RecordWell Data

Community Services and Public Safety Committee — Agenda Packet

Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Community Development and Public Services Committee · meeting of Jun 16, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting Monday, June 16, 2025, 10:00 AM 1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, SC Benjamin M. Racusin Council Chambers The meeting can be viewed on the Town’s YouTube Channel, the Beaufort County Channel, and Spectrum Channel 1304. 1. Call to Order 2. Pledge to the Flag 3. Adoption of the Agenda 4. Approval of the Minutes a. Special Meeting Minutes of May 12, 2025 b. Special Meeting Minutes of May 13, 2025 c. Regular Meeting Minutes of May 19, 2025 d. Special Meeting Minutes of May 28, 2025 5. New Business a. Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island to Amend Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend the current regulations for Tree Protection to include sections: 16-5- 115, 16-6-104 and Appendix C for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina and Providing for Severability and an Effective Date - Missy Luick, Director of Planning b. Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island to Amend Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend current regulations for Sign Standards to include sections: 16-5-114 and 16-10-105 for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina and providing for severability and an effective date - Missy Luick, Director of Planning c. Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island, to Amend Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to Page 1 of 115 amend the Current Regulations for the Measure of Height and Setback Encroachments for Residential and Nonresidential Development to Include Land Management Ordinance Sections 16-3-106, 16-5-102 and 16-10-102, and Providing for Severability and an Effective Date - Missy Luick, Director of Planning 6. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items 7. Adjournment FOIA Compliance: Public notification of this meeting has been published, posted, and distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the Town of Hilton Head Island. In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Hilton Head Island will not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or activities. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further accommodation should contact the Town of Hilton Head Island ADA Coordinator as soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Municipal Association of South Carolina (MASC) Civility Pledge: “I pledge to build a stronger and more prosperous community by advocating for civil engagement, respecting others and their viewpoints, and finding solutions for the betterment of my city or town.” Page 2 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Special Meeting Minutes 5/12/2025 Page 1 of 2 Town of Hilton Head Island COMMUNITY SERVICES AND PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE SPECIAL MEETING Monday, May 12, 2025, 9:00 AM Minutes Call to Order Chair Becker called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m. Committee Members Present: Tamara Becker, Chair; Steve Alfred, and Steve DeSimone Other Members of Town Council Present: Patsy Brison Adoption of the Agenda Mr. Alfred made a motion to adopt. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion carried 3-0. Executive Session At 9:00 a.m., Mr. DeSimone moved to enter into Executive Session for the reasons as stated by Chair Becker. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 3-0. At 12:04 p.m., Mr. Alfred moved to end Executive Session and return to the regular meeting. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion carried 3-0. Discussion of Appointment to Boards, Commissions, and Committees [Pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act Section 30-4-70 (a)(1)] related to: 1. Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee 2. Board of Zoning Appeals 3. Construction Board of Adjustments and Appeals 4. Design Review Board 5. Gullah Geechee Historic Neighborhood Community Development Corporation 6. Gullah Geechee Task Force 7. Housing Action Committee 8. Parks and Recreation Commission 9. Planning Commission Action from Executive Session There was no action as a result of executive session. Page 3 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Special Meeting Minutes 5/12/2025 Page 2 of 2 Adjournment Chair Becker adjourned the meeting at 12:04 p.m. Approved: ____________ The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 4 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Special Meeting Minutes 5/13/2025 Page 1 of 2 Town of Hilton Head Island COMMUNITY SERVICES AND PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE SPECIAL MEETING Tuesday, May 13, 2025, 9:00 AM Minutes Call to Order Chair Becker called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m. Committee Members Present: Tamara Becker, Chair; Steve Alfred, and Steve DeSimone Other Members of Town Council Present: Patsy Brison and Alex Brown Adoption of the Agenda Mr. Alfred made a motion to adopt. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion carried 3-0. Executive Session At 9:00 a.m., Mr. Alfred moved to enter into Executive Session for the reasons as stated by Chair Becker. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion carried 3-0. At 12:36 p.m, Mr. Alfred moved to end Executive Session and return to the regular meeting. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion carried 3-0. Discussion of Appointment to Boards, Commissions, and Committees [Pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act Section 30-4-70 (a)(1)] related to: 1. Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee 2. Board of Zoning Appeals 3. Construction Board of Adjustments and Appeals 4. Design Review Board 5. Gullah Geechee Historic Neighborhood Community Development Corporation 6. Gullah Geechee Task Force 7. Housing Action Committee 8. Parks and Recreation Commission 9. Planning Commission Action from Executive Session There was no action as a result of executive session. Page 5 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Special Meeting Minutes 5/13/2025 Page 2 of 2 Adjournment Chair Becker adjourned the meeting at 12:36 p.m. Approved: _________ The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 6 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes 5/19/2025 Page 1 of 10 Town of Hilton Head Island COMMUNITY SERVICES AND PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE MEETING Monday, May 19, 2025, 10:00 AM Minutes Call to Order Chair Becker called the meeting to order at 10:02 a.m. Committee Members Present: Tamara Becker, Chair; and Steve DeSimone Other Members of Town Council Present: Patsy Brison, Alex Brown, Alan Perry; and Melinda Tunner Adoption of the Agenda Mr. DeSimone made a motion to adopt. Mrs. Becker seconded. Motion carried 2-0. Approval of the Minutes Regular Meeting Minutes of April 21, 2025 Mr. DeSimone made a motion to adopt. Mrs. Becker seconded. Motion carried 2-0. New Business Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island to Amend Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to Amend the Traffic Impact Analysis Plan Requirements and Traffic Analysis Standards in Land Management Ordinance Sections 16- 2- 103, 16- 5-106 and Appendix D, and Providing for Severability and an Effective Date - Missy Luick, Director of Planning Missy Luick addressed the Committee with the following information. The Planning Commission held a public hearing on April 16, 2025, and, after consideration of the criteria set forth in Land Management Ordinance (LMO) Section 16- 2-103, voted unanimously to recommend that Town Council approve the proposed text amendment. Revitalize and Modernize the Economy is a focus area in the adopted Town Council 2023- 2025 Strategic Action Plan. In this regard, Town Council directed Town Staff to advance amendments to the Land Management Ordinance (LMO) in the 2024 Strategic Action Work Plan. The effort has been divided into two separate projects, the full LMO Overhaul and the priority amendments. The priority amendments include incremental changes to both the LMO and portions of the Municipal Code related to land management that address important and urgent issues in advance of the full LMO Overhaul. These priority amendments address pressing community development issues with the best short -term solution while minimizing unintended outcomes. Issues that require additional analysis and research or are more complex are recommended to be further explored during the full LMO Overhaul. Page 7 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes 5/19/2025 Page 2 of 10 At the September 24, 2024, Town Council Workshop, Town staff received comments and direction regarding amendments related to Traffic Impact Analysis. Effective transportation planning is essential for managing growth, ensuring mobility, and maintaining a safe and efficient transportation network. As communities develop, new projects introduce additional traffic, impacting roads, intersections, and multimodal infrastructure such as sidewalks, bike lanes, and transit systems. Without proper assessment, development can lead to congestion, safety hazards, and infrastructure strain. As part of the priority amendments, the Town is proposing to update its current requirements for these studies for a more comprehensive approach that better reflects the transportation needs of everyone, including pedestrians, cyclists, and transit users. The proposed amendments strengthen the Town’s requirements by: • Expanding the scope of study beyond traffic to include multimodal infrastructure such as sidewalks, bike lanes, and transit services, • Reducing the threshold for requiring a traffic study from 100 peak -hour trips to 50 peak-hour trips, ensuring that even moderate developments undergo proper transportation impact review, • Expanding the type of mitigation options that can be used to address transportation impacts, • Shifting approval authority from the LMO Official to the Town Engineer for consistency with best practices, • Adding new standards for unsignalized intersections, and • Eliminating exemptions associated with trips generated by previously existing development. These updates will make the Town’s process more responsive to the community's needs and promote a more balanced, multimodal, and forward- thinking approach to transportation planning, ensuring that growth aligns with the Town’s long- term mobility and infrastructure goals. These changes are part of an ongoing effort to update the Town’s regulations, with further revisions expected during the full LMO update. The Town currently requires a “Traffic Impact Analysis Plan.” Examples of projects that recently required a TIAP include: 1. 147 Residential Units on Jonesville Road and 2. 132 Residential Units on Office Way As part of this amendment, the threshold for requiring a TIAP is proposed to be lowered from 100 to 50 peak hour trips, thereby increasing the number of projects subject to analysis, in addition to removing the exemption for trips generated by a previously existing development. For instance, two recent projects that were not required to provide a TIAP but were exempted due to the trips factored in for previously existing development would have been required to provide a TIAP under the proposed language are the following: Page 8 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes 5/19/2025 Page 3 of 10 1. Timeshare development on Folly Field Road near Islanders Beach Park and 2. Waterfront restaurant on Squire Pope Road near the Rowing and Sailing Center at Squire Pope Community Park The proposed TIAP amendments would also require the evaluation of multimodal infrastructure, such as bike paths, sidewalks, and public transit options. Transportation impacts can be mitigated by expanded and more flexible mitigation strategies to address transportation impacts, such as replacing a traffic signal or uncontrolled intersection with a roundabout that meets the Town’s operational and design standards, changes to locations or design of median crossovers and removal of changes to the number and location, or design of access points. Additionally, new standards for unsignalized intersections have been introduced, requiring mitigation for impacts. (A table included in the original agenda packet demonstrates how the proposed amendments address demonstrated issues). The proposed text amendment aligns with the review criteria, as it: 1. Supports the Comprehensive Plan, which includes the following strategy and tactic: “Maintain, evaluate, and update as needed traffic analysis standards to guide development in accordance with the existing and future needs of the Town.” 2. Is required due to increased traffic and congestion. 3. Addresses a demonstrated community need to mitigate traffic impact and includes consideration of essential multimodal transportation options. 4. Ensure that overall transportation impacts and mitigation efforts are consistent with the intent of the LMO. 5. Results in safer and less congested streets and intersections ensuring orderly development and transportation networks. 6. Minimizes the overall impact of Town-wide development and resulting traffic. Committee Members had questions, comments and discussion regarding: clarify the te rm multimodal and the use in regards to transportation; if analysis was done on the two examples mentioned that would require a traffic impact analysis plan; look into the bli ghted areas on Hilton Head Island to attract redevelopment; redevelopment in residential areas affects the quality of life and the surrounding areas; have an traffic impact analysis plan done on some of the areas of interest to see what the impact on the developer would have been prior to this item being brought to Town Council; a request was made for the term “blighted” should be carefully defined; clarify how large of an area is analyzed when the traffic impact is studied; how does this plan being to be implemented moving forward; language included on downstream traffic impacts should be included in the plan; con cerns that the level of service “F” is too low; con sider what m ultimodal means to Hilton Head now and in the future; does this plan moving forward impact the Town if they do not own the road; Mrs. Becker made a motion to forward t he ordinance amending Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management O rdinance, to amend the Traffic Impact Analysis Plan Requirements and Traffic Analysis Standards in Land M anagement Page 9 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes 5/19/2025 Page 4 of 10 Ordinance 16-2-103, 16-5-106, and Appendi x D to the Full Town C ouncil for approval with condi tions including the commen ts of the Committee and other Town Council Members present but not limited to allow for improvements. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Chair Becker asked for public comment. Chester Williams addressed the Committee regarding legal issues and his concerns of the text of the ordinance that need to be addressed. Motion carried 2-0. Consideration of a Resolution Adopting the Program for Public Information 5- Year Update and Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Community Rating System Updates - Missy Luick, Director of Planning Missy Luick addressed the Committee with the following information. The Town of Hilton Head Island has actively participated in the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s (FEMA’s) Community Rating System (CRS) program since October 1, 1991. The Town is currently a Class 5 Community, which gives its residents in the Special Flood Hazard Area (SFHA) a 25% discount on their flood insurance premiums. The Lowcountry Council of Governments, on behalf of Beaufort, Colleton, Hampton and Jasper Counties and municipalities within each county, prepared the 2020 Lowcountry Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan. The 2020 Lowcountry Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan, adopted by Town Council in October 2021, replaced the Beaufort County Hazard Mitigation Plan as an appendix to the Town of Hilton Head Island Comprehensive Plan. This Plan assesses the communities’ vulnerabilities to natural hazards and includes long- term strategies to address these hazards and to prevent future damage and loss of life. The adoption of the Plan fulfills the continuing requirements that qualify the Town of Hilton Head Island for FEMA pre-disaster mitigation grants, post -disaster reconstruction assistance and continued participation in the Community Rating System (CRS). The Annual Evaluation Report of the 2020 Lowcountry Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan is prepared by Town staff to ensure there is a continuing and responsive planning process. Town Council adopted the Repetitive Loss Area Analysis (RLAA) in 2024 as a credited activity in CRS program. The purpose of the RLAA is to assess the potential causes of flooding in areas that have historically flooded and properties with repeated flood losses and maintain reduced FEMA flood insurance premium costs to residents. To maintain CRS credit for the RLAA, the RLAA document must be evaluated annually to maintain site-specific detail for each property, such as structure’s finish floor height, exterior a/c units, grades, plus nearby storm water inlets, catch basins and drainage waterway features. The results of the assessment are used to update recommendations for appropriate mitigation strategies to reduce or eliminate future flood losses. Town Council adopted the original Program for Public Information (PPI) in 2015 and the required five-year update in 2020 as a credited activity in the CRS program. The purpose of the PPI is to maintain reduced FEMA flood insurance premium costs to residents and to Page 10 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes 5/19/2025 Page 5 of 10 provide flood- related information to property owners through a robust outreach program. To maintain CRS credit for the PPI, the PPI Committee must meet annually to monitor, evaluate and revise, as needed, the outreach projects and flood insurance coverage assessment that are included in the program. The PPI Committee consists of eleven (11) members of the members including four (4) members of Town staff and seven (7) volunteers from the community that together have a wealth of knowledge regarding flood hazards and flood risk. Mr. DeSimone made a motion to forward to Town Council for consideration approval of the Lowcountry Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan, 2 025 Prog ram for Public Information, annual evaluation report of Repetitive Loss A rea Analysis, and a resolution approving the community rating system updates. Mrs. Becker seconded. Chair Becker asked for public comment. There was no public comment at this time. There were no comments from the Committee Members. Motion carried 2-0. Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island, Amending Municipal Code Section 12- 6-111, Definitions, and Section 12- 6-115, Resident Beach Parking Pass Parking, to Authorize Beach Parking Permits for Qualified Residents in Beaufort County, South Carolina, South Carolina - Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager Shawn Colin addressed the Committee with the following information. The Town of Hilton Head Island has long sought to balance providing beach access to residents, visitors, and the broader region while managing limited parking resources at public beach parks. Town Council has expressed interest in exploring mechanisms that recognize and support the beach access needs of local Beaufort County residents, while ensuring the sustainable management of beach parking facilities. Currently, the Town manages its beach resources primarily through revenues collected from the Beach Preservation Fee. Local ad valorem (property) taxes are not used to fund beach management efforts. The Beach Preservation Fee supports essential initiatives such as beach renourishment, park maintenance, and capital improvements to beach- related infrastructure. The proposed ordinance authorizes the establishment of an annual beach parking pass program exclusively available to qualified Beaufort County residents. Elements of the proposed program include: • Eligibility • Pass Limits • Pass Fee • Pass Usage Page 11 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes 5/19/2025 Page 6 of 10 The program is designed to: • Improve Accessibility • Support Resource Management • Generate Revenue • Strengthen Regional Collaboration The exclusion of Islanders Beach Park from the pass program is consistent with the Town’s longstanding policy to prioritize parking access at that facility exclusively for Hilton Head Island residents. The fiscal impact will vary based on annual program participation. Staff will track the number of passes issued and report annually as part of the Town’s budget process to ensure effective oversight and management. Mr. DeSimone made a motion to forward to Town Council for consideration for denial the Ordinance of the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island, amending Municipal Code Section 12 -6-111, Definitions, and Section 12- 6-115, resident beach parking pass, to authorize beach parking permits for qualified residents in Beaufort County, South Carolina. Mrs. Becker seconded. Chair Becker asked for public comment. Janice Grier addressed the Committee regarding her concerns of property owners, paying for parking in general and why this should not be open to Beaufort County Residents. She also stated the Islanders Beach Park is beginning to look like the parking on Coney Island. Richard Bisi addressed the Committee regarding the Committee discussing parking just before Memorial Day Weekend. He also believes that Town Council making a decision to offer 14,000 beach passes to Beaufort County Residents poses ramifications and is possibly illegal. Dee Anthony addressed the Committee of her of allowing Beaufort County Residents to have beach passes and if so they should not be for Islanders Beach Park. Susan Maynard addressed the Committee regarding the current number of parking spaces and crime at the Town beach parking lots. Committee Members had questions, comments and discussion regarding: the time frame of the fees ; allowing for the flexi bility to adjust the fees; if the fees were high er this could potentially deter and minimize traffic; the feed back received is that there should not be a charge for Beaufort County R esidents, hourly rates on the weekends, and an annual pass should be offered to Beaufort County Residents; what is the overall capacity at our beaches; could this be considered an unintended consequence; text conce rns of the definition of a “Beaufort County Resident ”; and the tr ue impact cannot be measured until paid parking is Page 12 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes 5/19/2025 Page 7 of 10 charged in Coligny. Motion carried 2-0. Consideration of a Resolution of the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island, Establishing the Fee for a County Resident Beach Parking Pass in Accordance with Section 12-6-115(B)(2) of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island and Modify Fees for Saturday and Sundays Beach Parking - Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager Shawn Colin addressed the Committee with the following information. Town Council is currently considering adoption of amendments to Sections 12-6-111 and 12-6- 115 of the Municipal Code, which would authorize the creation of a Beaufort County Resident Beach Parking Pass program. This program would provide eligible Beaufort County residents, living outside of the municipal limits of Hilton Head Island, with an annual pass option for parking in designated paid public beach parking areas (excluding Islanders Beach Park). The amendments, if adopted, specify that the fee for the Beaufort County Resident Beach Parking Pass will be established by Resolution of Town Council. In parallel, Town Council has expressed interest in adjusting weekend parking rates to align with weekday rates, providing more flexibility for users and improving consistency in rate structure. This includes a revision to Section 2 of the Resolution, adopted by Town Council on September 17, 2024, which established the Daily Maximum Fees for Paid Parking Areas. The proposed resolution includes the following: • Beaufort County Resident Beach Parking Pass Fees • Weekend Paid Parking Rate Adjustment Financial Impact • County Resident Pass: Potential to generate modest revenues depending on program participation; revenues will support operations and maintenance of beach parking facilities. • Weekend Rate Adjustment: Expected to have a neutral to positive impact on parking revenues, contingent on visitor parking patterns. Mrs. Becker made a motion to forward to Town Council, for consideration of approval, a resolution of the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island establishing the fee for a County resident beach parking pass, in accordance with Section 12- 6-115(B)(2) of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, and to modify beach parking fees for Saturdays and Sundays with the following conditions to be included: implementation of a flat $5 per hour fee, 7 days a week; elimination of the daily maximum fee; and initiation of the revised fee structure at the Coligny Beach parking lot. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Chair Becker asked for public comment. Richard Bisi addressed the Committee that Coligny Beach Park should not be free parking as it Page 13 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes 5/19/2025 Page 8 of 10 is the biggest lot on the Island and $5 is more than reasonable. Pamela Martin Ovens addressed the Committee that charging in the Coligny area would hurt local business especially Piggly Wiggly as he would not have any business. Committee Members had questions, comments and discussion regarding: there is no paid parking at Coligny Beach Park and that data is needed; turnover of parking is what is needed, not cars there all day as others need to enjoy the beach; $3 is not enough for parking; how does the current price for parking impact the projection and budget; c larification of Beaufort County Taxes and Beach Fee Taxes; our beaches are already crowed enough and parking should be charged at Coligny; Tybee Island charges $4 for parking and Hilton Head should be no lower than t hat there needs to be a way for anyone looking for parking can tell wh ere parking is available on Hilton Head Island; charging on the weekends should be tested for one year; and charging for parking on Saturday and Sundays is a better option to allow for more turnover. Motion carried 2-0. Consideration of a Resolution Amending the Adopted Integrated Pest Management Policy - Shawn Leininger, Assistant Town Manager Shawn Leniniger addressed the Committee with the following information. Environmental Sustainability is identified as a focus area in the Town Council approved 2023- 2025 Strategic Action Plan and includes the Assessment and Implementation of an Environmentally Friendly Landscape and Grounds Maintenance Best Practices Program as an additional strategy. The development of an Integrated Pest Management (IPM) policy is a best practice for management of grounds and facilities. In general terms, an IPM policy is a decision- making strategy that combines biological, cultural, physical, and chemical tools aimed on the long-term prevention of pests (plants and animals) or their damage. Following this strategy, pest control materials are selected and applied in a manner that minimizes risks to human health and nontarget organisms, is beneficial, and helps protect the environment. On October 15, 2024, Town Council adopted an IPM Policy. This Policy was developed through the assessment of current Town practices along with other environmentally conscious landscaping practices relating to pest and weed control management practices and products. Additionally, Town Staff met with certified professionals; other municipalities; local, state and national leaders in this field; representatives of the Non- Toxic Neighborhoods organization; as well as Town landscaping contractors to review these strategies and best practices. This resulted in the following three goals guiding the adoption of the Policy: 1. Reduce / eliminate pesticide use. 2. Provide notice to the public when pesticides are used in public spaces. 3. Ensure the Town is responsible for making pest management decisions. The IPM Policy further establishes the following: 1. Makes clear that existing service contracts that are not compliant with the IPM Policy will Page 14 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes 5/19/2025 Page 9 of 10 either be amended or terminated, and a new contract will be issued within twelve (12) months following adoption of the IPM Policy. 2. Prioritizes pest prevention beginning at the design stage and continues with the use of non-pesticide controls first. 3. Establishes that the Town is the approval authority of all pest control measures and institutes a written approval process. 4. Prohibits the use of any pesticide containing a substance known to be a human carcinogen as listed on the United States Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Report on Carcinogens Section. 5. Prohibits the use of Glyphosate products (Roundup, Ranger Pro, etc.). 6. Prohibits the use of EPA Level I (danger) pesticides unless it is deemed necessary to protect public health and prevent economic loss when other methods do not adequately control the pest. 7. Requires pesticide applications to be appropriate for the target pest and must be applied by those persons possessing a valid South Carolina commercial applicator license; or supervised by a person possessing such license. 8. When pesticide controls are necessary, identifies which pesticides, following the defined organic first, least toxic approach, can be applied on Town properties (park, field, playground, dog park, right-of-way, facilities/ buildings, and other Town property). 9. Requires notice be posted forty -eight (48) hours prior to pesticide application and the notice remain in place for at least twenty -four (24) hours after the application, unless the product label requires a longer re-entry period. 10. Requires all pesticide application records be provided to the Town by the contractor. Since the adoption of the Integrated Pest Management Policy the Town has implemented processes and procedures to ensure the effective delivery of the policy and have identified policy amendments that support its continued effective implementation. The following amendments that must be approved by Town Council: 1. Remove the phrase “least toxic” in describing the organic first policy. 2. Emphasize non-pesticide controls, an organic first approach, and establish when EPA level pesticides are permitted. 3. Modified the approval authority for determining when EPA level pesticides are permitted. 4. Provided for third-party annual review of any use of EPA level pesticides. 5. Amended the pesticide control requirements to provide consistent pesticide applications to all Town owned and managed properties. 6. Recognized that the State of South Carolina offers multiple licenses that are appropriate for the application of pesticides on Town owned and managed properties. 7. Swapped the use of the EPA signal word (level) with the EPA registration number on required notifications regarding the application of pesticides. 8. In recognition of the annual third- party review of any EPA level pesticide use, an annual report required is posted on the Town website. Mr. DeSimone made a motion to forward to Town Council for consideration of approval a resolution amending the adopted Integrated Pest Management Policy. Mrs. Becker Page 15 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes 5/19/2025 Page 10 of 10 seconded. Chair Becker asked for public comment. Kim Konte addressed the Committee with her thankfulness to the Town for taking this issue seriously and now when her son has practice on one of our fields she no longer has to worry about his health and safety. Pamela Martin Ovens thanked Council Member Patsy Brison, Shawn Lenininger, and Town Manager Marc Orlando. Committee Members had questions, comments and discussion regarding: this is a great effort and the contractor should be able to choose if a treatment plan is not working. Motion carried 2-0. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items There was no public comment at this time. Adjournment Chair Becker adjourned the meeting at 12:17 p.m. The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 16 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Special Meeting Minutes 5/28/2025 Page 1 of 2 Town of Hilton Head Island COMMUNITY SERVICES AND PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE SPECIAL MEETING Wednesday, May 28, 2025, 9:00 AM Minutes Call to Order Chair Becker called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m. Committee Members Present: Tamara Becker, Chair; Steve Alfred, and Steve DeSimone Other Members of Town Council Present: Patsy Brison and Alex Brown Adoption of the Agenda Mr. DeSimone made a motion to adopt. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 3-0. Executive Session At 9:00 a.m., Mr. DeSimone moved to enter into Executive Session for the reasons as stated by Chair Becker. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 3-0. At 11:58 a.m., Mr. DeSimone moved to end Executive Session and return to the regular meeting. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 3-0. Discussion of Appointment to Boards, Commissions, and Committees [Pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act Section 30-4-70 (a)(1)] related to: 1. Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee 2. Board of Zoning Appeals 3. Construction Board of Adjustments and Appeals 4. Design Review Board 5. Gullah Geechee Historic Neighborhood Community Development Corporation 6. Greenspace Advisory Committee 7. Gullah Geechee Task Force 8. Housing Action Committee 9. Parks and Recreation Commission 10. Planning Commission Action from Executive Session There was no action as a result of executive session. Page 17 of 115 Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety Committee Special Meeting Minutes 5/28/2025 Page 2 of 2 Adjournment Chair Becker adjourned the meeting at 11:58 a.m. Approved: ___________ The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 18 of 115 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court  Hilton Head Island  South Carolina  29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND Community Services and Public Safety Committee TO: Community Services and Public Safety Committee FROM: Missy Luick, Director of Planning CC: Shawn Leininger, Assistant Town Manager CC: Marc Orlando, Town Manager DATE: June 16, 2025 SUBJECT: Public Hearing for Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend Title 16 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend the current regulations for Tree Protection to include sections: 16-5-115, 16-6-104 and Appendix C, and Providing for Severability and an Effective Date RECOMMENDATION: Community Services and Public Safety Committee review and consider an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island to amend Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend current regulations for tree protection to include Section 16-5-115, Section 16-6-104, and Appendix C for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina and providing for severability and an effective date, and forward a recommendation to Town Council. The Planning Commission held a public hearing on May 21, 2025, and, after consideration of the criteria set forth in Section 16-2-103.B.3 voted unanimously to recommend that Town Council approve the proposed text amendment. BACKGROUND: Revitalize and Modernize the Economy is a focus area in the adopted Town Council 2023- 2025 Strategic Action Plan. In fulfillment of this focus area, Strategy #1 Establish a Growth Management Strategy states the Town will: “Successfully manage increasing and evolving future growth patterns in a manner that will ensure sustainability of Hilton Head Island’s unique character. Additionally, the Town must monitor economic and demographic trends, undertaking a comprehensive list of future planning activities, and proactively protecting the Island’s rich natural resources through appropriate design, regulation, and capital investment practices.” Page 19 of 115 Page 2 of 6 In this regard, Town Council directed Town Staff to advance amendments to the Land Management Ordinance (LMO) in the 2024 Strategic Action Work Plan. The effort has been divided into two separate projects, the full LMO Overhaul and the priority amendments. The priority amendments include incremental changes to both the LMO and portions of the Municipal Code related to land management that address important and urgent issues in advance of the full LMO Overhaul. These priority amendments address pressing community development issues with the best short-term solution while minimizing unintended outcomes. Issues that require additional analysis and research or are more complex are recommended to be further explored during the full LMO Overhaul. At the September 24, 2024, Town Council Workshop, Town staff received the following comments and direction regarding amendments related to tree protection: 1. Increase requirements for Live Oak and Laurel Oak tree preservation by reducing the diameter breast height (DBH): a. Live Oak single truck from 35 to 30 DBH b. Live Oak multiple trunk from 60 to 55 DBH c. Laurel Oak from 35 to 30 DBH 2. Update mitigation requirements by increasing the plant back tree size requirements (i.e., minimum height from 10 to 12 feet and diameter from 2 inches to 4 inches) 3. Update the list of native plants. 4. Remove the exception of specimen trees on single-family lots to reduce unnecessary removal of specimen trees. On May 21, 2025, the Planning Commission held a public hearing and voted unanimously to forward the amendment to Town Council with a recommendation of approval. SUMMARY OF AMENDMENT: Priority updates are proposed to strengthen tree protection during development and ensure that new projects align with the community’s environmental values. These changes aim to improve tree preservation, enhance ecological outcomes, and promote sustainable development. More specifically, these changes strengthen protections for significant trees and promote the use of native vegetation. Key updates include lowering the diameter breast height (DBH) thresholds for preserving Live Oak and Laurel Oak trees for specimen and significant classifications, resulting in more trees receiving protection. Mitigation requirements for tree removal are also enhanced by increasing the minimum size standards for replacement trees, ensuring greater environmental impact and maturity. Additionally, the list of approved native plants is expanded to support ecological diversity. Finally, specimen tree protections are extended to single-family lots which is consistent with existing private tree preservation standards within PUDs. Page 20 of 115 Page 3 of 6 ANALYSIS: Proposed Amendments Key updates include: 1. Enhanced Tree Preservation for Live Oak and Laurel Oak Trees:  The diameter breast height (DBH) threshold for preservation is reduced, increasing the number of protected “specimen” Live Oak and Laurel Oak trees. o Reduced five inches for Live Oak and Laurel Oak specimen trees  In addition to the Town Council recommendation, Staff also recommends that the DBH threshold be reduced for “significant” Live Oak and Laurel Oak trees. o Reduced four inches for single-trunk Live Oak and Laurel Oak significant trees o Reduced seven inches for multi-trunk Live Oak significant trees 2. Updated Mitigation Provisions Require Larger Replacement Trees:  The size requirements for replacement trees ("plant back" trees) are increased, ensuring greater environmental impact and maturity in replanting efforts. o Increased the minimum installation height by two feet for all tree categories (I-IV) o Increased the minimum trunk diameter by two inches for categories I-II. o Increased the minimum trunk diameter by one inch for categories III- IV. Please note that Staff recommends this as a slight variation from the September 24 meeting (one inch increase instead of two inches for cone-bearing evergreens, palms, and ornamentals). 3. Expanded Native Plant List:  The list of approved native plants is updated to reflect current ecological priorities and promote biodiversity. 4. Specimen Tree Protections and Single-Family Lot Exceptions.  Specimen tree protections are extended to include all single-family lots, reducing unnecessary removal of significant trees. The priority amendment changes aim to strengthen tree preservation, promote ecological health, and maintain the aesthetic and environmental character of the area. Additional changes to tree protection will be analyzed during the full LMO overhaul project. The following table shows how the proposed amendments address the demonstrated issues. Page 21 of 115 Page 4 of 6 Issue Proposed Amendment 1. Increase requirements for Live Oak and Laurel Oak tree preservation by reducing the diameter breast height (DBH): a. Live Oak single truck from 35 to 30 DBH b. Live Oak multiple trunk from 60 to 55 DBH c. Laurel Oak from 35 to 30 DBH Table 16-6-104.F.1: Specimen and Significant Trees Tree Type Specimen DBH (Inches) Significant DBH (Inches) Live oak Single trunk 35 30 28 24 Multiple trunks 60 55 (sum of all trunks) 48 41 Laurel oak 35 30 28 24 2. Update mitigation requirements by increasing the plant back tree size requirements (i.e., minimum height from 10 to 12 feet and diameter from 2 inches to 4 inches) Table 16-6-104.I.3: Minimum Planting Size for Supplemental and Replacement Trees Tree Category Minimum Height (Feet) Minimum Trunk Diameter (Inches) (Using ANSI Standards) Category I 10 12 2 4 Category II 10 12 2 4 Category III 6 8 1 2 Category IV 6 8 1 2 3. Update list of native plants. See Appendix C of proposed text amendment for new list of native plants. 4. Remove exception of specimen trees on single-family lots to reduce unnecessary removal of specimen trees. Sec.16-6-104. Tree Protection F. Specimen and Significant Tree Preservation 2. General Requirements a. No specimen tree may be removed except in accordance with paragraph b below. In addition, all specimen trees shall have the following protections, whether located on public or private land. with the exception of specimen trees located on single-family lots: Page 22 of 115 Page 5 of 6 (Revised 5-17-2016 - Ordinance 2016- 07) i. Any activities performed within the drip line of a specimen tree shall have the prior approval of the Official. ii. Specimen trees shall not be cut, removed, pushed over, killed, or otherwise harmed. iii. No more than 20 percent of the total area within the drip line of any specimen tree shall be subject to paving or soil compaction, and no paving or soil compaction is allowed within 15 feet of the tree trunk. (See Figure 16-6-104.F.2: Limits of Paving or Compaction near Specimen Trees.) The Official may allow paving or soil compaction beyond the 20 percent limit if low impact development techniques (e.g., pervious pavers, materials placed at or above grade, no use of mechanical machinery) are used as an alternative means of protecting the specimen tree. b.If preservation of a specimen tree causes unnecessary hardship, the applicant may apply for a variance from this subsection (see Sec. 16-2-103.S, Variance) once any required State or federal government agency approval, if applicable, to remove the tree is received in writing. Nonconformities Chapter 16-7 provides standards for nonconformities. This amendment will not create nonconformities. Text Amendment Review Standards Section 16-2-103.B.3 of the LMO provides standards for the review of Text Amendments and states the following: “In determining whether to recommend that Town Council adopt or deny the proposed text amendment, the Planning Commission may weigh the relevance of and consider whether and the extent to which the proposed Text Amendment: Page 23 of 115 Page 6 of 6 a. Is in accordance with the Comprehensive Plan; b. Is required by changed conditions; c. Addresses a demonstrated community need; d. Is consistent with the purpose and intent of the zoning districts in this Ordinance, or would improve compatibility among uses and ensure efficient development within the Town; e. Would result in a logical and orderly development pattern; and f. Would not result in significantly adverse impacts on the natural environment, including but not limited to water, air, noise, stormwater management, wildlife, vegetation, wetlands, and the natural functioning of the environment.” The proposed text amendment aligns with the review criteria, as it: 1. Supports the Comprehensive Plan’s goals concerning natural resource preservation and tree protection. 2. Is required due to continuing concerns with tree cutting and the loss of specimen and significant trees. 3. Addresses a demonstrated and vocalized community need to strengthen tree preservation, promote ecological health, and maintain the aesthetic and environmental character of the area. 4. Is consistent with the intent of the Ordinance and the Town’s efforts to preserve tree cover and habitat. 5. Results in more attractive and sustainable development, ensuring a logical and orderly development pattern. 6. Minimizes the impact of development on the natural environment by protecting trees and strengthening mitigation for the removal of trees. COMMUNITY SERVICES AND PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE ACTION: The Community Services and Public Safety Committee’s recommendation shall be based on the standards in Sec. 16-2-103.B.3, Ordinance Text Amendment Review Standards. The Committee has the following options when considering this agenda item. These include: 1. Recommend approval to Town Council. 2. Recommend denial to Town Council. 3. Recommend approval with conditions to Town Council. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Ordinance 2. Text Amendment Page 24 of 115 Attachment 1 –Tree Protection Amendment Ordinance 1 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ORDINANCE NO.__________ AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND TO AMEND CHAPTER 16 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE, THE LAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE, TO AMEND CURRENT REGULATIONS FOR TREE PROTECTION TO INCLUDE SECTIONS: 16-5-115, 16-6-104 AND APPENDIX C FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA AND PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the Town Council for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, has identified a continued need for the adoption of LMO Amendments to address needs and issues in the Town as such arise; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council seeks to amend the Land Management Ordinance to increase tree protection requirements for development to enhance ecological outcomes, and promote sustainable development; and, WHEREAS, on May 21, 2025, the Planning Commission held a Public Hearing to consider the proposed amendments to increase tree protection requirements for development, and the public had an opportunity to comment on the proposed amendments, and the Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend adoption of the amendments to increase tree protection requirements for development; and, WHEREAS, on June 16, 2025, the Community Services & Public Safety Committee voted ___ to recommend _______ of the proposed amendments to increase tree protection requirements for development; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds it is in the best interest of the Town and its citizens, residents and visitors to amend Land Management Ordinance by amending the current regulations for tree protection. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, AND IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY AND UNDER AUTHORITY OF SAID TOWN COUNCIL, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Amendment. That the Land Management Ordinance is amended as shown on Exhibit “A” to this Ordinance. Newly added language is illustrated with double underline and deleted language is illustrated with strikethrough. Section 2. Severability. If any section, phrase, sentence, or portion of this Ordinance is for any Page 25 of 115 Attachment 1 –Tree Protection Amendment Ordinance 2 reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct, and independent provision, and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions thereof. Section 3. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be effective upon its adoption by the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED BY THE COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ON THIS _____ DAY OF __________ , 2025. THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ____________________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor ATTEST: _____________________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk First Reading: Second Reading: APPROVED AS TO FORM: __________________________________ Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney Page 26 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 1 of 10 Chapter 16-5: Development and Design Standards Sec.16-5-115. Subdivision Standards A. Purpose and Intent The purpose of subdivision layout is to create a functional and attractive development with infrastructure and lots appropriately sized and located to minimize adverse impacts. The intent of this section is to provide clear requirements and guidelines for subdivision design for both Major and Minor Subdivisions. Subdivisions should promote the health, safety, convenience, order, prosperity and welfare of the present and future residents of the Town by: a. Providing for the orderly growth and development of the Town; b. Coordinating with the existing street system, transportation plans, and public facilities; c. Providing right-of-way for street and vehicular easements; d. Avoiding congestion and overcrowding and encouraging proper arrangement of streets in relation to existing planned streets; e. Preservation of the natural tree canopy and preservation of protected tree species; e.f. Ensuring there is adequate open space and recreation facilities; and f.g. Ensuring there is proper recordation of land ownership. C. General Requirements 1. Layout of the subdivision shall be based on complete site analysis. Streets and lots shall be designed to preserve significant trees, stands of trees and understory vegetation and situated to minimize alteration of natural and historic site features to be preserved. 2. The subdivision layout shall consider the practicality and economic feasibility of development of individual lots including the environmental characteristics, size of the site, and the requirements of this the Ordinance. 3. The applicant is required to demonstrate that they have made all reasonable efforts to preserve unique and fragile elements on site, including but not limited to wetlands, significant stands of significant stands of trees and individual trees of significant size, with development reserved for environmentally stable areas. (Revised 1-7-2020 - Ordinance 2020-02; revised 3-7-2023 - Ordinance 2023-04) 4. Open space and recreational areas shall be planned in accordance with Sec. 16-5-104, Open Space Standards. 5. Lots shall be situated so that stormwater may be easily directed away from buildings in subsequent site-specific development. Lots shall be configured so that buildings and general flood sensitive site facilities can be located out of drainageways. Subdivisions shall be designed so as to comply with Sec. 16-5-109, Stormwater Management and Erosion and Sedimentation Control Standards. 6. All lots shall have the access required by Sec. 16-5-105.I, Access to Streets. Page 27 of 115 LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 2 of 10 Chapter 16-6: Natural Resource Protection Sec.16-6-104. Tree Protection B. Applicability 2. Exemptions a. The following activities are exempt from the standards in this section and the requirement for a Natural Resources Permit: i. Removal of damaged protected trees during an emergency such as a hurricane, tornado, ice or wind storm, flood, wildfire or any other such act of nature; ii. The removal of invasive species; iii. Removal of a hazardous tree, provided such removal is reported to the Official within five days after removal. Removal of a hazardous tree may require mitigation at the discretion of the Official Official; (Revised 1-7-2020 - Ordinance 2020-02) iv. The selective and limited pruning and removal of trees or vegetation within sight triangles (see Sec. 16-5-105.H.4, Sight Triangles) as necessary to obtain clear visibility at street and driveway intersections; v. Necessary tree removal by a utility company consistent with plans submitted periodically to the Official for approval in accordance with Sec. 16-5-110, Utility Standards, provided such plans include appropriate provision for removal of any felled trees; vi. Topping of healthy trees is only permitted on land of the Hilton Head Island Airport, and only for the maintenance of the slope approaches to the airport as referenced in Sec. 16-3- 106.E, Airport Overlay (A-O) District; vii. Tree removal associated with forestry activities shielded from local development regulation in accordance with S.C. Code Ann. § 48-23-205, subject to the limitations on subsequent development in Sec. 16-6-104.E, Limitations on Development Applications Subsequent to Exempt Forestry Activity; and viii. Routine or seasonal pruning (see Sec. 16-5-103.H, Existing Vegetation, for restrictions on limbing trees in adjacent street and use buffers), subject to the following requirements and conditions: 01. Pruning shall be done according to the guidelines of the International Society of Arboriculture, as published in the Arborist Certification Guide. 02. No more than ten percent of the tree's leaf surface shall be removed. 03. Climbing spikes shall not be used on trees that are not being removed. 04. Property owners bear the burden of proving that they have met the above requirements. ix. Removal or pruning of trees in the PD-1 zoning district under the following conditions: Page 28 of 115 LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 3 of 10 01. On the Common Property owned by a Property Owners Association, to which all landowners of property located behind the security gate must belong, that is behind any security gate or access point that is manned a minimum of eight (8) hours per day, or at any point within the Spanish Wells PD-1, where the tree or trees to be removed or pruned are: a) Damaged, dead or dying or a fall hazard; or, b) Causing an actual, imminent hazard to pedestrian, bicycle or vehicular travel because roots of any tree or trees have uplifted pavement, or because branches and foliage are impeding travel sight lines, or because branches and foliage impede travel areas for pedestrians, bicycles and vehicles, and no feasible alternative to removing or pruning the tree or trees exists. b. No Natural Resources Permit is required where the proposed tree removal or alteration is reviewed and authorized in accordance with an approved Subdivision Plan (see Sec. 16-2-103.F), Development Plan (Minor or Major) (see Sec. 16-2-103.G), Small Residential Development (see Sec. 16-2-103.H) or Public Project (see Sec. 16-2-103.Q)—though compliance with the standards in this section is required. C. Tree Protection Information in Applications 2. Tree Survey a. The tree survey shall be in the form of a map or a site plan prepared and sealed by a registered land surveyor within two years of the date of application. The tree survey shall be at the same scale as the required site development plan and shall include the following information: i. The location of all Category I, II and IV trees with a DBH of 6 inches or greater, Category III trees (other than cedar and palmetto trees) with a DBH of 12 inches or greater and cedar and palmetto trees with a DBH of 8 inches or greater within the areas to be developed and within areas 25 feet beyond such area in each direction, or extending to the property line, whichever is less; (Revised 5-17-2016 - Ordinance 2016-07) ii. The location of any trees with a DBH less than 6 inches (Category I, II and IV), less than 8 inches (cedar and palmetto trees), and less than 12 inches (Category III other than cedar and palmetto trees) that the applicant wishes to count toward the minimum standard of tree coverage on the site; and (Revised 5-17-2016 - Ordinance 2016-07) iii. The species and DBH of all trees. b. In conjunction with the tree survey, trees shall be marked with color ribbons, using blue ribbons to mark trees to be preserved, red ribbons for trees to be removed, and orange ribbons for hazardous trees that are proposed to be removed (hazardous trees will not count towards the overall required tree replacement). In heavily wooded areas, the Official may allow large groups of a significant stand of trees to be preserved or removed to be marked with the appropriately colored ribbon extending around the perimeter of the group of trees. Page 29 of 115 LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 4 of 10 F. Specimen and Significant Tree Preservation 1. Specimen and Significant Tree Defined For purposes of this section, a specimen tree is any tree of a species designated by the State or federal government as an endangered, threatened, or rare species, or any tree of a type and with a DBH equal or greater than that indicated in Table 16-6-104.F.1, Specimen Trees, for the tree type. A tree that is within 20% of the size classified as a specimen, is considered a significant tree. (Revised 5-17-2016 - Ordinance 2016-07; revised 1-7-2020 - Ordinance 2020-02) TABLE 16-6-104.F.1: SPECIMEN AND SIGNIFICANT TREES TREE TYPE SPECIMEN DBH (INCHES) SIGNIFICANT DBH (INCHES) Live oak Single trunk 35 30 28 24 Multiple trunks 60 55 (sum of all trunks) 48 41 Laurel oak 35 30 28 24 Water oak 30 24 Red oak 25 20 White oak 20 16 All hickories 20 16 American elm 15 12 Loblolly and slash pines 35 28 Longleaf and pond pines 25 20 Red bay 10 8 Southern magnolia 30 24 Bald cypress and pond cypress 15 12 Black gum and sweet gum 30 24 Red maple 30 24 Spruce pine Any size Any size Red cedar 10 8 Sycamore 30 24 Black cherry 25 20 Sassafras 6 5 (Revised 1-7-2020 - Ordinance 2020-02) 2. General Requirements a. No specimen tree may be removed except in accordance with paragraph b below. In addition, all specimen trees shall have the following protections, whether located on public or private land. with the exception of specimen trees located on single-family lots: (Revised 5-17-2016 - Ordinance 2016-07) i. Any activities performed within the drip line of a specimen tree shall have the prior approval of the Official. ii. Specimen trees shall not be cut, removed, pushed over, killed, or otherwise harmed. Page 30 of 115 LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 5 of 10 iii. No more than 20 percent of the total area within the drip line of any specimen tree shall be subject to paving or soil compaction, and no paving or soil compaction is allowed within 15 feet of the tree trunk. (See Figure 16-6-104.F.2: Limits of Paving or Compaction near Specimen Trees.) The Official may allow paving or soil compaction beyond the 20 percent limit if low impact development techniques (e.g., pervious pavers, materials placed at or above grade, no use of mechanical machinery) are used as an alternative means of protecting the specimen tree. Figure 16-6-104.F.2: Limits of Paving or Compaction near Specimen Trees b. If preservation of a specimen tree causes unnecessary hardship, the applicant may apply for a variance from this subsection (see Sec. 16-2-103.S, Variance) once any required State or federal government agency approval, if applicable, to remove the tree is received in writing. (Revised 4-18-2017 - Ordinance 2017-05) I. Standards for Supplemental and Replacement Trees 3. Replacement Rate, Tree Category, Planting Size a. Trees that are removed shall be replaced at the rate of one tree for every ten tree inches removed per tree category. b. Supplemental and replacement trees shall be within the same or lower-numbered tree category (see Sec. 16-6-104.H, Tree Equivalency Table) as the trees being replaced. c. At the time of planting, supplemental and replacement trees shall have the minimum height and trunk diameter shown in Table 16-6-104.I.3 for the category of the tree. TABLE 16-6-104.I.3: MINIMUM PLANTING SIZE FOR SUPPLEMENTAL AND REPLACEMENT TREES TREE CATEGORY MINIMUM HEIGHT (FEET) MINIMUM TRUNK DIAMETER (INCHES) (USING ANSI STANDARDS) Category I 10 12 2 4 Category II 10 12 2 4 Category III 6 8 1 2 Page 31 of 115 LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 6 of 10 Category IV 6 8 1 2 (Revised 4-18-2017 - Ordinance 2017-05) Appendix C: Recommended Native Plants RECOMMENDED NATIVE PLANTS FOR BUFFERS AND WETLANDS This list is meant to be used as a guide, and is not all inclusive. Buffer and wetland plants are intended to supply a year-round filtering and habitat function. Therefore, using a diverse selection of flora is highly encouraged. COMMON NAME LATIN NAME LOCATION GRASSES, VINES, AND GROUNDCOVER Black Needle Rush Juncus roemerianus Tidal wetland Blue Flag Iris Iris virginica Freshwater wetland Lizard's Tail Saururus cernuus Freshwater wetland Maidencane Panicum hemitoman Freshwater wetland Muhley Grass Muhlenbegia capillaris Upland Passsion Flower Passiflora incarnata Upland Pickerelweed Pontederia cordata Freshwater wetland Saltmeadow Cordgrass Spartina patens Upland Sand Cordgrass Spartina bakeri Upland Smooth Cordgrass Spartina alterniflora Tidal wetland Soft Rush Juncus effuses Tidal wetland Wild Ginger Asarum canadense Upland Yellow Jassamine Gelsemium sempervirens Upland SHRUBS AND SMALL TREES Beautyberry Callicarpa Americana Upland Coral Bean Erythrina herbacea Upland Dahoon Holly Ilex cassine Upland Fetterbush Lyonia lucida Freshwater wetland/Upland Inkberry Ilex glabra Freshwater wetland/Upland Loblolly Bay Gordonia lasianthus Upland Salt Myrtle Baccharis halimifolia Upland Saw Palmetto Serona repens Upland Sparkleberry Vaccinium arboreum Upland Star Anise Illicium floridanum Upland Wax Myrtle Myrica ceriflora Upland Witch Hazel Hamamelis viginiana Upland Yaupon Holly Ilex vomitoria Upland MEDIUM AND LARGE TREES American Holly Ilex opaca Upland Page 32 of 115 LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 7 of 10 Bald Cypress Taxodium distichum Freshwater wetland/Upland Black Gum Nyssa sylvatica Freshwater wetland/Upland Laurel Oak Quercus laurifolia Upland Little Gem Magnolia Magnolia grandiflora "Little Gem" Upland Live Oak Quercus virginiana Upland Red Maple Acer rubrum Freshwater wetland/Upland Sabal palmetto Sabal palmetto Upland Southern Magnolia Magnolia grandiflora Upland Southern Red Cedar Juniperis silicicola Upland Sweet Gum Liquidamber styraciflua Freshwater wetland/Upland RECOMMENDED NATIVE PLANTS FOR BUFFERS AND WETLANDS This list is meant to be used as a guide, and is not all inclusive. Buffer and wetland plants are intended to supply a year-round filtering and habitat function. Therefore, using a diverse selection of flora is highly encouraged. COMMON NAME LATIN NAME LOCATION NATIVE PLANTS FOR DUNES Beach evening primrose Oenothera drummondii Primary Dune Beach morning glory Ipomoea imperati Primary Dune Bear-grass (yucca) Yucca filamentosa Primary Dune Camphor weed Heterotheca subaxillaris Primary Dune Climbing Butterfly pea Centrosema viriginianum Primary Dune Devil-joint cactus Opuntia drummondii Primary Dune Dune sunflower Helianthus debilis Primary Dune Dwarf palmetto Sabal minor Primary Dune Moundlily yucca Yucca gloriosa Primary Dune Prickly pear cactus Opuntia compressa Primary Dune Purple passion flower (vine) Passiflora incarnata Primary Dune Railroad vine Ipomea pes-caprae Primary Dune Salt myrtle Baccharus halimifolia Primary Dune Saw palm Serenoa repens Primary Dune Sea oats Uniola paniculata Primary Dune Seaside panicum Panicum amarum Primary Dune Spanish bayonet Yucca aloifolia Primary Dune Wax myrtle Myrica cerifera Primary Dune Yaupon holly Ilex vomitoria Primary Dune Yellow passion flower (vine) Passiflora lutea Primary Dune *Dune fields can contain several dune rows that have mostly grasses and other non-woody plants in them. Look at dune areas adjacent to yours to determine which plants are best to use in similar areas. NEVER plant a non- native plant in dune areas; they may become invasive. GRASSES, VINES, AND GROUNDCOVER Page 33 of 115 LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 8 of 10 Arrow Arum Peltandra virginica Lower Bank/Shallow Water Black Needle Rush Juncus roemerianus Tidal wetland, Salt marsh buffer Blue Flag Iris Iris virginica Freshwater wetland Bur-marigolds Bidens sp. (yellow flower, blooms in fall) Lower Bank/Shallow Water Buttonbush Cephalanthus occidentalis Lower Bank/Shallow Water Duck potato Sagittaria latifolia Lower Bank/Shallow Water Floating hearts Nymphoides aquatica Floating Plants Fragrant water lily Nymphaea odorata Floating Plants Golden club Orontium aquaticum Lower Bank/Shallow Water Hooded pitcher plant Sarracenia minor Lower Bank/Shallow Water Jack-in-the-pulpit Arisaema triphyllum Lower Bank/Shallow Water Large marsh pink Sabatia dodecandra Lower Bank/Shallow Water Lizard's Tail Saururus cernuus Freshwater wetland Maidencane Panicum hemitoman Freshwater wetland Muhley Grass Muhlenbegia capillaris Upland Passsion Flower Passiflora incarnata Upland Pickerelweed Pontederia cordata Freshwater wetland Rushes Juncus sp. Lower Bank/Shallow Water Saltmeadow Cordgrass Spartina patens Upland Salthay Spartina patens Salt marsh buffer Sand Cordgrass Spartina bakeri Upland Sea ox-eye Borrichia frutescens Salt marsh buffer Smooth Cordgrass Spartina alterniflora Tidal wetland Soft Rush Juncus effuses Tidal wetland Spikerushes Eleocharis sp. Lower Bank/Shallow Water Swamp rose mallow Hibiscus moscheutos Lower Bank/Shallow Water Watershield Brasenia schreberi Floating Plants Wild Rice Zizania aquatica Lower Bank/Shallow Water Wild Ginger Asarum canadense Upland Woolgrass bulrush Scirpus cyperinus Lower Bank/Shallow Water Yellow canna Canna flaccida Lower Bank/Shallow Water Yellow Jassamine Gelsemium sempervirens Upland Yellow fringed orchid Habenaria ciliaris Lower Bank/Shallow Water SHRUBS AND SMALL TREES American holly Ilex opaca Upland Beautyberry Callicarpa Americana Upland Cabbage palmetto Sabal palmetto Upland, salt marsh buffer Carolina cherry laurel Prunus caroliniana Upland Chickasaw plum Prunus angustifolia Upland Cinnamon fern Osmunda cinnamomea Upland Common persimmon Diospyros virginiana Upland Coral Bean Erythrina herbacea Upland Coral honeysuckle Lonicera sempervirens Upland Cross vine Anisostichus capreolata Upland Dahoon Holly Ilex cassine Upland Fetterbush Lyonia lucida Freshwater wetland/Upland Hercules’ Club Zanthoxylum clava-herculis Upland, salt marsh buffer Page 34 of 115 LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 9 of 10 Horse sugar Symplocus tinctoria Upland Inkberry Ilex glabra Freshwater wetland/Upland Loblolly Bay Gordonia lasianthus Upland Redbay Persea borbonia Upland Salt Myrtle Baccharis halimifolia Upland Sassafras Sassafras albidum Upland Saw Palmetto Serona repens Upland Southern Red Cedar Juniperus silicicola Upland, salt marsh buffer Sparkleberry Vaccinium arboreum Upland Star Anise Illicium floridanum Upland Sugarberry Celtis laevigata Upland Tough bumelia Bumelia tenax Upland, salt marsh buffer Trumpet vine Campsis radicans Upland Wax Myrtle Myrica ceriflora Upland Winged sumac Rhus copallina Upland Witch Hazel Hamamelis viginiana Upland Yaupon Holly Ilex vomitoria Upland MEDIUM AND LARGE TREES American Holly Ilex opaca Upland Bald Cypress Taxodium distichum Freshwater wetland/Upland Black Gum Nyssa sylvatica Freshwater wetland/Upland Florida Maple Acer barbatum Upland Hickories, various species Carya spp. Upland Laurel Oak Quercus laurifolia Upland Little Gem Magnolia Magnolia grandiflora "Little Gem" Upland Live Oak Quercus virginiana Upland Loblolly pine Pinus taeda Upland Long leaf pine Pinus Palustris Upland Red Maple Acer rubrum Freshwater wetland/Upland Sabal palmetto Sabal palmetto Upland Slash pine Pinus elliottii Upland Southern Magnolia Magnolia grandiflora Upland Southern Red Cedar Juniperis silicicola Upland Southern Red Oak Quercus falcata Upland Sweet Gum Liquidamber styraciflua Freshwater wetland/Upland Water Oak Quercus nigra Upland Page 35 of 115 LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 10 of 10 RECOMMENDED INVASIVE TREES AND PLANTS FOR REMOVAL The following is a list of common Invasive Trees and Plants in the Lowcountry. The list contains plants and trees that negatively impact native plants and trees and are recommended for removal. Therefore, using a recommended native plant list is encouraged.  Autumn-Olive Tree  Bamboo  Beach Vitex ground cover  Bradford Pear Tree  Chinese Privet Shrub  Chinese Silvergrass grass  Chinese Tallow Tree  Chinese Wisteria vine  Cogongrass grass  Common Reed (Phragmites) grass  English Ivy vine  Japanese Honeysuckle shrub  Japanese Stiltgrass grass  Kudzu Vine  Multiflora Rose Shrub  Non-Native Milkweed Page 36 of 115 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court  Hilton Head Island  South Carolina  29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 1 of 11 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND Community Services and Public Safety Committee TO: Community Services and Public Safety Committee FROM: Missy Luick, Director of Planning CC: Shawn Leininger, Assistant Town Manager CC: Marc Orlando, Town Manager DATE: June 16, 2025 SUBJECT: Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island to Amend Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to Amend Current Regulations for Sign Standards to Include Sections 16-5-114 and 16-10-105, and Providing for Severability and an Effective Date RECOMMENDATION: Community Services and Public Safety Committee review and consider an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island to amend Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend current regulations for sign standards to include Sections 16-5-114 and 16-10-105 for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina and providing for severability and an effective date, and forward a recommendation to Town Council. The Planning Commission held a public hearing on May 21, 2025, and, after consideration of the criteria set forth in Land Management Ordinance (LMO) Section 16- 2-103.B, voted unanimously to recommend that Town Council approve the proposed text amendment. BACKGROUND: Revitalize and Modernize the Economy is a focus area in the adopted Town Council 2023- 2025 Strategic Action Plan. In fulfillment of this focus area, Strategy #1 Establish a Growth Management Strategy states the Town will: “Successfully manage increasing and evolving future growth patterns in a manner that will ensure sustainability of Hilton Head Island’s unique character. Additionally, the Town must monitor economic and demographic trends, undertaking a comprehensive list of future planning activities, and proactively protecting the Island’s rich natural resources through appropriate design, regulation, and capital investment practices.” Page 37 of 115 Page 2 of 11 In this regard, Town Council directed Town Staff to advance amendments to the Land Management Ordinance (LMO) in the 2024 Strategic Action Work Plan. The effort has been divided into two separate projects, the full LMO Overhaul and the priority amendments. The priority amendments include incremental changes to both the LMO and portions of the Municipal Code related to land management that address important and urgent issues in advance of the full LMO Overhaul. These priority amendments address pressing community development issues with the best short-term solution while minimizing unintended outcomes. Issues that require additional analysis and research or are more complex are recommended to be further explored during the full LMO Overhaul. At the September 24, 2024, Town Council Workshop, Town staff received the following comments and direction regarding amendments related to sign regulation: 1. Sign standards are not content neutral as required from Reed v. Town of Gilbert Supreme Court decision. 2. Amending our sign code to be compliant with the Supreme Court decision will reduce our ability to regulate certain sign types. SUMMARY OF AMENDMENT: The proposed updates to the sign regulations aim to ensure compliance with federal case law by adopting a "content-neutral" approach. This change is in response to the U.S. Supreme Court's 2015 decision in Reed v. Town of Gilbert, which invalidated a town’s sign regulations for distinguishing between different types of non-commercial messages, such as political or event-related signs. The Court's decision made it clear that regulations based on the content of signs must be avoided, as content-based rules are subject to strict scrutiny, requiring a compelling governmental interest and narrowly tailored measures. The following updates are designed to align with these evolving legal standards and create fairer, more defensible sign regulations that preserve to the maximum extent possible current Town regulations regarding size, height, location, design, and permitting of signs. In addition, the amendments include minor clarifications and housekeeping changes to streamline the process and make the regulations easier to navigate. The proposed amendment is summarized as follows: 1. Noncommercial Message Substitution: This language was replaced. The purpose of a substitution clause is to assure that if the sign code allows a sign containing commercial copy, it shall also allow a non-commercial sign to the same extent. It should apply to every possible dimension of the sign, including location, duration of posting, size or area, materials or design requirements, requirement for permit, etc. 2. Flag Regulations: Flag regulations have been updated to reflect case law and federal law. Flags on Town property can only include the United States, South Carolina, or Town flag—unless Town Council specifically approves something Page 38 of 115 Page 3 of 11 else. On private property, you're allowed up to two flags per parcel, but they cannot be:  In street easements or public rights-of-way  Placed on public land, unless the public agency that owns the land puts them there  Larger than 24 square feet, unless the Design Review Board and Town Council approve a larger one (like on a telecommunications tower) These rules apply to all flags but must still follow state and federal laws about the U.S. and South Carolina flags. 3. Interior Site Signs: The current ordinance includes several sign types that are found internal to sites and in parking lots (menu boards, parking signs, shopping cart return sign, etc.). These signs are grouped together as “interior site signs.” Interior site signs are proposed to be exempt from permitting and subject to requirements. 4. Temporary Yard Signs: Temporary yard signs totaling six square feet or less during election seasons are proposed to be exempt from permitting based on legal review and case law. In no case can the Town regulate what message is displayed on these signs during the specified timeframe, even if not related to the election or referendum. 5. Temporary Yard Sign Standards: This section “standardizes” all temporary signs that are currently regulated by their content (real estate signs, construction signs, etc.). Paragraph H.1.a includes general requirements for durability, illumination, shape, number, size, and timeframe. Temporary yard signs are not exempt from permitting. One temporary yard sign is permitted per parcel. However, there are other circumstances and timeframes where “additional” temporary yard signs are permitted:  During permitted construction projects  When the building or property is listed for sale or lease  A timeframe before and after an election or referendum Concerning temporary yard signs 90 days before to seven days after an election or referendum, a permit is only required if the total size of the signs exceeds six square feet. Otherwise, signs are exempt from permitting and are allowable if compliant with Section E.1.b.ii.12. 6. Driveway Access Point Signs: While similar to “interior site signs,” these signs are oriented toward traffic control at driveway intersections. Driveway access point signs require a permit. Signs at driveway entrances (for non-residential properties) Page 39 of 115 Page 4 of 11 are allowed but must be no larger than 4 square feet and no taller than 3 feet. Only two signs are allowed per access point. 7. Interior Site Signs: Interior site signs that fall within setback areas (the required open spaces around a building) need a permit. Otherwise, the rules for size (4 square feet) and height (3 feet) apply to these signs as well. Given the importance of ensuring legal compliance, these changes are part of the priority amendments and will address immediate concerns. Further adjustments are expected during the full LMO update project. ANALYSIS: Proposed Amendments The proposed priority amendment streamlines and clarifies sign regulations, focusing on simplicity, consistency, maintaining community standards, and legal compliance. Based on the length of the text amendment, only the most noteworthy sections are included in the following table. All other changes are included in the attached text amendment and relate to the removal of content-based language and general editing. Issue Proposed Amendment Section B.2. Substitution of Noncommercial Message. This language was replaced. The purpose of a substitution clause is to assure, in one fell swoop, that if the sign code allows a sign containing commercial copy, it shall also allow a non-commercial sign to the same extent. It should apply to every possible dimension of the sign, including location, duration of posting, size or area, materials or design requirements, requirement for permit, etc. Notwithstanding anything contained in this Ordinance to the contrary, any sign erected pursuant to the provisions of this Ordinance may, at the option of the owner, contain a non- commercial message in lieu of a commercial message, and the non-commercial copy may be substituted at any time in place of the commercial copy. The non-commercial message may occupy the entire sign face or any portion thereof. The sign face may be changed from a commercial message to a non- commercial message or from one non- commercial message to another non- commercial message; provided, however, that there is no change in the size, height, setback, or spacing criteria contained in this Ordinance. Noncommercial signs shall be allowed in all zoning districts and may be substituted for any sign expressly allowed under this Ordinance. Noncommercial signs shall be subject to the same permit requirements, restrictions on size and type, and other conditions and specifications as apply to the sign for which they are being substituted. Page 40 of 115 Page 5 of 11 Section E.1.b.ii.01. Flags. Flag regulations have been updated to reflect case law and federal law. 01. Flags Non-governmental flags are deemed to be signs and shall be subject to the provisions of this section. The official flags of the federal, State, county, or municipal governments are not deemed to be signs provided no such flag shall exceed 40 square feet per face. The Official may waive this size provision for the United States flag when: (A) The Design Review Board approves a larger flag for use on a telecommunications tower designed as a flagpole; or (B) The Town Council approves a larger flag for display on public property or other appropriate noncommercial sites as determined by Town Council. (A) Flags on Town-Owned, Leased, Managed, or Operated Property. The Town, at the Town Manager’s discretion or when voted on by Town Council and unless otherwise permitted by this Section, may display the United States flag, South Carolina flag, or Town flag on any and all Town owned, leased, managed, or operated property in accordance with all applicable state and federal laws. Unless approved by the Town Council, any and all other displays of flags on property that is owned, leased, managed, or operated by the Town are not permitted. (B) Flags Generally. Flags shall comply with the following: 1. No more than two flags are allowed per parcel. 2. Flags shall not be placed within street easements and rights-of-way. 3. Flags shall not be placed on public property unless posted by the public entity owning the parcel. 4. The size of a flag shall not exceed 24 square feet. The Official may waive this size provision when the Design Review Board approves a larger flag for use on a telecommunications Page 41 of 115 Page 6 of 11 tower designed as a flagpole or on appropriate sites as determined by the Town Council. (C) The terms of this section are to be applied to flags generally and shall not be interpreted to supersede nor conflict with any applicable state or federal laws or regulations related to the United States or South Carolina flag. Section E.1.b.ii.03. Interior Site Signs. The current ordinance includes several sign types that are found internal to sites and in parking lots (menu boards, parking signs, shopping cart return sign, etc.). These signs are grouped together as “interior site signs.” Interior site signs are proposed to be exempt from permitting and subject to the following requirements. A new definition is located in Sec.16-10-105. General Definitions. 03. Incidental Interior Site Signs Interior site signs that are internally oriented on commercial and multi-family property shall not require sign permits as long as they are not readily legible or visible beyond the boundaries of the parcel on which they are located, do not exceed four square feet in area per sign, and do not fall within required setback areas. Signs located at the end of a parking space and within five feet of the parking space are limited to 1.5 square feet, and no more than three are permitted per parcel. However, signs within five feet of parking spaces are not permitted in shopping centers. Addresses, building numbers, entrance and exit signs, and traffic directional signs shall not require Sign Permits if they do not exceed four square feet in area per sign. If such sign contains commercial copy, the sign counts toward the allowable square footage for freestanding signs. Sec.16-10-105. General Definitions. Sign, Interior Site A permanent and internally oriented sign on a non-residential parcel that is not readily visible and legible beyond the boundaries of the parcel on which it is located and is intended for viewing from the interior of the subject parcel. Page 42 of 115 Page 7 of 11 Section E.1.b.ii.12. Temporary Yard Signs. Temporary yard signs totaling six square feet or less during election seasons are proposed to be exempt from permitting based on legal review and case law. In no case can the Town regulate what message is displayed on these signs during the specified timeframe, even if not related to the election or referendum. 12. Temporary Yard Signs Up to six square feet of temporary yard signs are allowed 90 days prior to an election or referendum to seven days after the election or referendum without permits. The temporary yard signs shall comply with the following requirements: (A) The number of temporary yard signs on a parcel is not limited during this timeframe as long as the total size does not exceed six square feet. (B) During this timeframe, temporary yard signs may be made from lightweight materials such as corrugated plastic, cardboard, wood, or similar materials and may be affixed to the ground with metal wire frames, wood stakes, or plastic stakes. (C) Temporary yard signs shall not be placed within street easements and rights-of-way. (D) Temporary yard signs shall not be placed on public property unless posted by the public entity owning the parcel. Section H.1. Temporary Yard Signs. This section “standardizes” all temporary signs that are currently regulated by their content (real estate signs, construction signs, etc.). Paragraph H.1.a includes general requirements for durability, illumination, shape, number, size, and timeframe. Temporary yard signs are not exempt from permitting. One temporary yard sign is permitted per parcel. However, there are other circumstances and timeframes where “additional” temporary yard signs are permitted: H. Standards for Specific Types of Signs 1. Temporary Yard Signs a. All temporary yard signs shall comply with the following requirements: i. A maximum of one temporary yard sign is allowed per parcel. ii. Temporary yard signs shall be constructed of ½-inch medium density overlay panel (MDO) or a material of equal durability. iii. Temporary yard signs shall not be illuminated. Page 43 of 115 Page 8 of 11 o During permitted construction projects o When the building or property is listed for sale or lease o A timeframe before and after an election or referendum Concerning temporary yard signs 90 days before to seven days after an election or referendum, a permit is only required if the total size of the signs exceeds six square feet. Otherwise, signs are exempt from permitting and are allowable if compliant with Section E.1.b.ii.12. Although the additional sign provisions may relate to what the signs will be used for, in no case can the Town regulate what is on the additional signs during these circumstances or timeframes. iv. Temporary yard signs shall be square or rectangular in shape. v. Temporary yard signs shall not be placed on public street right- of-way, private street easements, and publicly owned parcels, unless posted by the public entity owning the parcel. vi. The size of a temporary yard sign shall not exceed three square feet. vii. A temporary yard sign shall be removed within 90 days from the date of its permit, unless an extension is approved by the Official. b. One additional temporary yard sign is permitted per street frontage on a parcel from the time a building or development permit is issued for construction on the parcel to the time a building occupancy permit is issued. The additional temporary yard sign shall not exceed 20 square feet in size and shall not exceed six feet in height from the existing grade. c. One additional temporary yard sign is permitted per street frontage of a parcel when the parcel, or building or unit on a parcel, is listed for rent or sale to the time two days after the execution of a rental contract or closing of the sale. The additional temporary yard sign shall comply with the following requirements: i. On parcels with residential uses, the additional temporary yard sign shall not exceed four square feet in size and shall not exceed four feet in height from the existing grade. ii. On parcels with non-residential uses, the additional temporary yard sign shall not exceed 20 square feet in size and shall not Page 44 of 115 Page 9 of 11 exceed six feet in height from the existing grade. iii. Where placement on the ground is not feasible, the Official may approve the sign to be placed on the façade of the building listed for rent or sale. d. Additional temporary yard signs are allowed 90 days prior to an election or referendum to seven days after the election or referendum. Permits are required in accordance with this section if the total size of the signs exceeds six square feet. If the total size of the signs does exceed six square feet, see Section 16-5-114 E.1.b.ii.12. The additional temporary yard signs shall comply with the following requirements: i. The number of temporary yard signs on a parcel is not limited during this timeframe. ii. The total size of temporary yard signs during this timeframe shall not exceed 32 square feet per parcel. iii. During this timeframe, temporary yard signs may be made from lightweight materials such as corrugated plastic, cardboard, wood, or similar materials and may be affixed to the ground with metal wire frames, wood stakes, or plastic stakes. iv. Temporary yard signs shall not be placed within street easements and rights-of-way. v. Temporary yard signs shall not be placed on public property unless posted by the public entity owning the parcel. Page 45 of 115 Page 10 of 11 Section H.9. Driveway Access Point Signs. While similar to “interior site signs,” these signs are oriented toward traffic control at driveway intersections. Driveway access point signs require a permit. H. Standards for Specific Types of Signs 9. Driveway Access Point Signs On parcels with non-residential uses, driveway access point signs shall comply with the following standards: a. The maximum size of an individual driveway access point sign is four square feet. b. A maximum of two driveway access point signs are allowed per access point. c. The maximum height of a driveway access point sign is three feet. Section H.10. Interior Site Signs. Interior site signs within setback areas are not exempt from permitting. Otherwise, the size and height requirements are the same. H. Standards for Specific Types of Signs 10. 10. Interior Site Signs a. Interior site signs require sign permits if proposed within the required side and rear setback areas. b. The maximum size of an individual non- exempt interior site sign is four square feet. c. The maximum height of an individual non-exempt interior site sign is three feet. Nonconformities The approval of this text amendment will not create nonconformities. Several sign types were grouped into the “interior site sign” classification, but the same dimensional requirements will apply. Additionally, temporary yard signs cannot benefit from nonconforming rights. Text Amendment Review Standards Section 16-2-103.B.3 of the LMO provides standards for the review of Text Amendments and states the following: Page 46 of 115 Page 11 of 11 “In determining whether to recommend that Town Council adopt or deny the proposed text amendment, the Planning Commission may weigh the relevance of and consider whether and the extent to which the proposed Text Amendment: a. Is in accordance with the Comprehensive Plan; b. Is required by changed conditions; c. Addresses a demonstrated community need; d. Is consistent with the purpose and intent of the zoning districts in this Ordinance, or would improve compatibility among uses and ensure efficient development within the Town; e. Would result in a logical and orderly development pattern; and f. Would not result in significantly adverse impacts on the natural environment, including but not limited to water, air, noise, stormwater management, wildlife, vegetation, wetlands, and the natural functioning of the environment.” The proposed text amendment aligns with the review criteria, as it: 1. Supports the Comprehensive Plan by minimizing the impact of signs and ensuring high-quality signage. 2. Is required due to a US Supreme Court decision. 3. Addresses a community need to hold signage to high standards for aesthetics and to reduce the visual clutter caused by unregulated signage. 4. Is consistent with the zoning districts in this Ordinance by ensuring high-quality and visually unobtrusive signage. 5. Will result in more attractive street corridors and properties. 6. Will have no impact on the natural environment. COMMUNITY SERVICES AND PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE ACTION: LMO Sec.16-2-103-B.2.d states that the Community Services and Public Safety Committee’s recommendation shall be based on the standards in Sec. 16-2-103.B.3, Ordinance Text Amendment Review Standards. The Committee has the following options when considering this agenda item. These include: 1. Recommend approval to Town Council. 2. Recommend denial to Town Council. 3. Recommend approval with conditions to Town Council. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Ordinance 2. Text Amendment Page 47 of 115 Attachment 1 – Sign Regulations Amendment Ordinance 1 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ORDINANCE NO._________ AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND TO AMEND CHAPTER 16 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE, THE LAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE, TO AMEND CURRENT REGULATIONS FOR SIGN STANDARDS TO INCLUDE SECTIONS: 16-5-114 AND 16-10-105 FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA AND PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the Town Council for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, has identified a continued need for the adoption of LMO Amendments to address needs and issues in the Town as such arise; and, WHEREAS, in Reed v. Town of Gilbert, Arizona, the United States Supreme Court has found that content neutrality is required for ordinances regulating signs, and the Town Council seeks to amend the Land Management Ordinance to comply with content neutrality requirements; and, WHEREAS, the decision in Reed v. Town of Gilbert, Arizona, recognized that safety and aesthetics are valid subjects for local government to consider in the regulation of signs, and that a sign ordinance may address size, materials, lighting, moving parts, portability and location as well as other content neutral elements; and, WHEREAS, on May 21, 2025, the Planning Commission held a Public Hearing to consider the proposed amendments to regulations for sign standards, and the public had an opportunity to comment on the proposed amendments, and the Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend adoption of the amendments to regulations for sign standards; and, WHEREAS, on June 16, 2025, the Community Services & Public Safety Committee voted ___ to recommend adoption to Town Council of the proposed amendments to regulations for sign standards; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by an amendment to the Land Management Ordinance to regulate the construction materials, compliance with applicable building and electrical codes, size, location, number and illumination of signs, in order to promote and preserve the aesthetic quality of the Town by reducing visual clutter, and preserve and promote pedestrian, cyclist and motorist safety by reducing distractions along roadways; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by these Page 48 of 115 Attachment 1 – Sign Regulations Amendment Ordinance 2 amendments to the Town’s Sign Ordinance, which will promote and preserve the aesthetic quality of the Town, reduce visual clutter, reduce distractions along roadways, ensure adequate separation between signs, and aid in providing for adequate light, air, and open space and facilitate the creation of a convenient, attractive, and harmonious community. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, AND IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY AND UNDER AUTHORITY OF SAID TOWN COUNCIL, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Amendment. That the Land Management Ordinance is amended as shown on Exhibit “A” to this Ordinance. Newly added language is illustrated with double underline and deleted language is illustrated with strikethrough. Section 2. Severability. If any section, phrase, sentence, or portion of this Ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct, and independent provision, and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions thereof. Section 3. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be effective upon its adoption by the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED BY THE COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ON THIS _____ DAY OF __________ , 2025. THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ____________________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor ATTEST: _____________________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk First Reading: Second Reading: Page 49 of 115 Attachment 1 – Sign Regulations Amendment Ordinance 3 APPROVED AS TO FORM: __________________________________ Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney Page 50 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 1 of 32 Chapter 16-5: Development and Design Standards Sec.16-5-114. Sign Standards A. Purpose It is the purpose of this section to promote the public health, safety, and general welfare through a comprehensive system of reasonable, consistent, and nondiscriminatory sign standards and requirements. These sign regulations are intended to: 1. Maximize the value of commercial signage as a means of locating and identifying commercial establishments providing goods and services while, at the same time, discouraging the use of commercial signage to sell goods and services; 21. Encourage the construction of commercial signs of high-quality materials that are aesthetically pleasing and are compatible with their natural surroundings and with the buildings they identifythe parcels and buildings on which they are placed; 32. Avoid the creation of a distracting atmosphere that can result when businesses compete for attention through the use of commercial advertising signs; 4. and Pprotect, preserve, and enhance the unique aesthetic character, beauty, and charm of the Town, and thereby encourage the continued economic development within its limitsthe Town; and 53. Improve pedestrian and traffic safety and eliminate physical and visual clutter caused by signs that compete for the attention of pedestrian and vehicular traffic; and. 4. Prevent hazards caused by signs that are improperly secured or constructed. B. Applicability and Provisions 1. Applicability a. A sign may be erected, placed, established, painted, created, or maintained in the Town only in conformance with the standards, procedures, exemptions, and other requirements of this section and this Ordinance. Signs exempt from regulations under Sec. 16-5-114.E.1.b.ii, Signs Allowed Without a Sign Permit, shall not otherwise be subject to this Ordinance. b. With the exception of Sec. 16-5-114.H.5, Residential Real Estate Sales Signs, and Sec. 16-5- 114.H.6, Residential Short-Term Rental Signs, the provisions of this Ordinance shall not apply to single-family uses. cb. Signs located on property within those portions of a PD-1 district where vehicular access by the general public is restricted by a security gate staffed 8 hours each day by a security guard and within the Spanish Wells PD-1 District, and where such signs are not visible from any beach, navigable waterway, or public street are not subject to the provisions of this Ordinance. d. Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, no sign shall be subject to any limitation based on the content of the message contained on such sign. Page 51 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 2 of 32 ec. Any legal sign that does not comply with the provisions of this section due solely to the enactment of an amendment shall, upon the effective date of such amendment, become a legal nonconforming sign and shall be subject to the provisions of Title 16, Chapter 16-7: Nonconformities. fd. All signs shall comply with applicable building and electrical code requirements. ge. In accordance with IBC Section 1609.1, applications for new freestanding signs larger than 40 square feet shall include wind load calculations stamped and signed by a certified engineer and stating that the sign can withstand winds of up to 130 miles per hour. 2. Substitution of Noncommercial Message Notwithstanding anything contained in this Ordinance to the contrary, any sign erected pursuant to the provisions of this Ordinance may, at the option of the owner, contain a non-commercial message in lieu of a commercial message, and the non-commercial copy may be substituted at any time in place of the commercial copy. The non-commercial message may occupy the entire sign face or any portion thereof. The sign face may be changed from a commercial message to a non-commercial message or from one non-commercial message to another non-commercial message; provided, however, that there is no change in the size, height, setback, or spacing criteria contained in this Ordinance. Noncommercial signs shall be allowed in all zoning districts and may be substituted for any sign expressly allowed under this Ordinance. Noncommercial signs shall be subject to the same permit requirements, restrictions on size and type, and other conditions and specifications as apply to the sign for which they are being substituted. C. Sign Design, Construction, and Maintenance Guidelines 1. Design Guide The Hilton Head Island Design Guide defines Island Character and describes how development should be directed to preserve Island Character. Goals of the Design Guide that pertain to sign design include: a. Demonstrate the fundamental principles of good architectural design. b. Design structures with subtle visual impact and utilize natural materials, textures, and colors. c. Coordinate and harmonize the design of structures, parking, and site amenities. d. Conceal visually undesirable utilities and equipment. 2. Sign Design, Construction, and Maintenance Standards To meet these goals, sign design, construction, and maintenance shall comply with the following standards: a. Materials, colors, and shapes of proposed signs shall be complementary to the related buildings and to nearby structures and signs. Sign colors shall be non-reflective and shall not contain fluorescent colors. (See Figure 16-5-114.C.2: Examples of Signs that are Complementary to Nearby Structures.) b. Signs shall be constructed of high-quality materials. (See Design Guide.) c. The amount of information on signs shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the business or of any message to be conveyed. Objective factors to consider in determining reasonableness shall include, but not be limited to, physical location, size of the sign and typeface, colors of the sign and typeface, and sign height. Page 52 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 3 of 32 d. The visual impact of freestanding signs shall be softened with landscaping appropriate to the site. Figure 16-5-114.C.2: Examples of Signs that are Complementary to Nearby Structures e. Sign illumination shall comply with the standards in Sec. 16-5-114.D, Sign Illumination. Page 53 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 4 of 32 Figure 16-5-114.C.3: Examples of Freestanding Signs that Meet the Intent of The Hilton Head Island Design Guide f. Signs shall be maintained in good condition at all times and shall be kept free of cracked or peeling paint, missing or damaged sign panels or supports, and weeds, grass or vegetation that obscures the view of the sign message. D. Sign Illumination Electrical requirements pertaining to sign illumination shall be as prescribed under the latest adopted edition of the IBC. Illuminated signs shall conform to the following standards: 1. External illumination shall be by a steady stationary light source, shielded and directed solely at the sign. Light fixtures shall be restricted to not more than one shielded light fixture per side for signs up to 40 square feet and not more than two shielded light fixtures per side for signs over 40 square feet. 2. Light sources to illuminate signs shall neither be visible from any street right-of-way, nor cause glare hazardous to pedestrians or vehicle drivers or so as to create a nuisance to adjacent properties. All ground-mounted lighting must be obscured by landscaping approved by the Official. 3. The intensity of the light shall not exceed 20 foot-candles at any point on the sign. 4. Signs shall not have light-reflecting backgrounds but may use light-reflecting lettering or halo lighting. 5. The Official may permit internal illumination for menu board signs for eating establishments with a drive-through. Such signs shall not cause glare hazardous to pedestrians or vehicle drivers or so as to create a nuisance to adjacent properties. Such signs shall be placed and angled so that, to the greatest extent possible, they are not visible from public or private streets. 6. Lamps shall only produce a white light. Page 54 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 5 of 32 E. Sign Permits 1. Applicability a. General Unless exempted in accordance with subparagraph b below, a Sign Permit is required for each of the following types ofall signs prior to the sign being erected, placed, or displayed.: i. Freestanding Signs (Sec. 16-5-114.F). ii. Tenant Panels on Freestanding Signs (Sec. 16-5-114.F.10.a). iii. Facade and Hanging Signs (Sec. 16-5-114.G). iv. Temporary Signs for Permitted Signs (Sec. 16-5-114.H.1). v. Construction Signs (Sec. 16-5-114.H.2). vi. Nonresidential Real Estate Sales Signs (Sec. 16-5-114.H.3). vii. Nonresidential Real Estate Lease or Rent Signs (Sec. 16-5-114.H.4). viii. Residential Real Estate Sales Signs (Sec. 16-5-114.H.5). ix. Residential Short-Term Rental Signs (Sec. 16-5-114.H.6). x. Sign Systems (Sec. 16-5-114.H.7). xi. Temporary Special Event Signs (Sec. 16-5-114.H.9). xii. Signs with Changeable Copy (Sec. 16-5-114.H.10). xiii. Price Displays at Gas Sales Establishments (Sec. 16-5-114.H.11). xiv. Planned Unit Development Off-Premises Signs (Sec. 16-5-114.H.12). b. Exemptions i. Sign Alterations Exempt from Sign Permit A Sign Permit is not required prior to engaging in the following alterations to a sign: 01.The changing of copy on a sign permitted for changeable copy. 02.The painting or refinishing of the surface of a sign face or sign structure of a permitted sign so as to keep the appearance of such sign as permitted. ii. Signs Allowed Without a Sign Permit The following signs shall be allowed subject to compliance with the standards of this section, but no Sign Permit shall be required. The property owner's consent shall be obtained before erecting such signage. 01.Flags Non-governmental flags are deemed to be signs and shall be subject to the provisions of this section. The official flags of the federal, State, county, or municipal governments are not deemed to be signs provided no such flag shall exceed 40 square feet per face. The Official may waive this size provision for the United States flag when: Page 55 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 6 of 32 (A) The Design Review Board approves a larger flag for use on a telecommunications tower designed as a flagpole; or (B) The Town Council approves a larger flag for display on public property or other appropriate noncommercial sites as determined by Town Council. (A) Flags on Town-Owned, Leased, Managed, or Operated Property. The Town, at the Town Manager’s discretion or when voted on by Town Council and unless otherwise permitted by this Section, may display the United States flag, South Carolina flag, or Town flag on any and all Town owned, leased, managed, or operated property in accordance with all applicable state and federal laws. Unless approved by the Town Council, any and all other displays of flags on property that is owned, leased, managed, or operated by the Town are not permitted. (B) Flags Generally. Flags shall comply with the following: 1. No more than two flags are allowed per parcel. 2. Flags shall not be placed within street easements and rights-of-way. 3. Flags shall not be placed on public property unless posted by the public entity owning the parcel. 4. The size of a flag shall not exceed 24 square feet. The Official may waive this size provision when the Design Review Board approves a larger flag for use on a telecommunications tower designed as a flagpole or on appropriate sites as determined by the Town Council. (C) The terms of this section are to be applied to flags generally and shall not be interpreted to supersede nor conflict with any applicable state or federal laws or regulations related to the United States or South Carolina flag. Page 56 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 7 of 32 02.Holiday Seasonal decorations Decorations that are not internally illuminated shall not require a Sign Permit, provided they are displayed for no more than a total of 60 days per calendar year, excluding the time period between November 1 and January 15. Such decorations shall be maintained in a good condition at all times and shall be removed or replaced when they are overly weathered, torn, broken, or otherwise present a potential safety hazard. (A) Strings of lights used as holiday seasonal decorations shall be subject to the provisions of Sec. 16-5-114.E.1.b.ii.12, String Lights for Decoration. (B) Inflated holiday seasonal decorations are allowed from November 1 through January 15 of each year. (C) Windblown decorations are prohibited at all times. Figure 16-5-114.E.1.b.ii.02(A): Example of Conforming Holiday Seasonal Decorations with String Lights Figure 16-5-114.E.1.b.ii.02(B): Example of Conforming Holiday Seasonal Decorations Without String Lights Page 57 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 8 of 32 Figure 16-5-114.E.1.b.ii.03: Example of a Conforming Incidental Sign 03.Incidental Interior Site Signs Addresses, building numbers, entrance and exit signs, and traffic directional signs shall not require Sign Permits if they do not exceed four square feet in area per sign. If such sign contains commercial copy, the sign counts toward the allowable square footage for freestanding signs. Interior site signs that are internally oriented on commercial and multi-family property shall not require sign permits as long as they are not readily legible or visible beyond the boundaries of the parcel on which they are located, do not exceed four square feet in area per sign, and do not fall within required setback areas. Signs located at the end of a parking space and within five feet of the parking space are limited to 1.5 square feet, and no more than three are permitted per parcel. However, signs within five feet of parking spaces are not permitted in shopping centers. 04.Interior Indoor Signs Any sign that, in the Official's reasonable opinion, is to be viewed from the inside of a building only. 05.Nonresidential Real Estate for Lease or Rent Signs Such signs shall meet the requirements in Sec. 16-5-114.H.4, Nonresidential Real Estate Lease or Rent Signs. 06.Menus Menus attached to the facade of a building with no more than four square feet of sign face area located at the entrance or service window of a business. 07.Parking Signs Signs that reserve parking spaces for specific uses or businesses, except that such signs are not allowed in shopping centers per Sec. 16-5-114.I, Prohibited Signs. Parking signs shall not exceed 1.5 square feet in area per sign. No more than three parking signs shall be displayed at any given time on each parcel. 085.Public Signs Page 58 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 9 of 32 Signs erected by the federal, State, or local government, or governmental entity, including interpretive signs located on Town-owned property. Signs that are required by a public entity are considered public signs. 096.Sandwich Boards and Chalkboards Figure 16-5-114.E.1.b.ii.09: Example of a Conforming Sandwich Board Sign Freestanding, sandwich board and framed chalkboard signs that comply with each of the following standards: (A) One sign per business may be displayed during hours of operation. (B) Signs shall be placed within ten feet of the building entrance of the business displaying the sign. (C) Signs shall be placed to allow at least 36 inches of unobstructed pedestrian clearance adjacent to the sign. (D) Signs shall be limited to a maximum of six square feet in total area. (E) Sign frame colors are limited to earth tones. Sign face colors are limited to black (Pantone® Black or equivalent) or dark green (Pantone® 574 U or equivalent) with a matte finish. (F) Plastic or dry erase boards shall not be allowed. 10.Shopping Cart Return Signs identifying shopping cart return areas, provided that such signs are no larger than ten square feet. 0711.Stadium Signs Signs or banners that are located within a stadium and are not intended to be visible from outside of a stadium. 0812.String Lights for Seasonal Decoration (A) White or multi-color Sstrings of lights may be used for outside lighting or tree decoration from November 1 through January 15 of each year. Page 59 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 10 of 32 (B) Because many colors are used to celebrate various holidays during this time, multi-color lights are allowed. (CB) Flashing, blinking and chasing lights are prohibited. 0913.String Lights for Ambient Illumination (A) Strings of white lights may be used to provide ambient lighting for outdoor seating areas of an eating establishment. Such string lights shall be limited to the dining area. (B) Colored bulbs, colored lanterns, or other housing and rope lights are prohibited. Flashing and chasing lights are prohibited. (C) Strings of white lights may be hung from or displayed on trees, but may not be attached to trees with nails, hooks, fasteners, or other materials that penetrate the tree's bark. Figure 16-5-114.E.1.b.ii.13: Example of Conforming Strings of Lights Used for Ambient Illumination 14.Towing Signs Page 60 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 11 of 32 Figure 16-5-114.E.1.b.ii.14: Example of a Conforming Towing Sign (A) Public notice required by applicable law to be displayed on a property where vehicles may be towed. (B) Such signs shall not exceed four square feet in size and shall be limited to one sign per vehicular entrance to the property. 150.Traffic Control Signs Any public notice or warning required by applicable federal, State, or local law, regulation, or ordinance—including, but not limited to, warning flashers and variable message signs (VMSs) deployed temporarily by a government agency to guide traffic. When such signs are located on private property, they are subject to each of the following: (A) Sign faces shall not exceed four square feet per sign face. (B) The Official shall have authority to limit the number, location, and color of such signs. (C) Sign faces shall meet South Carolina Department of Transportation standards. 161.Window Signs Signs on the inside, or attached to the outside, of window glass shall comply with each of the following: (A) Window signs shall cover no more than 25 percent of the gross area of glass on any one side of a building. (B) Window signs shall not be illuminated. (C) No single window sign shall exceed four square feet in totality. 12. Temporary Yard Signs Up to nine square feet of temporary yard signs are allowed 90 days prior to an election or referendum to seven days after the election or referendum without permits. The temporary yard signs shall comply with the following requirements: (A) The number of temporary yard signs on a parcel is not limited during this timeframe as long as the total size does not exceed nine square feet. (B) During this timeframe, temporary yard signs may be made from lightweight materials such as corrugated plastic, cardboard, wood, or similar materials and may be affixed to the ground with metal wire frames, wood stakes, or plastic stakes. (C) Temporary yard signs shall not be placed within street easements and rights-of-way. (D) Temporary yard signs shall not be placed on public property unless posted by the public entity owning the parcel. Page 61 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 12 of 32 2. Sign Review a. Sign Review i. Signs Subject to Administrative Sign Review Unless review by the Design Review Board is required in accordance with Sec. 16-5- 114.E.2.a.ii below, signs are subject to review and approval of a Sign Permit application by the Official. ii. Signs Subject to DRB Sign Review Any permanent sign, including the sign face and structure, that is greater than 40 square feet, or any sign system that includes such a sign, is subject to review and approval of a Sign Permit application by the Design Review Board in accordance with the following procedures, which relate to the standard review steps and specific procedures in Sec. 16-2- 102, Standard Review Procedures. b. Sign Review Procedures i. Application Submittal An application for a Sign Permit may be submitted by persons identified in Sec. 16-2- 102.C.1, and shall be submitted in accordance with Sec. 16-2-102.C. ii. Staff Review and Action 01.On receiving a Sign Permit application subject to administrative sign review (see Sec. 16-5-114.E.2.a.i), the Official shall review and make a final decision on the application in accordance with Sec. 16-2-102.D. The Official's decision shall be based on the standards in Sec. 16-5-114.E.3, Sign Review Standards, and shall be one of the following: (A) Approve the application; Page 62 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 13 of 32 (B) Approve the application, subject to conditions of approval; or (C) Deny the application. 02.On receiving a Sign Permit application subject to DRB sign review (see Sec. 16-5- 114.E.2.a.ii), the Official shall transmit the application to the DRB. iii. Decision-Making Body Review and Decision On receiving a Sign Permit application subject to DRB sign review (see Sec. 16-5- 114.E.2.a.ii), the Design Review Board shall review the application, hold a public meeting and make a final decision on the application in accordance with Sec. 16-2-102.G. The Board's decision shall be based on the standards in Sec. 16-5-114.E.3, Sign Review Standards, and shall be one of the following: 01.Approve the application; 02.Approve the application, subject to conditions of approval; or 03.Deny the application. iv. Post-Decision Actions and Limitations 01.Notice of Decision The Official shall provide notice of the final decision on the application in accordance with Sec. 16-2-102.H.1. 02.Appeal (A) Appeals from the final decision of the Official on an application for a Sign Permit are governed by Sec. 16-2-103.V, Appeal of Official's Decision to Design Review Board, and S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-890. Page 63 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 14 of 32 (B) Appeals from the final decision of the Design Review Board on an application for a Sign Permit are governed by S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-890. 3. Sign Review Standards A Sign Permit application shall be approved on a finding the applicant demonstrates the sign complies with the standards in this section, including the standards in: a. Sec. 16-5-114.I, Prohibited Signs; b. Sec. 16-5-114.C, Sign Design, Construction, and Maintenance Guidelines; c. Sec. 16-5-114.D, Sign Illumination; d. Sec. 16-5-114.F, Freestanding Signs; e. Sec. 16-5-114.G, Facade and Hanging Signs; and f. Sec. 16-5-114.H, Standards for Specific Types of Signs. 4. Effect of Approval If a Sign Permit application is approved, the Official shall issue a Sign Permit. A Sign Permit authorizes only the approved sign, and not any other sign. 5. Expiration A Sign Permit is valid for a period of six months, unless the Official approves an extension for good cause in accordance with Sec. 16-2-102.J.2.b, Extension of Expiration Time Period. 6. Amendment A Sign Permit may be amended only in accordance with the procedures and standards for its original approval. F. Freestanding Signs 1. The total area and quantity of any freestanding signs for which a Sign Permit is required shall conform to the standards in Table 16-5-114.F, Freestanding Sign Standards. For planned unit developments that contain more than one category of use, the Official shall apply the appropriate use category to each building or development to calculate the total area and quantity of freestanding signs allowed. The number of freestanding signs for any development may not exceed the total number allowed in Table 16-5-114.F: Freestanding Sign Standards. TABLE 16-5-114.F: FREESTANDING SIGN STANDARDS RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT NUMBER OF DWELLING UNITS NUMBER OF SIGNS NUMBER OF FACES PER SIGN NO SINGLE SIGN FACE SHALL EXCEED TOTAL SIZE OF ALL SIGN FACES > 500 Dwelling Units 1 per entrance 4 120 sf 240 sf 300—500 Dwelling Units 1 per entrance 4 80 sf 160 sf Page 64 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 15 of 32 < 300 Dwelling Units 1 per entrance 4 40 sf 80 sf PUBLIC, CIVIC, INSTITUTIONAL, EDUCATIONAL, HEALTH SERVICES, RESORT ACCOMMODATIONS, COMMERCIAL RECREATION, OFFICE, COMMERCIAL SERVICES, VEHICLE SALES AND SERVICES, INDUSTRIAL OR OTHER USES TOTAL SQUARE FEET OF GROSS FLOOR AREA NUMBER OF SIGNS NUMBER OF FACES PER SIGN NO SINGLE SIGN FACE SHALL EXCEED TOTAL SIZE OF ALL SIGN FACES > 100,000 6, if the development has frontage on 4 or more streets 4, if the development has frontage on 2 or 3 streets 2, if the development has frontage on 1 street 4 120 sf 480 sf 40,000—100,000 3, if the development has frontage on more than 1 street 2, if the development has frontage on 1 street 4 80 sf 320 sf 2,500—39,999 2 4 40 sf 160 sf 2,499 or Less1 1 2 40 sf 40 sf NOTES sf = square feet 1. If an applicant in this category shall waive the right to have a freestanding sign, the applicant shall be permitted to exceed the size limitations of Sec. 16-5-114.G, Facade and Hanging Signs, by 50 percent. (Revised 6-6-2017 - Ordinance 2017-08) 2. The maximum height of any freestanding sign above the average grade elevation surrounding the sign shall not exceed the following: a. Eight feet where the sign face does not exceed 40 square feet; b. Ten feet where the sign face does not exceed 60 square feet; or c. Twelve feet where the sign face exceeds 60 square feet. 3. The bottom edge of the sign shall not exceed four feet in height from the lowest grade elevation at the base of the sign. 4. The maximum width of any freestanding sign shall not exceed the following: a. Fifteen feet where the sign face does not exceed 40 square feet; b. Twenty feet where the sign face does not exceed 60 square feet; or c. Twenty-five feet where the sign face exceeds 60 square feet. 5. All freestanding signs fronting on a street right-of-way shall be required to be set back at least 20 feet from the edge of the adjacent street right-of-way. However, if conditions exist so as to make this impractical, this setback may be reduced by the Official provided such reduction does not create a hazard to motorists or pedestrians and that no portion of the sign is located in the right-of-way. Page 65 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 16 of 32 6. Freestanding signs shall be separated by a distance of not less than 200-foot intervals along each street frontage of the premises. 7. Freestanding menu boards—including, but not limited to, those used for drive-through eating establishments—shall meet the standards of this section, but shall not count toward the total number of signs allowed for a business. 8. In lieu of a freestanding sign, a development may use signs on entrance structures such as fences or walls. The number of sign faces is limited to two per entrance, on either side of the entrance, and are confined to the entrance area. The distance between sign faces shall not exceed 100 feet. Such signs are subject to the size limitations of this section. Entrance structures are subject to the provisions of Sec. 16-5-102, Setback Standards. 9. Signs may be permitted in access easements, subject to the approval of the Official, if the applicant can demonstrate that the access easement provides a necessary means of vehicular access to the property for which the sign is proposed. In the event where a property is served by more than one necessary access easement, the sign shall be located within the easement that serves the street with the highest number of average daily vehicle traffic (ADT) as determined by the Official. 10. Directory signs are subject to the following standards: a. Changing the tenant panels of a directory sign does not require a Sign Permit where the new panel matches the approved tenant panel design, including materials, dimensions, and colors. b. The sign should not be, to the greatest extent practicable, visible from a street or right-of-way. G. Facade and Hanging Signs 1. The total size of facade and hanging signs shall not occupy more than ten percent of the area of the facade on which they are placed, with the maximum size of any one sign limited to 40 square feet. Developments with less than 2,500 square feet of gross floor area that waive the right to have a freestanding sign shall be permitted to exceed these size limitations by 50 percent. Figure 16-5-114.G.1: Examples of Facade and Hanging Signs that Meet the Intent of The Hilton Head Island Design Guide Page 66 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 17 of 32 Figure 16-5-114.G.2: Example of a Tenant Space in a Shopping Center with Two Conforming Signs—One Facade Sign and One Hanging Sign Perpendicular to the Storefront 2. No more than two signs may be placed on or displayed from any one facade of any one building. Shopping centers shall be permitted two signs per tenant facade, provided that only one such tenant sign is visible from any public way. Such tenant signs shall only be permitted in lieu of facade signs identifying the name of the shopping center or building. 3. Facade signs shall be contained within any single wall panel, window, door, or other architectural component upon which they are placed. 4. Hanging signs shall be located in consideration of their respective architectural element. 5. Tenant facade and hanging signs shall be located on the tenant space being identified. If this requirement cannot be reasonably achieved, the Official shall approve an alternate location. H. Standards for Specific Types of Signs 1. Temporary Yard Signs a. All temporary yard signs shall comply with the following requirements: i. A maximum of one temporary yard sign is allowed per parcel. ii. Temporary yard signs shall be constructed of ½-inch medium density overlay panel (MDO) or a material of equal durability. iii. Temporary yard signs shall not be illuminated. iv. Temporary yard signs shall be square or rectangular in shape. v. Temporary yard signs shall not be placed within street easements and rights-of-way. vi. Temporary yard signs shall not be placed on public property unless posted by the public entity owning the parcel. vii. The size of a temporary yard sign shall not exceed three square feet. viii. A temporary yard sign shall be removed within 90 days from the date of its permit, unless an extension is approved by the Official. b. One additional temporary yard sign is permitted per street frontage on a parcel from the time a building or development permit is issued for construction on the parcel to the time a building occupancy permit is issued. The additional temporary yard sign shall not exceed 20 square feet in size and shall not exceed six feet in height from the existing grade. Page 67 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 18 of 32 c. One additional temporary yard sign is permitted per street frontage of a parcel when the parcel, or building or unit on a parcel, is listed for rent or sale to the time two days after the execution of a rental contract or closing of the sale. The additional temporary yard sign shall comply with the following requirements: i. On parcels with residential uses, the additional temporary yard sign shall not exceed four square feet in size and shall not exceed four feet in height from the existing grade. ii. On parcels with non-residential uses, the additional temporary yard sign shall not exceed 20 square feet in size and shall not exceed six feet in height from the existing grade. iii. Where placement on the ground is not feasible, the Official may approve the sign to be placed on the façade of the building listed for rent or sale. a.d. Additional temporary yard signs are allowed 90 days prior to an election or referendum to seven days after the election or referendum. Permits are required in accordance with this section if the total size of the signs exceeds nine square feet. If the total size of the signs does not exceed nine square feet, see Section 16-5-114 E.1.b.ii.12. The additional temporary yard signs shall comply with the following requirements i. The number of temporary yard signs on a parcel is not limited during this timeframe. ii. The total size of temporary yard signs during this timeframe shall not exceed 32 square feet per parcel. iii. During this timeframe, temporary yard signs may be made from lightweight materials such as corrugated plastic, cardboard, wood, or similar materials and may be affixed to the ground with metal wire frames, wood stakes, or plastic stakes. iv. Temporary yard signs shall not be placed within street easements and rights-of-way. v. Temporary yard signs shall not be placed on public property unless posted by the public entity owning the parcel. 12. Temporary Signs for Permitted Signs a. When a Sign Permit has been issued for a permanent commercial sign, a separate Sign Permit may be issued for a temporary sign to identify the business while the permanent sign is being constructed. The temporary sign shall comply with the following standards: i. Only one sign with no more than two sign faces shall be displayed per proposed permanent sign. ii. Any temporary sign face shall not exceed 16 square feet. iii. The copy, logo, and colors on a temporary sign shall be identical to the copy, logo, and colors on the related permanent sign. iv. A temporary sign shall be constructed of ½-inch MDO or a material of equal durability. Banners shall not be a permitted material. v. A temporary sign shall be removed upon installation of the permanent identification sign or within 45 days from the date of its permit, unless an extension is approved by the Official. b. Temporary signs advertising a sales event, such as a grand opening or a seasonal sale, shall not be permitted. Page 68 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 19 of 32 c. Temporary special event signs are permitted as specified in Sec. 16-5-114.H.9, Temporary Special Event Signs. Figure 16-5-114.H.1.a: Example of A Prohibited Temporary Sign Figure 16-5-114.H.1.b: Example of a Conforming Temporary Sign 2. Construction Signs Figure 16-5-114.H.2: Example of a Conforming Construction Sign Any sign identifying a project under construction and located on the construction site shall comply with the following standards: a. Quantity is limited to one per street front of the property on which the construction is occurring. b. The total area of a freestanding construction sign shall not exceed 40 square feet. The total area of a facade construction sign shall not exceed 20 square feet. Each sign face shall not exceed 20 square feet. c. A freestanding sign shall be mounted so that its top edge is no higher than eight feet above grade. A facade-mounted sign shall be mounted so that its top edge is no higher than eight feet above grade. d. Such signs shall not be illuminated by artificial light. Page 69 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 20 of 32 e. Such signs shall be square or rectangular in shape. f. Such signs may not be erected prior to issuance of a Building Permit and shall be removed prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. 3. Nonresidential Real Estate Sales Signs a. A Sign Permit is required for the design of signs that advertise the sale of nonresidential property and are four square feet or smaller in size. Such signs shall comply with the following standards: i. The number of such signs placed on any one premises shall be limited to one sign per street frontage of the property being sold. ii. The sign shall be square or rectangular in shape. iii. The sign shall not exceed four square feet in area. iv. The amount of information on the sign shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the offering. v. The sign shall not be illuminated by artificial light. vi. The sign shall be removed within two days of completion of the sale of the property. b. A Sign Permit is required for each sign that advertises the sale of nonresidential property and is larger than four square feet. Such signs shall comply with the following standards: i. The number of signs placed on any one premises shall be limited to one sign per street frontage of the property being sold. ii. The sign shall be rectangular or square in shape. iii. The area of each sign shall not exceed 40 square feet total and 20 square feet per sign face. iv. The maximum height of each sign shall not exceed eight feet above the average grade within a 20-foot radius of the sign. The lower edge of each sign shall not exceed four feet in height from the lowest grade at the base of the sign. v. The amount of information on the sign shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the offering. vi. The sign shall not be illuminated by artificial light. vii. The sign shall be removed within two days of completion of the sale of the property. c. Where a freestanding sign is not feasible, the Official may approve a real estate sales facade sign. The sign shall comply with the following standards: i. The number of signs placed on any one premises shall be limited to one sign per street frontage of the property being sold. ii. The sign shall be square or rectangular in shape. iii. The area of each sign shall not exceed 20 square feet. iv. The maximum height of each sign shall not exceed ten feet above the average grade within a 20-foot radius of the sign. v. The sign shall be contained within any single wall panel, window, door, or other architectural component upon which it is placed. Page 70 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 21 of 32 vi. The amount of information on the sign shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the offering. vii. The sign shall not be illuminated by artificial light. viii. The sign shall be removed within two days of completion of the sale of the property. 4. Nonresidential Real Estate Lease or Rent Signs a. Buildings for Lease or Rent On premises where a whole building or whole buildings are offered for lease or rent and where there are no other tenant spaces on the premises, a nonresidential real estate sign offering the building or buildings for lease or rent may be displayed. Such signs shall comply with the following standards: i. A Sign Permit is required. ii. The number of signs placed on any one premises shall be limited to one sign per street frontage of the property to be let. iii. The sign shall be square or rectangular in shape. iv. The area of each sign shall not exceed 40 square feet total and 20 square feet per sign face. v. The maximum height of each sign shall not exceed eight feet above the average grade within a 20-foot radius of the sign. The lower edge of each sign shall not exceed four feet in height from the lowest grade at the base of the sign. vi. The amount of information on the sign shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the offering. vii. The sign shall not be illuminated by artificial light. viii. The sign shall be removed within two days of execution of a lease for the property. b. Tenant Spaces for Lease or Rent i. A nonresidential real estate sign offering tenant space for lease or rent shall be placed as a tenant panel on a permitted sign or as a panel on a permitted freestanding sign if there are such signs on site. Such signs shall comply with the following standards: 01.A Sign Permit is required. 02.If placed on a sign with other panels, such panels shall match the dimensions, materials, and colors of the other panels. The amount of information on the panel shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the offering. Page 71 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 22 of 32 Figure 16-5-114.H.4.b: Example of a Directory Sign with a Conforming Space for Lease Tenant Panel 03.If placed on a freestanding sign without other panels, a Sign Permit is required to ensure the panel complements the design of the freestanding sign. The amount of information on the panel shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the offering. ii. If there are no permitted signs on which a tenant panel or other panel may be placed to advertise a tenant space for lease or rent, a sign not exceeding four square feet in area may be used. The sign shall comply with the following standards: 01.A Sign Permit is required for an individual sign, regardless of whether the sign design has been approved for other uses. 02.The number of signs placed on any one premises shall be limited to one sign per street frontage of the building that includes the space to be let. 03.The sign shall be square or rectangular in shape. 04.The sign shall not exceed four square feet in area. 05.The amount of information on the sign shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the offering. 06.The sign shall not be illuminated by artificial light. 07.The sign shall be removed within two days of the execution of a lease for the property. 5. Residential Real Estate Sales Signs a. A Sign Permit is required for each sign advertising the sale of residential real estate. The design of the sign shall comply with the following: i. The sign shall be square or rectangular in shape. ii. The sign shall not exceed four square feet in area. Page 72 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 23 of 32 iii. The amount of information on the sign shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the offering and identification of the agent. b. Once a Sign Permit is issued for a sign design, individual signs are not required to be permitted. c. Such signs shall meet the following standards: i. The number of signs placed on any one premises shall be limited to one sign per street frontage of the property being sold. ii. Signs shall be placed on the parcel for sale. In multifamily or condominium development, signs shall be placed near the front door of the unit for sale. iii. Signs shall not be illuminated by artificial light. iv. Signs shall be removed within two days of the completion of the sale of the property. v. Each sign may have one information box or tube attached to the sign structure. Information boxes or tubes shall not be independently freestanding. d. A residential development (such as a named subdivision) with multiple properties for sale may use one real estate sign in lieu of individual real estate signs on each lot. A Sign Permit is required for each sign. Such signs shall comply with the following standards: i. The number of signs shall be limited to one per entrance of the development, not including paired one-way entrance lanes. ii. Signs shall be square or rectangular in shape. iii. The area of each sign shall not exceed 40 square feet total and 20 square feet per sign face. iv. The maximum height of each sign shall not exceed eight feet above the average grade within a 20-foot radius of the sign. The lower edge of each sign shall not exceed four feet in height from the lowest grade at the base of the sign. v. The amount of information on the sign shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the offering. vi. Signs shall not be illuminated by artificial light. vii. Signs shall be removed within two days of the completion of the sale of the property. viii. Each sign may have one information box or tube attached to the sign structure. Information boxes or tubes shall not be independently freestanding. 6. Residential Short-Term Rental Signs A Sign Permit is required for each sign advertising the short-term rental of a residence. Such signs shall meet the following standards: a. Signs are limited to one per residence. The sign shall be placed near the entrance of the residence, visible from the street and wall mounted no more than six feet above FEMA base flood elevation. The sign shall not be visible from the beach. b. The sign shall be 12 inches in height by 18 inches in length. Page 73 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 24 of 32 c. The sign shall be made of ½-inch PVC sign board or another material approved by the Official. d. The amount of information on the sign shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the offering. e. The sign shall not be illuminated by artificial light. 73. Sign Systems An integrated sign system design shall be required for all planned unit developments, commercial developments, office complexes, and shopping centers. a. These systems shall be reviewed for materials, colors, shapes, sizes, compatibility and architecture, and establishment of unity of design for the development. (See the Hilton Head Island Design Guide for guidance.) b. New individual signs and changes to existing individual signs shall conform to such sign systems. c. In the case of changes to any integrated sign system design, all existing signs in the sign system shall be brought into compliance with the changed design within three months of approval of any changes to the integrated sign system. 84. Permanent Special Event Signs Figure 16-5-114.H.8: Example of a Conforming Permanent Special Event Sign Permanent signs identifying special events may be erected only by the Town of Hilton Head Island. They shall comply with the following standards: a. Permanent special event signs may only announce events that are sponsored by a nonprofit or public entity, or public service announcements. Requests to display announcements shall be made to the Town Manager. b. Guidelines for determining the events or functions to be announced, copy, space, location, and display time limit shall be as proposed by the Official and approved by the Town Council. c. Public service announcements may obtain a higher priority for display than special event announcements, at the discretion of the Town Manager. 95. Temporary Special Event Signs The organizer of a special event (see definition in Sec. 16-10-105, General Definitions), shall obtain a Temporary Special Event Sign Permit prior to displaying temporary signs at a special event. The application shall state the location and dates of the event, the expected number of attendees, and the Page 74 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 25 of 32 types and number of proposed temporary signs. The application shall be submitted no fewer than five business days prior to the event. The following temporary special event signs may be used as specified: a. Off-Premises Signs Directing Traffic i. Signs directing traffic to the site of an event may be used for events at which more than 5,000 attendees are expected. ii. Signs shall meet South Carolina DOT standards. b. Off-Premises Signs Identifying Race Routes Signs intended to direct pedestrians, runners, and bicyclists on race routes are subject to the following standards: i. Such signs shall be no larger than two square feet each. ii. Such signs may be displayed one day prior to the event, during the duration of the event, and one day after the event. c. Off-Premises Post Mounted Banners i. Post mounted banners may only be used for events which are multi-day and at which more than 18,000 attendees are expected during the course of the event. ii. The banners shall be no larger than 16" in width and 45" in height. iii. The banners must be approved and installed as part of the Town permitting process. (Revised 12-5-2017 - Ordinance 2017-19) d. On-Premises Signs Identifying an Event Signs located at the entrances of special events that are meant to identify a special event are subject to the following standards: i. No more than two signs shall be displayed per event, with no more than four sign faces. Any single sign face shall not exceed 16 square feet. ii. Signs shall be constructed of ½-inch MDO, or a material of equal durability, mounted on four-by-four wood posts. iii. The amount of information on signs shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the event or other information to be conveyed. iv. Signs shall be displayed no sooner than one day prior to the event, during the duration of the event, and one day after the event. v. Signs shall not be illuminated by artificial light. (Revised 12-5-2017 - Ordinance 2017-19) e. On-Premises Signs Signs displayed within a special event are subject to the following standards: i. Signs shall be displayed no sooner than one day prior to the event, during the duration of the event, and one day after the event. ii. Banners and pennants are permitted within the area where the special event takes place. Page 75 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 26 of 32 (Revised 12-5-2017 - Ordinance 2017-19) 106. Signs with Changeable Copy a. Description of Changeable Copy Types. i. Manually activated changeable copy shall mean a sign or portion of a sign that can be changed or re-arranged manually or mechanically, and has a readerboard for the display of text information in which each alphanumeric character, graphic, or symbol is defined by objects, not consisting of an illumination device. ii. Electronically activated changeable copy shall mean a sign or portion of a sign that can be changed by means of remote electrically energized on-off switching combinations of alphanumeric character, graphic, or symbol. b. Signs with changeable copy are limited to one sign per street frontage per parcel. c. The total size of changeable copy shall not exceed 20 square feet per sign face, with no more than three lines of copy. d. Copy height shall be eight inches maximum and four inches minimum. e. Copy shall be securely fastened to the sign face and neatly maintained. f. Changeable copy shall be limited to announcing: i. On- premises special events. ii. Motion pictures or entertainment at a theater whose primary function is to provide musical or dramatic events; or iii. Gasoline prices as described in Sec. 16-5-114.H.11, Price Displays at Gas Establishments. g. Permanent Special Event Signs as described in Sec. 16-5-114.H.8, Permanent Special Event Signs, are exempt from the requirements of this section. h. Minimum Fixed Period. Electronic changeable copy shall remain fixed and should be changed no more than twice per day. i. Transition Between Copy. The duration of change between electronic changeable copy shall be accomplished within two seconds or less. (Revised 3-7-2023 - Ordinance 2023-04) 711. Price Displays at Gas Sales Establishments a. Petroleum product pumps and dispensers that are within view of a public way shall be allowed to display only the information needed to reasonably identify the products dispensed. b. Premises from which retail petroleum products are dispensed by pump shall be allowed one additional sign with a maximum size of ten square feet announcing the price per gallon of the products. The additional sign shall require a Sign Permit. c. In lieu of the one additional sign allowed above, the price per gallon may be displayed by increasing by ten square feet the area allowed within this section for a single freestanding sign. Page 76 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 27 of 32 812. Planned Unit Development Off-Premises Signs a. Planned Unit Development Off-Premises Directional Signs i. Planned unit developments (PUDs) may erect freestanding off-premises directional signs for the purpose of directing vehicle traffic to destinations within the development. Such signs must be located within the boundary of the PUD or on a parcel within 500 feet of the boundary that fronts on the major arterial serving the PUD. ii. Off- premises directional signs that are viewed from any public way shall comply with the following requirements: 01.The amount of information on signs shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the destination(s) and direction thereto. 02.Such signs shall be located within one mile of the intersection where vehicles must turn to reach the PUD. No more than two signs shall be placed in any one direction from such intersection with no more than three signs for any one development. 03.The total area of all signs for any one development shall not exceed 200 square feet of sign face with no single sign face greater than 80 square feet. Sign height, width, and structure shall meet the requirements of Sec. 16-5-114.F, Freestanding Signs. iii. Off-premises directional signs that are viewed from private streets internal to the development shall comply with the following requirements: 01.The amount of information on signs shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the destination(s) and direction thereto. 02.Such signs must be located within 200 feet of an intersection with no more than one sign viewed from any one direction. 03.Such signs shall be limited to 20 square feet of sign face. b. Planned Unit Development Off-Premises Identification Signs i. A planned unit development (PUD) whose primary entrance (right-of-way or easement) is located on a public street but is not within the boundary of the PUD shall be allowed one off-premises identification sign, which shall be located within the right-of-way or easement for the entrance street. ii. This sign shall comply with the following requirements: 01.The amount of information on such sign shall be no more than is necessary to provide reasonable identification of the PUD. 02.Such sign shall be subject to the standards of Sec. 16-5-114.F, Freestanding Signs. 9. Driveway Access Point Signs On parcels with non-residential uses, driveway access point signs shall comply with the following standards: a. The maximum size of an individual driveway access point sign is four square feet. b. A maximum of two driveway access point signs are allowed per access point. Page 77 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 28 of 32 c. The maximum height of a driveway access point sign is three feet. 10. Interior Site Signs a. Interior site signs require sign permits if proposed within the required side and rear setback areas. b. The maximum size of an individual non-exempt interior site sign is four square feet. c. The maximum height of an individual non-exempt interior site sign is three feet. I. Prohibited Signs The following types of signs are prohibited: 1. Abandoned signs and sign structures. 2. Signs with animated or moving effects (including but not limited to sign faces that periodically change to show different images or messages), and signs carried, waved, or otherwise displayed by persons either on public ways or in a manner visible from public ways, are prohibited. This provision is directed toward such displays intended to draw attention for a commercial purpose, and is not intended to limit the display of placards, banners, flags, or other signage by persons participating in demonstrations, political rallies, and similar events. 3. Balloons. 4. Banners, except within the boundaries of a special event. (See Sec. 16-5-114.H.9, Temporary Special Event Signs.) 5. Bench signs. 6. Dilapidated or damaged signs. 7. Signs attached to or painted upon piers, docks, or seawalls, other than official regulatory or warning signs. 8. Signs that emit sound, vapor, smoke, odor, particles, or gaseous matter. 9. Inflated signs and windblown signs other than holiday seasonal decorations. 10. Information boxes not attached to a real estate sign. 11. Internally illuminated signs that contain a visible light source, except for those signs complying with the provisions of Sec. 16-5-114.D, Sign Illumination. 12. Signs that are displayed or erected for which a Sign Permit has been denied or has not been issued. 13. Signs that exhibit statements, words, or pictures of an obscene or pornographic nature. 14. Signs that are not located on the parcel of the business or development it identifies, except that special event signs, directional signs, public park signs, and other signs that are specifically allowed under this section, are exempt. 15. Parking signs that limit parking spaces to certain uses or businesses within a shopping center. 165. Pennants except within the boundaries of a special event. (See Sec. 16-5-114.H.9, Temporary Special Event Signs.) Page 78 of 115 Attachment 2 – Exhibit A to Ordinance – Text Amendment Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:55 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 29 of 32 Figure 16-5-114.I.17: Examples of Prohibited Portable and Off-Premises Signs 17. Portable signs, or any sign not permanently attached to the ground or other permanent structure, including but not limited to signs attached to or painted on vehicles or trailers other than those advertising the business which the vehicle is used to conduct, either parked or being driven, and visible from the right-of-way, unless said vehicle is used as a vehicle in the normal day-to-day operations of the business, except that sandwich boards, chalkboards, and other signs that are specifically allowed under this section are exempt. 18. Signs located in the public rights-of-way, except signs in landscaped medians of private streets where the sign meets the minimum sight triangle distances of Sec. 16-5-105.H.4, Sight Triangles. 19. Signs where the sign or any portion of the sign is located on or extends above the roof of the building where the sign is located. 20. Signs attached to, placed on, painted on, or otherwise displayed on or from any tree or other vegetation. 21. Signs in or upon any body of water, other than official regulatory or warning signs, including any sign located on any land subject to periodic inundation by tidal saltwater. The Design Review Board may approve a permanent monument sign in or upon a body of water within a parcel if the Official determines that there is no other reasonable location for that sign on that parcel. 22. Signs towed behind a vehicle, watercraft, or aircraft. 23. All other signs that are not expressly exempt from regulation or expressly allowed under this Ordinance. (Revised 4-18-2017 - Ordinance 2017-05) Page 79 of 115 Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:58 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 30 of 32 Chapter 16-10: Definitions, Interpretation, and Measurement Sec.16-10-105. General Definitions Terms defined in this section shall have the meanings stated in the definition of the term. Sign Any words, lettering, parts of letters, figures, numerals, phrases, sentences, emblems, devices, structures, costumes, designs, trade names, or trademarks by which anything is made known (all or any of which are sometimes referred to as "copy"), and that are used to designate an individual, a firm, an association, a corporation, a profession, a business, or a commodity or products, and that are visible from any public street or adjacent property and used to attract attention. A sign includes the sign structure and the sign face on which any copy is displayed. Sign Area The area enclosed by the perimeter of the sign face. For signs consisting of copy or graphics individually applied to a facade, the sign area shall be considered as the area of an imaginary rectangle that will enclose all such items. Sign Face The part of the sign that is or can be used for the display of any copy or graphics, including any background material, panel, trim, color, or illumination that differentiates the sign from a facade or sign structure. Sign Structure Any supporting structure erected, used, or intended for the purpose of displaying any sign, with or without a sign thereon. Sign Structure Area The area within an imaginary rectangle that encompasses the sign minus the area of the sign face. Sign, Dilapidated Any sign that is structurally unsound, has defective parts, or is in need of painting or maintenance. Sign, Directory A freestanding or façade sign that serves to identify the location of tenant spaces within a multi-tenant building or development to pedestrians or motorists moving with the development. Sign, Driveway Access Point Any sign within a front setback area located at a driveway access point to a commercial parcel. Sign, Facade Any sign that utilizes any portion of a facade for support. Sign, Freestanding Any sign supported by a sign structure secured in the ground and that is wholly independent of any other support. Page 80 of 115 Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:58 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 31 of 32 Sign, Illegal Any existing sign that does not have a Sign Permit issued by the Town in accordance with Sec. 16-5- 114, Sign Standards. Persons responsible for such signs are subject to the enforcement provisions in Chapter 16-8: Enforcement. Sign, Illuminated Any sign which is directly or indirectly lighted by an artificial light source. Sign, Indoor Any sign located inside of a building that is not intended to be readily visible and legible from outside of the building. Sign, Inflatable Any sign that is either expanded to its full dimensions or supported by gasses contained within the sign, or sign parts, at a pressure greater than atmospheric pressure. Untethered airships are not considered to be inflatable signs. Sign, Interior Site A permanent and internally oriented sign on a non-residential parcel that is not readily visible and legible beyond the boundaries of the parcel on which it is located and is intended for viewing from the interior of the subject parcel. Sign, Internally Illuminated Any sign which has light transmitted outward through its face or any part thereof. Sign, Legal Any permitted sign that complies with the provisions of Sec. 16-5-114, Sign Standards. Sign, Off Premises Any sign located or proposed to be located at any place other than within the same platted parcel of land on which the specific business or activity being identified on such sign is itself located or conducted. Sign, Permitted Any sign for which a Sign Permit has been issued by the Town in accordance with Sec. 16-5-114, Sign Standards. Sign, Public Signs erected by, or required by, a federal, State, county, or municipal government or entity. Sign, Political Any sign erected for the purpose of advertising a candidate for public office or stating a position on a public issue on which an election or referendum is pending with respect to a particular campaign. Sign, Project Any sign erected and maintained on the premises temporarily during construction and displaying only the name of the project, architect, engineer, contractor, developer or finance organization upon which property such individual is furnishing labor, services or material. Sign, Public Utility Page 81 of 115 Created: 2024-07-16 16:10:58 [EST] (Supp. No. 9) Page 32 of 32 Any sign placed by a publicly regulated utility for the purpose of identifying its utility lines, devices, or other similar equipment. Sign, Real Estate Any sign advertising real property as being for rent, for lease, or for sale. Sign, Roof Any sign erected over or on the roof of a building. Sign, Special Event Any sign erected for the purpose of announcing a special event or function which may be of general interest to the community. Sign, Stadium Signs or banners that are located within a stadium and are not intended to be visible from outside of a stadium. Sign, Temporary Any sign or information transmitting structure intended to be erected or displayed for a limited period and that is not permanently affixed to the ground or a building.. Sign, Temporary Yard A temporary sign, often double-faced, that is supported by metal legs or wooden post(s) anchored into a lawn or landscaped area with no permanent foundation making it easy to install and remove. Sign, Traffic Directional/Safety Any sign that is designed, sized, and erected solely for the purpose of vehicular or pedestrian traffic direction or safety, and is without any commercial copy or graphics. Sign, Vehicle Any permanent or temporary sign affixed, painted on or placed in or upon any vehicle. Page 82 of 115 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court  Hilton Head Island  South Carolina  29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 1 of 19 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND Community Services and Public Safety Committee TO: Community Services and Public Safety Committee FROM: Missy Luick, Director of Planning CC: Shawn Leininger, Assistant Town Manager CC: Marc Orlando, Town Manager DATE: June 16, 2025 SUBJECT: Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island to Amend Title 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to Amend the Current Regulations for the Measure of Height and Setback Encroachments for Residential and Nonresidential Development to Include Land Management Ordinance Sections: 16-3-106, 16-5-102 & 16-10-102, and Providing for Severability and an Effective Date RECOMMENDATION: Community Services and Public Safety Committee review and consider an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island to amend Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend the current regulations for the measurement of height and setback encroachments for residential and nonresidential development to include Sections 16-3-106, 16-5-102, & 16-10-102 for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina and providing for severability and an effective date, and forward a recommendation to Town Council. The Planning Commission held a public hearing on May 21, 2025, and, after consideration of the criteria set forth in Section 16-2-103.B voted unanimously to recommend that Town Council approve the proposed text amendment. BACKGROUND: Revitalize and Modernize the Economy is a focus area in the adopted Town Council 2023- 2025 Strategic Action Plan. In fulfillment of this focus area, Strategy #1 Establish a Growth Management Strategy states the Town will: “Successfully manage increasing and evolving future growth patterns in a manner that will ensure sustainability of Hilton Head Island’s unique character. Additionally, the Town must monitor economic and demographic trends, undertaking a comprehensive Page 83 of 115 Page 2 of 19 list of future planning activities, and proactively protecting the Island’s rich natural resources through appropriate design, regulation, and capital investment practices.” In this regard, Town Council directed Town Staff to advance amendments to the Land Management Ordinance (LMO) in the 2024 Strategic Action Work Plan. The effort has been divided into two separate projects, the full LMO Overhaul and the priority amendments. The priority amendments include incremental changes to both the LMO and portions of the Municipal Code related to land management that address important and urgent issues in advance of the full LMO Overhaul. These priority amendments address pressing community development issues with the best short-term solution while minimizing unintended outcomes. Issues that require additional analysis and research or are more complex are recommended to be further explored during the full LMO Overhaul. At the September 16, 2024, Town Council Workshop, Town staff received the following comments and direction regarding amendments related to the measurement of height and setback encroachments for residential and commercial development: Residential: 1. Changes need to apply to existing subdivisions where possible. Current building heights are too high. 2. There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. 3. Need to increase setbacks. 4. Need to establish minimum lot sizes (to be addressed during the full LMO update). Nonresidential: 1. Current building heights are too high. 2. There needs to be more light, air, and separation between units. Need to increase setbacks. 3. Need to establish minimum lot sizes (to be addressed during the full LMO update). 4. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). On May 21, 2025, the Planning Commission held a public hearing and voted unanimously to forward the amendment to Town Council with a recommendation of approval. SUMMARY OF AMENDMENT: The mass and scale of recent developments have been of concern for both residential and nonresidential developments. New buildings are often larger and out of character with the existing surroundings. This priority amendment will modify how height is measured and reduce the allowable setback encroachments. Current regulations require that building heights be measured relative to flood zone elevations, which effectively increases the allowable height of the building. This amendment would change this to measure height from the pre-development grade elevation. This will provide a more accurate representation of the building’s scale relative Page 84 of 115 Page 3 of 19 to the surrounding landscape by adjusting the building height measurement. Current regulations also permit significant projections/ encroachments into setback areas. This amendment will provide more separation between buildings. Both of these changes will help to reduce the overall mass and scale of development in residential and nonresidential building types. ANALYSIS: Proposed Amendments Setback Angle. This priority amendment proposes to change the elevation above the ground at which the setback angle is measured. In practice, the standard minimum horizontal setback distance is measured from the property line or street right-of-way. No building or structure may be placed within the setback unless specifically exempted. However, the setback angle begins well over the minimum setback on the ground, and it applies to taller structures and upper stories. This requires buildings to “step back” at a specified angle (varies by zoning district) at a set point above the ground, which controls the overall mass and scale closer to property lines and the street. For residential structures, the current ordinance requires the setback angle to begin 20 feet over an elevation of 13 feet above mean sea level or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. For nonresidential structures, it begins 20 feet over an elevation of 11 feet above mean sea level or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. The lower the point at which the angle begins (red line), the more restrictive it is than if measured from a higher point (blue line). The example below in Figure 1 is for a residential structure with the pre-development grade less than 13 feet above mean sea level (not to scale). Figure 1 Setback Angle Page 85 of 115 Page 4 of 19 The blue line shows the existing LMO measurement and an allowable eave encroachment. The red line shows a more restricted horizontal building envelope that limits the mass and scale of new buildings. However, as the point where the angle measurement lowers, the likelihood of creating nonconformities increases when applying to existing buildings, as excessive encroachments may result (red line). Allowable Encroachments. A limited number of setback and height encroachments are allowable per Table 16-5-102.E. While the closest point of a building is subject to the minimum setback from property lines and the setback angle, certain architectural elements may extend into a setback area with limitations. For instance, if a side wall of a house is built up to the setback line, a bay window may extend up to two feet into a setback if not more than nine feet wide. Several allowable encroachments, such as open balconies and uncovered decks and porches, are proposed to be struck from Table 16-5-102.E to reduce allowable encroachments. While items like eaves, bay windows, and awnings are proposed to be retained in the table with reduced extent, other architectural elements and appurtenances are proposed to be removed so that they may no longer encroach into the maximum height limitation, setback angle area, and minimum setback. A further restriction is also included to prevent all allowable encroachments from being closer than 5 feet from a property line. The highest likelihood of resulting nonconformities will be those architectural elements that are proposed to be struck that are currently encroaching or very close to setback and height limitations. The example below in Figure 2 shows how an eave may still extend into a setback angle area by two feet (reduced from three feet), while an unenclosed porch can no longer extend into a minimum setback area. In the current LMO, an unenclosed porch can encroach into a setback by five feet. Figure 2 Encroachment Page 86 of 115 Page 5 of 19 Height. Building height is also proposed to be measured from pre-development grade in all cases, rather than the higher elevation of the pre-development grade or 13 feet or 11 feet above mean sea level (depending on residential or non-residential use). This means that if the building site is lower than 13 or 11 feet, depending on the building type, the measurement from pre-development grade to the highest point (red line) will be greater than measuring from 13 feet or 11 feet above mean sea level to the highest point (blue line). Figure 3 Building Height Measurement When applied to a recently submitted building plan, the difference in measurements can be observed between the current language of the LMO (blue line) and the proposed language (red line). Figure 4 shows the setback and setback angle area and Figure 5 shows building height measurement. Figure 4 Setback Angle on Building Plan Page 87 of 115 Page 6 of 19 Figure 5 Height Measurement on Building Plan Affected Properties. The following maps (Figures 6-7) show residential and nonresidential properties that may be affected by the proposed change to the LMO. Figure 6 shows that of 18,015 residential properties, 11,394 properties fall completely or partially below the threshold of 13 feet above mean sea level, which means the effective allowable height is being reduced. In Figure 7, of the 895 nonresidential properties, 380 are below the threshold of 11 feet above mean sea level. It is important to note that these properties are the most susceptible to being impacted by this proposed change and the approval of this amendment does not suddenly create 11,394 nonconforming structures. For any resulting nonconformities, the LMO has specific regulations on how such nonconformities may continue or be corrected depending on certain circumstances such as natural disasters, renovation, and other events. This is discussed further later in this report. Page 88 of 115 Page 7 of 19 Figure 6 Residential Properties 13 Feet Above Mean Sea Level Page 89 of 115 Page 8 of 19 Figure 7 Nonresidential Properties 11 Feet Above Mean Sea Level Page 90 of 115 Page 9 of 19 The following table demonstrates how the proposed amendments address the demonstrated issues. Issue Proposed Amendment There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). Sec.16-3-106. Overlay Zoning Districts H. Forest Beach Neighborhood Character Overlay (FB-NC O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks ii. Setbacks shall comply with the standards of Sec. 16- 5-102, Setback Standards, except that the 65 degree setback angle shall be measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). Sec.16-3-106. Overlay Zoning Districts I. Folly Field Neighborhood Character Overlay (FF-NC-O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks iii. Maximum setback angle of 65 degrees shall be measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). Sec.16-3-106. Overlay Zoning Districts J. Holiday Homes Neighborhood Character Overlay (HH-NC-O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks ii. 03.Side yard setback angles shall be a minimum of 65 degrees measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever Page 91 of 115 Page 10 of 19 is higher, at the setback line. The illustration in Sec. 16-5-102.D, Adjacent Use Setback Requirements, can be referenced for an example of a setback angle. There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). Sec.16-5-102. Setback Standards C. Adjacent Street Setback Requirements Table 16-5-102.C Notes: 2. Measured within the upper inward quadrant of the intersection of a horizontal plane at a height of 20 feet above 13 feet above Mean Sea Level for residential use or 11 feet above Mean Sea Level for nonresidential use, or pre-development grade, whichever is higher, and a vertical plane extending upward at the minimum setback distance (see Figure 16-5-102.C, Street Setback Angle). There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). Figure 16-5-102.C, Street Setback Angle Page 92 of 115 Page 11 of 19 There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). Sec.16-5-102. Setback Standards D. Adjacent Use Setback Requirements Table 16-5-102.D Notes: 2. Measured within the upper inward quadrant of the intersection of a horizontal plane at a height of 20 feet above 13 feet above Mean Sea Level for residential use or 11 feet above Mean Sea Level for nonresidential use, or pre-development grade, whichever is higher, and a vertical plane extending upward at the minimum setback distance (see Figure 16-5-102.D, Use Setback Angle). There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). Figure 16-5-102.D, Use Setback Angle Page 93 of 115 Page 12 of 19 Need to increase setbacks. Sec.16-5-102. Setback Standards E. Allowable Setback Encroachments TABLE 16-5-102.E: ALLOWABLE SETBACK ENCROACHMENTS Fences or walls • Allowed in adjacent use setbacks if located along common property lines and no more than 7 feet high • Allowed in adjacent street setbacks if less than 4 feet high Open balconies, fire escapes, or exterior stairways May extend up to 5 feet into any setback Required means of egress1 May extend up to 42 inches into any setback Chimneys or fireplaces1 May extend up to 2 3 feet into any setback if no more than 5 feet higher than the highest point of building to which it is attached Roof eaves and overhangs1 May extend up to 2 3 feet into any setback Awnings1 May extend up to 2 5 feet into any setback Bay windows1 May extend up to 2 3 feet into any setback if no more than 9 feet wide Sills or entablatures1 May extend up to 1 foot into any setback Uncovered porches, stoops, decks, patios or terraces May extend up to 5 feet into any setback Lighting fixtures May be located in any setback if no more than 20 feet high Roof dormers1 May extend up to 2 5 feet beyond the setback angle plane (horizontally or vertically) Spires, cupolas, domes, skylights, and similar rooftop architectural features May extend up above the setback angle plane if they occupy no more than 25% of the roof area Page 94 of 115 Page 13 of 19 of the structure to which they are attached and extend no more than 25% more than the height limit defined by the setback angle plane at the point(s) of penetration Solar collection devices See Sec. 16-4-103.E.8 Television or radio antennas1 May extend up to 10 feet above the setback angle plane if they are attached to a side or rear elevation of a structure Small wind energy conversion systems See Sec. 16-4-103.E.7 Amateur radio antenna See Sec. 16-4-103.E.1 Bike racks, bollards and other site furnishings (such as tables and chairs)1 Allowed in adjacent use and adjacent street setbacks Other architectural features not listed above (parts of a structure that provide visual interest to the structure and are nonhabitable and decorative in nature) May be allowed to penetrate the plane of the setback angle if the Official makes the following determinations: • The required setback angle cannot be met for the architectural elements using alternate site layouts without major modifications to an otherwise acceptable application; • The excepted architectural elements will not be major or dominant features of the structure; • The excepted architectural elements will not penetrate the vertical plane of the minimum required setback distance; • The exception is the Page 95 of 115 Page 14 of 19 minimum reasonably required to achieve the architectural goal; and • If applicable, the placement of the structure provides protection of prominent natural features on the site, such as trees, wetlands, or historic sites. Flagpoles/Flags1 Unless they constitute a "sign" and thus subject to Sec. 16-5-114.E, Flagpoles no more than 20 feet high and flags no greater than 20 square feet in area may be located in setbacks Signs1 See Sec. 16-5-114.E 1In no case shall an allowable encroachment for a listed feature extend into a setback to a point that is less than 5 feet from a lot line. Current building heights are too high. Chapter 16-10: Definitions, Interpretation, and Measurement Sec.16-10-102. Rules of Measurement C. Height 1. Calculation of Height a. Maximum structure height shall be measured from pre-development grade immediately adjacent to the structure. to a point level with the highest point of the structure. For development in each zoning district shall be calculated as follows: i. Residential maximum building height shall be measured from thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher; and Page 96 of 115 Page 15 of 19 ii. Nonresidential maximum building height shall be measured from eleven feet (11') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. b. The measurement of the height of a structure shall be the distance from the height as determined by 16-10-102.C.a immediately adjacent to the structure to a point level with the highest point of the structure. cb. Equipment such as satellite dishes and heating and air conditioning equipment installed on top of buildings are excluded from the measurement of height provided they are screened from view. dc. The height of fences shall be measured from preconstruction grade. Nonconformities Changes to building height calculations and allowable setback encroachments may result in the creation of legal nonconforming structures (structures that do not comply with current dimensional standards). Such structures are addressed in LMO Section 16-7, Nonconformities, and also in LMO Section 16-9, Disaster Recovery, which are outlined below. In most cases, there is flexibility in the LMO to address the various situations that apply. Chapter 16-7 provides general standards for nonconformities. The purpose statement of the Nonconformities Chapter reads as follows: “The zoning regulations and development standards established by this Ordinance are designed to guide the future development and redevelopment of land within the Town by encouraging and regulating site development and appropriate groupings of compatible and related uses that promote and protect the public health, safety, and general welfare. While the Town recognizes the continued existence of nonconformities is generally inconsistent with the purpose and intent of this Ordinance, it also recognizes this Ordinance needs to provide flexibility to encourage redevelopment of nonconforming development if it lessens the degree of the nonconformity and if redevelopment is consistent with the goals of the Comprehensive Plan and the district in which the development is located. This Chapter provides for the regulation of nonconforming uses, structures, signs, and site features, and specifies those circumstances and conditions under which such nonconformities are allowed to continue and redevelop.” Page 97 of 115 Page 16 of 19 LMO Section 16-7-101-C, Authority to Continue, states that legal nonconformities are allowed to continue in accordance with these standards. Repairs and normal maintenance are allowed. To keep legal nonconforming uses, structures, or site features in safe conditions, repairs and maintenance are permitted, provided that no alterations may be made except those allowed by this Chapter, as stated in LMO Section 16-7-101-E, Repairs and Maintenance. However, in the case that a legal nonconformity is discontinued or abandoned for 18 consecutive months, it shall not be reestablished. Within the nonconformities chapter, the terms "expansion", "enlargement" or "extension" refer to any increase in the size of a legal nonconforming structure, or site feature. Special provisions are included for the footprint of any existing nonconforming site feature or structure. According to LMO Section 17-7-101-H, the footprint of any existing nonconforming site feature or structure may be maintained or expanded as long as the applicant receives an approval as provided in Sec. 16-7-101.F, Substitution of Nonconformities for Redevelopment, unless one of the following is involved: 1. Expansion, enlargement, or extension associated with a nonconforming use; and 2. Replacement of a nonconforming site feature with a nonconforming structure; and 3. The demolition or modification of an existing nonconforming structure with the intent to rebuild or remodel the structure in accordance with an approved Zoning Map Amendment for the Redevelopment Overlay (R-O) District (see Sec. 16-3- 106.K); and 4. Nonconforming signs. Through the Substitution of Nonconformities for Redevelopment process, the Official is authorized to approve a Development Plan for such sites if the proposed development: 1. Will not include any new development that increases the amount of encroachment into any required buffer or setback; 2. Will not increase the impervious cover on the site over the maximum allowed for the district or the existing impervious cover, whichever is greater; 3. Will not result in a density in excess of what is allowed under this Ordinance, or the existing density, whichever is greater; 4. Will lessen the extent of existing nonconforming site features to the greatest extent possible; 5. Will not have an adverse impact on the public health, safety or welfare; and 6. Will lessen the extent of nonconformities related to any existing nonconforming structure on the site to the greatest extent possible. LMO Sec.16-7-103, Nonconforming Structures, outlines additional provisions that apply unless approved through the Substitution of Nonconformities for Redevelopment process. A legal nonconforming structure shall not be expanded, enlarged, relocated, or redeveloped, in whole or in part, unless the structure is made conforming in accordance Page 98 of 115 Page 17 of 19 with the provisions of this Ordinance or is otherwise allowed by the provisions in this Chapter or Chapter 16-9: Disaster Recovery. 1. Chapter 16-9 shall apply in all cases where any structure is damaged or destroyed as a direct result of any event that has been declared a State of Emergency due to a disaster by the Mayor in accordance with the Municipal Code. 2. In such cases, this chapter takes precedence over Chapter 16-7: Nonconformities. This chapter establishes an emergency permitting process for various building types such as Single-Family, Non-Single Family Structures, and Manufactured Homes that allows owners to submit documentation of their properties to allow repair and redevelopment to the state or condition that existed prior to the disaster without the necessity of full review. A legal nonconforming structure that is damaged or destroyed by means not covered by Chapter 16-9: Disaster Recovery (including intentional human destruction), may be repaired, reconstructed, or rebuilt per LMO Section 16-7-103.B, Damage or Destruction of Nonconforming Structure. This section establishes the requirements for legal nonconforming structures that are damaged or destroyed by means not covered by Chapter 16-9 which are summarized as follows: 1. Single-Family Dwelling Unit: legal nonconforming single-family structures may be rebuilt, restored or repaired meeting the Building Code (Title 15) and shall comply with the development standards of the LMO to the extent deemed reasonably practical by the Official. 2. Non-single-family structure less than 50% destroyed: structure may be rebuilt (if not more than 50% of its appraised fair market value immediately prior to the damage) within 18 months of damage or destruction. 3. Non-single-family structure more than 50% destroyed: structure shall not be repaired or replaced except in accordance with the current zoning and current Ordinance. For condo properties (horizontal property regimes), reconstruction is allowed if fully funded and approved by the owners, with restrictions. Examples of Nonconformities Q: Can any structure damaged in a named storm rebuild in its current condition? A: Yes, a landowner can repair, reconstruct, or rebuild any structure that is damaged or destroyed as a direct result of a natural disaster to the state or condition that existed prior to the disaster within 18 months of the declared disaster, but must be developed per Chapter 16-9, Disaster Recovery and be in compliance of Title 15, Building Code. Q: Can a single-family home that burns down outside a state of emergency be rebuilt with nonconformities? A: Yes, it can if it is rebuilt within 18 months, meets the requirements of the Building Code, is brought into conformance with the LMO to the extent deemed reasonably practical by the Official, and the applicant makes efforts to eliminate or lessen the extent of the nonconformities. Page 99 of 115 Page 18 of 19 Q: Can a commercial building that burns down outside of a state of emergency be rebuilt with nonconformities? A1: If less than 50% were destroyed, yes, it can be rebuilt with its existing nonconformities within 18 months of damage or destruction A2:If more than 50% were destroyed, no, it cannot be rebuilt with its nonconformities. It will have to be replaced or repaired in accordance with the standards of the LMO. In most cases, the LMO provides flexibility. Text Amendment Review Standards Section 16-2-103.B.3 of the LMO provides standards for the review of Text Amendments and states the following: “In determining whether to recommend that Town Council adopt or deny the proposed text amendment, the Planning Commission may weigh the relevance of and consider whether and the extent to which the proposed Text Amendment: a. Is in accordance with the Comprehensive Plan; b. Is required by changed conditions; c. Addresses a demonstrated community need; d. Is consistent with the purpose and intent of the zoning districts in this Ordinance, or would improve compatibility among uses and ensure efficient development within the Town; e. Would result in a logical and orderly development pattern; and f. Would not result in significantly adverse impacts on the natural environment, including but not limited to water, air, noise, stormwater management, wildlife, vegetation, wetlands, and the natural functioning of the environment.” The proposed text amendment aligns with the review criteria, as it: 1. Supports the Comprehensive Plan, by ensuring new and redeveloped housing maintains and enhances the character of the Island. 2. Is required due to concerns with the scale of buildings and impacts on adjacent properties and residents. 3. Addresses a demonstrated community need to control the overall mass, scale, and height of new buildings. 4. Ensures that development meets the intent of the Town’s zoning districts. 5. Results in logical and orderly development at the proper scale and are compatible with nearby buildings and structures. 6. Reduces the overall impact of Town-wide development, thus minimizing adverse effects on the environment and natural resources. COMMUNITY SERVICES AND PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE ACTION: The Community Services and Public Safety Committee’s recommendation shall be based on the standards in Sec. 16-2-103.B.3, Ordinance Text Amendment Review Standards. Page 100 of 115 Page 19 of 19 The Committee has the following options when considering this agenda item. These include: 1. Recommend approval to Town Council. 2. Recommend denial to Town Council. 3. Recommend approval with conditions to Town Council. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Ordinance 2. Text Amendment Page 101 of 115 Attachment 1 –Mass and Scale Amendment Ordinance Page 1 of 3 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ORDINANCE NO. 2025-_____ AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND TO AMEND CHAPTER 16 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE, THE LAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE, TO AMEND THE CURRENT REGULATIONS FOR THE MEASURE OF HEIGHT AND SETBACK ENCROACHMENTS FOR RESIDENTIAL AND NONRESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT TO INCLUDE LAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE SECTIONS: 16-3-106, 16-5-102 & 16- 10-102, AND PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, The Town Council previously adopted a Strategic Action Plan for 2023- 2025, and Strategy Number 1 states that the Town will: Successfully manage increasing and evolving future growth patterns in a manner that will ensure sustainability of Hilton Head Island’s unique character. Additionally, the Town must monitor economic and demographic trends, undertaking a comprehensive list of future planning activities, and proactively protecting the Island’s rich natural resources through appropriate design, regulation, and capital investment practices; and, WHEREAS, at its September 16, 2024, Town Council Workshop, Town staff received the following comments and direction regarding amendments to the Land Management Ordinance related to the measurement of height and setback encroachments for residential and commercial development: Residential: 1. Changes need to apply to existing subdivisions where possible. Current building heights are too high. 2. There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. 3. Need to increase setbacks. 4. Need to establish minimum lot sizes (to be addressed during the full LMO update) Commercial 1. Current building heights are too high. 2. There needs to be more light, air, and separation between units. Need to increase setbacks. 3. Need to establish minimum lot sizes (to be addressed during the full LMO update). 4. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property); and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the mass and scale of recent developments Page 102 of 115 Attachment 1 –Mass and Scale Amendment Ordinance Page 2 of 3 have been of concern for both residential and commercial developments, and the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by an amendment to the Land Management Ordinance to address development and design standards for residential and nonresidential development by improving the definition and regulations related to the measurement of height and to identify a maximum for setback encroachments to promote the design and development of more appropriately scaled development in the Town; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by an amendment to the Land Management Ordinance to require the height of structures be measured from the pre-development grade of the property on which the structure is built, and by amending the Land Management Ordinance to measure the setback angles at twenty (20) feet above the pre-development grade as this will ensure adequate separation between structures, provide for adequate light, air, and open space; prevent the overcrowding of land and facilitate the creation of a convenient, attractive and harmonious community; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by an amendment to the Land Management Ordinance to limit the types and extent of projections and encroachments that are allowed in the area of the setbacks as this will also ensure adequate separation between structures, provide for adequate light, air, and open space; prevent the overcrowding of land and facilitate the creation of a convenient, attractive and harmonious community; and, WHEREAS, on April 16, 2025, the Planning Commission decided to postpone the public hearing until next month’s Planning Commission meeting to include Section 16-3-106, and, WHEREAS, on May 21, 2025, the Planning Commission held a Public Hearing to consider the proposed amendments related to the definition and regulations for the measure of height and setback encroachments, and the public had an opportunity to comment on the proposed amendments, and the Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend that Town Council adopt the amendments to the definition and regulations for height and setback encroachments; and, WHEREAS, on June 16, 2025, the Community Services and Public Safety Committee discussed the proposed amendments related to the regulations for the measure of height and setback encroachments, and voted ___ to recommend that Town Council adopt the amendments the regulations for the measure of height and setback encroachments; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be Page 103 of 115 Attachment 1 –Mass and Scale Amendment Ordinance Page 3 of 3 furthered by these amendments which will ensure adequate separation between structures, provide for adequate light, air, and open space; prevent the overcrowding of land and facilitate the creation of a convenient, attractive, and harmonious community. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, AND IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY AND UNDER AUTHORITY OF SAID TOWN COUNCIL, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Amendment. That the Land Management Ordinance is amended as shown on Exhibit “A” to this Ordinance. Newly added language is illustrated with double underline and deleted language is illustrated with strikethrough. Section 2. Severability. If any section, phrase, sentence, or portion of this Ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct, and independent provision, and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions thereof. Section 3. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be effective upon its adoption by the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED BY THE COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ON THIS _____ DAY OF __ , 2025. THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ____________________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor ATTEST: _____________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk First Reading: Second Reading: APPROVED AS TO FORM: _____________________________ Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney Page 104 of 115 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 1 of 11 Chapter 16-3: Zoning Districts Sec.16-3-106. Overlay Zoning Districts H. Forest Beach Neighborhood Character Overlay (FB-NC-O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks i. In addition to the single-family setback requirements of Sec. 16-5- 102, Setback Standards, a side, and rear adjacent use setback shall be required. ii. Setbacks shall comply with the standards of Sec. 16-5-102, Setback Standards, except that the 65 degree setback angle shall be measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. iii. Side adjacent use setbacks shall be 10 feet for lots with a width of 70 feet and above. For lot widths less than 70 feet, the side adjacent use setback shall be equal to 12 percent of the lot width rounded to the closest whole number. However, to preserve significant trees or stands of trees any one side setback may be reduced to five feet, provided the sum of the required side setbacks is not reduced. iv. Rear adjacent use setbacks shall equal 10 percent of the lot depth or 10 feet, whichever is greater. However, to preserve significant trees or stands of trees, the rear setback may be reduced to five feet provided the sum of the required street and rear setbacks is not reduced. v. To preserve significant trees or stands of trees in the rear of the lot, the street setback may be reduced to 15 feet provided the sum of the required street and rear setback is not reduced. I. Folly Field Neighborhood Character Overlay (FF-NC-O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks In addition to the single-family setback requirements of Sec. 16-5-102, Setback Standards, with the exception that structures greater than 24 inches in height along minor arterials are required to have a minimum adjacent street setback of 20 feet, the following setbacks shall be required. Page 105 of 115 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 2 of 11 i. Rear yard setbacks shall be a minimum of ten percent of lot depth or ten feet, whichever is greater. ii. Side yard setbacks shall each contain a minimum of ten percent of the total lot width. iii. Maximum setback angle of 65 degrees shall be measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. J. Holiday Homes Neighborhood Character Overlay (HH-NC-O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks In addition to the single-family setback requirements of Sec. 16-5-102, Setback Standards, the following setbacks shall be required: i. Rear yard setbacks shall be a minimum of ten feet. ii. Side yard setbacks shall be a minimum of ten feet; however, to preserve existing trees, any one side yard setback may be reduced to five feet provided the sum of the required side yard setbacks equals at least 20 feet. 01.A lot with less than 50 feet of street frontage or less than 0.15 acres in area shall be permitted to reduce side yard setbacks to a minimum of five feet. 02.Dwelling units that are nonconforming as to the side yard setbacks identified above are permitted to be expanded along the subject boundary line; however, expansions shall be constructed no closer than five feet from the side property line. 03.Side yard setback angles shall be a minimum of 65 degrees measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre- development grade, whichever is higher, at the setback line. The illustration in Sec. 16-5-102.D, Adjacent Use Setback Requirements, can be referenced for an example of a setback angle. iii. In the case of a corner lot, the required 20-foot adjacent street setback may be reduced to ten feet for the street with the lower average daily trips (ADT). iv. Lots directly adjacent to Folly Field Road shall have a minimum adjacent street setback of 20 feet. Page 106 of 115 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 3 of 11 Chapter 16-5: Development and Design Standards Sec.16-5-102. Setback Standards C. Adjacent Street Setback Requirements Unless expressly exempted or modified in this subsection or for the CR, S, and IL Districts in Chapter 16-3: Zoning Districts, all portions of a structure shall be located to the interior of the vertical and angled planes established by the applicable minimum setback distance from an adjacent street and maximum setback angle shown in Table 16-5-102.C, Adjacent Street Setback Requirements, based on the proposed use and the classification of the adjacent street. (See Figure 16-5-102.C, Street Setback Angle.) TABLE 16-5-102.C: ADJACENT STREET SETBACK REQUIREMENTS PROPOSED USE MINIMUM SETBACK DISTANCE1/ MAXIMUM SETBACK ANGLE2 ADJACENT STREET (BY CLASSIFICATION) MAJOR ARTERIAL MINOR ARTERIAL ALL OTHER STREETS Single- Family Structure > 24 in high 50 ft4 /75° 40 ft 4 / 70° 20 ft 4 /60° Structure ≤ 24 in high 50 ft4 /n/a 30 ft 4 /n/a 10 ft 4 /n/a All Other Uses 50 ft4 /75° 40 ft4 /70° 20 ft4 /60° NOTES: in = inches ft = feet ° = degrees 1. Measured from the adjacent street right-of-way or easement line to the closest portion of a structure. A 5' setback is required from an access easement for Family Compounds and Family Subdivisions. A street setback from an easement line is not required for non-single-family properties. 2. Measured within the upper inward quadrant of the intersection of a horizontal plane at a height of 20 feet above 13 feet above Mean Sea Level for residential use or 11 feet above Mean Sea Level for nonresidential use, or pre-development grade, whichever is higher, and a vertical plane extending upward at the minimum setback distance (see Figure 16-5-102.C, Street Setback Angle). 3. The adjacent street setback shall be a minimum of five (5) feet on any parcel abutting a Town right-of-way acquired under the Town's Dirt Road Paving Program. See Section 16-5-105.D for additional details. 4. For corner lots, reduced to 10 feet from the right-of-way of the street with the lowest average daily vehicle traffic count (ADT). If both streets have equal ADT, the lot owner may choose which street shall be subject to the reduced setback distance. 5. For Family Compounds and Family Subdivisions, the minimum setback from a minor arterial shall be 25' and the minimum setback from all other streets shall be 10'. 6. Any further reductions to the adjacent street setbacks for Family Compounds and Family Subdivisions will require a variance from the BZA. Page 107 of 115 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 4 of 11 Figure 16-5-102.C, Street Setback Angle D. Adjacent Use Setback Requirements 1. Unless expressly exempted or modified in this subsection or for the CR and S Districts in Chapter 16-3: Zoning Districts, all portions of a structure shall be located to the interior of the vertical and angled planes established by the applicable minimum setback distance from adjacent properties and maximum setback angle shown in Table 16-5-102.D, Adjacent Use Setback Page 108 of 115 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 5 of 11 Requirements, based on the proposed use and the existing use of the adjacent property (or zoning of a vacant adjacent property). (See Figure 16-5- 102.D, Use Setback Angle.) Page 109 of 115 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 6 of 11 TABLE 16-5-102.D: ADJACENT USE SETBACK REQUIREMENTS1 PROPOSED USE3 MINIMUM SETBACK DISTANCE1/MAXIMUM SETBACK ANGLE2 USE OF ADJACENT DEVELOPMENT PROPERTY3 SINGLE- FAMILY DWELLING ALL OTHER RESIDENTIAL USES; COMMERCIAL RECREATION PUBLIC, CIVIC, INSTITUTIONAL, AND EDUCATION; RESORT ACCOMMODATION; OFFICES; COMMERCIAL SERVICES; VEHICLE SALES AND SERVICES; BOAT RAMPS, DOCKING FACILITIES, AND MARINAS INDUSTRIAL USES ZONING OF ADJACENT VACANT PROPERTY CON, PR, RSF-3, RSF-5, RSF-6, RM- 4 RM-8, RM-12 CR, CC, WMU, S, RD, SPC, LC, MF, MV, MS, NC, MED IL Single-Family6 20 ft4,5 /75° 20 ft4,5 /75° 30 ft4,5 /60° 40 ft4,5 /45° • Any Other Residential Uses • Commercial Recreation 20 ft/75° 20 ft/75° 25 ft/75° 30 ft/60° • Public, Civic, Institutional, and Education • Resort Accommodation • Offices • Commercial Services • Vehicle Sales and Services • Boat Ramps, Docking Facilities, or Marinas 30 ft/60° 25 ft/75° 20 ft/75° 20 ft/75° Industrial Uses 40 ft4,5 /45° 30 ft/60° 20 ft/75° 20 ft/75° Page 110 of 115 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 7 of 11 1. Measured from the common property line to the closest portion of a structure. 2. Measured within the upper inward quadrant of the intersection of a horizontal plane at a height of 20 feet above 13 feet above Mean Sea Level for residential use or 11 feet above Mean Sea Level for nonresidential use, or pre-development grade, whichever is higher, and a vertical plane extending upward at the minimum setback distance (see Figure 16-5-102.D, Use Setback Angle). 3. See Sec. 16-10-103 for a description or definition of the listed use classification and types. 4. Single family subdivision exterior boundary only. 5. For all Minor Subdivisions and Small Residential Developments, the entire single family exterior boundary setback may be reduced by 50% in area. The setback area shall not be reduced to less than 5 feet wide at any point; it may be reduced to 5 feet where adjoining another single-family dwelling lot in the same subdivision; may be reduced to less than 5 feet if it, when combined with the platted setback distance for the adjoining lot, is at least 10 feet. 6. For Family Compounds and Family Subdivisions, the minimum setback from an adjacent property shall be reduced by 10' from what is required in Table 16-5-102.D except that an adjacent use setback of 5' shall be required between single-family uses. 7. Any further reductions to the adjacent use setbacks for Family Compounds and Family Subdivisions will require a variance from the BZA. Page 111 of 115 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 8 of 11 Figure 16-5-102.D, Use Setback Angle 2. Where the adjacent property includes uses from more than one listed use classification/use type (including mixed-use developments), the adjacent use setback required shall be that for the use classification/use type to which the greatest percentage of the development's gross floor area is devoted. 3. The adjacent use setback distance applicable to lots along the perimeter of development subject to Small Residential Development Review may be reduced by up to 50 percent, down to no less than five feet. The Official may allow further reduction as necessary to ensure that the total area within such perimeter setbacks does not exceed 20 percent of the total area of the site of the Small Residential Development. Page 112 of 115 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 9 of 11 4. There is no adjacent use setback requirement for non-single-family properties when the proposed development and the adjacent development function as a single development due to having either shared parking, connecting vehicular access or shared stormwater facilities. The recording of a cross access easement agreement between the two properties is required. E. Allowable Setback Encroachments Table 16-5-102.E, Allowable Setback Encroachments, identifies features that are allowed to encroach beyond the vertical and angled planes defined by minimum adjacent street and use setback requirements. TABLE 16-5-102.E: ALLOWABLE SETBACK ENCROACHMENTS FEATURE EXTENT AND LIMITATIONS Fences or walls • Allowed in adjacent use setbacks if located along common property lines and no more than 7 feet high • Allowed in adjacent street setbacks if less than 4 feet high Open balconies, fire escapes, or exterior stairways May extend up to 5 feet into any setback Required means of egress1 May extend up to 42 inches into any setback Chimneys or fireplaces1 May extend up to 3 2 feet into any setback if no more than 5 feet higher than the highest point of building to which it is attached Roof eaves and overhangs1 May extend up to 3 2 feet into any setback Awnings1 May extend up to 5 2 feet into any setback Bay windows1 May extend up to 3 2 feet into any setback if no more than 9 feet wide Sills or entablatures1 May extend up to 1 foot into any setback Uncovered porches, stoops, decks, patios or terraces May extend up to 5 feet into any setback Lighting fixtures May be located in any setback if no more than 20 feet high Roof dormers1 May extend up to 25 feet beyond the setback angle plane (horizontally or vertically) Spires, cupolas, domes, skylights, and similar rooftop architectural features May extend up above the setback angle plane if they occupy no more than 25% of the roof area of the structure to which they are attached and extend no more than 25% more than the height limit defined by the setback angle plane at the point(s) of penetration Solar collection devices See Sec. 16-4-103.E.8 Page 113 of 115 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 10 of 11 Television or radio antennas1 May extend up to 10 feet above the setback angle plane if they are attached to a side or rear elevation of a structure Small wind energy conversion systems See Sec. 16-4-103.E.7 Amateur radio antenna See Sec. 16-4-103.E.1 Bike racks, bollards and other site furnishings (such as tables and chairs) 1 Allowed in adjacent use and adjacent street setbacks Other architectural features not listed above (parts of a structure that provide visual interest to the structure and are nonhabitable and decorative in nature) May be allowed to penetrate the plane of the setback angle if the Official makes the following determinations: • The required setback angle cannot be met for the architectural elements using alternate site layouts without major modifications to an otherwise acceptable application; • The excepted architectural elements will not be major or dominant features of the structure; • The excepted architectural elements will not penetrate the vertical plane of the minimum required setback distance; • The exception is the minimum reasonably required to achieve the architectural goal; and • If applicable, the placement of the structure provides protection of prominent natural features on the site, such as trees, wetlands, or historic sites. Flagpoles/Flags1 Unless they constitute a "sign" and thus subject to Sec. 16-5-114.E, Flagpoles no more than 20 feet high and flags no greater than 20 square feet in area may be located in setbacks Signs1 See Sec. 16-5-114.E 1 In no case shall an allowable encroachment for a listed feature extend into a setback to a point that is less than 5 feet from a lot line. Page 114 of 115 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 11 of 11 Chapter 16-10: Definitions, Interpretation, and Measurement Sec.16-10-102. Rules of Measurement C. Height 1. Calculation of Height a. Maximum structure height shall be measured from pre-development grade immediately adjacent to the structure to a point level with the highest point of the structure. for development in each zoning district shall be calculated as follows: i. Residential maximum building height shall be measured from thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher; and ii. Nonresidential maximum building height shall be measured from eleven feet (11') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. b. The measurement of the height of a structure shall be the distance from the height as determined by 16-10-102.C.a immediately adjacent to the structure to a point level with the highest point of the structure. cb. Equipment such as satellite dishes and heating and air conditioning equipment installed on top of buildings are excluded from the measurement of height provided they are screened from view. dc. The height of fences shall be measured from preconstruction grade. (Revised 3-7-2023 - Ordinance 2023-04) Page 115 of 115

Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.