01-11-2022 Meeting Minutes
City of Westminster · Oconee County · meeting of Oct 1, 2011 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Westminster
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
January 11, 2022
MINUTES
WESTMINSTER CITY COUNCIL
Regular Scheduled Meeting
Tuesday, January 11, 2022
The City Council of the City of Westminster met in a regular scheduled meeting on Tuesday,
January 11, 2022 at 6:00 pm at the Westminster Depot with Mayor Brian Ramey presiding. Those
in attendance were:
Brian Ramey Dale Glymph Rusty Cater
Jimmy Powell Danny Duncan Yousef Mefleh
Brad Chastain
City Administrator, Kevin Bronson
Rebecca Overton
Utility Director, Leigh Baker
Police Chief, Matt Patterson
Fire Chief, Michael Smith
City Attorney, Andrew Holliday
Members of the public and press
Notice of the meeting and the agenda was posted on a window at the Depot and at
westminstersc.org twenty-four hours prior to the meeting and all persons, organizations and
local media requesting notification and the agenda were notified by email.
Call to Order
Mayor Ramey called the meeting to order at 6:00 pm.
Invocation and Pledge of Allegiance
Mr. Rod Lyda, Pastor of Crossroads Baptist Church led the Council in the invocation
and pledge.
Certification of Quorum
Rebecca Overton certified a quorum.
Public Comments
1. Attorney Rick McDuff addressed Council with concerns about the AMI fee. He asked
Council to rescind the fee and refund the taxpayers. He informed Council his client
was ready to proceed with legal action if they do not remove the fee.
2. Rod Lyda, pastor of Crossroads Baptist Church asked Council for approval for a
Passion Service on April 15
th and suggested they be allowed to use the Depot
parking lot or the Retreat Street Park area. He also said they were planning to feed
2
January 11, 2022
the community and suggested it would be a time to unite people while spreading the
good news of Jesus.
3. Frankie Pearson thanked Council for what they do. He stated he believes a terrible
wrong has been done to citizens by still charging the AMI fee. He said he also
believed that everyone should pay the same amount for all services, regardless of
whether they are inside or outside city limits. He asked Council to step up and do
what is right.
4. Adam Dunn reminded Council that he is trying to build a Mother-in-Law suite and
said he had tried to get the property rezoned to allow it, but the rezoning did not
pass. He asked Council to consider changing the city ordinance to allow a detached
unit on his property and that the neighbors have no issues.
Comments from the Mayor and Council
Mayor Ramey addressed Mr. Dunn and stated that in order to give him the rezoning
like he had wanted, they would have opened the door for potential mobile home parks.
Mr. Ramey also addressed the AMI fee and stated that Council had already voted on
a first reading to remove the AMI fee. He stated that if a second reading goes through
then the fee will be removed and an audit of the AMI project will be conducted to
determine credits or refunds.
Danny Duncan stated that Council should have done what they said they were going
to do concerning the AMI fee and reduced it. He stated he is in favor of having Mr.
Bronson come up with a solution to give money back to the customers.
Mr. Mefleh stated that customers feel like they were over charged and that Council
needs to do what is needed to make it right.
Presentation by the Westminster Special Events Committee
Lacey Watkins and Jessica Glymph were present to give updates and address some
concerns about the Special Events Committee. Jessica stated that the Committee assists with
City events and other outside vendor events. She stated that the Committee asks for money
each year and for the most part, it is about the same each year. She said as the Committee
gets involved in more events, the bigger the need is for more money. She asked Council to
consider writing the Committee expenses as a regular line item expenditure in the annual
budget. She also asked Council to consider making a separate budgeted line item expense for
commercial decorations for Christmas, Fall, etc. She said this would free up some of the
expenses for the Committee as currently they are buying noncommercial grade decorations and
they just do not hold up. Jessica also asked Council to consider appointing the Committee a
designated storage area that would only be accessible to them to store all of the supplies and
decorations. She also asked Council to consider a more permanent structure of public
restrooms so that they could save a good portion on rented facilities.
3
January 11, 2022
Old Business
1. Second Reading of Ordinance #2022-01-11-01; Budget Amendment #3 to amend the
FY2021/2022 Annual Budget.
The FY2021/2022 Westminster Utility Budget includes a Meter Fee, which is charged to
all customers using the Automated Meter Reading System. The fee is $7.00 for each water
meter and each electric meter. In the event a water and electric meter are on the same account,
then only one fee is charged. If there are multiple locations then multiple $7.00 fees are applied.
That fee is charged to inside and outside City Customers. The budgeted revenue for this fee is
$308,119. The average monthly revenue is $25,677.
In order to remove the fee, the following usage increases are proposed:
Inside City:
1) remove the Meter Fee
2) no rate increase
Outside City:
1) remove the Meter Fee
2) 10% increase to the base fee
3) 24.95% increase to the per/1000 gallons
Mr. Bronson reminded Council this was a second reading of a previous passed
Ordinance and that if passed would not go into effect until the March 2022 billing. He also
advised Council that if passed it would be appropriate to do an audit of revenue and expenses
of the AMI project to determine what amount of credit or refund was justified. He stated that he
would ask Financial Advisor Jason White to assist with this audit.
Mr. Duncan stated that he felt it was essential to do the audit because customers
deserve an exact figure and asked everyone to be compassionate and understanding regarding
the City trying to fix water problems through the old lines.
Mr. Chastain expressed concern about understanding how the rate increase was going
to make up the revenue after the AMI fee was removed. Mr. Bronson assured him the math and
calculations used to determine the increase was carefully considered and calculated.
Mr. Cater wanted to clarify that the Ordinance does two things – it removes the AMI Fee
and passes the rate increase. He suggested a no vote for the Ordinance for rate increase
purposes would indeed leave the AMI fee active. Mr. Bronson verified this explanation as
correct.
Mr. Ramey reminded Council that they had discussed on other occasions the expensive
costs associated with covering over 130 miles of outside city limit lines. He stated removing the
fee and implementing the rate increase was the only way to make up the revenue the fee was
generating.
Upon a motion by Mr. Ramey and seconded by Mr. Glymph, the motion to approve
Ordinance #2022-01-11-01, amending the FY2021/2022 Budget, failed.
4
January 11, 2022
New Business
1. Appointment of a Mayor Pro Tempore for 2022
Upon a motion by Mr. Cater and seconded by Mr. Chastain, the motion to
nominate Danny Duncan as Mayor Pro-Temp for 2022 passed unanimously.
2. Appointment of a new Board Member for the Fire Department 1% Local Board of
Trustees
Upon a motion by Mr. Chastain and seconded by Mr. Duncan, the motion to
nominate Mr. Cater as the new Board Member for the Fire Department 1 %
Local Board of Trustees passed unanimously.
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Motion Yes
Cater No
Glymph Second Yes
Chastain No
Duncan No
Mefleh No
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Motion Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Second Yes
Duncan Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Motion Yes
Duncan Second Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Yes
5
January 11, 2022
3. Appointment to the Sewer Board
Upon a motion by Mr. Chastain and seconded by Mr. Ramey, the motion to
appoint Kevin Bronson and Leigh Baker to the Sewer Board passed
unanimously.
4. Appointment to the PMPA Board
Currently, Mr. Bronson is the PMPA Board Director and Mr. Chastain is the
Alternate Director.
Upon a motion by Mr. Powell and seconded by Mr. Cater, the motion to appoint
Brian Ramey as Alternate Director to the PMPA Board passed unanimously.
Upon a motion by Mr. Powell and seconded by Mr. Cater, the motion to pass the
PMPA Alternate Director Resolution passed unanimously.
5. Appointment to the Oconee Economic Alliance
Currently Mr. Bronson serves on the Oconee Economic Alliance but there is
another seat available.
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Second Yes
Cater Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Motion Yes
Duncan Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Second Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Yes
Duncan Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Motion Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Second Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Yes
Duncan Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Motion Yes
6
January 11, 2022
Upon a motion by Mr. Mefleh and seconded by Mr. Duncan, the motion to
appoint Mr. Powell to the Oconee Economic Alliance passed unanimously.
6. Appointment to the Local Development Board
Currently Mr. Duncan is on the Local Development Board and all Council
Members agreed that he continue to serve.
7. Appointment to the Special Events Committee
Mr. Duncan asked the City Attorney if it would be a conflict of interest of Mr.
Gymph served on the Committee since his wife Jessica is currently on the
Committee. Mr. Bronson clarified that the conflict may arise from HTAX monies
that are allocated for the Committee and Mr. Glymph being on Council who
oversees the allocation. He suggested having the Attorney draft a letter to the
Ethics Commission and ask them for a definitive answer on the issue. Mr. Cater
agreed with asking the Ethics Commission for an opinion on the matter and
asked that Mr. Glymph abstain from any votes regarding the Events Committee
or Big Foot Festival.
After discussion, it was agreed to wait on voting on Mr. Glymph until after an
opinion is received from the Ethics Commission.
At this point, Mr. Mefleh stated that when the vote was taken earlier on the
Budget Amendment and AMI Resolution that he did not fully understand the
ramifications of his vote. Mr. Holliday informed Mr. Mefleh that in order for the
topic to be discussed then he would need to make a motion to reconsider the
item.
Upon a motion by Mr. Mefleh and seconded by Mr. Glymph, the motion to
reopen discussion on Ordinance #2022-01-11-01 passed.
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Yes
Duncan Second Yes
Mefleh Motion Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater No
Glymph Second Yes
Chastain No
7
January 11, 2022
Mr. Mefleh clarified that he wanted the $7 AMI Fee to be taken off and did not realize
when he voted no on the Ordinance earlier that the fee would remain.
Upon a motion by Mr. Mefleh and seconded by Mr. Glymph the motion to approve
Ordinance #2022-01-11-01 as presented passed.
8. Consider Adoption of Safety Policy Statement
The Safety Policy Statement is adopted annually as a measure to lower our risk
rating for renewal with the MASC Insurance Program.
Upon a motion by Mr. Duncan and seconded by Mr. Ramey the motion to adopt
the Safety Policy Statement as presented passed unanimously.
9. Law Enforcement Assistance and Support Agreement: West Union
Upon a motion by Mr. Duncan and seconded by Mr. Chastain the motion to
approve the Law Enforcement Assistance and Support Agreement: West
Union passed unanimously.
Duncan No
Mefleh Motion Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater No
Glymph Second Yes
Chastain No
Duncan No
Mefleh Motion Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Second Yes
Cater Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Yes
Duncan Motion Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Yes
8
January 11, 2022
10. Consider Bid Award for Installation/Construction of a Raw Water Intake Pump House
The scope of this project includes the construction/installation of a building to
house two pumps and the installation of necessary electrical components to
operate the raw water intake. This project is to be funded from the Oconee
County ARP Funds.
Upon a motion by Mr. Duncan and seconded by Mr. Chastain the motion to
award the bid to Sterling Structure & Design in the amount of $262,000.00
passed unanimously.
11. Consider Two Bid Awards for Emergency Repairs to the Sewer System
These bids are for emergency repairs to the sewer lines along Retreat Street and
Mimosa Road as well as the 300 block of Retreat Street. Projects will be paid
with the State ARP Funds.
Upon a motion by Mr. Duncan and seconded by Mr. Mefleh the motion to award
the bid for emergency repairs for sewer line pipe bursting along Retreat
Street and Mimosa Road in the amount of $37,344.19 to Roper Brothers Inc.
General Contractors passed unanimously.
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Second Yes
Cater Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Motion Yes
Duncan Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Second Yes
Duncan Motion Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Yes
Glymph Yes
9
January 11, 2022
Upon a motion by Mr. Mefleh and seconded by Mr. Cater the motion to approve the
use of Roper Brothers Inc. General Contractors daily rate schedule for
emergency repairs to sewer lines along the 300 block of Retreat Street passed
Unanimously.
12. Consider Bid Award to Replace Two Sludge Pumps
The Water Treatment Plant has two sludge pumps. One that has been
inoperable for more than 10 years. The other pump has had extensive repairs in
the last five years and needs replacing. This project will be funded from Oconee
County ARP Funds.
Upon a motion by Mr. Duncan and seconded by Mr. Chastain the motion to
award the bid to Electric Motors and Drive Inc. for $18,670.00 to replace two
sludge pumps passed unanimously.
13. Consider Resolution supporting Appalachian Regional Commission grant match,
50% or $34,000.00
Upon a motion by Mr. Chastain and seconded by Mr. Cater the motion to
approve the resolution committing the City of Westminster to providing a
local match for the Appalachian Regional Commission (arc) funds
Chastain Yes
Duncan Motion Yes
Mefleh Second Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Second Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Yes
Duncan Yes
Mefleh Motion Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Second Yes
Duncan Motion Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Yes
10
January 11, 2022
managed by the South Carolina Department of Commerce Grants
Administration passed unanimously.
14. Consider Approval of the FY 2023 Budget Calendar
Mayor Ramey notated that a correction would need to be made to the City
Council Priority Setting Workshop. The Budget Calendar reflects a meeting for
January 26
th but that meeting should be on January 25th.
Upon a motion by Mr. Duncan and seconded by Mr. Glymph the motion to
approve the FY 2023 Budget Calendar passed unanimously.
15. Consider Conserfund Amendment 3
The Conserfund Loan Agreement is between the City of Westminster and the SC
Energy Office and is an ongoing Water Plant project that is being extended.
Upon a motion by Mr. Duncan and seconded by Mr. Cater the motion to approve
Conserfund Loan Amendment No. 3 passed unanimously.
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Second Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Motion Yes
Duncan Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Yes
Glymph Second Yes
Chastain Yes
Duncan Motion Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Second Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Yes
Duncan Motion Yes
Mefleh Yes
11
January 11, 2022
Routine Business
1. Approval of the December 9, 2021 Regular Meeting Minutes
Upon a motion by Mr. Cater and seconded by Mr. Duncan the motion to approve
the December 9, 2021 Regular Meeting Minutes passed unanimously.
2. Approval of the January 4, 2022 City Council Swearing-In Minutes
Upon a motion by Mr. Cater and seconded by Mr. Duncan the motion to approve
the January 4, 2022 City Council Swearing-In Minutes passed unanimously.
3. Comments from the Utility Director
Mr. Baker informed Council that crews has smoked sewer lines and found
some issues to fix. He also stated that he was seeing a reduction in the I
& I flow.
Mr. Baker addressed the water breaks on Hall Road and said that he had
been speaking to the engineer on how to resolve those issues and
hopefully would be able to do some repairs soon using some of the ARP
funds.
Mr. Baker informed Council he had recently hired a Water/Sewer
Supervisor. He also informed Council that there are some concerns with
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Motion Yes
Glymph Abstain
Chastain Yes
Duncan Second Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Yes
Member Motion Vote
Ramey Yes
Cater Motion Yes
Glymph Yes
Chastain Yes
Duncan Second Yes
Mefleh Yes
Powell Yes
12
January 11, 2022
Anderson Park and the fencing there. Mr. Baker also stated that he was
looking into putting cardboard recycle dumpsters in the parking lot of the
Police Department. This is still being discussed and trying to be worked
out.
Mr. Baker also informed Council the electric crew had wrapped some
poles with squirrel guard and that he had recently hired a line trimmer.
4. Comments from City Administrator
Mr. Bronson informed Council that Larry Brandt and Pope Flynn Law
Firms were asked to give a legal opinion on the City of Seneca letter and
their intention to file a lawsuit concerning voting rights with the OJRSA.
This letter is included with these minutes.
Mr. Bronson addressed Council on the recent vote by the OJRSA Board
to pass a 20% rate increase. He stressed to Council that this increase
would need to be passed onto City customers as there was no way the
City could absorb an increase like this. He advised that called meetings
would need to be scheduled for first and second readings.
Mr. Bronson informed Council that Judy Caywood with the Senior
Outreach Program was asking the City to deed the recently leased Pool
property over to the Senior Program so that they could apply for State
Grants. He asked Mr. Holliday to work up a sale document that would
deed this over to the group. Council expressed concerns that should the
Senior Program ever cease or decide to do something else with the
building and property that it could fall into the hands of someone with
other intentions. Council advised Mr. Holliday to address this is the deed
documents that should the building and property ever not be wanted by a
Senior Program that it would be given back to the City.
Mr. Bronson informed Council that Seamon Whiteside is ready to present
the conceptual plan on the Hall Street property.
Executive Session
Upon a motion by Mr. Duncan and seconded by Mr. Cater, the motion to enter into an
executive session for the purpose of:
a discussion of negotiations incident to proposed contractual arrangements and proposed sale
or purchase of property, the receipt of legal advice where the legal advice relates to a pending,
threatened, or potential claim or other matters covered by the attorney-client privilege,
settlement of legal claims, or the position of the public agency in other adversary situations
involving the assertion against the agency of a claim and a discussion of employment,
appointment, compensation, promotion, demotion, discipline, or release of an employee, a
13
January 11, 2022
student, or a person regulated by a public body or the appointment of a person to a public body
pursuant to S.C. Code Ann. 34-4-70(1) (2)
a. Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority – legal advice concerning threatened litigation
b. Piedmont Municipal Power Agency – legal advice concerning ongoing litigation
c. Personnel Matters related to the potential Staff Organizational Structure of the City
Organization
Upon motion by Mr. Chastain and seconded by Mr. Mefleh, the motion to exit executive
session and re-enter open session passed unanimously.
At this time, Mr. Cater submitted his resignation effective January 31st and he left the meeting at
9:23pm. Mr. Duncan then submitted his resignation effective immediately. Mr. Chastain said
that he would submit his resignation the next day.
Adjourn
Upon a motion by Mr. Mefleh and seconded by Mr. Powell, the motion to adjourn the meeting
at 9:40 pm passed unanimously.
(Minutes submitted by Rebecca Overton)
__________________________________ _____________________
Mayor Brian Ramey Date
Source: City of Westminster website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.