RecordWell Data

building codes agenda_2022-09-06_

City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Sep 2, 2022 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Mauldin

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE MEETING TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 6, 2022 | 6 PM 4th committee meeting Please note that members of the public may attend this meeting in-person but are encouraged to participate remotely. The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting- minutes-agendas/ to access the meeting via audio and videoconferencing. The Committee will meet in the Mauldin City Hall at 5 East Butler Road in the Council Chambers at 6 p.m. Building Codes (BDS) Committee AGENDA September 6, 2022 Committee Members: Diane Kuzniar (Chair), Taft Matney, Frank Allgood The Honorable Diane Kuzniar The Honorable Diane Kuzniar The Honorable Diane Kuzniar The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 1. Call to Order 2. Public Comment 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes a. Building Codes Committee Meeting: August 1, 2022 (Pages 3-7) 4. Reports or Communications from City Officers a. BDS Director David Dyrhaug 5. Unfinished Business None The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 6. New Business a. An ordinance to rezone property consisting of approximately 5.8 acres located at 25 Old Mill Road (tax map parcel: #M008.04-0 1-002.03) and providing an effective date ( Pages 8-13) b. Annexation and Establishment of Tanner Road Planned Development (Pages 14-63) i. An ordinance to provide for the annexation of property owned by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, and located at 30 Tanner Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-0 1-043.01) by one hundred percent petition method; and to establish a zoning classification of PD, Planned Development, for said property ii. An ordinance to provide for the annexation of property owned by W. Earl Jones, and located at 30 Tanner Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-01-043.02) by one hundred percent petition method; and to establish a zoning classification of PD, Planned Development, for said property The Honorable Diane Kuzniar Building Codes Committee * * * 1 iii. An ordinance to provide for the annexation of property owned by C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue, and located at 50 Tanner Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03 -01-043.00) by one hundred percent petition method; and to establish a zoning classification of PD, Planned Development for said property c. An amendment to Chapter 18, Article II (Nuisances) of the Mauldin Code of Ordinances to authorize the codes enforcement official rather than the building and zoning director to enforce certain provisions contained herein and for other matters related thereto ( Pages 64-68) d. An amendment to Chapter 18, Article II (Nuisances) of the Mauldin Code of Ordinances to establish certain standards to protect against nuisances caused by light trespass and for other matters related thereto (Pages 69-75) e. Drive-through facili ties in the Central Redevelopment District (CRD) (Pages 76-77) f. Electric vehicle charging stations (Pages 78-104) g. Board of Appeals membership (Page 105) 7. Public Comment The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 8. Committee Concerns The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 9. Adjourn The Honorable Diane Kuzniar Building Codes Committee * * * 2 Minutes Building Codes (BDS) Committee August 1, 2022 4th Committee Meeting Committee Members present: Diane Kuzniar (Chair) and Frank Allgood. Taft Matney joined via Zoom. Others present: Business and Development Services Director David Dyrhaug and Interim City Administrator Rebecca Vance 1. Call to Order- Chairwoman Kuzniar 2. Public Comment - None 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes a. Building Codes Committee Meeting: July 5, 2022 Motion: Councilman Allgood made a motion to approve the minutes with one spelling correction. Councilman Matney seconded the motion. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). 4. Reports or Communications from City Officers a. BDS Director David Dyrhaug The budget looks good. Mr. Dyrhaug reported Duke Energy has been contacted regarding the lighting ordinance and staff will meet with them soon for feedback. Applications are being taken for openings on the Planning Commission and Board of Zoning Appeals. 5. Unfinished Business - None 6. New Business a. An ordinance to rezone property consisting of approximately 23 acres located at North Main Street (portion of tax map parcel: #M008.04-01-004.00) and providing an effective date The City of Mauldin has received a signed petition requesting the rezoning of a tract of land including approximately 23 acres located along N. Main Street between Kellett’s Korner/Tommy’s Snack Bar at 602 N. Main Street and the C.F. Sauer manufacturing facility at 728 N. Main Street. Specifically, this rezoning includes the portion of the property on the east side of the railroad tracks. The applicant has requested that this tract be rezoned from I-1, Industrial, to R-M, Multi-Family Residential. The applicant is planning to develop a townhome Building Codes Committee * * * 3 community on approximately 15 acres of this tract. This community would consist of high-end townhomes with projected price points around $320,000 to $340,000. The community would also include a half-acre central community area. The developer is proposing to dedicate approximately 6.7 acres for a future park constructed by the City of Mauldin and an additional 1.5 acres for an entrance road into the future park. Additionally, the developer is proposing to reserve a 21-foot easement along the edge of the property next to the railroad right-of-way for future pedestrian and bicycle trail construction. The current setback is 25 feet, but the townhomes could be pushed back. The buffer between the project and Whispering Oaks will be dense. Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to send this item to Council with Councilman Allgood seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). b. An ordinance to rezone property consisting of approximately 5 acres located at West Butler Road and Laurel Meadows Parkway (tax map parcel: #M008.02-01-003.00) and providing an effective date The City of Mauldin has received a signed petition requesting the rezoning of a tract of land including approximately 5 acres located along W. Butler Road between Taylor Road and Laurel Meadows Parkway. The applicant has requested that this tract be rezoned from C-2, Commercial, to R-M, Multi-Family Residential. The applicant is planning to develop a townhome community. At present, Arbor Land Design is proposing to develop a 57-unit townhome community on this 5-acre tract. This community would consist of townhomes with projected price points starting at $300,000. The conceptual drawings for the proposed development do not depict any amenities but do include just under one acre of open space. Mr. Dyrhaug reached out to SCDOT as one of the concerns raised by residents is the lack of a left turn signal coming from Laurel Meadows Parkway and is waiting to hear back. The Planning Commission voted to approve this rezoning. The applicant was encouraged by the commission to reconsider the lack of amenities to the community. Mr. Allen was available from Arbor Land Design. Councilman Allgood asked if he knows how the residents may access the pool across from this proposed development. Mr. Allen said he does not know how to police this. Councilman Allgood then asked about the setback. Mr. Allen answered it is 25 feet. Councilman Allgood asked if the proposed open space was going to be clear-cut. Mr. Allen said 0.4 acres in the back should be preserved; that is their plan. There are a lot of trees in that area and can be used towards tree credits. Councilman Allgood asked why we do not see circular cul-de-sacs anymore. Mr. Allen said they take up too much space. Building Codes Committee * * * 4 Chairwoman Kuzniar asked why a pool was not being considered. Mr. Allen said a builder has not been selected, so that may be reconsidered. He agrees it makes sense to put one in. Motion: Councilman Allgood made a motion to send this item to Council with Councilman Matney seconding. Chairwoman Kuzniar said she is conflicted on this project. A lot of C2 land is being used and rezoned for homes which does not allow for businesses to come in. The Laurel Meadows community have said they would rather have this than a commercial project, but it gives her pause. Councilman Allgood asked if it is possible to pull a study together on what properties have changed from C2 to residential and if the commercial inventory is dwindling. Chairwoman Kuzniar said a lot of these developments are clear cutting trees. Mauldin is a Bird Sanctuary. The trees are being removed and the birds have no place. The wildlife is being pushed out. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). c. An ordinance to provide for the annexation of property owned by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, and located at 30 Tanner Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-01-043.01 & 0547.03-01-043.02) by one hundred percent petition method; and to establish a zoning classification of PD, Planned Development, for said property The following two items will be considered together. The City of Mauldin has received signed petitions requesting the annexation of two tracts of land consisting of three parcels including approximately 13 acres owned by Lynn Farmer and Elaine Ayscue located at 50 Tanner Road, and approximately 7.6 acres owned by Earl Jones and Nancy Jones located at 30 Tanner Road. The applicant has requested that these tracts be zoned PD, Planned Development upon annexation into the City of Mauldin. Flournoy Development Group is planning to develop a planned development. This proposal includes up to 473 residential units, approximately 16,000 square feet of workspace, 548 parking spaces (24 garage spaces and 524 surface parking spaces), a 12,000-square foot clubhouse, and 950-square foot maintenance/dog wash space. All workspaces and residential units, including apartments, townhome units, and carriage homes, will be for rent only. The entire project will be owned and managed as one property. The applicant is proposing three access points, subject to review and approval by SCDOT. This will include one driveway at Tanner Road and two driveways at Verdin Road. Sidewalks will be installed along Tanner Road and Verdin Road in order to promote walkability and connectivity. A traffic impact study has been done. The report acknowledges that the northbound traffic on Verdin Road at the Woodruff Road intersection and the southbound traffic on Feaster Road at the Woodruff Road intersection both currently operate at a level F during both morning and evening peak hours. The conditions at this signalized intersection are expected to worsen with Building Codes Committee * * * 5 this project. The traffic impact study recommends that the traffic signal be adjusted to allow longer green lights for Verdin Road and Feaster Road. The applicant is requesting these two items be sent to the Planning Commission for their thoughts on the project. Chairwoman Kuzniar asked if there would be a dedicated right turn lane into the property and was answered that DOT determined a dedicated turn lane was not warranted. Councilman Allgood asked about the ground floor workspace. Mr. Foster answered there is an upstairs and downstairs with an internal stairway that could be closed off if needed. Councilman Allgood asked about the comprehensive plan. Ryan Foster answered there will be a co-working space with units designed with internal offices. There will also be a business center that people can walk to. Councilman Allgood asked Allen Reid about the traffic produced from the project. Mr. Reid said the timing of the signal at Woodruff and Verdin would help with the traffic. There is also an improvement at the south end near Butler planned in the form of a recommended right turn overlap. Councilman Allgood then asked about the setback for the property. The engineer answered he believes it is 20 feet all the way around. Chairwoman Kuzniar said there are three schools across from the proposed development on Holland Road. She knows it will be hard to guess, but how many families move into developments like this? She is thinking about the extra strain on schools. Mr. Foster said it varies, but he can get data on similar locations. Chairwoman Kuzniar asked what the price point is for the townhomes and apartments. Mr. Foster said the apartments would start at $1300 and the townhomes would go to $2500 per month. The square footage of the apartments would be 700-1200. Councilman Matney joined in chambers during this discussion. Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to send this item to the Planning Commission for input. Councilman Allgood seconded the motion. Councilman Matney said this looks like a nice project with a live/work environment that transitions very well to C2. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). d. An ordinance to provide for the annexation of property owned by C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue, and located at 50 Tanner Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-01-043.00) by one hundred percent petition method; and to establish a zoning classification of PD, Planned Development for said property.- This item was included in the previous discussion. 7. Public Comment - None Building Codes Committee * * * 6 8. Committee Concerns - None Mr. Dyrhaug asked for clarification that the motion to send the Tanner Road item to the Planning Commission was for all three properties. Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to reconsider the motion and send both items with all three properties to the Planning Commission for input. Councilman Allgood seconded the motion. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). 9. Adjourn - Chairwoman Kuzniar adjourned the meeting at 7:46 p.m. Respectfully Submitted, Cindy Miller Municipal Clerk Building Codes Committee * * * 7 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: September 6, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6a TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Rezoning at 25 Old Mill Road REQUEST The City of Mauldin has received a signed petition requesting the rezoning of a tract of land pursuant to Section 4:2 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance. This petition includes approximately 5.8 acres located at 25 Old Mill Road. The applicant has requested that this tract be rezoned from I-1, Industrial, to S-1, Trades & Commercial Services. The applicant would like the flexibility to consider developing the remainder of the property for the additional uses allowed in the S-1 zoning district. HISTORY/BACKGROUND This building is currently occupied by multiple tenants including AAA Fencecrafters , Upstate Liquidator, Snaptight Aluminum, Elite Marketing, and Mag -It LLC. Presently, at the southeast end of the building there are approximately 2 acres of land that have not been developed. The applicant is currently exploring his options for the development of this unused portion of the property. There are no imminent plans for the development of this tract at this moment. PUBLIC HEARING The Planning Commission held a public hearing on August 23, 2022. No public comments were offered at the public hearing. OWNER(S): RPA Development, LLC – Ron Allen AUTHORIZED REP(S): N/A TAX MAP NUMBER(S): #M008.04-01-002.03 LOCATION: 25 Old Mill Road CURRENT ZONING: I-1, Industrial REQUESTED ZONING: S-1, Trades & Commercial Services SIZE OF PROPERTY: Approx. 5.8 acres Building Codes Committee * * * 8 ZONING EVALUATION Existing Zoning Classification The I-1 district is established to accommodate manufacturing, assembly, warehousing, and distribution operations. It is the intent of the district that such operations do not produce har mful noise, odor, smoke, dust, glare, or pollution. Proposed Zoning Classification The S -1 district is established to provide a transition between commercial and industrial districts by allowing: 1. Commercial uses which are service related; 2. Service-related commercial uses which sell merchandise related directly to the service performed; 3. Commercial uses which sell merchandise which requires storage in warehouses or outdoor areas; and 4. Light industries which in their normal operations would have a minimal eff ect on adjoining properties. The uses that are allowed in the S-1 district but not in the I-1 district include: Permitted Uses Conditional Uses Amusement or games facility Assisted living health care service Big box retail store Catering services Communication or information services Dry cleaning and laundry services Event center or banquet hall Exhibition facility Fitness/sports club, studio, or center Funeral home Health and personal care services Hospital Hotel Meeting or assembly hall Nursing home Office and professional services Outpatient health care service Passenger transportation services Pet and animal care services Public administration building Public park or recreation area Religious institution Restaurant Retail sales Social assistance services Tattoo and body piercing services Thrift or consignment store Bar, brew pub or drinking place Cemetery Day care center Fringe financial services Motor vehicle sales and services Multi-family dwellings Private outdoor recreation amenity Building Codes Committee * * * 9 Surrounding Development/Zoning These properties are surrounded by the following zoning and land uses: Direction Zoning District(s) Existing Use(s) North S-1 (City) Ahold Delhaize Distribution Services South I-1 (City) CompX Security Products East I-1 (City) McNaughton McKay West I-1 (City) Siroflex Inc Comprehensive Plan Analysis This property is designated as an “employment center” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. Employment Center areas are intended for industrial parks and office parks. The S-1 district is generally considered to be consistent with this “employment center” designation. REVIEW CRITERIA The Mauldin Zoning Ordinance does not contain any specified criteria that should be considered by the Planning Commission when reviewing requests for rezoning. However, the following criteria are typical of those used by other jurisdictions. A. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed since the Comprehensive Plan was adopted, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; B. Suitability of the site’s ph ysical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed in the proposed zoning district; C. Compatibility of all the potential uses allowed in the proposed zoning district with sur rounding uses and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density, nature of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning, and potential influence on property values; D. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate all potential uses allowed in the proposed district without compromising public health, safety or welfare; and E. Public need for the potential uses permitted in the requested zoning district. STAFF FINDINGS The analysis below includes staff findings pertaining to each criterion. CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 1. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; This property is designated as a n “employment center” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. Employment Center areas are intended for industrial parks and office parks. The S-1 district is general considered to be consistent with the “employment center” designation. Building Codes Committee * * * 10 CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 2. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed To staff’s knowledge, there are no apparent floodplains, wetlands, or topographic constraints on the site. Staff is not aware of any features at this site that would make it unsuitable for development. 3. Compatibility of the potential uses allowed with surrounding uses and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density, nature of use, traffic impacts, aesth etics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning, and potential influence on property values The tract is located in a transitional area between I- 1 and S -1 zoned properties. Most, but not all, of the uses allowed in S -1 would appear to be compatible with the surrounding uses. 4. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate potential uses allowed without compromising public health, safety, or welfare Staff is not aware of any utilities, including water and sewer, that would not be available at this tract. 5. Public need for the potential uses permitted The expectation is that the further development of this property would bring additional jobs and/or commercial services. This type of growth is supported by the Comprehensive Plan. TIMELINE On June 26, 2022, staff received the request to rezone this tract. On August 23, 2022, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing. At this meeting, the Planning Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning. STAFF RECOMMENDATION The rezoning appears to be consistent with the comprehensive plan and other S-1 zoning in the vicinity of the property. In staff’s opinion the request meets the criteria outlined above. PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION On August 23, 2022, the Planning Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning. ATTACHMENTS Proposed ordinance (maps included therein) Building Codes Committee * * * 11 ORDINANCE # __________ AN ORDINANCE TO REZONE PROPERTY CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY 5.8 ACRES LOCATED AT 25 OLD MILL ROAD (TAX MAP PARCEL: #M008.04-01-002.03) AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE WHEREAS, RPA Development, LLC, has petitioned the City of Mauldin to rezone +/- 5.8 acres from the I-1, Industrial District, to the S-1, Trades and Commercial Services District; and WHEREAS, a rezoning of the parcel is in keeping with the City of Mauldin 2014 Comprehensive Plan Update; and WHEREAS, the site is suitable for the types of uses that could be developed under the new zoning district; and WHEREAS, the potential uses permitted in the new zoning district meet a public need and are not detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare; and WHEREAS, the Mauldin Planning Commission has given favorable recommendation to the zoning application; and NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof Section 1. That the property described in zoning docket PC-2022-11-RZ and Greenville County Tax Map Parcel #M008.04-01-002.03 be rezoned from I-1 to S-1, Trades and Commercial Services. The property is further identified on the attached exhibit that is hereby incorporated into this ordinance, including Exhibit 1, Zoning & Property Map. Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage. Passed on First Reading ________________________________ Passed on Second Reading ______________________________ CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA ATTEST: BY: ________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ___________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ John Duggan, City Attorney Building Codes Committee * * * 12 EXHIBIT 1 Building Codes Committee * * * 13 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: September 6, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6b TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Annexation/Planned Development at 30 & 50 Tanner Rd REQUEST The City of Mauldin has received signed petition s requesting the annexation of three parcels of land pursuant to South Carolina Code of Laws Section 5-3-150. These petitions include approximately 13 acres owned by Lynn Farmer and Elaine Ayscue located at 50 Tanner Road, and approximately 7.6 acres owned by Earl Jones and Nancy Jones located at 30 Tanner Road. The applicant has requested that these tracts be zoned PD, Planned Development upon annexation into the City of Mauldin. Flournoy Development Group is planning to develop a planned development described below. TRACT #1 (30 Tanner Rd) TRACT #2 (30 Tanner Rd) TRACT #3 (50 Tanner Rd) AUTHORIZED REP(S): Flournoy Dev. Group & Gray Engineering Flournoy Dev. Group & Gray Engineering Flournoy Dev. Group & Gray Engineering OWNER(S): W. Earl Jones Nancy L. Jones W. Earl Jones C. Lynn Farmer Elaine F. Ayscue TAX MAP NUMBER(S): 0547.03-01-043.01 0547.03-01-043.02 0547.03-01-043.00 LOCATION: 30 Tanner Rd 30 Tanner Rd 50 Tanner Rd CURRENT ZONING: R-S (County) R-S (County) R-S (County) REQUESTED ZONING: PD, Planned Development PD, Planned Development PD, Planned Development SIZE OF PROPERTY: Approx. 0.9 acres Approx. 6.7 acres Approx. 13 acres CONTIGUITY: These tracts are directly contiguous to the Maple Brook Terrace Retirement Community at 150 Verdin Rd, the backside of 701 Brookfield Pkwy, and the Sonic Drive-In at 1534 Woodruff Rd. Building Codes Committee * * * 14 HISTORY/BACKGROUND Each of these two tracts are currently occupied by a single -family residence—one residence at 30 Tanner Road and one residence at 50 Tanner Road. These tracts have attracted various development interests over the years. PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT About Flournoy Development Group Flournoy is described on their website as “a distinguished member in the multifamily real estate industry.” They state they “[lead] the planning, development, and construction of luxury, Class A multifamily communities across the Sunbelt.” They claim to have developed and managed over 40,000 multi -family units. They indicate that they have successfully purchased and developed or are in the process of developing 5 other properties in Greenville. This includes District West at 101 Reedy View Dr (365 units) , The Aventine Greenville at 97 Market Point Dr (346 units) , Carolina Point Apartments at 201 Carolina Point Pkwy (346 units), and The Paddock Club Greenville at 50 Rocky Creek Rd (208 units). Overview of Proposed Development At present, Flournoy Development Group is proposed a planned development consisting of the following: • 4-story apartment buildings consisting of up to 365 apartment units • 2- and 3-story townhomes consisting of up to 100 townhome units • 2-story carriage homes consisting of up to 8 units • Ground floor work space units consisting of up to 14 units (these units will be connected to the residential units above the work space creating a live/work environment) • Accessory garages and amenities In total, this proposal includes up to 473 residential units, approximately 16,000 square feet of work space, 566 parking spaces (24 garage spaces and 542 surface parking spaces), a 12,000-square foot clubhouse, and 950-square foot maintenance/dog wash space. All work spaces and residential units, including apartments, townhome units, and carriage homes, will be for rent only. The entire project will be owned and managed as one property. Live/Work Units. The live/work units will consist of a ground floor work space connected to a upper floor apartment unit. The work spaces are intended to be used for small office spaces or small -scale neighborhood retail uses. The target market for these work spaces will be entrepreneurs, small businesses, and professionals. The size of each work space will generally range between 700 and 1,200 square feet. Examples of businesses that may occupy these work spaces may include accountant, architect, artist/artisan, attorney, computer software and multimedia related professional, consultant, engineer, coffee shop, fashion designer, clothing boutique, graphic designer, interior designer, hair stylist, home -based office worker, insurance agent, real estate or travel agent, one -on-one instructor, photographer, and other similar occupations. The following uses are not intended for these work spaces: vehicle repair or maintenance, adult businesses, massage parlors, large commercial restaurants utilizing a commercial kitchen, and uses that create excessive noise, dust, heat, smoke, and odors that create a nuisance or other safety concerns. It is the intent of the applicant that if market does not demonstrate a demand for these work spaces that the owner may convert the work spaces into apartment units. Building Codes Committee * * * 15 Apartments. The apartments will consist of 1-, 2-, and 3-bedroom units. Units will vary in size between 600 and 1,600 square feet. The buildings may vary in height between 2 and 4 stories. The exterior façade materials will consist primarily of masonry and fiber cementitious board. Amenities. Amenities planned for this project include, but are not limited to, upscale clubhouse space, meeting rooms for residents who work from home, co -working space, fitness and wellness rooms, a dog park, mail kiosk and package lockers, a swimming pool c ourtyard, and outdoor spaces providing grills, firepits, and other amenities. Traffic. A traffic impact study has been completed for the proposed development project. This study was performed by Allen J. Reid with Impact Designs, Inc. This study was based on a slightly lower number of units (471) than the number of units included in the planned development submission (473). The difference of two units should be relatively immaterial to the outcome of the study. INTERSECTION OF VERDIN/FEASTER/WOODRUFF LEVEL OF SERVICE (DELAY IN SECONDS PER VEHICLE) Street Existing Conditions in 2022 Conditions in 2025 without this Development Project Conditions in 2025 with this Development Project Conditions in 2025 with this Project and the Traffic Signal Adjustment Verdin Road (northbound) AM Peak Hour F (118.9) F (133.7) F (188.9) F (138.1) PM Peak Hour F (131.1) F (154.8) F (177.3) F (120.2) Feaster Road (southbound) AM Peak Hour F (128.8) F (133.7) F (188.9) F (138.4) PM Peak Hour F (131.1) F (154.8) F (177.3) F (123.0) Woodruff Road (eastbound) AM Peak Hour C (22.3) C (29.3) C (29.6) C (29.9) PM Peak Hour C (30.0) D (35.8) D (36.0) D (50.7) Woodruff Road (westbound) AM Peak Hour C (29.8) D (35.9) D (35.8) D (45.4) PM Peak Hour C (30.1) D (37.5) D (44.5) D (53.6) OVERALL AM Peak Hour D (45.8) D (53.7) E (62.7) E (60.4) PM Peak Hour D (54.2) E (64.1) E (71.6) E (69.8) At the Woodruff Road intersection, the report indicates that the northbound traffic on Verdin Road and the southbound traffic on Feaster Road both currently operate at a level “F” during both morning and evening peak hours. A level of service “F” generally means there is forced traffic flow and the traffic level exceeds the amount that can be served. A level of service “F” is generally characterized by stop-and-go waves, poor travel times, low comfort and convenience, and increased accident exposure. In order to soften the impact of this propo sed development project, the traffic impact study recommends that the traffic signal at the Woodruff Road intersection be adjusted to allow longer green lights for Verdin Road and Feaster Road. Building Codes Committee * * * 16 Even with this adjustment, Verdin Road and Feaster Road would still operate at a level F at this intersection. The table below compares the current traffic level to future traffic levels in 2025 at this intersection. The traffic impact study also indicates that this project will impact the overall level of service at the intersection of Verdin Road, E. Butler Road, and Holland Road. This intersection presently operates at a level C during both morning and evening peak hours. With or without this project, the morning peak hour level of service at the Butler Road intersection is projected to deteriorate to a level D by 2025. This development project would also cause t he evening peak hour level of service at this inters ection to also deteriorate to a level D. The traffic impact study recommends that a right turn overlap be installed on Verdin Road at this intersection to facilitate the high number of right turns from Verdin Road onto E. Butler Road. This would improve the evening peak hour level of service back to a level C for this intersection. The table below compares the current traffic level to future traffic levels in 2025 at this intersection. INTERSECTION OF VERDIN/HOLLAND/BUTLER LEVEL OF SERVICE (DELAY IN SECONDS PER VEHICLE) Street Existing Conditions in 2022 Conditions in 2025 without this Development Project Conditions in 2025 with this Development Project Conditions in 2025 with this Project and the Right Turn Improvements Verdin Road (southbound) AM Peak Hour D (37.9) D (39.4) D (47.6) D (47.4) PM Peak Hour D (41.8) E (55.7) E (69.6) D (46.9) Holland Road (northbound) AM Peak Hour C (34.8) D (37.4) D (37.6) D (37.4) PM Peak Hour C (32.8) C (32.1) C (32.3) C (32.3) East Butler Road (eastbound) AM Peak Hour C (29.2) D (37.3) D (39.6) D (39.9) PM Peak Hour C (20.5) C (26.2) C (28.9) C (28.9) East Butler Road (westbound) AM Peak Hour C (32.5) D (38.9) D (39.3) D (39.8) PM Peak Hour B (16.2) B (18.1) B (18.3) B (18.3) OVERALL AM Peak Hour C (32.4) D (38.0) D (40.0) D (40.0) PM Peak Hour C (25.3) C (31.0) D (35.4) C (30.6) In summary, the traffic impact study recommends the following improvements* to the current traffic system. These improvements are intended to soft en the blunt of the traffic that would be added by the proposed development. 1. Modify the parameters of the adaptive signal system at the intersection of Woodruff Road/Verdin Road/Feaster Road to allow for longer splits for Verdin Road and Feaster Road. 2. Install a right turn overlap on the southbound approach of Verdin Road at East Butler Road. Building Codes Committee * * * 17 * Please note that at the Planning Commission meeting the applicant indicated that SCDOT has indicated that it will not permit the signa l timing to be altered at the intersection of Woodruff Road/Verdin Road/ Feaster Road. The applicant expects that SCDOT will instead require turn lane improvements. The applicant expressed that they plan to abide by the requirements of SCDOT. Access. The applicant is proposing three access points, subject to review and approval by SCDOT. This will include one driveway at Tanner Road and two driveways at Verdin Road. Sidewalks will be installed along Tanner Road and Verdin Road in order to promote walkability and connectivity. Parking. In total, 784 parking spaces are proposed for this development project. This includes 542 surface parking spaces for the apartments, 24 garage spaces for the apartments, 200 garage and driveway parking spaces for the townhomes, and 18 garage spaces for the carriage homes. This is consistent with the minimum parking requirements for the City of Mauldin which is presently 1.5 parking spaces for each multi-family dwelling unit and 2.0 parking spaces for other dwellings. It appears that the parking being proposed is consistent with the requirements for the City of Mauldin. Utilities. All utilities are available including water and sewer. The applicant has provided letters of capacity and availability from the various utility providers. MetroConnects has a sewer line at Verdin Road that the developer is expected to tie into. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING The applicant held a neighborhood meeting on July 11, 2022. Based on the sign -in sheet, it appears that nearly 30 neighbors attended the meeting. It appears that most of the attendees were from the Towns at Woodruff Crossing townhome community on Tanner Road just outside the City of Mauldin and next door to the proposed planned development. According to the meeting summary provided by the applicant, questions and concerns covered topics including: traffic, amenities, tree preservation, stormwater runoff, landscape buffering and screening, light pollution, trespassing by pedestrians, property values, and the capacity of infrastructure. A ttached is the applicant’s summary of the neighborhood meeting. PUBLIC HEARING The Planning Commission held a public hearing on August 23, 2022. The following citizens provided public comments at this hearing.  Jane Lawrence, 121 Ashgrove Lane (County resident), indicated that her questions and concerns have been addressed by the applicant and she has no further comment.  Peggy Garland, 213 Louisville Drive (County resident), indicated that she is no t opposed to the development of this tract but also shared some concerns about the development of the site. Her concerns included: (1) stormwater runoff that may affect the upkeep of the existing retention pond at the adjacent Woodruff Cr ossing community, (2) the effect of additional sewer flow on the deteriorating sewer pipes that curren tly serve the Woodruff Crossing community, a nd (3) cut- through traffic from Tanner Road through the parking lots for the AAA Car Care Center to Hendrix Drive.  James Epling, 115 Ashgrove Lane (County resident ), shared the following concerns: (1) insufficient road ways to accom modate increas ing traffic in the area, and (2) the effect of the proposed development on property values in the Woodruff Crossing community. Building Codes Committee * * * 18 PLANNING AND ZONING About the PD District The PD district is established to encourage innovative and creative design of residential and/or commercial developments and to permit a greater amount of flexibility by removing some of the restrictions of conventional zoning. The procedures for a PD provide a mechan ism to evaluate each application on its own merit. Surrounding Development/Zoning These properties are surrounded by the following zoning and land uses: Direction Zoning District(s) Existing Use(s) North C-1/C-2 (County) C-1 (City) Express Oil Change, La Petite Academy, Sonic Drive-In, Greenville Car Wash, Master’s Mark Dry Cleaners, The Flat South S-1 (City) Maple Brook Terrace Retirement Community East S-1/C-1 (County) Kids ‘R’ Kids Learning Academy West C-2/R-M10 (County) AAA auto repair shop, strip shopping center including various tenants, Towns at Woodruff Crossing townhome community Comprehensive Plan Vision This property is designated as an “employment center” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. Employment Center areas are intended for industrial parks and office parks. STAFF FINDINGS Staff has reviewed this request as follows. CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 1. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; This property is designated as an “employment center” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. Employment Center areas are intended for industrial parks and office parks. However, with the number of vacancies in the adjacent Brookfield Corporate Office Park, it is not unreasonable to conclude that recent trends may suggest that office park development is not as viable as it once was pre-COVID. The Planning Commission and the City Council may or may not judge that the proposed planned development is consistent with the intent of the comprehensive plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area. Building Codes Committee * * * 19 CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 2. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed To staff’s knowledge, there are no apparent floodplains, wetlands, or topographic constraints on the site. Staff is not aware of any features at this site that would make it unsuitable for development. 3. Compatibility o f the potential uses allowed with surrounding uses and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density, nature of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zonin g, and potential influence on property values The tract is located in a transitional area between commercial uses to the north, west, and east, an office park to the south, a retirement apartment community to the south, and a townhome community to the west. The mix of apartments and work spaces appears to represent a blend of some of the surrounding uses, albeit the work space aspect of the proposed planned development is a relatively minor component. As evident in the traffic impact study, this proposed planned development would impact traffic at a couple of the nearby intersections. However, the traffic study recommend s improvements to the traffic system that would soften the impact of this traffic. 4. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate potential uses allowed without compromising public health, safety, or welfare Staff is not aware of any utilities, including water and sewer, that would not be available at this tract. This project is expected to connect to the e xisting MetroConnects sewer line along Verdin Road. There is some concern about the road infrastructure to be able to accommodate the additional traffic generated by this proposed planned development. This concern was expressed at the neighborhood meeting. During peak hours, Verdin Road and Feaster Road already experience failed traffic flow (LOS F) at the intersection of Woodruff Road. Additionally, Verdin Road is currently approaching unstable flow (LOS D) at East Butler Road during peak hours. The traffic study contains recommendations that will attempt to mitigate the impact of traffic generated by this planned development. However, Verdin Road at Woodruff Road will continue to experience failed traffic flow (LOS F) and Verdin Road at East Butler Road will continue to approach unstable flow (LOS D) even with these improvements to the traffic system. Building Codes Committee * * * 20 CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 5. Public need for the potential uses permitted The Comprehensive Plan forecasts changing lifestyles, such as young adults delaying marriage and parenthood, will continue to increase the demand fo r apartments and townhomes. Additionally, the growing number of single-parent households may also create more demand for apartments and townhomes. This planned development proposal would provide additional living options that support this forecast in the Comprehensive Plan. TIMELINE On July 11, 2022, the applicant met with interested neighbors to review their proposal and to seek questions and comments. On July 18, 2022, staff received the petition and accompanying documents to annex these tracts and established a Planned Development (PD) district. On August 1, 2022, (at the request of the applicant) the Building Codes Committee of City Council referred the planned development proposal to Planning Commission for their review and recommendation. On August 23, 2022, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing. At this meeting, the Planning Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the Planned Development. STAFF RECOMMENDATION The traffic conditions along Verdin Road do represent a concern. One of the lingering questions surrounding this project is whether the poor traffi c conditions on Verdin Road will be detrimental to the safety of motorists and pedestrians and the overall success and desirability of this development project. The incorporation of multi -family dwelling units together with workspaces that could be used fo r neighborhood retail and offices has great potential and could become a very desirable destination . The layout for the project has been thoughtfully designed. The presence of neighborhood retail and office together with angled parking lining the principal drive off of Verdin Road provide a “Main Street” feel. It’s nice that t he parking along Tanner Road is placed behind buildings. (It would be even better if the parking along Verdin Road was also placed behind buildings.) The combination of apartments, townhomes, and workspaces represents a reasonable transition to all of the varied surrounding uses. Staff views the incorporation of the workspaces as a feature that has the potential to really distinguish this development project. It is staff’s recommendation that the provision in the statement of intent that would allow the workspaces to be converted to apartments be stricken and instead that the workspaces be required as an integral component of the project. If at some later time there is no market for the workspaces and the applicant wishes to convert these spaces, they could formally apply for a change to the planned development. In staff’s opinion, it should be the Planning Commission and the City Council who should judge whether there is sufficient evidence that no market exists for the workspaces and not left to staff to judge. Building Codes Committee * * * 21 Ultimately, the Planning Commission and the City Council will need to make a judgment on any factors that they deem pertinent. PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION On August 23, 202 2, the Planning Commission voted 6 -0 to recommend approval of the Planning Development. Their recommendation was cont ingent upon the following revisions to the statement of intent, to which the applicant was agreeable. The applicant has agreed to each of these conditions and has since updated the statement of intent to reflect each of these conditions. 1. Any conversion of work spaces to apartment units would require approval of a formal change to the Planned Development in accordance with City of Mauldin procedures. 2. The buffering, landscaping, and fencing proposed a djacent to the Woodruff Crossing community will be updated in the statement of intent to reflect what was presented at the Planning Commission meeting. 3. Traffic improvements and traffic mitigation measures will be installed or implemented as required and approved by SCDOT. ATTACHMENTS Neighborhood meeting summary Proposed ordinances Planned development documents Building Codes Committee * * * 22 07/13/2022 VIA EMAIL: ddyrhaug@mauldincitysc.com Mr. David Dyrhaug Planning Director City of Mauldin 5 E. Butler Road Mauldin, SC 29662 Phone: 864-289-8979 RE: Community Meeting Summary Tanner Road Mixed Use Development City of Mauldin, Greenville County, South Carolina Dear Mr. Dyrhaug: The community meeting for the subject project was held on July 11 th, 2022 from 5pm to 7 pm at the Mauldin Library on 800 W Butler Road in Mauldin. The meeting was hosted by the development team which included Tom Burr with Flournoy Development Group, David Graffius with Gray Engineering Consultants, Inc. and Allen Reid with Impact Designs, Inc who is the traffic consultant. More than 25 members of the community were present to view the site plan and architectural rendering and to discuss their comments, questions and concerns. Attached please find the sign-in sheet, question/ response cards, visual boards used at the meeting and a copy of the mailed/received notices and mailing list. The format of the meeting was an open informal discussion where members of the development team discussed the project with the community individually. Then, the development team made a short presentation of the project to the group with an introduction of the development team and highlighted the overview of the project. The meeting discussions continued and the meeting lasted all 2 hours and the following subject questions were raised during the discussion. The development team answered these questions. Refer to questions/response cards for specific questions/responses. • Nearly all the members of the community present were from Woodruff Crossing condos, adjacent to the west of the project site. The owner of the Greenville Car Wash was present along with the owners of the subject property. • Questions about the existing vegetation between the condos and the subject property would be impacted. • Questions about traffic and how this project would impact traffic in the area. The community was concerned that the intersections now operate poorly and this will be worse. • Questions about stormwater. The community noted that they are under contract now for over hundred thousand dollars for stormwater remediation to their pond. They also pointed out that the existing apartments between them and Verizon next to their pond, have their foundations exposed due to the erosion for their pond. They worry the stormwater from this project will make it worse. Gray Engineering Consultants, Inc. Office: (864) 297-3027 132 Pilgrim Road Greenville, SC 29607 www.grayengineering.com G ra y E n g i n e e r i n g Building Codes Committee * * * 23 • Questions about existing storm runoff immediately behind the condos next to the property were raised. These owners said that there is a shallow ditch that captures runoff from the subject property and inundates this low area with rainwater. • Questions were raised about the potential of foot traffic from the new apartments going through the Woodruff Crossing property to get to QT, KFC or Walmart. They requested some type of barrier to deter this from happening. • Questions were raised about site lighting and ambient light pollution. • Questions were raised about the type of project, whether it is apartments or homes, what type of buildings they are, how high they are. • Questions were raised about how the new development would affect their home values. • Questions were raised about existing infrastructure such as available existing sewer capacity. A list of the main concerns discussed in bold below and the main responses to address them provided: 1. Stormwater. The development will provide an on-site detention pond that will be sized to handle large storm events and attenuate peak flows to at or below current conditions. 2. Traffic. While traffic impacts are being seriously considered, based upon the analysis performed by Design Impacts, Inc., increased traffic is expected to be spread out amongst driveways and road system with no major mitigation recommended. There is a potential for the signal at Woodruff/Verdin to be modified to ease congestion on Verdin/Tanner. The traffic study will be subject to the review and approval by the SCDOT. 3. Existing Vegetation. An attempt will be made to maintain as much existing vegetation as possible and to provide new plantings where possible. 4. Property Security. This development will consider new fencing and/or measures to keep pedestrians from this development out of their property. These considerations are all seriously being considered by the owner and engineer and internal discussions are on-going as to how the comments received can be best addressed and incorporated into the project to make it the best project possible for the community. Should you have any questions or comments or if further detail is needed, please do not hesitate to contact me direct at 864-297-3027 ext 124 or by my email below. Very truly yours, GRAY ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS, INC. David J. Graffius, P.E. Project Manager dgraffius@grayengineering.com - 2 – Gray Engineering Consultants, Inc. Office: (864) 297-3027 132 Pilgrim Road Greenville, SC 29607 www.grayengineering.com Building Codes Committee * * * 24 ORDINANCE -2022 AN ORDINANCE TO PROVIDE FOR THE ANNEXATION OF PROPERTY OWNED BY W. EARL JONES AND NANCY L. JONES, AND LOCATED AT 30 TANNER ROAD (TAX MAP PARCEL: 0547.03-01-043.01) BY ONE HUNDRED PERCENT PETITION METHOD; AND TO ESTABLISH A ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, FOR SAID PROPERTY WHEREAS, W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones , are the sole owner s of record title of a parcel of real property containing 0.9 acres, more or less, located at 30 Tanner Road, which property is contiguous to the City of Mauldin and is more particularly illustrated in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, an Annexation Petition, attached hereto as Exhibit 2, has been filed with the City of Mauldin by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, requesting that the aforementioned property be annexed into the City of Mauldin; and, WHEREAS, the property to be annexed is contiguous to the City of Mauldin, and is more particularly depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones , constitute one hundred (100%) percent of freeholders owning one hundred (100%) of the real property depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, the proposed zoning of PD, Planned Development , is compatible with the surrounding property uses in the area; and, WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council conclude that the annexation is in the best interest of the property owner and the City; NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the Mayor and Council of the City of Mauldin that: 1. ANNEXATION: The real property owned by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, and more particularly depicted in the map attached hereto marked as Exhibit 1, is hereby annexed into the corporate city limits of the City of Mauldin effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance. 2. ANNEXATION OF A PORTION OF ADJACENT RIGHTS-OF-WAY: All of that portion of Tanner Road along the edge of and adjoined to the annexed property shown on the attached Exhibit to the centerline of the afore-mentioned right-of-way is also hereby annexed into the corporate limits of the City of Mauldin effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance. Building Codes Committee * * * 25 3. ZONING ASSIGNMENT: The above referenced property owned is hereby zoned PD, Planned Development, as detailed in Exhibit 3 attached hereto. ____________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ATTEST: ________________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk First Reading: _________________________ Second Reading: ______________________ Approved as to Form: ________________________________________ City Attorney Building Codes Committee * * * 26 EXHIBIT 1 – ANNEXATION MAP Building Codes Committee * * * 27 EXHIBIT 2 – PETITION Building Codes Committee * * * 28 Building Codes Committee * * * 29 Building Codes Committee * * * 30 ORDINANCE -2022 AN ORDINANCE TO PROVIDE FOR THE ANNEXATION OF PROPERTY OWNED BY W. EARL JONES, AND LOCATED AT 30 TANNER ROAD (TAX MAP PARCEL: 0547.03-01-043.02) BY ONE HUNDRED PERCENT PETITION METHOD; AND TO ESTABLISH A ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, FOR SAID PROPERTY WHEREAS, W. Earl Jones is the sole owner of record title of a parcel of real property containing 6.7 acres, more or less, located at 30 Tanner Road, which property is contiguous to the City of Mauldin and is more particularly illustrated in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, an Annexation Petition, attached hereto as Exhibit 2, has been filed with the City of Mauldin by W. Earl Jones requesting that the aforementioned property be annexed into the City of Mauldin; and, WHEREAS, the property to be annexed is contiguous to the City of Mauldin, and is more particularly depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, W. Earl Jones constitutes one hundred (100% ) percent of freeholders owning one hundred (100%) of the real property depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, the proposed zoning of PD, Planned Development , is compatible with the surrounding property uses in the area; and, WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council conclude that the annexation is in the best interest of the property owner and the City; NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the Mayor and Council of the City of Mauldin that: 1. ANNEXATION: The real property owned by W. Earl Jones, and more particularly depicted in the map attached hereto marked as Exhibit 1, is hereby annexed into the corporate city limits of the City of Mauldin effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance. 2. ANNEXATION OF A PORTION OF ADJACENT RIGHTS-OF-WAY: All of that portion of Tanner Road along the edge of and adjoined to the annexed property shown on the attached Exhibit to the centerline of the afore-mentioned right-of-way is also hereby annexed into the corporate limits of the City of Mauldin effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance. Building Codes Committee * * * 31 3. ZONING ASSIGNMENT: The above referenced property owned is hereby zoned PD, Planned Development, as detailed in Exhibit 3 attached hereto. ____________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ATTEST: ________________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk First Reading: _________________________ Second Reading: ______________________ Approved as to Form: ________________________________________ City Attorney Building Codes Committee * * * 32 EXHIBIT 1 – ANNEXATION MAP Building Codes Committee * * * 33 EXHIBIT 2 – PETITION Building Codes Committee * * * 34 Building Codes Committee * * * 35 Building Codes Committee * * * 36 ORDINANCE -2022 AN ORDINANCE TO PROVIDE FOR THE ANNEXATION OF PROPERTY OWNED BY C. LYNN FARMER AND ELAINE F. AYSCUE, AND LOCATED AT 50 TANNER ROAD (TAX MAP PARCEL: 0547.03-01-043.00) BY ONE HUNDRED PERCENT PETITION METHOD; AND TO ESTABLISH A ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, FOR SAID PROPERTY WHEREAS, C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue , are the sole owners of record title of a parcel of real property containing 13 acres, more or less, located at 50 Tanner Road, which property is contiguous to the City of Mauldin and is more particularly illustrated in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, an Annexation Petition, attached hereto as Exhibit 2, has been filed with the City of Mauldin by C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue , requesting that the aforementioned property be annexed into the City of Mauldin; and, WHEREAS, the property to b e annexed is contiguous to the City of Mauldin, and is more particularly depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue, constitute one hundred (100%) percent of freeholders owning one hundred (100%) of the real property depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, the proposed zoning of PD, Planned Development , is compatible with the surrounding property uses in the area; and, WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council conclude that the annexation is in the best interest of the property owner and the City; NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the Mayor and Council of the City of Mauldin that: 1. ANNEXATION: The real property owned by C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue , and more particularly depicted in the map attached hereto marked as Exhibit 1, is hereby annexed into the corporate city limits of the City of Mauldin effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance. Building Codes Committee * * * 37 2. ANNEXATION OF A PORTION OF ADJACENT RIGHTS-OF-WAY: All of that portion of Tanner Road and Verdin Road along the edge of and adjoined to the annexed property shown on the attached Exhibit to the centerline of the afore-mentioned right-of-way is also hereby annexed into the corporate limits of the City of Mauldin effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance. 3. ZONING ASSIGNMENT: The above referenced property owned is hereby zoned PD, Planned Development, as detailed in Exhibit 3 attached hereto. ____________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ATTEST: ________________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk First Reading: _________________________ Second Reading: ______________________ Approved as to Form: ________________________________________ City Attorney Building Codes Committee * * * 38 EXHIBIT 1 – ANNEXATION MAP Building Codes Committee * * * 39 EXHIBIT 2 – PETITION Building Codes Committee * * * 40 Building Codes Committee * * * 41 Building Codes Committee * * * 42 TANNER ROAD DEVELOPMENT GREENVILLE COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA PRELIMINARY DEVELOPMENT PLAN • 08-10-2022 © COPYRIGHT 2022 DYNAMIK DESIGN PONDPOND VERDIN ROADVERDIN ROAD TANNER ROADTANNER ROAD WOODRUFF ROADWOODRUFF ROAD TANNER ROADTANNER ROAD VERDIN ROADVERDIN ROAD SITE TH TOWNHOMES 2 & 3 STORY TOWNHOMES : 100 UNITS (MAXIMUM) AVG. NUMBER OF BEDS PER UNIT : 2.2 - 2.4 (APPROX.) SERVED BY 1 CAR GARAGE & TANDEM SPACE W WORK SPACE GROUND FLOOR WORK SPACE : 14 UNITS (MAXIMUM) TOTAL : 16,000 SF (APPROX.) LW LW LW LW TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH G GARAGES 6 BAY GARAGES NO. OF GARAGES : 4 TOTAL GARAGE PARKING : 24 SPACES G G G G ENTRY / ENTRY / EXITEXIT ENTRY / ENTRY / EXITEXIT AN ON-SITE STORMWATER MANAGEMENT FACILITY WILL BE DESIGNED TO MEET GREENVILLE COUNTY STANDARDS AND SHALL ATTENUATE PEAK FLOW RATES FROM THE DEVELOPMENT TO LESS THAN PRE-DEVELOPMENT CONDITIONS. ENTRY / ENTRY / EXITEXIT POOLPOOL COURTYARDCOURTYARD TRASHTRASH DOGDOG PARKPARK 6’-0” FENCE6’-0” FENCE UNDISTURBED BUFFERUNDISTURBED BUFFER UNDISTURBED BUFFERUNDISTURBED BUFFER UNDISTURBED BUFFERUNDISTURBED BUFFER 10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER 10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER 10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER 10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER 10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER 6’-0” FENCE6’-0” FENCE 6’-0” FENCE6’-0” FENCE SITE INFORMATION VICINITY MAP LEGEND C1 AMENITIES PROPOSED MULTIFAMILY CLUB / LEASING TOTAL : 12,000 SF (APPROX.) C2 C1 C1 C2 TOTAL SITE AREA (APPROX.) : PROPOSED ZONING : 20.9 AC PD M MULTIFAMILY 4 STORY (TYPE VA) TOTAL UNITS : 365 (MAXIMUM) AVG. NUMBER OF BEDS PER UNIT : 1.3 - 1.4 (APPROX.) TOTAL PARKING : 566 SPACES (INCLUDING GARAGES) M M M M M CH CARRIAGE HOMES 2 STORY UNITS ABOVE 6 BAY GARAGES : 8 UNITS (MAXIMUM) AVG. NUMBER OF BEDS PER UNIT : 2.0 (APPROX.) TOTAL GARAGE PARKING : 18 SPACES CH CH CH TOTAL UNITS : 473 (MAXIMUM) PROPOSED MAINTENANCE / DOG WASH TOTAL : 950 SF (APPROX.) Building Codes Committee * * * 43 PIN 0547120108100 WOODRUFF CROSSING ASSOCIATION, INC. DB 2626, PAGE 3729 PB 50-R, PAGE 21 & 22 PIN 0547030105019 BROOKFIELD REALTY II, LLC 1" CRIMPED TOP PIPE FOUNDN: 1,088,702.06'E: 1,616,028.74'SC GRID NAD 83(NSRS 2011) 3/4" OPEN TOP PIPEFOUND (2.2' AG) (0.32' WEST OF LINE) 1-1/2" OPEN TOP PIPE FOUND (2.4' AG) (0.25' WEST OF LINE)N20°59'15"E 633.56' (TOTAL) 241.56' 100.33' 291.67' N69°30'20"W 151.45' N69°39'21"W S61°57'39"W 216.72' 1" CRIMPEDTOP PIPEFOUND(0.2' AG) 1" CRIMPEDTOP PIPEFOUND(FLUSH) WOODFENCE TREE LINE (TYP.) DENSE CLUSTEROF TREES DENSE CLUSTEROF TREES DENSE CLUSTER OF TREES 935 940 945 950 945 950 181.46' STORMWATERDETENTION AREA TH 33 TH 52 TH 50 TH 51 TH 45 TH 49TH 48TH 47 TH 37 TH 39TH 38 TH 43 TH 44 TH 40TH 41 TH 42 TH 60 TH 58 TH 59 TH 54 TH 53 TH 57 TH 56 TH 55 TH 61 TH 63 TH 62 TH 67 TH 68 TH 64TH 65 TH 66 TH 21 TH 22 TH 23 TH 24 TH 25 TH 26 TH 27 TH 28 TH 29 TH 30 TH 31 TH 32 TH 34 TH 35 TH 36 TH 46 950 951 950 950 951 950 950 950 951 951 951 950 950 950 950 950 950 950 950 POOL COURTYARD/ DEVELOPMENT AMENITIES 25' SETBACK 25' SETBACK 10' UNDISTURBED BUFFER 10' UNDISTURBED BUFFER 24' TYP 24'TYP 24' TYP 20.23' 18.23' 20.23' 18.23' 20.23' 18.23'27' TOP OF DAM = 950.00 TOP OF DAM = 950.00 ADDITIONAL EXISTING TREESAND VEGETATION MAY OR MAYNOT BE ABLE TO BE SAVEDDURING CONSTRUCTION 10 FOOT UNDISTURBEDBUFFER TO SAVE EXISTINGTREES AND VEGETATION,SUPPLEMENT ANY BAREAREAS WITH NEW PLANTINGS 10 FOOT UNDISTURBEDBUFFER TO SAVE EXISTINGTREES AND VEGETATION,SUPPLEMENT ANY BAREAREAS WITH NEW PLANTINGS PROPOSED 6' TALL OPAQUEPRIVACY FENCE ALONGPROPERTY LINE, ONLYDISTURB AS NEEDED TOINSTALL NEW FENCING END PROPOSED 6 FOOT HIGHWOODEN PRIVACY FENCE 6"OK 6"OK4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 12"OK 16"OK18"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 4"EL 8"OK 10"OK 12"OK 4"EL 2"EL 2"OK 8"OK 14"HK 4"EL 4"EL 8"SG 10"SG 6"SG 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 26"OK 24"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK4"OK 12"OK 14"OK 14"OK 12"OK 4"EL 2"SG2"SG 4"SG 2"SG 4"SG 4"SG 2"SG4"SG8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 10"OK 12"OK 14"OK 16"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 14"OK 10"OK 10"OK 6"OK 4"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 8"OK8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"SW 8"SW 12"PN 16"HK 16"PN 2"SG 12"SG 12"SG14"OK 16"OK 20"OK 20"OK 14"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 16"OK 6"OK 6"OK 2"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK4"OK4"OK 4"OK4"OK 4"OK 4"OK4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK CLUSTER 4"OK 4"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 2"OK 4"OK 2"OK 2"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"BI 4"SG6"SG 8"SG 4"SG8"SG 8"SG 12"SG 6"SG 8"SG8"SG 8"SG10"SG 4"SG 8"SG 12"OK 14"OK12"OK 10"OK 14"OK 6"OK 2"WC 2"WC 2"EL8"BI8"BI 6"OK 4"SGQUAD6"SG 10"SG QUAD8"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 4"EL 2"EL 4"EL 2"EL2"EL 6"EL 8"EL 6"SG 4"SG4"SG 4"SG 2"SG 12"SG 4"SG 4"SG 6"EL 8"BI 2"SG 2"SG2"SG4"SG 8"SG6"OK 10"OK 2"SG 4"SG 12"SG 4"SG 8"OK 8"SG 4"WC 2"WC2"WC TRIPLE8"OK4"BP 2"PO4"PO 4"PO 6"EL4"EL 4"EL 4"EL 8"EL 12"EL 10"EL 4"EL 6"EL 2"WC 2"WC 8"WC 4"WC 6"WC TWIN6"WC2"WC 2"WC 16"OK TRIPLE6"WC 2"WC 4"SG 8"SG 8"SG 10"OK 8"OK 8"OK8"OK 4"SG 8"SG 14"HK 2"EL 6"EL 8"OK 6"OK 10"OK6"OK 4"SG 10"SG 12"OK14"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"SG 8"OK 8"OK 6"SG2"SG 6"SG 2"SG 6"SG 2"SG 6"SG 10"SG 4"SG 4"SG 4"SG 4"SG TRIPLE4"SGTRIPLE2"SG 6"SG TRIPLE2"OK 2"OK CLUSTER 4"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 8"OK 8"OK 12"OK 12"OK 8"HK TRIPLE2"OK 10"OK 2"OK 2"OK 6"OK 4"SG 6"SG 8"SG 2"SG 8"SG 8"SG 4"SG 4"SG 4"SG 4"SG 2"SG 8"SG8"SG 8"OK 2"SG 2"SG TRIPLE2"SG QUAD2"SG 2"SG12"SG 12"SG 2"SG 10"SG 4"OK 4"SG 4"SG 4"SG 4"SG 4"SG 4"SG 4"SG 4"SG 6"SG 8"SG 12"SG 6"SG 6"SG 8"SG2"SG 2"SG 2"SG 8"SG 10"SG 10"SG 10"SG 14"PO 6"SW 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 6"OK 4"OK 8"OK 10"OK 12"OK 16"OK 4"OK 4"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 4"OK 6"OK 12"HK 8"SW 14"PN 4"SG 12"SG 4"SG6"SG 2"SG 6"SG 2"SG 14"OK 16"OK 34"OK 16"OK TWIN12"OK 4"OK 8"OK 6"OK 2"OK8"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 2"OK 8"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 6"OK 14"OK 4"OK 2"OK 4"SG 12"SW 16"PN 4"HK 6"OK 4"OK 2"OK 8"OK 12"OK 14"OK 4"OK 4"OK 14"OK 14"OK 14"OK 8"OK4"SG 14"PO 12"SG 4"SG 6"SG 12"SG 14"OK 14"OK 14"OK 14"OK 14"OK 14"OK 14"OK 14"OK 20"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 18"OK 6"OK 4"OK8"OK 10"OK 10"OK 8"OK 8"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 6"OK 6"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 18"OK 18"OK 16"OK 20"OK 4"OK 4"OK 6"OK 2"OK 8"OK 2"OK 8"OK 2"OK 14"OK 4"SG 4"SG 4"SG 14"OK 14"OK 16"OK 14"OK 14"OK20"OK 14"OK 4"SG 4"SG 6"OK 4"OK 8"OK 10"OK 6"OK 10"OK 10"OK 14"OK 14"OK 14"OK 14"OK 14"OK16"OK 16"OK 18"OK 2"OK 8"OK 6"OK 4"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 8"OK 10"PO 8"SW 14"PN TRIPLE12"SG 4"SW 16"OK 16"OK 14"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"OK 12"PN12"PN 10"OK 10"OK 6"OK 4"SG 2"SG 4"OK 2"OK 4"OK 2"OK 4"OK4"OK 16"PN 14"PN 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 4"OK 18"PO 16"PO 6"OK 2"OK 6"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 2"OK 8"OK 6"OK 14"OK 2"OK 10"OK 12"OK 16"OK 4"BI 2"BI2"BI 6"EL 14"OK CLUSTER 18"SG TWIN4"OK 4"PO 4"PO 6"SG 16"SG 2"SG 12"MA Building Codes Committee * * * 44 NORTHCONDO PROPOSED 6 FOOT HIGHWOODEN OPAQUE FENCEFOR ENTIRE LENGTH OFPROPERTY LINE THs PROPOSED LANDSCAPINGPROPOSED 4 FOOT HIGHPOND/WALL FENCE EXISTING NEIGHBORING VEGETATION MIDDLECONDO EXISTING 6 FOOT HIGHWOODEN OPAQUE FENCEPROPOSED 6 FOOT HIGHWOODEN OPAQUE FENCEFOR ENTIRE LENGTH OFPROPERTY LINE PROPOSED LANDSCAPING PROPOSEDRETAINING WALL PROPOSED 4 FOOT HIGHPOND/WALL FENCE THs EXISTING NEIGHBORING VEGETATION EXISTING NEIGHBORING VEGETATION SOUTHCONDO PROPOSED 6 FOOT HIGHWOODEN OPAQUE FENCEFOR ENTIRE LENGTH OFPROPERTY LINE PROPOSEDRETAINING WALL THs WEST PROPERTY LINE WEST PROPERTY LINE 10.0' BUFFERYARD10.0' BUFFERYARD WEST PROPERTY LINE 10.0' BUFFERYARD 240' 190' 270' PROPOSED BUFFERYARDSHRUB AT PLANTING ANDMATURE PROPOSED BUFFERYARDSHRUB AT PLANTING ANDMATURE PROPOSED BUFFERYARDSHRUB AT PLANTING ANDMATURE PROPOSEDRETAINING WALL PROPOSED LANDSCAPINGPROPOSED 4 FOOT HIGHPOND/WALL FENCE EXISTING 6 FOOT HIGHWOODEN OPAQUE FENCE PROPOSED 4 FOOT HIGHPOND/WALL FENCEPROPOSED 4 FOOT HIGHPOND/WALL FENCE PROPOSED 4 FOOT HIGHPOND/WALL FENCE Building Codes Committee * * * 45 STANDING SEAM ROOF WHITE CEMENTITIOUS PANEL WHITE CEMENTITIOUS PANEL GRAY BOARD & BATTEN GRAY BRICKDARK GRAY CEMENTITIOUS PANEL © COPYRIGHT 2022 DYNAMIK DESIGN TANNER ROAD DEVELOPMENT GREENVILLE COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA PRELIMINARY DEVELOPMENT PLAN • 08-10-2022 Building Codes Committee * * * 46 DARK GRAY CEMENTITIOUS PANEL DARK GRAY CEMENTITIOUS PANEL GRAY BOARD & BATTEN WHITE BOARD & BATTEN WHITE BOARD & BATTEN GRAY BRICKWHITE CEMENTITIOUS PANEL © COPYRIGHT 2022 DYNAMIK DESIGN TANNER ROAD DEVELOPMENT GREENVILLE COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA PRELIMINARY DEVELOPMENT PLAN • 08-10-2022 Building Codes Committee * * * 47 1 Tanner Road Mixed Use Community Statement of Intent City of Mauldin, SC August 2022 Table of Contents G e n e r a l O v e r v i e w 2 - 3 Multifamily Residential Units 3 W o r k S p a c e 3 P r o p e r t y M a i n t e n a n c e 4 D e v e l o p m e n t S c h e d u l e 4 Roadways and Interconnectivity 4 - 5 Impact on Public Facilities 5 G a r b a g e C o l l e c t i o n 5 F i r e P r o t e c t i o n 5 Design Style 6 Landscape and Screening 6 - 7 S i g n a g e 7 S i t e L i g h t i n g 8 E x a m p l e R e f e r e n c e P h o t o s 9 - 1 6 Building Codes Committee * * * 48 2 General Overview This Statement of Intent describes in detail a proposed mixed u se community, at the intersection of Verdin Road and Tanner Road. The site is appro ximately 20.99-acres and will be described in this Statement of Intent as the Tanner Road Mixed Use Community. The site has approximately 1,000 feet of frontage on Tanner Road which is th e northern boundary of the site, and approximately 725 feet of frontage on Verdin Road which is the eastern boundary of the site. The site consists of three parcels currently zoned R-S in Greenville County, TMS 0547030104300, 0547030104301, and 0547030104302 and are currently owned by the Ayscue and Farmer (0547030104300) and Jones (0547030104301 and 0547030104302) fam ilies. Combined, these three parcels comprise the ~20.99-acre site discussed herein. The existing property is currently surrounded by or is in close proximity to a mixture of uses including an office park, heavy commercial, neighborhood retail, assisted living development, a carwash, self-storage, attached single family, a bank, and other heavy commercial uses like a gas station. The property is currently in Greenville County and is used for agricultural though surrounded by commercial and office uses. Flournoy Development Group, who has successfully purchased and developed or is in- process of developing 5 other properties in Greenville, will be the master developer of the Tanner Road Mixed Use Community. This site was chosen due to its cent ralized location in the region with convenient proximity to an abundance of employment opportu nities, shopping, services, entertainment options, a robust roadway network, and the opport unity for this development’s future residents to support and be part of the surrounding community. The site is truly a location where its residents can live, work, and play within an activated environment. The Tanner Road Mixed Use Community will encompass a mix of use s including both multifamily residences and townhomes, along with live/work units integrated into select buildings that front the main drive accessing the community from Verdin R oad. The development will include no more than 365 multifamily residences, 100 townhomes, 8 carriage homes, and 14 work spaces. These work spaces will be physically connected to the residential unit above to allow the tenant to combine the work space with the residential unit above to become what we describe as a live/work unit. For clarity in this Statement of Intent, when describing density or number of units, we will divide these live/work units into live space (i.e., an apartment unit) and work space(s). By way of example, if we describe having 14 live/work units, this would equate to 14 apartment units and 14 work spaces. As outlined above, the development will have no more than 14 work spaces which can be combined with their associated living space above. The work portion of these units will generally range from approximately 700 square feet to approximately 1,200 square feet or larger. The work spaces are intended to be used for small office spaces or small-scale neighborhood retail uses and are primarily geared towards entrepreneurs, small businesses, and professionals. Examples of uses that may be seen in a live/work unit are an accountant, architect, artist/artisan, attorney, computer software and multimedia related professional, consultant, engin eer, a coffee shop, fashion designer, clothing boutique, graphic designer, interior designer, hair stylist, home-based office worker, insurance agent, real estate or travel agent, one-on-one instructor, photographer, and other Building Codes Committee * * * 49 3 similar occupations. Uses that are not intended for this type of space include, for example, vehicle repair or maintenance, adult businesses, massage parlors, large commercial restaurants utilizing a commercial kitchen, and uses tha t create excessive noise, dust, heat, smoke, and odors that are considered a nuisance or are unsafe for other residents or empl oyees. If changing marketplace conditions result in little to no demand for the work spaces, we may consider requesting a formal change to the Planned Development (PD) to convert these work spaces to standard apartment units in accordance with the City of Mauldin’s PD procedures. It is the desire of Flournoy Development Group for the subject property to be rezoned to Planned Development (PD), to allow for a development that is innovative in its land planning and site design concepts to create a high quality of life for its residents. We intend for the development to achieve a high level of aesthetics and be a development that exemplifies quality while promoting community, connectivity, and walkability across a variety of dynamic uses and residential product types. Multifamily Residential Units The total acreage of the site is approximately 20.99-acres and we are proposing no more than 473 multifamily residential units including the townhomes and carriage homes. The units will have a mixture of sizes, including 1, 2, and 3 bedroom dwellings. Units will vary in size from approximately 600 square feet up to approximately 1,600 square feet or more across the various product types previously described. Buildings will range from 2 stories to 4 stories in height. The exteriors will be constructed with a variety of materials but will consist primarily of masonry and fiber cementitious board. In addition to the multifamily units, residents will also have access to a plethora of amenities which are proposed to include but not be limited to upscale club space, meeting rooms for residents who work from home, co-working space, fitness and wellness rooms, a dog park, mail kiosk, package lockers, a swimming pool courty ard, and other courtyards containing outdoor entertainment spaces, grills, firepits, and other amenities. Work Space The work spaces previously described are also a part of the app roximate 20.99-acre site. These spaces will not be separate buildings and are designed to be vertically incorporated into several of the main buildings located along the main drive entering the community on the ground level of the buildings, with the intention to create an activat ed “main street” feel at this primary community entry. Work spaces will range in size from approxima tely 700 square feet to 1,200 square feet or larger. Due to these spaces being incorporated into the main multifamily buildings, the building heights are the same as the multifamily residential buildings. Parking for these units will be available in front of the buildings along the main entry drive as well as around the side and behind the buildings. Due to the nature of the work space, we anticipate that almost all the spaces will be occupied during normal working hours. Building Codes Committee * * * 50 4 Property Maintenance Due to the nature of this devel opment, the property will remai n one parcel and is not intended to be subdivided or sold to separate owners. As a result, no property owner’s association will be needed, as all maintenance for this community will be p erformed by the owner or their property management company. This includes private drive aisles, parking, storm water systems, sidewalks, landscaping, trash pickup, and all other aspects of the community needing maintenance. There will also be a single automobile wash area for resident u se only as well as a maintenance building and trash compactor. Development Schedule Planning and due diligence are currently in progress for the subject site and will continue until the property is fully rezoned. Once rezoning is complete , construction documents will be developed and submitted for permitting. Once permits are recei ved and the property is closed, it is anticipated that construction will begin. We anticipate this to occur during the first quarter of 2023. The project will be completed in one phase with each bui lding turning over at different times in a planned sequence. We anticipate our first building to open around the third or fourth quarter of 2024 and construction to be complete by late 2024 or early 2025. Roadways and Interconnectivity The Tanner Road Mixed Use Community currently has three proposed main points of ingress and egress. One is from Tanner Road and two from Verdi n Road. All roadway improvements will be internal to the development and will be pr ivate. A traffic impact study has been completed by a South Carolina licensed engineer and associ ated recommendations included within this study are currently under review by SCDOT. Based upon this traffic impact study, any increased traffic is expected to be spread out amongst driveways and road systems, and outside of potential traffic signal optimization at the Woodruff Road/Verd in Road intersection, or potential restriping of one northbound lane on Verdin Road to facilitate a dual left-turn lane from Verdin Road onto Woodruff Road, no additional roadway improvements or traffic mitigation measures are recommended or warranted (pe r the traffic impact study). N ote that any roadway improvements and/or traffic mitigation measures will be install ed or implemented as may be required and approved by SCDOT. Sidewalks (5’) will be installed along Tanner Road as well as Verdin Road in order to promote walkability and connectivity to the surrounding community and larger public sidewalk system. In addition to this sidewalk, t he internal sidewalk system within this development is designed to c onnect to the sidewalks along Tanner Road and Verdin Road, which creates convenient permanent connectivity to the vacant adjacent parcel. Relative to parking: the current design meets or exceeds the C ity of Mauldin minimum parking requirements for multiple-family dwellings (multifamily units and townhomes) and live/work units. In addition, minimum parking per industry standard will be provided based upon Building Codes Committee * * * 51 5 the final unit mix. The parking spaces will typically be 9’ x 1 8’ for all parking spaces whether back-to-back or adjacent to a curb or sidewalk. Handicap spaces will also be 9’x 18’. Impact on Public Facilities Sanitary Sewer New sewer lines will be installe d within the community itself by the developer and dedicated to the appropriate Sewer Sub-district. Sewer service is available and capacity analysis and sanitary sewer connections are currently being studied and reviewed. Water Water service is available from Greenville Water, and all nece ssary lines and connections will be installed by the developer as a private water main syst em to serve the project for water supply and fire service. Electricity Electricity is available from Laurens Electric, and undergroun d p o w e r l i n e s w i l l b e installed within the community. Storm Drainage Stormwater Management for the p roject will provide a permanent on-site storm drainage system and stormwater detention facility which will serve both water quality and water quantity. These systems will be designed to meet or exceed all local, state and federal regulations involving stormwater flows as well as an extensive erosion and sedimentation control plan for construction. Stormwater will continue to be released onto adjacent properties and will be designed to maintain the current existing flow pattern and direction without any adverse impact on downstream features. The stormwater system, including the detention ponds, will be maintained by the developer/owner. Garbage Collection Garbage collection will be by private contract carrier. All garbage will be collected in an enclosed trash compactor which will serve the entire community and can also be accessed by all residents and work space tenants. The compactor will be enclos ed and hidden by an opaque building material which will complement the materials used within the development. Fire Protection Mauldin Fire District will prov ide fire protection within the community. Building Codes Committee * * * 52 6 Design Style The design style of the Tanner Road Mixed Use Community begins first with the site plan, which was intentionally designed to account for the relationship between the buildings within the site as well as the relationship between the buildings on-site and the surrounding properties, views, and roadways. As reflected on the site plan, the main leasing office as well as the live/work units all front the main entry drive entering the site from Verdin Ro ad. This was done intentionally in order to create a more active, public, and engaging streetscape by tapping into a “main street” style look for residents and visitors as they enter the community. T he use of L-shaped and U-shaped buildings also allows for more interesting spaces between buildings, creating a slightly more urban feel and allowing for the integration of courtyards throughout the site to produce more relaxed spaces for residents to enjoy. The architecture of the project is also highly intentional and complimentary to the site plan as well. Since much of the surrounding land around the site is developed, our intention is to create a development that goes above-a nd-beyond a standard apartment c ommunity. With the addition of an architectural style that ties more traditional suburban q ualities with a slightly more modern urban design, we have successfully designed a more transitional community that is not only compatible with, but also adds a fresh look to the surrounding community. The architectural style of all the buildings and amenities is intended to bridge the more historic residential warmth of the city with the more commercialized feel of the area surrounding the site. Traditional exterior materials of brick and cementitious siding are creatively combi ned for a more modern look, blending seamlessly with the commercial storefronts, retail can opies or awnings, and signage at the live/work units along the main entry drive. Masonry and detailing at the street level will create a more pedestrian scale and interest, inviting the surrounding community into the development. Landscaping and Screening The Tanner Road Mixed Use Community will have a large array of different types of landscape depending upon the site area in question. Frontage along Tanner Road and Verdin Road will consist of street trees and other decorative landscaping around monument signs and the site entrances while a 10’ landscape buffer is maintained on these road frontages. In addition, and in response to feedback from the adjacent neighborhood, we have agreed to provide a minimum 10’ existing vegetative buffer yard along the entire western property line that will only be accessed and disturbed in order to construct an opaque privacy fence along the property. Any currently bare areas within this 10’ undisturbed buffer will be supplemented with new plantings as needed that will grow to a minimum 14’ tall at maturity. We are also responding to the neighboring community’s concerns by agreeing to also install a 6’ opaque privacy fence as a buffer in order to prevent foot traffic through the adjacent neighborhood. This privacy fence will essentially run the entire western property boundary. In addition to the privacy fence and existing vegetative/undisturbed buffer along the western property line, in areas where the existing vegetative buffer is non-existent, we will supplement the existing vegetation with evergreen shrubs which will be of a variety that will grow a minimum of 14’ tall. These will be installed approximately 10’ apart and serve as an Building Codes Committee * * * 53 7 additional form of landscaping screening to the adjacent neighborhood. The detention pond, which will also serve as a natural deterrent to foot traffic entering the neighboring community to the west, as well as the dog park will be surrounded by a 4-rail wooden fence with horse wire, similar to the one in the example photos enclosed within this Statement of Intent. In addition to the landscaping and buffers, the interior of the property will follow the below landscaping guidelines:  Plant material will be installed in parking lot islands, around all building foundations, in courtyards, and along all public roadways.   Where powerlines are present and large canopy trees cannot be p lanted, lower understory trees will be selected from Duke Energy’s approved plant list.    A mixture of deciduous canopy trees and evergreen trees will be planted throughout the community in tree islands and courtyards to create different sp aces throughout the community for residents and visitors to enjoy. Grasses and gro und covers will be used throughout the community to reduce heat, prevent erosion, and c reate an aesthetically pleasing landscape for the residents and the public. Mulch will also be used throughout to promote healthy plants, reduce erosion, and to help reduce water consumption.    All landscaping will be maintained regularly, and an irrigation system will be used to assist in keeping plant material vibrant and healthy. For water conservation, rain sensors and soil moisture sensors will be utilized in the community as well.   Hardscape material will also be utilized in certain areas of th e site to promote an aesthetically pleasing community and to delineate spaces that are more public in nature and spaces that are more socially active. A mixture of pavers, concrete, and other materials will be utilized to this end. Signage Signage will meet the City of Mauldin Sign Ordinance. Monumen t signs or a blade sign will be used at the main entrances. Monument signage (if utili zed) along Verdin Road will not exceed 10’ in height, and one smaller single faced monument sign along Tanner Road that will not exceed 8’ in height. The monument sign will include our property name and may also include the name of the work space tenants. Materials shall be the same or similar in nature to the main building materials and the design will complement the architect ure of the community. The sign will be either internally lit, back-lit, or lighted with a grou nd mounted light. No neon or scrolling/moving text shall be used. There may also be signage in front of or above the main entry of each work space in order to identify each individual busines s. This signage will either be part of an awning over each entry or a sign that is hung perpendicular on the side of the building. See example photos enclosed on later pages of this Statement of Int ent for additional reference. The leasing office will also have signage in front of the space or above the entry in order for visitors to identify the main entry point into that space. Directional si gnage will also be incorporated throughout the development to assist visitors and emergency veh icles in navigating the property efficiently. Building Codes Committee * * * 54 8 Site Lighting Lighting for the Tanner Road Mixed Use Community will vary depending on the application it is being used for. Along interior streets and parking, where buildings are nearby, and pedestrian activity is highest, decorative lantern type streetlights with a mounting height of no more than 18’ will be used to light the community. Due to feedback from the neighboring community, we are also minimizing lighting along the western property line and where present and within 50’ of the western property line, will reduce the height of those light poles to 12’. In limited areas where we have more than one row of parking, or near property lines, downlight shoebox type fixtures will be used to light these more open areas and will have a mounting height of no more than 20’ in height. Specialty areas on-site, like courtyards and around the pool, may possibly incorporate roughly 4’ high bollards for more localized lighting. Bollard lights will be full cutoff. Building lighting will also be incorporated into select areas of the buildings to introduce lighting to patios, balconies, and entry points into the buildings. All lighting near property lines will be full cut-off fixtures to prevent light from bleeding onto the adjacent properties. Building Codes Committee * * * 55 9 Example Reference Photos Example of 4 rail wooden fence with horse wire. Also, an example of “lantern” type light poles. Example of “lantern” lighting and ground level bollard light ing (full cutoff). Building Codes Committee * * * 56 10 Examples of courtyard design. Building Codes Committee * * * 57 11 Example of courtyard amenities. Example of Live/Work space. Building Codes Committee * * * 58 12 Examples of Live/Work space. Building Codes Committee * * * 59 13 Examples of Monument Signs. Building Codes Committee * * * 60 14 Example of Monument Sign. Example of Live/Work Space signage. Building Codes Committee * * * 61 15 Example of Live/Work Space signage. Examples of full cutoff Shoebox Light (per Laurens Electric Cooperative, Inc.). Subject development intends to utilize similar fixtures. Building Codes Committee * * * 62 16 Example of full cutoff Lantern Pole Light (per Laurens Electric Cooperative, Inc.). Subject development intends to utilize similar fixtures. Example of wooden fencing/privacy fence. Building Codes Committee * * * 63 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: September 6, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6c TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Code Enforcement of Nuisances BACKGROUND The City of Mauldin ’s nuisance ordinance cu rrently refer s to the Building and Zoning Director as responsible for the enforcement of the standards therein. Not only does the City not have a position by this name, but it has been the City’s practice for the City’s code enforcement officer to conduct the enforcement of the City’s nuisance standards. DRAFT ORDINANCE The attached ordinance, reviewed by the City Attorney, replaces the Building and Zoning Director with the Code Enforcement Official as the staff responsible for the enforcement of the City’s nuisance standards. See the attached draft ordinance for the full text of said ordinance. REQUEST This draft ordinance is being presented to the Building Codes Committee at this time for review and comment. If the Committee chooses, they may recommend this ordinance to the City Council for review. ATTACHMENTS Draft Ordinance Building Codes Committee * * * 64 ORDINANCE # __________ AN AMENDMENT TO CHAPTER 18, ARTICLE II (NUISANCES) OF THE MAULDIN CODE OF ORDINANCES TO AUTHORIZE THE CODES ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL RATHER THAN THE BUILDING AND ZONING DIRECTOR TO ENFORCE CERTAIN PROVISIONS CONTAINED HEREIN AND FOR OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO WHEREAS, the Mauldin City Council at various times reviews the city ordinances to make necessary improvements and/or changes; and, WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin recognizes the need to protect against nuisances that may impair public health, safety, and general welfare; and, WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin desires to amend its ordinance to authorize the codes enforcement official rather than then the building and zoning director to take enforce certain provisions contained in Chapter 18, Article II; and, WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin finds that the following amendment s to Chapter 18, Article II (Nuisance) promotes the health, safety, and welfare of the citizens and residents of the City of Mauldin. NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof that the Mauldin Municipal Code be amended as follows: Section 1 Amendment. Amend Chapter 18, Article II, Nuisances, as follows ( language that is struck through is language proposed to be deleted, underlined language is language proposed to be added, language is not struck through or underlined is not to be changed, and *** represents sections of the Zoning Ordinance that have been skipped and remain unchanged): CHAPTER 18 – ENVIRONMENT *** ARTICLE II. – NUISANCES DIVISION 1. – GENERALLY Section 18-31. – Condition of premises generally. All persons shall maintain their yards, cellars, drains, stable lots and all other lands owned or occupied by them in the city, whether occupied or vacant, in a clean and healthy condition. It shall be unlawful for the owner or occupant of any premises within the city limits to permit such premises to become filthy, dirty or so filled with rubbish as to emit Building Codes Committee * * * 65 dangerous or disagreeable odors to the annoyance or discomfort of persons who reside or transact business in that locality or who may pass along any street, lane, ally or sidewalk in the vicinity. Any place so kept or permitted is hereby declared a nuisance, subject to abatement by the building and zoning director code enforcement official or other official designated by the City Administrator. Section 18-32. – Report of unsanitary conditions to council. It shall be the duty of the building and zoning director the code enforcement official or other official designated by the City Administrator to report unsanitary conditions of buildings and premises to the City Administrator, who, in turn, shall inform the city council. Section 18-33. – Prohibited acts. It shall be unlawful for any person to do any act which offends, endangers, injures or impairs the health, safety or life of any individual. Any such act is hereby declared a public nuisance. Section 18-34. – Unsanitary, unsightly and unsafe conditions. (a) All premises within the city, whether vacant, improved or occupied, shall at all times be kept in a sanitary condition. All damp low places and all garbage, leaves, trash cans, vessels, broken bottles, pieces of me tal, china, glass or other materials that may hold water are hereby declared to be a public nuisance. Weeds, grass and other rank vegetation which is allowed to grow, stand uncut upon, or garbage, trash, eroded soil and other debris allowed to accumulate and remain on any lot or allowed to spill into the public right -of-way, so as to render the premises unsightly or unsanitary, are hereby deemed and declared to be a public nuisance and a detriment to health and safety. The occupant or lessee of any such p remises and the owner, his agent, representative or employee having control of any vacant premises within the city who shall permit or tolerate the existence of any conditions condemned in this section shall be guilty of a misdemeanor. (b) It shall be the duty of any owner and any lessee, occupant, agent or representative of the owner of any lot or parcel of land to cut or cause to be cut all weeds, grass and other rank vegetation and to remove all garbage, trash, eroded soil and other debris as often as may b e necessary to prevent the development of any of the conditions which are prohibited in this section. Section 18-35. – Conditions affording food or harborage for rats. (a) It shall be unlawful for any person to place, leave, dump or permit to accumulate any garbage, rubbish or trash in any building, vehicle and their surrounding areas in the city so that the same shall or may afford food or harborage for rats. Any violation of this section shall constitute a public nuisance. Building Codes Committee * * * 66 (b) It shall be unlawful and constitute a public nuisance for any person to permit to accumulate on any premises, improved or vacant, or on any open lots or alleys in the city, any lumber, boxes, barrels, b ricks, stones or similar materials and permit them to remain thereon unless the same shall be placed on open racks that are elevated not less than 18 inches above the ground and evenly piled or stacked, so that these materials will not afford harborage for rates or violate any other provisions of this article. Section 18-36. – Abatement. (a) The building and zoning director code enforcement official, upon receiving notice of the existence of any condition declared by this article, shall notify the existence of any condition declared by this article, shall notify the person responsible for such condition to clean up his premises and abate such public nuisance within ten days. It shall be sufficient notification to deliver the notice or a copy thereof to the person to whom it is addressed or to deposit a copy of such notice in the United States mail properly stamped and directed to such person at his last known address and post a copy thereof on the premises upon which the public nuisance exists. If service of notice cannot be obtained in either of such methods, notice will be posted in a conspicuous place, for 24 hours, on the premises where the violation has occurred. (b) Upon failure of the person to abate the cited public nuisance, as provided for in this section, within ten days after notice, a person violating these provisions of this section shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor and punished in accordance with section 1-6. (c) The employees or agents of the City may enter upon the premises of the offending person and cause the public nuisance to be removed therefrom. The cost of removing such nuisance shall become a lien upon the land, and such person shall be liable to the city for the costs of removal or abatement in addition to being subject to prosecution for violating this article. Section 18-37. – Right of entry to abate. The building and zoning director code enforcement official, together with his subordinates, assistants, workers, employees and agents, shall have the power to enter upon any premises within the City upon which there is suspected to be a public nuisance for the purpose of abating the same. Any person who in any manner hinders or obstructs any authorized officer or representative of the city in the inspecting of any premises within the City limits, in the abatement or removal of any public nuisance, or in the discharge of any duties prescribed in this article or any other ordinance for the prevention or correction of any unsanitary, unsightly, or unsafe condition in the City shall be guilty of a misdemeanor. *** Building Codes Committee * * * 67 Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage. Passed on First Reading: _______________________________ Passed on Second Reading: ______________________________ CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA BY: ________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ATTEST: ___________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ Daniel Hughes, City Attorney Building Codes Committee * * * 68 BUILDING CODES COMMITEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: September 6, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6d TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Light Trespass Ordinance BACKGROUND Earlier this year, s taff was asked to examine and explore the opportunity to consider outdoor lighting standards that could address nuisances created by outdoor lighting, particularly in residential neighborhoods. Some draft standards were considered by City Council on June 20, 2022. At that meeting, various members of City Council discussed concerns including: • What training or equipment will be required to enforce the standards of the ordinance? • Preference for standards that are quantitative and can be measured rather than standards that may require the judgment of the enforcement officer • Preference for standards that don’t rely on the interpretation of an official • Preference for a radius where the complaint can be generated CURRENT MAULDIN STANDARDS Presently, the City of Maul din has some outdoor lighting standards prescribed in Section 6:3.1 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance. These provisions primarily apply to new development and where new outdoor lighting fixtures are installed, except that these provisions do not apply to si ngle-family residential properties even though single-family residential properties may be the cause of glare and light pollution to other single-family properties. Additionally, these provisions do not apply to street lighting installed by a governmental agency. NEIGHBORING JURISDICTIONS STANDARDS Most of the other nearby jurisdictions, including Greenville County, the City of Simpsonville, and the City of Greer, have comparable outdoor lighting standards to the City of Mauldin and exempt single-family residential properties from outdoor lighting standards . Only the City of Greenville provides lighting standards that also apply at single-family residential properties. DUKE ENERGY PROCEDURES City staff recently had the opportunity to meet with Duke Energy officials to discuss the provisions being considered by the City of Mauldin. These officials commented that light glare is very d ifficult to define and enforce. Their experience is that what is perceived as glare is different from case to case. They advised Building Codes Committee * * * 69 that it is much easier to define, measure, and enforce light trespass as measured in foot-candles. They also expressed that the height restrictions that the City was considering for lights was not consistent w ith their practice. The light poles that they typically install have a height of about 25 feet above the ground, not including pedestrian lights which generally are shorter. They also advised that restricting light pole height may have little effect if adjacent properties have different grade elevations. These officials a lso explained the procedures the follow when installing light poles and revi ewing subsequent complaints. A property owner who requests the installation of a Duke light pole is required to sign a contract with Duke Energy. Included in the contract is a provision that the customer agrees to abide by local ordinances. When Duke Energy receives complaints about lights, they generally direct the complainant to talk directly to the property owner of the offending light. They do this to avoid ge tting in the middle of neighbor disputes. The property owner is able to request that Duke Energy make adjustments to the light to mitigate the concerns from a neighbor. Depending on the nature of the concern, Duke Energy is able to shield the light, lower the light on the pole, change out the color of the light, among other solutions. Duke Energy indicated that they generally respon d in about 3 -5 days, although on occasion they may be delayed due to extenuating circumstances. DRAFT ORDINANCE In response to the input receive from various members of City Council as well as Duke Energy officials, the attached draft ordinance has been greatly simplified. Specifically, the ordinance identifies exemptions including traffic control signals and devices, street lights, temporary emergency lighting, moving vehicle lights, navigation lights, public sports and recreational facilities, seasonal decorations, and oth er lighting on City of Mauldin property or a s may be required by SCDOT. The standards prescribed by the draft ordinance include: 1. Lighting may not illuminate an adjacent residential property in excess of 0.5 foot-candles of light; and 2. No blinking, flashing, or fluttering lights or other illuminated device that has a chan ging light intensity, brightness, or color is permitted in any district. See the attached draft ordinance for the full text of said ordinance. The limit of 0.5 foot-candles is the same as used in the zoning ordinance for nonresidential properties that abut residential properties. Please note that 0.5 foot-candles is about the equivalent light level of a standard 60-watt incandescent light bulb measured at a distance of about 11 feet from the bulb. If measuring a standard 100-watt incandescent light bulb, it would be the light level at distance of about 16 feet from the light bulb. These figures may differ depending on varying factors. Please note that in order to enforce this draft ordinanc e the City will need to purchase light meter devices which generally cost between $50 and $500 for each device. The Police Chief has commented that the officers that may assist in the enforcement of this ordinance will also need training. If there are frequent complaints of light trespass, the Police Chief has indicated that he may need to hire an additional code enforcement officer. TIMELINE On June 6, 2022, the Building Codes Committee voted 3-0 to forward a draft ordinance to City Council for consideration. Building Codes Committee * * * 70 On June 20, 2022, the City Council discussed a draft ordinance and referred it back to the Building Codes Committee. ATTACHMENTS Draft Ordinance Building Codes Committee * * * 71 ORDINANCE # __________ AN AMENDMENT TO CHAPTER 18, ARTICLE II (NUISANCES) OF THE MAULDIN CODE OF ORDINANCES TO ESTABLISH CERTAIN STANDARDS TO PROTECT AGAINST NUISANCES CAUSED BY LIGHT TRESPASS AND FOR OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO WHEREAS, the Mauldin City Council at various times reviews the city ordinances to make necessary improvements and/or changes; and, WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin recognizes the need to protect against nuisances that may impair public health, safety, and general welfare; and, WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin also desires to amend its ordinance to add “Division 4 – Light Glare and Light Trespass” to protect against light trespass that may impair the enjoyment of life and constitute a public nuisance; and, WHEREAS, the City of Mauldin finds that the following amendment s to Chapter 18, Article II (Nuisance) promotes the health, safety, and welfare of the citizens and residents of the City of Mauldin. NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof that the Mauldin Municipal Code be amended as follows: Section 1 Amendment. Amend Chapter 18, Article II, Nuisances, as follows (language that is struck through is language proposed to be deleted, underlined language is language proposed to be added, language is not struck through or underlined is not to be changed, and *** represents sections of the Zoning Ordinance that have been skipped and remain unchanged): CHAPTER 18 – ENVIRONMENT *** ARTICLE II. – NUISANCES *** DIVISION 4 – LIGHT TRESPASS Section 18-101. – Purpose The purpose of this section is to provide regulations that control light trespass onto adjacent residential properties. Building Codes Committee * * * 72 Section 18-102 – Definitions (a) “Foot-candle” – A measure of illuminance or a measure of how bright a light appears to the eye. On e foot-candle is equal to one lumen per square foot. As an example, a typical sixty-watt incandescent lamp (eight hundred forty lumens) produces an illuminance of 0.1 foot-candles at a distance of about twenty-five feet. (b) "Light trespass" – Any light emitted by an outdoor luminaire that shines directly or indirectly beyond the property on which the luminaire is installed. (c) “Luminaire” – A complete lighting unit including the lamps, together with the parts required to distribute the light, to posit ion and protect the lamps, and to connect the lamps to the power supply. Section 18-103. – Applicability. (a) The requirements of this section shall apply to all private and public property within the City except as may be exempted below. (b) The following are exempt from the provisions of this chapter. (1) Traffic control signals and devices; (2) Street lights; (3) Temporary emergency lighting (i.e., fire, police, repair workers) or warning lights; (4) Moving vehicle lights; (5) Navigation lights (i.e., communication towers, etc.) or any other lights where state or federal statute or other provision of the City of Mauldin codes and regulations that requires lighting which cannot comply with this section; (6) Public sports and recreational facilities; (7) Seasonal decorations; and (8) Other lighting on City of Mauldin property or as may required by SCDOT. Building Codes Committee * * * 73 Section 18-104. – Specific Standards for Lighting. (a) Lighting may not illuminate an adjacent residential property in excess of a measurement of 0.5 foot-candles of light. (b) No blinking, flashing or fluttering lights or other illuminated device that has a changing light intensity, brightness, or color is permitted in any district except for temporary holiday displays. Section 18-105. – Violations. (a) Upon receipt of a complaint , the code enforcement official or other city designee shall take appropriate light measurements with a light meter device at the property line of the party that placed the complaint . If a violation of this section is found to exist, the offending party will be given not more than thirty (30) days to remedy the violation . Appropriate remedies may include concealing or shielding the light source. (b) If the violation is not corrected within the prescribed period, the codes enforcement official or other city designee may either seek an injunctive relief through the Greenville County Court of Common Pleas and/or issue a citation. (c) Violation of the provisions of this chapter of failure to comply with any of its requirements shall constitute a misdemeanor. Upon conviction thereof, the person may be fined not more than five hundred dolla rs or imprisoned for not more than thirty days and in addition shall pay all costs and expenses involved in the case. Each day such violation continues shall be considered a separate offense. Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage. Passed on First Reading: _______________________________ Passed on Second Reading: ______________________________ CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA BY: ________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ATTEST: Building Codes Committee * * * 74 ___________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ Daniel Hughes, City Attorney Building Codes Committee * * * 75 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: September 6, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6e TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Drive-thru Standards in the Central Redevelopment District BACKGROUND Staff has been asked to include a discussion of drive-thru standards in the Central Redevelopment District as part of the agenda for the Building Codes Committee. CURRENT MAULDIN STANDARDS Presently, the City of Mauldin has general standards that require a minimum amount of distance for vehicles that queue or stack in drive-thru lanes depending on the type of business (e.g., bank, ATM, restaurant, car wash, etc.). There are no other restrictions on drive-thru facilities in the Central Redevelopment District. NEIGHBORING JURISDICTIONS STANDARDS Staff has studies the drive -thru standards provided by other jurisdictions in South Carolina, particularly within the Upstate. Below is a summary of the standards for selected jurisdictions. Greenville. The City of Greenville provides general standa rds that regula te how drive -thru lanes and facilities are laid out. They cannot be in front of a building, face a residential dwelling, or negatively impact the pedestrian experience. Where pedestrian pathways cross a drive-thru lane, the pedestrian pathway must be raised and made prominent to ensure pedestrian visibility and safety. They also have standards for drive- thru covers (roofs or canopies), speakers, and signs. Simpsonville. In their town center district, the City of Simpsonville restricts drive-thru lanes and windows from being located in front of a building. They also require drive-thru facilities to be l ocated as far as practicable from any pedestrian pathways. Fountain Inn. In their gateway district, the City of Fountain Inn restricts buildings on corner lots from locating drive-thru lanes between the building and the street. Greer. The City of Greer does not appear to have any restrictions on drive-thru facilities. Travelers Rest. The City of Travelers Rest does not appear to have any restriction on drive-thru facilities. Easley. The City of Easley does not allow drive -in or drive -thru facilities at restaur ant and dri nking establishments within their central commercial district. Building Codes Committee * * * 76 Clemson. The City of Clemson does not appear to have any restrictions on drive-thru facilities. Anderson. The City of Anderson does not appear to have any restrictions on drive-thru facilities. Spartanburg. In their downtown district, the City of Spartanburg restricts drive-thru facilities from locating within 500 feet of an existing drive-thru facility. They do not allow drive-thru lanes or windows in front of the building. Rock Hill. The City of Rock Hill provides general standards that do not allow drive-thru facilities in front of the building or to impede pedestrian paths. Order boxes and pickup windows must be setback at least 100 feet from any residential property or use. Fort Mill. The City of Fort Mill does not appear to have any restrictions on drive-thru facilities. Newberry. The City of Newberry does not appear to have any restrictions on drive-thru facilities. Aiken. In their down town district, the City of Aiken does not allow d rive-thru facilities at restaurants, although they do allow them for banks. Columbia. In their downtown district, the City of Columbia prohibits all drive-thru facilities. RECOMMENDED STANDARDS Generally, staff would at a minimum recommend standards that prohibit drive-thru lanes and windows from being located in front of a building. However, this would be a challenge to implement in the City Center area because many of the lots will front both Main Street and the future extension of Jenkins Court. If the City’s intent is to make Jenkins Court a pedestrian-oriented environment, a more appropriate standard may be to prohibit drive-thru lanes from being accessed via Jenkins Court and also to prohibit drive-thru lanes, windows, and order boxes from being located between the front of the building and Jenkins Court. Staff recognizes that Maverick Station, Tropical Grill, Dairy Queen, and the future development at the former BB&T location already have or will have drive -thru an d/or pickup window facilities. Another approach the City may consider is to prohibit drive-thru facilities in the City Center area north of either the former BB&T property or the Dairy Queen property. REQUEST Staff is seeking direction from the Committee and/or City Council to draft an ordinance amending the standards for drive -thru facilities in the Central Redevelopment D istrict. Please note that th e Planning Commission will need to review the ordinance before it can be approved by City Council. ATTACHMENTS None Building Codes Committee * * * 77 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: September 6, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6f TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Electric Vehicle Charging Stations BACKGROUND Staff has been asked to include a discussion of electric vehicle charging stations as part of the agenda for the Building Codes Committee. CURRENT MAULDIN STANDARDS Presently, the City of Mauldin has no standards that specific ally apply to or allow for electric vehicle charging stations. ABOUT ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING STATIONS Electric vehicle charging stations generally fall into one of three categories, designated as level 1, 2, and 3. Level 1 chargers are 120 volts and general ly use a standard outlet. Level 2 chargers are 240 volts and generally consist of a charging head and cord hard-wired to the circuit. Level 3 chargers are more than 240 volts and are much more complex. Some charging stations may also identify as level 4 which are relatively new to the industry and represent the high end of electric vehicle charging. Some of the standards the City may consider for electric vehicle charging stations include: • Where are certain types of charging stations allowed as an accessory use? as a primary use? • How should a charging station be sited on a lot or in a parking area? • What design requirements may be appropriate for charging stations? • What type of signage is permitted for charging stations? • Does a minimum percentage of charging stations need to be handicap accessible? Please review the attached articles and materials for an overview of electric ve hicle charging stations and guidance for local government. REQUEST Staff is seeking direction from the Committee and/or City Council to draft an ordinance regulating electric vehicle charging stations. Please note that th e Planning Commission will need to review the ordinance before it can be approved by City Council. Building Codes Committee * * * 78 ATTACHMENTS “Electric Vehicle Charging Stations,” American Planning Association, PAS Quicknotes, 2022. “Electric Vehicles Are on the Rise. Is Your Community Ready?”, Daniel Vock, Planning, July 1, 2021. “Electric Vehicle Infrastructure,” American Planning Association, Zoning Practice, July 2010. Sample Ordinance from St. Louis Park, Minnesota, 2019 Building Codes Committee * * * 79 PAS OUICKNOTES This PAS QuickNotes was prepared by Joe DeAngelis, AICP , Research Manager at the American Planning Association. Electric Vehicle Charging Stations After years of false starts, the time of electric vehicles (EVs) has finally arrived. Advancements in battery storage and vehicle range, lower prices, and federal investments and incentives are helping to pave the way for the mainstreaming of EVs. The rapid deployment of EV charging infrastructure is essential to maintaining this momentum. To help realize the wider benefits of EV adoption, especially the promised reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and other harmful forms of pollution associated with fossil fuels, it is essential for plan- ners to understand the evolving state of EV charging stations and how to maximize their benefits at the local level. BACKGROUND While battery-powered cars are nearly as old as cars themselves, widespread adoption of EVs has been elusive. EVs depend on the availability of widespread charging infrastructure, just like gas-powered vehicles depend on the availability of gas stations. But without a critical mass of EVs already on the road, there is little incentive to build charging stations. “Range anxiety,” a driver’s concern that their EV may run out of power, has long been a limiting factor in wider-scale EV adoption. A few notable shifts, however, may be spelling an end to this dynamic. Though the cost of an EV is still high compared to traditional cars, falling prices combined with federal and state incentives have helped to grow market share considerably. The National Electric Vehicle Infra- structure (NEVI) Formula Program, established under President Biden’s Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, has committed $5 billion for states to build out charging infrastructure along the interstate highway system and in disadvantaged communities. These developments, coupled with significant technological advancements in battery storage and charging speed as well as multibillion-dollar carmaker commit- ments and investments in EVs, all point to a future in which charging stations are ubiquitous across the country. Planners can play a role in helping to grow this network in ways that benefit their communities. CHARGING STATION TYPES EV charging infrastructure comes in three types: Level One, Level Two, and Level Three. Level One charg- ing, by far the most common type, requires nothing more than standard 120-volt power. This enables EVs to be charged at home, though the process is slow; it can take more than 24 hours to fully charge a de- pleted battery. However, topping up the battery overnight is more than enough for the roughly 39-mile- per-day average driven by most Americans. Limited electrical upgrades at home allow for Level Two charging, which uses 240-volt power. Its spe- cialized equipment adds to overall cost but can cut charging time by 50 percent or more, improving convenience. This is the most common charging station encountered in parking garages, parking lots, workplaces, and other public locations. Both Level One and Level Two charging can be built or retrofitted into existing public or private space, which makes them well suited for incidental charging while parked at a store or restaurant, at work, or while sleeping at home. Level Three charging can fill an empty battery in about 30 minutes. It is far more expensive to install and operate than Levels One and Two and is more likely to be built as dedicated infrastructure, similar to a traditional gas station. American Planning Association Planning Advisory Service Creating Great Communities for All A Publication of the American Planning Association | PAS QuickNotes No. 100 EV charging station on a college campus in San Luis Obispo, California. Credit: Swalls/iStock/gettyimages.com. Building Codes Committee * * * 80 Planners should consider how to best implement these charging stations in the local built environment. What are the zoning or siting implications for at-home or public charging infrastructure? How might the longer time to charge an EV lead to potential issues of site access for publicly accessible charging sta- tions? Given the growth in EVs, there may soon be far more demand for charging stations in convenient places. How can planners balance this increasing demand fairly and equitably with the needs of others? DISTRIBUTION AND EQUITY Ensuring the equitable distribution of charging stations while mitigating any potential issues of siting and design are two of the most critical challenges as EVs hit the mainstream. Currently, adoption rates for EVs and the availability of Level Two or Three charging stations are far lower in rural areas than in urban and suburban locations, and the distribution and accessibility of charging stations are important consider- ations. People who don’t live in single-family homes or lack a driveway or garage likely won’t have the op- portunity to charge at home and may have to rely on public or workplace charging stations, which tend to be located in or near affluent and primarily white neighborhoods. This dynamic can lead to “charging deserts,” particularly in Black and Latino communities. For residents of these areas, this will add additional barriers to EV adoption as well as increasingly disproportionate exposure to air pollution from gasoline- powered vehicles. With significant federal funding recently dedicated to expanding charging station infrastructure in both rural and urban areas, planners should play a major role at the local level in working to ensure charging stations are equitably distributed and accessible to all. TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE AND DISRUPTION As an emerging market, the technology of EVs and charging stations is changing rapidly. Given the sig- nificant technological advancements happening in battery storage, charging speeds, and vehicle range, there is potential for on-the-ground investments in charging infrastructure to become quickly outdated. The increasingly strident role played by a few large players in the EV field, particularly Tesla, may also lead to significant local challenges. Gas stations tend to be independently franchised and serve all kinds of gasoline-powered vehicles. Tesla charging stations, by contrast, are exclusive to owners of Tesla vehicles (unless other users purchase an adapter). Such proprietary charging technology, while initially helping to grow the industry as a whole, has led to questions regarding the role of the private sector in the public realm. Given the growth potential for EVs, there are also major implications for the future of gas stations in communities across the United States. What might happen to these sites, and the people who work there, is an open question. Planners should stay engaged in the mainstreaming of EVs generally, and the development of charging stations specifically. Planners are particularly well positioned to observe trends related to charging station deployment and EV adoption at the local level, particularly as new technology comes on the market, which can inform the development of local plans and codes. CONCLUSION While the deployment of charging infrastructure will have its challenges, the benefits of widespread EV adoption to climate and environmental outcomes are clear. Planners should work to ensure that charging stations are deployed fairly and equitably across communities now and into the future. FURTHER READING  Published by the American Planning Association  APA Learn. 2021. “Come Down to Electric Avenue.” Vock, Daniel. 2021. “Electric Vehicles Are on the Rise. Is Your Community Ready?” Planning, July 1. Other Resources  California Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development. 2019. Electric Vehicle Charging Station Permitting Guidebook. July. New Jersey Dept of Environment Protection. 2022. Charge Up Your Town: Best Management Practices to Ensure Your Town is EV Ready. February. New York State Energy Research and Development Authority. 2022. Charge NY: Charge Electric Best Practice Guides and Cases. U.S. Department of Transportation. 2022. National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure Formula Program– Minimum Standards for EV Charging Station Projects (23 CFR Part 680). A Publication of the American Planning Association | PAS QuickNotes No. 100 PAS QuickNotes (ISSN 2169-1940) is a publication of the American Planning Association’s Planning Advisory Service (PAS). Joel Albizo, fasae, cae, Chief Executive Officer; Petra Hurtado, phd, Research Director; Ann Dillemuth, aicp, Editor. © 2022 American Planning Association, 205 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 1200, Chicago, IL 60601-5927; planning.org. All rights reserved. APA permits the reproduction and distribution of PAS QuickNotes to educate and inform public officials and others about important planning-related topics. Visit PAS online at planning.org/pas to find out how PAS can work for you. Building Codes Committee * * * 81 22 Planning Summer 2021 ENERGY SYSTEMS Charging Ahead By DANIEL C. VOCK Building Codes Committee * * * 82 DISRUPTORSRDISRUPTORSR With 3.5 million electric cars expected in the U.S. in less than 10 years, charging infrastructure has to ramp up quickly. BRYAN DERBALLA/ THE NEW YORK TIMES Building Codes Committee * * * 83 24 Planning Summer 2021 The city eventually added 100 more EV chargers in 2019, making it easier for employees to get a spot. All around the city, in fact, chargers have become much more common, as the num- ber of EVs on the streets continues to climb. But the episode gave Bonstin a better appre- ciation for all the logistical issues that need to be taken care of if LA, the state of California, or even the whole country is to successfully replace carbon-spewing gas-powered vehicles with electric ones. Planners around the country will soon be wrestling with those kinds of considerations and more—if they aren’t already—as EVs become more common. “ A lot of municipalities have started to set the framework for electric vehicle chargers to be installed, ” says Amina Hassen, an associate for WXY Studio in New Y ork, who has worked with both the state and city of New Y ork to develop electric vehicle policies. “Four or five years ago, an electric vehicle charging station wasn’t even defined in [building] codes. ” “Where a lot of places will have to catch up is in the planning phases, ” she says. To ensure all individuals can make the choice to switch to an electric vehicle, local govern- ments will have to think about things like the places where people are already using electric vehicles, how placement of charging stations can be used to help economic development, and how to distribute infrastructure equitably, Hassen adds. More broadly, cities, regions, the federal government, and energy producers will also have to think about what kind of electrical power fuels the grid because increased power demand means increased emissions unless renewable energy is used. GRAPHIC ILLUSTRATIONS BY HAISAM HUSSEIN ILLUSTRATION BY JASON SCHNEIDER President Joe Biden is trying to speed along the transition by calling for all the federal gov- ernment’s vehicles, including U.S. Postal Service trucks, to be replaced with electric powered vehicles. The infrastructure plan also calls for building an extensive network of EV chargers and offering rebates to electric car buyers. (Biden’s plan has been criticized for not match- ing renewable energy with electrical vehicles.) Meanwhile, the auto industry appears to be moving in the same direction. General Motors, Ford Motor Company, and Volkswagen have all made bold promises about switching from gas and diesel power to electric-powered cars. Tesla, far and away the biggest manufacturer of EVs right now, doesn’t even sell gas-powered vehicles. The coming wave of EVs could change every- thing from simple parking space requirements for new developments to economic growth opportunities for disadvantaged neighborhoods. Not surprisingly, though, city leaders and plan- ners will have a big role in determining how many vehicles will come to town and where they’ll be able to be used. Charging challenges When it comes to the rollout of EVs, the most basic questions for cities will be over siting charging stations. The U.S. will need 9.6 million charging ports by 2030, the Edison Electric Insti- tute, an industry group, predicted nearly three years ago. By comparison, the U.S. Department of Energy says there are currently 42,000 public charging station in the country, offering a com- bined total of 100,000 charging ports. (That does not include private chargers, like those used for bus fleets or home charging.) Private companies and many homeowners W HEN SHANA BONSTIN FIRST BOUGHT AN ELECTRIC VEHICLE, A VOLKSWAGEN EGOLF, IN 2017, she didn’t realize how few available chargers there actually were. Bonstin, the deputy director of community planning in Los Angeles, knew that many new developments in the city now included charging infrastructure. Plus, the city itself was installing electric vehicle (EV) chargers at city hall, so she should have been able to refuel her car while at work. But it turned out that city hall did not initially have enough chargers for all the municipal employees who had EVs. The complexities of adding that much power and infrastructure in a historically significant building in downtown Los Angeles caused months of delays. Meanwhile, city employees made do by scheduling time on the few existing chargers on shared Excel spreadsheets. FURTHER IMPACTS: ENERGY SYSTEMS To facilitate the ongoing transition to renewable sources of energy, governments and communities will need to plan for widespread installation of solar and wind energy systems and infrastructure. Building Codes Committee * * * 84 American Planning Association 25American Planning Association 25 GRAPHIC ILLUSTRATIONS BY HAISAM HUSSEIN ILLUSTRATION BY JASON SCHNEIDER property owners who install chargers. Even add- ing a charger in a parking spot at a gas station can be tricky, Bonstin explains, because parking spots with EV chargers must be larger than regu- lar spots. If a building already has the minimum number of spots, they don’t have the space to add charging equipment. Los Angeles planners are also working with their electric utility (which is owned by the city) to get a better idea of what incentives or disincentives are currently in place. So, deciding when a building needs chargers could determine who gets rebates from the power company. If the city requires chargers up front for a subdivision, for example, the developer would likely receive the rebates. But if the developer only has to make the property “EV-ready, ” the rebate would go to the homeowner who installs the charger down the line, Bonstin says. Planners also have to wrestle with the extra infrastructure that may be required from new will continue installing stations on their own, but city officials will face pressures to install publicly available chargers and to ensure people who don’t own their own homes can still find a place to charge their vehicles. Different types of chargers work better in different settings. Home - owners, fo r example, can typically rely on Level 2 chargers in their garages. But a restaurant or retail store might want a fast charger so that customers can shop or dine in the half hour it takes their vehicles to charge. Local governments can help speed the growth of charging networks by allowing, incentivizing, or even requiring property owners to make those improvements. Los Angeles recently passed a change to its building code requiring new apartment buildings and hotels to install chargers, and to install infrastructure that will make it easy to add additional chargers in the future. Atlanta in 2017 required new homes to be “EV-ready, ” with the conduit, wiring, and electrical capacity necessary to add chargers later. Installing EV charging infrastructure is much easier for new develop- ments than it is for existing buildings, of course. “For all the buildings to go back and then put in the wiring in a couple of decades is going to be super cost-prohibitive. It’s better just to put it in now, ” says LA ’s Bonstin. It’s also going to be a tough sell, she adds, which is why she and other city leaders are considering a menu of incentives and requirements. One possible approach would be to readjust parking requirements for CHOOSING THE RIGHT CHARGER: SPEED AND POWER There are three current standards for EV charging stations, each with different charging speeds and different electrical infrastructure needs. That’s why it’s important to match the charger with the intended use. DIRECT CURRENT/ FAST CHARGING (480+V): By far the fastest—they recharge a car in 20-30 min- utes—they also draw the most power. But not all EVs can use these and there are no univer- sal standards for the charging ports, so one carmaker’s char- gers are often incompatible with other companies’ cars. LEVEL 2 (240V): The most common public char- gers, these use a higher volt- age outlet. Most homes and commercial properties have 240V lines to the building, but installing a charger could require extra electric work on the premises. These chargers add 10 to 20 miles of range for every hour of charging. LEVEL 1 (120V): Essentially universal chargers, these use a standard outlet like those in a home. They are the simplest to use and don’t require the installation of new electrical wiring. But they are the slowest charger type, giv- ing cars two to five miles of range for every hour they’re plugged in. Hours to full charge: 6–22 Hours to full charge: 2–8 Hours to full charge: 1/2 Building Codes Committee * * * 85 26 Planning Summer 2021 chargers. If the electric load gets large enough, “suddenly, an applicant or a developer needs this huge transformer to fit somewhere in the park- ing structure” or somewhere else nearby, and they look ugly, Bonstin says. “These infrastruc- ture components are solving one problem and creating another. So, then the question becomes: How do you store this in a more elegant way?” Ensuring widespread access Meanwhile, cities will also face challenges when installing public chargers on curbs or in munici- pal parking lots. Hassen, the urban planner from WXY Studio, says cities should make sure the technology they install is universally accessible. That not only means that the plugs should be able to service vehicles made by different companies, but also that the method of payment is widely accessible as well, she says. Right now, paying for electricity for your car is far more complicated than paying for gas; most charging stations don’t take credit or debit cards. Instead, they require you to be a member of a certain network that have their own cards or apps that allow you to pay. The balkanized systems orig- inally impeded London’s efforts to build out a robust web of charging stations, Hassen says, and that’s why places like New Y ork City have required that their chargers work on several dif- ferent networks. Then there’s the issue of where to install public chargers. Right now, EV owners tend to be wealthy, because the vehicles are so expensive (a problem states like California and automakers hope will fade as mass production of electric vehicles and new innovations make the prices of new electric vehicles similar to those of gas-powered vehicles). But that doesn’t mean that chargers should be concentrated in wealth- ier areas, cautions Adam Lubinsky, phd, aicp , WXY’s managing principal for planning. He says cities should account for equity in their siting decisions. Lower-income neighbor- hoods often have lower air quality and would therefore benefit the most from replacing gas-powered vehicles with zero-emission ones. Those neighborhoods also often host institu- tions—such as hospitals, community colleges, and schools—that people drive to rather than Leisure destinations offer good opportunities for top-off charging. And these stations outside Camden Yards in Baltimore blend well with the area’s character. JAMES BRUNKER/ALAMY Building Codes Committee * * * 86 American Planning Association 27 American Planning Association 27 PREP ARING TO THRIVE The long-term trends and emerging issues facing the profession are many and changeable, but can be grouped into critical topic areas. Planning is covering them all throughout 2021, in print and at planning.org/ planning. IN THIS ISSUE: ENERGY SYSTEMS Charging Ahead GOVERNMENT TECH & CYBERSECURITY 5 Tips to Safeguard Your Data (and Your Community) DIGITAL INFRASTRUCTURE Data Centers at the Edge PREVIOUS ISSUES: ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE Smart City Digital Twins DIGITALIZATION OF LIFE Ghosts in the Office DEMOGRAPHICS Why Can’t We Plan for Aging? HOUSING Here Comes the Neighborhood CLIMATE CHANGE Where Will Climate Migrants Go? PUBLIC REALM Spaces for All THE SHARING ECONOMY Find Your Next Planning Gig TRANSPORTATION Taking to the Air SMART CITIES Ahead of the Curb ECONOMIC RESTRUCTURING The Price of Racial Inequality DATA USE Fort Worth’s Data-Driven Planning Play AGRICULTURE AND FOOD A Move to Local Food Systems COMING UP: Civic Tech E-Commerce Planning Tools Political Ideologies Building Codes Committee * * * 87 28 Planning Summer 2021 LOCATIONS BEST SUITED TO CHARGING STATIONS MEDICAL CAMPUS Medical campuses tend to have a largely car-depen- dent workforce, amplified by shift workers who have fewer and less frequent off-hours public transit options. HIGHER EDUCA TION Post-secondary education draws employees and stu- dents from across the region. Campuses isolated from pub- lic transit have high propor- tions of auto commuters. PUBLIC SECTOR Municipal employees drive at higher rates than private sector employees and many work far from transit options, contrib- uting to their car dependency. NEIGHBORHOOD CENTER Neighborhood centers have a mix of commercial and residential uses. Drivers in neighborhood centers where residential construction lags commercial development are “garage orphans” and need charging where they park: on the street. LEISURE DESTINA TION Parks, public pools, cultural institutions (museums and science centers), stadiums, and other major institutions are leisure destinations that offer a good opportunity for EVSE exposure and top-off charging. These destina- tions may also have EV fleet charging needs. PEDESTAL Freestanding charging stations with single or dual charge ports. Station footprints are typically similar to municipal parking meters, although pedestals range in height and bulk. There is a wide variety of commercially available models among electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE) providers. L2 POLE-MOUNTED Chargers mounted on existing infrastructure such as a light pole, which makes the height of the unit adjustable. These chargers are slimmer than others, but typically only have one charge port. Installation costs are low if power to light pole is sufficient (or timed with streetlight upgrades). ILLUSTRATIONS BY HAISAM HUSSEIN SOURCE: CURB ENTHUSIASM: DEPLOYMENT GUIDE FOR ON-STREET ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING, 2018. BIT.LY/3I9ARML L2 TOWER Taller than pedestals, these freestanding charging stations feature a built-in cord management system that keeps cords elevated. Modular elements such as lighting or wifi infrastructure can be paired with the tower. Costs can be high if trenching or other complex installation is required. USER-SUPPLIED CORD (PLUG & SOCKET) A standard EV socket is mounted onto a freestanding pedestal or light pole and is appropriate for long dwell times. Users must supply their own cord. This charging option is popular in Europe, although not used in North America. CHOOSING THE RIGHT CHARGER: LOCA TION AND TYPE The firm WXY created a guidebook for New York City’s curbside EV charging efforts that includes a planning framework, identifies deployment zones, and digs into station placement and type. TYPES OF CHARGING STA TIONS Building Codes Committee * * * 88 American Planning Association 29American Planning Association 29 built locally. States like California, Nevada, and Tennessee all produce EVs. Georgia just reached an agreement to become a major source of the batteries that will go into those vehicles. Plug In America has catalogued the many different approaches that states and cities have taken to promote EVs, but Levin stresses that governments need to model the behavior they want to see in others. “Y ou better have charging at city hall and at major city facilities. If you don’t, you’re going to look like a dinosaur pretty quickly, ” he says. Top officials with city-issued vehicles, like the mayor and city council members, should have EVs. “That models the story you’re trying to tell. If the city council is all driving around in Suburbans, that doesn’t really tell the story of people con- verting to EVs. ” It’s not enough just to buy EVs. City lead- ers need to bring people along by educating staff about the new vehicles (including test drives) and hosting public events to build excitement, Levin adds. “If your city is going to invest in a big fleet of EVs for the police department, you better make sure that people are bought into it, or else they’re going to sit and gather dust. ” In Los Angeles, Bonstin says the city and other local governments in the area are pushing the switch to EVs every way they can, including moving its own fleet to electric vehicles. LA already has 900 EVs and has worked with other cities to give it more leverage with automakers to produce more. Local transit agencies are plan- ning to switch their vehicles to electric by the end of the decade, too. The city now has 10,000 commercial EV charging stations, a milestone it reached in Janu- ary, two years ahead of a goal set by Mayor Eric Garcetti, thanks in part to a rebate program from the city. City agencies have installed more than 1,300 chargers on their own, including more than 400 that are integrated with streetlights. “ A key tenet of our sustainability plan is that we lead with [the conversion], ” Bonstin says, “and I think we did that. ” Daniel C. Vock is a public policy reporter based in Washington, D.C. take transit, he says. That adds to emissions in those neighborhoods. Hassen notes that another equity consideration is putting public chargers on the street or in municipal lots. That would help renters and other people who don’t have private chargers to make the switch to electric vehicles when they become more affordable. “If you have no place to charge [an electric vehicle], and there is no developed public access infra- structure, it’s not really a viable option for you, ” she says. Jairo Garcia, a sustainable cities expert who helped Atlanta develop its climate action plan, says cities and states should encourage suburbanites to use EVs when they commute into the urban core. They can do that by allowing EVs to use carpool lanes on interstate highways and by reserving convenient parking spaces downtown for them. “Electric vehicles are more for the people outside the city, because here in the city, we don’t drive. The people who live in the suburbs, they are going to be the ones who benefit the most from using electric vehicles, ” he says. Electric vehicles can easily handle those daily commutes, and subur- banites have “plenty of land” where they can put chargers, Garcia says. Showing leadership As Congress considers Biden’s push for EVs, state and city governments are already enacting policies to speed the transition. Those range from high-profile promises, like that of California Gov. Gavin Newsom, to ban the sales of gas-powered vehicles in the state by 2035, to much lower-key moves that offer rebates or tax credits for residents who buy EVs. California’s heavy-handed approach may not be a good fit for the rest of the country, says Doug Kettles, the director of the Central Florida Clean Cities Coalition. But leadership can come in other ways. In Florida, for example, the state’s power companies are working together to encourage more widespread adoption of EVs through a group called Drive Electric Florida, which some environmental groups support as well. That group helped produce a plan to help municipalities prepare for questions like where to put new chargers. And several state agencies are working to produce a master plan that will look at logistical concerns as well as policy ideas that could help Florida’s switch to EVs. Kettles says that governments will be leading the movement, even if only because of cost considerations. The upfront cost of EVs has been declining, and auto industry experts expect that new electric cars will soon be the same price as new gas-powered cars. Significantly, the maintenance costs for EVs are lower than gas-powered vehicles. That means governments will soon have an obligation to buy them, Nettles says. “The total cost of ownership is going to be dramatically lower than a regular vehicle, and so the fiduciary responsibility of the businesses and the government is going to drive them to getting these vehicles, ” he says. “Y ou’re using taxpayer money or you’re using stockholder money. Y ou have to use it in the most efficient and effective way. That’s coming, and when it does, it’s going to come hard and fast. ” Joel Levin, the executive director of Plug In America, a group that advocates for the adoption of EVs, says cities and states have another eco- nomic incentive to promote a switch to EVs, because many of them are ILLUSTRATIONS BY HAISAM HUSSEIN Building Codes Committee * * * 89 Zoning Practice AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION 122 S. Michigan Ave. Suite 1600 Chicago, IL 60603 1776 Massachusetts Ave., N.W. Washington, D.C. 20036 zONING Practice juLy 2010 AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION issue number 7 Practice electric vehicle infrastructure How will your community accommodate electric veHicle cHarging? 7 7 Building Codes Committee * * * 90 zoningpractice 7 .10 AmericAN PlANNiNg AssociAtioN | page 2 Electric Vehicles: is Your Community Connected? By Timothy M. Bourcier, a i c p Electric vehicles are coming soon to a community near you. in early 2010, California-based Tesla Motors became the first company to boast mass production of an electric vehicle in the U.S., and it has recently partnered with Toyota to produce and market these vehicles. Before this, two major companies had low-speed, plug-in vehicles on the market (also known as neighborhood electric vehicles). The BMW Mini E, Chevrolet Volt, Toyota Prius PHEV (electric-gas hybrid), and the nis- san Leaf (plug-in rechargeable—all electric power) will be sold in select U.S. markets by the end of 2010, with a full rollout of the vehicles nationwide in 2011. While customers are lining up to pur- chase plug-in electric vehicles (EVs), organiza- tions, utility companies, and governments are concurrently forming partnerships and work- ing to craft policies to promote the sale and use of EVs. More than 6,500 charging stations across southern California and Tennessee will be installed as part of the initial rollout. However, it is likely that many locali- ties have not considered how to regulate and permit individual charging stations at homes and commercial centers. The loca- tion of charging stations probably has not been thoroughly considered, either. This article explores a number of issues com- munities should consider when regulating charging stations. it also examines current community initiatives and the development of charging stations. Finally, this article will look at how potential technologies could further change how EVs will be integrated so communities can plan for them. Brief History of tHe electric VeHicle Electric vehicles have been around since the early 1800s. The gas-powered internal combus- tion engine became more popular over time because higher performance and top speeds were achievable. Moreover, rechargeable, high- performance batteries and other technologies were not as viable as they are today. With advances in new technologies and policies pushing for alternative energy sources, automakers began reintroducing the EV. These new EVs use banks of re- chargeable batteries to power their electric motors. The batteries will be recharged by plugging the vehicle into an electrical outlet, similar to recharging household batteries in a battery charger. While Tesla and nissan have developed cars that run completely on battery power, Chevrolet and others are introducing vehicles that will continue to run on gas and also in- corporate plug-in rechargeable technologies. These cars are more advanced than existing hybrid vehicles and will rely less on gasoline. local electrical code This article does not examine local electri- cal and building codes. This is an important consideration, however, as charging sta- tions will likely have to be permitted and inspected by the local permitting authority. Professional installers will likely already be familiar with local codes or will have to become familiar with the code. Planning and development divisions should examine the electrical code and determine how this new technology is regulated. initial considerations EVs operate either partially or entirely on bat- tery power. The batteries need to be recharged periodically in order to receive the benefits of electrical power, or in the case of Tesla models and the nissan Leaf, the battery must be charged to operate at all. if these vehicles become as popular as hybrid vehicles, there will be a demand for places to charge them. in touting the ease of their products, some manufacturers seem to imply that EVs can be charged by simply plugging them in to a conventional outlet. However, recharging is not exactly that easy. These new electric ve- hicles will require a special outlet, specifically the J1772 five-pronged outlet, which has been developed for uniform use with plug-in ve- hicles. The vehicles charge at different rates based on the voltage of the outlet. A Level i station charges at 110 volts. A conventional 220 volt household outlet, or Level ii charging station, will require eight hours connection time to fully charge an all-electric-powered This diagram shows typical Level 1 and Level 2 charging station installations in a residential garage. ECotality, incorporated Building Codes Committee * * * 91 ASk THE AUTHor Join US onLinE! about the author Timothy M. Bourcier, a i c p, is president-elect of the Maryland Chapter of the American Planning Association. Bourcier is also a consultant with Davis, Bowen and Friedel, inc., based in of their Annapolis, Maryland, office. He has acted as the project manager for several comprehensive growth plans, zoning ordinance revisions, and other municipal projects and services in Maryland, Delaware, Virginia, Florida, Louisiana, and Mississippi. While with the City of South Mi- ami, Bourcier helped craft an ordinance dealing with incorporating personal generators into residential zoning districts—generators were used widely without regulation after hurricanes for emergency power. vehicle (hybrid vehicles require a shorter charging time, which is based on the battery’s capacity). A Level iii 440 volt station has also been developed, but is not being widely used at this time. Most plug-in vehicles that are in production or planned for production can be charged at a Level iii station to near capacity within 20 to 30 minutes. As users approach the end of the bat- tery range of an all-electric-powered vehicle, they will have to make arrangements for recharging. in neighborhoods comprised exclusively of detached single-family homes with off-street parking, users can charge vehicles on their property. Areas without off- street parking make recharging more compli- cated. When users get to the end of the bat- tery range of an all-electric-powered vehicle, they will need to plan in advance where and how to recharge. As EV sales increase, so will the demand for convenient places to fuel the vehicles. Since recharging takes con- siderably longer than filling up a gas tank, it’s necessary to accommodate the required 30-minute and longer refueling stops. Beyond the need for recharging infra- structure, the proliferation of EVs may have additional community impacts. Part of the allure of EVs is the reduction or elimination of greenhouse gas emissions. in areas where electricity is generated by coal plants, re- charging the vehicle will create emissions at the plant, which may defeat the purpose of using the vehicle to lower emissions. other issues arise in areas where energy infrastruc- ture is stretched thin and vehicle recharging may further strain the system (although some preliminary studies suggest infrastructure is in place nationally to handle widespread use of EVs). king County, Washington, is discover- ing that the overall electrical capacity exists, but the microgrid (transformers, conduits, etc.) needs to be upgraded. in response, some communities are requiring or incentiv- izing users to plug in during off-peak hours (this is discussed in greater depth later). How the electricity will be paid for is also an issue. if a shopping mall provides charging stations, will the user have to pay to fill up (as we cur- rently do at a gas station) or will they provide “free” charging stations, where costs likely will be passed on to all consumers? Do local governments have an opportunity and the capability (politically and legally) to control higher prices for everyone by making EV us- ers pay their own way? required in new development? How will local design standards be affected? All of these items will be discussed later as current local initiatives are explored. in the next section, this article takes a closer look at the develop- ment, planning, and land-use considerations for requiring and allowing charging stations. Zoning and land-Use considerations Parking is the primary land-use consideration associated with EVs. Having designated areas specifically for vehicle recharging purposes seems incompatible with a current trend Go online from August 16 to 27 to participate in our “Ask the Author” forum, an interactive feature of zoning Practice. Timothy Bourcier, a i c p, will be available to answer questions about this article. Go to the APA website at www.planning.org and follow the links to the Ask the Author section. From there, just submit your questions about the article using the e-mail link. The author will reply, and zoning Prac- tice will post the answers cumulatively on the website for the benefit of all subscribers. This feature will be available for selected issues of zoning Practice at announced times. After each online discussion is closed, the answers will be saved in an online archive available through the APA zoning Practice web pages. zoningpractice 7 .10 AmericAN PlANNiNg AssociAtioN | page 3 Each community will have to decide whether or not it will require designated parking areas for EV charging and how those requirements will be reflected in the local zoning code. The shopping mall example above also raises the issue of parking. Each community will have to decide whether or not it will re- quire designated parking areas for EV charg- ing and, if so, how those requirements will be reflected in the local zoning code. Beyond zoning, local governments will have to de- termine what role to take in creating public charging stations or setting aside publicly owned and maintained parking places for EVs. This will require much planning to ac- count for installation, operation, and mainte- nance costs. Also, if a community sets aside parking spaces for EVs to conveniently re- charge, it will need to enforce their provision in order for the initiative to be successful. Finally, new development and the built environment are macro considerations. How will charging stations affect historic com- munities? Should EV charging stations be away from residential garages and on-site surface parking lots across the U.S. When designating future land uses, charging stations should be an additional consideration for transportation planners with Metropolitan Planning organizations (MPos) and state and federal transportation entities. Stations will need to be strategically located along major transportation routes. in- corporation of charging stations at interstate rest areas that already exist should be further considered in the planning process. For the most part, recharging stations and devices are accessory to functions and facilities already in existence. one challenge for local governments will be incorporating these stations into zoning definition lists and use tables. Communities will have to determine where charging stations are ap- propriate (in which zones) and under what Building Codes Committee * * * 92 zoningpractice 7 .10 AmericAN PlANNiNg AssociAtioN | page 4 Assuming there is agreement to place charging stations in these private areas, loca- tion of the charging stations must be con- sidered. First, it will need to be determined whether a few stations should be placed strate- gically around a site, or whether a central loca- tion should be set aside for charging all vehicles within a complex. This decision will be partly based on several other issues discussed below. The size and layout of the complex or neighborhood should be the first consider- ation. For larger neighborhoods, one or sev- eral centralized charging stations would be most efficient, keeping in mind the general rule that people will not walk further than five minutes or one-quarter mile from their place of residence. A centralized parking location would also provide the opportunity for extra security to prevent mischief or ac- cidents in areas with high foot traffic. conditions. initially, this should be done through a study or a local comprehensive plan update process. The zoning districts in which stations are permitted should be based on several factors. First, wires will come from a station and connect into a vehicle; wires can be hazardous for pedestrians and can create an unattractive nuisance. The vehicle will have to occupy a space for at least 30 minutes with a high-voltage outlet to charge, and much longer times are required for the lower voltage chargers that are more widely avail- able at this time. Though allowing charging stations as a use within specific zoning districts will open the door for their development, the act of placing charging stations into the built envi- ronment is much more of a challenge. There are many issues to consider. spaces must be limited to recharging ve- hicles. For private parking facilities, owners or managers will have to come up with a system of enforcement, including punish- ment for misuse (fines or towing), permitting (stickers or other labels), and outreach to the community to provide information on the stations and their restrictions. Sporadic placement of stations again brings up safety and vandalism problems. if everyone has access to a charging area, it is likely cords will be cut. Children running between cars and the curb could trip or oth- erwise be injured, and an endless number of other scenarios could lead to lawsuits. More importantly for this article, it reduces the likeliness of installing charging stations. Sta- tions may need to be installed near existing security stations or monitored by camera to help decrease the chance of vandalism. The stations should also be located away from sidewalks and bicycle areas, near walls, and preferably alongside parallel parking areas. Since most parking lots are designed for perpendicular and angle parking, the wall is important to limit traffic between the areas in the front or rear of the car where the cord will be stretched to the outlet. if communities install chargers on pub- lic streets, the local jurisdiction will have to work through the same issues discussed for private developers. However, resolving these issues can be more complicated in the public realm. The location and type of charging station (speed of charge and pay versus free) are the most vital issues. Staff studies, committee reviews, policy adop- tion, and allocation of funds can take a long time. on-street charging areas will need to be specifically designated for EVs only, and communitywide training and outreach will be required for code enforcement officers, police, residents, and visitors. This will in- clude creating signage for EVs and deciding on how to monitor the security of the sta- tions. These types of campaigns may require extensive partnerships and planning. Cost is also an issue that needs to be considered in advance. Users will likely ei- ther “pay at the pump” by using a card or a pass with a barcode or other identifying de- vice, or simply plug in without paying. While the pass allows a driver to use the charging station, it also gives the owner of the station the ability to charge the user immediately like gas stations now do. Without a way to identify the user, plugging in to public charg- ing stations will likely require passing on the cost to everyone, including non-users. ECotality, incorporated This diagram shows how public charging stations could be integrated into existing surface parking lots. Higher density residential areas with no off-street parking, such as apartments, dormi- tories, and similar dwelling types, create the biggest challenges for siting charging stations. in areas like San Francisco and Washington, D.C., where single-family attached town houses or row houses are prevalent, charging stations affixed to the buildings themselves may not be viable. Cords stretching across sidewalks would create a hazard and might be a detriment to the pedestrian and bicycling environment. in these areas, the vehicle user will need the owner of the property or the ju- risdiction to install the station. For smaller neighborhoods, sporadic placement of stations would be more efficient. in areas where parking is assigned to leasing residents, placing a station for their use in a specific parking space would not be viable since apartments change hands fairly regularly. This means apartment complexes, dormitories, and other types of multifamily development that place stations in designated spaces will have to restrict use of those spaces to EV owners. This creates two obstacles: enforce- ment of designated parking and an overall loss of parking spaces. Similar to parking spaces for the handicapped, use of these Building Codes Committee * * * 93 zoningpractice 7 .10 AmericAN PlANNiNg AssociAtioN | page 5 in a private residential setting, requir- ing permits for users or placing stations in existing carports where the person leases the space can help avoid more sophisti- cated stations where a pass is required. While electricity is the main cost, mainte- nance and replacement of stations is an- other factor. Commercial uses, especially larger shopping centers, will also face many of the same issues. Commercial entities are already requesting installation of stations at existing developments, well ahead of the development of regulations at the lo- cal level. Surface parking lots at medium and large shopping centers will likely pose the greatest challenges due to the layout of parking lots, pedestrian traffic between parking lanes, shopping carts, and other physical obstacles. While private landowners will ulti- mately have to deal with their own liabili- ties, local governments have a duty to keep people safe and reduce potential hazards. Communities will have to work with stake- holders to determine the best locations for charging stations, taking into consideration convenience, safety, and other factors prior to amending the local zoning ordinance. Setting aside parking spaces for EV users at existing commercial centers with surface parking lots can also create parking congestion. Transforming existing parking spaces into charging stations will reduce the number of spaces allowed for general use. Local governments will need to review requests on a development-by-development basis to determine how congested existing parking is and what the effect will be of tak- ing spaces away from all users. As communities continue to grow, they can avoid many of the challenges presented by retrofitting by requiring the installation and set-aside of recharging spaces in a safe and efficient manner for new developments. The next section looks at how some commu- nities are addressing the issues discussed earlier for new development, including ini- tiatives and incentives by states and groups like the U.S. green Building Council. existing initiatiVes Major financial incentives are in place to get people to consider purchasing EVs. The irS is offering a $7 ,500 tax credit for the pur- chase of an EV, and states have additional incentives, with California and georgia each providing $4,000 in additional tax credits. Many state governments also provide grants to help consumers pay for the cost of charg- ing stations at their homes. Meanwhile, millions of dollars have been doled out to companies for continued research and de- velopment to improve related technologies. Since there is a strong effort to get EVs on the streets, there needs to be a similar effort to get charging stations on the streets. The strongest initiative for providing charging stations is occurring in California’s Bay Area. The mayors of San Francisco, oakland, and Communities will have to work with stakeholders to determine the best locations for charging stations, taking into consideration convenience, safety, and other factors prior to amending the local zoning ordinance. electric vehicles. While this is important since demand will be higher in these neigh- borhoods, it is likely difficult to determine who will buy plug-in vehicles until a profile can be made after vehicles are widely avail- able. Furthermore, since one of the major efforts is to install charging stations at owners’ homes, public stations should be focused on places of more frequent activity when users are away from home. The county has partnered regionally San Jose have developed a partnership to get charging stations placed in communities throughout the region. These cities are also looking to enhance their municipal fleets by purchasing more EVs. Currently, seven com- munities in the Bay Area and northern Cali- fornia have installed charging stations. king County, Washington, through the American recovery and reinvestment Act (stimulus package) and financial assistance from king County municipalities, approved of the installation of 200 charging stations on county-owned lands. Users will be able to access the stations by making an online reservation. The county is still in the process of deter- mining where to place most of the stations. So far, it has placed Level i (110 volt) units at park- and-ride carpooling lots throughout the county as part of an initiative to promote plug-in car use prior to the unveiling of the Chevrolet Volt and the nissan Leaf. There are no Level ii sta- tions currently installed, but the county’s trans- portation department is working with the Puget Sound regional Council (Seattle’s regional MPo) to determine the best locations. How- ever, only 25 percent of the funding for installa- tion of Level ii stations is designated for public chargers; most funds are being allocated for installations at private residences. While Level iii station installation is not part of this rollout, the county recognizes the eventual need for strategically located fast-charging stations. Part of king County’s effort in determin- ing the location of public charging stations is trying to predict which neighborhoods contain residents likely to purchase plug-in with oregon and British Columbia representa- tives to understand where stations should be located for travel between southern oregon and Vancouver on the i-5 corridor. This study is in its infancy, but is important to make sure EV owners are not stymied from travel due to a lack of stations. Along with the EV project, king County is also working to make sure us- ers can find EV stations by gPS. nissan will offer this feature with the purchase of a Leaf. Finally, another important king County regional initiative is the creation of a model ordinance to help municipalities understand how the stations can be installed, in which land-use areas they can be located, and what local permits are required. The main goal of this is to make sure all municipalities across king County properly install and locate charg- ing stations. Another important use for the model ordinance is to help potential purchas- ers have transparency with dealerships by making sure the locations where the vehicles will be used will allow the installation of charging stations. The ordinance was not complete as of the date of publication. Many public charging stations will also be used for charging municipal fleet vehicles. Although the installation effort is admirable, current policies concerning the number and type of units installed should be scrutinized by other communities looking to install charging stations. For example, in Martinez, California, three 110 Volt units were installed for public use and for charging four municipal vehicles. These Level i units will take at least five hours to fully charge an electric/gas hybrid vehicle Building Codes Committee * * * 94 zoningpractice 7 .10 AmericAN PlANNiNg AssociAtioN | page 6 or neighborhood electric vehicle. With a few sales to the general public and increased use by city workers, the four units could become quickly exhausted. The city may have to con- sider adding additional charging stations, which could have adverse impacts on parking as discussed earlier. Another option would be to replace existing units with Level ii sta- tions, or Level iii stations when available. Adding stations, juggling parking is- sues, and upgrading existing units may all be costly options. This is why it is important for communities to study the expected im- pact of EV sales locally and to learn about existing technologies for charging stations and their effects on parking facilities in or- der to develop a comprehensive strategy in advance of purchasing and installing units. Concerning local initiatives for instal- lation by developers, Vancouver is the first (and only known municipality) in the world to require the installation of charging sta- tions at new developments. in Vancouver, all new condo developments must dedicate 20 percent of parking spaces to EV charging (http://vancouver.ca/sustainability/electric_ vehicles.htm). All new one- and two-family dwellings are also required to install charg- ing stations for each unit as part of the city’s green Homes Program (http://vancouver. ca/commsvcs/CBoFFiCiAL/greenbuildings/ greenhomes/electricvehicle.htm). Although During the summer, many people make vacation trips and weekend getaways from Washing- ton, D.C., Baltimore, and Philadelphia to ocean City, Maryland. The nearly 150-mile trip from Washington, D.C., would require at least one stop along the way for an all-electric vehicle with a 100-mile range. More stops would be necessary for hybrid vehicles trying to maximize battery powered travel. As you can see from the map, U.S. 50 and U.S. 13 are the main routes to ocean City. These thoroughfares are littered with gas stations, outlet stores, fast food restaurants, and other busi- nesses you would expect to see in highway commercial areas. While the map includes several communities along these routes, not shown are the 50 or more other municipalities with their own unique features and historic main streets. Taking a comprehensive look at where to locate stations and the type of stations to in- stall could provide additional benefits to a community. For instance, it is likely a community or consumer will not want to wait longer than 10 minutes to charge their car at a fast food restaurant or at a gas station. in this situation, the locality should require the highest volt- age technology available for charging stations (Level iii) to prevent congestion and loitering where parking is limited. However, strategically placing Level i or Level ii stations in a main street community there was some pushback from the develop- ment community, Vancouver studies indicate that there is only a 0.5 percent increased cost to the developer to install a charging station. The added cost for developers brings up the dilemma seen in many planning is- sues: Should charging stations be mandated or should incentives be provided to promote installation? While the question of whether developers can be mandated to install charging stations in new developments has not yet been tested in U.S. courts, there is enough precedent with similar mandates to say that governments are likely able to legally require installation. Whether a community will exercise its power to mandate charging stations is a different issue. The community will have to consider how the added cost (though argu- ably minimal) will affect the consumer it will be likely passed on to. option two is to provide incentives to a developer to install charging stations for public use. We found no instances of local initiatives to promote installation of charging stations by developments while researching this article. However, a variety of incentives has been used to promote voluntary set-aside of affordable housing units in new develop- ments. Tax abatement, reductions in parking, density bonuses, and other creative incentives are all possibilities for communities unwilling to mandate installation of charging stations. nationally, there are two major incen- tives available to promote adding charging stations in new developments. UDr, inc., has installed charging stations at two Texas multifamily developments and is request- ing that the U.S. green Building Council recognize these features as part of the LEED certification scoring. if recognized, adding charging stations can help developers easily add points to achieve LEED certification. An additional incentive for develop- ers is cost savings over time. This can be achieved in areas with Smart grid electrical technology. Using solar technology, with or without Smart grid infrastructure, can also help developers recoup the costs of adding enhanced charging stations. While a complete discussion of a Smart grid is beyond the scope of this article, there are two important aspects of this technology that could provide incentives for developers to install charging stations. First, a Smart grid would allow consumers to choose what time of day they wanted to take power from the grid. Second, it would permit consumers to sell excess electricity generated on-site by solar panels back to the utility provider. The ability to control when charging would take place could lead to stations only being used during off-peak hours when electrical costs are much cheaper. Depend- cHarging stations and toUrism could draw people in to find something to do while their car is powering up. These leisurely stops often occur anyway, but an EV driver may stop in a specific community if they can both charge their vehicle and take in the small-town charm. More importantly for the planner, once ideal locations and charging station types are determined, the zoning districts in which they lie can be found by overlaying the proposed location on the zoning map. This can help determine the sections of the local zoning and development codes that need to be revised to incorporate the local EV strategy. Building Codes Committee * * * 95 Vol. 27, no. 7 Zoning practice is a monthly publication of the american planning association. subscriptions are available for $90 (U.s.) and $115 (foreign). W. paul farmer, f a i c p, executive director; William r. Klein, a i c p, director of research Zoning practice (issn 1548–0135) is produced at apa. Jim schwab, a i c p, and david morley, a i c p, editors; Julie Von Bergen, assistant editor; lisa Barton, design and production. copyright ©2010 by american planning association, 205 n. michigan ave., suite 1200, chicago, il 60601. the american planning association also has offices at 1776 massachusetts ave., n.W., Washington, d.c. 20036; www.planning.org. all rights reserved. no part of this publication may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the american planning association. printed on recycled paper, including 50-70% recycled fiber and 10% postconsumer waste. zoningpractice 7 .10 AmericAN PlANNiNg AssociAtioN | page 7 Photo courtesy of Portland general Electric. Design concept by Lisa Barton. technological evolution to become better for consumers—smaller, smarter, longer lasting, and wireless. research is currently being performed to create smaller batteries that charge faster, higher voltage charging sta- tions, and wireless charging options. Though nanotechnology concepts are being used to try to reduce battery size while maintaining or improving performance, other technologi- cal advances are on the brink. Two Massachusetts institute of Technol- ogy researchers experimented with an iron phosphate solution to use in battery packs and were successful in charging batteries at a higher rate of speed. The solution is ex- pected to be available in markets in 2011. Evatran Corporation has developed Level i and Level ii wireless charging stations and are currently marketing these to residences and to commercial establishments where con- sumer trips are likely to exceed 45 minutes. Plugless Power proximity charging systems allow a user to pull into a charging area and receive a charge based on inductive power transfer technology. Evatran is still working with carmakers at this time to install technol- ogy to make wireless charging possible. The Better Space project and SwapPack are providing an alternative to the park-and- recharge concept. Each company is proposing stations where EV users can swap out their used battery packs for newly charged ones. Though heavy equipment is needed for the switch, the entire process is expected to take less than two minutes. Battery packs have not been standardized at this time, so logisti- cally how this would work for different mod- els is still to be determined. However, the concept is quick, convenient, and gets rid of many of the cord-related liability concerns. conclUsion The regulation of new technologies can often overwhelming for communities. The goal of this article is to help governments prepare for plug-in vehicles before they become common. Though specific electrical specifications may be above and beyond the technical expertise of planning teams, the discussion herein is meant to include everyday concepts of zoning, land use, and economic development. The initial consideration for every com- munity is identifying the best public locations for charging vehicles. These places already exist: park and ride lots, commercial centers, main street communities, and the like. Local governments should determine maximum charge times before installing Level i, ii, or ing on the amount of energy created by solar panels and the amount of energy used by recharging vehicles, a developer could eas- ily recoup installation costs, reduce overall electrical costs paid by the developer in common areas, and ultimately reduce costs to consumers. The City of orlando has in- stalled a solar powered charging station and is currently testing this model. While much of the previous discus- sion shows how other communities are working to promote EVs, each community is different. Though not explicitly discussed, communities should come up with a plan that comprehensively looks at how potential mandates, incentives, technologies, and locations will best serve the government, utility providers, and users. The following section provides a brief discussion on devel- oping a local EV strategy. estaBlisHing a local eV strategy Problems stemming from adding charging stations into a community can be boiled down to the following major issues: 1) the lo- cation of stations; 2) how fast they will charge vehicles; and 3) the type of station. Breaking down each of these items is obviously more complex, especially location. in order to keep costs low, communities should consider forming a technical committee to deal with creating the overall EV strategy. Creating a committee is recommended because of the variety of items to consider within each greater problem area. With loca- tion, for instance, technicians will need to be consulted about the actual installation of the device. Code enforcement officials could help point out some of the safety hazards that may arise. An economic development official could help point out strategic locations to draw in those who have to wait for recharging vehicles. Each community will need to exam- ine the best makeup of the committee based on their own unique needs. The goal of the committee should be to “measure twice and cut once.” A good strategy can help lower a community’s costs by limiting the upgrade stations. it is inevi- table that upgrades will be necessary as new technologies will better fit the needs of the community. The following section examines some additional short- and long-term tech- nology advances that should be considered as part of any future strategy. fUtUre tecHnologies Much like cell phones and MP3 players, EVs and charging stations are going through a iii charging stations. The recommendations in this article will help planners determine where stations will actually be installed. regional coordination of station locations is vital to this process, as MPos and other organizations will likely have the best data and resources for helping determine how a local community fits in to the larger needs of travelers over long distances. other informa- tion, such as renewable stations using solar technology or the future of wireless stations, are things to keep in mind. Finally, the language and visual aids within local zoning and design codes need to be updated. This is much easier to do af- ter determining the locations of the charging stations and the zoning districts in which they lie. For new developments, Vancouver’s mandatory charging station requirements, king County’s upcoming model ordinance, and other potential problem areas dis- cussed in this article can help communities craft the appropriate language to avoid pit- falls. one interview subject mentioned that he was trying to learn from crises planners ran into when cell phone towers were being installed across the country. The process for regulating charging stations is very similar. Building Codes Committee * * * 96 Ordinance No. ___-18 Ordinance regarding parking standards including electric vehicle supply equipment The City of St. Louis Park does ordain: Section 1. Chapter 36 of the St. Louis Park City Code is hereby amended by adding underscored language. Section breaks are represented by ***. Section 36-142. Descriptions *** (d) Commercial uses *** (20) Motor fuel station means a facility which supplies and dispenses at retail motor fuels, including electrical charging, directly into a motor vehicle; it also includes the sale of lubricants, batteries, tires and motor vehicle accessories. Motor fuels may be self-serve or dispensed by an attendant. Light maintenance activities to vehicles including engine tune-ups, lubrication, repairs, and carburetor cleaning may also be conducted. Motor fuel stations may also include facilities for the retail electric charging of vehicles. Characteristics include outdoor activity, high traffic generation and extended hours of operation. This use excludes heavy automobile repair including, but not limited to, engine overhauls, automobile painting, and bodywork. *** Section 36-193. C-1 neighborhood commercial district *** (d) Uses permitted by conditional use permit. No structure or land in a C-1 district shall be used for the following uses except by conditional use permit. (1) Motor fuel station. The conditions are as follows: *** k. Refer to Section 36-361 (e)(3)c for electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE) requirements. *** DRAFT Building Codes Committee * * * 97 City Council Meeting of January 7, 2019 (Item No. 8b) Page 2 Title: Ordinance regarding parking standards including electric vehicle supply equipment. Section 36-194. C-2 general commercial district. *** (d) Uses permitted by conditional use permit. No structure or land in a C-2 district shall be used for the following uses except by conditional use permit. (1) Motor fuel station. The conditions are as follows: *** h. Refer to Section 36-361 (e)(3)c for electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE) requirements. *** Section 36-223. O office district. *** (d) Uses permitted by conditional use permit. No structure or land in an O district shall be used for the following uses except by conditional use permit. These uses shall comply with the office restrictions and performance standards of section 36-222 and all those general conditions provided in section 36-33 regarding conditional use permits, and with the specific conditions imposed in this subsection. (1) Motor fuel station. The conditions are as follows: *** g. Refer to Section 36-361 (e)(3)c for electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE) requirements. *** Section 36-244. I-G general industrial district. *** (e) Accessory uses. The following uses shall be permitted within any I-G district: (9) Motor fuel station. Subject to the following conditions: *** g. Refer to Section 36-361 (e)(3)c for electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE) requirements. Section 36-361. Off-street parking areas, paved areas, and loading spaces. *** DRAFT Building Codes Committee * * * 98 City Council Meeting of January 7, 2019 (Item No. 8b) Page 3 Title: Ordinance regarding parking standards including electric vehicle supply equipment. (e) Electric Vehicle Supply Equipment. The intent of this section is to facilitate and encourage the use of electric vehicles, to expedite the establishment of a convenient, cost-effective electric vehicle infrastructure, and establish minimum requirements for such infrastructure to serve both short and long term parking needs. (1) Definitions. a. Accessible electric vehicle charging station means an electric vehicle charging station where the battery charging station is located within accessible reach of a barrier-free access aisle and the electric vehicle. b. Battery charging station means an electrical component, assembly or cluster of component assemblies designed specifically to charge batteries within electric vehicles. c. Battery electric vehicle means any vehicle that operates exclusively on electrical energy from an off-board source that is stored in the vehicle’s batteries, and produces zero tailpipe emissions or pollution when stationary or operating. d. Charging levels means the standardized indicators of electrical force, or voltage, at which an electric vehicle’s battery is recharged. The terms 1, 2, and DC are the most common charging levels, and include the following specifications: 1. Level 1 is considered slow charging with 120v outlets. 2. Level 2 is considered medium charging with 240v outlets, charging head and cord hard-wired to the circuit. 3. DC is considered fast or rapid charging. Voltage is greater than 240. e. Electric vehicle means a vehicle that operates, either partially or exclusively, on electrical energy from the electrical grid, or an off grid source, that is stored on board for motive purposes. “Electric vehicle” includes: 1. Battery electric vehicle. 2. Plug -in hybrid electric vehicle. f. Electric vehicle charging stations (EVCS) means a public or private parking space that is served by battery charging station equipment that has as its primary purpose the transfer of electric energy (by conductive or inductive means) to a battery or other energy storage device in an electric vehicle. g. Electric vehicle charging station – private restricted use means an electric vehicle charging station that is: DRAFT Building Codes Committee * * * 99 City Council Meeting of January 7, 2019 (Item No. 8b) Page 4 Title: Ordinance regarding parking standards including electric vehicle supply equipment. 1. Privately owned and restricted access (e.g., single-family home, executive parking, designated employee parking, assigned parking at multi-family residential buildings); or 2. Publicly owned and restricted (e.g., fleet parking with no access to the general public). h. Electric vehicle charging station – public use means an electric vehicle charging station that is: 1. Publicly owned and publicly available (e.g., Park & Ride parking, public library parking lot, on-street parking); or 2. Privately owned and available to visitors of the use (e.g., shopping center parking). i. Electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE) means any equipment or electrical component used in charging electric vehicles at a specific location. EVSE does not include equipment located on the electric vehicles themselves. j. Electric vehicle infrastructure means conduit/wiring, structures, machinery, a nd equipment necessary and integral to support an electric vehicle, including battery charging stations and rapid charging stations. k. Electric vehicle parking space means any marked parking space that identifies the use to be exclusively for the parking of an electric vehicle. l. ’Electrical capacity’ shall mean, at minimum: 1. Panel capacity to accommodate a dedicated branch circuit and service capacity to install a 208/240V outlet per charger; 2. Conduit from an electric panel to future EVCS location(s ). m. Plug -in hybrid electric vehicle means an electric vehicle that: 1. Contains an internal combustion engine and also allows power to be delivered to drive wheels by an electric motor; 2. Charges its battery primarily by connecting to the grid or other off-board electrical source; 3. May additionally be able to sustain battery charge using an on-board internal- combustion-driven generator; and 4. Has the ability to travel powered by electricity. (2) Number of Required Electric Vehicle Charging Stations. DRAFT Building Codes Committee * * * 100 City Council Meeting of January 7, 2019 (Item No. 8b) Page 5 Title: Ordinance regarding parking standards including electric vehicle supply equipment. a. All new or reconstructed parking structures or lots with 14 or fewer parking spaces shall be allowed, but not required, to install EVSE. b. All new or reconstructed parking structures or lots with at least 15 but no more than 49 spaces, or expanded parking structures or lots that result in a parking lot with 15 to 49 parking spaces, shall install EVSE as required below. 1. Multiple-family residential land uses shall have 5% of required parking as Level 1 stations for resident parking. At least one handicapped accessible parking space shall have access to an EVCS. 2. Non-residential land uses with parking spaces available for use by the general public shall have one Level 2 station. At least one handicapped accessible parking space shall have access to an EVCS. c. All new or reconstructed parking structures or lots with at least 50 parking spaces, or expanded parking structures or lots that result in a parking lot with 50 or more parking spaces, shall install EVSE as required below. 1. Multiple-family residential land uses shall have 10% of required parking as Level 1 stations for resident parking, and one Level 2 station for guest parking. At least one handicapped accessible parking space shall have access to an EVCS. 2. Non-residential land uses with parking spaces available for use by the general public shall have at least 1% of required parking as Level 2 stations with a minimum of two spaces served by Level 2 charging, with at least one station adjacent to an accessible parking space. In non-residential zoned districts, DC charging stations may be installed to satisfy the EVCS requirements described above on a one-for-one basis. d. Notwithstanding the requirements of subsections a above, all new or reconstructed motor fuel stations as defined in Section 36-142(d)(20) shall be required to install at least one additional Level 2 charging station. A DC charging station may be installed to meet this requirement. e. In addition to the number of required EVCSs, the following accommodations shall be required for the anticipated future growth in market demand for electric vehicles: 1. Multiple-Family Residential Land Uses: all new, expanded and reconstructed parking areas shall provide the electrical capacity necessary to accommodate the future hardwire installation of Level 2 EVCSs for a minimum of 10% of required parking spaces. 2. Non-Residential Land Uses: all new, expanded and reconstructed parking areas shall provide the electrical capacity necessary to accommodate the future DRAFT Building Codes Committee * * * 101 City Council Meeting of January 7, 2019 (Item No. 8b) Page 6 Title: Ordinance regarding parking standards including electric vehicle supply equipment. hardwire installation of Level 2 or DC EVCSs for a minimum of 10% of required parking spaces. f. These requirements may be revised upward or downward by the City Council as part of an application for a conditional use permit or planned unit development based on verifiable information pertaining to parking. (3) Reductions to EVSE requirements. When the cost of installing EVSE required by this Chapter would exceed five percent of the total project cost, the property owner or applicant may request a reduction in the EVSE requirements and submit cost estimates for city consideration. When City Council approval of the project is not required, the Zoning Administrator may administratively approve a reduction the required amount of EVSE in order to limit the EVSE installation costs to not more than five percent of the total project cost. (4) Permitted Locations. a. Level 1 and Level 2 EVCSs are permitted in every zoning district, when accessory to the primary permitted use. Such stations located at single-family, two-family, and multiple-family shall be designated as private restricted use only. b. DC EVCSs are permitted in the non-residential districts, when accessory to the primary permitted use. c. If the primary use of the parcel is the retail electric charging of vehicles, then the use shall be considered a motor fuel station for zoning purposes. Installation shall be located in zoning districts which permit motor fuel stations. (5) General Requirements for Single-Family Residential Zoning Districts. a. EVSE shall be located in a garage, or on the exterior wall of the home or garage adjacent to a parking space. b. EVSE shall comply with all relevant design criteria as outlined in section (5)d, unless specifically exempted. (6) General Requirements for Multi-Family Residential and N on-Residential Development Parking. a. Accessible Spaces. A charging station will be considered accessible if it is located adjacent to, and can serve, an accessible parking space as defined and required by the ADA It is not necessary to designate the EVSE exclusively for the use of vehicles parked in the accessible space. b. EVSE – public use shall be subject to the following requirements: DRAFT Building Codes Committee * * * 102 City Council Meeting of January 7, 2019 (Item No. 8b) Page 7 Title: Ordinance regarding parking standards including electric vehicle supply equipment. 1. The EVCSs shall be located in a manner that will be easily seen by the public for informational and security purposes. 2. The EVCSs shall be located in desirable and convenient parking locations that will serve as an incentive for the use of electric vehicles. 3. The EVCS must be operational during the normal business hours of the use(s) that it serves. EVCS may be de-energized or otherwise restricted after normal business hours of the use(s) it serves. c. Lighting. Site lighting shall be provided where EVSE is installed, unless charging is for daytime purposes only. d. Equipment Design Standards. 1. Battery charging station outlets and connector devices shall be mounted to comply with state code, and must comply with all relevant Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requirements. Equipment mounted on pedestals, lighting posts, bollards, or other devices shall be designed and located as to not impede pedestrian travel or create trip hazards on sidewalks. 2. Electric vehicle charging devices may be located adjacent to designated parking spaces in a garage or parking lot as long as the devices do not encroach into the required dimensions of the parking space (length, width, and height clearances). 3. The design should be appropriate to the location and use. Facilities should be able to be readily identified by electric vehicle users and blend into the surrounding landscape/architecture for compatibility with the character and use of the site. 4. EVCS pedestals shall be designed to minimize potential damage by accidents, vandalism and to be safe for use in inclement weather. e Usage Fees. The property owner may collect a service fee for the use of EVSE. f. Maintenance. EVSE shall be maintained in all respects, including the functioning of the equipment. A phone number or other contact information shall be provided on the equipment for reporting problems with the equipment or access to it. *** (k) Design Requirements *** (8) Lighting. DRAFT Building Codes Committee * * * 103 City Council Meeting of January 7, 2019 (Item No. 8b) Page 8 Title: Ordinance regarding parking standards including electric vehicle supply equipment. a. Required parking lotsareas for six or more vehicles shall provide lighting. When lighting is provided in parking lots, during business hours the average horizontal illumination shall not exceed 5.0 footcandles during business hours, the an average minimum horizontal illumination shall be of 0.5 footcandles on asphalt and 1.0 footcandle on concrete, and the maximum horizontal illumination shall not exceed 7.0 footcandles on asphalt and 14.0 footcandles on concrete. between 0.4 and one footcandle. When parking lots are illuminated between 10 p.m. to 6 a.m., or 30 minutes past business hours, whichever is later, the minimum horizontal illumination shall be 0.2 footcandles and the maximum illumination shall be 2.8 footcandles during these times. The maximum average horizontal illumination level after business hours must be within 0.2 and 2.8 footcandles. b. In all parking ramps where lighting is visible from off-site, the maximum average horizontal illumination shall be 5.0 footcandles, the average minimum horizontal illumination shall be 1.0 one footcandle, and the maximum horizontal illumination shall be 14.0 footcandles. If the parking ramp uses motion-activated lighting, the minimum required lighting level shall be lowered to 0.2 footcandles when no motion is detected and the maximum lighting level shall be lowered to 2.8 footcandles when no motion is detected. The top level of parking ramps shall use the required lighting levels of parking lots when uncovered and open to the sky. Lighting levels at entries and exits shall be a minimum 1.0 footcandles and shall not exceed 14.0 footcandles, regardless of motion detected. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect fifteen days after its publication. Reviewed for administration: Adopted by the City Council Thomas K. Harmening, City Manager Jake Spano, Mayor Attest: Approved as to form and execution: Melissa Kennedy, City Clerk Soren Mattick, City Attorney First Reading January 7, 2019 Second Reading January 22, 2019 Date of Publication February 1, 2019 Date Ordinance takes effect February 16, 2019 DRAFT Building Codes Committee * * * 104 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: September 6, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6g TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Board of Appeals Membership BACKGROUND Out of seven seats designated by Mauldin ordinance, there are currently one three active members serving on the Board of Appeals. This includes one current member who has filed an application to be considered for appointment to the Planning Commission. Currently the Board does not have enough members to even meet and take action on an appeal , variance, or special exception. The City has received no applications from citizens interested in the Board of Appeals so far this year. NUMBER OF MEMBERS REQUIRED The City ’s Zoning Ordinance currently provides th at the B oard of Appeals will consist of 7 members appointed by the City Council. Members must be res idents of the City of Mauldin at the time of their appointment and must maintain residency throughout the term of their office, which is 3 years. State law (section 6-29-780) prescribes that the City may create a board between 3 and 9 members. The members should serve for overlapping terms between 3 and 5 years. REQUEST Considering the lack of interest in the Board of Appeals, s taff is seeking direction from the Committee and/or City Council if it has interes t in reducing the number of members serving on the Board from 7 members to either 5 or 3 members by ordinance. Please note that the Planning Commission will need to review the ordinance before it can be approved by City Council. ATTACHMENTS None Building Codes Committee * * * 105

Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.