Minutes (PDF)
Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
TOWN OF SULLIVAN’S ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
LAND USE & NATURAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL
Friday, March 14, 2014
The Land Use & Natural Resources Committee of Council met at 3:05 p.m. on March 14,
2014 at Town Hall, 2050-B Middle Street, all requirements of the Freedom of Information
Act having been met. Present were Committee members Pat O’Neil, Chair, Mayor Mike
Perkis and Council member Jerry Kaynard; Staff, Administrator Benke and Asst. to
Administrator Darrow.
There were approximately fifteen members of the public present, including Council
members Chauncey Clark, Susan Middaugh and Mary Jane Watson; no media
representatives present. Jeff Jackson, Town naturalist consultant, was present for agenda
item #5.
1. Call to Order. Chair O’Neil called the meeting to order, stated the press and
public were duly notified pursuant to state law and noted all members were present. Chair
O’Neil noted that the minutes from October 15, 2013 meeting were approved at a
subsequent Council Workshop.
2. 5-Year (2013) Draft Comprehensive Plan
Planning Commission Vice-Chair Currey provided a short report on the Draft 2013
Comprehensive Plan (recommended to Council by Planning Commission on May 8, 2013),
highlighting any recommended changes to the Needs & Goals from the 2008 Plan to the
2013 Draft Plan. Chair O’Neil acknowledged Commissioner Sydney Cook was present too.
Next steps: Council will receive draft documents and the report made to today’s
Committee for consideration at the April 7, 2014 Council Workshop.
Administrator Benke joined meeting at this time.
3. Biggert Waters Act – Update
Chair O’Neil noted federal legislation (HR 3370/S 72-22) is working its way through
Congress that would provide some relief for home-owners impacted by the Flood Insurance
rate changes pursuant to the Bigger Waters Act of 2012. Some of the highlights include:
Repeals the property sales trigger which immediately raises premiums of non-
compliant properties to full “actuarial” rates on the sale of the home or change in
insurance carrier. This significantly impacted the ability for some properties to be
sold and the market value of other homes in general.
Pre-FIRM structures (built before the Town’s flood plain maps were established),
including historic structures that do not comply with current flood elevations, will
see modest relief by having per-property rate increases capped at 18% per year, but
the ultimate rate increases are not capped.
2
It is anticipated the bills will pass both houses of Congress and be brought before President
Obama in the next week or two. Meanwhile FEMA will conduct additional studies, to
include affordability and ensuring flood plain map accuracy, over the next two years.
He noted the Town will continue to monitor flood insurance reforms and its impact to the
Island.
4. Staff Report (Recurring): Administrator Benke reviewed the Staff report
a. Zoning issues, Zoning Administrator Henderson
b. Building issues, Building Official Robinson
c. Reports on related Boards, Zoning Administrator Henderson
i. Planning Commission
1. Considering café eating establishment concept
2. Bicycle/pedestrian marsh boardwalk concept from Ben
Sawyer Bridge entrance sign to Patriot Street area
3. Battery to Beach (B2B) alternate route endorsed
ii. Board of Zoning Appeals: four (4) items on March agenda
iii. Design Review Board: eleven (11) items February-March
iv. Tree Commission: four (4) items between November-March
Committee comments:
Marsh boardwalk concept (Ben Sawyer Boulevard to Patriot Street):
Mayor Perkis submitted this concept may have not have the consensus of Council and
should be moved forward to the April Council Workshop/meeting for discussion.
Meanwhile, Council should direct Staff to discontinue expending more time and resources
for this concept until Council has the opportunity to express its level of support for the
concept.
Next Steps: Committee will move Bicycle/pedestrian marsh boardwalk concept (Ben
Sawyer Boulevard to Patriot Street) to April workshop for general Council discussion.
Until Council has time to review this concept, Mayor Perkis will direct Staff to suspend
expending additional time and energy on this matter.
Committee determined a formal motion on the 2013 Draft Comprehensive Plan would be in
order.
MOTION: Council member Kaynard made a motion to recommend to Council
that the Draft 2013 Comprehensive Plan be placed on the April 7, 2014 Council
Workshop for Council review; seconded by Chair O’Neil. MOTION
UNANIMOUSLY PASSED.
3
5. Review of status of Approved Projects in the Protected Land: Implementation
of approved projects and next steps
Jeff Jackson, Town naturalist consultant, provided an update on the Protected Land projects
approved by the Town.
Invasive Species Eradication
First session accomplished by professional volunteer arborist and naturalists. A
good group of experienced, qualified professionals assisted with this first phase
(some chemical use).
Second session would include interested residents and volunteers who would assist
with physical removal of invasive species without chemicals, under Town
consultant supervision. This would be an educational opportunity for the public, too.
Date/time will be determined in the near future.
Consultant is retaining a record of all species removed, by plant, to demonstrate
progress.
Nature Trail (Administrator Benke)
After months of reviewing and refining a proposed nature trail, Council approved
the sketch plan.
This week (March 12, 2014) the Town opened bids for construction of the Station
16 Nature Trail (boardwalks, decks and benches). Four bids were received and are
currently under Town Staff review.
Noted the nature trail is marked in the area. Town is ready to start construction.
Mayor Perkis asked if the Town received input from the Audubon Society.
Administrator Benke noted the Town received feedback from the Audubon Society,
Billy McCord with DNR and US Fish and Wildlife on the migratory birds in the
area.
Mayor Perkis asked for clarification on the width of the path, noting it was made very wide.
Administrator Benke noted that the Public Safety Chiefs felt it was important,
should boardwalks be built through the nature trail, that their Staff could access the
area with an ATV (all-terrain vehicle) in the event of a police or medical
emergency.
Chair O’Neil and Administrator Benke provided a general outline of the Town efforts to
increase Protected Land accessibility to the residents and public. Administrator Benke
mentioned grant funding that allowed for improvements to existing beach paths/boardwalks
and creating paths within the nature trails.
Barbara Spell (1702 Atlantic Avenue, Sullivan’s Island) asked about increased
tourism and the impact on Island residents. What about impact on traffic and
parking? How did you determine whether residents want this trail?
Mayor Perkis noted that this nature trail would not encourage a large group of non-Island
residents to come to the Island. He envisioned residents and few nature lovers regularly
utilizing the area.
4
Council member Kaynard noted that the Town cannot control the growing population in the
Charleston area. This population growth will naturally increase day visitors to all the
beaches.
Julia Khoury (1728 I’On Avenue, Sullivan’s Island) commented that the Protected
Land is already protected by deed restrictions. Asked how the Town would see
additional protection from the trail and other efforts.
Mayor Perkis clarified that, by allowing public accessibility to the Protected Land, the
Town should see an increase in the public’s awareness of the area’s value and support for
protecting the land.
Chair O’Neil stressed that the Town was seeking a balanced plan/approach for the
Protected Land and noted that this area would not become a Grand Canyon-type attraction.
Karen Coste (?) (322 Station 19 Street, Sullivan’s Island) asked for clarification that
there will be no additional construction beyond Phase One (Station 19 nature trail).
She wanted assurance that there would be no additional hardscape/boardwalk in the
future phases for Station 16-18 and down the Island. Noted she is trying to
understand the whole plan.
Administrator Benke clarified that the Town has not planned or discussed installing a
boardwalk from Station 16-18, as rumored and erroneously published in non-Town
publications.
Ms. Coste pressed for assurance that there would be no further construction in the
Accreted Land.
Administrator Benke clarified that the Town has not looked at the land from Station 16 east
to Station 28 ½. He could not speak to whether there are seasonal wetlands in the area
which a pedestrian would need to traverse.
Ms. Coste pressed for concession from Town Staff or Committee members that it
would be conceivable that, in the future, the Town might construct more boardwalks.
She stated she is trying to get an understanding of the plan for the entire area.
Administrator Benke noted the Town is not stating that additional boardwalks will or will
not be recommended as the area has not been explored.
Committee noted that a complete comprehensive plan for the Protected Land has not been
finalized.
Jeff Jackson noted that, in his opinion, there is not a need to install a boardwalk from
Station 16 to Station 18.
5
Comprehensive Management Plan for the Protected Land – Next Steps
Chair O’Neil noted that version 3A is the last/current iteration of the Town’s Draft
Comprehensive Accreted Land Management Plan.
Mayor Perkis noted that, about a year ago, Council asked the Mayor and Council member
Kaynard to help meet with different resident groups to get information, feedback,
viewpoints and seek concepts for which resident groups had general consensus, to assist the
Town Council with its efforts to develop a balanced Comprehensive Accreted Land
Management Plan.
Mayor Perkis noted that area residents, many on the beach front, have collaborated to
provide excellent feedback to the Town. Mayor Perkis referenced the resident feedback
that has been very recently provided to this Committee by area residents (Exhibit A –
untitled and unsigned document that self-references as a “draft active management plan”).
Mayor Perkis noted that the twenty-nine (29) recommendations from the resident group
represents a mix of ideas. He opined that some of the strategy recommendations are in-line
with the principles and directives formulated by the Town with its draft Accreted Land
Management Plan; some strategy recommendations are close to alignment with Town
principles and directives; and some strategy recommendations are outside the scope of the
Town’s principles and directives.
Mayor Perkis noted he sees these twenty-nine (29) recommendations as a good-faith effort
by a group of residents to provide helpful, positive feedback and ideas to the Town. He
reiterated that this resident report/recommendation has been very recently received by the
Town (Exhibit A). He recommends this information get forwarded to the Council for
consideration and study. He recommended that the Committee use this document (Exhibit
A) as a piece of the information it references when discussing and identifying Phase I & II
Protected Land project priorities. Mayor Perkis noted that some of the ideas in this
document (Exhibit A) would be useful for Phase II efforts, particularly the
recommendations regarding the transition zones and the nature center.
Mayor Perkis referenced the Town’s intent to have different management strategies by
zones along the Protected Land. He referenced the GIS zone measurement estimates
conducted by Zoning Administrator Henderson, at Council’s request, as a working
document to illustrate the different zones. Chair O’Neil instructed the GIS maps be placed
on the Town’s website now.
Chair O’Neil clarified that Mayor Perkis and Council member Kaynard see the document
received by the resident group (Exhibit A) as a way for these residents to provide additional
suggestions and input on the various items already identified within the framework of the
current Town (Draft) Comprehensive Accreted Land Management Plan.
Mayor Perkis noted that there may be resident suggestions that offer new ideas and
suggestions that were not previously considered in the current Town (Draft)
Comprehensive Accreted Land Management Plan.
6
Chair O’Neil asked for the author of the resident group’s document (Exhibit A). Mayor
Perkis clarified that he and Council Member Kaynard are not the authors of the document.
Council member Kaynard noted the document (Exhibit A) is a collaborative effort of many
residents and there is no single author, to his knowledge.
Council Member Kaynard clarified for residents the three simultaneous efforts for the
Protected Land:
1. Comprehensive Strategic Protected Land Management Plan
Town spent significant money approximately three years ago to have consultants provide
recommendations for a Town Comprehensive Strategic Protected Land Management Plan.
Council and this LUNR committee have spent hours over multiple meetings working
toward developing a strategic Plan tailored to the Town’s needs, incorporating consultant
recommendations, sensitive to the multiple viewpoints expressed by residents and faithful
to the Town’s stewardship responsibilities to these natural resources.
This Plan is slowly evolving – version 3A is the most recent draft.
2. Phase I and Phase II Protected Land Projects
The LUNR Committee is developing recommendations to Council for, and providing
oversight to, incremental projects that the Town felt could be accomplished within the
Protected Land in a multiple phase format. There are approximately a dozen projects on an
established list that the Committee calls “Exhibit E.” Eradication of invasive plant species
is an example of this type of project. These projects are deliberately and methodically
reviewed and considered within public meetings where residents have an opportunity to
provide input.
3. Communicate and Collaborate with Public – New Ideas & Feedback
Council wanted the LUNR committee to communicate with the public to seek collaboration
and areas of mutual consensus on strategies for the Protected Land. The resident group
plan mentioned tonight (Exhibit A) is an example of the results realized by the LUNR
Committee’s community outreach efforts.
Council member Kaynard recommended Council consider this feedback as the Town
moves forward with efforts related to Item 1 and #2 above (Comprehensive Plan and Phase
I/II Protected Land Projects).
Chair O’Neil acknowledged that the public has not had the opportunity to see the resident
group’s draft Active Management Plan (Exhibit A).
MOTION: Council member Kaynard recommended that the Committee
recommend to Council that it review and consider the transition zones and
nature center as potential next phase projects in the Protected Land, and,
review the resident proposal received by this Committee (Exhibit A); seconded
by Mayor Perkis. MOTION UNANIMOUSLY PASSED.
7
Committee discussed history of the Nature Center, broached approximately 20 years ago.
Residents asked about the cost of a Nature Center (unknown).
Residents complained about access to information reviewed by the LUNR today, wanting
information in advance. Residents requested streaming of Committee and Council
meetings on the website. Administrator Benke noted the Town is working toward the
digitization of Town records and placing information on the “cloud.” Chair O’Neil noted
that the committee and council minutes are not posted online until after they are approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at approximately 4:50 p.m.
(Councilman Perkis motioned; Councilman Kaynard seconded; unanimously passed).
Respectfully submitted,
Pat O’Neil, Chairman
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Approved at the April 11, 2014 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee Meeting
8
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
March 14, 2014 Meeting
Exhibit A
9
10
11
Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.