RecordWell Data

Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review — Agenda Packet

City of Spartanburg · Spartanburg County · Boards and Commissions · meeting of Aug 8, 2024 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Spartanburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

The City of Spartanburg Board of Architectural Design & Historic Review City of Spartanburg | Board of Architectural Design & Historic Review 1 AGENDA August 8th, 2024, at 5:30 P.M. Spartanburg County Council Chambers 366 N. Church Street – Spartanburg, SC 29303 (Please Note: Items as they appear on the Docket may or may not be considered in the order as they are presented. The Chairman will announce any changes after the roll call) I. Call To Order. II. Roll Call. III. Freedom of Information Act Compliance – Public notification of the City of Spartanburg’s Board of Architectural Design & Historic Review meeting has been published, posted and mailed in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the City of Spartanburg’s Zoning Ordinance. IV. Approval of Agenda. V. Disposition of Minutes from the July 11th, 2024, Meeting. VI. Old Business: 1. COA: 24-004-00018: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 400 Hampton Dr (TMS: 7-16-02-141.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval to pave the parking area for tenants. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single-Family District) zoning district. Owner/Applicant: Phuoc Do and Theresa Phan Contractor: Work, Inc. 2. COA: 24-004-00029: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 516 Peronneau St (TMS: 7-16-02-120.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval to install paved driveway. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single-Family District) zoning district. Owner/Applicant: Matt Johnston and Kimberly Rostan Contractor: Manello Construction. VII. New Business: None. VIII. Election of new Chair and Vice Chair for the Board. IX. Staff Updates: X. Adjournment. For more information, please contact the City of Spartanburg Planning Department at planning@cityofspartanburg.org or call (864) 596-2068. 1 of 61 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-07-11 Page 1 of 8 Meeting Minutes of the Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review Thursday, July 11th, 2024, at 5:30 PM Spartanburg County Council Chambers The City of Spartanburg Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review (HARB ) met in County Council Chambers on Thursday, July 11th, 2024, at 5:30 PM with the following members in attendance: Bill Michels, Mark Olencki, Michael Pittillo, Kenneth Brown, and James Gaffney. Representing the Planning Department - Martin Livingston, Community Director, Fredalyn Frasier, Planning Director, Nan Zhou, Planner II, and Oksana Holbrooks, Administrative Assistant. Special Staff Announcement: Ms. Frasier announced serving Board Member Tina Wilson passed away April, 20th, 2024. An exerpt from her obituary was read into the record. R oll Call: M r. Michels: Bill Michels Mr. Brown: Kenneth Brown Mr. Olencki: Mark Olencki Mr. Gaffney: James Gaffney Mr. Pittillo: Michael Pittillo Mr. Gaffney: Based on Freedom of Information Act Compliance public notification City of Spartanburg’s Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review meeting has been published, posted, and mailed in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance. A pproval of Agenda: A motion was made by Mr. Brown, seconded by Mr. Olencki, to approve the agenda. The motion was approved with a vote of 5-0. Approval of Meeting Minutes from May 9th, 2024. A motion was made by Mr. Michels, seconded by Mr. Pittillo to approve the agenda. The motion was approved with a vote of 5-0. O ld Business: N one. N ew Business: C ertificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 400 Hampton Dr. (TMS # 7-16-02-141.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval to pave the parking area for tenants. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single-Family District) zoning district. Owner/Applicant: Phuoc Do and Theresa Phan; Contractor: Work, Inc. P roject Description and History T he project site is an approximately 11,736 square foot lot in the Hampton Heights Historic District. The site abuts West Hampton Avenue to the north boundary and Hampton Drive to the east boundary. The lot currently contains one two-story structure, known as The Alexander Apartment, that was built in 1956. The structure has open front porches on both floors with a brick foundation. The structure has 2 of 61 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-07-11 Page 2 of 8 a hipped roof. Since this apartment complex was built prior to the adoption of the current City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance, it is a non-conforming use. T he applicant is requesting to pave the parking lot on the right side of the building to provide onsite parking for tenants due to the limited parking along Hampton Drive near the apartment complex. A nalysis Zoning Ordinance and Historic Design Manual Consistency The project site is in the Hampton Heights Historic District which has design guidelines used to eva luate the appropriateness of proposed changes in local historic districts to protect the visual qualities of historic properties that reflect the history and heritage of that community. These guidelines are outlined in the Design Guidelines for the City of Spartanburg Historic Districts and Landmarks. The purpose of the Design Guidelines is to provide property owners guidance for the preservation and protection of historic and architecturally valuable districts and sites in the City. The project is also subject to Section 510 of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation . This section allows the Board to review applicatio ns involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. Fi ndings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) 1. T he character and appropriateness of the design Hampton Heights Design Guidelines – Landscape states that “……new surfaces should be compatible with these [concrete, asphalt, and brick] predominant materials. The use of driving lanes, designed to facilitate only the car’s wheels, is a historic treatment which is encouraged to retain porous surface. Parking should be located in the side yard and rear yard spaces and not extend beyond the front setback line of historic buildings. Plant materials and enclosures should be utilized for screening parking areas. Paving of parking areas should be accomplished without the loss of existing vegetation or the creation of large impervious surfaces. The use of porous pavers as a paving surface is encouraged. Parking should be addressed in a manner that does not distract from the overall character of the district. parking to serve private residential lots shall be accommodated on-site. It is preferable to expand an existing driveway for parking, rather than to add a separate parking pad. Plant materials can be added around parking spaces to visually buffer the parking from the street.” • T he proposed driveway and parking lot are concrete with some existing vegetation surrounding the parking lot. 2. T he scale of the buildings The scale of the primary building will not be affected. Paving the driveway and parking lot will not affect the scale of the two-story apartment complex building. 3. The texture and materials The proposed material for the driveway and parking lot will be concrete. 4. T he relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings Currently, the immediate surrounding properties from the project site all have either a pre-existing concrete, gravel, or brick driveway in the front or side yard. 3 of 61 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-07-11 Page 3 of 8 5. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District Hampton Heights Design Guidelines clearly state the recommended placement of the parking lot, the appropriate materials for the new surface, and the planting vegetation. • Constructing a concrete driveway and a parking area to the side yard will accommodate the parking needs of the tenants and would be harmonious with the immediate surrounding properties that have a pre-existing concrete driveway. • However, the proposed material for the driveway and parking lot does not meet the Hampton Heights Design Guidelines. A pplicant: Phuoc Do, Owner. P ublic Speakers: Linda Powers Bilanchone, 182 W Hampton Ave. Brad Steinecke, 482 Pinckney Ct. Donna Pleanbe Burdette, 465 Hampton Dr. Steve Battocchio, 175 W Hampton Ave. Niko Gilman, 460 Hampton Dr. Sandy Battocchio, 175 W Hampton Dr. Kathy Taylor, 495 Hampton Dr. D iscussion: The proposed project needs survey for elevation for property. Parking along the street seems to be of growing problem in the neighborhood. Having extra available parking would seem to benefit the surrounding properties. A motion was made by Mr. Michels, seconded Mr. Brown to table the Certificate of Appropriateness until the next meeting for a storm water study, determination of curb cut, and a parking plan are presented by a vote of 5-0. C ertificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 265 S. Spring Street (TMS: 7-12-114-204.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval to install a new utility pole, a new small cell equipment along with components and hardware. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single-Family District) zoning district. Owner/Applicant: Verizon Wireless / Brian Deye Contractor: Justin Sullens. P roject Description and History The project site is located near the corner of Beta Way and S. Spring Street. The applicant is seeking to seeking approval to install a new utility pole, a new small cell equipment along with components and hardware in the city right of way. The project does not involve housing construction of any type of housing activity. These small cell sites are designed to provide better cell service coverage in densely populated areas and can be seen in several areas in downtown Spartanburg. A nalysis Zoning Ordinance and Historic Design Manual Consistency The project site is located in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District which has design guidelines for development. These guidelines are outlined in the Beaumont Village Design Guidelines for the City of Spartanburg Historic District Preservation Principles and Approaches . The purpose of the Guidelines is to provide property owners guidance for the preservation and protection of historic 4 of 61 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-07-11 Page 4 of 8 and architecturally valuable districts and sites in the City. The project is also subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation. This section allows the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. T he project site has a zoning designation of R -8 SFD, General Residential -Single- Family District, which allows for single family dwelling units. Section 510.6 of the City of Spa rtanburg Zoning Ordinance list standards for reviewing Certificate of Appropriateness. Specifically, Section 510.6 (C)(2) states that in reviewing applications for new construction or alteration, the board shall consider the U.S. Secretary of the Interior’ s Standards for Rehabilitation and the five criteria listed in the findings. T his item is appearing before the HARB due to section 510.10 Effect On Municipal and Public Utilities. All City departments and public utility companies shall be required to obtain approval from the Board in accordance with this Ordinance prior to widening or constructing streets or initiating any changes within the Historic Districts with regard to the character of street paving, sidewalks, parkways, trees, utility installation, lighting, walls, fences, structures, and buildings on property or easements owned or franchised by the City of Spartanburg or public utility companies. F indings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) a. T he character and appropriateness of the design – The project site is located approximately mid -block on Carlise Street. The applicant is seeking approval to install a new utility pole and a new small cell equipment along with components and hardware in the city right of way. The project does not involve housing construction of any type or housing repair. b. T he scale of the buildings – The scale of the building does not apply to this activity since it is in the city right of way. The utility pole and equipment would be visible from the street and would not have any effect on any existing structures. c. T he texture and materials – The texture and materials do not apply. The poles will be wood poles similar to the nearby streetlights and other utility poles in the neighborhood. d . The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings – There are other utility poles in the neighborhood including wood utility and light poles and metal light poles. This pole will be similar in nature but shorter than a regular utility pole and taller than the light pole with equipment attached to the pole. e . If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District – There is no indication that the character of the neighborhood would change due to the installation of the utility pole. Only two scattered site poles are proposed in the neighborhood in strategic locations. This pole location will be in the right of way between two properties. A pplicant: Brian Deye, Verizon Wireless. 5 of 61 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-07-11 Page 5 of 8 Ishmael Relkadi, Verizon Wireless. P ublic Speakers: Jarett Bond, 310 Hydrick St. Kathy Taylor, 495 Hampton Dr. Jenni & Jeremy Gilbert, 268 W Hampton Ave. Michael Arend, 551 Pinckney Ct. D iscussion: Having a cell tower in a Historic District seems very inappropriate. The proposed project will not be harmonious with the surrounding areas. A motion was made by Mr. Michels, seconded Mr. Olencki to deny the Certificate of Appropriateness as presented by a vote of 5-0. C ertificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 216 Carlisle Street (TMS: 7-12-14-186.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval to install a new utility pole, a new small cell equipment along with components and hardware. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single-Family District) zoning district. Owner/Applicant: Verizon Wireless / Brian Deye Contractor: Justin Sullens. P roject Description and History The project site is located approximately mid -block on Carlise Street between Hydrick street and the end of the cul-de-sac. The applicant is seeking to s seeking approval to install a new utility pole, a new small cell equipment along with components and hardware in the city right of way. The project does not involve housing construction of any type of housing activity. These small cell sites are designed to provide better cell service coverage in densely populated areas and can be seen in several areas in downtown Spartanburg. A nalysis Zoning Ordinance and Historic Design Manual Consistency The project site is located in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District which has design guidelines for development. These guidelines are outlined in the Beaumont Village Design Guidelines for the City of Spartanburg Historic District Preservation Principles and Approaches . The purpose of the Guidelines is to provide property owners guidance for the preservation and protection of historic and architecturally valuable districts and sites in the City. The project is also subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation. This section allows the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. T he project site has a zoning designation of R -8 SFD, General Residential -Single- Family District, which allows for single family dwelling units. Section 510.6 of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance list standards for reviewing Certificate of Appropriateness. Specifically, Section 510.6 (C)(2) states that in reviewing applications for new construction or alteration, the board shall consider the U.S. Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation and the five criteria listed in the findings. T his item is appearing before the HARB due to section 510.10 Effect On Municipal and Public Utilities. All City departments and public utility companies shall be required to obtain approval from the Board in accordance with this Ordinance prior to widening or constructing streets or initiating any changes within the Historic Districts with regard to the character of street paving, sidewalks, parkways, 6 of 61 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-07-11 Page 6 of 8 trees, utility installation, lighting, walls, fences, structures, and buildings on property or easements owned or franchised by the City of Spartanburg or public utility companies. F indings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) a. T he character and appropriateness of the design – The project site is located approximately mid -block on Carlise Street. The applicant is seeking approval to install a new utility pole and a new small cell equipment al ong with components and hardware in the city right of way. The project does not involve housing construction of any type or housing repair. b. T he scale of the buildings – The scale of the building does not apply to this activity since it is in the city right of way. The utility pole and equipment would be visible from the street and would not have any effect on any existing structures. c. T he texture and materials – The texture and materials does not apply. The poles will be wood poles similar to the nearby streetlights and other utility poles in the neighborhood. d . The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings – There are other utility poles in the neighborhood including wood utility poles and metal light poles. This pole will be similar in nature but shorter than a regular utility pole and taller than the light pole with equipment attached to the pole. e . If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District – There is no indication that the character of the neighborhood would change due to the installation of the utility pole. Only two scattered site poles are proposed in the neighborhood in strategic locations. This pole location will be in the right of way between two properties. A pplicant: Brian Deye, Verizon Wireless Ishmael Relkadi, Verizon Wireless. P ublic Speakers: Jenni & Jeremy Gilbert, 268 W Hampton Ave. D iscussion: Having a cell tower in a Historic District seems very inappropriate. The proposed project will not be harmonious with the surrounding areas. The proposed location of cell tower may be a safety hazard and obstruction of view for oncoming vehicles. A motion was made by Mr. Michels, seconded Mr. Olencki to deny the Certificate of Appropriateness as presented by a vote of 5-0. C ertificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 516 Peronneau St. (TMS # 7-16-02-120.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval to install paved driveway. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single- 7 of 61 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-07-11 Page 7 of 8 Family District) zoning district. Owner/Applicant: Matt Johnston and Kimberly Rostan; Contractor: Manello Construction Project Description and History The project site is an approximately 1.71 acre lot in the Hampton Heights Historic District. The site abuts Peronneau Street to the east boundary and South Hampton Drive to the south boundary. The lot currently contains one two-story single-family structure constructed in 1911. The house is a free classic Queen Anne house that has a cross-gabled, flared roof; the gable ends are clad in shingles and feature diamond-shaped windows. The front porch was restored during renovations in 2005, and based on evidence under the porch roof, the corner porch posts were doubled. The bay on the north side of the house has exposed brackets. The garage is original, though the doors had to be replaced using renovations. A previous owner purchased the house in 2000 and restored the exterior of the house and the garage and cleared the interior. The current owner purchased the house in 2008 and made some renovations to the interior of the house, including opening up the attic space for use, and have taken steps to secure LEED certification. The applicants request to replace the existing gravel driveway with a concrete driveway to match the existing concrete partial driveway. The current driveway is half concrete and half gravel. A nalysis Zoning Ordinance and Historic Design Manual Consistency The project site is in the Hampton Heights Historic District which has design guidelines to evaluate the appropriateness of proposed changes in local historic districts to protect the visual qualities of historic properties that reflect the history and heritage of that community. These guidelines are outlined in the Design Guidelines for the City of Spartanburg Historic Districts and Landmarks. The purpose of the Design Guidelines is to provide property owners guidance for the preservation and protection of historic and architecturally valuable districts and sites in the City. The project is also subject to Section 510 of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation . This section allows the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. F indings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) 1. T he character and appropriateness of the design H ampton Heights Design Guidelines – Landscape states that “……the established pattern of walks and drives within the district should be continued. Existing paving materials of concrete, asphalt, and brick should be repaired, where feasible. New surfaces should be compatible with these [concrete, asphalt, and brick] predominant materials. The use of driving lanes, designed to facilitate only the car’s wheels, is a historic treatment which is encouraged to retain porous surface. Parking should be located in the side yard and rear yard spaces and not extend beyond the front setback line of historic buildings. Plant materials and enclosures should be utilized for screening parking areas. Paving of parking areas should be accomplished without the loss of existing vegetation or the creation of large impervious surfaces. The use of porous pavers as a paving surface is encouraged. Parking should be addressed in a manner that does not distract from the overall character of the district. parking to serve private residential lots shall be accommodated on-site. It is preferable to expand an existing driveway for parking, rather than to add a separate parking pad. Plant materials can be added around parking spaces to visually buffer the parking from the street.” 8 of 61 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-07-11 Page 8 of 8 • T he proposed driveway is an extension of the existing concrete/cement driveway behind the public right of way. Existing planting vegetation is along the driveway. 2. T he scale of the buildings The scale of the primary building will not be affected. Replacing/installing a driveway will not affect the scale of the primary structure. 3. T he texture and materials The proposed material for the replacement of the gravel driveway will be concrete/cement. 4. T he relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings Currently, the immediate surrounding properties from the project site have either a pre -existing concrete driveway/pad or a two-strip concrete driveway in the front yard. 5. I f the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District Hampton Heights Design Guidelines clearly state the recommended placement and material of the driveway. The allowable driveway options presented in the design guideline include gravel/crushed stone driveway or a two-strip concrete driving lane. A pplicant: Matt Johnston, Owner. Frank Manello, Manello Construction. P ublic Speakers: None. D iscussion: NA. A motion was made by Mr. Michels, seconded Mr. Brown to table the Certificate of Appropriateness until next meeting. Board member Michael Pittillo, a physician, had to leave due to emergency medical call. The meeting lost quorum and deliberation ended. The case will move to the August meeting agenda as a continuation. T he meeting was adjourned at 7:34 PM. ______________________________ James Gaffney, Chairman 9 of 61 Page 2 of 16 PO Bo x 1749 • Spartanburg, SC 29304 • Phone: (864) 596-2068 • email: planning@cityofspartanburg.org website: www.cityofspartanburg.org TO: The Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review RE: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 516 Peronneau Street (TMS# 7- 16-02-120.00) in the Hampton Heights Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness to install paved driveway. The property is located in the R -8/SFD (General Residential - Single Family District). Owner / Applicant: Matt Johnston and Kimberly Rostan; Contractor: Manello Construction Date: August 8, 2024 Pr oject Description and History The project site is an approximately 1.71 acre lot in the Hampton Heights Historic District. The site abuts Peronneau Street to the east boundary and South Hampton Drive to the south boundary. The lot currently contains one two-story single-family structure constructed in 1911. The house is a free classic Queen Anne house that has a cross-gabled, flared roof; the gable ends are clad in shingles and feature diamond-shaped windows. The f ront porch was restored during renovations in 2005, and based on evidence under the porch roof, the corner porch posts were doubled. The bay on the north side of the house has exposed brackets. The garage is original, though the doors had to be replaced using renovations. A previous owner purchased the house in 2000 and restored the exterior of the house and the garage and cleared the interior. The current owner purchased the house in 2008 and made some renovations to the interior of the house, including opening up the attic space for use, and have taken steps to secure LEED certification. Th e applicants request to replace the existing gravel driveway with a concrete driveway to match the existing concrete partial driveway. The current driveway is half concrete and half gravel. Ana lysis Zoning Ordinance and Historic Design Manual Consistency The project site is in the Hampton Heights Historic District which has design guidelines to evaluate the appropriateness of proposed changes in local historic districts to protect the visual qualities of historic properties that reflect the history and heritage of that community. These guidelines are outlined in the Design Guidelines for the City of Spartanburg Historic Districts and Landmarks. The purpose of the Design Guidelines is to provide property owners guidance for the preservation and protection of historic and architecturally valuable districts and sites in the City. Planning Department 10 of 61 The p roject is also subject to Section 510 of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation. This section allows the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. RE VIEW UPDATE Following the July 11, 2024 HARB meeting City Planning Staff and Mr. Donnie Love, the City Historic Preservation Advisor, held two meetings to review site conditions and design options for the driveway and walkway. Mr. Love’s findings are detailed in the attached letter and provide the following guidance: Major vs Minor Work Clarification: The review of the guidelines clarifies the issue. The guidance provided in Section 10.2.3 is considered a recommendation a nd not a g uideline. At t he end o f S ection 5 , t he F o rma t for G uidelines defines a recommendation as “ being less c ritical to t he protection of the District but s till a d esirable process o r procedure to a dhere to wh en po ssible” o r a m inor work. I n t his c ase, s ince t he pr oposed driveway change i s i n the fr ont of the h ouse a nd c ontrary to t he r ecommendation, i t should be within the Board’s r esponsibility to re view. T ypically c hanges t o c haracter defining f eatures are n ot c onsidered minor works. The walk would be considered a minor work as it is less important than the drive. Driveway Treatment: While installing a full concrete driveway in place of the existing gravel is not appropriate, the proposal of driveway tracks combined with brick pavers could be considered as one alternative, extending the l ength of the drive until i t reaches the rear corner of the house whe re it could transition to all concrete. The applicant proposes like for like replacement of the existing concrete driveway apron. Walkway: The applicant proposes maintaining the original placement of the w alkway and incorporating concrete or floating pavers; based on review it would be considered a minor work as stated it is le ss imp ortant than the drive. The realignment of the walkway would be considered major work. Page 3 of 16 11 of 61 Page 4 of 16 Findings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) 1. The character and appropriateness of the design Hampton Heights Design Guidelines – Landscape states that “……the established pattern of walks and drives within the district should be continued. Existing paving materials of concrete, asphalt, and brick should be repaired, where feasible. New surfaces should be compatible with these [concrete, asphalt, and brick] predominant materials. The use of driving lanes, designed to facilitate only the car’s wheels, is a historic treatment which is encouraged to retain porous surface. Parking should be located in the side yard and rear yard spaces and not extend beyond the front setback line of historic buildings. Plant materials and enclosures should be utilized for screening parking areas. Paving of parking areas should be accomplished without the loss of existing vegetation or the creation of large impervious surfaces. The use of porous pavers as a paving surface is encouraged. Parking should be addressed in a manner that does not distract from the overall character of the district. parking to serve private residential lots shall be accommodated on -site. It is preferable to expand an existing driveway for parking, rather than to add a separate parking pad. Plant materials can be added around parking spaces to visually buffer the parking from the street.” • The proposed driveway is an extension of the existing concrete/cement driveway behind the public right of way. Existing planting vegetation is along the driveway. 2. Th e scale of the buildings The scale of the primary building will not be affected. Replacing/installing a driveway will not affect the scale of the primary structure. 3. The texture and materials The proposed material for the replacement of the gravel driveway will be concrete/cement. 4. Th e relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings Currently, the immediate surrounding properties from the project site have either a pre-existing concrete driveway/pad or a two-strip concrete driveway in the front yard. 5. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District Hampton Heights Design Guidelines clearly state the recommended placement and material of the driveway. The allowable driveway options presented in the design guideline s include gravel/crushed stone driveway or a two-strip concrete driving lane. S ubmitted by: N an Zhou, AICP City Planner II City of S partanburg Planning Department Attachments: Guideline Review Letter Conditions of Approval Application Photos – Site Photos Supporting Documents from the Applicant 12 of 61 DONALD L. LOVE JR, ARCHITECT , AIA 608 Otis Boulevard, Spartanburg, SC · 864.415.0459 lovejrd@gmail.com August 1, 2024 Fredalyn Frasier City of Spartanburg Planning Director Re: 516 Peronneau Street Dear Ms. Frasier, As a follow up to our meeting July 25, 2024, at 516 Peronneau Street in the Hampton Heights Historic District, I have reviewed the Guidelines for the Historic District as they apply to new walks and driveways in general, and whether the work should be considered a major or a minor work. On June 18, 2024, I provided a recommendation responding to the applicant’s request to install a concrete driveway to replace the existing gravel driveway that runs from the street to the rear yard. The issue was discussed at the July HARB meeting, but a final decision was not made. Last week, the property owners requested a meeting onsite so that they could provide additional information. Design drawings were provided for review at the meeting. The Guidelines reference walks and drives in Section 3.2.2 “Streetscape Characteristics and Materials” which states “All of these walks are constructed of concrete with brick occasionally used as an accent material” and “Drives are constructed of concrete as well as unpaved with gravel. Driveway tracks, narrow paved strips that allow a paved surface for wheels with open space in between, are also common”. Section 10.2.3 “Walks and Drives” states “Existing paving materials of concrete asphalt and brick should be repaired where feasible. New surfaces should be compatible with these predominate materials. The use of driving lanes, designed to facilitate only the car’s wheels, is a historic treatment which is encouraged to retain porous surfaces.” The adjacent example photograph also states that “driveway tracks or driving lanes, (are) a historic treatment that should be retained.” At the meeting July 25, 2024, we discussed options for the driveway and the walkway as well as whether or not either should be considered a major work. Review of the guidelines clarifies the issue. The guidance provided in Section 10.2.3 is considered a recommendation and not a guideline. At the end of Section 5, the Format for Guidelines defines a recommendation as “being less critical to the protection of the District but still a desirable process or procedure to adhere to when possible” or a minor work. In this case, since the proposed driveway change is in the front of the house and contrary to the recommendation, it should be within the Board’s responsibility to review. Typically changes to character defining features are not considered minor works. The walk would be considered a minor work as it is less important than the drive. As previously stated, installing a full concrete driveway in place of the existing gravel is not appropriate, however, driveway tracks combined with brick pavers could be considered as one alternative, extending the length of the drive until it reaches the rear corner of the house where it could transition to all concrete. Please let me know if you have any questions or require any additional information. Regards, Donald L. Love, Jr, Architect, AIA 13 of 61 Page 6 of 16 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL 516 Peronneau Street (TMS# 7-16-02-120.00) - Hampton Heights Historic District Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works 1. If one or more of the following conditions is not met with respect to all its terms, then this approval may be revoked. 2. Design must meet the Hampton Heights Historic District residential design guidelines. 3. All plans for future construction which are not covered by this review shall be submitted to the City Planning Department for review and approval. 4. Major modifications to plans or exceptions to completion may be granted only by the City authority which approved the project. 5. This permit shall be exercised within six months of the date of final approval, or it shall become null and void. Extensions may be granted with permission of the Board. 6. A building permit shall be obtained from the Building Department prior to commencement of work. 7. The development of the site shall be in substantial accordance with the approved plans submitted and on file in the Spartanburg City Planning Department. 14 of 61 Page 7 of 16 SITE MAP – 516 Peronneau Street 15 of 61 Page 8 of 16 Zoning Map – 516 Peronneau Street 16 of 61 Front of Property Page 9 of 16 17 of 61 Left Side of Property Page 10 of 18 of 61 Right Side of Property Page 11 of 19 of 61 Properties to the Right Side of the Project Site Page 12 of 20 of 61 Property Directly Across from the Project Site Page 13 of 16 21 of 61 Property in the Immediate Surrounding of the Project Site Page 14 of 16 22 of 61 Property in the Immediate Surrounding of the Project Site Page 15 of 16 23 of 61 Property in the Immediate Surrounding of the Project Site Page 16 of 16 24 of 61 Property to the Left Side of the Project Site Page 17 of 16 25 of 61 UPDATED 8/6/24 Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) Supplemental Materials Description of Proposed work [same text from Certificate of Appropriateness form] [1]Drivewayapron—Top25’adjacenttosidewalkiscurrentlyconcrete.Weareproposinga like-for-likereplacementtofixdamage. [2]Middlesection—Thissingle-lanesectionofdrivewayiscurrentlynon-original,non-porous gravel.Forthisportionofthedrivewaymostvisiblefromthestreet,weareproposingahistoric treatmentoftwotirestripswithapermeablepavercentersection.Tomanagestormwaterthe drivewaywouldbeboundedbysmall,historiccementswaleswithintegratedcurbsoneither side. [3]Endsection—Thisareabetweenthehouseandgarageincludesspacesfor2carstopark withroomforbothtoturnaround.Thissectioniscurrentlynon-original,non-porousgravel.We wouldliketoconvertthistocementwithextensivedrainstomanagestormwaterproblems. [4]Curvedfrontwalkway—Thissectioniscurrentlynon-original,non-porousgravel. Wewould liketoconvertthistonon-grouted,floatingflagstonewithaddeddrainstomanagestormwater. SatelliteviewfromGoogleMapsshowingroughsectionoutlines. Proposedworkwoulddirectly mirrortheadjacentdriveway,whichwasfullypouredwithconcreteseveralyearsago. 26 of 61 6" CONCRETE DRIVE LIGHT BROOM FINISH W/ INDUSTRIAL FIBER MESH, MIN. 3,000 PSI FINISH GRADE 95% COMPACTED SUBGRADE 6" CONCRETE DRIVE LIGHT BROOM FINISH W/ INDUSTRIAL FIBER MESH, MIN. 3,000 PSI FINISH GRADE 12", #4 REBAR W/ SLEEVE @ 24" O.C. 1/2" EXPANSION JT. EXISTING CONCRETE DRIVEWAY DOWEL SECTION P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P PP PP PERONNEAUST.-(PAVED) 10' 4' UP -3.75 -7.45 -7.75 0 -2 Filename:F:\Projects\19081\19081-00\Pdata\MK-Site and Drainage.dwg Plot Time:7/31/2024 12:38:25 PM SHEET TITLE: SHEET OF DATE:REVISIONS: DRAWN: APPROVED: JOB #: This drawing is the property of The LandArt Design Group, Inc. and contains proprietary information furnished with the understanding that it is not to be modified, copied, reproduced or used by others except as required for this specific project without written authorization by The LandArt Design Group, Inc. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. MATT JOHNSTON & KIM ROSTAN RESIDENCE 516 PERONNEAU STREET SPARTANBURG COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA SITE AND DRAINAGE PLAN SITE AND DRAINAGE PLAN 19081-00 01/19/23 EV TP REV. PER OWNERS COMMENTS 04/12/23 REV. PER OWNERS COMMENTS 04/27/23 REV. PER OWNER MEETING 05/10/23 REV. PER OWNER COMMENTS 05/17/23 REV. PER OWNER COMMENTS 07/06/23 REV. PER OWNER COMMENTS 07/24/24 L1 L1 NOTE: THE BASE INFORMATION FOR THIS DRAWING HAS BEEN COMPILED FROM A VARIETY OF SOURCES AT VARIOUS TIMES AND AS SUCH IS INTENDED TO BE USED ONLY AS A CONCEPTUAL GUIDE. ALL PROPERTY LINES, TRACT DIMENSIONS AND DESCRIPTIONS ARE FOR GRAPHIC PURPOSES ONLY, AS AN AID TO SITE LOCATION AND POSSIBLE POTENTIAL LAND USE. ANY PERSON DESIRING TO DETERMINE ACTUAL COMMITMENTS SHOULD EXAMINE THE APPROPRIATE PLATS, DEED RESTRICTIONS, COVENANTS, AND PLANNING AND ZONING REGULATIONS APPLICABLE TO SPECIFIC PORTIONS OF THE PROPERTY. ® YOU ARE REQUIRED TO CALL AT LEAST 3 WORKING DAYS BEFORE YOU DIG http://www.call811.com/ Know what'sbelow. Callbefore you dig. SCALE: 1" = 8' 1OVERALL PLAN L1 SYMBOLMANUFACTURER/MODEL/DESCRIPTIONQTY FX LUMINAIRE CC7 SMALL SCALE UP LIGHT USED FOR SMALL SCALE ELEMENTS. 5.9IN. L X 1.6IN. D STRAIGHT SHROUD. ORDER CODE: CC, BRASS, (AB) ANTIQUE BRONZE, 3-PRONG SPIKE LAMP: CC-1LED, 2W|2.4VA, 2700K, BEAMSPREAD: SPOT LIGHTING SCHEDULE 03 CONCRETE SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY NEW BROOM FINISHED CONCRETE DRIVEWAY 2,215 SF 32 EXTERIOR IMPROVEMENTS SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY TRIPLE HAMMERED HARDWOOD MULCH (3" THICK) 2.71 CY IPE DECK202 SF IPE DECK LANDING74 SF HANDRAIL34 LF CORTEN EDGING48 LF CURB SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY 6" CURB265 LF DRAINAGE SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY 18"X18" SQUARE DRAIN5 TRENCH DRAIN73 LF 12" DRAIN PIPE315 LF 6" DRAIN PIPE684 LF ROCK SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY WHITE RIVER ROCK - 1-3" SIZE477 SF FLAGSTONE WALKWAY349 SF PAVING SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY 2'X2' FIREROCK PAVERS (COLOR: OYSTER)762 SF TECHO-BLOC, INC. MIKA 03 (PERMEABLE)240 SF 90° HERRINGBONE PATTERN SITE FURNISHINGS SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTYMANUFACTURER LOLL DESIGN - JUT 18 PLANTER3 LOLL DESIGN - SLOPE 24 PLANTER2 LOLL DESIGN - SQUARE 24 PLANTER2 LOLL DESIGN - JUT 24 PLANTER2 LOLL DESIGN - SLOPE 18 PLANTER1 WALL SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY 52" HGT. STUCCO WALL25 LF 48" HGT. STUCCO PLANTER (HEIGHT OF DECK) 21 LF 03-01 32-01 32-03 32-04 32-05 32-06 C-101 DR-101 DR-102 DR-105 DR-106 K-102 K-103 P-101 P-105 S-101 S-102 S-103 S-104 S-105 W-101 W-102 REFERENCE NOTES SCHEDULE SCALE: 1/8" = 1'-0" 26" CONCRETE DRIVE DETAIL L1 SYMBOLCODEQTYBOTANICAL / COMMON NAMECONTSIZE TREES ACE RYU 1ACER PALMATUM `RYUSEN` / RYUSEN JAPANESE MAPLEB & B 7-8` ACE SEI 1ACER PALMATUM `SEIRYU` / SEIRYU JAPANESE MAPLE30 GAL CHA FRG 2CHAMAECYPARIS OBTUSA `FERNSPRAY` / FERNSPRAY HINOKI FALSE CYPRESS15 GAL SYMBOLCODEQTYBOTANICAL / COMMON NAMECONT SHRUBS JUN ALG 3JUNIPERUS RIGIDA `ALL GOLD` / SHORE JUNIPER5 GAL JUN BL72JUNIPERUS SQUAMATA 'BLUE STAR' / BLUE STAR JUNIPER5 GAL MUH CAP 5MUHLENBERGIA CAPILLARIS / PINK MUHLY GRASS3 GAL MUH WHC 4MUHLENBERGIA CAPILLARIS `WHITE CLOUD` / WHITE MUHLY GRASS3 GAL POD MAC2PODOCARPUS MACROPHYLLUS / YEW PINE15 GAL GROUND COVERS ZOY ZEO5,537 SF ZOYSIA X ZEON® / ZEON® ZOYSIASOD PLANT SCHEDULE 6" CONCRETE DRIVE DETAIL2 L1 PERMEABLE PAVER DETAIL3 L1 No. 178 The LandArt Design Group, Inc. No. 850 0 SCALE: feet 81624 1" = 8' 03-01 C-101 03-01 C-101 C-101 DR-101 DR-101 C-101 DR-101 K-103 DR-102 DR-102 DR-101 P-105 03-01 03-01 30 gal - 1 ACE SEI FLOWERBED FLOWERBED EX. VEGETATION EX. VEGETATION DR-101 32-01 32-01 5 gal - 2 JUN BL7 B & B - 1 ACE RYU DR-102K-102 15 gal - 2 POD MAC 12" SWALE 12" SWALE SCALE: N.T.S. 3PERMEABLE PAVER DETAIL L1 C-101 27 of 61 1 Flooding and stormwater management Theoriginallayoutofourneighborhoodheavilyrevolvedaroundthewaterwaysandtributaries… oneofwhichismentionedin3.2.1oftheGuidelinesandrunsdirectlythroughourbackyard. Theapproximatelocationofthetributaryinourbackyardissketchedinred. Duringheavyrains,wegetextensivestormwaterflowingthroughouryardasseeninthebelow videos. Withoutourintervention,thisstormwaterhasthreeverynegativeimpactstothe neighborhood.1)Waterentersourhistoricstructure,causingthesectionofhouseclosesttothe drivewaytosubsideconsiderably,2)thehistoricgaragestructurecontinuallyfloods,and3)a largeportionoftherainsrunsoffthesideyardjeopardizingourneighbor’sstructure. Videoshowingfloodingatfrontofhouse https://drive.google.com/file/d/17SLugmq6tJHBTheIwDJQP81PzH03NCyR/view?usp=sharing Videoshowingfloodingalongsideandinbackofhouse https://drive.google.com/file/d/17N-WqFCIarXOPoLcVQJ7SBmJv9UztRAs/view?usp=sharing 28 of 61 2 Withoutourintervention,afterwashingthroughandnearthehistoricstructures,whichhas resultedinflooding,propertydamageandasubsidedfoundation,thestormwateralleventually flowsdowntothehistorictributarybetweenIrwinandPeronneauStreets. HistoricpreservationisbrokendownintoseveralstepsintheGuidelines(pg.54).Beforeeven attempting rehabilitationor restoration,thefirststepis stabilization.The4requestsinthis proposalalladdress stabilizationofhistoricstructures(house,garage,andneighboring properties). 29 of 61 3 Tostopstormwaterfromdestabilizingourhistoricstructures,westrategicallylocatedlarge drainsaroundthehouseandatthebaseofthedriveway,trenchedthemhundredsoffeet throughyard(inblue),terminatingallthewaydownintothemainwatertributary(inred)atthe backofourproperty. Roughsketchofdrainagepipesburieddeepintheyard,terminatinginthetributaryattheback ofourproperty. 30 of 61 4 Architectural plan for proposed major work Closeupswillbeshownintheindividualproposalsforeachsectionofdrivewaybelow. Please seeseparatePDFforahigherresolutionversionofthisplan. 31 of 61 5 Description of Proposed work – Additional Materials and Photos. [1] Driveway apron — Top 25’ adjacent to sidewalk is currently concrete. We are proposing a like-for-like replacement to fix the damaged concrete. Section 10.2.3 “Walks and Drives” states “Existing paving materials of concrete asphalt and brick should be repaired where feasible. Section10.2.3oftheGuidelinestitled“WalksandDrives”states,“Existingpavingmaterialsof concreteasphaltandbrickshouldberepairedwherefeasible.” Close-upofarchitecturalplandetailingrepairstoexistingcementapronsection. Viewfromstreetdownthedriveway. 32 of 61 6 Viewoftopsectionlookingtowardsstreet. Closeupofoneofthedamagedareas. Wewouldalsoliketowidenthisconcretepadbya2 feet.DeliverytruckslikeAmazonandUPSwouldalwaysrunoffthesideofthedriveway,which iswhyiteventuallyerodedandbroke.Iaddedafewrowsofredbricktostabilize,butwewould likeamorepermanentsolution. 33 of 61 7 [2] Middle section — This single-lane section of driveway is currently non-original, non-porous gravel. For this portion of the driveway most visible from the street, we are proposing a historic treatment of two tire strips with a permeable paver center section. To manage stormwater the driveway would be bounded by small, historic cement swales with integrated curbs on either side. Theportionofourhistoricstructureboardingthissectionofdrivewayhasalreadybadly subsided(morethan6”). InouroriginalpresentationtoHARBonJuly11th,weproposedthis sectionofdrivewaytobeallconcretetoguidestormwaterpastourstill-sinkingstructure. I 34 of 61 8 TheJuly11thmeetingwascutshortduetotime,butnotbeforeoneoftheboardmembers proposedswitchingthissingle-lanesectiontotwotirestripswithacentralpaversection. Based onthisinput,wearrangedanin-personmeetingatthepropertyattendedbyFredalynFrasier andNanZhoufromthecityandDonnieLove,whoisanadvisortothecity,onThursday,July 25th.Workingtogetherwefoundasolutionwhichshouldbothprotectthestructureandfollow therecommendedhistoricguidelines. Ourproposalforthismiddlesectionofthedriveway incorporatestheseelements: ● Twotirestrips–Section10.2.3oftheGuidelinestitled“WalksandDrives”states,“The useofdrivinglanes,designedtofacilitateonlythecar’swheels,isahistorictreatment whichisencouragedtoretainporoussurfaces.” ● Permeablepavers–Thecentersectionbetweenthetirestripswouldbeconstructedofa permeablebasedwithspecializedpermeablepaverstoallowforsomeporousnessas recommendedinSection10.2.3oftheGuidelinesabove. ● Smallswalesoneithersideofthedriveway–thisisahistorictreatmentfound throughouttheneighborhood,oftenborderingdrivewaysandwalkways.Inourcase, thesesmall,shallowswaleswillguidestormwaterpasttheatriskhistoricstructure. ● Integratedcurbs–Duringthehardestrainstormslikethosepicturedinthevideosabove, thesecurbswillhelpcontainanystormwaterthatoverwhelmsthesmallswales. Close-upofarchitecturalplandetailingsingle-lanesectionthatwillreceivehistorictwotire-strip solutionwithpermeablepaversinthecenterarea. 35 of 61 9 Detailofpermeablepaverinstallationtoallowsomelevelofporousness. 36 of 61 10 [3] End section — This area between the house and garage includes spaces for 2 cars to park with room for both to turn around. This section is currently non-original, non-porous gravel. We would like to convert this to cement with extensive drains to manage stormwater problems. Inthatbacksectionofdriveway[3]wearepreppedforatrenchdraininfrontofthegarage,a smallerdrainnearthestuccowall,andacentral12”catchbasintomanagestormwaterrunoff. Viewofbacksectionofdrivewayfacingnorthwest. 37 of 61 11 WeconductedaninformalsurveyofhouseswithgaragesinHamptonHeightstoidentifythe predominantmaterialsusedfordrivewaysintheneighborhood. HOUSES WITH 2-CAR GARAGES Totalof[13]2-cargarages(bothhistoric garagesandmoremodernstructures) ● [9]all-cementdriveways–69% ● [2]blacktop–15% ● [1]gravel–8% ● [1]mixof2-tirestrips+largecement slabinfrontofgarage–8% Totalof[7] ORIGINAL2-cargarages ● [5]all-cement–71% ● [1]blacktop–14% ● [1]gravel–14% LIST OF HOUSES WITH 2-CAR GARAGES ● 508PeronneauSt—original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 189SHamptonDr. —originalattached2-cargarage,allcement driveway. ● 546PinckneyCourt —original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 592S.IrwinAve. —2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 539S.IrwinAve. —2-cargarage,cement,apronallblacktop driveway. ● 509S.IrwinAve. —original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 266HamptonCourt —original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 175WHamptonDr—non-original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 251WHamptonDr.(Ringo)—newlybuilt2-cargarage,cement apron,twotirestripsalongthehouse,fullcementpadinfrontofnew garagewithturnaroundspace. ● 245W.HamptonAve. —original2-cargarage,cement,apronall graveldriveway. ● 276SouthSpringSt. —original2-cargarage,convertedtoauxiliary dwelling,cementapron,allblacktopdriveway. ● 259HydrickSt. —newlyconstructed2-cargarage,allcement driveway. ● 277HydrickSt.—non-original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. HOUSES WITH 1-CAR GARAGES Totalof[12]1-cargarages ● [4]all-cementdriveways–33% ● [3]blacktop–25% ● [2]gravel–17% ● [1]paver–8% ● [1]2-tirestripswithfullcementpadin frontofgarage–8% ● [1]cementapronandallcementnear house,switchingto2-tirestripsinthe waybackbehindhouse–8% LIST OF HOUSES WITH 1-CAR GARAGES ● 503PeronneauSt—Newlybuilt1-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 510HamptonDr—original/old1-cargarage,cementapron,allpaver driveway. ● 551PinkneyCourt—original1-cargarage,cementapron,allblacktop driveway. ● 598S.IrwinAve. —large/non-originalbarnwith1garagedoor, cementapron,allgraveldriveway. ● 589S.IrwinAve. —original1-cargarage,cementapron,allgravel driveway. ● 498S.IrwinAve. —original1-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 476S.IrwinAve. —original1-cargarage,cementapron,allblacktop driveway. ● 200W.HamptonAve.—original1-cargarage/barn,cement,apron,all graveldriveway. ● 182W.HamptonAve.—original1-cargarage,cement,apronandfull cementdrivealongyardandhouse,switchesto2stripsintheway back,leadinguptothesinglecargarage. ● 286SouthSpringSt.—original1-cargarage,convertedtoashed, cementapron,twotirestripes,endingwithfullcementpadinfrontof garage/shed. ● 280SouthSpringSt.—original1-cargarage,cement,apronall blacktopdriveway. ● 283HydrickSt. —non-original1-cargarage,allcementdriveway. Tosummarizetheresultsabove: ● All2-cargaragesintheneighborhoodhadasolidsurfaceinfrontofthegarage. ● CementisbyfarthepredominantmaterialusedfordrivewaysinHamptonHeights. ● Therearenohistoricexamplesof2-tirestripdrivewaysdirectlyinfrontof2-cargarages. 38 of 61 12 [4] Curved front walkway — This section is currently non-original, non-porous gravel. We would like to convert this to non-grouted, floating flagstone with added drains to manage stormwater. THIS PART OF OUR PROJECT WAS RECLASSIFIED AS MINOR WORK 8/6/24 AND HENCE REMOVED FROM THIS PROPOSAL. 39 of 61 13 SUPPORTING MATERIALS Forhouseswithgarages,cementisbyfarthepredominantmaterialusedfordrivewaysin HamptonHeights. Section3.2.2specificallylistsconcrete1stwhendiscussingtheprofileofthehousesin HamptonHeights,implyingthatitisnotonlyappropriateandoriginalfortheneighborhood,but alsothepredominantmaterialused;thisdescriptioncorrelateswiththedataregarding prevalenceofconcreteonpage11. 40 of 61 14 Section5.3Step3abovehighlydiscouragesusinghistoricmaterials/styleswheretheydidnot originallyexist. 41 of 61 15 Thereisnorecordofourdrivewayoriginallybeingcement,gravel,orhavingthe2-tirestrips. Section10.2.3title“WalksandDrives”,specificallystatesthat,“Newsurfacesshouldbe compatiblewiththesepredominantmaterials.”Whentakingallthesefactorsand recommendationsintoaccount,webelievethemostappropriatesolutionwouldbecementas thatisbyfarthepredominantdrivewaymaterialusedforhousesinHamptonHeightswith garages. 42 of 61 Planning Department PO Box 1749 • Spartanburg, SC 29304 • phone: (864) 596-2068 • email: planning@cityofspartanburg.org website: www.cityofspartanburg.org Staff Use Only / Received by: _____________________ Date Received: _________________ Time: ____________ Permit Number: ________________________ Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) Historic Properties Owner: _________________________________________ Phone: __________________________ Address: ________________________________________ Email: _____________________________ City: _____________________________ State: __________________________ Zip: _________________ Applicant: _______________________________________ Phone: ____________________________ Address: ________________________________________ Email: _____________________________ City: _____________________________ State: __________________________ Zip: _________________ Contractor: ________________________________________ Phone: ____________________________ Address: ________________________________________ Email: _____________________________ City: _____________________________ State: __________________________ Zip: _________________ Address of Property: ________________________________________________________________________ Tax Map Number: __________________________________ Zoning District ___________________ Please select the activity requested: Alteration of Structure/Property New Construction on Vacant Lot Repair of Structure/Property Demolition of Structure Addition to Existing Structure Other Fees and Payments can be made using the Permit Number and the City of Spartanburg Payment Portal. To the best of my knowledge, the information on this application and all additional documentation is true, factual and complete. I hereby agree to abide by all conditions of any approvals granted by the City of Spartanburg. I understand that such conditions shall apply to the subject property only and are a right or obligation transferable by sale. I hereby authorize the staff of the Planning Department to inspect the premises of the above-described property. Applicant: Signature: __________________________ Date: _________________________ 43 of 61 Planning Department PO Box 1749 • Spartanburg, SC 29304 • phone: (864) 596-2068 • email: planning@cityofspartanburg.org website: www.cityofspartanburg.org Staff Use Only: Received by: _____________________ ____ MCOA - Minor _____ COA - Major Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) Additional Items Please attach to this Application nay of the applicable items: Site Plans or Surveys Detail Drawing(s), Floor Plans(s) or Sketch(es) Photographs of Existing property Material(s) and Sample(s) Photographs of Changes requested Other Description of Proposed work (attach extra sheets as needed): Please read and initial the following statements: ______ I am the owner of the property, or ______ I am acting on behalf of the owner(s) of this property and have attached a letter from the owner(s) indicating their knowledge of this application. ______ The information on this application represents an accurate description of the proposed work. ______ I have omitted nothing that might affect the decision of the Historic Architect Review Board. ______ I will attend (or send a representative to attend) the public hearing of this application before the Historic Architect Review Board. ______ I understand that issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness is not an authorization to begin work. 44 of 61 6" CONCRETE DRIVE LIGHT BROOM FINISH W/ INDUSTRIAL FIBER MESH, MIN. 3,000 PSI FINISH GRADE 95% COMPACTED SUBGRADE 6" CONCRETE DRIVE LIGHT BROOM FINISH W/ INDUSTRIAL FIBER MESH, MIN. 3,000 PSI FINISH GRADE 12", #4 REBAR W/ SLEEVE @ 24" O.C. 1/2" EXPANSION JT. EXISTING CONCRETE DRIVEWAY DOWEL SECTION P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P PP PP PERONNEAUST.-(PAVED) 10' 4' UP -3.75 -7.45 -7.75 0 -2 Filename:F:\Projects\19081\19081-00\Pdata\MK-Site and Drainage.dwg Plot Time:7/31/2024 12:38:25 PM SHEET TITLE: SHEET OF DATE:REVISIONS: DRAWN: APPROVED: JOB #: This drawing is the property of The LandArt Design Group, Inc. and contains proprietary information furnished with the understanding that it is not to be modified, copied, reproduced or used by others except as required for this specific project without written authorization by The LandArt Design Group, Inc. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. MATT JOHNSTON & KIM ROSTAN RESIDENCE 516 PERONNEAU STREET SPARTANBURG COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA SITE AND DRAINAGE PLAN SITE AND DRAINAGE PLAN 19081-00 01/19/23 EV TP REV. PER OWNERS COMMENTS 04/12/23 REV. PER OWNERS COMMENTS 04/27/23 REV. PER OWNER MEETING 05/10/23 REV. PER OWNER COMMENTS 05/17/23 REV. PER OWNER COMMENTS 07/06/23 REV. PER OWNER COMMENTS 07/24/24 L1 L1 NOTE: THE BASE INFORMATION FOR THIS DRAWING HAS BEEN COMPILED FROM A VARIETY OF SOURCES AT VARIOUS TIMES AND AS SUCH IS INTENDED TO BE USED ONLY AS A CONCEPTUAL GUIDE. ALL PROPERTY LINES, TRACT DIMENSIONS AND DESCRIPTIONS ARE FOR GRAPHIC PURPOSES ONLY, AS AN AID TO SITE LOCATION AND POSSIBLE POTENTIAL LAND USE. ANY PERSON DESIRING TO DETERMINE ACTUAL COMMITMENTS SHOULD EXAMINE THE APPROPRIATE PLATS, DEED RESTRICTIONS, COVENANTS, AND PLANNING AND ZONING REGULATIONS APPLICABLE TO SPECIFIC PORTIONS OF THE PROPERTY. ® YOU ARE REQUIRED TO CALL AT LEAST 3 WORKING DAYS BEFORE YOU DIG http://www.call811.com/ Know what'sbelow. Callbefore you dig. SCALE: 1" = 8' 1OVERALL PLAN L1 SYMBOLMANUFACTURER/MODEL/DESCRIPTIONQTY FX LUMINAIRE CC7 SMALL SCALE UP LIGHT USED FOR SMALL SCALE ELEMENTS. 5.9IN. L X 1.6IN. D STRAIGHT SHROUD. ORDER CODE: CC, BRASS, (AB) ANTIQUE BRONZE, 3-PRONG SPIKE LAMP: CC-1LED, 2W|2.4VA, 2700K, BEAMSPREAD: SPOT LIGHTING SCHEDULE 03 CONCRETE SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY NEW BROOM FINISHED CONCRETE DRIVEWAY 2,215 SF 32 EXTERIOR IMPROVEMENTS SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY TRIPLE HAMMERED HARDWOOD MULCH (3" THICK) 2.71 CY IPE DECK202 SF IPE DECK LANDING74 SF HANDRAIL34 LF CORTEN EDGING48 LF CURB SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY 6" CURB265 LF DRAINAGE SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY 18"X18" SQUARE DRAIN5 TRENCH DRAIN73 LF 12" DRAIN PIPE315 LF 6" DRAIN PIPE684 LF ROCK SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY WHITE RIVER ROCK - 1-3" SIZE477 SF FLAGSTONE WALKWAY349 SF PAVING SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY 2'X2' FIREROCK PAVERS (COLOR: OYSTER)762 SF TECHO-BLOC, INC. MIKA 03 (PERMEABLE)240 SF 90° HERRINGBONE PATTERN SITE FURNISHINGS SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTYMANUFACTURER LOLL DESIGN - JUT 18 PLANTER3 LOLL DESIGN - SLOPE 24 PLANTER2 LOLL DESIGN - SQUARE 24 PLANTER2 LOLL DESIGN - JUT 24 PLANTER2 LOLL DESIGN - SLOPE 18 PLANTER1 WALL SYMBOLDESCRIPTIONQTY 52" HGT. STUCCO WALL25 LF 48" HGT. STUCCO PLANTER (HEIGHT OF DECK) 21 LF 03-01 32-01 32-03 32-04 32-05 32-06 C-101 DR-101 DR-102 DR-105 DR-106 K-102 K-103 P-101 P-105 S-101 S-102 S-103 S-104 S-105 W-101 W-102 REFERENCE NOTES SCHEDULE SCALE: 1/8" = 1'-0" 26" CONCRETE DRIVE DETAIL L1 SYMBOLCODEQTYBOTANICAL / COMMON NAMECONTSIZE TREES ACE RYU 1ACER PALMATUM `RYUSEN` / RYUSEN JAPANESE MAPLEB & B 7-8` ACE SEI 1ACER PALMATUM `SEIRYU` / SEIRYU JAPANESE MAPLE30 GAL CHA FRG 2CHAMAECYPARIS OBTUSA `FERNSPRAY` / FERNSPRAY HINOKI FALSE CYPRESS15 GAL SYMBOLCODEQTYBOTANICAL / COMMON NAMECONT SHRUBS JUN ALG 3JUNIPERUS RIGIDA `ALL GOLD` / SHORE JUNIPER5 GAL JUN BL72JUNIPERUS SQUAMATA 'BLUE STAR' / BLUE STAR JUNIPER5 GAL MUH CAP 5MUHLENBERGIA CAPILLARIS / PINK MUHLY GRASS3 GAL MUH WHC 4MUHLENBERGIA CAPILLARIS `WHITE CLOUD` / WHITE MUHLY GRASS3 GAL POD MAC2PODOCARPUS MACROPHYLLUS / YEW PINE15 GAL GROUND COVERS ZOY ZEO5,537 SF ZOYSIA X ZEON® / ZEON® ZOYSIASOD PLANT SCHEDULE 6" CONCRETE DRIVE DETAIL2 L1 PERMEABLE PAVER DETAIL3 L1 No. 178 The LandArt Design Group, Inc. No. 850 0 SCALE: feet 81624 1" = 8' 03-01 C-101 03-01 C-101 C-101 DR-101 DR-101 C-101 DR-101 K-103 DR-102 DR-102 DR-101 P-105 03-01 03-01 30 gal - 1 ACE SEI FLOWERBED FLOWERBED EX. VEGETATION EX. VEGETATION DR-101 32-01 32-01 5 gal - 2 JUN BL7 B & B - 1 ACE RYU DR-102K-102 15 gal - 2 POD MAC 12" SWALE 12" SWALE SCALE: N.T.S. 3PERMEABLE PAVER DETAIL L1 C-101 45 of 61 UPDATED 8/6/24 Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) Supplemental Materials Description of Proposed work [same text from Certificate of Appropriateness form] [1]Drivewayapron—Top25’adjacenttosidewalkiscurrentlyconcrete.Weareproposinga like-for-likereplacementtofixdamage. [2]Middlesection—Thissingle-lanesectionofdrivewayiscurrentlynon-original,non-porous gravel.Forthisportionofthedrivewaymostvisiblefromthestreet,weareproposingahistoric treatmentoftwotirestripswithapermeablepavercentersection.Tomanagestormwaterthe drivewaywouldbeboundedbysmall,historiccementswaleswithintegratedcurbsoneither side. [3]Endsection—Thisareabetweenthehouseandgarageincludesspacesfor2carstopark withroomforbothtoturnaround.Thissectioniscurrentlynon-original,non-porousgravel.We wouldliketoconvertthistocementwithextensivedrainstomanagestormwaterproblems. [4]Curvedfrontwalkway—Thissectioniscurrentlynon-original,non-porousgravel. Wewould liketoconvertthistonon-grouted,floatingflagstonewithaddeddrainstomanagestormwater. SatelliteviewfromGoogleMapsshowingroughsectionoutlines. Proposedworkwoulddirectly mirrortheadjacentdriveway,whichwasfullypouredwithconcreteseveralyearsago. 46 of 61 1 Flooding and stormwater management Theoriginallayoutofourneighborhoodheavilyrevolvedaroundthewaterwaysandtributaries… oneofwhichismentionedin3.2.1oftheGuidelinesandrunsdirectlythroughourbackyard. Theapproximatelocationofthetributaryinourbackyardissketchedinred. Duringheavyrains,wegetextensivestormwaterflowingthroughouryardasseeninthebelow videos. Withoutourintervention,thisstormwaterhasthreeverynegativeimpactstothe neighborhood.1)Waterentersourhistoricstructure,causingthesectionofhouseclosesttothe drivewaytosubsideconsiderably,2)thehistoricgaragestructurecontinuallyfloods,and3)a largeportionoftherainsrunsoffthesideyardjeopardizingourneighbor’sstructure. Videoshowingfloodingatfrontofhouse https://drive.google.com/file/d/17SLugmq6tJHBTheIwDJQP81PzH03NCyR/view?usp=sharing Videoshowingfloodingalongsideandinbackofhouse https://drive.google.com/file/d/17N-WqFCIarXOPoLcVQJ7SBmJv9UztRAs/view?usp=sharing 47 of 61 2 Withoutourintervention,afterwashingthroughandnearthehistoricstructures,whichhas resultedinflooding,propertydamageandasubsidedfoundation,thestormwateralleventually flowsdowntothehistorictributarybetweenIrwinandPeronneauStreets. HistoricpreservationisbrokendownintoseveralstepsintheGuidelines(pg.54).Beforeeven attempting rehabilitationor restoration,thefirststepis stabilization.The4requestsinthis proposalalladdress stabilizationofhistoricstructures(house,garage,andneighboring properties). 48 of 61 3 Tostopstormwaterfromdestabilizingourhistoricstructures,westrategicallylocatedlarge drainsaroundthehouseandatthebaseofthedriveway,trenchedthemhundredsoffeet throughyard(inblue),terminatingallthewaydownintothemainwatertributary(inred)atthe backofourproperty. Roughsketchofdrainagepipesburieddeepintheyard,terminatinginthetributaryattheback ofourproperty. 49 of 61 4 Architectural plan for proposed major work Closeupswillbeshownintheindividualproposalsforeachsectionofdrivewaybelow. Please seeseparatePDFforahigherresolutionversionofthisplan. 50 of 61 5 Description of Proposed work – Additional Materials and Photos. [1] Driveway apron — Top 25’ adjacent to sidewalk is currently concrete. We are proposing a like-for-like replacement to fix the damaged concrete. Section 10.2.3 “Walks and Drives” states “Existing paving materials of concrete asphalt and brick should be repaired where feasible. Section10.2.3oftheGuidelinestitled“WalksandDrives”states,“Existingpavingmaterialsof concreteasphaltandbrickshouldberepairedwherefeasible.” Close-upofarchitecturalplandetailingrepairstoexistingcementapronsection. Viewfromstreetdownthedriveway. 51 of 61 6 Viewoftopsectionlookingtowardsstreet. Closeupofoneofthedamagedareas. Wewouldalsoliketowidenthisconcretepadbya2 feet.DeliverytruckslikeAmazonandUPSwouldalwaysrunoffthesideofthedriveway,which iswhyiteventuallyerodedandbroke.Iaddedafewrowsofredbricktostabilize,butwewould likeamorepermanentsolution. 52 of 61 7 [2] Middle section — This single-lane section of driveway is currently non-original, non-porous gravel. For this portion of the driveway most visible from the street, we are proposing a historic treatment of two tire strips with a permeable paver center section. To manage stormwater the driveway would be bounded by small, historic cement swales with integrated curbs on either side. Theportionofourhistoricstructureboardingthissectionofdrivewayhasalreadybadly subsided(morethan6”). InouroriginalpresentationtoHARBonJuly11th,weproposedthis sectionofdrivewaytobeallconcretetoguidestormwaterpastourstill-sinkingstructure. I 53 of 61 8 TheJuly11thmeetingwascutshortduetotime,butnotbeforeoneoftheboardmembers proposedswitchingthissingle-lanesectiontotwotirestripswithacentralpaversection. Based onthisinput,wearrangedanin-personmeetingatthepropertyattendedbyFredalynFrasier andNanZhoufromthecityandDonnieLove,whoisanadvisortothecity,onThursday,July 25th.Workingtogetherwefoundasolutionwhichshouldbothprotectthestructureandfollow therecommendedhistoricguidelines. Ourproposalforthismiddlesectionofthedriveway incorporatestheseelements: ● Twotirestrips–Section10.2.3oftheGuidelinestitled“WalksandDrives”states,“The useofdrivinglanes,designedtofacilitateonlythecar’swheels,isahistorictreatment whichisencouragedtoretainporoussurfaces.” ● Permeablepavers–Thecentersectionbetweenthetirestripswouldbeconstructedofa permeablebasedwithspecializedpermeablepaverstoallowforsomeporousnessas recommendedinSection10.2.3oftheGuidelinesabove. ● Smallswalesoneithersideofthedriveway–thisisahistorictreatmentfound throughouttheneighborhood,oftenborderingdrivewaysandwalkways.Inourcase, thesesmall,shallowswaleswillguidestormwaterpasttheatriskhistoricstructure. ● Integratedcurbs–Duringthehardestrainstormslikethosepicturedinthevideosabove, thesecurbswillhelpcontainanystormwaterthatoverwhelmsthesmallswales. Close-upofarchitecturalplandetailingsingle-lanesectionthatwillreceivehistorictwotire-strip solutionwithpermeablepaversinthecenterarea. 54 of 61 9 Detailofpermeablepaverinstallationtoallowsomelevelofporousness. 55 of 61 10 [3] End section — This area between the house and garage includes spaces for 2 cars to park with room for both to turn around. This section is currently non-original, non-porous gravel. We would like to convert this to cement with extensive drains to manage stormwater problems. Inthatbacksectionofdriveway[3]wearepreppedforatrenchdraininfrontofthegarage,a smallerdrainnearthestuccowall,andacentral12”catchbasintomanagestormwaterrunoff. Viewofbacksectionofdrivewayfacingnorthwest. 56 of 61 11 WeconductedaninformalsurveyofhouseswithgaragesinHamptonHeightstoidentifythe predominantmaterialsusedfordrivewaysintheneighborhood. HOUSES WITH 2-CAR GARAGES Totalof[13]2-cargarages(bothhistoric garagesandmoremodernstructures) ● [9]all-cementdriveways–69% ● [2]blacktop–15% ● [1]gravel–8% ● [1]mixof2-tirestrips+largecement slabinfrontofgarage–8% Totalof[7] ORIGINAL2-cargarages ● [5]all-cement–71% ● [1]blacktop–14% ● [1]gravel–14% LIST OF HOUSES WITH 2-CAR GARAGES ● 508PeronneauSt—original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 189SHamptonDr. —originalattached2-cargarage,allcement driveway. ● 546PinckneyCourt —original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 592S.IrwinAve. —2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 539S.IrwinAve. —2-cargarage,cement,apronallblacktop driveway. ● 509S.IrwinAve. —original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 266HamptonCourt —original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 175WHamptonDr—non-original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 251WHamptonDr.(Ringo)—newlybuilt2-cargarage,cement apron,twotirestripsalongthehouse,fullcementpadinfrontofnew garagewithturnaroundspace. ● 245W.HamptonAve. —original2-cargarage,cement,apronall graveldriveway. ● 276SouthSpringSt. —original2-cargarage,convertedtoauxiliary dwelling,cementapron,allblacktopdriveway. ● 259HydrickSt. —newlyconstructed2-cargarage,allcement driveway. ● 277HydrickSt.—non-original2-cargarage,allcementdriveway. HOUSES WITH 1-CAR GARAGES Totalof[12]1-cargarages ● [4]all-cementdriveways–33% ● [3]blacktop–25% ● [2]gravel–17% ● [1]paver–8% ● [1]2-tirestripswithfullcementpadin frontofgarage–8% ● [1]cementapronandallcementnear house,switchingto2-tirestripsinthe waybackbehindhouse–8% LIST OF HOUSES WITH 1-CAR GARAGES ● 503PeronneauSt—Newlybuilt1-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 510HamptonDr—original/old1-cargarage,cementapron,allpaver driveway. ● 551PinkneyCourt—original1-cargarage,cementapron,allblacktop driveway. ● 598S.IrwinAve. —large/non-originalbarnwith1garagedoor, cementapron,allgraveldriveway. ● 589S.IrwinAve. —original1-cargarage,cementapron,allgravel driveway. ● 498S.IrwinAve. —original1-cargarage,allcementdriveway. ● 476S.IrwinAve. —original1-cargarage,cementapron,allblacktop driveway. ● 200W.HamptonAve.—original1-cargarage/barn,cement,apron,all graveldriveway. ● 182W.HamptonAve.—original1-cargarage,cement,apronandfull cementdrivealongyardandhouse,switchesto2stripsintheway back,leadinguptothesinglecargarage. ● 286SouthSpringSt.—original1-cargarage,convertedtoashed, cementapron,twotirestripes,endingwithfullcementpadinfrontof garage/shed. ● 280SouthSpringSt.—original1-cargarage,cement,apronall blacktopdriveway. ● 283HydrickSt. —non-original1-cargarage,allcementdriveway. Tosummarizetheresultsabove: ● All2-cargaragesintheneighborhoodhadasolidsurfaceinfrontofthegarage. ● CementisbyfarthepredominantmaterialusedfordrivewaysinHamptonHeights. ● Therearenohistoricexamplesof2-tirestripdrivewaysdirectlyinfrontof2-cargarages. 57 of 61 12 [4] Curved front walkway — This section is currently non-original, non-porous gravel. We would like to convert this to non-grouted, floating flagstone with added drains to manage stormwater. THIS PART OF OUR PROJECT WAS RECLASSIFIED AS MINOR WORK 8/6/24 AND HENCE REMOVED FROM THIS PROPOSAL. 58 of 61 13 SUPPORTING MATERIALS Forhouseswithgarages,cementisbyfarthepredominantmaterialusedfordrivewaysin HamptonHeights. Section3.2.2specificallylistsconcrete1stwhendiscussingtheprofileofthehousesin HamptonHeights,implyingthatitisnotonlyappropriateandoriginalfortheneighborhood,but alsothepredominantmaterialused;thisdescriptioncorrelateswiththedataregarding prevalenceofconcreteonpage11. 59 of 61 14 Section5.3Step3abovehighlydiscouragesusinghistoricmaterials/styleswheretheydidnot originallyexist. 60 of 61 15 Thereisnorecordofourdrivewayoriginallybeingcement,gravel,orhavingthe2-tirestrips. Section10.2.3title“WalksandDrives”,specificallystatesthat,“Newsurfacesshouldbe compatiblewiththesepredominantmaterials.”Whentakingallthesefactorsand recommendationsintoaccount,webelievethemostappropriatesolutionwouldbecementas thatisbyfarthepredominantdrivewaymaterialusedforhousesinHamptonHeightswith garages. 61 of 61

Source: City of Spartanburg website. First collected Nov 1, 2026.