Minutes (PDF)
Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
TOWN OF SULLIVAN’S ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL
MINUTES
Tuesday, May 12, 2015
A meeting of the Administration Committee of Council was held at 4:00 p.m., Tuesday, May 12,
2015 at Town Hall, 2050-B Middle Street all requirements of the Freedom of Information Act
having been satisfied. Present were Committee members: Council members Jerry Kaynard
(Chair) and Susan Middaugh; Staff Administrator Benke, Asst. to Administrator/Human
Resources Darrow and Comptroller Blanton.
I. Call to Order. Chair Kaynard called the meeting to order, stated the press and
public were duly notified pursuant to state law and Committee had a quorum (Mary Jane Watson
absent). Chair Kaynard welcomed Council member elect Sarah Church to the meeting (no other
audience or press present).
II. Health Insurance - Update
Asst. to Administrator Darrow:
Town continues to participate with SC Employee Insurance Program/PEBA (SCEIP) to
provide employee health insurance products. This is the SC State health/medical
insurance program for state employees.
SCEIP continues to function under a “grandfathered” status with regard to the PPACA
(Affordable Care Act). Two consequences of the grandfathered status:
o SCEIP flagship policy, the Standard Health Plan (SHP), does not provide for all
the preventive care benefits mandated under the Affordable Care Act, namely free
wellness screenings for adult subscribers.
o SCEIP has not changed the employee/employer premium share percentage in the
past two years.
Town continues to provide benefits that supplement the SCEIP plan, on a reimbursement
basis: wellness screening reimbursement (employee and spouse) and deductible
reimbursement (employee pays first $200 of annual deductible). These reimbursement
benefits do not accrue for employees and are on a “use/lose” basis each calendar year.
Town continues to offset the employee health insurance expenses and a portion (up to
50%) of the employee’s dependent medical premium, depending upon the premium share
cap prescribed by SCEIP for all participating members.
Comptroller Blanton noted the Town has budgeted for an approximately 5% premium increase
for FY15-16, based upon preliminary rate information from SCEIP. Asst. to Administrator
Darrow clarified that, in the fall, SCEIP traditionally announces premium rate increases for the
upcoming Plan year (Jan-Dec), employer/employee prescribed premium cost shares and the
experience modifier surcharge for local subdivisions.
Approved as presented on 9/9/2015 with notation that 2 of 3 Committee members were not on the Committee or Council on May 12, 2015
2
III. Pending Projects - Recommendations
Chair Kaynard distributed to the Committee a summary of pending projects that have fallen
under the Administration Committee in the past (Exhibit A). He suggested it would be helpful
for the Committee to provide historical information in these minutes for future Committee
members. The Committee reviewed Chair Kaynard’s list (Exhibit A):
Pending Projects - Recommendations
1. CONTINUING ARCHIVING OLD RECORDS AT OLD TOWN HALL
2. TOWN COMMUNICATIONS PLAN
A. ANNUAL SURVEY OF RESIDENTS ON PRIORITIES
B. ESTABLISH RESIDENT COMMUNICATION LINKS
C. TV BROADCAST OF TOWN COUNCIL MEETINGS
D. PUBLISH ALL COUNCIL MEETING DOCUMENTS ON WEB
E. QUARTERLY TOWN HALL MEETINGS
Committee noted #2C really refers to multi-media broadcast of Council meetings (i.e. internet
video streaming)
3. ANNUAL EMPLOYEE APPRECIATION DAY
Chair Kaynard noted Council has awarded an additional employee holiday in the past few years,
but it has not been formalized in the Town’s personnel code/manual. The Committee noted an
Employee Appreciation Day has been awarded in early summer (June) or around Independence
Day in the past.
4. OUTSTANDING EMPLOYEE QUARTERLY AWARDS
5. CONTINUE DEPARTMENT HEAD ANNUAL EVALUATIONS AND ALL
EMPLOYEE WRITTEN ANNUAL EVALUATIONS
Chair Kaynard noted evaluations were distributed to Department Heads earlier in the year and
employee written evaluations are due by June 2015.
6. CONSIDER ANNUAL MERIT BONUS FOR OUTSTANDING EMPLOYEES WITH
BUDGET AMOUNT SET ASIDE FOR THIS PURPOSE
Chair Kaynard provided an explanation of this concept:
Merit bonus category as a one-time payment;
Salary is not increased by bonus amount;
Merit bonuses would be awarded if a pool of personnel related funds across departments
became available;
Department heads would nominate employees; Administration Committee and
Administrator review candidates for award consideration.
Approved as presented on 9/9/2015 with notation that 2 of 3 Committee members were not on the Committee or Council on May 12, 2015
3
Council member Middaugh stated she usually prefers employee salary increases because the
retirement pension is tied to the employee’s highest earned salary; however, she generally
supports finding ways to reward meritorious employees.
Chair Kaynard noted the Town primarily adjusts salaries across-the-board for cost-of-living
increases. This initiative would be a mechanism to provide additional merit awards without
burdening the Town with higher salaries subject to cost drivers such as employer contributions to
retirement plans and withholding taxes.
7. CONSIDER RELEASE OF TREE SURVEY TO THE PUBLIC
Chair Kaynard noted the Town needs to pursue ways for the Protected Land tree survey to get
accessed easily by residents, preferably online as opposed to coming into Town Hall. This
initiative would be in furtherance of Town communications/outreach.
8. CREATION OF HISTORICAL COMMISSION AND ARCHIVIST
9. CREATION OF ORIENTATION AND TRANSITION PLAN FOR NEW COUNCIL
MEMBERS
10. CONSIDER INCREASE IN PUBLIC COMMENTS AT COUNCIL MEETINGS FROM
20 MINUTES TO ONE HOUR AT QUARTERLY MEETINGS
Chair Kaynard noted that, should the Town not pursue a Town Hall format each quarter, he
would recommend extending the public comment time from 20 minutes to 1 hour during a Town
Council meeting once each quarter.
11. HOLD ANNUAL PLANNING RETREAT FOR TOWN COUNCIL IN JANUARY OF
EACH YEAR
Committee discussed the value of having an annual planned retreat for Council. Administrator
Benke submitted the retreat should be scheduled for November or December to allow for funding
of initiatives/strategies in the next fiscal year budget process.
12. CONSIDER DESIGNATION OF EXISTING TOWN EMPLOYEE AS DIRECTOR OF
RECREATION
Committee discussed the current role the Recreation Department has in the Town’s structure and
funding priorities. Chair Kaynard noted that Fire Chief Stith handles a number of recreation
activities for the Town, but the Town does not have a designated person to manage and prioritize
the recreation department and its budget. He submitted that, as a result, funding of Recreation
Department expenses is usually at the end of budget consideration.
Administrator Benke noted that the Town does not have Recreation Department staff. Chief
Stith, serving as head of the Maintenance Department, arranges for maintenance staff to conduct
Approved as presented on 9/9/2015 with notation that 2 of 3 Committee members were not on the Committee or Council on May 12, 2015
4
set-up and tear-down for Town Recreation related events. Multiple Town personnel share the
duties related to the planning and coordination of new or recurring recreation related activities
and recreation facilities.
Committee members remarked that the Recreation Committee of Council Chair, Mary Jane
Watson, performed much of the work in coordinating various community recreation events (i.e.
golf cart/bicycle parade, St. Patrick’s Family Park Day, etc.)
Chair Kaynard submitted it is not the Administration Department’s role to manage the budgeting
decisions for recreation related items. He noted the process for the Recreation Department
budget is weak and could be strengthened.
Administrator Benke suggested Council should define the role of the Recreation Department, its
priorities and goals. He submitted that different people define the Recreation Department as
various things, some being:
Town recreation equipment (lights, courts and nets)
Youth sports and structured, rented access to fields and equipment
Community related activities and events (Independence Day events, Valentine’s Day
cards for youth, St. Patrick’s Day family fun, etc.)
All of the above and even more
The Committee noted that a discussion of the Recreation Department’s mission, priorities and
goals is in order and ideally should be included on the agenda for the Council Retreat on
Wednesday, May 27, 2015.
13. CONSIDER ANNUAL PUBLIC SAFETY FIRST RESPONDERS HOLIDAY BONUS
IN DECEMBER OF $750.00 PER EMPLOYEE WITH ALL OTHER TOWN
EMPLOYEES RECEIVING $250.00 HOLIDAY BONUS
Chair Kaynard suggested that a one-time holiday bonus for staff is provided for many
municipalities, often at the holiday season. He noted a bonus would not be subject to retirement
withholding and not included as an increase in an employee’s base salary. Chair Kaynard noted
that Comptroller Blanton estimates a $750 bonus for public safety first responders and $250
bonus for other Town employees would cost the Town approximately $21,261.
Committee discussed the personnel budgets for departments, and, how most departments have
unfilled positions at some point in the year. These vacancies result in unexpended salaries.
Chair Kaynard suggested that Council could award a holiday bonus at its discretion should funds
become available.
MOTION: Chair Kaynard made a motion to recommend to Council to consider
awarding an annual holiday bonus in December of $750/employee for Public
Safety/First Responders and $250/employee for other regular Town employees, subject
to availability of funding; seconded by Council member Middaugh. MOTION
UNANIMOUSLY PASSED.
Approved as presented on 9/9/2015 with notation that 2 of 3 Committee members were not on the Committee or Council on May 12, 2015
5
14. RECOMMENDATIONS TO TOWN COUNCIL DECEMBER 18, 2012
Chair Kaynard noted Council should prioritize Preventive Care/Wellness Committee
activities, particularly as the Town funds a wellness reimbursement to employees.
A. Preventative Health Care Program
Staff continues to develop a Preventative Health Care Program with the assistance of the
Municipal Association and models of other municipalities. In addition, the Committee
recommends incorporating several health related activities:
Plan an annual activity day for members of Council, employees, members of
Boards and Commissions that would include friendly sports competition.
Incorporate a program that monitors, assesses and rewards safe weight loss.
Sponsor an Island run or walk for Council, employees, members of Boards and
Commissions.
Incentivize participation in at least 3 run or walks per year for employees and
Council.
Hold an annual Council reception which will recognize outstanding Council,
employee and Board member healthy lifestyle.
B. Annual Employee Reviews
The Administrator reported that reviews will begin in March. Department Heads will be
reviewed by the Administrator and staff will be reviewed by Department Heads. The
process will conclude by mid-April for the purposes of budget planning.
The Committee will ask that the Administrator include in each review a section for areas
of improvement and goal setting for the following year. Additionally, the Administrator
should counsel each department head to write an objective review.
C. Employee Service Awards
A number of employees reached milestones in 2012. The Administrator reviewed the
categories and discussed the employee service pin program. The Committee additionally
recommends establishing a “Know Your Employee Program” where a brief biography
will be written about each person and distributed through the water bills and posted on
the website. Additionally, the new Town Hall will have a display of employee
photographs.
D. Employee Appreciation Date
The Committee recommends that the recently discussed day off for employee
appreciation on December 31, 2012 be affirmed by a vote of Council and that the Mayor,
Chairman of Personnel Committee and Administrator prepare a letter of appreciation
to each employee.
Asst. to Administrator Darrow provided a brief report on the Town’s health insurance and
medical benefits program. Highlights of State Employee Insurance Program (SC EIP):
SC EIP remains “grandfathered” out of the Affordable Care Act changes through 2015.
Therefore benefits to the existing medical benefit plans will not substantially change.
Approved as presented on 9/9/2015 with notation that 2 of 3 Committee members were not on the Committee or Council on May 12, 2015
6
Town’s anticipated premium increase will be approximately 6%, including a 1% load
factor subsidy SC EIP may charge to participating local subdivisions.
SC EIP mandates no increase to the employee’s share of premium costs. Employer share
will increase by approximately 6%. Employee deductibles and co-pays increase slightly
(deductibles increase $20-40/year depending upon dependent coverage).
SC EIP recently announced coverage for same-sex marriages, opening a special
enrollment for qualified subscribers.
IV. Executive Session – Personnel Matters
Chair Kaynard noted the Committee needed to meet in executive session to discuss two
personnel matters.
MOTION: Council member Middaugh made a motion to go into executive session;
seconded by Chair Kaynard. MOTION UNANIMOUSLY PASSED.
Committee sequestered for executive session at 4:48p.m., returning at 5:10p.m.
Chair Kaynard noted the Committee was back in open session and no decisions or votes were
made in executive session.
MOTION: Chair Kaynard made a motion to recommend to Council the promotion
of Amanda Hawver to Lieutenant (Fire Department) with a five (5%) percent salary
increase; seconded by Council member Middaugh. MOTION UNANIMOUSLY
PASSED.
MOTION: Council member Middaugh made a motion to recommend to Council to
advertise and fill a vacant engineer position in the Fire Department; seconded by
Chair Kaynard. MOTION UNANIMOUSLY PASSED.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at approximately 5:13p.m. (Council
member Middaugh motioned; Chair Kaynard seconded; unanimously passed).
Respectfully submitted,
Jerry Kaynard, Chairman
Administration Committee
Approved by the Administration Committee, as presented, at the September 9, 2015 with
the notation that two of three committee members were not on this Administration
Committee or Town Council on the May 12, 2015 meeting
Approved as presented on 9/9/2015 with notation that 2 of 3 Committee members were not on the Committee or Council on May 12, 2015
7
EXHIBIT A
ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE Prepared by Chair Jerry Kaynard
MAY 12, 2015
Pending Projects - Recommendations
1. CONTINUING ARCHIVING OLD RECORDS AT OLD TOWN HALL
2. TOWN COMMUNICATIONS PLAN
A. ANNUAL SURVEY OF RESIDENTS ON PRIORITIES
B. ESTABLISH RESIDENT COMMUNICATION LINKS
C. TV BROADCAST OF TOWN COUNCIL MEETINGS
D. PUBLISH ALL COUNCIL MEETING DOCUMENTS ON WEB
E. QUARTERLY TOWN HALL MEETINGS
3. ANNUAL EMPLOYEE APPRECIATION DAY
4. OUTSTANDING EMPLOYEE QUARTERLY AWARDS
5. CONTINUE DEPARTMENT HEAD ANNUAL EVALUATIONS AND ALL
EMPLOYEE WRITTEN ANNUAL EVALUATIONS
6. CONSIDER ANNUAL MERIT BONUS FOR OUTSTANDING EMPLOYEES WITH
BUDGET AMOUNT SET ASIDE FOR THIS PURPOSE
7. CONSIDER RELEASE OF TREE SURVEY TO THE PUBLIC
8. CREATION OF HISTORICAL COMMISSION AND ARCHIVIST
9. CREATION OF ORIENTATION AND TRANSITION PLAN FOR NEW COUNCIL
MEMBERS
10. CONSIDER INCREASE IN PUBLIC COMMENTS AT COUNCIL MEETINGS FROM
20 MINUTES TO ONE HOUR AT QUARTERLY MEETINGS
11. HOLD ANNUAL PLANNING RETREAT FOR TOWN COUNCIL IN JANUARY OF
EACH YEAR
Approved as presented on 9/9/2015 with notation that 2 of 3 Committee members were not on the Committee or Council on May 12, 2015
8
12. CONSIDER DESIGNATION OF EXISTING TOWN EMPLOYEE AS DIRECTOR OF
RECREATION
13. CONSIDER ANNUAL PUBLIC SAFETY FIRST RESPONDERS HOLIDAY BONUS
IN DECEMBER OF $750.00 PER EMPLOYEE WITH ALL OTHER TOWN
EMPLOYEES RECEIVING $250.00 HOLIDAY BONUS
14. RECOMMENDATIONS TO TOWN COUNCIL DECEMBER 18, 2012
A. Preventative Health Care Program
Staff continues to develop a Preventative Health Care Program with the assistance of the
Municipal Association and models of other municipalities. In addition, the Committee
recommends incorporating several health related activities:
Plan an annual activity day for members of Council, employees, members of
Boards and Commissions that would include friendly sports competition.
Incorporate a program that monitors, assesses and rewards safe weight loss.
Sponsor an Island run or walk for Council, employees, members of Boards and
Commissions.
Incentivize participation in at least 3 run or walks per year for employees and
Council.
Hold an annual Council reception which will recognize outstanding Council,
employee and Board member healthy lifestyle.
B. Annual Employee Reviews
The Administrator reported that reviews will begin in March. Department Heads will be
reviewed by the Administrator and staff will be reviewed by Department Heads. The
process will conclude by mid-April for the purposes of budget planning.
The Committee will ask that the Administrator include in each review a section for areas
of improvement and goal setting for the following year. Additionally, the Administrator
should counsel each department head to write an objective review.
C. Employee Service Awards
A number of employees reached milestones in 2012. The Administrator reviewed the
categories and discussed the employee service pin program. The Committee additionally
recommends establishing a “Know Your Employee Program” where a brief biography
will be written about each person and distributed through the water bills and posted on
the website. Additionally, the new Town Hall will have a display of employee
photographs.
D. Employee Appreciation Date
The Committee recommends that the recently discussed day off for employee
Appreciation on December 31, 2012 be affirmed by a vote of Council and that the
Approved as presented on 9/9/2015 with notation that 2 of 3 Committee members were not on the Committee or Council on May 12, 2015
9
Mayor, Chairman of Personnel Committee and Administrator prepare a letter of
appreciation to each employee.
Approved as presented on 9/9/2015 with notation that 2 of 3 Committee members were not on the Committee or Council on May 12, 2015
Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.