2019_05_09 MHAC Packet
Edgefield County · Edgefield County · meeting of May 9, 2019 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Edgefield County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Edgefield County
Mobile Home Appeals Committee
County Council Chambers
May 9, 2019
6:00 PM
James Burt – Planning Commission Chairman Dist. I
Frank Gabriel – Planning Commissioner Dist. II
Fay Adams – Planning Commissioner Dist. III
The Mobile Home Appeals Committee meets based on need. Meetings are scheduled for the 4th
Thursday (when possible) 6:00 p.m. at 225 Jeter St., Edgefield, SC. These meetings are subject
to prior cancelation or change
Table of Contents
Mobile Home Appeals Committee Special Meeting Agenda .....................................................1
April 25, 2019 Mobile Home Appeals Committee Meeting Minutes ........................................3
1
Edgefield County
Mobile Home Appeals Committee Agenda
Special Meeting
County Council Chambers
May 9, 2019
6:00 PM
James Burt Frank Gabriel Fay Adams
This agenda may be modified at any time prior to or during the meeting described herein. A vote may be held on all
agenda items. The meeting may begin after the advertised start time if a reasonable adjustment to the advertised start
time is needed for any reason.
I. Call to Order
II. Approval of Agenda
a. Approval of May 9, 2019 Mobile Home Appeals Committee Meeting Agenda
III. Approval of Minutes
a. Approval of April 25, 2019 Mobile Home Appeals Committee Meeting
Minutes
IV. Adjournment
2
Page intentional left blank.
3
Edgefield County
Mobile Home Appeals Committee Meeting
Minutes
County Council Chambers
April 25, 2019
6:00 PM
James Burt Frank Gabriel Fay Adams
The Edgefield County Mobile Home Appeals Committee Meeting was held on Thursday April 25, 2019 at the
Edgefield county Council Chambers at 225 Jeter Street in Edgefield at 6:00pm. Notice of the time date and agenda
of this meeting was provided to Edgefielddaily.com, The Edgefield Advertiser and others when requested. Any
questions regarding the Mobile Home Appeals Committee should be directed to the County’s Planner Kevin
Singletary ksingletary@edgefieldcounty.sc.gov
Members present: Burt, Adams, Gabriel
Staff present: Clark, Singletary, Wall
I. Call to Order
Burt called the meeting to order at 6:07 pm.
II. Invocation
Burt gave an invocation.
III. Approval of Agenda
a. Approval of April 25, 2019 Mobile Home Appeals Committee Meeting
Agenda
Adams made a motion to approve the April 25, 2019 agenda. Gabriel seconded
the motion. Burt put the motion to a vote. All voted in favor (3-0). Motion passed.
IV. Public Hearing
a. Variance Request for a RV to be Used as a Temporary Residence
i. Mr. James Butler is requesting that the Mobile Home Appeals Committee
grant variance for a Recreation Vehicle to be used on his property as a
temporary residence. The property in question is (Parcel ID: 134-00-00-
002-000) which is located off of Scout Pond Rd. Mr. Butler will have an
opportunity to speak to the Mobile Home Appeals Committee before the
public hearing, during the public hearing, and may be called to the podium
to answer questions for the Committee.
Burt called the public hearing to order and asked if there were any public
comments.
Amanda Curry said she has land adjacent to the property asking for the
variance. She said that the last time she tried to get to her property she
wasn’t able to get to it because there was a gate at the road. Burt asked her
4
what her parcel number was and she stated 134-00-00-011-000. Singletary
said pointing out on the map that is the property just above Mr. Butler’s, it
is in the form of a triangle. Adams asked if there had been a road there
previously and Ms. Curry said yes years ago, there was a couple that lived
there but moved and since then they haven’t been able to access it. Adams
asked her if she had spoken to Mr. Butler about the gate and she replied no
that she didn’t even know who owned the property. Singletary told her to
come to the Building and Planning Department and bring her deed and
plat and they can help her find out about the easement to access her
property because no one can deny you access to your property. Burt said
he would also make a note to go check it out. Adams asked Mr. Butler if
he has denied them access to their property and Butler answered no and
Clark came up and showed the committee where Mr. Butler’s property and
easement is in conjunction to hers. Adams said that according to
Singletary, it’s not Mr. Butler that’s denying her access it’s the owner on
the other side of her that is denying access. There was more discussion
about the properties on the map. Clark clarified that she needs to come see
Singletary so he can see if she has deeded access through the other parcels
of land.
Burt called James Butler to the podium.
Butler stated his name was James Butler and his property is at 134-00-00-
0002, his 911 address is 109 Scout Pond Road. He said he and his wife
bought the property to build their home, while we were waiting to get
closed on the property, they have been volunteering with the Army Corp
of Engineers and living in their parks. He said they didn’t renew this year
with the Army Corp so to stay in the parks it is costing them money that
they do not have anywhere from $250-$350 every 2 weeks. He said they
already have the 1500 gallon septic tank and building permits and the well
and temporary power pole is established. He said the electric company is
coming out next week to run the underground electric. He said he
understands the ordinance is because DHEC wants to be able to control
black and gray water or your waste waters to contain those and dispose of
them properly. He said Mr. Clark came out to inspect the power pole and
caught him digging a trench in hopes that this committee will grants them
approval so they will have a direct line down to the septic. He said he’s in
the process now of breaking ground now for the foundation and
unfortunately he’s out of work waiting on the doctors to release him due to
a knee injury through his employer and he got hit head on in December
that same year, so he’s waiting on all that. He said his wife is terminal and
my mother-in-law who also stays with them has just been diagnosed with
abdominal cancer and that’s going to be costly and driving back and forth
between here and Aiken or back and forth from McCormick with the wear
and tear on vehicles and expenditures and everything else, he said he
won’t be able to watch over them and get anything accomplished at the
5
same time. He said it would be an extreme convenience to have the
campers. He said his uncle is letting them use his camper and he has one
of his own. He said he would greatly appreciate the financial help
permitting us to hook up the campers so they can have comfort with heat
and air and be able to have their waste water running into the septic tank
that is on site and be able to put a water regulator on the well so they have
fresh water into the RVs. He added it would save a lot of time, headache
and heartache.
Adams asked what kind of time frame he is looking at for the temporary
variance and Butler replied if everything works out, he is planning to have
Christmas in the house he promised his wife he would build her. Adams
asked to clarify that his wife is terminally ill along with his mother-in-law.
Butler replied his mother-in-law was just diagnosed with abdominal
cancer and his wife is terminal with System Morphea Scleroderma, the
University of Alabama saw her years ago in 2012 after a heart attack and
told them at that point 18-36 months and by the grace of God alone, she is
still with them. He said they also have a 17 year old son that’s at Strom
Thurmond High School as a junior and his daughter is attending college,
starting back in the fall and he added that’s his work crew. Adams asked
him if he’s doing the construction himself and Butler said yes ma’am.
Adams said but you will probably have help in some areas, Butler said he
was going to get a contractor to do the foundation.
Gabriel asked if it was just one RV and Butler replied that it was actually
two RVs, five people in two RV’s. Gabriel asked what type of RVs they
are, Butler said they are under 30’ pull behind camper trailers. He said in
keeping with compliance with any buildings hooked up to electricity, he
can strap the frames down for hurricane strapping to improve stability. He
added that when he read the ordinance the main reason he saw was DHEC
regulation, no more than 7 days in a 30 day period because of your water
treatments, but you can pitch a tent on your property 365 days out of the
year and that’s unregulated.
Adams asked how many acres of land and Butler answered 22.27.
Gabriel asked him where his mother-in-law was now and Butler said with
them, she’s been living with them since he and his wife got remarried in
2007, her husband skipped out on her and left her high and dry. Gabriel
said ok so you have your mother-in-law, your wife, yourself, a son and a
daughter, he asked their ages and Butler said 17 and 19 and they go to
Strom Thurmond and Aiken Tech. Gabriel asked if they had vehicles and
Butler said yes. Gabriel asked how big the house was going to be and
Butler said 1800 sqft, three bedrooms, and two baths. Gabriel asked if this
was his first request for a variance and Butler said yes. Gabriel asked if he
was staying on the property currently and Butler said they’ve been back
6
and forth to Aiken. Gabriel asked what’s in Aiken, Butler replied they
have a double-wide house in Aiken, Gabriel asked if it would
accommodate his family and Butler said being a paramedic and with her
condition, medications needing to be administered and stuff, if anything
happens to them and he’s here at the property then that means he has to
shut down everything and put everything up to secure those items, tools
and equipment, to get to them to make sure they are ok or have to meet
them in the hospital. Gabriel asked if they have phone service and Butler
said yes they do. Gabriel asked if there is a reason she has to leave her
place in Aiken. Butler said she lives with us, Gabriel said, “oh that’s your
place in Aiken” and Butler said yes.
Burt asked if he had ever built a house before and Butler said he has
worked with several construction crews before. Burt said 1800sqft and
you plan to have it done by December and you are going to do all the
plumbing, all the wiring, everything, Butler said yes sir. Burt said he just
can’t see that, he said he has a degree in carpentry/building and has done
all that stuff all his life, plumbing, certified in all that, but the point is,
number one he’s not going to approve two RVs to start with. He said if
they give a variance it’s just going to be one, and with the conditions
talking about their health, that makes it even worse because the purpose of
our ordinance is for safety and he know it’s private property but they are
responsible for the safety of all the individuals in this county, in today’s
world we have an at risk here. He went on to say if they did approve the
variance it would be on a temporary basis, and he won’t vote for two, he
said he thought that would be unsafe. He said tents are for camping and
you can’t compare RV’s and camping. He said you claim hardship but the
drive from Aiken is 45 minutes. Burt added that he couldn't see Mr. Butler
completing an 1800sqft house by himself in 9 months; it's a lot of work.
Butler said it would make a difference not to have to pack up every day
and go back to Aiken.
Adams said she feels that Mr. Butler had expressed hardship and she
doesn't see a difference in one or two RVs, if you have one out there and
you have half of your family in Aiken and the other half out there, you
haven’t saved any money, she said she’s certain it’s a financial hardship,
he has a medical problem and he’s trying to put his wife who is terminally
ill in a house before Christmas. She said she understands the County
ordinance but she would vote in favor of the variance that he has requested
and let the County deal with their ordinance. She added that they should
help people and not hinder them and he’s making an effort to build a
house that’s going to bring tax base into the county and she would be in
favor of giving him until Christmas and see what he can do.
7
Gabriel asked if there was a reason he had to leave his home in Aiken.
Butler said they haven’t lived in it in over two years, with volunteering
and working with the Army Corp of Engineers they haven’t been in the
home in two years. Gabriel asked him if he’s been traveling with his sick
wife and mother-in-law and kids. Butler said they have been in
McCormick County volunteering with the Army Corp and in order for his
son to get in with Strom Thurmond he spent the past 4 ½ months; Gabriel
interrupted by asking if they (Army Corp) provide housing for them and
Butler said no, RV. Burt asked where they stayed in McCormick. Butler
said between Modoc Campgrounds, Petersburg and they were gate
attendants for a month out at Windfield, and then spent this past winter in
Hamilton Branch. Gabriel asked if the Army Corp picked any of those
costs up and he said they provided them with a site, power and water.
Gabriel said but you still have the house in Aiken and Butler said yes sir.
Gabriel asked if he was working now and he said no, Gabriel then asked
how he was going to build his house, he said it’s not his business, but he
was just curious because he’s trying to make sure the county doesn’t get
stuck with two RVs on a lot and a foundation with no time frame and
people that are chronically ill. He said it seems to him that Aiken probably
has health care reasonably close where they are and they would be stable,
it’s legal, they won’t need any variances but instead you want to bring
them here and they’re not well and you want to build a house. He said he’s
trying to put all of this together and understand Mr. Butler’s plight, so he
said he wanted to ask some questions and he could tell him it’s none of his
business and that’s fine. Butler said he got hurt working EMS for Gold
Cross as a paramedic this was after over a year of service, they sent him
off the truck with no pay until approved and cleared by the doctor, since
then they have settled out the knee case with them and repaid the equity
note, his parents put up for him to get the property and get the services
initiated, he went on to say that the next settlement from getting hit head
on, on the way to the doctor’s office to get his surgical date for his knee
which ended up in a neck fusion, there’s $100,000 unfortunately the
lawyers are getting 1/3 of, SC law but that money is 18 days from now and
the first part of that will be coming in, that’s 100, then there’s another 75
against his insurance company that will be here in the next 4 months, so as
far as having the funds to get building materials so that he can set the
floor, sub floor, floor joist, put the double layer of ¾” in there and build
the exterior 2x6 walls and dry it in, those funds will be here in less than
three weeks. Gabriel said ok but you’re claiming financial hardship, he
said he’s not real clear on that. Butler said that as of right now he has 2
cent in his account until that check comes in. Gabriel said he understands
that he’s in a tight place and had to make some tough choices. Butler
added that as far as not staying in his place in Aiken, he would request a
closed door session. Gabriel said giving his hardship plea and then he’s
going to build a house and traveling back and forth from Aiken, it is not
that big of a deal, the cost of building a house verses the cost of two
8
trailers, kids, two ill people, God bless him for doing all this but I’m just
trying to put this puzzle together so it all makes sense. Butler said that as
soon as he can get all of his stuff out of the house in Aiken into the storage
buildings then they would be moving out there and at that point he can sell
the house in Aiken for additional funds.
Gabriel mentioned that RVs are extremely in inefficient with A/C and
heat; he added he is creating more hardship on himself other than just
staying in Aiken and waiting this out and getting his money, he said it
sounds like he’s putting the cart before the horse. Butler said he's spent
six and a half years coming to terms with his wife having terminal cancer
and he has turned it over to the Lord. He said no one knows when they
will be called up, his brother-in-law got murdered and that took money
they didn’t have to get him cremated and it hurt so being able to stay on
the property and have his wife less than 200 yards away, he could spend
more time with her while building the house, and it would be one less
mental stress and anguish. Gabriel said he understands all that and he’s not
trying to be the main thorn in his side but he’s just not real clear on why
he’s doing all this, with all this other stuff going on and he has only 2
cents in his checking account but building a house, he didn't understand
that and he feels for his situation and God Bless him for taking this on.
Butler said he promised his wife to build her a house and he was trying to
give them a little more stability and creature comfort than a tent and a cot
while he builds a house in your county and pay taxes in your county.
Gabriel said he was trying to stay focused on the variance. Butler said
what he read in the ordinance, one of the main reasons for not being able
to stay in your camper on your property is – one it can depreciate the
property if left abandoned, second is the DHEC violation for waste water -
they have the means to control that and they are just asking for the
county’s permission to enjoy it and spend time on it while they are getting
everything done.
Burt said the problem he has is if they get out there and they're still in that
camper two years from now if things don’t go right. He said the county
has ordinances and rules and regulations and we’ve got to hold them tight
because we have to deal with everybody and we have to treat everyone in
the county fair. He went on to say if they get out there and nature takes its
course the next thing is he could sue the county and attorneys go for broke
and that would put the tax payers in jeopardy. He said he might be able to
live with 6 months and one RV. He explained that the committee was in a
position that they have to represent the people of the county and they trust
them to keep the ordinances.
Gabriel asked if the RVs would be on a concrete slabs because if not the
bottom will fall out of them, the tires and frame can’t handle it if it's not
on something solid. He also made the point to say that if he is the sole
9
caregiver for these people, he is taking a tremendous risk because if
something happens to him in the process of building the house and he
winds up with a broken back because he fell off a ladder. Butler said at
least they would be there to witness it and get him some help. Gabriel said
yea but there goes their caregiver. Butler said that’s why they have a son
and daughter. Gabriel went on to say this isn’t making sense and it was a
tremendous liability, and he’s putting himself and the people that he loves
in jeopardy. He added he didn’t see a problem with one or two months.
Adams said she doesn't own a RV or know anything about camping but
her step-son and daughter-in-law lived in a RV while they were building
their house in Saluda County. She said he did a lot of the work but he had
contractors come in and help and she truly believes that Mr. Butler will
need some help, but if he doesn’t have a hardship then she’s never heard
of one. She added that she knows what it means to be close to loved ones
while they are sick. She said she is in favor of approving the variance and
just let County Council look at their ordinance if he goes past his time, let
them handle it. Gabriel said he’s not sure that’s how it works.
Butler said he saw no record in the ordinance about sleeping or residing in
a tent on your property, which is thinner material than shirts now, and
running extension cords for a/c. He said the RV would be safer from hail,
wind and bugs and provide a little more sense of security then a tent and
you could dispose of your sewage also. He said all the ordinance talks
about is DHEC violations of controlling waste.
Gabriel said the trailer itself is not HUD approved and the living
conditions of five people in two RVs would make conditions difficult and
putting two sick women in the middle of nowhere, what if you have to run
errands and leave them. Butler said he would take them with him. Gabriel
tried to clarify again that Mr. Butler wasn't working, only had two cents in
the bank, two sick people and now throwing in building a house all by
himself. Burt added that he has been building houses all his life and it's
impossible to do it in 9 months.
Gabriel made a motion to vote on the variance.
Burt made them motion to deny the variance. Gabriel seconded the
motion. Burt put the motion to a vote. Two voted in favor, one against (2-
1). Dissenting votes: Adams. Motion passed.
Butler asked about appealing their vote and Singletary told him decisions
by the Committee are final.
Adjournment
10
Gabriel made a motion to adjourn. Adams seconded the motion. Burt put
the motion to a vote. All voted in favor (3-0). Motion passed. Meeting
adjourned at 6:56 pm.
Source: Edgefield County website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.