RecordWell Data

​Agenda

Town of Seabrook Island · Charleston County · Agendas

Open the original document More from Town of Seabrook Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF SEABROOK ISLAND Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting March 22, 2023 – 1:00 PM Town Hall, Council Chambers 2001 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island, SC 29455 Watch Live Stream (YouTube) Virtual Participation: Individuals who wish to participate in the meeting via Zoom may call (843) 768- 9121 or email kwatkins@townofseabrookisland.org for log-in information prior to the meeting. Submit a Written Comment : Individuals who wish to submit a comment in advance of the Public Hearing may do so in writing by 12:00 pm on the day prior to the meeting using one of the following options: x Online: Variance 181 x Email: tnewman@townofseabrookisland.org x Mail or Hand Deliver: 2001 Seabrook Island Road, Seabrook Island, SC 29455 AGENDA CALL TO ORDER ELECTION OF CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting: February 22, 2023 [Pages 3–5] PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS 1. Variance # 181 [Pages 6–ϰ6] APPLICANTS: Malcolm Brennan (Applicant) Michael Martin (Owners) ADDRESS: 2919 Deer Point Drive TAX MAP NUMBER: 149-14-00-027 ZONING DISTRICT: R-SF2 (Residential Single-Family) CODE SECTION: § 10.5.A.1, Critical Area Setback VARIANCE REQUEST: 1) To allow 444 square feet of proposed open deck to encroach 8’-9’’ into the r equired critical area setback. 2) To allow 42 square feet of proposed exterior stair to encroach 4’- 1’’ into the required critical area setback. 3) To allow 19 square feet of proposed permeable paving to encroach 4’-1’’ into the required critical area setback. ITEMS FOR INFORMATION / DISCUSSION 1. Ther e are no items for information/discussion. ADJOURN TOWN OF SEABROOK ISLAND Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting February 22, 2023 MINUTES CALL TO ORDER Pr esent: Leggett, Palmer (Virtual), Pickney, Williams Absent: Fox Staff Present: Zoning Administrator Newman M r. Leggett served as acting chairman for the meeting. T he meeting was called to order at 1:00PM and Zoning Administrator Newman confirmed notice of this meeting was posted as described by the SC Freedom of Information Act. EL ECTION OF CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR The election of Chair and Vice Chair will be held at the March Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting. APP ROVAL OF MINUTES 1. Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting: December 28, 2022 M r. Pickney moved to approve the previous meeting minutes of December 28; Mr. Williams seconded. All voted in favor. The previous meeting minutes of December 28th were approved. PU BLIC HEARING ITEMS 1. Variance #18 0 AP PLICANT: Bill Senst (Applicant) Greg & Leigh Anne Spraetz (Owners) ADDRESS: 3112 Marsh Gate Drive TAX MAP NUMBER: 149-14-00-052 ZONING DISTRICT: R- SF2 (Residential Single-Family) CO DE SECTION: § 1 0.5.A.1, Critical Area Setbacks VARIANCE REQUEST: 1) T o reduce the required 25’ critical area setback to 15’-0” to allow for 561 square feet of first floor open deck and open stair. Z oning Administrator Newman presented the request made by the Applicant Bill Senst at 3112 Marsh Gate Drive to reduce the required 25’ critical area setback to 15’-0” to allow for 561 square feet of first floor open deck and open stair. 3 Zoning Administrator Newman noted that if the variance is approved, staff recommends adding the following: • The approved variance shall apply to the building layout as shown on the site-specific plan prepared by the Applicants and reviewed by the Board on February 22, 2023. Any modification to this site-specific plan prior to the issuance of a zoning permit, with the exception of minor corrections and/or modifications which conform to the requirements of the town’s DSO, shall require further review and approval by the Borad of Zoning Appeals. • The Applicants shall prepare and submit to the Zoning Administrator an as-built survey prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy (or within 30 days of passing the final inspection if no Certificate of Occupancy is required). The as-built survey shall be prepared and stamped by a professional land surveyor who is qualified to perform such services in the State of South Carolina. • The variance shall become null and void if the Applicants (or subsequent property owner) fail to obtain a building permit prior to the effective date of any changes to the SCDHEC-OCRM beachfront jurisdictional line and/or beachfront setback line affecting the subject property. The Board inquired if there were any objections to the variance. Zoning Administrator Newman clarified one objection was received and was included in the agenda packet. Bill Senest (Applicant) presented the variance request for 3112 Marsh Gate Drive. The Board clarified where the house is currently in relation to the setback lines. The Board inquired when the homeowners started creating their plans for this project. Greg Spraetz (homeowner), 712 Bell Out Drive Alpharetta, GA; added additional commentary to the Applicants presentation. John Carpenter, 3092 Marsh Gate Drive, inquired if the proposed variance the proposed deck would set a precedence for setback changes. Zoning Administrator Newman and the Board clarified for Mr. Carpenter the variance process. Zoning Administrator Newman read the letter received in opposition of this variance. The Board discussed how the variance fits within the criteria. Mr. Leggett noted the variance meets the criteria as follows: A) The size and shape of the subject property are unique conditions. B) The unique size and shape of the property does not appear to apply to other properties in the vicinity. C) Strict application of the DSO to this piece of property in combination with the unique size and shape of the lot restricts the utilization of the property. D) The requested variance has no impact on the existing zoning/character of the surrounding area. E) The use of the subject property is not changed by the granting of the requested variance. F) The variance request is not for profitability. G) The necessity for the variance is not the owner’s fault. 4 Mr. Pickney moved to approve Variance #180 as outlined by Mr. Leggett and with staff recommendations; Mr. Williams seconded. All voted in favor. Variance #180 was approved with staff recommendations. I TEMS FOR INFORMATION / DISCUSSION None. ADJOURN Mr. Pickney moved to adjourn the meeting; Mr. Williams seconded. All voted in favor. The meeting adjourned at 1:40PM Date: March 10, 2023 Prepared by: Katharine E. Watkins Town Clerk/Treasurer 5 TO: Town of Seabrook Island Board of Zoning Appeals Members FROM: Tyler Newman, Zoning Administrator SUBJECT: Variance Application # 181 – 2919 Deer Point Drive MEETING DATE: March 22, 2023 Variance Application #178 Applicants: Malcolm Brennan (Applicant) Michael Martin (Owner) Location: 2919 Deer Point Drive Tax Map Number: 149-14-00-027 Zoning District: R-SF2 (Residential Single-Family) Code Section: § 10.5.A.1, Critical Area Setback Purpose: 1) To allow 444 square feet of proposed open deck to encroach 8’-9’’ into the required critical area setback, 2) to allow 42 square feet of proposed exterior stair to encroach 4’-1’’ into the required critical area setback, 3) to allow 19 square feet of proposed permeable paving to encroach 4’-1’’ into the required critical area setback Overview The town has received a variance application from Malcolm Brennan of M. Brennan Architects Inc. on behalf of Michael Martin (collectively, the “Applicants”). The Applicants are requesting several encroachments into the required 25’ critical area setback in association with the construction of a new swimming pool and accompanying open deck, stairs, and walkway at 2919 Deer Point Drive (Block 49, Lot 17). In May 2022 the town’s Zoning Administrato r met with Mr. Martin to discuss possible improvements to his property including a proposed swimming pool. At that time the Zoning Administrator advised Mr. Martin that he would need to have his property surveyed to determine the location of the SCDHEC-OCRM critical line and corresponding 25’ setback. In November 2022 the Zoning Administrator was co ntacted by a Malcolm Brennan of M. Brennan Architects Inc. who indicated that he was designing a deck/pool addition at 2919 Deer Point Drive and that there were encroachments associated wi th the proposed additions that could require variances. Upon reviewing the proposed site plan, the town’s Zoning Administrator advised the applicant that he was correct in his assessment that there were setback encroachments shown that would not be permitted under the DSO and that the only means of deviating from the requirements of the DSO would be to seek a variance from the Board of Zoning Appeals. Under the town’s previous DSO §7.60.50, Marsh Setback, stated, “the minimum setback for a structure, exclusive of open decks, on a lot abutting the marsh shall be twenty-five (25) feet from the South Carolina Ocean and Coastal Resource Management critical area or the lot line, wh ich ev er i s lan d ward . N o p art of an op en d eck s h all b e close r t h an f if t een ( 15) f eet f ro m t h e MEMORANDUM 6 critical area.”. Under the town’s current DSO (effective July 1, 2022) §10.5.A.1, Critical Area Setback, states, “except as otherwise provided in this ordinance, no structure shall be placed above or below ground (including propane tanks) within 25 feet of any critical area”. The subject property is currently zoned R-SF2, Mo derate Lot Single-Family, and a single-family residence is a permitted use by-right. The property is 17,099 square feet in area, which is approximately 2.3% smaller than the minimum lot size in the R-SF2 distri ct (minimum lot size in R-SF2 is 17,500 square feet). A total of 15,547 square feet (or 90.92% of the lot) is designated as “highland.” Based on the site plan submitted with the vari ance application, the pr oposed new pool will comply with the 25’ critical area setback requirement as we ll as the 12.5’ side yard setback requirement. The proposed improvements do not cause the subject property to exceed the 40% maximum lot coverage requirement in the R-SF2 District. Additionally, based on the elevations provided with the submittal the proposed improve ments will also comply with the 36’ maximum height requirement (See Attachment 6, Full Plan Set). To allow for construction of the proposed 444 square feet of open deck, 42 square feet of exterior stair, and 19 square feet of permeable paving the Applicants are requesting the following variances from the requirements of the DSO: TYPE REQUIRED PER DSO VARIANCE (REQUESTED) Critical Area Setback 25 feet (§ 10.5.A.1) To allow 444 square feet of proposed open deck to encroach 8’-9’’ into the required critical area setback Critical Area Setback 25 feet (§ 10.5.A.1) To allow 42 square feet of proposed exterior stair to encroach 4’-1’’ into the required critical area setback Critical Area Setback 25 feet (§ 10.5.A.1) To allow 19 square feet of proposed permeable paving to encroach 4’-1’’ into the required critical area setback 7 In their application, the Applicants are requesting relief from the critical area setback requirements for the following reasons (See Attachment 4, Applicant’s Narrative): a) The property is located in the R-SF2 zoning district with a minimum lot size of 17,500 square feet however the total amount of high ground on the subject property is 15,547 square feet. The buildable area of the lot has been further restricted by the previous owner’s decision to construct the home behind the existing dune at the front of the property. This decision by the previous owner effectively increased the front yard setback from 30’ to over 65’ (See Attachment 5, Proposed Site Plan). b) In cases where large dunes exist on similar properties the home is typically constructed on top of the dune, thus destroying the vegetation and ecological integrity associated with this natural feature. In contrast, the existing home located at the subject proper ty w as pushed as far back as possible, preserving the dune and natural vegetation. c) T o construct a new pool without the pool encroaching into the 25’ cr itical area setback, the existing deck would need to be demolished. The requested variance allows the pr operty owner to recover his existing open deck. Before submitting this variance request, the property owner offered to purchase all or any part of the adjacent undeveloped property that is owned by the Kiawah Habitat Conservancy. The hope of this offer was to increase the size of the subject proper ty e nough to construct a new guest house and pool without the need for any variances. Unfortunately, the Kiawah Habitat Conservancy declined the offer. The only other available land on the subjec t property is located at the front. Sinc e s wimming pools are not permitted in the front yard, this option would require demolishing portions of the ex isting home to make room at the rear of the site. This option would also require constructing an addition on the front of the house to recove r t he demolished square footage. d) The proposed new deck will not extend closer to the OCRM critical line than the existing deck on the adjacent neighbor’s property (See Attachment 5, Proposed Site Plan). e) The owner of the subject property has not created this hardship. The decision to place the home so close to the 25’ critical area setback was made by the previous propert y o wner to preserve the existing dune at the front of the property. Also, at the time that the property was purchased (March 21, 2022) the property owner was under the impression that a future open deck, like the one associated with th is variance request, would have been permitted without the need for a variance. f) T he property owner is not requesting this variance to make the property more valuable. Rather he is making this request so that his family can enjoy the natural environment in the same manner as many of their neighbors. 8 Staff Comments As a matter of practice, the Town’s Zoning Administrator does not typically provide a recommendation in favor of, or in opposition to , a variance application. In our opinion, these requests are best left to the Board of Zoning Appeals following a thorough review of the relevant facts, including the receipt of testimony from interested parties during the required public hearing. In granting a variance, state law permits the Board of Zoning Appeals to attach such conditions as the Board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. Should the Board vote to approve the variance request, staff would recommend in favor of attaching the following conditions: x The approved variance shall apply to the building layout as shown on the site-specific plan prepared by the Applicants and reviewed by the Board on March 22, 2023. Any modification to this site-specific plan prior to the issuance of a zoning permit, with the exception of minor corrections and/or modifications which conform to the requirements of the town’s DSO, shall require further review and approval by the Board of Zoning Appeals prior to permitting. x The Applicants shall prepare and submit to the Zoning Administrator an as-built survey prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy (or within 30 days of passing the final inspection if no Certificate of Occupancy is required). The as-built survey shall be prepared and stamped by a professional land surveyor who is qualified to perform such services in the State of South Carolina. x The variance shall become null and void if the Applicants (or a subsequent property owner) fail to obtain a building permit prior to the effective date of any changes to the SCDHEC-OCRM beachfront jurisdictional line and/or beachfront setback line affecting the subject property. Respectfully submitted, Tyler Newman Zoning Administrator TylerN e w m a n 9 Criteria for Review Pursuant to Section 6-29-800(A)(2) of the SC Code of Laws, the Board of Zoning Appeals has the power to hear and decide appeals for variance from the requirements of the zoning ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the board makes and explains in writing the following findings: (a) there are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; (b) these conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; (c) because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and (d) the authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of th e district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. The board may not grant a variance, the effect of which would be to allow the establishment of a use not otherwise permitted in a zoning district, to extend physically a nonconforming use of land or to change the zoning district boundaries shown on the official zoning map. The fact that property may be utilized more profitably, if a variance is granted, may not be considered grounds for a variance. Other requirements may be prescribed by the zoning ordinance. In granting a variance, the board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the s urrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. 10 Attachments The following supplemental items have been attached for review: 1 Variance Application p. 11-13 2 Aerial Image p. 14 3 Property Zoning Report p. 15 4 Applicant’s Narrative p. 16-18 5 Proposed Site Plan p. 19 6 Full Plan Set p. 20-26 7 ARC Approval Letter p. 27 8 Property Deed p. 28-32 9 Site Photos p. 33-40 10 Public Hearing Notice – Letter to Neighboring Property Owners p. 41 11 Public Hearing Notice – Post & Courier Legal Ad p. 42-43 12 Public Hearing Notice – List of Neighboring Properties p. 44 13 Public Hearing Notice – Property Posting p. 45 11 12 13 14 15 Town of Seabrook Island Property Zoning Report 14 Feb 2023 THIS VERIFICATION IS MADE AS OF THE DATE OF THIS REPORT AND DOES NOT CONSTITUTE ANY REPRESENTATION OR ASSURANCE THAT THE PROPER TY WILL RETAIN ITS PRESENT ZONING CLASSIFICATION FOR ANY SPECIFIED PERIOD OF TIME. THE TOWN OF SEABROOK ISLAND SHALL ASSUME NO RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY ERRORS, OMISSIONS, OR INACCURACIES IN THE INFORMATION PROVIDED REGARDLESS OF HOW CAUSED; OR ANY DECISION MADE OR ACTION TAKEN OR NOT TAKEN BY ANY PERSON IN RELIANCE UPON ANY INFORMATION OR DATA FURNISHED HEREUNDER. Parcels Parcel ID: 1491400027 Owner: MARTIN MICHAEL J MARTIN ANNE MARIE Owner Street Address: 100 BLACK WALNUT LN Owner City State ZIP Code: SEABROOK ISLAND , SC 29455 Parcel Street Address: 2919 DEER POINT DR Zoning Count Zoning Code and Description Overlapping Quantities 1. 1 R-SF2 - Residential - Single-Family (Medium Lot) 17,747.32sf (0.41acres) 16 Ǥ”‡ƒ”…Š‹–‡…–•ǡ …Ǥ BZA Application  ͳͳ͵ƒ’’‘‘”‡‡”‹˜‡ǡ—‹–‡ͶǡŠƒ”އ•–‘ǡǤʹͻͶͳʹ Page 1 of 3 Š‘‡ǣͺͶ͵ǦͶͲ͸Ǧ͹ͺͳ͵ǡ ƒšǣͺͶ͵ǦͶͲ͸Ǧ͹ͺͳͶǡƒ‹Žǣ̷„”‡ƒƒ”…Š‹–‡…–•Ǥ…‘  Jan. 5, 2023 Tyler Newman Town of Seabrook Island 2001 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island, SC 29455 Reference : Martin Renovation 2919 Deer Point Drive Seabrook Island, South Carolina 29455 Dear Mr. Newman, The attached Drawings indicate the proposed improvements which the Owners would like to undertake. Also attached is the BZA application for the variance we will need in order to undertake these improvements. The Drawings submitted with this application have also been submitted to the ARC and we have requested a Letter of Acknowledgement from the ARC. Due to the limitation of space on the BZA Application Form, our responses are provided in this letter. The paragraphs below are enumerated to correspond with the BZA Application Form. A. Please provide a brief description of the proposed scope of work. A small new swimming pool with accompanying open deck, stair, and walkway. B. In order to complete the proposed scope of work, the Applicant(s) is (are) requesting a variance from the following requirement(s) of the town’s DSO: DSO Section References : DSO 10.5A.1 DSO Requirements: SETBACK Required. Except as otherwise provided in this ordinance, no structure shall be placed above or below ground (including propane tanks) within 25 feet of any CRITICAL AREA. We are requesting a variance from DSO Section 10.5A.1 to construct 444 sf of the proposed open deck, 42 sf of the proposed exterior stair, and 19 sf of the proposed permeable paving, extending 8'-9", 4'-1", and 4'-1" into the required 25' critical area setback. As shown on the Please note that 106 sf of the existing deck, stairs, and pavers already encroaches into the 25' OCRM setback area. Therefore, the total additional encroachment that we are requesting is (444 +42 + 19) - 106 = 399 sf. C. The application of the zoning requirements of the town’s DSO will result in unnecessary hardship, and the standards for a variance set by State Law and the DSO are met by the following facts: 1) There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to this particular piece of property as follows: 17 Ǥ”‡ƒ”…Š‹–‡…–•ǡ …Ǥ BZA Application  ͳͳ͵ƒ’’‘‘”‡‡”‹˜‡ǡ—‹–‡ͶǡŠƒ”އ•–‘ǡǤʹͻͶͳʹ Page 2 of 3 Š‘‡ǣͺͶ͵ǦͶͲ͸Ǧ͹ͺͳ͵ǡ ƒšǣͺͶ͵ǦͶͲ͸Ǧ͹ͺͳͶǡƒ‹Žǣ̷„”‡ƒƒ”…Š‹–‡…–•Ǥ…‘  This property is located in the R-SF2 Zoning District with a minimum lot size is 17,500 sf. However, the amount of high ground on this lot is only 15,547. The buildable area of the lot has been further restricted by the previous Owner's decision to construct the home behind the existing dune at the front of the property. This decision effectively increased the front yard setback from 30' to over 65'. See attached Site Plan 2) These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity as shown by: Where large dunes exist on similar properties, the home is typically constructed on top of the dune, thus destroying the vegetation and ecological integrity associated with this natural feature. In contrast, this home was pushed as far back as possible, thus preserving the dune and natural vegetation. 3) Because of these conditions, the application of the zoning requirements to this particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property as follows: To construct a new pool without encroaching on the 25’ OCRM setback line, the existing deck will be demolished. The variance we are requesting will allow the property owner to recover his open deck. Before submitting this request, Mr. Martin offered to purchase all or any part of the adjacent undeveloped property that the Kiawah Habitat Conservancy would be willing to sell. Our hope was to increase the size of this site enough to construct a new Guest House and pool without the need for any variances. After carefully considering our proposal, the Kiawah Habitat Conservancy decided not to sell any of their property. The only other available land on this site is located at the front of this property. Since swimming pools are not permitted in the front yard, this option would require demolishing portions of the existing home to make room at the rear of the site. This option would also require constructing an addition on the front of the house to recover the demolished square footage. We prefer not to pursue this option because of the impact of the addition on the existing dune and vegetation. In this particular case, the recent prohibition on open decks beyond the 25’ OCRM Setback line, effectively penalizes the commendable choice to preserve the existing dune and vegetation at the front of this site. 4) The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance for the following reasons: 18 Ǥ”‡ƒ”…Š‹–‡…–•ǡ …Ǥ BZA Application  ͳͳ͵ƒ’’‘‘”‡‡”‹˜‡ǡ—‹–‡ͶǡŠƒ”އ•–‘ǡǤʹͻͶͳʹ Page 3 of 3 Š‘‡ǣͺͶ͵ǦͶͲ͸Ǧ͹ͺͳ͵ǡ ƒšǣͺͶ͵ǦͶͲ͸Ǧ͹ͺͳͶǡƒ‹Žǣ̷„”‡ƒƒ”…Š‹–‡…–•Ǥ…‘  a. The proposed new deck will not extend closer to the OCRM line than the existing deck on the adjacent neighbor’s property. See attached Site Plan. b. The proposed decking will be permeable so no additional storm water runoff will be created. The foundation walls for the deck will extend approximately 8” above the finished grades and backfilled with 18” of gravel. Rainwater will flow between pavers or decking, onto the gravel below, and absorbed into the sandy subsoils. c. The pool overflow will be discharged behind the 25’ OCRM setback line. d. The proposed deck has a maximum projection of only 5’-11” beyond the existing deck and approximately 8’-9” beyond the 25’ Setback. See attached Site and Floor Plans. e. We have also enhanced the privacy between Lots 17 and 18 by adding 5 palm trees to the existing landscape buffer. D. The Owner of this property has not created this hardship. The decision to place the home so close to the 25’ OCRM setback line was made by the previous property owner to preserve the existing dune at the front of the property. As stated above, we have investigated every other available option to construct these improvements without the need for a variance. We are pursuing this variance because this design will allow the Owner to enjoy his property in the same manner as many of his neighbors while fully respecting the total environment, including the existing wetlands and the existing dune. Also please also note that at the time Mr. Martin purchased this property, March 21, 2022, he would have understood that a future open deck, similar to the one for which we are now requesting a variance, would have been permitted without a variance. E. The property Owner is not requesting this variance to make the property more valuable but so that his family may enjoy the natural environment in the same manner as many of their neighbors. Thank you for considering this request. Sincerely, Malcolm Brennan 19 DUHDVXPPDUf DUUHDSIOSWC4<03AAVI DUHDSILMKLKUSXRGC48087</.2 sSRMRKOSWFSYHUDKHFDOFXODWMSRGSHVRSWMRFOXGH THUPHDEOHZDONZDfV2 PDaMPXPDOOSZDEOHOSWFSYHUDKHTHUGVSWDEOH826÷ISUsSRMRK GMVWUMFWU1VI5C73%2 DUHDVXPPDUf HaMVWMRKTUSTSVHGWSWDO DUHDXRGHUUSSIOMRH50=47VI3VI50=47VI TSSO3536VI536VI LYDFVWDRG5=VI3VI5=VI GUMYZDf505A8VI3VI505A8VI ZDONZDfV3VI94VI..3VI HOHYDWHGGHFNV5=7VI567VI84=VI VWDMUV4A7VI15<VI49<VI  WSWDOV80948VI743VI90358VI ..WLMVMWHPMVTHUPHDEOHTDYMRKDRGMVRSWMRFOXGHGMRGVSOSW FSYHUDKHFDOFXODWMSR HaMVWMRKOSWFSYHUDKHC80948VIa43304<03AAVIC66%B73% TUSTSVHGOSWFSYHUDKHC90358VIa43304<03AAVIC68%B73% COPYRIGHTc2021\M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC.\DRAWINGSMAYNOTBEREPRODUCEDINANYFORMWITHOUTTHEWRITTENPERMISSIONOFTHEARCHITECTS. 113WappooCreekDrive,Ste.4 Charleston,SouthCarolina mbrennanarchitects.com M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC. ARCHITECTSARCHITECTS M MB DATE: REVISIONS SHEET JAN.4,2023 SeabrookIsland,SC29455 2919DEERPOINTDRIVE MARTINRENOVATIONA1 NEWSTEPSDOWN(42SFENCROACHMENT) NEWPOOL NEWDECK SITE/ROOFPLANSCALE:1"=10' GUTTERSANDDOWNSPOUTS LOCATIONOF PROPOSEDADDITION. NEWPERMEABLE WALKWAY.(19SFENCROACHMENT) (5)NEWPALMTREESTOENHANCELANDSCAPEBUFFER. FORREVIEW EXISTINGDUNE EDGEOFEXISTINGDECK MAX.PROJECTIONOFPROPOSEDDECK. ARCHITECTURAL A1SITEPLAN SURVEY OCRMSIGNEDSURVEY A2GROUNDFLOORPLAN A3FIRSTFLOORPLAN A4EXTERIORREARELEVATIONS A5EXTERIORLEFTSIDEELEVATION A6EXTERIORRIGHTSIDEELEVATIONS INDEXOFDRAWINGS 1-4-23 6-4-22 11-23-22 6-4-22 1-4-23 1-4-23 1-4-23 1-4-23 1-4-23 EXISTINGRETAININGWALL EXISTINGRETAININGWALL EXISTINGDRIVEWAY 588SFOPENDECK(444SFENCROACHMENT) 2-14-23 02-15-23 1 20 21 22 COPYRIGHTc2022\M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC.\DRAWINGSMAYNOTBEREPRODUCEDINANYFORMWITHOUTTHEWRITTENPERMISSIONOFTHEARCHITECTS. 113WappooCreekDrive,Ste.4 Charleston,SouthCarolina mbrennanarchitects.com M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC. ARCHITECTSARCHITECTS M MB DATE: REVISIONS SHEET SeabrookIsland,SC29455 MARTINRENOVATIONA2 2919DEERPOINTDRIVE INFINITYEDGE MAX.PROJECTIONOFPROPOSEDDECK EXISTINGDECKFOUNDATIONS LUPaOFGNPPURNDO ecsl=40:"A4-/1" JAN.4,2023 FORREVIEW EXISTINGWALLTOREMAIN EXISTINGWALLTOBEREMOVED. NEWPTWOODFRAMEDWALLWITHPTTRIM ONEXTERIORFACETOMATCHEXISTING ADJACENTPANELS. NEWREINFORCEDCONCRETEMASONRY WALLSANDPIERS. GUNITE LEGEND NEWFOUNDATIONS NEWEXTERIORSTAIR PERMEABLEPAVERWALKWAY REMOVEEXISTINGCMUWALLSANDPIERSSHOWNDASHED. HANDRAILABOVE HANDRAILABOVE EXISTINGDRIVEWAY MAX.PROJECTIONOFEXISTINGDECK. 15'OCRMCRITICALLINESETBACK. 25'OCRMCRITICALLINESETBACK. 15'OCRMCRITICALLINESETBACK. 25'OCRMCRITICALLINESETBACK. REMOVEEXISTINGSTAIRSHOWNDASHED. NEWFOUNDATIONS 12.5'SIDEYARDSETBACK 12.5'SIDEYARDSETBACK EXISTINGGARAGE NEWSCONCELIGHTFIXTURE.CONECTTONEW OREXISTINGSWITCHEDCIRCUIT.MATCH EXISTINGATEXTERIORLOCATIONS. CANLIGHTFIXTURE.PROVIDELENSON EXTERIORFIXTURES. NEWELECTRICALFIXTURE#1 NEWELECTRICALFIXTURE#2 23 ILSTaINPPSRNFO ecsl=40:"A4-/1" COPYRIGHTc2022\M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC.\DRAWINGSMAYNOTBEREPRODUCEDINANYFORMWITHOUTTHEWRITTENPERMISSIONOFTHEARCHITECTS. 113WappooCreekDrive,Ste.4 Charleston,SouthCarolina mbrennanarchitects.com M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC. ARCHITECTSARCHITECTS M MB DATE: REVISIONS SHEET SeabrookIsland,SC29455 2919DEERPOINTDRIVE MARTINRENOVATIONA3 HOTTUB DIPPINGPOOL (39SF) STEPS (198sf) BENCH NEWSTEPSDOWN BENCH GREATROOM KITCHEN DINING SUNROOM PERMEABLEPAVERS/DECKING SCREENPORCH/POOLCABANA MASTERBEDROOM RETRACTABLESCREEN 36"GATE INFINITYEDGE COPING 18"HIGHBENCH EXISTINGDRIVEWAYBELOW NEWDECK OCRMCRITICALLINE 15'OCRMCRITICALLINESETBACK. 25'OCRMCRITICALLINESETBACK. 15'OCRMCRITICAL LINESETBACK. RETRACTABLESCREENS NEWEXTERIORSTAIR 25'OCRMCRITICALLINESETBACK. 25'OCRMCRITICALLINESETBACK. PERMEABLEPAVERWALKWAY OCRMCRITICALLINE PROPOSEDDECKEXTENDS5'-10" BEYONDEXISTINGDECK. JAN.4,2023 FORREVIEW EXISTINGDECKTOBEREMOVED. EXISTINGSTEPS FACEOFEXISTINGWALL EXISTINGWALLTOREMAIN EXISTINGWALLTOBEREMOVED. LEGEND MAX.PROJECTIONOFEXISTINGDECK. 12.5'SIDEYARDSETBACK 12.5'SIDEYARDSETBACK PROVIDENEW32"WIDESCREENEDDOOR. REMOVEEXISTINGINSECTSCREENANDSCREENPORCH RAILSINTHESELOCATIONS.PROVIDENEW RETACTABLESCREENSYSTEMWITHREMOTECONTROL OPERATION,ASMANUFACTUREDBYPHANTOMSCREENS (1-866-828-2775)ORARCHITECTAPPROVEDEQUAL. MOUNTTRACKSFORRETRACTABLESCREENSYSTEMON EXISTINGCOLUMNSANDWRAPCOLUMNSWITHNEWPT TRIMTOCONCEALTRACKS.MOUNTOVERHEAD RETACTABLESCREENDRUMTOUNDERSIDEOF EXISTINGBEAMABOVEANDPAINTTOMATCHADJACENT WOODTRIM. SHOREUPEXISTINGROOFASNEEDEDUNTILNEW FIBERGLASSSTRUCTURALCOLUMNISINSTALLEDON NEWFOUNDATIONS. DRAWINGNOTES 1 2 2 21 33 18"HIGHBENCH COPING NEWSCONCELIGHTFIXTURE.CONECTTONEW OREXISTINGSWITCHEDCIRCUIT.MATCH EXISTINGATEXTERIORLOCATIONS.SEE FIXTURE#1ONSHEETA2. LEDTAPELIGHTCONCEALEDINCHANELSHAPED RAILING.CONCEALWIRINGINNEWALPOSTS. EXTERIORLOWVOLTAGEDECKLIGHT.MOUNT 20"ABOVEDECKU.N.O.SEEFIXTURE#2ON SHEETA2. 24 COPYRIGHTc2022\M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC.\DRAWINGSMAYNOTBEREPRODUCEDINANYFORMWITHOUTTHEWRITTENPERMISSIONOFTHEARCHITECTS. 113WappooCreekDrive,Ste.4 Charleston,SouthCarolina mbrennanarchitects.com M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC. ARCHITECTSARCHITECTS M MB DATE: REVISIONS SHEET A4 GaLTVLOISGDSGNGXDVLPO ecsl=40:"A4-/1" RSPRPTGESGDSGNGXDVLPO ecsl=40:"A4-/1" REMOVE EXISTINGRAILINGSYSTEM AND PROVIDE NEW CAPRAILAND CABLERAILINGSYSTEMBETWEEN  EXISTING NEWALPOSTS. MATCH EXISTINGLATTICEIN-FILL 2" X2"ALUMINUMNEWEL POSTS, CAPRAIL,ANDCABLE RAILING  SYSTEM STUCCO NEWFOUNDATION WALLS TOMATCHEXISTING. NEWSTAIRWITHCABLERAILINGPERMEABLEPAVERWALKWAY JAN.4,2023 FORREVIEW SeabrookIsland,SC29455 2919DEERPOINTDRIVE MARTINRENOVATION 25 COPYRIGHTc2022\M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC.\DRAWINGSMAYNOTBEREPRODUCEDINANYFORMWITHOUTTHEWRITTENPERMISSIONOFTHEARCHITECTS. 113WappooCreekDrive,Ste.4 Charleston,SouthCarolina mbrennanarchitects.com M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC. ARCHITECTSARCHITECTS M MB DATE: REVISIONS SHEET A5 FaLTVLOINFGVTLEFFNFXDVLPO ecsl=40:"A4-/1" RSPRPTFENFGVTLEFFNFXDVLPO ecsl=40:"A4-/1" MATCHEXISTINGLATTICE IN-FILL 2"X2"ALUMINUMNEWELPOSTS, CAP RAIL,AND CABLERAILING SYSTEM STUCCO NEW FOUNDATIONWALLSTO MATCHEXISTING. EXISTINGHOME JAN.4,2023 FORREVIEW SeabrookIsland,SC29455 2919DEERPOINTDRIVE MARTINRENOVATION 26 COPYRIGHTc2022\M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC.\DRAWINGSMAYNOTBEREPRODUCEDINANYFORMWITHOUTTHEWRITTENPERMISSIONOFTHEARCHITECTS. 113WappooCreekDrive,Ste.4 Charleston,SouthCarolina mbrennanarchitects.com M.BRENNANARCHITECTS,INC. ARCHITECTSARCHITECTS M MB DATE: REVISIONS SHEET A6 GaLTVLOHSLHIVTLEGGNGXDVLPO ecsl=40:"A4-/1" RSPRPTGESLHIVTLEGGNGXDVLPO ecsl=40:"A4-/1" JAN.4,2023 MATCHEXISTING  LATTICEIN-FILL2" X2"ALUMINUMNEWEL POSTS,CAPRAIL,ANDCABLE RAILINGSYSTEM STUCCO NEW  FOUNDATIONWALLSTOMATCHEXISTING.  EXISTINGSCREENED PORCH FORREVIEW SeabrookIsland,SC29455 2919DEERPOINTDRIVE MARTINRENOVATION 27 1202 Landfall Way ధ Johns Island, SC 29455 ధ 843-725-1560 ధ kburrell@sipoa.org February 10, 2023 Tyler Newman VIA email: tnewman@townofseabrookisland.org Zoning Administrator Town of Seabrook Island 2001 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island, SC 29455 Re: Block 49 Lot 17 – 2919 Deer Point / Remodel – Rear Decking Encroachment Dear Mr. Newman: It is my understanding that a variance request has been submitted to the Town of Seabrook Island Board of Zoning Appeals relating to the proposed encroachment into rear 25’ critical area setback to allow for a first-floor open deck and open stair along the rear setback. The SIPOA ARC performed a brief review of the remodel plans for this home and is aware of the perspective owners’ desire to install a pool in the rear deck and extend the decking toward the marsh. The pool would not encroach into the rear setback, but in order to have the desired area of pool decking, would require that the decking and stairs encroach into the rear critical area setback by less than 10’. The ARC feels that this is acceptable and meets the requirements of the SIPOA Policies and Procedures for Residential Development with regard to the allowed 10’ encroachment for open decking on properties that back up to open areas. The ARC has indicated that if the request for the variance is approved by the Town of Seabrook Island Board of Zoning Appeals, the project will then be reviewed for approval by SIPOA ARC Staff with the condition that the request meet all requirements of the SIPOA Policies and Procedures. Please contact me if you need any additional information. Very truly yours, Katrina Burrell, CMCA, AMS Director of Administration and Architectural Review cc: Michael Martin via email M. Brennan Architects, Inc. via email B49 L17 – 2919 Deer Point Drive (Master File) 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE TO: Neighboring Property Owners FROM: Tyler Newman, Zoning Administrator SUBJECT: Variance Request for 2919 Deer Point Drive (Variance #181) DATE: February 14, 2023 Dear Property Owner: The purpose of this letter is to notify you that the owners of 2919 DEER POINT DRIVE have requested a VARIANCE from the zoning requirements of the Town’s Development Standards Ordinance (DSO). The purpose of the variance request is to: x 1) A VARIANCE FROM DSO SECTION 10.5.A.1, CRITICAL AREA SETBACK, TO ALLOW 444 SQUARE FEET OF PROPOSED OPEN DECK TO ENCROACH 8’-9’’ INTO THE REQUIRED 25’ CRITICAL AREA SETBACK, 2) A VARIANCE FROM DSO SECTION 10.5.A.1, CRITICAL AREA SETBACK, TO ALLO W 42 SQUARE FEET OF PROPOSED EXTERIOR STAIR TO ENCROACH 4’-1’’ INTO THE REQUIRED 25’ CRITICAL AREA SETBACK. 3) A VARIANCE FROM DSO SECTION 10.5.A.1, CRITICAL AREA SETBACK, TO ALLOW 19 SQUARE FEET OF PROPOSED PERMEABLE PAVING TO ENCROACH 4’-1’’ INTO THE REQUIRED 25’ CRITICAL AREA SETBACK. A copy of the variance application is enclosed for your information. The Seabrook Island Board of Zoning Appeals will hold a PUBLIC HEARING on the variance request at the date and time listed below. This notification is being provided to you pursuant to Section § 20.2.B.2 of the DSO. PUBLIC HEARING DATE: Wednesday March 22, 2023 PUBLIC HEARING TIME: 1:00 PM PUBLIC HEARING LOCATION: TOWN HALL (2001 SEABROOK ISLAND ROAD) For information on how to submit a public comment during (or prior to) the Public Hearing, please refer to the attached Public Hearing Notice. T h e P u b l i c H e a r i n g w i l l b e l i v e s t r e a m e d o n t h e t o w n ’ s Y o u T u b e c h a n n e l b e g i n n i n g a t 1 : 0 0 P M a t t h e f o l l o w i n g address: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCIkF87knEApHD1q0kGlaGZg . If you have any questions about the contents of this lett er, please feel free to contact me by phone at (843) 768- 9121 or by email at tnewman@townofseabrookisland.org. Sincerely, Tyler Newman Zoning Administrator Tyler Newman 42 43 44 45 46

Source: Town of Seabrook Island website. First collected Nov 1, 2026.