RecordWell Data

BZA-Z Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of May 5, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING PUBLIC COMMENT MAY 5, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning (BZA-Z) will be held on Tuesday, May 5, 2026 at 5:15 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bza-z. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 184 Broad St. Harleston Village | Council District 8 | TMS# 457-12-01-103 | Zoned: STR | BZA2026-002339 Request variance from Sec. 54-301 to construct 2-story addition with a 3’ rear setback and a detached 2-story accessory building with a 25’ front setback, 3’ side setback, and 3’ rear setback (60’, 25’, and 6’ required). Owner: Naomie Olindo Applicant: Julia F. Martin Architects 1 Comment Submitted in Support: • Magda and Felix Pelzer, 182 Broad St. Submitted to Staff See attached letter. CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 44 State St. French Quarter | Council District 8 | TMS# 458-09-01-137 Zoned: GB, Accommodation Overlay District | BZA2026-002346 Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-220 for an accommodations use (2 sleeping units proposed, 10 sleeping units minimum required and 0sf of meeting space proposed, 400sf of meeting space required). Owner: Lot 3C Bradley Circle, LLC Applicant: John A. Massalon 1 Comment Submitted in Support: • Sharon and Tom Johnson, 46 F State Street Submitted to Staff See attached letter. Applicant Rebuttal: • John A. Massalon, Attorney for the Applicant Submitted to Staff See attached document. 3 Comments Submitted in Opposition: • Eddie Irions, 35 State Street Charleston, SC 29401 Submitted to Innovate Site on May 3, 2026 5:58 PM I purchased our home on State Street in 2011, and over the years I’ve seen how important it is to protect what little residential stability remains in the French Quarter. State Street works as a neighborhood because people actually live here, care for their homes, and take responsibility for the street and the community around them. Allowing a non-owner- occupied short-term rental at 44 State Street would move us further away from that balance. Residents already deal with ongoing parking challenges, increased traffic, and the growing pressure from nearby hotel development. Introducing another short-term rental—without an owner present—would only add to those strains and further erode the sense of accountability and community on the street. For those of us who have invested our lives and homes here, especially neighbors closest to this property, the impact would be real and lasting. I respectfully urge that this exception be denied in support of preserving State Street as a livable, residential part of the French Quarter. • Ryan Albert, 35 State Street Charleston, SC 29401 Submitted to Innovate Site on May 3, 2026 6:00 PM As a seven-year resident of 35 State Street in the French Quarter, I strongly object to the request for an exception allowing short-term rentals at 44 State Street without an owner residing on the premises. The strength and character of State Street lie in its residents— Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | May 5, 2026 Page 2 individuals who live here full-time, invest long-term, and contribute to the stability, safety, and sense of community that define our neighborhood. Non-owner-occupied short-term rentals undermine these values and shift the area further toward transient use rather than residential stewardship. With multiple large-scale hotels already being developed around the perimeter of our community, granting this exception would exacerbate existing challenges faced by residents, including parking shortages, street cleanliness, and the erosion of neighborhood cohesion. This would have a direct and negative impact on those of us who live on State Street, particularly residents adjacent to the proposed property. For the sake of livability, community preservation, and the remaining full-time residents of the French Quarter, I respectfully urge that this exception not be granted. • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached statement. Applicant’s Reply to Public Comment Concerning Application for Special Exception to Allow an Accommodations Use Under 54-220 at 44 State Street (TMS 458-09-01-137) Pr ior to submitting this special exception application, Mr. Abreu and the undersigned contacted the President of the French Quarter Neighborhood Association ( FQNA) to discuss this application. The President was kind enough to talk with us by telephone , and we exchanged several email messages thereafter. Based upon those communications we anticipate that the FQNA will oppose the application. Additionally, some public comment has been submitted via the Public Participation portal. Therefore, on behalf of my clients I offer the following additional comments in response to the public comments. First, Mr. and Mrs. Abreu value their relationship with this community and wish to be good neighbors. Since acquiring the property in 2021, the owners have worked closely with the Architectural Review Board (ARB) and town officials on a complete historic restoration of 44 State Street . Ther stewardship was recognized by a 2025 Carolopolis Award for the exterior restoration. The owners currently utilize a local management company to manage the property which is rented for periods of 30 days or more . While this ensures the building is occupied, it significantly limits the owners’ ability to personally use and maintain the property. The property is located in the accommodations overlay district and therefore, Mr. and Mrs. Abreu are seeking a special exception under Ordinance Section 54-220 so that they can lease at least one of the units on a short -term basis under the accommodations ordinance to allow for greater flexibility for the use of the property. The owner -occupied requirements of Section 54- 208 do not apply to this application. The concerns about traffic and parking are addressed more fully in the application. To summarize, the owners expect that most renters who rent for three (3) days or fewer will use Uber (or similar service) to get in and out of the City. However, if parking is needed, renters will be required to use the parking spaces in the nearby garage that the owner has leased. Also, daily street passes will not be given to renters. The owner understands the traffic issue, and he does not wish to encourage more street activity and cars. This proposed solution should effectively remove street crowding, not contribute to it. Over the last 6 months before the application submittal, Mr. Ab reu has performed an outreach to his immediate neighbors to garner feedback, and answer questions, or address Page 2 of 2 concerns. The neighbors located at 46-F State Street, who are also members of the FQNA, support the application as shown by the letter of support attached to this memorandum. As for concerns expressed by other neighbors, t he goal of the proposed use is to not adversely impact the neighborhood. The owners want to assure the community that if the Board grants this special exception the proposed change is not intended to create a "hotel" environment, but rather to allow the owners to maintain a consistent physical presence in Charleston. Rental periods of a month and longer term make that difficult, if not prohibitive . Traveling frequently from Connecticut, shorter rental terms would allow Mr. and Mrs. Abreu to: - Actively participate in the FQNA community and spend more time with local friends in Charleston and on Kiawah; - Personally oversee the careful maintenance required for the interior historic brick, exterior stucco, and surrounding grounds; and - Ensure the building is not vacant for extended periods. We si ncerely hope the Board views this application as a way to preserve a registered historic landmark while allowing the owners to transition into their retirement. s/ John A. Massalon John A . Massalon (SC Bar #10279) WILLS MASSALON & ALLEN LLC Post Office Box 859 Charleston, South Carolina 29402 (843) 727-1144 jmas salon@wmalawfirm.net ATT ORNEYS FOR THE APPLICANT CHAR LESTON, SC Ma y 4, 2026 1 To the Members of the Planning and Zoning Commission, As close neighbors at 46 F State Street, we are writing in strong support of the special use permit application for the property at 44 State Street. The owners' exemplary, Carolopolis award-winning restoration and their ongoing maintenance and beautification efforts have significantly improved our city block and positively contribute to Charleston's historic French Quarter. Additionally, our block—bordered by Cumberland, State Street, East Bay, and Lodge Alley—is already composed of businesses and short-term rental units, including the Lodge Alley Inn. Approving this special use permit would ensure consistency with the character of the neighboring properties. We urge you to approve 44 State Street's application. Sincerely, Sharon & Tom Johnson The Owners of 46 F State Street -- Best Regards Sharon Po Box 38 Edgartown, Ma 02568 Position Statement Board of Zoning Appeals - Zoning May 5, 2026 44 State Street Dear Board Members: The Preservation Society of Charleston (PSC) appreciates the property owners’ demonstrated commitment to the stewardship of this circa 1799 building that we were pleased to recognize with a 2024 Carolopolis Award. However, PSC cannot support the requested special exception to allow a two-unit accommodations use, as the proposal does not meet the requirements of Sections 54-220(a) or 54-220(h) of the Zoning Ordinance. • Section 54-220(a): The subject units are currently used as long-term residential rentals. Their conversion to short-term accommodations would result in a net loss of dwelling units, contrary to the intent of this provision. • Section 54-220(h): The request is inconsistent with the requirement that accommodations uses within the Accommodations Overlay Zone contain a minimum of 10 sleeping units. This standard, adopted as part of the 2018 ordinance amendments, was specifically intended to protect long-term housing stock and residential character, including from piecemeal changes that could, in aggregate, erase fine-grained details that define our historic neighborhoods. While the owners have indicated an intention to return the units to long-term residential use in the future, any zoning approval would run with the property and would not be limited to the current ownership or stated plans. For these reasons, PSC respectfully requests that the Board deny the application. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely, Anna-Catherine Alexander Director of Advocacy Initiatives CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 82 Maple St. North Central | Council District 4 | TMS# 463-11-02-053 | Zoned: SR-2 | BZA2026-002347 Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-110 to vertically extend a nonconforming east side setback to construct a rear second-story addition. Owner: Abby Robertson Applicant: Kim Williams 4 Comments Submitted in Support: • North Central Neighborhood Association Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Letters of Support Submitted to Staff See attached letters. • Robert Blair, 76 Maple St. • Sean Hannigan and Allison Hansen, 78 Maple St. • Paige and Jim Morris, 842 Rutledge Ave. North Central Neighborhood Association April 30, 2026 Christina Walsh Agenda Technician City of Charleston, SC Subject: 82 Maple St / BZA-Z May 5 / Agenda Item B-4. Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-110 to vertically extend a nonconforming east side setback to construct a rear second-story addition. NCNA Review Board Result: Approved The North Central Neighborhood Association strongly supports the request at 82 Maple St to vertically extend a nonconforming east side setback to construct a rear second-story addition. The NCNA Review Board hand-delivered 10 notices to impacted neighbors in advance of our public review meeting at Dart library on Thursday, April 30. No residents attended. During the meeting, owner Abby Robinson reviewed their plans and answered questions. The Review Board voted unanimously to support this request. The plan sensibly adds density without materially changing the character or scale of the house from the street. Helping growing families stay in their homes and on the peninsula is a top priority for North Central. Sincerely, Stephen Rosenberg President, North Central Neighborhood Association Cc:// Robert Summerfield, Craig Bennett CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 18 Trumbo St. Harleston Village | Council District 8 | TMS# 457-12-01-017| Zoned: DR-1F | BZA2026-002327 Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-501and requests variance from Sec. 54-301 to build a single-family detached dwelling unit on a lot of insufficient size (3,038sf existing, 4000sf required) with a 3’ west side setback and 6’ total side setbacks (9’ and 15’ required), and to exceed maximum lot coverage (57% proposed, 50% allowed). Owner: Cozy Development – 18 Trumbo LLC Applicant: Cozy Studio 2 Comments Submitted in Opposition: • Wiley Becker, 44 Rutledge Avenue, Charleston, SC 29401 Submitted to Innovate Site on Apr. 28, 2026 2:48 PM Harleston Village Association Charleston, South Carolina Re: Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning May 5, 2026 Meeting 18 Trumbo Street (Agenda Item 9) Dear Chair and Members of the Board, On behalf of Harleston Village neighbors, we respectfully oppose the variance request at 18 Trumbo St. The application does not meet the Sec. 54-924 variance criteria and should be denied. 1) No extraordinary or exceptional conditions... §54-924(a) The lot is approximately 3,048 sq ft and conforms to DR-1F. It is rectangular, has standard frontage on Trumbo, sits within a flat urban block, and is not encumbered by natural features / easements / irregular geometry. Applicant drawings (Sheets A100 / A101) show a compliant building envelope is feasible. The overage to 57% results from design choices... a larger footprint, expanded porches, and a back porch addition... not a site hardship. 2) Conditions are not unique... §54-924(b) The 50% coverage limit applies to similarly situated DR-1F parcels on this block. A prior variance at 6 Trumbo was granted due to an undersized lot... a condition not present here. The claimed constraint is common to the district standards, not unique to this property. 3) Reasonable use is not prohibited... §54-924(c) Reasonable as-of-right use can be made without a variance. The request reflects an economic preference to maximize square footage, which is not a cognizable hardship. 4) Harm to adjacent properties and district character... §54-924(d) At 57% coverage, meaningful open space on a narrow lot is eliminated, reducing light / air for 16 and 20 Trumbo, reducing existing off-street parking, and eroding the established rhythm of varied lots / yards that characterizes this block of Harleston Village. Process note... linked program not disclosed to BAR The BAR’s March 26 conceptual approval to shift 16 Trumbo was presented as a boundary correction. In practice, the shift appears to be approximately 11 feet, clearing the side yard for new construction at 18. Zoning relief typically precedes BAR review to avoid precisely this sequencing issue. The BAR did not evaluate an integrated two-lot program, and speculative upside is not a hardship under §54-924. Moving historic homes to make way for new construction is a poor precedent to be set. Please note also that the premature Zillow listing for 16 Trumbo (https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/16-Trumbo- St-Charleston-SC-29401/10904091_zpid/) includes living space beneath the raised home, for which a request to raise the home 2’ above BFE versus the typical 1’ was Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | May 5, 2026 Page 2 preliminarily approved by the BAR-S. Requested action Respectfully deny the variance under Sec. 54-924 on all four required findings. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully submitted, Harleston Village Association • Melissa Voorhees, 17 Trumbo Street Submitted to Innovate Site on May 4, 2026 10:45 AM This letter is to state opposition to the application submitted for 18 Trumbo Street requesting variances to build a single-family detached dwelling unit on a lot of insufficient size, with insufficient setbacks and exceeding the maximum lot coverage. The owners of the property are asking for three significant variances that have the potential to greatly impact the currently already poor water drainage in the vicinity. Our house was rebuilt in 2019 as a direct result of this type of flooding. There are multiple historic homes that are not elevated significantly above the street elevation that would be highly susceptible should conditions worsen. As a neighbor on a street that is often dealing with flooding during periods of heavy rainfall - approving exemptions to buildable lot area and the increase in lot coverage over what is allowed has the potential to compound the issue, with significant negative impact if granted. The exemption is not one driven out of necessity or hardship of any kind. It is driven purely by profit. It is the desire to buy one house and multiply that so that they can sell two houses. The owners are simply trying to maximize the profit on a property with zero regard to how it will impact the adjacent streets or neighborhood. They have that luxury because they have no intent to become a part of that neighborhood. We ask the board to seriously consider the impact these variances will have on the neighborhood- the city is investing significant amounts on water mitigation and protection, which is pointless if we continue to allow construction that goes against the laws in place. A developers ability to profit off a property should not come at the expense of the neighborhoods well being. Please consider the precedence and what is at risk if we continue down this path with approving variances that have the ability to significantly impact the neighborhood. We urge you to deny this request. Thank you for your consideration, Melissa and Ben Voorhees

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.