RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Meeting — Agenda Packet

Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Planning Commission · meeting of Apr 16, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Town of Hilton Head Island Planning Commission Meeting Wednesday, April 16, 2025, 2:00 PM 1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, SC Benjamin M. Racusin Council Chambers The meeting can be viewed on the Town’s YouTube Channel, the Beaufort County Channel, and Spectrum Channel 1304. 1. Call to Order 2. Pledge to the Flag 3. Adoption of the Agenda 4. Approval of the Minutes a. Regular Meeting Minutes of March 19, 2025 5. Unfinished Business 6. New Business a. Public Hearing for Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend Title 16 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend the Traffic Impact Analysis Plan requirements and Traffic Analysis Standards to include: 16-2-103, 16-5-106 and Appendix D. - Missy Luick, Director of Planning b. STDV-000243-2025 – Public Hearing request from Rich Stone of Stone by Stone Design, on behalf of Susana Legare, property owner, for a new street name request off Outlaw Road. The affected parcel is R511 003 000 0138 0000. - Joheida Fister, Deputy Fire Chief c. Annual Traffic Monitoring and Evaluation Report - Section 16-2-103.J.10 of the LMO provides that this report will be prepared and submitted annually by the LMO Official to the Planning Commission - Jeff Netzinger, Engineering and Projects Director d. Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend Title 16 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend the Setback Standards and Rules of Measurement related to Residential and Nonresidential Structures to include the following Sections: 16-5-102 and 16- Page 1 of 154 10-102 - Missy Luick, Director of Planning 7. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items 8. Commission Business 9. Chairman's Report 10. Staff Reports 11. Adjournment FOIA Compliance: Public notification of this meeting has been published, posted, and distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the Town of Hilton Head Island. In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Hilton Head Island will not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or activities. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further accommodation should contact the Town of Hilton Head Island ADA Coordinator as soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Municipal Association of South Carolina (MASC) Civility Pledge: “I pledge to build a stronger and more prosperous community by advocating for civil engagement, respecting others and their viewpoints, and finding solutions for the betterment of my city or town.” Page 2 of 154 Town of Hilton Head Island Planning Commission Meeting Minutes 3/19/2025 Page | 1 Town of Hilton Head Island PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING Wednesday, March 19, 2025, 2:00 PM Minutes 1. Call to Order Chairman Siebold called the meeting to order at 2:00 pm. Present were Chairman Siebold, Vice-Chairman Campbell, Ellen Whaley, Tom Henz, Joseph DuBois, and Ed Cordes. 2. Pledge to the Flag 3. Adoption of the Agenda Staff requested the following change to the presented agenda: recognition of outgoing Commissioner Albert Mealer to follow Approval of the Minutes. A motion to adopt the agenda with the proposed change was made by Commissioner Cordes. Commissioner Henz seconded. The motion passed unanimously. 4. Approval of the Minutes a. Regular Meeting Minutes of February 19, 2025 A motion was made by Vice-Chairman Campbell to approve the Regular Meeting Minutes of February 19, 2025. Commissioner DuBois seconded. The Minutes of February 19, 2025 were unanimously approved. b. Special Meeting Minutes of March 3, 2025 A motion was made by Commissioner DuBois to approve the Special Meeting Minutes of March 3, 2025. Vice-Chairman Campbell seconded. The Minutes of March 3, 2025 were unanimously approved. 5. Unfinished Business a. Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend Title 16 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend the current design regulations and requirements for open space and pathways in Major Subdivisions to include LMO Sections: 16-3-104, 16-3-105, 16-4-104, 16-5-103, 16- 5-104, 16-5-107, 16-5-115, 16-6-102, 16-10-102, 16-10-105, and Appendices A & D - Missy Luick, Director of Planning Chairman Siebold introduced the item and declared the Public Hearing open. Missy Luick, Director of Planning, presented a proposal of the remanded text amendment with the changes requested by the Planning Commission on February 19, 2025. Following the opportunity for public comment and Commission discussion, the Public Hearing was Page 3 of 154 Town of Hilton Head Island Planning Commission Meeting Minutes 3/19/2025 Page | 2 closed. A motion to recommend approval to Town Council as presented was made by Commissioner Henz. Commissioner Whaley seconded. The motion passed unanimously. 6. New Business a. STDV-001544-2024 – Public Hearing for an application from Leander Cannick, owner of 11 Yucca Drive, to name a new street off Yucca Drive. The affected parcel is R510 005 000 006C 0000. Chairman Siebold introduced the item and declared the Public Hearing open. Joheida Fister, Deputy Fire Chief, presented a proposal for a new street off of Yucca Drive to be named Yucca Lane. Following the opportunity for public comment and Commission discussion, the Public Hearing was closed. A motion was made by Commissioner Henz to approve the naming of this street as presented. Vice-Chairman Campbell seconded. The motion passed unanimously. b. Public Hearing for Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend Title 16 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend the Residential Base Zoning District Standards for the RM-12, Moderate to High Density Residential District and the Workforce Housing Program, to include the following LMO Sections: 16-3-104 and 16-4-105. - Missy Luick, Director of Planning Chairman Siebold introduced the item and declared the Public Hearing open. Ben Brown, Director of Strategic Initiatives, presented an overview of the Northpoint Initiative. Missy Luick, Director of Planning, presented a proposal of the text amendment as included in the packet. Following public comment and Commission discussion, the Public Hearing was closed. A motion was made by Commissioner Cordes that the Planning Commission forward to Town Council an approval of the text amendments as presented. Commissioner DuBois seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. c. Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend the Official Zoning Map with Respect to the 16 Parcels Located on Northpoint Circle to Rezone the Parcels from the Parks and Recreation (PR) District to the Moderate to High Density Residential (RM-12) District; and Providing for Severability and an Effective Date - First Reading - Missy Luick, Director of Planning Chairman Siebold introduced the item and declared the Public Hearing open. Missy Luick, Director of Planning, presented a proposal of the zoning map amendment as included in the packet. Following the opportunity for public comment and Commission discussion, the Public Hearing was closed. A motion was made by Commissioner Henz to recommend approval to Town Council. Page 4 of 154 Town of Hilton Head Island Planning Commission Meeting Minutes 3/19/2025 Page | 3 Vice-Chairman Campbell seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. d. Public Hearing for Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend Title 16 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend Chapter 16-5, Development and Design Standards, to add new Construction Management Standards as: 16-5-117. - Missy Luick, Director of Planning Chairman Siebold introduced the item and declared the Public Hearing open. Missy Luick, Director of Planning, presented the ordinance as included in the packet. Following the opportunity for public comment and Commission discussion, the Public Hearing was closed. A motion was made by Commissioner Whaley to recommend approval of the proposed text amendment as presented to Town Council. Commissioner DuBois seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. e. Consideration of the Capital Improvement Program Fiscal Year 2026 Priority Projects and recommendation to Town Council. - Jeff Netzinger, Engineering and Projects Director Jeff Netzinger, Engineering and Projects Director, presented the proposed Capital Improvement Program Fiscal Year 2026 Priority Projects. The Commissioners asked questions about the details and timelines of several projects. A motion was made by Commissioner Henz to recommend approval to Town Council. Commissioner Cordes seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. f. PPR-000119-2025 - Public Hearing request from the Town of Hilton Head Island for Public Project Review for a new restroom facility at Old Schoolhouse Park. The affected parcels are Beaufort County Tax Map Parcel number R511 007 000 0247 0000 and R511 007 000 0070 0000, located at 150 and 152 William Hilton Parkway. - Melissa Paul-Leto, Principal Planner Chairman Siebold introduced the item and declared the Public Hearing open. Melissa Paul-Leto, Principal Planner, presented a proposal for a restroom and storage facility with an open porch, at Old Schoolhouse Park located at 152 William Hilton parkway, and also known as parcel 70 on Beaufort County Tax Map number 7. During the opportunity for public comment, a resident shared concerns about parking, noise, and activity after dark. Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager, answered questions from the Commissioners. Commissioner Cordes stressed the importance of meeting ADA regulations as soon as possible. Following Commission discussion, the Public Hearing was closed. A motion was made by Commissioner DuBois to approve the project as presented. Commissioner Henz seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. 7. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items Page 5 of 154 Town of Hilton Head Island Planning Commission Meeting Minutes 3/19/2025 Page | 4 8. Commission Business 9. Chairman's Report a. Recognition of outgoing Commissioner Albert Mealer This item moved to follow Approval of the Minute: Chairman Siebold recognized outgoing Commissioner Albert Mealer for his service and presented a certificate on behalf of Planning Commission. 10. Staff Reports a. DPR-001470-2024 – Request from Judd Carstens, of Whitmer, Jones, Keefer, Ltd., for Development Plan Review for the property located at 862 William Hilton Parkway for modifications to the existing building and site. Trey Lowe, Development Services Program Manager, presented a commercial Development Plan Review to the Commission regarding 862 William Hilton Parkway. Proposed work includes adding an entrance canopy, awnings to the first floor, shutters to the second-floor windows, and improvements to the landscaping. The parcel is zoned Light Commercial (LC) District and is in the Corridor Overlay. Following Mr. Lowe's presentation, he answered several questions from the Commission. 11. Adjournment Chairman Siebold adjourned the meeting at 4:45 pm. The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 6 of 154 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court ⬧ Hilton Head Island ⬧ South Carolina ⬧ 29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND Planning Commission TO: Planning Commission FROM: Missy Luick, Director of Planning CC: Shawn Leininger, Assistant Town Manager CC: Marc Orlando, Town Manager DATE: April 16, 2025 SUBJECT: Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island to Amend Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to Amend the Traffic Impact Analysis Plan Requirements and Traffic Analysis Standards in 16-2-103, 16-5-106, and Appendix D RECOMMENDATION: Planning Commission hold a public hearing and consider an Ordinance to Amend Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to Amend the Traffic Impact Analysis Plan Requirements and Traffic Analysis Standards in 16-2-103, 16-5-106, and Appendix D . Town Staff recommends approval of the proposed text amendment. BACKGROUND: Revitalize and Modernize the Economy is a focus area in the adopted Town Council 2023- 2025 Strategic Action Plan. In fulfillment of this focus area, Strategy #1 Establish a Growth Management Strategy states the Town will: “Successfully manage increasing and evolving future growth patterns in a manner that will ensure sustainability of Hilton Head Island’s unique character. Additionally, the Town must monitor economic and demographic trends, undertaking a comprehensive list o f future planning activities, and proactively protecting the Island’s rich natural resources through appropriate design, regulation, and capital investment practices.” In this regard, Town Council directed Town Staff to advance amendments to the Land Management Ordinance (LMO) in the 2024 Strategic Action Work Plan. The effort has been divided into two separate projects, the f ull LMO Overhaul and the priority amendments. The priority amendments include incremental changes to both the LMO and portions of the Municipal Code related to land management that address important and urgent issues in advance of the full LMO Overhaul. These priority amendments address pressing community development issues with the best short-term solution while Page 7 of 154 Page 2 of 9 minimizing unintended outcomes. Issues that require additional analysis and research or are more complex are recommended to be further explored during the full LMO Overhaul. At the September 24, 2024, Town Council Workshop, Town staff received the following comments and direction regarding amendments related to Traffic Impact Analysis. 1. Change name from Traffic Impact Analysis to Transportation Impact Analysis Plan (TIAP) to account for a multimodal approach. 2. Reduce the threshold a develop ment needs to meet to trigger a mandatory TIA P from 100 peak hour trips to 50 peak hour trips. 3. Include multimodal infrastructure (suc h as bike paths, sidewalks, transit) in the analysis. 4. Include more impact mitigation options. 5. Clarify subject matter approval by the Town Engineer instead of the LMO Official as a best practice. 6. Add unsignalized intersections level of service standard including mitigation requirements and remove the discounting of impacts due to “background traffic ,” (i.e. the trips generated by previously existing development). SUMMARY OF AMENDMENT: Effective transportation planning is essential for managing growth, ensuring mobility, and maintaining a safe and efficient transportation network. As communities develop, new projects introduce additional traffic, impacting roads, intersections, and multi modal infrastructure such as sidewalks, bike lanes, and transit systems. Without proper assessment, development can lead to congestion, safety hazards, and infrastructure strain. For the Town, t his type of assessment is conducted during the development approval process and involves a detailed study of projected traffic volumes, travel patterns, and potential impacts on roadway safety and congestion. The analysis helps determine whether improvements , such as roadway expansions, new traffic signals, pedestrian enhancements, or transit service modifications , are necessary to maintain efficient and safe travel conditions as identified by the study parameters. While these studies are designed to assess how new projects affect traffic, there are concerns about whether the Town’s current process and requirements truly addresses the needs of residents. As part of the priority amendments, the Town is proposing to update its current requirements for these studies for a more comprehensive approach that better reflects the transportation needs of everyone, including pedestrians, cyclists, and transit users, while also being mindful of unnecessary costs. The proposed amendments strengthen the Town’s requirements by: • Expanding the scope of stud y beyond traffic to include multimodal infrastructure such as sidewalks, bike lanes, and transit services, Page 8 of 154 Page 3 of 9 • Reducing the threshold for requiring a traffic study from 100 peak-hour trips to 50 peak-hour trips, ensuring that even moderate developments undergo proper transportation impact review, • Expanding the type of mitigation options that can be used to address transportation impacts, • Shifting approval authority from the LMO Official to the Town Engineer for consistency with best practices, • Adding new standards for unsignalized intersections, and • Eliminating exemptions associated with trips generated by previously existing development. These updates will make the Town’s process more responsive to the community's needs and promote a more balanced, multimodal, and forward -thinking approach to transportation planning, ensuring that growth aligns with the Town’s long -term mobility and infrastructure goals . These changes are part of an ongoing effort to update the Town’s regulations, with further revisions expected during the full LMO update. ANALYSIS: Proposed Amendments The Town currently requires a “Traffic Impact Analysis Plan.” Examples of projects that recently required a TIAP include: 1. 147 Residential Units on Jonesville Road and 2. 132 Residential Units on Office Way It is proposed to be renamed to the “Transportation Impact Analysis Plan” to reflect a more comprehensive, multimodal approach that includes biking, walking, and transit. Oversight of TIAPs has shifted from the LMO Official to the Town Engineer to ensure technical accuracy and alignment with best practices. As part of this amendment, the threshold for requiring a TIAP is proposed to be lowered from 100 to 50 peak hour trips, thereby increasing the number of projects subject to analysis, in addition to removing the exemption for trips generated by a previously existing development. For instance, two recent projects that were not required to provide a TIA P but were exempted due to the trips factored in for previously existing development would have been required to provide a TIAP under the proposed language are the following: 1. Timeshare development on Folly Field Road near Islanders Beach Park and 2. Waterfront restaurant on Squire Pope Road near the Rowing and Sailing Center at Squire Pope Community Park The proposed TIAP amendments would also require the evaluation of multimodal infrastructure, such as bike paths, sidewalks, and public transit options. Transportation impacts can be mitigated by expanded and more flexible mitigation strategies to address transportation impacts, such as replacing a traffic signal or uncontrolled intersection with Page 9 of 154 Page 4 of 9 a roundabout that meets the Town’s operational and design standards , c hanges to locations or design of median crossovers and removal of changes to the number and location, or design of access points. Additionally, new standards for unsignalized intersections have been introduced, requiring mitigation for impacts. The following table demonstrates how the proposed amendments address demonstrated issues. Issue Proposed Amendment Clarify subject matter approval by the Town Engineer instead of the LMO Official as a best practice. The Town Engineer is now referenced throughout the text amendment as the decision-making authority concerning Transportation Impact Analysis Review. Change name from Traffic Impact Analysis Plan to Transportation Impact Analysis Plan to account for a multimodal approach. Reduce the threshold a developer needs to meet to trigger a mandatory TIA from 100 peak hour trips to 50 peak hour trips. Sec.16-2-103. Application Specific Review Procedures J. Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Review 2. Applicability a. A Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan, monitoring and mitigation requirements, and procedures set forth in this section are applicable to all development that would generate 50 or more peak hour trips, except as specifically exempted in paragraph 4 of this subsection. Add unsignalized intersections level of service standard including mitigation requirements. Chapter 16-5: Development and Design Standards C. Service Level Standards 3. The average total day on any approach to the Sea Pines Circle does not exceed 150 seconds per vehicle during the peak hour for an average July weekday, and the average total delay on any approach to any other traffic circle or roundabout does not exceed 55.0 seconds per vehicle during the peak hour for an average July weekday; and Page 10 of 154 Page 5 of 9 Include multimodal infrastructure (such as bike paths, sidewalks, transit) in the analysis. Appendix D: Application Submittal Requirements D-11. Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Review B. Submittal Requirements 7. The impact on non-motorized travel shall be based on the procedures and practices recommended by ITE, Transportation Research Board (TRB), AASHTO and FHWA. The applicant shall incorporate where possible any non-motorized recommendations included in Town and/or regional long-term plans in the vicinity of the site. The study should identify potential changes such as: a. Improvements to pedestrian crossings; b. Additional pedestrian or bicycle crossings; c. Improvements to pedestrian signals, pedestrian signal intervals, signs, and pavement markings; d. Construction of additional sidewalks or non- motorized pathways; e. Changes to the site design and access to ease non-motorized travel and reduce conflicts with vehicles, from the public right-of-way to the building entrances or on-site activity; and f. Other similar improvements to transportation facilities. Remove the discounting of impacts due to “background traffic.” i.e. the trips generated by previously existing development. LMO Sec. 16-2-103.J 2. Applicability a. A Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan, monitoring and mitigation requirements, and procedures set forth in this section are applicable to all development that would generate 50 or more peak hour trips, except as specifically exempted in paragraph 4 of this subsection. Page 11 of 154 Page 6 of 9 4. Exemptions The following types of development shall be exempt from the Transportation Impact Analysis Plan and mitigation requirements of this section: Development that would generate fewer than peak hour trips on the adjacent street. i. If the proposed development will be replacing a vacant or occupied structure on the same site, then for the purpose of determining exemptions, the number of peak hour trips generated by the proposed land use shall be reduced by the number of peak hour trips generated by the most recent legally established land use. ii. Proof of the most recent principal land use of a site shall be the responsibility of the applicant and shall be submitted to the for approval. Absent such proof, the peak hour trip rate will be based on the lowest trip generation of all the uses permitted by right in the site's zoning district. Include more impact mitigation options. Appendix D: Application Submittal Requirements D-11. Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Review B. Submittal Requirements 10. If the initial computerized analysis indicates that the Town's adopted traffic service level standards will be not be met, a mitigation plan must be included in the plan based on at least one additional computer analysis. This mitigation plan must show how the Town's adopted traffic service level standards will be satisfied. Applicants shall be responsible to mitigate the transportation impacts. Acceptable roadway mitigation measures are limited to the following: Page 12 of 154 Page 7 of 9 a. Traffic signal timing or phasing revisions, that not only mitigate traffic impacts generated by this development, but also result in safe and acceptable operations at the study intersection as demonstrated by a network traffic analysis; b. Addition of signs, signals, markings, or other measures to accommodate road crossings and improve safety for pedestrians and achieve ADA compliance; c. Pavement marking revisions; d. Adding additional intersection turn lanes not to exceed 4 lanes on minor arterial approaches and 5 lanes on major arterial approaches; e. Geometric improvements to signalized or unsignalized intersections, including traffic circles or roundabouts, to improve traffic operations, pedestrian and bicycle operations or to improve safety; f. Road widening; g. Adding a traffic signal at a location that is warranted per the Manual of Uniform Traffic Control (MUTCD); h. Replacing a traffic signal or uncontrolled intersection with a roundabout that meets the Town’s operational and design standards; i. Changes to locations or design of median crossovers to reduce congestion and mitigate accidents; j. Removal of changes to the number and location, or design of access points to reduce congestion and mitigate accidents; k. Additional signage; l. Other transportation-related safety improvements identified and/or recommended by the Town Engineer. Page 13 of 154 Page 8 of 9 Nonconformities Chapter 16-7 provides standards for nonconformities. This amendment will not create nonconformities and is not applicable. Text Amendment Review Standards Section 16-2-103.B.3 of the LMO provides standards for the review of Text Amendments and states the following: “In determining whether to recommend that Town Council adopt or deny the proposed text amendment, the Planning Commission may weigh the relevance of and consider whether and the extent to which the proposed Text Amendment: a. Is in accordance with the Comprehensive Plan; b. Is required by changed conditions; c. Addresses a demonstrated community need; d. Is consistent with the purpose and intent of the zoning districts in this Ordinance, or would improve compatibility among uses and ensure efficient development within the Town; e. Would result in a logical and orderly development pattern; and f. Would not result in significantly adverse impacts on the natural environment, including but not limited to water, air, noise, stormwater management, wildlife, vegetation, wetlands, and the natural functioning of the environment.” The proposed text amendment aligns with the review criteria, as it: 1. Supports the Comprehensive Plan , which includes the following strategy and tactic: “Maintain, evaluate, and update as needed traffic analysis standards to guide development in accordance with the existing and future needs of the Town.” 2. Is required due to increased traffic and congestion. 3. Addresses a demonstrated community need to mitigate traffic impact and includes consideration of essential multimodal transportation options. 4. Ensures that overall transportation impacts and mitigation efforts are consistent with the intent of the LMO. 5. Results in safer and less congested streets and intersections ensuring orderly development and transportation networks. 6. Minimizes the overall impact of Town-wide development and resulting traffic. PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION: LMO Sec.16-2-103-B.2.d states that the Planning Commission's recommendation shall be based on the standards in Sec. 16 -2-103.B.3, Ordinance Text Amendment Review Standards. Page 14 of 154 Page 9 of 9 The Planning Commission has the following options when considering this agenda item. These include: 1. Recommend approval to Town Council. 2. Recommend denial to Town Council. 3. Recommend approval with conditions to Town Council. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Ordinance 2. Text Amendment Page 15 of 154 Attachment 1 –Transportation Impact Analysis Amendment Ordinance Page 1 of 4 AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ORDINANCE NO. 2025-____ AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND TO AMEND CHAPTER 16 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE, THE LAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE, TO AMEND THE TRAFFIC IMPACT ANALYSIS PLAN REQUIREMENTS AND TRAFFIC ANALYSIS STANDARDS IN LAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE SECTIONS 16-2-103, 16 -5-106 AND APPENDIX D , AND PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, The Town Council previously adopted a Strategic Action Plan for 2023- 2025, and Strategy Number 1 states that the Town will: Successfully manage increasing and evolving future growth patterns in a manner that will ensure sustainability of Hilton Head Island’s unique character. Additionally, the Town must monitor economic and demographic trends, undertaking a comprehensive list of future planning activities, and proactively protecting the Island’s rich natural resources through appropriate design, regulation, and capital investment practices; and, WHEREAS, at its September 24, 2024, Town Council Workshop, Town staff received the following comments and direction regarding amendments to the Land Management Ordinance related to Traffic Impact Analysis Standards: 1. Change name from Traffic Impact Analysis to Transportation Impact Analysis Plan to account for a multimodal approach. 2. Reduce the threshold a developer needs to meet to trigger a mandatory TIA from 100 peak hour trips to 50 peak hour trips. 3. Include multimodal infrastructure (such as bike paths, sidewalks, transit) in the analysis 4. Include more impact mitigation options. 5. Clarify subject matter approval by the Town Engineer instead of the LMO Official as a best practice. 6. Add unsignalized intersections level of service standard including mitigation requirements and remove the discounting of impacts due to “background traffic,” (i.e., the trips generated by previously existing development); and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that Traffic Impact Analysis studies are important tools and assist the Town in avoiding congestion in the streets, undue concentration of population, safety hazards and overburdening of public infrastructure and also assist the Town in facilitating the creation of a convenient, attractive, and harmonious community ; and, Page 16 of 154 Attachment 1 –Transportation Impact Analysis Amendment Ordinance Page 2 of 4 WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by an amendment to the Land Management Ordinance Traffic Impact Analysis Plan Requirements and Traffic Analysis Standards to change the title to Transportation Impact Analysis Plan, amend applicability requirements, modify the threshold for requiring an analysis plan, increase mitigation options to moder nize the transportation rev iew process, prioritize multimodal considerations, and ensure a thorough evaluation of development impacts on the transportation network by including the following requirements: • Expanding the scope of Traffic Impact Analysis studies to include multimodal infrastructure such as sidewalks, bike lanes, and transit services, • Reducing the threshold for requiring a study from 100 peak -hour trips to 50 peak - hour trips, ensuring that even moderate developments undergo proper transportation impact review, • Expanding the type of mitigation options that can be used to address transportation impacts, • Shifting approval authority from the LMO Official to the Town Engineer for consistency with best practices, • Adding new standards for unsignalized intersections, and • Eliminating exemptions associated with trips generated by previously existing development; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that these requirements will make the development review process more responsive to the community's needs and promote a more balanced, multimodal, and forward -thinking approach to transportation planning, ensuring that growth aligns with the Town’s long -term mobility and infrastructure goals and that these things are in the best interests of the Town, and that the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by them; and, WHEREAS, on April 16, 2025 , the Planning Comm ission held a Public Hearing to consider the proposed amendments to change the applicability and to include multimodal options , and the public had an opportunity to comment on the proposed amendments, and the Planning Commission voted ___ to recommend that Town Council adopt the amendments Land Management Ordinance Traffic Impact Analysis Plan Requirements and Traffic Analysis Standards; and, WHEREAS, on _____________, the Community Services and Public Safety Committee discussed the proposed amendments to change the applicability and include multimodal options , and voted ___ to recommend that Town Council adopt the amendments Land Management Ordinance Traffic Impact Analysis Plan Requirements and Traffic Analysis Standards; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by this amendment to the Land Management Ordinance Traffic Impact Analysis Page 17 of 154 Attachment 1 –Transportation Impact Analysis Amendment Ordinance Page 3 of 4 Plan Requirements and Traffic Analysis Standards which will aid in avoiding congestion in the streets, undue concentration of population, safety hazards and overburdening of public infrastructure and also assist the Town in facilitating the creation of a convenient, attractive, and harmonious community. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, AND IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY AND UNDER AUTHORITY OF SAID TOWN COUNCIL, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Amendment. That the Land Management Ordinance is amended as shown on Exhibit “A” to this Ordinance . Newly added language is illustrated with double underline and deleted language is illustrated with strikethrough. Section 2 . Severability. If any section, phrase, sentence, or portion of this Ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct , and independent provision, and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions thereof. Section 3. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be effective upon its adoption by the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. Page 18 of 154 Attachment 1 –Transportation Impact Analysis Amendment Ordinance Page 4 of 4 PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED BY THE COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ON THIS _____ DAY OF __ , 2025. THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ____________________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor ATTEST: _____________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk First Reading: Second Reading: APPROVED AS TO FORM: _____________________________ Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney Page 19 of 154 Attachment 2: Exhibit A: Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Amendment Chapter 16-2: Administration Sec.16-2-103. Application Specific Review Procedures J. Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Review 1. Purpose The purpose of this subsection is to establish procedures and standards for the review and decision on Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plans, to ensure new development does not create street congestion beyond an amount established as acceptable by the Town. 2. Applicability a. The A Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan, monitoring and mitigation requirements, and procedures set forth in this section are applicable to all development as defined in this Title that would generate 50 or more peak hour trips, except for thatas specifically exempted in paragraph 4 belowof this subsection. b. Development Plan approval, with or without conditions or modifications, nor a Building Permit, shall not be granted until without the applicant has received for Development Plan approval first obtaining Traffic of a Transportation Impact Analysis Plan approval in accordance with this section, in addition to all other requirements, unless the development is specifically exempt as provided for in this Chapter. c. A Building Permit may not be issued for development undertaken in accordance with a previously issued final development permit until the applicant first obtains Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan approval, unless the development is exempt. 3. Trip Generation Rates Trip generation rates shall be taken from the most current edition of the Institute of Transportation Engineers'ITE Trip Generation Manual (ITE Manual), except; provided, however, that an applicant may elect to perform, at the applicant's expense, a trip generation study which shall be submitted to the Official Town Engineer in determining an exemption. The An applicant’s trip generation study shall be undertaken by a qualified traffic transportation engineering firm selected in accordance with Appendix D.11, and is subject to review and approval by the Official Town Engineer. For any proposed uses use not specifically listed in the ITE Manual, the Official Town Engineer shall determine the most appropriate trip generation rate. The Official Town Engineer may consider input from the applicant in making this decision. Trip rates shall be generated for pass-by trips, internal trips and multi-modal trips that are generated by a mode other than a personal motor vehicle. Trip Page 20 of 154 Page 2 of 14 rate reductions must be supported by the ITE handbooks or, if local data is used, approved by the Town Engineer. 4. Exemptions The following types of development shall be exempt from the Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan and mitigation requirements of this section: a. Activities and uses not constituting development (see Sec. 16-1-104.B, Development Activities Constituting Development), or exempt from Development Plan approval (see Sec. 16-2-103.G.3, Exemptions). b. Development that would generate fewer than 100 peak hour trips on the adjacent street. i. If the proposed development will be replacing a vacant or occupied structure on the same site, then for the purpose of determining exemptions, the number of peak hour trips generated by the proposed land use shall be reduced by the number of peak hour trips generated by the most recent legally established land use. ii. Proof of the most recent principal land use of a site shall be the responsibility of the applicant and shall be submitted to the Official for approval. Absent such proof, the peak hour trip rate will be based on the lowest trip generation of all the uses permitted by right in the site's zoning district. c.b. A residential development generating less than 200 peak hour trips in which at least 20 percent of the units will qualify and be maintained as affordable housing in accordance with this Ordinance. 5. Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Review Procedure a. Application Submittal An application for Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Review may be submitted by persons identified in Sec. 16-2-102.C.1, and shall be submitted in accordance with Sec. 16-2-102.C. b. Staff Review and Action I. No or Minor Mitigation Required Page 21 of 154 Page 3 of 14 For any proposed development that does not require any mitigation or for which mitigation is limited to adjustments to signal timing, signal phasing, or intersection restriping, or improvements serving non-motorized travel, the Official Town Engineer shall review and make a final decision on the application in accordance with Sec. 16-2-102.D. The Official's decision shall be based on the standards in Sec. 16-2-103.J.6, Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Standards, and shall be one of the following: 01. Approve the application as submitted; 02. Approve the application subject to conditions of approval or modifications; or 03. Deny the application. II. Major Mitigation Required Page 22 of 154 Page 4 of 14 Where the proposed development requires mitigation beyond just adjustments to signal timing, signal phasing, or intersection re-striping, or improvements serving non-motorized travel, the Official Town Engineer shall review the application and prepare a staff report with a recommendation for action in accordance with Sec. 16-2-102.D. The Official's Town Engineer recommendation shall be based on the standards in Sec. 16-2-103.J.6, Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Standards. Any mitigation improvements should comply with the latest edition of SCDOT’s Access and Roadside Management Standards (ARMS) manual and SCDOT Roadway Design Manual. c. Decision-Making Body Review and Decision I. For any proposed development that requires mitigation beyond just adjustments to signal timing, signal phasing, or intersection re-striping, the Planning Commission shall review the application and staff report at a public meeting and make a final decision on the application in accordance with Sec. 16-2- 102.G. The Commission's decision shall be based on the standards in Sec. 16-2- 103.J.6, Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Standards, and shall be one of the following: 01. Approve the Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan as submitted; 02. Approve the Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan subject to conditions of approval or modifications; or 03. Deny the Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan. II. Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plans containing mitigation other than that allowed in Appendix D (specifically D-11.B.8) will not be accepted. d. Post-Decision Actions and Limitations I. Notice of Decision The Official Town Engineer shall provide notice of the final decision on the application in accordance with Sec. 16-2-102.H.1. II. Appeal 01. Appeals from the final decision of the Official Town Engineer on an application for Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Review are governed by Sec. 16-2-103.U, Appeal of Official's Decision to Planning Commission, and S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-1150. 02. Appeals from the decision of the Planning Commission on an application for Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Review are governed by S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-1150. Page 23 of 154 Page 5 of 14 6. Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Standards The proposed Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan shall not be approved unless it is demonstrated the Town's street system can operate and comply with the Town's adopted traffic service level standards, and the plan complies with Sec. 16-5-106, Traffic Transportation Analysis Standards. 7. Expiration of Approval A Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan approval shall expire after one (1) year from the date of approval unless the applicant submits a complete Development Plan review application. 8. Amendment A Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan may be amended only in accordance with the procedures and standards for applicable to its original approval. 9. Traffic Transportation Mitigation Program Implementation a. Timing of Implementation If a traffic transportation mitigation program is part of an approved Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan, all approved traffic transportation mitigation improvements must be implemented prior to issuance of a Certificate of Compliance unless otherwise provided for as part of the approved Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan. b. Responsibility for Costs of Improvement; Reimbursement I. Except as provided for in provisions ii through iv below, t The costs of implementation of an approved mitigation program shall be the responsibility of the applicant, except as follows:. II. If an applicant is required to provide an improvement that would otherwise be funded by transportation impact fees, a transportation impact fee credit shall be available as provided in accordance with Sec. 16-5-116.K, Offsets to Impact Fees. III. If an applicant is required to provide an improvement which is eligible for a transportation impact fee credit as provided for in accordance with Sec. 16-5- 116.K, Offsets to Impact Fees, and the cost of the improvement exceeds the amount of the transportation impact fee otherwise calculated to be due in accordance with that section, the applicant may submit a plan for reimbursement to the Town Council for action. Such reimbursement plan shall be consistent with the Town's contractual obligations with respect to other planned street improvements and consistent with the Town's adopted Capital Improvements Program (CIP). IV. If an applicant is required to provide an improvement, other than a site-related traffic transportation improvement that is eligible for funding with transportation impact fees, or if an applicant proposes a change in priorities in the adopted CIP, the applicant may submit a proposal to the Town Council requesting consideration for inclusion of such improvement in the CIP or for a shifting of Page 24 of 154 Page 6 of 14 priorities within the CIP, together with a proposed reimbursement plan which is consistent with the requirements of this section. 10. Traffic Transportation Monitoring and Evaluation Report a. Report Annually, following the preparation of the June July intersection turning movement counts, the Official Town Engineer shall prepare a Traffic Transportation Monitoring and Evaluation Report, which shall include each of the following: I. Peak hour traffic turning movement counts for an average June July weekday for all signalized intersections as measured by the Town Engineer; II. Twenty-four hour traffic volumes on William Hilton Parkway, Palmetto Bay Road, Pope Avenue, and the Cross Island Parkway as measured by the Town Engineer; III. Historical trends over the past five years if available for items in paragraph II above; IV. Description of the operating conditions, relative to the adopted traffic service level standards, for each signalized intersection and how the operating conditions have changed since the last reporting period; V. Morning, midday, and afternoon peak hour volumes for Sea Pines Circle in reports for years evenly divisible by five two; and VI. Recommendations for mitigation improvements to intersections that fail to meet the traffic transportation standards outlined in Sec. 16-5-106, Traffic Transportation Analysis Standards. b. Certification of Traffic Transportation Data Based on the Traffic Transportation Monitoring and Evaluation Report, Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plans, and such other information as deemed appropriate, the Official Town Engineer shall certify the traffic transportation data to be used by all applicants, traffic transportation engineers, Town staff and consultants, in performing and reviewing Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plans. The Official Town Engineer will certify the traffic volume data on an annual basis or more frequently as deemed appropriate. c. Planning Commission Action I. The Traffic Transportation Monitoring and Evaluation Report prepared by the Official Town Engineer as described above shall be forwarded to the Planning Commission and simultaneously conveyed to the Town Council. Upon receipt of the Report and recommendations from the Official Town Engineer, the Planning Commission shall give notice and hold a public meeting for the purpose of discussing the Report and recommendations and eliciting public comments. II. Following its review, the Planning Commission shall forward the Traffic Transportation Monitoring and Evaluation Report and recommendations, and may forward its own supplemental report and recommendations, to the Town Council. Page 25 of 154 Page 7 of 14 11. Vehicular Multimodal Access Analysis a. All development shall have an access analysis undertaken by the Official Town Engineer. This analysis shall be undertaken to ensure that vehicular and multi- modal access to all proposed developments and subdivisions is accomplished in a safe manner. b. This analysis will identify any vehicular access improvements the applicant must install at the applicant's expense, such as deceleration lanes, and shall identify the location of any curb cuts based on, but not limited to sight distances, existing roadway infrastructure, opposing driveways locations, and shared vehicular access. This analysis will address requirements for adequate driveway design including, but not limited to turning radius and stacking distance. The standards in the South Carolina Department of Transportation's Access and Roadside Management Standards Manual shall serve as a guide for this review. c. This analysis will identify any improvements required to serve non-vehicular site access, including any modifications to or improvements of pathway crossings being impacted by the site development. d. The vehicular and multimodal access requirements approved by the Official Town Engineer shall be incorporated on development or subdivision plans prior to their approval. If an applicant is required to provide site-related traffic improvements, the cost of implementing such improvements shall be borne by the applicant and no such costs shall be eligible for a credit or offset from any transportation impact fees required in accordance with Sec. 16-5-116.K, Offsets to Impact Fees. Chapter 16-5: Development and Design Standards Sec.16-5-106. Traffic Transportation Analysis Standards A. Purpose The purpose of this section is to guide development in accordance with the existing and future needs of the Town in order to protect, promote and improve the public health, safety, morals, convenience, order, appearance, prosperity and general welfare of the citizens of the Town, by ensuring new development does not overburden and overly congest streets, pathways, sidewalks, and other transportation systems in the Town.'s streets. B. Intent The regulations of this section are designed and intended: 1. To ensure that the Town's adopted traffic transportation service level standards are met within the Town and to provide safety from fire, panic and other dangers, to promote the public health and general welfare, to prevent the Page 26 of 154 Page 8 of 14 overcrowding of land, to avoid undue concentration of population, and to facilitate safe and the adequate provision of street and non-motorized facilities. 2. To enable the Town Engineer or their designee to conduct an appropriate review and evaluation of the traffic multimodal transportation impacts of proposed development, to provide for the imposition of conditions in order to assure that new development does not impair the safety and the Town's ability and obligation to provide adequate adequacy of impacted street and transportation facilities to all its used by the Town’s citizens, and to prescribe necessary project-specific mitigation measures or to otherwise changes to the site design or operations, and establish the implementation timing and funding, as part of the condition traffic impact analysis plan approval. 3. To ensure that no traffic transportation impact analysis plan approvals are granted that would cause a reduction in the service level of any street facility that is currently operating in a manner that fails to satisfy the Town's adopted traffic service level standards. 4. To ensure that no traffic transportation impact analysis plan approvals are granted unless street facilities with adequate capacity to accommodate the traffic generated by the proposed development are available concurrently with the scheduled opening of the development. 5. To establish uniform procedures for the review of applications for traffic transportation impact analysis plan approval subject to the traffic transportation impact analysis plan requirements set forth herein. 6. To better coordinate the short-term growth potential of the Town with the immediately available street system capacity, taking into account exempt development and approved development that has not been built, to the extent to which these may be eligible for development plan approval without being subject to the traffic transportation impact analysis plan requirements of this section. 7. To better coordinate the long-term growth potential of the Town with an realistic assessment of street capacity which is currently and which may in the future become available, recognizing the limitations on the Town's financial resources, the constraints presented by the geography of the Island, and the need to preserve the Island's sensitive natural, historic, and environmental resources. 8. To better coordinate the type, location, amount, timing, and rate of development of proposed land uses in accordance with the Comprehensive Plan, zoning district regulations, and Official Zoning Map with the present and projected future availability of street system capacity. 9.8. To establish and maintain a traffic monitoring system to regularly determine the volume of traffic on the Town's street system and the degree to which capacity limits ("thresholds") are being approached or exceeded. To require that Transportation Impact Analysis Plans are prepared by a licensed Page 27 of 154 Page 9 of 14 professional transportation engineer, and that the plan contents and modeling are consistent with national guidelines and practices published by the Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE), the Transportation Research Board (TB), the Federal Highway Association (FHWA), the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (ASHTO), the National Association of City Transportation Officials. 10.9. It is not the intent of this section to deny to any person a reasonable opportunity to develop land in a beneficial manner, but rather to coordinate the type, location, amount, timing, and rate of development with the Town's reasonable ability to provide adequate public street facilities consistent with the Town's adopted traffic service level standards. To ensure that, in addition to measuring the impact on the roadway system, the transportation impact analysis plan measures the multimodal impacts, and mitigation measures, for non-motorized travel and transit. 10. To establish and maintain a traffic monitoring system to regularly determine the volume of traffic of the Town’s street system and the degree to which capacity limits (“thresholds”) are being approached or exceeded. C. Traffic Service Level Standards All required traffic transportation impact analysis plans shall, at a minimum, indicate compliance or non-compliance with the standards of this section. 1. The average total delay in seconds per vehicle for each signalized intersection does not exceed 55.0 seconds during the peak hour for an average July weekday; and 2. The volume-to-capacity (V/C) ratio for each signalized intersection does not exceed 0.90 during the peak hour for an average July weekday; and 3. The average total day on any approach to a traffic circle or roundabout the Sea Pines Circle does not exceed 150 seconds per vehicle during the peak hour for an average July weekday., and the average total delay on any approach to any other traffic circle or roundabout does not exceed 55.0 seconds per vehicle during the peak hour for an average July weekday; and 4. The Level of Service (LOS) for any vehicular traffic movement does not decline by more than one level per the requirements of the Highway Capacity Manual (HCM), nor to a Level of Service of “F”; and 5. The development causes safety issues or delays that require mitigation as determined by the Town Engineer. Page 28 of 154 Page 10 of 14 Appendix D: Application Submittal Requirements D-11. Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan Review A. Plan Preparation 1. Selection of Traffic Transportation Engineering Firm The Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan shall be prepared for the applicant by a qualified traffic Transportation engineer/engineering firm, selected from a list of traffic engineering firms maintained by the Town. The list shall be created through the solicitation by the Town of professional traffic engineers qualified to perform this service. The list shall contain the names of at least three traffic engineering firms. approved by the Town Engineer or their designee, and sealed by a licensed professional engineer registered in South Carolina. 2. Establishment of Traffic Transportation Impact Plan Parameters a. Prior to beginning the Traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan, the applicant shall supply the Official Town Engineer with the following: I. A written narrative describing the proposed land use(s), size and projected opening date of the project and any phases. The narrative must also identify the Beaufort County Tax Map and parcel numbers to be occupied by the proposed development; II. A site location map; and III. A proposed site plan showing the location of the proposed development on the site and vehicular access to public or private streets or any other development. IV. A study area map or maps that illustrate the intersections to be evaluated in the study, along with the relevant pedestrian and non- motorized pathway systems. The non-motorized map shall generally depict expected walking and bicycling patterns (origan and destinations), where people will cross roadways, and improvements needed. Public transportation systems shall be included in this study area map as well. V. For uses, as determined by the Town Engineer or their designee, a review of the transit or other mobility options, and how they can be accommodated on or near the site. Page 29 of 154 Page 11 of 14 b. Based on this information, along with the ITE Trip Generation Manual and available information on land use, travel patterns and traffic conditions, the Official Town Engineer will supply in writing to the applicant or the applicant's selected engineering firm the parameters to be followed in the study, including the study area for all modes, directional split of driveway traffic, trip distribution to multiple access points, trip distribution on the study area roadway network background traffic growth rate, previously approved or proposed projects that are but not completed projects, and the intersections to be analyzed along with any associated turning movement counts and signal timing data that which are available. B. Submittal Requirements An acceptable traffic transportation impact analysis plan shall include an accurate representation of the following elements: 1. A current site plan or subdivision plat identifying access to and from existing or proposed streets and intersections. In addition, a vicinity map shall be provided. 2. Description of the proposed development, including the type of proposed land use, the number of residential units by type, the number of existing and proposed lots, the type of proposed non-residential development and the amount of such development measured by gross floor area or other appropriate unit of measure, the general size and type of accessory development or facilities, and, for non-residential development, adequate information to identify the appropriate land use category or categories for trip generation. 3. Traffic, pedestrian, and bicycle counts must be collected and analyzed if the existing data is more than two years old or is determined to be unavailable by Town Engineer. The existing conditions shall consider and include any development in the study area that has generated a previous application for a TIAP study or other development in the study area that is projected to occur within five (5) years from the TIAP study as determined by the Town Engineer. Projected vehicular trips to and from the completed development, or any interim development phases, on the adjacent street during the a.m. and p.m. peak hours of the surrounding roadway network. In some cases the Town Engineer may also require an analysis of Saturday conditions or the peak hours of the proposed land-use. The percentage of passerby pass-by trips, if used in the plan, shall be included, as well as the source of this information. The trips shall be presented as “Multi-Modal Trips” with a listing of pass-by trips, internal trips (within the development), pedestrian, bicycle, transit, ride- hailing, or other trips. In cases where multi-use pathway segments or pathway crossings are being impacted by the development, the Town Engineer shall also require analysis of projected levels-of-service. Page 30 of 154 Page 12 of 14 4. A written narrative setting forth the assumptions upon which any projection, made in developing the traffic transportation impact analysis plan required under this part, is based upon. If the assumptions are derived from the ITE manual, the materials excerpts shall be identified. If the assumptions are not from the ITE manual, appropriate excerpts will the referenced materials shall be included in the study and the reasoning underlying the assumptions shall be stated in the narrative. If the project predicts fewer auto trips due to various travel demand management measures, assurances that those measures will be applied and are enforceable will be determined by the Town Engineer. 5. The traffic Transportation Impact Analysis Plan study shall be based on intersection analysis procedures for signalized intersections and roundabouts or traffic circles as identified in the Transportation Research Board's (TRB) current Highway Capacity Manual Special Report 209 and utilize computer software which emulates these procedures and is acceptable to the Official Town Engineer. Any analysis involving a traffic circle will utilize computer software which is designed to analyze traffic circles and is acceptable to the Official. The results of any required computer analysis shall, at a minimum, indicate compliance or non-compliance with the traffic transportation standards of Sec. 16-5-106, Traffic Transportation Analysis Standards. 6. Safety data in the study area, when required by the Town Engineer, shall include the types of collisions. The study should describe how safety will be influenced by the project’s transportation impacts and evaluate potential solutions. Potential mitigation measures shall be consistent with the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials AASAHTO Highway Safety Manual, Federal Highways Administration (FHWA) guides on non- motorized crossings, and other national research. 7. The impact on non-motorized travel shall be based on the procedures and practices recommended by ITE, Transportation Research Board (TRB), AASHTO and FHWA. The applicant shall incorporate where possible any non- motorized recommendations included in Town and/or regional long-term plans in the vicinity of the site. The study should identify potential changes such as: a. Improvements to pedestrian crossings; b. Additional pedestrian or bicycle crossings; c. Improvements to pedestrian signals, pedestrian signal intervals, signs, and pavement markings; d. Construction of additional sidewalks or non-motorized pathways; e. Changes to the site design and access to ease non-motorized travel and reduce conflicts with vehicles, from the public right-of-way to the building entrances or on-site activity; and f. Other similar improvements to transportation facilities. Page 31 of 154 Page 13 of 14 6.8. The intersections which must be analyzed in the study are identified as: a. Any signalized intersection that serves as a development's point of access to a major arterial. This will include intersections of public and private roads with major arterials, and driveways offering direct access to a major arterial; and b. The first signalized intersection on either side of the development's primary point of access to a major arterial; and c. Other signalized intersections on major arterials if within 1 road mile of the development's primary point of access to a major arterial and when in the opinion of the Official Town Engineer there is a potential for a significant impact to the intersection's level of service from site related site-related traffic; and d. Any traffic circle or roundabout, when in the opinion of the Official Town Engineer, there is a potential for a significant impact to the circle's level of service from site related traffic. 7.9. At a minimum, the plan must include the results of a computerized analysis projecting the operating conditions of critical intersections relative to signalized intersections and roundabouts or traffic circles identified in 8. above. The intersections shall meet the Town's adopted traffic service level standards outlined in 16-5-106. All other intersections must be projected to operate at levels of service acceptable to the Town Engineer. The analysis shall reflect the projected condition of these intersections and movements based on the full operation and/or build-out of the development date of the development and, where applicable, on other significant phase-in dates of the development project. 8.10. If the initial computerized analysis indicates that the Town's adopted traffic service level standards will be not be met, a mitigation plan must be included in the plan based on at least one additional computer analysis. This mitigation plan must show how the Town's adopted traffic service level standards will be satisfied. Applicants will only shall be responsible to mitigate the traffic transportation impacts. of their proposed development. Acceptable roadway mitigation measures are limited to the following: a. Traffic signal timing adjustments; timing or phasing revisions, that not only mitigate traffic impacts generated by this development, but also result in safe and acceptable operations at the study intersection as demonstrated by a network traffic analysis; b. Traffic signal phasing adjustments; Addition of signs, signals, markings, or other measures to accommodate road crossings and improve safety for pedestrians and achieve ADA compliance; c. Pavement marking revisions; Page 32 of 154 Page 14 of 14 d. Adding additional intersection turn lanes not to exceed 4 lanes on minor arterial approaches and 5 lanes on major arterial approaches; and e. Geometric improvements to traffic circles or roundabouts signalized or unsignalized intersections, including traffic circles or roundabouts, to improve traffic operations, pedestrian and bicycle operations or to improve safety; f. Road widening; g. Adding a traffic signal at a location that is warranted per the Manual of Uniform Traffic Control (MUTCD); h. Replacing a traffic signal or uncontrolled intersection with a roundabout that meets the Town’s operational and design standards; i. Changes to locations or design of median crossovers to reduce congestion and mitigate accidents; j. Removal of changes to the number and location, or design of access points to reduce congestion and mitigate accidents; k. Additional signage; l. Other transportation-related safety improvements identified and/or recommended by the Town Engineer. Page 33 of 154 Page 1 of 5 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND PLANNING DEPARTMENT One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island, SC 29928 843-341-4757 FAX 843-842-8908 STAFF REPORT NEW STREET NAME Case # New Street Name Public Hearing Date STDV-000243-2025 Red Fox Manor April 16, 2025 Parcel Data or Location: Applicant/Agent R511 003 000 0138 0000 AGENT – Rich Stone 386 Spanish Wells Road Unit B4 Hilton Head Island, SC 29926 Application Summary STDV-000243-2025 – Public Hearing request from Rich Stone of Stone by Stone Design, on behalf of Susana Legare, property owner, for a new street name request off Outlaw Road. The affected parcel is R511 003 000 0138 0000. Staff Recommendation Staff recommends the Planning Commission approve the Red Fox Manor street name application based on the criteria outlined in Land Management Ordinance Section 16-2-103.O.4 and enclosed herein. Background Rich Stone, Agent for the property located at 7 Outlaw Road, proposes to name an access easement located off Outlaw Road. See Attachment 1, Location Map. Red Fox Manor will provide direct access to 3 homes on the parcel. Due to the zoning in this area (WMU – Water Oriented Mixed Use), the residential dwelling unit density would allow up to 3 more homes on the parcel located at 9 Outlaw Road. This street will serve 3 homes and could potentially serve up to 3 more in the future The new road will provide direct access to the proposed single -family dwelling units located on the new access created off Outlaw Road. Page 34 of 154 Page 2 of 5 See Attachment B, Applicant Narrative and Plan. As set forth in LMO Section 16-2-103.O.3.d, Decision-Making Body Review and Decision, the Commission shall hold a public hearing and make a final decision on the application based on the standards in LMO Section 16-2-103.O.4, Street/Vehicular Access Easement Review Standards. Summary of Facts and Conclusion of Law Criterion A: No new street or vehicular access easement, or proposed modification of the name of an existing street or vehicular access easement, shall duplicate, be phonetically similar to, or in any way be likely to be confused with an existing street or vehicular access easement, despite of the use of prefixes or suffixes. (LMO Section 16-2-103.O.4.a). Findings of Fact: 1. Town staff, Town Fire & Rescue Dispatch, and Beaufort County Dispatch have determined Red Fox Manor is not duplicated within the Town or Beaufort County. 2. Town staff, Town Fire & Rescue Dispatch, and Beaufort County Dispatch have determined Red Fox Manor is not phonetically similar to an existing street or vehicular access easement. 3. Town staff, Town Fire & Rescue Dispatch, and Beaufort County Dispatch have determined Red Fox Manor will not likely be confused with an existing street or vehicular access easement. Conclusion of Law: 1. The proposed street name Red Fox Manor mmeets the requirements of this criterion. Summary of Facts and Conclusion of Law Criterion B: Name(s) shall be simple, logical, easy to read and pronounce, and are clear and brief. Use of frivolous or complicated words or unconventional spellings in names shall not be approved. (LMO Section 16-2-103.O.4.b). Findings of Fact: 1. Town staff, Fire & Rescue Dispatch, and Beaufort County Dispatch determined Red Fox Manor is simple, logical, easy to read and pronounce. 2. Town staff, Fire & Rescue Dispatch, and Beaufort County Dispatch determined Red Fox Manor is clear and brief. 3. Town staff, Fire & Rescue Dispatch, and Beaufort County Dispatch determined Red Fox Manor does not include frivolous or complicated words or unconventional spelling. Page 35 of 154 Page 3 of 5 Conclusion of Law: 1. The proposed street name Red Fox Manor mmeets the requirements of this criterion. Summary of Facts and Conclusions of Law Criterion C: It is desirable to use names that have some association with Hilton Head Island and specifically with the immediate location of the street or place, such as reference to local history or physiographic features. (LMO Section 16-2-103.O.4.c). Finding of Fact: 1. The proposed street name Red Fox Manor was chosen because the Red Fox is a species native to South Carolina, known for its adaptability and cleverness. The name reflects the State’s diverse wildlife. Conclusion of Law: 1. The proposed street name Red Fox Manor mmeets the requirements of this criterion. Summary of Facts and Conclusion of Law Criterion D: Use of a common theme is recommended for names of streets that are associated with one another, such as those within a residential development. (LMO Section 16-2-103.O.4.d). Findings of Fact: 1. The proposed name is Red Fox Manor. 2. Though Red Fox Manor is not associated with the names of streets within the development, it is not prohibited. Conclusion of Law: 1. The proposed street name Red Fox Manor mmeets the requirements of this criterion. Summary of Facts and Conclusion of Law Criterion E: Streets or vehicular access easements that continue through an intersection should generally bear the same name, except where the street crosses a major arterial or where existing address points on a street require that the street given a different name. (LMO Section 16-2-103.O.4.e). Finding of Fact: 1. The proposed Red Fox Manor does not continue through an intersection. Conclusion of Law: 1. T his criterion does not apply to this application. Page 36 of 154 Page 4 of 5 Summary of Facts and Conclusion of Law Criterion F: A street or vehicular access easement making an approximate right-angle turn where there is no possibility of extending the street or vehicular access easement in either direction shall be considered to be continuous and continue the same name. Where there is a choice of direction or a possibility of extending either section in the future, such configuration shall be considered to be an intersection and the street/easement segments extending from the intersection shall bear different names. (LMO Section 16-2-103.O.4.f). Findings of Fact: 1. The proposed Red Fox Manor would not make a right-angle turn. Conclusion of Law: 1. This criterion dooes not apply to this application. Summary of Facts and Conclusion of Law Criterion G. New or modified street names should generally use Drive, Lane, Place, Road, Street, or Way as suffixes. The following street designations should only be used if the street design meets one of the following descriptions. This list is not intended to limit the use of other appropriate suffixes. 1. Alley – A street providing vehicular access to the rear of lots or buildings, usually as a secondary means of access to a property. 2. Avenue – A street that is continuous. 3. Boulevard – A street with a landscaped median dividing the roadway. 4. Circle – A street with a complete loop on the end or a side street that intersects another street at two adjacent intersections. 5. Court – A street terminating in a cul-de-sac, not longer than 1,000 feet in length. 6. Extension – A section of street forming an additional length. 7. Parkway – A street designated as a collector or arterial road, with a landscaped median reflecting the parkway character implied in the name. (LMO Section 16-2-103.O.4.g). Finding of Fact: The proposed roadway is an access easement. Conclusion of Law: 1. T his criterion does not apply to this application. Summary of Facts and Conclusion of Law Criterion H. The suffixes Manor, Trace, and Common shall typically be used to name vehicular access easements. (LMO Section 16-2-103.O.4.h). Finding of Fact: 1. The proposed name is Red Fox Manor. Page 37 of 154 Page 5 of 5 Conclusion of Law: 1. The proposed street name Red Fox Manor m eets the requirements of this criterion. Summary of Facts and Conclusions of Law Criterion I. Where natural barriers, intervening land uses, or developments that break an existing street into two separate streets that are not likely to be reconnected in the future, the streets shall be named in a manner that considers the potential economic impact of the number of address points and type of addresses impacted. (LMO Section 16-2-103.O.4.i). Finding of Fact: 1. The subject street is not broken into two separate streets. Conclusion of Law: 1. This criterion does not apply to this application. PREPARED BY: JF March 31, 2025 Joheida Fister DATE Deputy Fire Chief REVIEWED BY: TL April 1, 2025 Trey Lowe, Development Services Manager DATE REVIEWED BY: SF April 1, 2025 Shea Farrar, Principal Planner & Planning Commission Coordinator DATE ATTACHMENTS: A) Location Map B) Applicant’s Narrative and Plan Page 38 of 154 ONE TOWN CENTER COURTHILTON HEAD ISLAND, S.C. 29928PHONE (843) 341- 4600 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND 7 Outlaw Road October 2024 Town of Hilton Head Island 0.01 0 0.01 0.02 0.030.005 Miles The information on this map has been compiled from a variety of sources and is intended to be used only as a guide. It is provided without any warranty or representation as to the accuracy or completeness of the data shown. The Town of Hilton Head Island assumes no liability for its accuracy or state of completion or for any losses arising from the use of the map. ® F U L L E R P O I N T E D R I V E O U T L A W R O A D SQUIRE POPE ROAD M A R V I N L A N E WRIGHT PLACE B E R M U D A P O I N T E C I R C L E 12 12 18 238 26 23 32 44 244 28 255u 20 38 26 229 16 18 7 1 12 4 11 20 13 4 33 48 9 24 25 22 42 49 90 10 31 36 8 30 27 36 27 18 34 21 14 234 14 94 32 16 46 23 91 7 28 22 24 40 6 101 92 3 16 19 10 10 28 Subject Property Page 39 of 154 1. Osprey Drive Named after the Osprey, a bird of prey commonly found near coastal and freshwater areas in South Carolina. Ospreys are known for their impressive fishing skills. 2. Palmetto Lane While palmettos are plants, the palmetto tree is also associated with the Carolina Wren, a small bird that often nests in these trees. The name reflects the natural habitat of native wildlife. 3. Alligator Way This name references the American alligator, a common native species found in South Carolina swamps, lagoons and rivers. Alligators play a vital role in the ecosystem. 4. Red Fox Road Named after the Red Fox, which is native to South Carolina and Known for its adaptability and cleverness. This street name highlights the state's diverse wildlife. 5. River Otter Way This name honors the river otter, a playful and social animal found in South Carolina's rivers and marshes, symbolizing the state's rich aquatic ecosystem. 6. White Tail Lane Named after the White-tailed deer, a common sight in South Carolina's forests and rural areas. Deer are an important part of the state's wildlife and hunting culture. Attachment B - Applicant Narrative and Plan Page 40 of 154 • VICINITY MAP I I N.T.S. '! 1,. SYMBOLS .T CMF 3" CONCRETE MONUMENT FOUND 1" IPPF O - 1" IRON PPE FOUND TELEPHONE SERVICE TElEVISIC>N SERVICE VALVE BOX A1C HEAT PUMP TBM - TEMPORARY BENCH MARK / / / / /i I Is 1/ I "' I OUTLAW ROAD 20' R/W REFERENCE PL.ATS LOT 1 R511 003000011J0OOO FENNELL BILLY E 68 SANDPIPER LANE WEST HARDEEVILLE SC 29927 1)A DIVISIONOf TAX MAP 3, PARCEL 12. SOUIRE POPEROAO . TOWN OF Htl TON HEAD ISlANO. BEAUFORT COUNTY, S.C. DRAWN: 5/J0/95, LAST REVISED: 8121195 RECORDED IN BOOK , P.il3E , OATm 8/241'95 ROD. BEAUFORT COUNTY, SC BY: FORREST F. BAUGHMAN S.C.R.L.S. I 4922 2) A BOUNDA RY SURVEY OF LOT 6-€ , OUTLAW ROAD , TOWN OF Hll TON HEAD ISLAND, BEAUFORT COUNTY, S.C. ORAWN: SISl29l202• BY: TERRY G. HATCHELL S.C .R.L.S . I 11059 PROPERTY AREA = 0.25 AC. 11,036 S.F. ADDRESS: 7 OUTLAW ROAD DISTRICT: 51 1, MAP: 3, PARCEL: 138 I I ~ // N:143788 .33 / E:2076517 .28 3-~P' / I I \ z ·~ .: ~ 1-, "l rn lll :. "' 1"1PPF z q 2 -t rn ~ ~ ' 1"1PPF N:143720 .38 E:2076-458.76 \ I I I I I I THIS PROPERTY LIES IN F.E.M.A. ZONE X SHADED - N/A COMMUNITY NO. 450250, PANEL: 0432G, DATED: 3/23/2021 fl ·, DRPLNE 0 '\ 18" HICKORY \ ~ ,f> ,f<,o .;; OUT LAW ROAD 25' EASEMENT TBM NAIL IN A 20" LIVE OAK ELEVATION: 13.00' NAVO 88 R511003000011GOOOO OUTLAW DOROTHY M 4621 DARLENE ST NORTH CHARLE STON SC 29405 ---- ---eOOEOFD,RTROAD--- -- '.] S45"25'06 "E - 123.86' ~ LOT 6-E 1'1P PF REPAIR± 150' OF OUTLAW ROAD TO SQUIRE POPE ROAD AND REPLACE WITH 20' ALL WEATHER ROAD ~ 303' TO NEAREST FIRE HYDRANT ' I I j!!: 11111 1l1il ttM 'f lt!!li ,1, I lii i I ' • I ! ' ~ · -!­ ~ct~o -1. . 10' BUILDING SETBACK LINE & - - - - - - TYPE A OPTION 1 BUFFER I I I " NOTES : N45"45'36"W- 123.83' LOT 6-F R511 003 000 0139 0000 GRANT CORNELL 3780 MISTY LAKE 3780 ELLENWOOD GA 30294 1). TH IS Pl.AT HAS BEEN PREPARED WITttOUT BENEFIT OF A COMPLETE rme SEARCH BY NANOINA. NC. 2). lHIS PROPERTY MAY BE SUBJECT TO EASEMENTS Of RECORD ANO COVENANT RESTRICTIONS AS RECORDED IN THE OFFICE Of THE ROD FOR BEAUFORT COUNTY. 3). SUBJECT PROPERTY DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE AFFECTED BY THE BEACHFRONT SETBACK REQUIREMENTS OF THE S.C. BEACH PROTECTION ACT OF JULY 1, 1968. 4). BULOING SETBACKS, WHETHER SHOWN OR NOT, SHOULD BE VERIFIED BY THE LOCAi.. BU LONG AUTHORITY. OFF-St REET \ PARK~lilG I • ; \ I ~~ Ll~l---~oi\_JI \l ~l I ~~ --'----r- I ~~ ml I ~- OFF-STREET \/ PARKl~G \ OFF-S7IREET PARKING I I I I I I I I I I I '~ ~ 1 I ~ ~ NEW "ALL WEATHER" ROAD CENTERED WITHIN RECORDED EASEMENT LOT 6-C R511 003 000 0136 0000 AIKEN GRANT ESTELLE KING GRANT LILLIAN PO BOX 21093 HILTON HEAD ISLAND SC 29925 MANUFACTURED HOME SITE PLAN OF: 1•1PPF LOT 6-E, OUTLAW ROAD, HILTON HEAD ISLAND, R51 1 003 000 0137 0000 AIKEN ESTELLA G PO BOX21093 HILTON HEAD ISL SC 29925 I I ~ OT 6-D I BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA PREPARED FOR: OUTLAW HHI, LLC I ~ ! ':lj -' I IS :i:: i !J I- • :, 3 0,3 1 :i: ~ I DATE : 10/02/2024 REVISED: 1/16/202S SCALE : 1" = 16' I ----- A ...... ~ ~~ CA~o( ~~ CA~o( 0~ /1, 0~ flc.5S/ '1, ~ ~.~~DINA INC~'>' • C:, q~O LANO~ 'Y ~ I ~ SEA ISLAND I ~ 1 ~6.C06703 / ~~ ~ .-.-.-i ■ ■ GRAPHIC SCALE ••• •11 0- 7'2 NRNDINR d.b.a Sea ls~nd land Survey, Inc. 10 Oak Pal1c Drive, Ur,1 C1 , I 48 5). TREE PROTECTION ZONES FOR A.Hr TREES LOCATED WITHIN 25" Of ANY PROPOSED GRADING, CONSTRUCTION, OR TREE REMOVALS. THESE PHYSICM. BARRIERS WILL BE MAINTANEO UNTL SUCH TIME TliAT THE WORK IS COMPLETED ON THE SITE. THE BARR E RS WU BE INST AL.LEO BEFORE THE HOME IS Pl.ACED AND A PRE..Q.EAR INSPECTION MUST BE PASSED TO VERIFY PROPER INSTALLATION. =~LANO SURVEY, ii~ SURVEYOR ~ / ~<99~~ NOTVALDUNLESSEMSOSSEO. ,,,,,_ ft;....~ Hilon Head Island, SC 29926 FILE No : 24202 Tel (843) 681'1248 E-mai: admin@nandinainc.com DWG No. : 7-24202 CERTIFI CATE OF AUTHORIZATION -IIIKT~-l'C. Page 41 of 154 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court ⬧ Hilton Head Island ⬧ South Carolina ⬧ 29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND Planning Commission TO: Planning Commission FROM: Darrin A. Shoemaker, P.E., Consulting Engineer CC: Missy Luick, Director of Planning, LMO Official Jeff Netzinger, P.E., Engineering and Projects Director Theresa McVey, Traffic Operations Manager DATE: April 16, 2025 SUBJECT: 2024 Traffic Monitoring and Evaluation Report RECOMMENDATION: The Planning Commission review and consider the 2024 Traffic Monitoring and Evaluation Report, discuss its findings and recommendations, and elicit public comments at the meeting in accordance with Section 16-2-103.J.10.c of the Land Management Ordinance (LMO). It is further recommended that the Planning Commission provide its comments on the report as well as any supplemental comments or recommendations to Town Council in accordance with Section 16-2-103.J.10.c.ii of the LMO. SUMMARY: This report and recommendations provided herein are prepared and respectfully submitted to the Planning Commission in accordance with the requirements outlined in Section 16 -2- 103.J.10 of the Town’s LMO as Attachment 1. Accordingly, the report summarizes trends relating to traffic demands within the Town, including July weekday traffic counts taken at intersections and on major arterials. Also summarized in the report are the results of operational analyses for the weekday morning and afternoon peak volume hours recorded at all the Town’s signalized intersections and Sea Pines Circle. The report includes mitigation recommendations for intersections found to be non-compliant with the operational goals outlined in LMO Section 16-5-106.C. The only intersection found deficient relative to these goals in July 2024 was that of William Hilton Parkway with Squire Pope Road and Chamberlin Drive during the weekday afternoon peak volume hour. Continuous traffic counts taken on the Town’s major arterials during a consecutive Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday in July 2024 indicated that demand increased 1.1 percent relative to comparable counts taken in July 2023. In aggregate, the recorded traffic volume was the highest ever collected by the Town during the annual visitor season count, supplanting the 2021 counts. Aggregate demand was 5.8 percent higher in July 2024 than that collected five years previous in 2019, an increase that translates to an effective annual rate-of-increase that is also 1.1 percent per annum. Morning and afternoon peak-hour demand on the Town’s signalized intersections increased 0.5 and 1 .1 percent, respectively, relative to the 202 3 Page 42 of 154 Page 2 of 2 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court ⬧ Hilton Head Island ⬧ South Carolina ⬧ 29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov counts. Total peak hour demand on Sea Pines Circle, however, decreased 4.5 percent from its previous count taken in 2022. Off-street pedestrian and bicycle crossings at the Town’s signalized intersections declined 8.8 percent from July 2023, but remains 46 percent higher than that counted five years ago in 2019, an effective rate -of-increase of 7.9 percent per annum during the most recent five-year period. Demand on the Cross -Island Parkway, the Fraser Bridge, and Palmetto Bay Road has increased an effective 26.4 percent since the end of toll collections in June 2021. Approximately 38.5 percent of on- and off-island traffic is using the Cross Island Parkway versus Wm. Hilton Pkwy., compared with 31.5 percent prior to the ending of toll collections. BACKGROUND: Section 16-2-103.J.10 of the LMO provides that this report be prepared and submitted annually to the Planning Commission for their review and discussion at a public meeting. The report is based on traffic counts that are collected annually by the Town each July on typical weekdays, Tuesday through Thursday. The 24-hour arterial counts reflected in the report were collected from Tuesday, June 9th through Thursday, June 11th, 2024, and all of the intersection turning movement counts were collected on Tuesday, July 9th, 2024. The counts were certified by the LMO Official as required by Section 16-2-103.J.10.b on January 6th, 2025. Upon their certification in this regard, the traffic counts summarized herein became the Town’s background dataset for existing traffic demand for use by staff, consultants, and development applicants in their preparation of Traffic Impact Analysis Plan studies that are required to be submitted to the Town as part of the development review process. ATTACHMENTS: 1) 2024 Traffic Monitoring and Evaluation Report Page 43 of 154 Page 44 of 154 Page 45 of 154 Page 46 of 154 Page 47 of 154 Page 48 of 154 Page 49 of 154 Page 50 of 154 Page 51 of 154 Page 52 of 154 Page 53 of 154 Page 54 of 154 Page 55 of 154 Page 56 of 154 Page 57 of 154 Page 58 of 154 Page 59 of 154 Page 60 of 154 Page 61 of 154 Page 62 of 154 Page 63 of 154 Page 64 of 154 Page 65 of 154 Page 66 of 154 Page 67 of 154 Page 68 of 154 Page 69 of 154 Page 70 of 154 Page 71 of 154 Page 72 of 154 Page 73 of 154 Page 74 of 154 Page 75 of 154 Page 76 of 154 Page 77 of 154 Page 78 of 154 Page 79 of 154 Page 80 of 154 Page 81 of 154 Page 82 of 154 Page 83 of 154 Page 84 of 154 Page 85 of 154 Page 86 of 154 Page 87 of 154 Page 88 of 154 Page 89 of 154 Page 90 of 154 Page 91 of 154 Page 92 of 154 Page 93 of 154 Page 94 of 154 Page 95 of 154 Page 96 of 154 Page 97 of 154 Page 98 of 154 Page 99 of 154 Page 100 of 154 Page 101 of 154 Page 102 of 154 Page 103 of 154 Page 104 of 154 Page 105 of 154 Page 106 of 154 Page 107 of 154 Page 108 of 154 Page 109 of 154 Page 110 of 154 Page 111 of 154 Page 112 of 154 Page 113 of 154 Page 114 of 154 Page 115 of 154 Page 116 of 154 Page 117 of 154 Page 118 of 154 Page 119 of 154 Page 120 of 154 Page 121 of 154 Page 122 of 154 Page 123 of 154 Page 124 of 154 Page 125 of 154 Page 126 of 154 Page 127 of 154 Page 128 of 154 Page 129 of 154 Page 130 of 154 Page 131 of 154 Page 132 of 154 Page 133 of 154 Page 134 of 154 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court ⬧ Hilton Head Island ⬧ South Carolina ⬧ 29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 1 of 9 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND Planning Commission TO: Planning Commission FROM: Missy Luick, Director of Planning CC: Shawn Leininger, Assistant Town Manager CC: Marc Orlando, Town Manager DATE: April 16, 2025 SUBJECT: Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island to Amend Chapter 16 of the Municipal Code, the Land Management Ordinance, to Amend the Current Regulations for the Measurement of Height and Setback Encroachments for Residential and Nonresidential Development to Include Sections: 16-5-102 & 16-10- 102 RECOMMENDATION: Planning Commission postpone the hearing and consideration of this amendment be to the May 21, 2025, Planning Commission meeting. Additional public notice is needed to include the Character Overlay Zoning Districts in LMO Section 16-3-106 in the proposed amendments. The information in this report will serve as a preview of the materials to be provided next month. BACKGROUND: Revitalize and Modernize the Economy is a focus area in the adopted Town Council 2023- 2025 Strategic Action Plan. In fulfillment of this focus area, Strategy #1 Establish a Growth Management Strategy states the Town will: “Successfully manage increasing and evolving future growth patterns in a manner that will ensure sustainability of Hilton Head Island’s unique character. Additionally, the Town must monitor economic and demographic trends, undertaking a comprehensive list o f future planning activities, and proactively protecting the Island’s rich natural resources through appropriate design, regulation, and capital investment practices.” In this regard, Town Council directed Town Staff to advance amendments to the Land Management Ordinance (LMO) in the 2024 Strategic Action Work Plan. The effort has been divided into two separate projects, the f ull LMO Overhaul and the priority amendments. The priority amendments include incremental changes to both the LMO Page 135 of 154 Page 2 of 9 and portions of the Municipal Code related to land management that address important and urgent issues in advance of the full LMO Overhaul. These priority amendments address pressing community development issues with the best short-term solution while minimizing unintended outcomes. Issues that require additional analysis and research or are more complex are recommended to be further explored during the full LMO Overhaul. At the September 16, 2024, Town Council Workshop, Town staff received the following comments and direction regarding amendments related to the measurement of height and setback encroachments for residential and commercial development Residential: 1. Changes need to apply to existing subdivisions where possible. Current building heights are too high. 2. There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. 3. Need to increase setbacks. 4. Need to establish minimum lot sizes (to be addressed during the full LMO update). Commercial: 1. Current building heights are too high. 2. There needs to be more light, air, and separation between units. Need to increase setbacks. 3. Need to establish minimum lot sizes (to be addressed during the full LMO update). 4. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). SUMMARY OF AMENDMENT: The mass and scale of recent developments ha ve been of concern for both residential and commercial developments. New buildings are often larger and out of character with the existing surroundings. This Priority Amendment will modify how height is measured and reduce the allowable setback encroachments. Current regulations require that building heights be measured relative to flood zone elevations, which effectively increases the allowable height of the building. This amendment would change this to measure height from the pre -development grade elevation. This will provide a more accurate representation of the building’s scale relative to the surrounding landscape by adjusting the building height measurement. Current regulations also permit significant projections/ encroachments into setback areas. This amendment will provide more separation between buildings. Both of these changes will help to reduce the overall mass and scale of development in single-family and commercial building types. As part of the final review of the proposed amendments, Town Staff identified three additional paragraphs in the LMO that referenced measuring the setback angle from 20 feet above a point 13 feet above mean sea level. These three references are located within the Forest Beach Neighborhood Character Overlay (FB-NC O) District, Folly Field Page 136 of 154 Page 3 of 9 Neighborhood Character Overlay (FF -NC-O) District, and the Holiday Homes Neighborhood Character Overlay (HH -NC-O) District. Since the public notice did not reference Section 16 -3-106, where the subject overlay districts are located additional public notice is needed resulting in the request to introduce these proposed amendments, collect any initial feedback, and postpone the public hearing. ANALYSIS: Proposed Amendments The following table demonstrates how the proposed amendments address demonstrated issues. Issue Proposed Amendment There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). Sec.16-3-106. Overlay Zoning Districts H. Forest Beach Neighborhood Character Overlay (FB-NC O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks ii. Setbacks shall comply with the standards of Sec. 16- 5-102, Setback Standards, except that the 65 degree setback angle shall be measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). Sec.16-3-106. Overlay Zoning Districts I. Folly Field Neighborhood Character Overlay (FF-NC-O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks iii. Maximum setback angle of 65 degrees shall be measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. Sec.16-3-106. Overlay Zoning Districts Page 137 of 154 Page 4 of 9 There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). J. Holiday Homes Neighborhood Character Overlay (HH-NC-O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks ii. 03.Side yard setback angles shall be a minimum of 65 degrees measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher, at the setback line. The illustration in Sec. 16-5-102.D, Adjacent Use Setback Requirements, can be referenced for an example of a setback angle. There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). Sec.16-5-102. Setback Standards C. Adjacent Street Setback Requirements Table 16-5-102.C Notes: 2. Measured within the upper inward quadrant of the intersection of a horizontal plane at a height of 20 feet above 13 feet above Mean Sea Level for residential use or 11 feet above Mean Sea Level for nonresidential use, or pre-development grade , whichever is higher, and a vertical plane extending upward at the minimum setback distance (see Figure 16-5-102.C, Street Setback Angle). There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property). Sec.16-5-102. Setback Standards D. Adjacent Use Setback Requirements Table 16-5-102.D Notes: 2. Measured within the upper inward quadrant of the intersection of a horizontal plane at a height of 20 feet above 13 feet above Mean Sea Level for residential use or 11 feet above Mean Sea Level for nonresidential use, or pre-development grade , whichever is higher, and a vertical plane extending upward at the minimum setback distance (see Figure 16-5-102.D, Use Setback Angle). Page 138 of 154 Page 5 of 9 Need to increase setbacks. Sec.16-5-102. Setback Standards E. Allowable Setback Encroachments TABLE 16-5-102.E: ALLOWABLE SETBACK ENCROACHMENTS Fences or walls • Allowed in adjacent use setbacks if located along common property lines and no more than 7 feet high • Allowed in adjacent street setbacks if less than 4 feet high Open balconies, fire escapes, or exterior stairways May extend up to 5 feet into any setback Chimneys or fireplaces1 May extend up to 3 feet into any setback if no more than 5 feet higher than the highest point of building to which it is attached Roof eaves and overhangs1 May extend up to 3 feet into any setback Awnings1 May extend up to 5 feet into any setback Bay windows1 May extend up to 3 feet into any setback if no more than 9 feet wide Sills or entablatures1 May extend up to 1 foot into any setback Uncovered porches, stoops, decks, patios or terraces May extend up to 5 feet into any setback Lighting fixtures May be located in any setback if no more than 20 feet high Roof dormers1 May extend up to 5 feet beyond the setback angle plane (horizontally or vertically) Spires, cupolas, domes, skylights, and similar rooftop architectural features May extend up above the setback angle plane if they occupy no more than 25% of the roof area of the structure to which they are attached and Page 139 of 154 Page 6 of 9 extend no more than 25% more than the height limit defined by the setback angle plane at the point(s) of penetration Solar collection devices See Sec. 16-4-103.E.8 Television or radio antennas1 May extend up to 10 feet above the setback angle plane if they are attached to a side or rear elevation of a structure Small wind energy conversion systems See Sec. 16-4-103.E.7 Amateur radio antenna See Sec. 16-4-103.E.1 Bike racks, bollards and other site furnishings (such as tables and chairs) Allowed in adjacent use and adjacent street setbacks Other architectural features not listed above (parts of a structure that provide visual interest to the structure and are nonhabitable and decorative in nature) May be allowed to penetrate the plane of the setback angle if the Official makes the following determinations: • The required setback angle cannot be met for the architectural elements using alternate site layouts without major modifications to an otherwise acceptable application; • The excepted architectural elements will not be major or dominant features of the structure; • The excepted architectural elements will not penetrate the vertical plane of the minimum required setback distance; • The exception is the minimum reasonably required to achieve the architectural goal; and • If applicable, the placement of the Page 140 of 154 Page 7 of 9 structure provides protection of prominent natural features on the site, such as trees, wetlands, or historic sites. Flagpoles/Flags Unless they constitute a "sign" and thus subject to Sec. 16-5-114.E, Flagpoles no more than 20 feet high and flags no greater than 20 square feet in area may be located in setbacks Signs See Sec. 16-5-114.E 1In no case shall an allowable encroachment for a listed feature extend into a setback to a point that is less than 10 feet from a lot line. Current building heights are too high. Chapter 16-10: Definitions, Interpretation, and Measurement Sec.16-10-102. Rules of Measurement C. Height 1. Calculation of Height a. Maximum structure height for development in each zoning district shall be measured from pre-development grade immediately adjacent to the structure to a point level with the highest point of the structure. as follows: Nonconformities Changes to building height calculations and allowable setback encroachments may result in the creation of nonconforming structures (structures that do not comply with current dimensional standards). Such structures are permitted to exist and to be maintained. They are impacted when they are expanded, relocated, altered, or damaged. Chapter 16 -7 provides standards for nonconformities. The purpose statement of the Nonconformities Chapter reads as follows: “The zoning regulations and development standards established by this Ordinance are designed to guide the future development and redevelopment of land within the Town by Page 141 of 154 Page 8 of 9 encouraging and regulating site development and appropriate groupings of compatible and related uses that promote and protect the public health, safety, and general welfare. While the Town recognizes the continued existence of nonconformities is generally inconsistent with the purpose and intent of this Ordinance, it also recognizes this Ordinance needs to provide flexibility to encourage redevelopment of nonconforming development if it lessens the degree of the nonconformity and if redevelopment is consistent with the goals of the Comprehensive Plan and the district in which the development is located. This Chapter provides for the regulation of nonconforming uses, structures, signs, and site features, and specifies those circumstances and conditions under which such nonconformities are allowed to continue and redevelop.” Legally nonconforming structures that are damaged or destroyed by means not covered by Chapter 16 -9: Disaster Recovery (including intentional human destruction), may be repaired, reconstructed, or rebuilt only in accordance with the following requirements. In the case of damaged structures: The LMO also provides an exception for single -family structures that are damaged or destroyed that states, “A single -family dwelling unit existing within the Town that is damaged or destroyed, and is either permitted in the district in which it is located, or is a legally established nonconforming use in that district, may be rebuilt, restored or repaired consistent with the requirements of Title 15 of the Municipal Code.” Title 15 of the Municipal Code refers to building code standards. For other structures, the degree of damage is considered in two scenarios: A building permit may be issued to rebuild, restore, or repair a legal nonconforming structure within 18 months of damage or destruction of not more than 50 percent of its appraised fair market value immediately prior to the damage. A legal nonconforming structure damaged or destroyed to the extent of 50 percent or more of its appraised fair market value immediately prior to the damage shall not be repaired or replaced except in accordance with the requirements of this Ordinance. In the case of redevelopment: To provide flexibility and encourage redevelopment of sites with nonconforming features or structures, the Town adopted a process in Sec. 16 -7-101.F, Substitution of Nonconformities for Redevelopment, that allows for more flexibility with nonnormalities. The Official is authorized to approve a Development Plan for such sites if the proposed development: 1. Will not include any new development that increases the amount of encroachment into any required buffer or setback; 2. Will not increase the impervious cover on the site over the maximum allowed for the district or the existing impervious cover, whichever is greater; 3. Will not result in a density in excess of what is allowed under this Ordinance, or the existing density, whichever is greater; Page 142 of 154 Page 9 of 9 4. Will lessen the extent of existing nonconforming site features to the greatest extent possible; 5. Will not have an adverse impact on the public health, safety or welfare; and 6. Will lessen the extent of nonconformities related to any existing nonconforming structure on the site to the greatest extent possible. In addition, the footprint of any existing nonconforming site feature or structure may be maintained or expanded as long as the applicant receives an approval as provided in Sec. 16-7-101.F, Substitution of Nonconformities for Redevelopment, unless one of the following is involved: 1. Expansion, enlargement, or extension associated with a nonconforming use; and 2. Replacement of a nonconforming site feature with a nonconforming structure; and 3. The demolition or modification of an existing nonconforming structure with the intent to rebuild or remodel the structure in accordance with an approved Zoning Map Amendment for the Redevelopment Overlay (R -O) District (see Sec. 16 -3- 106.K); and4.Nonconforming signs. 4. Nonconforming signs. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Ordinance 2. Text Amendment Page 143 of 154 Attachment 1 –Mass and Scale Amendment Ordinance Page 1 of 3 AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ORDINANCE NO. 2025-_____ AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND TO AMEND CHAPTER 16 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE, THE LAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE, TO AMEND THE CURRENT REGULATIONS FOR THE MEASURE OF HEIGHT AND SETBACK ENCROACHMENTS FOR RESIDENTIAL AND NONRESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT TO INCLUDE LAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE SECTIONS: 16-3-106, 16-5-102 & 16-10-102, AND PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, The Town Council previously adopted a Strategic Action Plan for 2023- 2025, and Strategy Number 1 states that the Town will: Successfully manage increasing and evolving future growth patterns in a manner that will ensure sustainability of Hilton Head Island’s unique character. Additionally, the Town must monitor economic and demographic trends, undertaking a comprehensive list of future planning activities, and proactively protecting the Island’s rich natural resources through appropriate design, regulation, and capital investment practices; and, WHEREAS, at its September 16, 2024, Town Council Workshop, Town staff received the following comments and direction regarding amendments to the Land Management Ordinance related to the measurement of height and setback encroachments for residential and commercial development: Residential: 1. Changes need to apply to existing subdivisions where possible . Current building heights are too high. 2. There needs to be more lighting, air, and separation between units. 3. Need to increase setbacks. 4. Need to establish minimum lot sizes (to be addressed during the full LMO update) Commercial 1. Current building heights are too high. 2. There needs to be more light, air, and separation between units . Need to increase setbacks. 3. Need to establish minimum lot sizes (to be addressed during the full LMO update). 4. There should be a relationship between height and proximity to the street and boundaries (lower closer to the street and boundaries of property); and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the mass and scale of recent developments Page 144 of 154 Attachment 1 –Mass and Scale Amendment Ordinance Page 2 of 3 have been of concern for both residential and commercial developments, and the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by an amendment to the Land Management Ordinance to address development and design standards for residential and nonresidential development by improving the definition and regulations related to the measurement of height and to identify a maximum for setback encroach ments to promote the design and development of more appropriately scaled development in the Town; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by an amendment to the Land Management Ordinance to require the height of structures be measured from the pre -development grade of the property on which the structure is built, and by amending the Land Management Ordinance to measure the setback angles at twenty (20) feet above the pre -development grade as this will ensure adequate separation between structures, provide for adequate light, air, and open space; prevent the overcrowding of land and facilitate the creation of a convenient, attractive and harmonious community; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by an amendment to the Land Management Ordinance to limit the types and extent of projections and encroachments that are allowed in the area of the setbacks as this will also ensure adequate separation between structures, provide for adequate light, air, and open space; prevent the overcrowding of land and facilitate the creation o f a convenient, attractive and harmonious community; and, WHEREAS, on April 16, 2025 , the Planning Comm ission held a Public Hearing to consider the proposed amendments related to the definition and regulations for the measure of height and setback encroachments, and the public had an opportunity to comment on the proposed amendments, and the Planning Commission voted ___ to recommend that Town Council adopt the amendments to the definition and regulations for height and setback encroachments; and, WHEREAS, on ________________, the Community Services and Public Safety Committee discussed the proposed amendments related to the regulations for the measure of height and setback encroachments , and voted ___ to recommend that Town Council adopt the amendments the regulations for the measure of height and setback encroachments; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the best interests of the Town, and the health, safety and welfare of its citizens, property owners, residents and visitors will be furthered by these amendments which will ensure adequate separation between structures, provide for adequate light, air, and open space; prevent the overcrowding of land and facilitate the creation of a convenient, attractive, and harmonious community. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY THE TOWN Page 145 of 154 Attachment 1 –Mass and Scale Amendment Ordinance Page 3 of 3 COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, AND IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY AND UNDER AUTHORITY OF SAID TOWN COUNCIL, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Amendment. That the Land Management Ordinance is amended as shown on Exhibit “A” to this Ordinance . Newly added language is illustrated with double underline and deleted language is illustrated with strikethrough. Section 2 . Severability. If any section, phrase, sentence , or portion of this Ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct , and independent provision, and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions thereof. Section 3. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be effective upon its adoption by the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED BY THE COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ON THIS _____ DAY OF __ , 2025. THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ____________________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor ATTEST: _____________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk First Reading: Second Reading: APPROVED AS TO FORM: _____________________________ Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney Page 146 of 154 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 1 of 8 Chapter 16-3: Zoning Districts Sec.16-3-106. Overlay Zoning Districts H. Forest Beach Neighborhood Character Overlay (FB-NC-O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks i. In addition to the single-family setback requirements of Sec. 16-5-102, Setback Standards, a side, and rear adjacent use setback shall be required. ii. Setbacks shall comply with the standards of Sec. 16-5-102, Setback Standards, except that the 65 degree setback angle shall be measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. iii. Side adjacent use setbacks shall be 10 feet for lots with a width of 70 feet and above. For lot widths less than 70 feet, the side adjacent use setback shall be equal to 12 percent of the lot width rounded to the closest whole number. However, to preserve significant trees or stands of trees any one side setback may be reduced to five feet, provided the sum of the required side setbacks is not reduced. iv. Rear adjacent use setbacks shall equal 10 percent of the lot depth or 10 feet, whichever is greater. However, to preserve significant trees or stands of trees, the rear setback may be reduced to five feet provided the sum of the required street and rear setbacks is not reduced. v. To preserve significant trees or stands of trees in the rear of the lot, the street setback may be reduced to 15 feet provided the sum of the required street and rear setback is not reduced. I. Folly Field Neighborhood Character Overlay (FF-NC-O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks In addition to the single-family setback requirements of Sec. 16-5-102, Setback Standards, with the exception that structures greater than 24 inches in height along minor arterials are required to have a minimum adjacent street setback of 20 feet, the following setbacks shall be required. i. Rear yard setbacks shall be a minimum of ten percent of lot depth or ten feet, whichever is greater. ii. Side yard setbacks shall each contain a minimum of ten percent of the total lot width. iii. Maximum setback angle of 65 degrees shall be measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. Page 147 of 154 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 2 of 8 J. Holiday Homes Neighborhood Character Overlay (HH-NC-O) District 4. District Regulations a. Setbacks In addition to the single-family setback requirements of Sec. 16-5-102, Setback Standards, the following setbacks shall be required: i. Rear yard setbacks shall be a minimum of ten feet. ii. Side yard setbacks shall be a minimum of ten feet; however, to preserve existing trees, any one side yard setback may be reduced to five feet provided the sum of the required side yard setbacks equals at least 20 feet. 01.A lot with less than 50 feet of street frontage or less than 0.15 acres in area shall be permitted to reduce side yard setbacks to a minimum of five feet. 02.Dwelling units that are nonconforming as to the side yard setbacks identified above are permitted to be expanded along the subject boundary line; however, expansions shall be constructed no closer than five feet from the side property line. 03.Side yard setback angles shall be a minimum of 65 degrees measured from 20 feet above thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher, at the setback line. The illustration in Sec. 16-5-102.D, Adjacent Use Setback Requirements, can be referenced for an example of a setback angle. iii. In the case of a corner lot, the required 20-foot adjacent street setback may be reduced to ten feet for the street with the lower average daily trips (ADT). iv. Lots directly adjacent to Folly Field Road shall have a minimum adjacent street setback of 20 feet. Page 148 of 154 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 3 of 8 Chapter 16-5: Development and Design Standards Sec.16-5-102. Setback Standards C. Adjacent Street Setback Requirements Unless expressly exempted or modified in this subsection or for the CR, S, and IL Districts in Chapter 16 -3: Zoning Districts, all portions of a structure shall be located to the interior of the vertical and angled planes established by the applicable minimum setback distance from an adjacent street and maximum setback angle shown in Table 16-5-102.C, Adjacent Street Setback Requirements, based on the propo sed use and the classification of the adjacent street. (See Figure 16-5-102.C, Street Setback Angle.) TABLE 16-5-102.C: ADJACENT STREET SETBACK REQUIREMENTS PROPOSED USE MINIMUM SETBACK DISTANCE1/ MAXIMUM SETBACK ANGLE2 ADJACENT STREET (BY CLASSIFICATION) MAJOR ARTERIAL MINOR ARTERIAL ALL OTHER STREETS Single-Family Structure > 24 in high 50 ft4 /75° 40 ft4 / 70° 20 ft4 /60° Structure ≤ 24 in high 50 ft4 /n/a 30 ft4 /n/a 10 ft4 /n/a All Other Uses 50 ft4 /75° 40 ft4 /70° 20 ft4 /60° NOTES: in = inches ft = feet ° = degrees 1. Measured from the adjacent street right-of-way or easement line to the closest portion of a structure. A 5' setback is required from an access easement for Family Compounds and Family Subdivisions. A street setback from an easement line is not required for non-single-family properties. 2. Measured within the upper inward quadrant of the intersection of a horizontal plane at a height of 20 feet above 13 feet above Mean Sea Level for residential use or 11 feet above Mean Sea Level for nonresidential use, or pre-development grade, whichever is higher, and a vertical plane extending upward at the minimum setback distance (see Figure 16-5-102.C, Street Setback Angle). 3. The adjacent street setback shall be a minimum of five (5) feet on any parcel abutting a Town right -of-way acquired under the Town's Dirt Road Paving Program. See Section 16-5-105.D for additional details. 4. For corner lots, reduced to 10 feet from the right-of-way of the street with the lowest average daily vehicle traffic count (ADT). If both streets have equal ADT, the lot owner may choose which street shall be subject to the reduced setback distance. 5. For Family Compounds and Family Subdivisions, the minimum setback from a minor arterial shall be 25' and the minimum setback from all other streets shall be 10'. 6. Any further reductions to the adjacent street setbacks for Family Compounds and Family Subdivisions will require a variance from the BZA. Page 149 of 154 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 4 of 8 Figure 16-5-102.C, Street Setback Angle (Revised 12-5-2017 - Ordinance 2017-19; revised 8-18-2020 - Ordinance 2020-19; revised 11-18-2020 - Ordinance 2020-27; revised 7-20-2021 - Ordinance 2021-15; revised 3-7-2023 - Ordinance 2023-04) D. Adjacent Use Setback Requirements 1. Unless expressly exempted or modified in this subsection or for the CR and S Districts in Chapter 16 -3: Zoning Districts, all portions of a structure shall be located to the interior of the vertical and angled planes established by the applicable minimum setback distance from adjacent properties and maximum setback angle shown in Table 16-5-102.D, Adjacent Use Setback Requirements, based on the proposed use and the existing use of the adjacent property (or zoning of a vacant adjacent property). (See Figure 16-5-102.D, Use Setback Angle.) Page 150 of 154 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 5 of 8 TABLE 16-5-102.D: ADJACENT USE SETBACK REQUIREMENTS 1 PROPOSED USE3 MINIMUM SETBACK DISTANCE1/MAXIMUM SETBACK ANGLE2 USE OF ADJACENT DEVELOPMENT PROPERTY 3 SINGLE- FAMILY DWELLING ALL OTHER RESIDENTIAL USES; COMMERCIAL RECREATION PUBLIC, CIVIC, INSTITUTIONAL, AND EDUCATION; RESORT ACCOMMODATION; OFFICES; COMMERCIAL SERVICES; VEHICLE SALES AND SERVICES; BOAT RAMPS, DOCKING FACILITIES, AND MARINAS INDUSTRIAL USES ZONING OF ADJACENT VACANT PROPERTY CON, PR, RSF-3, RSF-5, RSF-6, RM-4 RM-8, RM-12 CR, CC, WMU, S, RD, SPC, LC, MF, MV, MS, NC, MED IL Single-Family6 20 ft4,5 /75° 20 ft4,5 /75° 30 ft4,5 /60° 40 ft4,5 /45° • Any Other Residential Uses • Commercial Recreation 20 ft/75° 20 ft/75° 25 ft/75° 30 ft/60° • Public, Civic, Institutional, and Education • Resort Accommodation • Offices • Commercial Services • Vehicle Sales and Services • Boat Ramps, Docking Facilities, or Marinas 30 ft/60° 25 ft/75° 20 ft/75° 20 ft/75° Industrial Uses 40 ft4,5 /45° 30 ft/60° 20 ft/75° 20 ft/75° 1. Measured from the common property line to the closest portion of a structure. 2. Measured within the upper inward quadrant of the intersection of a horizontal plane at a height of 20 feet above 13 feet above Mean Sea Level for residential use or 11 feet above Mean Sea Level for nonresidential use, or pre-development grade, whichever is higher, and a vertical plane extending upward at the minimum setback distance (see Figure 16-5-102.D, Use Setback Angle). 3. See Sec. 16-10-103 for a description or definition of the listed use classification and types. 4. Single family subdivision exterior boundary only. 5. For all Minor Subdivisions and Small Residential Developments, the entire single family exterior boundary setback may be reduced by 50% in area. The setback area shall not be reduced to less than 5 feet wide at any point; it may be reduced to 5 feet where adjoining another single-family dwelling lot in the same subdivision; may be reduced to less than 5 feet if it, when combined with the platted setback distance for the adjoining lot, is at least 10 feet. 6. For Family Compounds and Family Subdivisions, the minimum setback from an adjacent property shall be reduced by 10' from what is required in Table 16-5-102.D except that an adjacent use setback of 5' shall be required between single-family uses. Page 151 of 154 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 6 of 8 7. Any further reductions to the adjacent use setbacks for Family Compounds and Family Subdivisions will require a variance from the BZA. Figure 16-5-102.D, Use Setback Angle 2. Where the adjacent property includes uses from more than one listed use classification/use type (including mixed-use developments), the adjacent use setback required shall be that for the use classification/use type to which the greatest percentage of the development's gross floor area is devoted. 3. The adjacent use setback distance applicable to lots along the perimeter of development subject to Small Residential Development Review may be reduced by up to 50 percent, down to no less than five feet. The Official may allow further reduction as necessary to ensure that the total area within such perimeter setbacks does not exceed 20 percent of the total area of the site of the Small Residential Development. 4. There is no adjacent use setback requirement for non-single-family properties when the proposed development and the adjacent development function as a single development due to having either shared parking, connecting vehicular access or shared stormwater facilities. The recording of a cross access easement agreement between the two properties is required. Page 152 of 154 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 7 of 8 E. Allowable Setback Encroachments Table 16-5-102.E, Allowable Setback Encroachments, identifies features that are allowed to encroach beyond the vertical and angled planes defined by minimum adjacent street and use setback requirements. TABLE 16-5-102.E: ALLOWABLE SETBACK ENCROACHMENTS FEATURE EXTENT AND LIMITATIONS Fences or walls • Allowed in adjacent use setbacks if located along common property lines and no more than 7 feet high • Allowed in adjacent street setbacks if less than 4 feet high Open balconies, fire escapes, or exterior stairways May extend up to 5 feet into any setback Chimneys or fireplaces 1 May extend up to 3 feet into any setback if no more than 5 feet higher than the highest point of building to which it is attached Roof eaves and overhangs 1 May extend up to 3 feet into any setback Awnings 1 May extend up to 5 feet into any setback Bay windows 1 May extend up to 3 feet into any setback if no more than 9 feet wide Sills or entablatures 1 May extend up to 1 foot into any setback Uncovered porches, stoops, decks, patios or terraces May extend up to 5 feet into any setback Lighting fixtures May be located in any setback if no more than 20 feet high Roof dormers 1 May extend up to 5 feet beyond the setback angle plane (horizontally or vertically) Spires, cupolas, domes, skylights, and similar rooftop architectural features May extend up above the setback angle plane if they occupy no more than 25% of the roof area of the structure to which they are attached and extend no more than 25% more than the height limit defined by the setback angle plane at the point(s) of penetration Solar collection devices See Sec. 16-4-103.E.8 Television or radio antennas1 May extend up to 10 feet above the setback angle plane if they are attached to a side or rear elevation of a structure Small wind energy conversion systems See Sec. 16-4-103.E.7 Amateur radio antenna See Sec. 16-4-103.E.1 Bike racks, bollards and other site furnishings (such as tables and chairs) 1 Allowed in adjacent use and adjacent street setbacks Other architectural features not listed above (parts of a structure that provide visual interest to the structure and are nonhabitable and decorative in nature) May be allowed to penetrate the plane of the setback angle if the Official makes the following determinations: • The required setback angle cannot be met for the architectural elements using alternate site layouts without major modifications to an otherwise acceptable application; • The excepted architectural elements will not be major or dominant features of the structure; • The excepted architectural elements will not penetrate the vertical plane of the minimum required setback distance; • The exception is the minimum reasonably required to achieve the architectural goal; and • If applicable, the placement of the structure provides protection of prominent natural features on the site, such as trees, wetlands, or historic sites. Page 153 of 154 Attachment 2: Exhibit A – Mass & Scale Amendment Page 8 of 8 Flagpoles/Flags 1 Unless they constitute a "sign" and thus subject to Sec. 16-5-114.E, Flagpoles no more than 20 feet high and flags no greater than 20 square feet in area may be located in setbacks Signs 1 See Sec. 16-5-114.E 1In no case shall an allowable encroachment for a listed feature extend into a setback to a point that is less than 10 feet from a lot line. Chapter 16-10: Definitions, Interpretation, and Measurement Sec.16-10-102. Rules of Measurement C. Height 1. Calculation of Height a. Maximum structure height for development in each zoning district shall be calculated measured from pre-development grade immediately adjacent to the structure to a point level with the highest point of the structure. as follows: i. Residential maximum building height shall be measured from thirteen feet (13') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher; and ii. Nonresidential maximum building height shall be measured from eleven feet (11') above mean sea level using the NAVD 88 vertical datum or pre-development grade, whichever is higher. b. The measurement of the height of a structure shall be the distance from the height as determined by 16-10-102.C.a immediately adjacent to the structure to a point level with the highest point of the structure. c. Equipment such as satellite dishes and heating and air conditioning equipment installed on top of buildings are excluded from the measurement of height provided they are screened from view. d. The height of fences shall be measured from preconstruction gradepre-development grade. Page 154 of 154

Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.