Rec Agenda January 2023
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Dec 30, 2022 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
RECREATION
COMMITTEE MEETING
TUESD AY, JANUARY 3, 2023 | 6 PM
2nd committee meeting
The Committee will meet in Mauldin City Hall at 5 East
Butler Road in the Council Chambers
at 6 p.m.
The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at
https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting-minutes-agendas/ to access the
meeting via audio and videoconferencing.
A quorum of Council will be present.
1
RECREATION COMMITTEE MEETING
JANUARY 3, 2023 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5 E. BUTLER ROAD
Committee Members: Frank Allgood (Chair), Taft Matney, and Michael Reynolds
1. Call to Order Chairman Allgood
2. Public Comment Chairman Allgood
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a.Recreation Committee Meeting: December 5, 2022
[Pages 3-5]
Chairman Allgood
4. Reports or Communications from City Officers
a. Recreation Director Bart Cumalander
i. Budget Review
Chairman Allgood
5. Unfinished Business
There is no unfinished business.
Chairman Allgood
6. New Business
a.Sports Center Free and Reduced Membership Fee Policy
[Pages 6-9]
b.Sports Center Membership Fees
Chairman Allgood
7. Public Comment Chairman Allgood
8. Committee Concerns Chairman Allgood
9. Adjournment
2
MINUTES
RECREATION COMMITTEE MEETING
DECEMBER 5, 2022 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5 E. BUTLER ROAD
1st committee meeting
Co
mmittee Members present: Frank Allgood (Chair), Taft Matney, and Michael Reynolds
Others present: City Administrator Seth Duncan and Recreation Director Bart Cumalander
1.
Call to Order- Chairman Allgood
2.
Public Comment- None
3.
Reading and Approval of Minutes
a. Recreation Committee Meeting: September 6, 2022
Mot
ion: Councilman Matney made a motion to accept the minutes with Councilman Reynolds
seconding.
V
ote: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
4. Re
ports or Communications from City Officers
a. Recreation Director Bart Cumalander
i. Budget Review
Mr.
Cumalander reported basketball and football are going well. The 11–12-year-old boys will be
playing for the football state championship in Orangeburg.
Th
e budgets are in good shape.
5. Un
finished Business- There is no unfinished business.
6. New
Business
a. Sports Center Membership- Staff needs direction on whether or not free or reduced memberships
should be offered to military members, retired employees, and people who have served on boards
and commissions.
It i
s the recommendation of the Recreation Department staff to extend free membership to current
City employees, current Council members, and active military and their dependents.
A
50% membership rate could be offered to part-time City employees, family members of full time
and part-time employees of the City of Mauldin, and to retired military and their dependents.
Li
fetime membership could be extended to retired employees who have 20 years or more of
creditable service to the City of Mauldin and elected officials who have 20 years or more of
creditable service to the City of Mauldin.
3
Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to send the recommendation of the Recreation staff
to Council with Councilman Reynolds seconding.
C
ouncilman Matney said there will be some pushback with this, but the employees need to have
access to the facility to participate in the wellness program. When a person is no
longer employed by the City, benefits cease. Councilman Matney said he would not have an
expectation to have access to the same level of service at the same price point when he is no
longer in office.
C
ouncilman Reynolds said he would like these membership rates included in the fee schedule
during the budget process. He would like this issue to be sent to the City Attorney since it involves
a benefit available to Council Members.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
b
. Sunset Park Fencing- It is the request of the Recreation Department to place a black vinyl chain link
fence around the rectangular field at Sunset Park. The placement of the fence would increase
safety for users of the field and would be a barrier between the field and the parking lot where cars
access the parking area. $50,000 has been budgeted for the fencing in capital improvements.
Two
quotes were received. The recommendation is to award the bid to Seegar’s Fencing Company
for $34,280. They have completed the fencing for all three of our new playgrounds and are a local
company. Option 2 would tie into the retention pond fencing and was included in the budget CIP.
C
hairman Allgood asked Mr. Cumalander why the fence was taken down and not replaced. Mr.
Cumalander said he did not have a good reason, except that it was the decision of the leadership
at that time
M
otion: Councilman Reynolds made a motion to send to Council the acceptance of Option 2 for
Seegar’s Fencing not to exceed $35,000 with Councilman Matney seconding.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
7.
Public Comment
May
or Merritt: I live at 214 Fairfield Drive. I am the former chair of Recreation, and former
employee of the Mauldin Sports Center. I wanted to take the opportunity to give you a little
background and Noah’s son Bart knows a lot more background than I do. It was a little problematic
in 2015, when we were having people trying to sign up for memberships. It was a little easier back
then, because there were 5 branches of the military. We didn’t count the Coast Guard, Merchant
Marine, and the National Guard and those others. Things change. Today those people get deployed.
Determining what is active duty is problematic for the front desk personnel because you have to
have paperwork. Plus, we had recruiters from Donaldson Center, SC TAC, they would say he has
taken his oath and we have his papers; can he have a membership and get in shape before he goes
to bootcamp? We accepted that.
4
The problem was, when they are deployed, then they are active duty. Then their spouses are
members of active duty, which would entitle them to 50%. Finding the paperwork to do that was
always problematic for them to present. Keep that in mind as we move this thing forward. That
could be a problem again; not insurmountable, but the people at the front desk need to be clear on
what is required in order to do that.
The l
ifetime membership, to me, I have never been a proponent of lifetime memberships for
anything, and that would include us. When we get to all elected officials, I would like that clarified
because you have the Planning Commission, Board of Zoning Appeals, and a Cultural board. Those
are not elected officials, but if that should be extended to them, it should be clarified in one way,
shape, or form. I would hope to see that before it comes to full Council.
I w
ill be glad to give you more opinions off the record, but those are the issues we ran into at the
front desk from 2015- I am sorry, 2010-2014. I resigned there before I was elected here in 2015.
Thank you.
Ch
airman Allgood: Based on the feedback we just received, when this comes to full Council, could
we have the number of current members at the Sports Center that are classified currently as active
military?
8. Co
mmittee Concerns- None
9. Ad
journment- Chairman Allgood adjourned the meeting at 6:18 p.m.
Res
pectfully Submitted,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
5
Page 1 of 1
RECREATION COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM
MEETING DATE: January 3, 2023
AGENDA ITEM: Sports Center Membership
TO: RECREATION COMMITTEE
FROM: Recreation Director, Bart Cumalander
SUBJECT: Sports Center Membership
REQUEST
The Recreation Department is seeking a request from the council on whether to continue to allow
free and 50% memberships for the groups as listed below.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
Since the Sports Center has been opened, the following groups have had free memberships and
50% membership discount.
• Active / inactive mayor, council, commission, board members
• Active military
• Active employee
• 50% membership discount for active military and employee spouse and/or dependents
membership
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
Looking to see if it is still viable to have the current free memberships stay in place or add a
charge to these memberships. This item was sent back to Committee from December Council.
FISCAL IMPACT
Based on the recommendation of the committee, there will either be no fiscal impact as
everything will either stay the same or there will be an increase in revenue due to payment
memberships.
RECOMMENDATION
The Recreation Department recommendation is attached.
ATTACHMENTS
6
CURRENT
The Mauldin Sports Center has been operating since 2007 and the following groups have had
free memberships or 50% membership discount.
FREE MEMBERSHIP
• Active / Inactive mayor, council member, commission, board member
• Active military
• Active employee
50% MEMBERSHIP DISCOUNT
• Active military spouse and/or dependents
• Employee’s spouse and/or dependents
RECOMMENDED
It is the recommendation of the Recreation Department to follow as outlined.
FREE MEMBERSHIP
• All full-time employees of the City of Mauldin
• All elected city officials at current time
• Active-duty military service member
50% MEMBERSHIP DISCOUNT
• Part-time employees of the City of Mauldin
• Family members of full-time and part-time employees of the City of Mauldin
• Retired military and veterans and their families
LIFETIME MEMBERSHIP
• Retired employees of 20 years of creditable service to the City of Mauldin
• Elected officials of 20 years of creditable service to the City of Mauldin
7
Active (serving) Active Active
Mayor 0 Military FREE 156 Military Spouse/Dependent Memberships 3
Mauldin City Council 4 Active Active
Commission 2 Employee FREE 186 Employee Spouse/Dependent Memberships 19
Board 1
Totals 7
InActive (not serving)
Mayor 3
Council 0
Commission 0
Board 0
Totals 3
NOTE: We could have active and inactive unaccounted for on the above table chart.
Spouse and dependent of military and city of mauldin employees are eligible for 50% off their membership fee.
Active = Active Mayor, Commission, Council, and Board who has a FREE membership
Inactive = Inactive Mayor, Commission, Council, and Board who has a FREE membership
8
Minutes Excerpt from City Council Meeting December 19, 2022
St
anding Committee Items
a. Sp
orts Center Membership-
Mot
ion: Chairman Allgood made a motion to hold this item on the floor for more discussion.
Councilman Reynolds seconded the motion.
As th
e City started looking at who was being offered free or reduced memberships to the Sports
Center, it came to light that Council members need to have this benefit outlined in a
compensation ordinance. Mr. Hughes agreed that elected officials’ compensation must be
voted on by ordinance. There are no other legal issues with the rest of the recommendations.
Co
uncilman Matney asked if the benefit would be taxable. Mr. Hughes said that would be a
question for a tax attorney.
May
or Merritt said his thoughts are concerning active-duty military members and how hard it is
to determine who is active duty and for how long. He also is not in favor of lifetime
memberships to the Sports Center.
Ch
airman Allgood rescinded his motion with agreement by Councilman Reynolds.
Mot
ion: Chairman Allgood made a motion to send this item back to the Recreation Committee.
Councilman Reynolds seconded the motion.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
9
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.