CITY COUNCIL meeting agenda september 19 2022
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Sep 19, 2022 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 19, 2022 | 7:00 PM
City Council meeting in the Mauldin City Hall Council
Chambers, 5 East Butler Road
Please note that members of the public are encouraged to participate remotely through Zoom.
Please visit the City’s website at https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting-minutes-
agendas/ to access the meeting via audio and videoconferencing.
1
CITY OF M
AULDIN
COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA
SEPTEMBER 19 , 2022
7:00 P.M.
CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 5 E. BUTLER
ROAD
1. Call to Order
a. Welcome
b. Invocation
c. Pledge of Allegiance
Mayor Merritt
2. Proclamations and Presentations
a. Constitution Week proclamation [Page 5]
b
. Hispanic Month proclamation [Page 6
Mayor Merritt
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a. City Council Meeting –August 15, 2022 [Pages 7-10 ]
b. Special Called Meeting- August 26, 2022 [Page 11]
c. Special Called Meeting-September 2, 2022 [Pages 12-13]
d. Special Called Meeting September 14, 2022 [Page 14 ]
Mayor Merritt
4. Public Comment Mayor Merritt
5. Report from City Administrator Interim City Administrator
6. Report from Standing Committees
a. Finance and Policy (Chairperson Reynolds)
b. Public Safety (Chairperson King)
c. Public Works (Chairperson Kraeling)
d. Economic Planning & Development (Chairperson Matney)
e. Building Codes (Chairperson Kuzniar)
f. Recreation (Chairperson Allgood)
7. Unfinished Business
a.An ordinance to rezone property consisting of approximately
23 acres located at North Main Street (portion of tax map
parcel: #M008.04-01-004.00) and providing an effective date
[Pages 15-25 ]
Mayor Merritt
Councilor Kuzniar
2
b. An o
rdinance to rezone property consisting of approximately 5 acres Councilor Kuzniar
located at West Butler Road and Laurel Meadows Parkway
(tax map parcel: #M008.02-01-003.00) and providing
an effective date [Pages 26-37 ]
8. New Bus iness Mayor Merritt
Ordinances- 1st reading
a. An ordinance to rezone property consisting of approximately
5.8 acres located at 25 Old Mill Road (tax map parcel:
#M008.04-01-002.03) [Pages 38-43]
b.Annexation and Establishment of Tanner Road Planned
Development – 3 ordinances [Pages 44-91]
An or
dinance to provide for the annexation of property owned
by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, and located at 30 Tanner
Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-01-043.01) by one hundred
percent petition and to establish a zoning classification of PD,
Planned Development for said property;
An or
dinance to provide for the annexation of property owned
by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, and located at 30 Tanner
Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-01-043.02) by one hundred
percent petition and to establish a zoning classification of PD,
Planned Development for said property;
An or
dinance to provide for the annexation of property owned
by C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue, and located at 50
Tanner Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-01-043.00) by one
hundred percent petition method; and to establish a zoning
classification of PD, Planned Development for said property;
c.An amendment to Chapter 18, Article II (Nuisances) of the
Mauldin Code of Ordinances to authorize the codes
enforcement official rather than the building and zoning
director to enforce certain provisions contained herein and for
other matters related thereto [Pages 92-96]
d.An amendment to Chapter 18, Article II (Nuisances) of the
Mauldin Code of Ordinances to establish certain standards to
protect against nuisances caused by light trespass and for
other matters related [Pages 97-103]
e.Amend Chapter 20, Article I, General Fire Prevention and
Protection, of the Mauldin Code of Ordinances regarding
Open Burning [Pages 104-107]
Cou
ncilor Kuzniar
Cou
ncilor Kuzniar
Cou
ncilor Kuzniar
Cou
ncilor Kuzniar
Cou
ncilor King
3
Sta
nding Committee Items
f.Bridgeway Station Connection [Pages 108-120] Councilor Allgood
g.Gilder Creek Trail Discussion [Pages 121-122] Councilor Allgood
h.Bid for K9 car upfit [Page 123] Councilor King
i.Bid for Police car upfit [Page 124] Councilor King
j.Record Retention Schedule [Pages 125-129] Councilor King
k.Contract with DJJ [Pages 130-136] Councilor King
l.Drive through facilities in CRD Discussion [Pages 137-139] Councilor Kuzniar
m.Sewer Rehab Program Contract [Pages 140-147] Councilor Kraeling
n.Side-Arm Trash Truck Purchase [Page 148] Councilor Kraeling
o.Stormwater Engineering Task Order 2 [Pages 149-159] Councilor Kraeling
p.Pedestrian Bridge Lighting [Pages 160-167] Councilor Matney
q. C
ouncilor Matney Landscape Architecture Services for Jenkins Street and
Jenkins Court [Page 168]
Comm
ittee of the Whole
r.Appointment of new Ministerial Recorder [Page 169]
9.Public Comment Mayor Merritt
10.Council Concerns Mayor Merritt
11.Adjournment Mayor Merritt
4
PRO
CLAMATION
WHER
EAS: The Constitution of the United States of America, the guardian of our liberties, embodies the
principles of limited government in a Republic dedicated to rule by law; and
WHEREAS: September 17, 2022, marks the two hundred and thirty-fifth anniversary of the framing of
the Constitution of the United States of America by the Constitutional Convention; and
WHEREAS: It is fitting and proper to accord official recognition to this magnificent document and its
memorable anniversary, and to the patriotic celebrations which will commemorate it; and
WHEREAS: Public Law 915 guarantees the issuing of a proclamation each year by the President of the
United States of America designating September 17 through 23 as Constitution Week,
NOW, THEREFORE I, Terry Merritt, Mayor of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, do hereby proclaim the
week of September 17 through 23 as
CONSTITUTION WEEK
and ask our citizens to reaffirm the ideals the Framers of the Constitution had in 1787 by vigilantly
protecting the freedoms guaranteed to us through this guardian of our liberties.
__________
__________________
Terry Merritt, Mayor
ATTEST:
____________________________
Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk
5
PROCLAMATION
WHEREAS, Each year, communities across our nation observe National Hispanic Heritage Month by
celebrating the histories, cultures, and contributions of generations of Hispanic-Americans whose
ancestors came from Mexico, Spain, the Caribbean, and Central and South America; and
WHEREAS, The observation started in 1968 as Hispanic Heritage Week under President Lyndon Johnson
and was expanded by President Ronald Reagan in 1988 (from September 15th to October 15th) due to
the fact that this window represents Independence Day in seven Latin American countries (Chile, Costa
Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico, and Nicaragua); and
WHEREAS, This month, we honor Hispanic and Latino individuals and cultures for enriching the fabric of
our society and being a vital component of the rich diversity that makes South Carolina a vibrant and
thriving community;
WHEREAS, Since 2000, South Carolina's Hispanic population has nearly tripled its proportion of the total
population (from 2.4% to nearly 6.9%). Over this same period, the Hispanic population grew 366% from
around 96,000 to just under 353,000 Making South Carolina’s population more dynamic and diverse;
and
WHEREAS, we acknowledge the challenges to attain equality and opportunity that many Hispanics and
minority groups still face in our nation and rededicate ourselves to creating a vibrant and inclusive
society where everyone may access the path to success and prosperity; and
WHEREAS, we recognize that the gifts, values, and personal sacrifices of our Hispanic brothers and
sisters are woven inextricably into the fabric of our common community heritage, strengthen our
society, and are vital to achieving our hopes and dreams for South Carolina; and
WHEREAS, the Hispanic Alliance, in seeking to foster collaboration and connectivity among people,
resources, and cultures, is joined by multiple public and private partners in honoring the
aforementioned contributions of Hispanic-Americans to our society;
NOW THEREFORE, I, Terry Merritt , Mayor of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, do hereby proclaim on
this 19
th day of September, 2022 that the period of September 15 through October 15 will be ‘‘Hispanic
Heritage Month’’ in the City of Mauldin and encourage all citizens of this community to observe and
take part in activities recognizing the contributions of Hispanics to the cultural life of our city, state,
nation, and world.
_______
_____________
Terry Merritt, Mayor
6
MINUTES
CITY OF MAULDIN
CITY COUNCIL MEETING AUGUST 15, 2022
7:00 P.M.
CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
Mem
bers present: Mayor Terry Merritt, Council members Taft Matney, Carol King, Jason Kraeling,
Michael Reynolds, Frank Allgood and Diane Kuzniar.
Oth
ers present: City Attorney Daniel Hughes and Interim City Administrator Rebecca Vance
1. Cal
l to Order- Mayor Merritt
a. Welcome- Mayor Merritt
b. Invocation- Councilwoman King
c. Pledge of Allegiance- Councilwoman King
2. Pro
clamations and Presentations- No proclamations or presentations
3. Rea
ding and Approval of Minutes
a. Special Called City Council Meeting –July 14, 2022
b. City Council Meeting- July 18, 2022
c. Special Called Meeting-July 22, 2022
d. Special Called Meeting -August 1, 2022
e. Special Called Meeting- August 11, 2022
Al
l of the minutes above were approved by unanimous consent.
4. Pub
lic Comment- None
5. Rep
ort from City Administrator- Interim City Administrator Rebecca Vance thanked department
heads and Council for their help and patience as the City moves forward with the many projects
presently being worked on.
6. Repo
rt from Standing Committees
a. Finan
ce and Policy (Chairperson Reynolds)- Chairman Reynolds reported all budgets look good.
b. Public Safety (Chairperson King)- Chairwoman King reminded everyone to be careful in
school zones as the new school year starts.
c. Public Works (Chairperson Kraeling)- None
d. Economic Planning & Development (Chairperson Matney)- None
e. Building Codes (Chairperson Kuzniar)- Chairwoman Kuzniar reported delinquent business license
fees are starting to come in.
f. Recreation (Chairperson Allgood)- None
7. Unfi
nished Business- There is no unfinished business.
7
8. Ne
w Business
O
rdinances- 1st reading
a. An
ordinance to rezone property consisting of approximately 23 acres located at North Main
Street (portion of tax map parcel: #M008.04-01-004.00) and providing an effective date
Mot
ion: Chairwoman Kuzniar made a motion to approve this ordinance on first reading with
Councilman Matney seconding.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
b. A
n ordinance to rezone property consisting of approximately 5 acres located at West Butler Road
and Laurel Meadows Parkway (tax map parcel: #M008.02-01-003.00) and providing an effective
date
Mot
ion: Chairwoman Kuzniar made a motion to approve this ordinance on first reading with
Councilwoman King seconding.
Ch
airwoman Kuzniar asked Austin Allen from Arbor Land Design a question regarding the
fencing or landscaping along West Butler Road. A resident said sometimes when they come off
Laurel Meadows Parkway and turn right onto West Butler they have a hard time seeing because
of the curve. Chairwoman Kuzniar said she is concerned if landscaping is installed that it will
block the view. Mr. Allen said there is room there to move the barrier back and they will make
sure the site distances are not blocked.
Co
uncilman Allgood asked what the setback will be. Mr. Allen answered it would
be 25 feet. Councilman Allgood said there were concerns regarding the lack of amenities to this
property and also the density of the project. Mr. Allen said the density is high, but some
surrounding properties also have a similar density. The plans are still being worked on, so he is
not sure of the amenities, but should have an answer by the next Council meeting.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (6-1) with Councilman Kraeling dissenting.
S
tanding Committee Items
c. Mav
erick Station Landscaping
Mot
ion: Chairman Matney made a motion to approve this contract with Councilman Reynolds
seconding.
Ch
airman Matney said this is outside the City’s normal practice. Our Public Works Department
landscapes City properties. He would like for the Public Works Committee to discuss the larger
subject of Public Works maintenance of right of ways as well.
Co
uncilwoman King said the City is currently maintaining the property. She is concerned that a
contract like this would go against the procurement policy. The City is currently maintaining the
8
property and there is a difference between landscaping and maintaining. This would set a
precedent.
Co
uncilman Kraeling said he is also concerned about the procurement process. This is not
something that needs to be decided now. The City needs to look at whether this would be cost
prohibitive.
May
or Merritt said he would like the Public Works Committee to look at this issue. The Public
Works department is already stretched and, as the City grows, there is even more of a burden on
the department.
Ch
airman Matney rescinded his motion with agreement by Councilman Reynolds.
Mot
ion: Chairman Matney made a motion to forward this to the Public Works Committee with
Councilman Reynolds seconding.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
d. C
ertification of Distressed Textile Mill Site Tax Credits
Mot
ion: Chairman Matney made a motion to adopt this resolution with Councilman Reynolds
seconding.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
e. Res
olution to Approve Purchase and Sale Agreement
Mot
ion: Chairman Matney made a motion to adopt this resolution and to authorize the Mayor
to sign this agreement with Councilman Kraeling seconding.
Vote: T
he vote was unanimous (7-0).
f. Co
ntract with Clemson University
Moti
on: Chairwoman King made a motion to approve the contract for law enforcement services
and add the Mayor as a signature line on the contract. Councilman Kraeling seconded the
motion.
May
or Merritt asked if he should sign the contract as the Mayor. Daniel Hughes said he believes
it is appropriate for the Mayor and the Chief to both sign the contract. The Mayor should sign
the contract in keeping with the City’s policies.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
g. O
pen Burning Permit for Adams Glen
Moti
on: Chairwoman King made a motion to approve the open burning permit for Adams Glen
subdivision. Councilman Kraeling seconded the motion.
9
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
h. C
onnection to Bridgeway Station
Moti
on: Chairman Allgood made a motion to send this item back to committee. Councilman
Reynolds seconded the motion.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
i. Co
mp and Class Plan
Moti
on: Chairman Reynolds made a motion to accept the contract with Evergreen Solutions with
Councilwoman King seconding the motion.
Ch
airman Reynolds said this will enable Human Resources to ensure the City is competitive in the
market for employees.
Ho
lly Abercrombie said the $28,500 will come from last year’s budget surplus.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
9. Pu
blic Comment- None
10. Co
uncil Concerns- Councilman Matney said we need to keep parents and students in mind as
children are being moved to college.
He
also mentioned Joel Ann Chandler’s birthday was yesterday.
11. Ad
journment- Mayor Merritt adjourned the meeting at 7:28 p.m.
Re
spectfully Submitted,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
10
MINUTES
CITY OF MAULDIN
SPECIAL CALLED CITY COUNCIL MEETING
AUGUST 26, 2022, 11:00 AM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
Me
mbers present: Mayor Terry Merritt, Council members Taft Matney, Carol King, Jason Kraeling, and
Frank Allgood. Councilwoman Diane Kuzniar and Councilman Michael Reynolds were not present.
Oth
ers present: Interim City Administrator Rebecca Vance and HR Director Mark Putnam
1. Call
to Order- Mayor Terry Merritt
a. Invocation- Councilwoman King
b. Pledge of Allegiance- Councilwoman King
c. Welcome- Mayor Merritt
2. Pr
oclamations and Presentations
a. South Carolina Law Enforcement Week
May
or Merritt read the proclamation.
3. Ne
w Business
a. Executive Session on a Personnel Matter regarding the Judicial Department as allowed by State
Statute Section 30-4-70 (a)(1)
M
otion: Councilwoman King made a motion to adjourn into executive session with Councilman
Kraeling seconding.
V
ote: The vote was unanimous (5-0).
Ma
yor Merritt reconvened the meeting at 12:55 p.m. Councilwoman King reported no decisions
were made and no votes taken in executive session.
b
. Possible action on items discussed in Executive Session
M
otion: Councilwoman King made a motion to accept the recommendation of Interim City
Administrator Vance for the appointment of the Clerk of Court. Councilman Allgood seconded the
motion.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (5-0).
4. Co
uncil Requests- None
5. Ad
journment- The meeting was adjourned at 12:57 p.m.
Res
pectfully Submitted,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
11
MINUTES
CITY OF MAULDIN
SPECIAL CALLED CITY COUNCIL MEETING
SEPTEMBER 2, 2022, 10:30 AM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
Me
mbers present were Mayor Terry Merritt, Council Members Taft Matney, Carol King, Michael
Reynolds, Diane Kuzniar and Frank Allgood. Councilman Kraeling was not present at the convening of
the meeting but attended the executive session and was present through adjournment.
Ot
hers present: Interim City Administrator Rebecca Vance
1. C
all to Order- Mayor Terry Merritt
a. Invocation- Mayor Terry Merritt
b. Pledge of Allegiance- Mayor Terry Merritt
c. Welcome- Mayor Terry Merritt
2. Ne
w Business
M
otion: Councilman Matney made a motion to go into executive session for the two items listed
below. Councilwoman King seconded the motion.
V
ote: The vote was unanimous (6-0).
a. E
xecutive Session to receive legal advice regarding Project Kick as allowed by State Statute
Section 30-4-70 (a)(2)
b
. Executive Session on a Personnel Matter regarding the Administration Department as allowed by
State Statute Section 30-4-70 (a)(1)
Ma
yor Merritt reconvened the meeting at 1:43 p.m. Councilman Matney reported no decisions were
made and no action taken in executive session.
c. Po
ssible action on items discussed in Executive Session
M
otion: Councilman Matney made a motion to authorize the Mayor to execute a non-binding
term sheet outlining the significant terms of an agreement to construct and operate a multi-
purpose stadium at Bridgeway Station by and between the City of Mauldin, Greenville Triumph,
and Hughes Investments, and to authorize City staff to take necessary steps to move forward.
Councilman Kraeling seconded the motion.
V
ote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
3. Co
uncil Requests- None
12
4. Adjournment- Mayor Merritt adjourned the meeting at 1:46 p.m.
Res
pectfully Submitted,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
13
MINUTES
CITY OF MAULDIN
SPECIAL CALLED CITY COUNCIL MEETING SEPTEMBER 14, 2022, 6:30 PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
Members present: Mayor Terry Merritt, Council members Taft Matney, Carol King, Jason Kraeling, Michael
Reynolds, Frank Allgood and Diane Kuzniar.
Others present: Rebecca Vance, Interim City Administrator and Mark Putnam, HR Director
1.Call to Order-Mayor Terry Merritt
a. Invocation- Councilman Kraeling
b. Pledge of Allegiance- Councilman Kraeling
c. Welcome- Mayor Merritt
2. New Business
a. Executive Session on a Personnel Matter regarding the Administration Department as allowed by
State Statute Section 30-4-70 (a)(1)
Motion: Councilman Reynolds made a motion to go into executive session with Cou ncilman
Allgood seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
Mayor Merritt reconvened the meeting at 6:52 p.m. Councilman Reynolds reported no decisions
were made and no action taken in executive session.
b. Possible action on items discussed in Executive Session
Motion: Councilman Reynolds made a motion to approve the contract with Seth Duncan as the
new City Administrator. Councilman Taft Matney seconded the motion.
Councilman Reynolds said this was an exciting process and Mr. Duncan rose to the top. The City is
happy to welcome him to the team.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
3. Council Requests-
Councilman Kraeling thanked the Public Works department for their quick response to replace a trash
can that had been damaged.
Mayor Merritt reminded everyone that the SOOIE barbecue festival would be held this Friday evening
and Saturday afternoon.
4. Adjournment- Mayor Merritt adjourned the meeting at 6:55 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
14
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM
MEETI
NG DATE: September 19, 2022
AGE
NDA ITEM: 7a
TO:
City Council
FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug
SUBJECT: Rezoning at N Main Street
*** 2nd Reading ***
REQUEST
The City of Mauldin has received a signed petition requesting the rezoning of a tract of land pursuant to
Section 4:2 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance. This petition includes approximately 23 acres located along
N. Main Street between Kellett’s Korner/Tommy’s Snack Bar at 602 N. Main Street and the C.F. Sauer
manufacturing facility at 728 N. Main Street. Specifically, this rezoning includes the portion of the property
on the east side of the railroad tracks. The applicant has requested that this tract be rezoned from I -1,
Industrial, to R-M, Multi-Family Residential. The applicant is planning to develop a townhome community
described below.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
This tract is currently undeveloped and is heavily wooded. Several groups have examined this property for
development in recent years. However, providing access to this property, particularly for industrial
development, has been extremely challenging. Existing railroad tracks cut off access to N. Main Street and
the railroad company has not granted permission to cross the tracks.
PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
At present, a company called Parker Group is proposing to develop a 99-unit townhome community on
approximately 15 acres of this tract. This community would consist of high-end townhomes with projected
OWNER(S): TJA, LLC – Robert Tommy Kellett
AUTHORIZED REP(S): Barrett Wood Parker Group Services
TAX MAP NUMBER(S): p/o #M008.04-01-004.00
LOCATION: Property along N. Main Street
between 602 N. Main St. and 728 N. Main St.
CURRENT ZONING: I-1, Industrial
REQUESTED ZONING: R-M, Multi-Family Residential
SIZE OF PROPERTY: Approx. 23 acres
15
price points around $320,000 to $340,000. The community would also include a half-acre central community
area.
A
ccess. Access to this proposed development project will be via Green Street at the end of Murray Drive.
The developer has purchased a nearly 1-acre tract at 9 Green Street where he plans to demolish the existing
home and construct a new street through the property which will provide access to the proposed development.
According to the Mauldin’s development regulations, 99 homes are the most homes that can be developed
with a single access (provided that the access is at least 26 feet wide to the first intersection).
B
uffering. The developer has indicated that he would like to install an attractive buffer between this
proposed development project and the adjacent Whispering Oaks townhome community. He is considering
tree preservation, heavy shrubbery, and/or fencing for the buffer.
D
edicated land for park and trail development. On the remaining portion of the 23-acre tract, the developer
is proposing to dedicate approximately 6.7 acres for a future park constructed by the City of Mauldin and an
additional 1.5 acres for an entrance road into the future park. Additionally, the developer is proposing to
reserve a 21 -foot easement along the edge of the property next to the railroad right -of-way for future
pedestrian and bicycle trail construction.
A
bout Parker Group
On
their website, Parker Group summarizes their mission as: “We value people over profit.” They describe
their approach to real estate as “caring about people and empowering them to begin the next phase of their
lives. It’s about being visionary, seeing a need and creating the solution proactively. It’s about impacting
lives. Our team does it all with professionalism, unbridled intelligence, and a tenacious curiosity that keeps
us moving forward.”
T
he Parker Group has undertaken development projects acr oss Greenville including the Hub (14 modern
Scandinavian-inspired townhomes), the Commons (commercial adaptive reuse development), Custom House
Condos (luxury condos on South Main Street), Burdette Street Cottages (7 homes in the Village of West
Greenville’s Arts District), and West Park & Townes (6 townhome units in downtown Greenville). In
addition, the Parker Group is redeveloping the former site of Family Dollar/Rite Aid/Eckerd’s in Mauldin at
the corner of N. Main Street and E. Butler Road.
NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING
In accordance with Section 4:3.3 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance, the applicant held a neighborhood
meeting on June 8, 2022. Based on the sign- in sheet, it appears that approximately 15 neighbors attended
the meeting, most of whom were from the Whispering Oaks townhome community.
A
ccording to the meeting summary provided by the applicant, questions and concerns covered topics
including: traffic, tree preservation, stormwater runoff, landscape buffering and screening, townhome size
and price points. Attached is the applicant’s summary of the neighborhood meeting.
PUBLIC HEARING
The Planning Commission held a public hearing on July 26, 2022. One non- resident citizen spoke at the
public hearing.
• S
am Davis, with Upstate Greenways & Trails Alliance, spoke in support of the project highlighting
that the proposed establishment of a trail easement along this property will help in the expansion of
the Swamp Rabbit Trail from CU-ICAR to Mauldin.
16
ZONING EVALUATION
Existing Zoning Classification
The
I-1 district is established to accommodate manufacturing, assembly, warehousing, and distribution
operations. It is the intent of the district that such operations do not produce harmful noise, odor, smoke,
dust, glare, or pollution.
Proposed Zoning Classification
The
R-M zoning designation is a multi-family residential district intended to provide a full range of medium-
to high- density multi- family housing types in addition to detached and attached single -family homes
recreational, religious, and educa tional facilities. This district is intended to provide a transition between
single-family districts and commercial districts.
Dev
elopment standards associated with the R-M zoning district include:
• Ma
ximum density: 16 units per acre
• Maximum building height: 45 feet
• Minimum perimeter setbacks: 25 feet
• Buffer required next to Whispering Oaks community: none required by ordinance
• Minimum open space: 15 percent of development area
• Minimum parking: 1.5 parking spaces per multi -family dwelling unit; 2 parking spaces per single-
family dwelling unit
Surrounding Development/Zoning
The
se properties are surrounded by the following zoning and land uses:
Direction Zoning District(s) Existing Use(s)
North I-1 (City) C.F. Sauer and other industrial facilities
South R-M (City) Whispering Oaks townhome community
East I-1 (City) Various industrial businesses
West C-2 (City) Landscape strip between railroad tracks and
N. Main Street
Comprehensive Plan Vision
Thi
s property is designated as an “employment center” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan.
Employment Center areas are intended for industrial parks and office parks. However, this designation in
the Comprehensive Plan does not account for the constrained access to this property.
REVIEW CRITERIA
The Mauldin Zoning Ordinance does not contain any specified criteria that should be considered by the
Planning Commission when reviewing requests for rezoning. However, the following criteria are typical of
those used by other jurisdictions.
A. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed since the Comprehensive
Plan was adopted, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the
general character of the area;
B. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support
the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed in the proposed zoning district;
17
C. Compatibility of all the potential uses allowed in the proposed zoning district with surrounding uses
and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density,
nature of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning,
and potential influence on property values;
D. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate all potential uses allowed
in the proposed district without compromising public health, safety or welfare; and
E. Public need for the potential uses permitted in the requested zoning district.
STAFF FINDINGS
The analysis below includes staff findings pertaining to each criterion.
CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS
1. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or,
if conditions have changed, consistency with
the overall intent of the Plan, recent
development trends, and the general character
of the area;
This property is designated as an “employment
center” in the future land use map of the
comprehensive plan. Employment Center areas are
intended for industrial parks and office parks.
However, the failed attempts in recent years to
design the type of access required for an
employment center, it would appear that the
conditions for this property have changed.
Considering that Green Street appears to be the
only viable so lution for access at this time, the
proposed development of a townhome community
at this tract seems to be more consistent with the
general character of the other properties along
Green Street. The Planning Commission and the
City Council may or may not j udge that the
proposed rezoning is consistent with the intent of
the comprehensive plan, recent development
trends, and the general character of the area.
2. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological,
hydrological and other environmental features
to support the breadth and intensity of uses that
could be developed
There is a small area (approximately one-half acre)
along the easternmost corner of the property
located in a floodplain. To staff’s knowledge, there
are no other apparent floodplains, wetlands, or
topographic constraints on the site. Staff is not
aware of any features at this site that would make
it unsuitable for development.
3. Compatibility of the potential uses allowed
with surrounding uses and zoning districts in
terms of suitability of location, impacts on the
environment, noise, density, nature of use,
traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop
adjacent properties under existing zoning, and
potential influence on property values
The tract is lo cated in a transitional area between
railroads tracks, industrial properties on the
backside, and townhomes and detached homes to
the south. Considering that the property will be
accessed via Green Street, it would seem that a
residential development would be better suited for
this site than would an industrial or office park
development, in terms of traffic, noise, aesthetics,
and other potential impacts. The Planning
Commission and the City Council may or may not
judge that this rezoning is compatible w ith the
surrounding uses.
18
CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS
4. Capacity of public infrastructure and services
to sufficiently accommodate potential uses
allowed without compromising public health,
safety, or welfare
Staff is not aware of any utilities, including water
and sewer, that would not be available at this tract.
This project is expected to connect to the existing
ReWa sewer line along the southern edge of the
property. If the project will generate more than 100
peak hour trips, the applicant will be required to
provide a traffic imp act study (TIS) before the
development plans can be approved. It does not
appear at this time that this project will generate
more than 100 peak hour trips. Therefore, a traffic
impact study is not
likely to be required for this
development project prior to preliminary plat.
5. Public need for the potential uses permitted The Comprehensive Plan forecasts that an aging
population, shrinking household sizes, and
affordability will continue to increase the demand
for smaller, low-maintenance housing. The current
conceptual development proposal would provide
additional living options that support this forecast
in the Comprehensive Plan. Additionally, this
rezoning also helps to meet the high demand for
housing around this area.
TIMELINE
On June 8, 2022, the applicant met with interested neighbors to review their proposal and to seek questions
and comments.
On J
une 17, 2022, staff received the request to rezone this tract.
On J
uly 26, 2022, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing. At this m eeting, the Planning
Commission voted 5-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning.
On A
ugust 1, 2022, the Building Codes Committee voted 3- 0 to forward this rezoning to City Council for
consideration.
On A
ugust 15, 2022, the City Council approved this rezoning on first reading.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
In staff’s opinion, it appears that the conceptual residential community at this tract has the potential to
introduce lesser impacts in terms of noise, traffic, aesthetics, and similar impacts in comparison to the type
of development that would otherwise be allowed by the current zoning of the property. For these reasons, it
appears that the conceptual residential community may be more compatible to the adjacent Whispering Oaks
townhome community than the current zoning for industrial development. Furthermore, the dedication of
land for public park and trail development may be a worthwhile endeavor for the City of Mauldin as it seeks
to expand pedestrian and bicycle facilities within the City.
Ulti
mately, the Planning Commission and the City Council will need to make a judgment on whether (1) this
rezoning is consistent with the vision for the future of this area, (2) the rezoning is compatible with the
surrounding uses, and (3) any other factors that they deem pertinent.
19
PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION
On July 26, 2022, the Planning Commission voted 5-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning.
ATTACHMENTS
Proposed ordinance (maps included therein)
Neighborhood meeting information
Conceptual drawing(s)
20
ORDINANCE # __________
AN ORDINANCE TO REZONE PROPERTY CONSISTING OF
APPROXIMATELY 23 ACRES LOCATED AT NORTH MAIN STREET
(PORTION OF TAX MAP PARCEL: #M008.04-01- 004.00) AND PROVIDING
AN EFFECTIVE DATE
WHEREAS, TJA LLC, has petitioned the City of Mauldin to rezone +/ - 23 acres from the I -1,
Industrial District, to the R-M, Multi-family Residential District; and
WHEREAS, a rezoning of the parcel is in keeping with the City of Mauldin 2014 Comprehensive
Plan Update; and
WHEREAS, the site is suitable for the types of uses that could be developed under the new zoning
district; and
WHEREAS, the potential uses permitted in the new zoning district meet a public need and are not
detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare; and
WHEREAS, the Mauldin Planning Commission has given favorable recommendation to the zoning
application; and
NO
W THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South
Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof
Section 1. That the property described in zoning docket PC -2022-09-RZ and Greenville County Tax Map
Parcel M008.04-01-004.00 be rezoned from I -1 to R-M, Multi-family Residential. The property is further
identified on the attached exhibit that is hereby incorporated into this ordinance, including Exhibit 1, Zoning
& Property Map.
Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage.
Passed on First Reading ________________________________
Passed on Second Reading ______________________________
CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA
ATTEST: B
Y: ________________________________
Terry Merritt, Mayor
_______________
____________________
Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk
APP
ROVED AS TO FORM:
_______________
____________________
John Duggan, City Attorney
21
EXHIBIT 1
22
23
24
25
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM
MEETI
NG DATE: September 19, 2022
AGE
NDA ITEM: 7b
TO:
City Council
FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug
SUBJECT: Rezoning at W Butler Road and Laurel Meadows Pkwy
*** 2nd Reading ***
REQUEST
The City of Mauldin has received a signed petition requesting the rezoning of a tract of land pursuant to
Section 4:2 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance. This petition includes approximat ely 5 acres located along
W. Butler Road between Taylor Road and Laurel Meadows Parkway. The applicant has requested that this
tract be rezoned from C -2, Commercial, to R -M, Multi-Family Residential. The applicant is planning to
develop a townhome community described below.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
This tract is currently undeveloped and is heavily wooded. This property has been listed as available for
commercial development for the last few years.
PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
At present, Arbor Land Design is proposing to develop a 57-unit townhome community on this 5-acre tract.
This community would consist of townhomes with projected price points starting at $300,000. The
conceptual drawings for the proposed development do not depict any amenities but do include just under one
acre of open space.
Access
. Access to this proposed development project will be via two separate drives along Laurel Meadows
Parkway. One drive will line up with Waterbrook Dr and the other drive will be slightly offset from the
OWNER(S): Abby & Matt, LLC
AUTHORIZED REP(S): Austin Allen Arbor Land Design
TAX MAP NUMBER(S): #M008.02-01-003.00
LOCATION: Property along W. Butler Rd.
between Taylor Rd. and Laurel Meadows Pkwy.
CURRENT ZONING: C-2, Commercial
REQUESTED ZONING: R-M, Multi-Family Residential
SIZE OF PROPERTY: Approx. 5 acres
26
second driveway into the Mauldin Library parking lot. The intersection of W. Butler Road and Laurel
Meadows Parkway is currently signalized which aids access at this intersection.
Buf
fering. The developer has not provided information about buffering adjacent to the Laurel Meadows
community but the conceptual drawings depict a storm water detention pond and open space adjacent to the
Laurel Meadows community.
Abou
t Arbor Land Design
On
their website, Arbor Land Design, also known as Arbor Engineering, describes its company as “actively
engaged in all aspects of landscape architecture and design, including residential and commercial; urban
planning; land use planning; parks and recreational development; and civil engineering.” Arbor Land Design
has been involved with projects all across the Greenville area. They are currently involved with providing
civil engineering for Riley Trace, Hawk Haven, Bethel Townes, Madison Park, Miller Park, Holly Ridge,
and Alston Chase, among others.
NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING
In accordance with Section 4:3.3 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance, the applicant held a neighborhood
meeting on June 20, 2022. Based on the sign- in sheet, it appears that approximately 12 neighbors attended
the meeting, most of whom were from the Laurel Meadows community and the Laurel Heights community.
Ac
cording to the meeting summary provided by the applicant, questions and concerns covered topics
including: traffic, insufficiencies at the intersection of W Butler Road and Laurel Meadows Parkway,
amenities, open space, tree preservation, stormwater runoff, landscape buffering and screening, target
demographic, price points, building façade materials, and rental homes. Attached is the applicant’s summary
of the neighborhood meeting.
PUBLIC HEARING
The Planning Commission held a public on July 26, 2022. The following citizens spoke at the public hearing.
• Joe
Hanson, 512 Laurel Meadows Parkway, expressed support for rezoning this property from
commercial but also shared some concerns about the proposed development of the site. His concerns
included: (1) traffic at the intersection of Laurel Meadows Parkway and W. Butler Road and the lack
of a dedicated left -turn arrow at the traffic signal for drivers on Laurel Meadows Parkway, (2) the
challenge that Laurel Meadows has of other uninvited communities using the Laurel Meadows
community pool, and (3) the displacement of wildlife.
• Jane Triplett*, 3 Kalmia Creek Drive, indicated that she does not believe that the property and
location is viable for commercial development. She commented that there is a curve along W. Butler
Road that causes visibility issues at the intersection of Laurel Meadows Parkway and W. Butler
Road. She also commented that the additional development along Ashmore Bridge Road has resulted
in increased traffic along Fowler Circle placing additional pressure on the signalized intersection at
Laurel Meadows Parkway and W. Butler Road.
* Pl
ease note that Ms. Triplett spoke after the floor had been closed to public comments but her comments
are shared here anyway.
27
ZONING EVALUATION
Existing Zoning Classification
The
C-2 district is established to promote accessible and central concentrations of business activities and
commercial establishments offering both retail goods and services to people from throughout the community.
This district is intended to serve both pedestrians as well as people who travel by automobile. Therefore, this
district is located along major roadways, and b usinesses are encouraged to locate in close proximity to one
another. Where necessary, adjacent residential areas are protected through landscaping and site design.
Proposed Zoning Classification
The
R-M zoning designation is a multi-family residential district intended to provide a full range of medium-
to high- density multi- family housing types in addition to detached and attached single -family homes
recreational, religious, and educational facilities. This district is intended to provide a transition between
single-family districts and commercial districts.
Dev
elopment standards associated with the R-M zoning district include:
• Ma
ximum density: 16 units per acre
• Maximum building height: 45 feet
• Minimum perimeter setbacks: 25 feet
• Buffer required next to Laurel Meadows community: none required by ordinance
• Minimum open space: 15 percent of development area
• Minimum parking: 1.5 parking spaces per multi -family dwelling unit; 2 parking spaces per single -
family dwelling unit
Surrounding Development/Zoning
The
se properties are surrounded by the following zoning and land uses:
Direction Zoning District(s) Existing Use(s)
North PD (City) Laurel Meadows community
South C-1 (City) Undeveloped commercial property
East R-20 (City) Undeveloped residential property
West C-2 (City)/
PD (City)
Mauldin Library
Laurel Heights community
Comprehensive Plan Vision
Th
is property is designated as a “multifamily residential” and also as part of a “regional corridor” in the
future land use map of the comprehensive plan. Multifamily residential areas are intended to include
apartments, townhomes, and duplexes. They should have good access to major roads as well as parks and
open space. A Regional Corridor is envisioned to include intense commercial uses, including “big box”
retail, drive-through restaurants, large shopping centers, and automotive service centers.
REVIEW CRITERIA
The Mauldin Zoning Ordinance does not contain any specified criteria that should be considered by the
Planning Commission when reviewing requests for rezoning. However, the following criteria are typical of
those used by other jurisdictions.
28
A. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed since the Comprehensive
Plan was adopted, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the
general character of the area;
B. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support
the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed in the proposed zoning district;
C. Compatibility of all the potential uses allowed in the proposed zoning district with surrounding uses
and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density,
nature of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning,
and potential influence on property values;
D. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate all potential uses allowed
in the proposed district without compromising public health, safety or welfare; and
E. Public need for the potential uses permitted in the requested zoning district.
STAFF FINDINGS
The analysis below includes staff findings pertaining to each criterion.
CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS
1. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or,
if conditions have changed, consistency with
the overall intent of the Plan, recent
development trends, and the general character
of the area;
This property is designated as “multifamily
residential” and also as part of a “regional corridor”
in the future land use map of the comprehensive
plan. Multifamily residential areas are intended to
include apartments, townhomes, and duplexes. A
regional corridor is envisioned to include intense
commercial uses, including “big box” retail, drive-
through restaurants, large shopping centers, and
automotive service centers. Consistent with the
“regional corridor” designation along W. Butler
Road and in the interest of expanding commercial
opportunities along W. Butler Road, staff has
commented to the applicant about preserving a
commercial area along the front of this property.
However, the applicant would rather rezone the
entire property to mul tifamily residential. The
Planning Commission and the City Council may or
may not judge that the proposed rezoning is
consistent with the intent of the comprehensive
plan, recent development trends, and the general
character of the area.
2. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological,
hydrological and other environmental features
to support the breadth and intensity of uses that
could be developed
To staff’s knowledge, there are no apparent
floodplains, wetlands, or topographic constraints
on the site. Staff is not aware of any features at this
site that would make it unsuitable for development.
29
CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS
3. Compatibility of the potential uses allowed
with surrounding uses and zoning districts in
terms of suitability of location, impacts on the
environment, noise, density, nature of use,
traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop
adjacent properties under existing zoning, and
potential influence on property values
The tract is located in a transitional area between
the Laurel Meadows and Laurel Heights residential
communities and commercial uses along W. Butler
Road, albeit this section of W. Butler Road is
currently underdeveloped in comparison to other
sections of W. Butler Road to the east. It appears
that the proposed residential development o f this
property is consistent with the residential
communities along Laurel Meadows Parkway.
However, the extension of this proposed residential
development along the front of the property is less
consistent with the general commercial
development along W. Butler Road. The Planning
Commission and the City Council may or may not
judge that this rezoning is compatible with the
surrounding uses.
4. Capacity of public infrastructure and services
to sufficiently accommodate potential uses
allowed without comprom ising public health,
safety, or welfare
Staff is not aware of any utilities, including water
and sewer, that would not be available at this tract.
This project is expected to connect to the existing
City sewer line along Laurel Meadows Parkway. If
the project will generate more than 100 peak hour
trips, the applicant will be required to provide a
traffic impact study (TIS) before the development
plans can be approved. It does not appear at this
time that this project will generate more than 100
peak hour trips. Therefore, a traffic impact study
is not likely to be required for this development
project prior to preliminary plat.
Notwithstanding, some of the citizens that have
commented on this project have indicated that there
are some deficiencies at the intersection of Laurel
Meadows Parkway and W. Butler Road.
5. Public need for the potential uses permitted The Comprehensive Plan forecasts that an aging
population, shrinking household sizes, and
affordability will continue to increase the demand
for smaller, low-maintenance housing. The current
conceptual development proposal would provide
additional living options that support this forecast
in the Comprehensive Plan. Additionally, this
rezoning also helps to meet the high demand for
housing around this area. However, the
Comprehensive Plan also has a stated goal to
ensure an adequate supply of non- residential land
to support future economic development. This
rezoning of the front of this property away from
commercial decreases the co mmercial growth
opportunities along W. Butler Road.
30
TIMELINE
On June 20, 2022, the applicant met with interested neighbors to review their proposal and to seek questions
and comments.
On J
une 27, 2022, staff received the request to rezone this tract.
On J
uly 26, 2022, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing. At this meeting, the Planning
Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning.
On A
ugust 1, 2022, the Building Codes Committee voted 3- 0 to forward this rezoning to City Council for
consideration.
On A
ugust 15, 2022, the City Council approved first reading of this rezoning.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
In staff’s opinion, the rezoning of the back part of this property for a townhome community appears consistent
and compatible with the adjacent Laurel Meadows and Laurel Heights communities. Conversely, the
presence of the proposed residential community along the front of W. Butler Road will introduce the first
and only residential community that front W. Butler Road between Main Street and Plant Street/Hollyridge
Court (notwithstanding the main office for the Ashmore Bridge Estates apartment community fronts on W.
Butler Road). It should be noted, however, that at Plant Street and Hollyridge Court, approximately one -
quarter mile west of this site, the Gleneagle apartment community and the Holly Ridge subdivision both front
along W. Butler Road. Additionally, the members of the surrounding community that have spoken about
this project have expressed that they do not support commercial development at this property.
Ulti
mately, the Planning Commission and the City Council will need to make a judgment on whether (1) this
rezoning is consistent with the vision for the future of this area, (2) the rezoning is compatible with the
surrounding uses, and (3) any other factors that they deem pertinent.
PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION
On July 26, 2022, the Planning Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning. Please note
that during their discussion, the Planning Commission expressed concern about the lack of amenities being
planned for the development project and have encouraged the applicant to consider including some amenities
in this project.
ATTACHMENTS
Proposed ordinance (maps included therein)
Neighborhood meeting information
Conceptual drawing(s)
31
ORDINANCE # __________
AN ORDINANCE TO REZONE PROPERTY CONSISTING OF
APPROXIMATELY 5 ACRES LOCATED AT WEST BUTLER ROAD AND
LAUREL MEADOWS PARKWAY (TAX MAP PARCEL: #M008.02 -01-003.00)
AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE
WHEREAS, Abby & Matt LLC, has petitioned the City of Mauldin to rezone +/ - 5 acres from the
C-2, Commercial District, to the R-M, Multi-family Residential District; and
WHEREAS, a rezoning of the parcel is in keeping with the City of Mauldin 2014 Comprehensive
Plan Update; and
WHEREAS, the site is suitable for the types of uses that could be developed under the new zoning
district; and
WHEREAS, the potential uses permitted in the new zoning district meet a public need and are not
detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare; and
WHEREAS, the Mauldin Planning Commission has given favorable recommendation to the zoning
application; and
NO
W THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South
Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof
Section 1. That the property described in zoning docket PC -2022-10-RZ and Greenville County Tax Map
Parcel M008.02-01-003.00 be rezoned from C-2 to R-M, Multi-family Residential. The property is further
identified on the attached exhibit that is hereby incorporated into this ordinance, including Exhibit 1, Zoning
& Property Map.
Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage.
Passed on First Reading ________________________________
Passed on Second Reading ______________________________
CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA
ATTEST: B
Y: ________________________________
Terry Merritt, Mayor
_______________
____________________
Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk
APP
ROVED AS TO FORM:
_______________
____________________
John Duggan, City Attorney
32
EXHIBIT 1
33
34
35
36
37
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM
MEETI
NG DATE: September 19, 2022
AGE
NDA ITEM: 8a
TO:
City Council
FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug
SUBJECT: Rezoning at 25 Old Mill Road
REQUEST
The City of Mauldin has received a signed petition requesting the rezoning of a tract of land pursuant to
Section 4:2 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance. This petition includes approximately 5.8 acres located at 25
Old Mill Road. The applicant has requested that this tract be rezoned from I-1, Industrial, to S-1, Trades &
Commercial Services. The applicant would like the flexibility to consider developing the remainder of the
property for the additional uses allowed in the S-1 zoning district.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
This building is currently occupied by multiple tenants including AAA Fencecrafters, Upstate Liquidator,
Snaptight Aluminum, Elite Marketing, and Mag-It LLC. Presently, at the southeast end of the building there
are approximately 2 acres of land that have not been developed. The applicant is currently exploring his
options for the development of this unused portion of the property. There are no imminent plans for the
development of this tract at this moment.
PUBLIC HEARING
The Planning Commission held a public hearing on August 23, 2022. No public comments were offered at
the public hearing.
OWNER(S): RPA Development, LLC – Ron Allen
AUTHORIZED REP(S): N/A
TAX MAP NUMBER(S): #M008.04-01-002.03
LOCATION: 25 Old Mill Road
CURRENT ZONING: I-1, Industrial
REQUESTED ZONING: S-1, Trades & Commercial Services
SIZE OF PROPERTY: Approx. 5.8 acres
38
ZONING EVALUATION
Existing Zoning Classification
The
I -1 district is established to accommodate manufacturing, assembly, warehousing, and distribution
operations. It is the intent of the district that such operations do not produce harmful noise, odor, smoke,
dust, glare, or pollution.
Proposed Zoning Classification
The
S-1 district is established to provide a transition between commercial and industrial districts by allowing:
1. Co
mmercial uses which are service related;
2. Service-related commercial uses which sell merchandise related directly to the service performed;
3. Commercial uses which sell merchandise which requires storage in warehouses or outdoor areas;
and
4. Light industries which in their normal operations would have a minimal effect on adjoining
properties.
Th
e uses that are allowed in the S-1 district but not in the I-1 district include:
Permitted Uses Conditional Uses
Amusement or games facility
Assisted living health care service
Big box retail store
Catering services
Communication or information services
Dry cleaning and laundry services
Event center or banquet hall
Exhibition facility
Fitness/sports club, studio, or center
Funeral home
Health and personal care services
Hospital
Hotel
Meeting or assembly hall
Nursing home
Office and professional services
Outpatient health care service
Passenger transportation services
Pet and animal care services
Public administration building
Public park or recreation area
Religious institution
Restaurant
Retail sales
Social assistance services
Tattoo and body piercing services
Thrift or consignment store
Bar, brew pub or drinking place
Cemetery
Day care center
Fringe financial services
Motor vehicle sales and services
Multi-family dwellings
Private outdoor recreation amenity
39
Surrounding Development/Zoning
The
se properties are surrounded by the following zoning and land uses:
Direction Zoning District(s) Existing Use(s)
North S-1 (City) Ahold Delhaize Distribution Services
South I-1 (City) CompX Security Products
East I-1 (City) McNaughton McKay
West I-1 (City) Siroflex Inc
Comprehensive Plan Analysis
Th
is property is designated as an “employment center” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan.
Employment Center areas are intended for industrial parks and office parks. The S -1 district is generally
considered to be consistent with this “employment center” designation.
REVIEW CRITERIA
The Mauldin Zoning Ordinance does not contain any specified criteria that should be considered by the
Planning Commission when reviewing requests for rezoning. However, the following criteria are typical of
those used by other jurisdictions.
A. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed since the Comprehensive
Plan was adopted, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the
general character of the area;
B. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support
the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed in the proposed zoning district;
C. Compatibility of all the potential uses allowed in the proposed zoning district with surrounding uses
and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density,
nature of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning,
and potential influence on property values;
D. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate all potential uses allowed
in the proposed district without compromising public health, safety or welfare; and
E. Public need for the potential uses permitted in the requested zoning district.
STAFF FINDINGS
The analysis below includes staff findings pertaining to each criterion.
CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS
1. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or,
if conditions have changed, consistency with
the overall intent of the Plan, recent
development trends, and the general character
of the area;
This property is designated as an “employment
center” in the future land use map of the
comprehensive plan. Employment Center areas are
intended for industrial parks and office parks. The
S-1 district is general considered to be consistent
with the “employment center” designation.
2. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological,
hydrological and other environmental features
to support the breadth and intensity of uses that
could be developed
To staff’s knowledge, there are no apparent
floodplains, wetlands, or topographic constraints
on the site. Staff is not aware of any features at this
site that would make it unsuitable for development.
40
CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS
3. Compatibility of the potential uses allowed
with surrounding uses and zoning districts in
terms of suitability of location, impacts on the
environment, noise, density, nature of use,
traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop
adjacent properties under existing zoning, and
potential influence on property values
The tract is located in a transitional area between I-
1 and S -1 zoned properties. Most, but not all, of
the uses allowed in S -1 would appear to be
compatible with the surrounding uses.
4. Capacity of public infrastructure and services
to sufficiently accommodate potential uses
allowed without compromising public health,
safety, or welfare
Staff is not aware of any utilities, including water
and sewer, that would not be available at this tract.
5. Public need for the potential uses permitted The expectation is that the further development of
this property would bring additional jobs and/or
commercial services. This type of growth is
supported by the Comprehensive Plan.
TIMELINE
On June 26, 2022, staff received the request to rezone this tract.
On August 23, 2022, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing. At this meeting, the Planning
Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning.
On September 6, 2022, the Building Codes Committee voted 2- 0 to forward this rezoning to City Council
for consideration.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
The rezoning appears to be consistent with the comprehensive plan and other S -1 zoning in the vicinity of
the property. In staff’s opinion the request meets the criteria outlined above.
PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION
On August 23, 2022, the Planning Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning.
ATTACHMENTS
Proposed ordinance (maps included therein)
41
ORDINANCE # __________
AN ORDINANCE TO REZONE PROPERTY CONSISTING OF
APPROXIMATELY 5.8 ACRES LOCATED AT 25 OLD MILL ROAD (TAX
MAP PARCEL: #M008.04-01-002.03) AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE
WHEREAS, RPA Development, LLC, has petitioned the City of Mauldin to rezone +/ - 5.8 acres
from the I-1, Industrial District, to the S-1, Trades and Commercial Services District; and
WHEREAS, a rezoning of the parcel is in keeping with the City of Mauldin 2014 Comprehensive
Plan Update; and
WHEREAS, the site is suitable for the types of uses that could be developed under the new zoning
district; and
WHEREAS, the potential uses permitted in the new zoning district meet a public need and are not
detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare; and
WHEREAS, the Mauldin Planning Commission has given favorable recommendation to the zoning
application; and
NOW
THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South
Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof
Section 1. That the property described in zoning docket PC -2022-11-RZ and Greenville County Tax Map
Parcel #M008.04-01-002.03 be rezoned from I-1 to S-1, Trades and Commercial Services. The property is
further identified on the attached exhibit that is hereby incorporated into this ordinance, including Exhibit 1,
Zoning & Property Map.
Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage.
Passed on First Reading ________________________________
Passed on Second Reading ______________________________
CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA
ATTEST: B
Y: ________________________________
Terry Merritt, Mayor
_______________
____________________
Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk
APP
ROVED AS TO FORM:
_______________
____________________
John Duggan, City Attorney
42
EXHIBIT 1
43
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM
MEETI
NG DATE: September 19, 2022
AGE
NDA ITEM: 8b
TO:
City Council
FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug
SUBJECT: Annexation/Planned Development at 30 & 50 Tanner Rd
REQUEST
The City of Mauldin has received signed petitions requesting the annexation of three parcels of land pursuant
to South Carolina Code of Laws Section 5-3-150. These petitions include approximately 13 acres owned by
Lynn Farmer and Elaine Ayscue located at 50 Tanner Road, and approximately 7.6 acres owned by Earl
Jones and Nancy Jones located at 30 Tanner Road. The applicant has requested that these tracts be zoned
PD, Planned Development upon annexation into the City of Mauldin. Flournoy Development Group is
planning to develop a planned development described below.
TRACT #1
(30 Tanner Rd)
TRACT #2
(30 Tanner Rd)
TRACT #3
(50 Tanner Rd)
AUTHORIZED
REP(S):
Flournoy Dev. Group
Gray Engineering
Flournoy Dev. Group
Gray Engineering
Flournoy Dev. Group
Gray Engineering
OWNER(S): W. Earl Jones
Nancy L. Jones
W. Earl Jones C. Lynn Farmer
Elaine F. Ayscue
TAX MAP
NUMBER(S):
0547.03-01-043.01 0547.03-01-043.02 0547.03-01-043.00
LOCATION: 30 Tanner Rd 30 Tanner Rd 50 Tanner Rd
CURRENT
ZONING:
R-S (County) R-S (County) R-S (County)
REQUESTED
ZONING:
PD, Planned
Development
PD, Planned
Development
PD, Planned
Development
SIZE OF
PROPERTY:
Approx. 0.9 acres Approx. 6.7 acres Approx. 13 acres
CONTIGUITY: These tracts are directly contiguous to the Maple Brook Terrace Retirement
Community at 150 Verdin Rd, the backside of 701 Brookfield Pkwy, and
the Sonic Drive-In at 1534 Woodruff Rd.
44
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
Each of these two tracts are currently occupied by a single- family residence— one residence at 30 Tanner
Road and one residence at 50 Tanner Road. These tracts have attracted various development interests over
the years.
PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
About Flournoy Development Group
Fl
ournoy is described on their website as “a distinguished member in the multifamily real estate industry.”
They state they “[lead] the planning, development, and construction of luxury, Class A multifamily
communities across the Sunbelt.” They claim to have developed and managed over 40,000 multi -family
units. They indicate that they have successfully purchased and developed or are in the process of developing
5 other properties in Greenville. This includes District West at 101 Reedy View Dr (365 units), The Aventine
Greenville at 97 Market Point Dr (346 units), Carolina Point Apartments at 201 Carolina Point Pkwy (346
units), and The Paddock Club Greenville at 50 Rocky Creek Rd (208 units).
Overv
iew of Proposed Development
At
present, Flournoy Development Group is proposed a planned development consisting of the following:
• 4-s
tory apartment buildings consisting of up to 365 apartment units
• 2- and 3-story townhomes consisting of up to 100 townhome units
• 2-story carriage homes consisting of up to 8 units
• Ground floor work space units consisting of up to 14 units (these units will be connected to the
residential units above the work space creating a live/work environment)
• Accessory garages and amenities
In t
otal, this proposal includes up to 473 residential units, approximately 16,000 square feet of work space,
566 parking spaces (24 garage spaces and 542 surface parking spaces), a 12,000-square foot clubhouse, and
950-square foot maintenance/dog wash space. All work spaces and residential units, including apartments,
townhome units, and carriage homes, will be for rent only. The entire project will be owned and managed
as one property.
Li
ve/Work Units. The live/work units will consist of a ground floor work space connected to a upper floor
apartment unit. The work spaces are intended to be used for small office spaces or small-scale neighborhood
retail uses. The target market for these work spaces will be entrepreneurs, small businesses, and
professionals. The size of each work space will generally range between 700 and 1,200 square feet.
Examples of businesses that may occupy these work spaces may include accountant, architect, artist/artisan,
attorney, computer software and multimedia related professional, consultant, engineer, coffee shop, fashion
designer, clothing boutique, graphic designer, interior designer, hair stylist, home -based office worker,
insurance agent, real estate or travel agent, one -on-one instructor, photographer, and other similar
occupations.
Th
e following uses are not intended for these work spaces: vehicle repair or maintenance, adult businesses,
massage parlors, large commercial restaurants utilizing a commercial kitchen, and uses that create excessive
noise, dust, heat, smoke, and odors that create a nuisance or other safety concerns.
Ap
artments. The apartments will consist of 1-, 2-, and 3-bedroom units. Units will vary in size between 600
and 1,600 square feet. Th e buildings may vary in height between 2 and 4 stories. The exterior façade
materials will consist primarily of masonry and fiber cementitious board.
45
Amenities. Amenities planned for this project include, but are not limited to, upscale clubhouse space,
meeting rooms for residents who work from home, co-working space, fitness and wellness rooms, a dog park,
mail kiosk and package lockers, a swimming pool courtyard, and outdoor spaces providing grills, firepits,
and other amenities.
Tra
ffic. A traffic impact study has been completed for the proposed development project. This study was
performed by Allen J. Reid with Impact Designs, Inc. This study was based on a slightly lower number of
units (471) than the number of units included in the planned development submission (473). The difference
of two units should be relatively immaterial to the outcome of the study.
INTERSECTION OF VERDIN/FEASTER/WOODRUFF
LEVEL OF SERVICE (DELAY IN SECONDS PER VEHICLE)
Street Existing
Conditions in
2022
Conditions in
2025 without this
Development
Project
Conditions in
2025 with this
Development
Project
Conditions in
2025 with this
Project and the
Traffic Signal
Adjustment
Verdin Road
(northbound)
AM Peak Hour F (118.9) F (133.7) F (188.9) F (138.1)
PM Peak Hour F (131.1) F (154.8) F (177.3) F (120.2)
Feaster Road
(southbound)
AM Peak Hour F (128.8) F (133.7) F (188.9) F (138.4)
PM Peak Hour F (131.1) F (154.8) F (177.3) F (123.0)
Woodruff Road
(eastbound)
AM Peak Hour C (22.3) C (29.3) C (29.6) C (29.9)
PM Peak Hour C (30.0) D (35.8) D (36.0) D (50.7)
Woodruff Road
(westbound)
AM Peak Hour C (29.8) D (35.9) D (35.8) D (45.4)
PM Peak Hour C (30.1) D (37.5) D (44.5) D (53.6)
OVERALL
AM Peak Hour D (45.8) D (53.7) E (62.7) E (60.4)
PM Peak Hour D (54.2) E (64.1) E (71.6) E (69.8)
At
the Woodruff Road intersection, the report indicates that the northbound traffic on Verdin Road and the
southbound traffic on Feaster Road both currently operate at a level “F” during both morning and evening
peak hours. A level of service “F” generally means there is forced traffic flow and the traffic level exceeds
the amount that can be served. A level of service “F” is generally characterized by stop-and-go waves, poor
travel times, low comfort and convenience, and increased accident exposure. In order to soften the impact
of this proposed development project, the traffic impact study recommends that the traffic signal at the
Woodruff Road intersection be adjusted to allow longer green lights for Verdin Road and Feaster Road. Even
with this adjustment, Verdin Road and Feaster Road would still operate at a level F at this intersection. The
table below compares the current traffic level to future traffic levels in 2025 at this intersection.
Th
e traffic impact study also indicates that this project will impact the overall level of service at the
intersection of Verdin Road, E. Butler Road, and Holland Road. This intersection presently operates at a
level C during both morning and evening peak hours. With or without this project, the morning peak hour
level of service at the Butler Road intersection is projected to deteriorate to a level D by 2025. This
development project would also cause the evening peak hour level of service at this intersection to also
46
deteriorate to a level D. The traffic impact study recommends that a right turn overlap be installed on Verdin
Road at this intersection to facilitate the high number of right turns from Verdin Road onto E. Butler Road.
This would improve the evening peak hour level of service back to a level C for this intersection. The table
below compares the current traffic level to future traffic levels in 2025 at this intersection.
INTERSECTION OF VERDIN/HOLLAND/BUTLER
LEVEL OF SERVICE (DELAY IN SECONDS PER VEHICLE)
Street Existing
Conditions in
2022
Conditions in
2025 without this
Development
Project
Conditions in
2025 with this
Development
Project
Conditions in
2025 with this
Project and the
Right Turn
Improvements
Verdin Road
(southbound)
AM Peak Hour D (37.9) D (39.4) D (47.6) D (47.4)
PM Peak Hour D (41.8) E (55.7) E (69.6) D (46.9)
Holland Road
(northbound)
AM Peak Hour C (34.8) D (37.4) D (37.6) D (37.4)
PM Peak Hour C (32.8) C (32.1) C (32.3) C (32.3)
East Butler Road
(eastbound)
AM Peak Hour C (29.2) D (37.3) D (39.6) D (39.9)
PM Peak Hour C (20.5) C (26.2) C (28.9) C (28.9)
East Butler Road
(westbound)
AM Peak Hour C (32.5) D (38.9) D (39.3) D (39.8)
PM Peak Hour B (16.2) B (18.1) B (18.3) B (18.3)
OVERALL
AM Peak Hour C (32.4) D (38.0) D (40.0) D (40.0)
PM Peak Hour C (25.3) C (31.0) D (35.4) C (30.6)
In summary, the traffic impact study recommends the following improvements* to the current traffic system.
These improvements are intended to soften the blunt of the traffic that would be added by the proposed
development.
1. Modify the parameters of the adaptive signal system at the intersection of Woodruff Road/Verdin
Road/Feaster Road to allow for longer splits for Verdin Road and Feaster Road.
2. Install a right turn overlap on the southbound approach of Verdin Road at East Butler Road.
*
Please note that at the Planning Commission meeting the applicant indicated
that SCDOT has indicated that it will not permit the signal timing to be
altered at the intersection of Woodruff Road/Verdin Road/ Feaster Road.
The applicant expects that SCDOT will instead require turn lane
improvements. The applicant expressed that they plan to abide by the
requirements of SCDOT.
Access. The applicant is proposing three access points, subject to review and approval by SCDOT. This will
include one driveway at Tanner Road and two driveways at Verdin Road. Sidewalks will be installed along
Tanner Road and Verdin Road in order to promote walkability and connectivity.
47
Parking. In total, 784 parking spaces are proposed for this development project. This includes 542 surface
parking spaces for the apartments, 24 garage spaces for the apartments, 200 garage and driveway parking
spaces for the townhomes, and 18 garage spaces for the carriage homes. This is consistent with the minimum
parking requirements for the City of Mauldin which is presently 1.5 parking spaces for each multi -family
dwelling unit and 2.0 parking spaces for other dwellings. It appears that the parking being proposed is
consistent with the requirements for the City of Mauldin.
Util
ities. All utilities are available including water and sewer. The applicant has provided letters of capacity
and availability from the various utility providers. MetroConnects has a sewer line at Verdin Road that the
developer is expected to tie into.
NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING
The applicant held a neighborhood meeting on July 11, 2022. Based on the sign- in sheet, it appears that
nearly 30 neighbors attended the meeting. It appears that most of the attendees were from the Towns at
Woodruff Crossing townhome community on Tanner Road just outside the City of Mauldin and next door to
the proposed planned development.
Ac
cording to the meeting summary provided by the applicant, questions and concerns covered topics
including: traffic, amenities, tree preservation, stormwater runoff, landscape buffering and screening, light
pollution, trespassing by pedestrians, property values, and the capacity of infrastructure. Attached is the
applicant’s summary of the neighborhood meeting.
PUBLIC HEARING
The Planning Commission held a public hearing on August 23, 2022. The following citizens provided public
comments at this hearing.
Ja
ne Lawrence, 121 Ashgrove Lane (County resident), indicated that her questions and concerns
have been addressed by the applicant and she has no further comment.
Peggy Garland, 213 Louisville Drive (County resident), indicated that she is not opposed to the
development of this tract but also shared some concerns about the development of the site. Her
concerns included: (1) stormwater runoff that may affect the upkeep of the existing retention pond
at the adjacent Woodruff Crossing community, (2) the effect of additional sewer flow on the
deteriorating sewer pipes that currently serve the Woodruff Crossing community, and (3) cut-through
traffic from Tanner Road through the parking lots for the AAA Car Care Center to Hendrix Drive.
James Epling, 115 Ashgrove Lane (County resident), shared the following concerns: (1) insufficient
roadways to accommodate increasing traffic in the area, and (2) the effect of the proposed
development on property values in the Woodruff Crossing community.
48
PLANNING AND ZONING
About the PD District
Th
e PD district is established to encourage innovative and creative design of residential and/or commercial
developments and to permit a greater amount of flexibility by removing some of the restrictions of
conventional zoning. The procedures for a PD provide a mechanism to evaluate each application on its own
merit.
Surrounding Development/Zoning
The
se properties are surrounded by the following zoning and land uses:
Direction Zoning District(s) Existing Use(s)
North C-1/C-2 (County)
C-1 (City)
Express Oil Change, La Petite Academy,
Sonic Drive-In, Greenville Car Wash,
Master’s Mark Dry Cleaners, The Flat
South S-1 (City) Maple Brook Terrace Retirement
Community
East S-1/C-1 (County) Kids ‘R’ Kids Learning Academy
West C-2/R-M10 (County) AAA auto repair shop, strip shopping center
including various tenants, Towns at
Woodruff Crossing townhome community
Comprehensive Plan Vision
Th
is property is designated as an “employment center” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan.
Employment Center areas are intended for industrial parks and office parks.
STAFF FINDINGS
Staff has reviewed this request as follows.
CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS
1. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or,
if conditions h ave changed, consistency with
the overall intent of the Plan, recent
development trends, and the general character
of the area;
This property is designated as an “employment
center” in the future land use map of the
comprehensive plan. Employment Center areas are
intended for industrial parks and office parks.
However, with the number of vacancies in the
adjacent Brookfield Corporate Office Park, it is not
unreasonable to conclude that recent trends may
suggest that office park development is not as
viable as it once was pre-COVID.
The Planning Commission and the City Council
may or may not judge that the proposed planned
development is consistent with the intent of the
comprehensive plan, recent development trends,
and the general character of the area.
2. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological,
hydrological and other environmental features
to support the breadth and intensity of uses that
could be developed
To staff’s knowledge, there are no apparent
floodplains, wetlands, or topographic cons traints
on the site. Staff is not aware of any features at this
site that would make it unsuitable for development.
49
CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS
3. Compatibility of the potential uses allowed
with surrounding uses and zoning districts in
terms of suitability of location, impacts on the
environment, noise, density, nature of use,
traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop
adjacent properties under existing zoning, and
potential influence on property values
The tract is located in a transitional area between
commercial uses to the north, west, and east, an
office park to the south, a retirement apartment
community to the south, and a townhome
community to the west. The mix of apartments and
work spaces appears to represent a blend of some
of the surrounding uses, albeit the work space
aspect of the proposed planned development is a
relatively minor component.
As evident in the traffic impact study, this proposed
planned development would impact traffic at a
couple of the nearby intersections. However, the
traffic study recommends improvements to the
traffic system that would soften the impact of this
traffic.
4. Capacity of public infrastructure and services
to sufficiently accommodate potential uses
allowed without compromising pu blic health,
safety, or welfare
Staff is not aware of any utilities, including water
and sewer, that would not be available at this tract.
This project is expected to connect to the existing
MetroConnects sewer line along Verdin Road.
There is some concern about the road infrastructure
to be able to accommodate the additional traffic
generated by this proposed planned development.
This concern was expressed at the neighborhood
meeting. During peak hours, Verdin Road and
Feaster Road already experience failed traffic flow
(LOS F) at the intersection of Woodruff Road.
Additionally, Verdin Road is currently
approaching unstable flow (LOS D) at East Butler
Road during peak hours. The traffic study contains
recommendations that will attempt to mitigate the
impact of traffic generated by this planned
development. However, Verdin Road at Woodruff
Road will continue to experience failed traffic flow
(LOS F) and Verdin Road at East Butler Road will
continue to approach unstable flow (LOS D) even
with these improvements to the traffic system.
5. Public need for the potential uses permitted The Comprehensive Plan forecasts changing
lifestyles, such as young adults delaying marriage
and parenthood, will continue to increase the
demand for apartments and townhomes.
Additionally, the growing number of single-parent
households may also create more demand for
apartments and townhomes. This planned
development proposal would provide additional
living options that support this forecast in the
Comprehensive Plan.
50
TIMELINE
On July 11, 2022, the applicant met with interested neighbors to review their proposal and to seek questions
and comments.
On July 18, 2022, staff received the petition and accompanying documents to annex these tracts and
established a Planned Development (PD) district.
On August 1, 2022, (at the request of the applicant) the Building Codes Committee of City Council referred
the planned development proposal to Planning Commission for their review and recommendation.
On August 23, 2022, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing. At this meeting, the Planning
Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the Planned Development.
On September 6, 2022, the Building Codes Committee voted 2-0 to forward this annexation to City Council
for consideration.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
There are legitimate concerns about the traffic conditions along Verdin Road. One of the lingering questions
surrounding this project is whether the poor traffic conditions on Verdin Road will be detrimental to the
safety of motorists and pedestrians and the overall success and desirability of this development project.
The incorporation of multi -family dwelling units together with workspaces that could be used for
neighborhood retail and offices has great potential and could become a very desirable destination. The layout
for the project has been thoughtfully designed. The presence of neighborhood retail and office together with
angled parking lining the principal drive off of Verdin Road provide a “Main Street” feel. The incorporation
of the workspaces has the potential to really distinguish this development project. It’s nice that the parking
along Tanner Road is placed behind buildings. (It would be even better if the parking along Verdin Ro ad
was also placed behind buildings.) The combination of apartments, townhomes, and workspaces represents
a reasonable transition to all of the varied surrounding uses.
Ultimately, the Planning Commission and the City Council will need to make a judgment on any factors that
they deem pertinent.
PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION
On August 23, 2022, the Planning Commission voted 6- 0 to recommend approval of the Planning
Development. Their recommendation was contingent upon the following revisions to the statement of intent,
to which the applicant was agreeable. The applicant has agreed to each of these conditions and has since
updated the statement of intent to reflect each of these conditions.
1. Any conversion of work spaces to apartment units would require approval of a formal change to the
Planned Development in accordance with City of Mauldin procedures.
2. The buffering, landscaping, and fencing proposed adjacent to the Woodruff Crossing community
will be updated in the statement of intent to reflect what was presented at the Planning Commission
meeting.
3. Traffic improvements and traffic mitigation measures will be installed or implemented as required
and approved by SCDOT.
51
ATTACHMENTS
Annexation Ordinances
Neighborhood Meeting documents
Planned Development documents
52
ORDINANCE -2022
AN ORDINANCE TO PROVIDE FOR THE ANNEXATION OF
PROPERTY OWNED BY W. EARL JONES AND NANCY L. JONES,
AND LOCATED AT 30 TANNER ROAD (TAX MAP PARCEL:
0547.03-01-043.01) BY ONE HUNDRED PERCENT PETITION
METHOD; AND TO ESTABLISH A ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF
PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, FOR SAID PROPERTY
WHEREAS, W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, are the sole owners of record
title of a parcel of real property containing 0.9 acres, more or less, located at 30
Tanner Road, which property is contiguous to the City of Mauldin and is more
particularly illustrated in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and,
WHEREAS, an Annexation Petition, attached hereto as Exhibit 2, has been
filed with the City of Mauldin by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, requesting
that the aforementioned property be annexed into the City of Mauldin; and,
WHEREAS, the property to be annexed is contiguous to the City of Mauldin,
and is more particularly depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and,
WHEREAS, W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, constitute one hundred
(100%) percent of freeholders owning one hundred (100%) of the real property
depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and,
WHEREAS, the proposed zoning of PD, Planned Development, is compatible
with the surrounding property uses in the area; and,
WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council conclude that the annexation is in the
best interest of the property owner and the City;
NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the Mayor and Council of the City of
Mauldin that:
1. ANNEXATION: The real property owned by W. Earl Jones and Nancy
L. Jones, and more particularly depicted in the map attached hereto marked as
Exhibit 1, is hereby annexed into the corporate city limits of the City of Mauldin
effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance.
2. ANNEXATION OF A PORTION OF ADJACENT RIGHTS-OF-WAY: All
of that portion of Tanner Road along the edge of and adjoined to the annexed
property shown on the attached Exhibit to the centerline of the afore-mentioned
right-of-way is also hereby annexed into the corporate limits of the City of Mauldin
effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance.
3. ZONING ASSIGNMENT: The above referenced property owned is
hereby zoned PD, Planned Development, as detailed in Exhibit 3 attached hereto.
53
____________________________________
Terry Merritt, Mayor
ATTEST:
________________________________________
Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk
First Reading: _________________________
Second Reading: ______________________
Approved as to Form:
________________________________________
City Attorney
54
EXHIBIT 1 – ANNEXATION MAP
55
EXHIBIT 2 – PETITION
56
57
58
ORDINANCE -2022
AN ORDINANCE TO PROVIDE FO
R THE ANNEXATION OF
PROPERTY OWNED BY W. EARL JONES, AND LOCATED AT 30
TANNER ROAD (TAX MAP PARCEL: 0547.03-01-043.02) BY ONE
HUNDRED PERCENT PETITION METHOD; AND TO ESTABLISH A
ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT,
FOR SAID PROPERTY
WHEREAS, W. Earl Jones is the sole
owner of record title of a parcel of real
property containing 6.7 acres, more or less, located at 30 Tanner Road, which
property is contiguous to the City of Mauldin and is more particularly illustrated
in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and,
WHEREAS, an Annexation Petition, attached hereto as Exhibit 2, has b
een
filed with the City of Mauldin by W. Earl Jones requesting that the aforementioned
property be annexed into the City of Mauldin; and,
WHEREAS, the property to be annexed
is contiguous to the City of Mauldin,
and is more particularly depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and,
WHEREAS, W. Earl Jones constitutes one hundred (100%) percent of
freeholders owning one hundred (100%) of the real property depicted in Exhibit 1
attached hereto; and,
WHEREAS, the proposed zoning of
PD, Planned Development, is compatible
with the surrounding property uses in the area; and,
WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council conclude that the annex
ation is in the
best interest of the property owner and the City;
NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by th
e Mayor and Council of the City of
Mauldin that:
1. ANNEXATION: The real property owned by W. Earl Jones, and more
particularly depicted in the map attached hereto marked as
Exhibit 1, is hereby
annexed into the corporate city limits of the City of Mauldin effective immediately
upon second reading of this ordinance.
2. ANNEXATION OF A PORTION OF ADJA
CENT RIGHTS-OF-WAY: All
of that portion of Tanner Road along the edge of and adjoined to the annexed
property shown on the attached Exhibit to the centerline of the afore-mentioned
right-of-way is also hereby annexed into the corporate limits of the City of Mauldin
effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance.
3. ZONING ASSIGNMENT: The above referenced property owned is
hereby zoned PD, Planned Development, as detailed in Exhib
it 3 attached hereto.
59
____________________________________
Terry Merritt, Mayor
ATTEST:
________________________________________
Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk
First Reading: _________________________
Second Reading: ______________________
Approved as to Form:
________________________________________
City Attorney
60
EXHIBIT 1 – ANNEXATION MAP
61
EXHIBIT 2 – PETITION
62
63
64
ORDINANCE -2022
AN ORDINANCE TO PROVIDE FO
R THE ANNEXATION OF
PROPERTY OWNED BY C. LYNN FARMER AND ELAINE F.
AYSCUE, AND LOCATED AT 50 TANNER ROAD (TAX MAP
PARCEL: 0547.03-01-043.00) BY ONE HUNDRED PERCENT
PETITION METHOD; AND TO ESTABLISH A ZONING
CLASSIFICATION OF PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, FOR SAID
PROPERTY
WHEREAS, C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue, are the s
ole owners of
record title of a parcel of real property containing 13 acres, more or less, located
at 50 Tanner Road, which property is contiguous to the City of Mauldin and is
more particularly illustrated in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and,
WHEREAS, an Annexation Petition, attached hereto as Exhibit 2, has been
filed with the City of Mauldin by C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue, requesting
that the aforementioned property be annexed into the City of Mauldin; and,
WHEREAS, the property to be annexed
is contiguous to the City of Mauldin,
and is more particularly depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and,
WHEREAS, C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue, constitute one hundred
(100%) percent of freeholders owning one hundred (100%) of the real property
depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and,
WHEREAS, the proposed zoning of
PD, Planned Development, is compatible
with the surrounding property uses in the area; and,
WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council conclude that the annex
ation is in the
best interest of the property owner and the City;
NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by th
e Mayor and Council of the City of
Mauldin that:
1. ANNEXATION: The real property owned by C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine
F. Ayscue, and more particularly depicted in the map attached hereto marked as
Exhibit 1, is hereby annexed into the corporate city limits of the City of Mauldin
effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance.
2. ANNEXATION OF A PORTION OF ADJA
CENT RIGHTS-OF-WAY: All
of that portion of Tanner Road and Verdin Road along the edge of and adjoined to
the annexed property shown on the attached Exhibit to the centerline of the afore-
mentioned right-of-way is also hereby annexed into the corporate limits of the City
of Mauldin effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance.
65
3. ZONING ASSIGNMENT: The above referenced property owned is
hereby zoned PD, Planned Development, as detailed in Exhibit 3 attached hereto.
____________________________________
Terry Merritt, Mayor
ATTEST:
________________________________________
Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk
First Reading: _________________________
Second Reading: ______________________
Approved as to Form:
________________________________________
City Attorney
66
EXHIBIT 1 – ANNEXATION MAP
67
EXHIBIT 2 – PETITION
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM
MEETI
NG DATE: September 19, 2022
AGE
NDA ITEM: 8c
TO:
City Council
FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug
SUBJECT: Code Enforcement of Nuisances
BACKGROUND
The City of Mauldin’s nuisance ordinance currently refers to the Building and Zoning Director as responsible
for the enforcement of the standards therein. Not only does the City not have a position by this name, but it
has been the City’s practice for the City’s code enforcement officer to conduct the enforcement of the City’s
nuisance standards.
DRAFT ORDINANCE
The attached ordinance, reviewed by the City Attorney, replaces the Building and Zoning Director with the
Code Enforcement Official as the staff responsible for the enforcement of the City’s nuisance standards.
See t
he attached draft ordinance for the full text of said ordinance.
TIME LINE
On September 6, 2022, the Building Codes Committee voted 2- 0 to forward this ordinance to City Council
for consideration.
REQUEST
This draft ordinance is being presented to the Building Codes Committee at this time for review and
comment. If the Committee chooses, they may recommend this ordinance to the City Council for review.
ATTACHMENTS
Draft Ordinance
92
ORDINANCE # __________
AN AME
NDMENT TO CHAPTER 18, ARTICLE II (NUISANCES)
OF THE MAULDIN CODE OF ORDINANCES TO AUTHORIZE
THE CODES ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL RATHER THAN THE
BUILDING AND ZONING DIRECTOR TO ENFORCE CERTAIN
PROVISIONS CONTAINED HEREIN AND FOR OTHER
MATTERS RELATED THERETO
WH
EREAS, the Mauldin City Council at various times reviews the city ordinances to make
necessary improvements and/or changes; and,
WH
EREAS, the City of Mauldin recognizes the need to protect against nuisances that may
impair public health, safety, and general welfare; and,
WH
EREAS, the City of Mauldin desires to amend its ordinance to authorize the codes
enforcement official rather than then the building and zoning director to take enforce certain
provisions contained in Chapter 18, Article II; and,
WH
EREAS, the City of Mauldin finds that the following amendments to Chapter 18,
Article II (Nuisance) promotes the health, safety, and welfare of the citizens and residents of the
City of Mauldin.
NOW
THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of
Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof that the Mauldin
Municipal Code be amended as follows:
Section 1 Amendment. Amend Chapter 18, Article II, Nuisances, as follows ( language that is
struck through is language proposed to be deleted, underlined language is language proposed to be
added, language is not struck through or underlined is not to be changed, and *** represents
sections of the Zoning Ordinance that have been skipped and remain unchanged):
CHAP
TER 18 – ENVIRONMENT
***
AR
TICLE II. – NUISANCES
DIV
ISION 1. – GENERALLY
Se
ction 18-31. – Condition of premises generally.
All persons shall maintain their yards, cellars, drains, stable lots and all other lands owned
or occupied by them in the city, whether occupied or vacant, in a clean and healthy condition.
It shall be unlawful for the owner or occupant of any premises within the city limits to permit
such premises to become filthy, dirty or so filled with rubbish as to emit dangerous or
disagreeable odors to the annoyance or discomfort of persons who reside or transact business
in that locality or who may pass along any street, lane, ally or sidewalk in the vicinity. Any
place so kept or permitted is hereby declared a nuisance, subject to abatement by the building
93
and zoning director code enforcement official or other official designated by the City
Administrator.
Sect
ion 18-32. – Report of unsanitary conditions to council.
It shall be the duty of the building and zoning director the code enforcement official or other
official designated by the City Administrator to report unsanitary conditions of buildings
and premises to the City Administrator, who, in turn, shall inform the city council.
Se
ction 18-33. – Prohibited acts.
It
shall be unlawful for any person to do any act which offends, endangers, injures or impairs
the health, safety or life of any individual. Any such act is hereby declared a public nuisance.
Se
ction 18-34. – Unsanitary, unsightly and unsafe conditions.
(a) A
ll premises within the city, whether vacant, improved or occupied, shall at all times
be kept in a sanitary condition. All damp low places and all garbage, leaves, trash
cans, vessels, broken bottles, pieces of metal, china, glass or other materials that may
hold water are hereby declared to be a public nuisance. Weeds, grass and other rank
vegetation which is allowed to grow, stand uncut upon, or garbage, trash, eroded soil
and other debris allowed to accumulate and remain on any lot or allowed to spill into
the public right -of-way, so as to render the premises unsightly or unsanitary, are
hereby deemed and declared to be a public nuisance and a detriment to health and
safety. The occupant or lessee of any such premises and the owner, his agent,
representative or employee having control of any vacant premises within the city
who shall permit or tolerate the existence of any conditions condemned in this section
shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.
(b) I
t shall be the duty of any owner and any lessee, occupant, agent or representative of
the owner of any lot or parcel of land to cut or cause to be cut all weeds, grass and
other rank vegetation and to remove all garbage, trash, eroded soil and other debris
as often as may be necessary to prevent the development o f any of the conditions
which are prohibited in this section.
Se
ction 18-35. – Conditions affording food or harborage for rats.
(a) I
t shall be unlawful for any person to place, leave, dump or permit to accumulate any
garbage, rubbish or trash in any building, vehicle and their surrounding areas in the
city so that the same shall or may afford food or harborage for rats. Any violation of
this section shall constitute a public nuisance.
(b) I
t shall be unlawful and constitute a public nuisance for any person to permit to
accumulate on any premises, improved or vacant, or on any open lots or alleys in the
city, any lumber, boxes, barrels, bricks, stones or similar materials and permit them
to remain thereon unless the same shall be placed on open racks that are elevated not
less than 18 inches above the ground and evenly piled or stacked, so that these
materials will not afford harborage for rates or violate any other provisions of this
article.
94
Se
ction 18-36. – Abatement.
(a) The building and zoning director code enforcement official, upon receiving notice of
the existence of any condition declared by this article, shall notify the existence of
any condition declared by this article, shall notify the person responsible for such
condition to clean up his premises and abate such public nuisance within ten days.
It shall be sufficient notification to deliver the notice or a copy thereof to the person
to whom it is addressed or to deposit a copy of such notice in the United States mail
properly stamped and directed to such person at his last known address and post a
copy thereof on the premises upon which the public nuisance exists. If service of
notice cannot be obtained in either of such methods, notice will be posted in a
conspicuous place, for 24 hours, on the premises where the violation has occurred.
(b) U
pon failure of the person to abate the cited public nuisance, as provided for in this
section, within ten days after notice, a person violating these provisions of this
section shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor and punished in accordance with
section 1-6.
(c) T
he employees or agents of the City may enter upon the premises of the offending
person and cause the public nuisance to be removed therefrom. The cost of removing
such nuisance shall become a lien upon the land, and such person shall be liable to
the city for the costs of removal or abatement in addition to being subject to
prosecution for violating this article.
Se
ction 18-37. – Right of entry to abate.
The building and zoning director code enforcement official, together with his subordinates,
assistants, workers, employees and agents, shall have the power to enter upon any premises
within the City upon which there is suspected to be a public nuisance for the purpose of
abating the same. Any person who in any manner hinders or obstructs any authorized officer
or representative of the city in the inspecting of any premises within the City limits, in the
abatement or removal of any public nuisance, or in the discharge of any duties prescribed in
this article or any other ordinance for the prevention or correction of any unsanitary,
unsightly, or unsafe condition in the City shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.
***
Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage.
Pa
ssed on First Reading: _______________________________
Pa
ssed on Second Reading: ______________________________
95
CI
TY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA
BY
: ________________________________
Terry Merritt, Mayor
ATTES
T:
___________________________________
Cin
dy Miller, Municipal Clerk
APP
ROVED AS TO FORM:
___________________________________
Da
niel Hughes, City Attorney
96
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM
MEETI
NG DATE: September 19, 2022
AGE
NDA ITEM: 8d
TO: City Council
FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug
SUBJECT: Light Trespass Ordinance
BACKGROUND
Earlier this year, staff was asked to examine and explore the opportunity to consider outdoor lighting
standards that could address nuisances created by outdoor lighting, particularly in residential neighborhoods.
Some draft standards were considered by City Council on June 20, 2022. At that meeting, various members
of City Council discussed concerns including:
• Wha
t training or equipment will be required to enforce the standards of the ordinance?
• Preference for standards that are quantitative and can be measured rather than standards that may
require the judgment of the enforcement officer
• Preference for standards that don’t rely on the interpretation of an official
• Preference for a radius where the complaint can be generated
CURRENT MAULDIN STANDARDS
Presently, the City of Mauldin has some outdoor lighting standards prescribed in Section 6:3.1 of the Mauldin
Zoning Ordinance. These provisions primarily apply to new development and where new outdo or lighting
fixtures are installed, except that these provisions do not apply to single -family residential properties even
though single-family residential properties may be the cause of glare and light pollution to other single-family
properties. Additionally, these provisions do not apply to street lighting installed by a governmental agency.
NEIGHBORING JURISDICTIONS STANDARDS
Most of the other nearby jurisdictions, including Greenville County, the City of Simpsonville, and the City
of Greer, have compa rable outdoor lighting standards to the City of Mauldin and exempt single -family
residential properties from outdoor lighting standards. Only the City of Greenville provides lighting
standards that also apply at single-family residential properties.
DUKE ENERGY PROCEDURES
City staff recently had the opportunity to meet with Duke Energy officials to discuss the provisions being
considered by the City of Mauldin. These officials commented that light glare is very difficult to define and
enforce. Their experience is that what is perceived as glare is different from case to case. They advised that
it is much easier to define, measure, and enforce light trespass as measured in foot -candles. They also
expressed that the height restrictions that the City was considering for lights was not consistent with their
practice. The light poles that they typically install have a height of about 25 feet above the ground, not
97
including pedestrian lights which generally are shorter. They also advised that restricting light pole height
may have little effect if adjacent properties have different grade elevations.
Th
ese officials also explained the procedures the follow when installing light poles and reviewing subsequent
complaints. A property owner who requests the installation of a Duke light pole is required to sign a contract
with Duke Energy. Included in the contract is a provision that the customer agrees to abide by local
ordinances. When Duke Energy receives complaints about lights, they generally direct the com plainant to
talk directly to the property owner of the offending light. They do this to avoid getting in the middle of
neighbor disputes. The property owner is able to request that Duke Energy make adjustments to the light to
mitigate the concerns from a neighbor. Depending on the nature of the concern, Duke Energy is able to
shield the light, lower the light on the pole, change out the color of the light, among other solutions. Duke
Energy indicated that they generally respond in about 3- 5 days, although on occasion they may be delayed
due to extenuating circumstances.
DRAFT ORDINANCE
In response to the input receive from various members of City Council as well as Duke Energy officials, the
attached draft ordinance has been greatly simplified. Specific ally, the ordinance identifies exemptions
including traffic control signals and devices, street lights, temporary emergency lighting, moving vehicle
lights, navigation lights, public sports and recreational facilities, seasonal decorations, and other lighting on
City of Mauldin property or as may be required by SCDOT. The standards prescribed by the draft ordinance
include:
1. Li
ghting may not illuminate an adjacent residential property in excess of 0.5 foot -candles of light;
and
2. No blinking, flashing, or fl uttering lights or other illuminated device that has a changing light
intensity, brightness, or color is permitted in any district.
See t
he attached draft ordinance for the full text of said ordinance.
The
limit of 0.5 foot -candles is the same as used in the zoning ordinance for nonresidential properties that
abut residential properties. Please note that 0.5 foot-candles is about the equivalent light level of a standard
60-watt incandescent light bulb measured at a distance of about 11 feet from the bulb. If measuring a standard
100-watt incandescent light bulb, it would be the light level at distance of about 16 feet from the light bulb.
These figures may differ depending on varying factors.
Ple
ase note that in order to enforce this draft ordinance the City will need to purchase light meter devices
which generally cost between $50 and $500 for each device. The Police Chief has commented that the
officers that may assist in the enforcement of this ordinance will also need training. If there are frequent
complaints of light trespass, the Police Chief has indicated that he may need to hire an additional code
enforcement officer.
TIMELINE
On June 6, 2022, the Building Codes Committee voted 3-0 to forward a draft ordinance to City Council for
consideration.
On
June 20, 2022, the City Council discussed a draft ordinance and referred it back to the Building Codes
Committee.
On S
eptember 6, 2022, the Building Codes Committee voted 2- 0 to forward this ordinance to City Council
for consideration.
98
ATTACHMENTS
Draft Ordinance
99
ORDINANCE # __________
AN AME
NDMENT TO CHAPTER 18, ARTICLE II (NUISANCES)
OF THE MAULDIN CODE OF ORDINANCES TO ESTABLISH
CERTAIN STANDARDS TO PROTECT AGAINST NUISANCES
CAUSED BY LIGHT TRESPASS AND FOR OTHER MATTERS
RELATED THERETO
WH
EREAS, the Mauldin City Council at various times reviews the city ordinances to make
necessary improvements and/or changes; and,
WH
EREAS, the City of Mauldin recognizes the need to protect against nuisances that may
impair public health, safety, and general welfare; and,
WH
EREAS, the City of Mauldin also desires to amend its ordinance to add “Division 4 –
Light Glare and Light Trespass” to protect against light trespass that may impair the enjoyment of
life and constitute a public nuisance; and,
WH
EREAS, the City of Mauldin finds that the following amendments to Chapter 18,
Article II (Nuisance) promotes the health, safety, and welfare of the citizens and residents of the
City of Mauldin.
NOW
THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of
Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof that the Mauldin
Municipal Code be amended as follows:
Section 1 Amendment. Amend Chapter 18, Article II, Nuisances, as follows ( language that is
struck through is language proposed to be deleted, underlined language is language proposed to be
added, language is not struck through or underlined is not to be changed, and *** represents
sections of the Zoning Ordinance that have been skipped and remain unchanged):
CHAP
TER 18 – ENVIRONMENT
***
AR
TICLE II. – NUISANCES
***
DIVISION 4 – LIGHT TRESPASS
Section 18-101. – Purpose
The purpose of this section is to provide regulations that control light trespass onto
adjacent residential properties.
100
Section 18-102 – Definitions
(a) “Foot- candle” – A measure of illuminance or a measure of how bright a light
appears to the eye. One foot-candle is equal to one lumen per square foot. As an example,
a typical sixty-watt incandescent lamp (eight hundred forty lumens) produces an illuminance
of 0.1 foot-candles at a distance of about twenty-five feet.
(b) "Light trespass" – Any light emitted by an outdoor luminaire that shines
directly or indirectly beyond the property on which the luminaire is installed.
(c) “Luminaire” – A complete lighting unit including the lamps, together with
the parts required to distribute the light, to position and protect the lamps, and to connect the
lamps to the power supply.
Section 18-103. – Applicability.
(a) The requirements of this section shall apply to all private and public property
within the City except as may be exempted below.
(b) The following are exempt from the provisions of this chapter.
(1) Traffic control signals and devices;
(2) Street lights;
(3) Temporary emergency lighting (i.e., fire, police, repair workers) or
warning lights;
(4) Moving vehicle lights;
(5) Navigation lights (i.e., communication towers, etc.) or any other lights
where state or federal statute or other provision of the City of Mauldin
codes and regulations that requires lighting which cannot comply with
this section;
(6) Public sports and recreational facilities;
(7) Seasonal decorations; and
(8) Other lighting on City of Mauldin property or as may required by
SCDOT.
Section 18-104. – Specific Standards for Lighting.
(a) Lighting may not illuminate an adjacent residential property in exce ss of a
measurement of 0.5 foot-candles of light.
101
(b) No blinking, flashing or fluttering lights or other illuminated device that has
a changing light intensity, brightness, or color is permitted in any district except for
temporary holiday displays.
Section 18-105. – Violations.
(a) Upon receipt of a complaint, the code enforcement official or other city
designee shall take appropriate light measurements with a light meter device at the property
line of the party that placed the complaint. If a violation of this section is found to exist, the
offending party will be given not more than thirty (30) days to remedy the violation.
Appropriate remedies may include concealing or shielding the light source.
(b) If the violation is not corrected within the prescribed period, the codes
enforcement official or other city designee may either seek an injunctive relief through the
Greenville County Court of Common Pleas and/or issue a citation.
(c) Violation of the provisions of this chapter of failure to comply with any of its
requirements shall constitute a misdemeanor. Upon conviction thereof, the person may be
fined not more than five hundred dollars or imprisoned for not more than thirty days and in
addition shall pay all costs and expenses involved in the case. Each day such violation
continues shall be considered a separate offense.
Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage.
Pa
ssed on First Reading: _______________________________
Pa
ssed on Second Reading: ______________________________
CI
TY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA
BY
: ________________________________
Terry Merritt, Mayor
ATTES
T:
___________________________________
Cin
dy Miller, Municipal Clerk
APP
ROVED AS TO FORM:
102
___________________________________
Da
niel Hughes, City Attorney
103
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ME
ETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8e
TO: C
ity Council
FROM: Chief Brian McHone
SUBJECT: Amend Standards for Open Burning
REQUEST
To consider an ordinance to amend certain standards pertaining to open burning.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
The City of Mauldin’s current code of ordinances states all open burn permits must be approved by City
Council. In last month’s Public Safety Committee meeting, there was discussion to remove this
requirement from the code.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
City Attorney Daniel Hughes has reviewed the draft ordinance to remove the requirement for Council
approval of open burning.
FISCAL IMPACT
None
RECOMMENDATION
Approval on first reading
ATTACHMENTS
Proposed ordinance
104
ORD
INANCE # __________
AN AME
NDMENT TO CHAPTER 20, ARTICLE I , GENERAL
FIRE PREVENTION AND PROTECTION, OF THE MAULDIN
CODE OF ORDINANCES TO AMEND CERTAIN STANDARDS
PERTAINING TO OPEN BURNING AND FOR OTHER
MATTERS RELATED THERETO
WH
EREAS, the Mauldin City Council at various times reviews the city ordinances to
make necessary improvements and/or changes; and,
WH
EREAS, the City of Mauldin recognizes the need to impose regulations pertaining to
open burning in order to protect public health, safety, and general welfare; and,
WH
EREAS, the City of Mauldin finds that the following amendment s to Chapter 20,
Article I promote the health, safety, and welfare of the citizens and residents of the City of Mauldin.
NOW
THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of
Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof that the Mauldin
Municipal Code be amended as follows:
Section 1 Amendment. Amend Chapter 20, Fire Prevention and Protection, Article I, In General,
as follows ( language that is struck through is language proposed to be deleted, underlined
language is language proposed to be added, language is not struck through or underlined is not
to be changed, and *** represents sections of the Zoning Ordinance that have been skipped and
remain unchanged):
CHAP
TER 20 – FIRE PREVENTION AND PROTECTION
AR
TICLE I. – IN GENERAL
***
Sec.
20-8. – Open burning.
(a) I
t shall be unlawful for any person to start, or cause to be started, an open fire to burn
any woodlands, brush, grass, structures, leaves, debris or other matter, except as
provided in this section.
(b) T
he city fire department may burn for official training purposes.
(c) T
he city may issue a burning permit, at its discretion, for the burning of trees, brush,
and undergrowth on land in excess of five acres where such land has been cleared for
development, under the following conditions:
(1) Burning for land clearing shall only be performed by a contractor duly licensed
in the state of South Carolina. The applicant shall give the city notice in writing
of all information required by the city. This notice shall include, but not be
105
limited to
, the location of the proposed burn, the material to be burned, the times
and dates of the proposed burn, and the location of public roads, streets,
property lines, and dwellings in the proximity of the burn.
(2) The applicant shall clear the area around the burn site and have immedi ately
available sufficient equipment and personnel to adequately secure the fire and
prevent its spread. If, in the opinion of the fire department, it is necessary for
the city to send fire department equipment to the burn site, the applicant shall
be responsible to pay for the reasonable cost thereof, as determined by the city.
Should burning become a danger to life or to property, the city may, without
prior notice, put out the fire.
(3) Only debris generated from the site may be burned. No matter may be burned
which is not native to the site. No materials shall be burned in violation of any
DHEC regulations and comply with the South Carolina Forestry Commission
burn regulations.
(4) The applicant shall conduct the burn at such location and under such conditions
that smoke or fumes will not go onto any roadway or the property of others and
not pose a health or environmental hazard. Weather, atmospheric conditions
and recent rainfall shall also be factors to be considered. Burning is permitted
only during such weather conditions as may deemed favorable for burning by
the chief of the fire department. Should adverse weather conditions arise after
the commencement of burning, the contractor shall put out any fires if directed
to do so by the chief of the fire department or his or her designee.
(5) N
o burning shall be carried out during any period which the governor or other
authorized official has declared that an emergency exists in connection with
forest fires or open burning.
(6) The applicant agrees to be f ully responsible for any damages or injuries to
others as a result of the burning activity. The city requires the applicant to
provide proof of liability insurance through an insurance company licensed with
the state of South Carolina in such amounts as determined by the city and not
less than $300,000.00.
(7) T
he city may impose such other conditions and restrictions as are deemed
appropriate based on the type and size of the proposed burn.
(8) The chief of the fire department and city administrator are authorized to
establish additional rules and regulations for burning permits. Should the
contractor or anyone else conducting a burning operation fail to comply with
any directions or conditions set by the chief or city administrator, the burning
operation shall immediately cease.
(9) The applicant will pay a permit fee , if any, as determined by resolution of the
city council. The permit shall be valid for a period of 30 days from the date of
issuance. No permit shall be issued without the approval of the city council.
106
(d) Thi
s section shall not prohibit cooking fires built in fireplaces, grills or barbecue pits
which shall be kept under competent and continuous supervision.
(e) T
he city may issue permits for open fires as part of special events under such terms and
conditions as provided by the city.
(f) Any person violating any provision of this section shall be subject to the penalties
provided for in Chapter 1, Section 1-6 of this Code.
***
Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage.
Pa
ssed on First Reading: _______________________________
Pa
ssed on Second Reading: ______________________________
CI
TY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA
BY
: ________________________________
Terry Merritt, Mayor
ATTES
T:
___________________________________
Cin
dy Miller, Municipal Clerk
APP
ROVED AS TO FORM:
___________________________________
Da
niel Hughes, City Attorney
107
CITY COUNCIL
AGEND
A ITEM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8f
TO:
FROM
:
SUBJECT:
City Council
J.R. Charles, Community Development Director
Consider Proposal from United Infrastructure Gr oup (UIG) to Complete the Mauldin Trail
REQUEST
To consider a proposal by United Infrastructure Group for the final portion of construction of the Mauldin
Trail. This construction project will create a completed trail between East Butler Road and the Bridgeway
Station Pedestrian Bridge
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
The Community Development Department reached out to UIG to ask if they would provide engineering
information/studies related to their original bid for the construction of the Mauldin Trail and the
Bridgeway Station Pedestrian Bridge. Mr. Michael Gantt said that UIG had created a preliminary design
of a trail based on an as-built study provided by AECOM. UIG did not have any other engineered
drawings that showed a construction plan for the Mauldin Trail.
Follow
ing up on this conversation, Mr. Gantt expressed an interest to bid on completing the Mauldin
Trail and connecting it to the Bridgeway Station Pedestrian Bridge. .
UIG has
provided a proposal which includes the following:
• The proposal includes all design and construction based on the 2020 RFP originally issued by the
City. UIG is proposing their plan as a unified project; in other words, it will include both the
engineering design and construction in a single proposal. The proposal will be ADA compliant; it
will exclude any signage/pavement markings since UIG does not know what is already
constructed on the trail.
• UIG’s quote assumes it will source material from the site in order to create a balanced
construction profile. In other words, they would use the existing dirt at the site to create a
smooth topography. This will prevent any trucking in of material to fill uneven terrain, as well as
minimize the disposal of any materials offsite.
• UIG proposes that it will cut approximately 250 feet of existing trail in order to fill in the
remaining 250 feet of required trail to make the connection to the Bridgeway Station Pedestrian
Bridge.
• The proposed start date of the project is October 2022, but this timeframe is dependent on how
UIG’s other projects progress.
• The design estimate is $30,000. The construction estimate is $201,500. The total cost of the
total proposal of $231,500.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
UIG’s proposed methodology for constructing the trail, namely the reclamation/reuse of existing trail to
be used to construct the remaining portion of the trail, is a key consideration. The Preliminary Profile
provided by UIG proposes the last 250 feet of the trail be used as material fill to construct the 250-275
108
feet of new trail which will connect to the bridge. By cutting the existing trail, UIG would create a
shallower drop in grade, reducing the potential for a sharp change in grade/elevation. While the
prospect of reclaiming and repurposing 250 feet of constructed trail is difficult to accept, the resulting
topographical change to the trail will more even path to meet the bridge.
Hughes
Investments is open to entering into partnership similar to the one created for the construction
of the Bridgeway Station Pedestrian Bridge: create a public/private partnership between the City and
Hughes Investment, allow Hughes Investment to select a contractor (in this case UIG), and the City enter
into a reimbursement agreement with Hughes Investments for the completion of the construction
project.
This is a d
ecision regarding the financial capacity of the City relative to the timing of the opening the of
Bridgeway Station Pedestrian Bridge. UIG is proposing a packaged project that encompasses both the
engineering and construction of the remaining Mauldin Trail for $231,500, and its start-time of October
could mean a completion date of December 2022 or January 2023. This exercise in collecting a proposal
from UIG gives the City a preview of the cost and timing to build the remaining portion of the trail,
whether that is UIG or another entity.
FISCAL IMPACT
If the City Council accepts UIG’s bid, it must identify a source for the $231,500 proposal. This item was not
identified in the FY-23 budget.
RECOMMENDATION
The Community Development Department recommends constructing the remaining portion of the trail.
The decision to engage UIG for the project or engage with AECOM to fund an engineering study only is a
City Council decision.
The adva
ntages to choosing to engage with UIG are: up-front knowledge of the entire cost of the
project, thereby creating the potential for a “Not To Exceed” cost scenario and the potential for
continuity in construction by allowing UIG to construct both the Pedestrian Bridge and complete the
trail.
The disadvan
tages of choosing UIG are: the City will be locked into a comprehensive contract for both
the engineering and construction of the trail; UIG’s availability may be undetermined due to its project
load/schedule; and the opportunity cost of choosing UIG, thereby removing the potential for a
construction quote from AECOM.
ATTACHMENTS
• “Swamp Rabbit Trail Connection to Pedestrian Bridge
• Email containing conversation between Community
Development Department and Mr. Michael Gantt of UIG
109
1. Instructions
1.1. Submission of Proposals
To be considered, interested parties should send one electronic (.pdf) version of a fully responsive
proposal. All proposal
s must be received on October 26, 2020 by noon (closing date and time) at
which time they will be opened in the upstairs conference room at City Hall. Proposals can be
emai
led to mputnam@mauldincitysc.com or mailed to the following address:
City of Mauld
in
Mark Putnam
5 East Butler Road
PO Box 249
Mauldin, SC 29662
(864) 289-8890
Offerors wish
ing to make changes to their proposals after submission but prior to noon may do so
by submitting the revisions by fax, email or hard copy. It is the Offeror’s sole responsibility to ensure
the revisions are received by the City prior to the closing date and time. Proposals received after the
closing date and time may not be accepted or considered.
Respons
es to this request for proposals will allow the City to rank the Offerors and enter
negotiations with the Offeror whose proposal is deemed most advantageous to the City with price
and other factors considered.
2. Introducti
on
2.1. Purpose
The City is requesting proposals from qualified contractors/firms for the design, build &
construction administration for paving approximately (0.25 mile) of trail, eleven (11) feet wide,
and related work such as quality control and assurance. Firms interested in providing the
aforementioned services must prepare and submit a proposal in accordance with the Scope of
Services in this Request for Proposals. The City will review proposals only from those firms that
include all of the information required to be included as described herein (in the sole judgment
of the City).
2.2. Backgr
ound
The City of Mauldin intends to construct a trail head and a section of the Swamp Rabbit Trail
along a .25 easement. This section will serve as the City’s first section of the Swamp Rabbit
Trail and will ultimately connect to a pedestrian bridge that will span across I-385.
3. Scope of Wor
k
The Swamp Rabbit Trail is a 22-mile multi-use (cycling, walking and running) greenway that traverses
throughout cities in Greenville County, SC. Currently, the trail commences in Travelers Rest and
traverses through the City of Greenville, SC. The City expects that the trail will eventually connect
to Mauldin. In anticipation of this future connection, the City has identified a location within the
City to construct a section of the trail. The proposed trail will begin on East Butler Road near the
Mauldin High School parking entrance for students and their athletic facilities and will traverse for a
distance of approximately .25 mile as detailed in Attachment A. In addition to the trail, the City
intends to construct a brick entryway for accessing the trail. Attachment B is a preliminary design
for the entryway.
110
The p
roposed Trail shall be eleven (11) feet wide and approximately 0.25 mile long and should
include a six inch crusher run base course that is properly compacted. The Trail should be
constructed per the attached specifications – Attachment C.
3.1. Proj
ect Manager
The Contractor will name a Project Manager who will be a single point of contact for City staff.
The Project Manager will be ultimately responsible for, but not limited to, the coordination,
quality control, invoicing, and successful completion of the project. The Project Manager shall
also be responsible for efficiently coordinating the Program Team (utility coordination, right-of-
way management, construction teams, etc.), furnishing all labor, materials, equipment, tools,
transportation, and supplies required to complete the project in accordance with the Plans,
Specifications and terms of the Contract. The Project Manager shall ensure the performance of
all services required by this document, within budget and the scheduled completion dates. It
shall be agreed and understood that all services performed shall be performed in the most
highly professional and ethical manner and each project shall be in accordance with the highest
industry standards.
3.2. Cont
ractor Requirements
The Contractor will implement a Quality Assurance / Quality Control program to ensure
material and construction practices conform to the latest published edition of the South
Carolina Department of Transportation Specifications, Construction Plans (where applicable),
the Contract and the enclosed Special Provisions. The work herein consists of applicable
construction methods to apply asphaltic surface course to compacted six-inch crusher run base.
Unless the means or methods of performing a task are specified or referenced elsewhere in this
document, the Contractor shall employ methods, at a minimum, considered industry standard
practices and conform to SCDOT and Specifications. This does not preclude the use of and/or
suggestion of new and innovative construction practices.
The Con
tractor must be a licensed general contractor in the State of South Carolina. Reference:
South Carolina Department of Labor, Licensing and Regulation, and South Carolina Contractors
Licensing Board.
The C
ontractor may work any weekday that weather permits. Saturday and holiday work is not
guaranteed, the City Point of Contact (POC) is to receive notification / schedule of intent to
work. Work on Sundays is not allowed. The Contractor shall develop and maintain a proposed
schedule of work to be submitted to the City. The schedule shall be provided in a bar-chart
format listing the sequence of work within the contract time frame. As a minimum,
construction schedules shall be updated bi-weekly and submitted to the City of Mauldin.
Changes in the schedule must be reviewed and approved by the POC.
Prior t
o the beginning of work, the County will provide a public notice to inform the general
public of the project. Written notification of at least ten (10) working days must be given to the
POC. Notice to all applicable agencies, specified contacts, for roads that require preparation
and/or adjustments by utility companies shall be the sole responsibility of the Contractor.
111
ASPHALT TRAIL SECTION
HIGH SIDE EXAMPLE LOW SIDE EXAMPLE
3-5' WIDE MI NIMUM COMPACTED SHOULDER COMPACTED
TO MIN. 92% STANDARD PROCTOR, AT 1V:6H MAX. CROSS
SLOPE (BEFORE 1V: 3H SLOPE MAX., 5' MIN. IF EXISTING
SLOPE EXCEEDS 1 V, 3H), SHOULDERS TO BE RIDEABLE
11' MIN. AND RECOVERABLE IN ALL CONDITIONS
NOTE: ----------+-�
HYDROSEED ONLY AREAS
ADJACENT TO EXISTING
TURFGRASS AREAS, MAI N TAI N
POSITIVE DRAINAGE IN TRAIL
SHOULDER (MULCH ALL OTHER
AREAS).
NOTE:
w z
- PAVI N G SECTIO N
(SEE DETAIL)
VARIES, MINIMIZE LIMIT
OF DISTURBANCE.
=
IN STALL EROSION CON TROL
BLANKET SYSTEMS AS SPECIFIED
FOR ALL SLOPES EXCEEDI NG 3, 1.
EXISTI NG
GROUND PER AASHTO GUIDE FOR THE
DEVELOPME N T OF BICYCLE
FACILITIES, CHAPTER 5,
RECOMME NDED MI NIMUM WIDTH
IS 11', HOWEVER VARYING
WIDTHS BASED ON USE ARE
SPECIFIED WITHIN THE
GUIDELINE.
,
;;c;
jn
l
L-□
PREPARED
SUBGRADE
MULCH OVER
IN HEAVILY WOODED AREAS SHOULDERS SHOULD
BE TRENCHED 3' OFF TRAIL TO 3' DEEP FOR
ROOT CON TROL ON CE EVERY 3 YEARS.
NOTES:
PREPARED SOIL STRUCTURAL FILL TO
CONDITION VARIES TIE
BACK TO EXISTI NG GRADE
WITH SWALE OF SHOULDER.
GRADE AND SLOPE INDICATED
1. MINIMIZE TREE REMOVAL AND DISTURBANCE WHE N CLEARI NG FOR PATHWAYS.
2. PREPARE SOIL TO A DEPTH OF 3", CLEA N AND FREE OF ALL ORGANIC LAYER (LEAVES/DEBRIS REMOVED)
3. CROSS SLOPE OF TRAIL NOT TO EXCEED 2%.
4. CON TRACTOR TO CON TACT GEOTECH NICAL EN GINEER IF ANY U N SUITABLE SOIL CONDITIO NS ARE ENCOUN TERED,
WHICH MAY COMPROMISE STRUCTURAL IN TEGRITY OF PA TH.
5. E NSURE TRAIL AND SHOULDERS ARE CLEARED OF ALL TREES AND VEGETATION THAT COULD CAUSE ROOT
GROWTH BELOW TRAIL BED.
6. 4" DASHED OR SOLID CEN TERLINE (THERMOPLASTIC OR RETRO REFLECTIVE PAI N T DEPE NDI NG O N TRAIL
CONDITIO NS.
7. EVERY 1/10 OF A MILE PROVIDE ALPHA NUMERIC MILEAGE SYSTEM W/ 4" NUMBERING (THERMOPLASTIC OR
RETRO REFLECTIVE PAI N T) AND POSTS EVERY 1 /2 MILE THAT ARE 2' MIN. FROM EDGE OF TRAIL
PAVING SECTION
2" TYPE C, ASPHALTIC
CONCRETE SURFACE
COURSE
STONE DUST SECTION
1/2" STONE DUST
6" GRADED AGGREGATE BASE COURSE (CRUSHER
RUN), COMPACT GABC AT OPTIMUM MOISTURE
CONTE NT TO REQUIRED GRADES AND THICK NESS
TO NOT LESS THAN 100 PERCENT OF MAXIMUM
DRY DENSITY ACCORDING TO ASTM D 1557.
6" GRADED AGGREGATE BASE COURSE (CRUSHER
RUN), COMPACT GABC AT OPTIMUM MOISTURE
CO NTENT TO REQUIRED GRADES AND THICK NESS
TO NOT LESS THAN 100 PERCENT OF MAXIMUM
DRY DENSITY ACCORDING TO ASTM D 1557.
-
I I .!.....!._ -I I l.!....!....!.- 111--111---'- 11
GEOTECHNICAL E NGINEER SHALL VERIFY
-n"i-;:;= :::n ;:;:: CONDITION PER PROJECT SPECIFICATIONS A ND ==ITT�n g��6�ii��
ic
;�R
E
��6
N
}��� �����Fl���:�s A ND
' 1 I
�
JURISDICTIONAL REQUIREMENTS. -
�
JURISDICTIONAL REQUIREMENTS.
COMPACTED SUBGRADE, 98% MINIMMUM
COMPACTION USING THE STANDARD PROCTOR TEST
SHALL BE ACHIEVED.
COMPACTED SUBGRADE, 98% MINIMMUM
COMPACTION USING THE STANDARD PROCTOR TEST
SHALL BE ACHIEVED.
GEOTECHNICAL E NGINEER SHALL VERIFY CO NDITIO N
PER PROJECT SPECIFICATIONS AND JURISDICTIONAL
REQUIREMENTS
GEOTECH NICAL ENGI NEER SHALL VERIFY CONDITION
PER PROJECT SPECIFICATIONS A ND JURISDICTIONAL
REQUIREMENTS
PAVING NOTES
SUBGRADE, BASE COURSE AND PAVEME NT CO NSTRUCTION METHODS SHALL
MEET THE MINIMUM REQUIREME NTS OF THE SCOOT "STANDARD
SPECIFICATIONS FOR HIGHWAY CO NSTRUCTION ", LATEST EDITIO N.
OBSTRUCTION MARKINGS
OBSTRUCTION (PIER, ABUTMENT, DRAIN, ETC.)
L
w
6" SOLID WHITE LINE
(THERMOPLASTIC OR RETRO REFLECTIVE PAINT)
------DIRECTION OF BICYCLE TRAVEL
L=WS
L=TAPER LENGTH (FT)
W=OBSTRUCTION WIDTH
S= BICYCLE APPROACH SPEED (MPH)
FIGURE 4-30
(20 MPH FOR GHS SWAMP RABBIT TRAIL)
NOTE: ALL EFFORTS SHOULD BE TAKEN TO ROUTE
TRAIL TO AVOID VERTICAL OBSTRUCTIONS
112
Submittal of Proposal for Swamp Rabbit Trail – City of Mauldin
United Infrastructure Group, Inc. Page 3 of 16
Extensive Design-Build Experience | UIG and ICE collectively have worked on over 35 design-build projects
totaling over $3.5B involving trails, roads, bridges, ports, etc., most of which are in South Carolina. We have a
keen understanding and familiarity with all facets of delivering a design-build project such as the Swamp Rabbit
Trail, including the planning and permitting processes, design criteria and standards, incorporating quality and
durability, maintenance of traffic and work zone safety, construction best-practices and techniques, and quality
assurance/quality control. Some of our relevant design-build projects are included in the next section.
Long-Standing Established Working Relationships | Through 20+ years and numerous successful projects
working together, the staff of UIG and ICE have excellent working relationships that have resulted in the
successful delivery of innovative high-quality projects delivered safely on schedule and on budget. These
established working processes will be applied to this Project during every phase of delivery.
Established Relationship with the CITY | UIG and ICE are currently working with the CITY and their developer to
design and build the Bridgeway Station Pedestrian Bridge project within a fixed budget while incorporating the
maximum amount of aesthetics possible and obtaining all approvals necessary from all agencies.
Statement of Understanding | UIG and ICE fully understand the City of Mauldin’s objectives and all
features necessary for this 0.25-mile multi-use trail from East Butler Road to the pedestrian bridge that we are
currently designing/building. We will design and construct the Project in accordance with the RFP criteria and
incorporate appropriate criteria from the AASHTO Guide for the Planning, Design, and Operation of Pedestrian
Facilities (July 2004) and AASHTO’s Guide for the Development of Bicycle Facilities, including cyclist criteria such as
2’ min. graded area adjacent to both edges of path, 5’ min. separation between path edges and top of slopes over
1V:3H, 8’ vertical clearance to obstructions, recommended grades no steeper than 5% with a graduated scale up to
11% or more for short distances, 5’ min. separation from roadways, 2% max. cross slopes, and careful design of
path-roadway intersections. We will also provide a trail entrance at East Butler Road with expanded hardscape and
landscape features that accommodates the existing substation driveway and trail entrance. Most importantly, UIG
and ICE will work integrally and cooperatively with City of Mauldin staff to design and build the final trail product
desired and ensure the most cost-effective solution while delivering the adjacent project. See Appendix C for our
preliminary Plan and Profile for the Swamp Rabbit Trail Project.
113
10+00 11+00 12+00 13+00 14+00 15+00 16+00 17+00 18+00 19+00 20+00 21+00 22+00 23+00 24+00 25+00 26+00 27+00 28+00 29+00 30+00 31+00 32+00
830
835
840
845
850
855
860
865
870
875
880
885
890
895
900
905
910
905.99
902.82
900.40
898.75
896.03
893.65
891.35
887.98
883.96
879.54
875.30
873.63
872.1 4
870.02
870.40
869.80
869.26
869.03
869.83
871.83
872.31
871.97
871.88
873.71
874.37
875.1 8
873.94
873.59
873.98
874.38
875.1 1
874.02
870.08
820
825
830
835
840
845
850
855
860
865
870
875
880
885
890
895
900
905
910
864.73
858.44
859.35
853.80
843.22
836.97
839.82
841.1 8
841.1 4
841.95
837.90
842.1 1
844.1 5
905.99
VPI STA. 1 0+30.00
ELEVATION 902.65
-1 1.1 3%
-3.9 8%
60.00' V.C.
VPI STA. 1 3+30.00
ELEVATION 890.72
-3.9 8%
-1 0.03
%
150.00' V.C.
VPI STA. 1 5+20.00
ELEVATION 871.67
-1 0.03
%
-0.8 0%
200.00' V.C.
VPI STA. 1 8+70.00
ELEVATION 868.86-0.8 0% +3.6 7%
100.00' V.C.
VPI STA. 1 9+70.00
ELEVATION 872.54
+3.6 7% -0.6 0%
100.00' V.C.
VPI STA. 21+00.00
ELEVATION 871.75-0.6 0% +2.7 6%
110.00' V.C.
VPI STA. 22+30.00
ELEVATION 875.34
+2.7 6% -2.2 4%
50.00' V.C.
VPI STA. 23+20.00
ELEVATION 873.32
-2.2 4% -1.3 9%
100.00' V.C.
VPI STA. 25+65.00
ELEVATION 869.90
-1.3 9%
-1 0.9 6
%
100.00' V.C.
VPI STA. 27+00.00
ELEVATION 855.1 0
-1 0.96%
+2.93%
170.00' V.C.
VPI STA. 30+60.00
ELEVATION 865.65
+2.9 3% -0.6 2%
200.00' V.C.
864.78
905.99
901.91
899.86
897.88
895.89
893.90
891.51
888.1 1
883.70
878.90
875.1 5
872.56
871.1 2
870.63
870.23
869.83
869.43
869.23
870.06
871.61
872.27
872.06
872.21
873.1 3
874.51
874.88
873.80
872.92
872.20
871.50
870.81
869.52
865.96
861.08
858.05
857.07
858.03
859.50
860.96
862.43
863.75
864.64
865.08
865.08
864.78
PROPOSED PROFILE
SWAMP RABBIT TRAIL
EXISTING GROUND
VERTICAL SCALE 1" = 10'
HORIZONTAL SCALE 1" = 50'
114
JR – As discussed, please see the attached markups to the original trail RFP (from City of Mauldin) and
from our proposal sent in response to the RFP. These documents show the scope we included in the
$231,500 quote we provided. Essentially, we have proposed to connect the last section of trail using the
original requirements from the City’s 2020 RFP, excluding any signage/pavement markings since we
don’t know what is out there on the already constructed portion of the trail. Additionally, our quote
assumes we can waste excess material on-site and/or balance the site such that we don’t have to truck
and dispose of any material offsite.
Desi
gn - $30,000
Construction - $201,500
Total - $231,500
Completion date – 4/30/2023 (with an attempt to complete in the fall of 2022 based on resource
availability)
Please
let me know if you have any questions or need any additional information.
Than
ks,
Michael
803-899-0178
115
CITY COUNCIL
AGEND
A ITEM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8f
TO:
FR
OM:
SUBJECT:
City Council
Recreation Director, Bart Cumalander
Connection to Bridgeway Station
REQUEST
It is the request of the Recreation and Public Works Department that we do a change order on the existing
contract with Cely Construction to connect the footbridge to Bridgeway Station.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
The new footbridge will connect to Bridgeway Station. Bridgeway Station will be a new development that
holds entertainment, housing and other businesses all together in one location. The new footbridge will
grant passage over 385 for pedestrians to get access to what Bridgeway Station has to offer.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
Cely Construction will have AECOM consulting on the project.
FISCAL IMPACT
It would be an extra $19,700 on the existing contract to connect the bridge to Bridgeway Station. The
funds for this project are coming from the HNA fund.
RECOMMENDATION
It is the recommendation of the Recreation and Public Works department to do a change order on the
existing Cely project for the connect of the footbridge and trail at Bridgeway Station.
ATTACHMENTS
Mauldin Walking Trail Proposal
116
Kevin Talbott
COO – Manager of Projects
Cely Construction Company, Inc.
P.O. Box 8497
Greenville, SC 29604
Greenville, SC
RE: Design and Permitting Services for Mauldin Trail and Bridge Tie In
Dear Mr. Talbot,
AECOM Technical Services, Inc. (AECOM) is pleased to present our proposal to provide services to
complete designs for the tie in of the Mauldin Trail to the new Pedestrian Bridge that is under
construction that will connect to Bridgeway Station.
Tasks associated with the scope of work anticipated include:
Task 1: Data Collection
Task 2: Design and Construction Plans
Task 3: SCDOT Permitting (optional)
Area of Survey
117
Scope of Work
Task 1: Data Collection
AECOM will review existing plans for the Pedestrian Bridge and the Constructed Mauldin Trail.
AECOM will complete a field visit to verify survey limits but anticipates gathering approximately 1.5
acres of Field survey data in the area between the pedestrian bridge and trail as shown on the
graphic above. Field Survey will include:
a. Horizontal and vertical control will be utilized from existing control set from the Pedestrian
Bridge Project. Boundary and Topographic surveying services shall be to the requirements of
the Minimum Standards Manual for the Practice of Land Surveying in South Carolina.
b. Locate site features on the one foot contour interval topo the with additional spot elevations
as necessary to accurately depict the existing drainage patterns of the area. Horizontally and
vertically locate all potential outfall drainage ditches and streams.
c. Locate all visible drainage and gravity sewer structures within the corridor and one structure
beyond the corridor limit. Information shall include top and invert elevations as well as pipe
location, size, and material.
d. Location of all visible existing above ground utility structures such as telephone pedestals,
water valves, water meters, gas valves, fire hydrants, and visible existing utility designations
by others will be shown. No connectivity of underground non-gravity utilities will be shown
except as marked by PUPS.
e. Surveyed property corners along with records for determining property lines and right of way
will be provided.
f. Prepare a Digital Terrain Model (DTM) or TIN file and combine it with existing model from the
corridor.
Deliverables:
1) Autocad or Microstation Cadd file of survey with a Digital Terrain Model (DTM) or TIN.
Task 2: Design and Construction Plans
Geometric Design - AECOM will develop an alignment to tie the existing trail to the pedestrian
bridge, while meeting design standards set forth in the AASHTO Bike and Pedestrian Guide. Cross
sections along the alignment will be provided, along with proposed contours.
Hydraulic Designs – AECOM will review existing conditions and develop a plan to address drainage.
The proposed design will show piping, ditches and the installation of any new structures and will
include pipe, type, size, and invert elevations.
Erosion Control Design - Design for minimizing erosion and off-site sedimentation during
construction will be developed. The location and type of erosion control devices will be shown on the
construction plans. It is assumed that the land disturbance will minimal and therefore not require a
Land Disturbance Permit, therefore it has not been included in this scope of work.
Utility Impacts - AECOM will make a concerted effort to design around and try to avoid unnecessary
relocations of utilities. If absolutely necessary, AECOM will coordinate with Utility Providers to
118
develop a plan for relocation and will be the responsibility of the CONTRACTOR will be responsible
for ensuring that utilities are relocated satisfactorily for construction to proceed.
Construction Plans - AECOM will submit electronic plans for 95% plan review and comment by the
Contractor and a PDF copy plans for the final submittal. It is anticipated that plans will include and/or
address the following at a minimum:
a. Title Sheet
b. General Notes Sheet
c. Summary of Quantities, Removal & Disposal Items
d. Typical Sections
e. Detailed Construction plan sheets
f. Detailed profile sheets
g. Storm drainage plans (may be included on roadway plan)
h. Erosion control Plans (may be included on roadway plan)
i. Utility conflicts
j. Cross-sections
k. Construction limits
Deliverables:
1) It is assumed that AECOM will provide an electronic PDF set of plans for review at 95% Plan
Level.
2) AECOM will provide Final Construction Plans at a scale of 1”=50’ which will include all of the
items listed above.
Task 3: SCDOT Encroachment Permitting (Optional)
AECOM will coordinate with SCDOT to obtain an encroachment permit for the work if required. It is
anticipated that submittals of the plans will be submitted to SCDOT for Review at Final plan stages.
This scope includes preparing checklists and supporting documentation required by SCDOT to
process encroachment permit application to include Sight Distance Calculations, Functional
Classifications, driveway profiles, drainage calculations/statements, etc. and up to one (1) meeting
with SCDOT at District office or on-site.
Schedule
It is anticipated that we could begin work on this project within 2 weeks of Notice to Proceed and we
could complete the work within 6 weeks of Notice to Proceed with the exception of Permitting if
required, which would be subject to review times.
Cost
Task Cost
Task 1: Data Collection $4,800.00
Task 2: Design and Construction Plans $11,400.00
Task 3: SCDOT Encroachment Permitting (Optional) $3,500.00
Total $19,700.00
119
Assumptions and Exclusions
There are several exclusions from this contract, and they include:
Wetland Delineations, Geotechnical Explorations, Hazardous Material Explorations, permitting other
than what is described above, Right of Way Acquisition, or field work for such tasks.
We appreciate this opportunity to offer our proposal for these services to Cely Construction
Company. It is assumed this work can be completed under a Standard AECOM Contract. As a
Principal of the firm, please do not hesitate to contact me at the email address or phone numbers
listed below should you have any questions about our submittal, or if you require additional
information.
Respectfully submitted,
Emily Swearingen, PE
Associate Vice President, South Carolina Transportation Business Leader
emily.swearingen@aecom.com
O. (864) 234-2261 or M. (803) 331-9717
AECOM Technical Services, Inc.
www.aecom.com
120
CITY COUNCIL
AGEND
A ITEM SUMMARY
MEETI
NG DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8g
TO: City
Council
FROM: Recreation Director Bart Cumalander
SUBJECT: Gilder Creek Trail
REQUEST
The Recreation Department is seeking guidance from City Council to decide how to move forward with
the Gilder Creek Trail project.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
The space selected for the Gilder Creek Trail was part of the Gilder Creek Multi-Use Trail Feasibility Study
performed by Davis &Floyd for the City of Mauldin. The trail will be located between East Butler Road and
Corn Road. This study estimated that the project would cost $890,426. No funding for this project was
budgeted in the FY 2023 budget.
The C
ity applied for and received a SCPRT Recreation Trails Program Grant for $66,000.89 for the Gilder
Creek Trail project and has until April of 2024 to complete the project. This project may be affected by the
SCDOT improvements to East Butler Road.
The Recrea
tion Committee considered this item at their September 6, 2022 meeting and forwarded it to
Council for discussion.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
After speaking with SCPRT, staff finds that there are three potential options for how to proceed with the
Gilder Creek Trail project.
The options are as follows:
1. Not accept grant funding for this project at this time
2. Accept grant funding and complete full project by budgeting for the project in the FY 2024 budget.
3. Accept grant funding and construct trail with alternative trail surface and/or route and in -kind
work to reduce costs within grant funding. SCPRT is amenable to this idea but the proposed work
would need to be approved by them before construction.
FISCAL IMPACT
The estimated cost for the Gilder Creek Trail project is $890,426. The City applied for and received a SCPRT
Recreation Trails Program grant for $66,000.89 for this project. No funding for this project was budgeted
in the FY 2023 budget. A funding source has not been identified for the remaining cost of the full project.
ATTACHMENTS
-“Gilder Creek Multi-Use Trail Feasibility Study” for City of Mauldin- Previously distributed
-State of South Carolina Department of Parks, Recreation and Tourism Recreation Trails Program project
agreement
121
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS, RECREATION AND TOURISM
RECREATIONAL TRAILS PROGRAM
PROJECT AGREEMENT
PROJ
ECT NUMBER: P28052201322
PROJECT NAME: Gilder Creek Multi-use Trail
PROJECT SPONSOR: City of Mauldin
GRANT AMOUNT: $66,000.89
PERIOD OF THIS AGREEMENT: Oct. 1, 2022 to April 30, 2024
PROJECT SCOPE (Described in detail in the project file, but is summarized as follows):
Con
struct a new accessible multi-use trail, approximately 2,400 feet in length, that will parallel Gilder Creek and connect
Butler Road wth Corn Road.
The State of South Carolina, represented by the Department of Parks, Recreation and Tourism, (hereinafter referred
to as PRT), and the Project Sponsor, mutually agree to perform this agreement in accordance with the guidelines
established by PRT, and with the terms, promises, maps, and assurances attached hereto and made part of this
agreement.
The State of South Carolina promises to obligate the amount of money referre d to herein. The Project sponsor
promises to execute the project above in accordance with the terms of this agreement.
Project must be completed and bills must be submitted by Apr. 30, 2024.
The f
ollowing special project terms and conditions were added t o this agreement before it was signed by the parties
involved:
1) The Project Sponsor agrees to operate the above described facilities in a nondiscriminatory manner with regards
to race, color, creed, national origin, or handicap such that the general public is not prohibited except possibly
during night hours when it might be deemed unsafe for use.
2) The Project Sponsor agrees to operate and maintain the above described facilities in a safe and usable manner
for their intended purposes throughout the agreement period.
3) The Project Sponsor agrees to erect and maintain throughout the agreement period, a sign which credits the
Recreational Trails Program in cooperation with the South Carolina State Trails Program and the Federal Highway
Administration for assisting in the project.
4) In the event that permits or other approvals may be required as a result of the activities proposed under this
project, the Project Sponsor must provide PRT with copies of same.
5) In the event that any portion of this agre ement applies to work on public lands by an organization or individual,
the Project Sponsor (organization or individual) will enter into a separate agreement with the public agency to
undertake the work and provide a copy to PRT.
In witness whereof, the parties hereto have executed this as of the date entered below.
The State of South Carolina Project Sponsor
By B
y
Department of Parks, Recreation & Tourism
Title
Date D
ate
122
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ME
ETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8h
TO: C
ity Council
FROM: Police Chief George Miller
SUBJECT: Award Bid for K9 vehicle upfit
REQUEST
Approve the bid for the upfit of the K9 vehicle to Unique Lighting Solutions in Spartanburg.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
An RFP was sent through different sources for the upfit of the K9 vehicle as per City policy.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
At the d ate of the deadline, only one business , Unique Lighting Solutions, had turned in a quote. Th ey
met all specifications that were required in the RFP.
FISCAL IMPACT
See RFP book previously provided
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends acceptance of the quote from Unique Lighting Solutions
ATTACHMENTS
RFP Book previously provided
123
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ME
ETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8i
TO: C
ity Council
FROM: Police Chief George Miller
SUBJECT: Award Bid for police vehicles
REQUEST
Approve the bid for the upfit of the police vehicles to Unique Lighting Solutions in Spartanburg.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
An RFP was sent through different sources for the upfit of the police vehicles as per City policy.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
At the date of the deadline, only one business, Unique Lighting Solutions, had turned in a quote. They
met all specifications that were required in the RFP.
FISCAL IMPACT
See RFP book previously provided
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends acceptance of the quote from Unique Lighting Solutions
ATTACHMENTS
RFP Book previously provided
124
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ME
ETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8j
TO: C
ity Council
FROM: Police Chief George Miller
SUBJECT: Records Retention Schedule
REQUEST
In the past it has been that the approval of the Records Retention Schedule has to be signed by the Chief
of Police and governing body.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
These records are internal investigations and disciplinary actions.
The r
etention of these records is 5 years from the date the employee was terminated, resigned, or retired.
At that time the records shall be destroyed. Any person still employed with the police department- their
records will be retained until the 5-year deadline after they leave employment.
We h
ave files that date back to the early 1990’s and some of the former employees are deceased.
FISCAL IMPACT
None
RECOMMENDATION
Council approval of the retention schedule for the Mauldin Police Department.
ATTACHMENTS
SC Archives policy
125
126
127
128
129
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
MEE
TING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8k
TO: Cit
y Council
FROM: Police Chief George Miller
SUBJECT: DJJ MOU
REQUEST
To approve a Memorandum of Understanding with the Department of Juvenile Justice.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
We have had a contrac t with DJJ to house juveniles that are arrested and cannot be released to their
parents.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
We do not have a juvenile holding facility and rely on the DJJ to house or juvenile offenders. We very
rarely use this service but have in emergency situations.
FISCAL IMPACT
$50.00 per day per juvenile.
RECOMMENDATION
Council approval of the MOU.
ATTACHMENTS
A copy of the MOU is attached
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM
MEETIN
G DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8l
TO: C
ity Council
FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug
SUBJECT: Drive-thru Standards in the Central Redevelopment District
BACKGROUND
Staff has been asked to include a discussion of drive-thru standards in the Central Redevelopment District as
part of the agenda for the Building Codes Committee.
CURRENT MAULDIN STANDARDS
Presently, the City of Mauldin has general standards that require a minimum amount of distance for vehicles
that queue or stack in drive -thru lanes depending on the type of business (e.g., bank, ATM, restaurant, car
wash, etc.). There are no other restrictions on drive-thru facilities in the Central Redevelopment District.
NEIGHBORING JURISDICTIONS STANDARDS
Staff has studies the drive -thru standards provided by other jurisdictions in South Carolina, particularly
within the Upstate. Below is a summary of the standards for selected jurisdictions.
Greenv
ille. The City of Greenville provides general standards that regulate how drive- thru lanes and
facilities are laid out. They cannot be in front of a building, face a residential dwelling, or negatively impact
the pedestrian experience. Where pedestrian pathways cross a drive-thru lane, the pedestrian pathway must
be raised and made prominent to ensure pedestrian visibility and safety. They also have standards for drive-
thru covers (roofs or canopies), speakers, and signs.
Simps
onville. In their town center district, the City of Simpsonville restricts drive-thru lanes and windows
from being located in front of a building. They also require drive -thru facilities to be located as far as
practicable from any pedestrian pathways.
Fount
ain Inn. In their gatewa y district, the City of Fountain Inn restricts buildings on corner lots from
locating drive-thru lanes between the building and the street.
Greer. Th
e City of Greer does not appear to have any restrictions on drive-thru facilities.
Trave
lers Rest. The City of Travelers Rest does not appear to have any restriction on drive-thru facilities.
Easl
ey. The City of Easley does not allow drive -in or drive -thru facilities at restaurant and drinking
establishments within their central commercial district.
Clems
on. The City of Clemson does not appear to have any restrictions on drive-thru facilities.
137
Anderson. The City of Anderson does not appear to have any restrictions on drive-thru facilities.
Spart
anburg. In their downtown district, the City of Spartanburg restricts drive-thru facilities from locating
within 500 feet of an existing drive-thru facility. They do not allow drive-thru lanes or windows in front of
the building.
Roc
k Hill. The City of Rock Hill provides general standards that do not allow drive -thru facilities in front
of the building or to impede pedestrian paths. Order boxes and pickup windows must be setback at least 100
feet from any residential property or use.
For
t Mill. The City of Fort Mill does not appear to have any restrictions on drive-thru facilities.
Newb
erry. The City of Newberry does not appear to have any restrictions on drive-thru facilities.
Aike
n. In their downtown district, the City of Aiken does not allow drive -thru facilities at restaurants,
although they do allow them for banks.
Colu
mbia. In their downtown district, the City of Columbia prohibits all drive-thru facilities.
OPTIONS
There are at least four approaches the City Council might consider with regard to drive-thru facilities in the
CRD.
1. Prohi
bit any future drive -thru facilities within the CRD district. Existing drive -thru facilities and
drive-thru facilities that are part of current development plans would be grandfathered. Existing
drive-thru facilities would be ineligible for any expansion (i.e., conversion to double drive -thru
lanes). Additionally, driveway access to the future Jenkins Court could be prohibited for properties
that operate drive-thru facilities.
2. Allow
future drive -thru facilities within the CRD district subject to conditional standards. Such
standards could include:
a. Driv
e-thru lanes, windows, and order boxes are prohibited between the front of the building
and the future Jenkins Court.
b. Where pedestrian pathways cross a drive- thru lane, the pedestrian pathway must be raised
and made prominent to ensure pedestrian visibility and safety.
c. Driveway access to the future Jenkins Court is prohibited.
d. Drive-thru covers (canopies and roofs) must be architecturally consistent with the roof
design and exterior finish materials of the primary building.
3. Prohi
bit drive-thru facilities in the City Center area north of the Dairy Queen property. This would
allow Maveri ck Station, Tropical Grill, Dairy Queen, and the future development at the former
BB&T property to have full rights to expand and redesign their drive-thru facilities.
4. Take
no action and continue to allow drive-thru facilities to developed in the CRD district.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
If the intent is for the City Center redevelopment project in the CRD district to highly prioritize pedestrian
orientation and design, then it is the staff’s opinion that drive-thru facilities should have no place in the CRD
district. In this case, the staff recommendation would be the first approach that would prohibit future drive-
thru facilities in the CRD district and relegate existing drive -thru facilities as grandfathered legal
nonconforming facilities.
138
REQUEST
The Building Codes Committee has sent this to the City Council for discussion. Staff is seeking direction
from the City Council as to the approach and standards it would like to consider for drive -thru facilities in
the CRD district.. Please note that the Planning Commission will need to review the ordinance before it can
be approved by City Council.
ATTACHMENTS
None
139
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM
MEETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8m
TO: City Council
FROM: Public Works Director, Matthew Fleahman
SUBJECT: Sewer Rehabilitation Program
REQUEST
Authorization is requested to execute the contract between the City of Mauldin and CaJenn
Construction & Rehabilitation (C/O Frazier Engineering, P.A).
HIST
ORY/BACKGROUND
In the Council approved FY2022 budget, $600,000 was budgeted in the Sewer Division of the Public Works
Department for sewer rehabilitation. These monies were included in the Federal ARPA distribution from
October 2022. In the FY2023 Council approved budget, $734,925 was budgeted in the Sewer Division of
the Public Works Department for sewer rehabilitation. These monies are included in the Federal ARPA
distribution which will be received in October 2023.
The Ci
ty of Mauldin (City) and Frazier Engineering (Engineer) entered into an Agreement dated March 15,
2015 for Engineering- Construction Management Services related to the City's Sewer Rehabilitation
Program. The contract has been amended to allow for the Engineer to provide general engineering services
related to the City's overall rehabilitation program and providing design and construction management
services for the City's sewer rehabilitation construction projects. The most recent amendments were made
during the December 2021 Council meeting to authorize the use of ARPA f unds to rehabilitate additional
sewer mainlines.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
CaJenn Construction & Rehabilitation is current doing sewer rehabilitation work for the City of
Simpsonville and Metro Connects. In both situations, Frazier Engineering is the consulting engineer on the
projects. The contracts with Metro and Simpsonville were competitive bid projects which Cajenn
Construction & Rehabilitation won. For the work in Mauldin, the Public Works Department asked if the
City could “piggy- back,” on either contract . Based on a review of both contracts, Frazier Engineering
determined that the Metro Connects contract was the “most similar,” to our proposed rehabilitation project.
In acc
ordance with the Council approved Purchasing Policy, Cooperative Purchasing is an approved
alternative to the sealed bid method of soliciting bids. This method which is most advantageous to the City
and result s in the most timely, acceptable quality, economical, and successful completion of the
construction project.
140
FINANCIAL IMPACT
The cost associated with this contract will not exceed $1,200,000.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends the City Council approve the contract that was previously distributed.
141
142
143
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
AGREEMENT ................................................................................................................................................ 00200-1
BID .............................................................................................................................................................. 00310-1
PERFORMANCE BOND ................................................................................................................................. 00400-1
PAYMENT BOND ......................................................................................................................................... 00500-1
GENERAL CONDITIONS ................................................................................................................................ 00700-1
FORMS ........................................................................................................................................................ 00950-1
TECHNICAL S
PECIFICATIONS
SECTION TITLE NO. OF PAGES
01010 SUMMARY OF WORK...................................................................................................................... ..31
01140 PROJECT A
CCESS AND RESTRICTIONS ............................................................................................... 1
01200 PROJECT MEETINGS ..........................................................................................................................1
01270 MEASUREMENT AND PAYMENT.......................................................................................................1 7
01300 SUBMITTALS ......................................................................................................................................3
01340 SHOP DRAWINGS, WORKING DRAWINGS, AND SAMPLES ................................................................ 7
01410 REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS AND REFERENCES ............................................................................ 2
01510 TEMPORARY UTILITIES ...................................................................................................................... 1
01550 VEHICULAR ACCESS AND TRAFFIC CONTROL .................................................................................... 1
01560 TEMPORARY BARRIERS AND CONTROLS ........................................................................................... 2
01570 ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION ........................................................................................................1
01700 PROJECT CLOSEOUT ..........................................................................................................................1
01720 PROJECT RECORD DRAWINGS ........................................................................................................... 3
01725 EXISTING UTILITIES ............................................................................................................................2
01740 CLEANING ......................................................................................................................................... 1
02650 SEWER CLEANING AND TELEVISION INSPECTION ............................................................................. 8
02766 CURED-IN-PLACE PIPE LINING (CIPP) FOR LATERALS.........................................................................7
02767 CIPP FOR MAIN SEWERS - UV CURED ..............................................................................................17
02768 MANHOLE REHABILITATION ..............................................................................................................9
02900 LANDSCAPE RESTORATION................................................................................................................6
144
SECTION 002
00
AGREE
MENT
THI
S AGREEMENT, made this ________ day of ___________________________, 20___, by and
between the City of Mauldin herein after called "OWNER" and CaJenn Construction & Rehabilitation
Services, Inc. of the City of Hoboken, County of Brantley, and State of Georgia, hereinafter called
"CONTRACTOR".
WIT
NESSETH: That for and in consideration of the payments and agreements hereinafter
mentioned:
1. The CO
NTRACTOR hereby agrees with the OWNER to commence and complete the
construction described as follows:
2
022-2023 SEWER REHABILITATION PROJECT
hereinaf
ter called the PROJECT.
2. This
AGREEMENT is being entered into through a COOPERATIVE PURCHASING
AGREEMENT (“PIGGYBACK” AGREEMENT) process in accordance with Title 11,
Chapter 35, Section 11-35-4810 of the South Carolina Code of Laws. The OWNER is
entering into this AGREEMENT with the CONTRACTOR based on the CONTRACTOR’s
Bid for the FM400B-343 Basin Find & Fix CIPP Project submitted to the Metropolitan
Sewer Subdistrict (dba MetroConnects), Greenville, South Carolina on February 10,
2022, at which time the Bid was publicly opened and read aloud. The CONTRACTOR
subsequently entered into an AGREEMENT with MetroConnects to perform the work.
The OWNER (City of Mauldin) is undertaking similar work as Bid on the MetroConnects’
FM400B-343 Basin Find & Fix CIPP Project, and via this AGREEMENT, the
CONTRACTOR agrees to perform the OWNER’s work in accordance with the terms,
conditions and specifications of the MetroConnects’ Contract Documents (except as
modified herein) at the unit prices bid on February 10, 2022.
The Co
ntract Documents bound with this AGREEMENT are directly incorporated from
the MetroConnects’ Contract with the CONTRACTOR for the FM400B-343 Basin Find &
Fix CIPP Project. Any modifications to the Contract Documents are as defined in Item 6
below.
3. The C
ONTRACTOR will furnish all of the materials, supplies, tools, equipment, labor, and
other services necessary for the construction and completion of the PROJECT descr ibed
herein.
4. The C
ONTRACTOR will commence work required by the CONTRACT DOCUMENTS
within fifteen (15) calendar days after the date of the NOTICE TO PROCEED and will
fully complete the PROJECT within 365 calendar days from the date of the NOTICE TO
PROCEED unless the period for completion is extended otherwise by the OWNER via
change order(s). The CONTRACTOR further agrees to pay, as liquidated damages, the
145
sum of seven hundred fifty dollars ($750) for each consecutive calendar day thereafter as
herein provided in the SPECIAL PROVISIONS.
5. The C
ONTRACTOR agrees to perform all of the WORK described in the CONTRACT
DOCUMENTS and comply with the terms therein for an amount of up to ($1,200,000)
One Million Two Hundred Thousand Dollars and No Cents based on the actual work
performed at the unit prices shown in the Bid Schedule. The OWNER may increase this
Contract Amount via change order(s) to complete additional sewer rehabilitation work.
6. The t
erm "CONTRACT DOCUMENTS" means and includes the following:
A. Agree
ment – Section 00200
B. Bid –
Section 00310 : The Bid included herein is the C ONTRACTOR’S Bid
submitted to MetroConnects for the FM400B-343 Basin Find & Fix CIPP Project on
February 10, 2022. The OWNER will utilize the same Bid Items for this PROJECT,
and the CONTRACTOR shall honor the unit prices bid as shown on the Bid Form.
C. Perf
ormance Bond – Section 00400
D. Payme
nt Bond – Section 00500
E. General
Conditions – Section 00700
F. Spec
ial Provisions – Section 01 010: The Special Provisions included in these
Contract Documents have been modified to reflect the specific project requirements
for the OWNER’s PROJECT.
G. Speci
fications directly incorporated from the MetroConnects ’ FM400B-343 Basin
Find & Fix CIPP Project as enumerated in the Table of Contents.
H. N oti
ce to Proceed
I. Chan
ge Orders
J. Draw
ings as prepared by Frazier Engineering, P.A. and issued to the
CONTRACTOR during construction of this PROJECT. In addition, the Drawings
prepared by Frazier Engineering, P.A. for the MetroConnects’ FM400B-343 Basin
Find & Fix CIPP Project dated January 2022 are incorporated herein by reference,
specifically the general requirements on Sheet G-1, the Technical Details shown on
Sheets D-1 through D-7, and the Erosion Control Details shown on Sheets EC -1
through EC-2.
K. These
Specifications prepared by Frazier Engineering, P.A. dated August 2022.
7. The O
WNER agrees to pay the CONTRACTOR in the manner and at such times as set
forth in the General Conditions such amounts as required by the CONTRACT
DOCUMENTS.
8. Th
is Agreement shall be binding on all parties hereto and their respective heirs,
executors, administrators, successors and assigns.
146
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed or caused to be executed by their
duly authorized officials, this Agreement in three (3) counterparts, each of which shall be deemed
an original, in the year and day first above written.
City o
f Mauldin
(OWN ER)
By:
_____________________________________
(SEAL
) _________________________________________
ATTE
ST _________________________________________
(Title of Authorized Official)
__________
________________________________
(Witness)
__________
________________________________
(Witness)
CaJenn
Construction & Rehabilitation Services, Inc.
(CONTRACTOR)
By:___
_________________________________
__________
____________________________
(Printed Name)
__________
____________________________
(Title)
PO B
ox 38
Hoboken, GA 31542
(SEAL)
ATT
EST:
__________
________________________________
(Witness)
__________
________________________________
(Witness)
(End
of Section 00200)
147
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM
MEETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8n
TO: City Council
FROM: Public Works Director, Matthew Fleahman
SUBJECT: Trash Truck Purchase
REQUEST
Authorization is requested to purchase a side-arm trash truck using the remaining funds available from the
FY2023 Capital Purchases.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
In the Council approved FY2023 budget, the Public Works Department was provided funds to purchase
two new leaf trucks, tw o new grapple trucks, and two new side -arm trash trucks. The City began its
transition to side -arm trash trucks in 2020 and when the two new trucks are delivered in September or
October, the entire fleet will have been replaced.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
The purchase price of both the grapple truck and leaf truck went up significantly from FY2021 to FY2023.
These price changes are due in part to inflation and material shortages. Due to these price changes, the
budgeted amounts for both were not sufficient to order two of each. The Public Works Department ordered
one of each, with delivery dates of January 2023.
With the transition to side -arm tr ash trucks, the entire fleet has been changed out; however, no side -arm
spare truck is available if a truck goes into the shop for maintenance. In these situations, the Department
will be r
equired to send out a rear loader truck and staff the back with paid employees. The purchase of a
spare would el
iminate this potential scenario and set the Department up to address the continued growth of
the City. Currently, four trash trucks and two recycle trucks go out on route each day. The proposed/
under construction developments within the City will quickly necessitate the need for an additional truck.
If this spare is purchased, the Department will have coverage for maintenance periods and be prepared
when an additional route is assigned to the Sanitation Division.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
The remaining funds available from the Capital Purchases is 295,441.68.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends the City Council approve the purchase of a new side-arm trash truck.
148
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM
MEETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8o
TO: City Council
FROM: Public Works Director, Matthew Fleahman
SUBJECT: Stormwater Engineering Task Order 02
REQUEST
Authorization is requested to approve Task Order 02 with KCI to provide stormwater asset inventory, on-
call GIS services, stormwater modeling, grant assistance, and a City-Wide Stormwater Master Plan.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
The City of Mauldin is part of Greenville County’s MS4 Stormwater permit. As part of the permit, the City
is responsible for drainage structures within City -Owned rights-of-way (ROWs). The Pubic Works
Department inspects and maintains these drainage systems so that stormwater will be properly conveyed to
drainage outfalls. In many portions of the City, stormwater drainage structures were constructed off the
ROW and on private property. These conveyances sometimes traverse several properties before emerging
back on City owned property. In accordance with State Law and City Policies, the City is not responsible
for these drainage structures on private property. In instances where drainage systems on private property
have been addressed by the City, the property owner and the City establish utility easements which grant
access and authority over the inspection and maintenance of the newly installed/repaired drainage structure.
The Cit
y identified a need to contract KCI to inspect, design, and oversee stormwater construction projects
in areas of the City where the installed drainage system is under sized, failing, or absent. This need extends
to both the City-owned ROW and private property. In Council Memorandum 9-1 dated September 8, 2021,
Council was provided a recommended Spending Plan for the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA). In it,
the City recommended allocating resources to address stormwater issues throughout the City.
On Dec
ember 6, 2021 the City issued a Request for Proposal for On-Call Engineering Services. After thirty
days, the submittal window was closed and a review team of three City employees was convened to review
and score the submittals. KCI was awarded the highest score and was contacted to generate an On -Call
services contract. City Council approved the contract with KCI during its March 2022 Council meeting.
149
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
Representatives from Public Works and City Administration met with KCI and identified data gaps in the
infrastructure inventory, specific GIS needs, and inquired about a City- Wide Master plan and grant
assistance. KCI put together Task Order 2 to address these needs.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
The City allocated 1,129,724 dollars in year one of the ARPA spending to fund necessary stormwater
management projects that improve the City’s stormwater infrastructure systems. The engineering services
associated with this task order are proposed at 411,600.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends the Public Works Committee and the City Council approve the previously
distributed
Task Order 02 with KCI.
150
TASK ORDER 02
to the
MSA for Professional Services
KCI
Project Number 962206647-2202
This Task Order effective as of the date of the last signature (“Effective Date”) is entered
into
by City of Mauldin (“Client”) and KCI Technologies, Inc. (“KCI”) with regard to the
project identified below (“Project”). Client and KCI shall collectively be referred to herein as
the “Parties.”
The Project: Multi ple Projects as Noted Below Designated as Task Order 2 – Tasks
A-E
Project Address: City Wide
Client’s
Representative:
Public Works Director: Matthew Fleahman
KCI’s
Representative:
Client Liaison: Elise Harris
Project Manager: Mack Kelly
All services provided by the Parties on the Project shall be governed by the terms of this
Task Order and those in the Master Services Agreement for Professional Services (“MSA”)
attached hereto as Attachment A and incorporated by reference herein.
The Parties shall complete this Task Order in accordance with the contract documents listed
on and attached as Attachment B (the “Contract Documents”).
Scope of Services
KCI’s scope of services, including deliverables (the “Services”), is as follows:
Task A - Detailed Asset Inventory of Stormwater Infrastructure
KCI will assist the City perform a Detailed Asset Inventory of the Stormwater Infrastructure.
Data Collection
The intent of this task is to collect and review data from existing sources and for water resource and natural
resource engineering staff to observe features to be modeled and visualize conceptually solutions to the
observed issues.
Review Existing Data Sources
KCI staff will assimilate relevant data, such as GIS, as-built drawings, FEMA flood studies, USGS
studies, history of flooding, etc. that would assist in the modeling effort. GIS data may include
aerial photography, topography, zoning maps, soils, and planimetrics.
Gaps Analysis
KCI staff will determine additional data needs based on the existing available data to complete the
modeling and analysis for the stormwater inventory and master plan. Through preliminary field
investigations, discussion with City Staff and GIS analysis, KCI staff will identify primary and
secondary modeling limits.
151
KCI staff will conduct one (1) meeting with City staff to discuss known problem areas and high
water marks. During this meeting, KCI GIS staff will discuss with the City the requirements for the
stormwater database.
Engineering Field Investigation and Stream Walks
KCI hydraulic engineers will conduct field investigations of the primary and secondary networks
described in Section 5 below. KCI will utilize the effective FEMA models to the extent possible and
verify that the major structure crossings model match what is in the FEMA model. If it is found that
the structures vary greatly from the effective FEMA model, KCI will alert our survey crews to
include those crossings as part of the stormwater inventory. KCI estimates approximately 35,000
linear feet of stream walk.
KCI will complete stream walks and photologs of the primary (stream) system as shown in Figure 1,
Attachment D with the City limits to collect data required for the modeling analysis and
geomorphic stream assessment. The field investigation and stream walk will include but not
necessarily limited to the following:
• Identify high water marks for survey location
• Measure channel dimensions for hydraulic model
• Verify landuses (visual)
• Estimate Manning’s N-values
• Verify watershed boundaries
• Identify key hydraulic structures to be modeled
• Conduct Photolog with GPS points
• Identify in-stream problem areas, including erosion and other instabilities or obstructions
and map via GPS
The summary of findings for the stream walks will be incorporated into the Watershed Plan.
Stormwater Inventory
The intent of this task is for KCI to capture the stormwater utility infrastructure within the City’s limits and
use the data to develop a Geographic Information System (GIS) for the stormwater utility systems. This
task will be accomplished using GPS as the primary means of data capture.
Geodatabase Design and Development
Following the kick-off meeting, KCI will conduct a virtual or in-person information gathering
meeting to review the City’s current GIS database and identify gaps between the current GIS data
and the City’s desired future-state database. A custom stormwater database schema and data
dictionary will be developed based on best practices and feedback from the City during the
information gathering meeting. The recommended data dictionary will define the feature classes,
attribution, domains, and relationships to be included in the database schema. A draft data
dictionary and geodatabase design (V1) will first be delivered to the City for review. KCI will
conduct an in-person or virtual workshop to review the materials with the City. Based on the
discussion, KCI will make changes to the draft geodatabase. The final geodatabase schema and
data dictionary (V2) will be delivered to the City for approval.
Deliverables:
• Virtual or in-person GIS database information gathering meeting
• Draft geodatabase schema and data dictionary (V1)
• Geodatabase design workshop
152
• Final geodatabase schema and data dictionary (V2)
Field Collection App Development
Using the latest Esri data collection application, ArcGIS Field Maps, KCI will develop a mobile app to
assist with the field collection effort. The ArcGIS Field Maps application will be configured to utilize
the GPS location information from the survey-grade GPS units. A web map, hosted on ArcGIS
Online and within KCI’s network, will be developed utilizing the custom geodatabase schema
developed and approved by the City and formatted for use with the ArcGIS Field Maps application.
Utilizing the approved geodatabase design (V2) will ensure data integrity and data standards
accepted by The City.
Deliverables:
• Field Maps configuration
• Field Data compilation
Stormwater Utility System Mapping
A draft Standard Operating Procedure is included as Attachment C which outlines in greater detail
the scope of survey to be provided.
As data is collected, KCI GIS specialists will monitor and review field-collected data to ensure
connectivity and that the collected data conforms with the data schema and standards approved
by the City. KCI will provide a QC report outlining issues encountered. KCI will work with the data
compilation team to resolve issues.
Digital Development System Connectivity
KCI will utilize ESRI ArcGIS software to compile a GIS representation of the stormwater utility
system. We will identify, organize and import relevant background files to supplement the project
field data and assist with establishing system connectivity. KCI shall provide system-wide
connectivity to the extent possible and perform quality control of the inventory by a hydraulic
engineer.
Upon completion of the quality control, KCI will submit a file geodatabase including the
stormwater compilation. KCI will orchestrate a work session with the City stakeholders to review
the results of the data compilation.
Deliverables:
• QC report
• Geodatabase review workshop
• Final file geodatabase
City Redline Review Process
After completion of the field inventory, KCI will provide a digital copy of the stormwater utility
geodatabase to the City and will work with the City to identify inaccuracies and anomalies. It is
intended that the City redline the database by circulating it among the various departments and
personnel associated with maintenance of the stormwater system. KCI will then edit the GIS layer
to reflect any changes. No additional field work is anticipated for this task.
153
KCI GIS staff will update the geodatabase based on one (1) round of City comments. After
approval, KCI will give the City the geodatabase for its use in future updates. KCI is not responsible
for any future updates after geodatabase approval.
Tas
k B - On-Call GIS
KC
I proposes to perform GIS support services on an as needed basis that may include tasks such as
management, design, implementation of software products, database migration, software upgrades,
application development, map configuration, data loading, optimization and other tasks associated
with the City’s GIS environment.
KCI will work with the City to identify the level of effort for each support service request to
det
ermine the most effective utilization of resource staffing. Prior to start of work on a task, the level
of effort will be provided to the City project manager for review and approval.
KCI
's fee for the Services will be the following hourly rates listed below by personnel classification
multiplied by the number of hours worked by each respective person (other time and expenses will
be as according to MSA):
Role Rate
GIS Project Manager $172.00
GIS Solution Architect $165.00
GIS Business Analyst, Senior $156.00
GIS Business Analyst $134.00
GIS Application Developer/DBA, Senior $135.00
GIS Application Developer $124.00
GIS Analyst, Senior $115.00
GIS Analyst $85.00
GIS Technician $77.00
Tas
k C - City Wide Stormwater Modeling
KC
I will assist the City by preparing a hydrologic and hydraulic model. Specific care will be placed on
coo
rdination of activities with the City’s staff. Prior to the field investigation phase, KCI will gather available
project information from the City and items which may require special attention during the field
investigation. Whenever possible, KCI will avoid duplication of previous technical efforts by other
government agencies.
The Hydrologic and Hydraulic (H&H) modeling will be divided into two categories: Primary and Secondary
systems. The primary system will consist of the stream networks throughout the City limits. KCI will
determine the nature boundary between the primary and secondary systems, but generally the minimum
drainage area size for the primary system is 20 acres. The primary system will include major roadway
crossings with larger pipes, culverts and bridges. The Secondary system will contain of open and closed-
network drainage throughout residential neighborhoods. These systems will comprise of ditches, pipes and
stormwater structures including inlets, catch basins, and manholes.
154
Pr
imary System Hydrologic Modeling
Subwatersheds will be delineated as appropriate and shall typically range in size between 20 and
100 acres. Subwatershed divides will occur at significant hydrologic features such as road
crossings, stream confluences and detention facilities. Watershed characteristics will be identified
for each subwatershed in a manner consistent with the NRCS (TR-55) and proposed land uses will
be developed from land use and zoning information provided by the City. Hydrologic parameters
will be include: drainage area, existing land use, future land use, curve number, time of
concentration, NRCS soil type, significant detention storage areas, directly connected impervious
area, and channel routing characteristics. KCI will use the US Army Corps of Engineers HEC-HMS
model to develop the primary system discharges, taking into account any significant
impoundments caused by undersized crossings. KCI will evaluate the 2-, 10-, 25-, 50-, 100- and
500-year storm events as part of the modeling effort. Existing and future land uses will be
evaluated for the watersheds.
Primary System Hydraulic Modeling
Hydraulic modeling of the primary system will utilize the US Army Corps of Engineers HEC-RAS
program. The primary systems studied in the hydraulic model will include the mainstems of Gilder
and Laurel Creeks and their tributaries within the City’s limits. Refer to Attachment D, Figure 1
Project Streams. The total primary system to be evaluated is approximately 75,000 linear feet. The
models used will determine the hydraulic profiles for the various flows developed by the
Hydrologic model. The effective FEMA models will be utilized to the extent possible to establish
and/or check calculated starting water surface elevations, provide a point of verification for model
results and provide hydraulic input data as applicable.
Identification of Secondary Systems
Secondary systems include selected drainage features that drain to the primary systems. This
category would include both closed drainage and open channel networks that drain to the primary
systems. Analyzed systems will be identified based on watershed reconnaissance, historical
drainage complaints, community input, feedback from the City and other means to determine
systems that may be undersized.
KCI staff will work with the City to determine the list of secondary systems to be modeled as part
of the Watershed Plan after the public meetings and stormwater inventory data is collected.
Modeling of these secondary systems will be handled in a future task assignment and will be
considered Additional Work.
Model Validation
Stormwater models will be validated using available high water marks, crest gauge results (if
available), regression equations and USGS gauges (if available), recent floodplain mapping efforts,
as well as other pertinent data provided by the City or the public. All validation efforts will be
documented and reported to the City. Upon completion of the validation process, runoff
hydrographs will be computed with results being presented to the City for their approval prior to
beginning any hydraulic modeling.
Floodplain Delineation and Mapping
KCI shall delineate riverine-generated floodplains for the existing and future 25- and 100-year
floods for the primary systems. The mapping of floodplains will be compared to the effective FEMA
floodplains for consistency but may differ based on different H&H modeling approaches. The limits
of the future floodplain mapping will extend upstream to the limits of the open channel
conveyance system.
155
Ta
sk D - City Wide Master Plan
KC
I will assist the City in preparing a City Wide Master Plan. The plan will include at minimum Flood
Hazar
d Mitigation Alternative Development, Bank Stability Alternatives, Evaluate Capital Construction
Costs, Prioritize Projects and Develop a Watershed Plan Report. The details of the scope are further
explained below.
Flood Hazard Mitigation Alternative Development
Based upon the modeling results portions of the storm drainage system not meeting design
standards will be identified and prioritized for possible improvements. Citizen and City staff input
will be cross-referenced to the model results to determine problems that may have been
misidentified, that should be classified as maintenance or nuisance issues, or that may not qualify
for services due to being outside the public right-of-way.
Once the problem areas have been identified, improvement options will be considered that may
include:
• Upgrade of the entire drainage system to meet established design criteria;
• Upgrade portions of the drainage system to lesser design standards;
• Use alternative best management practices for water quantity control, such as detention
ponds or other stormwater Best Management Practices (BMPs); and
• Alternative alignments and materials to minimize construction cost and impacts to private
property, transportation systems, and other existing infrastructure.
When possible, atypical and innovative solutions will be considered to reduce cost and provide
solutions which optimize the drainage system’s capacity/functionality and long-term condition
while balancing the important issues of neighborhood aesthetics and public relations. Level of
service criteria for the recommended stormwater system improvements under existing land use
conditions will be evaluated. The level of service of the recommended improvements under
potential future build-out conditions based upon available zoning will also be considered.
Bank Stability Alternatives
Based on the engineering field investigations and stream walks completed in Task 2, KCI will
recommend bank stabilization projects to protect structure foundations, utilities, and other critical
infrastructure. In some instances, stream restoration projects may be recommended, particularly if
the proposed restoration will act as mitigation for other recommended flood control projects.
Evaluate Capital Construction Costs
Capital Improvements will be recommended and a budget (planning level) cost analysis will be
computed using recent bid tab information of similar projects and input on the local bid climate
from City staff. Budget costs for improvements shall include, at a minimum, installation of the
following elements: storm drainage improvements, channel restoration and stabilization materials,
grading, necessary street improvements, water and sewer utility relocations (if the utility is located
within a specific utility easement instead of the public right-of-way), erosion and sediment control
measures, traffic control measures, miscellaneous items (e.g. fencing, walls, etc.), environmental
mitigation costs and easement acquisition estimates, and stormwater Best Management Practices
(BMPs) as appropriate.
156
Prioritize Projects
KCI will develop a prioritization matrix with the City during the kickoff meeting. KCI will work with
City staff to set the specific weighting criteria that will be used in the matrix. The prioritization matrix
will be used to rank the recommended projects based on factors such as, public safety, level of
service, flood reduction benefits, water quality improvements, capital costs, private property
impacts, permitting requirements, funding availability, etc.
Draft Watershed Plan Report
The draft watershed plan report will be prepared. It will include an executive summary as well as
supporting documentation for all the recommended projects. Permitting requirements for each
proposed project will be summarized including the expected permits required, potential mitigation
requirements, and summarization of any discussions with representatives from regulatory agencies.
Final Watershed Plan Report
KCI will incorporate City staff comments into a final planning report. Two (2) hard copies and an
electronic copy of the final report will be submitted to the City as the final deliverable for the
Watershed Inventory and Master Plan.
Task E - Grant Assistance
KC
I will assist the City prepare and submit a SCOR application for the Bishop Heights project, due October
31,
2022. The application requires a project narrative that includes Need, Project Description, Feasibility,
and Benefits/Impacts. Other requirements of the application include Preliminary Engineering Cost Estimate,
Project Area and Service Maps, Funding and Other Commitments and Viability Self-Assessment for RIA State
Grant Requests.
KCI will assist the City prepare and submit a SCOR – CBDG-Mitigation Buyout application for the Oak Park
project, due October 31, 2022. The application requires a project narrative that includes Need, Project
Description, Feasibility, and Benefits/Impacts. Other requirements of the application include Preliminary
Engineering Cost Estimate, Project Area and Service Maps, Funding and Other Commitments and Viability
Self-Assessment for RIA State Grant Requests.
Fee and Payment
KC
I’s fee for completion of the Services in accordance with the Contract Documents is summarized in the
table
that follows.
The following table subdivides this cost estimate into individual cost estimates for each component of the
Services.
Task Task Description Duration1
(Weeks)
Fee Type
Lump Sum / T&E
Estimated
Fee
A Detailed Asset Inventory of Stormwater
Infrastructure
20 Lump Sum 2 $273,000
B On-Call GIS 16 Time & Expenses,
Not to Exceed
$10,500
C City Wide Stormwater Modeling 6 Lump Sum $42,000
D City Wide Master Plan 8 Lump Sum $73,500
157
E Grant Assistance 4 Lump Sum $12,600
To tal (LS & T&E) $411,600
Notes:
1. Durations shown are estimated times to complete each task. Some tasks are sequential while others may
run concurrently. A detailed schedule with milestone dates will be prepared after the kickoff meeting and
submitted for Client review and approval.
Changed conditions or additional requirements may result in an adjustment to estimated fees and/or schedules.
Any estimate made by KCI to Client of the anticipated fees or completion schedule for its Services is
understood to be informational only. KCI does not guarantee the accuracy of fee estimates, shall not be bound
by the fee estimates as limits on the amount to be expended and charged in completion of the Services or any
component thereof, and shall bill and be paid for fees that exceed these fee estimates as a result of the changed
conditions or additional requirements.
2. The survey budget of Task A is $175,000. The professional services fee for this portion of the task is very
complicated to estimate. Complexities include inaccessibility issues (i.e. cars parked over structures, locked
gates, covered up or paved over structures, structures requiring mechanical assistance for removal, clogged
driveway and culvert pipes, access to survey satellites, etc.), weather, availability and level of effort provided
by City staff, and the lack of historical data to estimate the number of assets to be inventoried. We recommend
collecting the stormwater asset inventory for Primary Area 5 (544 acres) first (see Attachment D, Figure 2)
and comparing the actual cost with the anticipated cost (based on time and expenses). In the Residential Areas
(354 acres) we estimated 291 driveway pipes, 130 culvert pipes, and 237 drainage structures. In the
Commercial Areas (190 acres) we estimated 234 driveway pipes, 105 culvert pipes, and 191 drainage
structures. We anticipate 1 bridge structure in Primary Area 5. We based our production day on being able to
collect driveway and culvert pipe asset data in 7.5 minutes and drainage structure asset data in 12.5 minutes.
We expect to collect bridge asset data in 90 minutes. We expect the fee to complete the survey work for Area
5 to be approximately $35,500. At the conclusion of completing the stormwater asset survey for Primary Area
5, we will meet with the City to review the actual expenses and will: proceed, modify the scope to meet the
proposed fee or issue a change order to reduce or increase fee as may be necessary.
KCI
shall comply with the invoicing procedures described in the MSA.
Special Terms and Conditions
In
the event of a conflict between the following terms and conditions and the MSA with
regard to the Services, the terms and conditions listed in this Special Terms and Conditions
Section shall govern.
None.
In the event of any other conflict between the terms hereof and the MSA, the terms of
the MSA shall govern.
158
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have caused this Task Order to be duly executed. Each
Party warrants and represents that its respective signatories whose signatures appear below have
been and are on the date of signature duly authorized to execute this Task Order.
City of Mauldin
BY:
S
ignature
Name
Title
Date
KCI Technologies, Inc.
BY:
S
ignature
Name
Title
Date
Mehmet Boz, PhD, PE
Vice President
8/30/2022
159
CITY COUNCIL
AGEND
A ITEM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8p
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
City Council
J.R. Charles, Community Development Director
Authorize allocation of funding for Pedestrian Bridge Lighting
REQUEST
Authorize the allocation of $204,000 to fund the lighting of the Bridgeway Pedestrian Bridge.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
In June 2022, the City Council approved the funding of $195,000 based on an estimate for the lighting of
the Bridgeway Station Pedestrian Bridge, specifically to fund an all-white lighting scheme.
On July 11, 2022, Terry Rowe with Hughes Investments sent an email to Brandon Madden to update him
about an updated cost estimate. In her email, Ms. Rowe states, “We just received the final pricing for
the lighting package preferred by council. The proposal to install the lighting is $323,500 ($294,000
lighting + $29,500 coring of structure). However, our bridge contractor has confirmed that it is able to
perform the coring for $10,000. Therefore, the final pricing for the lighting is $304,000. We already had
budgeted $100,000 for lighting, so the additional funding required is $204,000.”
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
The funding of $195,000 for the lighting scheme for the Bridgeway Station Pedestrian Bridge was
authorized by City Council at its June 2022 meeting, and the final estimate from Emory Electric, coupled
with Ms. Rowe’s update regarding cost savings in the coring of the structure, indicates that the final
price for the lighting scheme will be $204,000. The difference between the estimated cost authorized by
the City Council at its June 2022 meeting and the final cost provided by Ms. Rowe is $9,000.
FISCAL IMPACT
The project will cost $204,000 according to the email provided by Ms. Rowe at Hughes Investments. This
is a $9,000 difference between the estimated cost authorized by the City Council at its June 2022 meeting
and the final cost provided by Ms. Rowe. Holly Abercrombie has identified funding in the City Budget to
cover this project. A Purchase Order will be created to administer this project since it is outside of the
bonded amount for the Bridgeway Pedestrian Bridge project.
RECOMMENDATION
Amend the City Council’s June 2022 action, which originally allocated $195,000 for the lighting of the
Bridgeway Station Pedestrian Bridge, to authorize the allocation of $204,000 to fund the lighting scheme
for the Bridgeway Station Pedestrian Bridge.
ATTACHMENTS
• Cost Estimate from Emory Electric
• Minutes from June 2022 City Council Meeting (edited to focus on Bridgeway Station Pedestrian
Bridge Lighting)
• Email from Terry Rowe with Hughes Investments explaining the cost breakdown
160
July 6, 2022 REV #13
United Infrastructure Group, Inc.
Attn: Joe Capriola, PE
Reference: Best & Final Proposal - Bridgeway Pedestrian Bridge Lighting Options – Mauldin,
SC (Design Build)
Scope of Work:
• Material, labor, and taxes for a complete electrical package per the following drawings dated:
a) Reference Drawings issued for Precast structure Only
• Electrical Building Permit and Fees based upon our illustrated scope only
• Scope:
1. Scope Details:
1. Lumenpulse Package:
1. Package has been selected as “White” Non -Color Rendering Fixture
Option.
2. All Branch Wiring is included as Standard Conduit, ENT, and Flexible
Conduit.
3. All Conductors are Included as Copper THHN/THWN.
4. No Control Conduits & Wiring are included for this syst em is either on
or off.
5. All Mounting of Lumenpulse Fixtures are included as Mechanical
Fasteners (Screw Type) and Epoxy Type Fasteners when and where
required
2. Electrical Service:
1. Provide and Install (1) 200A 120/208v 3P4W System
2. (1) 200A MCB Panel N3R Construction
3. (1) 200A 3P Meter Socket
4. (1) 30A 6 Pole N3R Lighting Contactor Controlled By 120V Photo -Cell
Device Mounted to the Contactor.
5. Grounding Per the NFPA NEC 70
6. All Equipment is priced and designed to be fastened to the structure.
3. Engineering:
1. Engineering of the Base Electrical Service Riser is included from prior
proposal. $3,125.00 Has been allocated for the Engineering Budget. if
the engineering becomes beyond that, Emory Electric reserves the
right to request additional fees per change proposal. This statement is
due to the City of Mauldin Possible additional requirements. We ar not
stating it will be more but, we would require clarification of possible
incurred charges.
161
• Exclusions:
1. Seismic bracing, supports, and/or engineering for Fixtures, Conduit Racking and o r
Equipment.
2. Sod, grass, and/or standard landscaping replacement/repair
3. Concrete, asphalt, and/or drywall cutting , Coring, patching, and/or painting , this
includes coring unless otherwise specified in scope.
4. Concrete Light Pole Bases are Excluded
5. Excavation of roadways, road crossings, and/or rock removal of any type
6. Concrete Encasement of any type, unless specifically identified in scope
7. Directional Boring, Unless Specifically Designated in Scope of Work
8. Telecommunications system, fire alarm system, security system, EMS, BMS, and/or
CCTV system equipment and/or installation
9. Penetration Sealing (Weather Proofing) of any Exterior Structure (Metal Siding,
Concrete, Wood and or any Exterior Surface
10. Engineering, CAD, and/or BIM design and/or coordination
11. Locating services outside of general 811 services
12. Bonding (if required, please add 1%)
13. X-Ray of slabs and/or wall structure
14. Ground Resistance Testing
15. Temporary Power and Lighting are Not Included.
16. Utility Fees
17. Utility Secondary/Primary Conduit from Source is by others
18. Equipment:
1. Scissor Lifts -Boom Lifts – Etc.
2. Safety Railing
3. Excavators, Tampers, Generators, Etc.
4. Emory Electric will utilize GC Equipment on the night shift for Lighting
Installation and Night Work
19. Excavation is Excluded, for any part of this proposal.
20. Structural Assumptions of Pre-Cast Beams, Piles, or Structure.
21. Weekend Work.
22. Concrete Lite Pole Bases are Excluded in this proposal, all Concrete Work is provided
and installed by others.
23. CCTV Camera Conduit work Excluded in this proposal due to the design is not
complete.
24. Pole Lighting is Excluded from this proposal
25. Color Rendering Lumenpulse System is Excluded from this proposal
26. Lighting Control Via Remote Link – Lighting is designed for On/Off Display Only.
162
General Notes:
27. Working Schedule:
1. Emory Electric understands that we will be assigned from day to day at
different times. These times must be schedule 2/3 days in advance. If out of
scheduled work happens, please allow, 2 -4 hours for dispatching of
manpower. There is no excepti on to this statement due to manpower
scheduling. No Weekend, Nights or off hour schedules are included.
1. Working Hours are included as follows:
1. Monday through Thursday
1. 7:00AM to 5:30PM when scheduled.
2. Night work is Excluded no Exceptions to this. All work
Must be handled during the normal working hours as
stated.
3. When Night Shift is Required, Emory Electric will
provide manpower accordingly. All Night Work Shifts
will and must be coordinate within 48hrs of the required
shift.
28. Proposal General Notes and Conditions
1. No Engineering, CAD, BIM, etc. are included. We recommend a full electrical
design to be handled by others.
2. Lead-Times for Equipment:
1. Distribution Equipment: 30-90 Days Upon Approval and Release
2. Lighting Package: 16-20 Weeks Upon Approval and Release
3. Step Lighting Package: 6-10 Weeks Upon Approval and Release
3. No Delay Charges, Overnight Shipping or Express Shipping is included. All
Shipping information will be defined at time of approval Only, the dates as
shown are best guess assumptions at this time.
PRICING SCHEDULE:
• Revised Bid Proposal: ..................................................................................... See Below:
1. Lumenpulse System – White – Non-Color Rendering: ................... $294,000.00
1. This Package included the Electrical Service
2. Pricing is included with what is stated, this pricing is included with Customer
Consideration from our vendors and will not be adjust any further.
2. Add Alternates: Not Included in any Pricing Above
1. Coring of Structure: .......................................................... $29,500.00
General Note:
Emory Electric appreciates the opportunity to bid this project. This proposal shall remain firm for
ten (10) days. Due to the evolving and changing of c ommodity pricing, Emory Electric reserves
163
the right to revise this proposal after the ten (10) day notice of this bid proposal. If you have any
questions or additional information is required, please do not hesitate to call.
Pricing for all Commodity items was updated on 7-8-22. This commodity pricing is protected for
the terms as stated 10 Days.
If awarded, Emory electric will commence Submittal process with Formal Letter of Intent. No
Release of Lighting Distribution Equipment will be released until the following approvals are
accepted.
Final Shipping dates will be issued upon Formal Approval of all Equipment has been approved.
Sincerely,
Richard S Blithe
Emory Electric Inc.
164
Details Of Selection: Example: True Depiction of Lighting on Bridge
Service Location:
165
The public hearing was convened at 7:10 p.m. and ended at 7:12 p.m. No comments were made.
MI
NUTES
CITY OF MAULDIN
INDIGO POINT PUMP STATION PUBLIC HEARING AND CITY COUNCIL MEETING
JUNE 20, 2022
7:00 P.M.
CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 5 E. BUTLER ROAD
Me
mbers present: Mayor Terry Merritt, Council members Carol King, Jason Kraeling, Michael Reynolds,
Frank Allgood and Diane Kuzniar. Councilmember Matney was not present at the Call to Order, but
came in during the Proclamation section of the meeting.
Others present: City Administrator Brandon Madden and City Attorney John Duggan
Committee of the Whole
Mot
ion: Councilman Matney made a motion to consider the following three items via the informal
method. Councilwoman King seconded the motion.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
i
. Greenville County Urban County Cooperative Agreement
and Resolution
Mot
ion: Councilman Matney made a motion to accept the agreement and resolution with the
Greenville County Redevelopment Authority. Councilwoman King seconded the motion.
Vo
te: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
j. Bridgeway Station Pedestrian Bridge lighting options
Motion: C ouncilman Matney made a motion to accept Option 2 for white LED lighting in the
additional amount of $ 195,000. This money will come from hospitality and
accommodations. Councilman Reynolds seconded the mo tion.
Vo te: The vote was unanimous (7 -0).
k. AT&
T Utility Tax Credit Agreement
M
otion: Councilman Matney made a motion to accept AT&T utility tax credit agreement in the
amount of $50,000 for certain expenditures at Bridgeway Station. Councilman Reynolds
seconded the motion.
Vot
e: The vote was unanimous (7-0).
166
Welcome JR! I apologize that my late reply – I was out of the office for a couple of days. This is a very
exciting project, and we are delighted to have the City of Mauldin as our partner.
We
were very pleased to hear that the Council approved additional funding for the lighting of the
pedestrian bridge last month. We just received the final pricing for the lighting package preferred by
council (please see attached). The proposal to install the lighting is $323,500 ($294,000 lighting +
$29,500 coring of structure). However, our bridge contractor has confirmed that it is able to perform
the coring for $10,000. Therefore, the final pricing for the lighting is $304,000. We already had
budgeted $100,000 for lighting, so the additional funding required is $204,000. The only outstanding
items are approval from SCDOT for the lighting and confirmation from Laurens Electric that it will
provide the conduit. If you have any questions or concerns, then please do not hesitate to contact me.
Som
e time when it is convenient for you, I would love to stop by and meet you in person. Please let me
know when you have a few minutes.
Che
ers,
Terry
Theres
a (Terry) C. Rowe
Hughes Investments, Inc.
P.O. Box 1177
Greenville, SC 29602
(864) 242-2100 (oofice)
(864) 270-9245 (cell)
167
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA IT
EM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8q
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
City Council
J.R. Charles, Community Development Director
Authorize allocation of funding for Landscape Architecture Services for Jenkins Street
and Jenkins Court
REQUEST
Authorize allocation of funding for Landscape Architecture Services for Jenkins Street and Jenkins Court
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
The City was awarded funds for roadway improvements to Jenkins Court and Jenkins Street. CoTransCo
designed these improvements and asked the City to provide landscape architecture designs to accompany
its engineering designs. Because CoTransCo does not offer these services, the City must hire a landscape
architect to design the civil improvements that will be incorporated into the construction project (i.e.
location of street lights, junction boxes, conduit splits, etc.)
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
The landscape architecture component of the Jenkins Court/Jenkins Street design is an integral part of
the overall street design. Without this component incorporated into CoTransCo’s overall street design
and bid package, civil improvements will have to be constructed after the road is finished (i.e. cutting
into the road/sidewalks to install improvements.) In order to prevent this from occurring, staff requests
that City Council authorize the hiring of a landscape architect to create a landscape architectural design
that CoTransCo can incorporate into its overall construction plan. This design will also inform the design
of future improvements to Jenkins Court.
FISCAL IMPACT
Staff has collected three bids from the following firms with their corresponding amounts: Seamon
Whiteside ($16,500), Stantec ($10,100), and Studio Main LLC ($6,000.)
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends hiring Studio Main LLC to develop the landscape architectural design for the Jenkins
Court/Jenkins Street construction project.
ATTACHMENTS
•Proposals from Seamon Whiteside, Stantec, and Studi o Main LLC were previously
distributed
168
CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ME
ETING DATE: September 19, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 8r
TO: C
ity Council
FROM: Mark Putnam
SUBJECT: Ministerial Recorder position
REQUEST
Approve a new part-time Ministerial Recorder.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
On September 9, 2022, Cierra Howard resigned from her position as part time Ministerial Recorder.
Ministerial Recorders conduct bond hearings, sign warrants, and assist the police department after
hours and as needed when the City’s Clerk of Court is unavailable due to vacation or sick time. For the
last several years Mauldin has had three ministerial recorders to ensure that the SC Court
Administration requirement of bond hearings being conducted 365 days per year and within 24 hours of
someone being arrested is always fulfilled.
Wit
h Ms. Howard’s resignation, the City must appoint a new ministerial recorder.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
On September 8, 2022, HR Director Mark Putnam interviewed Consuelo Barnett and he would like to
recommend that she be appointed as Ministerial Recorder.
FISCAL IMPACT
Approximately $2,200.00 for mandatory Judge School. Ministerial Recorders are part time and only paid
when they work. Judicial budget already includes this position.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends approval of Consuelo Barnett as part time Administrative Judge
ATTACHMENTS
None
169
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.