Finance Committee Agenda november 2022
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Nov 3, 2022 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
FINANCE AND POLICY
COMMITTEE MEETING
MON DAY, NOVEMBER 7, 2022 | 6 PM
3rd committee meeting
The Committee will meet in Mauldin City Hall at 5 East
Butler Road in the Council Chambers at 6 p.m.
The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at
https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting-minutes-agendas/ to access the
meeting via audio and videoconferencing.
A quorum of Council will be present.
1
FINANCE AND POLICY COMMITTEE MEETING
NOVEMBER 7, 2022, 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5 E. BUTLER ROAD
C
ommittee Members: Michael Reynolds (Chair), Carol King, Diane Kuzniar
1. Call to Order
2. P
ublic Comment
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a.Finance Committee Meeting: September
6, 2022 [Pages 3-4]
4. Reports or Communications from City Officers
a. Interim City Administrator Rebecca Vance
i. Budget Review
b. Finance Director Holly Abercrombie
i. Budget Review
ii.Budget Calendar [Page 5]
c. HR Director Mark Putnam
5. Unfinished Business
There is no unfinished business.
6. New Business
a.Insurance Renewal [Pages 6-8]
7. Public Comment
8. Committee Concerns
9. Adjournment
The Honorable Michael Reynolds
The Honorable Michael Reynolds
The Honorable Michael Reynolds
T
he Honorable Michael Reynolds
T
he Honorable Michael Reynolds
T
he Honorable Michael Reynolds
T
he Honorable Michael Reynolds
The Honorable Michael Reynolds
The Honorable Michael Reynolds
2
FINANCE AND POLICY COMMITTEE MEETING
SEPTEMBER 6, 2022, 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
1st committee meeting
Committee Members present: Michael Reynolds (Chair), Carol King, Diane Kuzniar
Others present: Finance Director Holly Abercrombie, HR Director Mark Putnam and Interim City
Administrator Rebecca Vance
1. Call to Order- Chairman Reynolds
2. Public Comment- None
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a. Finance Committee Meeting: August 1, 2022
Motion: Councilwoman Kuzniar made a motion to accept the minutes with Councilwoman King
seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
4. Reports or Communications from City Officers
a. Interim City Administrator Rebecca Vance
i. Budget Review- Ms. Vance reported we have finished the second month of the fiscal year and the
budget looks good.
b. Finance Director Holly Abercrombie
i. Budget Review- Ms. Abercrombie reported revenue is still being accrued.
c. HR Director Mark Putnam- Mr. Putnam reported that the 2022 evaluation process is on track. He
will be meeting with Evergreen this week to start the comp and class study.
5. Unfinished Business- There is no unfinished business.
6. New Business- There is no new business.
7. Public Comment
a. Dr. Walt McPhail: I have a concern. People have not been contacting me about my business.
Most of you know where I am. I have been there 44 years. The building has been there 60
something years and was built by R.V. Chandler. The parking lot has not changed. You pull in, I
have 16 parking spots- 9 or 10 for clients and the rest for my 10 employees. Van Broad came to
me before COVID and said we are going to put a curb in and you are going to have two parallel
parking spots. I have been trying to talk to the City since then and we have not reached a
conclusion to date.
3
I have no one to talk to. I am concerned about my business. I have the smallest lot, but a good
business. I have third and fourth generation clients. Most of you have been in my office. I am old
but not ready to retire. I need my parking. 17 spots for my clients and my staff. I would
appreciate talking to you. Van talked to me and then he said I will get back to you. I had a lawyer
contact him but we didn’t really get anything. That is where we are. I think I have 9 spots now for
our clients. They are also going to take 4 spots off of Jenkins Court.
What I propose is if I could buy or steal a 20x60 parking spot which is at the corner of Thumbs
Laundromat and the Old Four Seasons. I would appreciate it. I have lost a lot of sleep over this. I
have tried to be quiet during negotiations and saw you were having this meeting and thought I
needed to show up.
b. Nick Netchaeff: I am the owner of Distinctive Details. I did not know if this was a Council meeting
or not. My concerns are the same as Dr. McPhail’s. I have been there 35 years and agree with the
new City plan, but I have not been contacted. We have been complaining that there is not enough
contact with the business owners. When I saw this meeting was about the landscaping of Jenkins,
I contacted the Mayor. There is a lack of contacting the businesses. This has been going on for 10
years and it is the same problem we have had. No one comes around to talk to you. It would be
great to meet this gentleman and the new administrator. I did contact the Mayor. I have been
out of the loop for a year with a very sick dad. I contacted the Mayor to catch up with the plan. I
am in agreement with it but concerned about eminent domain. I have sleepless nights because of
this happening.
8. Committee Concerns- None
9. Adjournment- Chairman Reynolds adjourned the meeting at 6:13 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
4
August -
October
Pre-Budget Items
10- year Capital Budget updated and distributed to Committee.
Capital Committee meets and ranks the fiscal years items.
Council retr
eat - to establish goals and budget objectives for staff.
March March 1-15 Council budget notebooks are pr oduced and distributed by the
finance
department.
March 16 Budget Workshop with Council and staf
f.
March 30 Budget Workshop with Council and staf
f.
February Feb 6 Budget requests due to Finance Dir ector.
Feb 7-24 Budget is reviewed and r
efined as needed.
Feb 27 Any changes are pr
ocessed and entered by Finance staff.
December -
January
Budget request forms are prepared and distributed to Department Heads.
Finance staff compiles personnel and fringe benefit numbers.
Finance staff compiles Projected Revenue numbers.
City Administrator develops and distributes the Budget Guidance document.
April April 3-7 Budget revisions ar e inputed. Budget Ad is prepared.
April 12 Budget Ad is submitted to newspaper.
April 20 Budget Workshop with Council and staf
f.
April 26 Ad is circulated in the T
ribune Times.
May May 15 Public Hearing and first reading on the pr oposed Budget
Or
dinance.
June June 19 Second reading and Adoption on the pr oposed Budget
Or
dinance.
City of MauldinCity of Mauldin
FY2024 Budget CalendarFY2024 Budget Calendar
5
FINANCE AND POLICY COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM
M
EETING DATE: 11/07/2022
AG
ENDA ITEM: 6a
TO
: Finance and Policy
FROM: Mark Putnam
SUBJECT: Medical Benefits Renewal
REQUEST: Committee to review, debate and move to Council, with approval, for Vote.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND: The City of Mauldin’s Medical Benefits are renewed every year in
the month of December.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS: Staff in conjuncture with ECM (City’s insurance broker)
competitively bid out the City’s Health, Dental and Vision coverage to obtain the most affordable
and sufficient coverage for City Employees. Attached is results of bids.
RECOMMENDATION: HR Staff recommends that the Finance and Policy approve renewal
with Anchor Benefits, Proactive MD and Ameritas (Dental/Vision) to full Council.
ATTACHMENTS: Self-funded analysis
6
The City of Mauldin
January 1, 2023
Single Enrollment 142 142
Employee Spouse 9
Employee Child 12
Family Enrollment 29 8
Total Enrollment 171 171
SELF FUNDED
Premium / Fee Structure
Nationwide
2020
Nationwide
2021
Nationwide
2022
Nationwide
AccuRisk Renewal
Nationwide
AccuRisk - Alt. 1
Nationwide
AccuRisk - Alt. 2
Annual Administration Fees $181,602 $181,602 $185,706 $185,706 $185,706 $185,706
Admin Fee PEPM $88.50 $88.50 $90.50 $90.50 $90.50 $90.50
Network MAP/PHCS MAP/PHCS MAP/PHCS MAP/PHCS BCBS BCBS
Contract Type 12/12 24/12 24/12 24/12 24/12 24/12
No New Laser/Rate Cap No/No No/No No/No No/Yes-J.O. Ded. $100K
No/Yes-J.O. Ded.
$100K
No/Yes-J.O. Ded.
$100K
Specific w/TLO 60K Agg Sp w/TLO 60K Agg Sp wo/TLO 60K Agg Sp wo/TLO 60K Agg Sp wo/TLO 60K Agg Sp wo/TLO
Deductible: $60,000 $60,000 $65,000 $65,000 $70,000 $75,000
Specific Premium: Medical and Rx Medical and Rx Medical and Rx Medical and Rx Medical and Rx Medical and Rx
Single $96.61 $94.91 $92.06 $97.95 $90.64 $84.00
E/S $213.42 $206.24 $196.77 $207.78 $190.97 $175.69
E/C $168.49 $163.42 $156.49 $165.53 $152.38 $140.42
Family $348.20 $334.70 $317.59 $334.50 $306.74 $281.50
Aggregate
Aggregate Premium: Medical and Rx Medical and Rx Medical and Rx Medical and Rx Medical and Rx Medical and Rx
Single $10.33 $9.23 $8.63 $8.93 $9.33 $9.75
E/S $10.33 $9.23 $8.63 $8.93 $9.33 $9.75
E/C $10.33 $9.23 $8.63 $8.93 $9.33 $9.75
Family $10.33 $9.23 $8.63 $8.93 $9.33 $9.75
Aggregate Factors:
Single $322.87 $371.46 $427.00 $462.12 $464.81 $467.62
E/S $742.60 $854.36 $982.09 $1,062.88 $1,069.20 $1,075.51
E/C $581.17 $668.63 $768.59 $831.82 $836.76 $841.71
Family $1,226.92 $1,411.56 $1,622.58 $1,756.07 $1,766.50 $1,776.93
Risk Corridor 125% 125% 125% 125% 125% 125%
ANNUAL COST
Nationwide
2020
Nationwide
2021
Nationwide
2022
Nationwide
AccuRisk Renewal
Nationwide
AccuRisk - Alt. 1
Nationwide
AccuRisk - Alt. 2
Administration Fees: Anchor / MAP $181,602 $181,602 $185,706 $185,706 $185,706 $185,706
Specific Premium $245,363 $239,664 $231,145 $245,295 $226,465 $209,355
Aggregate Premium $21,197 $18,940 $17,709 $18,324 $19,145 $20,007
Includes Disease Management
Additional Nurse days
Additional Laser Risk No No No $35,000 $30,000 $25,000
Total Fixed Cost $448,162 $440,206 $434,559 $449,326 $431,316 $415,068
$ Increase in Fixed Cost -$ 7,955.52 -$5,646.84 $14,766.36 -$3,243.12 -$19,491.36
Est. Reimbursement Refund
Est. Total Fixed Cost $448,162 $440,206 $434,559 $449,326 $431,316 $415,068
$ Increase Est. Fixed Cost -$ 7,955.52 -$5,646.84 $14,766.36 -3,243.12 -34,257.72
EXPECTED Claims Liability $665,475 $765,625 $880,095 $952,487 $958,070 $963,817
MAXIMUM Claims Liability $831,844 $957,031 $1,100,118 $1,190,608 $1,197,587 $1,204,771
EXPECTED Annual Total Cost $1,113,637 $1,205,831 $1,314,654 $1,401,812 $1,389,386 $1,378,885
MAXIMUM Annual Total Cost $1,280,006 $1,397,237 $1,534,678 $1,674,934 $1,658,904 $1,644,839
$ Ann. Diff. Current / Expected $92 ,194 $108,823 $87,158 $74,732 $64,231
% Ann. Diff. Current / Expected 0.0% 8.3% 9.0% 6.6% 5.7% 4.9%
$ Ann. Diff. Current / Maximum $117,232 $137,440 $140,256 $124,226 $110,161
% Ann. Diff. Current / Maximum 9. 2% 9.8% 9.1% 8.1% 7.2%
To add TLO is a 5% increase Spec Rates plus $1.50 to Agg rate to add the TLO Option
Self Funded Renewal Analysis
7
The City of Mauldin
January 1, 2023
Single Enrollment 142 142
Employee Spouse 9
Employee Child 12
Family Enrollment 29 8
Total Enrollment 171 171
SELF FUNDED
Premium / Fee Structure
Nationwide
2020
Nationwide
2021
Annual Administration Fees $181,602 $181,602
Admin Fee PEPM $88.50 $88.50
Network MAP/PHCS MAP/PHCS
Contract Type 12/12 24/12
No New Laser/Rate Cap No/No No/No
Specific w/TLO 60K Agg Sp w/TLO
Deductible: $60,000 $60,000
Specific Premium: Medical and Rx Medical and Rx
Single $96.61 $94.91
E/S $213.42 $206.24
E/C $168.49 $163.42
Family $348.20 $334.70
Aggregate
Aggregate Premium: Medical and Rx Medical and Rx
Single $10.33 $9.23
E/S $10.33 $9.23
E/C $10.33 $9.23
Family $10.33 $9.23
Aggregate Factors:
Single $322.87 $371.46
E/S $742.60 $854.36
E/C $581.17 $668.63
Family $1,226.92 $1,411.56
Risk Corridor 125% 125%
ANNUAL COST
Nationwide
2020
Nationwide
2021
Administration Fees: Anchor / MAP $181,602 $181,602
Specific Premium $245,363 $239,664
Aggregate Premium $21,197 $18,940
Includes Disease Management
Additional Nurse days
Additional Laser Risk No No
Total Fixed Cost $448,162 $440,206
$ Increase in Fixed Cost -$ 7,955.52
Est. Reimbursement Refund
Est. Total Fixed Cost $448,162 $440,206
$ Increase Est. Fixed Cost -$ 7,955.52
EXPECTED Claims Liability $665,475 $765,625
MAXIMUM Claims Liability $831,844 $957,031
EXPECTED Annual Total Cost $1,113,637 $1,205,831
MAXIMUM Annual Total Cost $1,280,006 $1,397,237
$ Ann. Diff. Current / Expected $92 ,194
% Ann. Diff. Current / Expected 0.0% 8.3%
$ Ann. Diff. Current / Maximum $117,232
% Ann. Diff. Current / Maximum 9. 2%
To add TLO is a 5% increase Spec Rates plus $1.50 to Agg rate to add the TLO Option
Self Funded Renewal Analysis
ISSI
Companion - Alt.3
ISSI
Companion - Alt. 4
ISSI
Companion - Alt. 5
$0 $194,394 $194,394
$90.50 $90.50 $90.50
MAP/PHCS MAP/PHCS MAP/PHCS
24/12 24/12 24/12
J.O. Ded / $230K
B.B. Contract 12/12
J.O. Ded.$230K
B.B. Contract 12/12
J.O. Ded.$230K
B.B. Contract 12/12
60K Agg Sp wo/TLO 60K Agg Sp wo/TLO 60K Agg Sp wo/TLO
$65,000 $70,000 $75,000
Medical and Rx Medical and Rx Medical and Rx
$81.65 $78.02 $60.89
$162.65 $155.43 $121.30
$143.95 $137.56 $107.36
$244.30 $233.45 $182.19
Medical and Rx Medical and Rx Medical and Rx
$8.06 $8.32 $8.72
$8.06 $8.32 $8.72
$8.06 $8.32 $8.72
$8.06 $8.32 $8.72
$489.57 $496.90 $502.46
$975.22 $989.82 $1,000.89
$863.11 $876.04 $885.83
$1,464.79 $1,486.72 $1,503.35
125% 125% 125%
ISSI
Companion - Alt.3
ISSI
Companion - Alt. 4
ISSI
Companion - Alt. 5
$0 $194,394 $194,394
$200,879 $191,952 $149,807
$16,539 $17,073 $17,893
$165,000 $165,000 No
$217,419 $403,419 $362,094
-$217,140.84 -$31,140.36 -$72,464.88
$217,419 $403,419 $362,094
-$213,897.72 -31,140.36 -72,464.88
$1,095,567 $977,994 $988,935
$1,369,459 $1,222,493 $1,236,169
$1,312,985 $1,381,413 $1,351,030
$1,586,877 $1,625,912 $1,598,264
($1,669) $66,759 $36,376
-0.1% 5.1% 2.8%
$52,200 $91,234 $63,586
3.4% 5.9% 4.1%
8
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.