Finance Committee Agenda August 2023 PUBLIC
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Aug 3, 2023 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
FINANCE AND POLICY
COMMITTEE MEETING
MONDAY, AUGUST 7, 2023 | 6 PM
5th committee meeting
The Committee will meet in Mauldin City Hall at 5 East
Butler Road in the Council Chambers at 6 p.m.
The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at
https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting-minutes-agendas/ to access the
meeting via audio and videoconferencing.
A quorum of Council will be present.
2
FINANCE AND POLICY COMMITTEE MEETING
AUGUST 7, 2023, 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5 E. BUTLER ROAD
Com
mittee Members: Michael Reynolds (Chair), Carol King, Diane Kuzniar
1. Call to Order
2. Pub
lic Comment
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a.Finance Committee Minutes- June 5, 2023
4. Reports or Communications from City Officers
a. City Administrator Seth Duncan
b. Finance Director Holly Abercrombie
c. HR Director Mark Putnam
5. Unfinished Business
There is no unfinished business.
6. New Business
a.Keller Williams Real Estate Business License Late
Fee
b. Senior Center and Sports Center Copier Contract
c.FY 23 Surplus Projection Plan
7. Public Comment
8. Committee Concerns
9. Adjournment
The Honorable Michael Reynolds
The Honorable Michael Reynolds
The Honorable Michael Reynolds
The Hono
rable Michael Reynolds
The Hono
rable Michael Reynolds
The Hono
rable Michael Reynolds
The Hono
rable Michael Reynolds
The Honorable Michael Reynolds
The Honorable Michael Reynold
MINUTES
FINANCE AND POLICY COMMITTEE MEETING
JUNE 5, 2023, 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
2nd commitee mee�ng
C
ommitee Members present: Michael Reynolds (Chair) and Carol King. Councilwoman Kuzniar was out
of town and not present.
O
thers present: Finance Director Holly Abercrombie, HR Director Mark Putnam and City Administrator
Seth Duncan.
1. C
all to Order- Chairman Reynolds
2. P
ublic Comment- None
3. R
eading and Approval of Minutes
a. Finance Commitee Minutes- May 1, 2023
M
o�on: Councilwoman King made a mo�on to approve the minutes with Chairman Reynolds
seconding.
Vo
te: The vote was unanimous (2-0).
4. R
eports or Communica�ons from City Officers
a. City Administrator Seth Duncan- Mr. Duncan reminded Commitee of the MASC Annual Mee�ng.
A groundbreaking ceremony will be held at Maverick Yards on Monday at 9:00 a.m.
He thanked all departments for their hard work.
b. Finance Director Holly Abercrombie
i. Budget Review
The fiscal year is coming to an end. Budgets look good. Revenues are coming in well. The auditors
are coming Wednesday to do some preliminary work.
c. HR Director Mark Putnam
The benefits review for the first five months of the year has been done. This is an average year,
which is good. The employee engagement groups con�nue.
We have one new officer and two dispatchers ge�ng ready to come on board. There are three
o
penings in the fire department currently. Public Works has three openings and the Sports Center
has a new billing coordinator coming soon.
5. U
nfinished Business- There is no unfinished business.
6. N
ew Business
a. Ordinance 1019- Indigo Point Pump Sta�on Fee
In 2020, Mauldin City Council established an ordinance to assess a fee on an annual basis to
developed parcels contained within the Indigo Pointe subdivision for the purpose of maintaining
certain sewer capital improvements, including a sewer pump sta�on. The final development plan of
this subdivision will consist of 223 detached single-family lots and 92 townhome lots. The ini�al fee
was set at $135 in Fiscal Year 2020-2021, then lowered to $100 in FY 2021-2022, and $73.00 in FY
2022-2023. An addi�onal 93 lots have now been developed and need to be included within the
ordinance.
Staff is presen�ng an ordinance that will add the Pump Sta�on Fee to 93 addi�onal lots and maintain
the fee at $73.00 per year. The fee will be assessed annually on the property tax bill.
Mo�on: Councilwoman King made a mo�on to send this item to Council with Chairman Reynolds
seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (2-0).
b. GCRA Requalifica�on
E
very three years, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) requires
Greenville County to requalify for en�tlement status as an urban county and to cer�fy the
con�nua�on of Greenville County’s Urban County coopera�ve agreement between the
Redevelopment Authority, Greenville County, and the City of Mauldin. In 2014, the City of Mauldin
entered into a con�nuous coopera�ve agreement to par�cipate in Greenville County’s Community
Development Block Grant and HOME Investment Partnership Program (HOME). The coopera�ve
a
greement has been renewed every three years.
G
CRA has informed the City of Mauldin of its right to opt out of the coopera�ve agreement. Op�ng
out of the agreement would waive funding from CDBG and HOME program for the agreement
period. By signing the agreement and passing the resolu�on, the City will con�nue par�cipa�ng in
the CDBG and HOME program for Fiscal Years 2024-2026.
Mo�on: Councilwoman King made a mo�on to send this item to Council with Chairman Reynolds
seconding.
Vo
te: The vote was unanimous (2-0).
7. P
ublic Comment- None
8. C
ommitee Concerns- Councilwoman King stated the City Administrator threw out the first pitch
Friday night at the Recrea�on tournament.
9. A
djournment- Chairman Reynolds adjourned the commitee mee�ng at 6:50 p.m.
R
espec�ully Submited,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
Page 1 of 1
FINANCE & POLICY COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM
MEETING DATE: August 7, 2023
TO: Finance & Policy Committee
FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug
SUBJECT: Request to Wave Late Penalty Fees
NUMBER: 6a
OVERVIEW
The City has received a request from the legal counsel retained by Keller Williams Greenville Central to
waive the late penalty fees for their 2023 business license. They have expressed that they were waiting for
a written decision from the hearing on their 2022 business license appeal before they proceeded to pay the
fees for their 2023 business license. The business license renewal deadline was April 30, 2023, and they
did not receive the written decision from the May 1, 2023 City of Mauldin hearing regarding their 2022
business license appeal until May 18, 2023. Keller Williams’ legal counsel expressed that Keller Williams
is ready and willing to pay the fees for their 2023 business license under protest but they believe the late
fees should be waived. Therefore, they are requesting the late fees be waived.
The City’s legal counsel responded to Keller Williams’ legal counsel and informed them that they (Keller
Williams) have incorrectly calculated their 2023 business license tax amount due to their gross sales being
significantly underreported. The amount required for payment under protest must be at least 80 percent of
the amount due and they have failed to meet this threshold. They have further been notified that the failure
to pay the full amount due under protest could ultimately affect the late fees owed if their current appeal
fails.
Regarding their request to waive later fees for their 2023 business license, they have been informed that
only City Council can decide to grant such a request. They have been informed that their request would be
presented to the City’s Finance and Policy Committee for consideration at their meeting on August 7.
STAFF COMMENTS
While staff is making no recommendations regarding this matter, we do believe the Committee should be
provided its options in how it can proceed forward. According to the Standing Committees Rules, last
amended in February 2021, the Committee may:
• Disapprove any action being taken on the matter,
• Report on the matter (with any amendments) for action by city council at a council meeting,
• Defer action pending further review, or
• Forward the matter to another committee.
John B. Duggan
Daniel R. Hughes
Evan C. Bramhall
J. Alexander Zimmerman
DUGGAN & HUGHES, LLC
ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW
457-B Pennsylvania Avenue
Greer, South Carolina 29650
Telephone: (864) 879-0144 or (864) 334-2500
Facsimile: (864) 879-0149
July 19, 2023
Via Email and Regular Mail: beau@campbellteague.com
Beau Brogdon
Campbell Teague
16 W. North Street
Greenville, SC 29601
Mailing Address
Post Office Box 449
Greer, S.C. 29652
Re: Keller Williams Greenville Central Business License Renewal Application 2023
Dear Beau:
The City is in receipt of Keller Williams Greenville Central Business ("KWGC") 2023 Renewal
Application,
IRS Form 1065 showing gross receipts of $[REDACTED] for 2022, KWGC's payment
under protest in the amount of $[REDACTED], and your request for a waiver of late fees for your 2023
application.
Consistent
with the City's position for KWGC's business license tax due for its 2022 Renewal
Application, KWGC's determination of its business license tax for its 2023 Renewal Application is
incorrect. KWGC underreported its gross sales in the amount of $[REDACTED]. Accordingly, the
total amount owed is $[REDACTED] as shown by the City's handwritten changes to KWGC's 2023
Renewal Application attached hereto. The correct amount of payment under protest would be eighty
(80%) of the amount due or $[REDACTED]. After credit for the amount already paid ($[REDACTED]),
KWGC owes $[REDACTED] for its payment under protest. Keep in mind that the failure to pay the full
amount due under protest could affect the amount of late fees ultimately due from KWGC if KWGC's
current appeal fails (subject to your request for a waiver of the same).
It appears that the parties' positions regarding the amount of the business license tax due for
KWGC's 2023 application is the same as its 2022 application. The City consents to holding in abeyance
any appeal to City Council that KWGC may assert for its 2023 application pursuant to S.C. Code Ann.
§6-1-410 during the current appeal before the Administrative Law Court. If you need anything
further regarding this issue, please let me know.
Regarding
your request to waive late fees, as we discussed, only Council can decide to grant this
request. This request will be presented to the City of Mauldin Finance and Policy Committee for
consideration at its meeting on August 7, 2023 at 6:00 pm at Mauldin City Hall. The Committee will
determine if your request should be presented to full Council. You or a representative of K WGC is
welcome to address the committee at this meeting.
Page 1 of 2
FINANCE AND POLICY
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
M
EETING DATE:
AGENDA ITEM:
August 7, 2023
6b
T
O: Finance and Policy Committee
FROM: City Administrator Seth Duncan
SUBJECT: Recreation Department Copier Contracts
REQUEST
Ci
ty Council is requested to approve the signing a contractual agreement with Dex Imaging (they
bought Konica Minolta) for Recreation Department copier services.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
In January of 2020, the City contracted with Konica Minolta for several copiers in an effo rt to
consolidate the contracts to one vendor and only have one consoli dated copier lease. At the
time this was done, there were machines at the Cultural Center, Judicial Department, Sports
Center and Senior Center that had newer contracts that could not be bought out because they
had several years remaining. The other department copiers have since been added to the main
lease.
Th
ere are two copiers at the Sports Center (one main copier and a smaller one at the front desk)
and one at the Senior Cent er that now have expiring leases. These are the last copier s to be
added to the consolidated lease.
Dex Imaging has quoted the larger copiers with a program which does not have any per copy
overages; this saves the City money and also allows for easier budgeting, as we would know a
true price each month, instead of having to estimate. The current lease has per copy charges on
each machine. The two main copiers would be the same model leased for the other departments
in January 2020.
The quote for the smaller copier includes 1200 copies/prints per month with the excess billed at
$.01 each.
The current average bill for all three copiers is $1,534.48 per month.
A quote is attached to make this lease co -terminus with the leases approved in January 2020 ,
having them term at the same time.
TIMELINE/FISCAL IMPACT
Adding the Senior Center copier and both Sports Center copiers to the lease initially approved in
January 2020, to end in June 2025 will cost will be $1063.41 per month and includes all service,
parts, supplies, and maintenance.
There is a savings of approximately $471 per month on the 20-month lease (Co-terminus).
Pursuant to Council approval, the copiers could be installed in two to three weeks.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends acceptance of the quote from Dex Imaging for the co-terminus lease ending
in June 2025 for the three copiers in the Sports Center and S enior Center. Dex Imaging is
piggybacking on Konica Minolta’s South Carolina State contract #4400010832.
ATTACHMENTS
Quote from Dex Imaging
Asset Living
Barney Pannell
Sales Account Executive
DEX Imaging
10 Falcon Crest Drive, STE 150, Greenville, SC 29607
PHONE 336-209-1849
City of Mauldin
Proposal Prepared for
CURRENT SITUATION
Lease and Service
Program
All Parts,
Labor, &
Toner
Included
2-Xerox
W7835 &
Kyocera
M2540dw
Total Lease - $1515.78 mo.
Avg Additional Mth Expense $18.70
Total Lease plus Service & Overage Fees
$1,534.48 mo
Current Expenses: 2 Xerox W7835’s & Kyocera M2540dw
Lease and Service included = $1515.78 Mth
Black & White allowed 4,500 mo. Excess @ $0.0125
Black avg – 4,000
Color Images allowed 7,000 mo Excess @ $0.085
Color avg - 7220 or $18.70 extra per mo.
Investment and Service
Konica
Minolta
2-C250’s
&
BH4050ii
Service Base Rate *Both Copiers combined $296.00 Mth
Konica C250i ‘s = Unlimited Copies/Prints – Color and B/W – No Meter
Charge and No Escalation for the Term of the Lease
.
Konica BH4020i – Service Base $12.00 for 1200 Copies/Prints mo.
Excess billed @ $0.01 each
*Includes All Service, Parts, and Supplies (Toner). Maintenance is
B
illed Separate from the Monthly Lease Payment
Total Lease plus Service
20 mth – Co-Terminus – Lease and Sevice =
$1,063.41 mth Plus Tax
20 month FMV Lease -- $755.41 mth Plus tax
To end co-terminus with other Konica Leases 6/16/25
Service Program
C250 - Service Base - $148.00* Mth each Device
Unlimited Color and B/W copies/prints – No
escalation
Konica BH4050i – Service base = $12.00
Allowed 1200 Black prints/copies mo. Excess billed
@$0.01 each
EQUIPMENT Monthly Investment:
All Parts,
Labor, &
Toner
Included
FINANCE AND POLICY COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
M
EETING DATE: August 7, 2023
AGENDA ITEM: 6c
T
O: Finance and Policy Committee
FROM: Seth Duncan, City Administrator
SUBJECT: FY2023 Surplus Projection Plan
REQUEST
To provide a preliminary estimate to Council of the FY2023 Surplus Projection and staff recommended
Fund Balance expenditure plan.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
Annually, the City’s Finance Director prepares a preliminary report of anticipated revenues and
expenditures for the prior fiscal year. This report, in addition to highlighting capital expenditures of the
prior year, also includes a recommended allocation of surplus revenues for various capital projects.
I
n prior years, a spending plan would be incorporated into the current fiscal year budget modification.
This year, staff is requesting Council approval of this spending plan and will incorporate those exp enses
into the budget amendment when appropriate.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
The Finance Director is projecting a surplus between $2.8 million and $3.3 million for FY 2023. Staff is
proposing the following expenditure plan for surplus FY2023 funds.
$175,000 Sports Center equipment (pay-go instead of financed)
$190,000 2 Medical Quick Response Vehicles for Mauldin Fire Department
$75,000 City-wide Strategic Plan
$90,000 Fire Station Headquarters Owner Items
$1,100,000 Railroad crossing for City Center project
$725,000 MCIP reimbursement for City Center
$425,000 Comp Time buyout and elimination of Comp Time
Remaining Balance Allocated to the Capital Fund fund balance
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends Council approve FY2023 Surplus Projection Plan as drafted by staff.
ATTACHMENT(S)
• Year End Fiscal Summary for Council
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.