RecordWell Data

County Council Ad-Hoc Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Committee — Agenda Packet

Lancaster County · Lancaster County · General · meeting of Feb 19, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Lancaster County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Committee Members District 1: Stuart Graham District 4: Jose Luis District 5: Steve Harper, Chair Citizen: Maggie Norris Citizen: Darrell Walters PC Chair: Shelly Richards PC Vice-Chair: Judianna Tinklenberg Development Serv. Dir.: Allison Hardin Zoning Director: Shannon Catoe Ex-Officio: James Mulvaney Interim County Administrator Steve Willis County Attorney Ginny L. Merck-Dupont Clerk to Council Sherrie Simpson February 19, 2026 6:00 PM LANCASTER COUNTY COUNCIL County Council Ad-Hoc Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Committee Administration Conference Room, County Administration Building, 101 North Main Street, Lancaster, SC 29720 AGENDA 1. Call to Order County Council Ad-Hoc Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Committee Meeting - Committee Chair Steve Harper 2. Approval of the Agenda 3. Citizens Comments [Lancaster County Council welcomes comments and input from citizens who may not be able to attend Council meetings in person. Written comments may be submitted via mail to ATTN: Sherrie Simpson, Post Office Box 1809, Lancaster, SC, 29721, by email to Sherrie Simpson at ssimpson@lancastercountysc.gov or by online submission by selecting the "Citizens Comments" link located on the County website homepage under the Agendas and Minutes quick link at https://www.lancastercountysc.gov/. Comments must be no longer than approximately 3 minutes when read aloud. Comments received will be acknowledged during the Citizens Comments portion of the meeting. Comments will need to be received prior to 4:00 p.m. on the day of the meeting. Please use the same link above in order to submit input/comments for Public Hearings. *Please note that any handouts presented to Council or Council Boards and Commissions become an official part of the record and a copy is attached to the legal minutes for the meeting.] 4. Discussion and Action Items a. Approval of Minutes from the February 11, 2026, County Council Ad-Hoc Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Committee Meeting b. Decision Points - Allison Hardin c. Discussion of Subdivisions - Allison Hardin 5. Adjournment Anyone requiring special services to attend this meeting should contact 285-1565 at least 24 Page 1 of 77 hours in advance of this meeting. Lancaster County Council agendas are posted at the Lancaster County Administration Building and are available on the Website: https://www.lancastercountysc.gov/ Page 2 of 77 Agenda Item Summary Ordinance # / Resolution # : N/A Contact Person / Sponsor: Sherrie Simpson, Clerk to Council Department: Administration Date Requested to Be on Agenda: 2/19/2026 Council Action Requested: Approve or amend the minutes from the February 11, 2026, County Council Ad-Hoc Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Committee meeting. Strategic Plan Focus Alignment: Points to Consider: The draft minutes from the February 11, 2026, County Council Ad-Hoc Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Committee meeting are attached for Council's review and consideration. Funding and Liability Factors: There are no funding or liability factors regarding the approval of minutes. Recommendation: Approve the minutes as written. Attachments: 1. Draft Minutes from the 2-11-2026, County Council Ad-Hoc UDO Committee meeting Page 3 of 77 Page 4 of 77 Page 5 of 77 Page 6 of 77 Agenda Item Summary Ordinance # / Resolution # : N/A Contact Person / Sponsor: Allison Hardin, Dev. Service Dir Department: Planning Department Date Requested to Be on Agenda: 2/19/2026 Council Action Requested: Decision Points related to January 15, 2026 agenda Strategic Plan Focus Alignment: Quality Development Points to Consider: The consultants prepared a two-page Decision Point memo for the County Council, outlining 17 points where Council input was needed in the UDO draft. This memo was provided to the ad- hoc committee early on and in the packet for Jan 7, 2026. Discussions regarding tree save will help address the following decision point(s): TOPIC REFERENCE PAGE Consideration of a new Open Space Subdivision design option to replace the current Cluster Subdivision Overlay. § 9.3.3: Open Space Subdivision Design 394 Funding and Liability Factors: Recommendation: Include these considerations in the discussions. Attachments: 1. Decision Points Chart from White Smith Page 7 of 77 COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE i DECISION POINTS This document includes several decision points in callout boxes for County Counc il’s consideration and discussion. These decision point boxes identify topics that Council or County staff inquired about or requested more deliberation on and are located at the beginning of the chapter or section addressing the topic. The list below inc ludes a brief description of each topic and hypertext links to the location of the decision point in the draft. TOPIC REFERENCE PAGE Evaluation of the proposed Character Area Overlay to vary the development standards by geographical area. § 2.7.1: Character Area Overlay Districts 45 Preferences on future implementation of the Carolina Heelsplitter preservation standards. § 2.7.2: Carolina Heelsplitter Overlay District 49 Consideration of the need for the Highway Corridor Overlay in light of the proposed Character Area Overlay. § 2.7.3: Highway Corridor Overlay District 55 Preferences on inclusion of purpose statements for the various topics regulated. Ch. 4: Landscaping & Open Space 217 Preferences on details about buffer standards. § 4.3.2.3: Buffer Types 225 Preferences on screening for drive-thrus. § 4.3.4.7: Drive-Thru Facilities in the Northern Panhandle Overlay District 245 Consideration of proposed open space ratios in subdivisions and implementation details for open space. § 4.6.3: Open Space Requirements 269 Evaluation of the option for the deferred construction of required parking. § 5.3.3: Deferred Parking Plans 295 Consideration of continuing the regulation of outdoor lighting. Ch.6: Outdoor Lighting 321 Evaluation of prohibited lighting types. § 6.2.3: Prohibited Outdoor Lighting Preferences to regulate off-site lighting impacts. § 6.5: Limits to Off-Site Impacts 328 Preferences to provide special standards for security lighting. § 6.7.4: Security Lighting 335 Evaluation of whether to regulate signs by zoning district, Character Area, or both. Ch.7: Signs 342 Consideration of a new Open Space Subdivision design option to replace the current Cluster Subdivision Overlay. § 9.3.3: Open Space Subdivision Design 394 Page 8 of 77 COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE ii Preferences for regulation of required subdivision and site improvements by zoning district, Character Area, or both. § 9.4.1: Required Improvements for All Development 402 Consideration of external connection standards for residential subdivisions. § 9.6.4: External Connections 422 Consideration of the location of the flood damage prevention, stormwater management, and sediment and erosion control regulations and implementation details for these regulations. Ch.10: Natural Resources Protection 455 Page 9 of 77 Agenda Item Summary Ordinance # / Resolution # : N/A Contact Person / Sponsor: Allison Hardin, Dev. Service Dir Department: Planning Department Date Requested to Be on Agenda: 2/19/2026 Council Action Requested: Strategic Plan Focus Alignment: Points to Consider: The Ad-Hoc committee has discussed lot sizes and alternatives through multiple meetings; this is where we should use those discussions to determine, with the help of the consultants, how subdivisions will look in the future of Lanaster County. Some topics that should be discussed: 1. Should all residential subdivisions be held to the same standard based on their zoning district? Or is there an interest in higher standards in the Panhandle? 2. What will be the final vision of Conservation subdivisions? What zones will be allowed this option? 3. What information will be required for a subdivision application? Should a tree survey be required for the buffer areas? 4. Is there still a consensus that any commercial subdivisions will go through the full review with Planning Commission? 5. Is there an interest in requiring a small percentage of every large subdivision proposal (100+ lots) be set aside for starter homes? 6. Should lot size be determined by housing type instead of a static minimum in each zone? Attachments from the Smart Growth Manual are provided for information and resource on select subdivision-related issues. Sections of Draft UDO included in this packet: • Section 9 Subdivision Standards - General (including Conservation and Townhome subdivision regulations) • Section 11.1 Procedures - General Provisions • Section 11.2 Land Development Procedures • Section 11.2.6 Waivers (appeal process for Planning Commission), 11.2.7 Land Development Interpretations, and 11.2.8 Appeals of Administrative Decisions Page 10 of 77 Funding and Liability Factors: Recommendation: Attachments: 1. Section 9 Subdivision 9-30-25 v2 2. Section 11 Procedures 9-30-25 v2-2 3. Section 11.2 Land Development 9-30-25 v2-3 4. Section 11-2-6 Subdivision Waivers 9-30-25 v2-4 5. Subdivision - Smart Growth Manual 6. Zoning-Practice-2023-02-Rev Gentle Density Page 11 of 77 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS 9 9.1 PURPOSE 9.2.1 SCOPE COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 390 9 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS380 9.1 PURPOSE381 The purpose of this Chapter is to establish criteria for the site development and subdivision of real property within the jurisdiction of Lancaster County. These standards are intended to: A. Provide for the protection of the public health, safety, and welfare; B. Promote the orderly growth and development of Lancaster County; C. Provide for suitable residential and nonresidential development with adequate streets, utilities, and appropriate building sites; and D. Coordinate streets within proposed subdivisions with existing or planned streets and with other public facilities. 9.2 APPLICABILITY382 9.2.1 SCOPE The provisions of this Chapter shall apply to all land within Lancaster County’s jurisdiction and to those municipalities that have adopted this UDO. 380 This Chapter generally carries forward the current requirements of Chapter 6: Subdivision and Site Improvements with reorganization and other changes to improve the clarity and usability of the UDO. Some provisions have been relocated to other parts of the UDO: • TIA standards with staff changes have been relocated to Chapter 14: Submittal Requirements; • Street naming standards and procedures have been relocated to Chapter 10: Procedures; and • The variance provisions in 6.13.4: Variances have been relocated to Chapter 10: Procedures. Major changes include adding a new Open Space Subdivision design to resolve issues with the Cluster Subdivision Overlay and adding a new Townhouse Subdivision design. The Chapter also incorporates the Character Area Overlays for the applicability of development standards for subdivisions. 381 Carries forward Section 6.1: Purpose and Intent. 382 Carries forward Section 6.2: Scope and Applicability with change to clarify that the Chapter also applies to any municipalities that have adopted the UDO. Page 12 of 77 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS 9 9.2 APPLICABILITY 9.2.2 SUBDIVISION & SITE PLAN APPLICABILITY COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 391 9.2.2 SUBDIVISION & SITE PLAN APPLICABILITY383 A. Subdivisions. This Chapter applies to all Subdivisions as defined by this UDO, except for the following types of subdivisions: 1. The combination or recombination of portions of previously platted lots where the total number of lots is not increased and the resultant lots are equal to the standards of the governing authority; 2. The division of land into parcels of five acres or more where no new street is involved, and plats of these exceptions must be received as information by the planning agency, which shall indicate that fact on the plats; and 3. The combination or recombination of entire lots of record where no new street or change in existing streets is involved. B. Site Plans. 1. This Chapter applies to all other developments for which this UDO requires a site plan. 2. Developments requiring a site plan must comply with the generally applicable development and design standards, including Section 9.4: General Subdivision & Site Design Standards. 9.2.3 LAND SUITABILITY A. Unsuitable Land. The Administrator shall not approve for residential or commercial occupancy: 1. Land subject to flooding, insufficient drainage, or erosion; 2. Wetlands; 3. Land that has been used for the disposal of solid waste and not adequately mitigated; and 4. Any other land uses that would increase the danger to health, life, or property, or increase the flood hazard. 383 This Subsection significantly updates the applicability standards to remove North Carolina subdivision authority and clarifies the applicability of the Chapter to subdivisions and commercial developments requiring site plan approval. Page 13 of 77 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS 9 9.3 SUBDIVISION DESIGN 9.2.4 REQUIRED CONFORMANCE TO LANCASTER COUNTY SPECIFICATIONS MANUAL COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 392 B. Platting of Unsuitable Land. Unsuitable land shall be reserved for open space or buffers on all plats and shall not be part of a platted development lot. 9.2.4 REQUIRED CONFORMANCE TO LANCASTER COUNTY SPECIFICATIONS MANUAL A. County Council adopts and approves the Lancaster County Manual of Specifications, Standards, and Design (MSSD), which is located in Appendix C and is incorporated by reference in this UDO. B. Conformance to the MSSD is required in addition to the standards in this UDO. 9.3 SUBDIVISION DESIGN384 9.3.1 SUMMARY OF AVAILABLE SUBDIVISION DESIGNS385 A. The available subdivision designs for a parcel are based on the Character Area Overlay Districts (see Section 2.7.1: Character Area Overlay Districts). B. Table 9.3.1-1: Subdivision Designs Available in Each Character Area lists the subdivision design options permitted in each Character Area. Table 9.3.1-1: Subdivision Designs Available in Each Character Area SUBDIVISION DESIGN CHARACTER AREA REFERENCE NORTHERN PANHANDLE CENTRAL LANCASTER RURAL LANCASTER Conventional    9.3.2 Open Space    F Townhome    9.3.4 Key:  = Standard Applies |  = Standard Does Not Apply 384 This new Section clarifies the applicability of subdivision design standards, revises the Cluster Subdivision Overlay as an Open Space Subdivision design, and adds a Townhouse Subdivision design. 385 This new Subsection provides a matrix for the availability of subdivision designs by district. Page 14 of 77 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS 9 9.3 SUBDIVISION DESIGN 9.3.2 CONVENTIONAL RESIDENTIAL SUBDIVISIONS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 393 9.3.2 CONVENTIONAL RESIDENTIAL SUBDIVISIONS386 9.3.2.1 Purpose A. Conventional subdivisions are intended to provide contemporary subdivision outcomes that appeal to some residents of Lancaster County. B. Generally, conventional subdivisions include a hierarchical street system and limited connectivity to and within the development, with many streets ending in cul-de- sacs. 9.3.2.2 Applicability A. The standards contained in this Subsection apply to all proposed conventional subdivisions. B. Any proposed subdivision that does not meet the standards for an Open Space Subdivision or Townhouse Subdivision will be treated as a conventional subdivision. 9.3.2.3 Conventional Subdivision Design Standards Conventional subdivisions must comply with the generally applicable development and design standards, including: A. Section 9.4: General Subdivision & Site Design Standards; B. Section 9.5: General Lot Standards; C. Section 9.6: Connectivity; D. Section 9.7: Street Classifications; E. Section 9.8: Street Design and Construction Standards; and F. Section 9.9: Uniform Addressing and Numbering. 386 This new Subsection clarifies what standards apply to conventional subdivisions. Page 15 of 77 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS 9 9.3 SUBDIVISION DESIGN 9.3.3 OPEN SPACE SUBDIVISION DESIGN COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 394 9.3.3 OPEN SPACE SUBDIVISION DESIGN387 387 This Subsection significantly updates 4.4.1: Cluster Subdivision Overlay District (CSO). Important changes include: • Converting this option from a zoning overlay to a subdivision design; • Changing the name from “cluster” to “open space” to clarify the intent for provision of open space and to distinguish this option from previous practice; • Removing the requirement for a development agreement; • Adding clustering for groups of houses to reduce the density of houses in a specific area; • Changing the district in which the subdivision is allowed from MDR to LDR to better allow this development type while increasing the minimum lot size; • Increasing the minimum lot size to ½ acre (septic) and ¼ acre (sewer) to better accommodate this development type in areas without sewer service; • Removing the lot yield calculation. This subdivision option will be at the developer’s choice based on market and site characteristics; however, development outcomes will be certain because of required minimum lot sizes in the base district and in this subdivision design; Decision Point: This Subsection significantly changes current Subsection 4.1.1: Cluster Subdivision Overlay District (CSO). The footnote below outlines the important changes. The goals were to update the standards for flexible residential development while 1) ensuring that the density of dwelling units is appropriate; 2) requiring usable open space for the residents; and 3) addressing conservation concerns for sensitive areas, like wetlands and floodplains. • Does the Open Space Subdivision Design address County Council’s concerns with density of dwelling units? • Does the Open Space Subdivision Design require the preferred amount of usable open space? • Does the Open Space Subdivision Design require the preferred amount of overall conservation area? • The Open Space Subdivision Design regulates density by lot size. Should the design use the general gross density measurement instead? • Should the subdivision design include a density bonus as an incentive? • Is this subdivision design appropriate in locations that are served by sewer and those that are not? Or should it only be allowed in locations served by sewer? • Is this subdivision type appropriate in the LDR district and not the MDR District? Page 16 of 77 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS 9 9.3 SUBDIVISION DESIGN 9.3.3 OPEN SPACE SUBDIVISION DESIGN COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 395 9.3.3.1 Purpose A. Generally. 1. Open space subdivisions are residential developments that offer an alternative to traditional subdivision design. 2. Open space subdivisions are designed using a site planning technique that concentrates buildings and structures in the most buildable areas of a site in order to preserve the remaining area as open space for recreation and preservation of significant site features. B. Purpose. The purposes of the Open Space Subdivision Design standards include: 1. Encouraging accessible open space in residential developments to improve the residents’ quality of life; 2. Preserving scenic views and elements of the County's rural character and to minimize perceived density by minimizing views of new development from existing roads; 3. Minimizing site disturbance and erosion through retention of existing vegetation and avoiding development on steep slopes; 4. Preserving land for conservation, including those areas containing unique and sensitive features such as natural areas and wildlife habitats, steep slopes, streams, wetlands, and floodplains; 5. Providing for the recreational needs of county residents; 6. Allowing greater flexibility and efficiency in the siting of services and infrastructure by reducing road length, utility runs, and the amount of paving for development; and 7. To encourage the maintenance and enhancement of habitat for various forms of wildlife and to create new woodlands through natural succession and reforestation where appropriate. • Removing different standards for road widths; and • Simplifying buffers and open space regulations by cross-referencing the general standards in Section 4.6: Open Space. Page 17 of 77 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS 9 9.3 SUBDIVISION DESIGN 9.3.3 OPEN SPACE SUBDIVISION DESIGN COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 396 9.3.3.2 Applicability A. Generally. 1. The standards contained in this Subsection apply to all proposed Open Space subdivisions. 2. The following generally applicable subdivision design and infrastructure standards also apply unless a specific provision in this Subsection provides a different standard for Open Space Subdivisions: (a) Section 9.4: General Subdivision & Site Design Standards; (b) Section 9.5: General Lot Standards; (c) Section 9.6: Connectivity; (d) Section 9.7: Street Classifications; (e) Section 9.8: Street Design and Construction Standards; and (f) Section 9.9: Uniform Addressing and Numbering. B. Location and Minimum Acreage. 1. Zoning Districts. Open Space subdivisions are only permitted in the Low Density Residential District. Open Space subdivisions are not permitted in any other zoning districts. 2. Minimum Site Area. The minimum area for an Open Space subdivision is 30 gross acres in a contiguous parcel or parcels. 3. Street Access. Open Space subdivisions must adjoin or have direct access to at least one collector or higher-level street. 9.3.3.3 Open Space Requirement A. Required Open Space. An Open Space Subdivision must include the minimum open space provided in Table 9.3.3.3-1: Open Space Requirements. Table 9.3.3.3-1: Open Space Requirements CHARACTER AREA OPEN SPACE REQUIREMENT IMPROVED OPEN SPACE1 Northern Panhandle 40% 10% Central Lancaster 50% 5% Rural Lancaster 50% N/A Page 18 of 77 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS 9 9.3 SUBDIVISION DESIGN 9.3.3 OPEN SPACE SUBDIVISION DESIGN COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 397 Table 9.3.3.3-1: Open Space Requirements CHARACTER AREA OPEN SPACE REQUIREMENT IMPROVED OPEN SPACE1 1 For information on the requirements for improved open space, refer to Section 4.6.4: Open Space Types. B. Open Space Calculations. 1. Generally. (a) Open space is measured as a percentage of the total subdivision area as calculated in Subsection 4.6.3: Open Space Requirements. It includes: (1) Tree save areas required by Section 4.5: Tree Preservation; and (2) Improved open space required by this Subsection. (b) Improved open space is measured as a percentage of the total subdivision area. It is included in and not additional to the open space requirement. 2. Open Space. Required open space areas include the areas described in Section 4.6.4: Open Space Types, such as natural and improved open space, with a preference for the preservation of important scenic vistas, environmentally sensitive lands, habitat for wildlife, and historically or archaeologically significant areas. 3. Excluded Uses. Open space areas may not include land uses excluded from the open space calculation in Subsection 4.6.3: Open Space Requirements. 4. Improved Open Space. Improved open space required by this Section must only consist of the improved open space types listed in Table 4.6.3-1: Types of Open Space. 9.3.3.4 Lot Dimensions A. Minimum Lot Area. 1. The minimum lot area in an Open Space subdivision is: (a) 21,780 square feet for subdivisions where wastewater treatment is through septic systems; and (b) 10,890 square feet for lots served by public sewer. B. Minimum Lot Width. The minimum lot width for the district applies to Open Space Subdivisions. Page 19 of 77 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS 9 9.3 SUBDIVISION DESIGN 9.3.3 OPEN SPACE SUBDIVISION DESIGN COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 398 C. Setbacks. The following minimum setbacks are required for individual lots within an Open Space Subdivision. 1. Front Yard. The minimum front yard setback is 35 feet. 2. Rear Yard. The minimum rear yard setback is 25 feet. 3. Side Yard. The minimum side yard setback is 10 feet. D. Maximum Density. The maximum number of dwelling units allowed per acre does not apply to Open Space Subdivisions. 9.3.3.5 Design Standards A. Cluster Groups for Dwellings Required. Residential lots within Open Space Subdivisions shall be designed within a series of one or more Cluster Groups in accordance with the following standards. 1. Dwellings shall be located in distinct cluster groups of 20 or fewer dwellings. 2. A cluster group is defined by the outer perimeter of contiguous lots. 3. Cluster groups shall be visually defined and separated by open space that meets the requirements of Subsection 4.6.5: Location and Design of Open Space. B. Open Space Design Standards. The design standards for open space in Subsection 4.6.5: Location and Design of Open Space apply to Open Space Subdivisions. C. Pedestrian Network. Open Space Subdivisions shall include an interconnected pedestrian network comprised of sidewalks and multi-use trails that meet the following requirements. 1. Sidewalks. Sidewalks shall be provided on both sides of roads within a cluster group to connect lots and open space. 2. Greenways. Greenways shall: (a) Be located in open space areas between cluster groups; (b) Connect to the sidewalks located in cluster groups; (c) May be located on one or both sides of a road; and (d) Comply with the Greenway standards in Subsection C: (e) Greenways. Page 20 of 77 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS 9 9.3 SUBDIVISION DESIGN 9.3.4 TOWNHOUSE SUBDIVISIONS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 399 3. Connectivity. The pedestrian network within an Open Space Subdivision shall be designed to meet the following standards. (a) Sidewalks and multi-use trails shall provide a continuous pedestrian network throughout an Open Space subdivision. (b) The pedestrian network shall connect to all existing sidewalks or multi-use trails that abut the Open Space Subdivision boundary. (c) At least one sidewalk or multi-use trail shall extend to the Open Space Subdivision boundary at each subdivision entrance and connect with the existing sidewalk, if present. D. General Site Design Standards. The following general site design standards also apply: 1. Overall site design shall produce harmonious landscaping, enclosure of principal and accessory uses, sizes of structures, street patterns, and use relationships; 2. The site layout shall accommodate and preserve any features of historic, cultural, archaeological, or sensitive environmental value; 3. Individual lots, buildings, structures, streets, parking areas, utilities, and infrastructure shall be designed and sited to minimize the alteration of natural features, vegetation, and topography; and 4. Where practicable, individual lots, buildings, structures, streets, parking areas, utilities, and infrastructure should be designed and sited to be compatible with surrounding development patterns. 9.3.4 TOWNHOUSE SUBDIVISIONS388 9.3.4.1 Purpose The purpose of this Subsection is to establish additional standards for the design and development of townhouse subdivisions. 9.3.4.2 Applicability. A. The standards contained in this Subsection apply to all proposed townhouse subdivisions. 388 This new Subsection provides design standards for townhouse subdivisions. Page 21 of 77 SUBDIVISION AND INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS 9 9.3 SUBDIVISION DESIGN 9.3.4 TOWNHOUSE SUBDIVISIONS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 400 B. The following generally applicable subdivision design and infrastructure standards also apply unless a specific provision in this Subsection provides a different standard for Townhouse Subdivisions: 1. Section 9.4: General Subdivision & Site Design Standards; 2. Section 9.5: General Lot Standards; 3. Section 9.6: Connectivity; 4. Section 9.7: Street Classifications; 5. Section 9.8: Street Design and Construction Standards; and 6. Section 9.9: Uniform Addressing and Numbering. 9.3.4.3 Minimum Development Size The minimum size for a townhouse development is two acres. 9.3.4.4 Design Standards A. Sublot Access. Each sublot within a townhouse subdivision shall be provided with driveway access from either a public or private street or an alley. Where a townhome sublot is less than 24 feet wide, access may only be taken from the rear of the sublot. B. Building Design. Section 8.3.5: Townhomes provides building design standards. C. Front-Loaded Driveway Separation. Where driveway access is provided to the front of a sublot within a townhouse subdivision, each driveway shall be separated from other driveways by a minimum of eight feet and shall be designed in a manner to provide the maximum practical separation from driveway edge to driveway edge. D. Sublot Separation. The rear property lines of all sublots and exterior side property lines of each individual group of contiguous sublots within a townhouse subdivision shall be separated by a minimum distance of 20 feet. E. Sublot Outdoor Living Area. An outdoor living area shall be provided upon each sublot within a townhouse subdivision in accordance with the following standards: 1. The total outdoor living area must be at least the product of 12 feet multiplied by the width of the lot. For example, a 24-foot-wide lot would require at least a 288 square foot outdoor living area. 2. The minimum depth of any outdoor living area must be six feet. Page 22 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.1 GENERAL PROVISIONS 11.1.1 PURPOSE COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 509 11 PROCEDURES408 11.1 GENERAL PROVISIONS 11.1.1 PURPOSE409 The purposes of this Chapter are to: A. Establish an orderly process to develop land within Lancaster County consistent with standard development practices and terminology; and B. Provide a clear and comprehensible development process that is fair and equitable to all interests, including the applicants, affected neighbors, County staff and related agencies, and the County Council. 11.1.2 APPLICABILITY410 A. Generally. The provisions of this Chapter apply to all applications required by this UDO within the jurisdiction of Lancaster County. B. Construction Not to Commence Without Permit.411 A person shall not take any of the following actions without a permit or other approval if this UDO requires a permit or other approval: 408 The draft makes several important changes to the procedures provisions of the current UDO • Removes stormwater and flood control approvals from the UDO. Staff instructions were to remove and relocate the stormwater and flood control regulations to another part of the County Code. • Removes Certificates of Occupancy because these permits are governed by the Building Code, so treatment in the UDO is unnecessary. • Removes County Council determinations on conditional uses provided in 9.2.16 to comply with the S.C. Planning and Zoning Enabling Act. These uses have been converted to “Special Exception” uses that require Board of Zoning Appeals approval. • Removes 9.2.7.D: Administrative Modification of Dimensional Standards based on Council input to require strict compliance and not permit staff to waive the terms of the ordinance without a variance determined by a board. 409 This Section reorganizes current § 9.2.1: Purpose and Intent but does not make any substantive changes. 410 This Section carries forward current § 9.2.2.A. & B but does not make any substantive changes. 411 Carries forward current § 9.2.2.A. with revisions to remove passive voice. Page 23 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.1 GENERAL PROVISIONS 11.1.3 SUMMARY OF PROCEDURES COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 510 1. Use or occupy land; 2. Establish a use; 3. Erect, move, extend, enlarge, or demolish a structure; or 4. Excavate or fill any lot for the construction of any building. C. Fee Schedule. The County shall adopt a schedule of fees for applications, document processing, and fines specified in this Ordinance as part of the annual budgeting process. 11.1.3 SUMMARY OF PROCEDURES412 TABLE 11.1.3-1: SUMMARY OF PROCEDURES PERMIT/ PROCESS TYPE SECTION REVIEWING AGENCY PUBLIC NOTICE DECISION- MAKING AGENCY APPEAL PROCESS Zoning Permit 11.3.1 Admin None Admin BZA Home Occupation Permit 11.3.2 Admin None Admin BZA Temporary Use Permit 11.3.3 Admin None Admin BZA Small Wireless Permit 11.3.4 Admin None Admin BZA Special Exception Permit 11.3.5 Admin 1, 2, 3 BZA CP Variance 11.3.6 Admin 1, 2, 3 BZA CP Appeal of Administrative Decisions - Zoning 11.3.7 Admin 1, 2 BZA CP UDO Interpretations - Zoning 11.3.8 Admin None Admin BZA Minor Subdivisions & Recombinations 11.2.1 TRC None Admin PC Preliminary Plats (Major Subdivisions) 11.2.2 TRC 1, 3 PC CP 412 Carries forward current 9.2.3: Permit/Process Type Table with significant changes to match the procedures proposed in this draft. Page 24 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.1 GENERAL PROVISIONS 11.1.3 SUMMARY OF PROCEDURES COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 511 TABLE 11.1.3-1: SUMMARY OF PROCEDURES PERMIT/ PROCESS TYPE SECTION REVIEWING AGENCY PUBLIC NOTICE DECISION- MAKING AGENCY APPEAL PROCESS Civil Construction Plan 11.2.3 TRC None TRC PC Final Plats (Major Subdivisions) 11.2.4 TRC None TRC PC Street Names 11.2.5 Admin 1, PC CP Street Name Changes 11.2.5 Admin 1, 2, 3 PC CP Waivers 11.2.6 Admin 1, 2 PC CP UDO Interpretations - LDRs 11.2.7 Admin None Admin CP Appeal of Administrative Decisions - LDRs 11.2.8 Admin 1, 2 PC CP Zoning Map Amendments (Rezoning) 11.4.1 Admin, PC 1, 2, 3 County Council N/A Zoning Map Amendments for Planned Development Districts 11.4.2 TRC, PC 1, 2, 3 County Council N/A UDO Text Amendments 11.4.3 Admin, PC 1, 2 County Council N/A Comprehensive Plan 11.4.4 Admin, PC 1, 2 County Council N/A Development Agreements 11.4.5 Admin, PC 1, 2 County Council N/A Conditional Use 10.4.6 Admin Admin BZA Key: Admin = UDO Administrator/County Staff | TRC = Technical Review Committee | BZA = Board of Zoning Appeals | PC = Planning Commission | CP = South Carolina Court of Common Pleas Page 25 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.1 GENERAL PROVISIONS 11.1.4 SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 512 11.1.4 SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS413 Applications filed under this UDO must include the information required: A. By Chapter 14: Submittal Requirements; B. On the application form provided by the Development Services Department; and C. On the application checklist maintained by Development Services Department staff for the particular permit or approval. 11.1.5 PRE-APPLICATION MEETING414 A. Applicability. 1. Pre-application meetings with the UDO Administrator are required for: (a) Zoning Map Amendments (rezonings); (b) Zoning Map Amendments for Planned Development Districts; (c) Special Exception Permits; and (d) Major Subdivision – Preliminary Plats 2. An applicant may request a pre-application meeting with Development Services staff for any type of application required by this UDO. B. Timing. 1. Mandatory pre-application meetings must occur at least five (5) business days before the application is filed. 2. The applicant shall submit copies of a sketch plan and other relevant documents to the UDO Administrator at least three (3) business days before the scheduled pre-application meeting. C. Topics for Meeting. 1. The pre-application meeting is for informational purposes for the applicant and Development Services staff and can include an overview of the project, 413 The draft relocates § 9.2.5: Application Requirements to Chapter 14: Submittal Requirements. 414 This is a new Section that carries forward the scope of procedures that trigger the requirement in current UDO. It provides a uniform procedure for all pre-application meetings. Page 26 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.1 GENERAL PROVISIONS 11.1.6 COMMUNITY MEETING COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 513 site conditions, proposed uses, proposed layout, and any other information relating to the project. 2. No formal decisions are made at pre-application meetings. Comments by the applicant and Development Services staff are for purposes of information but are not binding on either the County or the applicant. 11.1.6 COMMUNITY MEETING415 A. Generally. 1. Community meetings are required for developments proposed of more than 50 lots that also require a zoning amendment (rezoning) and for Planned Development Districts (PDDs) of any size. For other applications, they are encouraged for applications before any public hearing or review by a board or commission. 2. Lancaster County is not responsible for organizing or coordinating community meetings. B. Purpose. Community meetings allow the applicant to explain the proposed project and hear the concerns of the neighborhoods and community. C. Notice. 1. Notice must be mailed to all property owners within 500 feet of the property boundary no fewer than 15 days before the meeting is held. 2. Signs containing a notice of the community meeting must be placed along the rights-of-way that abut the property, with one sign placed every 1,000 linear feet of road frontage. Signs must be a minimum of 18” x 24”, printed on both sides, and placed along the road at least 10 days before the scheduled meeting. 3. A notice of the meeting must be sent to the Lancaster County Planning & Zoning Department at least five days before the meeting. 4. All notice signs must be removed by the applicant within five days after the community meeting. 415 Carries forward current § 9.2.4.D.: Neighborhood Meeting but changes the term “neighborhood meeting” to “community meeting.” Page 27 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.1 GENERAL PROVISIONS 11.1.7 COMPLETENESS REVIEW COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 514 5. All notice actions are the responsibility of the developer and/or property owner. D. Recordkeeping. A summary of the meeting in the form of meeting notes or minutes along with a list and contact information for all attendees shall be submitted to the UDO Administrator who will forward the notes to the appropriate board for their review. 11.1.7 COMPLETENESS REVIEW416 A. Application Deadline. Applications shall be submitted to the UDO Administrator in accordance with submittal dates published on the Development Services calendar. B. Evidence of Authority. The UDO Administrator may require an applicant to present evidence of authority to submit the application. C. Application Filing Date. An application is “filed” or “submitted” on the date it is received if it is found to be complete and sufficient for processing by the Administrator. D. Sufficiency Review. The UDO Administrator has five business days to determine whether the application is complete. If the application is found to be incomplete and insufficient for processing, it will be rejected with a written notice of the information or fees that are needed. The applicant may re-apply once the insufficiency has been rectified. E. Sufficiency Determination. 1. The UDO Administrator reviews the application and accompanying materials to determine whether the application is complete and sufficient for processing. 2. An application is complete and sufficient for processing when it includes all information required for the permit or approval by this UDO and the Application Submittal Requirements list published by the Development Services Department. 416 This Section carries forward and revises § 9.2.2.C. Application Completeness Review. The revision removes the discretionary standard for the Administrator’s request for additional application materials not required in the UDO or applicable checklist and removes the discretionary allowance for the Administrator and others to deem an application incomplete after the initial five-day review period. Page 28 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.1 GENERAL PROVISIONS 11.1.8 PRIVATE RESTRICTIONS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 515 11.1.8 PRIVATE RESTRICTIONS417 A. The UDO Administrator shall request information on applications about the existence of any recorded covenants on the property that are contrary to, conflict with, or prohibit the permitted activity. B. If the UDO Administrator receives actual notice of a restrictive covenant in conflict with the permitted activity, the Administrator may not issue a permit or approval governed by this Ordinance until the applicant provides confirmation of a release from the covenant. However, this limitation does not apply to: 1. Building permits; or 2. Covenants restricting the type of structure that may be built or placed on a tract or parcel of land. C. This Section is intended to give effect to the requirements of S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29- 1145 and will be interpreted according to its terms. 11.1.9 NOTICE PROVISIONS418 A. Generally. 1. Lancaster County establishes the following notice procedures for applications under this UDO. 2. The Section for each procedure specifies the level of notice that is required. 3. Lancaster County is responsible for coordinating and completing these notice requirements. 417 This new Section is intended to implement the requirements of S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-1145 and will be interpreted according to its terms. The statute prohibits permits from being issued for applications that violate known covenants and declarations. However, it does not place a burden on Planning and Zoning staff to identify the existence of these restrictions if they are not known. 418 This Section significantly updates current § 9.2.4: Public Notification. Changes to Level 1 to require all members of the notification list to join the list on an annual basis instead of just non-media members and changes to email only notice. Changes in Level 2 for style and clarity. Completely replaces Level 3 Notice with a notice provision that complies with the South Carolina Planning and Zoning Enabling Act that includes publication, mailed notice, and posted notice. The revision removes mailed notice to all neighbors and other property owners but adds posted notice. Updates community-wide notice in current Level 3 as part of a new Level 4 as an option for community-wide rezonings. Page 29 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.1 GENERAL PROVISIONS 11.1.9 NOTICE PROVISIONS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 516 B. Notice to Applicants. The UDO Administrator shall provide written notice by email or regular mail to all applicants at least 15 days before any hearing on the matter. C. Level One – Freedom of Information Act List. 1. Required Notification Type. Level One Notice for a pending application or meeting shall be: (a) Posted in a prominent location in the County Administration Building; (b) Posted on the County’s website, and (c) Sent to each person and media provider who has filed a written request for notice with the Clerk to Council. 2. Notification List. Members may join this list on an annual renewal basis beginning January 1 of each year. Members of this distribution list must renew their participation in this distribution list on an annual basis. 3. Delivery Method. Notices shall be distributed by email. 4. Required Period of Notice. This notice shall be posted and emailed at least 24 hours before the time of the meeting. D. Level Two – General Notice in Newspaper. 1. Required Notification Type/Delivery Method. For Level Two Notice, the County shall publish a notice in a newspaper of general circulation. The notice shall include the time, place, and date of the hearing/meeting and include a description of the property and the nature of the proposal. 2. Required Period of Notice – Comprehensive Plan Amendments. The County shall publish the notice at least 30 calendar days before the hearing date. 3. Required Period of Notice – All Other Hearings and Meetings. The County shall publish a notice at least 15 calendar days before the hearing date. E. Level Three – Notification to the General Public. 1. Mailed Notice. Notice by mail will be provided to applicants and other interested parties as required by this Chapter. (a) The UDO Administrator or assignee will mail the required notice at least 15 days before any hearing for which notice is required. Page 30 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.1 GENERAL PROVISIONS 11.1.10 PUBLIC AND QUASI-JUDICIAL HEARINGS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 517 (b) Notice will be provided by regular mail unless certified mail is required by a specific process or state law. (c) Notices to property owners will be mailed to the owner’s address listed in the County’s tax records. 2. Posted Notice. (a) The UDO Administrator or assignee shall place and maintain all signs when posted notice is required for the process. (b) If posted notice is required by the process, the signs must be displayed for at least 15 days before the date of the hearing. (c) Only signs provided by the UDO Administrator may be used for posted notice. (d) Notice signs shall be placed in a conspicuous place or places on or adjacent to the affected premises. At least one sign shall be visible from each public thoroughfare that abuts the property. (e) All notice signs must be removed within five calendar days after the public hearing and returned to the UDO Administrator. (f) It is a violation of this Ordinance for any person to deface, damage, or remove posted notice signs. Page 31 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.1 MINOR SUBDIVISIONS & RECOMBINATIONS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 520 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.1 MINOR SUBDIVISIONS & RECOMBINATIONS420 11.2.1.1 Purpose The purpose of Minor Subdivision and Recombination Plat approval is to ensure that minor subdivisions and individual plats for land divisions and recombinations comply with this UDO. 11.2.1.2 Applicability A. The Minor Subdivision review process is allowed for any recombination of parcels and for those divisions of land that: 1. Do not require dedication of public utilities or public or private streets or changes to existing streets, including extension or rerouting; 2. Subdivide land into five or fewer lots (including the original lot); 3. Do not result in an increase in the number of parcels included in a subdivision previously approved by Lancaster County; and 4. Do not involve any other conditions that require any additional approvals from any County board or commission. B. Any division of land that does not meet all of the criteria in this paragraph must use the Major Subdivision process, except that townhouse buildings and multi-family buildings with units under separate individual ownership may also submit Minor Subdivision Plats after the common walls of the building are established. 11.2.1.3 Initiation A. Applicant Eligibility. An application for approval of a Minor Subdivision or Recombination Plat may be initiated by: 1. The owner of the lot that is proposed to be subdivided; or 420 This Section carries forward and reorganizes § 9.2.10.A.: Subdivision (Minor and Recombination) to match the common organization for all procedures. Clarifies that the TRC is the approval body for these applications. Removes the option for administrative relief if as-built conditions do not match the approved plat. An applicant would require a variance or waiver for further action. Page 32 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.1 MINOR SUBDIVISIONS & RECOMBINATIONS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 521 2. An agent of the owner of the lot that is proposed to be subdivided, with a notarized authorization from the lot owner. B. Application Requirements. 1. An application for approval of a Minor Subdivision or Recombination Plat shall be filed with the Development Services Department on an application form provided by the Development Services Department. 2. Chapter 14: Submittal Requirements provides the required submittals for Minor Subdivision and Recombination Plat applications. C. Pre-Application Meeting. A pre-application meeting is not required, but applicants are encouraged to call, email, or visit the Development Services Department for clarification and assistance in the preparation and submission of plats for approval. D. Stormwater Permits Required. If applicable, a Stormwater Permit is required as a prerequisite approval. 11.2.1.4 Completeness The UDO Administrator shall evaluate applications for completeness under the standards of 11.1.7: Completeness Review. 11.2.1.5 Amendments An applicant may submit additional information or amend an application for Minor Subdivision and Recombinations only in response to communications from Development Services staff that the application is not complete, as provided in 11.1.7: Completeness Review, or in response to a “Not Approved” letter from Development Services staff/TRC. 11.2.1.6 Notice Public notice is not required for this procedure. 11.2.1.7 Approval Process A. Once an application is deemed complete by the UDO Administrator, relevant staff members of the Technical Review Committee shall review the application and approve, deny, or approve with conditions the Minor Subdivision Plat within 60 days the application’s submittal. B. The UDO Administrator or assignee will sign and stamp approved Minor Subdivision or Recombination Plats. Page 33 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.1 MINOR SUBDIVISIONS & RECOMBINATIONS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 522 C. If no action is taken by the TRC and/or staff within this time period, the Minor Subdivision Plat shall be deemed approved. 11.2.1.8 Approval Criteria The TRC will review proposed Preliminary Plats for compliance with: A. The standards of this UDO; B. Applicable provisions of the County Code; C. Availability of water and sewer; and D. Other applicable state and federal laws. 11.2.1.9 Scope of Approval A. The approval of a Minor Subdivision Plat or recombination plat authorizes the applicant to record the plat with the Register of Deeds. B. No lots shall be transferred or conveyed before approval by the County and the recording of the plat for the subdivision. 11.2.1.10 Recordkeeping A. The UDO Administrator or assignee shall notify the applicant in writing of actions taken on a Minor Subdivision Plat or recombination application. B. The UDO Administrator shall retain copies of all Minor Subdivision Plats and recombination plats. 11.2.1.11 Expiration & Renewal A. Generally. The expiration and renewal of Minor Subdivision and Recombination Plat approvals are determined by the provisions of 12.9: Vested Rights. B. Filing Required. 1. All plats for Minor Subdivisions or Recombination Plats shall be recorded within 180 days of approval. Plats that are not filed within 180 days of approval are void. 2. The UDO Administrator may grant a single extension of the time for filing of up to 180 days based on a showing of good cause for the extension. Page 34 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.2 PRELIMINARY PLATS (MAJOR SUBDIVISIONS) COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 523 11.2.1.12 Appeals Appeals by the applicant or applicant’s agent must be in writing and filed within 30 calendar days of the date of the decision as provided in 11.2.8: Appeals of Administrative Decisions (Land Development). 11.2.1.13 Modifications The UDO Administrator cannot amend or modify a decision on a Minor Subdivision or Recombination Plat. An applicant or the applicant’s agent may file a new application to amend or modify an approved plat. 11.2.1.14 Reapplication An applicant or the applicant’s agent may resubmit a withdrawn or denied request for a minor subdivision or recombination at any time after the withdrawal or denial. 11.2.2 PRELIMINARY PLATS (MAJOR SUBDIVISIONS)421 11.2.2.1 Purpose A. Preliminary Plat approval is the first mandatory step in the subdivision of land for major subdivisions. B. Preliminary Plat approval is intended to ensure that all subdivisions of land and land development activities comply with the standards and requirements of this UDO. 11.2.2.2 Applicability A. Generally. Major Subdivision Preliminary Plat review applies to all proposed subdivisions of existing parcels that do not qualify for review as a Minor Subdivision or Recombination under 11.2.1.2: Applicability. This includes: 1. Subdivisions of land into more than five parcels; and 421 This Section updates 9.2.10.B.: Subdivision (Major) – Preliminary Plat to match the common organization for all procedures. Changes notification from community-wide to publication. Changes text from TRC approval to PC approval to clarify inconsistent approval authority references. Changed review period from 65 to 60 days to comply with the S.C. Planning and Zoning Enabling Act. Changes current two-year applicability to vested rights period. Page 35 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.2 PRELIMINARY PLATS (MAJOR SUBDIVISIONS) COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 524 2. Subdivisions requiring the dedication of public or private roads and utilities. B. Approval Required Before Land Disturbing Activity. Land-disturbing activity for a major subdivision shall not occur until after approval of a Preliminary Plat. 11.2.2.3 Initiation A. Applicant Eligibility. An application for approval of a Preliminary Plat may be initiated by: 1. The owners of the property that is proposed to be subdivided; or 2. An agent of the owners of the property that is proposed to be subdivided, with a notarized authorization from the lot owners. B. Application Requirements. 1. An application for approval of a Preliminary Plat shall be filed with the Development Services Department on an application form provided by the Development Services Department. 2. Chapter 14: Submittal Requirements provides the required submittals for Preliminary Plat applications. 3. A statement from the Lancaster County Water and Sewer District (LCWSD) indicating whether public utilities (water and sewer) are available to the property. C. Pre-Application Meeting. The applicant or applicant’s agent must participate in a pre-application meeting with the UDO Administrator as provided in 11.1.5: Pre- Application Meeting before filing for a Major Subdivision approval 11.2.2.4 Completeness A. The UDO Administrator shall evaluate applications for completeness under the standards of 11.1.7: Completeness Review. B. An application without the required notice from LCWSD regarding availability of public water and/or sewer is considered incomplete and will be returned to the applicant. Page 36 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.2 PRELIMINARY PLATS (MAJOR SUBDIVISIONS) COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 525 11.2.2.5 Amendments An applicant may submit additional information or amend an application for Preliminary Plat approval only in response to communications from Development Services staff that the application is not complete, as provided in 11.1.7: Completeness Review. 11.2.2.6 Notice Level One and Two Notices are required for this procedure as provided in 11.1.9: Notice Provisions. 11.2.2.7 Approval Process A. Review by Technical Review Committee. 1. Once an application is deemed complete, the TRC shall review the application for compliance and consistency with this UDO, other applicable provisions of the County Code, and other applicable state and federal regulations. 2. The UDO Administrator will summarize the findings and recommendations of the TRC in a report submitted to the Planning Commission. 3. Any proposed phasing plans for a major subdivision must be presented with the Preliminary Plat for approval by the Planning Commission after review and input from the TRC. B. Decision by the Planning Commission. 1. The UDO Administrator shall place the application on the agenda for the next regular meeting of the Planning Commission based on the Planning Commission calendar. All applications must go through the TRC review before being heard by the Planning Commission. 2. The UDO Administrator shall present an overview of the proposed subdivision to the Planning Commission and provide the report and recommendations of the TRC. 3. The Planning Commission shall review the report and recommendations from the TRC and Development Services staff, the application materials, and comments from the applicant, the applicant's representatives, and the public. 4. The Planning Commission has the authority to approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application. Page 37 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.2 PRELIMINARY PLATS (MAJOR SUBDIVISIONS) COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 526 5. The Planning Commission may only table or defer to another meeting the matter by agreement between the Commission chair and the applicant or the applicant’s agent. 6. The Planning Commission shall render a decision within 60 days of the date the application is accepted as complete unless a deferral is agreed upon by the applicant and Planning Commission. If no action is taken by the Planning Commission within this time period, the Preliminary Plat shall be deemed approved. 11.2.2.8 Approval Criteria The Planning Commission will review proposed Preliminary Plats for compliance with: A. The standards of this UDO; B. Applicable provisions of the County Code; and C. Other applicable state and federal laws. 11.2.2.9 Scope of Approval A. After the approval or approval with conditions of a Preliminary Plat by the Planning Commission, the applicant may prepare and submit Civil Construction Plans for review by the UDO Administrator and the TRC. B. The applicant shall not begin construction activities on the development site before approval of the Civil Construction Plans. 11.2.2.10 Recordkeeping A. The UDO Administrator shall notify the applicant in writing of actions taken on a Preliminary Plat application. B. The UDO Administrator shall retain copies of all Preliminary Plats. 11.2.2.11 Expiration & Renewal The expiration and renewal of Preliminary Plat approvals is determined by the provisions of 12.9: Vested Rights. 11.2.2.12 Appeals A. The appeal of Planning Commission decisions must be filed within 30 calendar days of actual notice of the decision. Page 38 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.3 CIVIL CONSTRUCTION PLANS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 527 B. Appeals shall be to the Circuit Court as provided in S.C. Code of Laws § 6-29-1150, et seq. 11.2.2.13 Modifications The UDO Administrator cannot amend or modify a decision on a Preliminary Plat. An applicant or the applicant’s agent may file a new application to amend or modify an approved plat. 11.2.2.14 Reapplication An applicant or the applicant’s agent may resubmit a withdrawn or denied request for Preliminary Plat approval at any time after the denial. Page 39 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.6 WAIVERS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 541 11.2.6 WAIVERS425 11.2.6.1 Purpose This Section establishes a procedure to allow the Planning Commission to waive requirements of Chapter 9: Subdivision & Site Design to avoid unnecessary hardships that could result from a strict application of the land development regulations. 11.2.6.2 Applicability This Section applies to all requests to waive the requirements of Chapter 9: Subdivision & Site Design. 11.2.6.3 Initiation A. Applicant Eligibility. An application for a Waiver may be initiated by: 1. The owner of the lot that is proposed to be subdivided or otherwise developed; or 2. An agent of the owner of the lot that is proposed to be subdivided or otherwise developed, with a notarized authorization from the lot owner. B. Application Requirements. 1. An application for a Waiver shall be filed with the Development Services Department on an application form provided by the Development Services Department. 2. Chapter 14: Submittal Requirements provides the required submittals for a Waiver application. C. Pre-Application Procedure. A pre-application meeting is not required, but applicants are encouraged to call, email, or visit the Development Services Department for clarification and assistance in the preparation and submission of requests for Waivers. 425 This Section provides a new “waiver” process for relief from the standards of the LDRs (analogous to variances in zoning) that will be heard by the Planning Commission. Page 40 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.6 WAIVERS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 542 11.2.6.4 Completeness The UDO Administrator shall evaluate applications for completeness under the standards of 11.1.7: Completeness Review. 11.2.6.5 Amendments An applicant may submit additional information or amend an application for a Waiver only in response to communications from Development Services staff that the application is not complete, as provided in 11.1.7: Completeness Review. 11.2.6.6 Notice Level One and Two Notices are required for this procedure as provided in 11.1.9: Notice Provisions. 11.2.6.7 Approval Process A. Review by the TRC and Development Services Staff. 1. The UDO Administrator shall solicit comments from the Technical Review Committee and other appropriate Development Services staff members regarding the Waiver request. 2. The UDO Administrator will provide a report and recommendation summarizing the County staff’s analysis of the request. B. Hearing. The Planning Commission shall review and issue a decision on all applications for Waivers. C. Authority. The Planning Commission may grant the Waiver, deny the Waiver, or may modify the standards as provided in the approval criteria below. 11.2.6.8 Approval Criteria A. When reviewing a Waiver request, the Planning Commission shall protect the public interests of the County and its citizens and consider whether the Waiver serves the general intent and spirit of this UDO. B. The Planning Commission may grant a Waiver from the terms of this Ordinance upon a finding that at least one of the following applies: 1. The Waiver requested is the minimum Waiver that will make possible the legal use of the land; Page 41 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.6 WAIVERS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 543 2. Owing to special conditions, a literal enforcement of the provisions of this Ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship or peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties; or 3. The Waiver requested will be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of this UDO and will not be injurious to a neighbor or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. 11.2.6.9 Scope of Approval A. The approval of a Waiver application waives a standard of this UDO indicated in Section 10.2.6.2 Applicability. It does not approve any specific application for land development or the subdivision of land. B. All County departments are bound by decisions on Waivers granted by the Planning Commission. 11.2.6.10 Recordkeeping A. The UDO Administrator shall notify the applicant in writing of actions taken on a Waiver application. B. The UDO Administrator shall maintain Planning Commission decisions on all Waivers with the grounds for approval or disapproval and any conditions attached to the action as a public record. C. The applicant must file the Planning Commission’s decision granting a waiver with the Lancaster County Register of Deeds and reference the subject property. 11.2.6.11 Expiration & Renewal UDO Waivers run with the land and do not expire. 11.2.6.12 Appeals A. The appeal of Planning Commission decisions must be taken within 30 calendar days of actual notice of the decision. B. Appeals shall be to the Circuit Court as provided in S.C. Code of Laws § 6-29-1150, et seq. Page 42 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.7 UDO INTERPRETATIONS (LAND DEVELOPMENT) COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 544 11.2.6.13 Modifications The Planning Commission shall not amend or modify a final decision on a Waiver. An applicant or the applicant’s agent may file a new application to amend or modify an approved Waiver after the final decision is made. 11.2.6.14 Reapplication An applicant or the applicant’s agent may resubmit a withdrawn or denied request for a Waiver at any time. 11.2.7 UDO INTERPRETATIONS (LAND DEVELOPMENT)426 11.2.7.1 Purpose A UDO Interpretation of the land development regulations is a written decision issued by the UDO Administrator regarding the interpretation of the land development provisions in this UDO. It is intended to clarify ambiguities or vagueness in the UDO and to clarify any ambiguities in future amendments. 11.2.7.2 Applicability This Section applies to all requests for interpretations of the requirements of Chapter 9: Subdivision & Site Design. 11.2.7.3 Initiation A. Applicant Eligibility. An application for a UDO Interpretation may be initiated by: 1. The owner of the lot that is proposed to be subdivided or otherwise developed; or 2. An agent of the owner of the lot that is proposed to be subdivided or otherwise developed, with a notarized authorization from the lot owner. B. Application Requirements. 426 This new provision allows the UDO Administrator to issue interpretations of the LDRs that are appealable to the Planning Commission. Page 43 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.7 UDO INTERPRETATIONS (LAND DEVELOPMENT) COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 545 1. An application for a UDO Interpretation shall be filed with the Development Services Department on an application form provided by the Development Services Department. 2. Chapter 14: Submittal Requirements provides the required submittals for a UDO Interpretation application. C. Pre-Application Procedure. A pre-application meeting is not required, but applicants are encouraged to call, email, or visit the Development Services Department for clarification and assistance in requests for UDO Interpretations. 11.2.7.4 Completeness The UDO Administrator shall evaluate applications for completeness under the standards of 11.1.7: Completeness Review. 11.2.7.5 Amendments An applicant may submit additional information or amend an application for a UDO Interpretation only in response to communications from Development Services staff that the application is not complete, as provided in 11.1.7: Completeness Review. 11.2.7.6 Notice Public notice is not required for this procedure. 11.2.7.7 Approval Process The UDO Administrator may approve or deny a request for an interpretation by issuing a written decision that shall be delivered by regular mail to the applicant. 11.2.7.8 Approval Criteria A. The UDO Administrator may issue a UDO Interpretation if there is an ambiguity or need for clarification demonstrated by the applicant. The interpretation shall be based on the purposes and standards of this UDO, other applicable laws, and previous interpretations of this UDO. B. The UDO Administrator may deny or reject the request if there is no ambiguity or need for clarification demonstrated by the applicant. C. The UDO Administrator shall render only one interpretation per issue. If an applicant requests an interpretation of an issue previously addressed, the Page 44 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.7 UDO INTERPRETATIONS (LAND DEVELOPMENT) COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 546 Administrator shall provide the Applicant with a copy of the previous interpretation. D. When interpreting the UDO, the UDO Administrator shall consider the standards of the UDO as the minimum provisions for the protection of the health, safety, and welfare of the general public. E. The UDO Administrator may rely on national, state, or local design standards, at the UDO Administrator’s discretion, when the UDO fails to address an issue. 11.2.7.9 Scope of Approval A. A UDO Interpretation becomes effective upon execution by the UDO Administrator. B. The UDO Interpretation applies to the review of: 1. Any pending application for the applicant who applied for the interpretation; and 2. All future applications filed on or after the effective date. 11.2.7.10 Recordkeeping A. The UDO Administrator shall notify the applicant in writing of the decision on a UDO Interpretation request. B. The UDO Administrator shall number UDO Interpretations sequentially in the order of their issuance and keep on file centrally where all UDO reviewers may access the interpretation. C. The Development Services Department shall maintain UDO Interpretations for public access and review in hard copy and on its Internet site until the County Council amends the applicable section of the UDO to clarify the UDO’s intended meaning. 11.2.7.11 Expiration & Renewal UDO Interpretations are valid until the County Council amends the applicable section of the UDO to clarify the UDO’s intended meaning. 11.2.7.12 Appeals Appeals by the applicant or applicant’s agent must be in writing and filed within 30 calendar days of the date of the decision as provided in 11.2.8: Appeals of Administrative Decisions (Land Development). Page 45 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.8 APPEALS OF ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS (LAND DEVELOPMENT) COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 547 11.2.7.13 Modifications A decision on a UDO Interpretation may be amended or modified by the UDO Administrator based on additional information from the applicant in response the UDO Interpretation issued by the Administrator. 11.2.7.14 Reapplication An applicant or the applicant’s agent may resubmit a withdrawn or denied request for a UDO Interpretation at any time. 11.2.8 APPEALS OF ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS (LAND DEVELOPMENT)427 11.2.8.1 Purpose The purpose of the appeals procedure is to allow the Planning Commission to review certain decisions made by the UDO Administrator or Technical Review Committee. 11.2.8.2 Applicability This Section applies to appeals by parties aggrieved by any administrative order, requirement, decision, or determination made by the UDO Administrator, TRC, or any other County administrative officer under: A. Chapter 9: Subdivision & Site Design; and B. Section 11.2: Land Development Procedures. 11.2.8.3 Initiation A. Applicant Eligibility. An application for an Appeal under the Land Development Regulations may be initiated by: 1. The owner of the lot that is proposed to be subdivided or otherwise developed; 427 This Section updates current § 9.2.14: Appeal of Administrative Decisions by limiting this class of decisions to the LDRs. It also removes the public notice requirement and makes the Planning Commission the decision-making body. Page 46 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.8 APPEALS OF ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS (LAND DEVELOPMENT) COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 548 2. An agent of the owner of the lot that is proposed to be subdivided or otherwise developed, with a notarized authorization from the lot owner; or 3. Any officer, department, board, or bureau of the County. B. Appeal Deadline. An appeal must be filed within 30 calendar days of the date of the decision notice or letter by filing an application to appeal with the UDO Administrator. C. Application Requirements. 1. An application for an Appeal of an Administrative Decision shall be filed with the Development Services Department on an application form provided by the Development Services Department. 2. Chapter 14: Submittal Requirements provides the required submittals for Appeal applications. D. Pre-Application Procedure. A pre-application meeting is not required, but applicants are encouraged to call, email, or visit the Development Services Department for clarification and assistance in the preparation and submission of Appeals. 11.2.8.4 Completeness The UDO Administrator shall evaluate applications for completeness under the standards of 11.1.7: Completeness Review. 11.2.8.5 Amendments An applicant may submit additional information or amend an application for an Appeal of Administrative Decisions only in response to communications from Development Services staff that the application is not complete, as provided in 11.1.7: Completeness Review. 11.2.8.6 Notice Level One and Level Two Notices are required for this procedure. 11.2.8.7 Approval Process A. Once an application is deemed complete, the UDO Administrator shall place the matter on the next regular meeting of the Planning Commission. Page 47 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.2 LAND DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 11.2.8 APPEALS OF ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS (LAND DEVELOPMENT) COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 549 B. The UDO Administrator shall present an overview of the Appeal application to the Planning Commission and provide the report and recommendations of the Development Services Department. C. Any party may appear in person or be represented by an agent at the hearing. D. After conducting the hearing, the Planning Commission shall adopt an order reversing or affirming, wholly or in part, or modifying the order requirements, decision, or determination in question. E. In deciding the Appeal, the Planning Commission shall have the powers of the officer from whom the appeal is taken and may issue or direct the issuance of a permit. F. The Planning Commission must act on the appeal within 60 days of the date when the Appeal is accepted as complete by the UDO Administrator. 11.2.8.8 Approval Criteria In considering an appeal of an administrative decision, the Planning Commission shall apply the purposes and standards of this UDO, other applicable laws, and previous interpretations of this UDO by the Commission and UDO Administrator. 11.2.8.9 Scope of Approval Approval of an Appeal does not authorize development. Any development that occurs after the decision on the Appeal is subject to all applicable requirements of this UDO, as amended by the Planning Commission’s decision, if applicable. 11.2.8.10 Recordkeeping A. The UDO Administrator shall notify the applicant in writing of actions taken on an Appeal. B. The decision of the Planning Commission must be in writing and permanently filed in the minutes of that reviewing body as a public record. C. All findings of fact and conclusions of law must be separately stated in final decisions or orders of the Planning Commission, which must be delivered to parties of interest by certified mail. 11.2.8.11 Expiration & Renewal Decisions on an Appeal do not expire and will govern all further actions on a development application and other actions for the development of the same site. Page 48 of 77 PROCEDURES 11 11.3 ZONING PROCEDURES 11.3.1 ZONING PERMITS COMBINED PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT | 9-30-25 LANCASTER COUNTY, SC UDO UPDATE PAGE 550 11.2.8.12 Appeals A. The appeal of Planning Commission decisions must be taken within 30 calendar days of actual notice of the decision. B. Appeals shall be to the Circuit Court as provided in S.C. Code of Laws § 6-29-1150, et seq. 11.2.8.13 Modifications A decision on an Appeal may not be amended or modified by the Planning Commission. 11.2.8.14 Reapplication An applicant or the applicant’s agent may resubmit a withdrawn or denied request for an Appeal after the withdrawal or denial if the time to appeal has not expired. Page 49 of 77 Page 50 of 77 Page 51 of 77 Page 52 of 77 Page 53 of 77 Page 54 of 77 Page 55 of 77 Page 56 of 77 Page 57 of 77 Page 58 of 77 Page 59 of 77 Page 60 of 77 Page 61 of 77 Page 62 of 77 Page 63 of 77 Page 64 of 77 FEBRUARY 2023 | VOL. 40 NO. 2 ZONING PRACTICE Practice Gentle Density In this Issue: The Legacy of Single-Family-Only Zoning | State and Local Responses | Gentle Density Zoning Standards | Public Involvement | Conclusion Unique Insights | Innovative Approaches | Practical Solutions Page 65 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 2 Practice Gentle Density By Jackie Berg, aicp, and John Houseal, faicp Cities, towns, and counties across the country are facing a housing availability and affordability crisis. To address the issue, many are developing plans and policies that promote housing stock diversification in both new and infill devel- opment scenarios (Figure 1). However, when such development proposals are presented for review and approval, neigh- bors often fiercely oppose them, citing concern over a perceived change in the character of their neighborhoods and loss in property value and quality of life. This issue of Zoning Practice explores zoning strategies that balance the con- cerns of residents and the demands of the housing market by accommodating gentle density increases in a context- sensitive manner. From historic downtown neighborhoods to modern residential subdivisions, the tools presented can be used by planners throughout the country to implement housing policy through regulation. The Legacy of Single- Family-Only Zoning Beginning in the early 20th century, zoning was introduced in American cities as a means to control booming development. Beyond land-use control, however, zoning was also motivated by special interests concerned with maintaining existing community character in the face of both cultural and physical change, especially changes in cultural and ethnic makeup resulting from immigration. As written by M. Nolan Gray in Arbitrary Lines, “[Zon- ing’s] defining contribution was to enshrine Figure 1. A range of medium-density housing types (Credit: Sightline Institute, Flickr ) Page 66 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 3 the single-family house as the urban ideal, while casting apartments as mere ‘par- asites’ and corner grocers as threats to public welfare.” After the Supreme Court ruled in favor of the constitutionality of zoning in the 1926 Euclid v Amber case, the federal government incentivized municipalities across the country to adopt zoning reg- ulations—often by tying the availability of federal funding for transportation infra- structure, housing subsidies, and disaster recovery to zoning implementation. The spread of zoning, especially single-fami- ly-only zoning, throughout the country is intimately linked to the rapid suburbaniza- tion experienced after World War II. The rise of the suburbs and the segregated, low-density land uses that define them, worsened issues of economic seg- mentation and related racial and ethnic segregation stemming from the high cost of car and home ownership required for suburban life. This transition left many inner-city neighborhoods in a state of disinvestment, further cementing the sen- timent that high-density housing leads to crime, property devaluation, and quali- ty-of-life decline. It also exacerbated the acute housing availability and affordability crisis since the Great Recession by limiting the amount and types of housing that can be built. State and Local Responses The legacy of single-family-only zoning and a severe housing affordability crisis have motivated several distinct types of state and local zoning-reform efforts. Some states and local jurisdictions have explored eliminating single-family-only zoning. Many others have taken less-drastic measures to reform regulations related to housing development in an effort to accommodate additional and affordable housing in sin- gle-family districts. Jurisdiction Action California Eliminated single-family-only zoning in cities and urbanized unincorporated areas by authorizing property owners to build two dwelling units on any single-family- zoned lot and to subdivide any single-family-zoned lot large enough to split into two lots of at least 1,200 square feet (Senate Bill 9, 2021) Charlotte, NC Rezoned all previously single-family-only districts as Neighborhood 1 Zoning Districts, which permit duplexes and triplexes in addition to single-family homes (Unified Development Ordinance, 2022) Gainesville, FL Rezoned all previously single-family-only districts as Neighborhood Residential districts, which permit up to four dwelling units per lot ( Ordinance No. 211358, 2022) Maine Eliminated single-family-only zoning by authorizing between two and four dwelling units on any lot in a zoning district that permits housing, depending on whether the lot is located in a designated growth area or has an existing dwelling unit (LD 2003, 2022) Minneapolis, MN Eliminated single-family-only zoning by authorizing up to three dwelling units on any lot in the lowest-intensity residential district ( Table 546-1) Oregon Eliminated single-family-only zoning for many cities by requiring all cities with populations of at least 1,000 in metropolitan service areas and all other cities with populations of at least 10,000 to permit at least two units on each lot in areas zoned for residential use ( HB 2001, 2019) Walla Walla, WA Rezoned all previously single-family-only zones as Neighborhood Residential zones, which permit duplexes, triplexes, fourplexes, and cottage homes in addition to single-family homes (Ordinance 2018-53, 2018) Table 1. Select State and City Actions to Eliminate Single-Family-Only Zoning Page 67 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 4 Efforts to Eliminate Single-Family-Only Zoning To combat the issues of housing avail- ability and affordability being faced by communities across the nation, several states and local governments have taken dramatic steps toward eliminating sin- gle-family-only zoning (Table 1). Many other communities, like Seattle, have considered eliminating single-family-only zoning but have not been successful due to backlash from residents. Commonly cited concerns related to eliminating sin- gle-family-only zoning include a desire to preserve existing community character in order to protect property values, combat crime, maintain traffic conditions, not over burden schools, conserve open space, and more. Although these concerns are under- standable at an emotional level, they often do not hold water in practice. For example, according to a study by Daniel Kuhlmann published in the Journal of the American Planning Association in 2021, home val- ues in Minneapolis increased three to five percent in comparison to similar homes outside of the city after local officials adopted a new comprehensive plan pro- posing the elimination of single-family-only zoning. The study further suggests that the increase in property value is seen most significantly in relatively inexpensive neigh- borhoods of Minneapolis, helping to lessen the gap between property values and to build equity for lower income homeowners. Other Efforts to Zone for Housing Affordability In addition to largely eliminating sin- gle-family-only zoning, California, considered by many as a leader in hous- ing reform, has recently passed a slew of other laws to mitigate the state’s housing shortage. For example, Senate Bill 6 (2019) allows for by-right multifamily hous- ing development in all commercial and office districts; Assembly Bill 2097 (2022) eliminates all parking requirements for housing within a half-mile of public transit; and Senate Bill 478 (2021) requires that floor-area-ratio restrictions on multifamily housing be a minimum of 1.0 for develop- ments with three to seven units and 1.25 for developments with eight to 10 units. This last bill also prohibits a local jurisdic- tion from denying a housing development proposal on the basis that the lot does not meet minimum size requirements. Some states, such as North Carolina (§160D-702(b)) and Oklahoma (SB 1713, 2020) have passed legislation that pro- hibits local governments from enacting design standards for one- and two-family housing (as defined by the building code), which includes single-family detached, duplex, and townhome development. The goal of the legislation is to reduce the costs associated with design standards, such as required building materials, roof form, façade articulation or type, glazing, and more. A larger number of municipalities and counties are adopting incremental zon- ing reforms, such as allowing accessory dwelling units (ADUs) in single-family zon- ing districts (Table 2). Known by many names, including granny flats, in-law units, backyard cottages, secondary units, car- riage houses, and more, an accessory dwelling unit is a smaller, independent dwelling unit that may be detached, Figure 2. Examples of accessory dwelling unit types (Prepared by Houseal Lavigne) Page 68 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 5 Jurisdiction Use Pearmissions Amherst, MA Permits one internal, attached, or detached ADU per single-family detached dwelling by right, subject to use-specific standards, in most residential districts (§5.011) Apple Valley, MN Permits one internal or attached ADU per single-family detached dwelling with a discretionary use permit, subject to use-specific standards, in its lowest-intensity residential district (§155.382) Bloomington, IN Permits one internal, attached, or detached ADU per single-family or duplex dwelling by right, subject to use-specific standards, in all residential districts (§20.03.030(g)(5)) Boise, ID Permits one internal, attached, or detached ADU per single-family detached dwelling by right, subject to use-specific standards, in most residential districts (§11-06-03.1.A) Chatham County, NC Permits one internal, attached, or detached ADU per single-family detached dwelling by right in all residential districts ( §10.13) Columbia, MO Permits up to two internal, attached, or detached ADUs per lot with a discretionary use permit, subject to use-specific standards, in its lowest- intensity residential district ( §29-3.3(gg)) Decatur, GA Permits one internal, attached, or detached ADU per single-family detached dwelling by right, subject to use-specific standards, in all residential districts (§6.8.3.A) Fayetteville, AR Permits one internal or attached and one detached ADU per single-family detached dwelling by right, subject to use-specific standards, in most residential districts (§164.19) Hudson, OH Permits one internal, attached, or detached ADU per single-family detached dwelling by right, subject to use-specific standards ( §1206.03(a)) Jenks, OK Permits one internal, attached, or detached ADU per single-family detached dwelling by right, subject to use-specific standards, in multiple residential districts (§16-5-12(B)) Madison, WI Permits one internal, attached, or detached ADU per lot, subject to use- specific standards, in all districts ( §28.151) Murray, UT Permits one internal, attached, or detached ADU per single-family detached dwelling by right, subject to use-specific standards, in all residential districts (§17.78) Nashville, TN Permits one internal or attached ADU per single-family detached dwelling by right and one detached ADU per single-family dwelling by right, subject to use-specific standards, in multiple residential districts ( §17.16.030.G) Olympia, WA Permits one internal, attached, or detached ADU per single-family detached dwelling by right, subject to use-specific standards, in all residential districts (§18.04.060.A) Oxford, MS Permits one internal, attached, or detached ADU per single-family detached dwelling by right, subject to use-specific standards, in all residential districts (§3.5.6) Table 2. Select Jurisdictions That Permit ADUs Page 69 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 6 attached, or internal to the primary dwell- ing on a parcel (Figure 2). Accessory dwelling units have several benefits, including affordability; providing a source of additional income for homeowners, making homeownership more realistic for moderate income households; and accommodating multigenerational living and supportive housing. Other states and local governments are reversing bans or limitations on manufactured housing, an affordable alternative to traditional single-family detached homes. For example, Cali- fornia (Government Code §65852.3), Idaho (§67-6509A), Kansas (§12-763), Nevada (§278.02095), Ohio (§519.212), and Washington (§35.21.684) require local jurisdictions to allow manufactured homes in areas zoned for single-family residences; Huntsville, Texas, overturned a ban on the placement of manufactured housing throughout the community; and London, Kentucky, reversed a regulation that required manufactured housing to be located in manufactured home communi- ties (parks) only. Shortcomings of These Efforts Like all legislation and regulatory reforms, the approaches discussed in the previ- ous sections have their shortcomings. For example, much of the legislation recently passed in California introduces blanket requirements across all commu- nities, regardless of their characteristics. However, in a state as large as California, characteristics such as slope, wildfire haz- ard, and flood risk can significantly impact how new housing formats and additional housing units overall are best regulated in a community. The North Carolina and Oklahoma prohibitions on design standards for one- and two-family housing have made it difficult for some communities to introduce missing-middle housing as an allowed infill housing type in established neigh- borhoods. Infill missing-middle housing in existing single-family only neighborhoods is an effective approach to accommo- dating affordable housing throughout a community and leveraging existing infra- structure to serve a greater number of people. Design standards that control the appearance of i nfill missing-middle hous- ing are often an important tool to provide fair certainty to residents. Knowing that the character of their neighborhoods will not be fundamentally altered, residents tend to not protest the allowance of diversified housing, streamlining initial regulation adoption and later development approval. Just as design standards can make infill missing-middle housing more palatable for residents, design and use standards can make ADUs more acceptable as well. The vast majority of the communities that allow ADUs today have some design and use standards. The primary topics regulated are unit type (i.e., detached, attached, or internal); bulk and mass; location on a lot; location of unit entry; parking and access; design in relation to primary and adjacent dwellings; and requirements for the owner of the property to use either the principal or accessory dwelling as their primary residence. Although these standards can be helpful in ensuring that ADUs blend into the character of neighborhoods, maintaining the appearance of a single- family detached neighborhood at the right-of-way, they can also severely limit the number of ADUs that can be built. The most limiting regulations are often lot coverage restrictions and parking requirements. Another significant barrier to the devel- opment of missing-middle housing in both infill and new development scenarios is the discretionary review process. Requiring special or conditional use approval, condi- tional district rezoning, architectural review commission approval, or the wide variety of other discretionary review procedures employed by municipali ties and counties can add to the time and, therefore, the cost of development. Discretionary review requirements also run the risk of denying approval to development proposals that Design standards that control the appearance of infill missing-middle housing are often an important tool to provide fair certainty to residents. Page 70 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 7 otherwise meet the requirements of reg- ulations, including design standards and other measures put in place to provide fair certainty to neighbors and applicants. Gentle Density Zoning Standards Learning from and building off of the successes and setbacks hi ghlighted pre- viously, the following section focuses on how local jurisdictions can accommodate and encourage the development of miss- ing-middle housing in new devel opment and infill development scenarios. Bulk and Dimensional Standards Bulk and dimensional standards, includ- ing lot area and width standards, setback requirements, and height and coverage restrictions, can play a significant role in blending missing-middle housing types into new and existing neighborhoods. For new neighborhoods, municipalities and counties should consider controlling density through minimum lot area and minimum lot area per dwelling unit stan- dards. As always, the minimum lot area requirement wi ll establish the base lot size for the district. The minimum lot area per dwelling unit standard, however, will ensure that missing-middle housing types like triplexes and quadplexes have a pro- portional amount of open space to their single-family detached and duplex neigh- bors. The minimum lot area per dwelling unit could be set at half of the minimum lot area requirement to accommodate duplexes in the same manner as sin- gle-family detached dwellings. Additionally, municipalities and counties should consider establishing a “build-to zone” that applies to all housing types in the same manner (Figure 3). This will ensure that the rhythm of develop- ment from the right-of-way is consistent, making the blend of housing types look more seamless. If eliminating lot area and width requirements is not realistic, municipal- ities can work to promote reinvestment in existing housing, especially naturally occurring affordable housing, by minimiz- ing nonconformities. To accomplish this, communities can conduct a nonconfor- mities analysis that compares the existing minimum lot area and width requirements established for a zoning district with exist- ing development within that district. Using tools such as ArcGIS, the analysis should first determine the number of parcels in each district that do not conform with the existing lot area and width requirements (Figure 4). Then the analysis should determine the number of parcels in each district that would remain nonconforming if the lot area and width requirements were reduced (Figure 5). Figure 3. Build-to zone (Prepared by Houseal Lavigne) Page 71 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 8 Figure 4. Nonconformities under existing lot area requirements (Prepared by Houseal Lavigne using ArcGIS Software) Figure 5. Nonconformities with reduced lot area requirements (Prepared by Houseal Lavigne using ArcGIS Software) Page 72 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 9 To ensure that reducing the lot area and width minimums would not alter the character of established neighborhoods (a common argument against this type of zoning reform), alternative minimums can be tested to see if they would create new opportunities for existing lots to be subdivided. New opportunities for sub- division include lots that are at least two times greater in area and twice the width of the alternative lot area and width min- imums being considered. Again, using a tool such as ArcGIS, new opportunities for subdivision can be examined to deter- mine whether they could lead to a change in neighborhood character. For example, if there is a concentration of parcels in a neighborhood that could be subdivided due to the proposed standards changing, would such an amendment result in a shift in neighborhood character. In some instances, it may be most appropriate for these parcels to be rezoned to another zoning classification that requires larger lots, thus preventing the creation of sev- eral new lots in an established area. In other circumstances, the alternative min- imums should be increased district wide to prevent opportunities for subdivision. However, if the parcels that represent new subdivision opportunities are scattered throughout neighborhoods, rather than clustered together, and surrounded by parcels that are more consistent with the alternative minimums, the new subdivision opportunities would not result in a shift in neighborhood character. Infill development is most common in older neighborhoods where it is eco- nomically viable to tear down aging structures and build new ones. These types of neighborhoods were often developed organically over time, in some cases before zoning regulations were put in place, and do not have consistent bulk and dimensional standards from one property to another. In these circum- stances, municipalities should consider eliminating or amending minimum lot area and width requirements to encourage and accommodate reinvestment. Additionally, municipalities should consider adopting an averaging or variable approach to yard setbacks. For example, in Bloomington, Illinois’ Downtown Residence District, the required front yard setback is the average of the front yard setbacks along the same side of the street and on the same block (§44-403.B(2)). Use Standards Use standards are supplementary require- ments for uses regardless of whether they are allowed by-right or by discretionary approval. The use standards highlighted below are equally appropriate in both new and infill development. Both new and existing neighborhoods can benefit from standards for high- er-density missing-middle housing types that regulate the allowed location of the housing type on a block and its related siting. For example, Bentonville, Arkansas’ Downtown Neighborhood (DN) districts distinguish between block-end and mid- block locations and allows higher densities at the former more liberally than the latter (§401.07-B). The DN districts also require that all residential buildings be oriented toward a public street and that all parking garages, lots, or spaces be located in the rear or interior side yard, rather than in the front yard (Figure 6). Municipalities and counties should also consider allowing single-family homes to be converted to multifamily buildings. Converting homes, especially historic properties, can help to extend the eco- nomic life of existing structures, beneficial in both maintaining neighborhood charac- ter and minimizing environmental impacts related to development. Use standards for single-family to multifamily conversions should require that the outward appear- ance of the structure be maintained in substantially the same manner and that parking be accommodated on-site. If eliminating lot area and width requirements is not realistic, municipalities can work to pro- mote reinvestment in existing housing, especially naturally occurring affordable housing, by minimizing nonconformities. Page 73 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 10 Design Standards Objective design standards can help to provide fair certainty as to the appearance and function of new and infill development for both current residents and develop- ers. Objective design standards can also streamline development approval since they can be reviewed for compliance by municipal staff rather than subjectively debated at discretionary review hearings. For new neighborhoods, design standards do not need to reflect and be complementary with existing development. Therefore, a municipality should consider facilitating robust community outreach before standards are drafted to ensure they meet the preferences and expec- tations of the community. Communities should consider focusing on three to five key design features that can provide streamlined, but not cookie-cutter devel- opment. Key design features could include roof type, building material mix, and porches and other entry features. Design standards for infill development should reflect and be complementary with existing neighborhood development. How- ever, in many infill development scenarios, there is not a consistent architectural style utilized throughout a neighborhood or even on the same block. In these cir- cumstances a combination of objective and subjective design standards may be needed. Objective design standards, like those discussed for new development above, should regulate key design features Figure 6. End of block versus mid- block townhouse parking standards (Prepared by Houseal Lavigne) Page 74 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 11 that are consistently seen throughout a neighborhood, such as dormers, wood siding, and front porches. Subjective design standards, such as requiring archi- tectural features in keeping with existing neighborhood character, should allow for flexibility if the design of adjacent prop- erties warrants such and should be an administrative approval. Transition Standards Ensuring an adequate transition between lower-density and higher-density hous- ing is often the most important planning consideration when contemplating how to accommodate diverse housing within communities and neighborhoods. When starting with a clean slate, mixed-density residential neighborhoods should integrate natural buffers, such as large stands of mature trees, creeks, and wetlands, into the site design to provide a visual and physical transition between higher- and lower-density uses as well as preserve valuable environmental features. To accomplish this, communities should consider adopting conservation design standards that allow flexibility in bulk and dimensional standards in exchange for environmental feature preservation. Transition standards for infill devel- opment should consider the relationship of new residences to surrounding devel- opment. For example, Morrisville, North Carolina, has transition standards that apply to buildings with a height that exceeds that of neighboring existing homes by one story or more (§5.9.6.C.3). Four transition techniques are estab- lished, and three are required to be met (Figure 7). The techniques include step- ping down the structure height and mass along the shared property line; increasing the side yard setback a minimum of 10 feet beyond what is required; providing variations in side-building-wall and roof form; and utilizing dormers and sloping roofs to accommodate upper stories. Public Involvement Zoning ordinance reform to accommo- date and encourage the development of missing-middle housing should include Figure 7. An example of infill transition standards (Credit: Town of Morrisville, North Carolina) Page 75 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 12 robust public involvement. Time spent at the beginning of the reform process to build community consensus often pays dividends in project adoption and imple- mentation. Changes in zoning that could impact the character of people’s neighbor- hoods can be scary, and without adequate understanding as to the reasoning behind the changes and their potential impacts, residents push back, and reform fails. Public involvement for zoning reform initiatives should focus on visualizing the potential impacts of proposed changes. Procedural modeling tools, such as Arc- GIS CityEngine, can be used to test and compare building envelopes and built form for higher density infill housing in the context of existing single-family houses (Figure 8). This type of visualization can help residents understand that density can be on the inside of a building without showing evidence of such on the outside. By utilizing procedural modeling, live testing at community meetings can allow consensus to be reached more easily. Conclusion To combat the housing availability and affordability crisis facing the nation, zon- ing reform will need to be considered by states, counties, and municipalities. Not all of the strategies presented in this arti- cle will be applicable in every community, as housing and development, resident sentiment, established neighborhood character, and so much more differ city to city. However, if the approach to zoning does not change, housing issues will likely not be addressed in a meaningful and impactful way. As a first step, jurisdictions should consider doing a chapter-by-chap- ter assessment of their zoning and subdivision ordinances to identify barriers Figure 8. Procedurally modeled density calculator and dashboard (Prepared by Houseal Lavigne using ArcGIS Software) Page 76 of 77 Zoning Practice | American Planning Association | February 2023 13 ZONING PRACTICE FEBRUARY 2023 | VOL. 40, NO. 2. Zoning Practice (ISSN 1548–0135) is a monthly publication of the American Planning Association. Joel Albizo, FASAE, CAE, Chief Executive Officer; Petra Hurtado, PHD, Research Director; David Morley, AICP, Editor. Subscriptions are available for $95. © 2023 by the American Planning Association, 205 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 1200, Chicago, IL 60601–5927; planning.org . All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means without permission in writing from APA. American Planning Association Creating Great Communities for All About the Authors Jackie Berg, aicp, is a Practice Lead with Houseal Lavigne. She is focused on working with municipalities to develop actionable plans and useful implementation tools that reflect the vision and goals of the community. Her experience with both planning and zoning grounds all her work in the realities of the market and effectively balances community aspirations with what it takes to get good development done. John Houseal, faicp, is a Partner and Founder of Houseal Lavigne and is regarded as one of the nation’s top urban planning professionals with a reputation as a leader in urban planning, contemporary development practices, and community outreach. He has worked with hundreds of communities across the country and has received multiple national and state level awards for a variety of urban planning and design related projects. to housing development. Utilizing the results of the assessment, community conversations should then be conducted to gather feedback on the best ways to eliminate identified barriers and create new housing opportunities. Then, based on the feedback received, recommenda- tions for ordinance amendments should be developed and presented to elected and appointed officials for consideration. Refined with elected and appointed offi- cial feedback, recommendations should be converted to text amendments, sup- ported with graphics and illustrations, and brought through the adoption pro- cess. This process will help to ensure that amendments address the barriers to housing the community is facing and are vetted by residents and community leader- ship – ideally making the adoption process go more smoothly and the resulting ordi- nances more responsive to local needs. Cover credit: Photo by Dan Bertolet, Sightline Institute: Missing Middle Homes Photo Library, Flickr Page 77 of 77

Source: Lancaster County website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.