RecordWell Data

building codes agenda_2022-10-03

City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Sep 29, 2022 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Mauldin

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE MEETING MONDAY , OCTOBER 3 , 202 2 | 6 PM 1st committee meeting Please note that members of the public may attend this meeting in-person but are encouraged to participate remotely. The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting- minutes-agendas/ to access the meeting via audio and videoconferencing. The Committee will meet in the Mauldin City Hall at 5 East Butler Road in the Council Chambers at 6 p.m. Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 2 Build ing Cod e s (BDS) Com mitte e AGENDA October 3 , 2022 C ommi ttee Members: Diane K uzniar (Chair) , T af t Matney, Frank Allg o o d 1. Call to Ord e r T he H onorabl e Di ane K uzniar 2. Pub lic Comment T he H onorabl e Di ane K uzniar 3. R eadi ng and A pproval of Mi nutes a. Build ing Co d e s Commi ttee M eeti ng: S eptember 6 , 2022 (Pages 3 -8) Th e Ho no rab le Diane K uzniar 4. R eports or Communications from City Officers a. BDS Dire cto r David Dyrhaug T he H onorabl e Di ane K uzniar 5. Unfinished B usiness None T he H onorabl e Di ane K uzniar 6. New Business a. An ordinance to rezone property consisting of ap p ro xim ate ly 94 acres located at 500 West Butler Ro a d (tax map parcel: #M008.02 -01- 002 .00) and p ro vid ing an e ffe ctive d ate (Pages 9 -25) b. An amendment to the Mauldin zoning ordinance e stab lishing d e finitio ns, stand ard s, and p ro hib itio ns fo r d rive-thru facilitie s (Pages 2 6-32) T he H onorabl e Di ane K uzniar 7. Pub lic Comment T he H onorabl e Di ane K uzniar 8. Commi ttee Concerns T he H onorabl e Di ane K uzniar 9. Ad journ T he H onorabl e Di ane K uzniar Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 3 Minutes Build ing Co d e s (BDS) Co m m itte e S eptember 6 , 2022 4th Commi ttee M eeti ng Committee Members present: Diane Kuzniar (Chair) and Frank Allgood. Councilman Taft Matney was not present at convening, but did attend via Zoom towards the middle of the meeting. Others present: David Dyrhaug, Building and Development Services Director and Rebecca Vance, Interim City Administrator 1. Call to Order- Chairwoman Kuzniar 2. Public Comment- None 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes- August 1, 2022 Motion: Councilman Allgood made a motion to approve the minutes with Chairwoman Kuzniar seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (2-0). 4. Reports and Communications from City Officers a. BDS Director David Dyrhaug- Mr. Dyrhaug reported his department is at 84% of a 83% ideal remaining budget percentage. A record number of building inspections came through last month at 1752. The number of permits for new homes decreased, but then came back up last month. 23 business licenses were issued last month. 5. Unfinished Business- There is no Unfinished Business 6. New Business a. An ordinance to rezone property consisting of approximately 5.8 acres located at 25 Old Mill Road (tax map parcel: #M008.04-01-002.03) and providing an effective date This petition includes approximately 5.8 acres located at 25 Old Mill Road. The applicant has requested that this tract be rezoned from I-1, Industrial, to S-1, Trades & Commercial Services. The applicant would like the flexibility to consider developing the remainder of the property for the additional uses allowed in the S-1 zoning district. Motion: Councilman Allgood made a motion to send this item to Council with Chairwoman Kuzniar seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (2-0). b. Annexation and Establishment of Tanner Road Planned Development Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 4 1. An ordinance to provide for the annexation of property owned by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, and located at 30 Tanner Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-01-043.01) by one hundred percent petition and to establish a zoning classification of PD, Planned Development for said property; 2. An ordinance to provide for the annexation of property owned by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, and located at 30 Tanner Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-01-043.02) by one hundred percent petition and to establish a zoning classification of PD, Planned Development for said property; 3. An ordinance to provide for the annexation of property owned by C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue, and located at 50 Tanner Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-01-043.00) by one hundred percent petition method; and to establish a zoning classification of PD, Planned Development for said property These petitions include approximately 13 acres owned by Lynn Farmer and Elaine Ayscue located at 50 Tanner Road, and approximately 7.6 acres owned by Earl Jones and Nancy Jones located at 30 Tanner Road. The applicant has requested that these tracts be zoned PD, Planned Development upon annexation into the City of Mauldin. Flournoy Development Group is planning to develop a planned development. A traffic impact study has been completed for the proposed development project. This study was performed by Allen J. Reid with Impact Designs, Inc. SCDOT is talking with the applicant on intersection improvements. Chairwoman Kuzniar asked if the improvements would be done before or after the development is finished. Mr. Dyrhaug said typically they are done before the development begins. David Graffius was present from Gray Engineering. As of last week, the DOT will further study the intersections and they are amenable to an additional green arrow from Verdin to Butler and additional turn lanes to Woodruff Road. Councilman Allgood asked about stormwater runoff and if there was any potential encroachment onto neighboring properties. Mr. Graffius said there would be a retention pond to hold stormwater from rain events. Councilman Allgood then asked if the pond could be half underground and half above ground. Mr. Graffius said it would not be as effective if constructed that way. This will be a dry retention pond. Councilman Allgood asked when the traffic questions will be answered so that Council will have all the information to make a decision. Mr. Graffius said he was not sure, it could be a couple of weeks. Chairwoman Kuzniar asked if the retention pond would be screened. Mr. Graffius said there are trees on the western side that will be kept at the property. There will also be a line of evergreen trees planted near the pond. Chairwoman Kuzniar asked if the residents would find the retention pond unappealing. Mr. Graffius said the residents would be looking at the green buffer instead of the low-lying areas where the pond is located. Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 5 Chairwoman Kuzniar asked about the conversion of workspaces to apartments. Mr. Dyrhaug said the statement of intent has been revised and if it needs to be converted, it will come back as a change to Council. Chairwoman Kuzniar said her concern is this will be all residential, without some nice retail. Mr. Dyrhaug said there could be businesses like boutiques, hair salons, coffee shops, etc. Small space retail, not like a full restaurant. Motion: Councilman Allgood made a motion to send this item to Council with Chairwoman Kuzniar seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (2-0). c. An amendment to Chapter 18, Article II (Nuisances) of the Mauldin Code of Ordinances to authorize the codes enforcement official rather than the building and zoning director to enforce certain provisions contained herein and for other matters related thereto This ordinance, reviewed by the City Attorney, replaces the Building and Zoning Director with the Code Enforcement Official as the staff person responsible for the enforcement of the City’s nuisance standards. Motion: Councilman Allgood made a motion to send this item to Council with Chairwoman Kuzniar seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (2-0). d. An amendment to Chapter 18, Article II (Nuisances) of the Mauldin Code of Ordinances to establish certain standards to protect against nuisances caused by light trespass and for other matters related City staff recently had the opportunity to meet with Duke Energy officials to discuss the provisions being considered by the City of Mauldin. These officials commented that light glare very difficult to define and enforce. Their experience is that what is perceived as glare is different from case to case. They advised it is much easier to define, measure, and enforce light trespass as measured in foot-candles. They also expressed that the height restrictions that the City was considering for lights was not consistent with their practice. The light poles that they typically install have a height of about 25 feet above the ground, not including pedestrian lights which generally are shorter. They also advised that restricting light pole height may have little effect if adjacent properties have different grade elevations. These officials also explained the procedures the follow when installing light poles and reviewing subsequent complaints. A property owner who requests the installation of a Duke light pole is required to sign a contract with Duke Energy. Included in the contract is a provision that the customer agrees to abide by local ordinances. When Duke Energy receives complaints about lights, they generally direct the complainant to talk directly to the property owner of the offending light. They do this to avoid getting in the middle of neighbor disputes. The property owner is able to request that Duke Energy make adjustments to the light to mitigate the concerns from a neighbor. Depending on the nature of the concern, Duke Energy Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 6 is able to shield the light, lower the light on the pole, change out the color of the light, among other solutions. Duke Energy indicated that they generally respond in about 3-5 days, although on occasion they may be delayed due to extenuating circumstances. Councilman Allgood said there is a part in the narration that says the police department may need to hire additional staff and buy light meters. Councilman Allgood said he doesn’t believe we will need to do that and asked Mr. Dyrhaug if he agreed. Mr. Dyrhaug said he agrees with Councilman Allgood that this is not going to be something that will be needed. The City should not receive a large number of light complaints. Councilman Allgood said this is a much better ordinance than what was considered at an earlier meeting. His previous concern was defining a radius, and this defines foot-candles. It addresses his concern. Motion: Councilman Allgood made a motion to send this item to Council with Chairwoman Kuzniar seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (2-0). e. Drive-through facilities in the Central Redevelopment District Presently, the City of Mauldin has general standards that require a minimum amount of distance for vehicles that queue or stack in drive-thru lanes depending on the type of business (e.g., bank, ATM, restaurant, car wash, etc.). There are no other restrictions on drive-thru facilities in the Central Redevelopment District. Staff has researched what neighboring communities have as standards. This is presented for discussion. Chairwoman Kuzniar said other communities have downtowns and that may be why they don’t have any restrictions. The City needs to decide if they want to have further drive-throughs and could restrict future development. Ms. Vance said drive-throughs could be a conditional use. Councilman Allgood said he got stuck in drive-through traffic this weekend and he understands why there would need to be restrictions. Mr. Dyrhaug said his opinion is if the City is trying to create a pedestrian environment, drive-throughs have no place. Chairwoman Kuzniar said there are plenty of places in the City that could still have drive-throughs, but for the CRD there should be a restriction. She would like to keep the City’s goal in mind. Chairwoman Kuzniar would like this item to go to Council for discussion. Councilman Matney joined at this time via Zoom. Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to send this item to Council for input with Councilman Allgood seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 7 f. Electric vehicle charging stations Staff was asked to look at this issue. Electric vehicle charging stations generally fall into one of three categories, designated as level 1, 2, and 3. Level 1 chargers are 120 volts and generally use a standard outlet. Level 2 chargers are 240 volts and generally consist of a charging head and cord hard-wired to the circuit. Level 3 chargers are more than 240 volts and are much more complex. Some charging stations may also identify as level 4 which are relatively new to the industry and represent the high end of electric vehicle charging. Chairwoman Kuzniar said this is an important issue and we will need charging stations eventually. She said Council could hold a workshop to discuss this topic. Councilman Matney said he would like to hear from the electric companies. Would our grid handle something like this? If there is a workshop, he would like them to provide information. Motion: Councilman Allgood made a motion to send this item to a Council workshop for further information with Councilman Matney seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). g. Board of Appeals membership Out of seven seats designated by Mauldin ordinance, there are currently only three active members serving on the Board of Appeals. This includes one current member who has filed an application to be considered for appointment to the Planning Commission. Currently the Board does not have enough members to even meet and take action on an appeal, variance, or special exception. The City has received no applications from citizens interested in the Board of Appeals so far this year. State law (section 6-29-780) prescribes that the City may create a board between 3 and 9 members. The members should serve for overlapping terms between 3 and 5 years. This is on the agenda to find out if there is any interest in reducing the number of seats on the ZBOA. Chairwoman Kuzniar said she would not have a problem with five members, but thinks three members is too few. Councilman Matney said the board is so important. It is a quasi-judicial board and their decision is final. He understands it is difficult to maintain a constant majority of seven. Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to direct staff to draft an ordinance reducing the number of seats of the Zoning Board of Appeals to five members with Councilman Allgood seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). 7. Public Comment- Jason Kraeling: 234 Devon Drive. You can rent light meters. I don’t think we will have a huge use for them, but they are expensive. You can rent them for a couple hundred bucks versus $15,000-20,000. I just wanted to say that before I forgot. Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 8 8. Committee Concerns- None 9. Adjournment: Chairwoman Kuzniar adjourned the meeting at 8:23 p.m. Respectfully Submitted, Cindy Miller Municipal Clerk Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 9 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: October 3, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6a TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Rezoning at 500 W. Butler Road REQUEST The City of Mauldin has received a signed petition requesting the rezoning of a tract of land pursuant to Section 4:2 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance. This petition includes approximately 94 acres located at 500 W. Butler Road. The applicant has requested that this tract be rezoned from R-20, Low-Density Residential, to a split zoning of R-M, Multi-Family Residential, and R-15, Low-Density Residential. The applicant is planning to develop a combination of apartments, townhomes, and detached single-family homes. The split between the two requested zoning districts will run along a stream that runs diagonally across the property from the northwest corner of the property to the southeast corner of the property. Approximately 41 acres have been requested to be rezoned to the R -M district and approximately 53 acres have been requested to be rezoned to the R-15 district. HISTORY/BACKGROUND This tract is currently occupied by a residence and cows. This tract backs up to a number of residential communities including Laurel Meadows, Knollwood Heights, Sunset Heights, Woodcreek, Ashmore Bridge Estates, and Daniel Court Homes. Additionally, the prope rty is adjacent to and faces commercial properties along W. Butler Road. OWNER(S): Billie Gene Schwiers Ltd. Partn. AUTHORIZED REP(S): Darren Webb  Mark III Properties, LLC Paul Harrison  Bluewater Civil Design, LLC TAX MAP NUMBER(S): #M008.02-01-002.00 LOCATION: 500 W. Butler Rd. CURRENT ZONING: R-20, Low-Density Residential REQUESTED ZONING: R-M, Multi-Family Residential & R-15, Low-Density Residential SIZE OF PROPERTY: Approx. 94 acres Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 10 PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT At the neighborhood meeting, the applicant presented a conceptual plan that depicts the following: • 297 apartment units along the western edge of the property adjacent to Taylor Road • 133 townhomes throughout the center/front of the property • 128 detached single-family homes throughout the back half of the property and along the eastern edge of the property In total, this entails 558 residences for the c onceptual development project that was presented at the neighborhood meeting. Access. Access to this proposed development project has been initially depicted as two entries along W. Butler Road and a single entry along Taylor Road. Taylor Road is not si gnalized at its intersection with Butler Road and neither conceptual entries along Butler Road are expected to be signalized. Buffering. The developer has not provided detailed information about buffering adjacent to existing communities but the conceptual drawing appears to depict minimal buffers adjacent to most of the existing communities except for at the rear adjacent to the Knollwood Heights community. About Mark III Properties Mark III Properties is a local residential development company. They have developed a few recent subdivisions in the City of Mauldin including: Highland Chase on E. Standing Springs Road, Butler Townes on E. Butler Road, Arden Woods on Ashmore Bridge Road, Camden Cottages on Standing Springs Road, and Meadow Springs on Standing Springs Road. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING In accordance with Section 4:3.3 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance, the applicant held a neighborhood meeting on August 18, 2022. Based on the sign- in sheet, it appears that approximately 50 neighbors attended the meeting from several of the surrounding communities. According to the meeting summary provided by the applicant, questions and concerns covered topics including: traffic, needed road improvements, deficiencies of Taylor Road, landscaping, stream buffers, wetlands, stormwater runoff and sedimentation, topography and grading, home sizes and price points, estimated population of the proposed community, wildlife protection, opposition to apartments, property setbacks, buffering and fencing, number of units, desi re for retail along W. Butler Road, and community entrances. Attached is the applicant’s summary of the neighborhood meeting. PUBLIC HEARING The Planning Commission held a public hearing on September 27, 2022. The following citizens spoke at the public hearing. • Lillian Fournier, 302 Daniel Court, expressed concerns about traffic, school overcrowding, and stated that she does not wish to see the property change. • Pam Nugent, 107 McSwain Drive, expressed concerns about traffic, school overcrowding, and asked about the buffering that would be provided. Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 11 • Diana Kuzniar, 503 Knollwood Drive, read a letter submitted by Anne Dawes of 202 Bel Arbor Lane. Ms. Dawes shared concerns about inadequate infrastructure, commute times, school overcrowding, and emergency care. • Pam Childers, 600 Laurel Meadows Parkway, expressed concerns about infrastructure, including streets, traffic, school overcrowding, and asked about the size of the homes. • Robert Clary, 131 Wood Creek Court, asked if a traffic study had been completed yet and stated that a traffic study should be reviewed before the property is rezoned. • Dwayne Goodwin, 500 Taylor Road, expressed concerns about the difficulty of making left -turns onto West Butler Road as well as the substandard conditions of Taylor Road. He also commented that has not heard nor seen any revisions to the plan for developing this property after the applicant received plentiful input at the neighborhood meeting. • Mary Bennett, 519 Waterbrook Drive, asked when the Planning Commission would vote on this matter and also asked if the members of the Planning Commission lived near this property. • Amy Goodwin, 500 Taylor Road, expressed concerns about trash compactors potentially be located next to Taylor Road. She also expressed concerns about voting on this rezoning before the traffic has been studied as well as about the effect of traffic on emergency response times. • Renee Eron, 926 Goldendale Court, expressed concerns about the loss of green space, changes to Taylor Road, traffic, and how City services would be impacted by a large number of homes. • Manuel Curcio, 109 Muirwood Drive, expressed concerns traffic, pedestrian safety, stormwater runoff, environmental impacts, and how the property would be landscaped. • Lisa Foley, 116 M uirwood Drive, expressed concerns stormwater runoff, loss of habitat for wildlife, and also how the development would affect the pond on her property. • Patty Harris, 700 Laurel Meadows Parkway, expressed concerns about the size of this development project, access (especially at Taylor Road), and reminded the Planning Commission that there is another townhome project in the works next to this property. • Bill Snyder, 116 Muirwood Drive, asked that if this rezoning is approved that the developer leave trees and don’t fill up the pond on his property with mud. ZONING ANALYSIS AND STANDARDS Existing Zoning Classification The R-20 zoning designation is a low -density residential district that primarily allows detached single - family residences. Customary recreational, religious, and educational facilities may also be allowed in this district. The standards in this district are intended to protect the residential character of the district and promote single-family living. Proposed R-M Zoning Classification The R -M zoning designation is a multi -family residential district intended to provide a full range of medium- to high-density multi-family housing types in addition to detached and attached single -family homes recreational, religious, and educational facilities. This district is intended to provide a transition between single-family districts and commercial districts. Development standards associated with the R-M zoning district include: • Maximum density: 16 units per acre • Maximum building height: 45 feet • Minimum perimeter setbacks: 25 feet Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 12 • Buffer required next to adjacent communities: none required by ordinance • Minimum open space: 15 percent of development area • Minimum parking: 1.5 parking spaces per multi-family dwelling unit; 2 parking spaces per single- family dwelling unit Presently, the number of acres that are proposed to be rezoned to the R-M district is approximately 41 acres. The R-M district would allow up to 656 apartments on this section of the property. Proposed R-15 Zoning Classification The R -15 zoning designation is a low -density residential district comparable to the R -20 district. The primary difference between the R-15 and the R-20 district is that the R-15 district allows a relatively higher density. The R-15 district generally allows 2.9 units per acre while the R-20 allows 2.2 units per acre. Development standards associated with the R-15 zoning district include: • Maximum density: 2.9 units per acre • Maximum building height: 30 feet • Minimum perimeter setbacks: 25 feet • Buffers required next to adjacent communities: None required by ordinance • Minimum open space: 30 percent of development area Presently, the number of acres that are proposed to be rezoned to the R -15 district is approximately 53 acres. The R-15 district would allow up to 153 homes on this section of the property. Surrounding Development/Zoning These properties are surrounded by the following zoning and land uses: Direction Zoning District(s) Existing Use(s) North R-15 (City) Knollwood Heights community South C-1 (City) Various commercial properties East C-2 (City) R-M (City) R-12 (City) R-20 (City) Dollar General Daniel Ct. Homes & Ashmore Br. Estates Apts. Woodcreek community Sunset Heights community West C-2 (City) PD (City) R-20 (City) Pending rezoning to R-M district for townhomes Laurel Heights community Large estate residences Comprehensive Plan Analysis This property is split among three different designations on the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. The front portion of the property is designated as a “regional corridor.” This is envisioned to include commercial uses such retail, restaurants, shopping centers, etc. The middle portion of the property is designated as “multifamily residential” which is intended to include apartments, townhomes, and duplexes. The back half of the property is designated as “low-density residential” which is intended to include single family homes on lots that typically ¼-acre or larger. Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 13 REVIEW CRITERIA The Mauldin Zoning Ordinance does not contain any specified criteria that should be considered by the Planning Commission when reviewing requests for rezoning. However, the following criteria are typical of those used by other jurisdictions. A. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed since the Comprehensive Plan was adopted, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; B. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed in the proposed zoning district; C. Compatibility of all the potential uses allowed in the proposed zoning district with surrounding uses and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density, nature of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning, and potential influence on property values; D. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate all potential uses allowed in the proposed district without compromising public health, safety or welfare; and E. Public need for the potential uses permitted in the requested zoning district. STAFF FINDINGS The analysis below includes staff findings pertaining to each criterion. CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 1. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; This property is split among three designations in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. This includes “regional corridor,” “multifamily residential,” and “low -density resident ial.” In the comprehensive plan these designations are layered with commercial and multifamily on the front part of the property with single -family residential on the back half of the property. The way that the rezoning has been proposed, the property is split diagonally instead of being layered. The front and west portion of the property is proposed as multifamily residential while the back and east portion of the property is proposed as single-family residential. There is no commercial area included in the proposed rezoning of this property. The general character of the area includes commercial along W. Butler Road, apartment and duplexes along a portion of the east boundary, and single -family residential surrounding the remainder of the property including the rear and the west boundary. It is staff’s opinion that the omission of any commercial area is not consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. Additionally, the design of the rezoning is not layered in a consistent manner as shown in the Comprehensive Plan. And the design of the rezoning does not necessarily match the character of adjacent communities. The rezoning is proposed such that apartments would be located adjacent to single-family residential to the west. And single -family homes would be located adjacent to apartments and commercial to the east. Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 14 CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 2. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed It appears that there are some hydrological features on the site including streams and potentially some wetlands. No wetlands delineation has been received yet to demonstrate if any wetlands exist. There also appear to be some steep topography in various sections of the property, particularly in proximity to some of the streams on the property. These features will certainly affect the design of the development. Staff is unable to say if the intensity of the uses allowed by the proposed zoning would negatively impact these environmenta l features. 3. Compatibility of the potential uses allowed with surrounding uses and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density, nature of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent pro perties under existing zoning, and potential influence on property values While the types of uses proposed for the property— including apartments, townhomes, and single -family homes —currently surround the property, the design of the rezoning does not match up to where these uses currently exist. While the single -family residential zoning located along the rear of the property appears to be compatible with the adjacent community, the multi- family residential zoning along the west of the property does not appear to be compatible to the adjacent community and the multi -family residential zoning along the front of the property is not consistent with the predominantly commercial nature of W. Butler Road. 4. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate potential uses allowed without compromising public health, safety, or welfare Staff is not aware of any utilities, including water and sewer, that would not be available at this tract. There are currently two ReWa sewer lines that run through this property. A traffic impact study has not yet been performed for the prospective development of this property, but one will be required. Taylor Road, which borders this property, currently ranges in width between 12 and 18 feet. Due to its substandard conditions, Taylor Road is insufficient to accommodate traffic and provide access to the prospective development of this property. About 25,000 to 30,000 vehicles travel on this section of W. Butler Road each day. There are legitimate concerns that it will be very difficult to turn left out of this property during peak hours. The prospects of a traffic signal being provided at this property are very low. Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 15 CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 5. Public need for the potential uses permitted The Comprehensive Plan forecasts tha t an aging population, shrinking household sizes, and affordability will continue to increase the demand for smaller, low -maintenance housing. The current conceptual development proposal would provide additional living options that support this forecast i n the Comprehensive Plan. Additionally, this rezoning also helps to meet the high demand for housing around this area. However, the Comprehensive Plan also has a stated goal to ensure an adequate supply of non-residential land to support future economic development. The front portion of this property could be an opportunity to expand commercial development in the City. TIMELINE On August 18, 2022, the applicant met with interested neighbors to review their proposal and to seek questions and comments. On August 23, 2022, staff received the request to rezone this tract. On September 27, 2022, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing. At this meeting, the Planning Commission voted 4-0 to recommend denial of the rezoning. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Due to the inconsistencies with the comprehensive plan, mismatches with adjacent land uses, and concerns about traffic and roads, staff does not support the rezoning as currently submitted. PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION On September 27, 2022, the Planning Commission voted 4-0 to recommend denial of the rezoning. ATTACHMENTS Proposed ordinance (maps included therein) Neighborhood meeting information Conceptual drawing(s) Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 16 ORDINANCE # __________ AN ORDINANCE TO REZONE PROPERTY CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY 94 ACRES LOCATED AT 500 WEST BUTLER ROAD (TAX MAP PARCEL: #M008.02- 01-002.00) AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE WHEREAS, Billie Gene Schwiers Ltd. Partn., has petitioned the City of Mauldin to rezone +/- 94 acres from the R -20, Low -Density Residential District, to a split zoning of the R -M, Multi -family Residential District, and the R-15, Low-Density Residential District; and WHEREAS, a rezoning of the parcel is in keeping with the City of Mauldin 2014 Comprehensive Plan Update; and WHEREAS, the site is suitable for the types of uses that could be developed under the new zoning district; and WHEREAS, the potential uses permitted in the new zoning district meet a public need and are not detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare; and WHEREAS, the Mauldin Planning Commission has given favorable recommendation to the zoning application; and NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof Section 1. That the property described in zoning docket PC-2022-13-RZ and Greenville County Tax Map Parcel M008.02-01-002.00 be rezoned from R-20 to a split zoning of R -M, Multi-family Residential, and R-15, Low-Density Residential. The property is fu rther identified on the attached exhibit that is hereby incorporated into this ordinance, including Exhibit 1, Zoning & Property Map. Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage. Passed on First Reading ________________________________ Passed on Second Reading ______________________________ CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA ATTEST: BY: ________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ___________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ John Duggan, City Attorney Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 17 EXHIBIT 1 Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 18 Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 19 Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 20 Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 21 Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 22 Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 23 Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 24 Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 25 Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 26 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: October 3, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6b TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Drive-thru Standards BACKGROUND Staff has been asked to review and consider updated drive-thru standards, including standards in the Central Redevelopment District. At its meeting on September 19, 2022, City Council members provided input on the type of standards of interest, particularly in the Central Redevelopment District. CURRENT MAULDIN STANDARDS Presently, the City of Mauldin has general standards that require a minimum amount of distance for vehicles that queue or stack in drive-thru lanes depending on the type of business (e.g., bank, ATM, restaurant, car wash, etc.). There are no other restrictions on drive-thru facilities in the Central Redevelopment District. DRAFT ORDINANCE Based on the input received at the September 19, 2022, City Council meeting, staff has drafted an ordinance that (1) defines drive -thru facilities, (2) prohibits new drive -thru facilities in the Central Redevelopment District, and (3) updates the general standards for drive-thru facilities in other parts of the City. Definition The definition for drive -thru facilities in the draft ordinance is: “The portion of an establishment where goods or services are provided to patrons who remain in motor vehicles. Such facilities are typically distinguished by parking spaces or driveways where patrons may remain i nside vehicles while placing or receiving orders at service windows, intercom devices or other electronic devices. These facilities comprise all driveways, queuing lanes and spaces, drive-in parking spaces, ordering stations, menu boards, services windows, intercom devices, and other appurtenances involved with the provision of goods and services to patrons in motor vehicles.” Central Redevelopment District (CRD) The draft ordinance would prohibit new drive -thru facilities in the Central Redevelopment Di strict. Existing drive -thru facilities in this district may remain but could not be expanded or enlarged. Additionally, existing drive-thru facilities would not be allowed vehicular access to new streets constructed within this district provided that the facility is still accessible via existing streets. Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 27 General Standards The draft ordinance updates the general standards for drive-thru facilities as follows: 1. The number of queuing spaces required for restaurant drive -thru facilities has been updated to require 3 spaces at the first service window and 2 spaces at each subsequent service window, in addition to the 4 spaces required at the ordering station. 2. The number of queuing spaces required for automatic car washes has been reduced from 6 to 4 spaces at the car wash entrance. 3. The number of queuing spaces required for self -service car washes has been reduced from 3 to 2 spaces at each bay or stall. 4. Where pedestrian pathways or routes cross a drive-thru lane, the pedestrian pathway or route must be raised and made prominent, such as through material changes, to ensure pedestrian visibility and safety. 5. If a drive-thru facility is covered, the roof over the drive-thru area must have the same architectural design and materials as the principal structure on site. 6. No appurtenance to the drive -thru facility, including, but not limited to, queuing lanes, drive -in parking spaces, service windows, ordering stations, menu boards, or similar appurtenances, shall be located between the front of the principal structure and the adjacent street right-of-way. For the full text of the draft ordinance, please see the attachment. REQUEST This draft ordinance is being presented for discussion and input. If the Committee is ready, this ordinance can be referred to the Planning Commission to review. ATTACHMENTS Draft ordinance Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 28 ORDINANCE # __________ AN AMENDMENT TO THE MAULDIN ZONING ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING DEFINITIONS, STANDARDS, AND PROHIBITIONS FOR DRIVE-THRU FACILITIES. WHEREAS, the Mauldin Comprehensive Plan establishes “City Center” areas that promote pedestrian-oriented development; and WHEREAS, the purpose and intent of the Central Redevelopment District is to encourage the redevelopment of the central area of the City in a manner that promotes pedestrian activity and safety; and WHEREAS, drive -thru facilities prioritize vehicular orientation over pedestrian orientation; and WHEREAS, this Ordinance is intended to minimize drive -thru facilities in areas where pedestrian orientation is integral to the character of the district; and WHEREAS, this Ordinance is intended to provide standards that will promote pedestrian safety in areas where drive-thru facilities may be appropriate; and WHEREAS, the City is engaged in ongoing efforts to update and refine the City’s master plan and zoning regulations; and WHEREAS, pursuant to properly published public notice, the Mauldin Planning Commission considered this matter at a public hearing on October 25, 2022. NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof that the Mauldin Municipal Code be amended as follows: Section 1 Amendment. Amend Section 3:3, Definitions, of Article 3, as follows ( language that is struck through is language proposed to be deleted, underlined language is language proposed to be added, language is not struck through or underlined is not to be changed, and *** represents sections of the Zoning Ordinance that have been skipped and remain unchanged): ARTICLE 3. – ZONING DISTRICTS, GENERAL STANDARDS, DEFINITIONS *** Sec. 3:3 – Definitions *** Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 29 Drive-thru facility. The portion of an establishment where goods or services are provided to patrons who remain in motor vehicles. Such facilities are typically distinguished by parking spaces or driveways where patrons may remain inside vehicles while placing or receiving orders at service windows, intercom devices or other electronic devices. These facilities comprise all driveways, queuing lanes and spaces, drive-in parking spaces, ordering stations, menu boards, service windows, intercom devices, and other appurtenances involved with the provision of goods and services to patrons in motor vehicles. *** Section 2 Amendment. Amend Section 5:6, CRD, Central Redevelopment District, of Article 5, as follows ( language that is struck through is language proposed to be delete d, underlined language is language proposed to be added, language is not struck through or underlined is not to be changed, and *** represents sections of the Zoning Ordinance that have been skipped and remain unchanged): ARTICLE 5. – ZONING DISTRICT REGULATIONS *** Sec. 5:6 – CRD, Central Redevelopment District. *** 5:6.16 Drive-thru Facilities. Drive-thru facilities shall be strictly prohibited within this district. Existing drive -thru facilities may remain but shall not be expanded or enlarged. Additionally, existing drive - thru facilities shall not be allowed vehicular access to new streets constructed within this district where the facility will still be accessible via existing streets. *** 5:6:1617 Architectural Design. *** Section 3 Amendment. Amend Section 6:1.1.5, Vehicle Queuing and Stacking Spaces, of Article 6, as follows ( language that is struck through is language proposed to be deleted, underlined language is language proposed to be added, language is not struck through or underlined is not to be changed, and *** represents sections of the Zoning Ordinance that have been skipped and remain unchanged): ARTICLE 6. – DEVELOPMENT AND DESIGN STANDARDS Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 30 *** Sec. 6:1 – Off-Street Parking Requirements. *** 6:1.1.5 Vehicle Queuing and Stacking Spaces The vehicle queuing and stacking standards of this section shall apply unless otherwise expressly approved by the Director. A. Minimum number of spaces. Off- street queuing spaces shall be provided as follows: Table 6:1.1.5(A): Vehicle Queuing Areas for Drive-thru Facilities Activity Type Minimum Queuing Spaces Measured From Bank teller lane, Pharmacy drive- thru 4 Teller or window Pharmacy drive-thru 4 Window Automated teller machine (ATM) 3 Teller machine Restaurant drive-through 4 Order box Restaurant drive-thru 4 spaces to each ordering station; and 3 spaces to the first service window; and 2 spaces between each service window Car wash stall, automatic 6 4 Entrance Car wash stall, self-service 3 2 Entrance Bay or stall Gasoline service stations 4 To pump Other uses As determined by Director as needed Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 31 B. Design and layout. Required queuing spaces are subject to the following design and layout standards: 1. Size. Queuing spaces shall be a minimum of eight (8) feet by twenty (20) feet in size. 2. Location Traffic circulation. Queuing spaces may not impede on- site or off- site traffic movements or movements into or out of off-street parking spaces. 3. Driveway design. Queuing spaces shall be separated from other internal driveways by raised medians if deemed necessary by the Director for traffic movement and safety. 4. Pedestrian design. Where pedestrian pathways or routes cross a drive-thru lane, the pedestrian pathway or route shall be raised and made prominent, such as through material changes, to ensure pedestrian visibility and safety. 5. Architectural design. If covered, the roof over a drive -thru area shall have the same architectural design and materials as the principal structure on site. 6. On-site location. No appurtenance to the drive-thru facility, including, but not limited to, queuing lanes, drive -in parking spa ces, service windows, ordering stations, menu boards, or similar appurtenances, shall be located between the front of the principal structure and the adjacent street right-of-way. Build ing Co d e s Co m m itte e Me e ting • • • 32 Section 4. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage. Passed on First Reading: _______________________________ Passed on Second Reading ______________________________ CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA BY: ________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ATTEST: ___________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ John Duggan, City Attorney

Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.