Design Review Board (DRB) — Minutes
City of Spartanburg · Spartanburg County · Boards and Commissions · meeting of Apr 2, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Spartanburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
DRB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-04-02
Page 1 of 8
Meeting Minutes of the Design Review Board (DRB)
Tuesday, April 2nd, 2024, at 5:30 PM
Dr. TK Gregg Recreation Center
The Design Review Board (DRB) on Tuesday, April 2nd, 2024, at 5:30pm. The following Board
Members were in attendance: Lucy Lynch, Alexander Newman, Tori Wallace Babcock and
Lauren Rogers. Representing the City of Spartanburg’s Planning Department was Martin
Livingston, Community Development Director; Oksana Holbrooks, Administrative
Assistant and Nan Zhou, Planner II.
Roll Call:
Mr. Newman: Alexander Newman
Ms. Lynch: Lucy Lynch
Ms. Rogers: Lauren Rogers (Late arrival)
Ms. Babcock: Tori Wallace Babcock
Ms. Lynch: Per the Freedom of Information Act, public notice of this meeting has been
published, posted and mailed in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the
requirements of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance. Okay if we could approve tonight’s
agenda unless there are any changes.
Approval of Agenda
On a motion by Mr. Newman and second by Ms. Babcock, the agenda was approved by a
vote of 4 to 0.
Mr. Newman: Motion to approve.
Ms. Babcock: I second
Ms. Lynch: All in favor say aye?
Attendees: Aye.
Ms. Lynch: The motion carries. Okay the minutes from March 5
th, 2024, if everyone has had a
chance to look through those and would like to approve?
Approval of Meeting Minutes for April 2nd, 2024
On a motion by Ms. Babcock to approved minutes from March 5
th meeting and second by
Mr. Newman, the minutes was approved by a vote of 4 to 0.
Ms. Babcock: Motion to approve minutes from March 5
th meeting.
Mr. Newman: Second.
Ms. Lynch: All in favor of approving the minutes from February 6th?
Attendees: Aye.
DRB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-04-02
Page 2 of 8
Old Business:
The Design Review Board (DRB) has received a request for Full and Final Approval for
conversion of residential on the first floor located at 249 E. Main Street (Tax Map Sheet: 7-
12-19-002.00). Owner/Applicant: Brandon McKillop. The Design Review Board (DRB) has
received a request for Full and Final Approval for conversion of residential on the first
floor located at 249 E. Main Street (Tax Map Sheet: 7-12-19-002.00). Owner/Applicant:
Brandon McKillop.
GENERAL PROJECT OVERVIEW
The applicant is seeking to convert an existing one-story commercial building into a two-unit
dwelling along Main Street between Broad Street and Dean Street.
AUTHORITY
This project is zoned DT-5. Formal design review and approval by the Design Review Board is
required because of the requested change in use on the ground floor along Main Street from
commercial to housing. The Board has previously approved the location of residential on the
ground floor facing Main Street at their October, 2023 meeting subject to additional design
scrutiny for consistency with the intent of the code.
DETERMINATION OF COMPLETENESS
• Application is complete for Final Approval Review
EXCEPTIONS REQUIRED FOR APPROVAL
• 6.1.2.B Key Principle: Housing – Housing should not be placed on the ground floor
frontage in D-T6 and along Main Street. – Approved by the DRB subject to design
review
CODE REVIEW
A. Applicability Matrix: This is a substantial modification where the improvements are
greater than 50% of appraised value. Full compliance is required to the extent practical.
Full compliance is required without exception for expansion areas and landscaping
standards.
• Use Standards: The proposed use is permitted by right (though not on the street facing
side). Approved by the DRB subject to design review
B. District Standards:
• 3.3.1 Lot Configuration: Compliant
• 3.3.2 Primary Building Standards: Compliant
• 3.3.4 Building Height: Compliant
• 3.3.5 Permitted Parking Location: Not applicable
DRB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-04-02
Page 3 of 8
• 3.3.6 Building Frontage: Shopfront – permitted – awning or canopy required
(see Table 1) – applicants have requested an exception to not install any canopy
or awning
C. General Standards:
• Not applicable
D. Lot/Site Standards:
o 5.1.1 Lot Frontage: All lots must front on a street, square, or common open
space. Compliant
E. Utilities and Trash Containment:
• 5.2.1 Underground Utilities: Compliant
• 5.2.2 Solid Waste Storage Areas: No information provided
• 5.2.3 Mechanical and Utility Equipment: No information provided
F. Building Standards:
• 6.1.2 General Design Principles - Housing: Housing should not be placed on the
ground floor
• frontage in D-T6 and along Main Street. – DRB previously approved exception
subject to design review
• 6.1.3 General Design Principles – Mixed-Use Infill and Redevelopment:
Compliant
• 6.1.4 General Design Principles – Downtown Should be Urban: Compliant
• 6.1.5 General Design Principles - Put People First: Ground floor activity is
critical to pedestrian comfort and activity. Long expanses of inactivity are
strongly discouraged. – DRB previously approved exception subject to design
review
• 6.2 Required Building Design Standards:
o 6.2.1 Architectural Style: Compliant
o 6.2.2 Compatibility: Compliant
o 6.2.3 Proportions: Compliant
o 6.2.4 Wall Materials: Compliant
o 6.2.5 Façade Treatment: Compliant
o 6.2.6 Building Entrances: Compliant
• 6.3 Specific Building Design Standards for Residential Structures/Frontages
in D-T5 (option a)
o 6.3.1 Roof and Eaves: Compliant
o 6.3.2 Façade Design: Presumed Compliant – Calculation not provided
but note on plan guarantees compliance
o 6.3.3 Building Entrances: Raised Entries Not Compliant – Exception
provided by the DRB subject to enhanced design
o 6.3.5 Materials: Compliant
• 6.4 Specific Building Design Standards for Mixed-use and Commercial
Buildings in D-T5 (option b)
o 6.4.1 Roof and Eaves: Compliant
o 6.4.2 Canopies/Awnings: Existing canopy to be removed with no
replacement – Installation of a canopy/awning is a requirement of the
building frontage (3.3.7)
DRB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-04-02
Page 4 of 8
o 6.4.3 Encroachments: Not applicable
o 6.4.4 Ground Level Detailing: Compliant
o 6.4.5 Materials: Compliant
G. Parking:
• Not Applicable
H. Streetscape and Site Landscaping:
• 8.1 Required Streetscape: 12 ft streetscape zone with a minimum 8 ft sidewalk
and trees planted in wells consistent with downtown standards (40 ft on-center). -
One tree is required if there are no conflicts with underground utilities
I. Signage: Not applicable.
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS FOR BOARD CONSIDERATION
• Front Unit Entry: The proposed front façade is consistent with the neighboring
commercial properties though we continue to question the direct access entry from the
sidewalk into the living space of the unit. The code requires that residential units be
elevated to provide a sense of privacy from the sidewalk but no alternate configuration
has been provided. We would strongly encourage some type of visual offset or an entry
vestibule to provide a more appropriate transition to the private space.
• Storefront Windows: The proposed Main Street elevation windows are high-quality but
residential-grade and we are not sure whether they are appropriate for a commercial,
storefront condition. We have requested that applicants bring samples to the meeting for
DRB review.
• Street Tree required: Because the application is a change in use, the streetscape is
required to be upgraded. Consistent with the downtown standards, one street tree is
required, using a tree well.
• Front Façade Canopy/Awning: The proposed recessed is proposed in lieu of the
provision of building canopy/awning as required by the building typology. The purpose
of this requirement along a main street is two-fold: to provide shelter prior to entry and to
provide shelter to pedestrian walking by. The grant of an exception is predicated upon a
change necessitated by a site-specific condition, building-specific condition or an
innovative manner in which to fulfill the overall design intent of this Code. We do not
believe that the application shows a building-specific need to eliminate this requirement
nor do we think that it shows an innovative manner in which to fulfill the design intent.
• Privacy Screening: The applicants have suggested that the individual residents can use a
flexible interior screen as a means to provide natural light while keeping curtains or
blinds open to avoid a blank wall condition. We do not think that this solution will
provide enough privacy to the unit to preclude this condition. Blank walls and dead
spaces simply do not encourage pedestrian activity. Great Main Streets have a continuity
of active, ground floor spaces that cast light onto the sidewalk at night and provide visual
diversity to a pedestrian. The lack of these ingredients causes a well-documented
emotional response that is equivalent to stress or fear which discourages pedestrian
DRB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-04-02
Page 5 of 8
activity. As well-intentioned as an interior screen may be, we do not think that it is
sufficient to permanently meet the intent of the code.
RECOMMENDATION
While the application addresses many of the DRB’s concerns, we still do not believe that the
proposed solution for the Main Street elevation will adequately address the need for the tenant’s
privacy and the importance of providing an active, ground floor. In addition, we do not think that
application has established a building-specific need to eliminate the proposed canopy/awning nor
have they provided an innovative solution that addresses the intent. In addition, no
accommodation has been made for the required street tree.
Because of these two outstanding issues, we are not able to provide a recommendation for
approval with specific exceptions granted by the Board as follows:
That the proposed elevation provides sufficient shelter to pedestrians on the sidewalk for
comfort and shelter; and
That the proposed design will prioritize pedestrian activity through the provision of an
active, ground floor space; and
That the required street tree is not practical to install due to existing site conditions (need
to define what these are).
Applicant:
Meghan Teague, AIA; Teague Studios.
Public Comments:
None.
Discussion:
The proposed project has been improved. Architecturally it is a good proposal. The proposed
project fits well with the surrounding businesses and buildings. Because of underground utilities
and adjacent light pole, the landscaping in front of the building may not be possible and
placement of trees may be in disarray of the surrounding properties. The city may alter the
sidewalk at a later point in time.
A motion was made by Ms. Babcock, seconded Mr. Newman for full & final approval with
the variances of a tree, canopy and pedestrian walkway requested by a vote of 4-0.
New Business:
The Design Review Board (DRB) has received a request for Preliminary conceptual
approval of the buildings form, massing, and placement on the site for the Grain District
Parking Garage located at 344 S. Daniel Morgan Avenue (Tax Map Sheet: 7-12-14-005.00)
in the DT-5 (Downtown Code) zoning district. Owner/Applicant: Morgan & Henry JOF
ESA II, LLC / Agent: Michael Judice; McMillan Pazdan Smith.
DRB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-04-02
Page 6 of 8
GENERAL PROJECT OVERVIEW
The proposed parking garage and surface parking lot is designed to provide parking for the
ballpark and a future office building planned along Main Street.
AUTHORITY
This project is zoned DT-5. Formal design review and approval by the Design Review Board is
required.
DETERMINATION OF COMPLETENESS
• Application is missing the following elements but may be sufficient for Preliminary
Review:
o Parking and Loading areas – Please show the drives from Daniel Morgan
o Material Selections and Colors – Please correct page 14 for consistency with the
other drawings (no brick shown) – note that final approval will require cut sheets
or manufacturer’s photos of the proposed materials
o Perspective Illustration – As needed by the DRB to understand the context of the
proposal
o Description of requested modification/special exceptions including a statement of
the unique design considerations that contribute to this request and the proposed
design solutions
EXCEPTIONS
• 8.1 Streetscape – Minimum 12 ft zone (preferred 16 ft zone) with trees in wells - proposal
is for a 5 foot sidewalk and a 4.5 ft planting strip
o Subject to DRB approval
CODE REVIEW
A. Use Standards: The proposed use is permitted by right. Applicable standards are
3.2.10.b – Parking Structure
o 3.2.10.b.1 Liner Buildings Required: Presumed compliant with additional of
future office building along Main Street required by development agreement with
City
o 3.2.10.b.2 High-Quality Materials: Compliant
o 3.2.10.b.3 Clear Entries: Compliant
o 3.2.10.b.4 Vents and Utility Openings: Assumed compliant – subject to Final
Approval review
B. District Standards:
• 3.3.1 Lot Configuration: Compliant
• 3.3.2 Primary Building Standards: Compliant
DRB – Meeting Minutes – 2024-04-02
Page 7 of 8
• 3.3.4 Building Height: Compliant
• 3.3.5 Permitted Parking Location: Not applicable
• 3.3.6 Building Frontage: Not applicable
C. General Standards:
o Not Applicable
D. Lot/Site Standards:
o Not Applicable
E. Utilities and Trash Containment:
• 5.2.1 Underground Utilities: Compliance presumed – TBD at Final
• 5.2.2 Solid Waste Storage Areas: Compliance presumed – TBD at Final
• 5.2.3 Mechanical and Utility Equipment: Compliance presumed – TBD at Final
F. Building Standards:
o Not Applicable
G. Parking:
• 8.2 Parking Area Landscaping (Required Plantings & Parking Area
Screening): Presumed compliant subject to Final Approval submission
H. Streetscape and Site Landscaping:
• 8.1 Required Streetscape: 12 ft streetscape zone (preferred 16 ft zone) with a
minimum 8 ft sidewalk and trees planted in wells consistent with downtown
standards (40 ft on-center). – Exception Required
I. Signage: Not applicable.
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS FOR BOARD CONSIDERATION
• Substandard Streetscape across frontage of parking lot and parking garage: The
proposed sidewalk zone along the frontage of this site is a 4.5 ft planting strip and a 5 ft
sidewalk directly adjacent to the building. The sidewalk along the ballpark edge to the
immediate south is an 8 ft planting strip, 6 ft sidewalk and a 2.5 ft foundation planting. At
a minimum, the code requires a 12 foot zone with an 8 ft sidewalk zone and trees planted
in wells. The approved ballpark sidewalk zone is the appropriate treatment for this entire
side of the access road and should be extended along the frontage of the parking deck for
continuity. We are concerned about the narrowness of the sidewalk and the fact that it is
not consistent with the approved stadium area. There is a primary stair tower exiting onto
the access road so it can be assumed that many people will egress onto that sidewalk. In
the absence of plans for any other building, it is unclear that an additional 3.5 ft precludes
any future development. However, to the pedestrians who will be using it and the trees
growing in the planting strip (or in the tree wells), it will be of immense benefit.
Source: City of Spartanburg website. First collected Nov 1, 2026.