2019 MINUTES_PLANNING COMMISSION
City of Darlington · Darlington County · meeting of Apr 16, 2020 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Darlington
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
DARLINGTON CITY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
TUESDAY, January 15, 2019 – 9 A.M.
Darlington City Hall, 400 Pearl St.
Attending were Planning Commission members Ms. Page, Ms. Boakye, Mrs. Kirchen, Mr.
Nettles, and Mr. Parnell; and staff Ms. Rock, planning and economic development director, and
Mr. Gainey, codes enforcement officer.
Call to Order: Mrs. Kirchen called the meeting to order at 9:06 a.m.
Approval of the Minutes for the meeting of Nov. 13, 2018: Ms. Page made a motion to accept
the minutes of the Nov. 13, 2018, meeting as presented. Mr. Parnell made the second. The
motion carried unanimously.
Renaming of Southern Pine Street in Honor of Sgt. Terrence Carraway: Ms. Rock said that City
Council wants to name a street and playground in honor of Sgt. Terrence Carraway. Due to
some confusion over Pine Street and Southern Pine Street, Council suggested that the Planning
Commission approve that change to honor Sgt. Carraway. A park on that street will be named in
his honor as well. The Commission suggested Carraway Street would be too general, and it
needed to be more recognizable, suggesting Sgt. Carraway Street as the new name. The public
hearing for the change will be held on March 19 after proper notification is made. Questions to
be answered include whether or not residents need to send out change of address forms to
their contacts and whether the City could provide a template and copies of such forms for
affected residents. Mr. Gainey suggested getting the Post Master to speak at the hearing to
help field questions. Mr. Nettles agreed, saying it would be good to be proactive. Mrs. Kirchen
also asked for the following to be explicitly stated on the agenda: Number of minutes allowed
per person for public comment and that no comments would be allowed following the public
hearing portion of the meeting. She also asked that the items on the agenda be limited.
Light Pollution Ordinance for Residential Property: The Commission discussed updates to the
lighting ordinance, regarding residential lighting, and backyard security lights. Mrs. Kirchen said
residents need to understand that shielding lights does not affect the perceived security. The
Board suggested doing a soft approach, focusing on not wasting energy, and print something
for the public to encourage shielding and show examples of good lighting fixtures available
before trying to update the ordinance. Ms. Rock said this was brought to the Commission at the
request of the Historic Landmarks Commission. She said she could make a flyer to insert in the
water bills.
New Business: Mrs. Kirchen said she asked the Storm Water Maintenance in the Oakdale and
Country Club areas be added to the agenda, and that at the last meeting City Council addressed
equipment needs to maintain the system. Mr. Nettles said he is concerned with the issue as he
pumps water from under his house every time it rains for the last five months. Mr. Gainey said
the equipment discussed includes a root cutter (approximately $11,000) and a camera to
identify what is causing blockages (approximately $75,000). The problem is money. Mr. Gainey
said residents and landscapers often pile leaves, grass clippings, and other yard debris in the
ditches, which slowly fills them up and compounds the flooding issues. He said Mr. Kinsaul and
Mrs. Carroll could be able to answer the questions raised. Mr. Parnell asked about the progress
of the storm water project in West Darlington. Ms. Rock said it was scheduled to be complete in
March. Mr. Gainey said he has obtained a four-foot ditch bucket for the City track hoe, but it
has yet to be used to clean out ditches because residents have complained about the look of
the ditches when dug. Ms. Boakye suggested having a community compost area to dump mulch
and grass clippings to help alleviate some of the drain and ditch clogging in a positive way. Mrs.
Kirchen said neighborhood conversations about proper maintenance could help too.
Director’s Report: Ms. Rock said the City’s Comprehensive Plan will be on the horizon for the
Commission soon. The plan must be completely redrafted every 10 years according to state
law.
The next meeting will be 9 a.m. Tuesday, March 19, 2019, in the courtroom of City Hall to
accommodate the potential for a higher than normal number of guests given the two public
hearings slated to be on the agenda.
Adjourn: The Commission adjourned at 10:16 a.m.
DARLINGTON CITY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
TUESDAY, March 19, 2019 – 9 A.M.
Darlington City Hall, 400 Pearl St.
Attending were Planning Commission members Ms. Page, Ms. Boakye, Mrs. Kirchen, and Mr.
Nettles; staff Ms. Rock, planning and economic development director, and Mr. Gainey, codes
enforcement officer; Mayor Gloria Hines; Council members Elaine Reed and Sheila Baccus; and
other guests.
Call to Order: Mrs. Kirchen called the meeting to order at 9:19 a.m.
Public Hearing for the renaming of Southern Pine Street in honor of Sgt. Carraway: Ms. Volice
Peterson, 49, spoke about how she lived on the street for 20 years and felt the change would
require more than changing her address with the mail, insurance, driver’s license, voter’s
registration, etc. She said a lot would have to be changed. She said we have a history on
Southern Pine Street too. If we wanted to move, that’s different. We are not asking for it. What
is the purpose. She was concerned about a mix-up with 911. She asked what was Sgt.
Carraway’s connection to Southern Pine Street. She said she didn’t have a problem with her
mail. She suggested looking at a side street off Kirven Street that wouldn’t affect anyone. She
said naming the park for him is ok. She said kids there need more than a park. It’s going to bring
people on the side of my house at night and there will probably be a lot of fighting. Postmaster
James Harrel said that the Postal Service would not require residents to make a change of
address and there would be no mail service interrupted. It will be transparent. He said it will be
similar to when the City changed Juniper Venus to Orange Street. Either address, the mail
would be delivered. If the Social Security office needs to verify the street address, you would
get letterhead from the Planning Commission. Ms. Peterson said the problem is
documentation. When asked, Ms. Rock said 48 people live on Southern Pine Street. Ms.
Peterson said most of those are renters and it is different when you are a homeowner. Ms.
Betty Marcus, next to speak and a resident of the street for 56 years, asked Ms. Rock to read
her letter. Ms. Rock read her letter that disagreed with the renaming of the street but agreed
that it was a great idea to honor Sgt. Carraway. Mr. Waddell Coe said he has lived on Southern
Pine Street for 48 years without any issue with the mail, 911, law enforcement, or EMS. He said
he was in favor of honoring Sgt. Carraway but said we need to make sure we are honoring the
right street. The entrance to the park area has always been on Magnolia Street, so that could be
one option. He also suggested Andover Street in front of Walmart since everyone goes there
and maybe place a memorial in recognition of Sgt. Carraway there too. He said a lot has to be
changed, pass ports, and that costs a lot to make all those changes. Ms. Reed, Council member
representing Ward 2 where Southern Pine Street is located, said she wanted to hear what
residents have to say and that she is in favor of what they want. She said she doesn’t want to
create a problem for residents there. She said everything to be done in the area is focused on
the area he was involved with, the children there. We can have more conversations about the
playground, but that’s what the parents of children in the area indicated that they wanted a
playground and park area. All we are trying to do is improve the area based on what’s been
indicated to us from those in the area. We also want to honor Sgt. Carraway. There has been
communication with the state delegation for naming a different street. The park is done, and it
will be there. She said we want to provide the same resources in all areas of the city. Mayor
Hines said she wants to piggy back on what citizens are saying. She said the 52 Bypass near
Verizon or another part of South Main Street can honor Sgt. Carraway. Residents in the crowd
favored something in the Walmart area. Ms. Baccus said she appreciates all the points you have
brought. She said I’m in agreement that this would be a lot of stress on residents, so we will
address all those options and then we’ll decide. The point of the parks is to improve the quality
of life for all citizens and put parks in different areas for stress relief. Ms. Rock noted that two
residents called her office to express agreement with the proposed name change. She said the
notice of this hearing was placed in the newspaper, 12 signs were posted along the street, and
certified letters were sent to all property owners and residents. She said that 27 of the certified
notices were returned undeliverable or refused, so she did not know if everyone on the street
knew of the possible change.
Public Hearing for the Zoning for 504 Young Street: Mr. Kevin Byrd, who owns property at 209
Windham Avenue and 484 Shearin Street, said he doesn’t want to be in the City limits. He said
we went through this 25 years ago. Ms. Rock said the proposal affects only that single address,
and the City is simply required to notify neighboring property owners of such a request. She
said she received no letters, phone calls, or messages about this matter.
Public Hearing for the Corrective Zoning Designation of several parcels on Pearl Street: No
members of the public came to speak on this matter. Ms. Rock said she received no letters,
phone calls, or messages about this matter. All the property owners except AT&T requested the
City to correct this designation.
Approval of the Minutes for the meeting of January 15, 2019: Ms. Boakye made a motion to
accept the minutes of the Jan. 15, 2019, meeting as presented. Mr. Nettles made the second.
The motion carried unanimously.
Renaming of Southern Pine Street in Honor of Sgt. Terrence Carraway: Ms. Boakye made a
motion to reject changing the name of Southern Pine Street. Ms. Page made the second. The
motion carried unanimously. Mr. Gainey said he would recommend the intersection of U.S. 52
and U.S. 52 Bypass because that wouldn’t affect anyone and possibly putting a memorial at the
flagpoles area. Ms. Rock said we could install it there only if SCDOT approves it. Ms. Page made
a motion to recommend that City Council name the intersection of U.S. 52 Business and U.S. 52
Bypass in memorial for Sgt. Carraway and recommend a memorial be placed there to explain
why. Mr. Nettles made the second. The motion carried unanimously.
Zoning Designation for 504 Young Street: This property owner has requested to annex into the
City of Darlington. This requires the City to designate a zoning district for this property. The
Commission will discuss and recommended the zoning designation to be set as Low Density
Residential (R-10). Ms. Rock said the tap fee and utility rates for water and sewer are lower for
City residents on City services, which is why the owner requested annexation. Ms. Page made a
motion to designate 504 Young Street as R-10, Low Density Residential. Ms. Boakye made the
second. The motion carried unanimously.
Corrective Zoning Designation of several parcels on Pearl Street: Ms. Rock said the parcels
include 201 Orange St. (TMN 164-14-02-075), 105 N. Dargan St. (TMN 165-02-02-089), 204
Pearl St. (165-02-02-049), 208 Pearl St. (TMN 165-02-02-048), 212 Pearl St. (TMN 165-02-02-
043), and 102 N. Sycamore St. (TMN 165-02-02-044) and are bordered on the North by Orange
Street, on the East by North Dargan Street, on the South by Pearl Street, on the West by North
Sycamore Street, and on the Northwest by the properties of Norma Lundy (TMN 164-02-076)
and Patricia Roberts (TMN 165-02-02-045). The business owners want the City to designate
these parcels commercial to reflect the current and previous uses of these properties and to
remove any unreasonable restrictions to these businesses caused by their current zoning
designation of R-10, which does not allow signage. Ms. Rock said the issue came up when a new
florist moved into one of the properties and was trying to install new signs. The options are GC,
General Commercial, or CC, Core Commercial. One difference is the building signage can take
up 25% of the wall area in GC and only 15% in CC. Mr. Gainey suggested CC since it is going into
downtown and the other side of Pearl is zoned CC. Mr. Nettles made a motion to designate the
properties as Core Commercial (CC). Ms. Page made the second. The motion carried
unanimously.
Director’s Report: Ms. Rock said the next meeting will be 9 a.m. Tuesday, May 21, 2019. Ms.
Boakye provided members will information regarding her campaign to represent the fourth
district of the South Carolina State Association of IBPOE Inc. Checks are due April 16, and funds
go to scholarships and youth activities. Ms. Boakye said she was also asked to be the state
director of youth.
Adjourn: The Commission adjourned at 10:09 a.m.
DARLINGTON CITY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
TUESDAY, June 18, 2019 – 9 A.M.
Darlington City Hall, 400 Pearl St.
Attending were Planning Commission members Ms. Boakye, Mr. Parnell, and Mr. Nettles; staff
Ms. Rock, planning and economic development director, and Mr. Gainey, codes enforcement
officer; and guest, Kay Pierson.
Call to Order: Mr. Nettles called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m.
Approval of the Minutes for the meeting of March 19, 2019: Ms. Boakye made a motion to
accept the minutes of the March 19, 2019, meeting as presented. Mr. Parnell made the second.
The motion carried unanimously.
Public Hearing on Zoning Change Request for 245 Columbian Street: Ms. Pierson, as a resident
of Columbian Street, said she prefers the property to be residential only. No others attended.
Zoning Change Request for 245 Columbian Street: Ms. Rock explained that Mr. Evans
requested the property be re-zoned from General Commercial (GC) to Office & Residential (OR).
This would create a distinct buffer between a residential neighborhood and commercial area
that does not exist presently. In its current GC zoning designation, many types of businesses
could occupy the space. Mr. Evans said he wants to create residential rental units. There is
rented residential on two sides of the property and across the street, so Ms. Rock said she
doesn’t feel it would change the character of the neighborhood. The rest of Columbian Street is
also zoned OR. Mr. Gainey said he felt zoning the property R-6, High Density Residential, would
be more appropriate as he feels the lot is too small for four units given parking requirements.
Mr. Nettles said the cars on the street would be an issue, especially given the cars created by
the tiny houses nearby. Mr. Gainey said that, if the property is zoned OR, it will give Mr. Evans
more leeway, and the property is oddly shaped already. He said I am trying to prevent future
issues. Ms. Rock said we do not need to be punishing him for the City’s past mistakes or errors
nor do we need to deter investment. Mr. Nettles made a motion to zone the property R-6. Ms.
Boakye made the second. The motion carried unanimously.
Light Pollution Presentation: Mr. Parnell gave a presentation on the problems with LED
lighting, mainly the blue rich, white light, and ways to control it to better serve people. He said
the light can be controlled, so it doesn’t damage our eyes. He had a proposed ordinance
revision written by a retired lighting engineer. Ms. Rock said she would get copies of the
current ordinance to the board to compare with the proposed ordinance. Mr. Nettles thanked
Mr. Parnell for the information and made a motion to table further discussion to July.
Director’s Report: Ms. Rock said she included information regarding the Elements of the
Comprehensive Plan for members to review, as this would be coming before the Commission
soon once the storm water project is complete freeing up the consultant to complete work on
the plan. The next meeting will be 9 a.m. Tuesday, July 16, 2019.
Adjourn: The Commission adjourned at 10:07 a.m.
DARLINGTON CITY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
TUESDAY, July 16, 2019 – 9 A.M.
Darlington City Hall, 400 Pearl St.
Attending were Planning Commission members Ms. Boakye, Mr. Parnell, Ms. Kirchen, and Mr.
Nettles; staff Ms. Rock, planning and economic development director, and Mr. Gainey, codes
enforcement officer; and guest, Sheila Baccus, city council person.
Call to Order: Ms. Kirchen called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m.
Approval of the Minutes for the meeting of June 18, 2019: Mr. Nettles made a motion to
accept the minutes of the June 18, 2019, meeting as presented. Mr. Parnell made the second.
The motion carried unanimously.
Zoning Designation for Property at the corner of Wyandot Street and Nez Perce Drive, TMN
184-00-01-045: Ms. Rock presented the Commission with an application to annex into the City
and asked the Commission to recommend a zoning designation for the property. A lengthy
discussion of how vacant lots in this neighborhood, as well as others, are used as a dumping
ground for yard debris and other trash. Mr. Gainey noted that it is against City ordinance for a
person to dump debris on another lot and that, if someone was paid to clean a yard, the
contractor was responsible for hauling off any debris. Commission members suggested signage
regarding the potential for a $500 to $2,000 fine as well as putting an ad in the newspaper to
show residents what is allowed and what is not, telling the community what the ordinance
states. The Commission asked that a phone number be listed as to where residents should
report offenders. Mr. Nettles made a motion to recommend this lot be designated in the Low
Density Residential, R-10, zoning district and preferably with the owner’s other properties
because he will not necessarily receive the services he is after unless the property has a
building. Ms. Boakye made the second. The motion carried unanimously.
Lighting Ordinance Proposed Update: Mr. Parnell gave a brief lighting demonstration to show
the difference between blue-rich LED light and incandescent, warm light. He suggested
accompanying the recommendation for the ordinance update with a letter and the article from
the American Medical Association supporting such controls. Ms. Baccus asked what it would
cost. Mr. Gainey clarified the proposed update only affects exterior lighting for new commercial
developments and those replacing or updating such fixtures. He said this explains what we
expect when someone plans to build in town. He said it also makes his job easier, though some
education will be necessary for current businesses to remain in compliance. Ms. Baccus asked if
moving forward aesthetics and design of specific fixtures would be considered part of this
ordinance. Mr. Nettles said it would be good to keep the aesthetics similar, but this just is the
basics. Mr. Nettles made a motion to recommend the proposed updates to the lighting
ordinance to City Council. Mr. Parnell made the second. The motion carried unanimously. Ms.
Rock said she would email the accompanying letter to members for approval.
Director’s Report: Ms. Rock said the Comprehensive Plan remains on hold until once the storm
water project is complete, August 15, freeing up the consultant to complete work on the plan.
The next meeting will be 9 a.m. Tuesday, Sept. 17, 2019.
Adjourn: The Commission adjourned at 10:10 a.m.
DARLINGTON CITY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
TUESDAY, September 17, 2019 – 9 A.M.
Darlington City Hall, 400 Pearl St.
Attending were Planning Commission members Mr. Parnell, and Mr. Nettles; staff Ms. Rock,
planning and economic development director, and Mr. Gainey, codes enforcement officer.
The meeting was rescheduled for 9 a.m. Tuesday, Oct. 15, due to lack of a quorum.
DARLINGTON CITY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
TUESDAY, October 15, 2019 – 9 A.M.
Darlington City Hall, 400 Pearl St.
Attending were Planning Commission members Ms. Boakye, Mr. Parnell, Ms. Kirchen, and Mr.
Nettles; staff Ms. Rock, planning and economic development director, City Manager Howard
Garland, and Mr. Gainey, codes enforcement officer; and guests, Danny Hoffman, Sam Evans,
and James W. Quick Jr.
Call to Order: Ms. Kirchen called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m.
Approval of the Minutes for the meeting of July 16, 2019: Mr. Nettles made a motion to
accept the minutes of the July 16, 2019, meeting as presented. Mr. Parnell made the second.
The motion carried unanimously.
Zoning Change Request Desigation for 16.85 acres between Old Florence Highway and
Friendship Street (TMNs 165-04-01-005 and 165-00-02-010): Ms. Rock presented the maps and
adjacent zoning information for the two parcels in question. Mrs. Kirchen asked for public
comment. Mr. Quick said he had questions and lives across D Avenue from the property. He
said he did not want tractor trailers right outside his front door. He said development would
create a lot of traffic. Mr. Quick said he owns the entire corner and putting anything across the
street will hurt him. Mr. Hoffman, who said he lives on Friendship opposite the property, said
he heard the property would be used for truck parking and a discharge pond. Mr. Hoffman said
he didn’t think the road could handle the additional traffic. The Commission said that, while
they did not want to hold up any expansion, they did want more information. Mr. Garland got a
representative from Georgia Pacific on the phone to answer questions of the Commission. Mr.
Jeff Gottke said the company planned to use the property for employee parking as well as for
trailer parking. The employee parking would make it safer and be nearer the stop sign and D
Avenue to allow employees to cross where traffic would slow normally. Trailer parking would
be on the side of the lot closest to the ballfield with any required storm water mitigation on the
back side (Friendship Street) of the property. Mr. Gottke said the company would meet all
setback and landscape buffer requirement and adjust their plan as needed to fit the City’s
codes. Mr. Gainey said that the required 50-foot setback and the trucks parking near the
ballfield would alleviate the major concerns brought by the neighbors. Mr. Nettles agreed and
made a motion to recommend City Council change the zoning designation for the property to
Basic Industrial to accommodate Georgia Pacific’s expansion plans. Mr. Parnell made the
second. The motion carried unanimously.
Zoning Change Request for Property on Blue Street (TMN 164-06-01-078): Ms. Rock presented
the Commission with an application to change the zoning designation for the property as well
as map of the area. Mr. Evans said he plans on building an 8-unit, two-story townhouse
complex on the site. The Commission discussed the use of the neighboring property, some in
the City limits and some not. Ms. Rock said she received no comment from the public via
phone, email, or letter about the potential change. Mr. Nettles made a motion to recommend
City Council change the zoning designation for the property to R-10 as requested by the
property owner. Mr. Parnell made the second. The motion carried unanimously.
Old Business: Mrs. Kirchen thanked Mr. Gainey for his follow-through that led to the
demolition of the Tyner warehouse.
Director’s Report: Ms. Rock said the Comprehensive Plan remains on hold awaiting an update
from the consultant on the plan’s progress. She also provided a list of new businesses in town.
The next meeting will be 9 a.m. Tuesday, Nov. 19, 2019.
Due to the lack of a quorum in September, Ms. Rock said she cancelled the joint board meeting.
Mrs. Kirchen said in light of the need to update the Comprehensive Plan she wanted to
reschedule it for the early spring to help facilitate that process.
Adjourn: The Commission adjourned at 10:02 a.m.
DARLINGTON CITY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
TUESDAY, November 19, 2019 – 9 A.M.
Darlington City Hall, 400 Pearl St.
Attending were Planning Commission members Ms. Boakye, Mr. Parnell, Ms. Page, and Mrs.
Kirchen; staff Ms. Rock, planning and economic development director, City Manager Howard
Garland, and Mr. Gainey, codes enforcement officer; city council members, Mayor Hines and
Ms. Baccus; and guest, Jannie Lathan.
Call to Order: Ms. Rock called the meeting to order at 9:08 a.m.
Approval of the Minutes for the meeting of October 15, 2019: Ms. Page made a motion to
accept the minutes of the Oct. 15, 2019, meeting as presented. Ms. Boakye made the second.
The motion carried unanimously.
Comprehensive Plan Update: Ms. Lathan presented details about the Comprehensive Plan
process. The administration is recommending a full update for 2020-2035 as the City will turn
200. She has benchmarked Florence, Hartsville, and Sumter and said the 2020 Census would be
vital to developing the next full-blown plan. She said she was organizing a Comprehensive Plan
Advisory Committee for Planning Commission to meet with on a quarterly basis as the City
develops this Darlington 2035 Plan. Right now, Mr. Garland said the Commission needed to
recommend the 2012 update by Dan Vismor to City Council for approval to stay in compliance
with state law. Council received the update years ago but never formally approved it. The 2012-
2013 update added the transportation and Priority Investment Elements, as required. Ms.
Lathan said the Commission should recommend Council adopt this update. She also suggested
developing an annexation plan and strategy to foster economic growth and development. Can
we afford to annex a particular area? We need to increase the population and the tax base. Ms.
Lathan gave the advisory committee members detailed surveys that she will synthesize the data
to begin working on the new plan. Ms. Boakye suggested added some type of social event or
drop-in for the advisory committee to encourage participation. Mayor Hines said the City needs
to push the 2020 Census because that is how we get federal dollars. Ms. Rock suggested putting
material about the Census and its importance in the water bill. Mrs. Kirchen said it was
important for us to dispel myths surrounding it, so people will complete the Census forms. Ms.
Lathan read and discussed each of the goals and action items in the 2013 Plan Update, noting
ways the City has followed through on portions of this plan. Ms. Page made a motion to accept
the addendum to the Comprehensive Plan and recommend Council adopt it. Mr. Parnell made
the second. The motion carried unanimously. City Council will take this up at the December 3
regular meeting.
2020 Calendar of Meetings: Ms. Rock presented a tentative calendar of meeting dates for 9
a.m. Tuesdays, Jan. 21, March 19, May 19, July 15, Sept. 15, and Nov. 17, with the potential for
more dates being added to include the work with the comprehensive plan advisory committee.
New Business Nytronics Property: Ms. Rock presented the report from the company cleaning
up the old Nytronics Property that is being directed by SCDHEC. The soils have been cleaned,
PCBs contained, and wells installed to monitor the levels of various chemicals in the ground and
water. The property can never be used for residential purposes because of the contamination;
however, state Textile Mill Site tax credits are available now to build and renovate any property
within 1,000 feet of the mill site. In two to three years, the property could be sold, and a new
industry use it since it has positives, such as rail access, water, sewer, and police protection.
Director’s Report: The next meeting will be 9 a.m. Tuesday, Jan. 21, 2020.
Adjourn: The Commission adjourned at 10:53 a.m.
Source: City of Darlington website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.