minutes council meeting june 19 2023
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Jun 19, 2023 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
MINUTES
CITY OF MAULDIN
COUNCIL MEETING
JUNE 19, 2023
CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
7:00 p.m.
Members present: Mayor Terry Merrit, Council members Carol King, Ta� Matney, Jason
Kraeling Frank Allgood and Diane Kuzniar. Councilman Michael Reynolds was not present.
Others present: City Atorney John Duggan and City Administrator Seth Duncan.
1. Call to Order- Mayor Merrit
a. Welcome- Mayor Merrit
b. Invoca�on- Councilwoman Kuzniar
c. Pledge of Allegiance- Councilwoman Kuzniar
2. Proclama�ons and Presenta�ons
a. Greenville Transit Authority Presenta�on- Walker Smith, Board Chair of the GTA, was
present to speak on the status of the transit authority.
b. BASF Scholar Presenta�on- Gerald Murphy of BASF gave a presenta�on on what BASF does
in the Mauldin community.
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a. City Council Mee�ng- May 15, 2023
The minutes were approved by unanimous consent.
4. Public Comment
a. Brenda Thompson- I live at 113 Summer Woods Drive in the Summer Woods
condominium complex. I have lived there for the past 15 years. I am a former nurse, a
former court reporter, and a former psychologist, so I am very much aware of the
emo�ons involved with this project. I have been a counselor and I know what frustra�on
is being caused by what is going on.
The proposed and the zoning commitee approved building is definitely something that is
weighing on the hearts and minds of every Summer Woods resident and there are 52
homes or families represented there, either by owners who are ren�ng it out, or by
owners who are living there. I bought my condominium because I wanted peace and
quiet.
2
Over 70 years of traveling through Mauldin had taught me that this is the place to be and
I would find it here. But pu�ng that building there is going to destroy that. Not only that, it
will endanger my home and other homes in the 100 and 300 buildings of Summer Woods by
the fact that the deten�on and reten�on ponds will cause runoff. I have seen it every �me
we have a rainstorm. Gilder Creek is very prone to flooding. We will be flooded out. I have
heard it said that Butler Road is going to become a commercial road. I am sorry, but I don’t
think the people of Mauldin want a Woodruff Road right down the middle of the road. I like
the small-town atmosphere and I am sure other people do too. My puppies love the small
town atmosphere because I walk them all the �me.
I had a stroke in January, so I had to quit working, but that doesn’t mean that I won’t be out
and walking, and that doesn’t mean that I don’t care about the people around me and each
one of you is included in that. I ask you before you approve the changing of that land from
resident to commercial that you pray about it. Ask your God if this is what He thinks you
should do and what He is leading you to. And take one further step; put yourself in the
middle of Summer Woods and think about what if I owned a condominium here and what if
it was my income that was going to be affected. What if my tax rates would be changed and
if the value of what I had worked my life for was going to be decreased.
Ed Morgan sent each of you an email and asked me to speak for him. Ed is very much against
this. Ed has lived in Summer Woods since its incep�on. You don’t want to lose a resident
like that, and Ed will do it. He will move. He is not going to put up with what we are going
to have to put up with. Please, please. As a woman well past her �me of age, I can’t move.
Don’t make it harder on me. Don’t send me back to the hospital with another stroke.
b. Julie Sangray-I live at 303 Summer Woods Drive. I fell in love with this town. I lost my
husband a year and a half ago. My daughter lives in Greenville. I came here and searched for
a month and a half. I found my home and bought it on June 5
th. I never heard anything of
this. I love the birds, the woods, and the deer. I sit out there and listen to the
happiness. The road out front is quiet, and not that congested. I fell in love with the area. If
I had known all this, I wouldn’t have spent every penny I had on this house. That’s all.
c. Phil Cochrane: I think you are familiar with me. My name is Phil Cochrane and I live at 435
Bishop Drive. You know what my agenda item is- every day of the week, every month of the
year, it is stormwater. We con�nue to have a big problem with stormwater in this City for
more than 25 years. I am familiar with where the stormwater runs all across the City. I am
encouraged by the steps this Council has taken recently in the last 6-8 months or a year,
notably with Mr. Kraeling leading the charge with public works. I hope that effort does abate
the stormwater that runs across everyone’s property, underneath the homes, and in my case,
my home floods. As I stand before you today, seeing that storm over the ocean that is going
to become a hurricane and seeing the forecast and the 4-5 inches of rain predicted for us this
week, means that I will not sleep very well the rest of this week. I may be soaking up water
all night long in my home.
3
The first thing I want to say is thank you for beginning the process of stormwater
abatement. You guys are to be credited for what you are doing and the steps you have been
taking. I echo this lady’s comments. All you have to do is come to my house and spend the
night when inches of rain are falling, and you would be in for an educa�on. It is temp�ng to
say if it is not affec�ng my house, then I don’t know what all the brouhaha is all about. If is
not affec�ng me, there is a tempta�on to not be concerned. I think this group of people
here are a litle different. You do take the needs of residents on your hearts, and you do
think of people other than yourselves.
I want you to remember me and my family. My son served in law enforcement for the City
of Mauldin and s�ll serves in law enforcement. I am a finely paid public servant. That was a
joke. I love my job, but I am not paid near what I would make in the private sector. But,
thank you for what you are doing. I look forward to what all of you can do along with Jason
to abate stormwater in our great City. Thank you.
d. Maria Johnston: I am Maria Johnston and I live at 301 Summer Woods Drive. I would
basically second everything Brenda said earlier. I can’t really add anything to it. I am
concerned about my home. I have lived there for 23 years. It is my life investment. If this
was happening in your backyard, you would be standing where I am.
e. Brady Pinto: Good evening. I live at 604 Summer Woods Drive. I came here to speak
about the mater. I agree with the first two speakers. I am a re�red postal worker and I
served in the armed forces, the Air Force. I used to live up North, in New Jersey. I came
from a very congested area and lived there for a while. I saw a lot of stuff up there that is not
good. I came here to warn you- you have books and sta�s�cs, and you have to look at the
conges�on. Where I live on Butler Road, as I come out, I look and then when it is clear, then
all of a sudden, cars. I say, wow, it wasn’t like this a couple of years back. I am serious. You
have to be careful.
Now I hear sirens. My wife has had a couple of strokes and the ambulance had to come in. I
said, oh my goodness, I hope the ambulance can come in. I pray to God they don’t have an
accident. No problem. This was a couple of years ago and now it is more congested. It is
beau�ful that you want to do nice things for Mauldin, but you have to realize that
conges�on can come so much. It can bring problems. You have to realize that. The crime
rate- I never read the newspaper so I don’t know if it is high or low, but conges�on can
increase that. You have to look and analyze that. Seriously. One neighbor and the next
neighbor- one wants to have a party and the other one is �red from work. Then you have a
fight and problems. Problems and problems and problems. Look at that. I know we want to
improve, but some�mes this is not the answer.
All I can say is this- Butler Road is not an area to be so congested. You have the schools,
pickleball, railroad train coming in, they are building new stuff. Corn Road, you are building
more stuff. It is ge�ng more congested. Thank you.
4
f. I am Tom Newton and I live at 505 Summer Woods Drive. I am the President of the HOA.
Many of us have been to the other mee�ngs and we have not been able to get them to listen
to our objec�ons, or if they did, they didn’t agree.
I just think this is the wrong place. The building, they are pu�ng in a large warehouse. We
thought if someone put in a commercial building there, it would be similar to Joy Real Estate.
We might s�ll have the woods behind our units. The woods are our backyards, basically,
with a pa�o. There are no fences. Just a pa�o to the woods. They will basically cut down all
of the trees where it slopes down at the back of the property.
I think they decided to put some kind of pipes underground to send stormwater into Gilder
Creek. Every �me we have a big rain, it floods. Again, we had trees along that creek and
some fell and did some damage to some of the units. This property with all the trees and
vegeta�on will be cut down for a parking lot. It doesn’t mater what kind of drainage you
put in, it will s�ll flood.
The other thing is the parking lot will have all of these lights. Our concern is the buffer. If
you are going to do it, do it right. How would you feel if you had a warehouse with all of
these lights in your backyard? It needs more of a buffer. I think they are talking about a six
foot fence. If you do decide to do this, I wish it would be a different style, so it wouldn’t
affect us so much. We would like to have a very good buffer between us and the business.
5. Report from City Administrator
Mr. Duncan reported an emergency purchase was made for the police department
WatchGuard System. The capacity is full. In-car videos cannot be loaded onto the server
without this addi�onal storage. The expenditure was $22,000.
The new online payment system for Judicial is live.
Spartan Fire has authorized the replacement of new front �res for Tower 1.
The MASC annual mee�ng is next month.
6. Report from Standing Commitees
a. Finance and Policy (Chairperson Reynolds)- None
b. Public Safety (Chairperson King)- None
c. Public Works (Chairperson Kraeling)- None
d. Economic Planning & Development (Chairperson Matney)- None
e. Building Codes (Chairperson Kuzniar)- None
f. Recrea�on (Chairperson Allgood)- None
5
7. Unfinished Business-
Ordinances- 2nd Reading
a. Ordinance 1017- FY 2023 Budget Amendment Ordinance
Mo�on: Councilwoman King made a mo�on to approve the ordinance with Councilman
Matney seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
Commitee of the Whole
b. Ordinance 1018- FY 24 Budget Ordinance
Mo�on: Councilwoman King made a mo�on to consider this item informally.
Councilman Matney seconded the mo�on. Councilman Kraeling recused himself from
vo�ng on this ordinance.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (5-0).
Mo�on: Councilwoman King made a mo�on to approve the ordinance on second reading
with Councilman Matney seconding. Councilman Kraeling recused himself from
vo�ng on this ordinance.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (5-0).
8. New Business
Ordinances – 1st Reading
a. Ordinance 1019 – Establishing a sewer pump sta�on fee for addi�onal parcels of the
Indigo Point development and for certain proper�es near and adjacent to the Indigo Point
development; and other maters related thereto.
Mo�on: Councilwoman King made a mo�on to approve the ordinance with Councilman
Allgood seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
b. Ordinance 1020- An ordinance to rezone two proper�es consis�ng of approximately 2
acres located at 307 E. Butler Road (tax map parcel #M004.02-01-009.01 and tax map
parcel #M004.02-01-009.02) and providing an effec�ve date
Mo�on: Chairwoman Kuzniar made a mo�on to approve the ordinance with Councilman
Matney seconding for the purposes of discussion.
6
Chairwoman Kuzniar is concerned about the number of parking spaces if a tournament
takes place, outdoor ligh�ng, and the removal of woods. The Council is elected to be the
voice of the residents. She asked why this project could not go into one of the empty box
stores around town that have plenty of parking. She will not support this ordinance.
Councilman Kraeling has concerns about the stormwater. There are a lot of moving parts
as Butler Road has not yet been improved.
Councilman Allgood liked Chairwoman Kuzniar’s comment on re-use of current buildings.
He men�oned there was no representa�on from the affected residents at the Building
Codes commitee mee�ng. The developer has addressed some of the resident’s concerns.
He is torn as he appreciates the comments from Summer Woods residents, but when
people live near a major thoroughfare; these types of things happen.
Councilwoman King thanked the Building Codes commitee for forwarding this item to
Council for discussion. The vote is for rezoning, but if the property is rezoned, it will allow
Carolina Sports Club to be built. She said this is a great project, but not at the right
loca�on.
Mr. Dyrhaug said a lot of the issues raised from residents have been addressed by the
developer. If there are any specific ques�ons, the developer is present at the mee�ng
tonight.
Councilman Allgood asked if rear parking was a possibility for the project. Mr. Dyrhaug
said it is possible, but Butler is expanding, which may limit parking.
Mayor Merrit said he has spoken to Joy Bailey, the adjoining property owner, and she has
no problem with the project. SCDOT’s project will address Gilder Creek drainage. There
will also be a traffic light at the entrance to Summer Woods. He has mixed feelings about
the project. He would prefer to hold this un�l Butler is completed. The planning
commission approved the project. There was a ques�on on whether overturning the
planning commission would take a supermajority.
Mr. Dyrhaug said the zoning ordinance specifies a rezoning request that was denied by the
planning commission requires a supermajority of Council to overturn. The zoning
ordinance does not men�on a supermajority requirement if Council is overturning an
approval by the planning commission.
If this ordinance is denied on first reading tonight, the property cannot be requested for
rezoning for 12 months.
7
Vote: Councilwoman King asked for a roll call vote. Councilman Matney- No,
Councilwoman King- No, Councilman Kraeling- No, Councilman Allgood- No,
Councilwoman Kuzniar-No, and Mayor Merrit- No. The vote was unanimous to deny and
the mo�on was defeated. (0-6).
Standing Commitee Items
c. Stormwater Engineering Task Order 3
Mo�on: Chairman Kraeling made a mo�on to approve Task Order 03 with KCI to conduct
a stormwater fee analysis and evalua�on. The engineering services associated with this
task order are proposed at 20,000 dollars. Councilwoman King seconded the mo�on.
Chairman Kraeling said no city in South Carolina is doing what we are doing as far as trying
to address stormwater. This is a start to look at funding mechanisms for this issue.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
d. Basin RG2 Sanitary Sewer Rehabilita�on Project
Mo�on: Chairman Kraeling made a mo�on to accept the grant for sewer rehabilita�on of
RG2. Councilwoman King seconded the mo�on.
The City was awarded 3,399,750 dollars from the South Carolina Rural Infrastructure
Authority. A municipal match of $600,000 is required by the City.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
e. GCRA Requalifica�on
Council is being asked to approve the City of Mauldin’s con�nued par�cipa�on in
Greenville County’s Urban County program and authorize the Mayor to sign the
coopera�ve agreement for Fiscal Years 2024-2026.
Mo�on: Chairwoman King made a mo�on to accept the GCRA resolu�on with
Councilman Matney seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
f. Re-appointment of Members of the Planning Commission
Mo�on: Chairwoman Kuzniar made a mo�on to re-appoint Kevin Greene, Johnathan
Paulsen, and Chauncelynn Locklear to the Planning Commission. Councilman Matney
seconded the mo�on.
8
Vote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
g. Re-appointment of Members of the Zoning Board of Appeals
Mo�on: Chairwoman Kuzniar made a mo�on to re-appoint Paul Calabrese and Phil
Cochrane to the Zoning Board of Appeals. Councilman Allgood seconded the mo�on.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
h. ID Scanners and Fire Turnout Gear Dona�ons
Mo�on: Chairwoman King made a mo�on to accept the resolu�on to donate police ID
Scanners and Fire Turnout Gear to agencies/countries that need the equipment.
Councilman Allgood seconded the mo�on.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
i. Lights and Sound System Cultural Center CIP
Mo�on: Chairman Matney made a mo�on to reallocate $75,000 originally planned for the
amphitheater in the FY23 budget to fund improvements to the audio/visual technology in
the theater. Councilwoman Kuzniar seconded the mo�on.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
j. Public Art Trail
Staff are looking for direc�on on the approval of art for the public art trail. A�er
discussion, Council prefers a hybrid system in which staff manages the solicita�on of art
proposals, the Mauldin Cultural Council selects/submits a limited number of finalists, staff
makes a recommenda�on and the City Council votes to allow the Mayor to sign the
contract, thereby approving the art piece. The Mayor and City Administrator also sit on the
Cultural Council board and will have input.
Mo�on: Chairman Matney made a mo�on to approve the hybrid system as described in
the paragraph above. Councilwoman King seconded the mo�on.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
k. Leadership Golden Strip Mural at Mauldin Cultural Center
Leadership Golden Strip has chosen to install murals in Fountain Inn, Simpsonville, and
Mauldin as their class project, and it has chosen Art Houzze to manage this project. Art
9
Houzze has quoted a 15-foot-wide x 20-foot-high mural in each Golden Strip city for
$10,059.40 per mural.
Leadership Golden Strip has pledged to raise the funding for this project, and it is currently
solici�ng dona�ons for the art project. The class has asked the City of Mauldin to
par�cipate in the funding of this project, and the Community Development Department
proposes contribu�ng $5,000 from its FY24 budget with the balance coming from
fundraising efforts by Leadership Golden Strip.
Mayor Merrit asked if other ci�es are being asked for $5,000. He said when he was in
Leadership Golden Strip, the group raised funds to pay for the project. Mr. Charles said he
was just asking for $5,000 as a member of the class.
Mo�on: Chairman Matney made a mo�on to allow the Community Development
Department to give $5,000 out of the hospitality and accommoda�ons adver�sing fund
towards the mural. There will be a workshop soon to develop ideas for the mural.
Councilwoman King seconded the mo�on.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
9. Public Comment
a. Shukri Elkahayyat: I live at 26 Endeavor Circle. I am a resident of the Whispering Oaks
townhome community and also a board member on the HOA. Some of the residents
have come here to support me and show their numbers. There are some residents who
were unable to be here tonight.
On May 30
th, a Public Works garbage truck leaked hydraulic fluid up and down Endeavor
Circle. While I can’t es�mate the amount of oil leaked, I can say with confidence that the
trail is approximately 2000 feet long and four feet wide in some areas. Through research,
I found that hydraulic oil can damage asphalt by breaking down the binders that hold
asphalt together, especially with temperatures under 32 degrees. Addi�onally, on May
25, 2021, the State News reported a hydraulic leak near the State House that immediately
forced road closures while clean-up efforts ensued. I communicated this informa�on to
our HOA and our HOA President called the City on May 30th. He was told that it would
wash away in the next rain. Knowing that wasn’t true, I called the City on June 1st and
spoke to Josh Roberts. He said he would discuss the mater with his superiors.
During this �me, myself and Tarryn Willey sent emails to the City. I spoke to Panagakos
Paving and was told hydraulic oil does affect the structural integrity of asphalt and if not
cleaned up immediately, does so prety quickly.
10
A�er further research, I found that seal coa�ng only improves the aesthe�cs, but
wouldn’t do anything to mi�gate the unrealized damage from the hydraulic oil.
Therefore, we are not in favor of seal coa�ng.
On June 7th, the City came out and tried to clean the spill with degreaser. Yesterday, I
used a spoon to effortlessly break up some of the asphalt. I tried the same thing in an
unaffected area and was unsuccessful.
On June 16th, Tarryn Willey received an email from Mathew Fleahman indica�ng that
Endeavor Circle was in the roadway inventory. I looked at the Mauldin roadway inventory
and was unable to locate Endeavor Circle. I did find Discovery Way and Challenger Court,
two small streets in our community, listed. This morning I met with Mat Fleahman. He
said he had been mistaken and Endeavor Circle was not included in the inventory. This
spill will accelerate the deteriora�on of our road. I expect home values will also
deteriorate because of the dilapidated road. This will also put a burden on our HOA.
I am asking the City to please consider including Endeavor Circle on the road inventory. If
the City is unable to do so, the residents of Whispering Oaks ask that the road is replaced
to the aesthe�c and structurally sound condi�on it was in before the spill. The burden
perpetrated by a City vehicle on private property should not be taken on by our residents,
some of which are on fixed incomes. We are asking for your help as your neighbors.
Thank you.
10. Council Concerns
Councilman Kraeling asked that the Council chair hydraulics be looked at. He then asked
the City Atorney to provide writen instruc�ons for simple majority and super majority
rules.
11. Adjournment- The Mayor adjourned the mee�ng at 9:08 p.m.
Respec�ully Submited,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
11
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.