Minutes (PDF)
Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Land Use & Natural Resources August 30, 2018 Minutes 1
TOWN OF SULLIVAN’S ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
LAND USE & NATURAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL
Thursday, August 30, 2018
Committee met at 8:45AM, this date, at Town Hall (2056 Middle Street), all requirements of the
Freedom of Information Act having been met. Present were Committee members
Councilmember Rita Langley (Chair), Mayor Pat O’Neil and Councilmember Chauncey Clark;
Staff: Administrator Benke; Director of Planning and Zoning Henderson; Asst. to Administrator
Darrow, Fire Chief Stith; Building Official Robinson.
1. Call to Order. Chair Langley called the meeting to order, stated the press and public
were duly notified pursuant to state law and all members were present; no media and thirty (30)
audience members present (including Council members Clark, Howard and Reese). Jeff
Jackson, Town arborist consultant for Protected Land, was also present.
2. Meeting Agenda – approved as presented
3. Transition Zone Management: Discussion of Draft Plan (Continuation)
Chair Langley noted the Committee continues discussion of the Transition Zone Management
Plan from its August 10, 2018 meeting.
Background: Council has held repeated meetings about the Protected Land to include Transition
Zone management. Town Council developed a Transition Zone Management Plan, after several
public meetings, that was approved at its February 25, 2016 Special Council meeting.
Chair Langley noted the Committee made recommendations for Band I at its last meeting and
will continue ongoing discussion of Band II and then Boardwalks in this meeting.
Committee recommendations from August 10, 2018 meeting include:
Town Council modify the Transition Zone Directives for Bands I & II to read as follows:
1. Band I (0-40 feet):
a. All trees > 6” DBH shall be retained, except cedar, pine and non-native
invasive species trees
b. All understory, shrubs (including myrtles), cedar and pine species and
small trees (defined as ≤ 6” DBH) shall be removed.
2. Band II (40-100 feet):
a. All trees shall be retained within this band except non-native invasive
species. Minimum threshold for consideration of a tree shall be
determined.
b. All understory, shrubs and myrtles shall be removed.
Land Use & Natural Resources August 30, 2018 Minutes 2
Transition Zone Band II: Definition of Tree and Minimum Tree Size to Cut
Committee Discussion
Chair Langley:
• Consulted with Jeff Jackson, Town arborist consultant, on question of tree definition and
size.
• Town Code §21-158 A. (7) defines a tree as, “Any living, self-supporting woody
perennial plant that is evergreen or deciduous.”
• Recommends minimum tree size retained within Band II be 3” dbh.
• Noted Town consultant CSE for Protected Land study recommended a 32’ buffer for fire
break.
Mayor O’Neil:
• Noted 3” dbh is a good starting point to discuss minimum tree size but suggested
including a 12’ height minimum.
• Commented the Transition Zone serves as the Town’s effort to be good neighbors to
property owners abutting the Protected Land by providing some active management
accommodations for these residents’ benefit.
• Noted Town’s tree survey of the Protected Land was for trees of all species 6” dbh or
larger, not 3” dbh.
• Questioned the use of word “remove” for trees/underbrush and whether this policy
directive would be a problem for external agencies like OCRM.
• Mentioned sea oats are State-protected vegetation.
Councilmember Clark:
• Commented the intent for the Transition Zone was to establish a separation between
residents and the forest area.
• Recommends Band II minimum tree size at 6” dbh. Noted he originally supported 9” dbh
and believes 6” dbh is a significant compromise.
• Supports 6” dbh minimum tree size as a practical and reasonable management size, plus
for safety and health reasons (fire break, mosquito abatement, etc.).
• Questioned if myrtles would die after years of repetitively trimming them down to the
root system.
• It was his understanding that the Town would enhance the Transition Zone by planting
vegetation such as sea oats, sweetgrass, etc.
Administrator Benke clarified for Committee that OCRM will not allow removal of root systems
for area seaward of their jurisdictional line.
Jeff Jackson clarified myrtles will not die due to annually cutting them to the root system.
Land Use & Natural Resources August 30, 2018 Minutes 3
Councilmember Clark provided slide presentation, highlights being (Exhibit A attached):
1. Supports concept of a separation band between houses and forest area, not a transition
within the transition zone.
2. Noted 44 lots/homes out of 900+ Island lots/homes would be directly impacted by the
Transition Zone clearance.
3. Supports goal of opening up the space to allow for healthier growth of grand trees
incorporating native beach vegetation such as sweetgrass and sea oats under the trees.
Public Comments:
Michael Moreland (1607 Atlantic Avenue) supports a compromise to thin out the trees for ease of
walking and seeing through the Protected Land area, and, to provide for healthier tree growth.
Submitted the accreted land mass is the main safety protection for the Island in severe
storms/water surge events, not the trees. Commented that, if the maritime forest was left alone,
the larger trees would naturally kill off the smaller species in a generation or two (approximately
50 years). Submitted the Town’s action would only accelerate the natural process, and, provide
an opportunity to cultivate growth of healthier, desirable trees.
Susan Middaugh (2420 Raven Drive) noted Council held a series of large, public meetings in
2014 with significant public input on the Protected Land and transition zones. Council voted 6-1
for the current Transition Zone Management Plan. Noted 40’ transition zone buffer (Band I) was
a compromise, as the Town consultant recommended a 32’ fire control buffer zone. Further
Band II included a balanced approach to manipulate the forest by retaining 25% of myrtles.
Does not support removing younger trees as the Town may lose slower growing, desirable trees
in lieu of faster growing trees.
Greg Hammond (2115 Pettigrew) urged Committee and Council to expeditiously move forward
in approving and implementing transition zone management activity.
Pete Budko (2061 Pettigrew) stated he walked, this morning, the approximately 2000 feet from
his home to the beach and noticed the pockets of dense vegetation along the area. Noted a small
percentage of the Protected Land forest will be impacted with this Transition Zone. Expressed
support for Councilmember Clark’s recommendation for minimum 6” dbh tree size and vision
for the transition zone.
Allison Bourland (1607 Atlantic Avenue) noted the number of dead trees and bushes in the
Protected Land and their proximity to her house. Questioned if the Town no longer saw this
vegetation as a fire hazard.
Lynn (Needle) Lyst (2419 Atlantic Avenue) submitted the Protected Land vegetation poses a
significant fire risk close to her home. She is unwilling to support this fire safety risk to her
family of four children and home. Asked for Staff to speak to the fire and safety risk the
Protected Land poses to her and others.
Land Use & Natural Resources August 30, 2018 Minutes 4
Committee asked for Fire Chief Stith’s input. Chief Stith reiterated his position that the Fire
Department’s primary function is to protect life and property. If a fire incident occurred in the
Protected Land, his staff would deploy to protect residents and their homes, not the forest.
Chief Stith clarified for Mayor O’Neil that he recalls three (3) fires in the area (of significant
size) during his 37 ½ year tenure.
Nicky Bluestein (2513 Atlantic Avenue) recounted Chief Stith previously stating in open
meeting/session that he recommended a 100’ fire break buffer as the best fire protection for
homes. That being said, it only takes one fire to decimate the front beach area.
Julia Khoury (1728 I’On Avenue) expressed support for an ecological balance in this area. Noted
fear tactics have been raised over the years on this matter, with fire hazards mentioned often.
The forestry commission has supported a recommended 32’ fire break between the homes and
Protected Land. Urged for balanced Protected Land management relying only upon expert
opinion.
Tim Reese (305 Station 20) expressed support for Councilmember Clark’s vision and proposal.
Town spent taxpayer funds in 2014 to survey 6”dbh trees already and the Town will pay for the
initial cutting for the whole of the Transition Zone in the first year. Urged Council to consider
cost and proceed with action that is economically feasible.
Ethel Needle (2419 Atlantic Avenue) noted she is a long-time resident who grew up on the
Island. Recalled the Town agreed years ago to manage the Protected Land but it has not done so.
Asked why the Station 24-25 area has been singled out with the most significant and dense
growth after decades of no Town Protected Land management. Noted she pays front beach tax
rates but is not beachfront. Stated it was time for a real compromise to help the residents in this
area or for Town to get these property owners’ taxes reduced.
Committee Discussion:
Mayor O’Neil: Asked Staff to comment on the practicality of implementing cutting should
Council approve Band II as follows: all trees at minimum size of 3” dbh and 12’ height,
removing non-native invasive vegetation and removing understory, shrub and myrtles.
Administrator Benke submitted Town staff and/or contractors should be able to implement
cutting of the Transition Zone under these terms, but stressed Staff cannot guarantee a few
smaller trees might not be accidentally cut.
Jeff Jackson, in response to Mayor O’Neil’s inquiry, concurred with Administrator Benke,
noting trees of 3” dbh can be reasonably identified.
Administrator Benke, in response to Chair Langley’s question, noted the Transition Zone work
can be bid out for the whole area or bid out to cut station/station.
Land Use & Natural Resources August 30, 2018 Minutes 5
MOTION: Mayor O’Neil moved to recommend to Town Council modification
of the Transition Zone Directives for Band II to read as follows:
Band II (40-100 feet):
a. All trees shall be retained within this band except non-native invasive species.
Minimum threshold for consideration of a tree shall be 3” dbh and 12’ in height.
b. All understory, shrubs and myrtles shall be removed.
Seconded by Chair Langley
DISCUSSION: Councilmember Clark reiterated support for cutting all trees under
6” dbh throughout the Transition Zone (Bands I and II).
CALL FOR QUESTION: MOTION PASSED 2-1 (Councilmember Clark
dissenting)
Transition Zone: Clearing Near Boardwalks
Active Transition Management Zone Directives (Item #3) states:
Boardwalks (10 feet on either side of the outer edge of town-owned boardwalks for such
distance seaward as permitted by relevant government authorities).
a. All non-native invasive species of flora shall be eliminated
b. All trees ≥ 6” dbh shall be retained, except cedar and pine species
c. All understory, shrubs (including myrtles), cedar and pine species and small trees
(defined as < 6” dbh) shall be removed
Committee Discussion
Chief Stith reviewed the boardwalk maintenance work performed by Staff, both routine work
and replacement of some/all portions of boardwalks on a rotating basis. Maintenance access for
boardwalks is needed, plus access on either side of boardwalks for those paths that provide for
emergency vehicle access to the beach. Clarified there could be a total vegetative break of 26’
wide for the boardwalks, incorporating a 6’ boardwalk and 10’ clearance on each side.
Councilmember Clark expressed support for clearing around boardwalks, not only for
maintenance but for safety reasons (fire break, mosquito control, etc.).
Mayor O’Neil noted that this directive would provide permissive, not mandatory, cutting
authority to Town Staff, to be executed at Staff discretion. Submitted Staff might not always
require 10’ clearance for each side of every boardwalk.
Land Use & Natural Resources August 30, 2018 Minutes 6
MOTION: Councilmember Clark moved to recommend to Town Council
modification of the Transition Zone Directives for Boardwalks to read as follows:
Boardwalks (At Town Staff discretion, for safety and maintenance, 10 feet on either
side of the outer edge of town-owned boardwalks for such distance seaward as
permitted by relevant government authorities).
a. All non-native invasive species of flora shall be eliminated
b. All trees ≥ 6” dbh shall be retained, except cedar and pine species
c. All understory, shrubs (including myrtles), cedar and pine species and small trees
(defined as < 6” dbh) shall be removed
Seconded by Mayor O’Neil. No Discussion
CALL FOR QUESTION: MOTION PASSED 2-1 (Chair Langley dissenting)
Committee opened floor for any questions/comments regarding boardwalks.
Julia Khoury (1728 I’On Avenue) asked for clarification whether beach paths, not containing
boardwalks, would remain at 6’ width maximum.
Committee clarified that it is only recommending vegetative cutting around beach paths with
boardwalks; natural/dirt footpath would remain 6’ width maximum.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at approximately 9:55AM (Mayor
O’Neil motioned; Councilmember Clark seconded; unanimously passed)
Respectfully submitted,
Rita Langley, Chair
Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Approved at the September 4, 2018 Council Workshop
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Sta 24
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Sta 16-18
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Sta 18-19
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Pettigrew
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Sta 22-26
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Sta 26-28
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Sand Dunes Club
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
16 East
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Sta 24 Pecans
Exhibit A
August 30, 2018 Land Use & Natural Resources Committee
Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.