Historic District Review Board meeting (Agenda Packet)
City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · meeting of Jul 9, 2025 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Beaufort
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MEETING AGENDA
The City of Beaufort
HISTORIC DISTRICT REVIEW BOARD
Wednesday, July 9, 2025, 2:00 P.M.
City Hall, Council Chambers, 2nd Floor – 1911 Boundary Street, Beaufort, SC
Please click the link below to access the streamed meeting on Zoom:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81503643819?pwd=8dyZ2owk5FCCScn1d7CTIvXqc6O3fc.1
Password: 657217 Meeting ID: 815 0364 3819 Call in Phone #: 1+929 205 6099
STATEMENT OF MEDIA NOTIFICATION: “In accordance with South Carolina Code of Laws,
1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, all local media were duly notified of the time, date, place, and agenda
of this meeting.”
Note: A project will not be reviewed if the applicant or representative is not present at the meeting.
I. Call to Order:
II. Review of Minutes:
A. May 14, 2025 Meeting Minutes
B. June 11, 2025 Meeting Minutes
III. Applications:
A. 1405 Duke Street, PIN R120 004 000 0345 0000, addition
Applicant: Martin W. Nash, homeowner
The applicant is requesting approval to build a screened-in detached adobe (200 sq. ft.) on an existing
platform at the rear of the existing house.
B. 605 Carteret Street, PIN R120 004 000 0637 0000, alterations
Applicant: Zach and Rihanna Graber, homeowners
The applicant is requesting approval for minor exterior changes, including new front door, shutters,
exterior paint color change and installation of gutters around the roof.
C. 807 Scott Street, PIN R120 004 000 0425 0000, exterior renovations
Applicant: Mirjam Kauffman for Stuart Feldman
The applicant is requesting approval on various interior & exterior renovations/alterations, including
changing location of existing door/window at rear elevation, placement of new windows, exterior
paint color change as well as screened-in rear porch enclosure.
IV. Discussion
V. Adjournment
1
Historic District Review Board
Meeting Minutes – May 14, 2025
CALL TO ORDER 0:02
A meeting of the Historic District Review Board was held in-person on Wednesday, May 14 at 2:00 pm.
ATTENDEES
Members in attendance: Eric Berman, (Vice-Chair), Rita Wilson, and Kim Petrella
Member absent: Mike Sutton (Chair) and Grady Woods.
Staff in attendance: Curt Freese, Community Development Director, Christopher Klement, Community
Development Planner, III, Nick Navia, Community Development Planner, I, Meadors Architects, and Julie A.
Bachety, Community Development Administrative Assistant II.
REVIEW OF MINUTES OF APRIL 9, 2025 0:05
Mr. Berman commented that on page 2 under the motion the second bullet 9’1”2 should be corrected to
either state 9 ½ feet or 9’ 6”. He also noted on page 2 under the motion the third bullet, conquer should
be corrected to “concur”.
Motion: Ms. Wilson made a motion to approve the April 9, 2025 minutes with the changes as noted.
Ms. Petrella seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.
All Historic District Review Board Meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s website at
http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter.
APPLICATIONS 1:14
A. 1203 Bay Street (The Cuthbert House), PIN R120 004 000 771A 0000, awning replacement
Applicant: Chris Ramm, Owner
The applicant is requesting approval for replacement of a green canvas awning at the rear of
The Cuthbert House with a standing seam metal shed roof.
Christopher Klement presented the staff report.
2
Public Comment:
Wallace Scarborough, 1207 Bay Street thanked the Board and said what they are doing is
important and keeping the historic integrity of these homes is vitally important to the economy
of Beaufort and that is why tourists come here. Mr. Scarborough is in favor of the project.
Lise Sundrla, Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF), stated HBF is in support of the project.
Public comment closed.
Motion: Ms. Petrella made a motion to approve alternative #2 – Shed-roof awning, option 1 as
presented by staff. Ms. Wilson seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.
B. 1107 Prince Street, PIN R120 004 000 0503 0000, alterations, additions 17:13
Applicant: Benjie Morillo, Architect
The applicant is requesting approval to partially demolish some walls within the existing
structure, as to add-on to the existing house, including changes to front, side/rear porches and
terrace.
Nick Navia presented the staff report.
Public Comment:
Lise Sundrla, Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF), said HBF is in favor of the project. Ms.
Sundrla commented that the building was mis-aged when it was surveyed and portions of it are
actually the 1940’s. Ms. Sundrla suggested keeping the character defining features.
Daniel Blackman, 1010 Duke Street said he is in favor of the project for renovations of the
house. He wanted clarification that this application does not include the ADU or the other
addition because the plans show them as “future addition” don’t show it this way. He is
concerned about the vertical board and batten versus horizontal; it’s very unusual in the
Northwest Quadrant (NWQ) and not consistent with the NWQ.
Public comment closed.
Motion: Ms. Petrella made a motion to preliminarily approve the application with staff’s
recommendations and to add the additional condition that the applicant restudy the siding, the
windows, consider a gable return for the front addition and that their submission explicitly
excludes the future addition and future ADU. Ms. Wilson seconded the motion. The motion
passed unanimously.
ADJOURNMENT 50:38
Ms. Wilson made a motion seconded by Ms. Petrella to adjourn. The meeting ended at 2:51 pm.
1
Historic District Review Board
Meeting Minutes – June 11, 2025
CALL TO ORDER 0:52
A meeting of the Historic District Review Board was held in-person on Wednesday, June 11, 2025 at 2:00
pm.
ATTENDEES
Members in attendance: Mike Sutton (Chair), Rita Wilson, Kim Petrella, and Grady Woods (via Zoom)
Member absent: Eric Berman, (Vice-Chair),
Staff in attendance: Curt Freese, Community Development Director, Christopher Klement, Community
Development Planner III, Nick Navia, Community Development Planner, I, Meadors Architects, and Julie A.
Bachety, Community Development Administrative Assistant II.
REVIEW OF MINUTES OF MAY 14, 2025 0:59
Chairman Sutton stated the minutes of the May 14, 2025 meeting today will be placed on the Board’s
next meeting for review since there is not a full board.
All Historic District Review Board Meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s website at
http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter.
APPLICATIONS 1:24
A. Permit Extension: 1114 Congress Street: Request for a one-year COA extension for the COA.
Applicant: Cherimie Crane Weatherford, Executive Director, Freeman’s Arts District
The applicant is requesting approval for a one-year COA extension for the COA.
Curt Frreese stated the applicant is requesting a one-year extension for their COA. Mr. Freese
referred to Section 9.1 that states, COAs are given two years and then the COA can be renewed
for one year periods five times, but it has to come before the Historic District Review Board
(HDRB) to be approved. The applicant has not started on the project, but it was approved two
years ago, and staff sees no reason why it cannot be renewed.
Public Comment:
2
None.
Public comment closed.
Motion: Ms. Petrella made a motion to approve the extension as requested. Ms. Wilson
seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.
B. 314 Charles Street, PIN R120 004 000 849B 0000, alterations 3:50
Applicant: Scott Haupt and Marilyn Marino, owners
Grady Woods recused himself from this project.
The applicants are requesting approval to install two (2) storm doors – 1 on the front and 1 on
the rear door of their home.
Nick Navia presented the staff report.
Public Comment:
Lise Sundrla, Director of Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF), agrees with staff’s
recommendation. This is an important structure. Ms. Sundrla referred to the Preservation
Manual. She provided the applicant a recommendation for whoever to go to look for wooden
storm doors that was recommended by Jeremy Tate, Staff Architect. Keeping it as wood will go
a long way with showing best practices for what to do with historic structures. Ms. Sundrla
stated that we don’t look at a mistake that was made previously and use that as a precedent to
go forward.
Public comment closed.
Motion: Ms. Petrella made a motion to approve the aluminum example as presented today.
Ms. Wilson seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.
C. 914 Newcastle Street, PIN R120 004 000 0279 0000, new construction 18:02
Applicant: Megan Chancellor Crumrine, Architect
Mr. Woods returned to the Board now.
The Applicant is requesting approval for construction of a new single-family residence.
Christopher Klement presented the staff report.
Public Comment:
Lise Sundrla, Director of Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF), said HBF is very pleased with the
changes that were made to minimize the height and scale of the building.
Public comment closed.
Motion: Mr. Woods made a motion to grant final approval with staff looking at the chimney cap
if there are any alterations. Ms. Petrella seconded the motion. The motion passed
unanimously.
3
Mr. Freese said that the HRB/Planning Commission Subcommittee has been 42:40
meeting, and they are making some good progress. Mr. Freese asked the board members if
they want to do a Fall Tour possibly in October. He also asked if the board members would be
interested in future training.
ADJOURNMENT 45:46
Ms. Petrella made a motion seconded by Ms. Wilson to adjourn. The meeting ended at 2:45 pm.
1405 DUKE STREET
Request to build a screened-in
detached adobe (200 sq. ft.) on an
existing platform at the rear of the
existing house.
HISTORIC REVIEW APPLICATION
MAJOR REVIEW (HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD)
Community Devetopment Department
1911 Boundary Stieet, Beaufort, South Carolina, 29902
p. (843) 525-7011/ f. (843) 986-5606
Email: development@cityofbeaufort.org/Website: www.cityofbeaufort.org
Application Fee:
see attached schedule
OFFICE USE ONLY:
: Date Filect 6/20/25
Application #: 28945
Zoning District:74-N
HAS PROJECT ATTENDED HTRC MEETING? (REQUIRED)☑ ES ☐NO
IS PROJECT A CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE? ☐
0 OR NON-CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE: ☐
FOR A LIST OF CONTRIBUTING OR NON-CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURES, PLEASE SEE:
https://cityofbeaufort.otg/350/Beaufort-County-Historic-Sites-Survey
APPLICABILITY FOR HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD: Major discretionary review board (HDRB) approval shall apply
to applications for Certification of Appropriateness per Section 9.10.2 for the following requests (please check all that apply):
☐ Newbuilding(s) in Historic Disttict
☐ Changes to exterior materials of Contributing Structures
☑Additions to Contributing Structures
☐ Non-similar roof replacement on Contributing Structures (roof with different materials)
☐Windowreplacements on Contributing Structures
Major changes to a Contributing or Non-contributing Site
Demolition
☐ Other changes to exterior of Contributing Structures
SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: All forms and information shallbe submitted digitally + 5 hard copies ofall documents. In
addition to a complete application form, applicants shall submit the required items according to the checklists on the subsequentpage.
Pursuant to Section 6-29-1145 of the South Carolina Code of Laws, is this tract or parcel restricted by any recorded covenant
that is contrary to, conflicis with, or prohibits the activity described in thisaplication? ☐ Yes ☑No
APPLICANT, PROPERTY, AND PROJECT INFORMATION:
APPLICANT NAME: MARTIN. W. NASH.
APPLICANT" ADDRESS: 1405 DaKE ST BEANORT IC. 29902
APPLICANT E-MAII: LWISEINC@AOL.COM
614 2000-6068680
APPLICANT PHONE NUMBER:
APLICANTTITLE: ☑
Homeowner Tenant Architect Engineer Developer
STAFF REPORT: Historic District Review Board (HRB)
1405 DUKE STREET
DATE: July 9, 2025
Background: The applicant is requesting approval to build a screened-in adobe (200 sqft) on an existing platform
at the rear of the existing house. The project consists of constructing a wooden frame atop of the existing wooden
platform and will feature a metal roof. The framing will be screened-in. There will be a screen door that opens out
into the backyard. The metal roof will be slightly angled to facilitate rain runoff. No electrical wiring or plumbing.
The applicant will be building the project by himself. The applicant has been to one (1) HTRC Meeting on June
11th, 2025.
GENERAL INFORMATION
Applicant: Martin W. Nash (Homeowner)
Site Address / Tax PIN: 1405 Duke Street; R120 004 000 0345 0000
Applicant's Request: The applicant is requesting approval to build a detached, screened-in
adobe (200 sq. ft.) on an existing platform at the rear of the existing
house.
Current Zoning: T4-NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT (T4-N)
Contributing/Neighborhood Contributing – Northwest Quadrant (ca. 1900)
Flood Zone/Base Flood Flood Zone X, Elevation: 22’-25’
ZONING DISTRICT INFORMATION
T4-NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT (T4-N)
Lot Width at Setback: N/A
Minimum Lot Size: N/A
Max Lot Coverage: 70% of lot area (This percentage indicates maximum lot coverage by roofs;
total impervious coverage may be an additional 10%. Parcels may also be
subject to Section 8.3 - Stormwater)
Min. Frontage Build Out 60% min; 85% max
Front Setback 0 ft -15 ft
Side Setback Corner: 0 ft – 10 ft; Interior: 5 ft min., 0 ft if attached
Rear Setback 10 ft min; from alley: 0 ft.
Building Height: Primary: 4 stories max; 3.5 stories max in & fronting Historic District &
interior lots along Allison Rd
Accessory: 2 stories / 30 ft max
SURROUNDING ZONING, LAND USE AND REQUIRED BUFFERS
Adjacent Zoning Adjacent Land Uses Setbacks for Adjacent Zoning
/Buffer required if rezoned
North: T4-HN 1406 Washington St
(noncontributing, ca. 1965) N/A
South: T4-N 1402/1406 Duke St (“Holy Trinity
Pentecostal Church”; contributing) N/A
East: T4-N 1403 Duke St (new build) N/A
West: T4-N 1407 Duke St (contributing, ca.
1870) N/A
2
Tree Removal Proposed:
No Specimen/Landmark trees are affected by this request.
Surrounding Area:
The property lies on the northside of Duke Street, close to the intersection of Duke and Wilmington. It lies within
the Northwest Quadrant neighborhood of the Historic District. The property is classified as a contributing
structure, with the surrounding properties mainly being single-family homes, with a church to the south of the
property.
Determination of adequate historic integrity for New Construction, Infill, Additions and Demolition:
As per the Beaufort Preservation Manual (Chapter 5) and the Beaufort Development Code (Section 4.7), the
compatibility of new infill construction as well as major renovations within Beaufort Historic District is determined
in consideration with the following principles: 1. Location, 2. Design, 3. Setting, 4. Materials, 5. Workmanship,
6. Feeling and 7. Association. See detailed staff analysis and recommendations in table below.
4.7.2 Integrity Guidelines (as per Beaufort
Development Code)
Rationale
Present
Staff Analysis of Rationale
1. Location: This is the relationship between the
property and its historical context.
YES ✓ 1405 Duke Street is located within the
Northwest Quadrant neighborhood of the
Historic District. It is in the rear of the
property, not visible from the street. Staff
believes the proposal would not impact the
relationship between the property and its
historical context within the area.
3
2. Design: This is the combination of elements
that create the feeling of a district or structure.
These elements include building patterns,
streetscapes, site elements, building size, mass
and scale, spatial relationships, and specific
architectural elements and details.
YES ✓ Staff believes the proposal will not alter the
streetscape, nearby site elements, or the
spatial relationship with nearby buildings.
3. Setting: This is the physical environment of a
property and should be evaluated on its context
as well as on the historical role the property has
played and continues to play. Important features
include topography, vegetation, man-made
features, and relationships between existing
structures and their surroundings.
YES ✓ Staff believes the relationship between the
house and the historic setting of the
neighborhood are not impacted by the
proposal.
4. Materials: These are the physical elements
that make up a property or district.
Yes ✓ Per the preservation manual, the proposed
materials are appropriate for the Historic
District.
5. Workmanship: This is the physical evidence
of the crafts of a particular culture or time
period. This particularly applies to rehabilitation
projects, but for new infill projects, workmanship
of surrounding structures should be considered
and respected.
YES ✓ Staff believes the workmanship of the
existing house as well as the surrounding
structures will not be impacted by the
proposal.
6. Feeling: This is the property's expression of
the aesthetic or historic sense of a particular
period of time. This particularly applies to
rehabilitation projects, but for new infill projects,
the feeling of surrounding structures should be
considered and respected.
YES ✓ Staff believes the feeling of the existing
house as well as the surrounding structures
will not be impacted by the proposal.
7. Association: This is the direct link between an
important historic event or person and a
property.
YES ✓ N/A
FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Staff Recommendation: Staff recommends FINAL APPROVAL of the screened-in adobe, in that it satisfies
the intent of the Beaufort Preservation Manual and requirements of the Beaufort Code, with the following
conditions:
1. Applicant to provide cutsheet specifications on roof color and materials.
2. Applicant to provide specific colors for wood framing and existing platform.
807 SCOTT STREET
Request for various interior & exterior
renovations/alterations, including changing
location of existing door/window at rear
elevation, placement of new windows,
exterior paint color change as well as
screened-in rear porch enclosure.
HRB - Review Set, Not For Construction
Scale
Date
Wren
Home
Designs LLC
mirjam.gerlach@outlook.com
803.741.4799Stuart Feldman & Kristen Seabury
Beaufort, SC 29902
6/26/2025 9:21:17 AMA10
Cover Sheet
Beaufort, SC 29902
A Renovation
June 25, 2025
807 Scott Street
Renovation Of
Existing Residence
807 Scott Street
Beaufort, South Carolina
1 Front/Left View2 Rear/Right View
Ref
Range
DW
EP
UP
DN
Ref
Range
DW
EP
UP
EP
UP
W/D DW
Range
Ref
Vent Hood
DN
DN
Existing
HVAC
WH
Dining
Kitchen
Closet
Existing Shelving
14' - 4"
14' - 3"
16' - 1"
21' - 6"
9' - 7 1/2"
6' - 1"
7' - 5"
4' - 1"
13' - 8 1/2"
6' - 8 1/2"
11' - 0"
3' - 8" 3' - 0 1/2"
Living
FP
Front Porch
Rear Porch
1) THE BUILDER OR CONTRACTOR MUST VERIFY
ALL DIMENSIONS PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION
2) THE CONTRACTOR MUST VERIFY COMPLIANCE
WITH ALL LOCAL BUILDING CODES IN THE AREA
WHERE CONSTRUCTION IS TAKING PLACE
3) VERIFY EXISTING LOAD BEARING CAPACITY OF
THE SOIL AT THE BUILDING SITE
4) ALL FEDERAL, STATE, AND LOCAL CODES, ORDINANCES,
REGULATIONS, ETC., SHALL BE CONSIDERED PART OF
THESE PLANS AND SHALL TAKE PREFERENCE OVER
ANYTHING SHOWN, DESCRIBED, OR IMPLIED
IN THE CASE OF VARIANCE
GENERAL NOTES
Relocate Existing
HVAC Return To
Accommodate
Pwdr
WH
Bath 3
Existing Shelving
5' - 6"
Remove Existing
Cased Opening
Frame In Its
Entirety, Infill Wall
Create New
Cased Opening
Remove Existing
Kitchen Cabinets
And Appliances In
Their Entirety, Cap
All Lines
Remove Existing
Window, Create
New Door
Opening
Remove Existing Door,
Infill Existing Opening To
Accommodate New
Window To Match
Existing
Existing Utilities in
Dining Cabinet.
Remove Existing
Door And Frame,
Widen Opening
FP
Remove Existing Mantel
and Cover Existing Fire
Place
14' - 4"
4' - 4"
Living
Hall/DiningHall/Dining
Bath 3
2' - 6"
6' - 6"
Bedroom 3
Closet
Laundry
14' - 7 1/2"
Shelving/Cabinet/
Banquet Seating
6' - 8 1/2"
14' - 3"
Kitchen
Island
Pwdr
Pantry
Living
Existing Porch
5' - 0"
3' - 0"
Zero
Entry
Shower
Field Verify for Head Height
6' - 6"
C/O
10' - 0"
Kitchen
3068
C/O
New Window
to Match Existing
New Window
to Match Existing
Front Porch
14' - 4"
HRB - Review Set, Not For Construction
Scale
Date
Wren
Home
Designs LLC
mirjam.gerlach@outlook.com
803.741.4799Stuart Feldman & Kristen Seabury
Beaufort, SC 29902
1/4" = 1'-0"
6/26/2025 9:21:17 AMA11
Floor Plans
Beaufort, SC 29902
A Renovation
June 25, 2025
807 Scott Street
1/4" = 1'-0"1 First Floor - Existing
1/4" = 1'-0"2 First Floor - Demolition
1/4" = 1'-0"3 First Floor - Renovation
EXISTING DOOR TO REMAIN
EXISTING SIDING TO REMAIN
EXISTING CORBELS TO
REMAIN TYP
EXISTING RAILINGS TO REMAIN
TYP
EXISTING RAILINGS TO REMAIN
TYP
EXISTING SCREEN DOOR PER IMAGE OF EXISTING
WEST ELEVATION TO REMAIN
EXISTING COLUMNS TO
REMAIN
EXISTING SIDING TO REMAIN
EXISTING CORBELS TO
REMAIN TYP
EXISTING RAILINGS TO REMAIN
TYP
EXISTING RAILINGS TO REMAIN
TYP
EXISTING COLUMNS TO
REMAIN
NEW WINDOW TO BE LOCATED BETWEEN
EXISTING WINDOWS, TO MATCH EXISTING,
USE EXISTING WINDOW REMOVED FROM
EAST ELEVATION ON SOUTH ELEVATION OR
NORTH ELEVATION WHERE POSSIBLE
HRB - Review Set, Not For Construction
Scale
Date
Wren
Home
Designs LLC
mirjam.gerlach@outlook.com
803.741.4799Stuart Feldman & Kristen Seabury
Beaufort, SC 29902
1/4" = 1'-0"
6/26/2025 9:21:25 AMA21
Elevations
Beaufort, SC 29902
A Renovation
June 25, 2025
807 Scott Street
1/4" = 1'-0"1 West Elevation - New
1/4" = 1'-0"2 North Elevation - New
1/4" = 1'-0"3 North Elevation - Existing
1/4" = 1'-0"4 West Elevation - Existing
HRB - Review Set, Not For Construction
Scale
Date
Wren
Home
Designs LLC
mirjam.gerlach@outlook.com
803.741.4799Stuart Feldman & Kristen Seabury
Beaufort, SC 29902
6/26/2025 9:21:34 AMA23
EXISTING
IMAGES
Beaufort, SC 29902
A Renovation
June 25, 2025
807 Scott Street
NEW PROPOSED WINDOWEXISTING NORTH ELEVATION
EXISTING SOUTH ELEVATION - EXISTING
WINDOWS NOT VISIBLE FROM STREET,
BEYOND VEGETATION
EXISTING EAST ELEVATION DOOR OPENING TO BE RELOCATED TO LEFT
WINDOW LOCATION, EXISTING WINDOW TO BE REUSED FOR NEW WINDOW
ON SOUTH OR NORTH ELEVATION, EXISTING SCREEN DOOR TO BE USED
FOR NEW SCREENED PORCH ON THIS ELEVATION (EAST ELEVATION).
EXISTING FRONT DOOR AND SCREEN DOOR TO REMAIN, NEW
PAINT COLOR FOR FRONT DOOR AND SCREEN DOOR FRAME,
EXISTING LIGHT FIXTURE TO REMAIN
COLOR SELECTIONS PER HISTORIC CHARLESTON
FOUNDATION COLOR SHEET
PORCH DECKING COLOR
PORCH CEILING COLOR TO MATCH EXISTING
SIDING COLOR TRIM/COLUMN/RAILING COLOR
DOOR COLOR
809 Scott Street 807 Scott Street 807 Scott Street 805 Scott Street
1
Selected Colors / specs for 807 Scott Street:
2
3
4
STAFF REPORT: Historic District Review Board (HRB)
807 SCOTT STREET
DATE: July 9, 2025
1
GENERAL INFORMATION
Applicant: Mirjam Kauffman (Architect) / Stuart Feldman (Owner)
Site Address / Tax PIN: 807 Scott Street / PIN: R120 004 000 0425 0000
Applicant's Request: The applicant is requesting approval for several alterations to the
existing structure. Proposed exterior renovations include:
• New exterior paint colors for siding, windows, doors and trim
• Relocation of one (1) existing window on rear (East elevation) to
North or South elevation & shifting of existing door at rear in lieu
of window (existing doors to remain)
• Additional window at North/South elevations
• Screen Porch enclosure at rear porch (East elevation)
• Repainting of the entire house in white color scheme
Current Zoning: T4-HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT (T4-HN)
Contributing/Neighborhood Contributing - Old Commons Neighborhood (c. 1885)
Flood Zone/Base Flood Flood Zone “Shaded X”, Elevation: 13’
Lot size / Square footage of
building / lot coverage
~4,356 sq. ft. (0.1 ac.) / 2,188 sq. ft. (roofed) = ~50% roofed coverage
ZONING DISTRICT INFORMATION
T4-HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT (T4-HN)
Lot Width at Setback: 40 ft. min. / (60 ft. min in the Point)
Minimum Lot Size: 4,000 sq. ft. (6,000 sq. ft. in The Point)
Max Lot Coverage: 55% [This percentage indicates maximum lot coverage by roofs; total
impervious coverage may be an additional 10%. Parcels may also be
subject to Section 8.3 (Stormwater)].
Min. Frontage Build Out 75% of lot
Front Setback Avg. prevailing setback on the block
Side Setback 6 ft. min. (interior), 5 ft min. (at corner)/ (10 ft. min. in the Point)
Rear Setback 15 ft min.
Building Height: 3 stories max. (primary); 2 stories or 30 ft. max. (accessory)
SURROUNDING ZONING, LAND USE AND REQUIRED BUFFERS
Adjacent Zoning Adjacent Land Uses Setbacks for Adjacent Zoning
/Buffer required if rezoned
North: T4-HN Residential Home (809 Scott St.,
c. 1900) N/A
South: T4-HN Residential Home N/A
East: T4-N Townhomes/Duplexes N/A
West: T4-HN Residential Home N/A
2 | P a g e
Background: Applicant is proposing various renovations to the exterior and interior of the existing dwelling.
Applicant has been to the HTRC Meeting on June 4, 2025 – Summary of discussion points:
1. Planning and Zoning:
o Contributing, ca. 1885
o T4-HN
o Screened porch will give the illusion of symmetry, so shouldn’t be an issue with the rear door
placement alteration
o Include a note saying that the bargeboards will not be removed/altered
o Provide cutsheets for the doors/windows/paint scheme
2. Building Codes:
o Energy code may be voided since it’s a contributing structure – still recommend meeting the code
however
o Hanging fixtures over tub is a concern.
o Make sure to not take out a supporting wall
3. Staff Architects (Meador Architecture):
o In future submissions, applicant should supply existing/demo elevations adjacent to the proposed,
similar to how existing/demo/proposed floor plans are shown.
o Show cardinal direction instead of “left,” “right” etc.
o Are the current front and rear doors original? Difficult to see doors behind screen doors in the
image. The proposed doors appear to be solid wood and are appropriate within the historic district.
If the existing doors are original and are in good condition, then staff has questions regarding why
they are proposed to be removed. If they are original but in poor condition, then documentation
needs to be provided illustrating their condition.
▪ Is applicant proposing to keep the existing screen doors? Staff recommends keeping them in
their current locations. (The repair sheet on page 16 notes there is an aluminum screen
door, but current photos show painted wood screen doors – so existing screen doors may
not be historic, or at least not original to this structure).
o Staff is supportive of the new window additions on the left and right elevations – applicant to
confirm if the existing windows are to remain and not be replaced.
▪ Provide a cutsheet for proposed windows – the most appropriate window would be a TDL
wood window with a muntin profile to match the existing. All other dimensions, including
rail and stile, casing, and sill dimensions are to match existing.
o Staff has concerns about removing the existing rear window and replacing the opening with a door,
as well as removing the existing door opening.
▪ Is the rear door historic? Ideally, staff would prefer the door opening be maintained to some
degree, and maybe the existing window be moved to the door location.
3 | P a g e
4. Historic Beaufort Foundation (HBF):
o Recommend retaining character defining features – 2 story piazza, bargeboard
o Concerned with breaking up the rhythm on façade facing the alley
o Do not recommend going dark colors for the door. Lighter is more appropriate.
Item HTRC & Staff
recommendations
(A) New exterior colors selections of (i.)“Historic Charleston Green” (DCR
#099), (ii.) “Cooper’s Basin” (DCR #071), (iii.) “Aunt Betty’s China”
(DCR #101), and (iv.) “Charleston White” (DCR #100) for siding,
windows, doors and trim
“Historic Charleston Green”
seems to be the most
appropriate color choice that
staff would recommend.
(i.) “Historic Charleston
Green” (Doors)
(ii.) “Cooper’s Basin” (Porch
decking)
(iii.) “Aunt Betty’s China”
(Siding)
(iv.) “Charleston White”
(Trim/Columns/Railing)
4 | P a g e
Tree Removal Proposed:
No Specimen/Landmark trees will be affected.
Surrounding Area:
This property is located in the midst of the Old Commons neighborhood. The buildings in the immediate vicinity
are pre-dominantly residential, single-family dwellings of mixed historically contributing/non-contributing
character.
(B) New Cellular PVC windows (North/South elevation) (Windsor Windows
& Doors)
New windows should be a
TDL wood window with a
muntin profile to match the
existing. All other dimensions,
including rail and stile, casing,
and sill dimensions are to
match existing.
FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
❖ The Beaufort Preservation Manual – Chapter 10: Doors, Windows and Shutters (page 150ff.)
General Guidelines:
➢ Repair or replace existing historic doors/windows in-kind
➢ Save as much historic door fabric as possible. In some cases, this will involve removing deteriorated
sections and patching as invisibly as possible
➢ Replace inappropriate doors/windows with doors/windows appropriate to the period of the house
➢ Extant nineteenth-century screen doors should be retained, maintained, and repaired to the greatest
extent possible.
❖ The Beaufort Preservation Manual – Chapter 14: Painting
Color Selection (p. 190/191):
➢ “(…) When possible, implementation of historically appropriate colors can be a suitable
approach. Verification of the original or early paint colors applied to a building must be
accomplished through a specific procedure of investigation and analysis.”
❖ Secretary of the Interior – Standards for Rehabilitation
#1: A property shall be used as it was historically or be given a new use that requires minimal change to its
distinctive materials, features, spaces and spatial relationships
5 | P a g e
#2: The historic character of a property will be retained and preserved. (…)
#3: (…)Changes that create a false sense of historical development, such as adding conjectural features or
elements from other historic properties, shall not be undertaken.
#4: Changes to a property that has acquired historic significance in its own right will be retained and
preserved.
#5: Distinctive materials, features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of craftmanship
that characterize a property shall be preserved.
#6: Deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration
required replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture,
and, where possible, materials. (…)
#7: Chemical or physical treatments, such as sandblasting, that cause damage to historic materials shall not
be used. The surface cleaning of structures, if appropriate, shall be undertaken using the gentlest means
possible.
#8: Significant archeological resources affected by a project shall be protected and preserved. If such
resources must be disturbed, mitigation measures shall be undertaken.
#9: New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction will not destroy historic material,
features, and spatial relationships that characterize the property. The new work will be differentiated
from the old and will be compatible with the historic materials, features, size, scale and proportion, and
massing to protect the integrity of the property and its environment.
#10: New additions and adjacent or related new construction will be undertaken in such a manner that, if
removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would
be unimpaired.
Staff Recommendation: Staff recommends FINAL APPROVAL of the proposed alterations, in that it
satisfies the intent of the Beaufort Preservation Manual and requirements of the Beaufort Code,
with the following conditions:
1. Staff is supportive of the proposed colors for the siding, trim and columns, porch decking, and
doors.
2. Applicant to clarify if the existing back door is historic (even though it is not original) and could
potentially be reused in the new door opening. If not, staff is supportive of the replacement
“Therma-tru” door. Applicant to note that the SDL door must have exterior muntins applied on the
glass. This also applies to the transom window above the door.
3. Staff is supportive of reusing the rear screen door in the new screened enclosure. Applicant to
clarify if the
4. Staff is supportive of the proposed window and door alterations, with one condition. The applicant
has provided details from the Windsor Legend window series, which is a vinyl window. Vinyl
windows are not appropriate in the historic district per the Beaufort Preservation Manual.
Additionally, t he City’s “Window Scenarios in the Historic District” guidelines note that wood
windows on contributing structures should be replaced with wood windows . To achieve the same
profiles and exact dimensions needed for a new window on this structure, a custom wood window
is the most appropriate option. This also applies to the transom window above the rear door. Both
windows are to be either TDL windows, or SDL windows with an exterior muntin grille applied on
the glass, as noted in the comment above.
6 | P a g e
Addendum: Beaufort County Historic Sites Survey 1997 – 807 Scott Street
7 | P a g e
8 | P a g e
9 | P a g e
605 CARTERET STREET
Request for minor exterior changes,
including new front door, shutters, exterior
paint color change and installation of
gutters around the roof.
STAFF REPORT: Historic District Review Board (HRB)
605 CARTERET STREET
DATE: July 9, 2025
1
GENERAL INFORMATION
Applicant: Zachary & Rihanna Graber (Homeowners)
Site Address / Tax PIN: 605 Carteret Street / PIN: R120 004 000 0637 0000
Applicant's Request: Applicant is requesting approval for the following exterior changes:
• Exterior paint color change;
• Color change of exterior shutters;
• Replace front door (residential vs. commercial); and
• Install gutters around roofline
Current Zoning: T4-NEIGHBORHOOD (T4-N)
Contributing/Neighborhood Contributing - The Point Neighborhood (c. 1880)
Flood Zone/Base Flood Flood Zone “AE”, Elevation: 6’-7’
Lot size / Square footage of
building / lot coverage
~2,178 sq. ft. (0.05 ac.) / 2,000 sq. ft. (roofed) = ~92% roofed
coverage
ZONING DISTRICT INFORMATION
T4-NEIGHBORHOOD (T4-N)
Lot Width at Setback: n/a
Minimum Lot Size: 4,000 sq. ft. (6,000 sq. ft. in The Point)
Max Lot Coverage: 70% [This percentage indicates maximum lot coverage by roofs; total
impervious coverage may be an additional 10%. Parcels may also be
subject to Section 8.3 (Stormwater)].
Min. Frontage Build Out 75% of lot
Front Setback 0 ft. min. / 15 ft. max.
Side Setback 5 ft. min. (interior), 0 ft min./ 15 ft. max. (at corner)
Rear Setback 10 ft min.
Building Height: 2 stories min.; 4 stories max. (primary bldg.)
SURROUNDING ZONING, LAND USE AND REQUIRED BUFFERS
Adjacent Zoning Adjacent Land Uses Setbacks for Adjacent Zoning
/Buffer required if rezoned
North: T4-N 607 Carteret St. (c. 1955; non-
contributing) N/A
South: T4-N 603 Carteret St. (“The Jeweler’s
Bench”; non-contributing) N/A
East: T4-N Vacant lot N/A
West: T4-N 602 Carteret St. (fmr. “Berean
Presbyterian Church”; c. 1900) N/A
2 | P a g e
Background: The applicant is requesting approval for various exterior alterations, including: a.) Exterior paint
color change to “Extra White”, b.) Color change of window shutters to “Tricorn Black”; c.) Replacement of
front door to a more residential style (3/4 glass door); d.) Installation of gutters around the house.
Applicant has been to the HTRC Meeting on June 11, 2025 – Summary of discussion points:
1. Planning and Zoning:
o Contributing, ca. 1880
o Zoning district: T4-N
2. Regarding Architecture (by Meadors Architects, Charleston):
o Staff is supportive of paint color change - paint color swatches have been provided.
o Gutters:
▪ See Chapter 13 of the Beaufort Preservation Manual
▪ Staff would be most supportive of a half-round aluminum or copper gutter system with a
plain round or rectangular downspout
▪ K-style gutters are not appropriate
▪ Corrugated downspouts are not appropriate
Item HTRC & Staff
recommendations
(A) New exterior color change to “Extra White” (Sherwin-Williams Color Code
#7006)
Color is befitting to
neighborhood and would
perfectly match with
proposed shutter color
“Tricorn Black” (see below).
3 | P a g e
(B) Shutters to be painted in “Tricorn Black” (Sherwin-Williams Color Code
#6258)
Color matches well with new
exterior color; creates a
classic look.
(C) New front door replacement as it: a.) resembles a more residential look
and b.) provides better security. New front door will be wooden 3 / 4 glass
door painted in “Tricorn Black”. See specs below:
HTRC/Staff recommends a
door with two lower panels,
as would be more in keeping
with the historic appearance.
(D) Installation of gutters around the entire house. HTRC/Staff would be most
supportive of a half-round
aluminum or copper gutter
system with a plain round or
rectangular downspout.
4 | P a g e
Tree Removal Proposed:
No Specimen/Landmark trees will be affected.
Surrounding Area:
This property is located along the main downtown North-South corridor of Carteret Street in the Point. The
buildings in the immediate vicinity are pre-dominantly historically contributing and intact. The overall character of
the Carteret Street corridor is of mixed uses of commercial, residential and institutional.
FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
❖ The Beaufort Preservation Manual – Chapter 10: Doors, Windows and Shutters (page 150ff.)
➢ Summary of Door Recommendations:
- Appropriate/Recommended: For new construction, paneled doors are appropriate for virtually
any house that might be built.
- Inappropriate/Not recommended: Modern flush doors.
❖ The Beaufort Preservation Manual – Chapter 13: Flashing, Gutters and Downspouts (page 179ff.)
➢ Summary of Recommendations:
- Appropriate: Use 1/2 round sheet metal gutters and round downspouts.
❖ The Beaufort Preservation Manual – Chapter 14: Painting (pages 187ff.)
➢ “The [Beaufort Development] Code in its elaboration of the HRB’s responsibilities, repeatedly
references exterior color as among the issues which affect a structure’s exterior architectural
appearance, and which therefore requires HRB review.”
➢ “It is thus the clear mandate of the HRB to review proposed alterations to the exterior color of
buildings within the Beaufort Historic District . It is not their clear mandate to require strict
restoration and research fidelity to the determination and recreation of a historic building’s colors […]
at a significant period of its history. The HRB must allow the distinctions in color expression which
accompany the architectural styles represented in the District, while at the same time encouraging
exterior color schemes which preserve the overall harmony and character of the District. Further, the
HRB is to prevent color schemes which disrupt that character.”
❖ Secretary of the Interior – Standards for Rehabilitation
#1: A property shall be used as it was historically or be given a new use that requires minimal change to its
distinctive materials, features, spaces and spatial relationships
#2: The historic character of a property will be retained and preserved. (…)
#3: (…)Changes that create a false sense of historical development, such as adding conjectural features or
elements from other historic properties, shall not be undertaken.
#4: Changes to a property that has acquired historic significance in its own right will be retained and
preserved.
#5: Distinctive materials, features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of craftmanship that
characterize a property shall be preserved.
#6: Deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration
required replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture,
and, where possible, materials. (…)
#7: Chemical or physical treatments, such as sandblasting, that cause damage to historic materials shall not
be used. The surface cleaning of structures, if appropriate, shall be undertaken using the gentlest means
possible.
5 | P a g e
#8: Significant archeological resources affected by a project shall be protected and preserved. If such
resources must be disturbed, mitigation measures shall be undertaken.
#9: New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction will not destroy historic material,
features, and spatial relationships that characterize the property. The new work will be differentiated
from the old and will be compatible with the historic materials, features, size, scale and proportion, and
massing to protect the integrity of the property and its environment.
#10: New additions and adjacent or related new construction will be undertaken in such a manner that, if
removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would
be unimpaired.
Staff Recommendation: Staff recommends FINAL APPROVAL of the proposed alterations, in that it
satisfies the intent of the Beaufort Preservation Manual and requirements of the Beaufort Code,
with the following conditions:
1. Applicant to provide cutsheets for the proposed gutter and downspout system. → Staff would be
most supportive of a half-round aluminum or copper gutter system with a plain round or
rectangular downspout. “K-style” gutters and corrugated downspouts are considered
inappropriate per the Beaufort Preservation Manual.
2. Staff is supportive of the proposed exterior color changes.
3. Staff is supportive of the proposed front door replacement , if the proposed door will also be solid
wood. Previously submitted door cutsheets were solid wood doors, with two options – one option
was for a slightly larger glass pane and a single raised panel below, or a slightly smaller glass pane
with two raised p anels below. The glass in both options was divided into four panes. Staff is
supportive of either option – applicant to clarify which option they plan on selecting. → Note that
any door with divided glass must either be TDL, or SDL with exterior muntin grilles applied on the
glass.
6 | P a g e
Addendum: Beaufort County Historic Sites Survey 1997 – 605 Carteret Street
Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Nov 1, 2026.