FJWSS Minutes 8-4-21
Town of Winnsboro · Fairfield County · meeting of Aug 4, 2021 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Winnsboro
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Minutes8/4/2021 FJWSSRM 1
MINUTES
REGULAR MEETING
FAIRFIELD JOINT WATER SEWER SERVICE
AUGUST 4, 2021
Present= John MCMeekin, Jason Taylor, Tim Roseborough, Brad Caulder, Kyle
Crager, Commissioners.
Others Present: C.D. Rhodes, Patti L. Davis, Scott EIIiott, Ty Davenport, Chris
Clauson, Bill Bingham, John Hoefer, Chad Johnston.
The Fairfield Joint Water Sewer Service met in regular session on August 4, 2021, at
6:00 p.in. at the Fairfield County Government Complex Building. In accordance with
the South Carolina Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80 (e), as amended, the
following persons and/or organizations have been notified of the time, date and
location of this meeting: The Independent Voice of Blythewood and Fairfield, The
Countrv Chronicle and four hundred ninety-two other individuals.
1. CALLTOORDER
In the absence of a Chair or Vice-Chair at this time, Mr. Rhodes called the
Regular Meeting to order at 6:03 p.in.
2. APPROVALOFAGENDA
Motion made by Commissioner MCMeekin, seconded by Commissioner Crager,
to approve the agenda, The motion carried unanimously 5-0.
3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Motion made by Commissioner Crager, seconded by Commissioner Taylor, to
approve the Regular Meeting minutes of June 18, 2020. 7lhe mofi-on carrfed
unanimously 5-0.
4. BACKGROUND AND UPDATE ON FJWSS
Mr. Rhodes stated there are now three new members on the Commission, so
he believes it would be helpful to review the background of the Commission,
to include why the Joint System was created and where we are today. The
Fairfield Joint Water Sewer System was created as a joint system under South
Carolina law. It is a very particular type of local government as authorized by
statute, and it may only be created when two or more local governments agree
to come together to create this new corporate entity, Joint systems are
created for a specific purpose. The FJWSS was created to provide water and
sewer service and was created under a statute that is specifically crafted to
allow local governments to come together to build and finance large water and
sewer infrastructure projects. It was created in 2019 by Fairfield County and
the Town of Winnsboro with the goal of allowing for the construction of a
Minutes8/4/2021 FJWSSRM 2
wastewater treatment plant. There is a real need for wastewater treatment
capacity in the County. The lack of this is inhibiting growth, particularly
commercial and industrial growth, but also residential growth. Building a
wastewater treatment plant is an incredibly expensive endeavor and is a
difficult thing to do from scratch. A joint system is an ideal vehicle, for a
number of reasons, for the construction of a large, very expensive pro].ect like
a wastewater treatment plant. This was the original goal when the FJWSS was
created. The conversations toward this end started in 2018, and there were a
lot of questions at this time as to how to get to the point where we are today,
with the biggest obstacle being funding. Over the years, several different
iterations and concepts were discussed as to how this plant could be funded.
The insurmountable cost obstacle has now been surmounted through the
settlement with Dominion, and we are now ready to hopefully start the process
at a pretty quick pace to begin construction on the plant. Over time, the
purpose of the Joint System has somewhat shifted. The Department of
Commerce initially insisted that the County and the Town take a regional
approach to wastewater treatment within the County, and they saw the Joint
System as the best way to make sure the regional approach was followed.
This is certainly still an incentive; however, today we find what the Town can
bring to the table and what the County can bring to the table coming together
in a way where both can benefit. The Town has customers that it is willing to
transfer to the Joint System to provide the initial seed money and also seed
waste. Winnsboro also controls, through the 208 Plan, most of the designated
management area in the County in which development is likely to take place.
Winnsboro has been willing to donate some of its designated management area
to the Joint System so that, over the years, the Joint System will have its own
customers and be an independent utility that is not reliant on its members for
funding. The Town is, therefore, bringing an essential element to the table,
and the Joint System will not work without all the items Winnsboro is offering.
The County, for its part, is now able to bring funding to the table. The County
needs the Town to be able to use the money to build a wastewater treatment
plant to attain a viable system. When these two important parts come
together, funding and customers, a new viable utility can then be created. The
funding problem has now been solved, and over the next few months, there
are a number of regulatory issues to get past before construction can be
started on the plant. This will be discussed later, but the first hurdle will be to
amend the Central Midlands 208 Plan to allow the plant to be located in the
County and to give the Joint System a customer base. This will be essential
for it to be a viable, independent, operating utility. We will be discussing the
various steps that need to be taken in order to allow the 208 amendments to
be presented to the Central Midlands COG. Mr. Rhodes then invited questions.
Commissioner MCMeekin asked for Mr. Rhodes to elaborate further on the PER.
Minutes8/4/2021 FJWSSRM 3
Per Mr. Rhodes, the PER (Preliminary Engineering Report) is a document to be
developed before moving forward with a large infrastructure pro].ect such as
this. In this case, this is an essential document to all of these procedural steps
that will be taken over the next few months. In order to approach the COG
for the 208 Plan amendments, the PER is the document they will rely on to
explain exactly what is being planned. Mr. Rhodes requested for Mr. Bill
Bingham of American Engineering to explain further. Per Mr. Bingham, the
PER is the beginning document for the 208. The 208 is a plan that is adopted
in each of the Council of Governments for each area of the State, and it
basically identifies the areas. The EPA has constructed this so that each
management agency will be responsible for what is going on with their
wastewater treatment. This was all a part of the Clean Water Act which was
established in 1972. The first step for the 208 amendments will be for plans
to be submitted to DHEC followed by applications for DHEC permits, and they
will then ask the COG if this is in conformance with the current 208 plan. If
the 208 Plan does not address what is being proposed, the answer will be no,
and approval must be obtained before moving forward. The COG has an
important role in the planning of the overall region. Fairfield County is a
member of the Central Midlands COG, and this is comprised of Fairfield,
Newberry, Richland and Lexington Counties. An important piece of the PER is
looking at all the alternatives that may exist instead of putting in a wastewater
plant. In Fairfield County, the only plants that exist are the Winnsboro Plant,
which is near capacity, and the Ridgeway Plant, which is not capable of taking
anywhere near the amount of flow that is needed. The PER is addressing all
possibilities and why they are or are not a possibility. Each objective is being
reviewed to decide how each would look and how each may or may not work.
The PER also addresses the waste load allocation given by DHEC. There is a
waste load for Big Cedar Creek, Wateree, Broad River and Sawney's Creek.
This information would include what limits would be on the wastewater. The
engineering calculations are needed to see if it is possible, using the best
available technologies, to treat the effluent. Then, long term viability is
examined with the current waste load allocations being 2M gallons a day and
4M gallons a day. Mr. Bingham stated the 7Q10 flow of the creek is examined,
which is the lowest flow in the creek for seven days in the last 10 years. The
PER is a very technical document and is tailored specifically to go to the COG
because it is an ``ask''; therefore, all of this information must be presented. An
NPEDS permit is needed, and this is the license to put wastewater into a body
of water.
5. ELECTION OF OFFICERS
Mr. Rhodes stated the last time officers were elected was the very first
Organizational Meeting of the Joint System. A slate of officers was presented
Minutes8/4/2021 FJWSSRM 4
at that time, and after discussion, this slate was voted on. The structure last
time was consistent with the Mayor serving as Chairman, County Council
member serving as the Vice Chair, Mr. Taylor was recommended to be the
Treasurer and Mrs. Davis served as the Secretary. The Chair, Vice Chair and
Treasurer must be members of the Commission, however, the secretary does
not. Therefore, based on the last structure, Mr. Rhodes proposed the following
slate of officers:
Chairman -John MCMeekin
Vice Chairman -Tim Roseborough
Treasurer -Jason Taylor
Secretary - Patti Davis
Motion made by Mr. MCMeekin, seconded by Mr. Crager, to approve the above
listed slate of officers for the Fairfield Joint Water Sewer System. 7lhe mori-on
carried unalnimously 5-0.
At this time, Mr. Rhodes suggested that items 6 and 7 be flipped on the
agenda. Motion made by Mr. Taylor, seconded by Mr. Crager, to amend the
agenda to flip the order of items 6 and 7. 7lhe mat/.on carr/.ed unan/.mows/y
5-a. Chairman MCMeekin then presided over the remainder of the meeting.
6. AMENDMENTS TO CENTRAL MIDLANDS 208 PLAN
Mr. Rhodes referred to Resolution No. 2021-01 -A Resolution of the Fairfield
Joint Water and Sewer System Commission Approving an Application to the
Central Midlands Council of Governments for Certain Amendments to the 208
Water Quality Management Plan for the Central Midlands Region. Among many
things the 208 Plan does is it designates certain local governments to plan for
wastewater treatment within specific areas. Within the Central Midlands
region, which includes Richland County, Newberry County, Fairfield County and
Lexington County, each county is divided among the utility providers within
the county, and all the utility providers are charged with planning for
wastewater treatment within their respective areas. Mr. Rhodes then referred
to a map shown by Mr. Bingham depicting the designated management agency
areas for Fairfield County, which includes Town of Winnsboro, Fairfield County,
Town of Ridgeway and Mitford. These entities are charged with controlling
wastewater service and treatment within their specific areas. Another aspect
of the 208 plan is the approval of wastewater treatment facilities within each
county. If a new management agency js added to a county, such as the
Fairfield Joint System, which would change the layout of the boundaries of the
management areas as shown on the map, or if a new wastewater facility is
being located in the county, those would all be amendments to the 208 Plan
Minutes8/4/2021 FJWSSRM 5
which must be approved by the COG, and ultimately by the Governor, DHEC
and the EPA. The Council of Governments is the first step in that process.
What is being requested of the COG is to approve both the Fairfield Joint
System as a management agency within Fairfield County and to approve some
new boundaries to the management agency areas that will give the Joint
System its own agency area. Request will also be made to approve the
location of the new plant within the southern part of the County. Back in 2020
when this process really started, all of Fairfield County, the Town of Winnsboro
and the Town of Ridgeway approved Resolutions that supported some
amendments to the 208 Plan, and one of those amendments was that
Winnsboro, Ridgeway and the County would all give up some portion of their
designated management areas so that the Joint System could have its own
management area. Mr. Bingham then showed the proposed designated
management area for the Fairfield Joint System on the map, to include along
I-77 (Megasite), which was critical to the initial discussions. Those Resolutions
all contemplated the map as shown and also contemplated that the plant would
be located in the southeastern portion of the County somewhere along Cedar
Creek and discharging into Cedar Creek. However, that plan has shifted over
time, and currently the plan is to discharge into the Broad River. Because of
the language used in the original Resolutions, they must now be changed to
support the application to the COG to reflect what the various governing bodies
have approved. The current document provided to the Commission is a
Resolution whereby the Joint System affirmatively informs the COG that it is
willing to accept the responsibilities of a management agency. The location of
the plant is listed as the southern part of the County with the specific site still
undetermined. It further gives the authority to the Chairman, legal counsel
and other officers of the Joint System to make the application to the COG for
the 208 Plan amendments. That application will have to be supported by one
of the existing management agencies in the County, so either Ridgeway,
Winnsboro or the County, and this issue will be worked through as the
application is finalized. Motion made by Commissioner Crager, seconded by
Commissioner Taylor, to approve Resolution No. 2021-01. Commissioner
Crager inquired if the revised Resolution would need to go back through the
three entities again. Mr. Rhodes agreed that this will need to happen. The
location of the plant is the item that is changing with management areas
remaining the same. Vice Chair Roseborough inquired concerning the location
of the plant. Mr. Rhodes stated the plant does not necessarily have to be in a
specific entity's management agency area, but authorization would be needed
from the entity that controls the area in which the plant is going to be located.
In this case, the plant is most likely going to be located within Winnsboro's
management area. An Agreement with Winnsboro will be discussed further
with the Commission not being asked to approve anything tonight, but there
Minutes8/4/2021 FJWSSRM 6
is an agreement between the Joint System and Winnsboro that deals with
several matters, including the transfer of some customers, some service area
that Winnsboro may give to the Joint System within the southern part of the
area delineated on the map and would also give the Joint System the
authorization of the 208 Plan to site a plant within Winnsboro's agency area.
Vice Chair Roseborough further inquired concerning placing the plant in the
Town of Winnsboro area. Mr, Rhodes stated it will not be within the Town of
Winnsboro itself, such as the corporate limits of the Town, but would be in
their territory. A meeting was held today between the engineers and lawyers
to talk through some of these issues, and the very slight possibility was
discussed that the plant might need to be located within Fairfield County's
area. If this is the case, then we would need Fair field County's authorization
to locate the plant there; however, Mr. Rhodes feels this is unlikely to happen.
Chairman MCMeekin stated effectively the location of the plant is being
changed, and also questioned further the map. Per Mr. Rhodes, the map is
the same as what Ridgeway has previously approved. They will be asked to
re-approve the 208 amendments which includes the map. For the next
agenda, an item will be listed to bring Ridgeway into the Joint System. There
are no anticipated problems, but it will need to go back before the Ridgeway
Coundil for approval. The motion carried unanimously 5-0.
7. PROPOSAL TO ADMIT THE TOWN OF RIDGEWAY AS A FJWSS MEMBER
Per Mr. Rhodes, included in the agenda packet was a one page proposal for
the admittance of the Town of Ridgeway. When Mr. Rhodes last met with the
Town of Ridgeway, the request at the time was that they adopt a resolution
supporting the amendments to the 208 plan, which they agreed to do. Their
condition was that they be admitted to the Fairfield Joint System. At the time
of the request, it was not known what structure the Joint System was going to
take. Now that there is a path forward, it is time to make a formal approach
back to Ridgeway for membership in the Joint System. Under State rules, if
an entity is a member of a joint system, they must also have representation
on the board of that I.oint system. Ridgeway would need to adopt a resolution
similar to the resolutions that were originally adopted by the County and the
Town where a determination is made that it is beneficial to the citizens for
them to become a member of the Joint System. The County and the Town of
Winnsboro would also both have to adopt resolutions supporting the addition
of Ridgeway as a new member. We are now at the point for the Joint System
to approve the proposal to the Town of Ridgeway for the parameters of their
admission. The following is the process for admitting a new member to the
Joint System :
Minutes8/4/2021 FJWSSRM 7
• The size of the Commission would be increased from five to seven
members.
• Ridgeway would have the right to appoint two representatives to the
Commission, similar to Winnsboro and the County. From the County,
the current structure includes the Chairman of County Council or a
Council Member and the County Administrator from the County. From
the Town of Winnsboro, this would include the Mayor and the Town
Manager. Jointly, the County and Town of Winnsboro appoint a citizen
of the County or one of the municipalities of the County. Ridgeway
would have similar rights with one member being the Mayor or member
of the Ridgeway Council and Ridgeway's Public Works Director or
designee serving ex officio.
• Fairfield County and Winnsboro will continue to appoint two
representatives each.
• Fairfield County and Winnsboro will retain the ability to jointly appoint
the seventh Commissioner. This is done because Fairfield County and
Winnsboro are bringing the critical pieces of this puzzle to the table.
The financial commitment would include:
• Ridgeway would have no obligation to contribute financially under
current Cost-Sharing Agreement. Currently, the Town of Winnsboro and
the County are dividing the day-to-day costs of the System, which
currently consist mainly of attorney fees. The engineering costs are
being paid by the County, but this is being done through a grant with
the Department of Commerce. The proposal is that this agreement
remain in place.
Fairfield County and Winnsboro will continue to split FJWSS costs 75/25
with 75°/o paid by the County and 25°/o paid by the Town of Winnsboro.
• These financial commitments are preliminary and will be superseded in
the future by a Participation Agreement among the parties.
Ridgeway's capacity in the plant or connection to the plant will be determined
by agreement among the parties at a later date,
Motion made by Commissioner Taylor, seconded by Commissioner Crager, to
approve the proposal to admit the Town of Ridgeway as a Fairfield Joint Water
Sewer Service member. Commissioner Caulder inquired concerning the
proposed changes to the By-Laws and when will the 75/25 split of the costs be
re-evaluated, Mr. Rhodes states this will fall by the wayside pretty soon, and
the Cost Sharing Agreement between the County and the Town of Winnsboro
documents this. It states expressly that it is only intended to carry through
Minutes8/4/2021 FJWSS RM 8
the point that there is actually an operating fund. This agreement will be
replaced by a very robust Participation Agreement. All of the individual
agreements will be contained in the Participation Agreement. It will lay out
how the funding of the construction of the plant will work, determine either
how the capacity of the plant is allocated initially or how it will be allocated
over time as the members need it and, most importantly, it will deal with the
funding of the operations of the Joint System. The 75/25 structure currently,
in a normal month, entails several hundreds of dollars, and in a busy month,
this could be a few thousand dollars. These are not big numbers, and once we
get to the operation of a utility, this should be allocated on a fair basis. Mr.
Rhodes stated exactly what the basis will be has not yet been determined, and
there will be many ways to do this. In some cases, this is divided based on
customers, which would not be applicable in this instance, and in other cases,
it is based on capacity. This will be worked through over the next few months
dealing with legal counsel for the Town and the County, and everyone will have
the opportunity to weigh in on this matter. Each party will need to be
comfortable and make sure they understand all that the Participation
Agreement will entail, because it will entirely replace the original Cost Sharing
Agreement. Chairman MCMeekin remembers discussions concerning the Joint
System beginning jn 2017, and he remembers this split was I.ust to get things
up and running and is a temporary agreement. Commissioner Crager
questioned, as a point of clarification, is the motion on the table for the
amendment of the By-Laws dated July 30 as included in the packet. Mr.
Rhodes stated the motion is not on the By-Laws as the By-Laws can only be
amended at a Special Called Meeting that is called for that purpose. The By-
Laws do not need to be amended until all the steps have been taken to actually
admit Ridgeway as a member. This draft was given as information, and this
document will hopefully be amended in the near future. Vice Chair
Roseborough inquired concerning the second member from Ridgeway and if
that member will have voting rights. Per Mr. Rhodes, service will be by virtue
of a position that is held. For instance, for Mr. Caulder's seat, anyone who is
the County Administrator or Interim County Administrator sits in that seat.
Likewise for Mr. Taylor's seat, anyone who is the City Manager of Winnsboro
sits in that seat. It does not matter who it is, and whoever holds that position
is automatically placed in that seat on the Joint System's board. By virtue of
the Public Works Director's role in Ridgeway, that person is on the board of the
Joint System and will be a voting member. 7lhe mo£/.on carr/.ed
unanimously 5-0.
8. FJWSS/WINNSBORO SERVICE AREA AGREEMENT
Mr. Rhodes stated this is not an action item, but a draft is being provided
concerning the Intergovernmental Wastewater Service Area Agreement. This
Minutes8/4/2021 FJWSS RM 9
agreement does three things, the first of which being the location of the plant
having Winnsboro authorize the Joint System to locate a plant within its
management area. The second item is the transfer of customers from the
Town of Winnsboro to the Joint System. Before now, this was only a verbal
agreement. This is important to allow better opportunities for industrial
growth, and it is also important in that the Joint System will have some flow
on day one to operate. There are also provisions in the agreement to protect
the customers. Finally, the third item pertains to the transmission line, which
will, in this case, be long. It will run through the southern part of Winnsboro's
management area. One of the benefits of having the plant located on the
Broad River is that over time it can connect additional customers to that
transmission line. In very general terms, this is what this agreement does.
This has been reviewed by regulatory council that represents the Joint System
and the Town's attorney. This document is a draft, but it will ultimately require
the approval of Town Council and the Joint System. Hopefully, a more accurate
draft will be offered at the next meeting. With no questions, Chairman
MCMeekin stated this will be taken as information.
9. ENGINEERING SCOPE OFWORK
Mr. Rhodes disseminated a document to the Commission members concerning
additional scope of work for American Engineering. This firm was originally
obtained by the Joint System by Resolution pursuant to the Procurement Policy
to provide engineering services in order to get to the point where a plant was
ready to be designed. The scope of work to actually design and build the plant
will be done pursuant to a Request for Qualifications competitive process.
Under the Joint System's Procurement Policy, it can retain professionals to do
professional services. It can hire who it thinks is best qualified and best able
to provide those services if it so desires. Since that time, there have been a
couple of scopes of work that have been approved. Mr. Rhodes asked for Mr.
Davenport to further explain what this entails and the next steps. Mr.
Davenport stated there were two scopes of work approved to date. The first
scope was deciding to use American Engineering to review and analyze the
PER that Thomas & Hutton had previously supplied. They will use any
information gleaned from this report that can be used in the future. This
analysis has been completed, and the next scope of work will be for them to
get us to a point where we had not been able to get an allocation in the Broad
River. We had a location to discharge along with the PER to present, and they
will carry us through the process to the territory realignments that were
discussed and move toward hopefully getting a discharge permit. Per Mr.
Rhodes, the next scope of work to be approved, which is still under the original
authorization but it is being brought back to the Commission for approval, is
to get to the point through preliminary design and through application for the
Minutes8/4/2021 FJWSS RM 10
NPEDS permit that will get us to the point where we are ready to send out the
RFQ for the actual engineering design work for the plant itself along with
overseeing construction of the plant. That said, Mr, Rhodes had hoped to get
this pulled together a little earlier. This document should be needed over the
next 30 to 60 days, but it is not needed today. Given that no one has had the
opportunity to review this information, this is being presented only for
informational purposes. This will be brought back before the Joint System at
the next meeting, which Mr. Rhodes expects to be next month, for approval.
Delaying this by a month will ultimately not hold up the preliminary design
work and ultimately make the application for the NPEDS permit. With no
further questions, Chairman MCMeekin stated this will be taken as information
as stated by Mr. Rhodes.
Mr. Rhodes introduced Mr. John Hoefer and Mr. Chad Johnston with the firm
of Willoughby & Hoefer. They have been retained as regulatory counsel for
the Fairfield Joint System, and they are well versed in the 208 processes and
the approvals needed from DHEC and other agencies. They have been involved
in this process with the Joint System for around a year. They can provide any
needed legal advice, but this should be shared only during an executive
session.
10. EXECUTIVE SESSION: (The following statement js provided in
compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act:
Subsequent to Executive Session, the Commission may take action on
matters discussed in Executive Session.)
Executive session was not needed at this meeting.
11. ADJOURN
At 7:11 p.in., it was moved by Commissioner Taylor, seconded by
Comm.iss.ioner Crager, to acljourr\. The motion carried unanimously 5-0.
ha#,QDQjinPAl" L. DAVIS
SECRETARY
Source: Town of Winnsboro website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.