06-08-2022 Council Workshop Minutes
City of Westminster · Oconee County · meeting of Oct 6, 2008 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Westminster
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
June 8, 2022
MINUTES
WESTMINSTER CITY COUNCIL
Public Meeting/Council Workshop
Wednesday, June 8, 2022
The City Council of the City of Westminster met in a called meeting on Wednesday June 8, 2022
at 4:00 pm at the Westminster Depot with Mayor Brian Ramey presiding. Those in attendance
were:
Da
le Glymph Adam Dunn Daby Snipes Brian Ramey
Jimmy Powell Audrey Reese
C
ity Administrator, Kevin Bronson
City Clerk, Rebecca Overton
Utility Director, Leigh Baker
Members of the public and press
Notice of the meeting and the agenda was posted on a window at the Depot and at
westminstersc.org twenty-four hours prior to the meeting and all persons, organizations and
local media requesting notification and the agenda were notified by email.
C
all to Order
Ma
yor Ramey called the meeting to order at 4:00 pm.
I
nvocation and Pledge of Allegiance
Mrs
. Audrey Reese led the Council in the invocation and Mrs. Daby Snipes led the pledge.
C
ertification of Quorum
R
ebecca Overton certified a quorum.
P
resentation by Troy Rosier/Public Meeting
Mr. Troy Rosier was present to update Council on the Water System Capital Improvement Plan
and to assist with the required public meeting. Mr. Rosier informed Council that having a public
meeting is a requirement of the USDA Rural Development loan/grant process. Mr. Rosier
pointed out to Council that there are areas of water lines within the water system that date back
to the 1970’s and 1980’s and are in dire need of replacement. He stated that the USDA Rural
Development is a great program and that the City would be wise to attempt to secure the project
funding through them. Mr. Rosier addressed the priority areas and discussed the importance of
maintaining and updating water service lines. Attached to these minutes is a copy of the Water
System Capital Improvement Plan, Map, and Public Notice.
At this time a motion by Mrs. Reese and seconded by Mr. Glymph was made to open the floor
for public comments. This motion passed unanimously.
2
June 8, 2022
A representative from the Boys Camp, which is located off Welcome Church Road, asked Mr.
Rosier if the Welcome Church Road repairs and construction would include coming down
Wilderness Trail. Mr. Rosier informed this representative that the construction would only be
on Welcome Church Road.
After no additional public comments, Mr. Glymph made a motion to close the public comment
session of the meeting. This motion was seconded by Mr. Powell and passed unanimously.
Presentation by Richard Tucker on Electrical System Upgrades
Mr. Richard Tucker was present to update Council on the electrical system upgrades. He
advised Council that much progress had been made in the areas of right of way clearing and
switching over some of the load from a 4.16 KV system to a 12.47 KV system. He stated that
about 90% of the updates and upgrades had been completed. A copy of the presentation is
attached to these minutes.
Adjourn
Upon a motion by Mayor Ramey and seconded by Mr. Glymph, the motion to adjourn the
meeting at 5:40 pm passed unanimously.
(Minutes submitted by Rebecca Overton)
__________________________________ _____________________
Mayor Brian Ramey Date
Westminster, SC
Electric System
2022 Status
by
Richard Tucker, P .E.
Tucker Engineering Associates Inc.
Power metering & Instrumentation Engineering
P.O. box 326, Locust, N.C., USA 28097
Tel: 281 827 2961 e-mail:richardaet@aol.com
Year 1921 - The Beginning
4.16KV Substation
This served the City until 1997
Entire Electric System
4.16 KV for 76 years
1996 - Immintent failure of
original 4.16KV substation
• By 1996, the old 4.16KV substation buss was
completely annealed with black and purple coloring
• The City designed and built a new
(44 – 12.47)KV substation in 1997
• A temporary “Step down bank” was installed to serve
the 4.16KV City loads with immediate 4.16 to
12.47KV conversion work to relieve the temporary
Step Down bank.
• Ckt 1201 was intended to be built to serve the North
West loads toward the Chau River Pumps after
immediate 4.16 to 12.47KV conversion.
Why change from 4.16KV to 12.47KV ?
• For a very small system, 4.16KV has it’s role & place
• The City of Westminster had grown beyond that
usefulness of a lower voltage EL system
• Line losses are very expensive with 4.16KV EL
systems that are beyond 1MVA – The City is now
between 6 and 10 MVA
• As P = 1.732 (EI), the same Power delivered at
4.16KV can be delivered with 4.16/12.47 amps or 1/3
the current through the EL system conductors
• The 4.16KV line losses are the square of the current
or (9) times that of a 12.47KV EL system
Temporary becomes permanent
• Although the new 44-12.47KV substation
avoided the City a massive Outage, the
4.16KV EL system was served by a
TEMPORARY “step down bank” which was
supposed to be retired within two years.
• Conversion for a new Ckt 1201 was
supposed to commence immediately before
the 1998 Summer peak.
New 44 – 12.47KV substation comfort
• With the new 44 – 12.47KV substation in place and a
fresh system study which was necessary to design
the substation, the Electric System was quickly
forgotten
• The next year, a forgotten substation temporary
component almost failed
Summer of 1998
• As immediate steps for conversion from 4.16 to
12.47KV were ignored, the step down bank could not
handle the Summer peak load and suffered an oil
temperature excursion well beyond it’s nameplate
rating
• The Fire Department was called to spray water onto
the step down bank tank bodies for several days until
a 1” water line was installed to provide a continuous
spray with fans to withstand the Summer peak.
• Ckt 1201 4.16 to 12.47KV conversion was initiated.
New Ckt 1201
• Ckt 1201 was completed by 2000.
• The Step down bank was relieved and
the water spray was discontinued.
• The Step down bank was still loaded
beyond 70%
• Fast forward to 2017
2000 – New Ckt 1201
Electric System
Challenges
• Two Decades of Maintenance Neglect
• Electric System Exposure
44-12.47KV Substation Transformer
12.47 – 4.16 KV Step down Bank
• Reducing Electric System Loses
• Routine Preventative Maintenance
Two Decades
Electric System Degradation
• 1997 44-12.47KV Substation 2017 - 18
Voltage Regulators Maintenance needed
12.47KV Circuit Breakers Maintenance needed
Ckt 1201 Breaker Failure with 6 hour outage
Ckt 1201 Protective Relay failure – 2 hour outage
• 12.47KV Circuit overloading
Ckt 1201 Winter peak Outage
Ckt 1203 Step Down Bank Winter peak Outage
• Tree Clearance non-existent
44-12.47KV Substation
12.47KV Voltage Regulators
44 -12.47KV Substation
12.47KV Circuit Breakers
CKT 1201 breaker failure
• During the fall of 2017, a transformer
lead caused a 3ph fault on the #336
MCM main feeder along Simpson Rd.
• The Ckt 1201 breaker failed to open
the fault and the feeder conductor fell
into the road bed and burned a trench
6” through the asphalt and road bed
Ckt 1201 Ckt Breaker failed
Ckt 1201 feeder burning in road bed
• Ckt 1203 during 2017-18 Winter peak
Breaker opened; Opened segments of
load to re – energize; Temp 03 deg F;
6 hour power interruption of downtown
• Ckt 1201 voltage regulators were set
to zero boost (Brown – out) to avoid
an outage for the remainder of the town.
12.47KV Circuits Overloaded
Electric System
Tree trimming neglected
• Momentary interruptions were
occurring during the Summer of 2017
and escalated in frequency in 2018
such that residence and business
owners were restarting electronic
systems upwards toward 20 times a day
• All Substation circuits were passing
through thick tree limb/bush growth.
44-12.47KV Substation
12.47KV Breakers’ IMPRS protective relays
• 2018 – 19 Winter peak Ckt 1203
protective relay failed; Ckt 1203 (step
down bank breaker opened for two
hours; Ckt 1203 load was shared by
Ckt 1201 and Ckt 1202; Ckt 1203
IMPRS relay was repaired;
• Life for chips in IMPRS – 10 yr; 22
years since purchase in 1997.
Westminster Electric System Exposure
44-12.47KV Substation transformer
• The 44-12.47KV 12/16/20 MVA Transformer
failure without a spare would incur an outage
of over two days and maybe longer. This is a
remote chance, but a real possibility.
• Duke Energy found a 10MVA 44-12.47KV
transformer for approximately $42,000 installed.
• Fortuatively, the City purchased this 10MVA just
two months before the main transformer failed.
Existing 44-12.47KV
Substation Transformer
Westminster Electric System Exposure
The 12.47- 4.16KV step down bank
Service to Down Town Critical Functions
• The 4.16KV step down bank still serves over 1/3 of the City
Electrical load
• The loss of this bank of transformers would cause an outage of
possibly two days to the center City loads which include the Town Hall,
Police Station, and other critical City loads.
• According to a 2019 February report from PMPA, Westminster has an
approximate 14% electrical energy loss. This is approximately (3)
times what other relatively sized 12.47KV operating municipals have as
energy loss.
• This is not a surprise. The electrical current through the distribution
lines is the ratio of the voltages – 12.47KV/4.16KV =
a factor of three (3). The heat loss is the square of that ratio = a
factor of nine (9). When the City’s distribution is operating at 12.47KV,
the losses should be reduced to 14/3 = 4.6% as the other 12.47KV
municipals. (14 – 4.6)% x $ 2,876,728 = $ 267,592 savings/yr when
fully operational at 12.47KV.
12.47-4.16KV Step Down
Bank
Routine Maintenance?
• There had been none until a start in
2018. This is sorely needed for the
Electrical System to provide reliable
service as an Electrical Energy
Provider.
• Leigh Baker, Supt of Utilities, has
reversed this. Digging out of problems.
What has been done to
correct these neglects?
• All of the Voltage Regulators have
been reconditioned by 2022.
• Recommendation is to purchase three
more 12.47 Voltage Regulators such
that maintenance rotation can be
performed and serve as spares
• The 12.47KV Circuit breakers need
refurbishment. Four have been
serviced of the 5 circuits anticipated.
• It is recommended to purchase an
extra breaker to allow refurbishment
“One at a time” and have an extra
serving as a spare.
What has been done to
correct these neglects?
What has been done to
correct these neglects?
• The Substation protective relays that
operate the Circuit Breakers are at the
end of their 10 life – in fact, they have
lasted 22 years since purchase.
• It has been discussed with Leigh Baker
that next year’s City budget should
allow purchase of new substation ckt
breakers
What has been done to
correct these neglects?
• The overloaded Ckt 1203 (Step down bank)
was slightly relieved via the Walhalla Rd
Phase I 4.16KV conversion to 12.47KV
• This was accomplished during the Spring of
2018 to squeeze by the 2018 Summer Peak.
Phase I conversion complete
Load along Walhalla Street
What has been done to
correct these neglects?
• The overloaded Ckt 1201 has been relieved
just before the 2018/19 Winter Peak with
great effort via the new Ckt 1205 requiring
Transmission Crossing and a Southern
Railroad crossing
• A portion of Ckt 1205 was introduced via the old
Jantzen line previously owned by Duke Energy and
allowed relief of Ckt 1201 before the 2018/19 Winter
Peak.
Phase I, II conversion complete
Southern Railroad Crossing
for East side of Wesminster loads
via New Ckt 1205
Duke Transmission Crossings to East Wesminster
via New Ckt 1205
What has been done to
correct these neglects?
• The 12.47-4.16KV step down bank:
a. It exposes over 1/3 of the City to an
extended outage
b. It provides the greatest energy loss
with the lower voltage
• Conversion phases 3 and 4 are almost
finished such that the 12.47-4.16 KV Bank
can be eliminated
4.16 – 12.47KV Conversion when Complete
Oops! Just in time for new 1MW load
What has been done to
correct these neglects?
• The City has been diligent with tree trimming
for proper right of way clearance for the
Electric System conductors during the 2018
period extending into 2022
• It must be noted that the nuisance tripping
has been stopped as now this is a regular
requirement for the El System
What now?
• With the completion of the 4.16 to 12.47KV
conversion of the total system, it is suggested that a
“Five Year Plan” be instituted for planning and
budgetary purposes
• Preventive maintenance is key to keeping the Electric
System reliable and efficient.
• A two man tree crew is suggested for continuous
R/W clearance and spare men.
• Proper Protective Relay/OCR/Fuse Ckt co-ordination
Credit where credit is due
• Not since Howard Adams led the Utilities of
Westminster in the 1980s to avert El System disaster
has a set of leadership put tremendous effort to save
the Westminster Electrical System.
• Chris Carter, City Administrator
• Kevin Bronson, City Administrator
• Leigh Baker, Utilities Supt. and his line Crew
• Mayor Brian Ramey
• The Westminster City Council
Source: City of Westminster website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.