RecordWell Data

BAR-L Meeting Results

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Apr 8, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE MEETING RE SULTS APRIL 8, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: James Meadors (Chair), Luda Sobchuk, Joel Trantham, Eddie Bello (Item 8 only) STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: B.D. Wortham-Galvin, Lawrence Courtney, Brad Thomas A. MINUTES 1. Review of Minutes from March 11, 2026, Meeting DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval of Minutes MADE BY: Trantham SECOND: Sobchuk VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0 B. APPLICATIONS 1. 589 ½ King Street BAR2026-002516 | TMS #4600804056 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 4 | Category 4 | c. 1890 | Height District 4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Approval of the relocation and partial demolition of a two-story structure. Owner: King and Spring Streets, LCC Applicant: Young + Wales Architects NOTE: The Board will convene at this address on Tuesday, April 7, 2026, at 8:30 a.m. for a site visit. DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval of relocation and partial demolition of structure as submitted with Staff Conditions MADE BY: Sobchuk SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • The Sanborn maps show a historic fabric pattern that will not be adversely affected by moving the structure closer to 593 King Street. The structure’s relationship to the sidewalk will remain the same. • There is a two -story addition to the rear of the structure that does not appear on the original Sanborn map, but is still older than 50 years old . Staff are not opposed to its demolition. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | April 8, 2026 Page 2 • The partial demolition maintains the historic brick wrap around on the ground floor. • The partial demolition maintains all the dormers on the north side of the structure and maintains 3 of the 4 dormers on the south side of the structure. The rear most dormer is visible from King Street (both currently and when moved). • The architecture is modest and the most significant façade, that facing King Street, will remain. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Salvage and reuse of historic materials. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of partial demolition and relocation of structure as submitted See City of Charleston YouTube Channel for Board Discussion 2. Southeastern Corner of Radcliffe Street and Saint Philip Street (address TBD) BAR2026-002514 | TMS #4601602041 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4 New Construction | Height Districts 2.5-3, 4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Conceptual Approval of an apartment complex and public parking garage. Owner: Warren Place Joint Venture Applicant: Evans and Schmidt Architects DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Condition and to restudy corner and detailing of precast elements MADE BY: Trantham SECOND: Sobchuk VOTE: FOR: 2 AGAINST: 1 Meadors against. STAFF COMMENTS: • The Applicant has met all Zoning requirements. • In general, Staff support the height, scale, and mass of the project. • Staff appreciate lining the parking deck with apartments at Radcliffe and Saint Philip Streets as it supports the context of the neighborhood. Staff support the architectural direction of the apartment structure. • Staff also support the different architectural expression on Radcliffe Street that clearly articulates the garage stair tower and car entrance/exit. Having different types of fenestration between the garage entrance and the apartments makes the program differentiation clear. • The garage is minimally visible from Warren Street (A0.3C, views 1 & 2), has partial visibility from Saint Philip Street (A0.3C, view 3), and is highly visible from Radcliffe Street. • Staff appreciate the use of brick on the highly visible façade on Radcliffe Street and the articulation of detailing at the top of the garage at that moment. Continued study of how to provide visual relief across the large expanse of blank wall is encouraged. • Staff recommend using the Radcliffe approach to material and detailing on the parts of the garage visible from Saint Philip Street, particularly the treatment of the stair tower which well set back in the block, appears to be particularly visible between t he Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | April 8, 2026 Page 3 single-family residence and the Warren Place structures. Staff require an enhanced render and continued study of the blank wall and its materiality at that moment (A0.3C, view 3). The prominence of the stair tower on Radcliffe Street makes sense as an architectural cue on a major public of right of way and entrance to the garage . Staff are less clear on why the tower that sits mid-block, and is visible from Saint Philip Street, would have the same type of prominent massing and roof articulation; particularly when the architectural direction of the elevations is different. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Continued study of the garage blank wall/stair tower materiality and details and its relative visibility behind the Saint Philip Streetscape. 2. At Preliminary, physical material samples are required. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions BOARD COMMENTS: • Agree with Staff Comment and many of the community comments that wrapping the parking garage with apartments is a positive solution. • This project has a relatively complex site shape and form so a critical component as this gets developed is working through unity of some of the materials and massings that help to break down but also create relationships across these elements. • There are some areas that need restud y, which include the blank walls. And having a clear understanding of which blank walls have brick and which ones do not, especially the ones visible to the street. The blank walls need materials and details that work with the language of the building. • Also understand the need to get the windows up in the level shift, but there are architectural elements (banding, cornices) that seem unresolved at this point and could benefit from some continuity. The (apartment) corner is one of those elements as well. • The architectural character could use some restudy/resolution. • Agree with all the comments by Staff the ones just mentioned by Board. • The blank walls that you can see from the street are very imposing and monolithic. Maybe there is a way to break it up horizontally and vertically (while remaining on the property line) with patterns or change of materials. • The apartment entrance on the corner of Saint Phillips and Radcliffe feels like an appendage and is not strong enough next to the masonry. It would benefit from more study. • The concept is well thought out. We are looking at height, scale, mass and architectural direction and a big part of that is those big blank walls on Radcliffe Street and through corridors (on Saint Philip). It is not resolved at all. The details are significant. • Also share the concerns about the (apartment) corner entrance and how that modification or restudy could effect H/S/M. See City of Charleston YouTube Channel for Board Discussion Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | April 8, 2026 Page 4 3. 280 Meeting Street BAR2026-002508 | TMS #4580103093 | Ansonborough | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1918, 1952 | Height District 3,4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Preliminary Approval of adaptive reuse with an additional story on an existing building and a separate duplex structure. Owner: 280 Meeting Street LLC Applicant: Bello Garris Architects DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Preliminary Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions with Final Review By Staff MADE BY: Sobchuk SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • The Applicant received Conceptual Approval from the Board on 11 March 2026. • At Conceptual Board and Staff had no comments or conditions for the rear accessory structure, approving of its H/S/M and architectural direction. • Also, at Conceptual, Board and Staff required the following for the main structure: (1) renderings of the pedestrian experience from the south (2) the restudy of the parapet/cornice on the third -story addition to the main structure (and/or the heavy appearance of the third-story addition) (3) restudy the lack of articulation/texture on the south elevation • The Applicant has provided a rendering of the pedestrian experience of South elevation (headed north) as requested. • The Applicant has restudied the third -story addition at the cornice/parapet and articulation of the south elevation as requested. • The appearance of the cornice and parapet has been subtly reduced and the change in materiality of the penthouse aids in both the subordination of the third story as well as providing additional texture. • The mechanicals and elevators on the roof appear more prominent in elevation drawings but are set back mid -structure so are not as visible in renderings as they appear in orthographics. Nevertheless, Staff may ask for screening at final review or in the permit upon further investigation of visibility. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. If physical material samples are not offered at this meeting, they are required the next time the applicant appears before the Board. [Note: physical materials were shown at this meeting] STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Preliminary Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions with Final Review by Staff See City of Charleston YouTube Channel for Board Discussion Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | April 8, 2026 Page 5 4. 131 Columbus Street BAR2026-002510 | TMS# 4600802001 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 4 | New Construction | Height District 8 | Old and Historic District Requesting Preliminary Approval of a new hotel. Owner: 131 Columbus NPV MCZ SPE LLC Applicant: GREC Architects DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Preliminary Approval with Board and Staff Comments and restudy of windows and details on West Elevation with Final Review by Board MADE BY: Trantham SECOND: Sobchuk VOTE: FOR: 2 AGAINST: 1 Meadors against. STAFF COMMENTS: • The Applicant received Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Conditions on 24 April 2024. • Board and Staff asked the Applicant to continue to study and refine color of metal panels on elevators shafts and blank west façade metal panels that align below as they appeared too dark in the renders. • The Applicant has restudied as requested. The cladding of the elevator shaft has been changed. The metal panels are now limestone plaster and are lighter in color. Staff support this change. • In addition, upon further study of the car drop off area on Columbus Street, the Applicant changed the dimensions of the arched columns and the area wherein cars may maneuver and increased the pedestrian area. Staff support these changes. • Staff have no comments related to the details as shown. • BAR purview of hardscape extends only to the property line. Any hardscape/landscape shown along the Lowline is required to go before DRC for approval. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. If physical material samples are not offered at this meeting, they are required the next time the applicant appears before the Board. [Note: physical materials were brought to this meeting] STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Preliminary Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions BOARD COMMENTS: • Is it possible to realign the arch stacks/the spacing of the bricks? • Their precedent sheet on A -25 does show examples of arches that don’t have an alignment pattern. • Very pleased at what has been brought forward here. This building as a uniform architectural identity that produces scale by the rhythm and order that is inherent in the architecture. The references you brought at quite applicable to this building and we don’t always see that. • You have set up on north, south, and east a language that is dynamic and refined. The west elevation windows are not the same and that extra window jutted out is quite jarring; when you add an extra pane of a window rather than it being the edge of the Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | April 8, 2026 Page 6 window that’s shifting. This side doesn’t have the regular armature that the other sides have. There is a justification for keeping the windows a little more like they were at Conceptual. The west elevation breaks from the window motif. It’s such a well refined element and want to see it here as well. • Liked the development of the reveal details from Conceptual to Preliminary. • Some of the material choices and changes are quite nice and have been improvements. • Agree with all of the comments about the west elevation. Understand that some of the changes are driven by interior changes/layouts, but the west elevation still needs work in not being consistent with the north, south and east. The west is lacking based o n the other 3 sides. • Given the site, the west façade is working as is. See City of Charleston YouTube Channel for Board Discussion 5. 649 Meeting Street BAR2026-002517 | TMS #4631602060 | East Central | Council District 4 Category 1 | c. 1897 | Height District 4 | Historic Corridor District/Landmark Overlay Requesting Final Approval for the replacement of four windows and one door. Owner: American College of Building Arts (ACBA) Applicant: Sacha Rosen DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval of window and door replacement with Board and Staff Comments and Final Review by Staff of For Permit Drawings. MADE BY: Trantham SECOND: Sobchuk VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • As a Category 1 building, Staff cannot approve in-kind replacements. • Staff support this request as well as the desire of the ACBA to do the work in house. STAFF CONDITIONS: Staff have no conditions. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of window and door replacement with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions and Final Review by Staff of For Permit Drawings. See City of Charleston YouTube Channel for Board Discussion Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | April 8, 2026 Page 7 6. 31 Laurens Street BAR2026-002518 | TMS #4580104002 | Ports Area | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 2025 | Height District 56/30V | Old City District Requesting Final Approval of two façade signs. Owner: L&S Charleston Property Owner LLC Applicant: Carolina Moon Signs DECISION: WITHDRAWN STAFF NOTE: Withdrawn by Applicant at Meeting 7. 40 Line Street BAR2026-002503 | TMS #4590503093 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 4 | New Construction | Height Districts 5, 8 | Old and Historic District Requesting Final Approval of two 600 sqft temporary banners. Owner: LC Line Street Phase I LLC Applicant: Milton Guerrero (FASTSIGNS) DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Denial of the temporary signage with Board and Staff Comments MADE BY: Trantham SECOND: Sobchuk VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: The following Zoning Ordinance clauses and BAR policy statements are relevant to this application. ­ Art. 1, Part 3, Sec, 54-120: Definitions ▪ Real Estate Sign. A temporary sign advertising the real property upon which the sign is located for rent, for lease, or for sale, and providing the name and location of the owner or his agent. ­ Art. 4, Part 3, Sec. 54-402: ▪ This Article shall not affect the jurisdiction of the Board of Architectural Review… to consider and act on applications for signage on premises within its jurisdiction, and nothing herein shall be construed to accord to an applicant a right to a sign of a particular design, size, height, or number thereof on premises within the jurisdiction of the Board of Architectural Review. ­ Art. 4, Part 3, Sec. 54-411: ▪ (b): Real estate or project signs shall be allowed without a permit, provided the following restrictions for the type of sign used are met: 1) 2(b):…multi-family developments containing eight (8) or more units…one (1) real estate or project sign not exceeding thirty -two (32) square feet in sign area per face and sixty -four (64) square feet in total sign area, and, if freestanding, not exceeding e ight (8) feet in height, shall be permitted. Property with two (2) or more street frontages shall be permitted one (1) additional sign per frontage. 2) 4: Real estate signs shall be removed within thirty (30) days of the rent, sale, or lease of a property. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | April 8, 2026 Page 8 ▪ (d): In lieu of a project sign or real estate sign as described in paragraph b above, banners associated with the opening of a new residential community, business, or institution may be erected without a permit. Said banners may be in place for up to thirt y (30) days from the date of the initial opening. Banner signs used in this manner shall be restricted to one banner at each entrance to the development, not to exceed forty -eight (48) square feet in size for each banner. Banners are to be attached to a pe rmanent structure, such as a building or fence, and not temporary supports, trees, automobiles, etc. • While the BAR does not have a formal policy statement on temporary signage, Staff reviews such applications on the powers and duties given to the BAR and its Staff in the Zoning Ordinance. • The applicant is proposing two 600 sqft banners that advertise the opening of the Line and Low apartments. • Regardless of whether an applicant meets the Zoning Ordinance requirements for temporary signage, the BAR has the authority to deny the sign based on its appropriateness. • Based on the Zoning Ordinance clauses stated previously, the application does not meet the requirements to be exempt from a sign permit. • Historically, Preservation staff have reviewed temporary signage at an administrative level, regardless of whether a permit is required or not, as they are exterior elements. • The signage proposed is excessively large • The applicant did not propose a timeframe for when the sign would be up in their application • The submittal does not show how the signs will be mounted on the building. • Staff is not opposed to temporary signage that meets the requirements of the Zoning ordinance STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial of the temporary signage. BOARD COMMENTS: • Staff comments are comprehensive on what is typical for Charleston and what is typically allowable in the Ordinance. • This is excessively large. It is close to the size of a Billboard. It is excessively large in its square footage compared to typical real estate signs. • Agree with everything that has been said here and by Staff. It’s too much. It’s blocking the building. It’s not Charleston. • Anchoring through the masonry is not acceptable. It’s part of a typical condition we would have here is that nothing would be anchored through the actual masonry. See City of Charleston YouTube Channel for Board Discussion Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | April 8, 2026 Page 9 8. 295 Calhoun Street BAR2026-002511 | TMS #4570202001 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 New Construction | Height District 7 | Old City District Requesting Preliminary Approval of an approximately 300-unit apartment building with retail space at the ground level. Owner: Southeastern Applicant: Jeffrey Rengering (LS3P) DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Preliminary Approval with Board and Staff Comments and further drawings of details for FRP and Precast joints and transition of materials and restudy of South façade balconies and mockup drawings with Final Review by Board MADE BY: Bello SECOND: Sobchuk VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 1 Meadors against. STAFF COMMENTS: • The Applicant received Conceptual Approval on 25 September 2024. • At the Conceptual Review, the Board and Staff asked for: (1) Restudy of the dark loggia on Calhoun. (2) All elevations shown in orthographic (not just renders). (3) Restudy of the South Façade for verticality and compositional hierarchy in the metalwork/balcony section. (4) Further study of the top of the building. • The Applicant has enclosed the loggia programming it with an amenity space. Staff support this response. • Elevations have been provided by the Applicant. The Calhoun and Halsey Street sides have always had sufficient verticality and did not require restudy. Staff are not concerned with the repetition on the Halsey Street hyphens are they are not long enough to cause concern. Staff support the brick South elevation massings with their rhythm of windows and balconies providing vertical articulation. Staff still find the South inner courtyard elevations to have a repetition that tends toward horizontal rather than vertical in the renderings. • The Applicant has pulled back rooftop equipment and used screening to conceal their appearance. Staff support this way of dealing with the roof line rather than an overly pronounced parapet and cornice. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. If physical material samples are not offered at this meeting, they are required the next time the applicant appears before the Board. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Preliminary Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions BOARD COMMENTS: • There are two things that are important to discuss, and one is that there are there material languages: there’s the FRP, the brick, and the precast. The joints at which these materials meet are critical. At the Calhoun Street façade there is a reveal detai l but Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | April 8, 2026 Page 10 there are other conditions where these materials are colliding. Those details aren’t quite resolved (e.g. where the brick and the step out cornice meet the FRP). Inside the brick, the details are good. Looking at the precast and the FRP and looking at the seaming and how they are going to come together, are they going to create a uniform look that’s going to be critical to be expressed across these elevations. If there are visible seams that break up the verticality that is a problem. • Wall sections would help for us to understand those transitions. • The joints need to be drawn. • The building has been developed really well and overall handsome. The site plan and public space is well done. • Don’t have a good feel for the FRP. It’s not a small component. It can be not so great if the joints are in weird places (e.g. in the middle of an arch). The joints are the biggest concern. • Leaving the mechanicals screened is the right decision. Might be worth looking at a lighter color so it doesn’t match the color of that top green so it recedes. • Might want to restudy the brick so it doesn’t become a big brown building. • The joints in the precast also need to be clarified. See City of Charleston YouTube Channel for Board Discussion

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.