building codes agenda_2023-04-03
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Mar 31, 2023 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
BUILDING CODES
COMMITTEE MEETING
MONDAY, APRIL 3, 2023 | 6 PM
1st committee meeting
Please note that members of the public may attend this meeting in-person but are
encouraged to participate remotely. The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom.
Please visit the City’s website at https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting-
minutes-agendas/ to access the meeting via audio and videoconferencing.
The Committee will meet in the Mauldin City Hall at 5 East
Butler Road in the Council Chambers at 6 p.m.
Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting
• • •
2
Build ing Cod e s (BDS) Com mitte e AGENDA
Ap ril 3 , 202 3
C ommi ttee Members: Diane K uzniar (Chair) , T af t Matney, Frank Allg o o d
1. Call to Ord e r T he H onorabl e Di ane
K uzniar
2. Pub lic Comment T he H onorabl e Di ane
K uzniar
3. R eadi ng and A pproval of Mi nutes
a. Build ing Co d e s Commi ttee M eeti ng:
March 6 , 2023 (Pages 3 -6)
T he H onorabl e Di ane
K uzniar
4. R eports or Communications from City Officers
a. B DS Department R eport, David Dyrhaug
b. Impact Fee Overview, Matt Noonkester
T he H onorabl e Di ane
K uzniar
5. Unfinished B usiness
None
T he H onorabl e Di ane
K uzniar
6. New Business
None
T he H onorabl e Di ane
K uzniar
7. Pub lic Comment T he H onorabl e Di ane
K uzniar
8. Commi ttee Concerns T he H onorabl e Di ane
K uzniar
9. Ad journ T he H onorabl e Di ane
K uzniar
Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting
• • •
3
Minutes
Build ing Co d e s (BDS) Co m m itte e
March 6, 2023
1st Commi ttee M eeti ng
Committee Members: Diane Kuzniar (Chair), Taft Matney, Frank Allgood
Others present: BDS Director David Dyrhaug and City Administrator Seth Duncan
1. Call to Order- Chairwoman Kuzniar
2. Public Comment- None
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a. Building Codes Committee Meeting: November 7, 2022
Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to approve the minutes with Councilman
Allgood seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
4. Reports or Communications from City Officers
a. BDS Director David Dyrhaug
Mr. Dyrhaug reported almost 1900 building inspections were done in February. This is a
record for the department. New home permits were back down in February at 28
permits issued. 25 business licenses were issued in February as well.
The department is over budget due to the contracted building inspector the City has
been using.
5. Unfinished Business- None
6. New Business
a. An ordinance to repeal zoning ordinance no. 2021-991 (Pages 5-11)
This item is to consider repealing Ordinance #2021-991, which rezoned approximately
5.6 acres across two properties located at 513 N. Main Street from R-15 and C-2 to R-M1
and C-2. The effect of this repeal would revert the zoning on these two properties back
to the original zoning on these two properties which consisted of R-15 and C-2. Since
this time, it appears that the front property is not going to be developed exactly as was
Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting
• • •
4
portrayed during the rezoning proceedings. At present, a federal credit union company
is under contract to purchase and develop the property. Preliminary conversations
about the design of this development do not appear to incorporate the pedestrian
orientation and intersection realignment that was previously envisioned.
Sebastian Carter was present to represent the project. The market has changed and a
new concept has come forward. Due to some unforeseen circumstances, the original
developer of the front parcels is not now attached to the project. The project went out
to the private market and this new proposal was deemed to be the least impactful. The
current offer is with Truliant Credit Union. Mr. Carter met with the City on Friday to find
support for the project. The current developer in the rear of the property is ready to
proceed with the 36 townhome project.
The alignment of Knollwood Road came up in discussion. It was the intention of the
other developer to help fund the project. The developer now is in favor of trying to get
this done, but the realignment does not impact either one of the new developments.
This is more of a request from the City.
Chairwoman Kuzniar asked about stormwater mitigation. Mr. Carter said there is a
creek at the rear of the property. There will be a catch basin for a 100-year storm as
required by Greenville County.
Councilman Allgood said a resident came to the last council meeting talking about
stormwater from the same creek and that might be worth taking a look at. Councilman
Allgood then said the original design was a two level restaurant, so to go from a mixed
use to a credit union was not the intent. He asked if there was anything else that could
be looked at. Mr. Carter said Truliant has been good to work with. The application for
rezoning only showed the road realignment and the rear property, not the front
development. The project has gone a long way with Truliant.
Councilman Allgood said it has been about a year, and does this fit with the City’s
vision?
Councilman Matney asked about the Knollwood realigning. Is this still being looked at
as part of the project? Mr. Carter said it makes sense as it separates the residential
from the commercial. DOT did agree that realignment was warranted, but there has
been no final approval. Mr. Carter said the City did request this as part of the
development initially. He said both he and Truliant are open to the realignment.
Councilman Matney asked about the sewer capacity and was answered there was
enough for the developments.
Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to not approve repealing the ordinance.
Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting
• • •
5
Chairwoman Kuzniar seconded the motion for discussion.
Councilman Allgood said he would like another public hearing since there have been
some changes.
Motion: Councilman Matney withdrew his motion and made a motion to hold this item
in committee. Councilman Allgood seconded the motion.
Councilman Matney said the reasoning behind the original motion to not repeal the
ordinance is because the residential component will continue and the realignment will
continue. This is important as part of the downtown development. Those are two
pieces of the original project that will continue. Right now, the front would still be C2 so
any commercial development would have to be considered. Councilman Matney said
his rationale was to allow the other two pieces to continue.
Councilman Allgood said he heard Truliant is ready to sign, but he didn’t hear that the
residential aspect was ready to go. Mr. Carter answered the civil engineer for the
residential portion is ready to be engaged and with the sale of the property up front, the
rear property is fully funded. David Dyrhaug said this part would have to go to the
planning commission.
Councilman Allgood said then the residential part would not start until the commercial
is underway.
Mr. Carter said the sewer capacity on the front meets the requirement of the previous
use, which was a car lot. If they had proceeded with the original plan with the
restaurant and other mixed use, he thinks it would have been difficult to come under
the capacity and would have been an obstacle.
Councilman Allgood said there should be style and design elements known. There are
many different kinds of credit union styles. He thinks it will be helpful to see what is
being considered. Mr. Carter said he would reach out to try and get some renderings.
Chairwoman Kuzniar asked if Truliant finishes construction and the townhomes are not
ready, will that cause construction vehicles to be able to access the property through
the townhomes? Mr. Carter said the traffic from construction vehicles would be
diverted away from Knollwood.
The vote was unanimous to hold this item in committee (3-0).
7. Public Comment- None
Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting
• • •
6
8. Committee Concerns- None
9. Adjourn- Chairwoman Kuzniar adjourned the meeting at 6:27 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
I m p l e m e n t i n g a D e v e l o p m e n t I m p a c t F e e P r o g r a m i n S o u t h C a r o l i n a
City of Mauldin
AGENDA
3 Documents-in-Review
4 Some Things to Consider
5 Questions?
1 Introduction
2 Solutions & Tools
Introduction
“Impact fees represent financial payments from a
developer to a local government that fund their
proportionate share of certain off-site capital
improvements needed to accommodate future
growth.”
― Mount Pleasant Development Impact Fee Study, 2017
The legality for collecting development impact fees is
expressed in the South Carolina Development Impact
Fee Act.
What Are Impact Fees?
What Are Impact Fees?
• Pass construction costs onto new
development rather than existing
development
• Legality for collecting impact
fees:
- City authority to collect fees
- Rational nexus test
- Must be non-discriminatory
• Growing interest by cities, towns
& counties throughout South
Carolina
What Are Impact Fees?
• Rapid growth & development
• Significant land available for
development
• Resistance to increased
property taxes
Others with Impact Fees in South Carolina
Rock Hill
Berkeley County
Summerville
Charleston
Mount Pleasant
Beaufort City / County
Hilton Head
Myrtle Beach
York County
Goose Creek
Dorchester County
Fort MillTega Cay
Lexington
Kershaw County
Camden
Charleston County
North Augusta
Anderson County
Aiken County
Lancaster County
Horry County
Forest Acres
Kiawah Island
Aiken
Atlantic Beach
Sumter City/County
Georgetown
Greenville County
Georgetown County
Source:
Land Use Law Update, SCAPA Conference,
2021 & City Explained, Inc. project list
Who Pays Impact Fees?
Who Pays Impact Fees?
Who Pays Impact Fees?
Who Pays Impact Fees?
Solutions & Tools
General Background on the Act
• Impact fees may be used for…
- design & engineering
- ROW acquisition
- construction
- utility relocation
- project financing
• Impact fees may not be use for…
- maintenance
- administrative costs
- operating costs
General Background on the Act
• All revenues maintained in an interest
bearing account
• Monies must be spent within 3 years
of scheduled date of construction in
the CIP
• Annual monitoring report
• Comprehensive review and update
every 5 years
• Any new project or fee change
requires an update to study
Formal Study Process
Prepare Impact Fee
Justification Report
2 3 41
Prepare Capital
Projects List
Prepare Housing
Affordability Study
Adopt Impact Fee
Ordinance
Typical Planning Process
Feasibility Study
Initial Study / Appropriateness
City Council Resolution
Prepare Supporting Documents
Impact Fee Study Report
Public Comment Period
Public Hearings
City Council Work Session
Develop Draft Ordinance
Adoption Process
Capital Improvements Plan
Commitment
Housing Affordability Analysis
Documents in Review
Impact Fee Study Report
A report that documents existing
conditions, anticipates future year needs
and their implementation costs, and
recommends maximum allowable impact
fees by category.
• Municipal Facilities & Services
• Parks & Recreation
• Fire Protection
• Transportation
• Schools
• Other Categories…
Impact Fee Categories:
What is it?
Impact Fee Study Report
Impact Fee Study Report
• Incremental cost per service unit
• Assumes constant current service delivery
standards for calculating maximum
allowable impact fees
Consumption-Driven Approach
Improvements-Driven Approach:
• Cost of increasing capacity at established LOS is
divided among new service units
• It does not charge new development for using
existing capacity, nor does it account for excess
capacity remaining in the system at the horizon year
• Identifies existing & future year deficiencies, but only
future year improvements are considered in impact
fee calculations
Application of a Discount Rate
A discount rate applies to the maximum allowable
impact fee to provide a reasonable fee for continued
residential or non-residential investment and to ensure
that impact fees collected do not exceed the cost of
providing capital facilities that support new
development.
What is it?
Capital Improvements Plan
What Costs Are Eligible?
Development impact fees collected must be spent on projects, or portions thereof, that
increase capacity to serve the needs of future development. Any portion of a capital
project intended to replace or rehabilitate existing assets, but not increase service
capacity, must be funded by other sources.
The CIP is a blueprint for future capital
expenditures funded over a fixed period of
time to meet anticipated demand.
What is it?
What is included?
• Capital improvement project description
• Start & completion dates
• Revenue & expenditure summaries
• Funding sources & schedule
Affordable Housing Study
A report that estimates the effect of
imposing new or updated development
impact fees on affordable housing in the
local jurisdiction.
What is it?
Development Impact Fee Ordinance
A development impact fee ordinance enacts the
rules and requirements formally adopted by
Town Council for establishing a development
impact fee system.
What is it?
Highlights:
• Supporting Documentation
• Jurisdiction (Service Zones)
• Application & Exemptions
• Determination of Fees
• Credits & Reimbursements
• Appeal Process
• Refunds
Development Impact Fee Ordinance
Some Things to Consider
Timing is Everything
• Economic Conditions
• Political Support & Understanding
• Other Programs in the Region
• Data Availability
• Potential Revisions to the Study
• Budget Planning Process
Partnering Strategy
• An open & honest approach to the
impact fee study will carry the day
through implementation.
• Increase the number of finger
prints on the study:
• Staff coordination meetings
• Policy-maker briefings
• General information meetings
Bringing It Back to Mauldin
Let’s CHAT
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.