Backup Material
Oconee County · Oconee County · meeting of Feb 23, 2026 · Other
Open the original document More from Oconee County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
BOARD MEMBERS
Jim Henderson, District 1 Gwen Fowler, District 2
Bill Gilster, District 3 Jason Cox, District 4
Chad Overholt, District 5 John Eagar, At-Large
Wayne McCall, At-Large
AGENDA
Monday, February 23, 2026 – 6:00 PM
Oconee County Council Chambers
1. Call to Order
2. Election of Officers
a. Chairman
b. Vice Chairman
c. Secretary
3. Approval of Minutes: December 17, 2025 meeting
4. Brief statement about rules and procedures
5. Special Exception Application SE25-000003. Umair Ali requests relief from the Fair
Play Village Overlay District for a service station. Ref. Sec. 38-11.2 (2) D 1. TMS 337-
00-03-009; Address: 503 E. Fairplay Blvd. Fair Play, SC 29643.
6. Variance Application VA25-000017. Umair Ali requests relief from the setback
requirement in Appendix A for a service station. Ref. Appendix A (a) 3. TMS 337-00-
03-009; Address: 503 E. Fairplay Blvd. Fair Play, SC 29643.
7. Adjourn
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
BOARD MEMBERS
John Eagar, Chairman, At-Large Jim Henderson, District 1
Gwen Fowler, District 2 Bill Gilster, District 3
Jason Cox, District 4 Tim Mays, District 5
Wayne McCall, At-Large
STAFF
Elise Dunaway
MINUTES
Monday, December 17, 2025 – 6:00 PM
Oconee County Council Chambers
1. Call to Order – Mr. Eagar called the meeting to order at 6:00 PM.
2. Motion to approve the minutes from November 24, 2025 – Mr. Mays made a
motion to approve the minutes; seconded by Mr. McCall. Mr. Eagar called for a
vote. The motion passed 6-0.
3. 2026 Meeting Calendar Revision – Mr. Mays made a motion to accept the
revision to the 2026 Meeting Calendar. Seconded by Mr. Gilster. Approved
Unanimously.
4. Brief statement about rules and procedures – Mr. Eagar outlined the
proceedings of the meeting going forward:
• The applicant will provide a presentation regarding the needs for the
variance for 5-minutes with the Board having the ability to grant more time
if needed.
• The Board will ask questions after each presenter
• The staff will address any additional issues
• Citizen comments will be allowed for period of 3-minutes each with the
Board’s request that the speakers not repeat what others are saying, but
rather concur or state other facts not previously presented
• There will be an applicant rebuttal period if necessary
• The Board will ask any further questions before deliberations
• Once the Board begins its deliberations, there will be no further input from
the floor. and the Board will begin it’s voting on four questions, and a
negative vote on any one of the four questions will require a denial of the
variance or special exception.
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
1. Variance application VA25-000019 - David Irvine requests relief from Sec. 16-
122 to build over the floodplain less than 3 feet above the base flood elevation.
TMS 052-03-06-010; Address: 331 Time Out Pl. Tamassee, SC 29686.
Applicant Comments:
Stated Name: David Irvine
Mr. Irvine explains he is wanting to add onto his house on Lake Cherokee. He is
requesting to build at the same height as the rest of the house within the floodplain.
In 2005, the highest level of water in Lake Cherokee was 1079.6ft.
Staff comments: Miss. Dunaway reminds the board to consider Section 1.2
Background and Meaning of Variance from the Variances and the National Flood
Insurance Program that states, “In some cases, a variance granted for floodplain
management purposes can result in a project that does not meet the minimum
standards of the NFIP. Because a variance can lead to an increased risk to life and
property, variances from flood elevation requirements or other floodplain
management requirements should be granted only rarely.”
Public comment: NA
Applicant rebuttal: NA
Board Questions/ Discussion:
The Board reviews Chapter 16-166 Considerations and Ch. 16-169 Conditions.
Consideration of VA25-00019:
I. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular
piece of property:
a. Motion – Mr. McCall made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by Mr.
Mays. No discussion
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
II. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity:
a. Motion – Mr. Henderson made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by
Mr. Mays. No Discussion
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
III. Because of these conditions, the application of this chapter to the particular
piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the
utilization of the property.
a. Motion – Mr. Gilster made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by Mr.
Mays. No discussion.
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
IV. The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent
uses or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed
by the granting of the variance.
a. Motion – Mr. Mays made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by Mrs.
Fowler. No Discussion. Mr. Eager opposed.
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
5 1
V. Mr. Eagar asked for an amendment – Based on the evidence presented to the
Board, do I hear a motion that the proposed variance be Approved based upon
Oconee County being held harmless in the event there is ever any damage to
the property resulting from flooding and that the property owner maintain
adequate FEMA Flood insurance on the property regardless of the cost.
a. Motion – Failed due to no second
OCONEE COUNTY
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
415 S. Pine St. Walhalla, SC 29691
864.638.4218
OconeeSC.com
planninginfo@oconeesc.com
The meeting will be broadcasted live on the County’s YouTube channel, which can be found on the
County’s website at www.oconeesc.com.
Rev. 07/2025
VI. Mr. Eagar asked – Based on the evidence presented to the Board, do I hear a
motion that the proposed variance be Approved.
a. Motion – Mr. McCall made a motion; seconded by Mrs. Fowler.
b. Discussion regarding conditions attached to the approval: NA
c. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the variance request was Approved.
5. Adjourn- Motion by Mr. Gilster. Second by Mr. McCall. Approved 6-0
Freedom of Information Act - Variance Application
Permitting Information
Code section from which a
variance is requested Sec-38-10.2 Upload Supporting
Documentation Here
Application is Application is not Is not
APPLICANT RESPONSES TO SECTION 38-7.1
Describe the extraordinary and exceptional condition (such
as size, shape, and topography) that pertains to the subject
property that does not generally apply to other land or
structures in the vicinity.:
The place is small and if we put canopy in 25 feet set back it
will not give us enough room to maneuver for vehicles
Which brings us very close to the main building if we can put
canopy little further from building it gives us enough safe
space to maneuver and turn around if it needs to be
Are the circumstances affecting the subject property the
result of actions by the applicant/owner? Explain.
No, the circumstances affecting the subject property are not
the result of actions by the applicant or owner. The need for
the variance arises from the existing site conditions and
roadway configuration, which limit the available area for
development while maintaining safe vehicle circulation and
access. The current road alignment and required driveway
placement constrain the location of the proposed canopy
and fuel dispensers.
These conditions existed prior to the applicant’s involvement
and were not created by any changes made to the property.
The proposed 5 foot setback for the canopy is necessary to
achieve proper site functionality and safety while
maintaining compliance with other zoning and design
requirements. The request is consistent with typical
commercial gas station layouts and does not result from any
self-imposed hardship by the owner.
Describe the ways in which application of the requirement(s)
of the ordinance effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict
the utilization of the subject property.:
Strict application of the 25-foot front setback requirement
unreasonably restricts the functional use and development
potential of the subject property. The existing road
alignment, right-of-way limits, and required driveway
locations reduce the available buildable area for proper fuel
canopy placement and safe vehicle circulation.
Will the proposed variance result in an activity that will not
be of substantial detriment to adjacent uses or to the public
good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by
the granting of the variance. Explain.:
Maintaining the full 25-foot setback would force the canopy
and fuel dispensers too far from the road, leaving
inadequate maneuvering space between the canopy,
parking, and the convenience store building. This restriction
would make it difficult to safely accommodate customer
traffic, fuel deliveries, and emergency vehicle access —
effectively preventing the property from being developed as
a modern, compliant gas station.
The requested 5 foot setback provides the minimum
necessary relief to allow reasonable use of the land
consistent with its commercial zoning, while still preserving
public safety and the overall intent of the ordinance.
General Contractor
ICC 113.2 Limitations on authority. An application for appeal shall be based on a claim that the true intent of this code of
the rules legally adopted there under have been incorrectly interpreted, the provisions of this code do not fully apply or an
equally good or better form of construction is proposed. The board shall have no authority to waive requirements of this
code.
Comments
OCONEE COUNTYS APPROVAL, PERMITTING, AND/OR INSPECTION(S) OF THIS PROJECT DOES NOT MEAN
THAT THE PROJECT IS IN COMPLIANCE WITH ALL APPLICABLE SUBDIVISION AND/OR HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION, OR SIMILAR ENTITYS, BUILDING AND LAND USE REQUIREMENTS OR RESTRICTIONS, BY
SIGNING BELOW YOU ACKNOWLEDGE THAT COMPLIANCE WITH ANY SUCH STANDARDS IS YOUR
RESPONSIBILITY.
Workflow Reviews Information
2/18/26, 1:34 PM Permit Details | Citizenserve
https://www3.citizenserve.com/Admin/PermitController?Action=DisplayPermitDetail&SelectedTab=Permits&Permit_ID=52621793&WorkOrder_ID=904… 1/3
Fair Play Development Corporation
February 12, 2026
To: The members of the Board of Zoning Appeals, Oconee County, SC
Ref: Special Exception Application SE25-000003 and Variance Application VA25-000017
We write regarding the application, by Umair Ali / Gondal Gee Enterprise LLC, for approval of the following
2 exceptions for a proposed service station located at 503 E. Fairplay Blvd., Fair Play SC 29643 (TMS
337-00-03-009):
1. Variance Application VA25-000017 requesting relief from the setback requirement in Appendix A
for a service station. Ref Appendix A (a) 3
2. Special Exception Application SE25-000003 requesting relief from the Fair Play Village Overlay
District for a service station. Ref. Section 38-11.2 (2) D 1
Our understanding is that currently there are no drawings or building specifications to review, simply the
application for permission to install a service station and receive relief from setback requirements if
granted.
We would ask that the BZA take the following into account as they deliberate their decision on this
application:
● Village of Fair Play Strategic Master Plan (Attached) – this plan was developed in partnership
with Oconee County in 2012 and updated in late 2021/early 2022. The Plan recognized
opportunities along Fair Play Boulevard for reinvestment that will create a more vibrant business
district, gathering places for citizens of the community and a more pedestrian and bicycle
friendly community. While the Plan does not dictate specific uses or businesses, it did include
before and after drawings of key sites and buildings to help portray the strategic vision for the
Village, including retaining and updating façade renovations for existing buildings. This
included the vacant building located on the property in question before the BZA. Without
drawings or building specifications to review and therefore an understanding of what is
intended by the applicant for this building, we cannot determine if the proposed service station
is in fact aligned with the Strategic Master Plan.
○ Based on this we strongly request that more information is provided to the BZA so that
they can make an informed decision.
● Fair Play Village Overlay – in reviewing the application for a special exception, the BZA will have
the option on whether to require structures on the property to conform to the standards
established in Appendix A (38-11.2 (2) D 1 [our understanding is requirements contained in
38-11.2 (2) D 4 in terms of heights, signage etc. will automatically apply]. In our opinion,
PO Box 103
Fair Play, SC 29643
fairplaydevelopment@gmail.com
Fair Play Development Corporation
Appendix A building standards SHOULD be applied if the applicant is to replace the existing
vacant building with a new structure (again this is unclear as there are no proposed drawings etc
included with the application). This would ensure that the design and appearance would at the
very least align with the existing buildings of e.g. Yoders and Diamond T in terms of roof lines,
siding, use of stone etc. and therefore more closely align with the overall Strategic Master Plan.
We appreciate the time and effort the BZA puts into reviewing these applications to ensure the best needs
of the community are met.
Thank you for your time and consideration of our input.
Yours Sincerely,
Alicia Walker
President, Fair Play Development Corp
PO Box 103
Fair Play, SC 29643
fairplaydevelopment@gmail.com
Fair Play Development Corporation
Questions from the Community
1. Will it be open 24/7?
2. Will it offer regular and diesel and non-ethanol and/or electric charging stations?
a. How many tanks will there be?
b. What regulations will they be required to meet?
3. Semi trucks (18 Wheelers)
a. Will there be parking for them?
b. Will there be diesel gas pumps for them?
4. Will the car gas lanes be sufficient size for vehicles with trailers, boats etc.?
5. Has traffic been studied to confirm if the roads can sufficiently handle the ingress and egress
into the proposed station?
6. Are there mandatory provisions in case of gasoline fire?
a. We have a volunteer fire department, do they have the proper equipment?
b. Are there rules around proximity of a gas station to a fire department?
7. What products will the service station sell other than gasoline?
a. Alcohol?
b. Cigarettes?
c. Lottery?
d. Food?
i. Hot, cold?
PO Box 103, Fair Play, 29643
Source: Oconee County website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.