RecordWell Data

Historic Preservation Commission Meeting — Agenda Packet

Town of Bluffton · Beaufort County · Historic Preservation Commission · meeting of Jul 1, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Town of Bluffton

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Wednesday, July 01, 2026 at 6:00 PM Theodore D. Washington Municipal Building, Henry “Emmett” McCracken Jr. Council Chambers, 20 Bridge Street, Bluffton, SC AGENDA This meeting can be viewed live on BCTV, on Sparklight Channel 9 and 417 or on Spectrum Channel 1304. I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. NOTICE REGARDING ADJOURNMENT The Historic Preservation Commission will not hear new items after 9:30 p.m. unless authorized by a majority vote of the Commission Members present. Items which have not been heard before 9:30 p.m. may be continued to the next regular meeting or a special meeting date as determined by the Commission Members. IV. ADOPTION OF MINUTES 1. June 3, 2026 Minutes V. PUBLIC COMMENT VI. OLD BUSINESS VII. NEW BUSINESS 1. 36 Wharf Street (COFA-03-25-019657): A request by the Applicant, Jamie Guscio (Kingfisher Construction), on behalf of Kathy Barbina and Tim Harris, Owners, for approval of an amended Certificate of Appropriateness-HD (COFA-HD) to allow the installation of alternate exterior doors. The property is in Old Town Bluffton Historic District, and zoned Neighborhood General-HD (NG-HD). (Staff -Charlotte Moore) VIII. DISCUSSION 1. Historic District Monthly Update. (Staff) IX. ADJOURNMENT NEXT MEETING DATE: Wednesday, August 5, 2026 Page 1 Town of Bluffton, SC Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Agenda July 01, 2026 “FOIA Compliance – Public notification of this meeting has been published and posted in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the Town of Bluffton policies.” In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Bluffton will not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or activities. The Town of Bluffton Council Chambers are ADA compatible. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further accommodation should contact the Town of Bluffton ADA Coordinator at 843.706.4500 or adacoordinator@townofbluffton.com as soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Executive Session – The public body may vote to go into executive session for any item identified for action on the agenda. *Please note that each member of the public may speak at one public comment session and a form must be filled out and given to the Town Clerk. To submit a public comment online, please click here: https://www.townofbluffton.sc.gov/FormCenter/Town-15/Public-Comment-60 Public comment is limited to 3 minutes per speaker. Page 2 Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Theodore D. Washington Municipal Building, Henry “Emmett” McCracken Jr. Council Chambers, 20 Bridge Street, Bluffton, SC June 03, 2026 I. CALL TO ORDER Chairman DePauw called the meeting to order at 6pm. II. ROLL CALL PRESENT Chairman Joe DePauw Vice Chair Carletha Frazier Commissioner Jim Hess Commissioner Tim Probst Commissioner Debbie Wunder Commissioner Lisa Sulka Commissioner Michael Sutcliffe III. ADOPTION OF MINUTES 1. May 6, 2026 Minutes Vice Chair Frazier made a motion to approve the minutes as written. Seconded by Commissioner Probst. Voting Yea: Chairman DePauw, Vice Chair Frazier, Commissioner Hess, Commissioner Probst, Commissioner Wunder, Commissioner Sulka, Commissioner Sutcliffe All were in favor and motion passed. IV. PUBLIC COMMENT V. OLD BUSINESS VI. NEW BUSINESS 1. Certificate of Appropriateness (95 Green Street): A request by Glenda Mikulak Roberts, Applicant and Owner, for review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-HD to construct a new 1.5-story house of approximately 2,342 SF at 95 Green Street in OId Town Bluffton Historic District and zoned Neighborhood General-HD. (COFA-08-24-019275)(Staff-Charlotte Moore) Staff presented. The applicant was present. The commissioners discussed the home’s height relative to nearby properties and raised concerns about tree preservation, requesting clarification on the site plan’s protection measures. They also reviewed the chimney cap visibility, wall section details, shutter consistency between the existing and proposed structures, and the vertical divisions in the door sidelites. Commissioner Hess made a motion to approve the application with the following conditions: 1. Remove the gate from the utility meter screening fence or, alternatively, provide landscaping to screen the meter. 2. Rotate the chimney cap to not be visible from the street. Page 3 Section IV. Item #1. Town of Bluffton, SC Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes June 03, 2026 3. Provide the source and type of brick proposed to be used for approval by Town staff. 4. Provide a rear elevation door that is wood, metal or metal-clad. 5. Headers on the porches are to be consistent. 6. Band boards on the porches are to be consistent. 7. Remove the vertical divides in the door sidelites. 8. Consistent with UDO Sec. 5.15.6.J., provide the roof material. and the following was determined to be appropriate: 1. The massing of the middle block Seconded by Commissioner Sulka. Voting Yea: Chairman DePauw, Vice Chair Frazier, Commissioner Hess, Commissioner Probst, Commissioner Wunder, Commissioner Sulka, Commissioner Sutcliffe All were in favor and the motion passed. VII. DISCUSSION 1. Historic District Monthly Update. (Staff) Staff reviewed the monthly report. The Commissioners had no questions. 2. Discussion regarding proposed amendments to non-contributing structures in Old Town Bluffton Historic District. No attachments. (Staff) Staff discussed the amendments being proposed to the UDO regarding the demolition of non- contributing resources. The commission asked for clarification on what the application process would be. VIII. ADJOURNMENT Vice Chair Frazier made a motion to adjourn. Seconded by Commissioner Sulka. Voting Yea: Chairman DePauw, Vice Chair Frazier, Commissioner Hess, Commissioner Probst, Commissioner Wunder, Commissioner Sulka, Commissioner Sutcliffe All were in favor and the motion passed. The meeting adjourned at 6:42pm. Page 4 Section IV. Item #1. 36 Wharf Street – Certificate of Appropriateness Historic Preservation Commission HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION STAFF REPORT Department of Growth Management MEETING DATE: July 1, 2026 PROJECT: COFA-03-25-019657 36 Wharf Street Two-story Carriage House – Under Construction APPLICANT: Jamie Guscio (Kingfisher Construction) PROPERTY OWNERS: Kathy Barbina and Tim Harris PROJECT MANAGER: Charlotte Moore, AICP APPLICATION REQUEST: The Applicant, Jamie Guscio (Kingfisher Construction), on behalf of Kathy Barbina and Tim Harris, Owners, requests that the Historic Preservation Commission approves the following: An amended Certificate of Appropriateness-HD (COFA-HD) to allow the installation of alternate exterior doors. The property is in Old Town Bluffton Historic District, and zoned Neighborhood General-HD (NG-HD). BACKGROUND: The Certificate of Appropriateness Final Plan was approved by the HPC on December 10, 2025. While conducting a rough inspection, Town Staff identified inconsistencies with the approved COFA, including: 1) installation of an unapproved man door opening on the right elevation; 2) installation of a full-lite door with built-in Venetian blinds on the left elevation; and, 3) installation of a full lite 4-lite door at the second-story right elevation. A six-panel door (a square/vertical combination) for the garage man door had not yet been installed at time of inspection. The approved COFA did not include a garage man door opening. The approved door on the left elevation was a metal-clad half-lite door. On the right elevation, the same metal-clad half-lite door was also approved. The Applicant was contacted regarding the discrepancy and wishes to retain the installed doors, which is an COFA amendment. The UDO Administrator approved the man door opening but deferred the alternate door review to the HPC. The graphics on the following page show the left and right carriage house elevations and the carriage house with the installed doors (except for the garage man door). These can Page 5 Section VII. Item #1. July 1, 2026 Page 2 36 Wharf Street - Certificate of Appropriateness Historic Preservation Commission also be seen in Attachment 4, along with photos of the doors proposed for the right elevation. REVIEW CRITERIA & ANALYSIS: In its review of this COFA-HD application, Town Staff and the Historic Preservation Commission are required to consider the criteria set forth in Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Section 3.18.3 (COFA-HD, Application Review Criteria), applying the standards and guidelines of UDO Sec. 5.15, Old Town Bluffton Historic District. The intent of the standards and guidelines is, in part, to provide guidance Page 6 Section VII. Item #1. July 1, 2026 Page 3 36 Wharf Street - Certificate of Appropriateness Historic Preservation Commission and ensure consistent development without discouraging creativity or forcing the replication of historic models. The applicable criteria of UDO Sec. 3.18.3 are provided below followed by a Staff Finding based upon review of the application submittals to date. 1. Section 3.18.3.B. Consistency with the principles set forth in the Old Town Master Plan. a. Finding. The Old Town Master Plan initiatives included the adoption of a form- based code with architectural standards for structures within the Old Town Bluffton Historic District. These standards are included in Article 5 of the UDO and are intended to ensure the application of traditional architecture and features, as well as authentic materials that are consistent with Old Town’s vernacular. The left elevation door with full-lite inset blinds is not a traditional door configuration for Old Town. Further, the second story door is inconsistent and is a full lite door with 4-lites without the traditional panel commonly used in Old Town. For the garage man door, the square/vertical panel combination is also atypical. 2. Section 3.18.3.C. The application must be in conformance with applicable provisions provided in Article 5, Design Standards. Finding. UDO Sec. 5.15.6 states that the “primary goal of [the Old Town Bluffton Historic District architectural standards] is authenticity. The standards encourage Bluffton vernacular and construction which is straightforward and functional, and which draws its ornament and variety from traditional assembly of genuine materials.” As referenced in Finding #1, the proposed doors suggest configurations that are not common of Old Town’s residential doors. Therefore, determinations of appropriateness for these doors are sought from the HPC. 3. Section 3.18.3.D. Consistency with the nature and character of the surrounding area and consistency of the structure with the scale, form and building proportions of the surrounding neighborhood. Finding . This criterion relates to the overall structure and is not applicable. 4. Section 3.18.3.F. The historic, architectural, and aesthetic features of the structure, including the extent to which its alteration or removal would be detrimental to the public interest. Finding. This is not applicable to this criterion. 5. Section 3.18.3.H. The application must comply with applicable requirements in the Applications Manual. Page 7 Section VII. Item #1. July 1, 2026 Page 4 36 Wharf Street - Certificate of Appropriateness Historic Preservation Commission Finding. The Certificate of Appropriateness Application has been reviewed by Town Staff and has been determined to be complete except for the applicable items in #2. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: It is the charge of the HPC to assess and interpret the standards and guidelines set forth in the UDO as they pertain to applications using the review criteria established in the UDO and to take appropriate action as granted by the powers and duties set forth in Section 2.2.6.E.2. The HPC shall determine the appropriateness of the alternate doors and the garage man door and whether they satisfy the requirements of the UDO. HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION ACTIONS: As granted by the powers and duties set forth in Section 2.2.6.E.2, the Historic Preservation Commission has the authority to take the following actions with respect to this application: 1. Approve the application as submitted by the Applicant; 2. Approve the application with conditions; or 3. Deny the application as submitted by the Applicant. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Location and Zoning Map 2. Application (Amendment 2) 05.07.2026 3. Approved Final COFA 12.10.2025 4. Elevation Changes and Proposed Doors Page 8 Section VII. Item #1. LOCATION & ZONING MAP 36 Wharf Street Neighborhood General-HD District ATTACHMENT 1 Page 9 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 2 Page 10 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 2 Page 11 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 12 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 13 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 14 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 15 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 16 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 17 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 18 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 19 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 20 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 21 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 22 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 23 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 24 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 25 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 3 Page 26 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 4 Page 27 Section VII. Item #1. ATTACHMENT 4 Page 28 Section VII. Item #1. Garage Man Door Second Story Door ATTACHMENT 4 Page 29 Section VII. Item #1. M E M O R A N D U M TO: Historic Preservation Commissioners FROM: Town of Bluffton Growth Management Staff RE: Site Feature Permits from May 17, 2026, to June 16, 2026 DATE: July 1, 2026 SUMMARY: Town Staff will be updating the Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) monthly on all site feature permits that have been applied for, approved, denied, withdrawn, put on hold, or issued. These permits are reviewed at Staff level. Address Description of Application Staff Status 32 Lawrence St Repairs to rotten wood on house Caroline Luke Approved 1276 May River Rd Unit 100 Dillard Jones signage Caroline Luke Approved 1260 May River Rd Greenhouse Signage Caroline Luke Applied Page 30 Section VIII. Item #1.

Source: Town of Bluffton website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.