RecordWell Data

building codes agenda_2023-06-05

City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Jun 1, 2023 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Mauldin

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE MEETING MONDAY , JUNE 5 , 202 3 | 6 PM 3rd committee meeting Please note that members of the public may attend this meeting in-person but are encouraged to participate remotely. The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting- minutes-agendas/ to access the meeting via audio and videoconferencing. The Committee will meet in the Mauldin City Hall at 5 East Butler Road in the Council Chambers at 6 p.m. Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 2 Building Codes (BDS) Committee AGENDA June 5, 2023 Committee Members: Diane Kuzniar (Chair), Taft Matney, Frank Allgood 1. Call to Order The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 2. Public Comment The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes a. Building Codes Committee Meeting: May 1, 2023 (Pages 3-5) The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 4. Reports or Communications from City Officers a. BDS Department Report, David Dyrhaug The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 5. Unfinished Business None The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 6. New Business a. An ordinance to rezone two propert ies consisting of approximately 2 acres located at 307 E. Butler Road (tax map parcel #M004.02-01-009.01 and tax map parcel #M004.02-01-009.02) and providing an effective date (Pages 6-20) b. Re-appointment of Members o n the Planning Commission with expiring terms (Page 21) c. Re-appointment of Members on the Zoning Board of Appeals with expiring terms (Page 21) The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 7. Public Comment The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 8. Committee Concerns The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 9. Adjourn The Honorable Diane Kuzniar Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 3 Minutes Building Codes (BDS) Committee May 1, 2023 4th Committee Meeting Committee Members: Diane Kuzniar (Chair), Taft Matney, Frank Allgood. Others present: BDS Director David Dyrhaug and City Administrator Seth Duncan 1. Call to Order- Chairwoman Kuzniar 2. Public Comment- None 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes a. Building Codes Committee Meeting: April 3, 2023 Motion: Councilman Allgood made a motion to approve the minutes with Councilman Matney seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). 4. Reports or Communications from City Officers a. BDS Director David Dyrhaug The budget looks good. The Planning Commission met and tabled the commercial rezoning at 307 East Butler Road while the applicant gathers more information on questions that were asked at the hearing. The planned development at Tanner and Verdin Roads has had a small decrease in the number of units and workspaces and the revised plan was approved by the Planning Commission. The number of inspections has decreased this month. 40 new homes were permitted in April. All homes are completed in Highland Chase on East Standing Springs Road. 7 new businesses opened in the City limits in April. b. Update on WOW! Fiber Cable Installation, Matt Shropshire Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 4 Mr. Shropshire reported 150,000 feet of innerduct has been placed in the City at a rate of about 5,000 feet a day. The restoration has been good overall. Chairwoman Kuzniar said the line was put in her yard over the weekend and she was very pleased with the work done. The workers are conscientious and worked all day long. She is concerned about the people who may have sod in their yards. She asked if the sod is dug up and then placed back down when the contractor is finished. Mr. Shropshire said that is what happens in most cases. He did provide Council with a letter that is given to the residents about this item. Councilman Matney thanked Mr. Shropshire for being responsive and a good corporate resident and taking care of issues as they arise. He asked how long the installation process will take. Mr. Shropshire said they should be out of Mauldin by the third quarter of this year. He will stay in contact with our Administrative staff. 5. Unfinished Business- None 6. New Business- None 7. Public Comment Eric Cothran: My name is Eric Cothran and I work for Cothran Homes. We are located at East Washington Street downtown and my company does work here in the Mauldin area. Thank you for taking the time to hear me. I would like to voice some concerns just from a builder’s perspective. Matt, the guy that was here has been very responsive, but we have had some issues in the neighborhood down the street near Shanks Driving Range. Just some cracked driveways, damaged sod, things like that. When you have a cracked driveway or damaged sod, when you go back and repair it, it is never quite the same. When you are trying to sell houses and build a community, these are issues we have to deal with. When the homeowner comes into our neighborhood and sees damaged sod or cracked driveways, it is not as easy to sell. I wanted to voice that concern. What gave the City of Mauldin the authority to come in and run this cable optic in our neighborhood? We never had a pre-con or a meeting, the guys just showed up. The guys in the field said we are working for Amco, or didn’t know who they were working for exactly. They have been very nice and very responsive and I did talk to Matt today. He said they would take care of any damage. I told my boss man, and he said Eric, sounds like you should go up there and talk to them so here I am. Thank you for your time and for listening to what I have to say. 8. Committee Concerns- None Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 5 9. Adjourn- Chairwoman Kuzniar adjourned the meeting at 8:33 p.m. Respectfully Submitted, Cindy Miller Municipal Clerk Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 6 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: June 5, 2023 AGENDA ITEM: 6a TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Rezoning at 307 E Butler Road REQUEST The City of Mauldin has received a signed petition requesting the rezoning of a tract of land pursuant to Section 4:2 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance. This petition has been made by Bennie Pettit and Kimberly McCullough, who has been appointed by the Cou rt as the personal re presentative for Bre nda Wilson. Bennie and Kimberly have both authorized Carolina Sports Club to request this rezoning for their property. This petition includes approximately 2 acres located at 307 E. Butler Road. The applicant, Carolina Sports Club, has requested that this tract be rezoned from R-12, Residential, to C-1, Light Commercial. The applicant is planning to develop an indoor facility/gymnasium for badminton and pickleball. HISTORY/BACKGROUND This tract is currently undeveloped and is wooded at the back portion of the tract. This property has been listed for sale for a while. OWNER(S): Bennie Pettit & Brenda Wilson AUTHORIZED REP(S): Lisa Williams  Klue Real Estate Advisors Carolina Sports Club, LLC TAX MAP NUMBER(S): #M004.02-01-009.01 & #M004.02-01-009.02 LOCATION: 307 E. Butler Road CURRENT ZONING: R-12, Residential REQUESTED ZONING: C-1, Light Commercial SIZE OF PROPERTY: Approx. 2.1 acres Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 7 PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT Carolina Sports Club, LLC intends to construct an indoor facility/gymnasium consisting of approximately 12,000 square feet. The facility would include approximately 9 indoor courts primarily for badminton, but that could also be used for pickleball. The facility would be used by members of the club, individuals receiving lessons, and would also host quarterly tournaments. Carolina Sports Club also has a broader vision of introducing badminton programs to the Greenville County School District. The applicant has presented to the Planning Commission that they will be installing a buffer consisting of a six -foot-tall wooden privacy fence along with additional landscap e plantin gs along each side of the property next to residential areas. The applicant will also construct an underground detention system to aid in the stormwater management of the property. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING In accordance with Section 4:3.3 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance, the applicant held a neighborhood meeting o n March 13 , 202 3. Notice of this meeting was provided in accordance with the City ’s requirements which includes mailing notices to property owners within 200 feet of the property and posting signage on the property. Based on the sign-in sheet, it appears that approximately 14 neighbors attended the meeting, most of whom either lived nearby on E. Butler Road or in the S ummer Woods townhome/condo community. According to the meeting summary provided by the applicant, questions and concerns covered topics including: building size, building setbacks, building design, stormwater drainage, parking, lighting, hours of operation, patrons, membership model, and wildlife habitat, among other questions and discussion . Attached is the applicant’s summary of the neighborhood meeting. PUBLIC HEARINGS The Planning Commission held a public hearing on April 25, 2023. Notice of this hearing was provided in accordance with the City ’s requirements which includes publishing notice in the Newspaper and posting signage on the property. The following citizens provided public comments at this hearing. • Ms. Brenda Thompson, at 113 Summer Woods Drive, stated that this project is just about money. She shared her concern about how close the project will be to her back door. She also expressed her concern about bringing people into Mauldin from outside the community. She is also concerned about noise that may be generated from the parking lot. • Mr. Dennis Raines, at 305 E. Butler Road, asked for clarification if this facility will be used for badminton only or if it will be used for both badminton and pickleball (up to this point he had heard both concepts). He expressed some concerns about buffering and asked if the buffering will include a wall or fence. He commented that he is generally alright with the C -1 zoning and asked if it would allow beer or alcohol to be served at the premises. • Mr. Tom Newton, at 505 Summer Woods Drive, introduced himself as the president of the Summer Woods HOA. He commented that he is not opposed to a business on this property but would like to see it pushed closer to the road. He also asked about the stormwater facilities for this project and commented that he would like to a detention pond included instead of underground detention. Finally, he too commented that he would like to see a fence or wall constructed along the property line. Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 8 After tabling the item on April 25, the Planning Commission held a second public hearing on May 23, 2023. The following citizens provided public comments at this second hearing. • Ms. B renda Thompson , at 113 Summer Woods D rive, clarified her statements about bringing people into Mauldin, that is to say about people coming into the community who will not be living in Mauldin, paying taxes in Mauldin, or supporting othe r businesses in Mauldin. She stated that some residents were not made aware of the meeting. She also stated that this character of this proposed facility is for more than just ne ighborhood use. She expressed concerns that th ere will not be enough parking for this facility, it will change the character of the area, and that it will contribute to flooding. • Mr. Jeff Moore, at 130 Brookbend Road, expressed concern that stormwater from this project will end up in his backyard of his home in the Holly S prings subdivision. He asked the Planning Commission to ensure that there will be enough sto rmwater control and management for this project. • Ms. Maria Johnston, at 301 Summer Woods Drive, indicated that she bought her home because of the woods behind her home. She expressed concern about loss of quality of life as well as concern that her property value would go down as a result of this project. • Mr. Tom Newt on, at 505 Summer Woods Drive, asked if there has been any study about the removal of trees on this property and how it would affect stormwater runoff and flooding. He also indicated that he has been told by real estate agents that his property values will decrease because of this project. He wishes the building would be positioned closer to the road. • Ms. Melinda Hoffman, at 420 E. Butler Road, urged the City to preserve its natural spaces such as exist on this property. ZONING ANALYSIS AND STANDARDS Existing Zoning Classification The R-12 district is a low density residential district intended to provide single -family living and related facilities such as recrea tional, religious, and educational facilities. The R -12 district allows for 12,000 - square foot residential lots or a comparable density of 3.6 units per acre. Proposed Zoning Classification The C-1 district is a light commercial district intended to promote small -scale retail, service, and professional offices that provide goods and services at a neighborhood scale . This district is generally located in areas adjacent to residential districts. Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 9 The types of uses and businesses allowed in the C-1 district include the following: • Day care center • Funeral home • Assisted living • Nursing home • Outpatient health care services (physicians, dentists, chiropractors, etc.) • Library • Meeting or assembly hall • Public administration building • Public safety facility • Religious institution • Technical or trade school • Social assistance services • Catering services • Communication or information services (publishing, broadcasting, recording studio, etc.) • Dry cleaning and laundry services • Financial establishment (banks, credit unions, etc.) • Health and personal care services (hair, nail, skin care, massage, sauna, etc.) • Office and professional services • Pet and animal care services • Restaurant • Retail sales • Grocery store or supermarket • Small box variety store • Amusement or games facility • Event center or banquet hall • Fitness/sports club • Exhibition facility • Public park or recreation area • Theater Development Standards This proposal to develop an i ndoor facility/gymnasium for badminton and pickleball at this particular property will be subject to the following development standards: Min. front building setback: 25 feet from the street right-of-way line Min. front streetscape buffer: 10-foot-wide landscape buffer Min. buffer adjacent to 305 E. Butler Rd: 30-foot-wide landscape buffer Min. buffer adjacent to Summer Woods: 20-foot-wide landscape buffer Min. bldg setback next to 309 E. Butler Rd: 5 feet from the property line Min. number of parking spaces: The City of Mauldin does not have specific parking requirements for a sports center, gymnasium, or indoor recreation facility. City staff expects to determine an appropriate parking requirement for this facility based on the study of other communities. For reference, the American Planning Association publishes a Parking Standards manual that contains the following model parking standards from other communities:  Indoor Rec. Facility: 1 space per 50 – 300* sq ft.  Commercial Indoor Rec. Facility: 1 space per 250 sq ft.  Gymnasium: 1 space per 100 – 400* sq ft.  Racquetball Court: 2 – 4* spaces per court * Number varies by community Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 10 Max. building height (measured to the cornice line): 45 feet^ ^ Maximum height may be increased to 50 feet if the project meets the prescribed design standards Primary façade materials required on the front and side of the building: Brick or brick veneer Natural or manufactured stone Acceptable façade materials allowed on the rear of the building: Brick or brick veneer Natural or manufactured stone Cementitious siding (fiber cement) Split-face block Max. light level at the property line: 0.5 foot-candles Comprehensive Plan Analysis This property is designated as a “neighborhood corridor” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. This designation is intended for the limited application of commercial uses, such as small-scale offices and retail, and is consistent with the C-1, Light Commercial District. Surrounding Development/Zoning These properties are surrounded by the following zoning and land uses: Direction Zoning District(s) Existing Use(s) North R-12 (City) Hillsborough community South R-12 (City/County) 10-acre residential property East O-D (City)/ R-M (City) Real estate office Summer Woods townhome/condo community West R-12 (City) 1.7-acre residential property REVIEW CRITERIA The Mauldin Zoning Ordinance does not contain any specified criteria that should be considered by the Planning Commission when reviewing requests for rezoning. However, the following criteria are typical of those used by other jurisdictions. A. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed since the Comprehensive Plan was adopted, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; B. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and oth er environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed in the proposed zoning district; C. Compatibility of all the potential uses allowed in the proposed zoning district with surrounding uses and zoning districts in te rms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density, nature of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning, and potential influence on property values; D. Capacity of public infrastruct ure and services to sufficiently accommodate all potential uses allowed in the proposed district without compromising public health, safety or welfare; and E. Public need for the potential uses permitted in the requested zoning district. Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 11 STAFF FINDINGS The analysis below includes staff findings pertaining to each criterion. CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 1. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; This property is designated as a “neighborhood corridor” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. This designation is intended for the limited application of commercial uses, typically small-scale offices and re tail. The C -1, Light Commercial District is consistent with this designation in the Comprehensive Plan. Additionally, in the last couple of years, the properties at 227 E. Butler Road and 301 E. Butler Road have been rezoned to commercial zoning districts. These properties are approximately 250- 300 feet to the west along East Butler Road. 2. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed There is a floodplain located at the back of this property. The applicant is not planning to disturb the floodplain. 3. Compatibility of the potential uses allowed with surrounding uses and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on t he environment, noise, density, nature of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning, and potential influence on property values The potential uses allowed in the C -1, Light Commercial District are intend ed to entail commercial uses that would have relatively less impact on adjacent residences as compared to the types of uses allowed in the general commercial district. Considering the nature of their indoor operations, the proposed business is expected to have a low impact on the adjacent residences. 4. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate potential uses allowed without compromising public health, safety, or welfare All utilities, including water and sewer, appear to be available at this tract. There is a ReWa sewer line available at the rear of the property and a City of Mauldin sewer line available at the front of the property. The proposed business is not expected to generate significant traffic. Generally, racquet cl ubs are associated with approximately 3.8 PM peak hour trips per court. For the nine courts anticipated in this facility, the business would generate about 34 PM peak hour trips which is well below the threshold of 100 peak hour trips that would trigger the requirement for a traffic impact study. Therefore, a traffic impact study would not be required for this project. Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 12 CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 5. Public need for the potential uses permitted As the population continues to grow in and around the City of Mauldin, there is an increased need for businesses that provide commercial products and services, as well as recreational opportunities, for the growing population. TIMELINE On March 13 , 202 3, the applicant met with interested neighbors to review their proposal and to seek questions and comments. On March 15, 2023, staff received the request to rezone this tract. On April 25, 2023, the Planning Commission voted, 3-2, to table this matter until additional information is received. On May 23, 2023, the Planning Commission voted, 3-1, to recommend approval of this rezoning. STAFF RECOMMENDATION In staff’s opinion, the C-1 zoning district that has been requested is consistent with the future land use map provided in the City’s Comprehensive Plan . Additionally, it is staff’s opinion that the impacts of the proposed indoor badminton club will be relatively minor and will benefit the community by providing more recreational opportunities. Ultimately, the Planning Commission and the City Council will need to make a judgment on whether (1) this rezoning is consistent with the vision for the future of this area, (2) the rezoning is compatible with the surrounding uses, and (3) any other factors that they deem pertinent. PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION On May 23, 2023, the Planning Commission v oted 3-1 to recommend approval of the rezoning , with Mr. Eskridge dissenting. ATTACHMENTS Proposed ordinance (maps included therein) Neighborhood meeting information Conceptual drawing(s) Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 13 ORDINANCE # __________ AN ORDINANCE TO REZONE TWO PROPERTIES CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY 2 ACRES LOCATED AT 307 E. BUTLER ROAD (TAX MAP PARCEL #M004.02-01-009.01 AND TAX MAP PARCEL #M004.02 -01- 009.02) AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE WHEREAS, Bennie Pettit and Brenda Wilson have petitioned the City of Mauldin to rezone +/- 2 acres from the R-12, Residential District, to the C-1, Light Commercial District; and WHEREAS, a rezoning of the parcel is in keeping with the City of Mauldin 2014 Comprehensive Plan Update; and WHEREAS, the site is suitable for the types of uses that could be developed under the new zoning district; and WHEREAS, the potential uses permitted in the new zoning district meet a public need and are not detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare; and WHEREAS, the Mauldin Planning Commission has given favorable recommendation to the zoning application; and NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof Section 1. That the property described in zoning docket PC-2023-02-RZ and Greenville County Tax Map Parcels M004.02-01-009.01 and M004.02-01-009.02 be rezoned from R-12 to C-1, Light Commercial. The property is further identified on the attached exhibit that is hereby incorporated into this ordinance, including Exhibit 1, Zoning & Property Map. Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage. Passed on First Reading ________________________________ Passed on Second Reading ______________________________ CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA ATTEST: BY: ________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ___________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ John Duggan, City Attorney Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 14 EXHIBIT 1 Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 15 Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 16 Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 17 Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 18 Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 19 CONCEPTUAL ARCHITECTURAL ELEVATIONS Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 20 Building Codes Committee Meeting • • • 21 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: June 5, 2023 AGENDA ITEM: 6b TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Expiring Terms on Planning Commission and Zoning Board of Appeals EXPIRING TERMS ON PLANNING COMMISSION Three seats on the Planning Commission are set to expire at the end of June. The members presently appointed to each of these seats have each requested to be reappointed to another term of three years. This includes: • Kevin Greene (Seat #1) • Jonathan Paulsen (Seat #4) • Chauncelynn Locklear (Seat #7) Mr. Greene and Ms. Lockl ear were each appointed to the Pl anning Commission in 2022 to fill mid-term vacancies. Mr. Paulsen has been serving since 2014 and has provided stability to the Planning Commission. Recommended Action: It is the recommendation of staff that Mr. Greene, Mr. Paulsen, and Ms. Locklear be reappointed to new three-year terms on the Planning Commission effective July 1, 2023. *Please note that in addition to these expiring t erms, there are currently two vacancies on the Pl anning Commission. There are no new candidates to present at this time for those vacancies. EXPIRING TERMS ON ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Two seats on the Zoning Board of Appeals are set to exp ire at the end of June. The members presently appointed to each of these seats have each requested to be reappointed to another term of three years. This includes: • Philip Cochrane (Seat #6) • Paul Calabrese (Seat #7) Mr. Cochrane was appointed to the Zoning Board of Appeals in 2022 to fill mid -term vacancies. Mr. Calabrese has been serving since 2017. Recommendation Action: It is the recommendation of staff that Mr. Cochrane and Mr. Calabrese be reappointed to new three-year terms on the Zoning Board of Appeals effective July 1, 2023.

Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.