RecordWell Data

Historic District Review Board — Agenda Packet

City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · Historic District Review Board · meeting of Aug 13, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Beaufort

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Please click the link below to access the webinar: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/88907423606?pwd=mWUgZIZJZLD4bIOFTcMz6UBTQTOADv.1 Password: 588094 Meeting ID: 889 0742 3606 Call in Phone #: 1+929 205 6099 City of Beaufort 1911 Boundary Street Beaufort Municipal Complex Beaufort, South Carolina 29902 (843) 525-7070 Historic District Review Board Regular Meeting Agenda August 13, 2025 Statement of Media Notification "In accordance with South Carolina Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, all local media was duly notified of the time, date, place and agenda of this meeting." Regular Meeting - Council Chambers, 2nd Floor - 2:00 PM Please note, this meeting will be broadcast via zoom and live-streamed on Facebook. You can view the meeting at the City's page; City Beaufort SC I. Call to Order II. Minutes A. May 14, 2025 Meeting Minutes B. June 11, 2025 Meeting Minutes C. July 9, 2025 Meeting Minutes III. Applications A. 404 Scott Street, PIN R120 004 000 0809 0000, addition Applicant: Thomas Rhodes, Architect IV. Discussion V. Adjourn Page 1 of 39 1 Historic District Review Board Meeting Minutes – May 14, 2025 CALL TO ORDER 0:02 A meeting of the Historic District Review Board was held in-person on Wednesday, May 14 at 2:00 pm. ATTENDEES Members in attendance: Eric Berman, (Vice-Chair), Rita Wilson, and Kim Petrella Member absent: Mike Sutton (Chair) and Grady Woods. Staff in attendance: Curt Freese, Community Development Director, Christopher Klement, Community Development Planner, III, Nick Navia, Community Development Planner, I, Meadors Architects, and Julie A. Bachety, Community Development Administrative Assistant II. REVIEW OF MINUTES OF APRIL 9, 2025 0:05 Mr. Berman commented that on page 2 under the motion the second bullet 9’1”2 should be corrected to either state 9 ½ feet or 9’ 6”. He also noted on page 2 under the motion the third bullet, conquer should be corrected to “concur”. Motion: Ms. Wilson made a motion to approve the April 9, 2025 minutes with the changes as noted. Ms. Petrella seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. All Historic District Review Board Meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s website at http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter. APPLICATIONS 1:14 A. 1203 Bay Street (The Cuthbert House), PIN R120 004 000 771A 0000, awning replacement Applicant: Chris Ramm, Owner The applicant is requesting approval for replacement of a green canvas awning at the rear of The Cuthbert House with a standing seam metal shed roof. Christopher Klement presented the staff report. Page 2 of 39 2 Public Comment: Wallace Scarborough, 1207 Bay Street thanked the Board and said what they are doing is important and keeping the historic integrity of these homes is vitally important to the economy of Beaufort and that is why tourists come here. Mr. Scarborough is in favor of the project. Lise Sundrla, Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF), stated HBF is in support of the project. Public comment closed. Motion: Ms. Petrella made a motion to approve alternative #2 – Shed-roof awning, option 1 as presented by staff. Ms. Wilson seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. B. 1107 Prince Street, PIN R120 004 000 0503 0000, alterations, additions 17:13 Applicant: Benjie Morillo, Architect The applicant is requesting approval to partially demolish some walls within the existing structure, as to add-on to the existing house, including changes to front, side/rear porches and terrace. Nick Navia presented the staff report. Public Comment: Lise Sundrla, Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF), said HBF is in favor of the project. Ms. Sundrla commented that the building was mis-aged when it was surveyed and portions of it are actually the 1940’s. Ms. Sundrla suggested keeping the character defining features. Daniel Blackman, 1010 Duke Street said he is in favor of the project for renovations of the house. He wanted clarification that this application does not include the ADU or the other addition because the plans show them as “future addition” don’t show it this way. He is concerned about the vertical board and batten versus horizontal; it’s very unusual in the Northwest Quadrant (NWQ) and not consistent with the NWQ. Public comment closed. Motion: Ms. Petrella made a motion to preliminarily approve the application with staff’s recommendations and to add the additional condition that the applicant restudy the siding, the windows, consider a gable return for the front addition and that their submission explicitly excludes the future addition and future ADU. Ms. Wilson seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. ADJOURNMENT 50:38 Ms. Wilson made a motion seconded by Ms. Petrella to adjourn. The meeting ended at 2:51 pm. Page 3 of 39 1 Historic District Review Board Meeting Minutes – June 11, 2025 CALL TO ORDER 0:52 A meeting of the Historic District Review Board was held in-person on Wednesday, June 11, 2025 at 2:00 pm. ATTENDEES Members in attendance: Mike Sutton (Chair), Rita Wilson, Kim Petrella, and Grady Woods (via Zoom) Member absent: Eric Berman, (Vice-Chair), Staff in attendance: Curt Freese, Community Development Director, Christopher Klement, Community Development Planner III, Nick Navia, Community Development Planner, I, Meadors Architects, and Julie A. Bachety, Community Development Administrative Assistant II. REVIEW OF MINUTES OF MAY 14, 2025 0:59 Chairman Sutton stated the minutes of the May 14, 2025 meeting today will be placed on the Board’s next meeting for review since there is not a full board. All Historic District Review Board Meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s website at http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter. APPLICATIONS 1:24 A. Permit Extension: 1114 Congress Street: Request for a one-year COA extension for the COA. Applicant: Cherimie Crane Weatherford, Executive Director, Freeman’s Arts District The applicant is requesting approval for a one-year COA extension for the COA. Curt Frreese stated the applicant is requesting a one-year extension for their COA. Mr. Freese referred to Section 9.1 that states, COAs are given two years and then the COA can be renewed for one year periods five times, but it has to come before the Historic District Review Board (HDRB) to be approved. The applicant has not started on the project, but it was approved two years ago, and staff sees no reason why it cannot be renewed. Public Comment: Page 4 of 39 2 None. Public comment closed. Motion: Ms. Petrella made a motion to approve the extension as requested. Ms. Wilson seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. B. 314 Charles Street, PIN R120 004 000 849B 0000, alterations 3:50 Applicant: Scott Haupt and Marilyn Marino, owners Grady Woods recused himself from this project. The applicants are requesting approval to install two (2) storm doors – 1 on the front and 1 on the rear door of their home. Nick Navia presented the staff report. Public Comment: Lise Sundrla, Director of Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF), agrees with staff’s recommendation. This is an important structure. Ms. Sundrla referred to the Preservation Manual. She provided the applicant a recommendation for whoever to go to look for wooden storm doors that was recommended by Jeremy Tate, Staff Architect. Keeping it as wood will go a long way with showing best practices for what to do with historic structures. Ms. Sundrla stated that we don’t look at a mistake that was made previously and use that as a precedent to go forward. Public comment closed. Motion: Ms. Petrella made a motion to approve the aluminum example as presented today. Ms. Wilson seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. C. 914 Newcastle Street, PIN R120 004 000 0279 0000, new construction 18:02 Applicant: Megan Chancellor Crumrine, Architect Mr. Woods returned to the Board now. The Applicant is requesting approval for construction of a new single-family residence. Christopher Klement presented the staff report. Public Comment: Lise Sundrla, Director of Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF), said HBF is very pleased with the changes that were made to minimize the height and scale of the building. Public comment closed. Motion: Mr. Woods made a motion to grant final approval with staff looking at the chimney cap if there are any alterations. Ms. Petrella seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Page 5 of 39 3 Mr. Freese said that the HRB/Planning Commission Subcommittee has been 42:40 meeting, and they are making some good progress. Mr. Freese asked the board members if they want to do a Fall Tour possibly in October. He also asked if the board members would be interested in future training. ADJOURNMENT 45:46 Ms. Petrella made a motion seconded by Ms. Wilson to adjourn. The meeting ended at 2:45 pm. Page 6 of 39 1 Historic District Review Board Meeting Minutes – July 9, 2025 CALL TO ORDER 1:18 A meeting of the Historic District Review Board was held in-person on Wednesday, July 9, 2025 at 2:00 pm. ATTENDEES Members in attendance: Mike Sutton (Chair), Eric Berman, (Vice-Chair), and Grady Woods. Member absent: Rita Wilson and Kim Petrella. Staff in attendance: Curt Freese, Community Development Director, Christopher Klement, Community Development Planner III, Meadors Architects, and Julie A. Bachety, Community Development Administrative Assistant II. REVIEW OF MINUTES OF MAY 14, 2025 1:30 Chairman Sutton stated the minutes of the May 14, 2025 meeting will be deferred to the Board’s next meeting due to the lack of board members. All Historic District Review Board Meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s website at http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter. REVIEW OF MINUTES OF JUNE 11, 2025 1:31 Chairman Sutton stated the minutes of the June 11, 2025 meeting will be deferred to the Board’s next meeting due to the lack of board members. All Historic District Review Board Meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s website at http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter. APPLICATIONS 1:55 A. 1405 Duke Street, PIN R120 004 000 0345 0000, addition Applicant: Martin W. Nash, homeowner The applicant is requesting approval to build a screened-in detached adobe (200 sq. ft.) on an existing platform at the rear of the existing house. Page 7 of 39 2 Curt Freese said regarding this project, when the packages went out on Thursday before the Fourth of July holiday, it was discovered by Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF) that they hold an easement on this property and that easement requires the applicant to obtain approval for any major changes and HBF has not made that approval. Mr. Freese recommends the Board defer the project. The applicant was present, but then left. Public Comment: Lise Sundrla, Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF) Director, said the project actually started with the applicant submitting an incomplete application. Then additional documents were submitted by the applicant yesterday and our Committee did not have time to review them. Public comment closed. Motion: Mr. Berman made a motion to defer the 1405 Duke Street project, and the Board will have some discussion about this at the end of the meeting. Mr. Woods seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. B. 605 Carteret Street, PIN R120 004 000 0637 0000, alterations 7:48 Applicant: Zach and Rihanna Graber, homeowners The applicants are requesting approval for minor exterior changes, including a new front door, shutters, exterior paint color change and installation of gutters around the roof. Christopher Klement presented the staff report. Public Comment: Lise Sundrla, Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF) Director, said HBF is in support of staff’s comments. However, it would be more in keeping with the style of the house not to choose the white paint color with the black surrounds around the windows. The building was built ca. 1880 in a similar style and form as to our Rainbow Row by George Holmes on Craven Street and during the Vernacular Period of our Victorian style with more of a pastel coloring. Public comment closed. Motion: Mr. Berman made a motion to approve with staff recommendations with the addition that the two vertical panel door was recommended and we’re approving it as it is presented but if the applicant decides to change exterior paint colors to a pastel palette that it can be approved at the staff level. Mr. Woods seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. C. 807 Scott Street, PIN R120 004 000 0425 0000, exterior renovations 23:20 Applicant: Mirjam Kauffman for Stuart Feldman The Applicant is requesting approval on various interior and exterior renovations/alterations, including changing location of existing door/window at rear elevation, placement of new windows, exterior paint color change as well as screened-in porch enclosure. Christopher Klement presented the staff report. Page 8 of 39 3 Public Comment: Lise Sundrla, Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF) Director, said HBF is supportive with staff’s comments with the same caveat with the color of the house and is ca. 1885. It does have an extinctive bay window on it. Ms. Sundrla suggested the applicant go in the direction of the pastel colors for the base, HBF feels it would be more appropriate than the white, but a secondary opportunity is to do the white base and then highlight the trim with a pastel. Public comment closed. Motion: Mr. Berman made a motion to approve with staff recommendations. Mr. Woods seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. D i s c u s s i o n 1:03:12 The Board discussed conservation easements and the process. If there is a property with a conservation easement, how do we know before it’s too late, the Board asked. Mr. Berman stated it should be filed with the Register of Deeds. Ms. Sundrla said typically she will know before meeting with the client. Chairman Sutton suggested Ms. Sundrla give the Board an informal training on Easements. Mr. Freese suggested making this topic part of the Fall tour/session. ADJOURNMENT 1:11:27 Mr. Woods made a motion seconded by Mr. Berman to adjourn. The meeting ended at 3:10 pm. Page 9 of 39 City of Beaufort Department Request for Historic District Review Board Agenda Item To: Historic District Review Board Date: 08/06/2025 From: Nicolas Navia, Community Development Planner I Item Name: 404 Scott Street, PIN R120 004 000 0809 0000, addition Applicant: Thomas Rhodes, Architect Meeting Date: August 13, 2025 Department: Community Development Department Background Information: Introduction: The applicant is requesting approval for an addition of a covered porch, with a brick walkway leading out to the sidewalk, new shutters, new siding, and new living fence. Existing windows and shingle roof to remain; porch roof to be a standing seam metal roof that will tie into existing shingle roof. Background: The applicant is requesting approval for a covered porch (182 sqft) located at the front of the existing ca. 1960 1-story structure. The project consists of the covered porch with a green standing seam metal roof, a new brick walkway leading to the sidewalk, new shutters, new siding, and a new living fence. The existing wood windows and asphalt shingle roof are to remain. The porch’s standing seam metal roof is to tie into the existing shingle roof. The applicant has been to one (1) HTRC Meeting on July 2nd, 2025. Legal Authority: S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-310 et seq. Comprehensive Planning Enabling Act Staff Recommendation: Staff is supportive of the overall project, in that it satisfies the intent of the Beaufort Preservation Manual. However, following aspects should be clarified before considering FINAL APPROVAL: 1. Staff recommends selecting a different color for the standing seam metal roof. Staff has concerns that the “Patina Green” color selected by the applicant will appear too different in color next to the existing dark gray asphalt shingle roof, even though it Page 10 of 39 is a low-slope roof. Staff recommends selecting a gray color to match the existing roof. Staff is supportive of the siding/trim/window color, shutter color, and porch ceiling color. 2. Applicant is proposing fiberglass shutters. Staff may be supportive of fiberglass shutters since this structure is non-contributing, but requests a sample or mockup of a shutter to better understand the appearance of the shutter. 3. The proposed shutters at the ganged window on the front (east) façade do not appear to be wide enough to cover the width of the windows. Staff recommends using bi-fold shutters at these windows with a longer shutter dog to accommodate both panels. 4. Staff recommends reducing the depth of the eave at the front of the porch from 2’- 0” to 1’-6” or shorter to better match the eave depths on the existing structure. Placed on Agenda For: Action Attachments: 1. Combined File 2. HRB Staff Report_404 Scott Street Page 11 of 39 CITY OF BEAUFORT UTH CAROLI HISTORIC REVIEW APPLICATION MAJOR REVIEW (HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD) Community Development Department 1911 Boundary Street, Beaufort, South Carolina, 29902 p. (843) 525-7011 / f. (843) 986-5606 Email: development@cityofbeaufort.org / Website: www.cityofbeaufort.org Application Fee: see attached schedule OFFICE USE ONLY: Date Filed: *Non-Cont 81-25 Application #: 39157 Zoning District: T4-N HAS PROJECT ATTENDED HTRC MEETING? (REQUIRED)☑YES ☐NO IS PROJECT A CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE? Ο OR NON-CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE: ✓ FOR A LIST OF CONTRIBUTING OR NON-CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURES, PLEASE SEE: https://cityofbeaufort.org/350/Beaufort-County-Historic-Sites-Survey APPLICABILITY FOR HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD: Major discretionary review board (HDRB) approval shall apply to applications for Certification of Appropriateness per Section 9.10.2 for the following requests (please check all that apply): ☐New building(s) in Historic District ☐Changes to exterior materials of Contributing Structures ☐ Additions to Contributing Structures Non-similar roof replacement on Contributing Structures (roof with different materials) ☐Window replacements on Contributing Structures ☑Major changes to a Contributing or Non-contributing Site Demolition ☐Other changes to exterior of Contributing Structures SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: All forms and information shall be submitted digitally + 5 hard copies of all documents. In addition to a complete application form, applicants shall submit the required items according to the checklists on the subsequent page. Pursuant to Section 6-29-1145 of the South Carolina Code of Laws, is this tract or parcel restricted by any recorded covenant that is contrary to, conflicts with,or prohibits the activity described in this application? Yes ☑ No APPLICANT, PROPERTY, AND PROJECT INFORMATION: APPLICANT NAME: Thomas Rhodes, AIA APPLICANT ADDRESS: 38 Meridian Road, Beaufort, SC 29907 APPLICANT E-MAIL: tom@f-farchitects.com APPLICANT PHONE NUMBER. (843) 522-8422 APPLICANT TITLE: ☐ Homeowner Tenant ☑Architect Engineer Developer Page 12 of 39 ITY OF BEAUFOR OUTH CAROLI HISTORIC REVIEW APPLICATION MAJOR REVIEW (HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD) Community Development Department 1911 Boundary Street, Beaufort, South Carolina, 29902 p. (843) 525-7011 / f. (843) 986-5606 Email: development@cityofbeaufort.org / Website: www.cityofbeaufort.org Application Fee: see attached schedule Hannah Fulton OWNER (IF OTHER THAN THE APPLICANT): 404 Scott Street, Beaufort, SC 29902 OWNER ADDRESS: PROPERTY ADDRESS:. same PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION NUMBER (TAXMAP PARCEL NUMBER): R120 004 000 0809 0000 PROVIDE A BRIEF PROJECT NARRATIVE: (Attach any necessary documentation, spec sheets, pictures, paint swatches, etc.): Addition of covered porch, brick walk to sidewalk New shutters, new siding, new living fence Existing shingle roof to remain, new roof over porch to be standing seam metal CERTIFICATION OF CORRECTNESS: I/we certify that the information in this application is correct. Thomas Rhodes APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE: OWNER'S SIGNATURE: Hannah Fulton (The owner's signature is required if the applicant is not the owner.) DATE: 8/1/25 DATE: 8/1/25 SCHEDULE: The Historic Review Board (HRB) typically meets the 2nd Wednesday of each month at 2pm. Staff will schedule HRB meeting after HTRC and review of application submittal for completeness and compliance with the Beaufort Preservation Manual and the City of Beaufort Development Code. CONTACT INFORMATION: City of Beaufort Community Development Department 1911 Boundary Street, Beaufort, South Carolina 29902 E-Mail: development@cityofbeaufort.org Phone: (843) 525-7011 Fax: (843) 986-5606 Page 13 of 39 Page 14 of 39 Page 15 of 39 Page 16 of 39 Page 17 of 39 Page 18 of 39 Page 19 of 39 Page 20 of 39 Siding and Trim Color SW 7008 Alabaster Shutter and Accent Color SW 6192 Coastal Plain Porch Ceiling CSP-545 Sheer Bliss Porch and Walk Brick = Cherokee Brick Dover Bluff - Georgia Classic Collection Standing Seam Metal Roof = Patina Green (Sentriclad Architectural Metals - 4M) Finish Selections Roof = 4M Metal Standing Seam Roof w/ 1" Rib Height Siding = 7-1/4" Hardie Plank Siding W/ 6" Exposure (Smooth Face) Trim = TruExterior Trim (Smooth Finish) Columns = 8x8 Hollow KDAT SYP Columns Brick Paver = Cherokee Brick Thin Brick with Corner Shape at all Corners Entry Door = Stained Stile and Rail Wood Door Windows = Existing Windows to Remain - Apply new Sealant and Paint Underside of Roof Deck = 1x6 Sq. Edge KDAT SYP T&G Shutters = Atlantic Premium Shutters (Operable, Smooth Finish) Material Selections PROPERTY ID (PIN): R120 004 000 0809 0000 SITE INFORMATION TOTAL LOT SIZE................................1,501 S.F. ZONING AND FLOOD INFORMATION ZONED T4-N NONCONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE FLOOD ZONE = X SHADED EXISTING F.F.E. = 9.33' (1988 NAVD) MAIN HOUSE AREA EXIST. FIRST FLOOR.......................723 S.F. FRONT PORCH.................................182 S.F. 2025 All Rights ReservedC 1 A4.3 1 A4.1 1 A5.1 1 15.75' A 1 1 GYPSUM WALLBOARD (LARGE SCALE) ACOUSTIC TILE CARPET & PAD GYPSUM WALL BOARD (ELEVATION) FLASHING, ETC BRICK (ELEVATION) HORIZONTAL SIDING (ELEVATION) ROOF SHINGLES (ELEVATION) WATERPROOFING, FELT, CONTINUOUS BLOCKING ROUGH LUMBER ROUGH LUMBEREARTH GRAVEL FINISH WOOD INSULATION BATTS RIGID INSULATION PLYWOOD (LARGE SCALE) PLYWOOD (SMALL SCALE) CONCRETE C.M.U. BRICK STEEL DETAIL-NO. SHEET-NO. ENLARGED DETAIL INDICATOR SHEET-NO. DETAIL-NO. SECTION CUT INDICATOR INTERIOR ELEVATION INDICATOR WINDOW MARK DOOR MARK ELEVATION ABOVE MEAN SEA LEVEL DETAIL-NO. SHEET-NO. OR OTHER SPECIFIED DATUM WALL TYPE REVISION NUMBER Refrigerator Roof Drain Radius Riser Room Roof Joist Required Revision Reinforcing Rough Opening Sheet Shelf Schedule Square Foot Square Specification Similar Solid Masonry Pier Stainless Steel Solid Core Wood Telephone Tread Suspended Steel Top of Steel Through Threshold Thick Top of Plate Typical Top of Slab Without Wood With Vertical Unless Otherwise Noted Verify in Field Vinyl Composition Tile Top of Sheathing Standard Quanity R. Floor Foot FL. F.D. GA. FT. F.J. Hose Bib GYP.BD. GALV. H.M. HCWD. H.B. Gauge Hollow Metal Gypsum Board Galvanized Floor Joist Floor Drain Hollow Core Wood Height Lavatory Laminate Kitchen HGT. HORIZ. LAV. LAM. KIT. Masonry Light Maximum LT. MAS. MEMB. MECH. MAX. Membrane Mechanical Horizontal A.F.F. ADJ. ABV. BD. APPROX. ANG. ALT. ALUM. Board Approximate Angle Alternate Aluminum Above Finish Floor Adjacent Above BOT. BSMT. BM. BLKG. L CLO. CLG. C.T. C CAB. Closet Ceiling Ceramic Tile Center Line Cabinet Bottom Basement Beam Blocking BuildingBLDG. T.Minimum MFR. MET. M.O. MISC. MIN. N.I.C. O.D. O.C. N.T.S. Outside Diameter On Center Not To Scale Not In Contract Masonry Opening Miscellaneous Manufacturer Optional Plate Precast OPT. OPNG. PL. P.LAM. P.C. Pair Plywood PR. PLYWD. P.S.I. P.S.F. P.T. Pounds Per Square Inch Pounds Per Square Foot Pressure Treated Plastic Laminate Opening CONC. COL. CMU. C.O. DIA. D.F. DTL. DEPT. CONT. Dimension Diameter Drinking Fountain Detail Department Continuous Concrete Column Concrete Masonry Unit Cased Opening EA. DWG. DS. DN. EQUIP. EQ. EMER. ELEC. EL. E.J. Equipment Equal Emergency Electrical Elevation Expansion Joint Each Drawing Down Spout Down DIM. Metal CentimeterCM. ExteriorEXT. UON. S.M.P. REF. W/O WD. W/ V.I.F. VERT. VCT. TYP. T.O.SL. T.O.SH. T.O.S. T.O.P. THRU. THRES. THK. TEL. SUSP. STL. STD. S.S. SQ. SPEC. SIM. SHT. SH. SCWD. SCHED. R.O. RM. R.J. REQD. REV. REINF. R.D. RAD. QTY. S.F. Weight Welded Wire Fabric P.V.C. Polyvinyl Chloride E.W. EXIST. Each Way Existing WWF WT. WaterproofingPainted WP.PTD. SYMBOLS INDEX OF DRAWINGSSELECTIONSABBREVIATIONS MATERIALS EXTERIOR ELEVATION INDICATOR A5.1 1 SHEET-NO. DETAIL-NO. LOCATOR MAP 3 24 Finished Room Over GarageFROG NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION SITE INFORMATION 8/1/2025 3:08:24 PM A1.0 TITLE SHEET FULTON PORCH HRB REVIEW 404 SCOTT STREET BEAUFORT, SC 8/1/25 FULTON PORCH 404 SCOTT STREET BEAUFORT, SC Sheet Number Sheet Name A1.0 TITLE SHEET A2.0 FLOOR PLAN & PHOTOS A3.0 EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS A4.0 SECTIONS AND DETAILS SURVEY SURVEY Page 21 of 39 A3.05 A3.0 A3.0 A3.0 1 2 4 8 A4.0 New Living Fence with Confederate Jasmine 8' - 4" 21' - 4 1/8"1' - 4 1/2" New Porch (Brick) Existing Walk New Siding and Trim over existing CMU 1' - 4 1/2" Gate New Brick Walk Trash 4' - 3 1/4"6' - 0 7/8"6' - 0 7/8"8' - 7 3/8" Swing 5' - 9 1/4" EXISTING HOUSE SCOTT STREET NEIGHBORING ACCESSORY STRUCTURE NEIGHBORING HOUSE NEW PORCHEXISTING HOUSE NEW PORCHEXISTING HOUSE Property Line New Living Fence with Confederate Jasmine Turf Grass Turf Grass Zone = T4-N 2' - 10 3/4" 2 A4.0 A4.0 4 182 Sq. Ft. 723 Sq. Ft. 8 A4.0 2 A2.0 Sim 2 A2.0 Sim 2 A4.0 Sim 2X4 KDAT SYP Fascia Half-Round Copper Gutter 2x Rafters @ 16" O.C. 1x6 Sq. Edge KDAT SYP T&G - Painted 1' - 0" 2' - 0" 1' - 0" ROOF AS SPECIFIED SHEATHING AS SPECIFIED PEEL AND STICK MEMBRANE AS SPECIFIED ELEC. CONDUCTOR 2X4 (FULL LENGTH OF RAFTER BAY) FASTENED TO RAFTER AND DECK ABOVE (ONLY WHERE REQ. FOR ELEC. FIXTURE) EXPOSED RAFTERT&G DECKING T&G DECKING 2X BLOCKING AS REQ. FOR FIXTURE MOUNTING - POCKET SCREW TO 2X4s 2025 All Rights ReservedC 8/1/2025 3:08:27 PM A2.0 FLOOR PLAN & PHOTOS FULTON PORCH HRB REVIEW 404 SCOTT STREET BEAUFORT, SC 8/1/25 1/4" = 1'-0"3 FIRST FLOOR Existing HouseScott Street and Existing House - Looking North WestScott Street and Existing House - Looking South West N 1/4" = 1'-0"1 FIRST FLOOR CEILING AND ELECTRICAL PLAN Light Fixture Schedule Fixtur e Tag Fixture Type Count Manufacturer Model Comments A WALL SCONCE 1 The CopperSmith Handcrafted Lighting East Bay Collection EB20 B CEILING MOUNTED FIXTURE 1 Lowcountry Originals Carmel "By The Sea" Chandelier Sloped Ceiling C CEILING FAN 1 MinkaAire F786-WHF Sloped Ceiling 1" = 1'-0"2 ELEC. CHASE IN PORCH CEILING Page 22 of 39 New Operable Shutters New Siding New Standing Seam Roof over New Porch (Patina Green) New Copper Gutter Gate New Living Fence with Confederate Jasmine Existing Roof To Remain New Wall Sconce New Entry Door - Ref. 4/A3.0 NEW PORCH EXISTING HOUSE New Operable Shutters New Siding New Living Fence with Confederate Jasmine New Standing Seam Roof over New Porch (Patina Green) Existing Vent New Copper Gutter A4.0 7 2 A4.0 4 A4.0 Existing Roof All Existing Wood Windows to Remain New Operable Shutters New Siding New Living Fence with Confederate Jasmine New Standing Seam Roof over New Porch (Patina Green) Existing Louvered Vent New Copper Gutter 2" 12" NEW PORCHEXISTING HOUSE A3.0 3 Existing Roof All Existing Wood Windows to Remain Siding and Trim Color SW 7008 Alabaster Shutter and Accent Color SW 6192 Coastal Plain Porch Ceiling CSP-545 Sheer Bliss Porch and Walk Brick = Cherokee Brick Dover Bluff - Georgia Classic Collection Standing Seam Metal Roof = Patina Green (Sentriclad Architectural Metals - 4M) Finish Selections FENCE HEIGHT 4'-0" MAX 2x4 Top Rail 3"x3"x1/4" Galv. Washer Spacer 4x4 Fence Post 1/2" x 1/2" Angle Frame (304 S.S.) 3"x3" McNICHOLS® Wire Mesh (304 S.S.) 2x4 Bottom Rail Set post in Concrete MIN. 1' - 4" All Wood for Fence Must be KDAT SYP - Painted Siding Color Insulated Glass Panel Insulated Glass Panel Square Sticking TruExterior Casing Stained Stile and Rail Wood Door 5 1/2" 5 1/2"5 1/2" 9 1/4" 5 1/2" 3 1/2"3 1/2" 5 1/2" 1/A4.0 Sim. 6/A4.0 Sim. MATCH EXIST. MATCH EXIST. 2025 All Rights ReservedC 8/1/2025 3:08:31 PM A3.0 EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS FULTON PORCH HRB REVIEW 404 SCOTT STREET BEAUFORT, SC 8/1/25 1/4" = 1'-0"5 East 1/4" = 1'-0"2 West 1/4" = 1'-0"1 North 1/4" = 1'-0"4 South 1 1/2" = 1'-0"3 FENCE DETAIL 3/4" = 1'-0"8 ENTRY DOOR KDAT Wood Fence - Painted "Alabaster" Existing Architectural Shingle - Gray 4M Standing Seam Roof "Patina Green" Hardie Plank Siding w/ 6" Exposure - Smooth Surface - Painted "Alabaster" TruExterior Trim Painted "Alabaster" KDAT Hollow Columns Painted "Alabaster" Fiberglass Operable Shutters w/ Smooth Finish - Painted "Coastal Plain" Thin Brick Pavers and Foundation Finish Cherokee Brick "Dover Bluff" Stained Sapele Entry Door Page 23 of 39 FIRST FLOOR 0' - 0" 7-1/4" Hardie Plank Siding W/ 6" Exposure (Smooth Face) Thin Brick Set on Mortar Bed A4.0 3 A4.0 5 2 A4.0 4 A4.0 A4.0 6 Sim 16" #5 @ 12" O.C. Turned-Down Concrete Slab KDAT 1x Attachment Strips @ 16" O.C. - Fasten to CMU with Concrete Screws @ 16" O.C. Min. 1" Rigid Insulation (R-5) 2x6 PT Plate - Anchor to CMU w/ (2) 5/8" x 8" Bolt per piece 2x6 Knee Wall 2x8 Rafters @ 16" O.C. 1x6 Sq. Edge T&G (KDAT, SYP, C&Better) Simpson Strong-Tie H2.5A @ ea. Rafter Cont. Blocking Btw. Rafters 1x TruExterior Trim Btw. Rafters All Exposed Hardie and TruExterior Trim and Siding Must have a Smooth Surface 2x10 Sleeper Fastened to ea. Exist. Rafter w/ (3) 16d Nails Standing Seam Roof w/ 1" Rib Height Existing Construction Existing Construction Toe-Nail ea. Rafter to Sleeper w/ (3) 16d Nails 8x8 KDAT Hollow Columns 2' - 0" 6 A4.0 1 A4.0 TruExterior Casing - Painted New Operable Impact Resistant Shutters - Smooth Fiberglass - Painted Existing Wood Windows to Remain - Seal and Paint 7-1/4" Hardie Plank Siding W/ 6" Exposure (Smooth Face) - Painted 5/4" TruExterior Skirt Board - Painted 2 1/2"2 1/2"2 1/2" 2 1/2" 2 1/2" 4" Lag Pintel w/ Flat Hinge - Typ. "S" Holdback - Typ. AZEK AZM75 Bed Moulding 8x8 KDAT Hollow Column TruExterior Trim 1/8" 1 3/4"2 1/8"3/8" 5/8" Galv. Threaded Rod Inside Column Align Align 3"x3"x1/4" Galv. Washer and Nut Wrap Beam W/ TruExterior Trim 7" 7" Built-up Beam Fasten Each Rafter to Beam W/ (2) 6" SDWC Simpson Strong-Tie Screws Half-Round Copper Gutter 2x4 KDAT Fascia-Rabbet as Shown 1x6 Sq. Edge T&G (KDAT, SYP, C&Better) Standing Seam Roof (1" Rib Height) 2x8 KDAT SYP Rafters @ 16" O.C. 3/4" 3 1/2" AZEK AZM93 Scotia TruExterior Trim 1" 7" 1 1/2" 8x8 KDAT Hollow Column Thin Brick set in Mortar Bed Concrete Slab / Foundation 5/8" Galv. Threaded Rod Embedded 8" MIN. in Concrete Thin Brick Corner Shape Along Perimeter Extend Thin Brick to Below Grade AZEK AZM75 Bed Moulding 8x8 KDAT Hollow Column TruExterior Trim 5/8" Galv. Threaded Rod Inside Column 3"x3"x1/4" Galv. Washer and Nut Wrap Beam W/ TruExterior Trim Built-up Beam 2x4 KDAT Fascia - Rabbet as Shown 1x6 Sq. Edge T&G (KDAT, SYP, C&Better) Standing Seam Roof (1" Rib Height) 2x8 KDAT SYP Rafters @ 16" O.C. 1-5/8" x #8 Ext. Screw @ 3" O.C. Staggered 1 1/4" Align 1' - 0" 1 A4.0 Extend Thin Brick to Below Grade AZEK AZM-197 Drip Cap TruExterior 5/4 Casing Existing Wood Windows to Remain - Seal and Paint 7-1/4" Hardie Plank Siding W/ 6" Exposure (Smooth Face) 5/4" TruExterior Skirt Board 4 1/2" 3 3/8" Metal Flashing KDAT 2x4 KDAT 1x4 KDAT 1x Attachment Strips @ 16" O.C. - Fasten to CMU with Concrete Screws @ 16" O.C. Min. 1" Rigid Insulation (R-5) - Tape All Seams 5/4 TruExterior Apron 2x TruExterior Sill Fluid Applied Flashing 6 A4.0 Existing Wood Windows to Remain - Seal and Paint Existing CMU WallExisting CMU Wall 4" 3/4" 3/4" 4" 1" KDAT 2x4 5/4 TruExterior Casing KDAT 1x Attachment Strips @ 16" O.C. - Fasten to CMU with Concrete Screws @ 16" O.C. Min.2x TruExterior Sill Below New Operable Impact Resistant Shutters 1" Rigid Insulation (R-5) - Tape all Seams 7-1/4" Hardie Plank Siding W/ 6" Exposure (Smooth Face) TruExterior Trim Tape all Insulation Seams - Typ. KDAT 1x Attachment Strips @ 16" O.C. - Fasten to CMU with Concrete Screws @ 16" O.C. Min. Existing CMU Wall 7-1/4" Hardie Plank Siding W/ 6" Exposure (Smooth Face) 1" Rigid Insulation (R-5) KDAT 1x Attachment Strips @ 16" O.C. - Fasten to CMU with Concrete Screws @ 16" O.C. Min. Drainage Cavity 3 1/2" 3 1/2" 2025 All Rights ReservedC 8/1/2025 3:08:33 PM A4.0 SECTIONS AND DETAILS FULTON PORCH HRB REVIEW 404 SCOTT STREET BEAUFORT, SC 8/1/25 3/4" = 1'-0"8 SECTION AT PORCH 3/4" = 1'-0"7 WINDOW ELEVATION 1 1/2" = 1'-0"3 EAVE DETAIL 1 1/2" = 1'-0"5 BRICK EDGE AND COLUMN BASE 1 1/2" = 1'-0"2 RAKE DETAIL 1 1/2" = 1'-0"6 WINDOW HEAD AND SILL DETAIL 1 1/2" = 1'-0"1 WINDOW JAMB DETAIL 1 1/2" = 1'-0"4 CORNER BOARD DETAIL Page 24 of 39 Page 25 of 39 9152 Hard Drive Foley Alabama 36536 REV:A/0 LIMITS NOT SPECIFIED FRACTION ± 1/32 - ANGULAR ± 1/2° .0 ± .010 - .00 ± .005 - .000 ± .0025 MATL ASSY REVISION DESCRIPTION DATE:04/18/2024 DRAWING BY:Jason Huang APPD APPD QTY JOB NO. DATE SCALE NAME DRAWING NUMBER SHEET NUMBER THIS DRAWING IS PROPERTY OF THE COPPERSMITH INC. AND IS SUBMITTED IN CONFIDENCE AND SHALL NOT BE REPRODUCED, COPIED NOR DISCLOSED TO OTHERS WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE COPPERSMITH INC. The CopperSmith (BDT) EB-20E Front View Standard back plate 3D Drawing for top spit caps Right View 7-W4*L15 Slotted holes on each side 203 [8"] 241 [9 1/2"] 137.5 [5 3/8"] 85° 114 [4 1/2"]394 [15 1/2"] 145.5 [5 3/4"]362.5 [14 1/4"] 508 [20"] 287.5 [11 3/8"] Bottom post and door size are all 12"or 13mm Brass Arm (14#) CP-1GJ& CB-1GJ Page 26 of 39 Page 27 of 39 Name : Carmel "By The Sea" Chandelier Item Number : LCO-KC-376 Dimensions : 61"L x 36"W x 38"H Canopy : 6" Round Material : Steel Bulb/Wattage : 4/40C Shown In : Aqua Marine Body Finishes : Our light fixture finishes are designed to be as lively and ever-changing as the Lowcountry landscape itself. Providing depth and characters to your custom design, our finishes reflect the unique beauty of the coastal landscape and produces a beautiful, natural patina as they age. Our nature-inspired finishes are truly a living art and not only protect your piece, but create a amore beautiful luster with time. Weight : 99 lbs Description : The Carmel “by the Sea” Chandelier offers soft, elongated arms and timeless form in round or oval styles. Understated and luminous, it's a versatile piece that brings warmth and sophistication to any setting. HEADQUARTERS • 6465 126th Avenue North • Largo, FL 33773 • US 888-743-9232 Page 28 of 39 Item # F786-WHF  Product Family Name: Simple  Category: EXTERIOR FAN  Certification 4009339  UPC Code: 706411058684  Finish: Flat White  Category Type: Ceiling Fan  Patents:   Notes:   Image File Name: F786-WHF.jpg MEASUREMENTS Blade Finish:   Reversible Blades: No  Blade Material: ABS  Slope: Yes  Blade Sweep: 44"  No. of Blades: 3  Blade Pitch: 26 DEGREES  Hanging Weight: 9.26  Downrod 1: 6  Downrod 1 Outside Dia: .75  Downroad 2:   Downrod 2 Outside Dia:   Ceiling to Lowest Point: (Dim A) 12.63  Ceiling to Blade (Dim B) 11.25  Lead Wire: 8"  Motor Size: DC 123x30mm  Low Low/Med. Medium Med/High High RPM: 51        196  Amps: 0.06        0.59  Watts: 3.89        48.06  CFM: 1615.0        5323.0  CFM/Watts: 415.17        110.76  LAMPING No. of Bulbs: 0  Light Type:   Light Kit Optional: Yes  Max Bulb Wattage:   Socket:   Integrated Light Kit: No  Dimmable: No  Ballast:   Rated Life Hours:   Uplight: No  Bulb/LED Included:   Color Temp.:   CRI: Initial Lumens:   Delivered Lumens:   GLASS Description:   Material:   Part No.:   Quantity:   Width:   Height:   Length:   CONTROLS Pull Chain Control: No  Works with Remote Control: Yes  Works with Wall Control: Yes  Reversible: Yes  Included Remote Control: RC400  Included Wall Control:   Smart Control: No  Compatible Remote Control(s):   Compatible Wall Control(s): WC400  Integrated Smart Control:   Compatible Smart Control: BD-1000  SHIPPING Carton Width: 8.63  Carton Height: 9.0  Carton Length: 22.75  Carton Weight: 11.0  Carton Cubic Feet: 1.023  Small Package Shippable: Yes  Master Pack Width:   Master Pack Height:   Master Pack Length:   Master Pack Weight:   Master Cubic Feet:   Multi-Pack: 1  Master Pack: 1  ENERGY STAR® Wet Location ETL Intertek For additional information, please contact Customer Care: 1-800-221-7977 | Product depicted on this spec sheet is protected by United States Federal and/or State laws including US Patent, Trademark and/or Copyright and unfair competition laws. Unauthorized reproduction or use carries severe legal penalties. Rev 08.10.2022 09:01 AM WARNING:Handling this product can expose you to chemicals including lead, which is known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. Wash hands with soap and water after installing, handling, cleaning or otherwise touching this product. For more information go to: www.P65Warnings.ca.gov. Page 29 of 39 4 Designed to be used in non-load-bearing applications, TruExterior Trim is suitable for ground and masonry contact and moisture-prone areas, which makes it ideal for exterior trim applications such as fascia, door trim, soffits, rake boards and a variety of other applications. There is no need to prime ends or field cuts. Plus, it can be painted any color. TruExterior Trim accepts common high-quality, exterior-grade fasteners and can be installed using standard woodworking tools and methods. Trim Page 30 of 39 3 Phenomenal Performance. Remarkable Workability. TruExterior Siding & Trim offers both and a lasting look while eliminating the need for gluing, gapping and other cumbersome and costly installation techniques. *Please see TruExterior Siding & Trim Limited Warranties and Product Data Sheets for proprietary test results, located at TruExterior.com. Always follow local building codes and construction best practices. See the complete Installation Guidelines for TruExterior Siding & Trim at TruExterior.com. APPLICATION ƒ Designed for use in non-structural applications ƒ Suitable for ground and masonry contact ƒ Can be used in moisture-prone areas ƒ Installation is the same regardless of the season TOOLS ƒ Installed using proven woodworking tools and methods ƒ Carbide-tipped blades and bits are recommended for a longer tool life FASTENING ƒ Accepts common high-quality, exterior-grade fasteners that are suitable for the local environment ƒ Can be fastened close to the edge ƒ No need for pre-drilling ƒ No mushrooming DURABILITY ƒ WUI listed ƒ No need to prime ends or field cuts ƒ Resists rot and termite attacks* ƒ No excessive swelling* PAINTING ƒ TruExterior products come pre-primed and do require paint ƒ No need to prime end cuts ƒ Can be painted with any high-grade exterior paint when following the paint manufacturer’s instructions ƒ Dimensionally stable, promoting long-lasting paint adhesions, even with dark colors* ƒ Virtually no moisture cycling, paint last longer than on wood* ƒ Traditional exterior-grade caulks and exterior-grade wood fillers are acceptable for filling nail holes BEAUTY ƒ Tighter gaps, minimal movement—it will move less than PVC and vinyl ƒ True look of cedar, real architectural detail WARRANTY ƒ 20 year limited warranty Pictured: Board-and-Batten Page 31 of 39 5 5/8 Trim Sizes 1X Trim Sizes 5/4 Trim Sizes 2X Trim Sizes Nominal Actual Nominal Actual Nominal Actual Nominal Actual — — — — — — 2 x 2 1-1/2" x 1-1/2" — — 1 x 3 3/4" x 2-1/2" 5/4 x 3 1" x 2-1/2" — — 5/8 x 4 5/8" x 3-1/2" 1 x 4 3/4" x 3-1/2" 5/4 x 4 1" x 3-1/2" 2 x 4 1-1/2" x 3-1/2" — — 1 x 5 3/4" x 4-1/2" 5/4 x 5 1" x 4-1/2" — — 5/8 x 6 5/8" x 5-1/2" 1 x 6 3/4" x 5-1/2" 5/4 x 6 1" x 5-1/2" 2 x 6 1-1/2 x 5-1/2" 5/8 x 8 5/8" x 7-1/4” 1 x 8 3/4" x 7-1/4" 5/4 x 8 1" x 7-1/4" 2 x 8 1-1/2" x 7-1/4" 5/8 x 10 5/8" x 9-1/4" 1 x 10 3/4" x 9-1/4" 5/4 x 10 1" x 9-1/4" 2 x 10 1-1/2" x 9-1/4" 5/8 x 12 5/8” x 11-1/4” 1 x 12 3/4" x 11-1/4" 5/4 x 12 1" x 11-1/4" 2 x 12 1-1/2" x 11-1/4" TruExterior Trim is reversible with woodgrain on one side and a smooth finish on the reverse. Available in a 16' length. Reversible Smooth/Woodgrain Finish BOARD-AND-BATTEN SIDING Whether a Modern Farmhouse design or creating accents on a gable, board-and-batten is one of the hottest trends in home exterior design. And it’s easy to create the board-and-batten look using just TruExterior Trim. TruExterior Trim comes pre-primed and does require paint. Page 32 of 39 Page 33 of 39 Page 34 of 39 STAFF REPORT: Historic District Review Board (HRB) 404 SCOTT STREET DATE: August 13, 2025 GENERAL INFORMATION Applicant: Thomas Rhodes (Architect) Site Address / Tax PIN: 404 Scott Street; R120 004 000 0809 0000 Applicant's Request: Applicant is requesting approval for the following exterior changes: • Addition of a covered porch, with a brick walkway leading out to the sidewalk • New shutters, new siding, new living fence • Existing windows and shingle roof to remain; porch roof to be a standing seam metal roof and tie into existing asphalt shingle roof Current Zoning: T4-NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT (T4-N) Contributing/Neighborhood Noncontributing – Old Commons (ca. 1960) Flood Zone/Base Flood Flood Zone: SX, Elevation: 9’ Existing Trees No Specimen/Landmark trees are affected by this request. ZONING DISTRICT INFORMATION T4-NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT (T4-N) Lot Width at Setback: N/A Minimum Lot Size: N/A Max Lot Coverage: 70% of lot area (This percentage indicates maximum lot coverage by roofs; total impervious coverage may be an additional 10%. Parcels may also be subject to Section 8.3 - Stormwater) Min. Frontage Build Out 60% min; 85% max Front Setback 0 ft -15 ft Side Setback Corner: 0 ft – 10 ft; Interior: 5 ft min., 0 ft if attached Rear Setback 10 ft min; from alley: 0 ft. Building Height: Primary Structures: 4 stories max; 3.5 stories max in & fronting Historic District & interior lots along Allison Rd Accessory Structures: 2 stories / 30 ft max SURROUNDING ZONING, LAND USE AND REQUIRED BUFFERS Adjacent Zoning Adjacent Land Uses Setbacks for Adjacent Zoning /Buffer required if rezoned North: T4-N 406 Scott St (Noncontributing, ca. 1940) N/A South: T4-N 801 Craven St (Noncontributing, ca. 2007) N/A East: T4-N 403 Scott St (Beth Israel Congregation – Synagogue; contributing, ca. 1907) N/A West: T4-N 809 Craven St/402 Scott St (noncontributing, ca. 1975) N/A Page 35 of 39 2 Background: The applicant is requesting approval for a covered porch (182 sqft) located at the front of the existing ca. 1960 1-story structure. The project consists of the covered porch with a green standing seam metal roof, a new brick walkway leading to the sidewalk, new shutters, new siding, and a new living fence. The existing wood windows and asphalt shingle roof are to remain. The porch’s standing seam metal roof is to tie into the existing shingle roof. The applicant has been to one (1) HTRC Meeting on July 2nd, 2025. Project timeline Jan. 2025 Feb. M ar. Apr. May Jun. Jul. Aug. Sep. Oct. Nov. Dec. 7/2: HTRC Meeting 8/1: HRB Application Submittal 8/13: HRB Meeting Applicant has been to the HTRC Meeting on July 2nd, 2025 – Summary of discussion points: 1. Planning and Zoning: o Noncontributing, ca. 1960 o Zoned T4-HN 2. Building Codes: o SX flood zone; 8’-9’ contours o Flood ordinance 50% and 33% rule may apply  33% is based on the footprint increase  50% of the cost of construction vs assessed value 3. Staff Architects (Meadors Architecture): o Staff is supportive of porch addition on structure, with some modi�ications  Staff recommends adding a horizontal beam on the sides of the porch, aligning with the beam across the front of the porch.  Staff recommends adding pilasters aligning behind the porch columns  The roof appears thin – provide accurate detail o Applicant to provide a section through the porch, as well as a typical eave and rake detail. o Applicant to note that the living fence cannot exceed a height of 4’-0”. o Staff is supportive of either keeping the existing painted CMU uncovered, or applying the siding since this is a noncontributing structure. Applicant to clarify what material the siding will be. Please note that vinyl siding is not permitted in the historic district. Cementitious siding must have a smooth �inish. o Provide a detail showing how the new siding will terminate at the skirtboard, as well as the windows and doors (drawings show new casings around windows and doors). o Applicant has noted that the porch �loor will be brick. Applicant to provide a detail of the brick and concrete slab. o Staff is supportive of shutter addition. Applicant to note that shutters must be operable with operable hardware. Faux shutters are not allowed. Shutters cannot be vinyl. Page 36 of 39 3 o Staff recommends the applicant keep the rectangular louvered vent detail (replace in-kind if needed), rather than install a circular vent. Circular vents are not a common detail in the historic district. o Applicant to provide material cutsheets for the following:  Brick  Standing seam roof  Paint colors • Siding • Shutters • Living fence • Columns/porch trim 4. Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF): o Recommend to maintain the CMU siding Tree Removal Proposed: No Specimen/Landmark trees are affected by this request. Surrounding Area: Located in the Old Commons neighborhood, the property lies on the west side of Scott Street facing east, close to the intersection of Scott Street and Craven Street. The property is classified as a noncontributing structure, with the north and south properties also being noncontributing structures, and the Beth Israel Congregation Synagogue (ca. 1907) directly across the street from the property. Determination of adequate historic integrity for New Construction, Infill, Additions and Demolition: As per the Beaufort Preservation Manual (Chapter 5) and the Beaufort Development Code (Section 4.7), the compatibility of new infill construction as well as major renovations within the Beaufort Historic District is determined in consideration with the following principles: 1. Location, 2. Design, 3. Setting, 4. Materials, 5. Workmanship, 6. Feeling and 7. Association. See detailed staff analysis and recommendations in table below. 4.7.2 Integrity Guidelines (as per Beaufort Development Code) Rationale Present Staff Analysis of Rationale 1. Location: This is the relationship between the property and its historical context. YES  404 Scott Street is located within the Old Commons neighborhood of the Historic District. Staff believes the proposal would not impact the relationship between the property and its historical context within the area. Page 37 of 39 4 2. Design: This is the combination of elements that create the feeling of a district or structure. These elements include building patterns, streetscapes, site elements, building size, mass and scale, spatial relationships, and specific architectural elements and details. YES  Front porches are an integral feature in Beaufort. Along with the other design features proposed, staff believes the proposal will not negatively alter the streetscape, nearby site elements, or the spatial relationship with nearby buildings. 3. Setting: This is the physical environment of a property and should be evaluated on its context as well as on the historical role the property has played and continues to play. Important features include topography, vegetation, man-made features, and relationships between existing structures and their surroundings. YES  Staff believes the relationship between the house and the historic setting of the neighborhood are not impacted by the proposal. 4. Materials: These are the physical elements that make up a property or district. YES  Per the preservation manual, the proposed materials are appropriate for the Historic District. While staff would have preferred to leave the CMU uncovered, hardie plank is an acceptable siding material for a noncontributing structure. The standing seam metal roof for the porch is also appropriate. 5. Workmanship: This is the physical evidence of the crafts of a particular culture or time period. This particularly applies to rehabilitation projects, but for new infill projects, workmanship of surrounding structures should be considered and respected. YES  Staff believes the workmanship of the existing house as well as the surrounding structures will not be impacted by the proposal. 6. Feeling: This is the property's expression of the aesthetic or historic sense of a particular period of time. This particularly applies to rehabilitation projects, but for new infill projects, the feeling of surrounding structures should be considered and respected. YES  Staff believes the feeling of the existing house as well as the surrounding structures will not be negatively impacted by the proposal. 7. Association: This is the direct link between an important historic event or person and a property. YES  N/A Page 38 of 39 5 FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Staff is supportive of the following items: 1. Applicant is proposing to clad the structure with a smooth cementitious lap siding. Staff is supportive of this siding but would also be in support of keeping the CMU exposed. 2. Staff is supportive of the proposed light fixture, and requests clarification regarding which finish the applicant plans to select. Staff would be supportive of either the copper or oil-rubbed bronze finish. Staff also recommends the fixture be electric. 3. Staff is supportive of the living fence design and color to match the siding. 4. Staff is supportive of the stained sapele front door. Staff is supportive of the overall project, in that it satisfies the intent of the Beaufort Preservation Manual. However, following aspects should be clarified before considering FINAL APPROVAL: 1. Staff recommends selecting a different color for the standing seam metal roof. Staff has concerns that the “Patina Green” color selected by the applicant will appear too different in color next to the existing dark gray asphalt shingle roof, even though it is a low-slope roof. Staff recommends selecting a gray color to match the existing roof. Staff is supportive of the siding/trim/window color, shutter color, and porch ceiling color. 2. Applicant is proposing fiberglass shutters. Staff may be supportive of fiberglass shutters since this structure is non-contributing, but requests a sample or mockup of a shutter to better understand the appearance of the shutter. 3. The proposed shutters at the ganged window on the front (east) façade do not appear to be wide enough to cover the width of the windows. Staff recommends using bi-fold shutters at these windows with a longer shutter dog to accommodate both panels. 4. Staff recommends reducing the depth of the eave at the front of the porch from 2’-0” to 1’-6” or shorter to better match the eave depths on the existing structure. Page 39 of 39

Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Nov 1, 2026.