RecordWell Data

Agenda

Town of Seabrook Island · Charleston County · Agendas

Open the original document More from Town of Seabrook Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF SEABROOK ISLAND Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting January 29, 2019 – 2:30 PM T own Hall, Council Chambers 2001 Seabrook Island Road AGENDA CALL TO ORDER A PPROVAL OF MINUTES 1 . Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting: January 18, 2019 [Pages 2–4] P UBLIC HEARING ITEMS 1. Variance # 157 [Pages 5–75] APPLICANT: John C. Butera & Jean W. Jones ADDRESS: 2633 Jenkins Point Road TAX MAP NUMBER: 149-00-00-046 (LT 34, BLK 52) ZONING DISTRICT: SR Single-Family Residential PURPOSE: Applicant is requesting a variance to reduce the 25 -foot marsh setback requirement (§ 7.60.50) for the purpose of installing a pervious pergola system over an existing deck at the rear of the principal residence 2. Variance # 158 [Pages 76–184] APPLICANT: Stephanie & Raymond Hamilton ADDRESS: 2959 Seabrook Island Road Road TAX MAP NUMBER: 149-10-00-036 (LT 12-B, BLK 42) ZONING DISTRICT: SR Single-Family Residential PURPOSE: Applicant is requesting a variance to exceed the 36 -foot maximum height requirement for a single -family residential structure by 1.2 feet (§ 7.90.20) I TEMS FOR INFORMATION / DISCUSSION T here are no Items for Information / Discussion AD JOURN TOWN OF SEABROOK ISLAND Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting January 18, 2019 – 2:30 PM Town Hall, Council Chambers 2001 Seabrook Island Road MINUTES Present: Walter Sewell (Chairman), Ava Kleinman, John Fox, Dick Finkelstein, Joe Cronin (Zoning Administrator) Absent: Robert Leggett Guests: None Chairman Sewell called the meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals to order at 2:30 PM. Zoning Administrator Cronin confirmed that the requirements of the Freedom of Information Act were fulfilled, and the meeting was properly posted. Chairman Sewell then welcomed Mr. Dick Finkelstein to the Board of Zoning Appeals. Mr. Finkelstein was appointed by council to fill the remainder of an unexpired term following Robert Quagliato’s recent resignation from the board. ELECTION OF CHAIR & VICE CHAIR FOR 2019 Chairman Sewell opened the floor for nominations for the position of chair. Ms. Kleinman nominated Walter Sewell to serve as chair for 2019. Mr. Finkelstein seconded the nomination. There being no further nominations, Chairman Sewell called for a vote on the nomination . The motion to elect Mr. Sewell as chair was APPROVED by a vote of 4-0. Chairman Sewell then opened the floor for nominations for the position of vice chair. Chairman Sewell nominated Ava Kleinman to serve as vice chair for 2019. Mr. Fox seconded the nomination. There being no further nominations, Chairman Sewell called for a vote on the nomination. The motion to elect Ms. Kleinman as vice chair was APPROVED by a vote of 4-0. APPOINTMENT OF SECRETARY FOR 2019 Chairman Sewell nominated Zoning Administrator Cronin to serve as Secretary to the Board for 2019. Mr. Fox seconded the nomination. There being no further nominations, Chairman Sewell called for a vote on the nomination. The motion to appoint Zoning Administrator Cronin as secretary was APPROVED by a vote of 4-0. 2 APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting: November 8, 2018: Ms. Kleinman noted a typo on page 7 of the draft minutes (“…from a legal standpoint, the Board shouldn’t address questions or of intent if there is a plain meaning in the ordinance.”). Ms. Kleinman made a motion to approve the minutes from the November 8, 2018, meeting as amended. Mr. Fox seconded the motion. The motion was APPROVED by a vote of 4-0. ITEMS FOR INFORMATION / DISCUSSION 1. Update to Application Forms: Zoning Administrator Cronin stated that he was in the process of finalizing a n electronic version of the new application forms. He added that the forms should be ready for review and approval when the Board meets again to review the minutes from the January 29th meeting. 2. Update on the Status of Previous Variances: Zoning Administrator Cronin provided an update on the status of Variance #131, which was approved by the Board in 2004. He stated that the town has no records indicating that the owner of Cotton Island (Tax Map # 149 -00-00-004) ever moved for ward with obtaining a permit and installing a septic system in lieu of connecting to the town’s utility system, as allowed by the variance. He added that town staff is currently seeking records from SCDHEC to determine if a septic system was ever inst alled at the site , as well as whether the expansion of the existing dock had been reviewed and permitted by OCRM. If staff is unable to identify any records of the septic system being installed, then the town will notify the current owner that the 2004 variance is now expired. In addition, he noted that the Development Standards Ordinance (DSO) was subsequently amended to remove the zoning requirement that new development be connected to th e town’s utility system. That section was instead placed under the utility section of the Code of Ordinances. If the current owner were to seek a renewal of the 2004 variance, the Board of Zoning Appeals would no longer have jurisdiction over the request, as it is no longer a part of the town ’s zoning requirements. Therefore, only Town Council could modify the utility requirements. SITE VISITS Zoning Administrator Cronin distributed copies of the following variance applications to members of the Board and provided a brief overview of each request: • Variance #157: 2633 Seabrook Island Road (To reduce the 25’ Marsh Setback) • Variance #158: 2959 Seabrook Island Road (To exceed the 36’ Maximum Building Height) Prior to departing for the site visits, Zoning Administrator Cronin stated that public notice of the site visits had been provided, pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act. He stated that the agenda for today’s meeting contained the following provision: “ These site visits will take place behind the Seabrook Island Property Owners Association security gate. Any individual wishing to observe one or both site visits who does not have access behind the security gate should contact (843) 768-5321 for assistance prior to th e meeting.” He added for the record that no one from 3 the public was present at the meeting, and that no one had requested access behind the security gate for the purpose of observing the site visits . Zoning Administrator Cronin not ed that the purpose of each site visit was for observational purposes only, and no testimony would be heard pertaining to the variance application. The meeting was recessed at approximately 3:45 PM. Board members then traveled individually to 2959 Seabrook Island Road . Staff members at Town Hall were notified that the Board was traveling to the sites, and anyone coming to Town Hall to observe one or both site visits should be directed to those locations. 1. 2959 Seabrook Island Road (Tax Map # 149-10-00-036 – Lot 12-B, Block 42): The Board reconvened at approximately 3: 57 PM at 2 959 Seabrook Island Road. Board members observed the site, as well as neighboring properties in the vicinity of the site. Board members asked general questions regarding the proposed variance ; however, no testimony was received. Mr. Patrick Nichols of 2961 Se abrook Island Road observed the site visit. Mr. Fox left the meeting at approximately 3:59 PM. The meeting was again recessed at approximately 4:09 PM. Board members then traveled individually to 2633 Jenkins Point Road to conduct the second site visit. Ms. Kleinman left the meeting at 4:10 PM. 2. 2633 Jenkins Point Road (Tax Map # 149-00-00-046 – Lot 34, Block 52): The Board, which now lacked a quorum, reconvened at approximately 4:22 PM at 2633 Jenkins Point Road. Board members observed the site, as well as neighboring properties in the vicinity of the site. Board members asked general questions regarding the proposed variance; however, no testimony was received. There were no observers present. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 4:36 PM. Minutes Approved: Joseph M. Cronin Zoning Administrator 4 MEMORANDUM TO: Town of Seabrook Island Board of Zoning Appeals Members FROM: Joseph M. Cronin, Town Administrator/Zoning Administrator SUBJECT: Variance Application # 157 – 2633 Jenkins Point Road (Lot 34, Block 52) MEETING DATE: January 29, 2019 Variance Application #157 Applicants: John C. Butera & Jean W. Jones (Owners) Location: 2633 Jenkins Point Road Tax Map Number: 149-00-00-046 (Lot 34, Block 52) Zoning District: SR Single-Family Residential Purpose: Applicant is requesting a variance to reduce the 25-foot marsh setback requirement (§ 7.60.50) for the purpose of installing a pervious pergola system over an existing deck at the rear of the principal residence Overview The Town has received a variance application from John C. Buter a and Jean W. Jones, the owners of Charleston County Tax Map # 149-00-00-046, as well as their contractor, Tommy Burl of Surfside Construction. The applicants are requesting a reduction in the 25-foot marsh setback requirement to allow construction of a pervious pergola system over an existin g deck at the rear of a single- family residence located at 2633 Jenkins Point Road (Lot 34, Block 52). As shown in the photos contained in Attachment #5, there is a circular roof cov ering a portion of the existing deck at the rear of the home. The existing roof, which covers an outdoor kitchen area, encroaches approximately 6.5 feet into the 25-foot marsh setback. If should be noted that the existing roof was conforming at the time of its construction in 2007-08. The roof was only made non-conforming by subsequent changes to the marsh critical line ov er the last 10 years. (See Attachment #4 for the as-built survey from 2008.) The applicants are proposing to remove the existing circular roof and to replace it with a pervious pergola system that will cover the entire deck, including porti ons which are currently uncovered. The Zoning Administrator denied a zoning permit in October 2018 due to the fact that a pergola would constitute a “roof or covering of any kind,” thereby converting the existing “pervious deck” (which requires a 15-foot marsh setback) into a “covered porch” (which requires a 25-foot marsh setback). The Zoning Administrator also determined that while the exis ting non-conforming roof may be repaired and maintained, its removal and replacement with anoth er non- conforming structure would require a variance from the Board of Zoning Appeals. 5 The applicants filed an appeal of the Zoning Administrator’s decision on October 9, 2018. The Board of Zoning Appeals considered the appeal on November 8, 2018, at which time the Board voted to uphold the Zoning Administrator ’s decision. At that time, the applicants were also advised that they may resubmit the request for consideration by the Board as a variance application. While a majority of the new pergola structure will meet the 25 -foot marsh setback requirement, the structure will encroa ch, at most, 7 feet into the required setback. The proposed pergola will not increase the extent of non-conformity in the area where the existing roof is present; however, one small corner of the deck, if allowed to be covered, would encroach appro ximately 2-3 feet into the 25-foot marsh setback. The areas of encroachment are highlighted in orange in the graphic on the right. The property is currently zoned SR Single-Family Residential, and a single-family residence is a permitted use by-right. With the exception of the aforementioned non-conforming roof, the existing home meets all other requirements of the town’s DSO: TYPE REQUIRED PER DSO DSO REFERENCE Front (Principal Structure) 30 feet § 7.60.20.10 Side (Conforming Lot) 15 feet § 7.60.20.20 Marsh (Open Deck) 15 feet § 7.60.50 Marsh (All Other Structures) 25 feet (Roof Nonconforming) § 7.60.50 Driveway (Conforming Lot) 6 feet § 7.60.70.10 Therefore, the applicants are requesting a variance from the DSO to allow for the following encroachment into the ma rsh setback: TYPE REQUIRED PER DSO VARIANCE (REQUESTED) Marsh (All Other Structures) 25 feet Allow encroachment of up to 7 feet where the existing roof is located and up to 3 feet where the non-conforming roof will be expanded In their application, the applicants have stated their intent in seeking a variance is to be able to use and enjoy their outdoor deck. The applicants argue that replaci ng the existing solid roof with a 6 pervious pergola system will allow water to flow through the de ck to the ground below, which is more in line with the intent of the marsh setback requirement. Staff Comments As a matter of practice, the town’s Zoning Administrator does n ot typically provide a recommendation in favor of – or in opposition to – a variance application. In our opini on, these requests are best left to the Board of Zoning Appeals following a thorou gh review of the relevant facts, including the receipt of testimony from interested parties during the required public hearing. In granting a variance, state law permits the Board of Zoning Appeals to attach such conditions as the Board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. Should the Board vote to approve the variance request, staff wo uld recommend in favor of attaching the following conditions: • The approved variance shall apply to the building layout as shown on the site- specific plan prepared by the applicant and reviewed by the Board on Jan uary 29, 2019 . Any modification to this site-specific plan prior to the issuance of a zoning permit, with the exception of minor corrections and/or modifications which confo rm to the requirements of the town’s DSO, shall require further review and approval by the Board of Zoning Appeals prior to permitting. • The variance shall expire on November 2, 2019 (five years from the date of the current OCRM Critical Line Survey) if no zoning permit has been issued by the town on or before that date. Respectfully submitted, Joseph M. Cronin Town Administrator/Zoning Administrator Joseph M. Croni 7 Criteria for Review Pursuant to Section 6-29-800(A)(2) of the SC Code of Laws, the Board of Zoning Appeals has the power to hear and decide appeals for variance from the requirements o f the zoning ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the board makes and explains in writing the following findings: (a) there are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; (b) these conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; (c) because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and (d) the authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. The board may not grant a variance, the effect of which would b e to allow the establishment of a use not otherwise permitted in a zoning district, to extend physically a nonconforming use of land or to change the zoning district boundaries shown on the official zoning map. The fact that property may be utilized more profitably, if a variance is granted, may not be considered grounds for a variance. Other requirements may be prescribed by the zoning ordinance. In granting a variance, the board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as t he board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. 8     Attachments    The following supplemental items have been attached for review:    Application & Property Information  1  Variance Application  p. 10‐13  2  Property Survey (2014)  p. 14‐15  3  Pergola Design & Renderings  p. 16‐29  4  As‐Built Survey (2008)  p. 30‐31  5  Property Photos  p. 32‐38  6  Zoning Map  p. 39‐40  7  Aerial Image  p. 41‐42  8  FEMA Base Flood Elevations (Current & Preliminary)  p. 43‐44  9  Title to Real Estate  p. 45‐50  10  Property Information Card  p. 51‐52  11  Public Hearing Notice – List of Neighboring Property Owners  p.  53‐54  12  Public Hearing Notice – U.S.P.S.  Certified Mail Receipts  p. 55‐ 57  13  Public Hearing Notice – Post a nd Courier Legal Ad  p. 58‐59  14  Public Hearing Notice – Property Posting  p. 60‐61    Other Information  15      2018 Zoning Denial & Appeal:    a) Letter of Zoning Denial  p. 62‐64  b) Notice of Appeal  p. 65‐69  c) Board of Zoning Appeals Notice of Decision  p. 70‐73    Written Correspondence Regarding the Proposed Variance Request  16  Letter from Charles Measter (Dec. 31, 2018)  p. 74‐75         9 ATTACHMENT #1 Variance Application 10 11 12 13 ATTACHMENT #2 Property Survey (2014) 14 0.50 in 0.85 in 0.22 in 0.07 in 15 ATTACHMENT #3 Pergola Design & Renderings 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 'HFHPEHU -HQNLQV3RLQW5RDG (1-2<7+(6+$'( 1RWWRVFDOH /$*%2/7 0,1,0%('(0(17 ,172($&+5$)7(5 72%(63(& '%< (1*,1((5,1* +2/('5,//(' )25%2/7$&&(66 6($/('%<*877(5   ; %($03(53/$1 (;,67,1*)5$0,1* +2//2:('726+2: %2/76 (;,6,71*522)'(&.,1* *877(5:,//&29(5$1'6($/ +2/(6'5,//('72)$&,/,7$7( ,167$//$7,212)/2:(5/$*6 ; 7(.6&5(:6 2& (;,67,1*)5$0,1* %2/763$&,1*$1'/(1*7+6 $5(68%-(&772&+$1*( '85,1*),1$/(1*,1((5,1*$33529$/ 25 'HFHPEHU -HQNLQV3RLQW5RDG (1-2<7+(6+$'( %2/763$&,1*$1'/(1*7+6 $5(68%-(&772&+$1*( '85,1*),1$/(1*,1((5,1*$33529$/ )$&,$&211(&7,21 26 27 28 EXISTING PROPOSED Existing Non-Conforming Covering (To Be Removed) Proposed Pergola Over Existing Deck Portion of Pergola which will encroach into setback 29 ATTACHMENT #4 As-Built Survey (2008) 30 31 ATTACHMENT #5 Property Photos 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 ATTACHMENT #6 Zoning Map 39 40 ATTACHMENT #7 Aerial Image 41 42 ATTACHMENT #8 FEMA Base Flood Elevations (Current & Preliminary) 43 FEMA Base Flood Elevation (Current) VE-14 FEMA Base Flood Elevation (Preliminary) AE-9/10 44 ATTACHMENT #9 Title to Real Estate 45 46 47 48 49 50 ATTACHMENT #10 Property Information Card 51 /0 /1 /2 /3 /1 /2 /4 /0/5/6 /7 /8 /9 /10 /11 /12 /13 /14 /15 /i255 /6 /14 /17 /15 /13 /18 /19 /i255 /20 /14 /17 /13 /7 /i255 /6 /8 /9 /14 /10 /21 /15 /8 /7 /13 /13 /22 /23 /1 /1 /12 /24 /25 /24 /7 /8 /9 /10 /11 /12 /13 /14 /15 /25 /24 /14 /17 /15 /13 /18 /26 /27 /14 /28 /11 /9 /15/29/8/30 /26 /24 /14/29/1/12 /28 /24 /1 /13 /8 /31 /32 /12 /17/29/29/8/9 /18 /32 /9 /11 /22 /14 /9 /13 /32 /20 /6 /25 /6 /7 /8 /9 /26 /8 /12 /22 /33 /34 /9 /21 /15 /13 /35 /21 /11 /36 /37 /38 /9 /17 /11 /39 /9 /32 /15/29/37/13 /8 /31/40/41/42 /9 /11 /22 /14 /9 /13 /39 /13 /32 /36 /24 /37/40/43/6 /22 /8 /9 /24 /11 /10 /21 /44/40/3/45 /0 /46 /5/47 /0 /1 /0 /48 /49 /50 /51 /52 /53 /54 /55 /56 /57 /i255 /48 /56 /59 /57 /55 /60 /61 /i255 /62 /56 /59 /55 /49 /i255 /48 /50 /51 /56 /52 /63 /57 /50 /64 /65 /66 /65 /67 /68 /69 /65 /70 /i255 /72 /66 /i255 /73 /74 /75 /76 /74 /75 /77 /73 /78 /i255 /73 /73 /79 /77 /80 /79 /81 /77 /i255 /82/83/i255/84 /85/86 /87 /88 /89 /90 /91 /88 /92 /93 /i255 /95/96/i255/97 /87 /95 /98 /99 /i255/100 /101 /92 /91 /88 /102 /103 /92 /91 /i255 /95 /96 /97 /100 /95 /98 /99 /i255/87 /103 /88 /104 /91 /101 /i255 /100 /105 /105 /88 /91 /106 /106 /i255 /96/103/92 /103 /88 /91 /107 /88 /91 /106 /108 /91 /105 /i255 /103 /106 /89 /107 /i255 /100 /106 /106 /91 /106 /106 /109 /91 /103 /88 /i255/87 /103 /93 /i255 /109 /91 /103 /88 /i255 /110 /111 /112 /113 /113 /113 /113 /113 /111/114/i255 /116 /114 /117 /117 /i255 /118 /119 /120 /121 /122 /120 /123 /i255 /124 /125 /122 /120 /126 /i255 /127 /128 /129 /i255 /123 /119 /130 /131 /127 /125 /125 /121 /i255 /122 /123 /132 /130 /120/128/110 /133 /117 /133 /116 /113 /110/112/116 /113 /110/134/116 /113 /110 /134 /i255 /135 /136 /88 /88 /91 /102 /92 /i255 /87 /103 /88 /104 /91 /101 /i255 /95 /102 /107 /89 /88/137/103/92 /138 /89 /102 /i255 /139/140/102/91 /88/i255/141 /142 /143 /144 /145 /146 /i255 /147/139/148/98/i255 /135 /i255 /145 /i255 /147/139/98/145 /149 /i255 /147 /145 /100 /98 /i255/150/148 /95/143 /145 /139/140/102/91 /88 /i255 /100 /105 /105 /88 /91 /106 /106/i255/151/152 /153 /153 /i255 /147 /145 /98 /154 /95 /98 /149 /i255 /87/139/95/98 /143 /i255 /147/139/148/98/149 /i255 /95 /149 /144 /100 /98/96/i255/149 /135 /i255 /151 /155 /156 /157 /157 /87 /88 /89 /90 /91 /88 /92 /93 /i255 /135 /101 /103 /106 /106 /i255 /135 /89 /105 /91/i255/158/159 /158 /i255 /160 /i255 /146 /145 /149 /95/96/160/149 /161 /146 /100 /104 /88 /91 /103 /162 /91/i255/163 /164 /153 /159 /159 /144 /91 /162 /103 /101 /i255/96/91/106 /104 /88 /138 /90 /92 /138 /89 /102/i255/149/136 /165 /105 /138 /166 /138 /106 /138 /89 /102 /i255 /98 /103/137/91/i255 /160 /147 /145 /98 /154 /95 /98 /149 /i255 /87/139/95/98 /143 /i255 /87 /144 /100 /98 /143 /100 /143 /95/139/98/i255/96/91/106 /104 /88 /138 /90 /92 /138 /89 /102 /i255 /160 /144/139/143/i255 /153 /156 /i255 /87/148/100/149 /145 /i255 /95 /95 /95 /i255 /87 /101 /103 /92 /149 /136 /107 /107 /138 /167 /i255 /145 /135 /160 /158 /164 /151 /87 /89 /101 /143/140/90/i255 /159 /159 /155 /i255 /148/138/106 /92 /89 /88 /138 /104 /i255 /95 /102 /107 /89 /88/137/103/92 /138 /89 /102 /i255 /143 /103 /167 /i255 /109 /91 /103 /88/i255/144 /103 /102 /105/i255/95 /137/90/88 /89 /166 /91/137/91/102 /92 /106/i255/168 /103/88 /169 /91 /92/i255/143 /103 /167 /91 /106/i255/87 /103 /93/137/91/102 /92 /i255 /116 /113 /110/134/170 /114 /113 /111 /129 /117 /113 /113/i255/170 /134 /134 /116 /129 /171 /113 /113/i255/170 /110 /129 /111 /134 /114 /129 /134 /113 /113/i255/170 /171 /129 /114 /116 /117 /172 /173 /117/i255/170 /171 /129 /114 /116 /117 /172 /173 /117 /i255 /116 /113 /110/173/170 /114 /113 /111 /129 /117 /113 /113/i255/170 /134 /134 /116 /129 /171 /113 /113/i255/170 /110 /129 /111 /134 /114 /129 /134 /113 /113/i255/170 /171 /129 /111 /134 /112 /172 /112 /116/i255/170 /171 /129 /111 /134 /112 /172 /112 /116 /i255 /116 /113 /110 /114 /170 /114 /113 /111 /129 /117 /113 /113/i255/170 /134 /134 /116 /129 /171 /113 /113/i255/170 /110 /129 /111 /134 /114 /129 /134 /113 /113/i255/170 /171 /129 /110 /114 /116 /172 /134 /111/i255/170 /171 /129 /110 /114 /116 /172 /134 /111 /i255 /116 /113 /110 /171 /170 /114 /113 /111 /129 /117 /113 /113/i255/170 /134 /134 /116 /129 /171 /113 /113/i255/170 /110 /129 /111 /134 /114 /129 /134 /113 /113/i255/170 /171 /129 /111 /111 /116 /172 /117 /111/i255/170 /171 /129 /111 /111 /116 /172 /117 /111 /i255 /149 /103 /101 /91 /106 /i255/96/138/106 /104 /101 /89 /106 /136 /88 /91 /i255 /174/88/103 /102 /92 /89 /88/i255/141 /89 /89 /169 /i255 /175 /i255 /87 /103 /162 /91/i255/96 /103/92/91/i255/96 /91/91 /105 /i255/176 /103 /104 /103 /102 /92 /i255/149 /103 /101 /91 /i255 /87 /88 /138 /104 /91 /i255 /148/142/141 /141 /100 /146/96/i255/154 /145 /98 /98 /145 /143/148/i255/150/159 /177 /156 /153 /i255 /177 /151 /155/i255/164 /178 /151 /177 /178 /151 /159 /158 /164/i255/174 /91 /179/158/180 /152 /164 /156 /180 /159 /159 /159 /i255 /i255 /135/139/144/100 /143 /149 /154 /109 /i255 /143/148/139/168/100/149 /i255/147/145 /156 /156 /153 /i255 /159 /153 /158/i255/156 /178 /151 /178 /151 /159 /159 /153/i255/174 /91 /179/153 /164 /159 /180 /159 /159 /159 /i255 /i255 /148/139/146/149 /145 /149/148/139/145/i255 /135 /146 /145 /145 /154 /i255/96/145/176 /145 /144/139/87/168/145/98/143/176 /151 /164 /155 /i255 /153 /164 /177/i255/155 /178 /153 /178 /158 /155 /155 /177/i255/174/91 /179/151 /164 /159 /180 /159 /159 /159 /i255 /i255 /98/139/143/i255 /149 /142 /87 /87 /144 /95 /145/96/145 /151 /152 /177 /i255 /152 /157 /151/i255/153 /178 /151 /164 /178 /158 /155 /155 /152/i255/174 /91 /179/159 /i255 /i255 /i255/145 /135 /i255 /156 /177 /157/i255/158 /178 /158 /178 /158 /155 /159 /159/i255/168 /103 /179/159 /i255 /i255 /95/137/90/88 /89 /166 /91/137/91/102 /92 /106 /i255 /141 /136 /138 /101 /105 /138 /102 /162/i255/143 /93 /90 /91 /i255/142 /106 /91 /i255 /135 /89 /105 /91 /96/91/106 /104 /88 /138 /90 /92 /138 /89 /102 /i255 /135 /89 /102 /106 /92 /88 /136 /104 /92 /91 /105 /109 /91 /103 /88 /i255/149 /92 /89 /88 /138 /91 /106/i255/141/91 /105 /88 /89 /89/137/106/i255/161 /138 /102 /138 /106 /108 /91 /105 /i255 /149 /181 /163 /161 /92 /163 /i255 /95 /137/90 /88 /89 /166 /91/137/91/102 /92 /149 /138 /182 /91 /i255 /146 /159 /158 /96/150/145/144/144/96 /140 /91/101 /101 /138 /102/162/151 /159 /159/164/158 /163 /177/157/159 /153/156 /180 /157 /155/158/i255 /146 /159/158/150 /100 /144 /154/150/100/109/96 /89/104 /169 /i255/150/103/101 /169/140/103/93/158 /155 /155/164/159 /159 /i255 /158 /180 /157 /155 /151 /146 /159/158/150 /100 /144 /154/150/100/109/96 /89/104 /169 /i255/150/103/101 /169/140/103/93/158 /155 /155/164/159 /159 /i255 /157 /156 52 ATTACHMENT #11 Public Hearing Notice: List of Neighboring Property Owners 53 sĂƌŝĂŶĐĞEŽƚŝĨŝĐĂƚŝŽŶ>ŝƐƚ Ϯϲϯϯ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐWŽŝŶƚZŽĂĚ WƌŽƉĞƌƚLJĚĚƌĞƐƐ KǁŶĞƌ;ƐͿŽĨZĞĐŽƌĚ DĂŝůŝŶŐĚĚƌĞƐƐ ŝƚLJ ^ƚĂƚĞ ŝƉ ϭϮϬϯ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐ>ĂŐŽŽŶƌŝǀĞE DĂƌŝƚnjĂΘƌŝĂŶŽĂ Ŭ ϭϯϲϬϰDĂŶŽƌZŽĂĚ ĂůĚǁŝŶ D ϮϭϬϭϯ ϭϮϬϳ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐ>ĂŐŽŽŶƌŝǀĞE :ŽŚŶŵďůĞƌ ϭϮϴĞůĚĞŶ,ŝůůZŽĂĚ tŝůƚŽŶ d Ϭϲϴϵϳ ϭϮϭϭ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐ>ĂŐŽŽŶƌŝǀĞE ĚĚŝĞĂǀŝƐ;dƌƵƐƚĞĞͿΘůŝnjĂďĞƚŚĂ ǀŝƐ;dƌƵƐƚĞĞͿ ϭϮϭϭ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐ>ĂŐŽŽŶƌŝǀĞE ^ĞĂďƌŽŽŬ/ƐůĂŶĚ ^ Ϯϵϰϱϱ dĂdžDĂƉηϭϰϵͲϬϬͲϬϬͲϬϱϭ ,ŽƌƐĞƐŚŽĞƌĞĞŬĞǀĞůŽƉŵĞŶƚ ϮϴϬϱ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐWŽŝŶƚZŽĂĚ ^ĞĂďƌŽŽŬ/ƐůĂŶĚ ^ Ϯϵϰϱϱ ϮϲϮϰ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐWŽŝŶƚZŽĂĚ dŝŵŽƚŚLJΘDĂƵƌĞĞŶĂƌƌ ϮϲϴϰZĂĚĨŽƌĚEt^ƚƌĞĞƚ EŽƌƚŚĂŶƚŽŶ K, ϰϰϳϮϬ ϮϲϮϵ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐWŽŝŶƚZŽĂĚ ŚĂƌůĞƐΘĂƌďĂƌĂDĞĂƐƚĞ ƌ ϮϰϯϬĞŶƚdǁŝŐƌŝǀĞ ^ĞĂďƌŽŽŬ/ƐůĂŶĚ ^ Ϯϵϰϱϱ dĂdžDĂƉηϭϰϵͲϬϬͲϬϬͲϬϯϵ ^ĞĂďƌŽŽŬ/ƐůĂŶĚWƌŽƉĞƌƚLJKǁŶĞƌƐƐƐŽĐŝĂƚ ŝŽŶ ϭϮϬϮ>ĂŶĚĨĂůůtĂLJ ^ĞĂďƌŽŽŬ/ƐůĂŶĚ ^ Ϯϵϰϱϱ ϭϯϬϯ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐ>ĂŐŽŽŶƌŝǀĞ^ dŚŽŵĂƐΘ>LJŶĚĂ&Ždž ϭϯϬϯ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐ>ĂŐŽŽŶƌŝǀĞ^ ^ĞĂďƌŽŽŬ/ƐůĂŶĚ ^ Ϯϵϰϱϱ ϭϯϬϲ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐ>ĂŐŽŽŶƌŝǀĞ^ 'ŝůůĞƐĂǀŝĞƚ;dƌƵƐƚĞĞͿΘsŝǀŝĂŶĞĂ ǀŝĞƚ;dƌƵƐƚĞĞͿ ϭϬϭŽLJůĞƌŝǀĞ 'ƌĞĞŶǀŝůůĞ ^ Ϯϵϲϭϱ ϭϯϬϳ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐ>ĂŐŽŽŶƌŝǀĞ^ ƵĚƌĞLJDĐEƵůƚLJ;dƌƵƐƚĞĞͿΘ&ƌĂŶŬDĐEƵůƚLJ;dƌƵƐƚĞĞͿ ϭϯϬϳ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐ>ĂŐŽŽŶƌŝǀĞ^ ^ĞĂďƌŽŽŬ/ƐůĂŶĚ ^ Ϯϵϰϱϱ ϭϯϭϭ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐ>ĂŐŽŽŶƌŝǀĞ^ ŝůĞĞŶ^ŵŝƚŚΘŽŶĂůĚ^ŵŝƚŚ;ŽͲdƌƵƐ ƚĞĞƐͿ ϭϯϭϭ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐ>ĂŐŽŽŶƌŝǀĞ^ ^ĞĂďƌŽŽŬ/ƐůĂŶĚ ^ Ϯϵϰϱϱ Ϯϲϯϳ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐWŽŝŶƚZŽĂĚ ϯϮϲĞĂĐŚůƵďsŝůůĂ>> ϳϭϯ^ƚ͘:ĂŵĞƐ^ƚƌĞĞƚ WŝƚƚƐďƵƌŐŚ W ϭϱϮϯϮ dĂdžDĂƉηϭϰϵͲϬϬͲϬϬͲϬϳϱ >ĂǁƌĞŶĐĞƌĂĚŚĂŵ: ƌ ϮϴϬϱ:ĞŶŬŝŶƐWŽŝŶƚZŽĂĚ ^ĞĂďƌŽŽŬ/ƐůĂŶĚ ^ Ϯϵϰϱϱ WƌŽƉĞƌƚLJKǁŶĞƌƐƐƐŽĐŝĂƚŝŽŶ ^ĞĂďƌŽŽŬ/ƐůĂŶĚWƌŽƉĞƌƚLJKǁŶĞƌƐƐƐŽ ĐŝĂƚŝŽŶ ϭϮϬϮ>ĂŶĚĨĂůůtĂLJ ^ĞĂďƌŽŽŬ/ƐůĂŶĚ ^ Ϯϵϰϱϱ ZĞŐŝŵĞ EŽƚƉƉůŝĐĂďůĞ 54 ATTACHMENT #12 Public Hearing Notice: U.S.P.S. Certified Mail Receipts 55 56 57 ATTACHMENT #13 Public Hearing Notice: Post & Courier Legal Ad 58 59 ATTACHMENT #14 Public Hearing Notice: Property Posting 60 61 ATTACHMENT #15-A 2018 Zoning Denial & Appeal: Letter of Zoning Denial 62 MEMORANDUM TO: Tom Berl, Surfside Construction, 3418 Green Heron Ct, Seabrook Island, SC 29455 FROM: Joseph M. Cronin, Town Administrator/Zoning Administrator SUBJECT: Zoning Permit Request for 2633 Jenkins Permit Road DATE: October 9, 2018 Dear Mr. BĞƌů: We have reviewed your zoning permit application, submitted on b ehalf of John C. Butler and Jean W. Jones (owners), to allow for the installation of a new pergola system over a portion of an existing deck at the rear of 2633 Jenkins Point Road (Charleston County Tax Map Number 149-00-00-046). Your request for a zoning permit for the above referenced prope rty has been DENIED for the following reasons: • The rear of the above referenced property abuts a marsh critical area which has been delineated on a survey by SCDHEC-OCRM. Pursuant to the town’s Development Standards Ordinance (DSO), all structures which abut a marsh (exclusive of “open decks”) s hall be set back at least 25 feet from the OCRM critical line. “Open decks” are permitted to encroach into the 25-foot marsh setback; provided, however, no part of the deck may be closer than 15 feet from the critical line. • Though the proposed pergola system is designed to allow water to pass through to the deck and ground below, the DSO defines a deck having a “roof or other covering of any kind” as a “porch” rather than a “deck.” • Therefore, in my opinion, the installation of a pergola system would require the covered portions of the existing deck to be reclassified as a “porch” rather than an “open deck,” and the 25-foot marsh setback would apply. Because the pergola system would encroach into the 25-foot marsh setback, the zoning permit application has been denied. • DSO Code References: o § 7.60.50. Marsh Setbacks. The minimum setback for a structure, exclusive of open decks, on a lot abutting the marsh shall be twenty-five (25) feet from the South Carolina Ocean and Coastal Resource Management critical area or the lot line, whichever is landward. No part of an open deck shall be closer than fifteen (15) feet from the critical area. o § 2.10. Definitions: ƒ (o) Deck. An open and uncovered horizontal surface, attached and accessib le to and being a part of the primary structure, which is constructed so that rain can 63 pass directly through it to the ground beneath. A deck having a roof or other covering of any kind is defined to be a porch. ƒ (ccc) Porch. A horizontal surface, attached and accessible to and being a part of the primary structure, which is constructed with or without wal ls and with a roof or covering of any kind. The term "porch" shall include any veranda, terrace, portico or similar projection from a main wall of a building and covered by a roof. Right to Appeal Any applicant who believes there has been an error in any order , requirement, decision, or determination by the Zoning Administrator in the enforcement of th e D S O m a y s u b m i t a N o t i c e o f Appeal to the Board of Zoning Appeals, pursuant to § 19.40 of the DSO . Any such appeal must be initiated within 30 days from the date of this letter. Variance Applications A n y a p p l i c a n t m a y s u b m i t a r e q u e s t f o r a v a r i a n c e f r o m t h e r e q uirements of the DSO by filing an Application for Variance to the Board of Zoning Appeals. In instances of unnecessary hardship, the Board of Zoning Appeals may authorize the granting of a variance from the requirements of the DSO upon finding that the request meets each of the following criteria: (a) There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining t o the particular piece of property in question because of its size, shape, or topography; and (b) Such conditions are peculiar to the particular piece of property involved and do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; and (c) Because of these conditions, application of DSO on this particu lar piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilitization of the property; and (d) Relief, if granted, would not cause substantial detriment to adjacent property, the public good or impair the purpose and intent of the DSO or the compreh ensive plan If you or the property owner would like to initiate an appeal or variance request, please contact our office as soon as possible. If you have any questions about the contents of this letter, pl ease feel free to contact me by phone at (843) 768-5321 or by email at jcronin@townofseabrookisland.org. Respectfully submitted, Joseph M. Cronin Town Administrator/Zoning Administrator Joseph M. Cronin 64 ATTACHMENT #15-B 2018 Zoning Denial & Appeal: Notice of Appeal 65 66 67 68 69 ATTACHMENT #15-C 2018 Zoning Denial & Appeal: Board of Zoning Appeals Notice of Decision 70 71 72 73 ATTACHMENT #16 Letter from Charles Measter (Dec. 31, 2018) 74 1 Joe Cronin From: Charlie Measter <cmeaster@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, December 31, 2018 12:04 PM To: Joe Cronin Subject: 2633 Jenkins Point Road Charles L. Measter 843-768-2520 2430 Bent Twig cmeaster@comcast.net Seabrook Island SC 29455 Dear Mr. Cronin, We object to reducing the 25 ft setback requirement on this property. To our knowledge you have had numerous requests for variances in the past and you have not allowed this setback requirement to be adjusted Best regards, Barbara & Charles Measter 75 MEMORANDUM TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Town of Seabrook Island Board of Zoning Appeals Members Joseph M. Cronin, Town Administrator/Zoning Administrator Variance Application # 158 – 2959 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 12-B, Block 42) MEETING DATE: January 29, 2019 Variance Application #157 Applicants: Raymond & Stephanie Hamilton (Owners) Galloway Family Homes (Builder) Location: 2959 Seabrook Island Road Tax Map Number: 149-10-00-036 (Lot 12-B, Block 42) Zoning District: SR Single-Family Residential Purpose: Applicant is requesting a variance to exceed the 36-foot maximu m height requirement for a single-family residential structure by 1.2 feet (§ 7.90.20) Overview The Town has received a variance application from Raymond and Stephanie Hamilton, the owners of Charleston County Tax Map # 149-10-00-036, as well as their builder, Clint Galloway of Galloway Family Homes. The applicants are requesting a variance from the town’s zoning requirements to exceed the 36-foot maximum height requirement for a single-family residential structure currently under construction at 2959 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 12-B, Block 42). The town’s Zoning Administrator approved a zoning permit (Permi t #14595) for construction of a new single-family home at 2959 Seabrook Island Road on March 16 , 2018. A building permit was subsequently issued by Charleston County, and construction on the new home began in the spring of 2018. As p ar t of it s p er mit t in g an d in sp ect ion p r oces s, t h e t own ’s D evelopment Standards Ordinance (DSO) requires a permit holder to perform and file with the town several surveys at various stages of the construction process. These include: x § 13.70.30. Foundation Survey. A South Carolina Registered Land Surveyor immediately u p o n c o m p l e t i o n o f t h e f o u n d a t i o n m u s t p e r f o r m a f o u n d a t i o n s u rvey for each new structure, or addition to an existing structure which exceeds o r is outside the furthermost limits of the existing footprint. Such survey must be filed wit h the Zoning Administrator before any further construction can proceed. • § 13.70.40. Certification of Height of Structure . Construction of any structure shall not proceed beyond the establishment of the roof peak line during construction without certifying to the Zoning Administrator in writing by a certified surveyor the height of said roof peak above the FEMA flood level for that site. • In addition, the town requires completion of a preliminary elevation certificate to verify that the foundation of a new structure meets the town and county’s minimum flood elevation requirements. As of October 30, 2018, the town had not received any of these docum ents from the builder, Galloway Family Homes. On that date, the town’s License & Permit Specialist, Lynda Stearns, sent a letter to Galloway reminding them of the ir obligation to file the required information. After 30 days in which no response was received, the town’s Code Enforcement Officer placed a “Stop Work Order” on the property on December 4, 2018. A follow up letter was sent by Ms. Stearns to Galloway on December 5, 2018. Galloway submitted a foundation survey, certificate of height and preliminary elevation certificate to the town on or around December 22, 2018. These documents were reviewed by the Zoning Administrator for consistency with the town’s DSO and the approved construction plans for the project. While the foundation survey and preliminary elevation certificate were found to comply, the certificate of height – which was completed by professional surveyor Lauren Maurice Wilder on December 6, 2016 – indicated that the total height of the structure (39.2 feet) exceeded the maximum allowable under the town’ s DSO by 1.2 feet . The town ’s Zoning Administrator, Joe Cronin, notified Galloway of this non -conformity on December 20 , 2018 , and the builder was further instructed on December 27, 2018, to either 1) bring the structure into conformity with the maximum height requirement; or 2) submit a variance application for consideration by the Board of Zoning Appeals. Prior to submitting their variance application , the builder notified the Zoning Administrator by phone that the primary reasons for the non-conformity were the SIPOA ’s request to raise the finished grade of the property for drainage purposes, as well as an error made in the field when constructing the building’s foundation. A review of the approved building plans, as well as the preliminary elevation certificate, support Galloway’s second claim regarding a building error. In the approved plans (see sheet 4.10 in Attachment #3), the finished elevation at the top of the first floor was intended to be 4 ’ 9” above the 15-foot design flood elevation, or 19’ 9” above mean sea level. On page 2 of the preliminary elevation certificate, however, the finished elevation at the top of the first floor was surveyed at 21.2 feet above mean sea level, or 1.3 feet higher than in the approved plans (see Attachment #5). This discrepancy resulted in the structure exceeding the maximum height requirement by 1.2 feet. A subsequent survey prepared by professional s urveyor Mark E. Lamb on January 17, 2019, indicated the structure exceeded the maximum height requirement by only 0.96 feet. The town’s maximum building height requirement is governed by § 7.90 of the town’s DSO, which contains the following provisions: 77 • § 7.90.20 The maximum height for any single family residential structure shall be thirty - six (36) feet above the combination of the base flood elevation and the Charleston County Building Department's minimum freeboard requirement as set forth and defined in the County's applicable rules, regulations and ordinances in effect at such time. In the event there exist elevations which are higher than the base flood elevation combined with the County's freeboard requirement as defined above, and such land is located within the building's footprint, then the maximum height of thirty-six (36) feet shall be measured from whichever is greater. o Note: The county’s current freeboard (FB) requirement is two (2) feet above Base Flood Elevation (BFE). Therefore, the maximum allowable height under the zoning ordinance is BFE + 2-foot FB + 36 feet; or alternatively, BFE + 38 feet. • § 7.90.30. Exemptions. Height limitations of this Ordinance shall not apply to monuments, water towers, transmission towers, utility poles, chimneys, flag poles or farm structures not intended for human occupancy. They do, however, apply to decks, widow walks, etc., erected on top of structures. As indicated on both the Wilder survey of December 6, 2018 (39.2 feet), as well as the subsequent Lamb survey prepared on January 17, 2019 (38.96 feet), it is clear that the building exceeds the town’s maximum height requirements by at least 0.96 foot, and as much as 1.2 feet. In reviewing options for addressing this error, the Zoning Administrator considered the following factors, as allowed by the DSO: • Pursuant to § 7.90.10 of the DSO, multi-family and commercial buildings may increase height one (1) additional foot for each three (3) feet of additional front setba ck with a maximum height of forty (40) feet above the required base flood elevation as established by Town Code. o Conclusion: While the home at 2959 Seabrook Island Road contains a front yard setback well in excess of the required 30 feet, the property is not zoned for multi- family or commercial use. Therefore, the Zoning Administrator determined that the additional height allowance authorized by § 7.90.10 would not apply. • In addition, § 13.70.60.20 of the DSO contains the following provisions for “Building Errors:” o In the event that a building has been partially constructed in a manner that it does not comply with yard requirements applicable at the time of such constructi on, such building may be exempt from district requirements provided a reduction has been approved by the Zoning Administrator in accord with the following provisions: (a) The Zoning Administrator has determined that: (1) The error does not exceed ten (10%) percent of the measurement that is involved; (2) The noncompliance was done in good faith, or through no fault of the property owner, or was the result of an error in location of the building subsequent to the issuance of a building permit, if such was required; (3) Such reduction will not impair the purpose and intent of this Ordinance; 78 (4) The reduced yard requirement will not be detrimental to the use and enjoyment of other property in the immediate vicinity; (5) The reduced yard requirement will not create an unsafe condition with respect to both other property and public streets; (6) To force compliance with the minimum yard requirements would cause unreasonable hardship upon the owner; and (7) The reduction will not result in an increase in density or floor area ratio from that permitted by the applicable zoning district regulation. (b) In approving such a reduction under the provision of this Section, the Zoning Administrator has allowed only a reduction necessary to provide reasonable relief and, as deemed available, and prescribed such conditions, to include landscaping and screening measures to assure compliance with the intent of this Ordinance. (c) The Zoning Administrator shall not have waived or modified the standards necessary for approval specified in this Section. (d) If there is an error greater than ten (10%) percent of the measurement that is involved, the property owners shall have obtained a variance from the Board of Zoning Appeals. o Conclusion: While the non-conforming height at 2959 Seabrook Island Road is less than 10% and appears to have been the result of a good faith error through no fault of the property owner , the provisions of § 13.70.60.20 deal explicitly with “yards.” Therefore, i t was the opinion of the Zoning Administrator that § 13.70.60.20 was intended to authorize “ de minimus ” encroachments into the required setbacks, but that such modifications would not be applicable to buildings which exceed the maximum height requirement. Absent any administrative remedies, the builder was advised to either modify the home to bring it into conformity with the town’s maximum height requirement, or to submit a variance application for consideration by the Board of Zoning Appeals. The applicant has elected to pursue the latter. The property is currently zoned SR Single -Family Residential, and a single -family residence is a permitted use by-right at this location. With the exception of the aforementioned building height, the structure at 2959 Seabrook Island Road will meet or exceed all other requirements of the DSO: TYPE REQUIRED PER DSO DSO REFERENCE Front (Principal Structure) 30 feet § 7.60.20.10 Side (Conforming Lot) 15 feet § 7.60.20.20 Rear (Principal Structure) 25 feet § 7.60.20.30 Rear (Deck/Open Space Lot) 15 feet § 7.60.50 Driveway (Conforming Lot) 6 feet § 7.60.70.10 Building Height 36 feet above BFE + FB (Nonconforming) § 7.90.20 Therefore, the applicants are requesting a variance from the DSO to allow for the following modification: 79 TYPE REQUIRED PER DSO VARIANCE (REQUESTED) Building Height 36 feet above Base Flood Elevation + Freeboard Allow the building height to exceed the maximum allowed by up to 1.2 feet In their application, the applicants have stated that bringing the house into conformity would result in an unnecessary hardship. They argue that the combination of the ARC ’s request to elevate the foundation, as well as a building error in the field which was not discovered until the house was fully framed, both contributed to the structure ’s current non -conforming height. The applicants further state that modifying the pitch of the roof to conform with the maximum height requirement would result in a structure which looks out of character with other homes in the vicinity, and that the front yard setback (approximately 57 feet) significantly exceeds the 30 -foot front yard setback required by the town’s DSO. Staff Comments As a matter of practice, the town’s Zoning Administrator does not typically provide a recommendation in favor of – or in opposition to – a variance application. In our opinion, t hese requests are best left to the Board of Zoning Appeals following a thoroug h review of the relevant facts, including the receipt of testimony from interested parties during the required public hearing. In granting a variance, state law permits the Board of Zoning Appeals to attach such conditions as the Board may consider advis able to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. Should the Board vote to approve the variance request, staff would recommend in favor of attaching the following conditions: • The approved variance shall apply to the building elevation as presented by the applicant and reviewed by the Board on January 29, 2019 . Any modification to this building elevation prior to the issuance of an amended zoning permit and/or certificate of occupancy , with the exception of minor corrections and/or modifications which conform to the requirements of the town’s DSO, shall require further review and approval by the Board of Zoning Appeals. • If the existing building permi t for 2959 Seabrook Island Road expires prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, or prior to the granting of an extension pursuant to § 7.90.20 of the DSO, a variance authorizing the structure to exceed the maximum height shall terminate upon expiration of the existing building permit. Respectfully submitted, Joseph M. Cronin Town Administrator/Zoning Administrator 80 Criteria for Review Pursuant to Section 6-29-800(A)(2) of the SC Code of Laws, the Board of Zoning Appeals has the power to hear and decide appeals for variance from the requirements of the zoning ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the board makes and explains in writing the following findings: (a) there are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; (b) these conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; (c) because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and (d) the authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. The board may not grant a variance, the effect of which would be to allow the establishment of a use not otherwise permitted in a zoning district, to extend physically a nonconforming use of land or to change the zoning district boundaries shown on the official zoning map. The fact that property may be utilized more profitably, if a variance is granted, may not be considered grounds for a variance. Other requirements may be prescribed by the zoning ordinance. In granting a variance, the board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. 81 Attachments The following supplemental items have been attached for review: Application & Property Information 1 Variance Application p. 83-86 2 Zoning Permit (March 2018) p. 87-88 3 Approved Building Plans (March 2018) p. 89-104 4 Approved Site Plan (March 2018) p. 105-106 5 Elevation Certificate (October 2018) p. 107-113 6 Foundation Survey (December 2018) p. 114-115 7 Certification of Height (December 2018) p. 116-117 8 Certification of Height (January 2019) p. 118-119 9 Property Photos p. 120-124 10 Zoning Map p. 125-126 11 Aerial Image p. 127-128 12 FEMA Base Flood Elevations (Current & Preliminary) p. 129-130 13 Title to Real Estate p. 131-136 14 Property Information Card p. 137-138 15 Public Hearing Notice – List of Neighboring Property Owners p. 139-140 16 Public Hearing Notice – U.S.P.S. Certified Mail Receipts p. 141-143 17 Public Hearing Notice – Post and Courier Legal Ad p. 144-145 18 Public Hearing Notice – Property Posting p. 146-147 19 Communication from Lynda Stearns to Galloway Homes p. 148-151 20 Communication from Joe Cronin to Galloway Homes p. 152-154 21 Communication between BOZA, Joe Cronin & SIPOA/ARC p. 155-157 Other Information 22 Height Certificates & Photos of Neighboring Properties a) 2962 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 3, Block 38) p. 158-160 b) 2960 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 4, Block 38) p. 161-163 c) 2958 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 5, Block 38) p. 164-166 d) 2956 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 6, Block 38) p. 167-169 e) 2963 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 12, Block 42) p. 170-171 f) 2961 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 12-A, Block 42) p. 172-174 g) 2957 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 12-C, Block 42) p. 175-177 h) 2955 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 12-D, Block 42) p. 178-180 Written Correspondence Regarding the Proposed Variance Request 23 Letter from Jean & Kevin Dunn (Jan. 08, 2019) p. 181-182 24 Letter from Julie McCulloch (Jan. 22, 2019) p. 183-184 82 ATTACHMENT #1 Variance Application 83 84 85 86 ATTACHMENT #2 Zoning Permit (March 2018) 87 88 ATTACHMENT #3 Approved Building Plans (March 2018) 89 3 4 TV GFI WP WP GFI SD CO/SD '83/(;287/(7 *),287/(7 5$1*('5<(59287/(7 :$7(53522)287/(7 :$7(53522) *),287/(7 &$79 7(/(9,6,21 287/(7 6,1*/(32/(6:,7&+ 7+5((:$<6:,7&+ )285:$<6:,7&+ &(,/,1*)$1 &(,/,1*685)$&(02817/,*+7 5(&(66('&$1/,*+7 :$//6&21&( :$//685)$&(02817/,*+7 &$5%210212;,'( 602.('(7(&725 602.('(7(&725 (;+$867)$1 (/(&75,&$/3$1(/ ',5(&7:,5($33/,$1&(&211(&7,21 6:,7&+(6 287/(76 /,*+7),;785(6 0,6&),;785(6 (/(&75,&$/ /(*(1' )/22'/,*+7 )/225287/(7 *$5$*(287/(7 Residence Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R 1/16/2018 12:58:57 PM Hamilton 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC 1-CS Cover Sheet CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 6+((7/,67 &6 &RYHU6KHHW  *URXQG)ORRU  )LUVW)ORRU  6HFRQG)ORRU  *URXQG)ORRU(OHFW  )LUVW)ORRU(OHFW  6HFRQG)ORRU(OHFW  5RRI3ODQ  )URQW(OHYDWLRQ  /HIW(OHYDWLRQ  5LJKW(OHYDWLRQ  5HDU(OHYDWLRQ  '9LHZV  6HFWLRQ  6HFWLRQ'HWDLOV  6LWH3ODQ *(1(5$/127(6  0$,1+286(:$//6(;7(5,2572%(; 812  *$5$*(:$//672%(3,(56 /289(56 812  ,17(5,25:$//672%(; 812  *$5$*(3/$7(+(,*+772%(   ),567)/2253/$7(+(,*+7672%(   6(&21')/2253/$7(+(,*+772%(  812  6&5((1('325&+522)3/$7(+(,*+772%(   38//(')5207232)),567)/5  )5217325&+3/$7(+(,*+772%(  38//(' )5207232)),567)/5  5$,6(+((/$61(('('720$7&+($9(63(5 (/(9$7,216  6(((1*,1((5,1*2575866/$<287)25$//)/225 &(,/,1*-2,676,=(6$1'63$&,1*+($'(5 %($0 6,=(6  $///,1(1&/26(7672+$9(6+(/9(625 '((3$663(&,),('  3$175<72+$9(6+(/9(6'((3  9(5,)<5(48,5('(*5(66:,1'2:60((7(*5(66 ::,1'2:0$18)$&785(5&$6(0(1760$<1((' (*5(66+$5':$5(  $1<522)+$9,1*$522)3,7&+25/(6672 +$9(/$<(562)522),1*)(/7,167$//('  &$%,1(7%/2&.,1*;&(17(5('21$//&$%,1(7 :$//6)5$0('#2&#$)) &$%,1(7+(,*+76$7+,*+72+$9(%/2&.,1* &$%,1(7+(,*+76$7+,*+72+$9(%/2&.,1* ,167$//%/2&.,1*)25&$%,1(7$%29( 5()5,*(5$725  :,1'2:6 '225*/$668)$&72572%($0$;2)  )25,03$&7  */$=(')(1(675$7,216+*&5$7,1*72%($0$; 2)  &(,/,1*,168/$7,2172%(5  :$//,168/$7,2172%($5  )/225,168/$7,2172%($5  $//'22567+$7$5(127',0(16,21('727+( &(17(5/,1($5((,7+(5&(17(5('252)) 1($5(67:$//  3529,'(678'&/867(56#(1'62)($&+%($0  3529,'(),5(%/2&.,1*$7$//&+$6(63(5,5&  6($/$//3(1(75$7,216)520*5281')/22572 +$%,7$%/(63$&($%29(Z),5(5$7('&$8/.  3529,'(7<3(;*<368021*5281')/225 &(,/,1*)25),5(%/2&.,1*72),567)/225  '8&76,1$77,&72+$9(5,168/'8&76 (/6(:+(5(72+$9(5,168/  +9$&6<67(03,3,1*72+$9(5,168/  0$;5,6(5+(,*+7,60,175($''(37+,6  :$7(5+($7(57<3($1'/2&$7,213(5 +20(2:1(5  $//%$51'22523(1,1*672%(/(667+$1'225 :,'7+ (/(&75,&$/127(6  $//%('5220602.('(7(&725672%(:$// 02817('$1'&(17(5('%(7:((1'225+($'(5$1' &(,/,1*81,7672%(,17(5&211(&7(' &$1%( :,5(/(66,17(5&211(&7('  ),(/'9(5,)</2&$7,212)7(/(9,6,21-$&.6$1' 3+21(-$&.6:,7+2:1(535,2572,167$//$7,21  (/(&75,&$/3$1(/72%(/2&$7('%<(/(&75,&,$1  (/(&75,&$/&2175$&72572,167$//$8//,67(' ',5(&7%85,$/&/$03 2('% 2172&217)7* 67((/Z&233(5*5281'  (/(&75,&$/&2175$&72572,167$//287/(7  ',6&211(&7,1$77,&)25$+8287/(772%( :,7+,12)81,7  $//9$03$1'$03287/(766+$//%(7$03(5 5(6,67$175(&(37$&/(63(51(&  3529,'(+,*+()),&,(1&</$03,1*)25$7/($67 2)/,*+7,1*),;785(6  $//9$03$03&,5&8,76,1$//522066+$// %(3527(&7('%<$/,67('&20%,1$7,217<3($)&, '(9,&((;&(37.,7&+(1%$7+52202876,'( 5(&(37$&/(6%$6(0(172563(&,$/'(',&$7(' &,5&8,763(51(& %  67$1'$5'(/(&75,&$/),;785(672%( $%29(%)(  )25&+$5/(6721&2817<  $//(/(&75,&$//2&$7('%(/2:)/22'(/(9$7,2172 &203/<:,7+5,17+(,5&257+( $33/,&$%/(&2'(,17+(1(&:+,&+(9(5 683(5&('(6  9(5,)<7<3( /2&$7,212):$7(5+($7(5 ,167$// 1(&(66$5<(/(&&20321(176 648$5()227$*( 1DPH +($7(' 64)7* 81+($7(' 64)7* 727$/81'(5 522) )LUVW)ORRU 6) 6) 6HFRQG)ORRU 6) 6) *URXQG)ORRU 6) 6) )URQW3RUFK 6) 6) 6FUHHQHG3RUFK 6) 6) 727$/64)7* 6) 6) 6) '(6,*1&5,7(5,$  6725<6,1*/()$0,/<5(6,'(17,$/6758&785(  /2&$7(',17+(&,7<2)6($%522.,6/$1'  3523(57<,6/2&$7(',1$1$()/22'=21(  6(()5217(/(9$7,216+((7)25%8,/',1*+(,*+7  3/$1672&203/<:,7+,5&,)*& ,)&Z6& 02',),&$7,216  3/$1672&203/<:,7+,3& ,0&  3/$1672&203/<:,7+,(&&  3/$1672&203/<:,7+1(& 522)9(17,1*&$/&6 VIRIDWWLFVSDFH  VI UHTXLUHGYHQWLODWLRQ [ VTLQFKHV UHTXLUHGYHQWLODWLRQ VTLQFKHVRIULGJHYHQWUHTXLUHG ,QVWDOODPLQLPXPRI/LQHDU)WRI9HQWXUL9HQW3OXVULGJHYHQWWKLVZLOOSURYLGH VTLQFKHVRIYHQWLODWLRQ VTLQFKHVRIYHQWHGVRIILWUHTXLUHG,QVWDOODPLQLPXPRI/LQHDU)WRIKDUGL YHQWHGVRIILWWKLVZLOOSURYLGHVTLQFKHVRIYHQWLODWLRQ$GGLWLRQDOO\LQVWDOO   URXQGVRIILWYHQWV7KLVZLOOSURYLGHDWRWDORIVTLQFKHVRIYHQWLODWLRQ )281'$7,219(17,1*&$/&6 VTXDUHLQFKRIYHQWLODWLRQSHUVTXDUHIRRWRIIORRUVSDFH /RXYHUHGYHQWVSURYLGHVIRIYHQWLODWLRQSHUOLQHDUIRRW VIRIJURXQGIORRUVSDFH DSSUR[OLQHDUIHHWRIORXYHUHGYHQWV WKLVZLOOSURYLGHVTLQFKHVRIYHQWLODWLRQ 6)*ULOOLQJ'HFN FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION (/6(/6/6666(/6/6(/666(/66/666(/66////(////(((((((((( (:+(:+++(:+(:+(:++++(:++(:+(:+(:+(:++(:+:++++(:+(:+:+++:::::::::((((((( (5((5((5((5((5((((5((5((5((555555(55(5(55(5(5555555(((((((((((((( 7272727272722227272227272222222222277777777777 +$+$$$$+$+$$+$++++++++++++++++ 9(9(9((((((((((((((((((((((5555555555555555555555555555 ,16,16,1616616,166,16661661666161666,166166666611111111111111 8/8//8/8/8/8/8/8/8/8/8//8///8/////8888888888 +++ ++ +++ +++++++ +++ + +++++ + 9$&&9$&9$&$&9$&$&9$&9$&9$&9$&9$&9$&9$&9$&9$&&&9$&&&&9$&&&9$&9$&&9$&&&&&9$&9$&9$&9$&&9$&&9$&&9$&$&$&$&9$$$9$999999999999999999999 6<6<6<6<6<6<6<<6<<6<6<<6<6<<6<6<6<6<6<<6<6<6<<<<<<<<6<<6<<6<<<<<6<<<<<<<<<<<<6<6<<6<666666666666666666666 67(67(67(67(67(67((67(67(67(67(67(((67(67(67(7(67((67((((((67((6767((((67(67((67((67(6776766777767676776777677767767666666666666666666666 03303330303033030330303330333333303033303333003330303333333303000000000000000 ,3,3,,3,,3,,3,,3,3,3,,3,,3,,3,3,,3,3,3333333333333333333333333333333333,,,,,,,,,,,,, 1*1*1*1*1*1*1*1**1*1**1******1***1*********1*1*1**1*****1****1*1*11111111111111 727272272727272222272727227227227272727272722727222722272222722722227272722227222222222272272777777777777777777777777777777777 +$9+$9+$9$9+$9$9+$9+$9$9+$9+$9+$9+$9$999+$99+$99+$99$9$9+$9+$99$9+$99999+$9+$9999+$99$9$99$99$9+$9+$9+$9$99$9$9$9$9+$9+$9$$+$$$$+$$$+$$$$$$$$$$$+$$$$+$$$$$$$+$+++++++++++++++ (5(5(5(5(5(55(5(5555(5555555(555(5(555(555(5(5(55555(555(5(5(5(5(55555(5(5(5(55(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 16816816816816868688881681681688816816816868816868168881688888866611661661616666661666166616666611111111111111111111 ////////////////////////  0 $;5,6(5+(,*+7,6 0,175($''(37+,6  ::: :: :::::: :::::: :::: ::: ::: :::::::::::::::::::: ::::::::: :::::::::::::::::::::: ::::: ::::::: :::: :::::: ::: :::::::::::: $7($7($7($7((7((7($7(($7(($7(((7(7((7(((($7(($7(($7($7(((($7($7($7($7(((($7((($7(($7($7(($7(($7(7(((7($7((((((((($7((7($7(($7($7((7($7(((((($7($7((7($7$7$7$7$7$7777$7777$77777$7$77$7$77777$7777$7$777777$77777777$77777777$7$7$7$7$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+5+5+5+5+5++++5+55555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 ($7(57<3((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((3((($1''$1'$1'''''''''''$1''''''''''''''''''$$ /2//////////////// &$7$7$7$77$77$7$777$77$7777$7777$7777$7777777$7$7$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ,21,2222222,2,2,22222,22,2,22222,22,222,2,2,222,2,22222222,2,,,, 3(5 +20+2000+2000+200000020+200020000200200020000+20+2000+20+2000+2020+20+20+2002002+20000+200200020+200+22+22222+2+222222222+2+22+2222+22222222+2+2222222222+++++++++++++ (2:(2:2:2::::::(2:(2:2::2:::(2:::::::2:2::::2::2:2:::2::2:(2::(2:(2:(2:2::2:2:2::2::2:2:2:2:(2:2:::2:::2:2:::2:2::::2:2:2:::2:::::222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222(2222222(222222222222222222222(22222222(((((( 1(5 $$ $$ $$$ $$$$$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$ ///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// %$5%$5%$55%$5%$5%$5$55$5555%$555%$5$55$5$5$55%$5%$5%$55$5%$5$%$5$555%$555% 5$5$55$5$5%$55%$55555%$55%$55%$5%$5%$555%$5%$5%$55555%$5%$5$55%$55555$5$555555%$55555$$$$$$$%$$$$$%$%$$$$$$%$$$$$$%$%$%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$%$%$$$%$%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 1'1111111111111111111111 225255252255525522222222222222 23232323233232332333233332332333332323233333332333333332332323333233333333333332222222222222222222222222222222222222222 (1,(1,(1,(1,1,1,1,1,(1,1,(1,(1,,,(1,(1,,(1,,,1,,1,(1,,(1(1(1(1(1(11111111111(1111(111111(1111(11(111111(111(11(111(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( 1*61*6*66*66*6*6*66*61*666666661*661*6661*666*61*66661*61*61*66661*61*61*6661*661*661*6*61*6*661*6*661*6666*61*6666661*61*66661*66661**1***1*******************1*1**********1*******1**1*******11111111111111111111111111111111111111111 72727227272272722222272272227227272222722222272222222222222222222222272222227222222227277777777777777777777777777777777 %(%(%((%(%(%(%(%(%(%(%((((%((%(((%((%((((%((%(((%(((%(((%(((((((%((%(%((((((%%%%%%%%%%%  /(/(/(/((((((/(/((((((((/(((/(/(/((/(/((/(/(/(((((/((/((((((((((((/(((/(/((/(/(/((/((//////////////////////////////////////// 66666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666 7+$+$$+$7+$+$++++++++++77777777777777777777777777777 1'1'1'1'1'1'1'111 225222222222222 ':,'':,':,':,'':,':,'':,','''':,':,':,'''''':,':,':,':,'':,':,':,':,''':,':,'''''':,','':,''':,''''':,':,'''':,':,':,':,':,'':,'','':,':,':,':,':,':,':,''''',''':,'''',':,':,':,'''':,':,'''''':,'':,:,:,:,,:,,,,:,,,:,,:,:,,,,,,,,,,,,,,:,:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: 7+7++7+7+7+++7++++7+7+++7+++7++++++++++++++77777777777777777777777 90 83 83 3 2 1 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 +% +% +% +,1*('/289(56 1 5.10   &RQFUHWH *DUDJH                                                                              3 0 6 8 2 8 6 8 6725$*(%(/2:67$,56 (/(9$725 3,(5:678&&2),1,6+7<3 75[:DOO 7\SZKHUHVKRZQ 6HH/RXYHU'HWDLO RQ3J 6(((1*,1((5,1*)253,(53,/,1*3/$&(0(17(1*29(55,'(6$5&+,7(&785$/6 $//:22'0$7(5,$/ $%29(%)($1'%(/2:72%(35(6685(75($7(' '((3(/(93,7 9(5,)<6,=( 63(&6Z0$18 (/(9$72572%(,167$//(',1 $&&25'$1&(Z$60($ 6/23( 6/23( 6/23( 3 0 6 8 751(:(/32677<3 75+,*+5$,/,1* :75;3,&.(76  ; 29(5+($' *$5$*('225  ; 29(5+($' *$5$*('225  ; 29(5+($' *$5$*('225             +9$&67$71'72%(/2&$7(' $0,12) $%9%)( 751(:(/32677<3 75+,*+5$,/,1* :75;3,&.(76 7<36(7%$&.)25 /289(56 %5($. $:$<:$//6 2 5.11            /,1(2):$//$%9  &OJ+JW &RQFUHWH *UDYHO +,1*('/289(5 75[:DOO 7\SZKHUHVKRZQ 75[:DOO 7\SZKHUHVKRZQ        +,1*('/289(5 *UDYHO %HORZ /) /) /) /) /) /) /)/)/)/) /) /) /) /) /) /) /) Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:58:58 PM 1.10 Ground Floor CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 Ground Floor )5217 5($5 91 83 '1 '1 3 2 1 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 16 15 14 3GU Laundry/Pantry Master Suite 15'-1" x 15'-10" Breakfast 12'-1" X 12'-0" Study 11'-8" x 12'-7"Foyer &RYHUHG)URQW 3RUFK 3DVV7KUX /RFDWHG)OXVK Z&RXQWHUWRS *ULOOLQJ'HFN       3$175< &$% ':     %XLOWLQV :HW%DU '(*5(( (175<(/(9$725   %DVH&DELQHWV %DVH&DELQHWV 'HHSEDVHFDE ZFRXQWHUWRSKJWWR PDWFKSDQWU\ 9$8/7 9$8/7 (1*,1((5723529,'($'',7,21$/ 6833257)25+2778%21325&+ (1*,1((5723529,'($'',7,21$/ 6833257,1&(,/,1*6758&785( )25$&$52/,1$6:,1*%(' 1 5.10                                                                                                                                    6FUHHQHG3RUFK                                           )5((67$1',1* 78%   9DXOWHG&OJ         :& 9$1,7< ; -$&.6 -$&.6 ;6&5((1'225 7532677<3 HDR @ 2860 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2860 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2860 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2860 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2850 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2850 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2850 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2850 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2850 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 5060 8'-3" PICT. HDR @ 2060 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2060 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 5060 8'-3" PICT. HDR @ 2860 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2860 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2860 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2860 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 5050 8'-3" PICT. HDR @ 2860 8'-3" D.H. HDR @ 2850 8'-3" D.H. 325&+%($063(& ' %<(1*,1((5 75%2;(' &2/801 75+,*+5$,/,1* :75;3,&.(76     751(:(/3267 751(:(/3267 $/(;$1'5,$/79*5229(' 3$1(/$5&+723 '523  &OJ+JW  &OJ+JW  &OJ+JW  [ 48$'6/,'(5)8///,7( )8///,7( '523 75%2;(' &2/801 &OJ+JW 325&+%($063(& ' %<(1*,1((5 75+,*+5$,/,1* :75;3,&.(76 6((%5$&.(7522)'(7$,/ 213* ;:$// ;:$// ;:$//  ; ,VODQG 678%83;:$//)25(/(&7 :$7(5 :$67( ;:$//72%($)) *$651$*( Z+22'$%9 )5,'*(: '((3 &$%$%9 '523 (*5(66                 ;:$//    &2  %$51'225  3NW  '%/%$51'225  3NW 2 4 8 0 2 6 8 0 2 4 8 0 3 0 8 0 2 8 8 0  3NW :& 9$1,7< : '   Family Room 18'-6" X 22'-11"   6WRU\&OJ+JW :22'%851,1*),5(3/$&( :5$,6('+($57+    &OJ+JW  &OJ+JW .LWFKHQ 0%DWK 0:LF /,1(2))/225$%9         +,*++$/):$// :*/$66$%9 2 5.11 /,1(2):$//$%9 /,1(2)6(&21' )/225$%9 :$//&$%6&RDW   6+(/9(6 7(03   3529,'(81'(5&2817(5 6833257             6+(/9(6 %$6(&$% 7(03 7(03  3/$7(+*7 213(5,0(7(5:$//6   +% Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:58:59 PM 1.11 First Floor CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 1st Floor )5217 5($5 92 '1 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 23(172 %(/2: /,1(1 ; '(*5(( (175<(/(9$725 Bed 2 11'-8" x 12'-7" Bed 3 15'-1" x 13'-0" Bed 4 12'-3" x 13'-0" 1 5.10                                     :&                                                                                              75$',7,21$/ 23(15$,/,1*                                    9$1,7< &+$6( :LF 7UH\&OJ 7UH\&OJ 7UH\&OJ 75$',7,21$/5$,/ 1(:(/3267  '%/  '%/  3NW  3NW 3 0 6 8 2 6 6 82 6 6 8 2 6 6 8 2 4 6 8 2 6 6 8 2 6 6 8 2 4 6 8 HDR @ 2860 7'-11" D.H. HDR @ 2860 7'-11" D.H. HDR @ 2860 7'-11" D.H. HDR @ 2860 7'-11" D.H. HDR @ 2860 7'-11" D.H. HDR @ 2850 7'-10" D.H. HDR @ 2850 7'-11" D.H. HDR @ 2840 7'-11" PICT. HDR @ 2840 7'-11" PICT. HDR @ 2840 7'-11" PICT. HDR @ 2840 7'-11" PICT. HDR @ 2860 7'-11" D.H. HDR @ 2860 7'-11" D.H. HDR @ 2860 7'-11" D.H. HDR @ 2840 7'-11" PICT. HDR @ 2840 7'-11" PICT. HDR @ 2840 7'-11" PICT. HDR @ 2840 7'-11" PICT. HDR @ 4046 7'-11" PICT. HDR @ 2846 7'-11" CSMT. HDR @ 2846 7'-11" CSMT. HDR @ 2860 7'-11" PICT. -$&.6                               :LF &+$6(   :& 9$1,7<  78%6+2:(5   )8//+*7 :$// )8//+*7:$// (*5(66 (*5(66 (*5(66   /,1(2):$//6%(/2: /,1(2):$//6%(/2: /,1(2):$//6%(/2: 2 5.11 '523'2:1 67$,5672$77,&/RIW 7(03(/,37,&$/:,1$%9 7(03 7(03 7(03 Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:00 PM 1.12 Second Floor CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 2nd Floor )5217 5($5 93 83 83 3 4 4 4 4 GFI WP GFI WP GFI WP GFI WP GFI WP +% +% +% +,1*('/289(56 *DUDJH 6725$*(%(/2:67$,56 (/(9$725 6((&6)25(/(&75,&$/ /(*(1'.(< 72/,*+7 $%29(  *), :3 *), :3 *), :3 *), :3 6725$*(/,*+7 6((0$1863(& 6 )25(/(&75,&$/ 726:,7&+#)5217'225 Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:00 PM 2.10 Ground Floor Elect. CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 Ground Floor Electrical )5217 5($5 94 83 '1 '1 3 4 4 GFI WP GFI WP 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 3 3 4 3 3 4 3 4 43 3 GFI GFI GFI GFI GFI GFI GFI GFIGFI GFIGFIGFIGFI GFI GFI 4 3 3 GFI WP GFI WP GFI 3GU Master Suite Breakfast Study Foyer &RYHUHG)URQW 3RUFK *ULOOLQJ'HFN %XLOWLQV :HW%DU '(*5(( (175<(/(9$725 6FUHHQHG3RUFK : ' Family Room .LWFKHQ 0%DWK 0:LF 72/,*+76 $%29( 72)$16 $%29( 72/,*+7 %(/2: 72/,*+7 $%29( SD SD CO/SD /DXQGU\3DQWU\ 72',6326$/ :3 :3 81'(5&$%,1(7 /,*+7,1* 72/,*+76 $%29( 287/(772 +22'$%9 *), *), *), *),)25':                   &225',1$7(+*7 :+20(2:1(5 &+$1'(/,(5 6((&6)25(/(&75,&$/ /(*(1'.(<     3$175< &$% #             72/,*+7629(5*$5$*('2256 Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:01 PM 2.11 First Floor Elect. CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 1st Floor Electrical )5217 5($5 95 '1 3 3 3 3 GFI GFI 3 4 4 4 4 4 GFI /,1(1 '(*5(( (175<(/(9$725 Bed 2 Bed 3 Bed 4 :LF :LF 726:,7&+%(/2: 726:,7&+ %(/2: 726:,7&+ %(/2: :3   72/,*+7 %(/2: :3 SD SD SD CO/SD 6((&6)25(/(&75,&$/ /(*(1'.(< 3529,'(/,*+7 6:,7&+)25$$                      Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:01 PM 2.12 Second Floor Elect. CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 2nd Floor Electrical )5217 5($5 96 0(7$/522)         &5,&.(7                       1 5.10 0(7$/6+('522)%(/2: &+,01(<&$3  5,'*(:9(17 3529,'(5$,1*877(5',9(57(5+(5( 3529,'(5$,1*877(5',9(57(5+(5( 3529,'(5$,1*877(5',9(57(5+(5( *$%/((1' 9$//(< 9$//(< 5,'*(:9(17 5,'*(:9(17 *$%/((1' *$%/((1' 9$//(< 5,'*(:9(17 *$%/((1'    2 5.11 3529,'(5$,1*877(5',9(57(5+(5( Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:01 PM 3.10 Roof Plan CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 Roof Plan )5217 5($5 97 Ground Floor 1st Floor 2nd Floor 1st Floor Plate Hgt 2nd Floor Plate Hgt Hdr. Hgt. Hdr Hgt.          %XLOGLQJ3DG# *DUDJH6ODE# BFE = AE13 Design Flood @ 15'      ',67$1&(2)7232)),567 )/225$%29('(6,*1)/22' 5$,6('+((/             0(7$/522)   &+,01(<72%(¶+,*+(57+$1 &/26(675,'*(¶$:$< $5&+,7(&785$/6+,1*/(6 522)%(<21' ´75&251(5%2$5'7<3 6((:,1'2:75,0'(7$,/21 23(5$%/(/289(5('6+877(5Z'$:*67<3 ´+,*+75[+$1'5$,/Z75[3,&.(76 522)%(<21' ´75%2;('&2/801 /289(56(('(7$,/21 ´%$1'%2$5'Z'5,3&$3 ´75)$6&,$7<3 ´75)5,(=(7<3 +$5',(/$36,',1* ´5(9($/7<3 :+(5(6+2:1 +$5',(%2$5' %$77(1 ´%$77(163$&,1* 7$%%<29(5&083,(56 7$%%<&+,01(< 0(7$/&+,01(<&$3 +9$&3/$7)250 %8,/'$0,12) ¶$%29(%)( (//,37,&$/     &+,01(<%(<21' 751(:(/3267 325&+%($063(& '%<(1*,1((5 6((63(& 6)25/,*+7 7532677<3   6((%5$&.(7522)'(7$,/ 213*         3,(5%(<21' 75,07<3 Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:02 PM 4.10 Front Elevation CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 Front Elevation 98 Ground Floor 1st Floor Ground Floor Plate Hgt 2nd Floor 23(1              5$,6('+((/ 0(7$/522) $5&+,7(&785$/6+,1*/(6 ´75&251(5%2$5' 6((:,1'2:75,0'(7$,/21 ´+,*+75[+$1'5$,/Z 75[3,&.(76 ´75%2;('&2/801 /289(56(('(7$,/21 ´%$1'%2$5'Z'5,3&$3 ´75)$6&,$7<3 ´75)5,(=(7<3 +$5',(/$36,',1* ´5(9($/7<3 :+(5(6+2:1 7$%%<29(5&083,(56 751(:(/3267 325&+%($063(& '%<(1*,1((5 6((%5$&.(7522)'(7$,/ 213* ´%$1'%2$5'Z'5,3&$3 &+,01(<72%(¶+,*+(57+$1 &/26(675,'*(¶$:$< 7$%%<&+,01(< 0(7$/&+,01(<&$3 &5,&.(7 +$5',(%2$5' %$77(1 ´%$77(163$&,1* ´%$1'%2$5'Z'5,3&$3 ´+,*+75[+$1'5$,/Z 75[3,&.(76 751(:(/3267         522)6/23( $5&+6+,1*/(6     75,07<3 Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:03 PM 4.11 Left Elevation CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 Left Elevation 99 Ground Floor 1st Floor Ground Floor Plate Hgt 2nd Floor 1st Floor Plate Hgt 2nd Floor Plate Hgt Hdr. Hgt. Hdr Hgt. 23(1              +9$&3/$7)250 %8,/'$0,12) ¶$%29(%)( 7532677<3 $5&+,7(&785$/6+,1*/(6 ´75&251(5%2$5' 6((:,1'2:75,0'(7$,/21 ´+,*+75[+$1'5$,/Z 75[3,&.(76 ´75%2;('&2/801 /289(56(('(7$,/21 ´75)$6&,$7<3 ´75)5,(=(7<3 +$5',(/$36,',1* ´5(9($/7<3 :+(5(6+2:1 7$%%<29(5&083,(56 751(:(/3267 325&+%($063(& '%<(1*,1((5 ´%$1'%2$5'Z'5,3&$3 +$5',(%2$5' %$77(1 ´%$77(163$&,1* ´%$1'%2$5'Z'5,3&$3 ´+,*+75[+$1'5$,/Z 75[3,&.(76 0(7$/522)         ´%$1'%2$5'Z'5,3&$3 ´75%2;('&2/801 325&+%($063(& '%<(1*,1((5 &+,01(<72%(¶+,*+(57+$1 &/26(675,'*(¶$:$< 7$%%<&+,01(< 0(7$/&+,01(<&$3 &5,&.(7 5$,6('+((/ Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:03 PM 4.12 Right Elevation CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 Right Elevation 100 Ground Floor 1st Floor Ground Floor Plate Hgt 2nd Floor 1st Floor Plate Hgt 2nd Floor Plate Hgt Hdr. Hgt. Hdr Hgt.               +9$&3/$7)250 %8,/'$0,12) ¶$%29(%)( 7532677<3 $5&+,7(&785$/6+,1*/(6 ´75&251(5%2$5' 6((:,1'2:75,0'(7$,/21 ´%$1'%2$5'Z'5,3&$3 ´+,*+75[+$1'5$,/Z 75[3,&.(76 ´%$1'%2$5'Z'5,3&$3 &+,01(<72%(¶+,*+(57+$1 &/26(675,'*(¶$:$< 7$%%<&+,01(< 0(7$/&+,01(<&$3 6((%5$&.(7522)'(7$,/ 213* ´75)$6&,$7<3 ´75)5,(=(7<3 /289(56(('(7$,/217$%%<29(5&083,(56751(:(/3267 +$5',(/$36,',1* ´5(9($/7<3:+(5(6+2:1 ´75%2;('&2/801 325&+%($063(& ' %<(1*,1((5          Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:04 PM 4.13 Rear Elevation CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 Rear Elevation 101 Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:08 PM 4.14 3D Views CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1 Front Left 2 Front Right 3 Rear Left 4 Rear Right 102 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 1 2 3 Ground Floor 1st Floor Ground Floor Plate Hgt 2nd Floor 1st Floor Plate Hgt 2nd Floor Plate Hgt Hdr. Hgt. Hdr Hgt. BFE = AE13 Design Flood @ 15'              23(1 &5,&.(7         5 5 5 6WDLUZHOO 6WDLUZHOO )R\HU %H\RQG )URQW 3RUFK .LWFKHQ)DPLO\%H\RQG%UHDNIDVW 6FUHHQHG 3RUFK *DUDJH *DUDJH %HG %HG *ULOOLQJ 'HFN &+,01(<72%(¶+,*+(57+$1 &/26(675,'*(¶$:$< 7$%%<&+,01(< 0(7$/&+,01(<&$3 75(<&OJ&217,182867+(50$/ $,5%$55,(5 Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:09 PM 5.10 Section CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"1 Section 1 $'',7,21$/,(&&&203/,$1&(,1)250$7,21 35(6&5,37,9(0(7+2'2),(&&&203/,$1&(72%(86(' 6((6(&7,21217+,66+((7)25'(6&5,37,212)59$/8(6$1'&217,18286$,5 7+(50$/%$55,(5 $%/2:(57(67:,//%(3(5)250(' 6((,(&&&203/,$1&()250)25'8&7,1)250$7,21 :,1'2:8 6+*&)$&7256 $5(6&+(&.$1'0$18$/-:,//%(6833/,('%<7+(+20(2:1(5%8,/'(5 $77,&$&&(663$1(/66+$//+$9($335235,$7(:($7+(5675,33,1*$5281'23(1,1*$1'5,168/$7,21$%29( 103 L501 (1 HOUR): 5/8"(15.9 mm) Fire-Shield Gypsum Board applied at right angles to 2x10 wood joists 16"o.c. with 6d nails, 1-7/8" long, .0915" shank, 1/4" heads, 6"oc. Wood joists supporting 1" nominal T&G wood subfloor and 1" nominal wood finish floor, or 19/32" plywood finished floor with long edges T&G and 19/32" interior plywood with exterior glue subfloor perpendicular to joists with joints staggered. (38 mm x 89 mm)wood studs,16"o.c.(406mm). (15.9mm)Fire-Shield MR Board nailed both sides 2 x 4 5/8"(15.9mm)Fire-Shield Gypsum Wallboard or 5/8" UL DETAIL 305 (1-HOUR RATED SEPARATION WALL): SIMILAR TO UL DETAIL 522 (1-HOUR RATED FLOOR/CEILING ASSEMBLY): MAINTAIN AS COMPONENT IN ASSEMBLY NOTE: WHERE HISTORIC FLOORING PRESENT/SALVAGEABLE FLOOR/CEILING WALL RECOMMEND USE OF SOUND BATTING INSULATION @ SEPARATION ASSEMBLY - TYP. RECOMMEND USE OF SOUND BATTING INSULATION @ SEPARATION ASSEMBLY - TYP. 1-1/2" 1-1/2" GRASPABLE HANDRAIL DETAIL CIRCULAR HANDRAIL NONCIRCULAR HANDRAIL HANDRAIL WITH CIRCULAR 1-1/4" MIN/2" MAX DIA 0.01" RADIUS TR. 1x6 METAL SCREEN TO BE INSTALLED BEHIND LOUVER LOUVER CALCS: 2 1_ 2" / 6" = 42% CLEAR OPENING LOUVER DETAIL PER PLAN PER PLAN 45° 2 1/2" 2 1/2" 1 3/4" 6" SHED ROOF & BRACKET DETAIL TR. 6x6 TIMBERTR. 6x6 R5'-61__ 16" 4'-0" 21_ 2" 31_ 2" 4 121" 3" 2'-111_ 2" 3'-3" 2'-41_ 2" 3" 51_ 2 " 3" 3" TR. 2x6 RAFTER DOOR/WINDOW TRIM DETAIL 3" CROWN INSTALL STANDARD FLASHING ABOVE ALL DOORS & WINDOWS 4" FIBER CEMENT OR TR. 2x4 TRIM (ALL SIDES) SLOPED SILL 7" ),5(3527(&7,21'(7$,/ Ground Floor 1st Floor Ground Floor Plate Hgt 2nd Floor 1st Floor Plate Hgt 2nd Floor Plate Hgt Hdr. Hgt. Hdr Hgt. 522)%(<21'                  /DXQGU\3DQWU\ .LWFKHQ %UHDNIDVW %H\RQG 6WRU\2SHQ )DPLO\5RRP 6FUHHQHG 3RUFK /RIW %HG %HG %DWK:LF *DUDJH 5 5 5 3DVV7KURXJK :LF%H\RQG 75(<&OJ 3LHU%H\RQG 5 &217,182867+(50$/ $,5%$55,(5 Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: 11x17 - 1/8" = 1'-0" 22x34 - 1/4" = 1'-0" Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R FINAL FOR CONSTRUCTION 1/16/2018 12:59:10 PM 5.11 Section + Details CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1/8" = 1'-0"2 Section 2 104 ATTACHMENT #4 Approved Site Plan (March 2018) 105 8.2 8.4 7.9 7.8 9.4 8.9 8.7 7.6 8.6 7.9 8.0 7.9 7.8 8.6 9.6 8.2 8.18.2 7.87.6 8.3 6.7 7.5 7.7 6.7 7.7 7.9 7.4 7.8 7.7 6.8 7.7 6.5 6.2 7.2 7.1 7.3 7.2 7.8 7.67.4 9 9 9 9 9 9 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 88 8 8 8 8 8 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 CL 10' DIAMETER PALMETTO SHRUB CL 10' DIAMETER PALMETTO SHRUB CL 10' DIAMETER PALMETTO SHRUB 4-2 W OAK 7 PINE 3-2-1 HOLLY 349 19 W OAK 12 PALM 344 16 W OAK 9 PALM 20 PINE 16 PINE 17 PINE 335 16 W OAK 18 PINE 9 PALM 10 PALM 331 14 W OAK 10 W OAK 11 W OAK 10 PALM 22 PINE 10 PALM 20 PINE 12 PALM 23 PINE 12 PINE 8 PINE 15 PINE 17 PINE 14 PINE 13 PALM 8 PALM 8 PALM 300 14 W OAK 299 19 W OAK 12 PALM 19 PINE 11 PALM 13 PALM 21 PINE 19 PINE 10 PALM 285 6-7 L OAK 16 PINE 21 PINE 12 PALM 10 PALM280 15 L OAK 20 PINE11 PALM10 W OAK 11 PALM 274 13 W OAK 10 PALM11 PALM 28 PINE 12 PALM 264 15 W OAK 16 PINE 18 PINE 22 PINE 24 PINE 15 PINE 11 PALM 15 PINE 9 PALM 255 16 W OAK 9 PALM 253 13 W OAK 252 14 W OAK 10 W OAK 250 12 W OAK 24 PINE 248 17 W OAK 16 PINE 10 PINE 9 PALM 9 W OAK 10 PINE 12 PALM 12 PINE 17 PINE 16 PINE 14 PINE 15 PALM 10 PALM 230 24 L OAK 12 PINE 10 PALM 227 12-4 L OAK 9 PALM 17 PINE 224 17 W OAK 24 PINE 11 PALM 8 HOLLY 314 16 MAGNOLIA 14" WO 19"W O 15"LO 12"/4"LO 13"WO 16"W O 16"WO 17"WO 17"WO 19"WO 24"LO 2N D FLR W INDOW 2N D FLR W INDOW 3RD F LR W IND OW 3RD F LR W IND OW 1ST F LR WINDO W 1ST F LR WINDO W2ND F LR W IND OW 2ND F LR W IND OW 2ND F LR W IND OW LOT 12A LOT 12C SEABROOK ISLAND PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION TMS# 147-00-00-002 (LAKE) N 28° 52'54" W 100.00' S 28° 52'54" E 100.00' LOT 12B 18000 SQ. FT 0.413 ACRES AE (ELEV. 12) PROXIMATE FLOOD LINE AE (ELEV. 13) ALL CORNERS ARE 1.5" OPEN PIPE FOUND N 61° 07'06" E 180.00' S 61° 07'06" W 180.00' AE (ELEV. 12) APPROXIMATE FLOOD LINE AE (ELEV. 13) CANOPY AREA CRITICAL ROOT SYSTEM AREA MAGNETIC WM ELEC. BOX ELEC. BOX 4"CO N 61° 06'20" E 100.03' TO 3/4" OPEN PIPE FOUND *25' SETBACK* 15' SETBACK 15' SETBACK 30' BLDG. SETBACK 6 '1 6,7(3/$1)25+286(/2&$7,21385326(621/< (/(&7521,&9(56,212)6859(<3529,'('%< 7+,5'3$57<         Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Designed Exclusively for: REFER TO GRAPHIC SCALE Copyright: RTE, LLC UWH   +2//<:22'6& 2/':$6+,1*721&2856( UWH 52%(577(&.(/6$5&+,7(&7 //& UWHFNHOV#JPDLOFRP 1R 1/16/2018 12:59:10 PM 6.10 Site Plan CC1745 Hamilton 05/08/2017 2959 Seabrook Isle Rd. Seabrook, SC Hamilton 1" = 20'-0"1Site 0406080 20 GRAPHIC SCALE 106 ATTACHMENT #5 Elevation Certificate (October 2018) 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 ATTACHMENT #6 Foundation Survey (December 2018) 114 115 ATTACHMENT #7 Certification of Height (December 2018) 116 117 ATTACHMENT #8 Certification of Height (January 2019) 118 119 ATTACHMENT #9 Property Photos 120 121 122 123 124 ATTACHMENT #10 Zoning Map 125 126 ATTACHMENT #11 Aerial Image 127 128 ATTACHMENT #12 FEMA Base Flood Elevations (Current & Preliminary) 129 FEMA Base Flood Elevation (Current) AE 12/13 FEMA Base Flood Elevation (Preliminary) AE-11 130 ATTACHMENT #13 Title to Real Estate 131 132 133 134 135 136 ATTACHMENT #14 Property Information Card 137 /0 /1 /2 /3 /1 /2 /4 /0/5/6 /7 /8 /9 /10 /11 /12 /13 /14 /15 /i255 /6 /14 /17 /15 /13 /18 /19 /i255 /20 /14 /17 /13 /7 /i255 /6 /8 /9 /14 /10 /21 /15 /8 /7 /13 /13 /22 /23 /1 /1 /12 /24 /25 /24 /7 /8 /9 /10 /11 /12 /13 /14 /15 /25 /24 /14 /17 /15 /13 /18 /26 /27 /14 /28 /11 /9 /15/29/8/30 /26 /24 /14/29/1/12 /28 /24 /1 /13 /8 /31 /32 /12 /17/29/29/8/9 /18 /32 /9 /11 /22 /14 /9 /13 /32 /20 /6 /25 /6 /7 /8 /9 /26 /8 /12 /22 /33 /34 /9 /21 /15 /13 /35 /21 /11 /36 /37 /38 /9 /17 /11 /39 /9 /32 /15/29/37/13 /8 /31/40/41/42 /9 /11 /22 /14 /9 /13 /39 /13 /32 /36 /24 /37/40/43/6 /22 /8 /9 /24 /11 /10 /21 /44/40/3/45 /0 /46 /5/47 /0 /1 /0 /48 /49 /50 /51 /52 /53 /54 /55 /56 /57 /i255 /48 /56 /59 /57 /55 /60 /61 /i255 /62 /56 /59 /55 /49 /i255 /48 /50 /51 /56 /52 /63 /57 /50 /64 /65 /66 /65 /67 /68 /69 /65 /70 /i255 /72 /66 /i255 /73 /74 /75 /76 /74 /75 /77 /73 /78 /i255 /79 /80 /76 /81 /80 /79 /82 /i255 /83/84/i255/85 /86/87 /88 /89 /90 /91 /92 /89 /93 /94 /i255 /96/97/i255/98 /88 /96 /99 /100 /i255/101 /102 /93 /92 /89 /103 /104 /93 /92 /i255 /96 /97 /98 /101 /96 /99 /100 /i255/88 /104 /89 /105 /92 /102 /i255 /101 /106 /106 /89 /92 /107 /107 /i255 /97/104/93 /104 /89 /92 /108 /89 /92 /107 /109 /92 /106 /i255 /104 /107 /90 /108 /i255 /101 /107 /107 /92 /107 /107 /110 /92 /104 /89 /i255/88 /104 /94 /i255 /110 /92 /104 /89 /i255 /111 /112 /113 /111 /114 /114 /114 /114 /115 /116/i255/118 /113 /119 /113 /i255 /120 /121 /122 /123 /124 /125 /125 /126 /i255 /127 /120 /128 /122 /129 /130 /i255 /124 /130 /131 /i255 /120 /121 /122 /123 /124 /125 /125 /126 /i255 /127 /120 /128 /122 /129/130/111/132 /115 /132 /118 /114 /111/113/118 /114 /111 /133/118 /114 /111 /133 /i255 /134 /135 /89 /89 /92 /103 /93 /i255 /88 /104 /89 /105 /92 /102 /i255 /96 /103 /108 /90 /89/136/104/93 /137 /90 /103 /i255 /138/139/103/92 /89 /i255 /140/101/141/96/142 /143/138/99/i255 /144 /143 /145 /88/140/101/99 /96 /145 /i255 /144 /i255/140/101/141/96/142 /143/138/99 /146 /101 /110/141/138/99/97/i255/141 /138/139/103/92 /89 /i255 /101 /106 /106 /89 /92/107 /107/i255/147/148 /149 /i255 /144 /145 /101 /i255 /142 /101 /150 /145 /99/97/145/146 /i255 /142 /99 /i255 /144 /151/141/141/145/146 /150 /96 /142 /142 /145 /i255 /144 /134 /i255 /149 /152 /148 /153 /154 /88 /89 /90 /91 /92 /89 /93 /94 /i255 /134 /102 /104 /107 /107 /i255 /134 /90 /106 /92/i255/152/155 /156 /i255 /157 /i255 /150 /101 /134 /157 /146 /145 /144 /157 /142/138/143 /101 /105 /89 /92 /104 /158 /92/i255/159 /155 /155 /155 /155 /142 /92 /158 /104 /102 /i255/97/92/107 /105 /89 /137 /91/93 /137 /90 /103/i255/144/135 /160 /106 /137 /161 /137 /107 /137 /90 /103 /i255 /99 /104/136/92/i255 /157 /88 /101 /146 /143 /i255 /144 /145 /101 /162 /146/138/138/163/i255 /96 /144 /142 /101 /99/97/i255 /97/92/107 /105 /89 /137 /91 /93 /137 /90 /103 /i255 /157 /142/138/143/i255 /147 /149 /162 /i255 /162 /142 /163 /i255 /148 /149 /i255 /144 /137 /93 /92 /i255 /99 /104/136/92/i255 /157 /145 /164 /143 /i255 /88/102 /104 /93 /144 /135 /108 /108 /137 /165 /101 /164 /157 /156 /153 /i255 /88 /90 /102 /143/139/91/i255 /155 /155 /152 /i255 /140/137/107 /93 /90 /89 /137 /105 /i255 /96 /103 /108 /90 /89/136/104/93 /137 /90 /103 /i255 /143 /104 /165 /i255 /110 /92 /104 /89 /i255/142 /104 /103 /106/i255/96 /136/91/89 /90 /161 /92/136/92/103 /93 /107/i255/141 /104/89 /166 /92 /93/i255/143 /104 /165 /92 /107 /i255/88 /104 /94/136/92/103 /93 /i255 /118 /114 /111 /133 /167 /111 /118 /119 /131 /114 /114 /114/i255/i255 /167 /111 /118 /119 /131 /114 /114 /114/i255/167 /111 /131 /116 /168 /168 /169 /114 /114 /i255/167 /111 /131 /116 /168 /168 /169 /114 /114 /i255 /118 /114 /111 /168 /167 /111 /168 /118 /131 /114 /114 /114/i255/i255 /167 /111 /168 /118 /131 /114 /114 /114/i255/167 /118 /131 /118 /112 /115 /169 /113 /111 /i255/167 /118 /131 /118 /112 /115 /169 /113 /111 /i255 /118 /114 /111 /116 /167 /111 /168 /118 /131 /114 /114 /114/i255/i255 /167 /111 /168 /118 /131 /114 /114 /114/i255/167 /118 /131 /111 /119 /119 /169 /119 /111 /i255/167 /118 /131 /115 /168 /111 /169 /114 /168 /i255 /118 /114 /111 /119 /167 /111 /168 /118 /131 /114 /114 /114/i255/i255 /167 /111 /168 /118 /131 /114 /114 /114/i255/167 /118 /131 /114 /112 /111 /169 /115 /114 /i255/167 /118 /131 /114 /112 /111 /169 /115 /114 /i255 /144 /104 /102 /92 /107 /i255/97/137/107 /105 /102 /90 /107 /135 /89 /92 /i255 /170/89/104 /103 /93 /90 /89 /i255 /162 /90 /90 /166 /i255 /171 /i255 /88 /104 /158 /92/i255/97 /104/93 /92/i255/97 /92/92 /106 /i255/150 /104 /105 /104 /103 /93 /i255/144 /104 /102 /92 /i255 /88 /89 /137 /105 /92 /i255 /144/141/110/143/140/i255/141/134/142 /138/151/97/i255/142 /142/134/155 /154 /156 /149 /i255 /148 /172 /173/i255/172 /174 /172 /174 /149 /155 /147 /172/i255/170 /92 /175 /147 /149 /156 /176 /155 /155 /155 /i255 /i255 /163 /145 /99 /99 /101 /146/97/i255/134 /142/101 /151/97/145/i255 /145 /i255 /177/146/143 /148 /153 /152 /i255 /172 /172 /173/i255/148 /174 /149 /174 /149 /155 /155 /148/i255/170 /92 /175 /147 /148 /155 /176 /155 /155 /155 /i255 /i255 /141/138/146/96 /143 /178 /i255/141/96/134 /140/101 /145 /142 /i255 /145 /i255 /143 /146 /151 /144 /143 /145/145/101 /149 /172 /155 /i255 /172 /173 /149/i255/156 /174 /173 /155 /174 /147 /152 /152 /154/i255/170 /92 /175 /148 /156 /176 /155 /155 /155 /i255 /i255 /i255 /110 /147 /153 /172 /i255 /155 /153 /156/i255/147 /155 /174 /154 /174 /147 /152 /153 /152/i255/170 /92 /175 /155 /i255 /i255 /96/136/91/89 /90 /161 /92/136/92/103 /93 /107 /i255 /162 /135 /137 /102 /106 /137 /103 /158 /i255/143 /94 /91 /92 /i255/151 /107 /92 /i255 /134 /90 /106 /92 /97/92/107 /105 /89 /137 /91 /93 /137 /90 /103 /i255 /134 /90 /103 /107 /93 /89 /135 /105 /93 /92 /106 /110 /92 /104 /89 /i255/144 /93 /90 /89 /137 /92 /107/i255/162/92 /106 /89 /90 /90/136/107/i255/179 /137 /103 /137 /107 /109 /92 /106 /i255 /144 /180 /159 /179 /93 /159 /i255 /96 /136/91 /89 /90 /161 /92/136/92/103 /93 /144 /137 /181 /92 /i255 138 ATTACHMENT #15 Public Hearing Notice: List of Neighboring Property Owners 139 Variance Notification List 2959 Seabrook Island Road Property Address Owner(s) of Record Mailing Address City State Zip 2955 Seabrook Island Road Hunter & Barbara Harwood 112 Old Orchard Lane Ocean NJ 07712 2957 Seabrook Island Road Leslie & Deborah Rogers 5910 Bradley Blvd Bethesda MD 20814 2961 Seabrook Island Road Nichols Living Trust 2961 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island SC 29455 2963 Seabrook Island Road David & Dorothea LeBlanc 2963 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island SC 29455 2956 Seabrook Island Road Kevin & Jean Dunn 2956 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island SC 29455 2958 Seabrook Island Road James T. Kindley Trust & Susan G. Kindley Trust 2958 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island SC 29455 2960 Seabrook Island Road Don & Debra Ferguson PO Box 11132 Rock Hill SC 29731 2962 Seabrook Island Road Charles & Lisa Baker 14108 Phoenix Road Phoenix MD 21131 2123 Kings Pine Drive Dziubek/Donovan Family Revocable Trust 444 Kenmont Avenue Pittsburgh PA 15228 2127 Loblolly Lane Kersti & Charles Riehl 5611 Cedarmere Drive Winston Salem NC 27106 2129 Loblolly Lane Peter & Patricia Brooke 2129 Loblolly Lane Seabrook Island SC 29455 2133 Loblolly Lane James L/ Bannwart Trust & Maryann V. Bannwart Trust 2133 Loblolly Lane Seabrook Island SC 29455 Property Owners Association Seabrook Island Property Owners Association 1202 Landfall Way Seabrook Island SC 29455 Regime Not Applicable 140 ATTACHMENT #16 Public Hearing Notice: U.S.P.S. Certified Mail Receipts 141 142 143 ATTACHMENT #17 Public Hearing Notice: Post & Courier Legal Ad 144 145 ATTACHMENT #18 Public Hearing Notice: Property Posting 146 147 ATTACHMENT #19 Communication from License & Permit Specialist Lynda Stearns to Galloway Homes 148 149 150 151 ATTACHMENT #20 Communication from Zoning Administrator Joe Cronin to Galloway Homes 152 1 Joe Cronin From: Joe Cronin Sent: Thursday, December 20, 2018 3:29 PM To: Clint Galloway Cc: Lynda Stearns Subject: 2959 Seabrook Island Road Attachments: 2959 Seabrook Island Road.pdf Clint,    I tried calling but wasn't able to get through to you. We received a certificate of height form for 2959 Seabrook Island  Road. The certificate lists the height of the roof peak as 39.2' above the FEMA Base Flood Elevation (BFE), which would  be 37.2' above BFE + 2' Freeboard.     The approved plan set shows the highest point of the roof (excluding the chimney) as 37' 6.5" above the BFE, or 35' 6.5"  above BFE + 2' Freeboard. The maximum allowable height per the DSO is 36' above BFE + 2' Freeboard, or 38' above BFE.    If the roof tops out at 39.2' above the BFE, then it is currently non‐conforming. Can you please have your surveyor verify  that the actual height from BFE to the top of the roof (excluding the chimney) is in fact 39.2'?    Joseph M. Cronin  Town Administrator  Town of Seabrook Island  2001 Seabrook Island Road  Seabrook Island, SC 29455  Office: (843) 768‐5321  Cell: (843) 637‐9832  www.townofseabrookisland.org    153 1 Joe Cronin From: Joe Cronin Sent: Thursday, December 27, 2018 11:55 AM To: Clint Galloway Subject: Height Ordinance Clint,    I had a chance to further review the town code, as well as previous history with non‐conforming construction errors.  Unfortunately, I have come to the conclusion that there is no administrative "wiggle room" regarding the non‐ conforming height at 2959 Seabrook Island Road.     § 13.70.60.20. of the DSO, which allows for administrative discretion in the case of "Building Errors," applies only to  "yards" (ie. setback) requirements.     At this time, I see only two options:    1) Revise the roof to bring it into conformity with the maximum height requirement; or    2) Apply for a variance from the Board of Zoning Appeals.     Joseph M. Cronin  Town Administrator  Town of Seabrook Island  2001 Seabrook Island Road  Seabrook Island, SC 29455  Office: (843) 768‐5321  Cell: (843) 637‐9832  www.townofseabrookisland.org     154 ATTACHMENT #21 Communication between BOZA Chairman Walter Sewell, Zoning Administrator Joe Cronin & SIPOA ARC Administrator Katrina Burrell 155 1 Joe Cronin From: Katrina Burrell <kburrell@sipoa.org> Sent: Wednesday, January 23, 2019 11:24 AM To: Joe Cronin; Heather Paton Cc: Walter Sewell Subject: RE: Variance #158 I am planning on attending and I will have some documentation to share with you and the Committee prior to the  hearing.    At some point during the review process, the ARC Committee may have mentioned increasing the height of the slab due  to drainage, etc., but that was never a requirement and was not included as conditions in any of the review process  approvals.  As such, the permitting plans that were stamped and approved indicate the ARC approved height of the slab,  the first floor and the roof ridge were are all at a lower elevation than is shown on the elevation certificate as the  existing heights.      ~Katrina   Katrina Burrell, CMCA, AMS  Architectural Review Administrator  Seabrook Island POA    1202 Landfall Way  Johns Island, SC  29455  843‐768‐0061  843‐725‐1560 Direct  843‐768‐4317 Fax          From: Joe Cronin <jcronin@townofseabrookisland.org>   Sent: Wednesday, January 23, 2019 11:19 AM  To: Heather Paton <hpaton@sipoa.org>; Katrina Burrell <kburrell@sipoa.org>  Cc: Walter Sewell <wsecondwind@yahoo.com>  Subject: FW: Variance #158    Heather & Katrina,  156 2   Chairman Sewell has asked if someone from SIPOA/ARC will be able to attend the Board of Zoning Appeals meeting on  01/22/2019 at 2:30 PM. In the height variance application for 2959 Seabrook Island Road, the applicants have stated  that the pad height for the structure was increased at the request of the ARC due to drainage concerns. If one or both of  you will be available to attend, it is likely that the Board will wish to hear information from SIPOA/ARC in regards to this  variance request.    Joseph M. Cronin  Town Administrator  Town of Seabrook Island  2001 Seabrook Island Road  Seabrook Island, SC 29455  Office: (843) 768‐5321  Cell: (843) 637‐9832  www.townofseabrookisland.org     From: Walter Sewell <wsecondwind@yahoo.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 23, 2019 10:26 AM  To: Joe Cronin <jcronin@townofseabrookisland.org>  Cc: Ava Kleinman <ava.kleinman@gmail.com>; Bob Leggett <rmlegg8@gmail.com>; John Fox  <johnfox8624@gmail.com>; Richard Finkelstein <finkelstein@ameritech.net>  Subject: Variance #158    Joe,    I have finished going through all of the material that was furnished to each Board Member on Friday, January 18 th and I  can’t find anything that shows the actual elevations of the various elements as compared to the design elevations for  those elements.  Maybe if I understood the various items on the ELEVATION CERTIFICATE and how to relate each to the  Architect’s Front Elevation drawing, I could figure it out but I haven’t been able to do that.    What we do have is the explanation that was provided at the meeting on the 18 th at which time we were told  that the  1.2 feet of over height was solely attributable to the top surface of the foundation (concrete footing) being set 1.2 feet  higher than designed and that this higher elevation was carried through further construction such that all succeeding  elements were 1.2 feet higher than designed.  As such, the cause of the over height would have been entirely in the  footing and there was no cumulative effect from subsequent vertical elements.    A reading of the hand written responses on each of the items on Variance Application – Form 3, dated 12‐27‐18, does  not say anything about the foundation that I can find.  Rather, it makes vague statements about “drainage” and “water  flow” among other things and then says the ARC “recommended increased pad” but does indicate whether that the role  of the ARC was associated with the cause or the cure.    What was stated last Friday sounds plausible, what was provided with the application I find puzzling at best, but of  greater concern is that the two explanations are totally different.    I believe that in reaching a decision in this matter, the Board needs to be confident that we have found what the facts  were (are) and that our determination was based on those facts.    Given that much of the applicant’s “case” is being attributed to the ARC, I believe that it is crucial that the ARC attend  the hearing of Variance #158, hear the testimony provided by the applicant and be afforded the opportunity to present  the ARC’s position and respond to any questions that the Board might have in this matter.    Walter  157 ATTACHMENT #22-A Height Certificates & Photos of Neighboring Properties: 2962 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 3, Block 38) Built 2000 158 159 160 ATTACHMENT #22-B Height Certificates & Photos of Neighboring Properties: 2960 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 4, Block 38) Built 2000 161 162 163 ATTACHMENT #22-C Height Certificates & Photos of Neighboring Properties: 2958 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 5, Block 38) Built 2008 164 165 166 ATTACHMENT #22-D Height Certificates & Photos of Neighboring Properties: 2956 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 6, Block 38) Built 2000 167 168 169 ATTACHMENT #22-E Height Certificates & Photos of Neighboring Properties: 2963 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 12, Block 42) Built 1988 170 171 ATTACHMENT #22-F Height Certificates & Photos of Neighboring Properties: 2961 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 12-A, Block 42) Built 2014 172 173 174 ATTACHMENT #22-G Height Certificates & Photos of Neighboring Properties: 2957 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 12-C, Block 42) Built 2001 175 176 177 ATTACHMENT #22-H Height Certificates & Photos of Neighboring Properties: 2955 Seabrook Island Road (Lot 12-D, Block 42) Built 2017 178 179 180 ATTACHMENT #23 Letter from Jean & Kevin Dunn (Jan. 08, 2019) 181 1 Joe Cronin From: Jean Dunn <jeandunn100@bellsouth.net> Sent: Tuesday, January 8, 2019 1:41 PM To: Joe Cronin Cc: 'Jean Dunn' Subject: 2959 Seabrook Island Road - Variance We received the public hearing notice regarding the requested variance for 2959 Seabrook Island Road.  Since we will be  out of town on the hearing date, we would like to submit these comments and questions:    1.  According to the variance request, the SIPOA ARC recommended increasing the pod to mitigate drainage  issues.  Wasn’t the maximum building height also discussed at that time?  Why didn’t the architect and builder  know the maximum height?  2. Why wasn’t this discovered earlier, before the house framing was completed?  We live across the street and as  the house was being built we thought the house seemed very high.    3. What recourse is available now that the house is framed?  4. How will the higher pod affect drainage onto the neighbors’ properties and into the street?  Will our street be  flooded when there are heavy rains?    Thank you,  Jean and Kevin Dunn  2956 Seabrook Island Road  182 ATTACHMENT #24 Letter from Julie McCulloch (Jan. 22, 2019) 183 1 Joe Cronin From: Julie McCulloch <juliemcculloch3075@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, January 22, 2019 12:22 PM To: Joe Cronin Subject: Zoning Board Appeals Hearing 1/29/19: 2959 Seabrook Island Road Dear Joe:    I’m writing to you on the above‐matter as a Seabrook Island property owner, not in my capacity as SIPOA President.  As I  don’t have the email addresses of the other Board members, I would ask that you route this communication to them.    It is my understanding that this property is coming before the Board at an upcoming meeting to request a Zoning  Variance regarding the structure height.  Specifically, to grant a variance to allow the height of the structure to exceed  the 36’ Base Flood Elevation (BFE) + 2’ Free Board (FB) by 1.2’.    I strongly urge the Board to deny this variance request.   This height requirement is well known to architects and  contractors.  It is a hard‐and‐fast number...in other words, not open to interpretation or “judgement.”  36 feet is 36 feet!    When we were building our house a few years ago, we had to design our roof structure specifically to ensure that our  home stayed within the height requirement.  I also know of others who have built homes and were required to modify  their roof design — during construction — to be within the height tolerance.    Granting this property a height variance would set an unfortunate precedent that will be hard to “undo” when future  circumstances arise.  In other words, property owners could say, “Hey, you approved 1.2’...mine’s only 1’ or 1.6’!”   Where would it stop?    There is no reason why you should permit these property owners and their builder to circumvent rules that have been  applied to every other property owner who has built/remodeled homes on this island.     Thank you for your consideration,    Julie McCulloch        Sent from Julie's iPad  184

Source: Town of Seabrook Island website. First collected Nov 1, 2026.