RecordWell Data

BAR-S Meeting Results

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Apr 23, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL MEETING RESULTS APRIL 23, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Lindsay Van Slambrook, William Bill Turner, Becky Fenno, Darryl Cobb STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: Frankie Pinto, Travis Galli A. Minutes 1. Review of Minutes from the April 9, 2026 Meeting DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Deferred MADE BY: Van Slambrook SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 B. Applications 1. 251 W. Poplar Street BAR2026-002493 | TMS# 463-07-04-006 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1945 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for the partial demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: Robert Chitty Applicant: Brian Crouch Architect, LLC Site visit on 04/23/2026 at 8:30 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval of demolition with staff condition MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Chimney is included in the area of demolition, this is a character defining feature and should be retained as is. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Area of demolition should be adjusted to not include chimney, whether below or adjacent. Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 2 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of demolition with staff conditions BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Clarification that only looking at demolition so cannot discuss retention and reuse of the windows 2. 872 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002519 | TMS# 463-11-03-015 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1940 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting OPT-IN REVIEW for demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way AND conceptual approval for proposed addition. Owner: Joe & Rebecca Miller Applicant: Abigail WR Brennan Site visit on 4/23/2026 at 8:50 a.m. DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Deferral with Board conditions MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Restudy porch roof • Restudy dormer size / proportions • Restudy new bump out STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Staff appreciate that the existing corners have been retained and the new roof for the rear addition is tucked under the existing eave. 2. Dormers follow typical staff conditions, kept down from the ridge and in from the edges. 3. Rear additions appear very disjointed 4. Since this property is one lot over from the corner with Simons, it does have visibility STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Proposed new roof should be hand crimped, standing seam. 2. Restudy additions to simplify the massing STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial as submitted BOARD QUESTIONS: • Column size on front porch, 5 ½” PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 3 o Appreciate applicant responding to feedback o Cumulative effect of alterations o Dormers typically more vertically proportioned o Reference 191 Sans Souci • HCF o Encouraged by rehabilitation o Request porch roof be removed, will significantly alter historic appearance BOARD COMMENTS: • Not sure roof plan works, water shed issue where addition side steps • Appreciate the site visit and being respectful of existing building at the rear • Struggle with addition in the “L” space of the house • Struggle with porch roof changing appearance of modest appearance of the house • Dormer proportions need study • A lot of good stuff going on • Mass of porch roof • Beef up columns • Proportions of dormers need work, maybe narrow into width of windows • Issue with complexity of roof form in the back • Working around the tree. Back is workable, it’s the side addition • Hipped roof over flat roof addition, maybe relate a little better 3. 477 Huger Street BAR2026-002512 | TMS# 460-03-03-103 | Hampton Park Terrace | Council District 6 Category 3 (Group 1) | c. 1915 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for the partial demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: David Gutman, Emma Katzka Applicant: Andrew Nissen Site visit on 04/23/2026 at 9:10 a.m. DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Denial of demolition MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Railing and wraparound porch are character defining and should not be altered STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial of demolition BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 4 o Request denial, character defining features should be retained • PSC o Not in support, should be retained • Kevin Eberle, president of neighborhood association o Didn’t speak to neighborhood association, automatically recommend denial o Not in support, character defining feature BOARD COMMENTS: • Don’t allow enclosure of porches • Clarification of demolition purview, only look at removal • While can’t discuss infill, there are ways to do behind balustrade 4. 22 Ashton Street BAR2026-002402 | TMS# 460-11-01-062 | Westside | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1935 | Old City District Requesting final approval, following previous staff denial, for wholesale siding replacement. (application requests wood replacement) Owner: Katie Lovvorn (speaker) Applicant: Christopher Oberle Site visit on 4/23/2026 at 9:30 a.m. DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Denial as submitted MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Permit denied by staff 12/23/25 due to full siding replacement. (request was for hardie) BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC o Suggest working with staff on which areas can be repaired • HCF o Can’t support wholesale replacement. Encourage working with staff BOARD COMMENTS: • There is significant damage on east side. New siding on addition could be removed • Siding on the front and under piazza in good conditions • Didn’t evaluate rear, if not visible is not under purview • Hardie can exacerbate moisture problems on historic house • Close cell spray foam can cause significant damage Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 5 • Replacing in kind means wood, not specific type of wood • Denial of front and west side, no jurisdiction on rear, work with staff on repair • If staff feels entire east side needs replacement then staff can approve removal 5. 75 Tradd Street BAR2026-002513 | TMS# 457-16-02-005 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1815 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for partial infill of second floor piazza. Owner: Mary Early Applicant: Evans and Schmidt Architects Site visit on 4/23/2026 at 9:50 a.m. DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Deferral for restudy based on Board discussion MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. While staff understand the continuation of the existing piazza enclosure, the existing infill does not follow BAR policy. 2. Proposal will remove the railing and column from visibility on west elevation, which is the only visible portion of the piazza. 3. Drawings note that the railing will be retained in attic. While appreciated, this is not enforceable or under BAR purview STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Restudy BOARD QUESTIONS: • Visibility from the street, only the portion on the side PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Piazza is distinctive feature o Not in support of enclosure • PSC o Not supportive of infill o Already extensive infill BOARD COMMENTS: • On west elevation if previous infill extended to corner, then wouldn’t have purview • Original column is inside existing infill • Awkward as is, will be less awkward as proposed • No rhyme or reason for as is • Existing is not usable porch area • Last remaining piece of piazza that went down this side, but awkward • Will look better as proposed, upstairs piazza already infilled Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 6 • Like seeing reminder that porch was there • Way to retain corner and achieve what client wants • Only 2 ways to clean this up. Either as proposed or bring entire wall in behind columns • Could stop wall at edge of column • Previous approval (last year), hole in wall 6. 62 Society Street BAR2026-002497 | TMS# 458-01-03-045 | Ansonborough | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1840 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval to remove porch enclosure, replace hyphen, removal of previous addition, and renovations to kitchen house. Owner: Williams-Tortorigi Family Trust Applicant: Sebastian von Marschall DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Staff appreciate the return to historic conditions and cleaning up the cluttered façade of the hyphen STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC o Happy to see reversal of 1980s addition o While not visible, would like to encourage reducing size of opening on carriage house • HCF o Happy to see rehab of historic structure, in support BOARD COMMENTS: • Don’t have problem with size of windows as they are not visible from public ROW • On west elevation, tall portion, water table banding. Reference historic porch • Positive changes Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 7 7. 46 Romney Street BAR2026-002501 | TMS# 461-13-01-039 | East Central | Council District 4 Not Surveyed | c. 2005 | Historic Corridor District Requesting conceptual approval for renovation with new entry addition. Owner: St. Andrew’s Church Land Trust Applicant: The Middleton Group – Jennifer Parker DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Staff appreciate the cleaning up the cluttered façade with the new entrance 2. New front façade windows are better proportioned than existing STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Beautifully designed 8. 44 Savage Street BAR2026-002476 | TMS# 457-12-03-129 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 4 | c. 1870 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for new accessory building. Owner: Leslie & Joe Stafford Applicant: Fenno Architecture DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0 Recused: Fenno BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Removal of existing shed can be approved at staff 2. Proposed is subordinate and compatible with existing building Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 8 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Well done • Appreciate the simplicity, relates well to the parent building 9. 30 Society Street BAR2026-002525 | TMS# 458-01-03-030 | Ansonborough | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1840 | Old & Historic District Requesting preliminary approval for rear additions and restoration. Owner: 30 Society St LLC Applicant: Carlin Architecture Studio, Sean Carlin DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board discussion, and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Traditional treatment for streetside door and transom • Refine detail and dimensions of porch rail and columns • Give the bay on the rear most building a separate roof treatment STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Previous motion and conditions have been addressed. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Preliminary approval with final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • Plate height of second floor, 8’ • On Society elevation, louvered shutters between columns PUBLIC COMMENT: • John M_, 58 Anson Street o Louvered front door not in keeping with neighborhood o Existing gate has been there 50+ years, would like retained BOARD COMMENTS: • Original structure, current porch design is much better • Appreciate that retain board and batten shutters, was originally ancillary building Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 9 • Louvered shutter door at street is unusual • Elements begin to tie together • Rear still a little suburban, but better • No existing drawings in submittal, difficult to review • Front seems unresolved, louvered door and transom • Bump out at kitchen should have separate roof • Doesn’t seem sufficient for preliminary • Treatment of door • Design of front isn’t appropriate yet 10. 171 Broad Street BAR2026-002521 | TMS# 457-12-03-039 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 4 | c. 1870 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for fenestration alterations and new rear second story addition. Owner: David & Marianela Flores Applicant: FORMVOID – Charles Kane DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff observations and conditions, Board conditions and preliminary / final review by staff MADE BY: Fenno SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Differentiate the siding STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. While staff have no issue with the second floor addition being inline with the existing structure, the new addition should still be subordinate to the existing. 2. The windows on the front façade are labelled as demolition. Applicant to confirm that they are to be repaired and reinstalled 3. Per the BAR Policy for Screening of Piazzas and Porches: a. Screening for a piazza or porch should be installed in a manner that is completely reversible, resulting in as little damage to the fabric of the building as possible. b. The framework of the screening should be as minimal as possible. c. The framework should be constructed interior of the columns, porch beam, and balustrade so that these elements remain in the forefront. d. The color of the framework should generally be flat black so it recedes into the background or painted to match the columns and balustrade. This will be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. e. Aluminum screening will not be allowed. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Lower the new ridge to tuck under the existing eave 2. Differentiate the new windows STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with staff and Board conditions and preliminary / final review by staff Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 10 BOARD QUESTIONS: • Age of rear addition, 1988. Built at one time • No visibility from Savage Street • Corner board at rear of second floor PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC o Lower roofline, subordinate to historic structure BOARD COMMENTS: • Agree with staff about the roof, needs to tuck under. Maintain window sill alignment • Break in roof form is needed. Either different form or tuck under • Would look disjointed to have different window on second floor • Addition needs to be more distinct than existing house. drop roof, make sure corner board is expressed • Typically would ask for delineation, change in siding, maybe smaller profile • (staff condition 2) Change windows if changing them all (on addition) 11. 3 Savage Street BAR2026-002468 | TMS# 457-12-03-060 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1890 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval to elevate building and shift on site, and fenestration alterations. Owner: H. Chapman McKay Applicant: Sebastain von Marschall DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Deferral for restudy based on Board discussion MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Staff has no issue with carriage door but the divided lite / transom is too similar to the historic structure. Change lite pattern to not match historic window. 2. Lite pattern on south door and window should not match historic windows STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Change lite pattern on carriage doors to not match historic windows. 2. The water table should be at DFE. Should have same special relationship to windows as existing water table. 3. Side addition should have water table to match the elevated existing structure STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with staff and Board conditions and preliminary / final review by staff Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 11 BOARD QUESTIONS: • Raising slab 1’6” above existing grade PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Supportive of elevation o Restudy needed to ensure it reads as elevated 2 story instead of 3 story structure o Elevation guidelines BOARD COMMENTS: • Understand bringing siding down • Understand staff wanting reference for historic placement • Don’t think bump out needs a base, reads as later addition • City guidelines typically to take historic form and raise it up, preserved. Feels like different architect element • Always encouraged keeping much closer to existing • Brick base feels tall • Keep door where it is and add stairs, more pleasant entry experience • Happy brick base rather than stucco, gives texture at eye level • Maintain historic south elevation (door) • Ability to park if stairs are outside. • Could the stairs parallel the building, issue with carriage doors • Retain as much of the existing detailing as possible 12. 114 Cannon Street BAR2026-002522 | TMS# 460-11-04-165 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 6 | Not Surveyed | c. 1850 | Old City District Requesting conceptual approval for new pergola and wall, and fenestration and hardscape alterations. Owner: Rakesh Govindji Applicant: GJS Architecture – Robert Victor Gerber DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Deferral for restudy based upon Board and staff conditions MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Restudy the height. First floor cornice is good reference point STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Previous site wall was removed for life safety. 2. Wall should be behind or inline with the façade of 114 Cannon, not 116 Cannon. 3. Pergola feels too residential in nature, encourage higher degree of detailing or different materiality. 4. There are pergolas at restaurants that both BAR have approved. But they are metal and are set back from the right of way. Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 12 5. The proposed roll top window is inappropriate for historic structure, a casement would be more appropriate. The window is also incorrectly labeled as an existing opening. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Push pergola and wall back on site so the wall is in line with 114 Cannon front façade. 2. If Pergola columns have masonry bases, they should be brick to match wall 3. Restudy pergola material. 4. Restudy rolltop window. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with Board and staff conditions and preliminary / final review by staff BOARD QUESTIONS: • Placement of property line needs to be confirmed along street PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Agree with staff that the pergola should be pushed back either in line or behind façade • Pergola should also be lowered to cornice height • Agree with staff on material on column bases, stay consistent • A roll up window would be inappropriate for a historic building • Would like to see restudy of pergola material. If using pressure treated lumber would look bad in a couple years • Pergola drawn very chunky, if using dimensional lumber won’t look right 13. 47 Legare Street BAR2026-002526 | TMS# 457-12-04-106 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1904 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for new garden wall. Owner: Leslie Morgan Applicant: Leslie Morgan DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. The brick arch is inappropriately scaled. 2. Staff is confused how it would attach to existing wall which curves down to approximately 4’ in height. Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 13 3. Per the BAR policy statement for freestanding walls, fencing and screening a. Fences and walls should be appropriately scaled for their context so as to prevent a fortress-like appearance. 4. Drawings appear contradict one another in the wall / arch size. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deferral for restudy BOARD QUESTIONS: • Removing existing columns and constructing new • Age of existing wall / column, 1970s • Using old English brick instead of Savannah gray • Multiple drawings, one is more appropriately scaled. • Will touch existing wall PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • The curve in existing wall will be filled in • Overall height to top of arch, 7’10” • The second drawing, not the one with the dimensions • Checked ordinance, max wall height of 7’ with a pier height of 8’. Confirm with zoning arch is allowed 14. 12 Franklin Street BAR2026-002401 | TMS# 457-12-01-054 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1851 | Old & Historic District Requesting final approval for installation of metal cornice and fenestration changes. Owner: Alex & Dr. Clayton Crantford Applicant: Glenn Keyes Architects DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Since this is a Category 2, staff can only approve repairs to match. 2. Staff appreciate the return of the cornice. 3. The portions of piazza being infilled are the reconstructed portion. 4. Follows piazza infill policy a. The location of the piazza enclosure shall be to the rear of the piazza, be minimal in size, and not alter the conceptual relationship between the house and the piazza. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 14 BOARD QUESTIONS: • Age of addition. Footprint is old but has been rebuilt. Added on in 1999/2000 • Cornice to be pressed metal PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Easement holder, in compliance with easement o Porch approval conditional on restoration of cornice BOARD COMMENTS: • Infill of piazza typically frowned upon, but not historic piazza • Excited about return of the cornice 15. 299 King Street BAR2026-002494 | TMS# 457-04-04-101 | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1975 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for mural and window graphics. Owner: Ladybird Books, Summer Anderson Applicant: SDCO Partners, Courtney Rowson DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval for the mural, conceptual approval for window graphics on “center bay windows” with preliminary / final by staff MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • See motion STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Staff are always appreciative of public art. Murals must be approved by the Board 2. Window graphics 20% rule, ATF a. By ordinance standard, windows are 100% covered, Sign area shall be calculated as the entire area within a rectangle enclosing the extreme limits of the sign face, including any frame or border. 3. While staff is not opposed to exceeding the 20% window coverage, the scale shown feels more geared to vehicular traffic than pedestrian. Staff would also prefer a non-repeating pattern that is not cut off. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Remove text from window graphics. 2. Remove horizontal signage on canopy. 3. Reduce window coverage using a smaller pattern. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with staff conditions and preliminary / final review by staff BOARD QUESTIONS: • None Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | April 23, 2026 Page 15 PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Ok with the mural. Understand the concept of putting the person under the tree, wonder if is should be placed between the pilasters • The window graphics are overkill, do need to be scaled back • Think window graphics are cool, but concern about precedent setting • Maybe scale graphics to just around front door

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.