RecordWell Data

Historic District Technical Review Committee (HTRC) / Pre-Design Meeting (Agenda Packet)

City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · meeting of Jul 2, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Beaufort

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

HTRC/PRE-DESIGN MEETING AGENDA Meeting – Wednesday, July 2, 2025 at 10:00 AM This meeting will be held at 1911 Boundary Street (Beaufort City Hall) in the first-floor Planning Conference room. Please click the link below to join the webinar: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/86706195142?pwd=jJ30InKNRWe0OUaFPABt6QIptxe8Cg.1 Password: 242241 Meeting ID: 867 0619 5142 Call in Phone#: +1 929 205 6099 Agenda items: I. Projects: a. 605/607/609 Bladen Street (non-contributing; new infill development) – Follow- up discussion on infill development on three (3) new lots for new single-family dwellings; Submitted by Paul Trask (Developer), Bill Chambers (Architect) & Ryan Lyle (Engineer) b. 404 Scott Street (Non-Contributing, c. 1960) – Proposal to add-on front porch with standing seam metal roof, brick walkway, shutters, new siding and living fence; Submitted by Tom Rhodes with Frederick & Frederick (Architect) II. Staff Discussion III. Adjournment If you have any questions, please call (843) 525-7014. cc: Paul Trask (Developer) / Bill Chambers (Architect) / Ryan Lyle (Engineer) Tom Rhodes (Architect) 605/607/609 BLADEN STREET Follow-up discussion on revisions to proposed single-family development on three (3) new lots 605/607/609 BLADEN STREET Revised / updated Conceptual Plan & Elevations 605/607/609 BLADEN STREET Submitted plans / elevations from March 2025 CITY OF BEAUFORT HTRC – Pre-Design Application Meeting 1911 BOUNDARY STREET BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29902 (843) 525-7011 FAX: (843) 986-5606 Meeting Summary Date: 3/26/2025 Project Address: 608 Bladen Street Project Narrative: Concept discussion for subdivision of subject lot for 3 new single-family homes. Applicant: Paul Trask (Developer) Synopsis of staff comments: • Planning and Zoning: o T4-N, non-contributing o Conform to lot coverage requirements o Obtain access easements • Architecture: o Bladen Street Redevelopment o Staff is generally supportive of the architecture design of the proposed buildings but has concerns that the three structures are visually too dense on this lot. While the master plan for Bladen Street envisions a single larger footprint building, staff is pleased to see the applicant’s approach to split the site with multiple buildings for scale and street rhythm. However, the three structures seem too close to each other and do not successfully harmonize with the street rhythm. Staff recommends studying the layout with two structures on the lot instead of three or maybe reducing the buildings’ widths.  Please provide dimensions between the structures on the site/floor plan. o If the applicant wishes to keep this configuration with three structures of this size, staff recommends the following:  The dormers seem large for the size of the buildings, staff recommends the applicant reduce the scale of the dormers  Staff recommends the applicant study the façade of the middle structure without the transom windows. Note: transom windows over windows are not common in the district  Staff recommends reducing the size of the gable window on the middle structure  Staff recommends reducing the width of the porch on the middle structure (there is no dimension, but staff believes this is about 12’-9” wide). This could be reduced so that the building can shift away from its neighbor to the north, where the distance between the buildings seems tight o Applicant to demonstrate compliance with Section 2.4.1 frontage build-out (60%, 85% max.) o Applicant to demonstrate compliance with Section 2.4.1 maximum lot coverage (70% of lot area, lot coverage by roofs), total impervious coverage may be an additional 10% o Applicant to demonstrate compliance with Section 2.4.1 setbacks Applicant’s Next Steps: Address comments, can come back to HTRC for another round of review (recommended) or apply for permits if you have everything ready. Be advised that this letter is given as a courtesy to applicants and may not contain all project guidelines. For a complete history of the meeting, please request the audio recording. Please refer to the Beaufort Code for applicable sections. If there are any changes to the project, not discussed in this meeting, you will need to return to a HTRC – Pre-Design meeting. If you have any questions, feel free to call the Community Development Department at (843) 525-7014. Thank you for your patience and cooperation during the review process. Sincerely, City of Beaufort Community Development STAFF REPORT - HTRC / Pre-design Meeting DATES: 1.) 03/26/2025; 2.) 07/02/2025 GENERAL INFORMATION Applicant: Paul Trask (Property owner / Developer) Site Location/Address: 605-609 Bladen Street / PIN: R120 004 000 0587 0000 Applicant's Request: Concept discussion for subdivision of subject lot for three (3) new single family homes. Current Zoning: T4-N Located within the Historic Beaufort District? If so, contributing or non- contributing structure? Within Historic Beaufort District / Non-contributing Also, within Bladen Street Redevelopment Overlay District Lot size: ~6,530 sq. ft. (0.15 ac) ZONING DISTRICT INFORMATION T4-N Lot Width at Front Setback: n/a Max Lot Coverage: 70% This percentage indicates maximum lot coverage by roofs; total impervious coverage may be an additional 10%. Parcels may also be subject to Section 8.3 (Stormwater) Minimum lot size n/a Max. Frontage Build Out 60% min; 85% max Front Setback 0 ft. min. / 15 ft. max. Side Setback Interior: 5 ft. min. or 0 ft. if attached; Corner/from alley: 0 ft min., 10 ft. max. Rear Setback 10 ft min. / 0 ft. from alley Building Height: 3.5 stories max. (in & fronting Historic District) SURROUNDING ZONING, LAND USE AND REQUIRED BUFFERS Adjacent Zoning Adjacent Land Uses Setbacks for Adjacent Zoning /Buffer required if rezoned North: T4-N Parking lot N/A South: T4-N Pat Conroy Literary Center 5 ft. (interior setback) East: T4-N Residential dwelling (c. 1955) 5 ft. (interior setback) West: T4-N Infill dev. (residential) N/A Background: The property owner / developer (Paul Trask) is proposing to first subdivide and then develop subject lot into three (3) new residential dwelling units. Approximate square footage of proposed new houses: 2,500 – 3,000 ft.2 2 FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS • Sec. 4.7 Historic District Infill Design Guidelines – A.2. Integrity of the district, determined by a. Location, b. Design, c. Setting, d. Materials, e. Workmanship, f. Feeling & g. Association. • Sec. 4.7 Historic District Infill Design Guidelines – B. New Construction Shall Reinforce the Historic Significance of the District: Infill buildings should relate to and strengthen the core characteristics of the district, as identified in the National Register nomination's "Statement of Significance."1. New construction should build upon the history and established pattern of the district through its design, landscape, use, and cultural expression. An understanding of the character and significance of the district should predicate any design or development activities. • Sec. 4.7 Historic District Infill Design Guidelines – C. New Construction Shall Complement and Support the District: The Historic District has a distinct rhythm of massing, scale, and siting. Infill buildings should not deviate in a detracting manner from these elements, but appear as complementary members of the district. • Sec. 4.7 Historic District Infill Design Guidelines – D. Infill Shall be Compatible Yet Distinct: New buildings should be identifiable as being of their period of construction; however, they should not be so differentiated that they detract from - or visually compete with - their historic neighbors. Within historic districts, compatibility is more important than differentiation. • Sec. 4.7 Historic District Infill Design Guidelines – E. The Exterior Envelope and Patterning of New Buildings Shall Reflect District Characteristics: Infill design elements, patterning, texture, and materials should reflect the aesthetic and historic themes of the district. • Sec. 2.7.3.F Redevelopment District Overlays – Specific to the Bladen Street Redevelopment District: 4. Master Plan: See Appendix B.2.3 for the original Bladen Street Master Plan. 404 SCOTT STREET Proposal for front porch addition & small upfits, incl. new siding, shutters and living fence STAFF REPORT - HTRC / pre-Design Meeting DATE: 07/02/2025 GENERAL INFORMATION Applicant: Tom Rhodes (Architect) for Hannah Fulton (Homeowner) Site Location/Address: 404 Scott Street / PIN: R120 004 000 0809 0000 Applicant's Request: To add front porch (metal standing seam roof) with a brick walkway, new siding, shutters, and a living fence Current Zoning: T4-NEIGHBORHOOD (T4-N) Located within the Historic Beaufort District? If so, contributing or non-contributing structure? Within Historic Beaufort District (Old Commons) Non-Contributing (c. 1960) Lot size: ~1,306 ft2 (0.03 ac); Size of dwelling: 720 sq. ft. ZONING DISTRICT INFORMATION T4-NEIGHBORHOOD (T4-N) Lot Width at Front Setback: n/a Max Lot Coverage: 70% [This percentage indicates maximum lot coverage by roofs; total impervious coverage may be an additional 10%. Parcels may also be subject to Section 8.3 (Stormwater)]. Max. Frontage Build Out 75% of lot area Front Setback 0 ft. min. / 15 ft. max. Side Setback 5 ft. min. (interior), 0 ft min./ 15 ft. max. (at corner) Rear Setback 10 ft min. Building Height: 2 stories min.; 4 stories max. (primary) SURROUNDING ZONING, LAND USE AND REQUIRED BUFFERS Adjacent Zoning Adjacent Land Uses Setbacks for Adjacent Zoning /Buffer required if rezoned North: T4-N 406 Scott St. (c. 1940; non- contributing) N/A South: T4-N 801 Craven St. (new built) N/A East: T4-N Jewish Synagogue / Methodist Church N/A West: T4-N 809 Craven St. (non-contrib.) N/A Background: The applicant wants to add a front porch with a standing-seam metal roof as well as change the current siding to board-and-batten and add new shutters as well as a living fence. No additional heated square footage. 2 FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS • Sec. 4.7.2 – Historic District Infill Design Guidelines / General Principles for Compatible Infill: ➢ Location: This is the relationship between the property and its historical context ➢ Design: This is the combination of elements that create the feeling of a district or structure. These elements include building patterns, streetscapes, site elements, building size, mass and scale, spatial relationships, and specific architectural elements and details. ➢ Setting: This is the physical environment of a property and should be evaluated on its context as well as on the historical role the property has played and continues to play. Important features include topography, vegetation, man-made features, and relationships between existing structures and their surroundings. ➢ Materials: These are the physical elements that make up a property or district. ➢ Workmanship: This is the physical evidence of the crafts of a particular culture or time period. This particularly applies to rehabilitation projects, but for new infill projects, workmanship of surrounding structures should be considered and respected. Retaining the details of the original craft and craftsman (i.e., wood, masonry, tabby etc.) of the original building ensures the historic fabric is retained and serves as an important component of the integrity and the patina of age of individual structures and the district as a whole. ➢ Feeling: This is the property's expression of the aesthetic or historic sense of a particular period of time. This particularly applies to rehabilitation projects, but for new infill projects, the feeling of surrounding structures should be considered and respected. ➢ Association: This is the direct link between an important historic event or person and a property. This particularly applies to rehabilitation projects, but for new infill projects, association of particular sites and neighborhoods should be considered. • Secretary of the Interior – Standards for Rehabilitation #1: A property shall be used as it was historically or be given a new use that requires minimal change to its distinctive materials, features, spaces and spatial relationships #2: The historic character of a property will be retained and preserved. (…) #3: (…) Changes that create a false sense of historical development, such as adding conjectural features or elements from other historic properties, shall not be undertaken. #4: Changes to a property that has acquired historic significance in its own right will be retained and preserved. #5: Distinctive materials, features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of craftmanship that characterize a property shall be preserved. #6: Deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration required replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture, and, where possible, materials. (…) #7: Chemical or physical treatments, such as sandblasting, that cause damage to historic materials shall not be used. The surface cleaning of structures, if appropriate, shall be undertaken using the gentlest means possible. #8: Significant archeological resources affected by a project shall be protected and preserved. If such resources must be disturbed, mitigation measures shall be undertaken. #9: New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction will not destroy historic material, features, and spatial relationships that characterize the property. The new work will be differentiated from the old and will be compatible with the historic materials, features, size, scale and proportion, and massing to protect the integrity of the property and its environment. #10: New additions and adjacent or related new construction will be undertaken in such a manner that, if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired.

Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Nov 1, 2026.