Public Works Committee november 2023 agenda
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Nov 3, 2023 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC WORKS
COMMITTEE MEETING
MONDAY,NOVEMBER 6, 2023 | 6 PM
3rd Committee Meeting
The Committee will meet in Mauldin City Hall at 5 East
Butler Road in the Council Chambers at 6 p.m.
The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at
https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting-minutes-agendas/ to access the
meeting via audio and videoconferencing.
A quorum of Council will be present.
1
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE MEETING
NOVEMBER 6 , 2023, 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5 E. BUTLER ROAD
Co
mmittee Members: Jason Kraeling (Chair), Carol King, Michael Reynolds
1. Ca
ll to Order
2. Publ
ic Comment
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a.Public Works Committee- September 5, 2023 [Pages 3-5]
4. Reports or Communications from City Officers
a. PW Director Matthew Fleahman
Sidewalk Update
5. Unfinished Business
There is no unfinished business.
6. New Business
a.Discussion on Stormwater Fee Report [Pages 6-34]
7. Public Comment
8. Committee Concerns
9. Adjournment
Chairperson Jason Kraeling
Ch
airperson Jason Kraeling
Ch
airperson Jason Kraeling
Ch
airperson Jason Kraeling
Ch
airperson Jason Kraeling
Ch
airperson Jason Kraeling
Ch
airperson Jason Kraeling
Ch
airperson Jason Kraeling
Ch
airperson Jason Kraeling
2
MINUTES
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE MEETING SEPTEMBER 5, 2023, 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
1st commitee mee�ng
C
ommitee Members: Chairman Jason Kraeling and Commitee Member Michael Reynolds.
Councilwoman King joined during the department report.
O
thers present: PW Director Mathew Fleahman and City Administrator Seth Duncan
1. C
all to Order- Chairman Kraeling
2. P
ublic Comment- None
3. R
eading and Approval of Minutes
a. Public Works Commitee- August 7, 2023
Mo�on: Councilman Reynolds made a mo�on to approve the minutes with Chairman Kraeling
seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (2-0).
4. R
eports or Communica�ons from City Officers
a. PW Director Mathew Fleahman
M
r. Fleahman reported $46,250 has been made so far on the sale of vehicles and other older
assets.
All of the City vehicle’s GPS units have been updated.
5. U
nfinished Business- There is no unfinished business.
6. N
ew Business
a. Resolu�on- Transfer of Assets from ReWa to City of Mauldin
Authoriza�on is requested to execute the Right-of-Way (ROW) Assignment of Facili�es and the Quit-
Claim Deed for the transfer of assets from Renewable Water Resources (REWA) to the City of
Mauldin.
D
uring the design phase of the Indigo Pointe Subdivision, REWA required that the developer upsize
the associated pump sta�on to accommodate the flow from approximately 100 homes in the Pine
Forest Subdivision. This upsizing allowed REWA to decommission a pump sta�on in the Pine Forest
Subdivision once a gravity connec�on to the Indigo Pointe was made.
D
uring the 2021 calendar year REWA worked with MetroConnects and the City of Mauldin to design
a series of new gravity mains and manholes to redirect flow into the City’s collec�on system
network. Construc�on ac�vi�es began in 2022 and finished by the end of the year. Approximately
290 linear feet of new sewer main and one manhole was installed to connect to the City’s system.
3
All appropriate sewer system tests were conducted and passed under the supervision of City staff.
The City’s system started accep�ng flows at the end of 2022 and no issues have been noted to
date. The final step in the process is to transfer ownership of these assets from REWA to the City of
Mauldin. The new line bisects two individual parcels, so two separate documents are necessary for
the ROW assignment.
Mo�on: Councilman Reynolds made a mo�on to send this item to Council with Councilwoman
King seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
b. Discussion- Recycling Program Change
Th
e City of Mauldin began its implementa�on of side arm trucks into the Sanita�on Division in
March 2020. Ini�ally, the plan was only to replace trash trucks; however, the plan evolved, and
recycling trucks were added to the replacement plan. During the 2021 fiscal year, City Council
approved the purchase of two side arm trucks to replace the rear loading recycle trucks. Delivery
dates for the trucks con�nued to be pushed back due to several issues; however, they are now part
of the City’s fleet.
Unlike trash, recycling services have been provided in more than one container. Both a roll out can
and a small bin have been u�lized for curbside services. Side-arm trucks cannot serve the small
bin, so in an�cipa�on of the transi�on, Public Works discon�nued the sale of small bins in 2021.
In order to minimize confusion over the transi�on to side-arm recycling service, the Public Works
Department intends to generate and distribute a door hanger to every Sanita�on customer in the
City which will include the cost of blue cans, the start date of the trucks, loca�ons to place blue
cans, materials accepted in blue cans, and no�ce that blue bins will no longer be served. In
addi�on to the door hangers, the Public Works Department intends to ini�ate a 45-day public
outreach campaign on both the City’s Website and social media, sharing the same informa�on
presented on the door hangers. In both cases, it will be clearly iden�fied that the City will not be
providing blue cans for free and it will be the responsibility of the homeowner to purchase a can if
recycling services are desired. Recycling bins are $50.00 each, which is the City’s cost. This is not a
revenue-genera�ng program.
Councilman Reynolds sugges�ng offering the cans at a discount. Mr. Duncan said there are new
neighborhoods purchasing the new bins now, and it would not be fair to discount some of the cans
but not all.
Councilwoman King thanked Mr. Fleahman for including informa�on on what can be recycled for
ci�zens’ educa�on.
Chairman Kraeling said it could be added to the door hanger wording that the City is picking up
addi�onal cans without a tax increase.
This item was for informa�on only.
4
7. Public Comment- None
8. C
ommitee Concerns-Chairman Kraeling thanked the department for promptly taking care of a
damaged garbage can complaint.
C
ouncilman Reynolds expressed his condolences for the loss of a Public Works employee over the
weekend.
9. A
djournment- Chairman Kraeling adjourned the mee�ng at 6:18 p.m.
R
espec�ully Submited,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
5
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM
M
EETING DATE: November 6, 2023
AG
ENDA ITEM: 6a
TO
: Public Works Committee
FROM: Public Works Director, Matthew Fleahman
SUBJECT: Stormwater Fee Analysis and Evaluation
REQUEST
For discussion purposes, the Public Works Committee asked to review the 2023 Stormwater Fee Analysis
and Evaluation prepared by KCI and provide feedback on the contents of the report.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
The City of Mauldin is part of Greenville County’s MS4 Stormwater permit. As part of the permit, the City
is responsible for drainage structures within City -Owned rights-of- way (ROWs). The Publ ic Works
Department inspects and maintains these drainage systems so that stormwater will be properly conveyed to
drainage outfalls. The existing system includes 3,103 catch basins, 8 stormwater detention ponds, and
approximately 58 miles of stormwater pipes in sizes varying from 6-inch to 96-inches. The City allocated
$34,000 in funding to maintain City-owned rights-of-way related to stormwater in FY2024.
T
he City had identified a need to fund stormwater capital improvement projects where the project costs and
scope exceed the budget and abilities of the Public Works Department. It was determined that design and
construction could be contracted and potentially paid for through a Capital Improvement Plan and/or
enterprise fund. In June of 2023, the Public Works Committee and City Council authorized KCI to conduct
a Stormwater Fee Analysis and Evaluation. The intent of the report was to determine a potentia l funding
source and identify the operating budget based on the revenues from the potential funding source. The
report was presented to Council in September 2023, and staff from KCI were present at the October 2023
Council meeting to present the findings of the report.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
The 2023 Stormwater Fee Analysis and Evaluation prepared by KCI compared four cities of similar size
and population and presented the stormwater fee associated with each. This comparison illustrated that the
City of Mauldin’s residents pay less than 50% of the lowest fee associated with the comparable cities. In
the report, KCI made several considerations for determining the potential fee and generated five potential
alternatives. Each alternative was evaluated, and a potential revenue stream was identified for each. These
revenue streams varied from $257,000 to $725,000 annually. In all but one of the five alternatives, the
majority (approximately 66%) of the potential revenue stream is funded from non-residential entities.
6
As part of the report, KCI proposed the utilization of this revenue stream to create an independent
Stormwater Division in Public Works. The proposal identified Capital needs, staffing needs, and a
recommendation on the amount of work proposed annually. The revenue stream was also presented to fund
a Capital Projects Budget, where contracted design and construction services could be obtained to work on
large scale projects.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
The financial impact will be determined bas ed upon the approach adopted by Council. If this program
proceeds, a stormwater fee would be assessed on property tax bills (as current) and remitted to the City by
the County. Funding could become first available in FY2025 with most work and projects begi nning
FY2026.
ADMINISTRATOR COMMENTS
The only way to improve or remediate stormwater issues beyond the public right-of-way is through the
implementation of a stormwater capital fund. This fund should be comprised of revenue generated for
specific purposes and segmented from other activities.
7
ISO 9001:2015 Certified | Employee-owned Since 1988
Stormwater Utility
Fee Evaluation
City of Mauldin Public Works
October 16th, 2023
8
Background
City of Mauldin
Population increased 8.8% from 2020-2022
Current population roughly 27,500
Rising concerns of flooding along with increased
costs
9
Background
Greenville County Stormwater
Charges between $22.80-$25.65 annually
Annually the County collects roughly $707,000 from
the City’s property owners
City of Mauldin does not receive any of these funds
10
Analysis and Comparison of Similar Cities
Comparison to
c
ities of similar
size and/or
population
Cities Used for
Co
mparison
► City of Anderson
► City of North
Augusta
► Town of Fort Mill
► City of Greenville
11
Analysis and Comparison
of Similar Cities
Comparison of average annual
residential fee to area of the city Comparison of average annual residential
fee to population of the city
12
Overview of Fee Structure Analysis
Considerations
Flat or Variable Fee
Equivalent Residential Units (ERUs)
Minimum charge
Fee Credits
13
Overview of Fee Structure Analysis
Fee Structure Alternatives
Alternative
Flat or
Variable Fee
(Residential)
Flat or
Variable Fee
(Non-
residential)
Minimum
Charge
Fee
Credits
1 Flat Fee Flat Fee Yes No
2 Variable Fee Variable Fee No No
3 Variable Fee Variable Fee Yes Yes
4 Flat Fee Variable Fee No No
5 Flat Fee Variable Fee Yes Yes
14
Analysis
Fee Structure
Alternative Residential Fee Non-residential Fee Minimum
Charge
Fee
Credits
1 $25 developed or undeveloped $45 for developed
$25 for undeveloped
Yes No
2 $25 - <1,000 sq ft and developed
or undeveloped
$28 - >1,000 sq ft and developed
$27 per ERU for developed
$25 for undeveloped
No No
3 $25 - <1,000 sq ft and developed
or undeveloped
$28 - >1,000 sq ft and developed
$27 per ERU for developed
$25 for undeveloped
Yes Yes
4 $25 developed or undeveloped $27 per ERU for developed
$25 for undeveloped
No No
5 $25 developed or undeveloped $27 per ERU for developed
$25 for undeveloped
Yes Yes
Alternative
Residential
Fees
Collected
Non-
residential
Fee
Total Fee Minimum
Charge
Fee
Credits
1 $225,000 $32,000 $257,000 $25 None
2 $245,000 $484,000 $725,000 None None
3 $245,000 $476,740 $717,740 $25 $7,260
4 $226,500 $484,000 $710,000 None None
5 $226,500 $476,740 $702,740 $25 $7,260
15
Analysis
Fee Structure
Residential Fee Non-residential Fee Total Fee Collected Annually
$25.65 (Greenville
County Existing
Fee)
$27 per ERU for
developed
$22.80 for undeveloped
$707,000
$28 (Alternative 2
fee)
$27 per ERU for
developed
$25 for undeveloped
$725,000
$30 $32 per ERU for
developed
$30 for undeveloped
$848,000
$35 $37 per ERU for
developed
$35 for undeveloped
$983,000
$36 $37.50 per ERU for
developed
$36 for undeveloped
$1,000,000
$72 $74.50 per ERU for
developed
$72 for undeveloped
$2,000,000
16
Analysis
Fee Structure
City Residential Fee
City of Anderson $54
City of North Augusta $60
Town of Fort Mill $72
City of Greenville $79.33
Greenville County Existing $25.65
City of Mauldin ($725,000 collected annually) $25.65 + $28
City of Mauldin ($848,000 collected annually) $25.65 + $30
City of Mauldin ($983,000 collected annually) $25.65 + $35
City of Mauldin ($1,000,000 collected annually) $25.65 + $36
City of Mauldin ($2,000,000 collected annually) $25.65 + $72
17
Analysis
Stormwater Utility Fee Use Scenarios
Option 1
• Bid out work to
various
contractors
annually
Option 2
• In-house crew to
include 4
employees &
equipment
Option 3
• Hybrid of In-
house crew and
bidding out
work annually
Annual Cost
3 Crew @ $20/hr w/ benefits $195,000
1 Crew Leader @$25/hr w/ benefits $80,000
Equipment (truck, trailer, dump truck, mini ex) $40,000
Fuel & Maintenance $10,000
Total $325,000
18
Analysis
Stormwater Utility Fee Budgeting Scenarios
Using option 3 –hybrid approach
With an annual revenue of $725,000
• $550,000 annually for in-house construction
• $175,000 annually for contracted work
Annual Cost
4-Man Crew $325,000
7,800 LF of 18-in installed over 13 weeks $93,600
2,600 LF of 24-in installed over 13 weeks $52,000
Structures and Misc. Stone $79,400
26 weeks of repairs, maintenance, emergencies No additional Cost
Total $550,000
19
Analysis
Stormwater Utility Fee Projects
Knollwood
Drive
$200,000
Holly
Springs
$500,000
Bishop
Heights
$2,050,000
Year 1 - Bid
Knollwood
Drive
Year 4 - Bid
Holly Springs
Year 11 - Bid
Bishop
Heights
20
Conclusions & Recommendations
Recommended Fee Structure
Residential
< 1,000 sq ft,
developed or
undeveloped
= $25
Residential
> 1,000 sq ft
& developed
= $28
Non-
residential
developed
= $27 * ERU
Non-
residential
undeveloped
= $25
Stormwater Improvement Project Funding
In-House Contracted
$550,000 $175,000
21
Design Report
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
Prepared for:
City of Mauldin
Prepared by:
KCI Technologies Inc.
8.22.2023
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:03 PM
22
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 2
Background
In recent years, the City of Mauldin (the City) has experienced significant growth coinciding with
population increases throughout the Upstate of South Carolina. Along with new development, the City
has also annexed previously unincorporated portions of Greenville County into the City. Census records
show that the City’s population has increased 8.8% from 2020 to 2022 alone. The current population for
the City is roughly 27,500 people. Along with this growth has come rising concerns of flooding and
stormwater management within the City. As infrastructure has aged and costs for construction have
increased, the overall cost to maintain a stormwater system has become an increased concern that requires
the City to look at various funding options.
The purpose of this evaluation is to assess funding options for the City to develop and fund a capital
improvements program with the goal of maintaining their existing stormwater infrastructure. The City has
tasked KCI with evaluating the best way to fund a capital improvements budget and determine what a
reasonable stormwater improvements budget would be for the City based on a 10-year cycle. The fee
collected would be in addition to the current fee landowners pay to Greenville County, but the funds
would go directly into the City’s special revenue fund for stormwater. The additional fee assessment
would be applied to the incorporated areas of the City.
Greenville County currently charges a stormwater utility fee across the entire county, including all
incorporated cities, such as the City of Mauldin, with the exception of the City of Greenville which
charges citizens its own fee. Greenville County also collects stormwater permitting fees for new
developments throughout the County. These fees are used to fund Greenville County’s MS4 Land
Development Department. Although landowners within the City pay fees to Greenville County each year,
the City does not directly receive any funding from those fees to fund repair or improvement projects
within the city limits.
Greenville County currently charges between $22.80 to $25.65 per year for single family residential
properties, agricultural properties, and vacant properties zoned as commercial. For all other properties,
such as multi-family residential properties and commercial or industrial properties, an equivalent
residential unit (ERU) is calculated based on the property’s impervious area. The total impervious area is
then divided by 2,477 square feet to determine the ERU for the property. This ERU is multiplied by $27
to calculate the total fee for the property. Greenville County lists specific properties that are exempt from
this stormwater fee. A breakdown of Greenville County’s Fee and Billing Polices is shown in Appendix
A. Based on data received from Greenville County, the County collects roughly $707,000 annually in fees
from landowners within the City.
Analysis and Comparison of Similar Cities
As a point of reference, several cities similar in size and circumstance to the City were evaluated to
determine how other entities collect fees to maintain their stormwater infrastructure. Figure 1 shows the
comparison of population and growth rate for each city that was compared.
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:03 PM
23
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 3
Figure 1 - Population Growth Comparison
City of Anderson, South Carolina
The City of Anderson is similarly located within the Upstate of South Carolina and has a comparable
population size to the City of Mauldin with an estimated population of roughly 29,500 residents. The City
of Anderson is roughly 15 square miles. The City of Anderson stormwater fee is based on an Equivalent
Residential Unit (ERU) and is broken down into two types, residential and non-residential properties.
All residential properties are equal to one (1) ERU and are billed $4.50 monthly for a total fee of $54 each
year. This is also considered the minimum charge per parcel regardless of parcel size or runoff coefficient
(C).
The City of Anderson uses a runoff coefficient (C) to relate the impervious area to the density of
development or land use of the parcel. The ERU for each parcel is determined using a formula that
accounts for the parcel area, the runoff coefficient, an average residential parcel area and an average
residential runoff coefficient. This ERU is then multiplied by the same $4.50 monthly fee to calculate the
total monthly fee for each non-residential parcel. The City of Anderson’s full Stormwater Utility Fee
Manual is provided in Appendix B.
The City of Anderson also offers a stormwater fee credit to non-residential undeveloped or vacant lots
based on their reduced impact of development and reduced water quality impairment on the drainage area.
Several examples of this fee credit calculation are shown in the City of Anderson Stormwater Utility Fee
Manual.
5000
15000
25000
35000
45000
55000
65000
75000
1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020
Population
Year
Population Growth Comparison
Mauldin Anderson North Augusta Fort Mill Greenville
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:04 PM
24
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 4
Town of Fort Mill, South Carolina
The Town of Fort Mill is similar in population size to the City of Mauldin with a population of roughly
28,000. The Town of Fort Mill is roughly 5 square miles. The Town of Fort Mill is a suburb of Charlotte,
North Carolina.
The Town of Fort Mill’s most recent stormwater utility fee credit manual was released in October 2014.
The Town of Fort Mill bases its stormwater fee on an ERU for both residential and non-residential
properties. The ERU is based on a calculated average impervious area for a single-family parcel in the
town limits. The town charges $72 per ERU. The Fort Mill system does not differentiate between
property types and is based solely on size of parcel. If a parcel is equivalent to 4 ERUs, then the fee of
$72 is multiplied by 4 ERUs and the fee for that property would be $288 yearly.
The Town of Fort Mill also provides utility credits for citizens who help mitigate both pollution and
stormwater flow. The maximum reduction a property owner can receive is 50%. Credits are given for
mitigation efforts, such as rain barrels, rain gardens, and vegetated filter strips. The Town of Fort Mill’s
Stormwater Utility Fee Facts sheet and the Stormwater Utility Fee Credit Manual are provided in
Appendix C.
City of North Augusta, South Carolina
The City of North Augusta is similar in size to the City of Mauldin with a population of roughly 24,500.
The City of North Augusta is roughly 20 square miles. It is a smaller, growing city that surrounds the
larger City of Augusta, Georgia.
The property owner is charged $5 per ERU per month for a total of $60 per ERU per year. Single-family
residential properties are charged one ERU, while multi-family residential properties are charged 0.75
ERU for each dwelling.
Non-residential properties are charged based on a calculated ERU for each property. The fee is based on
the impervious area and a runoff coefficient which is determined by the property use. For example, a
hotel would have an ERU of 5.71 per acre while a shopping center would have an ERU of 6.58 per acre.
Properties with less than 25% of pervious surface are charged at a rate of 8.66 ERU per acre, which is the
maximum rate that the City of North Augusta charges. The guidance for the City of North Augusta’s
stormwater utility fee is shown in detail in their municipal code, provided in Appendix D.
The City of North Augusta also offers exemptions and credits based on the property type and stormwater
management used on site. The minimum charge was set at one ERU, regardless of credits or exemptions
granted. The City of North Augusta’s Stormwater Management Service Charge Credits Technical
Manual is provided in Appendix D.
City of Greenville, South Carolina
Although the City of Greenville is larger in population than the City of Mauldin, it is the only other City
within Greenville County that currently charges a stormwater utility fee separate from the fee charged by
Greenville County. The population of the City of Greenville is around 72,000 and is roughly 30 square
miles.
Greenville County’s stormwater utility fee is broken down between residential and non-residential
properties. Developed residential property with less than 1,640 square feet of livable space are charged
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:04 PM
25
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 5
$45.17 yearly and developed residential property with greater than 1,640 square feet of livable space are
charged $79.33. Undeveloped residential properties are charged $45.17.
Developed commercial/industrial properties and undeveloped commercial/industrial properties are each
charged $79.33 annually per ERU. The City of Greenville’s Stormwater Utility Fee Chart is shown in
Appendix E.
The City of Greenville also offers deductions from the stormwater utility fee for non-residential properties
where owners implement stormwater quantity and quality control measures. The City of Greenville’s
Credit Fee Deductions Manual is shown in Appendix E.
Additional Comparison of Similar Cities
The graphs that follow sumamrize data regarding each city and town. Figure 2 compared the residential
fee or fee per ERU and the population of each city. Figure 3 compared the residential fee or fee per ERU
and the area of the city.
Figure 2- Fee Compared to Population
0
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
60000
70000
80000
$0.00
$10.00
$20.00
$30.00
$40.00
$50.00
$60.00
$70.00
$80.00
$90.00
Mauldin Anderson North Augusta Fort Mill Greenville
Population
Residential Fee or Fee per ERU ($)
City
Fee Compared to Population
Fee (per year) Population
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:04 PM
26
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 6
Figure 3 - Fee Compared to Area of City
Overview of Fee Structure Analysis
In reviewing and analyzing the stormwater utility fee structure for the cities summarized, it was quickly
apparent that each community has a different fee structure and applied different formulas that may have
been established based on special circumstance or for political reasons. The narrative that follows
provides the potential advantages and cautions of note related to the various fee structure components.
Flat or Variable Fee
A flat fee for each property would be a set fee charged to each property owner regardless of the property
type or use. Although this is a simple way to distribute fees, it may not account for the impact each
property has on the overall stormwater drainage issues within the City in an equitable manner.
A variable fee can be determined by two methods:
1. Based on property’s total impervious area
Determine an ERU for each property
2. Based on a calculated runoff coefficient
assigned by property use
ERU calculated for each acre of property
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
$0.00
$10.00
$20.00
$30.00
$40.00
$50.00
$60.00
$70.00
$80.00
$90.00
Mauldin Anderson North Augusta Fort Mill Greenville
City Area (Square Miles)
Residential Fee or Fee per ERU ($)
City
Fee Compared to Area of City
Fee (per year) City Area (Sq mi)
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:04 PM
27
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 7
This varying fee helps account for the variable impact that each property has on the overall stormwater
drainage system and is a more equitable way to account for the amount of stormwater flow each parcel of
land will contribute.
Equivalent Residential Units (ERUs)
Based on the previous year’s fee collection data for the City, Greenville County currently calculates
ERUs such that the percentage of fees collected from residential properties versus non-residential
properties is proportional to the amount of impervious area that each contributes. The fees are based on
impervious area, with residential properties accounting for roughly 30% of the fees and impervious area,
while non-residential properties accounts for roughly 70% of the fees and impervious area. Greenville
County’s method applied to the City appears to have an equitable way to allocate fees for residential and
non-residential properties. This breakdown of fees is similar to what other cities and counties use but does
not take into account runoff coefficients that smaller cities may also consider.
Figure 4 - Total Impervious Area
Minimum Charge
Setting a minimum charge ensures that the City meets its yearly funding goals and that every property
owner, except for those exempt, is contributing to the continued maintenance of the stormwater
infrastructure that they benefit from.
Fee Credits
Fee credits allow for homeowners to receive reimbursement for stormwater management measures they
implement that will benefit the stormwater system as a whole. It also helps to incentivize property owners
to implement stormwater management measures. Below are some examples of credits that the City could
offer to their residents.
Residential
29%
Non-
Residential
71%
Total Impervious Area
Residential
31%
Non-
Residential
69%
Total Fees Collected
Figure 5 - Total Fees Collected
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:04 PM
28
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 8
Table 1 - Fee Credit Reductions
One drawback of offering fee credits is the additional costs required for the City to process applications,
review them and then maintain a database of the fee credits awarded each year. Also, the public’s
misunderstanding of these fee credits could be a factor.
Fee Structure Alternatives
After analyzing the various fee structures, five (5) alternatives were developed for consideration. The
alternatives are summarized below:
► 1 - Flat fee for all residential, industrial, and commercial properties; minimum charge set; no
fee credits
► 2 - Variable fee for residential and non-residential based on impervious area/ERUs; no
minimum charge set; no fee credits allowed
► 3 - Variable fee for residential and non-residential based on impervious area/ERUs; minimum
charge set; fee credits allowed
► 4 - Fee broken down between residential and non-residential properties; flat fee for residential
and calculated fee for non-residential based on impervious area; no minimum charge set; no fee
credits
► 5 - Fee broken down between residential and non-residential properties; flat fee for residential
and calculated fee for non-residential based on impervious area; minimum charge set; fee
credits allowed
Table 2 below provides a summary of the five alternatives to include whether a flat or variable fee is used
for the residential and non-residential properties, if there is a minimum charge and if there are fee credits
offered.
Stormwater Control Measures (SCM) Fee Reduction
Structural SCM
Retention pond Up to 50%
Retention ditch Up to 30%
Rain Barrel Up to 25%
Rain Garden Up to 25%
Vegetation filter strip Up to 25%
Non-Structural SCM
Low impact Parcel Credit Up to 20%
Education Credit Up to 25%
Watershed Stewardship Credit Up to 10%
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:04 PM
29
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 9
Table 2 - Stormwater Utility Fee Alternatives
Analysis
The tables below show various fee alternatives that were evaluated and approximate fees that would be
collected yearly based on each alternative. An approximation was used to calculate the fee credits that
could be awarded. KCI assumed that 15% of the non-residential properties would qualify for an estimated
10% fee credit. Table 3 below provides a summary of the input values for calculating the expected
revenue for each alternative. Table 4 summarizes the expected revenue for each alternative.
Table 3 - Stormwater Utility Fee Breakdown
Table 4 - Stormwater Utility Fees Collected Yearly
Alternative
Flat or
Variable Fee
(Residential)
Flat or
Variable Fee
(Non-
residential)
Minimum
Charge
Fee
Credits
1 Flat Fee Flat Fee Yes No
2 Variable Fee Variable Fee No No
3 Variable Fee Variable Fee Yes Yes
4 Flat Fee Variable Fee No No
5 Flat Fee Variable Fee Yes Yes
Alternative Residential Fee Non-residential Fee Minimum
Charge
Fee
Credits
1 $25 developed or undeveloped $45 for developed
$25 for undeveloped
Yes No
2 $25 - <1,000 sq ft and developed
or undeveloped
$28 - >1,000 sq ft and developed
$27 per ERU for developed
$25 for undeveloped
No No
3 $25 - <1,000 sq ft and developed
or undeveloped
$28 - >1,000 sq ft and developed
$27 per ERU for developed
$25 for undeveloped
Yes Yes
4 $25 developed or undeveloped $27 per ERU for developed
$25 for undeveloped
No No
5 $25 developed or undeveloped $27 per ERU for developed
$25 for undeveloped
Yes Yes
Alternative
Residential
Fees
Collected
Non-
residential
Fee
Total Fee Minimum
Charge
Fee
Credits
1 $225,000 $32,000 $257,000 $25 None
2 $245,000 $484,000 $725,000 None None
3 $245,000 $476,740 $717,740 $25 $7,260
4 $226,500 $484,000 $710,000 None None
5 $226,500 $476,740 $702,740 $25 $7,260
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:04 PM
30
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 10
KCI evaluated the effects of a $5 and $10 increase to the fees for alternative 2 in Tables 3 and 4 to
determine the magnitude of funds collected each year. KCI also calculated what fee would be required to
achieve a $10 million and $20 million ten-year budget, shown below in Table 5.
Table 5 - Stormwater Fee Analysis
Figure 4 - Fee Comparison to Other Cities
Stormwater Utility Fee Use Scenarios
KCI provided three scenarios for using the stormwater utility fee to consider. The first option is to spend
each year’s budget bidding out work to a contractor in order to repair or maintain as much of the
stormwater system as possible.
$0.00
$10.00
$20.00
$30.00
$40.00
$50.00
$60.00
$70.00
$80.00
$90.00
Mauldin Anderson North Augusta Fort Mill Greenville
Fee (per year)
City
Fee Compared to Other Cities
$72 Total Fee
$36 Total Fee
$35 Total Fee
$30 Total Fee
Base Fee
Residential Fee Non-residential Fee Total Fee Collected Annually
$30 $32 per ERU for
developed
$30 for undeveloped
$848,000
$35 $37 per ERU for
developed
$35 for undeveloped
$983,000
$36 $37.50 per ERU for
developed
$36 for undeveloped
$1,000,000
$72 $74.50 per ERU for
developed
$72 for undeveloped
$2,000,000
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:04 PM
31
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 11
The second option is for the City to have an “in-house” crew that would be tasked with the repair,
maintenance, and improvement of the City’s stormwater system. The staff would likely consist of 4 full-
time employees and their salary would come from the special revenue fund created by the stormwater
utility fee. In addition to the employees, the crew would require a truck, trailer, dump truck and skid steer
for maintenance use. The employee’s annual pay and an annualized payment for the equipment would
cost the City roughly $325,000 per year. This would leave $400,000 of the budget for purchasing the
necessary material and renting equipment as needed for the stormwater projects for that year.
Table 6 - Annual In-House Costs
The final option is for the City to partially perform in-house labor and bid out the larger construction
work. This would allow the City to continue using staff for smaller repairs and maintenance while bidding
out larger construction work.
Stormwater Utility Fee Budgeting Scenarios
KIC has developed a scenario in which the City would take a hybrid approach to using the stormwater
utility fee by establishing a 10-year stormwater improvement plan. A proposed capital improvements
budget for the City would be based on a 10-year funding cycle. This budget would be used to fund small
to medium scale projects. Examples of these projects would be culvert replacement of pipes under 36” in
diameter, maintenance of existing failing culverts, maintenance of streams and ditches, or replacements of
storm drain pipes.
Based on the recommended stormwater utility fee, the City would collect approximately $725,000
annually in fees. This would ensure that the City has a 10-year budget of $7,250,000.
KCI analyzed how much linear feet of stormwater could be replaced yearly with the 4-man crew and
equipment described above. It was assumed that the crew could complete construction of 600 linear feet
of 18-inch pipe or 200 linear feet of 24-inch pipe each week. A summary of construction cost is shown
below. Based on an annual cost of $550,000 for in-house construction, the remaining $175,000 could be
used annually for contracted work.
Table 7 - Annual In-House Construction Costs
Annual Cost
3 Crew @ $20/hr w/ benefits $195,000
1 Crew Leader @$25/hr w/ benefits $80,000
Equipment (truck, trailer, dump truck, mini ex) $40,000
Fuel & Maintenance $10,000
Total $325,000
Annual Cost
4-Man Crew $325,000
7,800 LF of 18-in installed over 13 weeks $93,600
2,600 LF of 24-in installed over 13 weeks $52,000
Structures and Misc. Stone $79,400
26 weeks of repairs, maintenance, emergencies No additional Cost
Total $550,000
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:04 PM
32
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 12
Stormwater Utility Fee Projects
The City would use funds collected for both small maintenance issues as well as medium sized
construction projects to address flooding and drainage problems. Several potential capital improvements
projects are listed below. These projects are recommended based on conversations with the City staff.
► Knollwood Drive: This project was previously recommended to the City as a result of a design
study. The proposed solution would be to crown Knollwood Drive and add ditches and
driveway pipes along the road to convey stormwater runoff to the designed outfall. It is
estimated that this project would cost approximately $200,000.
► Holly Springs: This project was previously recommended to the City as a result of a design
study. The proposed solution would be to move the stormwater conveyance system to the right-
of-way along Springvale Drive and remove the existing storm drainpipes from private
property. The project would cost approximately $500,000.
► Bishop Heights: The project was previously recommended to the City as a result of a design
study. This project solution would be to construct a curb and gutter system throughout the
neighborhood. It would also include a storm drain network throughout the neighborhood. All
stormwater infrastructure currently on private property would either be abandoned in place or
demolished. The project would cost approximately $2,050,000.
Using the hybrid approach of an in-house crew and contracting out work, the projects above could be bid
out in the order shown below as contracted work without any revenue anticipation bonds.
If no in-house work were done and revenue anticipation bonds were issued, the three projects above could
be completed within the next three years and debt service retired in year four.
Year 1 - Bid
Knollwood
Drive
Year 4 - Bid
Holly Springs
Year 11 - Bid
Bishop
Heights
Year 1-3 - Bid Knollwood
Drive, Holly Springs &
Bishop Heights
Year 4 Debt Service Retired
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:03:05 PM
33
Stormwater Utility Fee Evaluation
| 13
Conclusions and Recommendations
Based on KCI's understanding of the City's needs and our research as summarized in this report, an
annual Stormwater Utility Fee Budget of $725,000 should be adequate. The revenue to generate this
annual budget would be $25 for residential properties, less than 1,000 square feet and $28 for larger
residential properties. The fee for undeveloped non-residential properties would be $25. The fee for non-
residential developed properties would be $27 times the ERU for the property.
The annual expenses would balance doing projects with staff, equipment, materials and supplies for doing
In-House stormwater improvement projects and contracting out the services needed to design, permit and
construct Contracted stormwater improvement projects.
Table 8 - Stormwater Improvement Project Funding
Based on the above revenue and expenses, 3 of the Projects KCI has already provided Feasibility Studies
on, could be funded in the first 11 years (Knollwood Dr, Holly Springs, and Bishop Heights).
Residential > 1,000 sq ft & developed
$28
Residentail < 1,000 sq ft, developed or
undeveloped
$25
Non-residential Undeveloped
$25
Non-residential Developed
$27 x ERU
Stormwater Improvement Project Funding
In-House Contracted
$550,000 $175,000
Draft Print
08/21/2023 1:01:45 PM
34
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.