RecordWell Data

Historic District Review Board — Agenda Packet

City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · Historic District Review Board · meeting of Sep 10, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Beaufort

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

MEETING AGENDA The City of Beaufort HISTORIC DISTRICT REVIEW BOARD Wednesday, September 10, 2025, 2:00 P.M. City Hall, Council Chambers, 2nd Floor – 1911 Boundary Street, Beaufort, SC Please click the link below to access the webinar: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/82837710964?pwd=94IBeHFR4LhnP07Tgk1yrDg67gHsMK.1 Password: 472352 Meeting ID: 828 3771 0964 Call in Phone #: 1+929 205 6099 STATEMENT OF MEDIA NOTIFICATION: “In accordance with South Carolina Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, all local media were duly notified of the time, date, place, and agenda of this meeting.” Note: A project will not be reviewed if the applicant or representative is not present at the meeting. I. Call to Order: II. Review of Minutes: A. August 13, 2025 Meeting Minutes III. Applications: A. 811 Congress Street, PIN R120 004 000 0104 0000, sketch approval Applicant: Larry Holman, owner The applicant is requesting conceptual approval for a new construction duplex at 811 Congress Street. B. 1107 Prince Street, PIN R120 004 000 0503 0000, alterations, additions Applicant: Benjie Morillo, Architect, Frederick + Frederick Architects The applicant is requesting final approval for various alterations & additions to exterior & interior, including interior addition of a bedroom (front), expansion of kitchen/dining areas, new front porch (unscreened), new side porch (screened) as well as new terrace at the rear of dwelling and a new driveway. IV. Discussion V. Adjournment 1 Historic District Review Board Meeting Minutes – August 13, 2025 CALL TO ORDER 1:10 A meeting of the Historic District Review Board was held in-person on Wednesday, August 13, 2025 at 2:00 pm. ATTENDEES Members in attendance: Mike Sutton (Chair), Eric Berman, (Vice-Chair), Rita Wilson, Kim Petrella, and Grady Woods. Staff in attendance: Christopher Klement, Community Development Planner III, Nick Navia, Community Development Planner I, Meadors Architects, and Julie A. Bachety, Community Development Administrative Assistant II. REVIEW OF MINUTES OF MAY 14, 2025 1:18 Mr. Sutton abstained from voting since he was absent from the May 14, 2025 meeting. Motion: Mr. Berman approved the minutes as presented. Mr. Woods seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. All Historic District Review Board Meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s website at http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter. REVIEW OF MINUTES OF JUNE 11, 2025 2:00 Mr. Berman abstained from voting since he was absent from the June 11, 2025 meeting. Motion: Mr. Woods approved the minutes as presented. Ms. Wilson seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. All Historic District Review Board Meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s website at http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter. REVIEW OF MINUTES OF JULY 9, 2025 2:42 Ms. Wilson abstained from voting since she was absent from the July 9, 2025 meeting. 2 Motion: Mr. Berman approved the minutes as presented. Mr. Woods seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. All Historic District Review Board Meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s website at http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter. APPLICATIONS 3:14 A. 404 Scott Street, PIN R120 004 000 0809 0000, addition Applicant: Thomas Rhodes, Architect The applicant is requesting approval for an addition of a covered porch, with a brick walkway leading out to the sidewalk, new shutters, new siding, and new living fence. Existing windows and single roof to remain; porch roof to be a standing seam metal roof that will tie into existing shingle roof. Nick Navia presented his staff report. Public Comment: Lise Sundrla, Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF) Director, said we are in agreement with these changes. Ms. Sundrla talked about false narratives. She commented that it is very important for everyone to be thinking about this and how we go forward protecting the integrity of our historic district is making sure that where every possible to follow the Secretary of Interior Standards, so what changes are made are reversible. Ms. Sundrla believes the changes proposed are reversable. Ms. Sundrla prefers for the applicant to keep the CMU structure because it is the architectural character of the building when it was done. She doesn’t mind the green for the roof. Public comment closed. Motion: Mr. Berman made a motion to approve the project as presented with removing the comment about changing the roof color, but leave all other staff recommendations in place. Ms. Wilson seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Mr. Berman left the meeting at this point 35:10 Mr. Sutton stated at this point that the Board had a discussion as part of their 35:36 training dialogue and not an agenda item. Ms. Sundrla passed out documents to the board members giving them an update on what is happening with 1001 Greene Street property that HBF purchased. ADJOURNMENT : Mr. Woods made a motion seconded by Mr. Woods to adjourn. The meeting ended at 2:40 pm. 811 CONGRESS STREET The applicant is requesƟng conceptual approval for a new construcƟon duplex at 811 Congress Street STAFF REPORT: Historic District Review Board (HRB) 811 CONGRESS STREET DATE: September 10, 2025 GENERAL INFORMATION Applicant: Larry Holman (Architect) Site Address / Tax PIN: 811 Congress Street; R120 004 000 0104 0000 Applicant's Request: Applicant is requesting conceptual approval of a new construction duplex at 811 Congress Street. Current Zoning: T4-HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT (T4-HN) Contributing/Neighborhood Vacant lot – Old Commons Flood Zone/Base Flood Flood Zone: X, Elevation: 16 ft – 18 ft Existing Trees No Specimen/Landmark trees are affected by this request. ZONING DISTRICT INFORMATION T4-HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT (T4-HN) Lot Width at Setback: 40 ft min Minimum Lot Size: 4,000 sqft min Max Lot Coverage: 55% of lot area (This percentage indicates maximum lot coverage by roofs; total impervious coverage may be an additional 10%. Parcels may also be subject to Section 8.3 - Stormwater) Frontage Build Out 75% max Front Setback Average Prevailing Setback on Block Side Setback Corner/Alley: 5 ft min Interior: 6 ft min Rear Setback 15 ft min; from alley: 0 ft. Building Height: Primary Structures: 3 stories max Accessory Structures: 2 stories or 30 ft max SURROUNDING ZONING, LAND USE AND REQUIRED BUFFERS Adjacent Zoning Adjacent Land Uses Setbacks for Adjacent Zoning /Buffer required if rezoned North: T4-HN 1107 West St (Noncontributing, ca. 1920) N/A South: T4-HN 812 Congress St (Contributing, ca. 1900) N/A East: T4-HN 807 Congress St (Noncontributing, ca. 1930) N/A West: T4-N 1102 West St (Contributing, ca. 1930) N/A 2 Background: The applicant is requesting conceptual approval for a new construction duplex located at the north- east corner of Congress and West Street. The site is currently vacant after the approved (in 2014) demolition of a 1950s noncontributing 1-story frame dwelling. The applicant has been to four (4) HTRC Meetings. Project timeline Jan. 2024 Feb. M ar. Apr. May Jun. Jul. Aug. Sep. Oct. Nov. Dec. 5/1: 1st HTRC Meeting 7/24: 2nd HTRC Meeting Jan. 2025 Feb. M ar. Apr. May Jun. Jul. Aug. Sep. Oct. Nov. Dec. 5/28: 3rd HTRC Meeting 8/6: 4th HTRC Meeting 8/18: HRB Meeting Request 9/10: HRB 3 Summary of the 8/6/2025 HTRC Meeting Comments: 1. Planning and Zoning: o Zoned T4-HN 2. Architecture: o Staff is supportive of the changes to the front façade and believes it is a better representation of the architecture found in the Beaufort historic district. o Staff is unsure why the gable at the back of the structure is taller than the gable on the front of the structure. Staff recommends lowering the rear gable so that it aligns with the top of the main gable. o The rear façade (north) appears to be very wide with only one set of ganged windows on each floor. Staff believes more windows may be added to this façade based on the current interior configuration, or with slight modifications to the interior configuration. Staff also recommends reducing the width of the front gabled portion on the north façade. o Staff has questions about the deck on the east elevation. Staff believes it creates an awkward roof form above it. Is this structure a duplex? The plan is that of a duplex, but there is an interior staircase that appears to communicate between the first and second floors. Without the kitchen upstairs, the plans read as a typical four-bedroom single-family house. o Staff recommends spacing the windows on the west elevation in the kitchen farther apart. They appear to crowd each other. Staff would be supportive of reducing the width of these windows. o Staff is supportive of the side porch design on the west elevation. o There is no garage floor plan, but staff is generally supportive of the design. Staff recommends adding more fenestration above the garage doors – the set of ganged windows appears small on this wall with large expanses of siding on either side of it. o Provide a site plan that shows the lot coverage. For a T4-HN property, the maximum lot coverage (coverage by roofs) is 55%. 3. Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF): o Front (south) façade:  Much improved – design is much more in keeping with historic district.  Concerned that rear roof height appears taller than front gable. o East elevation:  Was removing the windows intentional? • If so, suggest they be added back.  Purpose of railing on first level?  Roof height appears taller than front gable. From the design, it is visible from the South elevation. o North Elevation:  Ganged windows don’t match the rest of the house fenestration. Consider separating the windows. o West elevation:  Much improved! o Garage:  West elevation is much improved.  Roof height appears the same as the main house. Suggest lowering the garage roof. (Also suggest lowering the height of the rear roof of the main house.) Tree Removal Proposed: No Specimen/Landmark trees are affected by this request. 4 Surrounding Area: Located in the Old Commons neighborhood, the lot lies on the north-east corner of Congress and West Street. The surrounding properties mostly date from 1900-1930 and are a mix of contributing and noncontributing structures. Determination of adequate historic integrity for New Construction, Infill, Additions and Demolition: As per the Beaufort Preservation Manual (Chapter 5) and the Beaufort Development Code (Section 4.7), the compatibility of new infill construction as well as major renovations within the Beaufort Historic District is determined in consideration with the following principles: 1. Location, 2. Design, 3. Setting, 4. Materials, 5. Workmanship, 6. Feeling and 7. Association. See detailed staff analysis and recommendations in table below. 4.7.2 Integrity Guidelines (as per Beaufort Development Code) Rationale Present Staff Analysis of Rationale 1. Location: This is the relationship between the property and its historical context. YES  811 Congress Street is located within the Old Commons neighborhood of the Historic District. Staff believes the proposal would not negatively impact the relationship between the property and its historical context within the area. 2. Design: This is the combination of elements that create the feeling of a district or structure. These elements include building patterns, streetscapes, site elements, building size, mass and scale, spatial relationships, and specific architectural elements and details. YES  Staff believes that after multiple revisions through the various HTRC meetings, the design has reached an acceptable level for Conceptual Approval by the HRB. Staff believes the proposal will not negatively alter the streetscape, nearby site elements, or the spatial relationship with nearby buildings. 3. Setting: This is the physical environment of a property and should be evaluated on its context as well as on the historical role the property has played and continues to play. Important features include topography, vegetation, man-made features, and relationships between existing structures and their surroundings. YES  Staff believes the relationship between the house and the historic setting of the neighborhood are not negatively impacted by the proposal. 4. Materials: These are the physical elements that make up a property or district. YES  A full material list has not yet been provided. Staff believes this is fine for Conceptual Approval. Of the materials shown within the plans (Horizontal Concrete Board Siding & Stucco Foundation), staff finds these acceptable. 5 5. Workmanship: This is the physical evidence of the crafts of a particular culture or time period. This particularly applies to rehabilitation projects, but for new infill projects, workmanship of surrounding structures should be considered and respected. YES  Staff believes the workmanship of the surrounding structures will not be negatively impacted by the proposal. 6. Feeling: This is the property's expression of the aesthetic or historic sense of a particular period of time. This particularly applies to rehabilitation projects, but for new infill projects, the feeling of surrounding structures should be considered and respected. YES  Staff believes the feeling of the surrounding structures will not be negatively impacted by the proposal. 7. Association: This is the direct link between an important historic event or person and a property. YES  N/A FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Staff Recommendation: Staff recommends CONCEPTUAL APPROVAL of the new construction duplex at 811 Congress Street, in that it satisfies the intent of the Beaufort Preservation Manual and requirements of the Beaufort Code, with the following changes being made to obtain final approval: 1. The rear gable, as currently shown, creates an odd connection with the main side-gabled form since it is taller than the side gable, so a small portion of it is visible from the front façade. Staff recommends lowering the rear gable so that it aligns with the top of the main gable. 2. On the east elevation, the main side-gable form lacks a corner adjacent to the door, so the gable does not protrude from the wall as is shown on the west elevation. This is an odd detail and should be resolved. Refer to the east elevation on sheet A4, and the second-floor plan on sheet A2 at the deck. 3. The rear façade (north) appears to be very wide with only one set of ganged windows on each floor. Staff believes more windows may be added to this façade based on the current interior configuration, or with slight modifications to the interior configuration. Staff also recommends reducing the width of the front gabled portion on the north façade. 4. Staff recommends spacing the windows on the west elevation in the kitchen farther apart. They appear to crowd each other. Staff would be supportive of reducing the width of these windows. 5. There are currently no windows proposed on the east elevation. Staff believes the applicant should add fenestration to break up the blank expanses of wall. 6. Applicant to provide drawings for the garage. Only the west elevation has been shown at this time. 6 7. Staff recommends adding more fenestration above the garage doors – the set of ganged windows appears small on this wall with large expanses of siding on either side of it. 8. Staff requests the applicant to provide an accurate site plan that includes the proposed lot coverage. 1107 PRINCE STREET The applicant is requesƟng final approval for various alteraƟons & addiƟons to exterior & interior, including interior addiƟon of a bedroom (front), expansion of kitchen/dining areas, new front porch (unscreened), new side porch (screened) as well as new terrace at the rear of dwelling and a new driveway STAFF REPORT: Historic District Review Board (HRB) 1107 PRINCE STREET DATE: September 10, 2025 1 GENERAL INFORMATION Applicant: Benjie Morillo (Architect) Site Address / Tax PIN: 1107 Prince Street / PIN: R120 004 000 0503 0000 Applicant's Request: Applicant is requesting final approval for the following: • Partial demolition (exterior & interior) per demolition plan (sheet D2.1); • Enclosure of existing screened porch; • Addition/extension of building footprint towards front (add. Bedroom & front porch), east side (extension of current kitchen/dining area & installation of new screened porch) as well as the rear (new terrace); • New driveway Current Zoning: T4-NEIGHBORHOOD (T4-N) Contributing/Neighborhood Non-Contributing - The Northwest Quadrant (c. 1960) Flood Zone/Base Flood Flood Zone “X”, Elevation: 17’ - 18’ Lot size / Square footage of building / lot coverage 10,055 sq. ft. (0.23 ac.) / 1,224 sq. ft. (existing); 1,511 sq. ft. (new - conditioned); 2,338 sq. ft. (new – unconditioned) / = 12% roofed footprint coverage (existing); = 23% roofed footprint coverage (new) ZONING DISTRICT INFORMATION T4-NEIGHBORHOOD (T4-N) Lot Width at Setback: n/a Minimum Lot Size: n/a Max Lot Coverage: 70% [This percentage indicates maximum lot coverage by roofs; total impervious coverage may be an additional 10%. Parcels may also be subject to Section 8.3 (Stormwater)]. Min. Frontage Build Out 60% min; 85% max Front Setback 0 ft. min. / 15 ft. max. Side Setback Corner: 0 ft. – 10 ft.; Interior: 5 ft. min., 0 ft. if attached Rear Setback 10 ft. min; from alley: 0 ft. Building Height: Primary: 4 stories max; 3.5 stories max in & fronting Historic District Accessory: 2 stories / 30 ft max SURROUNDING ZONING, LAND USE AND REQUIRED BUFFERS Adjacent Zoning Adjacent Land Uses Setbacks for Adjacent Zoning /Buffer required if rezoned North: T4-HN 1106 Duke St (SFH, contributing, ca. 1920) N/A 2 | P a g e ❖ Background: The applicant is requesting final approval for various exterior & interior alterations/additions to a non-contributing single-family residential dwelling, built c. 1960, including: a.) Partial demolition of interior walls, enclosure of existing screened porch, removal of existing doors and windows; b.) Addition of conditioned space in the front in form of an additional bedroom, enlarged kitchen/dining area; c.) Addition of a roofed (unscreened) front porch; d.) Installation of a new screened porch (east side); e.) Addition of a terrace (back of house); f.) Placement of a new driveway. ▪ Applicant has been to one (1) HTRC Meeting on September 11th, 2024 ▪ Applicant has also already been to one (1) HRB Meeting on May 14th, 2025 1108 Duke St (SFH, noncontributing, ca. 1945) South: T1 St. Helena’s Anglican Church & Cemetery (600 Newcastle St) N/A East: T4-N Grand Army of the Republic Hall (706 Newcastle St, ca. 1896) N/A West: T4-N House of God Church (1109 Prince St., noncontributing, ca. 1900) N/A 3 | P a g e ❖ Summary of HTRC Meeting on September 11, 2024 – Main discussion points: 1. Planning and Zoning: o Need to obtain a curb cut approval from SCDOT o ADU design approval ideally to be submitted with the property 2. Building Codes: o All setbacks seem to be met o Flood Zone: X 3. Architecture (Meadors): o Zoned T4-N o Non-contributing, circa 1960 o Provide the pervious and impervious coverage information o Staff supports proposed changes and additions o Pay attention to Beaufort Code Section 4.7 for seven integrities for infill. o Staff supports proposal to raise roof by 2 but concerned with how this impacts the scale of the portion that faces the street. Could the roof pitch be steeper with plate height minimally changing? o Staff does not support the use of the transom window as they are not typical of Beaufort Historic District. Staff supports window sizes being slightly larger than typical to create a differentiated yet compatible aesthetic. Possibly keep windows similar in scale on the front elevation and switch to larger windows down the sides and rear. o Since the existing windows are 6/6, can a different configuration other than 1/1 be used? Maybe 2/2? o Consider the cladding material as it wraps the building. There may be moments where the cladding changes at intersections of old and new o Recommend adding simple cap and base to all columns 4. Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF): o 1960’s building, still in shape and form to the district and neighborhood o Agree with staff architects on not having transom over the windows o Suggest trying to stick to the original form of the 1960’s design o Important to differentiate the original form from the additions o 2/2 windows are preferred by HBF on the existing structure ❖ Summary of Historic District Review Board (HDRB) Meeting on May 14, 2025 – Main discussion points: 1. Applicant to note that all windows and doors must have external grilles with internal spacer bars; 2. Staff recommends the applicant add one or two windows on the west façade at Bedroom 1 to break up the continuous stretch of blank wall. Staff would be supportive of either of the window sizes already shown on the west façade; 3. Applicant restudy the siding (horizontal vs. vertical clapboard siding) and windows (fiberglass composite vs. pure vinyl); 4. Consider a gable return for the front addition; and 5. That the applicant’s submission excludes the future addition and future ADU. 4 | P a g e ❖ Comparison between last and this HDRB Meeting request: HDRB Meeting - 5/14: HDRB Meeting - 9/10: Changes West elevation: ➢ Before: 2 x “DH1” windows (W: 2’ – 9 5/8”; H: 5’ – 8 7/8”); 3 x “DH2” windows (W: 2’ – 7 5/8”; H: 3’- 4 7/8”) ➢ After: 4 x “DH1” windows (W: 2’ – 9 5/8”; H: 5’ – 8 7/8”); 2 x “DH2” windows (W: 2’ – 7 5/8”; H: 3’- 4 7/8”) ➢ More windows have been added North elevation: ➢ Before: 1st back door (W: 3’ – 3 3/4”; H: 8’ – 9”); 2nd back door (W: 3’ – 3 5/8”; H: 8’ - 9”); 2 x “DH1” windows (W: 2’ – 9 5/8”; H: 5’ – 8 7/8”); 2 x “DH3” windows (W: 2’ – 11 5/8”; H: 5’ – 0 7/8”) ➢ After: 1st back door (W: 3’ – 2 1/2”; H: 8’ – 9”); 2nd back door (W: 3’ – 3 5/8”; H: 8’ - 6”); 2 x “DH1” windows (W: 2’ – 9 5/8”; H: 5’ – 8 7/8”); 2 x “DH3” windows (W: 2’ – 11 5/8”; H: 5’ – 0 7/8”) ➢ Same quantity, but somewhat different sizes of windows & manufacturer of windows and doors has changed (Marvin vs. Andersen → see spec sheet) 5 | P a g e East elevation: ➢ Before: 1 x regular back door (W: 3’ – 0 1/8”; H: 7’ – 11 1/2”); 1st slider door (W: 5’ – 11 ¼ “; H: 7’ 11 ½”); 2nd slider door (W: 5’ – 11 ¼ “; H: 7’ 11 ½”); 1 x “DH1” windows (W: 2’ – 9 5/8”; H: 5’ – 8 7/8”); 2 x gable windows (special fits) ➢ After: 1 x regular back door (W: 3’ – 0 1/8”; H: 7’ – 11 1/2”); 1st slider door (W: 5’ – 11 ¼ “; H: 7’ 11 ½”); 2nd slider door (W: 5’ – 11 ¼ “; H: 7’ 11 ½”); 2 x “DH1” windows (W: 2’ – 9 5/8”; H: 5’ – 8 7/8”); 2 x gable windows (special fits) ➢ One (1) more “DH1” - window has been added South elevation: ➢ Before: 1 x front door (W: 3’ – 4”; H: 8’ – 0”); 5 x “DH1” windows (W: 2’ – 9 5/8”; H: 5’ – 8 7/8”); ➢ After: 1 x front door (W: 3’ – 4”; H: 8’ – 0”); 5 x “DH1” windows (W: 2’ – 9 5/8”; H: 5’ – 8 7/8”); ➢ Front door: made of Sapele wood; ➢ Generally: Change from Hardie Reverse Board & Batten Siding to Hardie Lap Siding, Smooth ➢ Added: Box Eave Return 6 | P a g e ❖ Tree Removal Proposed: No Specimen/Landmark trees will be affected. ❖ Surrounding Area: This property lies within the Northwest Quadrant neighborhood of the Historic District. While this property itself is classified as noncontributing, many of the surrounding properties are classified as contributing structures. With the cemetery immediately to the south, and the multitude of churches all within a single block, this immediate area of Prince Street is of no doubt significant importance to the district. ❖ Determination of adequate historic integrity for New Construction, Infill, Additions and Demolition: As per the Beaufort Preservation Manual (Chapter 5) and the Beaufort Development Code (Section 4.7), the compatibility of new infill construction as well as major renovations within Beaufort Historic District is determined in consideration with the following principles: 1. Location, 2. Design, 3. Setting, 4. Materials, 5. Workmanship, 6. Feeling and 7. Association. See detailed staff analysis and recommendations in table below. 4.7.2 Integrity Guidelines (as per Beaufort Development Code) Rationale Present Staff Analysis of Rationale 1. Location: This is the relationship between the property and its historical context. YES ✓ 1107 Prince Street is in an area of the Northwest Quadrant that features many cemeteries and churches. The proposed renovations respect the sensitive historic context of the area, and do not detract or pull influence or attention away from the more prominent structures and sites in the immediate area. 2. Design: This is the combination of elements that create the feeling of a district or structure. These elements include building patterns, streetscapes, site elements, building size, mass and scale, spatial relationships, and specific architectural elements and details. YES ✓ The proposed design of the renovation maintains the overall feeling of the Northwest Quadrant. The newly renovated house will not alter the streetscape, nearby site elements, or the spatial relationship with nearby buildings. 3. Setting: This is the physical environment of a property and should be evaluated on its context as well as on the historical role the property has played and continues to play. Important features include topography, vegetation, man-made features, and relationships between existing structures and their surroundings. YES ✓ The relationship between the house and the historic setting of the neighborhood are well respected by the proposed design, materials and dimensions. 7 | P a g e 4. Materials: These are the physical elements that make up a property or district. YES ✓ The proposed materials are all acceptable within the Historic District for a noncontributing structure. 5. Workmanship: This is the physical evidence of the crafts of a particular culture or time period. This particularly applies to rehabilitation projects, but for new infill projects, workmanship of surrounding structures should be considered and respected. YES ✓ The proposed renovation respects the workmanship of the existing house as well as the surrounding structures. 6. Feeling: This is the property's expression of the aesthetic or historic sense of a particular period of time. This particularly applies to rehabilitation projects, but for new infill projects, the feeling of surrounding structures should be considered and respected. YES ✓ The proposed aesthetics respect the feeling of surrounding structures, and promotes the feeling in regard to historic sense, composition and architecture. 7. Association: This is the direct link between an important historic event or person and a property. YES ✓ The proposed renovation is in keeping of the architectural integrity and preservation standards and thus respects the historic importance the house has to the Beaufort Historic District. FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Staff Recommendation: Staff recommends Final Approval for the proposed alterations/additions, in that it satisfies the intent of the Beaufort Preservation Manual and requirements of the Beaufort Code. 1. Applicant to clarify the color of the windows and doors. The material sample sheet noted that the doors and windows will be black, but the color appears to be dark green. The colored renderings also make the doors and windows appear green. Staff is in support of either a black or a dark green but requests clarification. 2. Applicant is proposing to use 1x8 Hardie trim for the window heads. This appears to be too large in comparison with the smaller 1x4 trim on the sides – refer to 3D renderings on sheets A3.2 and A3.3. Staff recommends reducing the window head trim to 1x6. 3. There appears to be a small portion of metal roof between the porch beam and porch roof on the west side, which is best seen on rendering 1/A3.2. This appears to be an odd detail. Staff recommends this section of standing seam metal roof be removed and left as a simple porch beam. 4. Staff recommends the applicant select a different roof color than the “Solar White” and would recommend a light or dark gray color instead. 5. Applicant to provide a cutsheet for the metal roof. 6. Applicant to clarify the design and height of the screening system for the HVAC service yard on the west façade. 8 | P a g e In addition, the previously discussed recommendations have been implemented and staff is in support. 7. Applicant has removed previously shown future addition and garage from the site plan. A label for a “future courtyard” is shown. Applicant to note that this courtyard is not part of any approval for the proposed work to the main house. 8. Applicant has changed cladding material from board and batten to lap siding. 9. Applicant has circled the simulated divided lite selection on the window cutsheets – see sheet 4 of the cutsheet pages. 10. Applicant has added two (2) additional windows on the west façade – one (1) in bathroom #1 and another in bedroom #1.

Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Nov 1, 2026.