. SPECIAL EXCEPTION CASE SUMMARY May 5, 2026 | 5:15 p.m. Case Number: BZA2025-002346 Subject Property: 44 King St. / TMS# 458-09-01-137 Zoning District: GB, Accommodations Overlay District Property Owner: Lot 3C Bradley Circle, LLC Applicant: John A. Massalon Requested Action: Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-220 for an accommodations use (2 sleeping units proposed, 10 sleeping units minimum required and 0sf of meeting space proposed, 400sf of meeting space required). Project Description: Request Special Exceptions to allow the construction of an accommodations use on the parcel. The proposed accommodations use will be comprised of a total of 2 sleeping units. The property is currently comprised of 2 residential units. Unit 1is a 3-bedroom 3 1/2-bath unit occupying the first and half of the second floor. Unit 2 is a 2-bedroom 2 1/2-bath unit occupying half of the second and all of the third floor. Case History: Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-220 Accommodations Overlay Zone Permitted uses. In any Accommodations overlay zone, land may be used and buildings or structures may be erected, altered or used for any purpose allowed by the base zoning district as listed in Article 2: Part 3, and the following uses, subject to the approval of the Board of Zoning Appeals- Zoning: 1. Accommodations uses. The Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning may permit accommodations uses as an exception where it finds that: (a) the accommodations use will not result in a net loss of dwelling units that have been occupied within five years of the date of application for the exception; provided however, the BZA-Z may approve the alteration or replacement of such existing dwelling units on the same site as the accommodations use, or within a radius of one quarter (¼) mile from the site if the proposed off site location does not result in an over concentration of low income households, as defined by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, as adjusted by the Department of Housing and Community Development; and provided further, the BZA-Z shall require any such alteration or replacement to include dwelling units of substantially the same size and type of those being altered or replaced and shall require that no certificate of occupancy shall be issued for the accommodations uses until either a certificate of occupancy has been issued for all dwelling units being altered or replaced or irrevocable bonds or letters of credit in favor of the City in amounts equivalent to one Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 44 State St. Page 2 hundred twenty-five (125%) per cent of the costs to complete construction or renovation of the dwelling units, as determined by the Chief Building Inspector, has been filed with the City. (b)the accommodations use, if located in the Accommodations Overlay on the peninsula, will not reduce or displace more than 25% of office space that has been used for such purpose within five years of the application for the exception; (c)the accommodations use, if located in the Accommodations Overlay on the peninsula, will not displace more than 25% of the linear frontage of existing ground floor storefront retail space on the property; (d)the location of the accommodations use will not significantly increase automobile traffic on streets within residential districts; (e)the location of the accommodations use will contribute to the maintenance, or creation, of a diverse mixed-use district; (f)the total square footage of interior and exterior floor area for restaurant and bar space in the proposed accommodations use, including restaurant/bar patron use areas, bar areas, kitchen, storage, and bathroom facilities, shall not exceed 12 percent of the total interior, conditioned floor area in the accommodations use, except that each accommodations use shall be permitted to exempt from the calculation of total restaurant floor area one interior, ground floor restaurant tenant space if the total tenant space does not exceed 2,000 square feet, the restaurant tenant does not serve alcoholic beverages, and the exempt restaurant tenant space is clearly labeled with these restrictions on the floor plans submitted with the application for this zoning special exception; (g)the accommodations use proposed guest drop off and pick up area(s) is located outside the public right-of-way and on the property utilized for the accommodations use if the accommodations use contains more than 50 sleeping units, and if 50 sleeping units or less, the proposed guest drop off and pick up area(s) are located outside the public right-of-way if feasible, and the location and design of the guest drop-off and pick-up area(s) has been reviewed by the Department of Traffic and Transportation and determined to be safe and not be an impediment to traffic and that every effort has been made to minimize traffic impacts; (h)the total number of sleeping units within the buildings or structures on the lot or parcel in which the accommodations use is located is equal to or exceeds ten (10) sleeping units. (i)within areas of the accommodations overlay zone designated as "A-1", "A-2", "A-3", "A-4", "A-5", "A-6", or "A-7" on the zoning map, the number of sleeping units within the buildings or structures on the lot or parcel in which the accommodations use is located shall not exceed 50 in areas designated "A-1"; 180 in areas designated "A-2"; 225 in areas designated "A-3"; 100 in areas designated "A- 4"; 150 in areas designated "A-5"; 69 in areas designated "A-6"; and 175 in areas designated "A- 7"; provided, however, that within the portion of the area designated "A-1" bounded by King Street on the west, Meeting Street on the east, Mary Street on the south and Line Street on the north (the "Full-Service Corridor"), the number of sleeping units within the buildings or structures on the lot or parcel in which the accommodations use is located may exceed 50, but shall not exceed 250, if the accommodations use qualifies as a Full-Service Hotel, meaning that the accommodations use provides 20,000 or more square feet of meeting, conference and banquet space of which 15,000 square feet thereof is contiguous, an on-site restaurant that serves breakfast, lunch and dinner seven days a week and other services such as a concierge, a spa/health club, laundry, turndown service, newspaper delivery, security personnel and airport shuttle; and in no event shall any accommodations use on the peninsula exceed 250 sleeping units; Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 44 State St. Page 3 (j)the proposed accommodations use will not share any of its buildings, structures, facilities, or operations with another accommodations use; (k) (1)The proposed accommodations use, if located in the accommodations overlay on the peninsula, incorporates meeting and conference space at a ratio of 400 square feet per 10 sleeping units, or fraction thereof, with respect to the first 150 sleeping units, and incorporates meeting and conference space at a ratio of 1000 square feet for every 10 sleeping units, or fraction thereof, exceeding 150 sleeping units. In either case, at least 75% of the meeting and conference space shall be contiguous; (2)Notwithstanding subsection k(1) hereof, if the accommodations use contains more than 50 sleeping units and is located in the Full-Service Corridor, the provisions of subsection (i) hereof shall govern the square footage of required meeting and conference space; (l)the proposed accommodations use will not result in there being more than eight (8) Full-Service Hotels on the peninsula, inclusive of those Full-Service Hotels existing on the peninsula and those with approved special exceptions as of the effective date of the ordinance from which this section derives; for purposes of this subsection (l) only, a Full-Service Hotel means a Full-Service Hotel as defined in subsection (i) having in excess of 150 sleeping units; and (m)to assist in providing affordable housing opportunities for its employees, the applicant for the accommodations use commits to contribute to the City of Charleston Affordable/Workforce Housing Account a fee payable upon the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, calculated as follows: $5.10 per square foot of area used for sleeping units and the hallways adjacent to sleeping units, stairwells and elevators. C. Application requirements. In making the findings required in subsection b.1, the Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning shall consider the following information to be provided by the applicant in site plans, floor plans and building elevations that will govern the construction of the building in which the accommodations use is located, along with a detailed written assessment report to be submitted with the application: 1.The number of existing dwelling units on the property, including units on the property that were occupied as dwelling units within five years of the date of the application for the exception, the type of unit (rental or owner-occupied; one-family detached; one-family attached; two-family or multi- family; occupied or unoccupied), by income range of the most recent occupant(s), the rental price for rental units and market price for owner occupied units relative to the area median income figures that are determined annually by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and adjusted by the City of Charleston Department of Housing and Community Development, or its successor, the physical condition of the units (sound, deficient, deteriorated or dilapidated), the square footage and number of bedrooms in each unit, and if the units are proposed to be physically altered or replaced, a description and plan showing the square footage and number of bedrooms in the altered or replaced units, and their location; 2.The effect of the physical alteration or replacement or relocation of dwelling units on the housing stock of a particular type on the property and whether a condition should be attached to a special exception approval for the accommodations use requiring a minimum percentage of the dwelling units on the property or replaced off-site to remain affordable based on the annually updated median area income values; 3.The presence of office space on the property, or the presence of spaces on the property that were occupied as office spaces within five years of the date of application for the exception; Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 44 State St. Page 4 4.The linear frontage of existing ground floor storefront retail space on the property; 5.The location and design of guest drop off and pick up areas for the accommodations use; 6.The cumulative number of vehicle trips generated by the proposed accommodations use and other accommodations uses that are either existing or approved within an area identified by the Department of Traffic and Transportation, the traffic circulation pattern serving the accommodations use and efforts made to minimize traffic impacts; 7.The distance of the main entrance and parking entrance of the accommodations use from a road classified as an arterial or collector road; 8.The land uses within five hundred feet (500') of the accommodations use, to include the location, square footage, and number of rooms in existing accommodations uses and accommodations uses that have been approved; 9.The proximity of residential districts to the accommodations use; 10.The accessory uses proposed for the accommodations use, such as restaurants, spas, bars, pools and the like, in terms of their location, size, impact on parking, traffic generation, noise or odors in or to a residential district; 11.The demonstrated provision of off-street parking at the rate of two spaces that meet the design requirements of section 54-318 for each three sleeping units, provided however, the utilization of mechanical or other means of parking that meet the ratio of two spaces for each three sleeping units shall be allowed; 12.The presence of industrial uses and uses which use, store, or produce toxic or hazardous materials in quantities in excess of those specified by the EPA listing of toxic and hazardous materials, within five hundred feet (500') of the accommodations use; 13.The commitment to environmental sustainability and recycling; 14.The distance of the accommodations use from major tourist attractions; 15.The distance of the accommodations use from existing or planned transit facilities; 16.The long term provision of on- or off-site parking for employees who drive vehicles to work, including an estimate of the number of employees that will drive to work during the maximum shift and the location of parking spaces to be provided, and the demonstrated provision of free transit passes or other incentives to encourage employee use of public transportation; 17.The number of sleeping units proposed as part of the accommodations use; 18.The provision of shuttle bus services to and from the Historic Districts by accommodations uses with more than 50 sleeping units located outside the area designated "A-1" through "A-6" on the zoning map; 19.The commitment to make affirmative, good faith efforts to see that construction and procurement opportunities are available to MBEs (minority business enterprises) and WBEs (women business enterprises) as outlined in section 2-268 (e)(1), (2), and (3) of the Code of the City of Charleston; Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 44 State St. Page 5 20.The commitment to make affirmative, good faith efforts to hire personnel, representative of the population of the Charleston community, at all employment levels. D. Violations: In addition to any remedies otherwise available to the City under State law or the City Code, a violation by the owner or operator of the accommodations use of any provisions or conditions of an exception granted hereunder, to include any deviation from the plans and written assessment as required by subsection c. hereof, shall subject the owner or operator of the accommodations use to having its business license and/or certificate of occupancy revoked. E. Applicability: The provisions of this Section 54-220 shall apply to special exceptions for accommodations uses granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning after May 28, 2019, it being the intent of City Council that special exceptions approved by the Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning prior to May 28, 2019 be entitled to and governed by the vested rights provisions accorded by Article 9, Part 5 of this Chapter. The provisions of this Section 54-220 shall not apply to Planned Unit Developments that include accommodations uses as an authorized use that were approved as of May 28, 2019. Special Exception Requirements/ Findings of Fact: For Special Exception requests, applicants should list the specific approval(s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as § 54-110, § 54-206, or sections in Article 5: Applicants Responses: Section 54-220(b)(1)(a): No Net Loss of Dwelling Units STANDARD: the accommodations use will not result in a net loss of dwelling units that have been occupied within five years of the date of application for the exception; provided however, the BZA-Z may approve the alteration or replacement of such existing dwelling units on the same site as the accommodations use, or within a radius of one quarter (¼) mile from the site if the proposed off site location does not result in an over concentration of low income households, as defined by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, as adjusted by the Department of Housing and Community Development; and provided further, the BZA-Z shall require any such alteration or replacement to include dwelling units of substantially the same size and type of those being altered or replaced and shall require that no certificate of occupancy shall be issued for the accommodations uses until either a certificate of occupancy has been issued for all dwelling units being altered or replaced or irrevocable bonds or letters of credit in favor of the City in amounts equivalent to one hundred twenty-five (125%) percent of the costs to complete construction or renovation of the dwelling units, as determined by the Chief Building Inspector, has been filed with the City. Response – The property was acquired by the current owner on June 21, 2021, approximately five years prior to the date of this application. With approval from the architectural review board and town building officials, the property has been converted to two residential dwelling units, an increase in the overall number of dwelling units for this specific building. Prior to acquisition by the current owner Mr. Abreu, 44 State Street housed at least one apartment and the law office of Slotchiver and Slotchiver. The building was owned from 1983 until 2021 by Carole and Irvin Slotchiver. Based on this history there is no net loss of dwelling units occupied within five years of the dates of the application. Section 54-220(b)(1)(b): Minimize Displacement of Office Space. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 44 State St. Page 6 STANDARD: the accommodations use, if located in the Accommodations Overlay on the peninsula, will not reduce or displace more than 25% of office space that has been used for such purpose within five years of the application for the exception; Response – Based on information from the prior owner, at one point 44 State Street, under Slotchiver ownership, included 4395 square feet of law office space and an unknown portion for residential accommodations. The property was vacant and listed for sale in 2020. The applicant believes any commercial space on the property has not been in use within 5 years of this application. Section 54-220(b)(1)(c): Minimize Displacement of Existing Retail Space. STANDARD: the accommodations use, if located in the Accommodations Overlay on the peninsula, will not reduce or displace more than 25% of the linear frontage of existing ground floor storefront retail space on the property. Response – The property was not utilized for retail at the time the current owners purchased the property and is not currently being used for retail. Section 54-220(b)(1)(d): Traffic Impacts on Residential Streets. STANDARD: the location of the accommodations use will not significantly increase automobile traffic on streets within residential districts Response – When the property was purchased by the current owners it included five electric meters potentially qualifying for ten parking permits if each unit had been separately rented. With the renovations, Mr. Abreu reduced the number of electric meters to two and the property is only allowed 4 residential parking permits on State Street. The reduction from 10 cars to 4 cars would indicate a reduction in vehicular traffic from the prior use. The Applicant expects that most renters who rent for 3 days or fewer will use Uber (or similar service) to get in and out of the City. However, if parking is needed, renters will be required to use the parking spaces in the nearby garage that the owner has leased. Also, daily street passes will not be given to renters. The owner understands the traffic issue, and he wishes to not encourage more street activity and cars. This proposed solution should effectively remove street crowding, not contribute to it. Section 54-220(b)(1)(e): Contribute to Diverse Mixed-Use District. STANDARD: the location of the accommodations use will contribute to the maintenance, or creation, of a diverse mixed-use district Response –The attached Exhibit from the City’s zoning map indicates the proximity of structures in this area with the dominant structures being those associated with the Lodge Alley Inn. The area remains as diverse as possible, with Lodge Alley Inn as dominant as it is in the area. Other uses within the block are 46 A and 15 Lodge Alley (46 D State Street), housing a law office and an apartment. 46 B is used for culinary tours. The owners are not certain of the use of 46 C. The Anglin Smith Gallery and the Horton Hayes Gallery are located on opposite corners of State and Queen Streets. 189 East Bay is the High Cotton Restaurant. Also, it should be noted that the accommodation overlay zone ends at 44 State Street and Lodge Alley on State Street. Section 54-220(b)(1)(f): Limitation on Restaurant and Bar Space. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 44 State St. Page 7 STANDARD: the total square footage of interior and exterior floor area for restaurant and bar space in the proposed accommodations use, including restaurant/bar patron use areas, bar areas, kitchen, storage, and bathroom facilities, shall not exceed 12 percent of the total interior, conditioned floor area in the accommodations use, except that each accommodations use shall be permitted to exempt from the calculation of total restaurant floor area one interior, ground floor restaurant tenant space if the total tenant space does not exceed 2,000 square feet, the restaurant tenant does not serve alcoholic beverages, and the exempt restaurant tenant space is clearly labeled with these restrictions on the floor plans submitted with the application for this zoning special exception Response – The owner has no intention or desire to create restaurant and/or bar space within 44 State Street. Therefore, these requirements are inapplicable. Section 54-220(b)(1)(g): Location of Guest Drop-off and Pick-up. STANDARD: the accommodations use proposed guest drop off and pick up area(s) is located outside the public right-of-way and on the property utilized for the accommodations use if the accommodations use contains more than 50 sleeping units, and if 50 sleeping units or less, the proposed guest drop off and pick up area(s) are located outside the public right-of-way if feasible, and the location and design of the guest drop-off and pick-up area(s) has been reviewed by the Department of Traffic and Transportation and determined to be safe and not be an impediment to traffic and that every effort has been made to minimize traffic impacts; Response – The accommodation use contains less than 50 sleeping units. The proposed guest drop off and pick-up area(s) would be at the curb in front of the building or at the leased garage spaces obtained by Mr. Abreu and should not be an impediment to the public right of way. The owners have secured off street parking for both units at a lot within two city blocks of the building. It is expected that most short-term renters are travelers staying for 3 or 4 days and will use Uber (or similar service) to be dropped off in front of the building. Section 54-220(b)(1)(h): Minimum Number of Sleeping Units. STANDARD: the total number of sleeping units within the buildings or structures on the lot or parcel in which the accommodations use is located is equal to or exceeds ten (10) sleeping units. Response – Each unit has sleeping accommodations for 5 adults for a total of 10 adults. However, the intent is to limit the number of adults to 4 within each unit, consistent with the existing short term rental ordinance. This additional restriction will prevent overcrowding of this historically significant building and be supportive of the building’s maintenance and the broader community impact. Section 54-220(b)(1)(i): Maximum Number of Sleeping Units. STANDARD: The number of sleeping units within the buildings or structures on the lot or parcel in which the accommodations use is located shall not exceed 50. Response – The property’s sleeping accommodations will be limited to 8 total adults across the two units. Section 54-220(b)(1)(j): Restriction on Shared Facilities. STANDARD: the proposed accommodations use will not share any of its buildings, structures, facilities, or operations with another accommodations use; Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 44 State St. Page 8 Response – The property owner does not share its building, structures, or facilities with another accommodation use and does not have any plans to do so in the future. Section 54-220(b)(1)(k): Meeting and Conference Space. STANDARD: (1) The proposed accommodations use , if located in the accommodations overlay on the peninsula, incorporates meeting and conference space at a ratio of 400 square feet per 10 sleeping units, or fraction thereof, with respect to the first 150 sleeping units, and incorporates meeting and conference space at a ratio of 1000 square feet for every 10 sleeping units, or fraction thereof, exceeding 150 sleeping units. In either case, at least 75% of the meeting and conference space shall be contiguous; (2) Notwithstanding subsection k(1) hereof, if the accommodations use contains more than 50 sleeping units and is located in the Full-Service Corridor, the provisions of subsection (i) hereof shall govern the square footage of required meeting and conference space. Response –Not applicable. This property does not have meeting or conference space. Section 54-220(b)(1)(l): Restriction on Number of Full-Service Hotels on the Peninsula. STANDARD: the proposed accommodations use will not result in there being more than eight (8) FullService Hotels on the peninsula, inclusive of those Full-Service Hotels existing on the peninsula and those with approved special exceptions as of the effective date of the ordinance from which this section derives; for purposes of this subsection (l) only, a Full-Service Hotel means a Full-Service Hotel as defined in subsection (i) having in excess of 150 sleeping units Response - The property owner is not operating a full-service hotel nor is there an intent to convert the property to a full-service hotel. Section 54-220(b)(1)(m): Commitment for Affordable/Workforce Housing Contribution. STANDARD: to assist in providing affordable housing opportunities for its employees, the applicant for the accommodations use commits to contribute to the City of Charleston Affordable/Workforce Housing Account a fee payable upon the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, calculated as follows: $5.10 per square foot of area used for sleeping units and the hallways adjacent to sleeping units, stairwells and elevators Response – The applicant has no objection to, and will pay, the fee of $5.10 per square foot of area used for sleeping units and the hallways adjacent to sleeping units, stairwells, and elevators. SECTION 54-220(C) APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS. Section 54-220(c)(1): Impact to Dwelling Units on the Property. REQUIREMENT: The number of existing dwelling units on the property, including units on the property that were occupied as dwelling units within five years of the date of the application for the exception, the type of unit (rental or owner-occupied; one-family detached; one-family attached; two-family or multifamily; occupied or unoccupied), by income range of the most recent occupant(s), the rental price for rental units and market price for owner occupied units relative to the area median income figures that are determined annually by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and adjusted by the City of Charleston Department of Housing and Community Development, or its successor, the physical condition of the units (sound, deficient, deteriorated or dilapidated), the square footage and number of bedrooms in each unit, and if the units are proposed to be physically altered or replaced, a description and plan showing the square footage and number of bedrooms in the altered or replaced units, and their Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 44 State St. Page 9 location; Response: There were approximately 5 apartments at one point on the property, but the property has been vacant since it was listed for sale in 2020 according to former owner. Section 54-220(c)(2): Impact to Housing Stock. REQUIREMENT: The effect of the physical alteration or replacement or relocation of dwelling units on the housing stock of a particular type on the property and whether a condition should be attached to a special exception approval for the accommodations use requiring a minimum percentage of the dwelling units on the property or replaced off-site to remain affordable based on the annually updated median area income values; Response: Not applicable as this application is not expected to have an effect on the available housing stock in this area. Section 54-220(c)(3): Presence of Office Space. REQUIREMENT: The presence of office space on the property, or the presence of spaces on the property that were occupied as office spaces within five years of the date of application for the exception; Response: There was a law office located on the property but according to Steven Slotchiver that office was relocated to a Mt. Pleasant building in approximately 2018. Section 54-220(c)(4): Linear Frontage. REQUIREMENT: The linear frontage of existing ground floor storefront retail space on the property; Response: None Section 54-220(c)(5): Guest Drop Off and Pick Up. REQUIREMENT: The location and design of guest drop off and pick up areas for the accommodations use; Response: State Street/Lodge Alley Section 54-220(c)(6): Traffic Impact. REQUIREMENT: The cumulative number of vehicle trips generated by the proposed accommodations use and other accommodations uses that are either existing or approved within an area identified by the Department of Traffic and Transportation, the traffic circulation pattern serving the accommodations use and efforts made to minimize traffic impacts; Response: Based on the location of 44 State Street, in the center of Historic Charleston, it is not expected that the proposed use will have any significant impact on the vehicle trips in this area or the traffic circulation. As noted above, it is expected that vehicles used to access the property will be local ride sharing services such as Uber or Lyft. Section 54-220(c)(7): Distance to Arterial or Collector Road. REQUIREMENT: The distance of the main entrance and parking entrance of the accommodations use from Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 44 State St. Page 10 a road classified as an arterial or collector road; Response: 44 State Street is located approximately 360 feet, the length of Lodge Alley, from East Bay Street. Section 54-220(c)(8): Neighboring Land Uses. REQUIREMENT: The land uses within five hundred feet (500') of the accommodations use, to include the location, square footage, and number of rooms in existing accommodations uses and accommodations uses that have been approved; Response: Within the block and the properties surrounding 44 State Street we estimate that there is short term rental available for at least 160 occupants. We estimate that at least 150 of those are associated with the Lodge Alley Inn and the remaining are associated with the two short term rental units that are part of 46 State Street (46 E & F). The attached exhibit indicates the proximity of structures in this area with the dominant structures being those associated with the Lodge Alley Inn. The area remains as diverse as possible, with Lodge Alley Inn as dominant as it is in the area. Other uses within the block are 46 A and 46 D, housing a law office and an apartment. 46 B is used for culinary tours and the owners are not certain of the use of 46 C. 189 East Bay is the High Cotton Restaurant. Also, it should be noted that the accommodation overlay zone ends at 44 State Street and Lodge Alley on State Street. Section 54-220(c)(9): Proximity of Residential Districts. REQUIREMENT: The proximity of residential districts to the accommodations use; Response: There exist both full-time residences and rental properties (both long-term and short-term) on State Street. Section 54-220(c)(10): Accessory Uses. REQUIREMENT: The accessory uses proposed for the accommodations use, such as restaurants, spas, bars, pools and the like, in terms of their location, size, impact on parking, traffic generation, noise or odors in or to a residential district; Response: No accessory uses are proposed for the accommodations use. Section 54-220(c)(11): Off-Street Parking. REQUIREMENT: The demonstrated provision of off-street parking at the rate of two spaces that meet the design requirements of section 54-318 for each three sleeping units, provided however, the utilization of mechanical or other means of parking that meet the ratio of two spaces for each three sleeping units shall be allowed; Response: Owner/Applicant has secured off-street parking for two vehicles Section 54-220(c)(12): Presence of Industrial or Other Uses Which Produce Excessive Hazardous Materials. REQUIREMENT: The presence of industrial uses and uses which use, store, or produce toxic or hazardous materials in quantities in excess of those specified by the EPA listing of toxic and hazardous materials, within five hundred feet (500') of the accommodations use; Response: None known. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 44 State St. Page 11 Section 54-220(c)(13): Commitment to Environmental Sustainability. REQUIREMENT: The commitment to environmental sustainability and recycling; Response: Owner/Applicant will provide for recycling and proper disposal. Section 54-220(c)(14): Distance from Major Tourist Attractions. REQUIREMENT: The distance of the accommodations use from major tourist attractions; Response: The City Market and many downtown Charleston tourist attractions are within walking distance from 44 State Street. Section 54-220(c)(15): Distance from Planned Transit Facilities. REQUIREMENT: The distance of the accommodations use from existing or planned transit facilities; Response: The DASH route includes the French Quarter and is accessible to 44 State Street.. Section 54-220(c)(16): Employee Parking. REQUIREMENT: The long term provision of on- or off-site parking for employees who drive vehicles to work, including an estimate of the number of employees that will drive to work during the maximum shift and the location of parking spaces to be provided, and the demonstrated provision of free transit passes or other incentives to encourage employee use of public transportation; Response: The owner/applicant has no employees for the proposed short-term rental but has hired a local property manager, AvantStay, to ensure the proper maintenance and parking ordinances are supervised. Section 54-220(c)(17): Proposed Sleeping Units. REQUIREMENT: The number of sleeping units proposed as part of the accommodations use; Response: Two units that sleep a total of 10 adults but will be limited to 8 adults. Section 54-220(c)(18): Provision of Shuttle Servies. REQUIREMENT: The provision of shuttle bus services to and from the Historic Districts by accommodations uses with more than 50 sleeping units located outside the area designated "A-1" through "A-6" on the zoning map; Response: Not applicable as refers to accommodations of 50 or more units. Section 54-220(c)(19): Commitment to Opportunities for MBEs and WBEs. REQUIREMENT: The commitment to make affirmative, good faith efforts to see that construction and procurement opportunities are available to MBEs (minority business enterprises) and WBEs (women business enterprises) as outlined in section 2-268 (e)(1), (2), and (3) of the Code of the City of Charleston; Response: Not applicable as 44 State Street renovation is complete. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 44 State St. Page 12 Section 54-220(c)(20): Commitment to Hire Personnel Representative of the Population of Charleston Community. REQUIREMENT: The commitment to make affirmative, good faith efforts to hire personnel, representative of the population of the Charleston community, at all employment levels. Response: Not applicable as no hiring is anticipated. Staff Recommendation: Recommends Denial Staff Analysis: Staff are recommending denial of the special exception request due to the applicant not meeting all the conditions outlined in Sec. 54-220(b). Attachments: • Application • Zoning Map • Site Plan Staff Contact: • Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov +$5':$5(6(76 6+((7127(6 67$,560867 %(5(&216758&7(' *5281')/225'2256&+('8/( '225&21),*85$7,216 6/,',1*3$7,2 3$7,2)5(1&+ ( 1(::,1'2:6$1'(;7(5,25 '22560867%(,03$&75$7(' &   +LVWRULF5HQRYDWLRQ 6WDWH6WUHHW &KDUOHVWRQ6RXWK&DUROLQD 5(96)2567$,5 3/$15(9,6,216 $''522)67$,5 6758&785$/&25    X 0D\, 2026 44 State Street 458-09-01-137 Lot 3C Bradley Circle, LLC John A. Massalon 843-727-1144 860-810-8173 P.O. Box 859, Charleston, SC 29402 jmassalon@wmalawfirm.net Attorney X X X GB/Accomodations Overlay s/John A. Massalon 3/30/2026 See attachment CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 82 Maple St. SPECIAL EXCEPTION CASE SUMMARY May 5, 2026 | 5:15 p.m. Case Number: BZA2026-002347 Subject Property: 82 Maple St. / TMS# 463-11-02-053 Zoning District: SR-2 Property Owner: Abby Robertson Applicant: Kim Williams Requested Action: Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-110 to vertically extend a nonconforming east side setback to construct a rear second-story addition. Project Description: Request Special Exception to vertically extend the existing nonconforming east side setback to construct a second-story addition. The proposed second story addition is comprised of a master bedroom addition with accompanying bathroom and walk-in closet. The proposed addition will not be visible from the public right-of-way. Case History: Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-110.f. NON-CONFORMING USES The non-conforming use of a building or structure cannot be physically extended to provide more area for the non-conforming use, and the number of bedrooms in a non-conforming two-family dwelling or muli-family dwelling use cannot be increased, unless the Board of Zoning Appeals— Zoning, after a duly advertised public hearing, finds that the extension or increase of the non- conforming use is: (1) limited to extending or increasing the non-conforming use then in existence; and (2) would not result in an unreasonable intensification of the non-conforming use. In considering the reasonableness of the intensification of the extension or increase, the Board shall consider the effect of the extension or increase on properties in the vicinity to include traffic impacts; vehicular and pedestrian safety; parking impacts; potential impacts of noise, lighting, fumes or obstruction of air flow or light on adjoining property; impacts on the aesthetic character of the environs, to include the possible need for screening. If an extension or increase is permitted, the Board may imposed reasonable and appropriate conditions and safeguards for the protection of the public interest and neighboring properties, including but not limited to, limitations on the days and hours during which the proposed use may be operated, and shall require, for properties located in the Old and Historic District, that exterior alterations be approved by the Board of Architectural Review, regardless of whether said alterations are visible from a public street or thoroughfare. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 82 Maple St Page 2 Special Exception Requirements/ Findings of Fact: For Special Exception requests, applicants should list the specific approval(s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as § 54-110, § 54-206, or sections in Article 5: Applicants Response: Sec.54-110 The Board shall consider the effect of the extension or increase on properties in the vicinity to include traffic impacts; vehicular and pedestrian safety; parking impacts; potential impacts of noise, lighting, fumes or obstruction of air flow or light on adjoining property; impacts on the aesthetic character of the environs, to include the possible need for screening. The existing structure is located within the setback. Our request is to build a second story over the are that is nonconforming. Staff Recommendation: Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: Staff are recommending approval of the request for special exception due to the proposed modifications to the existing home being limited to increasing the non-conforming use in existence; and would not result in an unreasonable intensification of the non-conforming use. Attachments: • Application • Zoning Map • Site Plan Staff Contact: • Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov N40'40' 40'40' 114.5'114.5'114.5'114.5' 9' SETBACK 9' SETBACK 5' FIRE PROTECTION ZONE EXISTINGMAIN HOUSE EXISTING SINGLESTORY ADDITIONNEW SECONDSTORY EXISTINGDECK EXISTINGSHED 15'15' 15'15' 26'3"26'3" 23'3"23'3" 20'6"20'6" EXISTINGPATIO EXISTINGDRIVEWAY 38'8"38'8" EXISTINGSTAIRS &PATH 82 MAPLE STREET CHARLESTON, SC 29403 SHEET NUMBER DATE: THE ROBERTSON/HUGHEY RESIDENCE SCALE AS NOTED CCOVER PAGE PROJECT INFOTMS# 463-11-02-053Zoning Classification: SR-2Flood Zone: XProperty Setbacks:Front: 25'S/W Setback: 9'N/E Setback: 9'Rear: 25' Lot Occupancy Info: 50%Lot Area: 4791 SFMaximum Building Coverage Allowed: 2396 SFExisting Building Coverage: 1,903 SFProposed Building Coverage: 1,903 SFHeated Square Footage Calculations: Existing: First Floor: 1130 SF Second Floor: 780 SFTotal: 1910 SFProposed: First Floor: 1130 SF Second Floor: 1130 SFTotal: 2260 SF 03.13.2026PROPOSED SITE PLAN - NO FOOTPRINT CHANGESSCALE: 1" = 10'-0" CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 17 Guerard Rd VARIANCE CASE SUMMARY May 5, 2026 | 5:15pm Case Number: BZA2026-002348 Subject Property: 17 Guerard Rd. / TMS# 421-14-00-052 Zoning District: SR-8 Property Owners: Josh & Emily Broome Applicant: Amber Aument Requested Action: Request Variance from Sec. 54-301 to build a rear addition with a 7’ west side setback (9’ required). Project Description: The applicant is requesting a variance to construct a rear addition comprised of an expansion of the existing primary bedroom. The area of the proposed rear addition encroaching within the 9’ west side setback is comprised of a small portion of the proposed primary bedroom expansion. The encroachment is variable, due to the angle of the property line the encroachment gradually increases from 0’ to 2’ at its greatest depth of encroachment. Case History: Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-301 Height, area and setback regulations The setbacks for the SR-8 Zoning District are as follows: Front: In the SR-8 district, no building shall be built with a front setback closer to, or further back from the front property line, than the average front setback of the buildings on the lots on either side of the lot upon which the building is to be built, plus or minus 5 feet. In the event there are no buildings on both sides of the lot on which the building is to be built, the front setback shall be the same as the building on the lot on the same side of the street adjacent to the lot upon which the building is to be built. Rear: 25’ South/West Side: 9’ North/East Side: 9’ Variance Test/ Findings of Fact: The following is excerpted from Section 54-924 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. This test is based on S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-800. A variance may be granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 17 Guerard Rd. Page 2 Applicant Responses: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; See plans 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; See plans 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and See plans 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. See plans Staff Recommendation: Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: Staff are recommending approval of the variance due to the odd shape of the lot resulting in an angled setback line that prevents the reasonable expansion of the home consistent with the existing west side façade. Attachments: • Zoning Map • Site Map • Application Staff Contact: Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov PERVIOUS DRIVE NEWSCREENEDPORCH NEW CARPORT REDUCED FRONT PORCH SF PERVIOUS DRIVE 16' SIDE SETBACK 9' SIDE SETBACK 25' REAR SETBACK TURF LAWNNEWHEATED EXISTING FOOTPRINT TO REMAIN 17 GUERARD RD LOT INFORMATION LOT SIZE: 24,040 SF LOT WIDTH: 94'-0" LOT DEPTH: 89'-0" FLOOD ZONE: X TMS #: 421-14-00-052 PRINCIPAL BUILDING AREA PRINCIPAL BUILDING COVERAGE IMPERVIOUS COVERAGE MAX HEIGHTMAX PERMITTED : 35'-0"EXISTING : 23'-6" ZONING: SR-8 CHARLESTON, SC 29407 MAX PERMITTED (25%) : 6,010 SF PROPOSED : 5,159 SF FIRST FLOOR HEATED SF: 3,193 SF SECOND FLOOR HEATED SF: 896 SF FRONT PORCH SF: 124 SF GARAGE SF: 100 SF MAX PERMITTED (40%) : 9,616 SF EXISTING : 4,176 SF FIRST FLOOR HEATED SF: 2,540 SF SECOND FLOOR HEATED SF: 974 SF FRONT PORCH SF: 204 SF GARAGE SF: 458 SF CARPORT SF: 565 SF PROPOSED (17.7%): 4,263 SF EXISTING (13.3%): 3,202 SF FIRST FLOOR HEATED SF: 2,540 SF FRONT PORCH SF: 204 SF GARAGE SF: 458 SF PROPOSED (18.4%): 4,427 SF EXISTING (15.9%): 3,828 SF FIRST FLOOR HEATED SF: 2,540 SF FRONT PORCH SF: 204 SF GARAGE SF: 458 SF AC SF: 32 SF AC SF: 32 SF STEPS SF: 132 SF DECKS + STEPS SF: 594 SF PROPOSED : 23'-6" SCREENED PORCH SF: 281 SF FIRST FLOOR HEATED SF: 3,193 SF FRONT PORCH SF: 124 SF GARAGE SF: 100 SF CARPORT SF: 565 SF SCREENED PORCH SF: 281 SF FIRST FLOOR HEATED SF: 3,193 SF FRONT PORCH SF: 124 SF GARAGE SF: 100 SF CARPORT SF: 565 SF SCREENED PORCH SF: 281 SF 696 KING ST.CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA 29403T. 843.822.0426AUMENT DESIGN STUDIO PROJECT: 17 GUERARD ROADDATE: BZA-Z SUB. 04.03.26, HEARING 05.05.26SHEET:S3 scale: 1" = 10'-0" Instructions – NOTE: APPLICATION P ROCEDURE HAS CHANGED. This application, along with the required information, must be submitted in PDF format to BZA-Z@charleston-sc.gov. Applicant will then be invoiced for fee. Applications are due by 12 Noon on the deadline date and must be complete to be accepted and placed on an agenda. A sign will be posted on the property, and a public hearing will be conducted by the Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning. Permits authorized by the Board cannot be issued during a five (5) business day appeal period following the decision of the Board, except for use variances, the appeal period shall be fifteen (15) calendar days. An appeal to the Board during this appeal period stays all further action on the application. THE APPLICANT HEREBY REQUESTS: A Variance and/or Special Exception as indicated on page 2 of this application. Reconsideration of a decision of the Board or action of a zoning official (attach Appeal form). Extension of an unexpired Variance and/or Special Exception approval. MEETING DATE REQUESTED: Property Address TMS # Property Owner Daytime Phone Applicant Daytime Phone Applicant’s Mailing Address E-mail Address Relationship of applicant to owner (same, representative, prospective buyer, other) Zoning of property Information required with application: (check information submitted) Scaled plans or plats, including elevations, showing the variance(s) or special exception(s) being requested For new construction or additions within a flood zone, show HVAC units and platform on scaled plan Scaled floor plans with rooms labeled and the total floor area for each dwelling unit noted are required for a l l density variances and building additions, unless exempted by the Zoning staff Plans or documents necessary to show compliance with special exception requirements YES or NO - Is this Property restricted by any recorded covenant that is contrary to, conflicts with or prohibits t h e proposed land use encompassed in this permit application? § 6-29-1145 of the South Carolina Code of Laws Optional but very helpful information : Photographs Letters or petitions from neighbors or organizations directly affected by your request I certify that the information on this application and any attachments is correct, that the proposed improvement(s) comply with private neighborhood coven ants, if there are any, and that I am the owner of the subject property or the authorized representative of the owner. I authorize the subject property to be posted with a notice of the Board hearing and inspected. Applicant Date City of Charleston Page 1 of 2 Application for Variance, Special Exception, Reconsideration, or Extension to the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning (BZA-Z) Time application received Receipt # Fee $ For office use only Date application received Staffperson 05.06.2026 17 Guerard Road 421-14-00-052 Josh and Emily Broome 843.364.4771 Amber Aument 843.822.0426 1 Cool Blow St. Unit 136. Charleston, SC 29401 amber@amberaument.com Design Professional Sr-8 Amber Aument 04.02.26 BZA-Z Application (continued) Page 2 of 2 For Variance requests, applicants should list the specific variance(s) being requested and, if possible, explain how the variance test that follows is met (add as an attachment if necessary): Variance Test: The Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning is authorized to approve a variance from the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6-29-800) For Special Exception requests, applic ants should list the specific approval(s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as § 54-110, § 54-206, or sections in Article 5 (add as an attachment if necessary): All approvals of the Board shall remain valid for two (2) years from the approval date, unless extended in accordance with the provisions of Article 9, Part 5 of the zoning ordinance. Applicants may not apply for the same request that has been denied by the Board until a period of six (6) months has lapsed. 11/23 Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability 2 George Street Charleston, South Carolina 29401 (843) 724-3781 www.charleston-sc.gov/zoning See attached application. CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 262 Captain Goddard Rd. VARIANCE CASE SUMMARY May 5, 2026 | 5:15pm Case Number: BZA2026-002349 Subject Property: 262 Captain Goddard Rd / TMS# 276-02-02-048 Zoning District: DI-RI Property Owners: Justin & Tiffani Iselin Applicant: Cara Schnedier – Dillard Jones Builders Requested Action: Request variance from Sec. 54-263 Daniel Island Master Plan zoning regulations to allow a bridge to encroach 5’ into the required 10’ visual buffer zone setback. Project Description: The applicant is requesting a variance to construct a bridge within the required 10’ visual buffer zone. The bridge is intended to provide access to the high-ground rear portion of the lot where a detached single-family dwelling unit will be constructed. Case History: This request was previously approved by the BZA-Z during the 5/15/2022 meeting. The vested rights of the previous approval expired on 12/31/2025 with the end of the South Carolina Permit Extension Joint Resolution of 2023. Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-263 – Daniel Island Maste Plan Zoning Text Within the DI-PUD District, land may be used and buildings erected, altered, or used pursuant to the Daniel Island Master Plan Zoning Text, adopted by Ordinance 1993- 32 on March 23, 1993; and amended by Ordinance 1994-440 on December 20, 1994, and Ordinance 1995-160 on May 9, 1995; and Ord. No. 2015-075, §§ 1, 2, on July 21, 2015; and amended by Ord. No. 2015-141, §§ 1, 2, on October 13, 2015; and amended by Ord. No. 2019-023, on April 9, 2019; and amended by Ord. No. 2020-003, on Jan. 14, 2020; and amended by Ord. No. 2020-075, June 9, 2020, and amended by Ord. No. 2023-249, on December 5, 2023, made a part hereof. 4.1(12) Visual Buffer Zone Setback. The minimum setback from the Visual Buffer Zone for principal and accessory buildings is 10 feet, except as permitted in Section 8: Exceptions to Lot and Building Regulations. Rear and side yards are allowed in the platted Visual Buffer Zone, but buildings and other land disturbance activities are prohibited. Variance Test/ Findings of Fact: The following is excerpted from Section 54-924 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. This test is based on S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-800. A variance may be Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 262 Captain Goddard Rd. Page 2 granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: Applicant Responses: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; See narrative 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; See narrative . 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and See narrative . 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. See narrative Narrative: Requesting extension on previously approved zoning (BZA2021-001442) request to provide variance request for a bridge for vehicle access for a proposed single-family residence. Bridge will encroach into the 10-ft setback required from visual buffer zone. Staff Recommendation: Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: In accordance with the previous approval granted on 5/15/2022 and with no change or alteration between the previously approved plans and those submitted by the applicant staff are recommending approval of the variance request. Attachments: • Zoning Map • Site Map • Application Staff Contact: Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov A-1.1 SITE PLAN W/GROUND FLOOR SITE PLAN 1 SCALE 1" = 20'-0" SITE PLAN 1 SCALE 1" = 20'-0" PROPERTY IS LOCATED IN SPECIAL FLOOD ZONE AE-10 & 11 LOT COVERAGE CALC. LOT SQUARE FOOTAGE 79873 S.F BUILDING FOOTPRINT MAIN 5128 S.F DRIVEWAY, STEPS AND WALKS 9401 S.F. POOL 606 S.F. TOTAL 15135 S.F. LOT COVERAGE= 15135/79873 18% LOT MAY BE SUBJECT TO EASEMENTS AND RESTRICTIONS PROPERTY APPEARS TO LIE IN FLOOD ZONE PARKER LAND SURVEYING, LLC 5910 GRIFFIN STREET, HANAHAN, SC 29410 TEL: (843) 554-7777 FAX: (843) 554-7779 DATE: SHOWING LOT LOCATED SCALE: 1" = REFERENCE: NOT OBVIOUS OR APPARENT TO THE SURVEYOR. FEMA REVISION CHECK: LAUREN MAURICE WILDER S.C.P.L.S. No. 29523 TOPOGRAPHIC and TREE SURVEY DANIEL ISLAND PARK SUBDIVISION, PARCEL "FF", BLOCK "B" 22, TMS # NOT YET ASSIGNED IN THE CITY OF CHARLESTON, BERKELEY COUNTY, SC. 20' JUNE 18, 2020 AE (ELEV. 10 & 11), AND DIP-FF-B-22/ KRB PLAT RECORDED IN PLAT INST# 2020026168 of -26166-26169 VE (ELEV. 12) 45015C 0720 E, REVISED DECEMBER 7, 2018 7/7/20 7 7 7 7 6 6 6 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 N GRID LOT FF-B-22 79873 SQ. FT 1.834 ACRES N 78°44'15" W 144.46' N 05°09'12" E 90.52' L1 L2 L3 L4 N08°31'47"E 46.46' N00°58'31"E 27.73' N04°41'29"W 27.75' N05°54'52"E 43.52' N05°50'11"E 46.05' N04°22'31"W 23.92' 30.75' S38°00'50"E 17.84' S10°19'20"E 23.62' S47°17'24"W L5 L6 L7 L8 L9 L10 N 12°04'53" E 49.55' 24.32' N05°04'20"E L11 L12 L13 L14 L15 L16 L17 N04°10'26"W 30.06' L18 L19 L20 L21 N10°43'40"E 33.84' L22 L23 N23°31'34"E 37.19' N66°28'38"E 41.80' N83°20'41"E 39.75' 37.64' S33°54'21"E 54.97' S18°45'24"W S 00°48'14" W 57.53' 30.09' S11°54'02"E 40.15' S20°05'12"W S 33°46'39" E 46.54' S 79°09'22" E 66.27' L24 S 66°56'30" W 59.73' S 78°44'45" W 56.14' S23°53'13"W 47.63' S 30°18'36" W 52.67' S 36°14'27" W 52.89' L25 N71°09'42"E 32.56' N69°24'28"E 31.61' N 62°53'09" E 57.03' S 25°38'36" E 107.41' LOT FF-B-22 79873 SQ. FT 1.834 ACRES APROX. FLOOD LINE AE (ELEV. 11) VE (ELEV. 12) APROX. FLOOD LINE AE (ELEV. 10) AE (ELEV. 11) SURVEYED FOR AXON HOMES PROPERTY LINE WITH PROPERTY CORNER. ALL MONUMENTS ARE 1" OPEN PIPE W/CAP FOUND UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED NF = NOT FOUND C 1 LOT FF-B-21 LOT FF-B-23 PROPERTY OF DANIEL ISLAND ASSOCIATES LLC TMS# 275-00-00-092 MARSH JURISDICTIONAL FRESHWATER WETLAND O/S FF/B/2 MARSH MARSH 262 PROPERTY OF DANIEL ISLAND ASSOCIATES LLC TMS# 275-00-00-092 MARSH MARSH MARSH MARSH MARSH C A P T A I N G O D D A R D R O A D ( 5 0 ' R / W ) CURVE TABLE CURVE RADIUS LENGTH CHORD CHORD BEARING C1 150.00 116.96 114.02 S38°55'25"W LINE DATA LINE LENGTH BEARING L1 24.65' N07°01'32"W L2 8.30' N70°09'33"W L3 12.55' S05°01'22"W L4 27.16' S80°45'26"W L5 17.30' S21°45'10"W L6 17.23' S41°02'49"E L7 12.15' S57°46'42"E L8 12.94' N60°22'33"E L9 13.78' S48°56'48"E L10 18.57' S62°13'00"E L11 14.51' N30°05'09"W L12 10.25' N41°23'01"E L13 10.71' S73°07'20"E L14 18.85' N30°29'44"E L15 20.85' N49°51'17"W L16 15.10' N51°52'46"W L17 10.11' N37°03'17"W L18 16.28' N44°47'54"E L19 14.21' N22°05'07"W L20 21.23' N09°42'04"W L21 16.69' N38°14'15"E L22 30.39' N24°21'25"E L23 14.24' N30°20'36"E L24 26.56' S34°45'26"W L25 9.19' S32°18'56"E OCRM CRITICAL LINE PER RECORDED PLAT CERTIFIED 1/23/20 OCRM CRITICAL LINE PER RECORDED PLAT CERTIFIED 1/23/20 20' VISUAL BUFFER ZONE 25' OCRM BUFFER 10' VISUAL BUFFER ZONE 20' VISUAL BUFFER ZONE 25' OCRM BUFFER 10' VISUAL BUFFER ZONE 10' SETBACK 10' SETBACK 15' FRONT SETBACK 20 0 10 20 1 inch = 20 ft 116' TO CENTERLINE INTERSECTION OF CAPTAIN GODDARD ROAD ELEC. BOX MAN HOLE LIGHT POLE ELEC. BOX S 12°35'21" W 19.92' TO 1" OPEN PIPE W/CAP FOUND WM DITCH DITCH NF NF NAIL IN TREE ROOT FOUND NF NF NF NF NF NAIL IN TREE ROOT FOUND NF NF NF NF NF NF NF NF NF BENCHMARK: MAG NAIL EDGE OF ASPHALT (7.42' ELEV. 88 DATUM) 1 0 G E N E R A L U T I L I T Y E A S E M E N T SETBACKS PER ONLINE ORDINANCES AND REFERENCED PLAT AND SHOULD BE VERIFIED WITH ALL GOVERNING MUNICIPALITIES AND ASSOCIATIONS BEFORE DESIGN OR CONSTRUCTION 5.3 6.7 7.1 7.4 7.8 7.9 7.6 4.9 4.5 4.2 5.2 6.6 7.2 7.7 7.5 4.7 4.8 4.3 4.1 5.1 5.8 7.1 7.8 5.3 4.3 4.8 4.4 4.5 4.8 5.3 6.0 6.8 7.3 7.4 7.3 6.4 5.7 5.0 4.2 4.8 6.4 6.8 7.1 7.8 4.5 4.5 4.1 4.3 4.1 4.6 3.7 3.9 4.3 4.5 4.4 3.1 4.6 3.2 4.5 3.4 4.5 4.1 4.6 4.6 4.6 4.0 4.6 4.6 4.6 4.6 4.3 4.3 4.7 5.2 5.3 5.2 5.3 5.2 5.2 4.8 4.7 4.9 4.8 4.6 5.1 5.3 5.2 4.9 17 PINE 16 PINE 15 PINE 11 PINE 11 PINE 15 PALM 19 PALM 9 PINE 17 PALM 22 PALM 24 PALM 9 PINE 18 PALM 12 PALM 10 PINE 14 PINE 10 PINE 13 PALM 13 PALM 10 PINE 14 PALM 13 PALM 12 PALM 8 PINE 18 PALM 13 PINE 9 PINE 14 PALM 17 PALM 12 PINE 8 PINE 14 PINE 25 OAK 10 PINE 9 PINE 12 PINE 16 PALM 21 PALM 9 PINE 8 PINE 8 PINE 12 PALM 16 PALM 9 PINE 10 PINE 11 PINE 13 PINE 16 PINE 16 PINE 16 PALM 16 PALM 16 PINE 21 PALM 13 PINE 10 PINE 11 PINE 10 PINE 12 PINE 12 PINE 13 PINE 13 PALM 18 PALM 12 PINE 9 PINE 8 PINE 11 PINE 11 PINE 12 PINE 17 PINE 13 PINE 18 PINE 16 PALM 14 PINE 12 PINE 11 PINE 8 PINE 8 PINE 11 PINE 12 PINE 9 PINE 12 PINE 8 PINE 9 PINE 8 PINE 10 OAK 9 PINE 9 PINE 9 PINE 9 PINE 10 PINE 12 PINE 14 PINE 11 PINE 8 PINE 12 PINE 8 PINE 11 PINE 8 PINE 8 PINE 10 PINE 14 PINE 19 PALM 17 PINE 17 PINE 17 PINE 11 PINE 13 PINE 9 PINE 10 PINE 15 PINE 8 PINE 11 PINE 12 PINE 26 OAK 11 PINE 10 PINE 13 PINE 16 PINE 18 PINE 9 PINE 20 PALM 8 PINE 18 PINE 14 PINE 16 OAK 16 PINE 15 PINE 15 PINE 10 PINE 10 PINE 11 PINE 8 PINE 17 PINE 9 PINE 12 PINE 8 PINE 8 PINE 9 PINE 8 PINE 13 PINE 14 PINE 13 PINE 16 PINE 18 PALM 16 PINE 9 PINE 13 PINE 9 PINE 4+9 OAK 11 OAK 11 PINE 439 24 PALM CANOPY RADIUS 462 25 OAK CANOPY RADIUS 711 26 OAK CANOPY RADIUS PROPOSED 2 STORY RESIDENCE MOTOR COURT DRIVEWAY DRIVEWAY BRIDGE 10'-0" PORTION OF DRIVEWAY IN R.O.W. SHALL BE PLAIN BROOM FINISH CONCRETE DATE: DESIGN BY: JOB NO.: SCALE: DLB COPYRIGHT 2024 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED IT IS A VIOLATION OF LAW FOR ANY PERSON, UNLESS ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTION OF DLB CUSTOM HOME DESIGN, TO ALTER THIS DOCUMENT. PRINTED OR ELECTRONIC DRAWINGS AND DOCUMENTATION MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION. THIS DRAWING WAS PREPARED AT THE SCALE INDICATED. INACCURACIES IN THE STATED SCALE MAY BE INTRODUCED WHEN DRAWINGS ARE REPRODUCED BY ANY MEANS. USE THE GRAPHIC SCALE BAR TO DETERMINE THE ACTUAL SCALE. DRAWN BY: DLB SHEET TITLE: SHEET NO. 1/4" = 1'-0" U.N.O. NO. REVISION DESCRIPTION DATE 1 PERMIT REVIEW SET 3/30/26 2 3 4 5 6 7 2401 3/30/2026 ARCHITECTURAL PLANS 262 CAPTAIN GODDARD ROAD DANIEL ISLAND SUBDIVISION CHARLESTON, SC 29492 PARCEL FF-B-22 TMS#276-01-03-029 ISELIN RESIDENCE DILLARD JONES 500 HAYES PARK BLVD JOHNS ISLAND SC 29455 843-239-2424 DLB CUSTOM HOME DESIGN, INC PHONE: 843-303-2979 EMAIL: DLBCUSTOMHOMEDESIGN@GMAIL.COM WWW.DLBCUSTOMHOMEDESIGN.COM Instructions – NOTE: APPLICATION P ROCEDURE HAS CHANGED. This application, along with the required information, must be submitted in PDF format to BZA-Z@charleston-sc.gov. Applicant will then be invoiced for fee. Applications are due by 12 Noon on the deadline date and must be complete to be accepted and placed on an agenda. A sign will be posted on the property, and a public hearing will be conducted by the Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning. Permits authorized by the Board cannot be issued during a five (5) business day appeal period following the decision of the Board, except for use variances, the appeal period shall be fifteen (15) calendar days. An appeal to the Board during this appeal period stays all further action on the application. THE APPLICANT HEREBY REQUESTS: A Variance and/or Special Exception as indicated on page 2 of this application. Reconsideration of a decision of the Board or action of a zoning official (attach Appeal form). Extension of an unexpired Variance and/or Special Exception approval. MEETING DATE REQUESTED: Property Address TMS # Property Owner Daytime Phone Applicant Daytime Phone Applicant’s Mailing Address E-mail Address Relationship of applicant to owner (same, representative, prospective buyer, other) Zoning of property Information required with application: (check information submitted) Scaled plans or plats, including elevations, showing the variance(s) or special exception(s) being requested For new construction or additions within a flood zone, show HVAC units and platform on scaled plan Scaled floor plans with rooms labeled and the total floor area for each dwelling unit noted are required for a l l density variances and building additions, unless exempted by the Zoning staff Plans or documents necessary to show compliance with special exception requirements YES or NO - Is this Property restricted by any recorded covenant that is contrary to, conflicts with or prohibits t h e proposed land use encompassed in this permit application? § 6-29-1145 of the South Carolina Code of Laws Optional but very helpful information : Photographs Letters or petitions from neighbors or organizations directly affected by your request I certify that the information on this application and any attachments is correct, that the proposed improvement(s) comply with private neighborhood coven ants, if there are any, and that I am the owner of the subject property or the authorized representative of the owner. I authorize the subject property to be posted with a notice of the Board hearing and inspected. Applicant Date City of Charleston Page 1 of 2 Application for Variance, Special Exception, Reconsideration, or Extension to the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning (BZA-Z) Time application received Receipt # Fee $ For office use only Date application received Staffperson May 5th, 2026 262 Captain Goddard, Chalreston, SC, 29492 Justin and Tiffani Iselin Dillard Jones Builders - Cara Schnedier 843-955-8240 122 N Laurens St, Greenville, SC 29601 caras@dillardjones.com Builder Representative SFR 04.03.2026 2760202048 BZA-Z Application (continued) Page 2 of 2 For Variance requests, applicants should list the specific variance(s) being requested and, if possible, explain how the variance test that follows is met (add as an attachment if necessary): Variance Test: The Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning is authorized to approve a variance from the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6-29-800) For Special Exception requests, applic ants should list the specific approval(s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as § 54-110, § 54-206, or sections in Article 5 (add as an attachment if necessary): All approvals of the Board shall remain valid for two (2) years from the approval date, unless extended in accordance with the provisions of Article 9, Part 5 of the zoning ordinance. Applicants may not apply for the same request that has been denied by the Board until a period of six (6) months has lapsed. 11/23 Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability 2 George Street Charleston, South Carolina 29401 (843) 724-3781 www.charleston-sc.gov/zoning Requesting extention on previously approved zoning (BZA2021-001442) request to provide variance request for a bridge for vehicle acces for a proposed single-family residence. Bridge will encroach into the 10-ft setback required from visual buffer zone. CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 162 Ashley Ave. VARIANCE CASE SUMMARY May 5, 2026 | 5:15pm Case Number: BZA2026-002350 Subject Property: 162 Ashley Ave. / TMS# 460-15-04-061 Zoning District: MU-2/WH Property Owner: Senior Cottages Acquisitions, LLC Applicant: Ellis R. Lesemann Requested Action: Request variance from Sec. 54-317 to provide no off-street parking (74 required) for a mixed-use development. Project Description: The applicant is requesting relief from the required number of off-street parking spaces to construct a mixed-used building. The proposed building will be comprised of 3,000sf of commercial retail use on the ground floor and 44 multi-family units. The proposed multi-family units are intended to be student housing for MUSC. The applicant is currently working towards an off-site parking agreement with the owner of the properties at 134 & 136 Rutledge Ave, and 158 Ashley Ave. The properties at 134 & 136 Rutledge avenue are located further than 400’ from 162 Ashley Ave. therefore the provisions of Sec. 54-319 which would allow off-site parking would not apply. Case History: Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-317 Required number of off-street parking spaces by land use USE Number of Spaces Required Residential - Multiple (3 or more) dwellings or dwellings (one or more) within commercial bldgs. 1½ per unit, except that the minimum requirement shall be 1 per unit within the MU-1 and MU-2 districts Business, Entertainment, and Office - Retail and personal service establishments not including food stores (on the peninsula) 1 per 400 square feet of gross floor area Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 162 Ashley Ave. Page 2 Variance Test/ Findings of Fact: The following is excerpted from Section 54-924 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. This test is based on S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-800. A variance may be granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: Applicant Responses: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; The subject property has extraordinary physical, regulatory, and geographic conditions that are unusual and exceptional, even in the context of an urban infill development. First, the parcel is developable for its intended purpose but is small. The 0.25-acre parcel cannot physically accommodate parking at any meaningful scale while simultaneously achieving the residential density that is necessary for the project to be feasible while also satisfying the ground-floor commercial use requirement imposed by the MU-2/WH zoning designation. The project meets the purpose and intent of the MU-2/WH zoning classification and is supported by MUSC. Also, the property is located in Flood Zone “AE.” As a result, applicable regulations prohibit all residential dwelling systems, including associated electrical, HVAC, fire-alarm, and mechanical equipment from being situated below the Design Flood Elevation (DFE), which is set at the Base Flood Elevation (BFE) plus two feet of freeboard for new commercial and mixed-use buildings. These floodplain restrictions prohibit the possibility of below-grade parking, which is the only parking typology that could potentially be achieved on a lot of this size without sacrificing the ground-floor commercial use. Additionally, and most significantly, the 400-foot radius surrounding 162 Ashley Avenue is dominated by property that is owned by MUSC. The only parking options available in the area beyond what could be secured within MUSC’s parking garage are the surface lots at 134 and 136 Rutledge. 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; The conditions described above are specific to 162 Ashley Avenue and do not apply to other properties in the surrounding area, which are already developed and are largely devoted to institutional uses owned and operated by the State of South Carolina. The properties adjacent to or near the project are overwhelmingly owned and occupied by MUSC, which is one of the largest academic medical centers in the Southeast. MUSC's campus encompasses multiple city blocks in this portion of Charleston's medical district and operates its own dedicated parking garages and surface lots that serve the campus community. These institutional properties are not subject to the mixed-use development standards, Workforce Housing overlay requirements, or the obligation to devote the ground-floor space to commercial uses. As a result, surrounding properties are either exempt from requirements or are themselves parking facilities in service of the institutional uses. Also, other properties in the vicinity are generally larger and have more flexibility to accommodate parking on-site. The project has a unique situation based on its small size, ground-floor use restriction, and encirclement by institutional uses. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 162 Ashley Ave. Page 3 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and Strict enforcement of § 54-319's 400-foot distance requirement, as applied to this property, would effectively prohibit the Applicant from satisfying its parking obligations under the City’s Zoning Ordinance and would prevent the viable development of the parcel in light of the restrictions that apply under the MU-2/WH zoning classification. There are no parcels within 400 feet of 162 Ashley Avenue that are available to provide the needed balance of parking. The project cannot accommodate parking on-site, but it will provide a much-needed and much-desired supply of housing to support and enliven the Medical District. Due to the lack of any other off-site option that is within 400 feet, strict application of § 54-319 would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict utilization of the property. The practical consequence of denial would be to preclude development of the property in conformance with its MU-2/WH designation. The City has zoned this parcel for dense mixed-use development and has imposed a workforce housing requirement in recognition of the need for accessible housing in proximity to the Medical District. The Applicant wishes to meet this need, but strict adherence to the distance limitation would preclude the project. A denial of the variance would frustrate the City’s policy objectives and render the property infeasible for its intended use. The parking available at 134 and 136 Rutledge Avenue is accessible and adequate to serve both residential and commercial uses and will be secured by a long-term lease agreement that guarantees its availability. 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. Granting the requested variance will not harm adjacent properties, the public good, or the character of the district. On the contrary, approval of the variance advances public interest in numerous respects. The project is a student-focused, mixed-income residential development designed to serve the Medical District and the MUSC community. The residents will primarily be students, medical residents, faculty, and employees of MUSC who, based on proximity, will tend to walk or use a bike rather than drive cars. The off-site parking at 134 and 136 Rutledge Avenue is a short walking distance from 162 Ashley Avenue and can be accessed through a safe pedestrian walkway that runs through the MUSC parking garage with well- marked crosswalks. The variance will not negatively alter the character of the Medical District, but rather will affirmatively enhance it by allowing more students, faculty, and employees to live in the Medical District. The existing character of the MU-2 zone already reflects a dense, walkable neighborhood in which off-site and remote parking arrangements are commonplace. There are also numerous public transit options that are well-utilized. The 162 Ashley Avenue project is consistent with and contemplated by the City’s specific urban planning for this area. Approval of the variance furthers these goals. No adjacent property owner will be adversely affected by the variance. The off-site parking lots at Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 162 Ashley Ave. Page 4 134 and 136 Rutledge Avenue are existing parking resources, so their continued use for parking will not generate additional impacts. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6- 29-800) Staff Recommendation: Recommends Approval with Conditions Staff Analysis: Staff recommend approval of the variance request with the condition that the applicant provide staff with completed off-site parking agreements for the number of off-street parking spaces required per Sec. 54-317. Attachments: • Zoning Map • Site Map • Application Staff Contact: Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov PT CW DN DN DN DN ASHLEY AVENUE 50'-0" RIGHT-OF-W AY PROPERTY LINE PER SEC. 54-306.N - HEIGHT DISTRICT 85/30 40'-0" SETBACK C.L. OF ASHLEY AVENUE TERMINATE (8") (750GPM) FIRE PROTECTION MAIN APPROXIMATELY 5’-0” FROM OUTSIDE OF BUILDING. SEE CIVIL SITE UTILITY PLAN FOR CONTINUATION. COORDINATE EXACT LOCATION, DEPTH AND SIZE OF CIVIL CONNECTION PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION. TERMINATE (3") (440 WSFU, 127.6 GPM) DOMESTIC WATER MAIN APPROXIMATELY 5’-0” FROM OUTSIDE OF BUILDING. SEE CIVIL SITE UTILITY PLAN FOR CONTINUATION. COORDINATE EXACT LOCATION, DEPTH AND SIZE OF CIVIL CONNECTION PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION. TERMINATE (2") DOMESTIC WATER TO RETAIL SPACE APPROXIMATELY 5’-0” FROM OUTSIDE OF BUILDING. SEE CIVIL SITE UTILITY PLAN FOR CONTINUATION. COORDINATE EXACT LOCATION, DEPTH AND SIZE OF CIVIL CONNECTION PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION. TERMINATE (6") SANITARY MAIN APPROXIMATELY 5’-0” FROM OUTSIDE OF BUILDING. SEE CIVIL SITE UTILITY PLAN FOR CONTINUATION. DFU’S: (531) FINISH FLOOR ELEVATION: (10.25)’. INVERT AT CIVIL CONNECTION: (-0.60)’ +/-. COORDINATE EXACT LOCATION, SIZE AND INVERT OF CIVIL CONNECTION PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION. SLOPE PIPING AT (1/8") FALL PER FOOT. UTILITY CONNECTION AT STREET, GAS LINE FROM UTILITY CONNECTION TO GAS METER, AND GAS METER TO BE PROVIDED BY GAS COMPANY. GAS PIPING FROM GAS METER TO BUILDING SIZED USING 2 PSI INLET PRESSURE, (240 FEET EQUIVALENT), (2550 CFH), AND TABLE 402.4(5) OF THE 2021 SOUTH CAROLINA FUEL GAS CODE. RUN GAS PIPING INSIDE BUILDING AS TIGHT TO STRUCTURE AS POSSIBLE. COORDINATE EXACT LOCATION OF GAS METER PRIOR TO INSTALLATION. COORDINATE EXACT ROUTING OF GAS PIPING INSIDE BUILDING WITH ALL PERTINENT TRADES PRIOR TO INSTALLATION. FDC FREE STANDING SIAMESE CONNECTOR THE LINE SHOWN ABOVE IS EXACTLY ONE INCH LONG AT THIS SHEETS ORIGINAL PAGE SIZE LS3P PROJECT: ORIG SUBMISSION: SHEET NAME: SHEET: A B C D E 1 2 3 4 5 6 DATE DESCRIPTION∆ COPYRIGHT 2024 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. PRINTED OR ELECTRONIC DRAWINGS AND DOCUMENTATION MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM LS3P ASSOCIATES LTD. 1681 2/3/2026 9:04:09 AM P-050 OVERALL SITE PLAN - PLUMBING 1512-250015 02/02/26 WHITE LION CAPITAL LLC 162 Ashley Avenue Charleston, South Carolina 29425 162 Ashley Avenue PERMIT SET JMBRAE 24020806 WWW.LS3P.COM 205 1/2 KING STREET CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA 29401 TEL. 843.577.4444 FAX. 843.722.4789 Jordan & Skala Engineers 4501 Charlotte Park Dr., ● Suite 100 Charlotte, NC 28217 p. 704.599.4377 ● f. 704.509.9330 Project Number: Drawn By: Checked By: Certification No.: Scale: 1" = 10'-0" PLUMBING SITE PLAN1 PRICING GENERAL NOTES: THE INFORMATION CONTAINED WITHIN THESE DOCUMENTS IS GENERAL IN NATURE AND AS SUCH, MAY NOT DESCRIBE ALL COMPONENTS OR CONDITIONS NECESSARY FOR THE COMPLETED PROJECT. THE CONTRACTOR, BY USING THESE DOCUMENTS AS PART OF ANY EFFORT TO ESTABLISH A PRELIMINARY PRICING SET FOR CONSTRUCTION, ACKNOWLEDGES THE INCOMPLETE NATURE OF THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN, AND WILL THEREFORE INCORPORATE REASONABLE AMOUNTS AND ASSUMPTIONS IN THEIR ESTIMATE NECESSARY TO PROVIDE A COMPLETE PROJECT THAT IS CONSISTENT WITH THE DESIGN INTENT OF THESE DOCUMENTS. THE CONTRACTOR IS RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL MECHANICAL, ELECTRICAL, PLUMBING, AND FIRE PROTECTION FEATURES INDICATED IN THE DOCUMENTS AS COMPLETE AND WORKING SYSTEMS. ANY FEATURE INDICATED IN ONE DISCIPLINE’S DESIGN IS ASSUMED TO BE INCLUDED AND INCORPORATED IN ALL DISCIPLINES AND SHOULD BE COORDINATED BETWEEN SUB-CONTRACTORS AS NECESSARY AND REQUIRED FOR FULLY FUNCTIONING SYSTEMS. SHOULD THE CONTRACTOR NOTE ANY CONFLICTING OR CONTRADICTORY INFORMATION IN THESE DOCUMENTS, THEY ARE INSTRUCTED TO NOTIFY THE ARCHITECT AS SOON AS POSSIBLE OR IDENTIFY THE ITEM AS A SEPARATE LINE ITEM AND PRICE THE MORE COSTLY OF THE DIFFERING CONDITIONS. REFER TO CIVIL, LANDSCAPE, INTERIOR DESIGN, POOL DESIGN AND ARCHITECTURAL DRAWINGS FOR ADDITIONAL SCOPE OF PLUMBING WORK THAT MAY NOT BE INDICATED IN THIS SET OF DOCUMENTS. PLUMBING PRICING NOTES: PROVIDE COMPLETE AND WORKING CODE COMPLIANT SYSTEMS: ABOVE AND BELOW GRADE SANITARY, VENT, PRIMARY AND SECONDARY STORM SYSTEM, DOMESTIC HOT AND COLD WATER PIPING FOR OVERALL BUILDING AND ASSOCIATED AMENITY AREAS, SHUT-OFF AND BALANCING VALVES, HUB DRAINS FOR ALL WATER HEATERS AND MECHANICAL CLOSETS AND GAS INSTALLATION WITHIN ALL DWELLING UNITS AND AMENITY AREAS, INSULATION AND HEAT TRACE FOR PIPING LOCATED IN UNCONDITIONED AREAS, FLOOR DRAINS IN ALL MECHANICAL AND PUMP ROOMS, AND ELECTRICAL SERVICE COORDINATED AND PROVIDED BY THE ELECTRICAL CONTRACTOR. PUMP ROOMS: PUMP ROOMS SHALL BE COMPLETE WITH DOMESTIC BOOSTER PUMP, FIRE PUMP AND ALL ASSOCIATED APPURTENANCES TO PRODUCE A COMPLETE WORKING, CODE COMPLIANT SYSTEM. PROVIDE MINIMUM 6” FLOOR DRAIN IN MIDDLE OF ROOM AND AT EACH LOCATION OF FIRE AND DOMESTIC BOOSTER PUMP. SHUT-OFF VALVES: PROVIDE SHUT-OFF VALVES AT EACH MAJOR BRANCH PIPING TAKE-OFF. ROUTE PIPING SO VALVES ARE LOCATED ABOVE ACCESSIBLE CEILINGS WHEREVER POSSIBLE. WHERE VALVES ARE LOCATED ABOVE INACCESSIBLE CEILINGS, PROVIDE ACCESS PANEL TO ACCESS SHUT-OFF VALVES. REFER TO JSE SPECIFICATION 220000 PLUMBING GENERAL FOR ACCESS PANEL REQUIREMENTS. PRIMARY STORM SYSTEM: PRIMARY STORM PIPING SHALL BE SIZED BASED ON ACCEPTED RAINFALL RATES FOR THE AREA WHERE THE PROJECT WILL BE CONSTRUCTED. REFER TO ARCHITECTURAL PLANS FOR PRIMARY DRAIN LOCATIONS. SECONDARY STORM SYSTEM: SHALL BE PROVIDED BY ROOF DRAINS THAT TERMINATE AT DOWNSPOUT NOZZLE MOUNTED APPROXIMATELY 18” ABOVE FINISH GRADE, OR THROUGH SCUPPERS. REFER TO ARCHITECTURAL PLANS FOR SECONDARY DRAIN LOCATIONS. EXPANSIVE SOILS: PROVIDE PIPEHANGERS FOR EXPANSIVE SOILS IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 2.11.H OF JSE SPECIFICATIONS 220000 PLUMBING GENERAL. ELEVATOR SUMP PUMP: COORDINATE EXACT NUMBER, SIZE, AND LOCATION OF ELEVATOR SUMP PUMPS WITH ARCHITECT. PROVIDE ELEVATOR SUMP PUMP WITH A MINIMUM CAPACITY OF 3,000 GALLONS PER HOUR (50 GPM) FOR EACH ELEVATOR CAR, IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASME A17.1 REQUIREMENTS. PROVIDE OIL MINDER SYSTEM FOR HYDRAULIC ELEVATORS, OR IF REQUIRED BY LOCAL JURISDICTION FOR NON-HYDRAULIC ELEVATORS. FOR SINGLE ELEVATORS, PROVIDE 4” HUB DRAIN. FOR DOUBLE ELEVATORS, PROVIDE 6” HUB DRAIN. FOR THREE OR MORE ELEVATORS, PROVIDE 8” HUB DRAIN. MECHANICAL CLOSETS IN DWELLING UNITS AND AMENITY AREAS: PROVIDE 2” HUB DRAIN AT EACH MECHANICAL CLOSET WITHIN DWELLING UNITS. PROVIDE 4” HUB DRAIN IN EACH MECHANICAL CLOSET LOCATED IN AMENITY AREAS. EXPANSION FITTINGS: FOR ALL DWV VERTICAL PIPING SHALL BE EQUAL TO IPEX HxH 21381 -AWBC SERIES. EXPANSION FITTINGS SHALL BE LOCATED IN THE CEILING SPACE OF THE DWELLING UNITS ON THE LOWEST LEVEL AND EVERY OTHER FLOOR THEREAFTER FOR WOOD-FRAMED BUILDINGS. EXPANSION FITTINGS SHALL BE LOCATED IN THE CEILING SPACE OF THE DWELLING UNITS ON THE LOWEST LEVEL AND EVERY EIGHT (8) FLOORS THEREAFTER FOR CONCRETE BUILDINGS. RETAIL AREAS: PROVIDE 4” SANITARY VTR AT EACH FUTURE RETAIL LOCATION. GARAGE DRAINAGE: PROVIDE DRAINS AT LOCATIONS SHOWN ON ARCHITECTURAL AND STRUCTURAL PLANS. BALCONY DRAINAGE: REFER TO ARCHITECTURAL DRAWINGS FOR BALCONY DRAINAGE LOCATIONS. CONNECT BALCONY DRAINAGE TO PRIMARY STORM SYSTEM, UNLESS OTHERWISE DIRECTED BY ARCHITECT. FOOD SERVICE AREAS: PROVIDE MINIMUM 2,000 GALLON GREASE INTERCEPTOR AT RETAIL SPACE THAT WILL BE CONSIDERED A RESTAURANT OR FOOD SERVICE RETAIL SPACE. PROVIDE MINIMUM 4 ” GREASE WASTE PIPING, 316L STAINLESS STEEL 20 GAUGE SOIL PIPE WITH PUSH FIT SOCKET CONNECTIONS AND GREEN (HIGH TEMPERATURE) SEALING RINGS. DEDUCTIVE ALTERNATE: SERVICE WEIGHT HUB AND SPIGOT CAST IRON SOIL PIPE PER ASTM A -74, COATED ON OUTSIDE. FITTINGS: SERVICE WEIGHT HUB AND SPIGOT CAST IRON SOIL PIPE FITTINGS PER ASTM -A-74, COATED ON OUTSIDE. JOINTS: NEOPRENE GASKETED JOINTS PER ASTM C564 AND ASTM C 1563. PROVIDE 4 ” SANITARY VTR AND 4” GREASE WASTE VTR AT EACH FOOD SERVICE LOCATION. PROVIDE 2 ” GAS MAIN AT 2 PSI TO EACH FOOD SERVICE LOCATION. HEAT TRACING: PROVIDE HEAT TRACING AT 8 WATTS PER LINEAR FOOT IN ACCORDANCE WITH JSE SPECIFICATIONS 220000 PLUMBING GENERAL FOR ALL GREASE WASTE PIPING RUNS LONGER THAN 50’-0”. GAS-FIRED ROOFTOP EQUIPMENT: COORDINATE REQUIREMENTS FOR GAS -FIRED ROOFTOP EQUIPMENT WITH MECHANICAL CONTRACTOR. PROVIDE SEDIMENT TRAP, GAS SHUT-OFF VALVE AND GAS PRESSURE REGULATOR AT EACH GAS-FIRED EQUIPMENT LOCATION. HEAT TRACING: PROVIDE HEAT TRACING ON ALL SANITARY P -TRAPS, FIRE PROTECTION AND DOMESTIC WATER LINES LOCATED IN UNCONDITIONED AREAS. HEAT TRACING SHALL BE PROVIDED AT 8 WATTS PER LINEAR FOOT. REFER TO JSE SPECIFICATIONS 220000 PLUMBING GENERAL AND 210000 FIRE PROTECTION GENERAL FOR ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS. ROOF HYDRANTS: PROVIDE NON-FREEZE ROOF HYDRANTS IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO ROOFTOP MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT AND AT 100’-0” MAXIMUM INTERVALS. COORDINATE LOCATIONS OF ROOFTOP EQUIPMENT WITH MECHANICAL CONTRACTOR. PROVIDE SHUT-OFF VALVE AND ACCESS PANEL AT EACH LOCATION. EXTERIOR AND INTERIOR HOSE BIBBS: PROVIDE NON-FREEZE EXTERIOR HOSE BIBBS NEAR SERVICE ENTRY LOCATIONS AND AROUND THE PERIMETER OF THE BUILDING ON APPROXIMATELY 100 FOOT INTERVALS. PROVIDE HOSE BIBBS IN ALL PUBLIC AND EMPLOYEE RESTROOMS AND AT THE SWIMMING POOL DECK. PROVIDE HOT/COLD WATER HOSE STATION AT LOADING DOCK AND CAN WASH AREAS. STRUCTURAL: AT THE TIME OF SUBMISSION, STRUCTURAL DESIGN DRAWINGS WERE NOT AVAILABLE. WHERE PLUMBING STACKS ARE SHOWN DROPPING AGAINST COLUMNS, THE TOP OF FOOTING SHALL BE DROPPED THIRTY INCHES (30”) BELOW BOTTOM OF FINISH SLAB IN ORDER TO ACCOMMODATE PLUMBING ELBOWS AND MAINTAIN REQUIRED DEPTH OF COVER FOR PIPING. ADDITIONAL PLUMBING ROUTING AND COORDINATION MAY BE REQUIRED WHEN STRUCTURAL DRAWINGS ARE RECEIVED AND REVIEWED. DOMESTIC WATER SERVICE: PROVIDE 3” DOMESTIC WATER SERVICE ROUTED THROUGH BUILDING. AMENITY AND DWELLING UNIT PLUMBING FIXTURES AND APPURTENANCES: COORDINATE EXACT MODEL NUMBERS, FINISHES AND REQUIREMENTS FOR PLUMBING FIXTURES AND APPURTENACES WITH OWNER, ARCHITECT, AND INTERIOR DESIGNER PRIOR TO ORDERING AND INSTALLING PLUMBING FIXTURES. COORDINATE ADA AND NON -ADA AREAS WITH ARCHITECT PRIOR TO ORDERING AND INSTALLING PLUMBING FIXTURES. FIRE SPRINKLER SERVICE: PROVIDE 8” FIRE SERVICE ROUTED THROUGH BUILDING. PROVIDE CLASS 1 AUTOMATIC STANDPIPE IN EACH STAIRWELL ON THE MAIN LEVEL. AMENITIES AREAS: AT THE TIME OF SUBMISSION, INTERIOR DESIGN DRAWINGS OF THE AMENITY AREAS WERE NOT AVAILABLE. REFER TO INTERIOR DESIGN DRAWINGS FOR LOCATIONS AND REQUIREMENTS FOR ALL PLUMBING FIXTURES LOCATED IN AMENITY AREAS. HOT WATER RECIRCULATING PUMPS: PROVIDE HOT WATER RECIRCULATING PUMP IN ALL DWELLING UNITS AND AMENITY AREAS WHERE THE DEVELOPED LENGTH OF HOT OR TEMPERED WATER PIPING, FROM THE SOURCE OF HOT WATER TO THE FIXTURES THAT REQUIRE HOT OR TEMPERED WATER, EXCEEDS 50 FEET. PROVIDE TACO MODEL 007-SF5-IFC WITH STAINLESS STEEL CARTRIDGE, CASING AND IMPELLER, 1/25 HP, 115V, 60Hz, 1Ph, 0.76 AMPS, 3250 RPM, AT EACH LOCATION. CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 18 Trumbo St. VARIANCE CASE SUMMARY May 5, 2026 | 5:15pm Case Number: BZA2026-002327 Subject Property: 18 Trumbo St. / TMS# 457-12-01-017 Zoning District: DR-1F Property Owner: Cozy Development – 18 Trumbo LLC Applicant: Cozy Studio Requested Action: Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-501and requests variance from Sec. 54- 301 to build a single-family detached dwelling unit on a lot of insufficient size (3,038sf existing, 4000sf required) with a 3’ west side setback and 6’ total side setbacks (9’ and 15’ required), and to exceed maximum lot coverage (57% proposed, 50% allowed). Project Description: The Applicant is requesting a special exception to construct a single-family home on a lot of insufficient size as well as a variance from the setback and lot coverage requirements to accommodate the proposed home. Portions of the home adjacent to this property at 16 Trumbo St. encroach over the property line into 18 Trumbo St. Case History: BAR2026-002434 – The applicant has received conceptual approval for alterations of the home at 16 Trumbo St. to remove the portions of the home encroaching into 18 Trumbo St. Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-301 Height, area and setback regulations The setbacks for the DR-1F are as follows: Front: 25’ Rear: 25’ South/West: 9’ North/East: 3’ Maximum Percent of Lot Occupied by Buildings: 50% Sec. 54-501 Lot of record of insufficient size Where the owner of a lot at the time of the adoption of this chapter or his successor in title thereto does not own sufficient land to enable him to meet the minimum lot size requirements of this chapter the board of zoning appeals may upon approval of site plan deemed not in conflict with the intent and purposes of this ordinance authorize any use permitted in the district in which the lot is located. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 18 Trumbo St. Page 2 Variance Test/ Findings of Fact: The following is excerpted from Section 54-924 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. This test is based on S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-800. A variance may be granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; See narrative 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; See narrative 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and See narrative 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. See narrative Variance Narrative: Special Exception Requirements/ Findings of Fact: Special Exception Narrative: Request a variance from Sec. 54-301side setbacks to allow a new non-conforming single-family residence. Where the owner of a lot at the time of the adoption of this chapter or his successor in title thereto does not own sufficient land to enable him to meet the minimum lot size requirements of this chapter the board of zoning appeals may upon approval of site plan deemed not in conflict with the intent and purposes of this ordinance authorize any use permitted in the district in which the lot is located. See Narrative 54-506 Exception to Front Setback Requirements & Exception for Porches and Exterior Stairs in Front and Rear Setbacks. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6- 29-800) Staff Recommendation: Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: Staff are recommending approval of the special exception and variance request due to the requirements of the ordinance unreasonably restricting and effectively prohibiting the use of the property. The 32’ width of the lot along with setback and lot occupancy requirements of Sec. 54-301 unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property as a detached single-family home. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | May 5, 2026 | 18 Trumbo St. Page 3 Attachments: • Zoning Map • Site Map • Application Staff Contact: Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov Range • • • • • • • • • • • • 18 TRUMBO STREET CHARLESTON, SC, 29401 TMS: 457-12-01-017 PROPERTY OWNER: NEIGHBORHOOD: HARLESTON VILLAGE ZONING: DR-1F STR OVERLAY BUILDING SETBACKS (TABLE 3.1): FRONT AND REAR SETBACK: TOTAL - 3' FRONT - 25' REAR - 25' SIDE SETBACKS TOTAL - 15' SOUTH/WEST - 9' NORTH/EAST - 3' SEC. 54-506 EXCEPTION TO FRONT SETBACK REQUIREMENTS & EXCEPTION FOR PORCHES AND EXTERIOR STAIRS IN FRONT AND REAR SETBACKS MAX BUILDING HEIGHT (TABLE 3.1): 50' OLD CITY HEIGHT DISTRICT 3 LOT AREA: 3048 SF MAX BUILDING COVERAGE (TABLE 3.1): 50% PROPOSED BUILDING COVERAGE - 57% FEMA FLOOD ZONE: AE(11') EXISTING TREES - NO GRAND TREES SITE INFORMATION A200 A200 A2003 2 4 18' - 0" 17' - 0" 18' - 0" 37' - 0" 48' - 6" 7' - 6"2' - 0" 23' - 0"9' - 0"5' - 0" FRONT PORCH LIVING SPACE 995 SF BACK PORCH 16 TRUMBO 20 TRUMBO 8' - 6" 19' - 0" HVAC SIDEWALK TRUMBO STREET 6' WALL 7' WALL POOL HOUSE POOL HOT TUB 7' WALL 6' WALLDRIVEWAY 11' - 9 1/4" 14 TRUMBO 181 QUEEN 179 QUEEN 177 QUEEN 32.36' FRONT PROPERTY LINE 97.39' SIDE PROPERTY LINE 35.30' REAR PROPERTY LINE 87.23' SIDE PROPERTY LINE FIRE HYDRANT STORM DRAIN PROPOSED 7' WALL 18 TRUMBO 63' - 6" 27' - 11" 10' - 6" 6' - 1 1/2" 9' - 0" 15' - 0" POOL 1' - 8 3/8" 1' - 2" 9' - 6" 4' - 8" 3' - 2" PROPOSED 7' WALL 2' - 5" 30' - 7" 3' - 4" THE DRAWING AND THE DESIGN SHOWN IS THE PROPERTY OF COZY STUDIO. THE REPRODUCTION, COPYING OR OTHER USE OF THE DRAWING WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT IS PROHIBITED AND ANY INFRINGEMENT WILL SUBJECT TO LEGAL ACTION. © 2025 COZY STUDIO. COZY.CHARLESTON@GMAIL.COM 843 . 955 . 9662 A100 SITE PLAN 18 TRUMBO BZA COZY STUDIO 104 BROAD ST, SUITE 200, CHARLESTON, SC 29401 3/5/2026 1/8" = 1'-0"1 SITE PLAN REV DATE 0' 8'4' 16'2' 1/8" = 1'-0" Instructions – NOTE: APPLICATION P ROCEDURE HAS CHANGED. This application, along with the required information, must be submitted in PDF format to BZA-Z@charleston-sc.gov. Applicant will then be invoiced for fee. Applications are due by 12 Noon on the deadline date and must be complete to be accepted and placed on an agenda. A sign will be posted on the property, and a public hearing will be conducted by the Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning. Permits authorized by the Board cannot be issued during a five (5) business day appeal period following the decision of the Board, except for use variances, the appeal period shall be fifteen (15) calendar days. An appeal to the Board during this appeal period stays all further action on the application. THE APPLICANT HEREBY REQUESTS: A Variance and/or Special Exception as indicated on page 2 of this application. Reconsideration of a decision of the Board or action of a zoning official (attach Appeal form). Extension of an unexpired Variance and/or Special Exception approval. MEETING DATE REQUESTED: Property Address TMS # Property Owner Daytime Phone Applicant Daytime Phone Applicant’s Mailing Address E-mail Address Relationship of applicant to owner (same, representative, prospective buyer, other) Zoning of property Information required with application: (check information submitted) Scaled plans or plats, including elevations, showing the variance(s) or special exception(s) being requested For new construction or additions within a flood zone, show HVAC units and platform on scaled plan Scaled floor plans with rooms labeled and the total floor area for each dwelling unit noted are required for a l l density variances and building additions, unless exempted by the Zoning staff Plans or documents necessary to show compliance with special exception requirements YES or NO - Is this Property restricted by any recorded covenant that is contrary to, conflicts with or prohibits t h e proposed land use encompassed in this permit application? § 6-29-1145 of the South Carolina Code of Laws Optional but very helpful information : Photographs Letters or petitions from neighbors or organizations directly affected by your request I certify that the information on this application and any attachments is correct, that the proposed improvement(s) comply with private neighborhood coven ants, if there are any, and that I am the owner of the subject property or the authorized representative of the owner. I authorize the subject property to be posted with a notice of the Board hearing and inspected. Applicant Date City of Charleston Page 1 of 2 Application for Variance, Special Exception, Reconsideration, or Extension to the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning (BZA-Z) Time application received Receipt # Fee $ For office use only Date application received Staffperson April 7, 2026 18 Trumbo Street Charleston, SC 29401 Cozy Development - 18 Trumbo LLC Cozy Studio 843-955-9662 104 Broad St Suite 200 Charleston, SC 29401 cozy.charleston@gmail.com Design Professional DR-1F 457-12-01-017 Ben Mack 3/5/2026 BZA-Z Application (continued) Page 2 of 2 For Variance requests, applicants should list the specific variance(s) being requested and, if possible, explain how the variance test that follows is met (add as an attachment if necessary): Variance Test: The Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning is authorized to approve a variance from the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6-29-800) For Special Exception requests, applic ants should list the specific approval(s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as § 54-110, § 54-206, or sections in Article 5 (add as an attachment if necessary): All approvals of the Board shall remain valid for two (2) years from the approval date, unless extended in accordance with the provisions of Article 9, Part 5 of the zoning ordinance. Applicants may not apply for the same request that has been denied by the Board until a period of six (6) months has lapsed. 11/23 Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability 2 George Street Charleston, South Carolina 29401 (843) 724-3781 www.charleston-sc.gov/zoning Request a varience from Sec. 54-301side setbacks to allow a new non-conforming single-family residence. and Rear Setbacks. 54-506 Exception to Front Setback Requirements & Exception for Porches and Exterior Stairs in Front

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.