council minutes february 2023
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Mar 21, 2023 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES
CITY OF MAULDIN
COUNCIL MEETING
FEBRUARY 20, 2023
7:00 P.M.
CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
Members present: Mayor Terry Merritt, Council Members Taft Matney, Carol King, Jason
Kraeling, Michael Reynolds, Frank Allgood and Diane Kuzniar.
Others present: City Administrator Seth Duncan and City Attorney John Duggan
1. Call to Order-
Mayor Merritt
a. Welcome- Mayor Merritt
b. Invocation- Councilwoman King
c. Pledge of Allegiance- Councilwoman King
2. Proclamations and Presentations
a. Proclamation for Tim Brett
b. Proclamation for L.S. Green, Sr.
State Representative David Vaughan presented each of the families of Tim Brett and L.S.
Green, Sr. with a State proclamation and a flag flown above the State House.
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a. City Council Goals Session- January 6, 2023
Motion: Councilwoman King made a motion to approve the minutes with Councilman
Matney seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
b. City Council Meeting – January 17, 2023
Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to approve the minutes with Councilwoman
King seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
4. Public Comment- None
5. Report from City Administrator
a. Departmental annual reviews
The Police, Fire, BDS, Public Works and Recreation Departments gave their year-end
summary reports.
6. Report from Standing Committees
a. Finance and Policy (Chairperson Reynolds)
Compensation Study report by Evergreen Solutions
Mark Holcombe of Evergreen Solutions presented a proposed comp and class plan with
new ranges and several proposals on how this may be implemented.
b. Public Safety (Chairperson King)- Chairwoman King said it was nice to hear from all the
department heads and a common theme she heard was making the City of Mauldin better.
She thanked each department for working together towards that goal.
c. Public Works (Chairperson Kraeling)- None
d. Economic Planning & Development (Chairperson Matney)- None
e. Building Codes (Chairperson Kuzniar)- None
f. Recreation (Chairperson Allgood)- None
7. Unfinished Business- None
8. New Business
Ordinances – 1st Reading- None
Standing Committee Items
a. Sports Center Free and Reduced Membership Fee Policy [Pages 8-9]
Motion: Chairman Allgood made a motion to accept this policy with Councilman
Matney seconding.
Councilwoman Kuzniar said she would like to see a definition of “family” where the
policy states “and their families” under military members. Their families could be
aunts, uncles, etc.
City Administrator Duncan said a potential resolution to the problem may be striking the
word “families” and replacing it with “dependents.” That is a structured term for
military members. ID cards are also issued to dependents and could be shown for proof
at the Sports Center front desk.
Motion: Councilman Kraeling made a motion to amend the original motion to
strike the word families and add dependents. Councilwoman Kuzniar seconded the
motion.
Chairman Allgood asked if “dependents” should be added to the policy in the section
above instead of family members.
Councilman Kraeling made a motion to amend his amendment to change the word
families in both sections to dependents. Councilwoman Kuzniar said she does not have
a problem with that.
Councilman Matney said a dependent could be someone up to the age of 18. What
about a college student who is still a dependent? A student can remain on a parent’s
insurance until the age of 26. He would be more comfortable with family members
residing at the same address. Councilman Matney would vote against simply labeling
them dependents.
Councilwoman King said perhaps we could put immediate family members residing at
the same address. There could be a disabled child who would be a dependent for life.
Councilwoman Kuzniar said a child going to college is probably still a dependent on a tax
return.
Vote: The vote on the amendment to change the word families to dependents was 1-6
with Councilwoman Kuzniar voting for the amendment. The amendment failed.
Motion: Councilman Matney made an amendment to the motion to say immediate
family members of full time and part time employees of the City of Mauldin residing at
the same physical address as employee. Councilman Matney also moved to allow the
employees to change the wording as necessary to enforce the intent of Council.
Councilwoman Kuzniar seconded the amendment.
Vote: The vote on the amendment was 6-1 with Councilman Reynolds dissenting.
Motion: Councilman Reynolds made a motion to allow a part-time employee to have a
free membership, but not their family. He would also like to require the military
member to be a City resident to have a free membership. There was no second to the
motion.
Vote: The vote on the original motion as amended was 6-1 with Councilman Reynolds
dissenting.
b. School Resource Officer Agreement Amendment
Motion: Chairwoman King made a motion to approve this amendment to accept two
SRO grant positions- one for Bethel Elementary and one for Mauldin Elementary.
Councilman Reynolds seconded the motion.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
c. Mauldin Fire Department Mutual Aid Agreement
Motion: Chairwoman King made a motion to accept the County fire mutual aid
agreement. Councilman Reynolds seconded the motion.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
d. Stewart-Cooper-Newell Contract Amendment 1
Motion: Chairwoman King made a motion to authorize the Mayor to execute a contract
amendment with Stewart-Cooper-Newell to increase the Reimbursable Allowance
Budget by $3,500 to not exceed a total of $11,000. Councilman Matney seconded the
motion.
City Administrator Duncan said the City agreed to a Reimbursable Allowance Budget of
$7,500 in the original agreement with Stewart-Cooper-Newell. Due to higher than
expected number of permit review submissions and associated printing costs, the
Architect requests to increase the Reimbursable Expenses Allowance Budget to cover
projected related expenses though the agreed construction timeline as outlined in the
construction documents. Staff believes that the increase is reasonable based upon the
expected travel demands to complete the construction timeline. All expected charges
to this line item will be sent to Greenville County for payment as have all previous
engineering expenses. Once all Greenville County bond proceeds have been expended,
any additional charges will be assessed against the City of Mauldin’s bond proceeds.
Councilman Reynolds asked how much the total contract was. Mr. Duncan answered
$360,000 plus $7500 in reimbursable expenses.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
e. Fire Station Tap Fees payment to CloverLeaf
Motion: Chairwoman King made a motion to authorize payment in the amount of
$46,326.13 from the General Fund Capital Fund Balance to The CloverLeaf Group, LLC
for water and sewer fees related to the construction of the new fire station.
Councilman Kraeling seconded the motion.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
f. Municipal Judge Re-Appointments
Motion: Chairwoman King made a motion to re-appoint Jack Read as Chief Trial Judge;
Will McKibbon and Christopher Jackson as Associate Trial Judges; Curtis Spearman and
Mark Putman as Administrative Judges through the expiration of the newly created two-
year appointment terms. Councilman Kraeling seconded the motion.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
g. Additional Weekend Judge Appointment
Motion: Chairwoman King made a motion to appoint the Honorable Erika Stinson as
part-time Administrative Judge for City of Mauldin. Councilman Kraeling seconded the
motion.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
h. Public Works Parking Lot Repaving RFP
Motion: Chairman Kraeling made a motion to accept the bid by Panagakos for paving
the Public Works parking lot. Councilwoman King seconded the motion.
The City allocated $250,000 in its Capital Improvement Plan for the 2022 – 2023 annual
budget for the repaving of the parking lot. The lowest bid was $269,823 by Panagakos.
$25,000 will be pulled from the sewer fund to cover the difference.
Motion: Councilman Reynolds made an amendment to the motion to add $25,000 out
of the sewer fund for the difference between the original budgeted amount and the
amount bid. Councilwoman King seconded the motion.
Councilwoman Kuzniar questioned the amount of $25,000, when the difference is only
a little over $19,000.
Motion: Councilman Allgood made a motion to change the amount transferred from
the sewer fund to $20,000. Councilwoman Kuzniar seconded the motion.
Vote: The vote on the amendment to the amendment was unanimous (7-0).
Vote: The vote on the amendment was unanimous (7-0).
Vote: The vote on the original motion as amended was unanimous (7-0).
i. Sale of Old/Damaged Equipment
Motion: Chairman Kraeling made a motion to adopt a resolution for authorization to
proceed on the sale of old/damaged public works equipment. Councilman Reynolds
seconded the motion.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
j. KCI Task Order 1 Amendment
Motion: Chairman Kraeling made a motion to approve an amendment to Task Order 01
with KCI to provide stormwater project design services. Councilman Allgood seconded
the motion.
The City allocated 1,129,724 dollars in year one of the ARPA spending to fund necessary
stormwater management projects that improve the City’s stormwater infrastructure
systems. The engineering services associated with this task order were proposed at
226,600. Amending the task order to eliminate one section reduces the cost 25,000
dollars to a total of $201,600.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
k. KCI Task Order 2 Amendment
Motion: Authorization is requested to approve an amendment to Task Order 02 with
KCI to provide stormwater asset inventory, on-call GIS services, stormwater modeling,
grant assistance, and a City-Wide Stormwater Master Plan. Councilman Allgood
seconded the motion.
The City allocated 1,129,724 dollars in year one of the ARPA spending to fund necessary
stormwater management projects that improve the City’s stormwater infrastructure
systems. The engineering services associated with this task order are proposed at
$411,600. Removing GIS services from the Task Order ($10,500) and increasing the
additional fee to complete the asset survey ($165,000) brings the services associated
with this task to $566,100.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
Committee of the Whole- None
9. Public Comment
Brian Patton: I live at 123 Kingsley Drive. I dropped off some pictures this afternoon. This is
specifically for Mr. Kraeling and Mr. Fleahman. Kingsley Drive has a serious stormwater
problem. The second week of November, we had a five-foot tree trunk stuck in the creek
going into the stormwater box. I stopped because two weeks before, water had flooded
into the street. I stopped and KCI was there, I asked if they were doing just generic GPS
marking, he said yes, and I said, did you notice the log? He said yes, but all we are doing is
just marking.
One of the homeowners called public works. For about fourteen years, we have had a joke.
I said they are going to tell you it is Greenville County’s problem. Greenville County is going
to tell you it is Mauldin’s problem. I don’t know who came out, but he came out within
two days. He took the tops off of the boxes, he then put the tops back on the boxes with
the tree trunk still in there. It was left until Saturday. This past Saturday. He was advised to
call the Corps of Engineers. If you could play this really quick. I could have printed the
pictures, but you will see the video.
The videos and pictures were shown.
I would like to know, is, yes, this is a Greenville County problem, or is it a Greenville
County/Mauldin problem and that it is on the radar. If someone could stop by, you know
where I live. Maybe something could get done if it is on the radar, in a couple of years.
Being asked to call the Corps of Engineers, I don’t know. Thank you.
Dr. Walter McPhail: Thank you Council. I appreciate the opportunity to talk to you.
Basically, I want to talk about City Center. You had a good business announcement in the
Greenville News about things happening. Something caught my attention and I wanted to
talk to you about it. That is Jenkins Street and Jenkins Court. That basically is like hand
grenades exploding. I have been here for 45 years and it is a great place to live and to
work. We live here, we work here. I have twelve staff who work for me on Jenkins Court.
To show you how good they are, the first three have been with me two or three years,
Chuck has been with me 44 years, Dr. Kennon has been with me 28 years, I have a groomer
who has been with me 25 years, and I have a wife that has been with me 45 years. We like
Mauldin and want to stay here.
We don’t necessarily as landowners know what is going on. I have tried to approach the
City three or four times and no one has ever come to my office until JR came the other day.
That is the first time the City has approached me. I even sent a letter to the City
Administrator from a lawyer. No response after two years, except one or two references
that we can’t talk to you, because you sent a letter. I was trying to get involved in the plan
for parking because it is critical to my business. What we want to start off with is you take
the first phase, and this is a drawing that shows 14 spaces. The second drawing, this is
where the City, and when I say City, it has taken a long time to figure out the moving parts.
You are in agreement with Greenville County.
The County, CoTransCo is who came by my office the other day and that is the first real
contact I have had. He brought me a roll of paper of all of your plans. Next thing I knew, I
had an appraiser send me a letter. He wanted to do an unsolicited appraisal of my
property, which he did. I let him come in the following week. What I want to read, and I am
sure none of you have read my appraisal which Joel Norwood did. You may have a dollar
figure; I won’t ask for a show of hands, because that would not be wise. I am going to read
pages 70-71 and highlight what is written in blue. Basically, all this is background
information. I want Council to know what is going on and what hasn’t been going on. I
want to stay in business like what we are doing now. We have been there 45 years and I am
not ready to retire.
Description of Acquisition- the new right of way requires 537 square feet. It is located at the
corner of Jenkins Street and Jenkins Court. The road right of way on Jenkins Street becomes
a new 25 wide right of way and there is a new side item 25X25. That comes right in front of
my front door and comes within 10 feet of the corner. Many of you have been to my office
and you can imagine that it will be taken by the County. The road project includes drainage,
curb, gutter and sidewalks. Afterwards, access will only be from a specified 40 feet wide
driveway. Access from two streets will be reduced to one street. Access will be removed
Jenkins Street which eliminates three parking spaces there and it is a heavily traveled spot.
Three spaces from the kennel side of the building which were there from RV Chandler will
be eliminated. The side angle eliminates one more space and the new driveway and new
right of way on Jenkins Court cuts off the rest of the parking.
Based on the space, the subject will have 2-3 parallel parking spaces after the project
potential. I have 36-40 clients a day coming to park, and some of them park twice. That is
in the information that I sent. Then the highlight here is the highest and best use
afterwards. After the project, the subject land is smaller than before. Access is changed,
parking is lost, it had 13 spaces and best-case scenario is 2-3 spaces after. The loss of the
parking causes a total loss to the business’ functionalities. The business cannot survive and
since it is a highly specialized building, it cannot be remodeled for another use. The
building’s improvements have no utility and no value after the project. The highest and best
use is taking it apart after the project. Therefore, the value added is land, less demolition
costs.
I was shocked. I doubt any of you know the extent of what these plans call for or the
consequences. I am here tonight to let you know that I am not sure the left hand knows
what the right hand knows about this business. My building has been there for 60 years,
built by RV Chandler. RV owned the property you are selling to the Parker Group, and
owned what is now the street, but it was private land to start with. He built that building
for his daughter. He later sold it to Mr. Cannon; they straightened out the property line to
allow for more parking, but still, if you have a long truck, it goes over the parking. He
created the parking in the 60s. I think the City of Mauldin bought it in 2007. We have been
there for 65 years. That is the situation.
I am summarizing part of this. The main thing is you are taking away parking spots. I need
offsite parking. We have 14 now, we use 4 at Thumbs Up Laundry and Jenkins Court. I
still need a total of 18 parking spots for my clients. You put a curb like this, people cannot
pull in our area. Back it up a little, first we learned about this when Jeff Hildebrand from
CoTransCo came in and gave me a set of plans. It took me a while to understand the plans,
but it calls for a 10 -foot sidewalk with 40 foot curbing in between. I think I can work with
Jeff, but I need you as Council to know where we are coming from. We have been able to
negotiate down to five feet rather than 10 feet all the way up and down.
The other point I need to put in there is we have not had any visitation from the City on my
property and I have tried. However, JR did come down the other day and his position is not
to discuss the situation. I have been told only to discuss with Jeff Hildebrand, and I think we
can do that. But his instructions were, his instructions, and this kind of gets me a little bit,
and I have been working with the City for a long time, Jeff wants a reply within 60 days and
that is from January. That is why I am talking to you because you all don’t know what is
going on. JR said we will negotiate. If we don’t resolve it, we will go to meditation. If that
doesn’t resolve it, we will go to court, leading to condemnation. There is another word I can
use, and I am sure you can think of it. I am not going to use it because I don’t think it needs
to go that far. I am here to resolve this.
I want you to consider option 1. There are two other options, but option 1 said I am
protecting my interests and stay in the City of Mauldin. I am not ready to retire and sell and
be forced out of business. I believe we can work out an amicable solution with McPhail
Animal Hospital and Mauldin City Center by, maintaining the parking at Jenkins Court and a
five-foot rollover sidewalk along our eastern property line. The other part is to provide
seven needed staff parking places on Jenkins Court or the Four Seasons property 10 feet
from the street, but they need to be deeded to me. You are taking away my deeded
property, but I need these parking spaces deeded to me for my future. Parking may be used
on this land during non-business hours by the public, and I understand minimum public
parking will be provided in the townhouse area across the street.
Since the City project is stating 537 square feet on a heavily traveled road, and taking away
our parking spots on Jenkins Court, it is only reasonable that replacement parking be
provided to lessen the economic impact on McPhail Animal Hospital. The sign needs to be
relocated and we propose to take 10 feet from the entrance of the building, obstructing
ingress and egress. In the event this occurs, I would like a written guarantee from the City
that there will be no hindrance in using this entrance, future sale of property, or ordinances
reducing our occupancies or efficiencies. In the event Mauldin chooses not to provide
deeded parking spaces, I will consider purchasing the Four Seasons property at a value to be
determined by Joel Norwood, the appraiser. There are a couple of other options in there
that you can read.
That is my game plan and that is what I would like you to be aware of, and I think that is the
preferred way to resolve this situation. I am glad to have anyone come by my office and I
would also be glad to answer any questions you may have since this is an opportunity to talk
to the decision makers. I appreciate the opportunity to be here, Mr. Mayor.
Councilman Allgood: Mr. Duncan, can you tell us how many parking spaces will be going in
when the townhouses are built?
Seth Duncan: Are you referring to down the street?
Councilman Allgood: It is my understanding there will be public parking around the
townhouse area. When all is said and done, I am wondering how many could potentially be
used by Dr. McPhail over the course of the project.
Mr. Duncan stated he did not have that information tonight, but the number is included in
the plan. He will send that information to Council.
Dr. McPhail: That will be good to know. There will be some parallel parking on Jenkins
Court. I attended a meeting when the developer talked about doing the townhouses, and
my recollection is that there would be minimal public parking in the townhouse area. What
was also surprising is that there will be two-car garages, but they would be parked in front of
each other.
Councilman Allgood told Dr. McPhail he appreciates him coming to speak to Council tonight
and he would like to talk further.
Dr. McPhail: This will go back to CoTransCo who will basically go to Mr. Duncan who will
come to you. It will be up to you. I think the stickler will be the deeded parking. I don’t
think you will want to give that up. But is very important for my business and my clients to
be able to access and get in.
Councilman Allgood asked Dr. McPhail if it was correct that he had talked to Jeff about the
sidewalk going from 10 feet to 5 feet.
Dr. McPhail: Jeff suggested that. He also suggested he could put in a rolled level
sidewalk without a curb. That is what we were asking for a long time ago, which is no
problem. Those were his suggestions. I appreciate the opportunity and I also want to tell
you that you need a raise. Thank you for listening to everyone and being on Council.
10. Council Concerns- None
11. Adjournment- Mayor Merritt adjourned the meeting at 9:45 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.