RecordWell Data

BAR-L Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Apr 8, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE PUBLIC COMMENT APRIL 8, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Architectural Review – Large (BAR -L) will be held on Wednesday, April 8, 2026 at 4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bar. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 B. APPLICATIONS 1. 589 ½ King Street BAR2026-002516 | TMS #4600804056 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 4 | Category 4 | c. 1890 | Height District 4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Approval of the relocation and partial demolition of a two-story structure. Owner: King and Spring Streets, LCC Applicant: Young + Wales Architects NOTE: The Board will convene at this address on Tuesday, April 7, 2026, at 8:30 a.m. for a site visit. No Comments Submitted 2. Southeastern Corner of Radcliffe Street and Saint Philip Street (address TBD) BAR2026-002514 | TMS #4601602041 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4 New Construction | Height Districts 2.5-3, 4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Conceptual Approval of an apartment complex and public parking garage. Owner: Warren Place Joint Venture Applicant: Evans and Schmidt Architects 13 Comments Submitted: • Fred L. Willis, III, 99 ½ Alexander Street Submitted to Staff on April 7, 2026 With all the talk by the city about better design in Charleston, the proposal for the apartments called Radcliffe Place on the BAR-L agenda this week is, at best a very mediocre design. Sadly, the CofC apartments on Warren Street that front on the corner of Warren and King were approved with similar mediocrity, as was Kelly House and most of CofC housing. Can’t we do better? Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 2 I hope that you will point out that our city deserves better design than what this conceptual plan, and point out the shortcomings of what is before the BAR. This project flies in the face of the city’s stated goal of better design and better quality materials. Please oppose this plan and encourage the applicant to come back with a more architecturally interesting design that compliments rather than detracts from the nearby historic neighborhoods. • Zac Viscidi, 59 Cypress St Submitted to Innovate Site on Feb. 28, 2026 3:26 PM BAR should support the construction of this apartment complex. Increasing the density in the heart of our city will allow CofC to grow. This benefits the entire city as more individuals are able to come to this storied institution, bringing immense economic value to the city and region. This is particularly great because the transportation needs of these individuals, located in the heart of the city will be less impactful. I would encourage the city to lower the parking requirement and allow the developer to build even more units in this building. • Mark Lane, Lane Properties Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Inderjit Singh, 23 Warren Street Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Helen T. Hill, Explore Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • King Street Grocery, 435 King Street Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Arthur S. Milligan, Jr., Housing Authority of the City of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Wesley Ropp, Charleston Water System Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Elizabeth P. Bowles, 85 Montagu Street Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Barry D. Gumb, JFRONE LLC Submitted to Staff See attached letter. Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 3 • Shannon McAloon, Playa Bowls, 429 King Street Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Stephen Nelson, Proof, 437 King Street Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Rev. Dr. JohnBosco Ikemeh, St. Patrick Catholic Church, 127 St. Philip Street Submitted to Staff See attached letter. 3. 280 Meeting Street BAR2026-002508 | TMS #4580103093 | Ansonborough | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1918, 1952 | Height District 3,4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Preliminary Approval of adaptive reuse with an additional story on an existing building and a separate duplex structure. Owner: 280 Meeting Street LLC Applicant: Bello Garris Architects No Comments Submitted 4. 131 Columbus Street BAR2026-002510 | TMS# 4600802001 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 4 | New Construction | Height District 8 | Old and Historic District Requesting Preliminary Approval of a new hotel. Owner: 131 Columbus NPV MCZ SPE LLC Applicant: GREC Architects No Comments Submitted 5. 649 Meeting Street BAR2026-002517 | TMS #4631602060 | East Central | Council District 4 Category 1 | c. 1897 | Height District 4 | Historic Corridor District/Landmark Overlay Requesting Final Approval for the replacement of four windows and one door. Owner: American College of Building Arts (ACBA) Applicant: Sacha Rosen No Comments Submitted 6. 31 Laurens Street BAR2026-002518 | TMS #4580104002 | Ports Area | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 2025 | Height District 56/30V | Old City District Requesting Final Approval of two façade signs. Owner: L&S Charleston Property Owner LLC Applicant: Carolina Moon Signs No Comments Submitted Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 4 7. 40 Line Street BAR2026-002503 | TMS #4590503093 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 4 | New Construction | Height Districts 5, 8 | Old and Historic District Requesting Final Approval of two 600 sqft temporary banners. Owner: LC Line Street Phase I LLC Applicant: Milton Guerrero (FASTSIGNS) No Comments Submitted 8. 295 Calhoun Street BAR2026-002511 | TMS #4570202001 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 New Construction | Height District 7 | Old City District Requesting Preliminary Approval of an approximately 300-unit apartment building with retail space at the ground level. Owner: Southeastern Applicant: Jeffrey Rengering (LS3P) 2 Comments Submitted: • Ellen Hoffman, Charleston, SC Submitted to Staff on March 26, 2026 My comments are regarding #8 on the agenda, 295 Calhoun Street New Construction BAR2026-002511 TMS#4570202001 in Harleston Village. So many concerns regarding this application. The massive size, the poor infrastructure, and the excessive flooding issues especially in this area. This is a portion of Calhoun that will affect the ingress/egress of this street. It's where commuters drive onto the peninsular. Charleston is at a critical point and this project is detrimental to it if it is accepted as is. Please downsize, pay attention to flooding issues and to the impact on present infrastructure that is not in place to support this project currently. • Joe McGee, 1 Magazine Street Submitted to Innovate Site on Apr. 7, 2026 11:55 AM Harleston Village Association Bar & Zoning Committee, respectfully resubmits our September 24 statement regarding 295 Calhoun (attached) and appreciate the applicant’s design progress. However, these changes do not resolve our core concern that the project remains over-scaled and insufficiently responsive to the adjacent residential neighborhood. While traffic and drainage fall outside BAR’s formal scope, their direct impact on nearby properties makes them legitimate concerns. And as the TRC process lacks transparency, there is no clear way to confirm that these issues are being adequately addressed. //////////////////////////// 5 September 2024 City of Charleston Board of Architectural Review-Large 2 George Street, Third Floor Charleston, SC 29401 RE: 295 Calhoun Street Dear Members of BAR-L, Again, and for the seventh time, we write to you today to express our reactions to a new proposal seeking conceptual approval for the very large residential building proposed for 295 Calhoun Street. Our comments reflect a recent meeting with the building’s new design team from which we came away with the sense that the project is moving in more positive direction that did any of its prior iterations. We are agreed that the project is now in more capable hands. Our concerns about the size of the building remain as do our regrets that our neighborhood failed to successfully oppose the Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 5 rezoning now in place along the south side of Calhoun Street. We retain the opinion that the building as proposed still fails to respect the residential scale of our neighborhood. Height comparisons to the hospital district ignore the looming, visually disruptive presence the proposed building will have on our neighborhood. The zoning decision that will allow the proposed building to drop into our neighborhood was, in our opinion, unfortunate. Our neighborhood will soon have to accommodate a five addition to the Ronald MacDonald House, the next in what we fear may be a line of very large buildings along Harleston Village’s northern boundary, all of them, proposed or feared, too tall and too large to fit into the residential scale of our neighborhood. Our previously stated preference for a building not taller than five stories is renewed here. Recognizing that zoning allows for a taller building, we encourage this board to limit the building’s height to seven stories. We repeat our previous preference that the building be set back more from Calhoun Street. We have noted in the past and do so today that in making comparisons to Roper Hospital, this project ignores one of that old building’s attributes, its more generous setback from Calhoun. We acknowledge that although zoning allows building out to property lines that allowance is not a requirement. We renew our observation that setting the proposed building back from Calhoun Street as do both Roper Hospital and MUSC’s Children’s Hospital, will soften the impact of the proposed building on our neighborhood and form a more gracious visual "gateway" to one of Charleston’s most heavily used entry corridors. We note for future discussion that the transition of cladding and delineation of stories as the building turns from Calhoun to Halsey Boulevard as well as the west face of the building strikes us as visually awkward in that the east and west faces of the building do not answer the Calhoun facade. We commend this proposal for modulating the east and west facades of the building but suggest reconsideration of the Calhoun Street façade can find a solution to the two large blocks that now dominate this face of the building. We note that the comparisons drawn between the proposed building and its surroundings all face west and north. At best, we think these comparisons are misleading and submit that the better comparisons would face east and south into our neighborhood. Sincerely, Harleston Village Zoning and Bar Committee RECEIVED MAR 0 9 2026 (*ivoi-(;iiakles-|'on PLANNING OCPAirrMENT February 26, 2026 Mr. Lawrence Courtney BAR 2 George Street, Suite 3100 Charleston, SC 29401 Dear Mr. Courtney: I am the owner of the property located at 23 Warren Street. I have reviewed the Brumley Company plans for the proposed apartment/garage complex to be built at the corner of Radcliffe and St. Philip Streets and I am in full support. I feel that the architecture is excellent and fits well into the neighborhood. The area badly needs the parking and the added apartments ensure that the project will blend in appropriately from a design standpoint. Thank you. Sincerely, Inderjit Sfngh March 9, 2026 Rece/veo Charleston Board of Architectural Review (BAR) Mr. Lawrence Courtney j fvlAR J g 2 George Street, Suite 31 GO f Charleston, SC 29401 Dear Mr. Courtney, 1 am writing to express my strong support for The Brumley Company's proposed development of a 318-space parking garage, with seven residential apartments incorporated along the exterior of the building, at the comer of Radcliffe Street and St. Philip Street. Parking on the Charleston peninsula continues to be one of the most persistent challenges for both residents, students and visitors. This project represents a thoughtful and practical solution by replacing the existing surface lot with a structure that would increase capacity from 73 spaces to 318 spaces, resulting in 245 additional parking spaces in an area where demand consistently exceeds supply. Expanding parking capacity at this location would help alleviate pressure on nearby streets and improve accessibility to the surrounding neighborhood. The additional parking would also provide meaningful support to nearby businesses and institutions. Merchants along the King Street corridor would benefit from increased parking availability within convenient walking distance, helping sustain the vitality of one of Charleston's most important commercial districts. In addition, several nearby houses of worship would see improved accessibility for their congregations, particularly during services and special events when parking demand is highest. Importantly, the project makes efficient use of an existing parking site while incorporating residential units that enhance the peninsula's mixed-use character. Developments that thoughtfully increase capacity without expanding the footprint of surface parking are critical to maintaining Charleston's economic vitality while preserving the character of our historic urban environment. For these reasons, I respectfully encourage your support of this proposal and appreciate your consideration. Helen T. Hill President & CEO CHARLESTON AREA CONVENTION & VISITORS BUREAU 375 Meeting Street I Charleston, South Carolina 29403 I 843.853.8000 I ExploreCharleston.com @ExploreChar}eston ^/® ©ExpIoreCHS Dear Board of Architectural Review, As a King Street retailer, convenient and dependable parking is critical to our customers' decision to visit and stay. Apartments and a garage at Radcilffe and St. Philip would directly support small, locally owned businesses by making downtown shopping easier, more inviting, and less stressful. We have reviewed the design with the applicant and we are in full support of the height, scale and mass of the project. Please support and approve this Important project. Best Regards, king street grocery 435 king street Charleston,SC 29403 Ci 1Q70 1985 AWARD FOR DESIGN EXCELLENCE PRESIDENT RONALD REAGAN HOUSING AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF CHARLESTON 550 MEETING STREET, CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA 29403 TELEPHONE (843) 720-3970 FAX (843) 720-3977 Arthur S. Milligan, Jr. (MBA, CCIM, CPM, PHM) President <& CEO March 2, 2026 Lawrence Courtney (BAR) 2 George Street Suite 3100 Charleston, SC 29401 FEDERAL DESIGN ACHIEVEMENT AWARD NA'nONAL ENDOWMENT FOR THE ARTS 1986, 1991 HONOR AWARD AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS 1997, 2014, 2018 FOUNDERS AWARD HISTORIC CHARLES TON FOUNDATION 1989, 1990, 1997 (AROLOPOLIS AWARD PRESERVATION SOCIETY OF CHARLESTON 2000, 2006 HOUSING ACHIEVEMENT AWARD S.C. STATE HOUSING HNANCE AND DEVELOPiMEiNT AUTHORITT' 1991 SPECIFIC ACTIVITY AWARD U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT 2011,2013, 2014, 2015 HUMAN SERVICE AWARD CCHRCO 2009, 2010,2012 NATIONAL AWARD OF MERIT NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT OFFICIALS RE: Letter of Support for BAR Application - 15 Radcliffe and 120 St. Philip Streets Dear Lawrence Courtney, On hehalf of the Housing Authority of the City of Charleston, I express our support for the BAR application concerning 15 Radcliffe and 120 St. Philip Streets. These proposed changes will enhance the residential character of the neighborhood and align with broader efforts to preserve and improve the surrounding community. Based on our understanding, the project at 15 Radcliffe Street is a necessary step in advancing the planned restoration and use of the property, ensuring that it can contribute meaningfully to the area. Similarly, we understand the project at 120 St. Philip Street will reinforce the residential nature of the neighborhood. This will provide stability and long-term protection for the existing housing, including the four residential units owned by the Housing Authority directly across the street. The Housing Authority remains committed to supporting initiatives that promote neighborhood preservation and responsible development. We respectfully urge the approval of this application, as it represents a positive step toward maintaining the character and livability of this historic community. 1991-98 CERTIFICATE OF EXCELLENCE IN MANAGEMENT OPERATIONS U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT 1994,1999 SUS TAINED PERI'ORMANCE AWARD U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT Celebrating 90 Years ofService Organi^d May 5, 1935 Thank you for your consideration. Should you require any further information, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, Arthur S. Milligan, Jr, President & CEO Charleston Water System PO Box B Charleston, SO 29402 103 St. Philip Street (29403) (843) 727-6800 www.charlestonwater.com March 3, 2026 Board of Commissioners Thomas B. Pritchard, Chairman Kathleen G, Wilson, Vice Chair William E. Koopman, Jr., Commissioner Mayor Wiiiam S. Cogswell, Jr., Ex-Officio City Councilmember Perry K. Waring, Ex-OfficIo Officers Wesley Ropp, CMA, Chief Executive Officer Jonathan Ladd, P.E., Assistant Chief Executive Officer Russell Muggins, P.E., Capital Projects Officer Baker Mordecai, P.E., Chief Operating Officer Evelyn Ferguson, Chief Administrative Officer Heather Coward-Tague, Chief Finandal Officer Tracy Evans, Chief Information Officer Mr. Lawrence Courtney City of Charleston Board of Architectural Review 2 George Street, Suite 3100 Charleston, SC 29401 Re: Proposed Parking Garage at Radcliffe and St. Philip Streets Dear Mr. Courtney: I am writing to express Charleston Water System's support for the proposed parking garage at the comer of Radcliffe and St. Philip Streets, as submitted by Mr. Frank Brumley. We understand that this application seeks architectural approval only and does not involve any requests for zoning variances, height adjustments, or changes in permitted use. We have closely followed the evolution of this project since 2015, including the most recent updates that incorporate residential units along the street frontages. We appreciate the developer's efforts to respond to community feedback and to enhance neighborhood compatibility by wrapping the garage structure with ten residential units—three along St. Philip Street and seven along Radcliffe Street. The addition of student-oriented housing near the College of Charleston, combined with structured parking, represents a thoughtful approach to integrating needed infrastructure with the surrounding built environment. As you know, parking in this portion of the peninsula remains a significant challenge for the general public, students, area businesses, and government entities like CWS. CWS continues to lease off-site parking for employees for weekday parking and allows the public to park in our primary parking lot in the evenings and on weekends. Thank you in advance for your consideration of this application. Sincerely, Wesley Ropp, CMA Chief Executive Officer Charleston Water System cc: Mr. Frank W. Bmmley 67 Broad Street, STE 102 Charleston, SC 29401 Supporting public health and protecting the environment. 85 Montagu Street Charleston, SC. 29401 March 3,2026 Mr. Lawrence Courtney Board of Architectural Review 2 George Street Suite 3100 ICharleston, SC 29401 Dear Sir: I am the owner of 25 and 27 Radcliffe Streets and am very happy to endorse the plans of The Brumley Company currently scheduled before this board on March 11,2026. As previously expressed to this board, Mr Brumley has always been a person of high caliber and a lover of the city of Charleston. He has the highest standards, which are easily shown by his plans for the property fronting on both Radcliffe and St. Philip Street. I am confident that this project will tie a great improvement to the neighborhood. Sincerely, Elizabeth P. Bowles JRFONE LLC 2012 WAPPOO DRIVE CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA 29412 March 16, 2026 Mr. Lawrence Courtney Board of Architectural Review City Of Charleston 2 George Street, Suite 3100 Charleston, South Carolina 29401 Re: Corner of Radcliffe & St. Philip Streets Dear Mr. Courtney: JFRONE LLC is the owner of 5 Warren Street and 9 Warren Street in the City of Charleston. We have no objection to the proposed parking garage and related apartments to be built of the corner of Radcliffe and St. Philip Streets. I am available should you need further assurance. With kind regards, Barry D. Gumb Member of JFRONE LLC fc-^' ^■,. , ,.i'5''3^J« " '-' f' '' - • * ', . '"' c ^ March 2,2026 Dear Board of Architectural Review, Our business has been on King St since 2018. As a King Street retailer, convenient and dependable parking is critical to our customers' decision to visit and stay downtown. Apartments and a garage at Radcliffe and St. Philip would directly support small, locally owned businesses by makmg downtown topping easier, more inviting, and less stressful. We have reviewed the design with the applicant and we are in fiill support of the height, scale and mass of the project. Please support and approve this important project. Best Regards, a Shannon McAloon Playa Bowls 429 King St Charleston, SC 29403 Dear Board of Architectural Review, As a King Street retailer, convenient and dependable parking is critical to our customers' decision to visit and stay. Apartments and a garage at Radcliffe and St. Philip would directly support small, locally owned businesses by making downtown shopping easier, more inviting, and less stressful. We have reviewed the design with the applicant and we are in full support of the height, scale and mass of the project. Please support and approve this important project. 437 King Street Charleston, SC, 29403 received FEB 2 7 2026 UlYOKCIl.M{U':iilO\ planning DKPAnrMFMT October 30, 2024 February 24, 2026 Lawrence Courtney Board of Architectural Review 2 George Street, Suite 3100 Charleston, SC 29401 RE: Project Design Proposed for the corner of Radcliffe and St. Philip Streets, Charleston Dear Mr. Courtney and Members of the Board: As pastor of St. Patrick Catholic Church on St. Philip Street, I write you representing the four hundred and fifty (450) families who come to worship with us every weekend. I’m happy to share that my parish and I are in full support of Brumley Company’s design for the corner of Radcliffe and St. Philip Streets. We have supported the developer from the inception as approvals have been sought for prior permits for zoning and moving of a house from 15 Radcliffe to 120 St. Philip. As you know, St. Patrick has been at the corner of Radcliffe and St. Philip for almost 200 years. We have had the pleasure of working with the Brumley Company and have truly valued their role in enhancing the neighborhood through their business. We are pleased with the proposed design of their plan, especially with the addition of apartments which allows the parking structure to better blend in with the surrounding neighborhood. Having a parking lot nearby will only help us better serve our parishioners. We have every reason to believe that they will continue their excellent work with the properties they are seeking design approval of on this corner. Sincerely, Rev. Dr. JohnBosco Ikemeh Cc: Frank Brumley 127 St. Philip Street Charleston, SC 29403 Telephone: (843) 723-6066

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.