RecordWell Data

_10062026-1274

Town of Summerville · Berkeley County · meeting of Oct 6, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Summerville

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Board of Architectural Review Minutes September 1, 2026 Members Present: David Price (Chair) Beth Huggins (Vice Chair) Tim Pye Ken Battle Don Baus Kimsey Hollifield Staff Present: Jim Langenstein, Planner II Minutes Meeting was called to order at 6:00 PM by Chairman Price. I. Approval of Minutes – Mr. Hollifield motioned to approve the August 4, 2026 minutes. Mr. Battle seconded the motion. Motion carried 6-0. Public Hearing a. Mr. Langenstein read an e-mail that he received from Ms. Karyn Healey – Re:100 Marion Ave – She was disappointed to see the number of after-the-fact design changes to this property. The most obvious change being going from a turned column to a boxed one. “Continuity of design for the structures should be the primary driver not the history of columns on the primary structure or other samples in the Historic District.” She felt that the turned column would visually connect the two structures. Old Business - None New Business 1. 116 Charleston Place – Stephen Mueller presented the application. Applicant requested to renovate the entire exterior of the existing cinder block residence. As part of this project, the existing roof will be demolished including the existing chimney, and the existing car port will be removed to allow access to the proposed two car garage. The existing front porch is proposed to be enclosed with new front and rear porches constructed. The rear porch will be connected to the proposed two car garage by a breeze way. The roof will be reconfigured and will be covered with an ash gray standing seam metal roof. The applicant was concerned about oil canning on a flat panel metal roof and requested to use striations in the panel to increase panel strength and minimize the oil canning effect. Mr. Price said that flat panel metal roofs are recommended in the Historic District and that striations are typically rejected. The applicant responded that he would prefer a metal roof, but would use black asphalt shingle roof if needed. The metal roof will not be visible from the street due to the roof’s orientation. A discussion followed about the roofing with Mr. Pye expressing acceptance of using the striated standing seam metal roof since it has limited visibility from the street. Mr. Baus questioned the metal roof striations for the front porch gable. He thought that it might look a bit busy with the larger “eyebrow” of the roofing profile. Mr. Mueller responded that they are planning to put gutters on this structure so that they may soften this profile a bit. The proposed siding is Hardi plank lap siding for the walls with board and batten detailing in the gables. Mr. Price mentioned that board and batten siding is typically not recommended in the Historic District. A discussion ensued and it was agreed that its limited use in the garbles as an accent was acceptable. All the siding and trim will be painted white, which was the historic color of the house. All the existing windows will be replaced with 2 over 2 simulated divided light windows with black frames. Ms. Huggins questioned the railings on the front and rear porches. Mr. Mueller said that they would be simple square picket cottage railing detail. The rear porch will have the same picket railing detail with a screened porch. Mr. Baus motioned to approve the application with the raised seam metal roof with striations with the understanding that it was approved due to its limited visibility from the street and its installation on a non-historic house. Mr. Battle seconded the motion. Motion carried 6-0. 2. 127 W Richardson Ave – This application requested to install seasonal window art for the remainder of the year. This paint is applied to the exterior of the window and does not come off until sprayed with a cleaning agent by the artist. This application is currently a gray area in our UDO, since it is not a sign because it doesn’t advertise the establishment nor the food and drink that they sell and it’s not a permanent mural. It is being considered as a temporary mural. The BAR currently has purview over this application, but the Cultural Arts Committee may assume this oversight in the future. This establishment has done several of these window paintings in the past. Last Christmas, they did a Grinch theme. This spring, a colorful spring flower display was done. For July 4 th , a bald eagle and an American flag with fireworks was added. The displays are seasonal, festive, and family friendly. Ms. Huggins suggested not to totally paint the windows so that people can see in and out. Currently, 25% coverage is allowed for window signs. A similar guideline would be appropriate. The applicant was amenable to this criterion. Overall, the application was well received. Ms. Huggins motioned to approve this application with the stipulation that it does not cover more than 25% of the window. Mr. Battle seconded the motion. Motion passed 6- 0. 3. 100 Marion Ave – Mr. Taylor Charpie and Mr. James Rogers presented this application which was for after-the-fact approval for renovations to their pool house and pavilion. Mr. Price opened the discussion by saying that he would like to approach this application as a new project rather than focus on the past approval. Mr. Charpie explained that as they got into the demolition, it was discovered that the beam height for the pavilion would only be around 7’. It was decided at that time that the height would need to be increased 1’-6” to get the desired beam height. They also discovered additional damage, and termites as the demolition continued necessitating the removal of additional finishes that were previously not supposed to be removed. The column change from a turned column to a squared one was based on a statement from a contractor stating that it would “mess with the integrity of the building.” Mr. Price responded that a turned column would not reduce the building’s integrity. He has had new turned columns on his property that match the existing columns for over 30 years. His main concern was the overlapping of the roofs. He wanted to see a unified roof height throughout the building. Mr. Charpie replied that they would need to submit new structural drawings to handle the increased weight load for this change. Mr. Rogers stated that it was possible, but there are significant financial implications. The two transom windows were discussed, and Mr. Price did not have an issue with them. The variations between the submitted drawings was also discussed. The submitted elevations are different from the renderings. The windows are more rectangular, and the doors are more spaced out in the renderings than in the elevations. The drawings need to be rectified so that everything is coordinated. Mr. Rogers stated that the rendering is the more accurate of the two drawings and that the elevations and plans will be revised to match them. Ms. Huggins preferred the single level roof but understands the want for a higher ceiling height in the pavilion. She wanted to see more elements from the house brought into the new structure. More discussion followed regarding the proportionality of the raised pavilion roof. Mr. Pye commented on the extent of the changes and that the applicants should have known to stop and seek BAR approval given their experience. By proceeding, they put the Board in a difficult position. He agreed with Ms. Huggins that some of the house elements need to be implemented into this design. The fireplace was too massive, the brackets were not decorative enough, and the columns were lacking detail. Mr. Baus suggested packing out the base and tops of the columns in similar proportions to the existing turned columns and chamfering the middle to add more detail to them. It was suggested to remove the corner brackets if possible. Discussion ensued regarding the design of the fireplace. The proposed fireplace is substantial and goes from floor to ceiling without deviating its width. Mr. Pye recommended tapering the chimney as it got taller to decrease its massiveness and begin the transition to the proposed chimney. Discussion regarding the chimney ensued. Board members recommended using similar detailing as the existing chimneys on the primary structure. Mr. Hollifield motioned to approve the application with the two-tiered roof, conditioned upon submittal and approval of plans to staff with changes to the windows, columns, fireplace, and chimney as discussed. Mr. Baus seconded this motion. Motion approved 6-0. As there was no more business in front of the Board, Mr. Pye motioned to adjourn. Ms. Huggins seconded the motion. Motion carried 6-0. Meeting was adjourned at 7:54. Respectfully submitted, Jim Langenstein, RLA Planner II

Source: Town of Summerville website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.