minutes pw nov 2022
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Dec 12, 2022 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE MEETING
NOVEMBER 7, 2022, 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5 E. BUTLER ROAD
2nd committee meeting
Committee Members present: Jason Kraeling (Chair), Carol King, Michael Reynolds
Others present: PW Director Matthew Fleahman and Interim City Administrator Rebecca Vance
1. Call to Order- Chairman Kraeling
2. Public Comment- Submitted by email (attached)
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a. Public Works Committee Meeting: September 6, 2022
Motion: Councilwoman King made a motion to accept the minutes with Councilman Reynolds
seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
4. Reports or Communications from City Officers
a. Public Works Director Matt Fleahman
Budget Review- The departments are where they need to be. The vactor truck was delivered and
the Public Works employees love it. The boom truck was also delivered. The HVAC project
continues and several departments have had theirs replaced.
5. Unfinished Business- There is no unfinished business.
6. New Business
a. On-Call Sanitary Sewer Engineer Contract- CHA has bought Frazier Engineering. Nothing in the
City’s contract will change. All employees of Frazier will stay the same. This item needs to be
approved for a name change only.
Motion: Councilwoman King made a motion to send this item to Council with Councilman Reynolds
seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
b. Municipal State Highway Project Agreement- This action would approve and authorize the
Municipal State Highway Project Agreement for the Butler Road P030553 repaving project.
Motion: Councilwoman King made a motion to send this item to Council with Councilman Reynolds
seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
7. Public Comment- None
8. Committee Concerns- Councilman Reynolds mentioned committee could look at addressing bulk
Items so it will be clear in the ordinance and clear up any confusion.
9. Adjournment- Chairman Kraeling adjourned the meeting at 6:32 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
~ PUBLIC COMMENT ~
For
Mauldin City Public Works
C
ommittee
Meeting
Monday,
N
ovember 7, 2022
at
6
:00
PM.
11/6/22
Submit by
MJ
Seeche,
Member
-
Bent Brook
HOA
, Inc.
(non
-
profit)
, Private Investor
&
Taxpayer
.
Representing Self
.
Conformant to advisement from
Cindy Miller
-
Munic
ipal Clerk
on:
9/30/2022 8:43 AM
Will be glad to include your comments in minutes regardless of whether you can attend
the meeting or not. A PDF will be fine.
9/29/2022 8:26 AM You may submit in writing your comment for the minutes to me.
Any time would b
e fine.
9/26/2022 9:43 AM
P
ublic
comment will be included in minutes and no, there is no requirement to submit
any information regarding items beforehand.
Subject:
Clarifications
,
Errors
and
Omissions
to
Agenda
Item 6a, New Business
.
Written & presented
by
Mathew
D.
Fleahman, Public Works Director, shown in
Mauldin City
P
ublic Works
Committee
Minutes
Monday, July 6, 2020 6:00 p.m. 5th committee meeting
.
Respectfully
s
ubmitted by Cindy Miller.
Below
numbers
refer to paragraphs in Item 6a
from
July 6,20
20
P
W
minutes
, that were not originally numbered.
1.
Greg Fincher
-
PW Director
(former)
saw no reason in 2008 to remove City dumpster
, despite City no
longer offering dumpster service to commercial business. Bent Brook is non
-
profit.
To convert to
95 gallon
g
reen cans
,
MJ Seeche
{MJS}
& Mr. Fincher agreed that Bent Brook HOA would require compensation for
$950 dumpster 2005 payment as credit to can cost if P
ublic
W
orks (PW)
wishes to eliminate dumpster.
2.
Clarification:
Dumpster was removed Jan. 2014 from Be
nt Brook by City when HOA {
Bent Brook
Home
Owners Association} bought green cans at
$60 each
full price. Michael Lambert
, former PW Director,
refused to discuss credit toward can cost for dumpster removal. MJ Seeche in writing indicated to Lambert
no objec
tion to conversion to cans & only concern was partial credit for dumpster cost.
Lambert
disrespected 8/12/04 Tom Lynn
, former PW Director,
written agreement that provides dumpster to remain
at Bent Brook for resident use with City no charge trash removal o
n circle
into perpetuity
.
City trash
removal started April 2005.
Omission
:
Director Fleahman f
ail
ed
to mention reason for not
expecting
to pay
for green cans: Bent Brook paid $950 for city dumpster under 8/12/04 written agreement with Thomas
Lynn
-
former P
W Director.
MJ Seeche explained
in person
to both
Codes Enforcement
Officer Jen Ryan 6/17/20
&
PW Director
Fleahman 6/19/20
,
PW
agreement
8/12/04 & Lambert
1
2/12/13 letter. Copies were sent
by MJS
to Mathew
Fleahman
-
PW Director, Brandon Madden
-
City Admi
nistrator & Simon H. Kaye
-
Bent Brook
Association
Manager
6/17/20
11:39 PM.
Jan.
2014 Lambert gave no consideration for 2005 Bent Brook HOA Dumpster $950 payment per 8/12/04
PW
agreement. Bent Brook HOA bought
(not MJS)
8 green cans Jan.2014 & 2 more subse
quently. Lambert
12/12/13 letter to Bent Brook HOA indicates City to provide trash removal at circle, about 3
25
feet from
Miller Rd.,
when green cans bought. Trey Eubanks
-
City Administrator, approved Lambert 12/12/13 letter to
Bent Brook HOA
, despite Math
ew Fleahman 6/19/20
error
assertion that Lambert 12/12/13 letter was not
approved.
Real Estate tax paid by
19
individual deeded
unit owners
, not HOA,
covers City trash service. Not
free.
Same as single family house.
Bent Brook HOA is victim of City PW dict
ated prior agreements being
breached by PW, despite HOA good faith compliance.
Bent Brook is not apartments.
3. Error:
“residents at the Bent Brook Town Homes have been disposing of loose hypodermic needles
.”
There was never any evidence or proof linking
any Bent Brook resident to needle disposal in trash.
Director
Fleahman was not present 6/17/20 when Ms. Ryan required no notice meeting with MJS. Director Fleahman
account of conversation is hearsay
&
factually inaccurate
.
Several owners reported to MJS se
eing non
residents dumping trash in cans.
MJ Seeche was shock
ed,
dismayed
& pledged
cooperat
ion
to all aspects of
needles
in trash
& illegal dumping, when first informed
6/17/20 by Codes Enforcement Officer Jen Ryan
.
Same
at meeting
6/19/20 commit to Direc
tor Fleahman on needles & illegal dumping.
Signs were promptly
~ PUBLIC COMMENT ~
posted by MJS on medical waste & illegal dumping per Director Fleahman request. There had never been
illegal dumping prior & none since
si
g
ns posted
.
Cans were never dumped along road.
Conten
tion was
MJS
being told
on 6/17/20 by Ms. Ryan that claimed Bent Brook was not entitled to City
trash service per ordinance. MJS advised
professionally,
three former PW Directors attested to Bent Brook
right to City trash service.
July 7, 2020 letter to Be
nt Brook HOA from Director Fleahman confirmed HOA
right to City trash service.
Ms. Ryan is no longer employed by City.
Ms.
Ryan correctly cited
excluded
construction trash
{
flooring
}
placed street side for Bulk pickup.
MJ Seeche
removed items from curb da
ys ahead of deadline, as Officer Ryan confirmed June 29, 2020 3:12 PM.
Unit
104
,
T.L.H Lawson,
inherited owner,
had been warned twice prior with no fine, that City will not remove
construction trash, per ordinance. Mr. Lawson was fined by HOA & paid $50
pe
r Bent Brook HOA,
Fine
Resolution
For
Violation
of Trash Policy, notarized
April
2, 2015. Recorded
Instrument
Number:
2019083434
.
Book Type: DE Book: 2578 Page: 4515
.
Recorded Date: 10/21/2019 03:28:07 PM
Greenville
County Regist
e
r of Deeds. SC HOA Act
2018 compliant.
6/17/20
Josh Roberts
-
Sanitation Supervisor,
was present
with Ms. Ryan
. MJS had to request
t
here (3) time
that he offer business card to know his authority
.
MJS does not entertain
or consult
persons that refuse to
identify
them self
as is
indecorous & combative
.
Mr. Roberts did not participate in conversation.
4.
Omission
: No
citation.
”To empty cans, City trash truck is required to back into the property and all the way
to the backside of the parking lot, in order to retrieve cans in the d
umpster storage area. This current pick up
method is in violation of City Ordinance.
“
9.
“
Mayor Merritt asked if one
-
armed bandit would be able to get back to the dumpsters. Mr. Fleahman said it is
hit or miss whether you can pull in and turn around. If
you go in the morning, everyone is still home, and the
cars are in the parking spaces.
Error & Omission:
“
pull in and turn around
”
does require use of parking spaces. Proof is City rear load trash
truck backed in from April 2005 to July 2020 with no iss
ues. From 1990 to April 2005 front load contractor
trash truck had no access issue. From April 2022 to present contractor front load trash truck has no issue.
Some r
esidents brought cans to Miller Rd. from July 2020 to April 2022 for City trash removal
dic
tate
. HOA
was forced to
hire
private service for bagged trash removal on circle, that it can ill afford. Some owners are
too old to bring can to street, majority of owners refused to bring cans to street as Convents, Conditions &
Restrictions require HOA
to handle trash
as part of monthly HOA fee
. Board of Directors tried
for 1 year
to
hire casual labor 1 hour per week to bring can
s
to/from street. Nobody wants job.
{Review End:
Monday, July 6, 2020 6:00 p.m. Mauldin City Public Works Committee Minutes Mo
nday, July 6,
2020 6:00 p.m. 5th committee meeting.5th committee meeting
.}
========================================
11/7/22 Current
:
Mauldin City Public Works Committee
is asked for written confirmation
by11/30/22
for
Bent Brook
Bulk & Brush
ordinance
allo
wed
items placed by
street
by owners
to be City removed.
N
ot
contractors.
City approved in 2002 & never objected until 6/17/20
, then relented
.
Single family homes are
allowed to place Bulk & Br
ush
by street for City removal as usual & customary.
Examples o
f bulk items
include: major appliances, furniture, mattress, vacuum cleaner, TV & water heater. Director Fleahman has
recently asserted “all or nothing” in reference to City household trash service required to obtain street side
Bulk & Brush removal. No wr
itten, signed & approved “policy” has been forth to support what MJS considers
arbitrary
unwarranted contingency.
General trash & Bulk/Brush are not mutually exclusive.
HOA
-
non profit
sole income is member owners
that are
entitled to Bulk & Brush City ser
vice that is highly valued.
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.