Public Works Committee February 2024 agenda
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Feb 1, 2024 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC WORKS
COMMITTEE MEETING
MONDAY,FEBRU ARY 5, 2024 | 6 PM
3rd Committee Meeting
The Committee will meet in Mauldin City Hall at 5 East
Butler Road in the Council Chambers at 6 p.m.
The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at
https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting-minutes-agendas/ to access the
meeting via audio and videoconferencing.
A quorum of Council will be present.
1
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE MEETING
FEBRU ARY 5 , 2024 , 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 5 E.
BUTLER ROAD
Committe
e Members:
1. Call to Or
der
2. Public Comme
nt
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a.Public Works Committee- January 2, 2024 [Pages 3-5]
4. Reports or Communications from City Officers
a.PW Director Matthew Fleahman
Roadway Analysis and Evaluation
Update on Senior Center Roof
5. Unfinished Business
There is no unfinished business.
6. New Business
a.Stormwater Fee Analysis [Pages 6-25]
b.Ordinance to Sell Butler Road property for ROW [Pages 26-97]
c.SCIIP Grant Contractor Selection [Pages 98-118]
7. Public Comment
8. Committee Concerns
9. Adjournment
Chairperson Kraeling
Chairperso
n Kraeling
Chairperso
n Kraeling
Chairpers
on Kraeling
Chairperso
n Kraeling
Chairpers
on Kraeling
Chairpers
on Kraeling
Chairpers
on Kraeling
Chairperso
n Kraeling
2
MINUTES
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE MEETING JANUARY 2, 2024, 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
6th commitee mee�ng
Co
mmitee Members present were Chairman Jason Kraeling, Commitee members Carol King
and Michael Reynolds.
Ot
hers present were PW Director Mathew Fleahman and City Administrator Seth Duncan.
1. Ca
ll to Order- Chairman Kraeling
2. Pu
blic Comment
MJ
Seeche- 309 Miller Road in Mauldin.
Mr. Seeche submited a public comment in September 2023 that did not make it into
commitee minutes. Mr. Seeche is asking bulk items that the City will or will not picked up be
listed on the City website to provide clarifica�on as well as any other informa�on per�nent to
bulk items.
M
r. Seeche said he was told in a previous email that he could submit public comment
through email for inclusion in the Public Works commitee mee�ng minutes. That prac�ce
has happened in the past, but he is now being told that in order to have public comment
included in the minutes you must come in person or par�cipate electronically. Mr. Seeche
asked for staff to cite any standing commitee rule or ordinance that requires in person or
electronic par�cipa�on in order to be included in the minutes. Mr. Seeche was advised there
is no writen rule or standard governing this prac�ce.
M
r. Seeche said he does not an�cipate an answer to his ques�ons tonight and would prefer a
writen response by the responsible party.
3. Re
ading and Approval of Minutes
a. Public Works Commitee- December 4, 2023
M
o�on: Councilwoman King made a mo�on to approve the minutes with Councilman
Reynolds seconding.
Vo
te: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
4. Re
ports or Communica�ons from City Officers
a. PW Director Mathew Fleahman
T
he department has goten through the holiday season. Decora�ons will be taken down
next week. The Sewer Division has worked very hard to complete all goals set forward in
3
the sewer maintenance program plan. Mr. Fleahman atributed that to the leadership in the
department.
All divisions are where they need to be in their budgets.
Councilman Reynolds thanked Mr. Fleahman for being the right leader to push the
employees toward excellence.
Roadway Analysis and Evalua�on
County staff requested a list of road improvement projects from various jurisdic�ons to
ar�culate the significant need that exists throughout the County. A request was made to
City staff for a list of top road projects/improvements and the City’s roadway inventory and
associated PCI scores. This informa�on was provided on September 29, 2023. During the
December Commitee mee�ng, the Public Works Department was tasked with making new
lists, where City and State roads were separated. In addi�on to separa�ng the roadways, it
was expected that the roadways would be ranked in terms of priority. Below are these new
lists:
Ci
ty Roads
1 Hol
land Road (city) – Resurface from Vendue Ct. to E. Butler Rd
2 Adams Mill (city/state) – Resurface from Ashmore Bridge to Brooks Road.
3 Bridges Road (city/state) - Resurface from E. Butler to Bethel Road
4 Maple Drive (city) - Resurface from Ashmore Bridge to Peachtree Lane
5 Crestwood Drive (city) - Resurface from Ashmore Bridge to Whatley Circle
6 Whatley Circle (city) - Resurface from W. Butler to 276S
7 Hun�ngton Circle (city) - Resurface from Knollwood Drive to end
8 Fargo St (city) - Resurface from Bethel Drive to Danbury Lane
9 Bartlet St (city) - Resurface from Fargo Street to Danbury Lane
10 Bangor St (city) - Resurface from Fargo Street to Bartlet Street
St
ate/County Roads
1 Ash
more Bridge Road (state) – Widening between Fork Shoals Rd and W. Butler Rd
2 W. Butler (state) – Resurface from Conestee Rd to HWY 276
3 HWY 276N/S (state) – Resurface from East Standing Springs to Innova�on Drive
4 Miller Road (state) – Resurface from Murray Drive to Woodruff Road
5 Interchange Improvement (state) – Forrester Drive and Hamby Drive
6 Hamby Road (state) – Resurface from Miller Road to Forrester Drive
7 N. Golden Strip - Resurface from SC417 to Bethel Drive
8 Old Mil (state) – Resurface from E. Butler to Forrester Drive
9 Fowler Circle (county) – Widening from W. Butler Road to Murphy Lane
10 Brooks Road (county/city) - Resurface from New Neely Ferry Rd to Shawn Drive
4
Councilwoman Kin g said the road condi�ons are serious problems and if the road sales tax
falls through, she would like to know what Plan B might be.
5. Un
finished Business- There is no unfinished business.
6. New
Business- There is no new business.
7. Pu
blic Comment- None
8. Co
mmitee Concerns- Councilwoman King asked Mr. Fleahman to let his employees know
how appreciated they are.
Mr
. Duncan men�oned that minutes are records what happened during a mee�ng. Mr.
Seeche was advised that he must be present in person or electronically to be included in the
minutes. Comments sent by email will be dispersed to Council members, but not included in
the record of the mee�ng.
9. Adj
ournment- Chairman Kraeling adjourned the mee�ng at 7:43 p.m.
Re
spec�ully Submited,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
5
Stormwater Division Plan
February 2024
6
C i t y o f M a u l d i n
Page 2
Stormwater Division Plan
Table of Contents
1. INTRODUCTION
2. POLICY AND ORDINANCES
3. STORMWATER BUDGET
4. STORMWATER FUNDING FEE STRUCTURE
5. DIVISION DESIGN DISCUSSION
APPENDIX A – DRAFT Stormwater Policy
APPENDIX B – 2024-2025 DRAFT Stormwater Division Budget
7
C i t y o f M a u l d i n
Page 3
Stormwater Division Plan
1. INTRODUCTION
The City of Mauldin has experienced significant growth in recent years. Along with this growth
have come rising concerns of flooding and stormwater management within the City. As
infrastructure has aged and costs for construction have increased, the overall cost to maintain the
stormwater system has become an increased concern. In recent years, the Streets Division mission
has expanded to include stormwater inspections, pipe and basin cleaning, basin repairs, and pipe
replacements. In transitioning the Streets Division to a more stormwater centered operation, funds
allocated for streets maintenance have been diverted towards stormwater controls. While efforts
from the Streets Division have been significant, the issues surrounding the stormwater
infrastructure within the municipal boundaries far exceed the current expenditure level within the
Division.
In addition to the stormwater infrastructure currently maintained within the City’s right of way
(ROW) network, a significant amount of stormwater infrastructure exists on private property.
These private property systems are not maintained and have degraded in some cases to the point
of failure. City Ordinances and City Policies prevent staff from working on these systems without
a financial contribution in the form of pipe cost reimbursement from the affected homeowner. In
these situations, an easement dedicated to the City is also required.
During the 2022 calendar year, the City of Mauldin identified a need for engineering services for
stormwater and contracted with KCI to provide these engineering services. The City tasked KCI
with mapping the existing stormwater network as part of an asset inventory and to investigate areas
of known concern throughout the City. The area of concerns included Knollwood and Edgewood Drive,
the Holly Springs neighborhood, the Bishop Heights neighborhood, the Harrison’s Plaza, Bi-lo Distribution
Center, and portions of Oak Park Drive . The asset inventory was added to the City’s Geographic
Information System (GIS) and the reports for the areas of concern were brought before the council
for consideration. A grant was applied for and received for proposed repairs to the Oak park Drive
drainage area.
During the 2023 calendar year, the City identified a need to fund stormwater capital improvement
projects where the project costs and scope exceed the budget and abilities of the Public Works Department.
It was determined that design and construction could be contracted and potentially paid for through a Capital
Improvement Plan and/or enterprise fund. In June of 2023, the Public Works Committee and City Council
authorized KCI to conduct a Stormwater Fee Analysis and Evaluation. The intent of the report was to
determine a potential funding source and identify the operating budget based on the revenues from the
potential funding source. The report was presented to Council in September 2023.
To better serve our citizens and to address the stormwater issues within the municipal boundaries of the
City, the Public Works Department has developed the basis for the creation of a standalone Stormwater
Division. In this report, the Department breaks down the cost associated with the proposed
Division, the recommended funding mechanism, the Policy and Ordinance changes required, and
a preliminary Capital Planning for future activities.
8
C i t y o f M a u l d i n
Page 4
Stormwater Division Plan
2. Policy and Ordinances
POLICY
T
he City of Mauldin issued its Stormwater Policy on August 17, 2020. In this policy, the City summarizes
information presented in its Code of Ordinances and outlines the abilities of the City to address stormwater
issues on private property. With the creation of a standalone Stormwater Division, the City will be required
to adopt a new stormwater policy to be representative of the new duties and abilities of the Public Works
Department.
Restrictions present in the existing policy relate to the purchase of materials and access to private property.
With the intent of the new Stormwater Division to be one that repairs and maintains all stormwater
infrastructure these restrictions should be modified or eliminated. State Laws do restrict the expenditure of
public monies on private property, so the City will be required to obtain an easement across private property
before any work is completed on every project. The costs associated with obtaining these easements are
presented in Section 3- Stormwater Budget and will be a realized expenditure on every stormwater
project.
A draft stormwater policy is attached in Appendix A. In the draft policy, all references to resident material
expenditures have been removed. Appropriate language addressing permanent easements has been added.
If the Stormwater Division is created, the Public Works Department will bring the attached policy before
Committee and Council to be adopted.
ORDINANCES
T
he City of Mauldin addresses stormwater in three Chapters within its Code of Ordinances. Soil and
Sedimentation control is presented in Chapter 32, Stormwater Management in Article III of Chapter 40,
and work activities are presented in Article II of Chapter 36. Prior to any work activities of the proposed
Stormwater Division, it is recommended that Article II of Chapter 36 be revised to mirror the language
presented in the DRAFT Stormwater Policy in Appendix A. Additionally, it is recommended that the three
Chapters be revised and merged into one which outlines the entirety of the City’s Stormwater Policy. If
the Stormwater Division is created, the Public Works Department will bring a revised Chapter 40 –
Stormwater management before Committee and Council to be adopted.
9
C i t y o f M a u l d i n
Page 5
Stormwater Division Plan
3. Stormwater Budget
The Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation Design Report by KCI identified varied fee structures and presented
a potential annual budget for each. The budget provided estimates for salaries, costs for fuel, and some
estimates for materials. While these estimates were functional for the report, they did not account for many
costs associated with day-to-day operations of a Public Works Division. Before any recommendation for
a fee structure could be made, a draft budget was required to better estimate the real costs of the Division.
Attached in Appendix B is the DRAFT 2024-2025 Stormwater Division Budget. The Draft budget accounts
for a team of four staff members with one member being funded as a supervisor. The associated costs for
insurance, retirement, workers comp, and FICA are identified. In the budget, expenses for training,
supplies, auto and equipment maintenance, fuel, cell phones, uniforms, liability insurance, and materials
are also identified.
In the contract services of the DRAFT budget, expenditures for tree removals, legal services, and
engineering services are presented. It is expected that with every easement granted to the City, legal
services will be rendered. There is also a high certainty that large diameter trees will be required to be
felled to complete pipe replacement work. While staff can drop trees, the likelihood of trees located near
residential structures presents a potential liability to the Department. To remove this liability, a contract
service for removal is recommended. In some situations, design services will be required to address
undersized and poorly designed systems. The City would be liable if an “in-house” redesign under preforms
or fails. To eliminate this liability, engineering services are budgeted.
The DRAFT budget includes $155,000 for pipe, asphalt, stone, and concrete. These materials are essential
to every excavation job and represent the bulk of the “non-staff” costs. These values are preliminary
estimates and very likely to increase as the Division develops. It is expected that the Division will start on
small projects and develop into larger more complex projects over time.
The initial DRAFT budget includes the capital purchase of three pieces of equipment. The three budget
sheets are included in Appendix B with the DRAFT Budget and include new shoring, a new trailer, and an
excavation roller. It is expected that any additional equipment will be shared with the Streets Division and
as the Division and/or workload increases, equipment purchases be included in the 10-year Capital
Improvement Plan.
The Stormwater Utility Fee Budgeting Scenario presented by KCI in the Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
Design Report presented an annual cost for in-house construction at $550,000 dollars. In the DRAFT
budgeting scenario of this report, the Division is shown to be a cost of $640,782.14 with an additional initial
capital expenditure of $65,000 for a total of $705,782.14. As noted earlier, the initial estimate was very
conservative and did not take into account many costs associated with day-to-day operations of a Public
Works Division.
10
C i t y o f M a u l d i n
Page 6
Stormwater Division Plan
4. Stormwater Funding Fee Structure
In the Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation Design Report by KCI it was recommended that the City adopt a
“$25 fee for residential properties, less than 1000 square feet and a $28 fee for larger residential properties.
The fee for non-residential developed properties would be $27 times the Equivalent Residential Unit (ERU)
for the property.” In this scenario, the City would potentially generate 729,000 dollars in annual revenue.
A breakdown of the fee scenarios is presented below in the report’s Table 4.
Table 4 - Stormwater Utility Fees Collected yearly
Alternative
Residential
Fees
Collected
Non-
residential
Fee Total Fee
Minimum
Charge
Fee
Credits
1 $225,000 $32,000 $257,000 $25.00 None
2 $245,000 $484,000 $729,000 None None
3 $245,000 $476,740 $721,740 $25.00 $7,260
4 $226,500 $484,000 $710,500 None None
5 $226,500 $476,740 $703,240 $25.00 $7,260
The KCI report expanded on the fee program and identified what potential revenue would be available at
higher rates. This information is shared from their report’s Table 5.
Table 5 - Stormwater Fee Analysis
Residential Fee Non-residential Fee
Total Fee
Collected
Annually
$30 $32 per ERU for developed
$30 for undeveloped
$848,000
$35 $37 per ERU for developed
$35 for undeveloped
$983,000
$36 $37.50 per ERU for developed
$36 for undeveloped
$1,000,000
$72 $74.50 per ERU for developed
$72 for undeveloped
$2,000,000
11
C i t y o f M a u l d i n
Page 7
Stormwater Division Plan
5. Division Design Discussion
The costs associated with the proposed Stormwater Division only account for routine maintenance and pipe
replacement work along properly dedicated easements. Bigger projects that involve larger drainage areas
such as neighborhoods like Bishop Heights would be more appropriately handled as contracted out work.
In situations like these, Capital Planning is needed along with a revenue stream to support the work. In the
proposed fee structure by KCI, a total annual revenue stream of $729,000 would be generated. With the
proposed budget of $705,782.14 as presented in Section 3, a surplus of approximately $24,000 would be
available for Capital Projects.
Several Capital Projects were identified in the KCI report and included Bishop Heights, Knollwood,
Swinton Drive, and Holly Springs. Each project comes with significant challenges with costs varying from
$250,000 up to $2,300,000. In some situations, like Swinton Drive, recommendations from KCI included
purchasing properties rather than undertaking a $4,600,000 construction project. At the fee rate proposed
by KCI, Capital Projects would either not be undertaken or would have to wait for enough reserve to be
built up as some municipal match for a grant. Ideally, the purpose of a Stormwater Division would be to
address the larger issues within the City. For this to occur, a larger revenue stream would be required to
meet the expectations of a Capital Projects budget.
A surplus of $200,000 to $300,000 annually would be recommended to provide for projects to be
undertaken within a reasonable amount of time. To satisfy this funding expectation a stormwater
Residential Fee of $36 and Non-Residential Fee of $37.50 per ERU for developed $36 for undeveloped is
recommended. At this fee structure an anticipated revenue stream of $1,000,000 is proposed. With this
fee structure, the anticipated revenue stream would be sufficient to fund the Division and provide for Capital
Project budgeting.
As noted in the KCI report, the bulk of the stormwater revenue generated would come from non-residential
properties within the City. In response to Committee concerns about what this would mean for businesses,
Table 6 below presents the existing stormwater fee for a select number of businesses and the proposed total
fee at the recommended stormwater Non-Residential Fee.
Table 6 - Stormwater Fees Non-Residential
Site ERU Current Fee Proposed City Fee Total Fee
GBS 76 $2,052 $2,850 $4,902
Compex 143 $3,861 $5,363 $9,224
CS Sauer 136 $3,672 $5,100 $8,772
Spectrum 82 $2,214 $3,075 $5,289
Harrisons 149 $4,023 $5,588 $9,611
Kellets 39 $1,053 $1,463 $2,516
BASF 122 $3,294 $4,575 $7,869
12
Appendix A
Draft Stormwater Policy
Stormwater Division Plan
February 2024
13
1
City of Mauldin Government
Procedure Manual
Title: Storm Water Policy
Department: Public Works
Effective Date: _______________
I. Purpose
The City of Mauldin (City) only owns, operates, and maintains stormwater facilities within City right
of way, properly dedicated easements, or on City-owned property.
This policy is intended to provide guidance for the Public Works Director and those designated
by the Public Works Director (i.e. Engineering Services Manager) to make management decisions
regarding what type of corrective action to take on the system (e.g., repair or replace).
II. Policy
The City of Mauldin will only make repairs to storm drainage facilities that lie within the City’s street
rights-of-ways or properly executed drainage easements with permanent encroachment provisions .
Storm drainage systems within State road rights-of-way are maintained by the State Department of
Transportation (SCDOT). Storm drainage facilities that lie outside the City’s rights-of way are
considered to be the private property of the owner of the real property on which the facilities are
located.
City ordinances prohibit City personnel or equipment from doing maintenance of storm drainage
systems across private property. The City will not enter private property to correct or make repairs
to storm drainage facilities on private property even if the owner gives the City the express
permission to do so. The City does not own the pipes, catch basins, etc. nor does the City own the
rights-of-way or easements of these systems on private property. It does not matter whether there
is a drainage easement across the property or not. This is not a City-owned easement. Therefore, it
is the responsibility of the property owner to correct any storm drainage issue on their property.
Likewise, if the storm drainage issue lies in a common easement managed by a Homeowner's
Association, the Homeowner's Association would be responsible for correcting the issue. Developers
constructed the facilities during the subdivision’s development and any claims about such facilities
should be directed to the developer
The City does not perform any creek bank maintenance or stabilization. The City has never
maintained creeks, rivers, drainage ditches and the like. These are naturally occurring drainage areas
that are subject to erosion during periods of heavy rainfall. Their courses may even change over time.
Therefore, individuals owning land on which these drainage areas exist have the responsibility to
maintain them. In most instances, such drainage areas are shown on recorded plats of the subdivision
or development and exist for the benefit of adjoining landowners. Usually easements are recorded
on the plats or restrictive covenants concerning their existence and use.
Deleted: The reason is that once the City makes repairs, the
City will have a continuing obligation to maintain the facility.
Storm drainage facilities outside the rights-of- way are not
deeded or dedicated to the City and therefore the City does not
own or maintain them. The City will not accept a dedication of
storm water facilities that lie outside of road rights of ways. ¶
¶
14
2
III. Work on City Right-of-Way and Property
Work may be performed on city rights-of-way or property in the following cases:
A. Roadside ditches: The City may provide labor, equipment, pipe, and cover material to pipe
roadside ditches on city roads, if piping a roadside ditch on a city road or bridge will materially
benefit the road or bridge.
B. Driveway entrances: The City may provide and/or install drainage lines at private driveway
entrances to facilitate proper roadway drainage, subject to the following conditions:
1. No more than 20 linear feet of pipe 36 inches or less in diameter may be provided per lot.
2. No pipe or structures larger than 36 inches in diameter may be installed by the City. Larger
structures installed on a City right-of-way by others require an encroachment permit.
3. As many as two driveway entrances, not over 20 feet in width, will be permitted on each lot,
and may be paved from a minimum distance of seven feet to a maximum distance of the
right-of-way line, measured from the edge of the roadway and perpendicular to the
centerline. No more than 20 feet of pipe may be furnished by the City. Although two driveway
entrances are allowed, the City will only provide the materials for one driveway entrance. If
a citizen desires a second one, the citizen must pay the cost of the materials, installation and
maintenance.
4. No pipe may be furnished, installed or maintained on private roads. Installation of pipe for
private roads requires an encroachment permit. Roads being constructed for dedication to
the City shall be considered private prior to final acceptance.
IV. Work off City right-of-way and property.
Work may be performed off City rights-of-way or property in the following cases:
A. Protection of City street or bridge: For correcting a situation detrimental to a City street or bridge
which affects the safety of the traveling public. Such work may include, but is not limited to,
stream channel improvement and sight distance obstruction removal. Upon specific approval of
the City administrator, private driveways may be scraped only to the extent necessary to protect
a city or county road within the city limits by channeling water into side ditches and cleaning side
ditches. Hold harmless agreements are required for all such types of work.
B. Drainage work off City rights-of-ways and properties: To perform maintenance on dedicated
easements, provided that such maintenance will provide for the free flow of surface water to a
live stream and/or relieve regional flooding conditions along a live stream. The City may provide
labor, materials, and equipment to perform maintenance on drainage easements and installation
of erosion protection, but the easement, in general, must carry water from public roads or lands
or be regional in nature. This work will be accomplished only upon request and approval of all
property owners adjacent to the easement and after a properly executed hold harmless
agreement, and right of entry easement agreement, signed by all such owners is filed with the
City and accepted for recording. Felled trees may be removed only if impeding the normal flow
of water and only if it affects a public interest, public health, or public safety.
No maintenance assistance is offered to any development until completion. After completion of
a development project, no such assistance shall be rendered to commercial developments,
industrial sites, golf courses, apartment complexes, or mobile home parks, without specific
approval of council. A record of each project undertaken is to be maintained in the City Public
Works Department and made available upon request. The record is to include manpower and
Deleted: provided that the affected property owner provides
all necessary pipe, and catch basin materials on the site, but
Deleted: , the City Council may approve provision of the
necessary materials at the city's expense
Deleted: ¶
¶
¶
15
3
equipment usage.
In the event the work is done by the private property owner, the work must be performed by a
licensed, qualified contractor. All work must be inspected during installation and approved by
the public works department upon completion and before covering.
1. Types of work:
The following types of drainage assistance may be performed by the City Public Works
Department provided it affects a public interest, public health, or public safety:
a. Machine cleaning of normally dry drainage easements to allow free flow of surface
water.
b. Installation or removal of pipe (labor and equipment only) on normally dry drainage
easements. Materials must be furnished by the property owner. All materials furnished
including pipe, catch basins, grates and lids must meet City standards.
c. Installation of large stone or other erosion protection materials (labor and equipment
only) on normally dry drainage easements.
d. Unclogging and repair of pipe systems (labor and equipment only) on normally dry
drainage easements.
2. Conditions:
The drainage assistance described above may only be performed under the following
conditions:
a. All requests for off right-of-way drainage assistance must be approved by the Public
Works Director.
b. All affected property owners must execute drainage assistance agreements which shall
include an easement with permanent encroachment provisions and a hold harmless
agreement. These agreements shall be filed with the public works department.
c. Drainage assistance may be provided for circumstances involving water which originates
from public lands or public rights-of-ways to natural stream beds or drainage systems.
d. No materials will be furnished by the City for any of the above types of work.
e. No assistance shall be provided to any development prior to its completion.
f. No off-right-of-way drainage assistance shall be performed more than once in a 12-
month period except under extraordinary circumstances and with the concurrence of the
City Administrator.
V. Greenville County Storm Water Program
In 2002, as a federal mandate, the County of Greenville established a storm water program in order
to comply with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Clean Water Act. Programs were
created to address water quality issues related to the storm water runoff and to help correct some
of the County's worst flooding problems. Greenville County has jurisdiction within the City of Mauldin
to enforce this Act.
A. Responsibilities of Property Owners within the City of Mauldin Limits
1. Property owners continue to be responsible and accountable for actions that could lead to
water quality degradation and flooding issues.
2. Property owners are prohibited from attempting to block the natural path of water on their
property in any way.
16
4
3. Property owners should consider the natural drainage path when installing fences and sheds.
4. Property owners are prohibited from attempting to divert water from your property onto
another property. It is important to keep drainage ditches in your yard free of debris so that
water can drain properly. Yard debris also causes algae blooms which affect water quality.
5. Pursuant to state law, it is the responsibility of property owners with streams on or adjacent
to their properties to keep the streams free of debris and fallen trees.
6. Property owners are prohibited from dumping any substances such as dog waste, yard waste,
motor oil, antifreeze, or paint into creeks or streams on their property or storm drains in your
neighborhood. Streams and storm drains are part of the stormwater system. Dumping items
will directly affect the water quality and can result in fines and enforcement actions.
7. Water from a neighboring property should be settled between the property owners.
8. If the water is coming from an entire subdivision, contact Greenville County's Land
Development Division (864-467-4610).
9. If you plan on making modifications to your property that may disturb the topsoil or alter
drainage patterns, please check with Greenville County Land Development.
City Administrator Date
17
5
18
Appendix B
2024 – 2025 Draft Stormwater Division Budget
Stormwater Division Plan
February 2024
19
DEPARTMENT: STREET
FUND NUMBER: 100
DEPARTMENT FUNCTION CODE
010 SALARIES 176,800.00
Merit 5,304.00
COLA 3,536.00
010 TOTAL 185,640.00$
012 OVERTIME
Regular Overtime 2,500.00
Special Events Overtime 500.00
012 TOTAL 3,000.00$
021 FICA 14,430.96
021 TOTAL 14,430.96$
024 RETIREMENT 36,311.18
024 TOTAL 36,311.18$
025 GROUP INSURANCE 40,000.00
025 TOTAL 40,000.00$
028 WORK COMP 7,500.00
028 TOTAL 7,500.00$
100 SUPPLIES
Materials for general office use in the daily routines of Public
Works Department. These include such items as pencils, pens,
file folders, envelopes, copier paper, stationary, paper clips, etc,
and inspection forms. 1,000.00
Employee safety equipment 2,000.00
Tools for work trucks 2,000.00
Chainsaw blades, weed eater attachments, mower blades 1,000.00
100 TOTAL 6,000.00$
150 EMPLOYEE EXPENSES
Required training for safety and per Workers Comp insurance.
Conference; Seminars, safety training and Trade Show
participation. Magazines, Periodicals. 3,000.00
150 TOTAL 3,000.00$
170 REPAIRS & MAINTENANCE AUTO
All vehicle repairs and preventive maintenance for Stormwater
Division vehicles. This account is also for the purchase of tires
and their installation and/or repair on these vehicles. 15,000.00
170 TOTAL 15,000.00$
LINE ITEM
OBJECT # DETAIL & JUSTIFICATION FOR ITEMS BUDGETED
DETAIL
AMOUNTS:
FY2025
BUDGET:
20
DEPARTMENT: STREET
FUND NUMBER: 100
DEPARTMENT FUNCTION CODE
LINE ITEM
OBJECT # DETAIL & JUSTIFICATION FOR ITEMS BUDGETED
DETAIL
AMOUNTS:
FY2025
BUDGET:
180 GAS & OIL
This account covers all fuels for all vehicles and equipment the
street department operates. The oil used by the above listed
vehicles and equipment is purchased from this account and the
oil for preventive maintenance is budgeted in this account. 7,000.00
180 TOTAL 7,000.00$
210 TELEPHONE
Telephone, Verizon service & internet service 3,500.00
210 TOTAL $ 3,500.00
260 REPAIR AND MAINTENANCE
Repairs & Maintenance on Stormwater Division equipment to
include: Backhoe, Mini-Excavator, Skid Steer, Trailers,
chainsaws and backpack blowers. 15,000.00
260 TOTAL 15,000.00$
350 ASPHALT/CONCRETE SUPPLIES
Hot asphalt, crush and run, washed stone, rip-rap, cold patch,
mortar, and concrete. 30,000.00
350 TOTAL $ 30,000.00
410 UNIFORMS
The Street Dept. provides uniforms for street employees. This
line item is for rental & cleaning and maintenance of Street
Department crews uniforms. 3,600.00
410 TOTAL 3,600.00$
624 LIABILITY INSURANCE
General Payroll Liability 4,300.00
624 TOTAL 4,300.00$
001-624 LIABILITY INSURANCE-AUTO 27,000.00
001624 TOTAL 27,000.00$
650 CONTRACTS & SERVICES
Legal services for Stormwater Projects 50,000.00
Engineering Services 25,000.00
Tree removal services 15,000.00
21
DEPARTMENT: STREET
FUND NUMBER: 100
DEPARTMENT FUNCTION CODE
LINE ITEM
OBJECT # DETAIL & JUSTIFICATION FOR ITEMS BUDGETED
DETAIL
AMOUNTS:
FY2025
BUDGET:
EAM GIS Services 6,000.00
650 TOTAL 96,000.00$
700 OTHER EXPENSES
Miscellaneous Uncategorized Expenses. 5,000.00
Stormwater Charges - Greenville County 7,000.00
700 TOTAL 12,000.00$
730 DRAINAGE
Drainage Projects to include pipe, concrete, and stone 125,000.00
730 TOTAL 125,000.00
830 NON-CAPITAL EQUIPMENT
Equipment budgeted last year
Concrete saw 2,000.00
Dewatering pump 2,000.00
Power Tools, backpack blowers, chainsaw 2,500.00
830 TOTAL 6,500.00$
Department (Function) Grand Totals 640,782.14$
22
FY2024 Capital Project Budget Sheet
Item:
Fund:
Name of Project:
Description of Project:
Project justification:
Fiscal Year Expenditure Amount
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
Impact on Future Budgets:
CIP 5 Year Expenditure Schedule
Estimated Cost:
Department:
23
FY2024 Capital Project Budget Sheet
Item:
Fund:
Name of Project:
Description of Project:
Project justification:
Fiscal Year Expenditure Amount
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
Impact on Future Budgets:
CIP 5 Year Expenditure Schedule
Estimated Cost:
Department:
24
FY2024 Capital Project Budget Sheet
Item:
Fund:
Name of Project:
Description of Project:
Project justification:
Fiscal Year Expenditure Amount
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
Impact on Future Budgets:
CIP 5 Year Expenditure Schedule
Estimated Cost:
Department:
25
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
MEETI
NG DATE: February 5, 2024
AGENDA ITEM: 6b
TO: Public Works Committee
FROM: Seth Duncan, City Administrator
SUBJECT: Sale of Property E. Butler
DISCUSSION
The Public Works Committee is being asked make a positive recommendation to Council to approve the
sale of certain property along E. Butler Road to SCDOT for the purpose of road improvements as part of
the Butler Road Improvement Project.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
In late November 2023 , the City received the appraisal findings from ORC Real Estate Solutions for
Infrastructure for the sale of 0.11 acre (5,161 SF) of land along E. Butler Road in front of City Hall and the
old Fire Station. The property is being purchased by SCDOT as part of the Butler Road Improvement
Project which will see the improvement of E. Butler Road from Bridges Road to HWY 276. Improvements
will include stormwater changes, inclusion of a 10- foot multi-use path, intersection changes, and other
improvements.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
The City owns a number of parcels along the project corridor and due to the nature of this project SCDOT
is increasing its right-of-way throughout the project area. The parcels related to this appraisal are directly
in front of City Hall and the old Fire Station. As described in Exhibit A from the documents below, SCDOT
is seeking to acquire a thin strip of City property for the purpose of building a dedicated right-turn lane onto
HWY 276.
The
new right -of-way will affect several City features including a landscaped planter with tree, a brick
retaining wall, existing landscaping, an irrigation vault, the Mauldin Police Department sign, City
wayfinding sign, a memorial, and Blue Star Memorial Highway sign. These features will need to be
relocated outside of the DOT’s new right-of-way before project start. The cost to relocate these features is
known as the “Cost to Cure” in the offer below.
SC
DOT is offering the following compensation to the City:
$30,966.00 for fee simple title to 0.11 acre (5,161 SF) of land and all improvements thereon,
if any, in fee simple.
$79,592.00 Cos t to Cure
$110,558.00 Total
St
aff have found the appraisal fair and cost to cure acceptable.
26
Also note, that as part of these improvements, SCDOT will be modifying access for the driveway used by
Bohemian Bull. Post construction conditions will not allow for a full access driveway, therefore SCDOT
will be converting it to a right-in, right-out access.
FISCAL IMPACT
The City will receive $110,558 for the sale of this property to SCDOT. Staff suggest dedicating those funds
to Cost to Cure activities as described in the appraisal.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends Committee make a positive recommendation to City Council for the sale of this property
to SCDOT as stated in the offer.
ATTACHMENTS
Appraisal Letter and Docs
27
MAULDIN ORDINANCE _______________-2024
AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE CONVEYANCE OF
ANY AND ALL INTEREST IN CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY IN THE CITY OF MAULDIN
WHE
REAS, the City of Mauldin (“City”) owns certain road right-of-way property lying
and situate within the city limits of Mauldin, County of Greenville along East Butler Road
identified as Tracts 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 on the “SCDOT Area of Acquisition from Tracts 3, 4, 5,
6, 7, 8 Proj ID PO30563” attached hereto as Exhibit “A;” and,
WHEREAS, the South Carolina Department of Transportation (“the SCDOT”) desires
for the City to convey its interest in the area of acquisition from Tracts 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8
shown on Exhibit “A” to the SCDOT as part of the SCDOT’s Butler Road Improvements Project
(See www.buildingabetterbutler.com
); and,
WHEREAS, pursuant to S.C. Code § 5-7-40, a municipality may convey or dispose of
property it owns by Ordinance; and,
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Council find that it is in the best interest of the City of
Mauldin to convey the area of acquisition from Tracts 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 as shown on Exhibit
“A” to the SCDOT by quit-claim deed attached hereto as Exhibit “B” for the consideration
stated in said deed.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED, by the Mayor and Council of the City of
Maul
din, that the Mayor of the City is hereby authorized, empowered, and directed to execute,
acknowledge and deliver the quit-claim deed attached hereto as Exhibit “B.”
This Ordinance shall be effective upon second reading approval thereof and no further
authorization is required to execute and deliver all documents related to the conveyance
contemplated by this Ordinance.
28
Terry W. Merritt, Mayor
ATTEST:
Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk
Introduced by: __________________________________
First Reading: __________________________________
Second Reading: ________________________________
Approved as to form: _____________________________
Daniel R. Hughes
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM
MEETI
NG DATE: February 5, 2024
AGE
NDA ITEM: 6d
TO:
Public Works Committee
FROM: Public Works Director, Matthew Fleahman
SUBJECT: Sewer Rehabilitation Program
REQUEST
Authorization is requested to execute the attached contract between the City of Mauldin and Atlantic Coast
Contractors, Inc. (C/O Frazier Engineering, P.A).
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
The City identified a need for additional funding for sewer rehabilitation and submitted a grant application
to the South Carolina Rural Infrastructure Authority for funding. On April 27, 2023, the City was informed
that a grant amount of $3,399,750 was awarded to the City for the Basin RG2 Sanitary Sewer Rehabilitation.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
The City of Mauldin posted the project on the City website and on the South Carolina Business
Opportunities (SCBO) website. Bids were submitted and a public bid opening was conducted on November
20, 2023. Atlantic Coast Contractors, Inc. was the lowest bid. All procurement and contract documents
were sent to the SC Rural Infrastructure Authority to be reviewed, and on January 17, 2024 the City was
notified that all were satisfactory.
FINCANCIAL IMPACT
The City was awarded 3,399,750 dollars from the South Carolina Rural Infrastructure Authority. A
municipal match of $600,000 is required by the City. The rehabilitation funds from the 2022-2023 and the
2023-2024 fiscal budgets were used as the municipal match.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends the Public Works Committee and the City Council approve the contract.
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
01210-1
SECTION 01210
AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT, made this ________ day of ___________________________, 20___, by and
between the City of Mauldin herein after called "OWNER" and Atlantic Coast Contractors, Inc. of
the Town of Denver, County of Lincoln, and State of North Carolina, hereinafter called
"CONTRACTOR".
WITNESSETH: That for and in consideration of the payments and agreements hereinafter
mentioned:
1. The CONTRACTOR hereby agrees with the OWNER to commence and complete the
construction described as follows:
BASIN RG2 SANITARY SEWER REHABILITATION PROJECT
hereinafter called the PROJECT.
2. The CONTRACTOR will furnish all of the materials, supplies, tools, equipment, labor, and
other services necessary for the construction and completion of the PROJECT described
herein.
3. The CONTRACTOR will commence work required by the CONTRACT DOCUMENTS
within fifteen (15) calendar days after the date of the NOTICE TO PROCEED and will
fully complete the PROJECT within the time for completion specified in the SPECIAL
PROVISIONS of the CONTRACT DOCUMENTS unless the period for completion is
extended otherwise by the CONTRACT DOCUMENTS. The CONTRACTOR further
agrees to pay, as liquidated damages, the sum of one thousand dollars ($1000) for each
consecutive calendar day thereafter as herein provided in the SPECIAL PROVISIONS.
4. The CONTRACTOR agrees to perform all of the WORK described in the CONTRACT
DOCUMENTS and comply with the terms therein for the sum of ($2,691,950.87) Two
Million Six Hundred Ninety-One Thousand Nine Hundred Fifty Dollars and Eighty-Seven
Cents or as shown in the Bid Schedule.
112
01210-2
5. The term "CONTRACT DOCUMENTS" means and includes the following:
A. Advertisement for Bids
B. Information for Bidders
C. Bid
D. Bid Bond
E. Agreement
F. Performance Bond
G. Payment Bond
H. General Conditions
I. Supplemental Conditions
J. Special Provisions
K. Notice of Award
L. Notice to Proceed
M. Change Orders
N. Drawings prepared by CHA Consulting, Inc. dated August 2023, and listed in the
Special Provisions.
O. Specifications prepared by CHA Consulting, Inc., and dated August 2023
P. Addendum No. 1 dated October 21, 2023 and Addendum No. 2 dated November
3, 2023
6. The OWNER agrees to pay the CONTRACTOR in the manner and at such times as set
forth in the General Conditions such amounts as required by the CONTRACT
DOCUMENTS.
7. This Agreement shall be binding on all parties hereto and their respective heirs,
executors, administrators, successors and assigns.
113
01210-3
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed or caused to be executed by their
duly authorized officials, this Agreement in four (4) counterparts, each of which shall be deemed
an original, in the year and day first above written.
City of Mauldin
(OWNER)
By:____________________________________
_____________________________________
(Printed Name)
____________________________________
(Title of Authorized Official)
(SEAL)
ATTEST
__________________________________________
(Witness)
__________________________________________
(Witness)
Atlantic Coast Contractors,Inc.
(CONTRACTOR)
By:____________________________________
______________________________________
(Printed Name)
______________________________________
(Title)
7680 Townsend Drive
Denver, NC 28037
(SEAL)
ATTEST:
__________________________________________
(Secretary)
__________________________________________
(Witness)
(End of Section 01210)
114
December 1, 2023
Matthew D. Fleahman
Public Works Director
City of Mauldin
700 East Standing Springs Road
Simpsonville, SC 29680
Re: Basin RG2 Sanitary Sewer Rehabilitation Project
SCIIP Grant # A-23-C130
Recommendation of Award
Dear Matthew:
Bids were received for the Basin RG2 Sanitary Sewer Rehabilitation project on November 20, 2023 at 3:00 pm. The
following three bids were received:
Bidder Bid Amount
Atlantic Coast Contractors, Inc. $2,691,950.87 (see Note 1 below)
CaJenn Construction & Rehab Services, Inc $2,780,530.20
Portland Utilities Construction Company $3,619,006.24
Note 1: Atlantic Coast Contractor’s (ACC) bid had five minor math errors under Item’s No. 7A, B, C, D,
and E as listed below. These minor errors equated to a difference in the total bid price of only $19.41.
7A: 11,000 LF x $53.62 = $589,820.00; ACC’s bid listed $589,800.23
7B: 1,000 LF x $66.08 = $66,080.00; ACC’s bid listed $66,080.81
7C: 500 LF x $84.63 = $42,315.00; ACC’s bid listed $42,314.91
7D: 200 EA x $289.83 = $57,966.00; ACC’s bid listed $57,965.63
7E: 10 EA x $521.69 = $5,216.90; ACC’s bid listed $5,216.91
Correct Total = $761,397.90 – ACC Total $761,378.49 = +$19.41
These minor math errors in no way affect award of this Contract.
Each bid included a 5% bid bond. A certified bid tabulation is attached for your review.
We have reviewed the bids received and determined that all bids were responsive, responsible bids based on the
requirements specified in Specification Section 01110 of the Contract Documents. CHA Consulting, Inc. (CHA)
considers the unit prices received for this project to be reasonable for the work and in line with other sewer
rehabilitation projects recently bid in the Upstate.
We have determined the bid by Atlantic Coast Contractors, Inc. (ACC) to be the lowest responsive, responsible bid,
as defined by the Contract Documents, for this project. ACC’s bid prices for the work are reasonable and cost-
competitive for the planned work. In addition, ACC meets the specified experience requirements and has
successfully completed numerous similar CHA projects in Charlotte, NC over the last 20 years.
115
Based on our review, we recommend that the City of Mauldin award the Basin RG2 Sanitary Sewer Rehabilitation
Project to Atlantic Coast Contractors, Inc. for the total bid amount of $2,691,950.87.
Please let me know if you have any questions. We look forward to working with you throughout construction of this
project.
Sincerely,
CHA CONSULTING, INC.
Aaron M. Frazier, P.E. , Project Manager
Attachment: Certified Bid Tabulation
116
NOTICE OF AWARD
To: Atlantic Coast Contractors, Inc.
7680 Townsend Drive
Denver, NC 28037
Attn: Matt Butler
Project Description:
BASIN RG2 SANITARY SEWER REHABILITATION PROJECT
The OWNER has considered your BID submitted on November 20, 2023 for the above-
described WORK in response to its Advertisement for Bids and Information for Bidders.
The OWNER has approved your BID in the amount of $2,691,950.87 for award for the above-
described WORK pending and conditioned upon the following:
1. Execution of a written contract by both parties and delivery of the executed
Contract to the Contractor after approval and certification by the OWNER’s legal
counsel;
2. Delivery of the Contractor’s Performance Bond, the Payment Bond and the
required Certificates of Insurance within fifteen (15) calendar days from the date
of this Notice.
3. Obtaining any and all required regulatory agency approvals.
4. Procurement of all rights-of-way. In this instance your acceptance of this award
will be acknowledgment that you understand no Notice to Proceed will be issued
until final procurements of all rights-of-way for the project. The Contractor and
the Owner may agree for the Contractor to begin work in other areas of the
Project avoiding unprocured properties.
This Notice of Award is not a Contract.
If you fail to execute said Agreement and to furnish said Bonds and Certificates of Insurance
within fifteen (15) calendar days from the date of this Notice, said OWNER may elect to
consider all your rights arising out of the OWNER’S acceptance of your BID as abandoned and
as a forfeiture of your BID BOND. The OWNER may also pursue all other rights and remedies
it may have under law.
You are required to return an acknowledge copy of this Notice of Award to the OWNER.
117
DATED THIS ___________________DAY OF ____________________, 2024.
CITY OF MAULDIN (OWNER)
By: ____________________________________________
Title:______________________________________
ACCEPTANCE OF NOTICE
Receipt of the above Notice of Award is hereby acknowledged by Atlantic Coast Contractors,
Inc. this _______ day of ____________________, 2024.
By:_____________________________________
Title:____________________________________
118
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.