RecordWell Data

Capital Projects Quarterly Workshop and City Council Special Worksession — Agenda Packet

City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · General · meeting of Aug 26, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Beaufort

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Join from PC, Mac, iPad, or Android: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/88953273552?pwd=5rQbMPXRs8VeUvnSvaohT6lpu8IXZr.1 Passcode:343018 +13017158592 Webinar ID: 889 5327 3552 City of Beaufort 1911 Boundary Street Beaufort Municipal Complex Beaufort, South Carolina 29902 (843) 525-7070 City Council Capital Projects Quarterly Workshop/Special Worksession Agenda August 26, 2025 Statement of Media Notification "In accordance with South Carolina Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, all local media was duly notified of the time, date, place and agenda of this meeting." Capital Projects Quarterly Workshop/Special Worksession - Planning Conference Room - 5:00 PM Please note, this meeting will be broadcast via zoom and live-streamed on Facebook. You can view the meeting at the City's page; City Beaufort SC I. Call to Order - Philip Cromer, Mayor II. Presentation A. Capital Projects Update III. Discussion A. Employee Compensation Discussion IV. Adjourn Page 1 of 118 City of Beaufort Department Request for City Council Agenda Item To: City Council Date: 08/21/2025 From: Raul Dominguez, Capital Projects Director Item Name: Capital Projects Update Meeting Date: August 26, 2025 Department: City Managers Office Background Information: Introduction: Quarterly Project Overview Background: Legal Authority: Staff Recommendation: Placed on Agenda For: Attachments: 1. August 26 Qtrly Meeting Page 2 of 118 Scott Marshall CITY MANAGER 843-525-7070 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Philip E. Cromer, Mayor Mike McFee, Mayor Pro Tem Neil Lipsitz Mitch Mitchell Josh Scallate John Sauvé ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 843-379-7525 CITY OF BEAUFORT 1911 Boundary Street BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 Tuesday August 26, 2025 MEMORANDUM To: City Council From: Raul Dominguez, CIP Director Re: Capital Improvement Program Quarterly Report- Q-3 CY 2025 I. Summary Report CIP Director continues to be immersed in integral meetings with our area partners such as Beaufort County Engineering, BJWSA, Dominion Energy, SCDOT, and LATS. These meetings help all of us stay informed on projects affecting our area and increase our project coordination. The CIP Portal on the City website continues to be updated for the public in our ongoing efforts to expand our projects notifications and communications. II. Project Updates The following is a list of identified capital projects which have been completed to date: Southside Park Phase 1 Pigeon Point Park Allison Road Pigeon Point Landing Repairs Battery Shores Drainage Battery Shores Paving Page 3 of 118 Scott Marshall CITY MANAGER 843-525-7070 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Philip E. Cromer, Mayor Mike McFee, Mayor Pro Tem Neil Lipsitz Mitch Mitchell Josh Scallate John Sauvé ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 843-379-7525 CITY OF BEAUFORT 1911 Boundary Street BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 Active Projects The downtown and Point projects are set to kick off late September – early October. King St – Contract has been awarded to J. H. Hiers pre-con meetings are being held to communicate timelines with affected stakeholders, business owners and public. Charles/Craven – Bidding and Contract award is being managed by the South Carolina Office of Resilience those processes are under way. Port Republic – Because of the increase in costs this project may not be possible to accomplish during this cycle of work however, this will be on the top of the list as a shovel ready project for the next Capital Project Planning session. Waterfront Park – Engineering report has been added to AirTable. Phase 1A has been completed and we are looking to combine phase 1b & 2 for Waterfront Advisory Committee and City Council to review. Presentation of this phase to be made September 2nd for the WAC and Staff. Day Dock – Staff and Engineers are working on efforts to open the day dock plans are still under review and consideration. Washington St. Park – The park continues to come along very nicely, the framing is being wrapped with the cypress exterior as called for in the plans. Phase 2 RFP is out with an expected bid opening of September 18th. Southside Park Phase 2 – An open house meeting was held with staff, Davis & Floyd, and Wood & Partners to gather community input. Phase two will consist of four items outlined in the Master Plan which are Dog Park upgrades, Disc Golf, Open Field play area, Additional Trails. The remaining items within the master plan will be addressed in Phase 3. Page 4 of 118 Scott Marshall CITY MANAGER 843-525-7070 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Philip E. Cromer, Mayor Mike McFee, Mayor Pro Tem Neil Lipsitz Mitch Mitchell Josh Scallate John Sauvé ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 843-379-7525 CITY OF BEAUFORT 1911 Boundary Street BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 1st SCVAD – The selection committee is still in the negotiations phase with regards to design/scope of services. The committee along with the stakeholder group are also looking into future funding possibilities via non-profits, grants, community outreaches etc. Duke St – The Mayor, City Manager, and Deputy City Manager met with State Representatives to include SCDOT representatives to discuss the exception to on street parking request as approved in phase 1 & 2. I am also working with our local SCDOT engineer in efforts to accomplish this project. As part of this project there will be some improvements to the dip in the road. Pigeon Point Landing – There has been community involvement, and a few ideas have been shared with staff and design/engineers. The design and engineering team have put the request into the equation, and they will not work for the benefit of all. However, there have been a couple of modifications based on those conversations which as you can see. Bayard St. – Upon having onsite conversation with stakeholders, we have come to a mutual agreement of the re-alignment of the stormwater pipes, and the project is now in the final design stage. There is also a need for title clearing and this is also underway. Pigeon Point Stormwater Study – The City was notified that the Brick Grant was being withdrawn as part of the government cutbacks for federal assistance. However, Alan Eisenman and I contacted the grant provider, and our grant is still good. The CIP department along with finance will be working together in preparing this RFP for posting. Page 5 of 118 Scott Marshall CITY MANAGER 843-525-7070 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Philip E. Cromer, Mayor Mike McFee, Mayor Pro Tem Neil Lipsitz Mitch Mitchell Josh Scallate John Sauvé ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 843-379-7525 CITY OF BEAUFORT 1911 Boundary Street BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 This concludes my report of these high-level projects, the remaining projects will be covered at our fourth quarter meeting. Page 6 of 118 City of Beaufort Department Request for City Council Agenda Item To: City Council Date: 08/21/2025 From: Alan Eisenman, Finance Director, John Sauve, Deputy City Manager Item Name: Employee Compensation Discussion Meeting Date: August 26, 2025 Department: City Managers Office Background Information: Introduction: In Fiscal Year 25, Council budgeted for a compensation and workforce study. After completion of the procurement process, Management Advisory Group (MAG) was selected. During the spring of this year MAG completed a classification and compensation study. In Fiscal Year 26, Council budgeted for a 3% Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA), an up to 2.5% Merit Bonus, plus set aside of approximately 2.5% ($621,090) for a placeholder, knowing that this study would be recommending market adjustments. On July 8, 2025, Management Advisory Group (MAG) presented the Classification and Compensation Study Final Report to Council. City leadership convened a committee (Finance, Human Resources, City Manager’s Office, and department representatives) to review MAG’s report and produce implementation scenarios that incorporate department-level corrections and policy considerations. The committee developed multiple scenarios, and staff modeled the short- and long-term fiscal impacts with financial advisor First Tryon. The Committee reviewing these options was comprised of: Scott Marshall, City Manager (final review) JJ Sauve, Deputy City Manager Ivette Burgess, Human Resources Director Alan Eisenman, Finance Director Sandy Rice, Assistant Finance Director Ashley Brandon, Public Information Officer Linda Roper, Downtown Operations Director Stephenie Price, Police Chief Page 7 of 118 Tim Ogden, Fire Chief Nate Farrow, Public Works Director Background: Summary of Scenarios The following summarizes the core features of each implementation scenario presented by Management Advisory Group and refined by the staff/committee. Use these short descriptions when comparing fiscal and policy tradeoffs in the memorandum. 1. Scenario #1 — MAG Final Report (as drafted). Implements MAG’s recommended pay-grade structure and pay adjustments without department- level corrections for recent promotions or compression anomalies. Represents the baseline MAG proposal used for initial fiscal modeling. (FY26 modeled impact: $671,786). 2. Scenario #2 — MAG Final Report with Department Input Adjustments (Committee recommendation). Combines MAG’s pay-grade framework with department-submitted corrections (for example, recently promoted employees and overstated compressions). Includes a 3.5% Additional Cost-of- Living Adjustment (COLA) and adjustments to align employee pay with the revised grade minimums; raises the lowest minimum to $40,988 to meet the committee’s living-wage benchmark. Recommended for implementation because it preserves MAG’s market alignment while correcting administratively identifiable errors. (FY26 modeled impact: $640,025). 3. Scenario #3 — Department Input plus $1,000 Public Safety Supplement. Starts from department-corrected pay grades and adds a targeted, recurring supplement of $1,000 to Police and Fire positions to improve public-safety competitiveness. Creates a higher recurring cost than Scenario #2 and affects multi-year fund projections accordingly. (FY26 modeled impact: $781,345). 4. Scenario #4 — Department Input plus $2,000 Public Safety Supplement. Same as Scenario #4 but with a $2,000 recurring supplement for Police and Fire. Produces the largest near-term and long-term budgetary impact among the scenarios presented and would require a sustainable funding plan if adopted. (FY26 modeled impact: $919,708). Page 8 of 118 Legal Authority: Staff Recommendation: Staff's recommendation for Council's consideration is Scenario #2 (MAG Final Report with Department Input Adjustments) and authorize funding the FY26 budget impact of $640,025 from the General Fund unassigned fund balance, Parks and Tourism fund balance, and Stormwater fund balance as modeled by staff and First Tryon. A corresponding budget amendment to implement these changes effective retroactive to July 1, 2025 will be brought forward for Council's consideration in a future Council meeting. Placed on Agenda For: Attachments: 1. Compensation Study Implementation Memorandum 2. Compensation Study Presentation 3. Compensation Study Scenario Summary 4. MAG Beaufort Final Report Page 9 of 118 Scott Marshall CITY MANAGER 843-525-7070 John Sauvé ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 843-379-7525 CITY OF BEAUFORT 1911 Boundary Street BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Philip E. Cromer, Mayor Mike McFee, Mayor Pro Tem Neil Lipsitz Mitch Mitchell Josh Scallate Page 1 of 7 August 21, 2025 MEMORANDUM To: City Council From: Compensation Study Implementation Committee Re: Compensation Plan Implementation Recommendation Recommendation Approve Scenario #2 (MAG Final Report with Department Input Adjustments) and authorize funding the FY26 budget impact of $640,025 from the General Fund unassigned fund balance, Parks and Tourism fund balance, and Stormwater fund balance as modeled by staff and First Tryon. Background In Fiscal Year 25, Council budgeted for a compensation and workforce study. After completion of the procurement process, Management Advisory Group (MAG) was selected. During the spring of this year MAG completed a classification and compensation study. In Fiscal Year 26, Council budgeted for a 3% Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA), an up to 2.5% Merit Bonus, plus set aside of approximately 2.5% ($621,090) for a placeholder, knowing that this study would be recommending market adjustments. On July 8, 2025, Management Advisory Group (MAG) presented the Classification and Compensation Study Final Report to Council. City leadership convened a committee (Finance, Human Resources, City Manager’s Office, and department representatives) to review MAG’s report and produce implementation scenarios that incorporate department-level corrections and policy considerations. The committee developed multiple scenarios, and staff modeled the short - and long -term fiscal impacts with financial advisor First Tryon. The Committee reviewing these options was comprised of: Scott Marshall, City Manager (final review) JJ Sauve, Deputy City Manager Ivette Burgess, Human Resources Director Page 10 of 118 Scott Marshall CITY MANAGER 843-525-7070 John Sauvé ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 843-379-7525 CITY OF BEAUFORT 1911 Boundary Street BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Philip E. Cromer, Mayor Mike McFee, Mayor Pro Tem Neil Lipsitz Mitch Mitchell Josh Scallate Page 2 of 7 Alan Eisenman, Finance Director Sandy Rice, Assistant Finance Director Ashley Brandon, Public Information Officer Linda Roper, Downtown Operations Director Stephenie Price, Police Chief Tim Ogden, Fire Chief Nate Farrow, Public Works Director Summary of Scenarios The following summarizes the core features of each implementation scenario presented by Management Advisory Group and refined by the staff/committee. Use these short descriptions when comparing fiscal and policy tradeoffs in the memorandum. 1. Scenario #1 — MAG Final Report (as drafted). Implements MAG’s recommended pay -grade structure and pay adjustments without department -level corrections for recent promotions or compression anomalies. Represents the baseline MAG proposal used for initial fiscal modeling. (FY26 modeled impact: $671,786). 2. Scenario #2 — MAG Final Report with Department Input Adjustments (Committee recommendation). Combines MAG’s pay -grade framework with department -submitted corrections (for example, recently promoted employees and overstated compressions). Includes a 3.5% Additional Cost-of-Living Adjustment (COLA) and adjustments to align employee pay with the revised grade minimums; raises the lowest minimum to $40,988 to meet the committee’s living -wage benchmark. Recommended for implementation because it preserves MAG’s market alignment while correcting administratively identifiable errors. ( FY26 modeled impact: $640,025). 3. Scenario #3 — Department Input plus $1,000 Public Safety Supplement. Starts from department -corrected pay grades and adds a targeted, recurring supplement of $1,000 to Police and Fire positions to improve public -safety competitiveness. Creates a higher recurring cost than Scenario #2 and affects multi-year fund projections accordingly. (FY26 modeled impact: $781,345). 4. Scenario #4 — Department Input plus $2,000 Public Safety Supplement. Page 11 of 118 Scott Marshall CITY MANAGER 843-525-7070 John Sauvé ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 843-379-7525 CITY OF BEAUFORT 1911 Boundary Street BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Philip E. Cromer, Mayor Mike McFee, Mayor Pro Tem Neil Lipsitz Mitch Mitchell Josh Scallate Page 3 of 7 Same as Scenario #4 but with a $2,000 recurring supplement for Police and Fire. Produces the largest near -term and long -term budgetary impact among the scenarios presented and would require a sustainable funding plan if adopted. (FY26 modeled impact: $919,708). What Scenario #2 Does (Committee Recommendation) • Implements a 3.5% Additional Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA) for all employees retroactive to 7/1/25. • Adjusts employee pay to new MAG pay grade minimums with compression corrections informed by department input (e.g., recently promoted employees and overstated compressions were corrected). • Raises the lowest minimum pay grade to $40,988 to remain above the 2025 living wage benchmark cited by the committee. • FY26 budget impact: ($640,025). Pros and Cons for Scenario #2 (Committee Recommendation) Pros • Retains MAG’s market alignment while correcting identifiable departmental errors (promotions, overstated compression), increasing perceived fairness. • Includes a 3.5% Additional COLA and raises lowest minimum to a living -wage benchmark, aiding recruitment and retention at entry levels. • Corrects pay compression and aligns pay grades while honoring department-level promotions and adjustments. • Brings lowest pay above a living wage benchmark, supporting recruitment and retention for entry-level roles. • Lower near -term and multi -year fiscal pressure than scenarios that add degrees/certification pay or targeted public safety supplements. Cons / Considerations Page 12 of 118 Scott Marshall CITY MANAGER 843-525-7070 John Sauvé ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 843-379-7525 CITY OF BEAUFORT 1911 Boundary Street BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Philip E. Cromer, Mayor Mike McFee, Mayor Pro Tem Neil Lipsitz Mitch Mitchell Josh Scallate Page 4 of 7 • Requires careful HR verification of department corrections to avoid inconsistent application. • Does not establish automatic ongoing pay for degrees and certifications (if Council desires incentive pay for educational attainment, Scenario #3 or a policy add -on will be required). • Targeted supplements for Police and Fire are deferred; competitive pressures in public safety labor markets may continue. If Council prioritizes public safety supplementing, Scenario #4 or #5 should be considered with clear long -term funding plans. Fiscal Analysis — Capacity to Fund FY26 Impact for Scenario #2 (Committee Recommendation) Bottom line: Implementing Scenario #2 in FY26 costs $640,025 that has currently not been budgeted. Staff recommends paying that one -time cost from the City’s available fund balance so no tax increase or service cuts are required this year. • Simple comparison: $640,025 is about 34% of the projected one -time surplus for FY 25 ($1,900,000). • What it does to reserves: Using fund balance for this cost leaves the City with substantial reserves remaining; it does not exhaust the City’s savings. • Multi-year outlook: The financial model shows small net increases in the General Fund in later years (FY27: +$150,000; FY28: +$703,000). Parks & Tourism is projected to dip (FY27: ($377,321); FY28: ($114,021)) but begins from a strong reserve; Stormwater effects are negligible. • Practical implication: Approving Scenario #2 and funding it from fund balance avoids immediate fiscal pain and is fiscally supportable under current projections, provided staff continues routine monitoring. Recommended action: Approve Scenario #2, fund the FY26 cost ( $640,025) from the General Fund unassigned fund balance, and require quarterly fund-balance updates from Finance. Alternatives Considered Scenario #1 — MAG Final Report (as drafted) Page 13 of 118 Scott Marshall CITY MANAGER 843-525-7070 John Sauvé ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 843-379-7525 CITY OF BEAUFORT 1911 Boundary Street BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Philip E. Cromer, Mayor Mike McFee, Mayor Pro Tem Neil Lipsitz Mitch Mitchell Josh Scallate Page 5 of 7 FY26 modeled impact: ($671,786). Pros • Implements MAG’s market-based recommendations without delay, ensuring full alignment to the consultant’s market analysis. • Provides a clear, consultant- backed justification for pay -grade and pay -range adjustments. • Administrative implementation is straightforward because it follows the consultant deliverable without added policy design. Cons • Does not incorporate known department -level corrections (recent promotions, compression anomalies), which may produce perceived inequities or require corrective administrative actions later. • Slightly higher FY26 cost than the committee -revised scenario without commensurate administrative refinement. • May generate employee relations issues where department facts were not incorporated before implementation. Scenario #3 — Department Input plus $1,000 Public Safety Supplement FY26 modeled impact: ($781,345). Pros • Targets an acute market pressure area—public safety —helping recruitment and retention for Police and Fire in the near term. • Simpler to administer than an education differential program; direct supplement tied to position classifications. • Demonstrates Council prioritization of public safety compensation while retaining department-corrected pay-grade structure. Cons Page 14 of 118 Scott Marshall CITY MANAGER 843-525-7070 John Sauvé ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 843-379-7525 CITY OF BEAUFORT 1911 Boundary Street BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Philip E. Cromer, Mayor Mike McFee, Mayor Pro Tem Neil Lipsitz Mitch Mitchell Josh Scallate Page 6 of 7 • Adds recurring cost that worsens multi-year projections compared to Scenario #2. • A fixed supplement may not fully resolve market competitiveness for hard-to-fill specialty roles within public safety. • Creates precedent for position-specific supplements that can be difficult to remove or narrow later without impacting morale. Scenario #4 — Department Input plus $2,000 Public Safety Supplement FY26 modeled impact: ($919,708). Pros • Provides the strongest near -term recruitment and retention signal to Police and Fire among the presented options. • May more effectively close pay gaps with regional comparators where competitive pressure is highest. Cons • Largest FY26 and recurring fiscal impact of all scenarios, significantly affecting multi-year fund projections and constraining other budget priorities. • Increased long -term fiscal obligation necessitates identification of sustainable funding sources to avoid structural budget imbalance. • Risks internal equity pressures across non -public-safety departments that do not receive supplements. Implementation Steps (recommended if Council approves Scenario #2) 1. Approve Scenario #2 and authorize the FY26 budget amendment to implement the changes effective retroactive to 7/1/25. 2. Authorize use of General Fund unassigned fund balance, Parks and Tourism fund balance and Stormwater fund balance to cover the FY26 impact of $640,025, with staff to identify and present the precise appropriation entries in the FY26 amended budget. Page 15 of 118 Scott Marshall CITY MANAGER 843-525-7070 John Sauvé ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER 843-379-7525 CITY OF BEAUFORT 1911 Boundary Street BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Philip E. Cromer, Mayor Mike McFee, Mayor Pro Tem Neil Lipsitz Mitch Mitchell Josh Scallate Page 7 of 7 3. Direct HR to coordinate pay adjustments, update payroll processes to incorporate new pay grades, and ensure retroactive pay is processed correctly. 4. Direct Finance and HR to include Scenario #2 in the long -term financial monitoring reports and present any necessary corrective actions if fund balances materially change in FY26. 5. If Council wishes to pursue degrees/certifications or public safety supplements in the near term, direct staff to return with (a) a policy and administrative framework for verifying and administering education/certification pay, and (b) updated multi-year fiscal modeling identifying sustainable funding sources. Page 16 of 118 EMPLOYEE COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT SCENARIOS AUGUST 26, 2025 City of Beaufort, South Carolina Page 17 of 118 Background • Management Advisory Group (MAG) presented the Classification and Compensation Study Final Report on July 8, 2025 in Council Worksession meeting. • City staff leadership committee formed to review MAG’s report and to prepare various implementation scenarios. • Analyzed the impact of implementation scenarios with long-term financial model with City’s financial advisors, First Tryon 2 Page 18 of 118 Implementation Scenarios 1. Management Advisory Group (MAG) Final Report 2. Management Advisory Group (MAG) Final Report with Department Input Adjustments- Committee Recommended 3. Management Advisory Group (MAG) Final Report with Department Input Adjustments and Implementation of Additional $1,000 Fire and Police Support 4. Management Advisory Group (MAG) Final Report with Department Input Adjustments and Implementation of Additional $2,000 Fire and Police Support 3 Page 19 of 118 MAG Final Report/Scenario #1 • Includes 3.5% Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA) for all employees retroactive to 7/1/25. • Includes adjustment to bring employees to new pay grade minimums • Includes compression adjustments for internal alignment • City staff added cost of overtime and working holidays and corresponding payroll benefits • The fiscal year 2026 budget impact is ($671,786). 4 Page 20 of 118 MAG Final Report Scenario #1 Summary 5 Category Amount 3.5% Additional COLA $ 411,637 Adjustment to Minimum $ 326,190 Compression Adjustment $ 188,305 Overtime and Working Holidays Additional Cost $ 82,375 Total Benefits $ 284,369 Total Implementation Costs $ 1,292,876 FY26 Budget $621,090 FY26 Budget Impact ($671,786) Page 21 of 118 MAG Final Report with Department Input Adjustments Scenario #2 • Includes additional 3.5% Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA) for all employees retroactive to 7/1/25. • Includes adjustment to bring employees to new pay grade minimums • Finance, HR, and Assistant City Manager met with department directors to discuss MAG report • Departments noticed that recent promotions were not included in Final MAG Report and some compression adjustments were overstated for longer tenured employees. These adjustments were taken into account in this scenario. • Committee referenced living wage for single adult in Beaufort County is $40,320 from United Way’s 2025 Asset Limited, Income Constrained, Employed (ALICE) report. Committee increased the lowest minimum pay grade to $40,988 to stay above the living wage. • Committee’s recommended scenario • The fiscal year 2026 budget impact is ($640,025). 6 Page 22 of 118 MAG Final Report with Department Input Adjustments Scenario #2 Summary 7 Category Amount Additional 3.5% COLA $ 396,034 Adjustment to Minimum $ 400,888 Compression Adjustment $ 104,801 Overtime and Working Holidays Additional Cost $ 82,017 Total Benefits $ 277,374 Total Implementation Costs $ 1,261,114 FY26 Budget $621,090 FY26 Budget Impact ($640,025) Page 23 of 118 Department Input Adjustments with Additional $1,000 for Police and Fire Scenario #3 • Includes Department Input Adjustments • Includes an additional $1,000 per year increase for all firefighters and police officers with the exception of both Chiefs. • Strategy is to gain a competitive edge in recruitment and retention. • The fiscal year 2026 budget impact is ($781,345). 8 Page 24 of 118 Department Input Adjustments with Additional $1,000 for Police and Fire Scenario #3 Summary 9 Category Amount Additional 3.5% COLA $ 396,034 Adjustment to Minimum $ 400,888 Compression Adjustment $ 104,801 Overtime and Working Holidays Additional Cost $ 93,131 Additional $1,000 for Police and Fire $127,000 Total Benefits $ 280,581 Total Implementation Costs $ 1,402,434 FY26 Budget $621,090 FY26 Budget Impact ($781,345) Page 25 of 118 Department Input Adjustments with Additional $2,000 for Police and Fire Scenario #4 • Includes Department Input Adjustments • Includes an additional $2,000 per year increase for all firefighters and police officers with the exception of both Chiefs. • Strategy is to gain a competitive edge in recruitment and retention. • The fiscal year 2026 budget impact is ($919,708). 10 Page 26 of 118 Department Input Adjustments with Additional $2,000 for Police and Fire Scenario #4 Summary 11 Category Amount Additional 3.5% COLA $ 393,691 Adjustment to Minimum $ 400,888 Compression Adjustment $ 104,801 Overtime and Working Holidays Additional Cost $ 104,245 Additional $2,000 for Police and Fire $254,000 Total Benefits $ 283,173 Total Implementation Costs $ 1,540,798 FY26 Budget $621,090 FY26 Budget Impact ($919,708) Page 27 of 118 Scenarios #1- #4 Summary 12 Category Scenario #1 MAG Scenario #2 MAG with Dept Input Scenario #3 Dept Input with $1k Fire and Police Scenario #4 Dept Input with $2k Fire and Police Additional 3.5% COLA $ 411,637 $ 396,034 $ 396,034 $ 393,691 Adjustment to Minimum $ 326,190 $ 400,888 $ 400,888 $ 400,888 Compression Adjustment $ 188,305 $ 104,801 $ 104,801 $ 104,801 Overtime and Working Holidays Additional Cost $ 82,375 $ 82,017 $ 93,131 $ 104,245 Additional $2,000 for Police and Fire $ - $ - $127,000 $254,000 Total Benefits $ 284,369 $ 277,374 $ 280,581 $ 283,173 Total Implementation Costs $ 1,292,876 $ 1,261,114 $ 1,402,434 $ 1,540,798 FY26 Budget $621,090 $621,090 $621,090 $621,090 FY26 Budget Impact ($671,786) ($640,025) ($781,345) ($919,708) Page 28 of 118 Fiscal Year 2026 Financial Impact • City staff recommends using available fund balance to implement compensation study for FY26. 13 Fund FY25 Projected Increase in Fund Balance FY25 Projected Fund Balance FY26 Projected Fund Balance FY26 Budget Impact with Scenario #2 General $1,900,000 $8,050,000 (Unassigned) $7,944,000 (Unassigned) ($541,125) Parks and Tourism $376,000 $4,636,000 $3,775,000 ($79,600) Stormwater $145,000 $309,000 $309,000 ($19,300) Total $2,421,000 $12,995,000 $12,028,000 ($640,025) Page 29 of 118 Long-Term Financial Impact • City staff worked with financial advisors First Tryon updating the City’s long term financial model with Scenario #2- MAG Final Report with Department Input Adjustments. • Long-Term Financial Model shows net increase of General fund balance of the following: • FY27- $150,000 • FY28- $703,000 • Long-Term Financial Model shows net decrease of Parks and Tourism fund balance of the following: • FY27- ($377,321) • FY28- ($114,021) • City can absorb due to healthy fund balance of $4,636,000 14 Page 30 of 118 Long-Term Financial Impact • Long-Term Financial Model shows nominal net increase/decrease Stormwater fund balance of the following: • FY27- ($1,900) • FY28- $5,800 15 Page 31 of 118 Future Considerations • The MAG report mentions education, licensure, and certification pay with the following pay structure: • Degrees • Associate: $2,000 • Bachelor: $3,000 • Masters- $3,500 • Certification and Licensure: $1,000 • Creates explicit pay incentives for educational attainment and professional licensure, supporting career development and professionalization of the workforce. • Requires new policy, verification protocols, and administrative resources to document and audit eligibility, increasing HR workload and implementation risk. 16 Page 32 of 118 Questions/Comments 17 Page 33 of 118 Department Current Payroll Flat 3.5% Adj to Min Comp Adj Overtime and Working Holidays Additional Cost Total Benefits Total Proposed Payroll % Change FY 2026 Budget for Compansation Study 3% COLA Already implemented Remaining Budget for Comp Study Benefits Budget for Comp Study FY26 Budget Savings FY26 Budget Impact CITY MANAGER'S OFFICE $650,174 $22,756 $10,640 $0 $509 $8,753 $42,658 $692,832 6.56% $45,537 $23,967 $21,570 $5,654 (15,435) DOWNTOWN OPERATIONS $241,961 $8,469 $6,019 $0 $0 $3,944 $18,432 $260,392 7.62% $12,793 $6,733 $6,060 $1,588 (10,783) FINANCE $586,641 $18,013 $3,603 $0 $108 $5,694 $27,419 $614,060 4.67% $34,110 $17,953 $16,158 $4,235 (7,026) FIRE $3,869,865 $135,445 $169,544 $89,920 $58,559 $130,912 $584,380 $4,454,245 15.10% $238,649 $125,604 $113,044 $32,658 $108,000 (330,677) HUMAN RESOURCES $225,373 $7,888 $0 $0 $0 $2,067 $9,956 $235,328 4.42% $13,850 $7,289 $6,560 $1,719 (1,676) MUNICIPAL COURT $233,960 $8,189 $2,759 $5,371 $0 $4,277 $20,596 $254,556 8.80% $16,452 $8,659 $7,793 $2,043 (10,760) COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT $697,586 $24,416 $0 $7,130 $0 $8,268 $39,814 $737,400 5.71% $39,687 $20,888 $18,799 $4,927 (16,088) POLICE $4,008,290 $139,484 $123,324 $59,105 $19,381 $97,421 $438,715 $4,447,005 10.95% $255,165 $134,297 $120,868 $34,919 $68,796 (214,132) PUBLIC WORKS $1,342,217 $46,978 $10,301 $26,779 $3,818 $23,032 $110,907 $1,453,124 8.26% $76,440 $40,231 $36,208 $9,490 (65,209) Total $11,856,067 $411,637 $326,190 $188,305 $82,375 $284,369 $1,292,876 $13,148,942 10.90% $732,683 $385,622 $347,060 $97,233 $176,796 (671,786) Management Advisory Group (MAG) Final Report- Scenario #1 Page 34 of 118 Department Current Payroll Flat 3.5% Adj to Min Comp Adj Overtime and Working Holidays Additional Cost Total Benefits Total Proposed Payroll % Change FY 2026 Budget for Compensation Study 3% COLA Already implemented Remaining Budget for Comp Study Benefits Budget for Comp Study FY26 Budget Savings FY26 Budget Impact CITY MANAGER'S OFFICE $650,174 $16,447 $10,640 $0 $0 $7,100 $34,187 $684,361 5.26% $45,537 $23,967 $21,570 $5,654 (6,963) DOWNTOWN OPERATIONS $241,961 $8,469 $6,019 $5,000 $848 $5,330 $25,665 $267,626 10.61% $12,793 $6,733 $6,060 $1,588 (18,017) FINANCE $590,230 $20,658 $1,478 $0 $156 $5,843 $28,135 $618,365 4.77% $34,110 $17,953 $16,158 $4,235 (7,742) FIRE $3,560,203 $123,500 $228,490 $66,357 $58,032 $137,530 $613,908 $4,174,111 17.24% $238,649 $125,604 $113,044 $32,658 $108,000 (360,206) HUMAN RESOURCES $225,373 $7,888 $0 $0 $0 $2,067 $9,956 $235,328 4.42% $13,850 $7,289 $6,560 $1,719 (1,676) MUNICIPAL COURT $233,960 $8,189 $2,759 $5,371 $0 $4,277 $20,596 $254,556 8.80% $16,452 $8,659 $7,793 $2,043 (10,760) COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT $697,586 $24,416 $0 $0 $0 $6,399 $30,815 $728,401 4.42% $39,687 $20,888 $18,799 $4,927 (7,088) POLICE $4,090,173 $139,490 $136,540 $11,583 $19,191 $87,278 $394,082 $4,484,256 9.63% $255,165 $134,297 $120,868 $34,919 $68,796 (169,500) PUBLIC WORKS $1,342,217 $46,978 $14,963 $16,490 $3,790 $21,550 $103,770 $1,445,987 7.73% $76,440 $40,231 $36,208 $9,490 (58,072) Total $11,631,878 $396,034 $400,888 $104,801 $82,017 $277,374 $1,261,114 $12,892,992 10.84% $732,683 $385,622 $347,060 $97,233 $176,796 (640,025) Management Advisory Group (MAG) Final Report with Department Input Adjustments- Scenario #2 Page 35 of 118 Department Current Payroll Flat 3.5% Adj to Min Comp Adj Additional $1,000 Police- Fire Overtime and Working Holidays Additional Cost Total Benefits Total Proposed Payroll % Change FY 2026 Budget for Compensation Study 3% COLA Already implemented Remaining Budget for Comp Study Benefits Budget for Comp Study FY26 Budget Savings FY26 Budget Impact CITY MANAGER'S OFFICE $650,174 $16,447 $10,640 $0 $0 $7,100 $34,187 $684,361 5.26% $45,537 $23,967 $21,570 $5,654 (6,963) DOWNTOWN OPERATIONS $241,961 $8,469 $6,019 $5,000 $848 $5,330 $25,665 $267,626 10.61% $12,793 $6,733 $6,060 $1,588 (18,017) FINANCE $590,230 $20,658 $1,478 $0 $156 $5,843 $28,135 $618,365 4.77% $34,110 $17,953 $16,158 $4,235 (7,742) FIRE $3,560,203 $123,500 $228,490 $66,357 $62,000 $65,599 $139,717 $685,662 $4,245,865 19.26% $238,649 $125,604 $113,044 $32,658 $108,000 (431,959) HUMAN RESOURCES $225,373 $7,888 $0 $0 $0 $2,067 $9,956 $235,328 4.42% $13,850 $7,289 $6,560 $1,719 (1,676) MUNICIPAL COURT $233,960 $8,189 $2,759 $5,371 $0 $4,277 $20,596 $254,556 8.80% $16,452 $8,659 $7,793 $2,043 (10,760) COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT $697,586 $24,416 $0 $0 $0 $6,399 $30,815 $728,401 4.42% $39,687 $20,888 $18,799 $4,927 (7,088) POLICE $4,090,173 $139,490 $136,540 $11,583 $65,000 $22,738 $88,298 $463,649 $4,553,822 11.34% $255,165 $134,297 $120,868 $34,919 $68,796 (239,067) PUBLIC WORKS $1,342,217 $46,978 $14,963 $16,490 $3,790 $21,550 $103,770 $1,445,987 7.73% $76,440 $40,231 $36,208 $9,490 (58,072) Total $11,631,878 $396,034 $400,888 $104,801 $127,000 $93,131 $280,581 $1,402,434 $13,034,312 12.06% $732,683 $385,622 $347,060 $97,233 $176,796 (781,345) Department Input Adjustments with Additional $1,000 for Police and Fire- Scenario #3 Page 36 of 118 Department Current Payroll Flat 3.5% Adj to Min Comp Adj Additional $2,000 Police- Fire Overtime and Working Holidays Additional Cost Total Benefits Total Proposed Payroll % Change FY 2026 Budget for Compensation Study 3% COLA Already implemented Remaining Budget for Comp Study Benefits Budget for Comp Study FY26 Budget Savings FY26 Budget Impact CITY MANAGER'S OFFICE $650,174 $14,104 $10,640 $0 $0 $6,485 $31,230 $681,403 4.80% $45,537 $23,967 $21,570 $5,654 (4,006) DOWNTOWN OPERATIONS $241,961 $8,469 $6,019 $5,000 $848 $5,330 $25,665 $267,626 10.61% $12,793 $6,733 $6,060 $1,588 (18,017) FINANCE $590,230 $20,658 $1,478 $0 $156 $5,843 $28,135 $618,365 4.77% $34,110 $17,953 $16,158 $4,235 (7,742) FIRE $3,560,203 $123,500 $228,490 $66,357 $124,000 $73,167 $141,903 $757,416 $4,317,619 21.27% $238,649 $125,604 $113,044 $32,658 $108,000 (503,714) HUMAN RESOURCES $225,373 $7,888 $0 $0 $0 $2,067 $9,956 $235,328 4.42% $13,850 $7,289 $6,560 $1,719 (1,676) MUNICIPAL COURT $233,960 $8,189 $2,759 $5,371 $0 $4,277 $20,596 $254,556 8.80% $16,452 $8,659 $7,793 $2,043 (10,760) COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT $697,586 $24,416 $0 $0 $0 $6,399 $30,815 $728,401 4.42% $39,687 $20,888 $18,799 $4,927 (7,088) POLICE $4,090,173 $139,490 $136,540 $11,583 $130,000 $26,284 $89,318 $533,215 $4,623,389 13.04% $255,165 $134,297 $120,868 $34,919 $68,796 (308,633) PUBLIC WORKS $1,342,217 $46,978 $14,963 $16,490 $3,790 $21,550 $103,770 $1,445,987 7.73% $76,440 $40,231 $36,208 $9,490 (58,072) Total $11,631,878 $393,691 $400,888 $104,801 $254,000 $104,245 $283,173 $1,540,798 $13,172,675 13.25% $732,683 $385,622 $347,060 $97,233 $176,796 (919,708) Department Input Adjustments with Additional $2,000 for Police and Fire- Scenario #4 Page 37 of 118 2992 Reidville Road Spartanburg, SC 29301 703-590-2750 – phone www.magintl.org Classification and Compensation Study Final Report for City of Beaufort, SC July 24, 2025 RFP No: 14 – 008 October 25, 2013 Page 38 of 118 1 Classification & Compensation Study Executive Summary It has been a pleasure collaborating with City leadership on the Classification and Compensation Study. We are pleased to present our findings & recommendations. Since the report is lengthy and very technical, we thought it appropriate to provide a summary of the results along with some clarification on the different sections of the report. Below is a brief explanation of key aspects of the study. Section 1: Compensation Philosophy A compensation philosophy is a n organization 's formalized explanation of its compensation approach and structures. It is often used to advertise vacant positions, establish consistency in pay practices and encourage productivity among their employees. While Human Resources (HR) often designs and communicates the policies, they typically work with the organization's senior leadership to ensure their philosophies support organizational goals and add value to their operations. Important considerations when developing a compensation philosophy: - Equity - Market Trends - Organizational Objectives - Recruitment - Retention - Budgeting To assist with the development of a compensation philosophy, MAG has included a general outline of a philosophy that the City can use as a starting point to further develop a formal philosophy. Page 39 of 118 2 Section 2: Introduction & Approach To begin the study, Management Advisory Group (MAG) requested that the City provide employee data to start the study process. Specifically, MAG requested detailed information on each employee – name, job title, salary, hire date, etc. Once that information was received, MAG, then, conducted an internal ranking of each position to determin e grade placement on the new salary scales. The internal ranking was based on the following criteria or Job Factors: - Data Responsibility - People Responsibility - Asset/Financial Responsibility - Education Level Required for the Job - Experience Level Required for the Job - Mathematical/Statistical Analysis Requirements - Judgement Required for the Job - Decision-making Required for the Job - Type of Equipment Operated or Utilized - Safety Responsibility - Physical Demands - Complexity of the Work Performed - Impact of Errors - Unavoidable Hazards Exposure Upon completion of the internal review, MAG conducted a market survey to determine the current market rate of pay for positions in the study. For analysis and comparison purposes, MAG collected salary and wage data from the following organizations: - City of Cayce - City of Charleston - City of Clemson - City of Hardeeville - City of Savannah, GA - City of West Columbia - Town of Bluffton - Town of Hilton Head - Town of Moncks Corner - Town of Port Royal - Beaufort County - Colleton County - Jasper County - O*NET Page 40 of 118 3 Private sector salary and wage data was collected from the Federal Department of Labor’s Bureau of Labor Statistics via the online portal O*NET. The final step to develop the new salary schedules was using MAG’s software to statistically (Data & Statistical modeling technique known as linear regression) match the internal data with the market data to create the competitive new salary schedules. Section 3: Selected Compensation Policies In this section, MAG provides “Best Practices” policies to serve as a guide for maintaining the new compensation & classification system. MAG is not attempting to rewrite all HR policies, but rather providing guidelines based on our expertise and expertise to ensure consistency and fairness with the administration of the new plan. In many cases policies may already be in-place to address the compensation-related issues. If that is the case, the City can continue with existing policies, modify current policies based on our information presented or adopt the guidelines presented in their entirety. The policy guidelines presented by MAG address compensation-related issues such as: - Determining Starting Salaries for New Hires - Compensation Determinations for Promotions - Reclassification Impact on Compensation - Lateral Transfers - Voluntary Demotions - Involuntary Demotions - Temporary Assignment of Interim Job Roles Section 4: Total Rewards Compensation has two forms: Direct and Indirect. Direct compensation is typically salary or some other type of pay incentive provided directly to the employee, while indict compensation consists of employee -related benefits paid on behalf of the employee by the employer. When put together, they form the total rewards package that the employee receives from the organization. In this section, MAG provides examples and general information regarding total rewards to assist the City with a review of its current offerings. Page 41 of 118 4 Section 5: Proposed Retention Incentive Pay Policy In this section, MAG provides examples of various types of employee incentives to help improve morale within the organization. Employee incentives are rewards and privileges that motivate employees to meet organizational goals. In the workplace, employers may provide monetary or non-monetary incentives through an employee incentive s program to encourage employees to uphold excellent behavior and job performance. Section 6: Proposed Premium Pay Polices The City of Beaufort may develop written plans to provide additional compensation for nonexempt employees who work non-standard shifts or who are subject to call back. Such plans may include shift differentials, on-call pay, call-back pay, and/or premium pay. The City recognizes that certain work-related circumstances call for compensation in the form of premium pay in addition to an individual's base salary. In this section, MAG provides specific recommendations for the following types of additional compensation: - Shift Differential - On-Call Pay - Premium Pay - Pay for Certifications, Education, and Licensure Section 7: Salary Survey Summary This section of the report shows the market survey results for a sampling of positions (Benchmark Jobs) within the City. When viewing this report, it is critical to understand that City positions in general have different work schedules based on annual days and annual hours worked. In order to understand current-market-pay conditions, we must establish a common baseline for annua l duty days and hours worked. Since the standard full-time annual hours worked in the U.S. is 2080 hours per year based on 260 days, the salary survey data and proposed salary ranges are based on 2080 annual work hours . However, we adjusted the Full-Time Equivalences (FTE’s) of those employees who do not work 2080 annual hours to accurately reflect their actual annual work hours to determine any proposed pay adjustments recommended for implementation cost calculations. Page 42 of 118 5 As you review Section 7, you will see a line-by-line comparison of the market results as compared to the city’s current ranges. The overall results of the market salary survey data indicate the City has fallen behind the market for the majority of benchmark positions documented in the Survey Summary. Below is a breakdown of the City’s current pay ranges relative to the initial data from market peers. The new pay structures, which are discussed and highlighted in Section 8, would bring the City’s pay structure inline with current market levels. Section 8: Proposed Pay Plan This section of the report outlines the proposed classification and compensation plans developed by MAG. Understanding that job classes do not move in unison in the labor market , some occupations are more sensitive to issues of supply and demand in the labor market than others. Also, overall economic conditions within the country have a profound impact on the overall labor market and can have varying degrees of impact on certain occupational grou ps and their prevailing compensation rates and wages. This is particularly true of public safety positions. With that being said, MAG developed three separate pay plans for the City using the same regression model, but with structural adjustments to ensure competitiveness of the jobs on the respective plans. The three plans are: Fire, Police, and Unified. Section 9: Alphabetical Classification List This section takes the Proposed Pay Plan information and sorts the classifications by alphabetical order for quick reference. Section 10: Class Comparison List This section takes the Proposed Pay Plan information and sorts the classifications by pay grade for quick reference. Min Mid Max -2.21% -1.71% -1.37% Current Pay Structure Page 43 of 118 6 Section 11: Implementation Cost Summary This single-page summary breaks down the total cost of implementing the proposed classification & compensation study developed by MAG: Note: The above totals do not include the cost of Overtime Pay and Fringe Benefits $411,637 3.5% COLA $326,190 Adjustment to New Minimum $188,305 Compression Adjustment $926,132 Total Applied Adjustments 7.8% Change in Total Payroll Implementation Cost by Adjustment Page 44 of 118 1 MANAGEMENT ADVISORY GROUP INTL., INC. MANAGEMENT CONSULTING SERVICES July 24, 2025 Ivette Burgess Human Resources Director City of Beaufort 1911 Boundary St Beaufort, SC 29902 (843) 525-7018 iburgess@cityofbeaufort.org Dear Ivette, Management Advisory Group International, Inc. (MAG) is pleased to present this Final Compensation & Classification Study Report to the City of Beaufort. This report has been developed based on: • Job analysis of included classifications based on Current Job Descriptions (internal relationships); and • Market analysis (external competitiveness) The Final Report is organized into the following Sections: • Section 1: Proposed Compensation Philosophy • Section 2: Introduction and Approach • Section 3: Selected Compensation Policies • Section 4: Total Rewards • Section 5: Proposed Retention Incentive Pay Policy • Section 6: Premium Pay Policy • Section 7: Salary Survey Summary • Section 8: Proposed Pay Plans • Section 9: Alphabetical Classification List • Section 10: Classification Comparison List • Section 11: Implementation Cost Summary • Section 12: Staffing & Workforce Assessment Page 45 of 118 2 MANAGEMENT ADVISORY GROUP INTL., INC. MANAGEMENT CONSULTING SERVICES Please note that Sections 3, 4, 5, and 6 are presented as “Best Practice” guidelines to assist the C ity with maintaining the study. The C ity reserves the right to adopt as is, alter, or outright reject the information. The guidelines should not be interpreted as an attempt by MAG to write or revise any existing policies. MAG would like to express our thanks to all employees and staff who have participated in this important project. Sincerely, Steve Foster Consultant Management Advisory Group, Inc. 2992 Reidville Road Spartanburg, SC 29301 Office: 703-590-7250 Cell: 828-551-9638 steve@maginc.org Page 46 of 118 Management Advisory Group International, Inc. © 2025 City of Beaufort, SC Classification & Compensation Study Final Report Table of Contents Executive Summary Transmittal Letter Table of Contents Section 1.0 – Proposed Compensation Philosophy ................................................................ Section 1 Section 2.0 – Introduction and Approach .............................................................................. Section 2 Section 3.0 – Selected Compensation Policies ....................................................................... Section 3 Section 4.0 – Total Rewards ................................................................................................... Section 4 Section 5.0 – Proposed Retention Incentive Pay Policy ......................................................... Section 5 Section 6.0 – Premium Pay Policies ........................................................................................ Section 6 Section 7.0 – Salary Survey Summary ................................................................................. …Section 7 Section 8.0 – Proposed Pay Plans ........................................................................................... Section 8 Section 9.0 – Alphabetical Classification List .......................................................................... Section 9 Section 10.0 – Classification Comparison List ...................................................................... Section 10 Section 11.0 – Implementation Cost Summary .................................................................... Section 11 Section 12.0 – Workforce Development .............................................................................. Section 12 Page 47 of 118 SECTION 1.0 Proposed Compensation Philosophy Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 1 Page 48 of 118 Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 1-1 1.0 – Proposed Compensation Philosophy The City of Beaufort strives to provide exemplary service to the community by being a model for 21st Century municipal government operations. Recognizing the importance of our workforce of resolute and talented professional staff, we are committed to promoting organizational and community values that include exceptional service to the public; consistent and excellent performance; innovation; good fiscal, social, and environmental stewardship; and ethical behavior. To achieve and maintain our ambitious standards of service and performance, the City must continue to attract and retain well -qualified staff who exemplify the organization’s values. A public service environment that is attractive to such individuals depends upon many factors, including pride, teamwork, a competitive compensation program, and non-monetary benefits such as recognition in the workplace for accomplishments, professional development and opportunities for promotion and a positive work environment. The City is committed to being an “employer of choice” as part of an overall strategy of attracting and retaining talent that will uphold the City’s organizational values. The compensation program is committed to retaining and attracting high -skilled, high-performing staff capable of delivering the highest standards of public service to our community. The City expects all staff to consistently perform to those ambitious standards in their work performance, customer service, ethics, and passion for public service. The City strives to administer pay and benefits in a way that is fair and transparent to all, that provides equal pay for equal work, and that does not take into consideration race, ethnicity, religion, sex, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, or other factors unrelated to work performance. In order to provide competitive, sustainable, and responsible compensation, the City will consider the following: Total compensation which consists of but is not limited to direct compensation, e.g., salary; and indirect compensation such as health insurance, retirement, professional development, work life balance policy & programs, and time-off benefits. In evaluating competitive compensation, the City will consider: A. Financial sustainability as reflected by the City’s financial forecasts and revenue projections, competing service priorities, long -term liabilities, capital improvement and other asset requirements, and fund reserve levels. B. The “relevant labor market” which may vary depending upon classification but is primarily defined by geographic region ( local and/or state-wide) and key markets ( private and non-profit agencies) and if applicable, private sector when readily available and effectively comparable. C. “Internal Relationships” refers to the relative value of classifications to one another as determined by the City. 2 Page 49 of 118 1.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 1-2 D. The City will compare responsibilities, skill level, knowledge, ability, and judgment to determine similarity, and evaluate the equity of pay differentials. E. Other relevant factors may include unforeseen economic, regulatory, or service changes. F. Transparency with the community, recognizing that taxpayers and ratepayers fund all employee compensation and deserve commensurate value from all those who work for the City. This includes not only disclosure of the components of workforce compensation, but adequate advance notice of material policy changes in order to participate effectively in decision -making that affects the City’s finances. Ideally, every three to five years, the City will evaluate its compensation structure, programs, and policies to assess market competitiveness, effectiveness and compliance with applicable State and federal law. This is with the understanding that more frequent adjustments to the compensation structure may be needed as a result of intermittent evaluations or other factors already cited. This will be accomplished by working with the City’s Human Resources staff to fairly apportion compensation and benefits, utilizing all the resources and tools available to the City. 3 Page 50 of 118 SECTION 2.0 Introduction and Approach Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 4 Page 51 of 118 Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 2-1 2.0 – Introduction & Approach Introduction The City of Beaufort contracted with Management Advisory Group International, Inc. (MAG) to conduct a compensation survey and assessment for all current City job classifications. This report presents the findings and recommendations of the study. MAG’s findings and recommendations are based on: • 2025 Labor Market Data • 2026 Labor Market (Estimates) • Current organizational structure • Discussions with Human Resources and review of current compensation practices • Interviews with Department Heads • Job analysis & review based on current job descriptions • Internal equity and external competitiveness considerations The goal of the City for this project was to provide the foundation for an appropriate classification and compensation system and pay plan based on current compensation levels for similar public sector employers, and local market competitors . In response, MAG has developed a proposed pay plan and developed salary adjustment recommendations for current incumbents in included City classifications. Project Focus The objectives of the study were to: • Conduct a review of all City job titles • Review salary and compensation data from similar/competitor organizations • Develop a revised classification plan • Develop a revised compensation and pay plan • Provide options for the City’s consideration to find a reasonable and cost-effective way to transition to the new plan(s) A list of project tasks and activities is indicated below by Exhibit 2-1. 5 Page 52 of 118 2.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 2-2 EXHIBIT 2-1 City of Beaufort, SC PROJECT TASKS Project Initiation – Developed project proposal, work plan and timeline. Discussed with City administration and revised project work plan. Initial Meetings – Discussed with City Human Resources administration, City leadership and key management to clearly define the scope, goal(s), and objective(s) for the proposed study. Developed/Distributed Salary Survey Instrument – Conducted a salary survey to gather compensation information from target organizations for selected City benchmark classifications. Collected/Analyzed Compensation Data – Collected and reviewed compensation data from published data sources. Conducted Job Analysis – Performed analysis of compensable factors based on Job Profile Questionnaires. Developed Revised Pay Plan – Developed a preliminary proposed pay plan based on the results of the market salary survey, job analysis, and internal/external equity considerations. Developed Salary Adjustment Recommendations – Developed salary adjustment recommendations for all City classifications based on the revised pay plan (s) and employee classification, current salary , and longevity in current position. Developed & Submitted Draft Report – Developed and submitted a Draft Report for City review integrating the job analysis, proposed pay and classification plan, salary survey, and implementation recommendations. Revised Draft Report – Incorporated the City ’s technical review of materials. Develop & Submit Final Report – Submitted a Final Report upon final review. Exhibit 2-2 illustrates a flow-chart process used for developing a proposed pay and classification plan. 6 Page 53 of 118 2.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 2-3 EXHIBIT 2-2 City of Beaufort, SC PROJECT FLOWCHART 7 Page 54 of 118 2.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 2-4 Approach Overview To begin the study, MAG requested and reviewed preliminary information from the City. At this time, MAG conducted initial discussions with human resources administration and tailored several instruments to be used in conducting the compensation and classification analysis, including: • Job Profile Questionnaires (JPQs) • A review of current labor market data (Market Survey), which included several data sources comparable to the City The study methodology included: • Collection of current personnel, human resources, and organizational background information • Identification and selection of comparable agencies for the market data • Identification of classification benchmarks • Conducting a salary survey for selected positions • Analysis with recommendations concerning the relative ranking of City positions to develop a classification plan to ensure internal equity MAG developed job profiles for classifications covered in the study, based on the factors below, to identify an appropriate pay range. The development of a job profile typically includes numerous factors, such as: • Involvement with Data, People, and Assets • Experience/Vocational Requirements • Educational/Vocational Requirements • Mathematical Requirements • Communications Requirements • Judgment Requirements • Impact of Decisions • Complexity of Work • Safety of Others Responsibilities • Physical Requirements • Equipment Usage • Unavoidable Hazards 8 Page 55 of 118 2.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 2-5 Initial Meetings and Orientation Upon agreement to proceed, the project team communicated with Human Resources staff to discuss the study’s objectives, along with the strengths and needs of the current organizational compensation management systems. City management provided input regarding the City’s preferences and needs of the systems to be developed. MAG’s representatives requested documentation about current compensation and classification programs, reviewed and discussed with management these systems, and developed an understanding of concerns to be addressed. The project team also discussed with staff an overview of the scope, content, and methodology of the study, encouraged employee cooperation and commitment, and establish ed appropriate time limits for completing and returning necessary forms. MAG staff serve as a facilitator to bring these primary source data together in a meaningful way, organize it into a pay plan or plans, depending on the needs of the organization and to support and assist the organization with making crucial decisions regarding overall hierarchal placement of jobs. The study results and outcomes are not the result of decisions made in isolation by the consultant but are the result of the consultants working to bring together all of the different viewpoints of the stakeholders, assisting and supporting in ordering responsibilities of the work into a compensation and classification plan that serves as a starting point for making current and future placement decisions. Market Review The City of Beaufort employs a wide range of jobs that contain a mix of work responsibilities found in both the public and private sectors . The market data utilized for selected benchmark positions reflected the variety of duties and responsibilities in which City employees engage . Market data is one of the key components of a classification and compensation study, as well as one of the more difficult and sensitive activities in the study process. In a collaborative effort with the Human Resources staff, MAG developed a list of target organizations to be surveyed. Upon approval of the target list, the survey instrument, and the benchmark classifications, MAG reviewed the market and performed the technical analysis and evaluation of the collected data. Organizations typically included as targets in a salary survey are those that are: • Competing with the City for employees, for either lower level or higher-level positions • Geographically situated in such a fashion as to automatically be considered a competitor • Structured similarly to the City, or providing similar types of services • Attractive to highly valued employees for one reason or another 9 Page 56 of 118 2.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 2-6 Surveyed: 1. City of Cayce 2. City of Charleston 3. City of Clemson 4. City of Hardeeville 5. City of Savannah, GA 6. City of West Columbia 7. Town of Bluffton 8. Town of Hilton Head 9. Town of Moncks Corner 10. Town of Port Royal 11. Beaufort County 12. Colleton County 13. Jasper County 14. O*NET **Note: O*NET Online (aggregated salary information for the local area from the Federal Dept. of Labor, Bureau of Labor statistics to obtain private sector. Benchmark Classes The job classes included as benchmarks in the survey were clearly and concisely described. All classes had a clear and identifiable relationship to other City classes and were representative of the various functional areas within the various work areas/units within the City. In the survey instrument, benchmark jobs were carefully described in a class profile . In addition to the statement of job duties and responsibilities, specific information pertaining to the education requirements and work experience needed for the class was included . The respondent’s matching class title, annual minimum and maximum salary, duty days, and annual hours were also included in the survey. The data from the survey was used to assist with the classification of the various jobs within the pay structure. It is important to note, however, that the market study simply serves as an indicator of market trends and the internal job analysis is the most critical element in determining pay grade assignment. Proposed Pay Plans Based on the uniqueness and diversity of positions within the City, MAG has proposed three separate pay plans: Unified, Fire, and Police. Although distinctive, both plans were built from the same linear regression payline. Employees performing the same duties were placed in the same class and pay grade, regardless of the number of hours (PT/FT). Implementation Costs 10 Page 57 of 118 2.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 2-7 MAG’s implementation options and recommendations consider the following: • Current salary • Current job title or rank • Length of time in current position (based on promotion date) • Information from HR staff, Department Head Interviews, and comments from initial draft No employee should receive any additional salary adjustments once their salary has reached the maximum of the range. The recommendation is to freeze the salary until market data supports an increase in pay range maximum. Progressive governments often coordinate with MAG on an annual basis to refresh their market competitive position to ensure that they do not “lose ground” from a compensation perspective. Pay Plan Structure MAG has established the Unified Pay Plan structure for the City with pay ranges of 55% from minimum to maximum and a 5% differential between each pay grade. Fire and Police Pay Plan structures include pay ranges of 55% and a 2.5% differential between pay grades. All recommended structures are transparent, permit employees to have a perspective that provides some security, but are still wholly dependent on the City’s ability to fund future structure adjustments. Plan Implementation MAG recommends that the new compensation structure goes into effect as soon as feasible along with the recommended salary adjustments. First, all current employees receive a 3.5% Cost -of-Living Adjustment (COLA). Then, any employee below the minimum of their proposed pay grade range after the COLA are brought up to that level. Finally, those current employees whose pay is below their designated target salary are provided an additional “equity” adjustment to reach the target salary, which is designed to spur individual movement within their respective pay ranges, address salary compression, and serves as a hedge against inflation. Please note that t he system is hardwired to prevent a ny employee whose current salary exceeds the maximum of their proposed pay grade from receiving any type of adjustment. However, MAG strongly recommends that anyone above the maximum receive the 3.5% adjustment because a COLA is theoretically not considered a pay raise, but, rather, a hedge against the increased cost of living. MAG suggests that the new compensation structure go into effect at the start of the upcoming fiscal year. The total cost summaries for each department are noted in Sections 11. Annualized Implementation Cost: $926,132 or a 7.8% increase to current payroll **Note: Total Cost Numbers do not include Overtime Pay and Fringe Benefit Costs. 11 Page 58 of 118 2.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 2-8 Salary Compression Salary compression, also known as wage or pay compression, is a pay differential that results from various causes, but that is often deemed as unfair or unequal by members of the workforce within the organization. It is an issue that many management and human resources professionals deal with on a regular basis. There are numerous reasons for these kinds of differentials that occur, and they often seem justified at the outset. However, over time , wage compression can lead to low morale and hurt feelings within the ranks of previously loyal employees. Examples of Salary Compression Salary compression is not a new concept. For example, it’s a widespread practice for an organization to offer a higher starting salary to sought after employees who may be “rock stars” or as someone who has a great deal to offer the organization. Higher pay is used as an incentive to lure the candidate. It is also seen when viewing fixed salaried professionals like managers and supervisors versus hourly employees who are eligible for rewards like shift differentials and overtime pay. Sometimes pay inequities are seen after a consolidation of two or more functional areas that were run very differently from one another previously. Wage compression can also occur in an organization with a sizable percentage of low wage earners when the low wage rates are increased; as new hires come on, they are earning the s ame amount as those who may have been with the organization for years. Impact of Wage Compression Impacts of wage compression can be seen on a one-to-one level or across entire organizations. Those whose pay is compressed, or who are receiving less money, are likely to be affected by low morale. They will feel discouraged, naturally. It doesn’t make sense to continue working just as hard when their efforts are not perceived as being compensated. This can lead to a more noticeable problem of deficient performance in employees, which hurts the bottom line and affects everyone. There may also be retention issues related to salary compression. Those who feel slighted are more likely to look for alternate employment. High turnover rates are costly to any organization. It may also be harder to recruit from within for higher level positions if employees see no economic benefit in accepting the added responsibility and work of a promotion. Purpose of the Implementation Plan The foundation of the implementation calculation is one that is forward looking and does not look back on how current salaries came about. Transition to a new plan is not meant to change every pay decision, promotion or other legal changes in salary that h ave occurred over the tenure of the employee; nor is it meant to pretend the new pay structure should be retroactive in concept to the day an employee was hired. 12 Page 59 of 118 2.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 2-9 To the extent that any uniform formula may result in unintended consequences, there may be isolated instances where administrative adjustments would be needed in order to address an inequity that is not readily apparent. This is not intended to address internal inequities perceived by employees, which might result from previous pay structures or previous pay decisions. MAG assumes that all previous salary changes were based on information that was considered valid and appropriate at the time the decision was made. 13 Page 60 of 118 SECTION 3.0 Selected Compensation Policies Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 14 Page 61 of 118 Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 3-1 3.0 – Selected Compensation Policies As part of the overall study, Management Advisory Group typically offers observations and recommendations regarding best practices in compensation policies. These observations are not meant to replace existing policies, but to provide a fresh look and compare Beaufort compensation policies against “best practices.” An objective statement of compensation policies also includes the expressed outcome to attract, reward, and retain qualified employees who can help the City achieve its mission. In support of the vision statement, MAG observations may assist the City as it strives to provide a total compensation program that enables the City to: • Attract and retain a high-quality and diverse workforce • Reward and retain qualified employees • Provide a fair and consistent framework for assigning jobs • Maintain salary structures at market competitive levels • Ensure fair and consistent pay practices • Comply with applicable laws and regulations • Operate within the constraints of fiscal resources • Be an employer that inspires excellence As an employer, the City embraces a fair and equitable compensation plan to support the achievement of the following goals. 1. The City strives to provide a total compensation program that is fiscally sound, equitable and competitive in the defined marketplace. 2. Both benchmarking of select classifications and consideration of the job profile is used as a best practice for compensation of similar positions. 3. Competitive ranges are established for all positions to provide the flexibility needed to adapt to market changes, maintain internal equity and address the needs of the City that will ensure an elevated level of service to the community. 4. Starting pay for new employees is based upon education and work experience related to positional requirements as well as market conditions. 5. Pay adjustments, other than allowances and supplements, are provided to employees when appropriate to address equity, market responsiveness, and consistency in the administration of the City’s compensation program. 6. Employees are eligible for pay increases resulting from true promotions and reclassifications. 7. Part-time/temporary employees may not be eligible for the same benefits as full -time employees. 8. Fair Labor Standards requirements will be applied fairly and consistently to applicable positions. 15 Page 62 of 118 3.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 3-2 9. Benefit plans and other non -cash compensation plans are reviewed periodically for competitiveness, cost effectiveness, and their value to employees and the City. 10. Pay ranges for the City job groups are reviewed as needed, but not less than every five years. Compensation Policies: The following recommendations cover recommendations for both the implementation of the plan, as well as the on-going administration of the plan. Numerous opportunities exist for varied work experiences and career advancement within the City. The following outlines how associated pay changes can be administered based on the category of change. All final decisions on the administration of pay are subject to approval by the City Manager based on feedback from Human Resource s. In all instances of employee/job reassignment, the employee would be placed in the range, not to exceed the maximum of the range unless specifically stated. Unless otherwise stated, any change in pay will be effective with the next full pay period. A. Reclassification 1. When a job has been reclassified to a higher pay grade, the employee’s salary shall increase at least 5% in the new pay grade that includes the new salary but is not more than the maximum salary of the new pay grade. If the reclassification results in an upgrade of one pay grade, the employee’s pay will be moved upward by 5%. An upgrade of two or more pay grades will increase the employee’s pay by an additional 2.5% increase for each additional pay grade, up to a maximum of 20%. For general reclassifications done as a result of an internal or external compensation study, or as a result of a normal budget process review, if the employee has been in the position since on, or before, the first day of the fiscal year, the effective date of any approved change will be the first day of the fiscal year, or the effective date of implementation as approved by the City Council. Otherwise, for an individual reclassification, done outside the normal budget cycle, the effective date of the pay increase will be consistent with the next full pay period. Reclassification or changes in pay grade, whether resulting from an internal or external compensation study or individual change in pay grade, shall not be retroactive with respect to calculating the new salary. Internal Equity Adjustments as a result of the implementation of a system-wide study shall not be subject to the same guidelines as the “Reclassification” guideline. Internal Equity Adjustments can be the result of the application of a formula, applied to all positions in the same pay plan, and are done to ensure that employees’ salaries are internally equitable and are not done to reflect an individual “job audit” of a single member incumbent. 16 Page 63 of 118 3.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 3-3 Internal Equity Adjustments are also not tied to performance measures. The leadership may determine an Internal Equity Adjustment strategy that is separate and apart from the guidelines that cover reclassification. Internal Equity Adjustments, resulting from an internal or external comprehensive review, can be to a higher, or lower, pay grade and are not considered a reclassification, promotion, or demotion. 2. When a job has been reclassified to a lower pay grade, the affected employee(s) shall have their pay adjusted accordingly. The employee’s salary will be placed within the salary range of the lower grade. The effective date will be the day following the City Council’s adoption date of the budget and the change will be reflected in the next full pay period. If, after the pay grade adjustment, the employee(s) salary is greater than the maximum salary of the new pay range, the employee will continue to be paid at the higher rate of pay, the salary would be “frozen,” and the employee is typically ineligible for any pay adjustment until the range “catches up” with the salary and allows for movement. B. Promotion 1. When an employee is promoted, as a result of a job change or job progression, to a higher pay grade position, within the same, or to a different, salary schedule, the salary placement within the new pay grade shall be determined as follows: apply 5% on the salary of the previous grade/schedule and salary for promotions of one pay grade, and an additional 2.5% for each additional pay grade up to a maximum of 20%. The resulting pay will be no less than the minimum of the new pay grade and no less than a 5% salary increase, but not more than the maximum salary of the assigned pay grade. The effective date will be the day of approval. 2. There may be times when the uniqueness of an individual job and level or necessary skills required by the City, and not just possessed by the incumbent, may require a higher salary schedule placement than stipulated in this section. Under such circumstances, the City Manager may approve a higher salary step within the assigned pay grade. C. Lateral Transfer A lateral transfer occurs when an employee is transferred from one job class to another in the same pay grade. When there is no change in pay grade there shall be no adjustment in base salary. A lateral transfer is not considered a reclassification or a promotion. 17 Page 64 of 118 3.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 3-4 D. Temporary Assignment(s) 1. “Interim” or temporary assignment (s) occurs when the City recognizes a critical job assignment need that must be met and cannot be met through the normal recruitment process. This can occur when an unexpected vacancy occurs; when a mission critical job cannot be filled in a timely fashion; or when a mission objective changes abruptly and requires immediate action. 2. Temporary or “interim” assignment(s) would be anticipated to last more than 30 days, but less than 6 months. A temporary or “ interim” assignment is to fill a vacancy and not to assume the duties of another employee who is on approved leave, i.e., vacation, holiday, medical, or other short-term absence(s). 3. If the position assigned is lower in pay grade (or equivalent pay range) this would not result in a lower salary for the assigned employee even if the employee’s salary exceeded the maximum of the new pay range. 4. If the position assigned is higher in pay grade and extends beyond 30 days, but less than 6 months, there should be a 5% “temporary assignment” pay adjustment for the first pay grade and 2.5% for each additional pay grade to a maximum of 20% or the minimum of the new grade, whichever is higher. The employee’s salary shall not exceed the maximum of the assigned range. Employees receiving temporary assignment pay shall sign an agreement acknowledging the understanding that they are receiving “Temporary Assignment Pay” and also acknowledging that when the temporary assignment ends, the “assignment pay” will also end. E. Hiring 1. The hire rate for a new employee with no equivalent and /or relevant level experience is typically the minimum of the salary range to which the job classification is assigned. 2. New hiring rates above the minimum (or re-hires) for employees with prior experience that is directly relevant experience and/or experience that can be verified by the Human Resources Department may be considered. To determine prior relevant experience credit, the chart below will apply. Employees who have left the City and have been officially terminated will be re-hired using this formula and will not be rehired at the previous salary. Re-hires who have left the City’s employment will be considered using the same formula as new hires. 18 Page 65 of 118 3.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 3-5 Years of Experience Starting Pay 1 to < 3 Pay Grade Minimum 3 to < 5 Pay Grade Minimum Plus 3% 5 to < 7 Pay Grade Minimum Plus 6% 7 to < 11 Pay Grade Minimum Plus 9% 11 to < 15 Pay Grade Minimum Plus 12% 15 to < 20 Pay Grade Minimum Plus 15% 20 or more Pay Grade Minimum Plus 20% 3. Internal Equity is an equally important consideration in filling a vacant position. Before a salary offer is made, Human Resources will also consider the current salaries , level of education, relevant licenses/certifications, and length of service in the same/similar job class or classes of current incumbents. It is the policy of the City to make every effort to avoid inverted salary relationships by bringing in newly hired employees at a salary that exceeds the current salaries of comparably placed existing employees in the same/similar job class. 4. The Human Resources department may additionally consider a higher salary offer if the open position is determined to be a “hard to fill” position. 5. “Hard to fill” positions will be designated as such by the Human Resources Department and will be based on the length of time the position has remained unfilled, the difficulty to recruit, the “mission critical” nature of the work and the market conditions of the position, at the time of a vacancy. 6. Hiring Range is typically considered that span in salary between the minimum of the range and the market point for most positions . For Directorships or Assistant Director -level positions, the qualifications of the applicant and/or the needs of the City should include the discretion to hire anywhere within the range. However, consideration should still be given to existing salaries of other employees who are in directly comparable leadership positions. 19 Page 66 of 118 3.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 3-6 F. Maximum of the Range Ranges are established to reflect the market value of a given job profile and not an incumbent. Once an employee reaches the maximum of his/her assigned range, the salary is frozen, and the employee is not eligible for any additional compensation unless there is a range movement that would result in a higher maximum. G. Salary Adjustment for Department Directors There should be some flexibility for making salary adjustments for Departmental Directors beyond an annual increase when it is based on exceptional performance. The salaries of other equivalent employees should also be given consideration to not create undue inequity in the salary relationships between and among comparable levels of peers. H. Demotion 1. Voluntary Demotion If the demotion is voluntary, placement at the appropriate level within the new salary grade would be based on experience and prior performance and must be approved by the Department Head and the Human Resources Department. In a voluntary demotion, the performance appraisal date remains unchanged. 2. Involuntary Demotion If an employee is involuntarily demoted as a result of disciplinary action, for example, or action related to unacceptable job performance, the rate of pay may be reduced by at least 2.5% per grade reduction or by a minimum of 5%; and the employee’s salary must be reduced to at least the maximum of the lower Pay Grade, and may be placed at any salary within the lower Pay Grade as long as there is a minimum 5% reduction in pay. The employee will be placed on conditional status for a period of twelve months. There will be no salary increase at the end of the conditional period. The salary is established in the same manner as for voluntary demotion. A performance appraisal must be completed within twelve months of the date of the demotion. A proficient performance appraisal will result in release from conditional status. and continuation in the position subject to continued satisfactory performance. There will be no salary increase at the end of the conditional period. The performance appraisal date shall be established one year from the effective date of the demotion. 20 Page 67 of 118 3.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 3-7 Future Salary Adjustment Recommendations The cost to implement and maintain the compensation system should be driven by changes in the labor market and/or internal relationships and should be applied globally to the system, which, in turn, adjusts each salar y range. Compensation systems that are well maintained address two primary issues on an annual basis: • The cost to maintain competitiveness within the system • The cost to adjust individual salaries From time to time, the City may determine the need to adjust pay grades/ranges based on some factor, such as the Employment Cost Index (ECI) to maintain competitiveness at salary range minimums and hiring rates, as well as accommodate current incumbent pay progression within the grades. Ideally, funding permitting, the City should conduct a salary/market review periodically to assess market conditions and ensure a competitive posture in personnel recruitment and retention. At this time, a more detailed comparison to the external marke t, as well as , to immediate competitors can be made using a comprehensive methodology such as that used in this review. MAG recommends that any adjustments to the pay plan be based on 50% of the approved COLA determined by the City Council. For example, if the City Council approves a 6% COLA, the pay ranges on all pay plans should increase by 3%. This will assist employee movement through their designated pay range because their actual increase is greater than the increase to the pay ranges. Proposed Compensation Plan Regardless of an organization's philosophy concerning advancement opportunities afforded to employees, it is essential that movements in the economy, and more specifically, the labor market in which the City competes, be addressed at the system level. Accordingly, salary administration procedures should take priority based on funding levels and the City’s philosophy on pay. Career Path vs Career Ladders Career Path vs Career Ladder What is the Difference? A career path is a track of employment with a progression of acquired education, experience, achievement, and responsibility, moving through job positions within a professional field or organization. For example, an analytical track career path, a managerial track career path, or a quality management track career path. A Career Path is designed to encourage students to enter a certain field of study (e.g., Public Health Laboratory Science) and to demonstrate the possibilities within that field of study. A career path for a field of study in Laboratory Science can begin with a position as a Laboratory Aide, then a Laboratory Technician, followed by a Laboratory Scientist. 21 Page 68 of 118 3.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 3-8 This career path then opens a wealth of interrelated Laboratory Science tracks, and a professional can move from one track to another over the course of a career. A series of steps within a job classification, each with increasing responsibility as expertise is developed, allowing for recognition of professional growth. The steps on the career ladder may require competition for advancement. For example, progressing through the Federal GS System, or moving from Laboratory Scientist I to Laboratory Scientist II to Laboratory Scientist III. A Career Ladder is designed to encourage and assist staff to further their professional development and to reward them for their commitment to professional growth and excellence without moving to a new career path. Employee Performance and Compensation in the Public Sector The theory of pay for performance is unquestioned. The practice is universal in the private sector and important to the growth of the U.S. economy. Rewarding superior performance has gained acceptance in all aspects of life. It’s now a global practice. Government is different from the private sector in three key respects though. Two of those differences—the fact that performance ratings and pay increases are not confidential, and that changes to the system inevitably involve politics—are likely to prompt resistance to program changes. A third difference is that in the private sector, pay for performance triggers continuous attention to performance metrics. For many organizations, the incentives that motivate are the prospect of year -end bonuses and gains from stock ownership. Both reinf orce the importance of organizational success. In business, financial rewards are solidly entrenched. The transition to pay for performance in government should be managed as organizational change since it redefines the role of managers and their relationship with staff. Managers who have relied on micromanagement will need to relinquish control. Performance-related pay makes no sense where employees are tightly controlled. The problem of inflated performance ratings will have to end. It also changes employee jobs and career expectations. The highest hurdle promises to be creating performance processes that generate credible and defensible year-end ratings. Recognizing star performers as well as those whose performance is unacceptable is important to every employer. That’s obviously central to pay for performance. 22 Page 69 of 118 3.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 3-9 As a general proposition, we believe there are four fundamental requirements for an effective performance-based pay system: 1. Performance expectations are clearly defined and understood 2. Performance is measured accurately and communicated effectively by well - intentioned, trained Managers 3. The process is managed consistently across the organization 4. Differences in performance can result in meaningful differences in compensation outcomes Government’s purpose is to provide critical services requiring collective support through political processes. Effectiveness and cost control are the primary measures of success. In contrast, private sector organizations must create profit to exist, so the ir standards are different. Although the transition to a pay for performance system is challenging, and requires a fundamental shift in thought processes, operations, it is an effective way of managing limited financial resources and rewarding key performers within government. Alternative Approaches to Compensation: Skilled -Based & Competency-Based Pay Traditional pay structures within organizations have traditionally been focused on the assigned job. Wages have been based on position and seniority and influenced by factors like the minimum wage and negotiation. Although skills and competence have been reflected indirectly, pay systems have not been designed to encourage the development of individuals. With technological advancements and the focus on productivity and quality, many organizations now recognize the need to focus on individual contributions. Skill-based Pay Skill-based systems have long been used to define jobs within the trades. Increasing skill levels are the determining factor in describing positions like apprentice, journeyman, and expert craftsman. Other examples of skill-based pay systems can be found among white- collar jobs where the organization is providing a career progression based on increasing technical skill as an alternative to being promoted through various management levels. 23 Page 70 of 118 3.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 3-10 Competency Based Pay The term competency-based pay describes a system where rewards are based on the use of competence without consideration for results. The premise is that individual performance depends on having relevant competencies and higher levels of competence will pro duce superior performance. A competency base pay system focuses on individuals. In practice, competency-based systems are seldom used in a pure form. Competency may be one of the factors determining pay, but performance may also be a factor. Application While both skill- and competency-based pay systems are focused on individuals rather than jobs, how the individual is evaluated for pay purposes is different. Skill-based systems are better defined, having been used for years as the basis for defining certain jobs. Pay is based on skills verified by some type of assessment or certification. These pay systems have been applied both to blue-collar and white-collar jobs. In contrast, competency-based pay systems have been applied as components of a pay system and so far, have been applied to individuals at professional or management levels. Trends The tendency toward leaner organizations over the past few decades has contributed to the development of pay systems that favor employees with a broad base of skills and competencies. Some of the results related to this trend include reduced staffing levels and expectations of higher performance by individuals. 24 Page 71 of 118 SECTION 4.0 Total Rewards Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 25 Page 72 of 118 Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 4-1 4.0 – Introduction to Total Rewards Total Rewards Total rewards are the monetary and non-monetary returns provided to employees in exchange for their time, talents, efforts, and results. It involves the deliberate integration of five key elements that effectively attract, motivate, and retain the talent required to achieve desired business results. The five key reward elements are: • Remuneration/Compensation • Benefits • Work-Life • Performance and Recognition • Development and Career Opportunities These elements represent the “tool kit” from which an organization chooses to offer and align a value proposition that creates value for both the organization and the employee. An effective total rewards strategy is the art of combining these five elements into tailored packages designed to achieve optimal motivation. This results in satisfied, engaged, and productive employees, who in turn create desired business performance and results. In this successful exchange relationship, the employee provides time, talent, effort, and results --- and the employer provides a total rewards package that is perceived as valuable by the employee. The Context for Total Rewards Total rewards operate in the context of an overall organizational strategy, organizational culture, and human resources strategy. Indeed, an organization’s exceptional culture or external brand value may be considered a critical component of the total employment value proposition. In addition, other external influences on an organization that affect total rewards design include: • Legal/regulatory issues • Cultural influences and practices • Competition • Labor market Total Reward Definitions and Examples Remuneration/Compensation Pay provided by an employer to an employee for services rendered (i.e., time, effort, and skill). 26 Page 73 of 118 4.0 City Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 4-2 Remuneration/Compensation comprises four core elements: • Fixed pay – Also known as “base or basic pay,” fixed pay is nondiscretionary compensation that does not vary according to performance or results achieved. It usually is determined by the organization’s pay philosophy and structure. • Variable pay – Also known as “pay at risk,” variable pay changes directly with the level of performance or results achieved. It is a one-time payment and must be re-established and re- earned each performance period. • Short-term incentive pay – A form of variable pay; short-term incentive pay is designed to focus and reward performance over a period of one year or less. • Long-term incentive pay – A form of variable pay; long-term incentive pay is designed to focus and reward performance over a period longer than one year. Benefits Programs an employer uses to supplement the cash compensation that employees receive. These programs are designed to protect the employee and his or her family from financial risks and can be categorized into the following elements: • Social Insurance • Unemployment • Worker’s compensation • Social Security • Disability (occupational) Group Insurance • Medical • Dental • Vision • Prescription Drug • Mental Health • Life Insurance • Accidental Death and Dismemberment Insurance (AD&D) • Disability 27 Page 74 of 118 4.0 City Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 4-3 Pay for Time Not Worked These programs are designed to protect the employee’s income flow when not actively engaged at work. • At work (breaks, clean-up time, uniform changing time) • Away from work (vacation, government holidays, company holidays, personal days) Work-Life A specific set of organizational practices, policies, and programs, plus a philosophy, which actively supports efforts to help employees achieve success at both work and home. There are seven major categories of organizational support for work-life effectiveness in the workplace. These categories encompass compensation, benefits, and other human resources programs. In combination, they address the key intersections of the worker, his or her family, the community, and the workplace. The seven categories are: • Workplace flexibility • Paid and unpaid time off • Health and well-being • Caring for dependents • Financial support • Community involvement • Management involvement/culture change interventions Performance & Recognition Performance: A key component of organizational success, alignment of organizational, team and individual performance is assessed in order to understand what was accomplished, and how it was accomplished. Performance involves the alignment of organizational, team and individual effort toward the achievement of business goals and organizational success. Performance planning is a process whereby expectations are established linking the individual with team and organizational goals. Care is taken to ensure goals at all levels are aligned, and there is a clear line of sight from performance expectations of individual employees all the way up to the organizational objectives and strategies set at the highest levels of the organization. Performance is the manner of demonstrating a skill or capacity. Performance feedback communicates how well people do a job or task compared to expectations, performance standards and goals. Performance feedback can motivate employees to improve performance. 28 Page 75 of 118 4.0 City Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 4-4 Recognition acknowledges or gives special attention to employee actions, efforts, behavior, or performance. It meets an intrinsic psychological need for appreciation of one’s efforts and can support business strategy by reinforcing certain behaviors (e.g., extraordinary accomplishments) that contribute to organizational success. Whether formal o r informal, recognition programs acknowledge employee contributions immediately after the fact, usually without predetermined goals or performance levels that the employee is expected to achieve. Awards can be cash or non- cash (e.g., verbal recognition, trophies, certificates, plaques, dinners, tickets, etc.). The value of recognition plans is that they: • Reinforce the value of performance improvement • Foster continued improvement, although it is not guaranteed • Formalize the process of showing appreciation • Provide positive and immediate feedback • Foster communication of valued behavior and activities Development and Career Opportunities Development: A set of learning experiences designed to enhance employees’ applied skills and competencies. Development engages employees to perform better and engages leaders to advance their organization’s people strategies. Career Opportunities: A plan for employees to advance their career goals and may include advancement into a more responsible position in an organization. The organization supports career opportunities internally so that talented employees are deployed in positions that enable them to deliver their greatest value to the organization. Development and career opportunities include the following: Learning Opportunities • Tuition assistance • Corporate universities • Innovative technology training • Attendance at outside seminars, conferences, virtual education, etc. • Self-development tools and techniques • On-the-job learning; rotational assignments at a progressively higher level • Sabbaticals with the express purpose of acquiring specific skills, knowledge, or experience • Coaching/Mentoring • Leadership training • Access to experts/information networks association memberships, attendance and/or presentation at conferences • Exposure to resident experts • Formal or informal mentoring programs in or outside one’s own organization 29 Page 76 of 118 4.0 City Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 4-5 Advancement Opportunities Internships • Apprenticeships with experts • International assignments • Internal job postings • Job advancement/promotion • Career ladders and pathways • Succession planning • Providing defined and respectable “on and off ramps” throughout the career life cycle An Integrated Total Rewards Strategy Culture Culture consists of the collective attitudes and behaviors that influence how individuals behave. Culture determines how and why a company operates in the manner that it does. Typically, it is comprised of a set of often unspoken expectations, behavioral norms, and performance standards to which the organization has become accustomed. Culture change is difficult to achieve because it involves changing attitudes and behaviors by altering their fundamental beliefs and values. Organizational culture is subject to internal and external influences; thus, culture is depicted as a contextual element of the total rewards model, overlapping within and outside the organization. Environment The environment is the total cluster of observable physical, psychological, and behavioral elements in the workplace. It is the tangible manifestation of organizational culture. Environment sets the tone, as everyone who enters the workplace reacts to it, either consciously or unconsciously. Because they are directly observable and often measurable, specific elements of the environment can be deliberately manipulated or changed. The external environment in which an organization operates can influence the internal environment; thus, environment is depicted as a contextual element of the total rewards model, overlapping within and outside the organization. Attraction The ability of an organization to attract the right kind of talent necessary to achieve organizational success. The attraction of an adequate (and perpetual) supply of qualified talent is essential for the organization’s survival, and it is one of the key planks of business strategy. One way an organization can address this issue is to determine which “attractors” within the total rewards program brings the kind of talent that will drive organizational success. A deliberate strategy to attract the quantity and quality of employees needed to drive organizational success is one of the key planks of business strategy. 30 Page 77 of 118 4.0 City Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 4-6 Retention An organization’s ability to keep employees who are valued contributors to organizational success for as long as is mutually beneficial. Desired talent can be retained on staff by using a dynamic blend of elements from the total rewards package as employees move through their career lifecycles. However, not all retention is desirable, which is why a formal retention strategy with appropriate steps is essential. Motivation The ability to cause employees to behave in a way that achieves the highest performance levels. Motivation is comprised of two types: • Intrinsic Motivation is linked to factors that include an employee’s sense of achievement, respect for the whole person, trust, appropriate advancement opportunities and others, intrinsic motivation consistently results in higher performance levels. • Extrinsic Motivation is most frequently associated with rewards that are tangible, such as compensation and benefits. There are also defined levels of intensity regarding motivation: • Satisfaction – how much I like things here • Commitment – how much I want to be here • Engagement – how much I will actually do to improve business results 31 Page 78 of 118 SECTION 5.0 Proposed Retention Incentive Pay Policy Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 32 Page 79 of 118 Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 5-1 5.0 – Proposed Retention Incentive Pay Policy Purpose The purpose of the Retention Incentive Pay Policy is to recognize those employees who have faithfully served the citizens of the City through their continued service as employees of Beaufort. Rules for Longevity Pay A. Only full-time regular and part -time regular employees will be eligible to receive retention pay. Part-time regular employees will receive retention pay that will be prorated based on the number of hours the employee normally works compared to a 40-hour week. B. Employees will be recognized for continued service to the City based on the number of completed years that the employee has worked for the City. Calculation payout is based on the employee’s anniversary date. C. Only continuous unbroken years of service will be computed when determining the amount of retention pay an employee is to receive. D. Employees who leave employment with the City, but are reinstated within thirty (30) calendar days of their date of termination will not have this period considered as a break in service for the purpose of determining the amount of retention pay. E. The following amounts of retention pay will be given to eligible employees based on the number of completed years of service to the City: Retention Incentive Pay Scale Years of Service Amount Years of Service Amount 1 $200 11 $1,350 2 $250 12 $1,500 3 $350 13 $1,750 4 $500 14 $1,900 5 $650 15 $2,050 6 $750 16 $2,200 7 $850 17 $2,350 8 $950 18 $2,500 9 $1,050 19 $2,700 10 $1,200 20 + $3,000 33 Page 80 of 118 5.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 5-2 F. The retention pay will be paid as a lump sum on the employee’s anniversary date. The employee will be responsible for all applicable taxes associated with the longevity pay. G. Continuation of retention pay distributions are contingent upon the approval of funding for this program by the City Council through the annual budget process. 34 Page 81 of 118 SECTION 6.0 Premium Pay Policies Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 35 Page 82 of 118 Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 6-1 6.0 – Premium Pay Policies The City of Beaufort may develop written plans to provide additional compensation for nonexempt employees who work non-standard shifts or who are subject to call back. Such plans may include shift differentials, on-call pay, call-back pay, and/or premium pay. The City recognizes that certain work-related circumstances call for compensation in the form of premium pay in addition to an individual's base salary. Shift Differential A shift differential is a fixed amount of money expressed on a cents per hour basis. Shift differentials are provided for each hour actually worked to supplement base pay. Shift differentials apply only to hours actually worked and are included in the regular rate of pay in the calculation of overtime. Pay rate increases are not applied to shift differentials. The shift differential may cause the hourly base pay rate to exceed the pay range maximum of the salary range without violating applicable Human Resources Policies and Procedures on wage and salary administration. The rate of pay for shift differential is $1.25 per hour. On-Call Pay Employees are on call when they are scheduled to respond if called back to perform work. Unless another amount is approved in accordance with this procedure, employees on call are paid one hour of straight time for each on-call period up to 24 hours. Such pay is for the inconvenience of being on call and is not for actual hours worked. On-call pay is included in the computation of the employee’s regular rate of pay, but is not considered hours worked for the purpose of calculating overtime. Employees scheduled to be on call should be given advance notice when practical. Regardless of whether a written plan is in place, all employees entitled to on-call pay under federal or state law will be compensated for such time. Supervisors must notify the Department of Human Resources if employees not covered by a written plan are required to be on-call. Call-Back Pay Call-back pay is to compensate employees for the interruption and inconvenience when they are required to report to work at an unexpected time or day. Emp loyees who are called back to work will be paid for a minimum of three hours, regardless of the number of hours worked. An employee who works more than three hours when called back will be paid based on actual hours worked. Travel time is not considered hours worked. Overtime pay will be based solely on actual hours worked. Call-back pay does not apply to scheduled work hours. Employees who are required to return to work two hours or less before their normal shift time and who continue working into the norm al shift or who are held over beyond their normal shift are not considered called back and will be paid only for actual hours worked. Each employee is required to report to work when called back unless excused by the supervisor on duty. Employees may not evade contact or fail to respond when contacted. 36 Page 83 of 118 6.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 6-2 Premium Pay The City may develop premium pay plans to provide additional compensation for exempt employees to ensure continuity of services during emergencies, unusual circumstances, late shift work schedules, weekend work, and holidays. Premium pay is at the rate of at least one and one-half times the employee’s regular rate of pay. Employees will not receive both premium pay and overtime pay (nonexempt) for the same hours of work regardless of the total number of hours the employee works during the week. Education, Licensure & Certification Pay The purpose of this policy is to provide guidance regarding additional compensation to eligible staff employees of the City who (after their employment date and completion of their Introductory Period) attain additional job -related or job -enhancing degrees from regionally accredited colleges and universities and/or job -related or job -enhancing professional certifications and licensures from appropriate agencies. The City encourages and rewards continuing education among its employees. Therefore, budget permitting, all regular staff who have satisfactory job performance may be considered for a salary increase upon completion of additional job -related or job - enhancing degrees from regionally accredited colleges and universities and/or upon receiving select job -related or job -enhancing cert ifications or licensures. These certifications/licensures are frequently from nationally recognized certifying or licensing organizations. Regular part-time staff should receive a prorated amount based upon their full-time equivalency (FTE). For example, an eligible part-time employee of 0.50 FTE may be eligible for an amount equal to 50% of the $3,500 for a Masters’ degree. Prior to enrolling in a degree, certification, or licensure program, the employee must receive appropriate approval by using the Request for Compensation for Additional Degrees, Certifications, and Licensures form. Failure to do so in advance may result in denial of the request. Once the degree, certification, or licensure has been obtained, the employee should provide documentation of such accomplishment to their respective department. At that time, a Personnel Action form should be submitted, along with a copy of the approved Compensation for Additional Degrees, Certifications, and Licensures Form , and the appropriate documentation from the employee to increase the employee's base salary. The Personnel Action form should only include the increase as it pertains to this policy and should not include other raises and/or merit increases. An increase in an employee's base salary should not be included using the budget process. 37 Page 84 of 118 6.0 City of Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 6-3 If an employee has an approved Compensation for Additional Degrees, Certifications, and Licensures Form and transfers to another department, the employee must seek full approval from the new department in order for the salary increase to be paid. The new department is not required to approve the form and/or salary increase. Increases, to the extent permitted under the City budget, will be effective the first of the month following the completion of the degree, certification, or licensure. Degree • Associate: $2,000 • Bachelor: $3,000 • Masters/EDS/JDS: $3,500 Certification/Licensure • Certification: $1,000 • Licensure: $1,000 The types of certifications and licensures that may be rewarded are typically those that are nationally recognized across a wide variety of industries. These require continuing education to maintain the certification or licensure or have an expiration date. Although it is not possible to list all the designations, examples include Operators, Certified Public Accountant, Professional Engineer, Skilled-Craft Occupations, and Professional Architect. 38 Page 85 of 118 SECTION 7.0 Salary Survey Summary Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 39 Page 86 of 118 Min Mid Max Job Class Title Averages For Each Job Class Range Width Min Mid Max BEAUFORT Range Width Salary Survey Results for BEAUFORT, SC ASSOCIATE II - PARKS $38,570 $45,858 $53,147 37.8% $37,702 $46,970 $56,238 49.2%-2.3% 2.4% 5.5% MECHANIC $38,864 $47,437 $56,010 44.1% $33,175 $41,247 $49,318 48.7%-17.1% -15.0% -13.6% COURT CLERK II $39,539 $48,655 $57,770 46.1% $38,917 $48,252 $57,587 48.0%-1.6% -0.8% -0.3% ASSOCIATE II - STORMWATER $40,001 $48,979 $57,956 44.9% $37,702 $46,970 $56,238 49.2%-6.1% -4.3% -3.1% ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT $40,123 $49,465 $58,807 46.6% $39,043 $49,183 $59,323 51.9%-2.8% -0.6% 0.9% PERMIT TECHNICIAN $39,192 $49,974 $60,756 55.0% $43,791 $54,567 $65,343 49.2%10.5% 8.4% 7.0% FIREFIGHTER $44,662 $50,322 $55,983 25.3% $39,731 $45,825 $51,919 30.7%-12.4% -9.8% -7.8% SRO $44,960 $52,867 $60,774 35.2% $45,062 $56,879 $68,697 52.5%0.2% 7.1% 11.5% FIREFIGHTER I $42,997 $53,356 $63,716 48.2% $45,975 $55,433 $64,892 41.1%6.5% 3.7% 1.8% FIREFIGHTER II $48,194 $55,564 $62,934 30.6% $47,604 $58,801 $69,999 47.0%-1.2% 5.5% 10.1% OFFICE MANAGER - PUBLIC WORKS $45,941 $55,972 $66,002 43.7% $43,595 $54,244 $64,893 48.9%-5.4% -3.2% -1.7% HR SPECIALIST $44,297 $56,536 $68,775 55.3% $43,791 $54,567 $65,343 49.2%-1.2% -3.6% -5.3% PATROLMAN I $48,281 $57,331 $66,381 37.5% $51,145 $62,346 $73,547 43.8%5.6% 8.0% 9.7% PLANNER $47,909 $59,548 $71,188 48.6% $43,791 $54,567 $65,343 49.2%-9.4% -9.1% -8.9% FIREFIGHTER III $54,950 $63,699 $72,448 31.8% $52,011 $64,498 $76,985 48.0%-5.7% 1.2% 5.9% RESIDENTIAL INSPECTOR $51,074 $63,968 $76,863 50.5% $51,090 $63,337 $75,584 47.9%0.0% -1.0% -1.7% PATROLMAN II $54,893 $64,037 $73,181 33.3% $54,168 $67,595 $81,022 49.6%-1.3% 5.3% 9.7% ACCOUNTING CLERK $52,030 $65,362 $78,695 51.2% $51,090 $63,337 $75,584 47.9%-1.8% -3.2% -4.1% PATROLMAN III $59,727 $69,404 $79,080 32.4% $59,612 $74,418 $89,224 49.7%-0.2% 6.7% 11.4% FACILITIES MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR $56,509 $70,831 $85,153 50.7% $52,256 $66,683 $81,111 55.2%-8.1% -6.2% -5.0% FIRE LIEUTENANT $55,714 $72,414 $89,114 59.9% $58,092 $72,307 $86,523 48.9%4.1% -0.1% -3.0% POLICE SERGEANT $64,475 $75,829 $87,183 35.2% $61,930 $76,496 $91,062 47.0%-4.1% 0.9% 4.3% FIRE CAPTAIN $66,754 $82,260 $97,766 46.5% $66,709 $82,534 $98,360 47.4%-0.1% 0.3% 0.6% PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER $67,850 $83,732 $99,614 46.8% $63,265 $78,423 $93,581 47.9%-7.2% -6.8% -6.4% POLICE LIEUTENANT $77,295 $90,339 $103,384 33.8% $71,535 $90,923 $110,312 54.2%-8.1% 0.6% 6.3% CITY CLERK $73,293 $91,545 $109,797 49.8% $63,265 $78,423 $93,581 47.9%-15.9% -16.7% -17.3% BATTALION CHIEF $75,755 $92,299 $108,842 43.7% $73,502 $91,906 $110,311 50.1%-3.1% -0.4% 1.3% BUILDING OFFICIAL $75,549 $94,714 $113,878 50.7% $75,561 $93,483 $111,405 47.4%0.0% -1.3% -2.2% POLICE CAPTAIN $79,189 $94,944 $110,698 39.8% $77,225 $98,086 $118,946 54.0%-2.5% 3.2% 6.9% COURT ADMINISTRATOR $76,241 $97,277 $118,314 55.2% $63,265 $78,423 $93,581 47.9%-20.5% -24.0% -26.4% DEPUTY FIRE CHIEF - FIRE MARSHAL $87,697 $108,237 $128,777 46.8% $81,297 $102,671 $124,045 52.6%-7.9% -5.4% -3.8% PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR $86,855 $108,313 $129,771 49.4% $95,379 $115,670 $135,960 42.5%8.9% 6.4% 4.6% FIRE CHIEF $90,835 $113,841 $136,847 50.7% $95,379 $115,670 $135,960 42.5%4.8% 1.6% -0.7% COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR $92,270 $116,470 $140,669 52.5% $95,379 $115,670 $135,960 42.5%3.3% -0.7% -3.5% HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR $94,153 $117,983 $141,813 50.6% $95,379 $115,670 $135,960 42.5%1.3% -2.0% -4.3% POLICE CHIEF $94,287 $118,175 $142,063 50.7% $95,379 $115,670 $135,960 42.5%1.1% -2.2% -4.5% Friday, April 4, 2025 Page 1 of 24:21:16 PM 40 Page 87 of 118 Min Mid Max Job Class Title Averages For Each Job Class Range Width Min Mid Max BEAUFORT Range Width Salary Survey Results for BEAUFORT, SC FINANCE DIRECTOR $93,880 $119,081 $144,282 53.7% $95,379 $115,670 $135,960 42.5%1.6% -2.9% -6.1% DEPUTY CITY MANAGER $108,391 $136,935 $165,479 52.7% $102,174 $126,689 $151,204 48.0%-6.1% -8.1% -9.4% $62,979 $77,462 $91,945Survey Averages 45.19% $61,614 $76,161 $90,707 -2.21% -1.71% -1.37% 47.22% Friday, April 4, 2025 Page 2 of 24:21:16 PM 41 Page 88 of 118 SECTION 8.0 Proposed Pay Plan Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 42 Page 89 of 118 Proposed Pay Plan City of Beaufort, SC FIRE Grade Code Proposed Class Title Ann Min Ann Mid Ann Max Hrly Min Hrly Mid Hrly Max 201 $47,000 $59,897 $72,794 $17.05 $21.73 $26.41 470-ffrec FIREFIGHTER/EMT RECRUIT 203 $49,379 $62,929 $76,479 $17.92 $22.83 $27.75 470-ff1e FIREFIGHTER I/EMT 206 $53,176 $67,768 $82,359 $19.29 $24.59 $29.88 470-ff1a FIREFIGHTER I/EMT ADVANCED 207 $54,506 $69,462 $84,418 $19.78 $25.20 $30.63 470-ff2e FIREFIGHTER II/EMT 209 $57,265 $72,978 $88,692 $20.78 $26.48 $32.18 470-ff1p FIREFIGHTER I/PARAMEDIC 470-ff2a FIREFIGHTER II/EMT ADVANCED 211 $60,164 $76,673 $93,182 $21.83 $27.82 $33.81 470-ff3e FIREFIGHTER III/EMT* 212 $61,668 $78,590 $95,512 $22.38 $28.52 $34.66 470-ff2p FIREFIGHTER II/PARAMEDIC 213 $63,210 $80,555 $97,899 $22.94 $29.23 $35.52 470-ff3a FIREFIGHTER III/EMT ADVANCED 215 $66,410 $84,633 $102,855 $24.10 $30.71 $37.32 470-ff3p FIREFIGHTER III/PARAMEDIC 218 $71,516 $91,140 $110,764 $25.95 $33.07 $40.19 470-firelta FIRE LIEUTENANT/EMT ADVANCED 220 $75,137 $95,754 $116,372 $27.26 $34.74 $42.22 470-fireltp FIRE LIEUTENANT/PARAMEDIC 222 $78,940 $100,602 $122,263 $28.64 $36.50 $44.36 482-cpta FIRE CAPTAIN/EMT ADVANCED 224 $82,937 $105,695 $128,452 $30.09 $38.35 $46.61 482-cptp FIRE CAPTAIN/PARAMEDIC 226 $87,135 $111,045 $134,955 $31.62 $40.29 $48.97 483-bce BATTALION CHIEF/EMT* 228 $91,547 $116,667 $141,787 $33.22 $42.33 $51.45 483-bca BATTALION CHIEF/EMT ADVANCED 230 $96,181 $122,573 $148,965 $34.90 $44.47 $54.05 483-bcp BATTALION CHIEF/PARAMEDIC 17 Active Proposed Classes in the FIRE Pay Plan * Incumbent Position Only Based on 2756 Annual Hours Thursday, July 3, 2025 10:37:07 AM Page 1 43 Page 90 of 118 Proposed Pay Plan City of Beaufort, SC FIRE-PT Grade Code Proposed Class Title Ann Min Ann Mid Ann Max Hrly Min Hrly Mid Hrly Max 401 $35,471 $45,204 $54,938 $17.05 $21.73 $26.41 470-ffrec-pt FIREFIGHTER/EMT RECRUIT - PT 403 $37,267 $47,493 $57,719 $17.92 $22.83 $27.75 470-ff1e-pt FIREFIGHTER I/EMT - PT 407 $41,136 $52,423 $63,711 $19.78 $25.20 $30.63 470-ff2e-pt FIREFIGHTER II/EMT - PT 411 $45,406 $57,865 $70,325 $21.83 $27.82 $33.81 470-ff3e-pt FIREFIGHTER III/EMT* - PT 413 $47,705 $60,795 $73,885 $22.93 $29.23 $35.52 470-ff3a-pt FIREFIGHTER III/EMT ADVANCED - PT 5 Active Proposed Classes in the FIRE-PT Pay Plan * Incumbent Position Only Based on 2080 Annual Hours Thursday, July 3, 2025 10:37:07 AM Page 2 44 Page 91 of 118 Proposed Pay Plan City of Beaufort, SC POLICE Grade Code Proposed Class Title Ann Min Ann Mid Ann Max Hrly Min Hrly Mid Hrly Max 301 $60,000 $76,464 $92,928 $26.83 $34.20 $41.56 420-p1 POLICE OFFICER I 303 $63,038 $80,335 $97,632 $28.19 $35.93 $43.66 420-p2 POLICE OFFICER II 305 $66,229 $84,402 $102,575 $29.62 $37.75 $45.87 431-inv1 INVESTIGATOR I 420-p3 POLICE OFFICER III 307 $69,582 $88,675 $107,768 $31.12 $39.66 $48.20 431-inv2 INVESTIGATOR II 430 POLICE CORPORAL 309 $73,104 $93,164 $113,224 $32.69 $41.67 $50.64 440-sgt POLICE SERGEANT 311 $76,805 $97,880 $118,956 $34.35 $43.77 $53.20 440-1stsgt POLICE 1ST SERGEANT 8 Active Proposed Classes in the POLCE Pay Plan Based on 2236 Annual Hours Thursday, July 3, 2025 10:37:07 AM Page 3 45 Page 92 of 118 Proposed Pay Plan City of Beaufort, SC UNIFIED Grade Code Proposed Class Title Ann Min Ann Mid Ann Max Hrly Min Hrly Mid Hrly Max 101 $39,036 $49,748 $60,459 $18.77 $23.92 $29.07 515-a1parks ASSOCIATE I - PARKS 515-a1sw ASSOCIATE I - STORMWATER 102 $40,988 $52,235 $63,482 $19.71 $25.11 $30.52 516-a2gs ASSOCIATE II - GENERAL SUPPORT 516-a2parks ASSOCIATE II - PARKS 520-a2sw ASSOCIATE II - STORMWATER 103 $43,037 $54,847 $66,656 $20.69 $26.37 $32.05 104-aacd ADMIN ASST - COMMUNITY & DEVELOPMENT 104-aapd ADMIN ASST - POLICE 104-aapw ADMIN ASST - PUBLIC WORKS 100 COURT CLERK II 104-aahr HUMAN RESOURCES ASSISTANT 104 $45,189 $57,589 $69,989 $21.73 $27.69 $33.65 104-aa2recpd1 POLICE RECORDS CLERK 105 $47,449 $60,469 $73,489 $22.81 $29.07 $35.33 146 ACCOUNTING CLERK I 237 BUSINESS LICENSE ADMINISTRATOR 209 BUSINESS LICENSE INSPECTOR 104-etcoord EVENTS AND TOUR COORDINATOR 525 FLEET TECHNICIAN 226 PERMIT TECHNICIAN 520-traftech TECHNICIAN - TRAFFIC 106 $49,821 $63,492 $77,163 $23.95 $30.53 $37.10 149 EVIDENCE TECHNICIAN 107 $52,312 $66,667 $81,021 $25.15 $32.05 $38.95 459 COURT SECURITY OFFICER 148 OFFICE MANAGER - FIRE 147 OFFICE MANAGER - POLICE 234-plan PLANNER I 108 $54,928 $70,000 $85,072 $26.41 $33.65 $40.90 238-accclk ACCOUNTING CLERK II 2020 DEPUTY CLERK OF COURT 109 $57,674 $73,500 $89,326 $27.73 $35.34 $42.95 541-gensupspv GENERAL SUPPORT SUPERVISOR 111 OFFICE MANAGER - PUBLIC WORKS 541-spvparks PARKS SUPERVISOR 220-resins RESIDENTIAL INSPECTOR 420-p1sro SCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICER I 541-swsupv STORMWATER SUPERVISOR Based on 2080 Annual Hours Thursday, July 3, 2025 10:37:07 AM Page 4 46 Page 93 of 118 Proposed Pay Plan City of Beaufort, SC UNIFIED Grade Code Proposed Class Title Ann Min Ann Mid Ann Max Hrly Min Hrly Mid Hrly Max Based on 2080 Annual Hours 110 $60,558 $77,175 $93,792 $29.11 $37.10 $45.09 104-cpsc CAPITAL PROJECTS SUPPORT COORDINATOR 234 DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COORDINATOR 104-aahrcmo HUMAN RESOURCES SPECIALIST 420-p2sro SCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICER II 451 VICTIMS ADVOCATE/SERVICES COORDINATOR 111 $63,586 $81,034 $98,482 $30.57 $38.96 $47.35 104-cass ACCREDITATION MANAGER 204 DOWNTOWN MANAGER 541-facmainspv FACILITIES MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR 234-plan2 PLANNER II 420-p3sro SCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICER III 112 $66,765 $85,085 $103,406 $32.10 $40.91 $49.71 485 FIRE INSPECTOR 541-opsmgr OPERATIONS MANAGER 113 $70,103 $89,340 $108,576 $33.70 $42.95 $52.20 222 CODES ENFORCEMENT MANAGER 440-sgtsr SCHOOL RESOURCE SERGEANT 115 $77,289 $98,497 $119,705 $37.16 $47.35 $57.55 440-sgttrain POLICE SERGEANT - TRAINING 116 $81,153 $103,422 $125,690 $39.02 $49.72 $60.43 201 CITY CLERK 234-plan3 PLANNER III 438 POLICE MASTER SERGEANT 116 PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER 117 $85,211 $108,593 $131,975 $40.97 $52.21 $63.45 444-ltinv INVESTIGATIONS LIEUTENANT 444 POLICE LIEUTENANT 118 $89,472 $114,023 $138,574 $43.02 $54.82 $66.62 202 COURT ADMINISTRATOR 238-fssprocadm FINANCIAL SYSTEMS SPECIALIST/PROCUREMENT ADMINISTRATOR 261 MEDICAL TRAINING OFFICER 238-senacct SENIOR ACCOUNTANT 119 $93,945 $119,724 $145,502 $45.17 $57.56 $69.95 220-bldgoff BUILDING OFFICIAL 483-cpttrain FIRE CAPTAIN - TRAINING 487 FIRE MARSHAL 410 POLICE CAPTAIN Thursday, July 3, 2025 10:37:07 AM Page 5 47 Page 94 of 118 Proposed Pay Plan City of Beaufort, SC UNIFIED Grade Code Proposed Class Title Ann Min Ann Mid Ann Max Hrly Min Hrly Mid Hrly Max Based on 2080 Annual Hours 121 $103,575 $131,995 $160,416 $49.80 $63.46 $77.12 489-dfcadm DEPUTY FIRE CHIEF - ADMINISTRATION 489-dfcops DEPUTY FIRE CHIEF - OPERATIONS 445 DEPUTY POLICE CHIEF 117 DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROJECTS 576 PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR 122 $108,753 $138,595 $168,437 $52.29 $66.63 $80.98 233 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR 205 HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR 123 $114,191 $145,525 $176,859 $54.90 $69.96 $85.03 118 DIRECTOR OF DOWNTOWN OPERATIONS 240 FINANCE DIRECTOR 124 $119,900 $152,801 $185,702 $57.64 $73.46 $89.28 490 FIRE CHIEF 450 POLICE CHIEF 129 $153,027 $195,017 $237,008 $73.57 $93.76 $113.95 241 DEPUTY CITY MANAGER 132 $177,148 $225,757 $274,366 $85.17 $108.54 $131.91 200 CITY MANAGER 73 Active Proposed Classes in the UNIFIED Pay Plan Thursday, July 3, 2025 10:37:07 AM Page 6 48 Page 95 of 118 SECTION 9.0 Alphabetical Classification List Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 49 Page 96 of 118 Proposed Class List By Title City of Beaufort SC Proposed Class Title Code Pay Plan Grade Min Mid Max # A 146ACCOUNTING CLERK I 105 $47,449 $73,489UNIFIED 1$60,469 238-accACCOUNTING CLERK II 108 $54,928 $85,072UNIFIED 1$70,000 104-casACCREDITATION MANAGER 111 $63,586 $98,482UNIFIED 1$81,034 104-aacADMIN ASST - COMMUNITY & DEVELOPMENT 103 $43,037 $66,656UNIFIED 1$54,847 104-aapADMIN ASST - POLICE 103 $43,037 $66,656UNIFIED 1$54,847 104-aapADMIN ASST - PUBLIC WORKS 103 $43,037 $66,656UNIFIED 1$54,847 515-a1pASSOCIATE I - PARKS 101 $39,036 $60,459UNIFIED 3$49,748 515-a1sASSOCIATE I - STORMWATER 101 $39,036 $60,459UNIFIED 4$49,748 516-a2gASSOCIATE II - GENERAL SUPPORT 102 $40,988 $63,482UNIFIED 1$52,235 516-a2pASSOCIATE II - PARKS 102 $40,988 $63,482UNIFIED 4$52,235 520-a2sASSOCIATE II - STORMWATER 102 $40,988 $63,482UNIFIED 3$52,235 B 483-bcaBATTALION CHIEF/EMT ADVANCED 228 $91,547 $141,787FIRE 2$116,667 483-bceBATTALION CHIEF/EMT* 226 $87,135 $134,955FIRE 1$111,045 483-bcpBATTALION CHIEF/PARAMEDIC 230 $96,181 $148,965FIRE 0$122,573 220-bldBUILDING OFFICIAL 119 $93,945 $145,502UNIFIED 1$119,724 237BUSINESS LICENSE ADMINISTRATOR 105 $47,449 $73,489UNIFIED 1$60,469 209BUSINESS LICENSE INSPECTOR 105 $47,449 $73,489UNIFIED 1$60,469 C 104-cpsCAPITAL PROJECTS SUPPORT COORDINATOR 110 $60,558 $93,792UNIFIED 1$77,175 201CITY CLERK 116 $81,153 $125,690UNIFIED 1$103,422 200CITY MANAGER 132 $177,148 $274,366UNIFIED 1$225,757 222CODES ENFORCEMENT MANAGER 113 $70,103 $108,576UNIFIED 1$89,340 233COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR 122 $108,753 $168,437UNIFIED 1$138,595 202COURT ADMINISTRATOR 118 $89,472 $138,574UNIFIED 1$114,023 100COURT CLERK II 103 $43,037 $66,656UNIFIED 2$54,847 459COURT SECURITY OFFICER 107 $52,312 $81,021UNIFIED 4$66,667 D 241DEPUTY CITY MANAGER 129 $153,027 $237,008UNIFIED 1$195,017 2020DEPUTY CLERK OF COURT 108 $54,928 $85,072UNIFIED 1$70,000 489-dfcDEPUTY FIRE CHIEF - ADMINISTRATION 121 $103,575 $160,416UNIFIED 1$131,995 489-dfcDEPUTY FIRE CHIEF - OPERATIONS 121 $103,575 $160,416UNIFIED 1$131,995 445DEPUTY POLICE CHIEF 121 $103,575 $160,416UNIFIED 1$131,995 Thursday, July 3, 2025 Page 1 of 4 50 Page 97 of 118 Proposed Class List By Title City of Beaufort SC Proposed Class Title Code Pay Plan Grade Min Mid Max # 234DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COORDINATOR 110 $60,558 $93,792UNIFIED 1$77,175 118DIRECTOR OF DOWNTOWN OPERATIONS 123 $114,191 $176,859UNIFIED 1$145,525 117DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROJECTS 121 $103,575 $160,416UNIFIED 1$131,995 204DOWNTOWN MANAGER 111 $63,586 $98,482UNIFIED 1$81,034 E 104-etcEVENTS AND TOUR COORDINATOR 105 $47,449 $73,489UNIFIED 1$60,469 149EVIDENCE TECHNICIAN 106 $49,821 $77,163UNIFIED 1$63,492 F 541-facFACILITIES MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR 111 $63,586 $98,482UNIFIED 1$81,034 240FINANCE DIRECTOR 123 $114,191 $176,859UNIFIED 1$145,525 238-fssFINANCIAL SYSTEMS SPECIALIST/PROCUREMENT ADMINISTRA 118 $89,472 $138,574UNIFIED 1$114,023 483-cpttFIRE CAPTAIN - TRAINING 119 $93,945 $145,502UNIFIED 1$119,724 482-cptFIRE CAPTAIN/EMT ADVANCED 222 $78,940 $122,263FIRE 3$100,602 482-cptFIRE CAPTAIN/PARAMEDIC 224 $82,937 $128,452FIRE 0$105,695 490FIRE CHIEF 124 $119,900 $185,702UNIFIED 1$152,801 485FIRE INSPECTOR 112 $66,765 $103,406UNIFIED 1$85,085 470-firelFIRE LIEUTENANT/EMT ADVANCED 218 $71,516 $110,764FIRE 5$91,140 470-firelFIRE LIEUTENANT/PARAMEDIC 220 $75,137 $116,372FIRE 3$95,754 487FIRE MARSHAL 119 $93,945 $145,502UNIFIED 1$119,724 470-ff1FIREFIGHTER I/EMT 203 $49,379 $76,479FIRE 3$62,929 470-ff1FIREFIGHTER I/EMT - PT 403 $37,267 $57,719FIRE-PT 1$47,493 470-ff1FIREFIGHTER I/EMT ADVANCED 206 $53,176 $82,359FIRE 0$67,768 470-ff1FIREFIGHTER I/PARAMEDIC 209 $57,265 $88,692FIRE 0$72,978 470-ff2FIREFIGHTER II/EMT 207 $54,506 $84,418FIRE 10$69,462 470-ff2FIREFIGHTER II/EMT - PT 407 $41,136 $63,711FIRE-PT 1$52,423 470-ff2FIREFIGHTER II/EMT ADVANCED 209 $57,265 $88,692FIRE 3$72,978 470-ff2FIREFIGHTER II/PARAMEDIC 212 $61,668 $95,512FIRE 2$78,590 470-ff3FIREFIGHTER III/EMT ADVANCED 213 $63,210 $97,899FIRE 6$80,555 470-ff3FIREFIGHTER III/EMT ADVANCED - PT 413 $47,705 $73,885FIRE-PT 1$60,795 470-ff3FIREFIGHTER III/EMT* 211 $60,164 $93,182FIRE 2$76,673 470-ff3FIREFIGHTER III/EMT* - PT 411 $45,406 $70,325FIRE-PT 2$57,865 470-ff3FIREFIGHTER III/PARAMEDIC 215 $66,410 $102,855FIRE 3$84,633 470-ffreFIREFIGHTER/EMT RECRUIT 201 $47,000 $72,794FIRE 3$59,897 470-ffreFIREFIGHTER/EMT RECRUIT - PT 401 $35,471 $54,938FIRE-PT 2$45,204 Thursday, July 3, 2025 Page 2 of 4 51 Page 98 of 118 Proposed Class List By Title City of Beaufort SC Proposed Class Title Code Pay Plan Grade Min Mid Max # 525FLEET TECHNICIAN 105 $47,449 $73,489UNIFIED 1$60,469 G 541-genGENERAL SUPPORT SUPERVISOR 109 $57,674 $89,326UNIFIED 1$73,500 H 104-aahHUMAN RESOURCES ASSISTANT 103 $43,037 $66,656UNIFIED 1$54,847 205HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR 122 $108,753 $168,437UNIFIED 1$138,595 104-aahHUMAN RESOURCES SPECIALIST 110 $60,558 $93,792UNIFIED 1$77,175 I 444-ltinINVESTIGATIONS LIEUTENANT 117 $85,211 $131,975UNIFIED 1$108,593 431-invINVESTIGATOR I 305 $66,229 $102,575POLICE 4$84,402 431-invINVESTIGATOR II 307 $69,582 $107,768POLICE 0$88,675 M 261MEDICAL TRAINING OFFICER 118 $89,472 $138,574UNIFIED 1$114,023 O 148OFFICE MANAGER - FIRE 107 $52,312 $81,021UNIFIED 1$66,667 147OFFICE MANAGER - POLICE 107 $52,312 $81,021UNIFIED 1$66,667 111OFFICE MANAGER - PUBLIC WORKS 109 $57,674 $89,326UNIFIED 1$73,500 541-opsOPERATIONS MANAGER 112 $66,765 $103,406UNIFIED 1$85,085 P 541-spvPARKS SUPERVISOR 109 $57,674 $89,326UNIFIED 1$73,500 226PERMIT TECHNICIAN 105 $47,449 $73,489UNIFIED 1$60,469 234-plaPLANNER I 107 $52,312 $81,021UNIFIED 1$66,667 234-plaPLANNER II 111 $63,586 $98,482UNIFIED 0$81,034 234-plaPLANNER III 116 $81,153 $125,690UNIFIED 1$103,422 440-1stPOLICE 1ST SERGEANT 311 $76,805 $118,956POLICE 4$97,880 410POLICE CAPTAIN 119 $93,945 $145,502UNIFIED 2$119,724 450POLICE CHIEF 124 $119,900 $185,702UNIFIED 1$152,801 430POLICE CORPORAL 307 $69,582 $107,768POLICE 0$88,675 444POLICE LIEUTENANT 117 $85,211 $131,975UNIFIED 2$108,593 438POLICE MASTER SERGEANT 116 $81,153 $125,690UNIFIED 2$103,422 420-p1POLICE OFFICER I 301 $60,000 $92,928POLICE 9$76,464 420-p2POLICE OFFICER II 303 $63,038 $97,632POLICE 6$80,335 420-p3POLICE OFFICER III 305 $66,229 $102,575POLICE 4$84,402 104-aa2POLICE RECORDS CLERK 104 $45,189 $69,989UNIFIED 2$57,589 Thursday, July 3, 2025 Page 3 of 4 52 Page 99 of 118 Proposed Class List By Title City of Beaufort SC Proposed Class Title Code Pay Plan Grade Min Mid Max # 440-sgtPOLICE SERGEANT 309 $73,104 $113,224POLICE 6$93,164 440-sgttPOLICE SERGEANT - TRAINING 115 $77,289 $119,705UNIFIED 1$98,497 116PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER 116 $81,153 $125,690UNIFIED 1$103,422 576PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR 121 $103,575 $160,416UNIFIED 1$131,995 R 220-resiRESIDENTIAL INSPECTOR 109 $57,674 $89,326UNIFIED 1$73,500 S 420-p1sSCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICER I 109 $57,674 $89,326UNIFIED 1$73,500 420-p2sSCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICER II 110 $60,558 $93,792UNIFIED 1$77,175 420-p3sSCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICER III 111 $63,586 $98,482UNIFIED 2$81,034 440-sgtSCHOOL RESOURCE SERGEANT 113 $70,103 $108,576UNIFIED 1$89,340 238-senSENIOR ACCOUNTANT 118 $89,472 $138,574UNIFIED 1$114,023 541-swsSTORMWATER SUPERVISOR 109 $57,674 $89,326UNIFIED 1$73,500 T 520-trafTECHNICIAN - TRAFFIC 105 $47,449 $73,489UNIFIED 2$60,469 V 451VICTIMS ADVOCATE/SERVICES COORDINATOR 110 $60,558 $93,792UNIFIED 1$77,175 103 Job Classes Thursday, July 3, 2025 Page 4 of 4 53 Page 100 of 118 SECTION 10.0 Class Comparison List Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 54 Page 101 of 118 Min Mid Max Proposed Pay Plan: FIRE Grade City of Beaufort SC Class Comparison List By Pay Plan Proposed Class Title Original Title Annual Range Working Title $47,000 $72,794201 $59,897 FIREFIGHTER 39,731 51,919FIREFIGHTER/EMT RECRUIT 45,825 FIREFIGHTER RECRUIT 39,731 51,919FIREFIGHTER/EMT RECRUIT 45,825 $49,379 $76,479203 $62,929 FIREFIGHTER I 45,974 64,891FIREFIGHTER I/EMT 55,433 FIREFIGHTER RECRUIT 39,731 51,919FIREFIGHTER I/EMT 45,825 $54,506 $84,418207 $69,462 FIREFIGHTER I 45,974 64,891FIREFIGHTER II/EMT 55,433 FIREFIGHTER II 47,604 69,998FIREFIGHTER II/EMT 58,801 FIREFIGHTER III 52,011 76,985FIREFIGHTER II/EMT 64,498 FIREFIGHTER RECRUIT 39,731 51,919FIREFIGHTER II/EMT 45,825 $57,265 $88,692209 $72,978 FIREFIGHTER II 47,604 69,998FIREFIGHTER II/EMT ADVANCED 58,801 FIREFIGHTER RECRUIT 39,731 51,919FIREFIGHTER II/EMT ADVANCED 45,825 $60,164 $93,182211 $76,673 FIREFIGHTER III 52,011 76,985FIREFIGHTER III/EMT* 64,498 $61,668 $95,512212 $78,590 FIREFIGHTER II 47,604 69,998FIREFIGHTER II/PARAMEDIC 58,801 $63,210 $97,899213 $80,555 FIREFIGHTER III 52,011 76,985FIREFIGHTER III/EMT ADVANCED 64,498 FIREFIGHTER RECRUIT 39,731 51,919FIREFIGHTER III/EMT ADVANCED 45,825 $66,410 $102,855215 $84,633 FIREFIGHTER III 52,011 76,985FIREFIGHTER III/PARAMEDIC 64,498 $71,516 $110,764218 $91,140 LIEUTENANT FIRE 58,091 86,523FIRE LIEUTENANT/EMT ADVANCED 72,307 $75,137 $116,372220 $95,754 FIRE LIEUTENANT 58,091 86,523FIRE LIEUTENANT/PARAMEDIC 72,307 LIEUTENANT FIRE 58,091 86,523FIRE LIEUTENANT/PARAMEDIC 72,307 $78,940 $122,263222 $100,602 CAPTAIN 66,708 98,359FIRE CAPTAIN/EMT ADVANCED 82,534 $87,135 $134,955226 $111,045 BATTALION CHIEF 73,502 110,310BATTALION CHIEF/EMT* 91,906 $91,547 $141,787228 $116,667 7/3/2025 10:38:02 AM 55 Page 102 of 118 Min Mid Max Proposed Pay Plan: FIRE Grade City of Beaufort SC Class Comparison List By Pay Plan Proposed Class Title Original Title Annual Range Working Title $91,547 $141,787228 $116,667 BATTALION CHIEF 73,502 110,310BATTALION CHIEF/EMT ADVANCED 91,906 7/3/2025 10:38:02 AM 56 Page 103 of 118 Min Mid Max Proposed Pay Plan: FIRE-PT Grade City of Beaufort SC Class Comparison List By Pay Plan Proposed Class Title Original Title Annual Range Working Title $35,471 $54,938401 $45,204 FIREFIGHTER 39,731 51,919FIREFIGHTER/EMT RECRUIT - PT 45,825 $37,267 $57,719403 $47,493 FIREFIGHTER 39,731 51,919FIREFIGHTER I/EMT - PT 45,825 $41,136 $63,711407 $52,423 FIREFIGHTER 39,731 51,919FIREFIGHTER II/EMT - PT 45,825 $45,406 $70,325411 $57,865 FIREFIGHTER 39,731 51,919FIREFIGHTER III/EMT* - PT 45,825 PATROLMAN 59,612 89,223FIREFIGHTER III/EMT* - PT 74,417 $47,705 $73,885413 $60,795 FIREFIGHTER 39,731 51,919FIREFIGHTER III/EMT ADVANCED - PT 45,825 7/3/2025 10:38:02 AM 57 Page 104 of 118 Min Mid Max Proposed Pay Plan: POLICE Grade City of Beaufort SC Class Comparison List By Pay Plan Proposed Class Title Original Title Annual Range Working Title $60,000 $92,928301 $76,464 PATROLMAN I 51,145 73,546POLICE OFFICER I 62,346 PATROLMAN I 59,612 89,223POLICE OFFICER I 74,417 $63,038 $97,632303 $80,335 PATROLMAN II 54,167 81,021POLICE OFFICER II 67,594 PATROLMAN II 51,145 73,546POLICE OFFICER II 62,346 $66,229 $102,575305 $84,402 INVESTIGATOR I 54,167 81,021INVESTIGATOR I 67,594 INVESTIGATOR I 59,612 89,223INVESTIGATOR I 74,417 PATROLMAN III 54,167 81,021INVESTIGATOR I 67,594 MASTER POLICE OFFICER 59,612 89,223POLICE OFFICER III 74,417 PATROLMAN III 51,145 73,546POLICE OFFICER III 62,346 PATROLMAN III 54,167 81,021POLICE OFFICER III 67,594 $73,104 $113,224309 $93,164 SERGEANT 61,930 91,061POLICE SERGEANT 76,496 SERGEANT 59,612 89,223POLICE SERGEANT 74,417 $76,805 $118,956311 $97,880 1ST SERGEANT 63,165 97,334POLICE 1ST SERGEANT 80,250 7/3/2025 10:38:02 AM 58 Page 105 of 118 Min Mid Max Proposed Pay Plan: UNIFIED Grade City of Beaufort SC Class Comparison List By Pay Plan Proposed Class Title Original Title Annual Range Working Title $39,036 $60,459101 $49,748 ASSOCIATE I - PARKS 33,174 49,318ASSOCIATE I - PARKS 41,246 ASSOCIATE I - STORMWATER 33,174 49,318ASSOCIATE I - STORMWATER 41,246 $40,988 $63,482102 $52,235 ASSOCIATE II - GENERAL SUPPORT 37,702 56,238ASSOCIATE II - GENERAL SUPPORT 46,970 ASSOCIATE II - PARKS 37,702 56,238ASSOCIATE II - PARKS 46,970 ASSOCIATE II - STORMWATER 37,702 56,238ASSOCIATE II - STORMWATER 46,970 $43,037 $66,656103 $54,847 ADMIN ASST - COMMUNITY & DEVELOPMENT 38,916 57,587ADMIN ASST - COMMUNITY & DEVELOPMENT 48,251 ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT 39,042 59,322ADMIN ASST - POLICE 49,182 ADMIN ASST - PUBLIC WORKS 39,276 59,901ADMIN ASST - PUBLIC WORKS 49,589 COURT CLERK II 38,916 57,587COURT CLERK II 48,251 ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT 38,916 57,587HUMAN RESOURCES ASSISTANT 48,251 $45,189 $69,989104 $57,589 ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT II - RECORDS CLERK 39,042 59,322POLICE RECORDS CLERK 49,182 ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT II - RECORDS CLERK 39,042 59,322POLICE RECORDS CLERK 49,182 $47,449 $73,489105 $60,469 ACCOUNTING CLERK III 43,790 65,343ACCOUNTING CLERK I 54,566 BUSINESS LICENSE ADMINISTRATOR 43,790 65,343BUSINESS LICENSE ADMINISTRATOR 54,566 BUSINESS LICENSE INSPECTOR 43,790 65,343BUSINESS LICENSE INSPECTOR 54,566 EVENTS AND TOUR COORDINATOR 43,790 65,343EVENTS AND TOUR COORDINATOR 54,566 MECHANIC 33,174 49,318FLEET TECHNICIAN 41,246 PERMIT TECHNICIAN 43,790 65,343PERMIT TECHNICIAN 54,566 TECHNICIAN - TRAFFIC 43,595 64,893TECHNICIAN - TRAFFIC 54,244 $49,821 $77,163106 $63,492 EVIDENCE TECHNICIAN 45,061 68,696EVIDENCE TECHNICIAN 56,879 $52,312 $81,021107 $66,667 COURT SECURITY 59,612 89,223COURT SECURITY OFFICER 74,417 COURT SECURITY 51,145 73,546COURT SECURITY OFFICER 62,346 OFFICE MANAGER-FIRE 46,277 69,992OFFICE MANAGER - FIRE 58,135 OFFICE MANAGER-POLICE 45,061 68,696OFFICE MANAGER - POLICE 56,879 7/3/2025 10:38:02 AM 59 Page 106 of 118 Min Mid Max Proposed Pay Plan: UNIFIED Grade City of Beaufort SC Class Comparison List By Pay Plan Proposed Class Title Original Title Annual Range Working Title $52,312 $81,021107 $66,667 PLANNER 43,790 65,343PLANNER I 54,566 $54,928 $85,072108 $70,000 ACCOUNTING CLERK 51,090 75,583ACCOUNTING CLERK II 63,336 DEPUTY CLERK OF COURT 51,090 75,583DEPUTY CLERK OF COURT 63,336 $57,674 $89,326109 $73,500 GENERAL SUPPORT - SUPERVISOR 52,255 81,111GENERAL SUPPORT SUPERVISOR 66,683 OFFICE MANAGER - PUBLIC WORKS 43,595 64,893OFFICE MANAGER - PUBLIC WORKS 54,244 SUPERVISOR - PARKS 52,255 81,111PARKS SUPERVISOR 66,683 RESIDENTIAL INSPECTOR 51,090 75,583RESIDENTIAL INSPECTOR 63,336 PATROLMAN III/SRO 45,061 68,696SCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICER I 56,879 STORMWATER SUPERVISOR 52,255 81,111STORMWATER SUPERVISOR 66,683 $60,558 $93,792110 $77,175 CAPITAL PROJECTS SUPPORT COORDINATOR 51,090 75,583CAPITAL PROJECTS SUPPORT COORDINATOR 63,336 DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COORDINATOR 51,090 75,583DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COORDINATOR 63,336 HUMAN RESOURCES SPECIALIST 38,916 57,587HUMAN RESOURCES SPECIALIST 48,251 PATROLMAN II - SRO 54,167 81,021SCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICER II 67,594 VICTIMS ADVOCATE/SERVICES COORDINATOR 54,167 81,021VICTIMS ADVOCATE/SERVICES COORDINATOR 67,594 $63,586 $98,482111 $81,034 COMMUNITY AFFAIRS & STANDARDS SPECIALIST 39,042 59,322ACCREDITATION MANAGER 49,182 DOWNTOWN MANAGER 51,090 75,583DOWNTOWN MANAGER 63,336 FACILITIES MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR 52,255 81,111FACILITIES MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR 66,683 PATROLMAN III/SRO 77,225 118,946SCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICER III 98,085 $66,765 $103,406112 $85,085 OPERATIONS MANAGER 62,694 94,630OPERATIONS MANAGER 78,662 $70,103 $108,576113 $89,340 CODES ENFORCEMENT MANAGER 63,264 93,580CODES ENFORCEMENT MANAGER 78,422 SRO SERGEANT 61,930 91,061SCHOOL RESOURCE SERGEANT 76,496 7/3/2025 10:38:02 AM 60 Page 107 of 118 Min Mid Max Proposed Pay Plan: UNIFIED Grade City of Beaufort SC Class Comparison List By Pay Plan Proposed Class Title Original Title Annual Range Working Title $77,289 $119,705115 $98,497 TRAINING SERGEANT 63,165 97,334POLICE SERGEANT - TRAINING 80,250 $81,153 $125,690116 $103,422 CITY CLERK 63,264 93,580CITY CLERK 78,422 PLANNER III 63,264 93,580PLANNER III 78,422 MASTER SERGEANT 68,139 97,634POLICE MASTER SERGEANT 82,886 PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER 63,264 93,580PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER 78,422 $85,211 $131,975117 $108,593 INVESTIGATIONS LIEUTENANT 71,534 110,312INVESTIGATIONS LIEUTENANT 90,923 LIEUTENANT 71,534 110,312POLICE LIEUTENANT 90,923 PATROL LIEUTENANT 71,534 110,312POLICE LIEUTENANT 90,923 $89,472 $138,574118 $114,023 COURT ADMINISTRATOR 63,264 93,580COURT ADMINISTRATOR 78,422 FINANCIAL SYSTEMS SPECIALIST/PROCUREMENT ADMINISTRATOR 63,264 93,580FINANCIAL SYSTEMS SPECIALIST/PROCUREMENT ADMINISTRATOR 78,422 MEDICAL TRAINING OFFICER 77,497 113,547MEDICAL TRAINING OFFICER 95,522 SENIOR ACCOUNTANT 63,264 93,580SENIOR ACCOUNTANT 78,422 $93,945 $145,502119 $119,724 BUILDING OFFICIAL 75,560 111,404BUILDING OFFICIAL 93,482 CAPTAIN - TRAINING 77,497 113,547FIRE CAPTAIN - TRAINING 95,522 DEPUTY FIRE CHIEF - FIRE MARSHAL 81,297 124,044FIRE MARSHAL 102,671 CAPTAIN 77,225 118,946POLICE CAPTAIN 98,085 $103,575 $160,416121 $131,995 DEPUTY FIRE CHIEF - ADMINISTRATION 81,297 124,044DEPUTY FIRE CHIEF - ADMINISTRATION 102,671 DEPUTY FIRE CHIEF - OPERATIONS 81,297 124,044DEPUTY FIRE CHIEF - OPERATIONS 102,671 DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROJECTS 95,379 135,960DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROJECTS 115,669 PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR 95,379 135,960PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR 115,669 $108,753 $168,437122 $138,595 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR 95,379 135,960COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR 115,669 HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR 95,379 135,960HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR 115,669 $114,191 $176,859123 $145,525 7/3/2025 10:38:02 AM 61 Page 108 of 118 Min Mid Max Proposed Pay Plan: UNIFIED Grade City of Beaufort SC Class Comparison List By Pay Plan Proposed Class Title Original Title Annual Range Working Title $114,191 $176,859123 $145,525 DIRECTOR OF DOWNTOWN OPERATION 95,379 135,960DIRECTOR OF DOWNTOWN OPERATIONS 115,669 FINANCE DIRECTOR 95,379 135,960FINANCE DIRECTOR 115,669 $119,900 $185,702124 $152,801 FIRE CHIEF 95,379 135,960FIRE CHIEF 115,669 POLICE CHIEF 95,379 135,960POLICE CHIEF 115,669 $153,027 $237,008129 $195,017 DEPUTY CITY MANAGER 102,173 151,204DEPUTY CITY MANAGER 126,688 $177,148 $274,366132 $225,757 CITY MANAGER 124,915 185,400CITY MANAGER 155,157 7/3/2025 10:38:02 AM 62 Page 109 of 118 SECTION 11.0 Implementation Cost Summary Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 63 Page 110 of 118 City of Beaufort SC Implementation Report DRAFT Summary for City of Beaufort SC Current Payroll $11,856,067 # Positions 183 # Not Adj 1Flat 3.5% Adjustment $411,637 # Positions Adjusted (any type) 182 Adjustment To Minimum $326,190 # Adjusted To Minimum 77 Adjustment Toward Mid $0 # Adjusted Toward Mid# Adjusted Toward Mid Pt 0 Adjustment For Compression $188,305 # Adjusted For Compression 71 Adjustment To Step $0 # Adjusted To Step 0 OrgExp Adjustment $0 # OrgExp Adjustments 0 Stipends / Supplements $0 # Assignment 0 Total Applied Adjustments $926,132 % Change in Total Payroll 7.81%Proposed Payroll $12,782,199 FICA Rate: 0 Proposed Payroll plus FICA $12,782,199 Wednesday, July 23, 2025 Pg 1 of 1Report# 1DRAFT 64 Page 111 of 118 SECTION 12.0 Staffing & Workforce Assessment Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 65 Page 112 of 118 Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 12-1 12.0 – Staffing and Workforce Assessment The City has sought consulting assistance to conduct a review of current workforce levels to determine if the current number of staff (FTE’s) meets organizational needs. Based on the review, MAG was requested to provide recommendations for the addition or elimination of FTE’s. This portion of the project supplements the primary scope of work which has focused on the compensation study. MAG conducted formal interviews with the City management team and department heads, using a prescribed format to discuss service delivery, staffing levels, and any unmet needs. The most significant major finding in terms of organizational structure was that the span of control for the City Manager is within the range (5-9 direct reports to the City Manager) found in other municipalities MAG has studied in recent years. Current Organization Structure The current organizational structure provided by the City indicates nine (9) direct reports to the City Manager position. They include: • Deputy City Manager • Downtown Operations Director • City Clerk • Police Chief • Fire Chief • Finance Director • Human Resources Director • Public Works Director • Community Development Director The current organizational structure, span of control, and reporting relationships to the City Manager are not recommended for change. The City has developed and monitored Strategic Plans since 2019, in which priorities are discussed, resulting in “key focus areas”. This is an excellent practice that should be continued, as it provides guidance to departments and assigns responsibility to the appropriate department. There are 43 Initiatives in the current Strategic Plan. The City is at the forefront of best practices in this area and should be commended. Overall Number of Full-Time Equivalent (FTE) Positions City budget documents indicate that there are a total of 192 FTE’s across all departments and funds. Most departments have remained stable (at the same level) the last few years. A few School Resource Officers and an IT position were added in FY 2024. Also, a Director of Public Projects position (three-year temporary FTE funded by ARPA) was added in FY 2025, due to the increase in the number of capital projects. The IT position was eliminated in FY 2025. Overall, the number of FTE’s is 192, including the five (5) positions for City Council. Most positions are in the Police and Fire departments. 66 Page 113 of 118 12.0 City Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 12-2 Departmental Comments and Recommendations Office of the City Manager This office has five (5) FTE’s, including the City Manager, Deputy City Manager, Director of Public Projects, City Clerk, and Public Information Officer. The areas of need appear to be in Public Information and records management for the City Clerk. In the next budget cycle, the City should consider adding the following position: • Media Specialist to support the Public Information Officer Within a 2-3 year timeframe, the City should consider adding: • Records/Data Management Specialist to support the City Clerk Within five (5) years, the City should consider an Emergency/Risk Manager position. No other positions are suggested for the Office of the City Manager. Downtown Operations Department This department is a standalone department that reports directly to the City Manager. There are currently three (3) FTE positions, including the Director of Downtown Operations, Downtown Manager, and Events & Tour Coordinator. As the number of events being held by more organizations and with new pavilions in the City for private events, the City should consider: In the next budget cycle, the City should consider adding the following position: • Administrative Assistant Within a 2-3 year timeframe, the City should consider adding: • A Laborer position. Within five (5) years, the City should consider an additional Tour Coordinator position, depending on demands in the community. No other positions are suggested. 67 Page 114 of 118 12.0 City Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 12-3 Municipal Court Administration This department indicates four (4) FTE’s, with one (1) being vacant. Positions include the Court Administrator, a Deputy Clerk of Court (vacant), and two (2) Court Clerk II positions. Within two (2) years, the City should consider the addition of one (1) Court Clerk II position, and promotion of one of the Court Clerk II incumbents to a Court Clerk III level (as a lead position). Human Resources Department This department reports directly to the City Manager. There are currently three (3) positions in Human Resources. This level of staffing is normal for a city with an employment level similar to Beaufort . Human Resources should be tasked with overseeing the implementation of the classification and compensation study. If a Risk Management function and position is ultimately established in the City, it would be appropriate to locate in Human Resources. No other staffing recommendations are provided. Finance Department This department reports directly to the City Manager. There are seven (7) FTE’s, including the Finance Director, Financial Systems Specialist, Senior Accountant, Accounting Clerk, Accounting Clerk III, Business License Administrator, and Business License Inspector. Within the next budget cycle, the City should consider a position to focus on risk management. This type of position is often assigned to Human Resources or Finance. Internal discussion should determine the most appropriate and efficient placement. 68 Page 115 of 118 12.0 City Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 12-4 Community Development Department This department is currently a standalone department reporting directly to the City Manager. Demands on the department have remained fairly stable in the last several years, and the staffing level has remained the same. The work is not entry level due to its complexity and public interactions, and support for boards and commissions. No additional positions are recommended. If the economy and resulting development are slowed, consideration should be given to reducing the workforce in this area, including Building Inspectors, Planners, and clerical support. If development continues, no reductions are recommended. Public Works Department Current functions in Public Works include solid waste, streets and traffic, facilities maintenance, parks maintenance, and administration. Staffing levels have remained stable over the last several years. The department reports that there are 25 FTE’s, including three (3) vacant positions. Over the next five (5) years, the department anticipates greater responsibility for stormwater infrastructure needs, parks development, expected new equipment and facilities, and more in-house tree work, lighting, and traffic signal work. If current contracted work is brought in-house to be done by Public Works, the City should anticipate requests for additional staffing. Positions could include Parks Associates (3) and Stormwater Associates (2). Any additional FTE’s would be a function of the change in contracted work. Otherwise, staffing levels are appropriate for the work required. 69 Page 116 of 118 12.0 City Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 12-5 Fire Department Similar to many other municipalities, the Fire Department has had challenges hiring and retaining certified Firefighters and Paramedics. MAG’s compensation recommendations should be helpful on this issue. The City is fortunate that there has been limited turnover in the Fire Department, even as the number of annual calls has increased in recent years (doubled since 2017). The Fire Department is unique in that it also has responsibility for the Town of Port Royal. The staffing levels in the department appear to be sufficient, with the number of stations (4) and shifts to be covered. Future considerations should include a Fire Inspector. No other staffing recommendations are made at this time. Within five (5) years, an outside review should be considered to determine whether a stand-alone ladder company is needed, and whether stations are needed in Burton and Lady’s Island. That would imply 12-15 new positions for each new station, if it is determined to be necessary. Further, within a few years, an outside review should be completed to determine if savings might be possible from some form of consolidation with County EMS. 70 Page 117 of 118 12.0 City Beaufort, SC Management Advisory Group International, Inc. ©2025 12-6 Police Department Overall demands on the department have increased. There have been an increasing number of community events, increasing demand of responsiveness to requests (speeding/complaints), increases in mental health issues, and increases in homeless crises. As with many other municipalities, all of the increases for time and attention have placed a strain on officers for limited resources available. The department reports 60 full-time positions and six (6) part-time positions. There are 2.5 vacant Officer positions. Staffing levels for Police Departments are typically a function of: • Trends in calls for service (CFS) over the past five (5) years • Review of self-initiated events, current workload, types of CFS • Risks and hazards within the community that need to be considered • Population and growth trends • Methods of deployment and assignment • Impact of external laws and regulations • Overtime and lost time (sick, comp leave, vacation data) • Consideration of alternative shift schedules on staffing levels • Response time data • Community expectations for service levels There are now 55 sworn positions, and the Department forecasts a need for 70 sworn positions in five (5) years. No changes are recommended at this time. However, growth and service demands and the criteria above should be monitored continuously. 71 Page 118 of 118

Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Nov 1, 2026.