Minutes (PDF)
Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Land Use & Natural Resources February 7, 2018 Minutes 1
TOWN OF SULLIVAN’S ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
LAND USE & NATURAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL
Wednesday, February 7, 2018
Committee met at 9:00AM., this date, at Town Hall, 2056 Middle Street, all requirements of the
Freedom of Information Act having been met. Present were Committee members
Councilmember Rita Langley (Chair), Mayor Pat O’Neil and Councilmember Chauncey Clark;
Staff: Administrator Benke, Zoning Administrator Henderson, Asst. to Administrator Darrow
and Building Official Robinson.
1. Call to Order. Chair Langley called the meeting to order, stated the press and public
were duly notified pursuant to state law and all members were present; no media and ten
(10) audience members present (including Council members Church and Reese).
2. Meeting Agenda
MOTION TO AMEND: Mayor O’Neil moved to approve the meeting agenda with
the following amendment: move the last item, “Transition Zone Management:
Preliminary Discussion,” to the first order of business; seconded by Council
member Clark. AMENDED AGENDA MOTION UNANIMOUSLY PASSED.
3. Transition Zone Management: Preliminary Discussion
Staff Report: (Administrator Benke)
Overview of current status:
• Council has discussed the management of the Protected Land (oceanfront conservation
deed restricted land) for a number of years, approving a Transition Zone two years ago.
• Ongoing litigation regarding the Protected Land (Bluestein, et al v. TOSI) is currently in
appeal phase, with the Plaintiff’s Appellate Court date to be announced soon, hopefully
in mid-March/April 2018. Town attorneys have requested Town Council defer taking
any action/implementation in the Transition Zone until resolution at Appellate Court.
Council requested Staff provide preliminary information on Transition Zone management during
this appellate period.
External Agency Coordination:
• Lowcountry Open Land Trust (LOLT) holds the restricted deed for the Protected Land.
This agency approved management of the space, in principle, on March 20, 2017
(pursuant to paragraph 3 of the deed restrictions).
• SC Department of Health and Environmental Control (SCDHEC) has authority for state
jurisdictional lines. SCDHEC had no comment on any portion of the Town’s Transition
Zone management plan landward of the jurisdictional setback, but would require more
specific information for any management of land/beach seaward of the jurisdictional
Land Use & Natural Resources February 7, 2018 Minutes 2
setback, likely denying complete eradication of roots for vegetation seaward of the
setback line.
Planning Components:
• First order of business - Survey Transition Zone (approximately 23 acres of land)
o Mark Transition Zone bands
o Identify baseline/setback
o Noted Town did a mock-survey of the Transition Zone area between Station 17-
18 (Sand Dunes Club), marking space with pegs/stakes.
o Stakes/pegs can be blown away in a storm and/or moved. Staff recommends
cutting begin within a few weeks of survey completion.
o Council may wish to use the existing tree survey for tree size, but that is a Council
decision
• Timeline/Scope/Methodology
o Cutting would take approximately 2-2 ½ months to complete (cuttings would be
ground/mulched). All cutting within the Transition Zone should be accomplished
at one time, not piece-meal.
o Clearing of debris (i.e. post-hurricane, off-shore materials, etc.) should be
accomplished in tandem with cutting with the Transition Zone.
o Town should consider including removal of popcorn trees at this time
o Equipment to be used: remote controlled Gyrotrac operated by an I-Pad. This
cutting equipment would be on tractor treads to navigate the sandy ground. The
Town tested the use of this equipment on the Stith Park mound, finding it
effectively ground/mulched bamboo. The equipment would meet SCDHEC
requirements.
• Budget/Bid Process
o Staff recommends Council should budget between $200,000 - $300,000 for this
project.
o Project cost requires competitive bidding through RFP process. Timeline for
advertisement to selection would be approximately 4-6 weeks.
Council members noted some funds have been set aside for Transition Zone management but not
a sufficient amount. They noted this would be referred to Council for discussion with the FY19
budget.
Public Questions/Comments:
Wayne Guckenberger (2105 Pettigrew, SI), expressed no support for herbicide treatment of
the area (if included in the final management plan), noting he would pay any additional costs for
treatment of land behind his property without herbicides.
Manda Poletti (1771 Atlantic Avenue, SI), commented on the post-Hurricane Irma storm
vegetative/non-vegetative debris in the Transition Zone, specifically in the Station 17 area.
Additionally, the Station 17 area has attracted people as a “hang-out” place.
Pete Butko (2160 Pettigrew, SI), requested Council consider alternative funding opportunities
(i.e. resident shared expense) and additional revenue streams.
Land Use & Natural Resources February 7, 2018 Minutes 3
Committee members noted the budget and funding sources are still under discussion and Council
will continue exploring all funding options.
Julia Khoury (1728 I’On Avenue, SI), supports use of herbicides only for the eradication of
Chinese Tallow (popcorn trees) due to necessity, but does not support herbicides otherwise,
especially as it may threaten ground cover.
Manda Poletti (1771 Atlantic Avenue, SI), noted there are companies that use very organic
products to eradicate vegetation, commenting her landscaper specifically uses highly organic
products at her request.
Administrator Benke:
• Clarified that use of herbicides would be at Council’s direction and is one of many
management options for the area. Additionally, if Council directed use of any herbicides,
the type/use would be subject to approval under the Town’s NPDS permit.
• Gyrotrac machine would be approximately four (4’) feet wide and five (5’) feet long on
tractor treads, operated remotely via an I-pad by a qualified contractor. The machine
would be able to navigate closely around the trees.
Susan Middaugh (2420 Raven Drive, SI), commented that herbicide use may not be necessary,
noting repetitive cutting/mowing may give the same effect. She expressed support for an
evaluation period following initial cutting.
Mayor O’Neil expressed support for an initial/first cutting cycle followed by a one-year
evaluation.
NO FORMAL ACTION TAKEN: retained on committee agenda for future review.
4. Polystyrene/Styrofoam Containers on Island: Community Outreach/Public
Awareness
Continuation of topic discussed at last Committee meeting.
Staff Report:
Committee requested Staff gather data on debris type/quantity on the beach and research/develop
a proposed community outreach/public awareness program.
Administrator Benke
• Reviewed data compiled July 1 – December 31, 2017 by SCDHEC/OCRM volunteer-
driven “Adopt a Beach” Program (Exhibit A).
o In six-month period approximately 29 pounds of total debris was collected
o Cigarette butts were the main trash contributor, but weighing 0.4lbs.
o Class 3 (polystyrene) debris - approximately 5 ½lb was collected in 6 months
• Noted some polystyrene debris was brought onto the Island by visitors, but an unknown
quantity would have washed ashore with tides/storm surges.
Asst. to Administrator Darrow:
Presented Community Outreach/Public Awareness program concept (Exhibit B).
Land Use & Natural Resources February 7, 2018 Minutes 4
Council Comments:
• Littering in general, not polystyrene, is the key to retaining the Town’s clean beach
• Applauded the number of proactive residents witnessed regularly walking and cleaning
the beach
• Noted the Town has a no-littering ordinance in effect
o Questioned if the current littering ordinance needs review/revision
o Questioned if a specific ordinance against polystyrene and single-use plastic bags
would be necessary and enforceable
• Noted other communities, such as Town of Mt. Pleasant, are considering banning
polystyrene containers and single-use plastic bags in businesses
• Committee members expressed mixed opinions on supporting an ordinance at this time to
ban single-use plastic bags and polystyrene containers:
o Support not having items on beach
o Noted Sullivan’s Island businesses, in general, are sensitive about not providing
these products
o Noted a new ordinance, or revision of the existing littering ordinance, would force
beach visitors to pay attention to single-use bag and polystyrene littering or face
penalties.
o Consideration of an ordinance would demonstrate proactive support for the
community
Administrator Benke:
• Noted the Town’s current littering ordinance specifies no bottles on the beach and
littering, in general.
• Successful enforcement and prosecution would require a beach services officer
witnessing someone littering.
• SC Assembly is currently considering relevant legislation, specifically
S0068/H3529 (of Session 122 Assembly), that would, if ratified in current proposed
form, restrict municipalities from banning “auxiliary containers.” Rather, regulation of
auxiliary containers would reside solely with the State Assembly.
o It is his understanding that municipalities with laws against single-use
bags/polystyrene (or other auxiliary containers) may be “grandfathered” by the
SC Assembly.
o Additionally, it is unclear if municipalities would be authorized to ban
transport/use of various containers in public spaces (parks, beach, etc).
• Noted municipalities’ regulatory authority would be subject to legal interpretation of any
final, ratified SC Assembly law. He deferred any Council questions to legal staff.
Public Comments:
Mary English (1306 Thompson Avenue, SI), walks the beach daily, commends her neighbors
who clean regularly and does not observe a Styrofoam problem (observes beer can, plastic juice
bags and bottle cap litter); noted boat debris washing or blowing on-shore is big litter culprit.
Land Use & Natural Resources February 7, 2018 Minutes 5
Kimberly Brown (2118 Pettigrew, SI), reiterated her suggestion made at the last Committee
meeting for Town to purchase more colorful, but still biodegradable, dog fecal refuse baggies
(litter she observes the most).
Rayeann Osborne (1801 Atlantic Avenue, SI), echoed comments about dog fecal bag litter;
suggested reinstating garbage cans on the beach side of each beach path/station.
Wayne Guckenberger (2105 Pettigrew, SI), supports brighter color dog fecal bags and even
selling advertisement on it. Noted he would like to see the Island become a trash-in/out
environment where trash receptacles were not needed.
Pete Butko (2160 Pettigrew, SI), recommends aggressive enforcement of non-licensed dogs;
promotes partnering with a recycling contractor to have recycling cans/collection beach-front
and/or street-side of beach paths/stations.
Manda Poletti (1771 Atlantic Avenue, SI), echoed comments from Mr. Butko, noting a
recycling contractor hands out recycle bags at Clemson football games for collection. Noted
otherwise those cans would end up in the regular trash containers.
Sarah Church (1655 Atlantic Avenue, SI), commented that cigarette butts are the biggest litter
problem in her opinion.
Committee Comments:
Committee members
• Expressed support for recycling, in general, but did note that beachgoers in the past have
thrown regular trash into recycling bins at the beach paths. This would be challenge to
successful recycling efforts.
• Support partnering with other Charleston area beaches to coordinate public
relations/public service announcements, to enhance visibility of clean beach initiatives.
NO FORMAL ACTION TAKEN: Retained on committee agenda for future review
5. 2018 Sullivan’s Island Comprehensive Plan: Update on Project
Staff Report (Zoning Administrator Henderson):
Reported the Planning Commission has begun the 10-year review/re-write of the Town’s
Comprehensive Plans, with Town Staff and BCD-COG consultant.
Public Notice/Participation:
• Project specific website (http://bit.ly/2018_SI_COMP_PLAN)
o Surveys for residents (only) targeting specific topics/Plan elements
o Working documents as Plan progresses
o Timeline when public may expect Commission to review various elements
• Methodology: Commission will review Plan incrementally, considering the 9 elements
individually.
Land Use & Natural Resources February 7, 2018 Minutes 6
o Process for Commissioners:
(1) Receive one-two elements as information only (public meeting)
(2) Review (at home) provide questions/edits to Staff between meetings
(3) Staff compiles Commissioner questions and conducts additional research, as
needed
(4) Discuss/review/edit at following Steering Committee workshop (public
meeting)
(5) Commissioners make formal recommendations for preliminary approval at
regular meetings (public)
(6) Element set-aside and Commission moves to next element piece (via motion
at public meeting)
(7) Commission reviews compiled draft Plan for another review and public
hearing (public meeting held with minimum two-weeks newspaper notice)
(8) Commission makes recommendation to Council for adoption of draft 2018
Plan (by Resolution approval at public meeting)
(9) Council takes up draft Plan and reviews it either in various standing Council
Committees or Council, as whole (public meeting)
(10) Council may choose to modify portions of the Plan and may choose to
return the Plan to Planning Commission for more work, or approve as
amended through ordinance process (public meetings)
(11) Council would approve Plan through multi-step ordinance process (public)
• Project Status:
January 10, 2018 Meeting:
Commissioners gave preliminary approval to the Vision Statement/Guiding Principles
February 15, 2018 Meeting:
Commissioners will consider Population and Community Facilities elements, with
department heads in attendance for the Community Facilities element.
March 14, 2018 Meeting
Review Cultural Resources and Housing Elements
Committee commended Staff on the project website, noting it was user-friendly and informative.
Mayor O’Neil advised public that the Finance Committee, a committee of the whole Council,
would meet at 8:30AM on Friday, February 9, 2018, at Town Hall, to discuss funding options for
the Wastewater Treatment System Retrofit project. He encouraged interested residents to attend.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at approximately 10:10AM
(Councilmember Clark motioned; Mayor O’Neil seconded; unanimously passed)
Respectfully submitted,
Rita Langley, Chair
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Approved at the February 20, 2018 Regular Council Meeting
Exhibit A
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
Exhibit A
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
CLEAN BEACH
INITIATIVE
TO W N O F S U L L I VA N ’ S I S L A N D
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee (February 7, 2018) 1
Exhibit B
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
A BUILDING BLOCK APPROACH
• Increase public awareness as an option in lieu of ordinances, or, to compliment an ordinance
• Public awareness efforts should be two-fold:
– Reach visitors before coming to SI with targeted ads and PSA’s
– Raise anti-litter awareness once visitors are on-island
• A few public awareness strategies:
– Create a Clean Beach Ad campaign for
• SI online communication platforms
• Other local/regional/national agencies and/or platforms
– Implement an Adopt a Beach clean up program
– Evaluate current signage: prominent litter awareness signage at beach access points
– Promote awareness of current trash receptacles and cigarette butt containers
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee (February 7, 2018) 2
Exhibit B
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
BEACH AWARENESS ADVERTISEMENT
CAMPAIGN (TOWN PLATFORMS)
1. CREATE A BEACH AWARENESS PAGE ON THE TOWN’S NEW WEBSITE:
• Map of the Beach with danger points
• List of access pathways
• Beach regulations
• Keep it clean tips
• Beach Sweep/Adopt a Beach information
11. PROMOTE “KEEP IT CLEAN” ON TOWN’S OTHER MEDIA PLATFORMS
• T witteraccount (regular monthly highlights/blasts)
• T ownFacebook page (regularly highlight activity/photos)
• Include in T own’smonthly E-Newsletters
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee (February 7, 2018) 3
Exhibit B
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
BEACH AWARENESS ADVERTISEMENT
CAMPAIGN (OTHER PLATFORMS)
1. TARGET “KEEP IT CLEAN” PSA’S/ADS TO FREE MEDIA OUTLETS
• Broadcast on Comcast 60 Government Channel
• Profile articles in newspapers (online & print)
• Drive readers to T own platforms for more information
II. PARTNER AWARENESS CAMPAIGN WITH OTHER AGENCIES
Local/Regional/National – some examples:
• Charleston Visitor’sBureau (seek link on their site)
• Local businesses in Charleston area (specifically SI, IOP ,Mt. Pleasant, Charleston)
• Local schools
– K-12 and colleges (including alumni groups)
• Non-profit (NPO) examples
– Boy/Girl Scouts,
– SC Sea Grant Consortium
– Conservation minded NPO’s like Surfrider Foundation
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee (February 7, 2018) 4
Exhibit B
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
INFORMATION USEFUL FOR BEACH
AWARENESS CAMPAIGN
1. TIPS TO “KEEP IT CLEAN”
2. ADOPT A BEACH PROGRAM
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee (February 7, 2018) 5
Exhibit B
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
KEEP IT CLEAN: 10 TIPS!
• Stay away from plastic bags! Instead of using plastic bags to bring your snacks, use reusable bags and containers.
• Bring a trash bag with you to make sure you throw everything away; that way trash won’t be buried in the sand
throughout the day or left when you leave.
• If you are walking along the beach and see trash or cans/bottles, safely pick them up and throw them away.
• Make a game with your friends and family on who can gather the most cans. Whoever wins, gets to keep the money when
you cash them in!
• Switch over to reusable water bottles, instead of single-use plastic bottles (this can make a huge difference each day).
• Instead of making this weekend focused around eating and drinking, make it about socializing and physical activity. Play
some Frisbee!
• If you are allowed to have bonfires at the beach, refrain from burning your trash, especially plastics. Also, make sure the fire
is fully out before you leave.
• If you have pets, pick up after them, so nobody will experience stepping in something other than sand.
• Don’t smoke! Cigarette butts are the leading pollutant on our beaches and there are many negative effects that come
from the cigarettes in our water. If you have the urge to smoke, be sure to dispose of the entire cigarette butt
appropriately.
• Encourage others you know to use these tips and to do their part in keeping our beaches cleanLand Use & Natural Resources Committee (February 7, 2018) 6
Exhibit B
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
ADOPT A BEACH PROGRAM
OPTION: PROMOTE REGULAR BEACH SWEEPS
T ownalready receives 2-3 regular beach sweep special requests/year from school/college alumni groups (various times of
year)
Annual SC statewide Beach/River Sweep participating site (early September)
OPTION: PROMOTE DHEC’s EXISTING ADOPT-A-BEACH PROGRAM
The Adopt-A-Beach program is part of the DHEC Marine Debris Initiative and is a great way for businesses, civic
clubs, school groups and neighborhood associations to make a significant contribution to the preservation of our
coastal environment.
• DHEC's Office of Ocean and Coastal Resource Management (OCRM) has a new application for the Adopt-A-
Beach Program at MyCoast South Carolina.
• The new system provides a streamlined process for program registration, beach adoption, and marine debris
data reporting.
• T o get started, visit the MyCoast South Carolina Adopt-A-Beach homepage to register with MyCoast, establish a
beach cleanup group, and select a beach to adopt. In the new system, you will choose an entire beach to adopt
rather than targeting a specific stretch of beach. If you have
• DHEC contact Liz Hartje at hartjeen@dhec.sc.gov.
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee (February 7, 2018) 7
Exhibit B
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
CURRENT BEACH PATH SIGNAGE
T own has comprehensive signage on the beach paths
Additional signage can be found ocean-front near Station access points
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee (February 7, 2018) 8
Exhibit B
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
CONSIDER PROMINENT
BEACH LITTER SIGNS
• At the beach end of the access paths and/or
• Facing towards the beach
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee (February 7, 2018) 9
Exhibit B
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
BEACH AWARENESS EVENTS/OTHER
PROMOTE “KEEP IT CLEAN” BEACH AWARENESS AT EVENTS OTHER THAN SWEEPS
Examples:
• Booth at 1-2 Farmers Market Events
• Partner with local schools/colleges and their conservation clubs
• National Events:
– National Beach Day ( Aug 30th)
– Earth Day for Beaches (July 1-7th)
SEEK BLUE WAVE BEACH DESIGNATION WITH CLEAN BEACHES COUNCIL
http://www.cleanbeaches.com/
Clean Beaches Council promotes designation through national media at no additional T own cost.
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee (February 7, 2018) 10
Exhibit B
February 7, 2018 LUNR Committee
Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.