RecordWell Data

Agenda

Town of Seabrook Island · Charleston County · Agendas

Open the original document More from Town of Seabrook Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF SEABROOK ISLAND  Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting  May 28, 2019 – 1:00 PM  Town Hall, Council Chambers  2001 Seabrook Island Road  AGENDA  CALL TO ORDER  APPROVAL OF MINUTES  1. Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting: March 22, 2019 [Pages 2–14]  2. Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting: May 15, 2019 [ P a g e s   1 5 – 1 6 ]  PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS  1. Variance # 161 [ P a g e s   1 7 – 1 1 0 ]  APPLICANT: Robert & Cynthia Reddersen  ADDRESS: 802 Treeloft Trace  TAX MAP NUMBE R:  147‐10‐00‐055  ZONING DISTRICT:  PDD/Multi‐Family  PURPOSE:  Applicant is requesting  a  variance  from the 15‐foot rear yard  setback requirement (§ 7.60.40.30) to 3.5 feet to allow for the  expansion of an existing non‐conforming open deck   OLD BUSINESS ITEMS  1. Review and Approval of New Variance Applications Form   [Pages 111–113]  ITEMS FOR INFORMATION / DISCUSSION  1. St a t u s   o f   P r e v i o u s   V a r i a n c e s  [Pages 114–129]  ADJOURN  TOWN OF SEABROOK ISLAND Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting March 22, 2019 – 2:30 PM Town Hall, Council Chambers 2001 Seabrook Island Road MINUTES Present: Walter Sewell (Chair), Ava Kleinman (Vice Chair), Bob Leggett, John Fox, Joe Cronin (Zoning Administrator) Absent: Richard Finkelstein Guests: James Ott, Deborah Ott, Judith McLean, Paul Corkish, Deborah Corkish Chairman Sewell called the meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals to order at 2:30 PM and introduced himself and Board members Kleinman, Fox and Leggett to those in attendance. Zoning Administrator Cronin confirmed that the requirements of the Freedom of Information Act were fulfilled, and the meeting was properly posted. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting: February 28, 2019 : Ms. Kleinman made a motion to approve the minutes from the February 28, 2019, meeting as submitted. M r. Fox seconded the motion. The motion was APPROVED by a vote of 4-0. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS 1. 2566 Seabrook Island Road (Tax Map # 14 7-01-00-033 – Lot 49, Block 5): Chairman Sewell introduced the first variance request , which was submitted by James and Deborah Ott , the owners of 2 566 Seabrook Island Road . Chairman Sewell disclosed for the record that the Board had conducted a site visit to 2566 Seabrook Island Road on February 28, 2019, at which time the Board viewed the subject property, as well as neighboring properties. He added that no testimony was rec eived during the site visit. He asked whether any Board members had subsequently visited the property, to which none responded in the affirmative. Chairman Sewell then administered an oath to Zoning Administrator Cronin and asked him to provide a brief overview of Variance Application #159. Zoning Administrator Cronin stated that the town had received a completed variance application from James and Deborah Ott , the owners of 2566 Seabrook Island Road. The applicants were requesting a reduction of the 25-foot marsh setback requirement to allow for the installation of a pool/swim spa and hot tub within a deck at the rear of the property. 2 Zoning Administrator Cronin stated that the existing deck, which was proposed to be modified and expanded, would meet the 15-foot setback requirements for “open decks.” However, the pool/swim spa and hot tub would be considered “structures” under the DSO and, therefore, would need to meet the 25 -foot marsh setback requirement. He stated that the applicants were seeking a variance for the pool/swim spa and hot tub (which would be set into the deck) to meet the same 15-foot setback requirement as the deck itself. He added that the applicants were also seeking a variance from the marsh setback requirement to allow a brick paver patio and fire pit in the rear yard to be located within five feet of the critical line. In order to move forward with the proposed improvements, the applicants sought approval of a variance to grant relief from the following setback requirements, as provided in the town’s DSO: Type DSO Reference DSO Requirement Variance Requested Marsh Setback § 7.60.50 25 feet Reduce the march setback to 15 feet to allow the pool/swim spa and hot tub to be located within an open deck and Reduce the march setback to 5 feet to allow a paver patio and fire pit to be installed as shown on the site plan As part of their variance request, the applicants stated that strict application of the 25 -foot marsh setback requirement would result in an unnecessary hardship. The applicants further argued: (a) The existing home and deck were built by a previous owner, before current restrictions were in place, and in a manner that would not allow these features to be added in another location on the lot; (b) The unique shape of the lot and marsh location, the home’s placement on the lot, and the existing configuration of the home creates a specific hardship that is not found on neighboring properties; (c) The strict application of the ordinance would restrict the homeowners’ ability to utilize their rear deck space and access the non "built on" portion of the lot for relaxation and recreational purposes that other properties are able to utilize; and (d) The granting of the variance will allow similar uses that neighboring properties are able to enjoy. The pool and hot tub feature will be minimally visible with open decking below; and a low, permeable area, made of natural materials for a fire pit will be well shielded by vegetation. Prior to opening the public hearing , members of the Board asked questions of Zoning Administrator Cronin. 3 Ms. Kleinman asked why the town ha s a marsh setback requirement. Zoning Administrator Cronin responded that the marsh setback primarily serves two purposes: To protect critical areas by providing a buffer from new development and to protect property owners and their property from future changes to the marsh area over time. Ms. Kleinman also asked why the ordinance allows open decks to encroach 10 feet into the required marsh setback. Zoning Administrator Cronin responded that an open deck is pervious and would allow rainwater to pass through the structure to the ground below. This is different from a roof or other impervious structure, which would channel and direct runoff away from the structure. He noted that “open decks” are narrowly defined in the DSO. Mr. Fox stated that water from an open deck is still channeled in some form, as a deck will have planks along its floor. He stated that it is also possible to place other impervious items, such as tables, on a deck which would channel water. Ms. Kleinman asked why a pool or hot tub which was set into a n open deck would not be considered as part of the deck. Zoning Administrator Cronin responded that while a pool or hot tub would only collect rain water rather than generate runoff, the DSO defines a “structure” (25-foot setback) fairly broadly, whereas an “open deck” (15 -foot setback) is defined narrowly, and a pool or hot tub would not fall within that definition. Chairman Sewell then called on the applicants to provide additional information related to their variance request. Chairman Sewell administered an oath to each individual prior to receiving his or her testimony. • Jim Ott: Mr. Jim Ott of 2566 Seabrook Island Road spoke on behalf of the applicants. Mr. Ott provided a summary of the project. Mr. Ott stated that he and has wife have owned property on Seabrook Island since 2004 and purchased the home at 2566 Seabrook Island Road in 2017. He stated that he knew they would not have enough space to install a traditional pool in the rear yard as a result of the setback requirements, so they were seeking to install something within the footprint of the deck that would allow them to have a pool with minimal impact to the critical area . They were also seeking an option which was consistent with the spirit of the ordinance. The plan was to recess the pool/swim spa and hot tub within the deck. He added that the structures would remain about 5 f eet above the ground level so that water could pass underneath. He stated that the patio and fire pit were intended to be a birthday gift from his wife. The intent of these amenities was to allow him and his wife to have a comfortable area to use and enjoy their rear yard. He added that he had met with the neighbors on both sides of his property, and that neither had expressed any reservations or objections with his plans. Chairman Sewell asked if members of the Board had any questions for Mr. Ott. Mr. Leggett asked if the deck would be enclosed by side boards. Mr. Ott responded in the affirmative. 4 Mr. Fox asked if the swim spa and hot tub would be permanently affixed or whether they would simply be sitting on or within the deck like furniture. Mr. Ott responded that they would be fully self-contained units and would be dropped into the deck by a crane. He said that the units are not permanent fixtures, and no mechanical equipment would be located on the ground. Zoning Administrator Cronin noted that the town had received a letter from Chris Bonner, the architect for the project , in advance of the meeting. He stated that a copy of the letter had been forwarded to board members the previous day. He asked that this letter be entered into the public record for Variance Request #159. There was no objection. Chairman Sewell asked if any other Board members had questions for the applicant. There were no additional questions. Chairman Sewell opened the public hearing to individuals who wished to speak in favor of the variance request. Chairman Sewell administered an oath to each individual prior to receiving his or her testimony. • Paul Corkish: Mr. Paul Corkish of 2545 Seabrook Island Road spoke in favor of the request. He stated that he thought it was a reasonable request and had no objections. • Deborah Corkish: Ms. Deborah Corkish of 2545 Seabrook Island Road also spoke in favor of the request. Ms. Corkish stated that she had read through the public notice and had no concerns regarding the request. She stated that she and her husband have a pool at the rear of their home and that it is a great amenity to have in the summer months. Chairman Sewell then opened the public hearing to individuals who wished to speak in opposition to the variance request. No one spoke in opposition to the request. There being no further comments, Chairman Sewell closed the public hearing. Chairman Sewel l asked if the applicants or their representatives had any additional comments. No additional comments were offered. Chairman Sewell asked members of the Board whether they had any additional questions. There were no additional questions. Chairman Sewell then called on Zoning Administrator Cronin to review the four criteria under state law which must be used by the Board when hearing and deciding variance requests. Zoning Administrator Cronin stated that the Board has the power to hear and decide appeals for variance from the requirements of the zoning ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes and explains in writing the following findings: 5 1) There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2) These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; 3) Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and 4) The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. Chairman Sewell noted that, in granting a variance, the Board has the authority to attach such conditions as the Board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. Referencing the staff write up contained within the agenda p acket, Chairman Sewell stated that the Zoning Administrator had recommended the following conditions, should the Board vote to approve the variance request: 1) The approved variance shall apply to the building layout as shown on the site-specific plan prepared by the applicant and reviewed by the Board on March 22, 2019. Any modification to this site-specific plan prior to the issuance of a zoning permit, with the exception of minor corrections and/or modifications which conform to the requirements of the tow n’s DSO, shall require further review and approval by the Board of Zoning Appeals prior to permitting. 2) The variance shall expire on September 25, 2022 (five years from the date of the current OCRM Critical Line Certification) if no zoning permit has been issued by the town on or before that date. Chairman Sewell opened the floor for additional discussion. Ms. Kleinman stated that she understands the reasons why the applicants are coming forward with a variance request; however, she didn’t feel that they have documented that an “extraordinary condition” truly exists. She added that approving this variance would establish a precedent for future variance requests from the marsh setback requirement. While she had less concern about the pool than the patio and fire pit (which would be 5 feet from the critical line), she stated her belief that the pool/swim spa and hot tub wer e structures and not “furniture.” Mr. Fox stated that he didn’t think anything being proposed would be classified as permanent construction. He added that the pavers would be unanchored, permeable , set in sand and could be carried off at any time. 6 Mr. Leggett stated that he didn’t see a difference between moving a fire pit and chairs into and out of the rear yard any time they were being used. Chairman Sewell noted that much of what the Board deals with is associated with marshfront lots. He stated that there are several practical reasons for this, such as the fact that these lots are all irregular, they are generally of shallower depth , and regardless of the critical line moving over time, there would still be issues as a result of developers trying to maximize the number of marshfront lots. There being no further discussion, Chairman Sewell called for a motion . Ms. Kleinman recommended that the requests be taken up separately. Chairman Sewell responded that the Board may take up the request as three separate motions. The first would be whether to approve or deny the variance request for the pool/swim spa and hot tub. The second would be whether to approve or deny the variance request for t he patio and fire pit . Lastly, if one or both of the first two motions are approved, the third would be whether to attach the conditions recommended by the Zoning Administrator. Mr. Fox recommended that if the Board votes to approve a variance for the pool/swim spa and hot tub, then the Board should also clarify that these types of self-contained units are not considered “structures” and , therefore, would not be subject to the regular setback requirements. Zoning Administrator Cronin responded that he understood the basis for Mr. Fox’s comment; however, he did not feel that this type of decision was properly before the Board for consideration . He added that if this was an appeal of an administrative determination, then the Board could certainly make such a decision . However, as a variance request, the Board should only determine whether the request meets the minimum requirements for a variance, as established by state law. He stated tha t this would be a question of a broader policy interpretation rather than a property -specific request, and that such a decision has not been properly advertised as required by state and local law. Chairman Sewell stated that, in his opinion, the pool/swi m spa and hot tub didn’t appear to be much different than a large glass-top table or other furniture placed on a deck. Mr. Leggett stated that he lives around the corner from the subject property. He observed that most homes in the area have similar issu es to those discussed today. He felt that what made this request “extraordinary” was the fact that the critical lines have moved over time. Following a thorough review of the application, including all supporting materials received in advance of the meeting, and all testimony received during the public hearing, Mr. Leggett made the following motion regarding the variance request for the SWIM S PA/HOT TUB , which was seconded by Mr. Fox: 1) The Board finds that strict application of the Town’s DSO would result in an unnecessary hardship; 7 2) For the reasons referenced in the applicants’ request for variance, the Board finds that the Property meets the criteria for approval of a variance, as outlined in § 6-29- 800(A)(2) of the SC Code of Laws; and 3) The requested variance is hereby approved, and the marsh setback requirement for the Property is amended, as follows: Type DSO Requirement Variance Approved Marsh Setback 25 feet Reduce the march setback to 15 feet to allow the pool/swim spa and hot tub to be located within the open deck as shown on the proposed site plan There being no further discussion on the motion, Chairman Sewell called for a vote. Chairman Sewell reminded members that a “yes” vote was in favor of granting the variance, while a “no” vote was opposed to granting the variance. IN FAVOR (YES) OPPOSED (NO) Chairman Sewell Mr. Leggett Mr. Fox Ms. Kleinman The motion to grant the variance was APPROVED by a vote of 3-1. Mr. Leggett then made the following motion regarding the variance request for the PAVER PATIO & FIRE PIT, which was seconded by Mr. Fox: 1) The Board finds that strict application of the Town’s DSO would result in an unnecessary hardship; 2) For the reasons referenced in the applicants’ request for variance, the Board finds that the Property meets the criteria for approval of a variance, as outlined in § 6-29- 800(A)(2) of the SC Code of Laws; and 3) The requested variance is hereby approved, and the marsh setback requirement for the Property is amended, as follows: Type DSO Requirement Variance Approved Marsh Setback 25 feet Reduce the march setback to 5 feet to allow the paver patio and fire pit to be installed as shown on proposed site plan 8 There being no further discussion on the motion, Chairman Sewell called for a vote. Chairman Sewell reminded members that a “yes” vote was in favor of granting the variance, while a “no” vote was opposed to granting the variance. IN FAVOR (YES) OPPOSED (NO) Chairman Sewell Mr. Leggett Mr. Fox Ms. Kleinman The motion to grant the variance was APPROVED by a vote of 3-1. To protect established property values in the surrounding area, and to promote the public health, safety, and general welfare , Mr. Fox made a motion, seconded by Mr. Leggett, to attach the following conditions to the above reference d variances, as allowed by § 6 -29- 800(A)(2)(d)(i) of the South Carolina Code of Laws : 1) The approved variance shall apply to the building layout as shown on the site-specific plan prepared by the applicant and reviewed by the Board on March 22, 2019. Any modification to this site-specific plan prior to the issuance of a zoning permit, with the exception of minor corrections and/or modifications which conform to the requirements of the town’s DSO, shall require further review and approval by the Board of Zoning Appeals prior to permitting. 2) The variances shall expire on September 25, 2022 (five years from the date of the current OCRM Critical Line Certification) if no zoning permit has been issued by the town on or before that date. The motion to attach the conditions to the two variances was APPROVED by a vote of 4-0. Chairman Sewell recessed the meeting at 3:21 PM. The meeting was reconvened at 3:30 PM. 2. 3009 Rascal Run (Tax Map # 149-05-00-059 – Lot 5, Block 48): Chairman Sewell introduced the second variance request, which was submitted by Clarkson and Judith McLean , the owners of 3009 Rascal Run . Chairman Sewell disclosed for the record that the Board had conducted a site visit to 3009 Rascal Run on February 28 , 2019, at which time the Board viewed the subject property, as well as neighboring properties. He added that no testimony was received during the site visit. He asked if any Board members had subsequently visited the property, to which none responded in the affirmative. Chairman Sewell then called on Zoning Administrator Cronin to provide a brief overview of Variance Application #160. Chairman Sewell reminded Zoning Administrator Cronin that he was still under oath. Zoning Administrator Cronin stated that the town had received a completed variance 9 application from Clarkson and Judith McLean, the owners of 3009 Rascal Run. The applicants were requesting a reduction in the 25 -foot rear/marsh setback requirement to allow an unheated sunroom to be converted into conditioned living space at the rear of their existing single-family residence. He stated that the existing residence was constructed in 1986, which was prior to the town’s incorporation. The property was purchased by Mr. and Mrs. McLean in July of 2018. In October of 2018, the applicants (through their contractor, Harper Construction) applied for and received a zoning permit from the town to enclose 2 openings in their “hot tub porch” and replace 5 remaining windows with impact resistant glass (Permit #15267). The permit application did not include a request to install ductwork, which would thereby convert the existing “porch” into conditioned living space. The project scope was subsequently modified to add ductwork and vents without review and approval from the town. Because the existing residence encroaches approximately 5.1 feet into a required rear yard setback, this modification would result in the expansion of an existing non -conforming dwelling. Zoning Administrator Cronin noted that while the heated square footage of the non- conforming residence would increase, the footprint of the existing building would not change, as no walls, roofing or other structures would further encroach into the required setback. In order to move forward with the proposed improvements , the applicants sought approval of a variance to grant relief from the following setback requirements, as provided in the town’s DSO: Type DSO Reference DSO Requirement Variance Requested Rear Setback Marsh Setback § 7.60.20.30 § 7.60.50 25 feet To allow encroachment of up to 5.1 feet into the required rear/marsh setback so an existing non-conforming porch may be converted into conditioned living space. As part of their variance request, the applicants stated that strict application of the 25 -foot marsh setback requirement would result in an unnecessary hardship. The applicants further argued: a) The existing home was built in 1986 (prior to the town’s inco rporation) under different zoning requirements than existing today; b) Had it been built under the town’s current zoning requirements, the existing home would meet or exceed the 25-foot setback; c) The existing porch area is already fully enclosed with a roof, walls and windows, and the applicants are only seeking to install HVAC ducts to condition (though not expand) the existing space; and d) The modification will not be of substantial detriment to neighboring properties, the public good or the character of the district as no exterior modifications will be made to the existing structure. (ie. No visible changes to the building footprint, walls, roofline, etc.) 10 Prior to opening the public hearing, members of the Board asked questions of Zoning Administrator Cronin. Mr. Leggett asked if the applicant had requested a permit prior to installing the duct work whether the application would have been approved. Zoning Administrator Cronin responded that the work still would have been inconsistent with the DSO; however, because it was such a minor change and did not alter the existing building footprint in any way, he likely would have signed off on the request. This request was ultimately brought before the Board because of a complaint submitted by another party. Ms. Kleinman asked if the name of the complainant was public information. Zoning Administrator Cronin responded that this property was discussed publicly at a prior meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals. He added that the complaint was submitted by email by one of the parties to that appeal. Mr. Fox noted his observation during the site visit that the two new registers were actually located outside the setback area. He stated that if the variance was denied, the owners could still achieve the same objective by simply leaving the bedroom doors open. Zoning Administrator Cronin confirmed both of these observations. Chairman Sewell asked about the nature of the complaint. Zoning Administrator Cronin responded that the complainant alleged the owners were expanding the home by converting a porch into heated square footage, thereby making the existing home more non-conforming than it is today, even though the building footprint would remain unchanged. Chairman Sewell asked if the Board had been furnished copies of the complaint. He stated that he would not have a problem giving copies to the board, but he would be hesitant to include it in the public agenda packet. He recommended obtaining an opinion from the Town Attorney. Chairman Sewell recommended that this information should be provided to the Board when it is germane to a variance request. Ms. Kleinman responded that such information does not impact or alter the town’s standards. Zoning Administrator Cronin added that, in his opinion, how an issue is identified does not have as much bearing as the fact the property was inspected and non -permitted work was found to have taken place by the town’s Code Enforcement Officer, which is how we got to this point. Chairman Sewell then called on the applicants to provide additional info rmation related to their variance request. Chairman Sewell administered an oath to each individual prior to receiving his or her testimony. • Judith McLean: Ms. Judith McLean of 2480 Cat Tail Pond Road spoke on behalf of the applicants. Ms. McLean stated that the owners’ contractor, Harper Construction, had obtained a permit to install windows and make other improvements to the property. While this work was taking place, an HVAC contractor was called to the property to do repair work which did not require a permit. Her husband, Clarkson, asked the contractor what would be involved in putting two additional vents in the sunroom at the rear of the property. This was a minor improvement and the contractor was able 11 to install the duct work and vents that same day. The owners did not realize at the time that this was a big deal. She stated that the person who complained was never invited onto their property, nor did they contact the owners prior to going onto their property. She stated that she and her husband are respectfully requesting a variance so that the vents will not have to be removed and they can have heat ing and air conditioning in the space. Chairman Sewell asked if members of the Board had any questions for Ms. McLean. There were no questions. Chairman Sewell opened the public hearing to individuals who wished to speak in favor of the variance request. No one spoke in favor of the request. Chairman Sewell then opened the public hearing to individuals who wished to speak in opposition to the variance request. No one spoke in opposition to the request. There being no further comments, Chairman Sewell closed the public hearing. Chairman Sewell then called on Zoning Administrator Cronin to review the four criteria under state law which must be used by the Board when hearing and deciding variance requests. Zoning Administrator Cronin stated that the Board has the power to hear and decide appeals for variance from the requirements of the zoning ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes and explains in writing the following findings: 1) There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2) These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; 3) Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably re strict the utilization of the property; and 4) The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. Chairman Sewell noted that, in granting a variance, the Board has the authority to attach such conditions as the Board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. Referencing the staff write up contained within the agenda packet, Chairman Sewell stated that the Zoning Administrator had recommended attaching two conditions, should the Board vote to approve the variance request. 12 Chairman Sewell asked if there were any additional questions or comments prior to voting. Ms. Kleinman observed that this situation appeared to her to meet the standards for a variance because it was an unusual situation and an extraordinary situation. She added that this would be a “de minimus” encroachment. There being no further discussion, Chairman Sewell called for a motion. Following a thorough review of the application, including all supporting materials received in advance of the meeting, and all testimony received during the public hearing, Mr. Fox made the following motion, which was seconded by Mr. Leggett: 1) The Board finds that strict application of the Town’s DSO would result in an unnecessary hardship; 2) For the reasons referenced in the applicants’ request for variance, the Board finds that the Property meets the criteria for approval of a variance, as outlined in § 6-29- 800(A)(2) of the SC Code of Laws; and 3) The requested variance is hereby approved, and the marsh setback requirement for the Property is amended, as follows: Type DSO Requirement Variance Approved Marsh Setback 25 feet To allow encroachment of up to 5.1 feet into the required rear/marsh setback so an existing non-conforming porch may be converted into conditioned living space. There being no further discussion on the motion, Chairman Sewell called for a vote. Chairman Sewell reminded members that a “yes” vote was in favor of granting the variance, while a “no” vote was opposed to granting the variance. IN FAVOR (YES) OPPOSED (NO) Chairman Sewell Ms. Kleinman Mr. Leggett Mr. Fox The motion to grant the variance was APPROVED by a vote of 4-0. To protect established property values in the surrounding area, and to promote the public health, safety, and general welfare , Mr. Fox made a motion, seconded by Mr. Legget t, to attach the following conditions to the above reference variance, as allowed by § 6 -29- 800(A)(2)(d)(i) of the South Carolina Code of Laws : 13 1) The approved variance shall apply to the building layout as shown on the site-specific plan prepared by the applicant and reviewed by the Board on March 22, 2019. Any modification to this site-specific plan prior to the issuance of a zoning permit, with the exception of minor corrections and/or modifications which conform to the requirements of the town’s DSO, shall require further review and approval by the Board of Zoning Appeals prior to permitting. 2) The variance shall expire on July 13, 2023 (five years from the date of the current survey) if no zoning permit has been issued by the town on or before that date. There being no further discussion on the motion, Chairman Sewell called for a vote. Chairman Sewell reminded members that a “yes” vote was in favor of attaching the conditions, while a “no” vote was opposed to attaching the conditions. IN FAVOR (YES) OPPOSED (NO) Chairman Sewell Ms. Kleinman Mr. Leggett Mr. Fox The motion to attach the conditions was APPROVED by a vote of 4-0. ITEMS FOR INFORMATION / DISCUSSION There were no Items for Information / Discussion. There being no further business, Chairman Sewell called for a motion to adjourn. M r. Fox made a motion, seconded by Mr. Leggett, to adjourn the meeting. The motion was APPROVED by a vote of 4-0, and the meeting was adjourned at 3:52 PM. Minutes Approved: Joseph M. Cronin Zoning Administrator 14 TOWN OF SEABROOK ISLAND Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting May 15, 2019 – 2:30 PM Town Hall, Council Chambers 2001 Seabrook Island Road MINUTES Present: Ava Kleinman, John Fox, Joe Cronin (Zoning Administrator) Absent: Walter Sewell (Chairman), Bob Leggett, Dick Finkelstein Guests: Skip Crane (Town Council), Paul LeBlanc (PLB Planning Group) Vice Chairwoman Kleinman called the meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals to order at 2:30 PM. Zoning Administrator Cronin confirmed that the requirements of the Freedom of Information Act were fulfilled, and the meeting was properly posted. Vice Chairwoman Kleinman stated that the Board did not have a quorum and, therefore, no votes would be taken; however, those present would still receive items for information which do not require a vote, as well as conduct the site visit to 802 Treeloft Trace, as scheduled. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting: March 22, 2019: No action was taken due to the lack of a quorum. NEW BUSINESS ITEMS 1. Review and Approval of New Variance Applica tion Form: No action was taken due to the lack of a quorum. ITEMS FOR INFORMATION / DISCUSSION 1. Update on the Status of Previous Variances: Zoning Administrator Cronin provided an update on the status of Variance #131, which was approved by the Board in 2004. He stated that the town was still waiting on confirmation from SCDHEC as to whether a septic tank was ever installed on the property. Additional information will be provided once it is received. 2. Development Standards Ordinance (DSO) Update : Town Administrator Cronin stated that the town had recently entered into a contract with the PLB Planning Group for the purpose of reviewing and updating the town’s DSO. He then introduced the project consultant, Mr. Paul LeBlanc, of PLB Planning Group. Mr. LeBlanc introduced himself and his firm. Mr. LeBlanc then provided an overview of the project scope, approach and time line. Members of the 15 Board, town staff and the project consultant then discussed general goals and objectives of the DSO update, as well as specific items of concern which should be addressed as part of the update. SITE VISITS Zoning Administrator Cronin distributed copies of the following variance application to members of the Board and provided a brief overview of the request: • Variance #161: 802 Treeloft Trace (To reduce the 15-foot rear yard setback requirement to 3.5 feet to allow for the expansion of an existing non-conforming open deck) Prior to departing for the site visits, Zoning Administrator Cronin stated that public notice of the site visits had been provided, pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act. He stated that the agenda for today’s meeting contained the following provision: “ This site visit s will take place behind the Seabrook Island Property Owners Association security gate. Any individual wishing to observe the site visit who does not have access behind the security gate should contact (843) 768- 5321 for assistance prior to the meeting. ” He added that no individuals had contacted the town to request access behind the security gate in advance of the meeting . Zoning Administrator Cronin noted that the purpose of the site visit was for observational purposes only, and no testimony would be heard pertaining to the variance application. The meeting was recessed at approximately 3:10 PM. Board members then traveled individually to 802 Treeloft Trace. Staff members at Town Hall were notified that the Board was traveling to the site, and anyone coming to Town Hall to observe the site visit should be directed to that location. 1. 802 Treeloft Trace (Tax Map # 147-10-00-055): The Board reconvened at approximately 3:29 PM at 802 Treeloft Trace . Board members and the Zoning Administrator observed the site, as well as neighboring properties in the vicinity of the site. Board members asked general questions regarding the proposed variance request; however, no testimony was received. Aside from the town’s DSO consultant, Mr. LeBlanc, no other individuals were present to observe the site visit. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 3:39 PM. Minutes Approved: Joseph M. Cronin Zoning Administrator 16               MEMORANDUM    TO:  Town of Seabrook Island Board of Zoning Appeals Members      FROM:  Joseph M. Cronin, Town Administrator/Zoning Administrator      SUBJECT:  Variance Application # 161 – 802 Treeloft Trace      MEETING DATE:  May 28, 2019      Variance Application #161  Applicants:  Robert & Cynthia Reddersen  Location:  802 Treeloft Trace  Tax Map Number:  147‐10‐00‐055  Zoning District:  PDD/Multi‐Family  Purpose:  Applicant is requesting a variance from the 15‐foot rear yard s etback  requirement (§ 7.60.40.30) to 3.5 feet to allow for the expansion of an  existing non‐conforming open deck      Overview    The Town has received a variance application from Robert and Cynthia Reddersen, the owners of  Charleston County Tax Map # 147‐10‐00‐055. The applicants are requesting a reduction in the 15‐ foot  rear  yard  setback  requirement  pertaining to  open  decks to allow for the  expansion of  an  existing non‐conforming deck at the rear of 802 Treeloft Trace. The property is located within the  Treeloft Villas regime.      The existing residence was constructed in approximately 1978, which was nearly a decade prior to  the town’s incorporation. The property was purchased by Mr. and Mrs. Reddersen in July of 2015.     While  conducting routine  inspections in  March  of 2019,  the  town’s  Code  Enforcement  Officer  identified a deck being installed at  802 Treeloft  Trace without necessary permits from the town  and county. A stop‐work order was issued, and the contractor was instructed to come to town hall  to apply for a permit.     On  March 19, 2019,  the  applicants  –  through  their  contractor  (Mike  Dohoney’s Barrier  Island  Construction  Specialists) –  submitted a zoning  permit  application  (#15680)  seeking approval  to  remove and replace the existing deck at the rear of their property.   Upon review by the  town’s  Zoning  Administrator,  it  was  determined  that  1)  The  existing  deck,  which  was  located  approximately 7.5 to  8.0 feet from the rear property line, did not conform to the town’s current   Development Standards Ordinance (DSO); and 2) At its closest point, the proposed deck expansion  would be located approximately 3.5 feet from the rear property line, thereby making the new deck  more non-conforming than the existing deck. The Zoning Administrator advised the applicants that the permit could not be approved without a variance from the Board of Zoning Appeals. The property is currently zoned PDD/Multi-Family and a multi-family residential unit is a permitted use by-right. Under the DSO, the structure located at 802 Treeloft Trace is considered an “existing non-conforming structure .” While the structure complies with the town’s 15-foot minimum spacing requirement between structures, the structure does not meet the minimum front and rear yard setback requirements. The existing deck at the rear of the unit is located approximately 7.5 to 8.0 feet from the rear property line, and encroachment of approximately 7.0 to 7.5 feet. TYPE REQUIRED PER DSO DSO REFERENCE Front (Principal Structure) 30 feet (Nonconforming) § 7.60.40.10 Side (Between Structures) 15 feet § 7.60.40.20 Rear (Principal Structure) 25 feet (Nonconforming) § 7.60.40.30 Rear (Open Deck) 15 feet (Nonconforming) § 7.60.60 In order to extend the existing non-conforming deck to the outer edge of the walls, the applicants are requesting a variance from the DSO to allow for the following encroachment: TYPE REQUIRED PER DSO VARIANCE (REQUESTED) Rear Yard (Open Deck) 15 feet Reduce the rear yard setback requirement for open decks from 15 feet to approximately 3.5 feet to allow for the expansion of an existing non - conforming deck. In their application, the applicants have stated their intent in seeking a variance is to increase the usable square footage of their deck from 49.17 square feet to 91.2 square feet. The proposed deck will use the standard design for deck replacements, as adopted by the Treeloft Villas regime. This same standard has been used for all other deck replacements within the regime, including 801 and 803 Treeloft Trace, which are immediately adjacent to the applicants’ unit. The applicants further argue: a) The Treeloft Villas regime was laid out and developed in 1978 (prior to the town’s incorporation) under different zoning requirements than existing today. The application of the town’s current setback standards will severely restrict the use of their property; b) Had it been built under the town’s current zoning requirements, the existing unit would have been constructed to meet or exceed the minimum setback requirements; c) The original decks in Treeloft Villas were designed to accommodate only two people, while the units themselves were designed to accommodate 4- 6 individuals. The extended p lan would allow for four chairs and a small table, which is more in keeping with the designed capacity of the villa; and 18 d) The modification will not be of substantial detriment to neighboring properties, the public good or the character of the district , as the proposed desig n was created specifically for units located within the Treeloft Villas and Sealoft Villas regimes. These designs were approved by both regimes as well as SIPOA. The plan will extend to, though not exceed, the outer walls of the villa, and the only encroachment will be on the golf course side of the building. Additionally, this standard design has been used by many other villa owners in the Treeloft and Sealoft regimes, many of which further encroached into the rear yard setback area. Staff Comments As a matter of practice, the town’s Zoning Administrator does not typically provide a recommendation in favor of – or in opposition to – a variance application. In our opinion, t hese requests are best left to the Board of Zoning Appeals following a thorough review of the relevant facts, including the receipt of testimony from interested parties during the required public hearing. In granting a variance, state law permits the Board of Zoning Appeals to attach such conditions as the Board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. Should the Board vote to approve the variance request, staff would recommend in favor of attaching the following conditions: • The approved variance shall apply to the building layout as shown on the site-specific plan prepared by the applicant and reviewed by the Board on May 28, 2019. Any modification to this site-specific plan prior to the issuance of a zoning permit, with the exception of minor corrections and/or modifications which conform to the requirements of the town’s DSO, shall require further review and approval by the Board of Zoning Appeals prior to permitting. • Consistent with the state’s Vested Rights Act, the variance shall expire on May 28, 2021 (two years from the date of approval) if no zoning permit has been issued by the town on or before that date. Respectfully submitted, Joseph M. Cronin Town Administrator/Zoning Administrator 19 Criteria for Review Pursuant to Section 6-29-800(A)(2) of the SC Code of Laws, the Board of Zoning Appeals has the power to hear and decide appeals for variance from the requirements of the zoning ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the board makes and explains in writing the following findings: (a) there are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; (b) these conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; (c) because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and (d) the authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. The board may not grant a variance, the effect of which would be to allow the establishment of a use not otherwise permitted in a zoning district, to extend physically a nonconforming use of land or to change the zoning district boundaries shown on the official zoning map. The fact that property may be utilized more profitably, if a variance is granted, may not be considered grounds for a variance. Other requirements may be prescribed by the zoning ordinance. In granting a variance, the board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. 20     Attachments    The following supplemental items have been attached for review:    Application & Property Information  1  Variance Application  p. 22‐32  2  Zoning Permit Application  p. 33‐40  3  Site Plan (Original & Proposed)  p. 41‐42  4  Subdivision Plat (1978)  p. 43‐44  5  Property Photos  p. 45‐51  6  Zoning Map  p. 52‐53  7  Aerial Image  p. 54‐55  8  FEMA Base Flood Elevations (Current & Preliminary)  p. 56‐57  9  Title to Real Estate  p. 58‐63  10  Property Information Card  p. 64‐65  11  Public Hearing Notice – Letter to Neighboring Property  Owners  p. 66‐67  12  Public Hearing Notice – List of Neighboring Property Owners  p. 68‐69  13  Public Hearing Notice –  U.S.P.S. Certified Mail Receipts  p. 70‐73  14  Public Hearing Notice – Post and Courier Legal Ad  p. 74‐75  15  Public Hearing Notice – Property Posting  p. 76‐77    Other Information  16  Typical Unit ( Treeloft Villas)  p. 78‐79  17  Regime Standard for D eck Replacements (Treeloft Villas)  p. 80‐83  18  Photos of Original Deck and New Regime Standard (Treeloft Vi llas)  p. 84‐86  19  Photos of Neighboring Properties: 801 & 803 Treeloft Trace  p. 87‐89  20  Setback Illustration for Treelo ft Villas  p.90‐91    Written Correspondence Regarding the Proposed Variance Request  21  Letter from Treeloft Villas Owners Association (April 10, 2019)  p. 92‐98  22  Letter from Seabrook Island Club (April 18, 2019)  p. 99‐100  23  Letter from Stewart Fife (April 24, 2019)  p. 101‐102  24  Letter from Heather Fife (April 24, 2019)  p. 103‐104  25  Letter from Richard Heilman (May 1 , 2019)  p. 105‐106  26  Letter from Steve Hildreth (May 16, 2019)  p. 107‐108  27  Letter from Joanne Fagan (May 22, 2019)  p. 109‐110         21 ATTACHMENT #1 Variance Application 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 ATTACHMENT #2 Zoning Permit Application 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 ATTACHMENT #3 Site Plan: Original & Proposed 41 Original        Proposed      42 ATTACHMENT #4 Subdivision Plat (1978) 43 44 ATTACHMENT #5 Property Photos 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 ATTACHMENT #6 Zoning Map 52 53 ATTACHMENT #7 Aerial Image 54 819 2511 TREELOFT V I L L A S 1471000054 1471000055 1471000056 1471000072 1471000008 1471100064 1471000053 1470000027 1470000001 Date: 4/18/2019 ´ 03 0 6 015 Feet Author: Charleston County SC 802 Treeloft Trace 1 inch = 39 feet Note: The Charleston County makes every effort possible to produce th e most accurate information. The layers contained in the map service are for information purposes only. The Charleston County makes no warranty, express or implied, nor any guaranty as to the content, sequence, accuracy, timeliness or completeness of any of the information provided. The County explicitly disclaims all representations and warranties. The reader agrees to hold harmless the Charleston County for any cause of action and costs associated with any causes of action which may arise as a consequence of the County providing this information. ´ 55 ATTACHMENT #8 FEMA Base Flood Elevations (Current & Preliminary) 56 FEMA Base Flood Elevation (Current) AE-13 FEMA Base Flood Elevation (Preliminary) AE-11 57 ATTACHMENT #9 Title to Real Estate 58 59 60 61 62 63 ATTACHMENT #10 Property Information Card 64 /0 /1 /2 /3 /1 /2 /4 /5/6/7 /8 /9 /10 /11 /12 /13 /14 /15 /16 /i255 /7 /15 /18 /16 /14 /19 /20 /i255 /21 /15 /18 /14 /8 /i255 /7 /9 /10 /15 /11 /22 /16 /9 /13 /23 /24 /23 /8 /9 /10 /11 /12 /13 /14 /15 /16 /24 /23 /15 /18 /16 /14 /19 /25 /26 /15 /27 /12 /10 /16/28/9/29 /25 /23 /15/28/1/13 /27 /23 /1 /14 /9 /30 /31 /13 /18/28/28/9/10 /19 /31 /10 /12 /32 /15 /10 /14 /31 /21 /7 /24 /7 /8 /9 /10 /25 /9 /13 /32 /33 /34 /10 /22 /16 /14 /35 /22 /12 /36 /37 /38 /10 /18 /12 /39 /10 /31 /16/28/37/14 /9 /30 /31 /10 /12 /32 /15 /10 /14 /39 /14 /31 /36 /23 /37/40/41/7 /32 /9 /10 /23 /12 /11 /22 /42/40/43/44 /5 /3 /41 /5 /4 /4 /4 /4 /0 /0/45 /5 /1 /5 /46 /47 /48 /49 /50 /51 /52 /53 /54 /55 /i255 /46 /54 /57 /55 /53 /58 /59 /i255 /60 /54 /57 /53 /47 /i255 /46 /48 /49 /54 /50 /61 /55 /48 /62 /63 /64 /63 /65 /66 /67 /63 /68 /i255 /70 /64 /i255 /71 /72 /73 /74 /72 /73 /75 /76 /77 /i255 /78 /79 /80 /76 /79 /74 /76 /i255 /81/82/i255/83 /84/85 /86 /87 /88 /89 /90 /87 /91 /92 /i255 /94/95/i255/96 /86 /94 /97 /98 /i255/99 /100 /91 /90 /87 /101 /102 /91 /90 /i255 /94 /95 /96 /99 /94 /97 /98 /i255/86 /102 /87 /103 /90 /100 /i255 /99 /104 /104 /87 /90 /105 /105 /i255 /95/102/91 /102 /87 /90 /106 /87 /90 /105 /107 /90 /104 /i255 /102 /105 /88 /106 /i255 /99 /105 /105 /90 /105 /105 /108 /90 /102 /87 /i255/86 /102 /92 /i255 /108 /90 /102 /87 /i255 /109 /110 /111 /109 /112 /112 /112 /112 /113 /113/i255/115 /112 /116 /i255 /117 /118 /119 /119 /120 /121 /122 /117 /i255 /123 /119 /i255 /117 /118 /124 /i255 /125 /119 /126 /127 /118 /121 /121 /128 /i255 /129 /125 /120 /126 /130/131/113 /132 /116 /109 /132 /116 /112 /109/133/116 /112 /109 /115/116 /112 /109 /115 /i255 /134 /135 /87 /87 /90 /101 /91 /i255 /86 /102 /87 /103 /90 /100 /i255 /94 /101 /106 /88 /87/136/102/91 /137 /88 /101 /i255 /138/139/101/90 /87 /i255 /140 /141/95/95/141/140 /142 /141 /97 /i255 /134 /108 /97 /143/144/94/99 /i255/144/i255/140 /141/95/95/141/140 /142 /141 /97 /140/138/145/141 /140 /143 /i255 /142 /138/139/101/90 /87 /i255 /99 /104 /104 /87 /90/105 /105/i255/146/147 /147 /148 /i255/138/149/149 /141 /108 /i255 /149 /97 /i255 /145 /150 /140 /151 /141 /i255 /152 /99 /i255 /147 /147 /153 /154 /146 /86 /87 /88 /89 /90 /87 /91 /92 /i255 /134 /100 /102 /105 /105 /i255 /134 /88 /104 /90/i255/154/153 /154 /i255 /155 /i255 /140 /141 /142 /94/95/155/142 /156 /140 /99 /103 /87 /90 /102 /157 /90/i255/158 /153 /153 /153 /153 /149 /90 /157 /102 /100 /i255/95/90/105 /103 /87 /137 /89/91 /137 /88 /101/i255/142/135 /159 /104 /137 /160 /137 /105 /137 /88 /101 /i255 /97 /102/136/90/i255 /155 /143 /140 /141 /141 /149/138/156/143 /i255 /152 /94 /149 /149 /99 /142 /i255/95/90/105 /103 /87 /137 /89 /91 /137 /88 /101 /i255 /155 /149/138/143/i255 /161 /153 /147 /i255 /86 /100 /102 /91 /142 /135 /106 /106 /137 /162 /i255 /99 /149 /155 /163 /153 /i255 /86 /88 /100 /143/139/89/i255 /153 /153 /164 /i255 /144/137/105 /91 /88 /87 /137 /103 /i255 /94 /101 /106 /88 /87/136/102/91 /137 /88 /101 /i255 /143 /102 /162 /i255 /108 /90 /102 /87 /i255/149 /102 /101 /104/i255/94 /136/89/87 /88 /160 /90/136/90/101 /91 /105/i255/165 /102/87 /166 /90 /91/i255/143 /102 /162 /90 /105 /i255/86 /102 /92/136/90/101 /91 /i255 /116 /112 /109 /115 /167 /109 /112 /112 /124 /112 /112 /112/i255/167 /109 /112 /112 /124 /112 /112 /112/i255/167 /116 /112 /112 /124 /112 /112 /112/i255/167 /116 /124 /111 /115 /116 /168 /116 /112 /i255/167 /116 /124 /111 /115 /116 /168 /116 /112 /i255 /116 /112 /109 /111 /167 /109 /112 /112 /124 /112 /112 /112/i255/167 /109 /112 /112 /124 /112 /112 /112/i255/167 /116 /112 /112 /124 /112 /112 /112/i255/167 /116 /124 /111 /112 /115 /168 /116 /112 /i255/167 /116 /124 /111 /112 /115 /168 /116 /112 /i255 /116 /112 /109 /169 /167 /109 /112 /112 /124 /112 /112 /112/i255/167 /109 /112 /112 /124 /112 /112 /112/i255/167 /116 /112 /112 /124 /112 /112 /112/i255/167 /116 /124 /169 /112 /113 /168 /110 /112 /i255/167 /116 /124 /169 /112 /113 /168 /110 /112 /i255 /116 /112 /109 /113 /167 /109 /112 /112 /124 /112 /109 /116/i255/167 /109 /109 /112 /124 /113 /112 /112/i255/167 /116 /109 /112 /124 /113 /109 /116/i255/167 /116 /124 /113 /133 /111 /168 /116 /112 /i255/167 /116 /124 /113 /133 /111 /168 /116 /112 /i255 /i255 /142 /102 /100 /90 /105 /i255/95/137/105 /103 /100 /88 /105 /135 /87 /90 /i255 /170/87/102 /101 /91 /88 /87 /i255 /145 /88 /88 /166 /i255 /171 /i255 /86 /102 /157 /90/i255/95 /102/91 /90/i255/95 /90/90 /104 /i255/152 /102 /103 /102 /101 /91 /i255/142 /102 /100 /90 /i255 /86 /87 /137 /103 /90 /i255 /140 /i255 /141 /i255 /145 /i255 /149 /94 /152 /94 /97 /170/i255 /143 /140 /150 /142/143/153 /172 /164 /146 /i255 /163 /146 /173/i255/173 /174 /147 /153 /174 /147 /153 /154 /146/i255/170 /90 /175 /147 /153 /153 /176 /153 /153 /153 /i255 /i255 /145 /140 /150 /97 /141 /i255 /140/138/97/99/149/95/i255/141/95 /172/154 /173 /i255 /153 /164 /147/i255/161 /174 /163 /153 /174 /147 /153 /153 /147/i255/170 /90 /175 /154 /i255 /i255 /i255 /97 /154 /173 /163 /i255 /161 /154 /148/i255/163 /174 /163 /174 /154 /164 /161 /161/i255/170 /90 /175 /146 /153 /176 /153 /153 /153 /i255 /i255 /i255 /94/136/89/87 /88 /160 /90/136/90/101 /91 /105 /i255 /145 /135 /137 /100 /104 /137 /101 /157 /i255/143 /92 /89 /90 /i255/150 /105 /90 /i255 /134 /88 /104 /90 /95/90/105 /103 /87 /137 /89 /91 /137 /88 /101 /i255 /134 /88 /101 /105 /91 /87 /135 /103 /91 /90 /104 /108 /90 /102 /87 /i255/142 /91 /88 /87 /137 /90 /105/i255/145/90 /104 /87 /88 /88/136/105/i255/156 /137 /101 /137 /105 /107 /90 /104 /i255 /142 /177 /158 /156 /91 /158 /i255 /94/136/89/87 /88 /160 /90/136/90/101 /91 /142 /137 /178 /90 /i255 /140 /153 /154 /95/179 /141/149/149/95 /139 /90/100 /100 /137 /101/157/154 /164 /173/161/154 /158/153/153 /147/154 /176 /147 /148 /164 /i255 /i255 65 ATTACHMENT #11 Public Hearing Notice: Letter to Neighboring Property Owners 66 PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE TO: FROM: SUBJECT: DATE: Neighboring Property Owners Joseph M. Cronin, Town Administrator/Zoning Administrator Variance Request #161 - 802 Treeloft Trace April 19, 2019 Dear Property Owner, The purpose of this letter is to notify you that the owners of 802 TREELOFT TRACE have requested a VARIANCE from the zoning requirements of the Town’s Development Standards Ordinance (DSO). The purpose of the variance request is to REDUCE THE REAR YARD SETBACK REQUIREMENT FROM 15 FEET TO APPROXIMATELY 3.5 FEET TO ALLOW FOR THE EXP ANSION OF AN EXISTIN G NON -CONFORMING OPEN DECK (§ 7.60.40.30). A copy of the variance application is enclosed for your information. The Town’s Board of Zoning Appeals has scheduled a PUBLIC HEARING, during which time the Board will hear testimony from any individual who wishes to speak regarding the variance request. This notification is being provided to you pursuant to Section § 19.30.20.30 of the DSO . PUBLIC HEARING DATE: Tues. May 28, 2019 PUBLIC HEARING TIME: 1:00 PM PUBLIC HEARING LOCATION: Seabrook Island Town Hall 2001 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island, SC 29455 In addition to attending the public hearing, interested parties may submit written comments in advance of the public hearing, as follows: ONLINE: www.townofseabrookisland.org (Through 12:00 PM on May 21, 2019) BY E-MAIL: jcronin@townofseabrookisland.org BY MAIL: Town of Seabrook Island, Attn: Zoning Administrator 2001 Seabrook Island Road, Seabrook Island, SC 29455 If you have any questions about the contents of this letter, please feel free to contact me by phone at (843) 768-9121 or by email at jcronin@townofseabrookisland.org. Sincerely, Joseph M. Cronin Town Administrator/Zoning Administrator 67 ATTACHMENT #12 Public Hearing Notice: List of Neighboring Property Owners 68 Variance Notification List 802 Treeloft Trace Property Address Owner(s) of Record Mailing Address City State Zip 2473 High Hammock Road Glenn A. Boesger Trust 2531 Dorset Road Columbus OH 43221 2482 High Hammock Road Robert & Mary King 2998 East Avenue Rochester NY 14610 2511 High Hammock Road Kevin & Mary Brown 1023 Englewood Ct Summerville SC 29483 801 Treeloft Trace Thomas & Lindsay Yancey 801 Treeloft Trace Seabrook IslandSC 29455 803 Treeloft Trace Richard & Carole Heilman 11402 Stonewood Ln Rockville MD 20852 804 Treeloft Trace FIFE 2005 Trust 804 Treeloft Trace Seabrook IslandSC 29455 818 Treeloft Trace Richard & Sandra Allen 818 Treeloft Trace Seabrook IslandSC 29455 819 Treeloft Trace Donald Bouder 1262 Tumblestone Drive Mount Joy PA 17552 TM # 147‐00‐00‐027 The Club at Seabrook Island 1002 Landfall Way Seabrook IslandSC 29455 Property Owners Association Seabrook Island Property Owners Association 1202 Landfall Way Seabrook IslandSC 29455 Regime Treeloft Villas Owners Association 3741 Betsy Kerrison Pkwy, Suite I Johns Island SC 29455 69 ATTACHMENT #13 Public Hearing Notice: U.S.P.S. Certified Mail Receipts 70 71 72 73 ATTACHMENT #14 Public Hearing Notice: Post & Courier Legal Ad 74 75 ATTACHMENT #15 Public Hearing Notice: Property Posting 76 77 ATTACHMENT #16 Typical Unit (Treeloft Villas) 78 79 ATTACHMENT #17 Regime Standard for Deck Replacements (Treeloft Villas) 80 81 82 83 ATTACHMENT #18 Photos of Original Deck & New Regime Standard (Treeloft Villas) 84 85 86 ATTACHMENT #19 Photos of Neighboring Properties: 801 & 803 Treeloft Trace 87 88 89 ATTACHMENT #20 Setback Illustration for Treeloft Villas 90 dZ>K&ds/>>^  ^ĞƚďĂĐŬůŝŶĞƐĂƌĞĂƉƉƌŽdžŝŵĂƚĞ Setbacks 30’ Front 25’ Rear 15’ Open Deck Buildable Area ATTACHMENT #21 Letter from Treeloft Villas Owners Association (April 10, 2019) Treeloft Villas Owners Association Board of Directors Stephen Hildreth – President R o b e r t N e w m a n – Vice President Robert Fine – Treasurer M a r k P r e s t e r o – Secretary Robert Reddersen – At Large 3471 Betsy Kerrison Pkwy., Suite I, Johns Island, SC 29455 – 843.768.7185(0) – 843.768.7186(f) www.reliablehomesc.com April 10, 2019 Board of Zoning Appeals Town of Seabrook Island 2001 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island, SC 29455 RE: Variance Request from 802 Treeloft Trace To Whom It May Concern: Please allow this letter to serve as formal notice that the Treeloft Villas Owners Association Board of Directors is in favor of a variance being granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals to the owner of 802 Treeloft Trace with regard to the construction of a deck extension pursuant to the specifications further described below. In 2008, the Treeloft Board prepared a set of deck expansion plans to serve as a guide for all Treeloft owners and to ensure that deck improvements were uniform across all Treeloft properties. These plans were approved by the SIPOA Architectural Review Committee. There have been several owners in the Treeloft Association who have taken advantage of this standard upgrade. The extension does not extend further than the width of the actual villa itself; it only allows an owner to extend their deck roughly two feet to the edge of the villa. When the Treeloft Board adopted this standard, it was the intent that all owners would be allowed to make this modification should they wish to do so. In addition, the Board worked hard to choose plans for extending one’s deck which were modest and in good taste with the overall appearance of the community. See attached photos of an original deck and one that has been extend per the Treeloft Standard, as well as the SIPOA ARC approved plans. Recently, the Treeloft Board was provided with the attached map showing the “buildable area” highlighted in white. As you will see, at least eight (8) villas would not be allowed to extend their decks per the approved Treeloft standard due to setbacks. In principal, the Board would, in the future, be in favor of variances being granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals to all Treeloft homeowners currently impacted by setbacks to extend their decks pursuant to the deck extension plans referenced above. Please do not hesitate to contact me should you have any questions or need any further information. Sincerely, Stephen Hildreth Board President for Treeloft Villas O.A. dZ>K&ds/>>^  ^ĞƚďĂĐŬůŝŶĞƐĂƌĞĂƉƉƌŽdžŝŵĂƚĞ Setbacks 30’ Front 25’ Rear 15’ Open Deck Buildable Area Attachment A Dwg. 100 (10X10 rear deck; 8X10 front deck) Dwg 101 (10X10 front deck with revised stairway) ATTACHMENT #22 Letter from Seabrook Island Club (April 18, 2019) 1 Joe Cronin From: Caleb Elledge <celledge@discoverseabrook.com> Sent: Thursday, April 18, 2019 12:53 PM To: Joe Cronin Cc: mhdohoney@aol.com; Sean Hardwick Subject: Treeloft Hello Joe,    Mike Dohoney met with Sean Hardwick and me last week regarding a deck he has or is putting on a home on Treeloft. I  believe the issue is that it crosses or comes too close to the Club’s property line. For what it is worth, Sean and I are fine  with this and have no issues at all if the deck were to cross onto club property in this particular location.  I meant to  mention this to you at Town Hall last week at the emergency planning meeting, but it slipped my mind.  Please let me  know if you have any questions. Thanks!    Caleb Elledge, CCM General Manager/Chief Operating Officer   Seabrook Island, South Carolina www.discoverseabrook.com        ATTACHMENT #23 Letter from Stewart Fife (April 24, 2019) 1 Joe Cronin From: "stewart.fife@gmail.com" <no-reply@weebly.com> Sent: Wednesday, April 24, 2019 12:31 PM To: Joe Cronin Subject: New Form Entry: Public Comments - Variance #161 You've just received a new submission to your Public Comments - Variance #161. Submitted Information: Name Stewart Fife Address 804 Treeloft Trace Seabrook Island, SC 29455 Email Address stewart.fife@gmail.com Do you support the approval of Variance #161? Yes - In Favor Comment Dear Sir or Madam, I'm writing in strong support of the Reddersen's appeal and respectfully request that you please consider reducing the rear yard setback requirement in order to allow the Reddersens to expand their deck in the same manner in which other Treeloft Villa decks have been expanded. Thank you for taking my comment into consideration. Best wishes, Stewart Fife ATTACHMENT #24 Letter from Heather Fife (April 24, 2019) 1 Joe Cronin From: "heather_fife@hotmail.com" <no-reply@weebly.com> Sent: Wednesday, April 24, 2019 12:36 PM To: Joe Cronin Subject: New Form Entry: Public Comments - Variance #161 You've just received a new submission to your Public Comments - Variance #161. Submitted Information: Name Heather Fife Address 804 Treeloft Trace Seabrook Island, SC 29455 Email Address heather_fife@hotmail.com Do you support the approval of Variance #161? Yes - In Favor Comment I am strongly in favor of the Reddersen's appeal. By reducing the rear yard setback requirement, they will be able to expand their rear deck and bring it into conformance with other Treeloft Villas. Best, Heather Fife ATTACHMENT #25 Letter from Richard Heilman (May 1, 2019) 1 Joe Cronin From: "rheilman@his.com" <no-reply@weebly.com> Sent: Wednesday, May 1, 2019 3:14 PM To: Joe Cronin Subject: New Form Entry: Public Comments - Variance #161 You've just received a new submission to your Public Comments - Variance #161. Submitted Information: Name Richard Heilman Address 803 Treeloft Trace Email Address rheilman@his.com Do you support the approval of Variance #161? Yes - In Favor Comment As the owner of the neighboring villa at 803 Treeloft, our property falls into the same setback restrictions as 802 Treeloft. We were never advised of such restrictions when purchasing and I'm now shocked to learn of the setback situation. The Reddersens are correct to note that the setback restrictions were put in place retroactively long after the construction of the houses. As with other situations of which I'm aware on the island, our villas should be grandfathered in and thus not encumbered by the now current setback rules. ATTACHMENT #26 Letter from Steve Hildreth (May 16, 2019) 1 Joe Cronin From: "Shildrethsr@aol.com" <no-reply@weebly.com> Sent: Thursday, May 16, 2019 8:18 AM To: Joe Cronin Subject: New Form Entry: Public Comments - Variance #161 You've just received a new submission to your Public Comments - Variance #161. Submitted Information: Name Steve Address Hildreth Email Address Shildrethsr@aol.com Do you support the approval of Variance #161? Yes - In Favor Comment ATTACHMENT #21 Letter from Joanne Fagan (May 22, 2019) 1 Joe Cronin From: no-reply@weebly.com Sent: Wednesday, May 22, 2019 5:29 AM To: Joe Cronin Subject: New Form Entry: Public Comments - Variance #161 You've just received a new submission to your Public Comments - Variance #161. Submitted Information: Name Joanne Fagan Address 813 Treeloft Trace Email Address Joanne.fagan@comcast.net Do you support the approval of Variance #161? Yes - In Favor Comment I am in favor of this variance being passed, as it will benefit all Treeloft and Sealoft homeowners. As these setback standards were implemented after incorporation of the Town of Seabrook Island, it is only fair that homeowners in these communities be grandfathered to perform improvements to their homes under the guidelines of the particular regime and ARC approval. Variance Application (Rev. 05/2019) Page 1 of 3 TOWN OF SEABROOK ISLAND 2001 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island, SC 29455 (843) 768-9121 APPLICATION FOR VARIANCE Board of Zoning Appeals Any applicant seeking a variance from the zoning requirements of the Town of Seabrook Island’s Development Standards Ordinance (hereafter, the “DSO”) must submit a written application, along with a $350.00 application fee and all required supplemental information. Applications must be typed or written legibly in ink. Please attach an additional sheet of paper if more space is needed. If you need assistance filling out this application form, please contact the Zoning Administrator by phone at (843) 768-9121 or by email at jcronin@townofseabrookisland.org. 1. PROPERTY INFORMATION Please provide information regarding the property which is subject to the variance request. Property Address Tax Map Number Block Lot Lot Size (Square Feet) Is this property subject to an OCRM critical line? (eg. Marsh or Beachfront Lots) Yes No Is this property subject to private restrictions or covenants? (eg. SIPOA or regime) Yes No 2. APPLICANT(S) Please provide information regarding the individual(s) who is (are) submitting the variance request. Applicant Name(s) Applicant Address Applicant Phone Number Applicant Email Address If the Applicant is NOT an owner of the property, what is the relationship to the Property Owner(s)? 3. PROPERTY OWNER(S) If the Applicant(s) is (are) NOT the property owner(s), please provide information for the property owner(s). Owner Name(s) Owner Mailing Address Owner Phone Number Owner Email Address Designation of Agent (Required if the Applicant(s) is(are) NOT a Property Owner): I (we) hereby designate and appoint the above named Applicant(s) as my (our) agent(s) to represent me (us) in this application. Owner Signature(s) Date Date 4. CERTIFICATION Under penalty of perjury, I (we) hereby certify that the information contained in this application , including all supplemental materials, is true and accurate to the best of my (our) knowledge. Applicant Signature(s) Date Date OFFICE USE ONLY Date Filed: Variance Application #: Hearing Date: Variance Application (Rev. 05/2019) Page 2 of 3 5. VARIANCE REQUEST A. Please provide a brief description of the proposed scope of work: B. In order to complete the proposed scope of work, the Applicant(s) is (are) requesting a variance from the following requirement(s) of the town’s DSO: 1) DSO Section Reference(s): 2) DSO Requirement(s): C. The application of the zoning requirements of the town’s DSO will result in unnecessary hardship, and the standards for a variance set by State Law and the DSO are met by the following facts: 1) There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to this particular piece of property as follows: 2) These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity as shown by: 3) Because of these conditions, the application of the zoning requirements to this particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property as follows: 4) The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance for the following reasons: Variance Application (Rev. 05/2019)    Page 3 of 3  6. APPLICATION MATERIALS    In addition to the completed Variance Application Form, all  requests for variance must  be accompanied by the  supplemental  materials  listed  below.  An  application  is  not  considered  “complete”  until  all  required  documentation has been received by the Zoning Administrator. Below is a checklist of the required materials:      Completed & Signed Variance Application Form (Paper Required; PDF Optional)     Please submit one completed paper application. All signatures must be original.    $350.00 Application Fee     The application fee may be paid by cash or check only.    As‐Built Survey / Survey of Existing Conditions (Paper Required; PDF Optional)     All applications must be accompanied by an as‐built survey which accurately illustrates the  existing conditions on the property, including setback measurements for all structures.    Proposed Site Plan (Paper & PDF Required)     Required for all new structures and/or exterior modifications which will change the footprint of  one or more existing structures.   For lots abutting a marsh or beachfront jurisdictional line, the location of the critical line must be  certified by OCRM within the previous five (5) years.    Scaled Architectural Drawings: (Paper & PDF Required)     Required for all new structures and/or exterior modifications to existing structures.    Architectural drawings must show, at a minimum:  o A detailed floor plan or plan view; and  o Front, side and rear elevations, as appropriate.    Letter of Approval from Property Owners Association and/or Regime: (Paper Required; PDF Optional)     Required for all properties which are subject to private restrictions and/or covenants.   If approval is pending, please attach a Letter of Acknowledgement from the POA and/or Regime.    Letters of support, petitions, photographs, and any other documentation which an Applicant feels may     support his or her request may be attached but are not required. (Paper & Digital Files Optional)    CRITERIA FOR REVIEW    Pursuant to Section 6‐29‐800(A)(2) of the SC Code of Laws, the Board of Zoning Appeals has the power to hear  and decide appeals for variance from  the requirements of  the zoning ordinance when strict application of  the  provisions of the  ordinance would  result in unnecessary hardship. A  variance may be  granted in an individual  case of unnecessary hardship if the board makes and explains in writing the following findings:    (a) there are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property;    (b) these conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity;    (c) because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance t o the particular piece of property would  effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and    (d) the authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public  good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance.    The  board  may not  grant a  variance,  the  effect  of  which  would  be  t o a l l o w  t h e e s t a b l i s h m e n t o f a u s e n o t  otherwise permitted in a zoning district, to extend physically a nonconforming use of land or to change the zoning  district boundaries shown on the official zoning map. The fact that property may be utilized more profitably, if a  variance is granted, may not be considered grounds for a variance. Other requirements may be prescribed by the  zoning ordinance.    In granting a variance,  the board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character,  or other  features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to  protect established  property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare.    1 Joe Cronin From: Lynda Stearns Sent: Wednesday, May 22, 2019 10:23 AM To: Joe Cronin Subject: FW: 2016-09-29 Amendment to Conservation Easement.PDF Attachments: 2016-09-29 Amendment to Conservation Easement.PDF     From: David Maybank III <dmaybank3@maybankproperties.com>   Sent: Tuesday, May 21, 2019 5:45 PM  To: Lynda Stearns <Lstearns@townofseabrookisland.org>  Subject: 2016‐09‐29 Amendment to Conservation Easement.PDF    Lynda,    I received your letter regarding the septic tank on Cotton Island.  At the date of our purchase of the island, there was no  septic system in place.  I have attached a copy of the amended conservation easement that was recorded on September  30, 2016 at the Charleston County ROD at Book 0587 Page 109.  Paragraph 3 of this easement amendment prohibits,  among other things, the construction of septic systems.  Based on the amended conservation easement, I believe the  concern outlined in your letter is moot.    Please let me know if you have any additional questions.    Best regards,      David    ‐‐ ‐‐     David Maybank III  Maybank Properties LLC  P.O. Box 20397  Charleston, SC 29413‐0397     (843) 740‐9200 (main number)  (843) 740‐9201 (my office direct)  (843) 720‐1061 (office fax)  (843) 813‐2815 (mobile)  dmaybank3@MaybankProperties.com     www.MaybankProperties.com     

Source: Town of Seabrook Island website. First collected Nov 1, 2026.