RecordWell Data

Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review — Agenda Packet

City of Spartanburg · Spartanburg County · Boards and Commissions · meeting of Apr 11, 2024 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Spartanburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

The City of Spartanburg Board of Architectural Design & Historic Review City of Spartanburg | Board of Architectural Design & Historic Review 1 AGENDA April 11, 2024, at 5:30 P.M. Spartanburg County Council Chambers 366 N. Church Street – Spartanburg, SC 29303 ( Please Note: Items as they appear on the Docket may or may not be considered in the order as they are presented. The Chairman will announce any changes after the roll call) I. Call To Order. II. R oll Call. III. F reedom of Information Act Compliance – Public notification of the City of Spartanburg’s Board of Architectural Design & Historic Review meeting has been published, posted and mailed in c ompliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the City of Spartanburg’s Zoning Ordinance. IV . Approval of Agenda. V. D isposition of Minutes from the March 14, 2024, Meeting. V I. Old Business: None. V II. New Business: COA: 24-004-00017: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 481 S. Irwin Avenue (TMS: 7-16-02-137.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking a pproval to remove existing and replicate original pickets and railings on the front porch. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single-Family District) zoning district. Owner/Applicant: John Edwin Foster, Paula Foster Paul / Contractor: Nicklas Renfro. V III. Approved Certificate of Appropriateness for Minor Works since the March 14, 2024, Meeting. I X. Staff Updates: X. A djournment. F or more information, please contact Martin L. Livingston, Jr., AICP, CPM, Community Development Director at (864) 580-5323 or by email at planning@cityofspartanburg.org. Page 1 of 33 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-03-14 Page 1 of 6 Meeting Minutes of the Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review Thursday, March 14th, 2024, at 5:30 PM Spartanburg County Council Chambers The City of Spartanburg Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review (HARB ) met in County Council Chambers on Thursday, March 14 th, 2024, at 5:30PM with the following members in attendance: Bill Michels, Kenneth Brown, Mark Olencki, Rod McCants, Michael Pittillo, Glory Boozer and James Gaffney. Representing the Planning Department is, Martin Livingston, Community Director, Nan Zhou, Planner II, and Oksana Holbrooks, Administrative Assistant. Roll Call: Mr. Michels: Bill Michels Mr. McCants: Rod McCants Mr. Brown: Kenneth Brown Mr. Pittillo: Michael Pittillo Dr. Boozer: Glory Boozer Mr. Olencki: Mark Olencki Mr. Gaffney: James Gaffney Mr. Gaffney: The Freedom of Information Act Compliance called for public notification to the City of Spartanburg’s Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review meeting has been published, posted, and mailed in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance. Approval of Agenda: A motion was made by Dr. Brown, seconded by Dr. Boozer, approve the agenda. The motion was approved with a vote of 7-0. Approval of Meeting Minutes from February 8th, 2024. A motion was made by Mr. Brown, seconded by Mr. Michels approve the agenda. The motion was approved with a vote of 7-0. Old Business: None. Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 767 N. Liberty Street (TMS# 7-08-15-216.00) in the Beaumont Mill Village Historic District. Applicant is seeking approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness to install a wood handicap ramp and a deck on the rear of the house. The property is located in the R-6 (General Residential District). Owner: Lamar Montjoy / Applicant/Contractor: Ben Palmer – Ben Palmer Contracting, LLC Project Description and History The project site is an approximately 14,080 square foot lot in the Beaumont Mill Village Historic District. The site is a corner lot located at the intersection of North Liberty Street and Sloan Street. The lot currently contains one two- story vinyl primary structure with a symmetrical front facade that was built in 1910. The structure has a brick foundation, an interior chimney, an open front porch, with a hipped roof. This house is classified as House Type 7 – American Four Square in Beaumont Mill Village Design Guidelines. Page 2 of 33 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-03-14 Page 2 of 6 On February 9th, an inspector from the Building Department found out the contractor was building the handicap ramp in the rear of the house without a Certificate of Appropriateness and a building permit on file. The inspector issued a STOP Working Order to the contractor and told the contractor and owner to file a Certificate of Appropriateness with the Planning Department. The owner filed a Certificate of Appropriateness with the Planning Department in late February. Staff visited the property on February 29 th and had a conversation with the owner and learned that the purpose of having the handicap ramp and a deck at the back of the house is to assist her mom get out of the house and enjoyed sunshine on the well-constructed wide handicap ramp. There is not much space in the front yard and side yard to build a handicap ramp. Analysis Zoning Ordinance and Historic Design Manual Consistency The project site is located in the Beaumont Mill Village Historic D istrict which has design guidelines for development. These guidelines are outlined in the Design Guidelines for the City of Spartanburg Historic Districts and Landmarks. The purpose of the Design Guidelines is to provide property owners guidance for the preservation and protection of historic and architecturally valuable districts and sites in the City. The project is also subject to Section 510 of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation . This section allows the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. F indings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) 1. The character and appropriateness of the design – The applicant indicated that the handicap ramp and a deck are needed for the applicant’s mom to be able to get out of the house from the back of the house and enjoy some sunshine on the well - constructed wide handicap ramp and move around. Currently there are no standards for handicap ramps in the Beaumont Mill Village design guidelines. The wood handicap ramp is installed in the back yard facing Sloan Street for the convenience of the applicant’s mom having access to the rear yard. There is not enough room in the front yard and side yard for the handicap ramp. A search of the Secretary of the Interior website for accessibility and historic structures resulted in the following guideline found in the Illustrated Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings “…Although this work [Accessibility] is quite often an important aspect of rehabilitation projects, it is usually not a part of the overall process of protecting or repairing character -defining features; rather, such work is assessed for it potential negative impact on the building's historic character. For this reason, particular care must be taken not to radically change, obscure, damage, or destroy character - defining materials or features in the process of undertaking work to meet various code requirements.” Based on the above Secretary of the Interior’s recommendations, the handicap should be designed not to radically change or destroy character -defining features of the historic structure and appear to be part of the historic structure. Therefore, pickets and railing probably should be added to the handicap ramp and paint the ramp to make it look like part of the house and to be consistent with the color of the house. 2. T he scale of the buildings – The scale of the primary building will not be affected. The handicap ramp is an extension of the entrance from the rear of the house and access to the rear yard is necessary for health reasons. 3. The texture and materials – The handicap ramp is made of wood and is un-painted. Pickets and railings are not installed on the handicap ramp. Page 3 of 33 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-03-14 Page 3 of 6 4. The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings – Currently, properties in the immediate surroundings do not have handicap ramps installed in the front, side, or rear yards. 5. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District – Even though the handicap ramp is not originally built with the primary structure on the lot, and there are no handicap ramps installed in the immediate surroundings, it may not be harmonious with the historic characters of Beaumont Mill Village. However, given the circumstances of the property owner’s physical condition and health concerns, having a handicap ramp will allow her to ingress and egress the house from the back and enjoy some sunshine conveniently, averting difficulties caused by inaccessible ho me. Property owners should be aware that the handicap should be in compliance with the building code, which means the handicap ramp may need to alter the height and the slope. Pickets and railings should be added to the handicap ramp for safety reasons. Applicant: Lamar Montjoy, Owner. Consultant: Donnie Love, Preservation Architect Public Speakers: None. Discussion: The corner lots have more leeway. The proposed handicap ramp seems appropriate and would not be detrimental to the surrounding neighborhood. A motion was made by Mr. Olencki, seconded Mr. Brown to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness with condition to paint the deck to match the front of house and add some landscaping throughout with a vote of 7-0. New Business: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 542 Kingston Street (TMS: 7-08-15-148.00) in the Beaumont Mill Village Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval to replace an existing window with a door, add a rear deck, and replace the front door. The property is located in the R-6 (General Residential District). Owner/Applicant: Danielle Drag; Drag Street, LLC / Contractor: Ben Bradner. Project Description and History The project site is located on an approximately 4,800 square foot lot in the Beaumont Mill Village Historic District. The site is located on the corner of Reynolds Street and Kingston Street. The site currently contains one structure that was constructed approximately in 1910. This residential structure is a vinyl sided framed bungalow with painted masonry, no chimney, and one front door and one door to the left side of the structure. The Beaumont Mill Village Historic Design Guidelines list this structure as House Type One – Saddlebag circa 1890-1910. The applicant is seeking to add a rear deck to the visible corner where none currently exist. The applicant is requesting to replace an existing window with a door to the deck. The applicant is also Page 4 of 33 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-03-14 Page 4 of 6 requesting to remove the existing fiberglass door and replace with a metal door or wood door with what appears to be a two panel door with divided lite windows. Analysis Zoning Ordinance and Historic Design Manual Consistency The project site is located in the Beaumont Mill Village Historic District which has design guidelines for development. These guidelines are outlined in the Beaumont Village Design Guidelines for the City of Spartanburg Historic District Preservation Principles and Approaches. The purpose of the Guidelines is to provide property owners guidance for the preservation and protection of historic and architecturally valuable districts and sites in the City. The project is also subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation. This section allows the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. The project site has a zoning designation of R-6, General Residential District, which allows for single family dwelling units. Section 510.6 of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance list standards for reviewing Certificate of Appropriateness. Specifical ly, Section 510.6 (C)(2) states that in reviewing applications for new construction or alteration, the board shall consider the U.S. Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation and the five criteria listed in the findings. Findings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) a. The character and appropriateness of the design – The applicant is seeking to add a rear deck to the visible corner where none currently exist. The applicant is requesting to replace an existing window with a door to the deck. The applicant is also requesting to remove the existing fiberglass door and replace it with a metal door or wood door with what appears to be a two-panel door with divided lite windows. Adding a deck and a door to the rear of the structure would change the character of the structure and would not be appropriate. Since the structure was built without a deck, a deck to the rear visible from the street would be inappropriate for the existing design. A rear deck and changing the door design would be more appropriate if the improvements were not visible from the street. The removal of a window to add a rear door and deck would change the character of the structure. A metal door in the front would not be consistent with the historic character of the neighborhood. Changing the front door to a wood door would be more consistent to the charact er and appropriateness of the neighborhood. The Beaumont Mill Village Design guidelines provide an appropriate door type for the structure and list the recommended door as a Folk Victorian Door for House Type 1. Three options are available to the applicant in the Design Guidelines. b. The scale of the buildings – The scale of the building would change minimally with the addition of a rear deck. There would not be a significant change in the scale of the building or any changes to the building envelope. c. The texture and materials – The applicant is proposing a Southern pine treated deck. While a wood deck would be appropriate in the rear, the location of the deck visible from the street would not be appropriate since adding a deck and a rear door would change the character of the str ucture. Adding a wood front door would be appropriate. The addition of a metal door would not be appropriate. Changing the front door to a wood door would be more consistent to the character and appropriateness of the neighborhood. The Beaumont Mill Village Design guidelines provide an appropriate door type for the structure and Page 5 of 33 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-03-14 Page 5 of 6 list the recommended door as a Folk Victorian Door for House Type 1. Three options are available to the applicant in the Design Guidelines. d. The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings – Corner properties tend to be very visible in historic districts. Since this property is located on the corner it is important that historic features remain as much as possible. Rear decks a typically allowed and owners are allowed to make significant changes to the rear when those changes are not visible form the street. Removing the rear window, adding a new door and adding a rear deck would not be appropriate for the structure and this corner property. Adding a wood front door and replacing the existing door would be appropriate. The Beaumont Mill Village Design guidelines provide an appropriate door type for the structure and list the recommended door as a Folk Victorian Door for House Type 1. Three options are available to the applicant in the Design Guidelines. e. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District – The applicant is seeking to add a rear deck to the visible corner where none currently exist. The applicant is requesting to replace an existing window with a door to the deck. The applicant is also requesting to remove the existing fiberglass door and replace it with a metal door or wood door with what appears to be a two-panel door with divided lite windows. Adding a deck and a door to the rear of the structure would change the character of the structure and would not be appropriate. Since the structure was built without a deck, a deck to the rear visible from the street would be inappropriate for the existing design. A rear deck and changing the door design would be more appropriate if the improvements were not visible from the street. Front metal door would not be consistent with the historic character of the neighborhood. A metal door in the front would not be consistent with the historic character of the neighborhood. Changing the front door to a wood door would be more consistent to the character and appropriateness of the neighborhood. The Beaumont Mill Village Design guidelines provide an appropriate door type for the structure and list the recommended door as a Folk Victorian Door for House Type 1. Three options are available to the applicant in the Design Guidelines. The recommended door type submitted by the applicant would not be consistent with the design guidelines. The removal of a window to add a rear door and deck would change the character of the structure. The changes requested to the rear of the structure would not be Harmonious to the historic district. Applicant: Danielle Drag, Owner. Consultant: Donnie Love, Preservation Architect Public Speakers: None. Discussion: Corner lots typically have more leeway with the usage allowance of rear yard. However, this corner lot is very visible from the road and allowing the proposed deck, window and door at the proposed location would be detrimental to the character of the structure and does not meet the historic guidelines. A motion was made by Mr. Michels, seconded Mr. Brown to deny the Certificate of Appropriateness as presented. However, if the applicant would like to comply with the Planning Page 6 of 33 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-03-14 Page 6 of 6 Department’s recommended doors that are allowed in Historic District they may replace and paint the front door by a vote of 7-0. Staff Announcements: None The meeting was adjourned at 6:08 PM. ______________________________ James Gaffney , Chairman Page 7 of 33 Planning Department PO Box 1749 • Spartanburg, SC 29304 • Phone: (864) 596-2068 • email: planning@cityofspartanburg.org website: www.cityofspartanburg.org TO: The Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review RE: RE: COA: 24-004-00017: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 481 S. Irwin Avenue (TMS: 7-16-02-137.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval to remove existing and replicate original pickets and railings on the front porch. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single-Family District) zoning district. Owner/Applicant: John Edwin Foster, Paula Foster Paul / Contractor: Nicklas Renfro. DATE: April 11, 2024 Project Description and History The project site is located on an approximately 38,000 square foot lot in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The site is located mid -block between W. Hampton Avenue and South Hampton Drive. The site currently contains one structure that was built approximately in 1909. This residential structure is a vinyl sided framed Queen Anne structure with a side porch removed that will be reinstalled. The applicant is seeking to replace existing pickets and railing that are currently at a height of approximately 30 inches in height. The owner is requesting to replicate the previous original pickets and railings on the property. Analysis Zoning Ordinance and Historic Design Manual Consistency The project site is located in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District which has design guidelines for development. These guidelines are outlined in the Hampton Heights Design Guidelines for the City of Spartanburg Historic District Preservation Principles and Approaches . The purpose of the Guidelines is to provide property owners guidance for the preservation and protection of historic and architecturally valuable districts and sites in the City. The project is also subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation. This section allows the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropr iateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. The project site has a zoning designation of R-8 SFD, General Residential Single-Family District, which allows for single family dwelling units. Section 510.6 of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance list standards for reviewing Certificate of Appropriateness. Specifically, Section 510.6 (C)(2) states that in reviewing applications for new construction or alteration, the board shall consider the U.S. Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation and the five criteria listed in the findings. Page 8 of 33 Page 2 of 8 Findings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) a. Th e character and appropriateness of the design – The applicant is seeking to replace existing pickets and railing that are currently at a height of approximately 30 inches in height. The applicant has requested to install spindles or balusters at the original height of no greater than 30 inches with 5 inches on occurrence. The installation of new ra ilings on front porches typically require s the tops of railings to be a height of no less than 36 inches to meet current building code requirements. The Secretary of the Interiors Guidelines for Restoring Historic Buildings recommends “recreating a missing wood feature that existed during the restoration period based on documentary and physical evidence; for example, duplicating a wood dormer or porch”. Balusters, spindles, and pickets are used interchangeably throughout the document and have similar meanings. If allowed to replace the porch railings, staff recommends a sample design be submitted with measurements for review. b. Th e scale of the buildings – The scale of the building would not be affected since only the pickets and railings will be replaced or repaired to meet the building codes standards or the historic standards. c. Th e texture and materials – The applicant is proposing to replicate the balusters and railings on the front porch with wood railings to match the existing railings and the original railings. Wood balusters and railings were the predominate feature in the neighborhood and for this structure. Any other type of materials would not be consistent. d. The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings – Wood balusters, spindles, pickets and railings are the predominant feature in the neighborhood for porches that have a height that require railings. e. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District – The applicant is requesting to replicate the previous original pickets and railings on the property. The applicant has requested to install spindles or balusters at the original height of no greater than 30 inches with 5 inches on occurrence. The installation of new railings on front porches typically requires the tops of railings to be a height of no less than 36 inches to meet current building code requirements. The Secretary if the Interiors Guidelines for Restoring Historic Buildings recommends “recreating a missing wood feature that existed during the restoration period based on documentary and physical evidence; for example, duplicating a wood dormer or porch”. The recreation of the wood balusters and railings would be harmonious with the existing neighborhood features if replicated. Subm itted by: Ma rtin L. Livingston, Jr., AICP, CPM Community Development Director Atta chments: Conditions of Approval Application and Materials Site Photos Page 9 of 33 Page 3 of 8 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL FOR THE PROJECT ON PROPERTY AT: 481 S. Irwin Avenue (TMS: 7-16-02-137.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District Owner/Applicant: John Edwin Foster, Paula Foster Paul Contractor: Nicklas Renfro. 1. If one or more of the following conditions is not met with respect to all its terms, then this approval may be revoked. 2. All plans for future construction which are not covered by this review shall be submitted to the City Planning Department for review and approval. 3. Major modifications to plans or exceptions to completion may be granted only by the City authority which approved the project. 4. T his permit shall be exercised within six months of the date of final approval , or it shall become null and void. Extensions may be granted with permission of the Board. 5. A building permit shall be obtained from the Building Department prior to commencement of work. 6. The development of the site shall be in substantial accordance with the approved plans submitted and on file in the Spartanburg City Planning Department. Major modifications to plans or exceptions to completion may be granted only by the City authority which approved the project. project. Page 10 of 33 Page 4 of 8 SITE MAP Page 11 of 33 Page 5 of 8 ZONING MAP Page 12 of 33 Page 6 of 8 PHOTOS Page 13 of 33 Page 7 of 8 PHOTOS Page 14 of 33 Page 8 of 8 PHOTOS Page 15 of 33 Page 16 of 33 Page 17 of 33 Page 18 of 33 Page 19 of 33 Page 20 of 33 Page 21 of 33 Page 22 of 33 Page 23 of 33 Page 24 of 33 Page 25 of 33 Page 26 of 33 Page 27 of 33 Page 28 of 33 Page 29 of 33 Page 30 of 33 Page 31 of 33 Page 32 of 33 DONALD L. LOVE JR, ARCHITECT , AIA 608 Otis Boulevard, Spartanburg, SC · 864.415.0459 lovejrd@gmail.com March 30, 2024 Martin Livingston City of Spartanburg Neighborhood Services Director Re: March 30, 2024 Dear Martin, The purpose of this letter is to assist the Spartanburg Historic Architecture Review Board with a determination of appropriateness for new porch railing at 481 South Irwin Avenue, in the Hampton Heights Historic District. Review of the Guidelines for the Historic District and the Secretary’s Standards for Rehabilitation forms the basis for my opinion. I have also reviewed Preservation Brief 45 Preserving Historic Wooden Porches from the National Park Service. The applicant has requested approval to replace the deteriorated wood railing on the front porch with new wood railing. The existing railing is not original to the house. No drawings of the new railing were provided, however, a graphic from the City of Greensboro’s Historic District guidelines showing typical handrail designs and a typical handrail section was provided for review. Installation of new railings is allowed by The Hampton Heights Design Guidelines as major work. The Guidelines state “Repair of porches shall not result in the removal of original materials (such as balusters, columns, handrails, brackets, and roof detailing) unless seriously deteriorated. If replacement materials must be introduced, the new shall match the old in design, color, texture, and where possible, materials. The Secretary’s Standards for Rehabilitation state, “New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The ne w work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment.” On March 28, 2024, I visited the property with you to observe the railing. The current railing appears to be similar to a photo of the house from the 1950’s, however, the design of the railing in the photo appears to be inconsistent with typical rail design from the period of the house construction, indicating that it may have also been a replacement. If the existing wooden railing is to be replaced with new railing, the design should match that of the original construction, assuming that the design can be verified to be accurate using photo documentation. If not, a design for the new rails should be provided for review prior to approval of the COA. Please let me know if you have any questions or require any additional information. Regards, Donald L. Love, Jr, Architect, AIA Historic Preservation STAFF APPROVED MINOR WORKS SINCE MARCH 14, 2024, MEETING Approved Date Street Address Approved Work 3/15/2024 481 S. Irwin Avenue Remove existing damaged two by 10 water damaged porch floor joist and install two new floor joist. Remove all porch floor boards and install new 1 X 4 tongue and groove pinewood floor boards. Temporarily remove the porch columns and repair columns and floor boards and reinstall columns to their original position. Remove existing side porch (already removed – photo provided) and replace with deck and lattice on side porch – railing and spindles to match front porch. 3/16/2024 683 Southern Street Remove existing roofing asphalt shingles to deck, re-nail any loose boards, install new roof deck boards where needed, and install new asphalt roofing shingles. 3/20/2024 562 S. Irwin Ave. Replace existing gutters with new gutters and install additional gutters as needed to reduce drainage problems around the foundation of the house Page 33 of 33

Source: City of Spartanburg website. First collected Nov 1, 2026.