Finance Committee Agenda Feb 2024
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Feb 1, 2024 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
FINANCE AND POLICY
COMMITTEE MEETING
MONDAY, FEBR UARY 5, 2024 |6 PM
1st committee meeting
The Committee will meet in Mauldin City Hall at 5 East
Butler Road in the Council Chambers at 6 p.m.
The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at
https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting-minutes-agendas/ to access the
meeting via audio and videoconferencing.
A quorum of Council will be present.
1
FINANCE AND POLICY COMMITTEE MEETING
FEBRUARY 5, 2024, 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5 E. BUTLER ROAD
Co
mmittee Members:
1. Call to Order
2. Pu
blic Comment
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a.Finance Committee Minutes-January 2, 2024 [Pages 3-4]
4. Reports or Communications from City Officers
a. City Administrator Seth Duncan
Up date on 601 Bus Route
CGI Video Contract Expiration
b. Finance Director Holly Abercrombie
Budget Review
c.HR Director Mark Putnam
SCMIT/SCMIRF update [Pages
5-25]
5. Unfinished Business
There is no unfinished business.
6. New Business
a.Employee Handbook [Page 26]
7. Public Comment
8. Committee Concerns
9. Adjournment
Chairperson Reynolds
Chairperson Reynolds
Chairperson Reynolds
Chairperson Reynolds
Ch
airperson Reynolds
Ch
airperson Reynolds
Ch
airperson Reynolds
Chairperson Reynolds
Chairperson Reynolds
2
MINUTES
FINANCE AND POLICY COMMITTEE MEETING
JANUARY 2, 2024, 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
1st commitee mee�ng
C
ommitee Members present: Chairman Michael Reynolds, Commitee members Ta� Matney
and Carol King.
O
thers present: HR Director Mark Putnam and City Administrator Seth Duncan
1. C
all to Order- Chairman Reynolds
2. P
ublic Comment- None
3. R
eading and Approval of Minutes
a. Finance Commitee Minutes-November 6, 2023
Mo�on: Councilwoman King made a mo�on to approve the minutes.
Chairman Reynolds seconded the mo�on.
Councilman Matney did not vote since he was not a member of this commitee at the last
mee�ng.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (2-0).
4. R
eports or Communica�ons from City Officers
a. City Administrator Seth Duncan
Mr. Duncan reported Hometown Legisla�ve Ac�on Day is Tuesday, February 6th in
Columbia.
The Council mee�ng this month will move to January 16th from January 15th, which is the
Mar�n Luther King Jr . Holiday.
Finance Director Abercrombie was s�ll on vaca�on. Mr. Duncan reported property tax
revenues have started coming in.
b. Finance Director Holly Abercrombie
3
c. HR Director Mark Putnam
Mr. Putnam reported the comp/class plan was implemented, Juneteenth was added, and
the new FLSA/Comp �me policy was implemented last year. The personnel policy will be
looked at during the first quarter of the year. Councilwoman King said she looked
forward to going through the personnel policy again. The current version was adopted four
years ago.
5. U
nfinished Business- There is no unfinished business.
6. Ne
w Business- There is no new business.
7. P
ublic Comment- None
8. C
ommitee Concerns- None
9. A
djournment- Chairman Reynolds adjourned the mee�ng at 6:06 p.m.
R
espec�ully Submited,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
4
South Carolina
Municipal Insurance and
Risk Financing Fund
Annual Review
City of Mauldin
2023
5
The Right Partner Can Make All the Difference
The Risk Management Services programs of the Municipal Association of South Carolina endeavor to be the provider of
choice for the workers’ compensation, property and liability needs of South Carolina municipal entities. RMS’ mission is
to provide members with personalized service not found with traditional insurance.
On the following pages of this annual review, you’ll see data about RMS services provided to your entity for the past
year, as well as a snapshot of coverage, claims, grant usage, and participation by entity staff in RMS-offered trainings.
This annual review is meant to be a user-friendly report designed to provide concise information needed to gain an
understanding of your organization’s loss control efforts. Based on the numbers, you may want to encourage greater
participation in our no-cost training activities or inquire about grants your entity may be eligible to receive. Your RMS loss
control consultant is always available to help guide you.
On behalf of our board of trustees and staff, thank you for your continued membership. We look forward to another
successful year.
• 24/7 online resources • Online Claims Portal
• Law enforcement model policies • Quarterly newsletter, RiskLetter
• Loss prevention services and programs • GatherGuard Liability Coverage
• Liability reduction toolkits • Live seminars
• Dedicated claims adjusters onsite • LocalGovU online training
• Risk management manual available online • Annual grants
• Dedicated, local in-house loss control, underwriting
and claims staff
• Public works safety and risk management model
policies and procedures
• Response to resistance law enforcement simulator • Free labor and general liability hotlines
SCMIRF Member Resources
Grants Utilized in 2023
Hotline Hours Utilized in 2023
Training Services Utilized in 2023
Law Enforcement Liability Reduction $0
Public Works Property and Liability Reduction
Grant
$0
Employment Liability 10.00
General Liability 0.00
LocalGovU Courses Taken 401
Training Seminar Attendees 3
Member-Specific Onsite Training 0
Heather Ricard
Director of Risk Management Services
Page 1
6
Quick Look Indicators
2023 Change 2023 Annual Average
2018-2022
Property Claims Frequency
4 1
Property Claims Cost
$241,112 $4,266
Auto Physical Damage Claims Frequency
20 10
Auto Physical Damage Cost
$68,546 $21,918
Auto Liability Claims Frequency
15 9
Auto Liability Claims Cost
$77,711 $64,009
General Liability Claims Frequency
7 6
General Liability Claims Cost
$26,776 $93,454
Public Officials Claims Frequency
0 1
Public Officials Claims Cost
$0 $37,114
Law Enforcement Liability Claims Frequency
0 1
Law Enforcement Liability Claims Cost
$0 $14,694
Total Tort Claims Frequency
7 7
Total Tort Claims Cost
$26,776 $145,262
2023 Loss Summary
Coverage Open
Claims
Closed
Claims
Total
Claims
Total
Incurred
Loss Ratio Experienc
e Modifier
Unmodified
Premium
Modified
Premium
Property Claims 2 2 4 $241,112 302.47% n/a $79,716 n/a
Auto Physical
Damage Claims
2 18 20 $68,546 56.12% n/a $122,151 n/a
Automobile Liability
Claims
3 12 15 $77,711 61.06% 1.09 $127,274 $139,062
General Liability
Claims
2 5 7 $26,776 25.16% 0.56 $106,427 $59,089
Public Officials
Liability Claims
0 0 0 $0 0.00% 0.56 $50,625 $28,107
Law Enforcement
Liability Claims
0 0 0 $0 0.00% 0.56 $143,337 $79,581
Total Tort Liability
Claims
2 5 7 $26,776 8.91% 0.56 $300,390 $166,778
Reserves are only an estimate and may not be indicative of the final settlement value of a case
Page 2
7
Page 3
8
Page 4
9
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
Total
Claims
Total
Incurred
Total
Claims
Total
Incurred
Total
Claims
Total
Incurred
Total
Claims
Total
Incurred
Total
Claims
Total
Incurred
Automobile 12 $131,461 9 $44,156 8 $98,105 9 $20,027 15 $77,711
General
Liability
6 $2,275 3 $226,582 10 $28,130 2 $209,750 7 $26,776
Law
Enforcement
Liability
2 $0 0 $0 1 $20,000 0 $0 0 $0
Public
Officials
Liability
0 $0 0 $0 2 $185,572 1 $0 0 $0
Page 5
10
Total tort claims include general liability, law enforcement liability and public officials liability
Page 6
11
# of Claims Loss Cause Description Total
Incurred
1 3028 Slip & Fall Other Outside $20,015
1 3034 Clmt/Property Hit By Falling Obj $5,650
1 3131 Falling/Flying Object $1,111
1 3175 Loading/Unloading $0
1 3064 Faulty Roadway Holes Etc. $0
1 3058 Motorized Vehicle $0
1 3026 Slip & Fall Other Inside $0
# of Claims Loss Cause Description Total
Incurred
# of Claims Loss Cause Description Total
Incurred
2023 General Liability Top 10 Causes of Loss
2023 Law Enforcement Liability Top 10 Causes of Loss
2023 Public Officials Liability Top 10 Causes of Loss
Page 7
12
Page 8
13
# of Claims Loss Cause Description Total
Incurred
6 1001 Rear-Ended Ov $49,967
1 1029 Ran Off Road $15,987
2 1043 Debris Falling Off Vehicle $6,575
2 1004 Hit Parked Vehicle $4,200
1 1003 Hit While Parked $856
1 1025 Backed Into Ov $125
1 1026 Backed Into By Ov $0
1 1011 Hit Stationary Obj. $0
2023 Auto Liability Top 10 Causes of Loss
# of Claims Loss Cause Description Total
Incurred
2 4001 Rear-Ended Ov $31,492
3 4011 Hit Stationary Obj. $12,597
1 4034 Oth Hit Insured-Lane Chg $8,062
3 4028 Intersection-Not At Fault $6,757
1 4029 Ran Off Road $6,213
1 4504 Hail Damage $3,265
1 4026 Backed Into By Ov $125
2 4002 Rear-Ended By Ov $35
2 4004 Hit Parked Vehicle $0
2 4600 No Damage Member Vehicle $0
2023 Auto Physical Damage Top 10 Causes of Loss
Mauldin Vehicles 201
Pool average of vehicles with an auto claim 9.10%
Percent of Mauldin vehicles with an auto claim 17.40%
Pool average incurred claims cost per fleet vehicle $556
Total incurred cost per Mauldin vehicle claim $728
2023 City of Mauldin Vehicle Claims Versus SCMIRF Pool Vehicle Claims
Page 9
14
Modifier Savings
0.50 $163,009
0.75 $54,080
1.00 ($54,849)
1.50 ($272,706)
2.50 ($708,421)
Total Amount
Modified and Unmodified
Lines
$609,761
Deductible Credit $0
Membership Credit (2%) ($13,684)
Excess Liability Charge $0
Premium Adjustment $0
Cyber Liability $0
Final Billed Premium $596,077
Line Of Coverage Amount
Property $99,329
Auto Physical Damage $124,653
Boiler and Machinery $3,358
Crime $1,554
Bond $0
Total Unmodified Lines $228,894
Line Of Coverage Auto Liability General Liability Law Enforcement
Liability
Public Official
Liability
Unmodified Premium $126,475 $113,377 $168,086 $50,709
Experience Modifier 1.35 0.69 0.69 0.69
Modified Premium $170,382 $78,684 $116,653 $35,192
Risk Self-Assessment
Adjustment (5%)
($8,519) ($3,934) ($5,833) ($1,760)
Total Modified
Premium
$161,863 $74,750 $110,820 $33,433
Total - Modified
Lines
$380,866
2024 SCMIRF Premium Breakdown
Modified Lines of Coverage
Unmodified Lines of Coverage
Final Billed Premium
Hypothetical Premium Analysis with Different Experience
Modifiers
Per Claim Deductible = $1,000
Per Claim Deductible = $0
2023 Risk Self-Assessment Score: 100%
Premium values may not reflect waived amounts due to changes requested throughout the policy year
Page 10
15
Experience Modification Factors
Year Automobile
Liability
Tort Liability
2024 1.35 0.69
2023 1.09 0.56
2022 0.87 0.58
2021 0.70 0.78
2020 0.56 1.03
2019 0.52 1.30
Member to SCMIRF
Claim Reporting Lag
Time
Days
City of Mauldin 5.0
SCMIRF Pool Claim
Reporting Lag Time
7.2
Page 11
16
South Carolina Municipal Insurance Trust
Annual Review
City of Mauldin
2023
17
The Right Partner Can Make All The Difference
The Risk Management Services programs of the Municipal Association of South Carolina endeavor to be the provider of
choice for the workers’ compensation, property and liability needs of South Carolina municipal entities. RMS’ mission is
to provide members with personalized service not found with traditional insurance.
On the following pages of this annual review, you’ll see data about RMS services provided to your entity for the past
year, as well as a snapshot of coverage, claims, grant usage and participation by entity staff in RMS-offered trainings.
This annual review is meant to be a user-friendly report designed to provide concise information needed to gain an
understanding of your organization’s loss control efforts. Based on the numbers, you may want to encourage greater
participation in our no-cost training activities or inquire about grants your entity may be eligible to receive. Your RMS loss
control consultant is always available to help guide you.
On behalf of our board of trustees and staff, thank you for your continued membership. We look forward to another
successful year.
SCMIT Member Resources
• 24/7 online resources • Quarterly newsletter, RiskLetter
• Fire service model policies • Training calendar
• Loss prevention services and programs • Training resources
• Annual grants • Live seminars
• Risk management manual available online • LocalGovU online training
• Dedicated, local in-house loss control,
underwriting and claims staff
• Public works safety and risk management
model policies and procedures
• Online Claims Portal • Response to resistance law enforcement
simulator
Grants Utilized in 2023
Training Services Utilized in 2023
Fire Service $0
Law Enforcement Officer Safety Grant $788
Public Works $0
LocalGovU Courses Taken 401
Training Seminar Attendees 3
Member-Specific Onsite Training 0
Heather Ricard
Director of Risk Management Services
Page 1
18
Quick Look Indicators
2023
Change
2023 Annual Average
2018-2022
Total Claims (excluding Notice Only)
21 22
Medical-Only Claims
8 11
Notice-Only Claims
4 6
Indemnity Claims
13 11
Claims over $75,000
0 2
Total Incurred Claims
$55,317 $402,132
Capped Incurred Claims ($75,000)
$55,317 $185,311
Medical Cost Incurred Per Claim
$1,130 $5,030
Medical Cost (SCMIT Pool Average Per Claim)
$2,060 $4,152
Indemnity Cost Incurred Per Claim
$192 $14,591
Indemnity Cost (SCMIT Pool Average Per Claim)
$1,978 $10,694
Average Cost Per Claim
$2,634 $18,446
Experience Modifiers
1.61 1.12
Loss Ratio
14.68% 120.35%
Summary of Losses
Year Open
Claims
Closed
Claims
Total
Claims
Total
Incurred
Losses
Experience
Modifier
Unmodified
Premium
Modified
Premium
Loss
Ratio
2023 8 13 21 $55,317 1.61 $376,721 $605,021 14.68%
2022 3 20 23 $491,929 1.47 $342,170 $502,568 143.77%
2021 0 18 18 $235,460 1.18 $354,982 $417,109 66.33%
2020 2 20 22 $843,367 1.05 $315,560 $332,327 267.26%
2019 0 28 28 $192,846 0.99 $328,460 $323,869 58.71%
2018 0 18 18 $247,057 0.94 $329,474 $308,784 74.99%
Reserves are only an estimate and may not be indicative of the final settlement value of a case
Page 2
19
Page 3
20
# of Claims Body Part Code Body Part Description Total Incurred
7 35 Hand $22,290
1 12 Brain $8,964
1 90 Multiple body parts $5,876
1 10 Multiple head injury $5,271
1 53 Knee(s) $4,015
3 42 LOW BACK AREA (LUMBAR AREA & LUMBO SACRA $3,252
1 54 LOWER LEG (TIBIA, FIBULA AND CORRESPONDI $2,765
1 04W Face $1,000
1 33 Lower arm $511
1 55 Ankle $449
# of Claims Loss Nature Code Loss Nature Description Total Incurred
1 28 Fracture $19,989
2 07 Concussion $14,235
3 16 DISLOCATION (PINCHED NERVE,SLIPPED DISC, $9,052
3 37 Inflammation $4,814
4 52 Strain $3,500
6 40 Laceration $3,463
1 66 Poisoning - chemical (Other than metals) $264
1 04 Burn $0
# of Claims Loss Cause Code Loss Cause Description Total Incurred
1 10 Caught; machine or machinery $19,989
2 77 Injured by; motor vehicle $9,212
1 25 Fall; from different level/elevation $5,876
4 74 Injured by; fellow worker, patient $5,325
1 26 Fall; from ladder or scaffolding $5,271
4 79 Injured by; object being lifted/handled $3,663
1 99 Misc; other - miscellaneous, NOC $2,765
2 85 Injured by; animal or insect $1,275
1 81 Injured by; struck or injured NOC $1,000
1 12 Caught; object handled $478
2023 Top 10 Losses by Body Part
2023 Top 10 Losses by Nature
2023 Top 10 Losses by Cause
Page 4
21
2023 Losses by Job Classification Number of Claims Total Incurred Average Loss
BUILDING/ MAINTENANCE & CUSTODIAL 2 $8,036 $4,018
FIREFIGHTERS 6 $8,070 $1,345
LANDSCAPE GARDENING & DRIVERS 1 $19,989 $19,989
MUNI,TOWNSHIP,CO/ST EMPLY NOC 1 $182 $182
POLICE OFFICERS & DRIVERS 11 $19,041 $1,731
Page 5
22
Page 6
23
Page 7
24
2023 Lag Time Averages Days
Mauldin Reporting Lag Time 1.76
Employee Reporting Lag Time 0.62
2023 Claims Averages
Mauldin full-time equivalents 295
Number of claims per 100 full-time
equivalents
7.13
SCMIT claims per 100 full-time equivalents 6.97
Total incurred cost per 100 full-time
equivalents
$188
SCMIT incurred cost per 100 full-time
equivalents
$1,074
2024 SCMIT Premium Breakdown
Per Claim Deductible Amount $2,500
Unmodified Premium $362,653
Experience Modifier 1.63
Modified Premium $589,718
Risk Self-Assessment Adjustment (5%) ($29,486)
Deductible Credit ($50,981)
Membership Credit (2%) ($7,253)
Final Premium $501,998
2023 Risk Self-Assessment Score: 100%
Hypothetical Premium Analysis with Different
Ex Mods
Modifier Savings
0.50 $352,667
0.75 $274,374
1.00 $196,082
1.50 $39,498
2.50 ($273,671)
Page 8
25
FINANCE AND POLICY COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM
MEETING DATE: February 5, 2024
AGENDA ITEM: Discussion on Employee Handbook Revision Procedures
TO: City Council
FROM: Human Resources Director
ITEM NUMBER: 6a
SUBJECT: Discussion o n Employee Handbook Revisions
REQUEST
Discussion on employee handbook revision process and to receive initial Committee feedback on
potential revisions to the employee handbook.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
Mauldin’s current employee handbook was revised and adopted in 2020. The employee
handbook is four (4) years old and needs to be revisited and revisions made where needed to
ensure compliance with state/federal law and other personnel changes adopted by Council.
ANALYSIS
The City’s Human Resources staff will begin the process of drafting revisions to the employee
handbook to ensure compliance with state/federal law and other personnel changes adopted
by Council. During this process, staff will review handbooks from local municipalities, MASC
model handbook and consult with labor attorney Kevin Strum. HR staff will also evaluate
current processes and policies against best practices, emerging opportunities regarding
retention and recruitment, and a benefits review. HR staff will also conduct a listening
session/survey with staff to see what internal ideas might be worth exploring as well. The
timeline for handbook revision to be brought forward to committee for review is May 2024.
FISCAL IMPACT
None associated with this request.
RECOMMENDATION
Provide HR staff with initial feedback on specific items, themes or new benefits Council would
like to see staff evaluate during the handbook revision process.
26
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.