RecordWell Data

BZA-Z Staff Reports

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Nov 3, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 39 State St. SPECIAL EXCEPTION CASE SUMMARY November 3, 2026 | 5:15 p.m. Case Number: BZA2026-002488 Subject Property: 39 State St. / TMS# 458-09-01-101 Zoning District: SR-5 Property Owners: Tony & Paula Morgan Applicant: Julie O’Connor – American Vernacular, Inc. Requested Action: Request Special Exception to vertically extend a nonconforming 0’ east side setback to construct an addition to the existing third-story. Project Description: The applicant is requesting a Special Exception to construct a third-story rear addition onto the existing home within the required 3’ east side setback. The addition is comprised of a full en-suite bathroom. The proposed addition is located entirely behind the front façade of the home and is not visible from the public rights-of-way. Case History: Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-110.f. NON-CONFORMING USES The non-conforming use of a building or structure cannot be physically extended to provide more area for the non-conforming use, and the number of bedrooms in a non-conforming two-family dwelling or multi-family dwelling use cannot be increased, unless the Board of Zoning Appeals—Zoning, after a duly advertised public hearing, finds that the extension or increase of the non-conforming use is: (1) limited to extending or increasing the non-conforming use then in existence; and (2) would not result in an unreasonable intensification of the non-conforming use. In considering the reasonableness of the intensification of the extension or increase, the Board shall consider the effect of the extension or increase on properties in the vicinity to include traffic impacts; vehicular and pedestrian safety; parking impacts; potential impacts of noise, lighting, fumes or obstruction of air flow or light on adjoining property; impacts on the aesthetic character of the environs, to include the possible need for screening. If an extension or increase is permitted, the Board may imposed reasonable and appropriate conditions and safeguards for the protection of the public interest and neighboring properties, including but not limited to, limitations on the days and hours during which the proposed use may be operated, and shall require, for properties located in the Old and Historic District, that exterior alterations be approved by Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 39 State St. Page 2 the Board of Architectural Review, regardless of whether said alterations are visible from a public street or thoroughfare. Special Exception Requirements / Findings of Fact: For Special Exception requests, applicants should list the specific approval(s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as § 54-110, § 54-206, or sections in Article 5: Applicants Response: Sec.54-110 The Board shall consider the effect of the extension or increase on properties in the vicinity to include traffic impacts; vehicular and pedestrian safety; parking impacts; potential impacts of noise, lighting, fumes or obstruction of air flow or light on adjoining property; impacts on the aesthetic character of the environs, to include the possible need for screening. Staff Recommendation : Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: Staff are recommending approval of the request for special exception due to the proposed modifications to the home being limited to increasing the non-conforming use in existence; and would not result in an unreasonable intensification of the non-conforming use. Attachments: • Application • Zoning Map • Site Plan Staff Contact: • Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov BZA-Z Application (continued) Page 2 of 2 For Variance requests, applicants should list the specific variance(s) being requested and, if possible, explain how the variance test that follows is met (add as an attachment if necessary): _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Variance Test: The Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning is authorized to approve a variance from the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6-29-800) For Special Exception requests, applicants should list the specific approval(s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as § 54-110, § 54-206, or sections in Article 5 (add as an attachment if necessary): _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ All approvals of the Board shall remain valid for two (2) years from the approval date, unless extended in accordance with the provisions of Article 9, Part 5 of the zoning ordinance. Applicants may not apply for the same request that has been denied by the Board until a period of six (6) months has lapsed. Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability 2 George Street Charleston, South Carolina 29401 (843) 724-3781 www.charleston-sc.gov/zoning 6/22 we are requesting a vertical extension of a non-conforming north setback for a small addition on the rear of the 3rd floor of the house. This addition will be directly above an existing 2 story mass. The use will remain single family so will have no impact of traffic. It is behind the existing house and is compatible with the neighborhood. DARCHITECTERETSIGERUOSFOETATSTHCAROLINARACHELBEVERLEYBURTONSummerville, SCNo. 8440 151 Sheppard St.CharlestonSouth Carolina29403843-856-4818www.americanvernacular.com A M E R I C A N VERNACULAR ® T002 SITE PLAN SITE PLAN SCALE: 1/8" = 1' - 0" ISSUES/REVISIONSAS BUILTS DRAWINGS AND THE DESIGN ARE THEPROPERTY OF THE ARCHITECT WHETHERTHE PROJECT FOR WHICH THEY AREPREPARED IS EXECUTED OR NOT.THE DRAWINGS SHALL NOT BE USEDBY THE PROJECT OWNER OR ANYONEELSE FOR ANY OTHER PROJECT.THESE DRAWINGS CANNOT BE CHANGED ORREPRODUCED WITHOUT WRITTENCONSENT OF THE ARCHITECT. 8/31/26 DATE: September 28, 2026 Morgan Residence 39 State Street Charleston, South Carolina SITE PLAN - AS BUILT SCALE: 1/8" = 1'-0" 1 T002 ZONING SR-5 FLOOD ZONE SHADED X EXISTING BUILDING COVERAGE LOT SIZE: 3,523 SF BUILDING COVERAGE: MAIN HOUSE: 921 SF SHED: 112 SF TOTAL: 1,033 SF BUILDING COVERAGE RATIO: 29.3% ALLOWABLE: 35% (1,233 SF) SCHEMATICS9/14/26 SITE PLAN - PROPOSED SCALE: 1/8" = 1'-0" 2 T002 PROPOSED BUILDING COVERAGE LOT SIZE: 3,523 SF BUILDING COVERAGE: MAIN HOUSE: 921 SF SHED: 112 SF TOTAL: 1,033 SF BUILDING COVERAGE RATIO: 29.3% ALLOWABLE: 35% (1,233 SF) REVISIONS9/28/26 MAG(S) BCRN BCRNBCRN MAG(S) REBAR(S) REBAR(S) MAG(S) PUNCH(S) (N:345882.11',E:2329376.18') MAG(S) MAG(S) BCRN COLCRN PUNCH(F) CP CP CP LP LP EMH UTL STATE STREET (50' R/W) FACE OF CURB GATE 6' MASONRY WALL 2" BRICK WALL POND 5' MASONRY WALL 20.7' 29.1' 10.4' 10.2' WOOD SHED 46.3' L1 L2 7.0' 24.0' 16.8' L3 METAL ACCESS 0.8' A B C D E FG H I J K 7' BRICK AND MASONRY WALL BRICK L FLAGSTONE BRICK AND FLAGSTONE BUILDING LINE THE PROPERTY LINE BUILDING LINE THE PROPERTY LINE 3 STORY BRICK & MASONRYBUILDING 3 STORY MASONRY BUILDING 1 STORY BRICK BUILDING 1 STORY MASONRY 0.8' .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .... .. .. .. . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 4.4' 10.9' 3.8' 7.6' 8.7' 18.5' 0.8'. . .. . ``` ``` ``` ``` `````` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` `` `````` ``` ````````` ``` ``````````````` ``` ``` `````` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` `````` ``` .. ``` ``` ``` . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .PERPETUAL EASEEMENT PER REFERENCE #4 . .. . . 3 STORY BRICK & WOOD FRAME BUILDING .. .... .... .. .. .... .. .. .. .. .. ADDRESS IS No. 37 ADDRESS IS No. 39 1ST FLOOROPEN 2ND & 3RD FLOORSENCLOSED L4 L5 L6 L7 SLATE ``` 0.08 acres 3523 sq ft 0.02 acres 967 sq ft ``` ``` . . . . . . . . .. . .. .. . .. . TMS: 458-09-01-100 No. 41 STATE STREET N/F: MARK G. PHILLIPS, ETAL TMS: 458-09-01-097LOT C No. 10 PHILADELPHIA ALLEY N/F: THE FOOTLIGHT PLAYERS, INC. TMS: 458-09-01-096LOT B No. 20 QUEEN STREET N/F: THE FOOTLIGHT PLAYERS, INC. TMS: 458-09-01-104 PART OF LOT B AND STRIPNo. 33 STATE STREET N/F: BARNWELL PROPERTIES TMS: 458-09-01-103 No. 35 STATE STREET N/F: EDDIE LEE IRIONS, JR. ENC1ENC2ENC3 ENC4 ENC5 ENC6 ENC7 ``` ENC8 ENC9 ENC10 ENC11 ENC12 ENC13 ENC14 1ST & 2ND FLOORSENCLOSED 3RD FLOOR DECK TMS: 458-09-01-102TOTAL AREA B-C-D-E-B TMS: 458-09-01-101TOTAL AREA A-B-E-D-F-G- H-I-J-K-L-A ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` ```STONE (TYPICAL) L8 L9 NEW 6' ACCESS EASEMENT CHH CHH GHH S 81Ā47'19" W N 04Ā58'49" W N 82Ā18'27" E N 82Ā35'09" E S 82Ā44'11" W S 05Ā43'58" E N 80Ā51'57" E S 08Ā59'24" E N 81Ā01'11" E WM WM WM 66.64' 46.90' TOTAL 47.00' 29.08' 24.80' 22.00' 58.35' 30.09' 36.10' 35.90' MAG(S) BCRN BCRNBCRN MAG(S) REBAR(S) REBAR(S) MAG(S) PUNCH(S) (N:345882.11',E:2329376.18') MAG(S) MAG(S) BCRN COLCRN CP CP CP LP LP EMH UTL STATE STREET (50' R/W) FACE OF CURB GATE 6' MASONRY WALL 2" BRICK WALL POND 5' MASONRY WALL 20.7' 29.1' 10.4' 10.2' WOOD SHED 46.3' L1 L2 7.0' 24.0' 16.8' L3 METAL ACCESS 0.8' A B C D E FG H I J K 7' BRICK AND MASONRY WALL BRICK L FLAGSTONE BRICK AND FLAGSTONE BUILDING LINE THE PROPERTY LINE BUILDING LINE THE PROPERTY LINE 3 STORY BRICK & MASONRYBUILDING 3 STORY MASONRY BUILDING 1 STORY BRICK BUILDING 1 STORY MASONRY 0.8' .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .... .. .. .. . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 4.4' 10.9' 3.8' 7.6' 8.7' 18.5' 0.8'. . .. . ``` ``` ``` ``` `````` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` `` `````` ``` ````````` ``` ``````````````` ``` ``` `````` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` `````` ``` .. ``` ``` ``` . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .PERPETUAL EASEEMENT PER REFERENCE #4 . .. . . 3 STORY BRICK & WOOD FRAME BUILDING .. .... .... .. .. .... .. .. .. .. .. ADDRESS IS No. 37 ADDRESS IS No. 39 1ST FLOOROPEN 2ND & 3RD FLOORSENCLOSED L4 L5 L6 L7 SLATE ``` 0.08 acres 3523 sq ft 0.02 acres 967 sq ft ``` ``` . . . . . . . . .. . .. .. . .. . TMS: 458-09-01-100 No. 41 STATE STREET N/F: MARK G. PHILLIPS, ETAL TMS: 458-09-01-097LOT C No. 10 PHILADELPHIA ALLEY N/F: THE FOOTLIGHT PLAYERS, INC. TMS: 458-09-01-096LOT B No. 20 QUEEN STREET N/F: THE FOOTLIGHT PLAYERS, INC. TMS: 458-09-01-104 PART OF LOT B AND STRIPNo. 33 STATE STREET N/F: BARNWELL PROPERTIES TMS: 458-09-01-103 No. 35 STATE STREET N/F: EDDIE LEE IRIONS, JR. ENC1ENC2ENC3 ENC4 ENC5 ENC6 ENC7 ``` ENC8 ENC9 ENC10 ENC11 ENC12 ENC13 ENC14 1ST & 2ND FLOORSENCLOSED 3RD FLOOR DECK TMS: 458-09-01-102TOTAL AREA B-C-D-E-B TMS: 458-09-01-101TOTAL AREA A-B-E-D-F-G- H-I-J-K-L-A ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` ``` ```STONE (TYPICAL) L8 L9 NEW 6' ACCESS EASEMENT CHH CHH GHH S 81Ā47'19" W N 04Ā58'49" W N 82Ā18'27" E N 82Ā35'09" E S 82Ā44'11" W S 05Ā43'58" E N 80Ā51'57" E S 08Ā59'24" E N 81Ā01'11" E WM WM WM 66.64' 46.90' TOTAL 47.00' 29.08' 24.80' 22.00' 58.35' 30.09' 36.10' 35.90' 3' REAR SETBACK 7' SIDE SETBACK 3' SIDE SETBACK 3' SIDE SETBACK 7' SIDE SETBACKRAIN FLOOR EM CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 5 Saint Margaret St. SPECIAL EXCEPTION CASE SUMMARY November 3, 2026 | 5:15 p.m. Case Number: BZA2026-002489 Subject Property: 5 Saint Margaret St. / TMS# 463-15-01-040 Zoning District: SR-2 Property Owners: Gerald & Rachel Leach Applicant: Gerald Leach. Requested Action: Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-110.f. to vertically extend a nonconforming 3’ east side setback (9’ required) to convert a half-story to a second story. Project Description: The applicant is requesting a Special Exception to expand the rear half of the existing half-story within the required 9’ east side setback. The addition is comprised of a an expansion to the existing bedroom as well as a proposed closet and en-suite bathroom. Case History: Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-110.f. NON-CONFORMING USES The non-conforming use of a building or structure cannot be physically extended to provide more area for the non-conforming use, and the number of bedrooms in a non-conforming two-family dwelling or multi-family dwelling use cannot be increased, unless the Board of Zoning Appeals—Zoning, after a duly advertised public hearing, finds that the extension or increase of the non-conforming use is: (1) limited to extending or increasing the non-conforming use then in existence; and (2) would not result in an unreasonable intensification of the non-conforming use. In considering the reasonableness of the intensification of the extension or increase, the Board shall consider the effect of the extension or increase on properties in the vicinity to include traffic impacts; vehicular and pedestrian safety; parking impacts; potential impacts of noise, lighting, fumes or obstruction of air flow or light on adjoining property; impacts on the aesthetic character of the environs, to include the possible need for screening. If an extension or increase is permitted, the Board may imposed reasonable and appropriate conditions and safeguards for the protection of the public interest and neighboring properties, including but not limited to, limitations on the days and hours during which the proposed use may be operated, and shall require, for properties located in the Old and Historic District, that exterior alterations be approved by the Board of Architectural Review, regardless of whether said alterations are visible from a public street or thoroughfare. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 5 Saint Margaret St. Page 2 Special Exception Requirements/ Findings of Fact: For Special Exception requests, applicants should list the specific approval(s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as § 54-110, § 54-206, or sections in Article 5: Applicants Response: Sec.54-110 The Board shall consider the effect of the extension or increase on properties in the vicinity to include traffic impacts; vehicular and pedestrian safety; parking impacts; potential impacts of noise, lighting, fumes or obstruction of air flow or light on adjoining property; impacts on the aesthetic character of the environs, to include the possible need for screening. Staff Recommendation : Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: Staff are recommending approval of the request for special exception due to the proposed modifications to the home being limited to increasing the non-conforming use in existence; and would not result in an unreasonable intensification of the non-conforming use. Attachments: • Application • Zoning Map • Site Plan Staff Contact: • Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov BZA-Z Application (continued) Page 2 of 2 For Variance requests, applicants should list the specific variance(s) being requested and, if possible, explain how the variance test that follows is met (add as an attachment if necessary): Variance Test: The Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning is authorized to approve a variance from the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6-29-800) For Special Exception requests, applic ants should list the specific approval(s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as § 54-110, § 54-206, or sections in Article 5 (add as an attachment if necessary): All approvals of the Board shall remain valid for two (2) years from the approval date, unless extended in accordance with the provisions of Article 9, Part 5 of the zoning ordinance. Applicants may not apply for the same request that has been denied by the Board until a period of six (6) months has lapsed. 11/23 Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability 2 George Street Charleston, South Carolina 29401 (843) 724-3781 www.charleston-sc.gov/zoning GENERAL PROPERTY SURVEY CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 131 Columbus St. SPECIAL EXCEPTION CASE SUMMARY November 3, 2026 | 5:15pm Case Number: BZA2026-002490 Subject Property: 131 Columbus St. / TMS# 460-08-02-001 Zoning District: LI Property Owner: 131 Columbus NPV MCZ SPE LLC Applicant: Samuel Morris, Nelson Mullins Riley and Scarborough LLP Requested Action: Request to amend the Special Exception approval for an accommodations use under Sec. 54-220 to reduce the contiguous meeting space to 12,000sf (15,000sf required, 15,504sf previously approved) as part of a reduction in height and overall square footage. Project Description: The applicant is requesting to amend their previously granted special exception by altering the previously approved design, reducing the proposed contiguous meeting space from 15,504sf to 12,000sf. The previously approved design depicting the proposed second floor meeting space measuring 15,504sf will be removed reducing the overall building height from the eight to seven stories. The meeting space requirement will then be accomplished by the 12,000sf shown on the proposed seventh floor including the previously approved meeting space and proposed restaurant. Case History: On August 3rd 2021 the BZA-Z approved a special exception to allow the construction of the accommodations use with 125 parking spaces provided. The applicant then received a special exception on May 16th, 2023, to amend the original approval that resulted in modifications to the building plans relocating the parking to an underground garage. The original approval also received a vested rights extension on May 5th, 2026. On September 15th, 2026 the board approved a subsequent amendment to the special exception approval reducing the overall parking to 82 spaces with several conditions attached requiring an increase in parking through the installation of stackers if the overall parking usage exceeds what is provided onsite. Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-220 Accommodations Overlay Zone Permitted uses. In any Accommodations overlay zone, land may be used and buildings or structures may be erected, altered or used for any purpose allowed by the base zoning district as listed in Article 2: Part 3, and the following uses, subject to the approval of the Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning: Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 2 1. Accommodations uses. The Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning may permit accommodations uses as an exception where it finds that: (a) the accommodations use will not result in a net loss of dwelling units that have been occupied within five years of the date of application for the exception; provided however, the BZA-Z may approve the alteration or replacement of such existing dwelling units on the same site as the accommodations use, or within a radius of one quarter (¼) mile from the site if the proposed off site location does not result in an over concentration of low income households, as defined by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, as adjusted by the Department of Housing and Community Development; and provided further, the BZA-Z shall require any such alteration or replacement to include dwelling units of substantially the same size and type of those being altered or replaced and shall require that no certificate of occupancy shall be issued for the accommodations uses until either a certificate of occupancy has been issued for all dwelling units being altered or replaced or irrevocable bonds or letters of credit in favor of the City in amounts equivalent to one hundred twenty-five (125%) per cent of the costs to complete construction or renovation of the dwelling units, as determined by the Chief Building Inspector, has been filed with the City. (b)the accommodations use, if located in the Accommodations Overlay on the peninsula, will not reduce or displace more than 25% of office space that has been used for such purpose within five years of the application for the exception; (c)the accommodations use, if located in the Accommodations Overlay on the peninsula, will not displace more than 25% of the linear frontage of existing ground floor storefront retail space on the property; (d)the location of the accommodations use will not significantly increase automobile traffic on streets within residential districts; (e)the location of the accommodations use will contribute to the maintenance, or creation, of a diverse mixed-use district; (f)the total square footage of interior and exterior floor area for restaurant and bar space in the proposed accommodations use, including restaurant/bar patron use areas, bar areas, kitchen, storage, and bathroom facilities, shall not exceed 12 percent of the total interior, conditioned floor area in the accommodations use, except that each accommodations use shall be permitted to exempt from the calculation of total restaurant floor area one interior, ground floor restaurant tenant space if the total tenant space does not exceed 2,000 square feet, the restaurant tenant does not serve alcoholic beverages, and the exempt restaurant tenant space is clearly labeled with these restrictions on the floor plans submitted with the application for this zoning special exception; (g)the accommodations use proposed guest drop off and pick up area(s) is located outside the public right-of-way and on the property utilized for the accommodations use if the accommodations use contains more than 50 sleeping units, and if 50 sleeping units or less, the proposed guest drop off and pick up area(s) are located outside the public right-of-way if feasible, and the location and design of the guest drop-off and pick-up area(s) has been reviewed by the Department of Traffic and Transportation and determined to be safe and not be an impediment to traffic and that every effort has been made to minimize traffic impacts; Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 3 (h)the total number of sleeping units within the buildings or structures on the lot or parcel in which the accommodations use is located is equal to or exceeds ten (10) sleeping units. (i)within areas of the accommodations overlay zone designated as "A-1", "A-2", "A- 3", "A-4", "A-5", "A-6", or "A-7" on the zoning map, the number of sleeping units within the buildings or structures on the lot or parcel in which the accommodations use is located shall not exceed 50 in areas designated "A-1"; 180 in areas designated "A-2"; 225 in areas designated "A-3"; 100 in areas designated "A-4"; 150 in areas designated "A-5"; 69 in areas designated "A-6"; and 175 in areas designated "A- 7"; provided, however, that within the portion of the area designated "A-1" bounded by King Street on the west, Meeting Street on the east, Mary Street on the south and Line Street on the north (the "Full-Service Corridor"), the number of sleeping units within the buildings or structures on the lot or parcel in which the accommodations use is located may exceed 50, but shall not exceed 250, if the accommodations use qualifies as a Full-Service Hotel, meaning that the accommodations use provides 20,000 or more square feet of meeting, conference and banquet space of which 15,000 square feet thereof is contiguous, an on-site restaurant that serves breakfast, lunch and dinner seven days a week and other services such as a concierge, a spa/health club, laundry, turndown service, newspaper delivery, security personnel and airport shuttle; and in no event shall any accommodations use on the peninsula exceed 250 sleeping units; (j)the proposed accommodations use will not share any of its buildings, structures, facilities, or operations with another accommodations use; (k) (1)The proposed accommodations use, if located in the accommodations overlay on the peninsula, incorporates meeting and conference space at a ratio of 400 square feet per 10 sleeping units, or fraction thereof, with respect to the first 150 sleeping units, and incorporates meeting and conference space at a ratio of 1000 square feet for every 10 sleeping units, or fraction thereof, exceeding 150 sleeping units. In either case, at least 75% of the meeting and conference space shall be contiguous; (2)Notwithstanding subsection k(1) hereof, if the accommodations use contains more than 50 sleeping units and is located in the Full-Service Corridor, the provisions of subsection (i) hereof shall govern the square footage of required meeting and conference space; (l)the proposed accommodations use will not result in there being more than eight (8) Full-Service Hotels on the peninsula, inclusive of those Full-Service Hotels existing on the peninsula and those with approved special exceptions as of the effective date of the ordinance from which this section derives; for purposes of this subsection (l) only, a Full-Service Hotel means a Full-Service Hotel as defined in subsection (i) having in excess of 150 sleeping units; and (m)to assist in providing affordable housing opportunities for its employees, the applicant for the accommodations use commits to contribute to the City of Charleston Affordable/Workforce Housing Account a fee payable upon the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, calculated as follows: $5.10 per square foot of area used for sleeping units and the hallways adjacent to sleeping units, stairwells and elevators. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 4 C. Application requirements. In making the findings required in subsection b.1, the Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning shall consider the following information to be provided by the applicant in site plans, floor plans and building elevations that will govern the construction of the building in which the accommodations use is located, along with a detailed written assessment report to be submitted with the application: 1.The number of existing dwelling units on the property, including units on the property that were occupied as dwelling units within five years of the date of the application for the exception, the type of unit (rental or owner-occupied; one-family detached; one-family attached; two-family or multi-family; occupied or unoccupied), by income range of the most recent occupant(s), the rental price for rental units and market price for owner occupied units relative to the area median income figures that are determined annually by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and adjusted by the City of Charleston Department of Housing and Community Development, or its successor, the physical condition of the units (sound, deficient, deteriorated or dilapidated), the square footage and number of bedrooms in each unit, and if the units are proposed to be physically altered or replaced, a description and plan showing the square footage and number of bedrooms in the altered or replaced units, and their location; 2.The effect of the physical alteration or replacement or relocation of dwelling units on the housing stock of a particular type on the property and whether a condition should be attached to a special exception approval for the accommodations use requiring a minimum percentage of the dwelling units on the property or replaced off-site to remain affordable based on the annually updated median area income values; 3.The presence of office space on the property, or the presence of spaces on the property that were occupied as office spaces within five years of the date of application for the exception; 4.The linear frontage of existing ground floor storefront retail space on the property; 5.The location and design of guest drop off and pick up areas for the accommodations use; 6.The cumulative number of vehicle trips generated by the proposed accommodations use and other accommodations uses that are either existing or approved within an area identified by the Department of Traffic and Transportation, the traffic circulation pattern serving the accommodations use and efforts made to minimize traffic impacts; 7.The distance of the main entrance and parking entrance of the accommodations use from a road classified as an arterial or collector road; 8.The land uses within five hundred feet (500') of the accommodations use, to include the location, square footage, and number of rooms in existing accommodations uses and accommodations uses that have been approved; 9.The proximity of residential districts to the accommodations use; Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 5 10.The accessory uses proposed for the accommodations use, such as restaurants, spas, bars, pools and the like, in terms of their location, size, impact on parking, traffic generation, noise or odors in or to a residential district; 11.The demonstrated provision of off-street parking at the rate of two spaces that meet the design requirements of section 54-318 for each three sleeping units, provided however, the utilization of mechanical or other means of parking that meet the ratio of two spaces for each three sleeping units shall be allowed; 12.The presence of industrial uses and uses which use, store, or produce toxic or hazardous materials in quantities in excess of those specified by the EPA listing of toxic and hazardous materials, within five hundred feet (500') of the accommodations use; 13.The commitment to environmental sustainability and recycling; 14.The distance of the accommodations use from major tourist attractions; 15.The distance of the accommodations use from existing or planned transit facilities; 16.The long term provision of on- or off-site parking for employees who drive vehicles to work, including an estimate of the number of employees that will drive to work during the maximum shift and the location of parking spaces to be provided, and the demonstrated provision of free transit passes or other incentives to encourage employee use of public transportation; 17.The number of sleeping units proposed as part of the accommodations use; 18.The provision of shuttle bus services to and from the Historic Districts by accommodations uses with more than 50 sleeping units located outside the area designated "A-1" through "A-6" on the zoning map; 19.The commitment to make affirmative, good faith efforts to see that construction and procurement opportunities are available to MBEs (minority business enterprises) and WBEs (women business enterprises) as outlined in section 2-268 (e)(1), (2), and (3) of the Code of the City of Charleston; 20.The commitment to make affirmative, good faith efforts to hire personnel, representative of the population of the Charleston community, at all employment levels. D. Violations: In addition to any remedies otherwise available to the City under State law or the City Code, a violation by the owner or operator of the accommodations use of any provisions or conditions of an exception granted hereunder, to include any deviation from the plans and written assessment as required by subsection c. hereof, shall subject the owner or operator of the accommodations use to having its business license and/or certificate of occupancy revoked. E. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 6 Applicability: The provisions of this Section 54-220 shall apply to special exceptions for accommodations uses granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning after May 28, 2019, it being the intent of City Council that special exceptions approved by the Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning prior to May 28, 2019 be entitled to and governed by the vested rights provisions accorded by Article 9, Part 5 of this Chapter. The provisions of this Section 54-220 shall not apply to Planned Unit Developments that include accommodations uses as an authorized use that were approved as of May 28, 2019. Special Exception Test/ Findings of Fact: The following is excerpted from Section 54-924 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. This test is based on S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-800. A variance may be granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: Applicant Responses: Section 54-220(b)(1)(a): No Net Loss of Dwelling Units STANDARD: the accommodations use will not result in a net loss of dwelling units that have been occupied within five years of the date of application for the exception; provided however, the BZA-Z may approve the alteration or replacement of such existing dwelling units on the same site as the accommodations use, or within a radius of one quarter (¼) mile from the site if the proposed off site location does not result in an over concentration of low income households, as defined by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, as adjusted by the Department of Housing and Community Development; and provided further, the BZA-Z shall require any such alteration or replacement to include dwelling units of substantially the same size and type of those being altered or replaced and shall require that no certificate of occupancy shall be issued for the accommodations uses until either a certificate of occupancy has been issued for all dwelling units being altered or replaced or irrevocable bonds or letters of credit in favor of the City in amounts equivalent to one hundred twenty-five (125%) percent of the costs to complete construction or renovation of the dwelling units, as determined by the Chief Building Inspector, has been filed with the City. Response – The proposed accommodations use will not result in a net loss of dwelling units that have been occupied within five years of the date of application for the exception. Section 54-220(b)(1)(b): Minimize Displacement of Office Space. STANDARD: the accommodations use, if located in the Accommodations Overlay on the peninsula, will not reduce or displace more than 25% of office space that has been used for such purpose within five years of the application for the exception; Response – The proposed accommodations use is located in the Accommodations Overlay on the peninsula and will not reduce or displace any office space. Section 54-220(b)(1)(c): Minimize Displacement of Existing Retail Space. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 7 STANDARD: the accommodations use, if located in the Accommodations Overlay on the peninsula, will not reduce or displace more than 25% of the linear frontage of existing ground floor storefront retail space on the property. Response – The proposed accommodations use is located in the Accommodations Overlay on the peninsula and will not displace more than 25% of the linear frontage of existing ground floor storefront retail space. if any, on the property. Section 54-220(b)(1)(d): Traffic Impacts on Residential Streets. STANDARD: the location of the accommodations use will not significantly increase automobile traffic on streets within residential districts Response – The proposed accommodations use is located on non-residential sections of Columbus and Spring Streets which connect to King and Meeting Streets, both and will not significantly increase automobile traffic on streets within residential districts per the Traffic Impact Analysis of Bihl Engineering, LLC. Section 54-220(b)(1)(e): Contribute to Diverse Mixed-Use District. STANDARD: the location of the accommodations use will contribute to the maintenance, or creation, of a diverse mixed-use district Response – The location of the proposed accommodations use will contribute to the maintenance, or creation, of a diverse mixed-use district, as the immediate block surrounding this property includes a shuttered grocery store and a moving and storage company. Section 54-220(b)(1)(f): Limitation on Restaurant and Bar Space. STANDARD: the total square footage of interior and exterior floor area for restaurant and bar space in the proposed accommodations use, including restaurant/bar patron use areas, bar areas, kitchen, storage, and bathroom facilities, shall not exceed 12 percent of the total interior, conditioned floor area in the accommodations use, except that each accommodations use shall be permitted to exempt from the calculation of total restaurant floor area one interior, ground floor restaurant tenant space if the total tenant space does not exceed 2,000 square feet, the restaurant tenant does not serve alcoholic beverages, and the exempt restaurant tenant space is clearly labeled with these restrictions on the floor plans submitted with the application for this zoning special exception Response – The total square footage of interior and exterior floor area for restaurant and bar space in the proposed accommodations use will be 14,175 square feet (less than 12%), including restaurant/bar patron use areas, bar areas, kitchen. storage, and bathroom facilities which does not exceed 12 percent of the total interior, conditioned floor area in the accommodations use. Section 54-220(b)(1)(g): Location of Guest Drop-off and Pick-up. STANDARD: the accommodations use proposed guest drop off and pick up area(s) is located outside the public right-of-way and on the property utilized for the accommodations use if the accommodations use contains more than 50 sleeping units, Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 8 and if 50 sleeping units or less, the proposed guest drop off and pick up area(s) are located outside the public right-of-way if feasible, and the location and design of the guest drop-off and pick-up area(s) has been reviewed by the Department of Traffic and Transportation and determined to be safe and not be an impediment to traffic and that every effort has been made to minimize traffic impacts; Response – The proposed accommodations use guest drop off and pick up area is located outside the public right-of-way and on the property to be utilized for the accommodations use to minimize traffic impacts. Section 54-220(b)(1)(h): Minimum Number of Sleeping Units. STANDARD: the total number of sleeping units within the buildings or structures on the lot or parcel in which the accommodations use is located is equal to or exceeds ten (10) sleeping units. Response – The total number of sleeping units within the buildings or structures on the lot or parcel in which the accommodations use is located is one hundred seventy-four (174) units which exceeds ten (10) sleeping units. Section 54-220(b)(1)(i): Maximum Number of Sleeping Units. STANDARD: The number of sleeping units within the buildings or structures on the lot or parcel in which the accommodations use is located shall not exceed 50. Response – The property is within the Full-Service Corridor and will have one hundred seventy-four (174) sleeping units. The applicant seeks an amendment to allow only 12,497 square feet of the required 20,000 square feet of meeting, conference and banquet space square feet to be contiguous. 12,611 contiguous square feet of meeting, conference and banquet space will be on the top floor and the remainder will be on the bottom floor. The requested reduction to 12,611 square feet of contiguous meeting, conference and banquet space still meets the 20,000 total square feet requirement but allows flexibility to account for the subject property’s limited floor plate. Section 54-220(b)(1)(j): Restriction on Shared Facilities. STANDARD: the proposed accommodations use will not share any of its buildings, structures, facilities, or operations with another accommodations use; Response – The proposed accommodations use will not share any of its buildings. structures, facilities, or operations with another accommodations use. Section 54-220(b)(1)(k): Meeting and Conference Space. STANDARD: (1) The proposed accommodations use , if located in the accommodations overlay on the peninsula, incorporates meeting and conference space at a ratio of 400 square feet per 10 sleeping units, or fraction thereof, with respect to the first 150 sleeping units, and incorporates meeting and conference space at a ratio of 1000 square feet for every 10 sleeping units, or fraction thereof, exceeding 150 sleeping units. In either case, at least 75% of the meeting and conference space shall be contiguous; (2) Notwithstanding subsection k(1) hereof, if the accommodations use contains more than 50 sleeping units and is located in the Full-Service Corridor, the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 9 provisions of subsection (i) hereof shall govern the square footage of required meeting and conference space. Response – The proposed accommodations use will contain more than 50 sleeping units and is located in the Full-Service Corridor, and is governed by the provisions of subsection (i) hereof. Section 54-220(b)(1)(l): Restriction on Number of Full-Service Hotels on the Peninsula. STANDARD: the proposed accommodations use will not result in there being more than eight (8) FullService Hotels on the peninsula, inclusive of those Full-Service Hotels existing on the peninsula and those with approved special exceptions as of the effective date of the ordinance from which this section derives; for purposes of this subsection (l) only, a Full-Service Hotel means a Full-Service Hotel as defined in subsection (i) having in excess of 150 sleeping units Response - The proposed accommodations use will not result in there being more than eight (8) Full-Service Hotels on the peninsula. Section 54-220(b)(1)(m): Commitment for Affordable/Workforce Housing Contribution. STANDARD: to assist in providing affordable housing opportunities for its employees, the applicant for the accommodations use commits to contribute to the City of Charleston Affordable/Workforce Housing Account a fee payable upon the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, calculated as follows: $5.10 per square foot of area used for sleeping units and the hallways adjacent to sleeping units, stairwells and elevators Response – To assist in providing affordable housing opportunities for its employees, the developer of the accommodations use commits to contribute to the City of Charleston Affordable/Workforce Housing Account a fee payable upon the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, calculated as follows: $5.10 per square foot of area used for sleeping units and the hallways adjacent to sleeping units, stairwells and elevators. SECTION 54-220(C) APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS. Section 54-220(c)(1): Impact to Dwelling Units on the Property. REQUIREMENT: The number of existing dwelling units on the property, including units on the property that were occupied as dwelling units within five years of the date of the application for the exception, the type of unit (rental or owner-occupied; one-family detached; one-family attached; two-family or multifamily; occupied or unoccupied), by income range of the most recent occupant(s), the rental price for rental units and market price for owner occupied units relative to the area median income figures that are determined annually by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and adjusted by the City of Charleston Department of Housing and Community Development, or its successor, the physical condition of the units (sound, deficient, deteriorated or dilapidated), the square footage and number of bedrooms in each unit, and if the units are proposed to be physically altered or replaced, a description and plan showing the square footage and number of bedrooms in the altered or replaced units, and their location; Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 10 Response: No existing dwelling units have been on this property in more than five (5) years. Section 54-220(c)(2): Impact to Housing Stock. REQUIREMENT: The effect of the physical alteration or replacement or relocation of dwelling units on the housing stock of a particular type on the property and whether a condition should be attached to a special exception approval for the accommodations use requiring a minimum percentage of the dwelling units on the property or replaced off-site to remain affordable based on the annually updated median area income values; Response: No existing dwelling units have been on this property in more than five (5) years. Section 54-220(c)(3): Presence of Office Space. REQUIREMENT: The presence of office space on the property, or the presence of spaces on the property that were occupied as office spaces within five years of the date of application for the exception; Response: No existing dwelling units have been on this property in more than five (5) years. Section 54-220(c)(4): Linear Frontage. REQUIREMENT: The linear frontage of existing ground floor storefront retail space on the property; Response: There is no linear frontage of existing ground floor storefront retail space on the property. Section 54-220(c)(5): Guest Drop Off and Pick Up. REQUIREMENT: The location and design of guest drop off and pick up areas for the accommodations use; Response: The guest drop off and pick up areas for the proposed accommodations use will enter and exit from Columbus Street and are located internal to the project. Section 54-220(c)(6): Traffic Impact. REQUIREMENT: The cumulative number of vehicle trips generated by the proposed accommodations use and other accommodations uses that are either existing or approved within an area identified by the Department of Traffic and Transportation, the traffic circulation pattern serving the accommodations use and efforts made to minimize traffic impacts; Response: The cumulative number of vehicle trips the proposed accommodations use is projected to generate is 80 new vehicle trips during the AM peak hour (45 entering and 35 exiting), 102 new vehicle trips during the PM peak hour (52 entering and 50 exiting), and 1,473 daily. Efforts made to minimize traffic impacts include location on the Lowline and near CARTA stops as well as proving bicycle parking. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 11 Section 54-220(c)(7): Distance to Arterial or Collector Road. REQUIREMENT: The distance of the main entrance and parking entrance of the accommodations use from a road classified as an arterial or collector road; Response: The main and parking entrance of the proposed accommodations use is 298 feet from King Street and 470 feet front Meeting Street, which are both classified as major arteries. Section 54-220(c)(8): Neighboring Land Uses. REQUIREMENT: The land uses within five hundred feet (500') of the accommodations use, to include the location, square footage, and number of rooms in existing accommodations uses and accommodations uses that have been approved; Response: The existing land uses within 500 feet of the proposed accommodations use include accommodations, manufacturing/printing, commercial/office, park. parking, and residential. Section 54-220(c)(9): Proximity of Residential Districts. REQUIREMENT: The proximity of residential districts to the accommodations use; Response: Residential districts are located west of King Street and east of Meeting Street. Section 54-220(c)(10): Accessory Uses. REQUIREMENT: The accessory uses proposed for the accommodations use, such as restaurants, spas, bars, pools and the like, in terms of their location, size, impact on parking, traffic generation, noise or odors in or to a residential district; Response: Up to two restaurant are being proposed for this accommodations use. This proposed use is not expected to have any consequential impact on parking, truffle generation, noise or odors in or to any residential districts. Section 54-220(c)(11): Off-Street Parking. REQUIREMENT: The demonstrated provision of off-street parking at the rate of two spaces that meet the design requirements of section 54-318 for each three sleeping units, provided however, the utilization of mechanical or other means of parking that meet the ratio of two spaces for each three sleeping units shall be allowed; Response: BZA approved an amendment allowing for initial capacity for 82 spaces via mechanical parking, scalable to 98 as demand warrants. Section 54-220(c)(12): Presence of Industrial or Other Uses Which Produce Excessive Hazardous Materials. REQUIREMENT: The presence of industrial uses and uses which use, store, or produce toxic or hazardous materials in quantities in excess of those specified by the EPA listing Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 12 of toxic and hazardous materials, within five hundred feet (500') of the accommodations use; Response: There are no known industrial uses which use, store, or produce toxic or hazardous materials in quantities in excess of those specified by the EPA listing of toxic and hazardous materials within five hundred feet (500) of the proposed accommodations use. Section 54-220(c)(13): Commitment to Environmental Sustainability. REQUIREMENT: The commitment to environmental sustainability and recycling; Response: The proposed accommodations use will be committed to environmental sustainability and recycling. Section 54-220(c)(14): Distance from Major Tourist Attractions. REQUIREMENT: The distance of the accommodations use from major tourist attractions; Response: The proposed accommodations use is located on the peninsula and is in close proximity to major tourist attractions on the peninsula as well as off-peninsula locations such as Patriot's Point and Highway 61 plantations. Section 54-220(c)(15): Distance from Planned Transit Facilities. REQUIREMENT: The distance of the accommodations use from existing or planned transit facilities; Response: The proposed accommodations use is located within 100 feet from a CARTA bus stop and HOP bus stop. and abuts the proposed Lowline which will provide access to the proposed LCRT stop. Section 54-220(c)(16): Employee Parking. REQUIREMENT: The long term provision of on- or off-site parking for employees who drive vehicles to work, including an estimate of the number of employees that will drive to work during the maximum shift and the location of parking spaces to be provided, and the demonstrated provision of free transit passes or other incentives to encourage employee use of public transportation; Response: A portion of the 82 spaces (scalable to 98) will be available to employees who drive. The use will also provide free transit passes or other incentives and bicycle parking where appropriate. Section 54-220(c)(17): Proposed Sleeping Units. REQUIREMENT: The number of sleeping units proposed as part of the accommodations use; Response: 174 sleeping units are proposed as part of the accommodations use. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 13 Section 54-220(c)(18): Provision of Shuttle Servies. REQUIREMENT: The provision of shuttle bus services to and from the Historic Districts by accommodations uses with more than 50 sleeping units located outside the area designated "A-1" through "A-6" on the zoning map; Response: Not applicable. Section 54-220(c)(19): Commitment to Opportunities for MBEs and WBEs. REQUIREMENT: The commitment to make affirmative, good faith efforts to see that construction and procurement opportunities are available to MBEs (minority business enterprises) and WBEs (women business enterprises) as outlined in section 2-268 (e)(1), (2), and (3) of the Code of the City of Charleston; Response: The proposed accommodations use is committed to make affirmative. good faith efforts to see that construction and procurement opportunities are available to MBEs (minority business enterprises) and WBEs (women business enterprises) as outlined in section 2-268 (e)(1), (2), and (3) of the Code of the City of Charleston. Section 54-220(c)(20): Commitment to Hire Personnel Representative of the Population of Charleston Community. REQUIREMENT: The commitment to make affirmative, good faith efforts to hire personnel, representative of the population of the Charleston community, at all employment levels. Response: The proposed accommodations use is committed to make affirmative, good faith efforts to hire personnel, representative of the population of the Charleston community at all employment levels. Staff Recommendation: Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: Staff recommend approval of the amendment to the previously approved Special Exception due to the proposed changes reducing the overall size and scale of the building to be more compatible with the existing buildings in the surrounding area. Attachments: • Zoning Map • Site Map • Application Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 131 Columbus St. Page 14 Staff Contact: Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov ADJACENT LOT (N.I.C.) TWO-WAY TRAFFIC COLUMBUS STREET 20 MPH TWO-WAY TRAFFIC SPRING STREET 25 MPH EXISTING 2-STORY BUILDING (N.I.C.) EXISTING 8-STORY BUILDING (N.I.C.) EXISTING 4-STORY BUILDING (N.I.C.) EXISTING 8-STORY BUILDING (N.I.C.) EXISTING 5-STORY BUILDING (N.I.C.) LOWLINE (FUTURE DEVELOPMENT) LOWLINE (FUTURE DEVELOPMENT) VEHICLE DRIVE ENTRY VEHICLE DRIVE EXIT EXIT PROPOSED BUILDING 131 COLUMBUS STREET PROPOSED DRIVEWAY VALET PARKING RAMP ENTRY/ EXIT LOWLINE (FUTURE DEVELOPMENT) 275' FRONT PROPERTY LINE 275.4' REAR PROPERTY LINE 60' REAR PROPERTY LINE 68' REAR PROPERTY LINE 25' - 0" 10' - 0" LOADING N SCALE: ©2026 OFFSET ARCHITECTURE PLLC 1" = 20'-0" 131 COLUMBUS ST. | CHARLESTON, SC 10/02/26 BZA-01 SITE PLAN CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 30 Pendleton St. VARIANCE CASE SUMMARY November 3, 2026 | 5:15pm Case Number: BZA2026-002491 Subject Property: 30 Pendleton St. / TMS# 463-07-02-068 Zoning District: SR-2 Property Owners: William & Anna Gruenloh Applicant: Anna Gruenloh Requested Action: Request Variance from Sec. 54-301to build an ADU with a 6’ rear setback and a 8’ east side setback (25’ and 9’ required). Project Description: The applicant is requesting a variance from Sec. 54-301 to construct a detached ADU with a 6’ rear setback and an 8’ east side setback. The proposed ADU is comprised an unconditioned two- car garage on the first floor, and a bedroom, bathroom, living/kitchen space on the second floor. The proposed ADU must abide by the setbacks of the SR-2 zoning district as the existing pool cabana prevents the application of the exception in Sec. 54-506.f. The location of the ADU in the eastern rear of the property is intended to limit its visibility from the public right of way while also maintaining sufficient area to accommodate the three off-street parking spaces required for this parcel. Case History: Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-301 Height, area and setback regulations The setbacks for the SR-2 Zoning District are as follows: Front: 25’ Rear: 25’ South/West: 9’ North/East: 9’ Maximum Lot Coverage: 50% Sec. 54-506.f. Exceptions to side and rear setback requirements for accessory building exceeding a footprint of 100 square feet Notwithstanding the setback requirements of this Chapter, accessory buildings meeting all the conditions listed below, shall be allowed to encroach to within three (3) feet of interior side and rear property lines, except when those property lines abut marshes, rivers or lakes, in which case setback requirements for principal buildings relative to those abutting or encroaching property lines shall apply to all buildings. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 30 Pendleton St. Page 2 1. Only one accessory building using this exception shall be permitted on a lot; and 2. Accessory building(s) and principal building shall meet lot occupancy requirements in Table 3.1 of Section 54-301; and 3. Accessory building shall meet accessory building setback requirements in Table 3.1 of Section 54-301; and 4. Accessory building height shall not exceed one and one-half (1½) stories and a maximum eave height of eleven (11) feet unless the principal building is two (2) or more stories, in which case the accessory building shall not exceed two (2) stories and a total height of 24 feet measured from the ground to the peak of a gable, hipped, or shed roof. For the purposes hereof, a crawl space in the principal building exceeding six (6) feet in height shall count as a story; and 5. The footprint of the accessory building (see definition for "building" in Sec. 54-120) shall not exceed 600 square feet in total area; and 6. Accessory building shall not include a dwelling unit except where additional dwelling units are permitted on the lot by this Chapter; and 7. Accessory building shall be on same lot as principal building and located to the rear of the principal building. Variance Test/ Findings of Fact: The following is excerpted from Section 54-924 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. This test is based on S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-800. A variance may be granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: Applicant Responses: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property See Narrative 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; See Narrative 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and See Narrative 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. See Narrative Narrative: In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 30 Pendleton St. Page 3 protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6-29-800) Staff Recommendation: Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: Staff are recommending approval of the variance request due to location of the existing home in relation with the setbacks creating an extraordinary and exceptional condition unique to this particular piece of property that in turn creates an unreasonable restriction on its utilization. The strict application of the rear and side setback requirement would shift the proposed ADU toward the front of the lot reducing the available area necessary for the lot to accommodate the required parking. Attachments: • Zoning Map • Site Map • Application Staff Contact: Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov 9.5 9.5 10.2 10.1 10.2 10.2 10.2 10.2 10.1 9.8 9.8 9.9 9.9 9.9 9.9 9.9 9.9 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.1 10.0 10.0 10.2 10.5 10.6 10.5 10.5 10.5 9.6 9.7 9.4 9.4 9.6 9.6 9.7 9.7 11.2 9.9 9.9 10.9 10.7 10.3 9.9 10.1 10.0 10.1 10.5 10.1 10.1 10.1 9.9 10.2 10.2 10.3 10.0 10.3 10.5 11.1 11.0 10.7 10.3 10.6 10.5 10.3 10.3 10.5 10.5 10.9 10.1 10.9 10.9 11.1 11.1 11.0 10.2 10.0 10.5 10.1 9.7 9.5 9.8 9.4 9.1 9.0 9.0 9.6 9.7 9.3 9.3 9.7 9.1 9.5 9.4 9.3 9.3 10.2 10.4 10.3 10.1 10.1 10.2 10.2 10.1 10.3 10.1 9.9 10.2 10.2 10.9 10.1 9.8 10.6 10.6 9.9 9.7 9.7 10.0 9.8 9.5 11.0 10.3 10.2 11.0 11.0 30.1' 25.0' 40.2' 29.7' 6.05' 9.0' 6.05' 37.9' 32.5' 8.5' 16.1' 47.4' 7.0' 1.85' 6.1' 1.85' 24.0' 1.0' 11.5' 2.4' 8.8' 12.2' 19.2' 12.2' 5.1' 2.4' 5.3' 30.3' 3.0' 3.0' 3.2' 3.2' 8"/8"/6" HOLLY 9" CEDAR 11"/10" UNKNOW N TREE 12"/9"/8"/7" UNKNOW N TREE 14" PALM 13" PALM 12" PALM 11" PALM 10" PALM 9" PALM 8" PALM 11" PALM 16" PALM 14"/10" MAGNOLIA 32" LIVE OAK 9"/7"/6" OAK 16" PALM 13" PALM 10" PALM 11" PALM 10" PALM PENDLETON STREET 50' R / W 2 STORY BRICK & W OOD SIDI NG HO USE LOW EST FLOOR F.F.E.=10.0' 2nd FLOOR F.F.E.=18.2' COVERED PORCH STEPS A/C ADJACENT GARAGE ADJACENT GARAGE STEPS A/C A/C STEPS OPEN WOOD DECK OPEN W OOD DECK POOL PUM P POOL HEATER POOL CABANA (F.F.E.=11.2') GRAVEL AREA GRAVEL AREA W ATER M ETER SEW ER M ANH OLE 4' B RIC K W ALL W / C OLU M N S 4' B RIC K W ALL W / C OLU M N S EDGE O F PAVEM EN T 6" C ON C RETE C URB 6' WOOD FENCE 6' WOOD FENCE 6' WOOD FENCE 6' WOOD FENCE 5' C.M.U. WALL GRATE INLET 5/8" REB AR FOUND N AIL FOU ND IN TREE B ASE M AG N AIL FOUND IN C OLU M N PROPERTY C ORNER FALLS IN W ALL N AIL FOU ND IN W ALL 6' WOOD FENCE 6' WOOD FENCE 6' W O OD FEN C E 6' W O OD FEN C E 6' W O OD FEN C E 6' W OO D FENC E 6' WOOD FENCE 6' WOOD FENCE 5/8" REB AR FOUND S 11°57'51" W 45.10' N 77°32'27" W 120.00' N 12°28'48" E 109.12' S 77°57'53" E 119.01' LOTS 247, 248 & 249 - BLOCK Q RIVERSIDE PARK SUBDIVISION 30 PENDLETON STREET W ILLIAM M ICHAEL & ANNA LASSITER GRUENLOH TM S No. 463-07-02-068 13 ,093 13 ,093 13 ,093 13 ,093 Sq.Ft. Sq.Ft. Sq.Ft. Sq.Ft. 0. 30 1 0. 30 1 0. 30 1 0. 30 1 Ac. Ac. Ac. Ac. LOT 260 & PART OF LOT 261 - BLOCK Q RIVERSIDE PARK SUBDIVISION 189 SAN SOUCI STR EET DAVID L. & LO UISE C. GASTON TMS No. 463-07-02-062 RIVERSIDE PARK SUBDIVISION SARAH LOUISE STEVENSON PHILLI PS TMS No. 463-07-02-061 LOT 262 & PART OF LOT 261 - BLOCK Q RIVERSIDE PARK SUBDIVISION 183 SAN SOUCI STR EET FREDERICK A. SM ALLS TMS No. 463-07-02-063 25' FRONT SETBACK N 11°57'51" E 9.90' (TIE) 25' REAR SETBACK 25' FRONT SETBACK 6' WOOD FENCE 6' W O OD FEN C E POOL TILE AREA TILE AREA TILE AREA 6' WOOD FENCE GATE STONE PAVERS STONE PAVERS STONE PAVER DRIVE GATE C ON C RETE 9' SIDE SETBACK 9' SIDE SETBACK 25' REAR SETBACK S 11°57'51" W 64.90' BENCHM ARK: M AG NA IL SET IN PAVEM ENT ELEV ATION = 9.66' (NAVD 1988) BENCHM ARK: M AG NA IL SET IN PAVEM ENT ELEV ATION = 9.40' (NAVD 1988) X 11 11 11 11 11 11 10 10 10 10 11 11 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 W 110' TO THE RIGHT-OF-W AY OF CLEMSON STREET S P S/B 3'-0" S/B 3'-0" 8.2' 8.1' 6.1' 6.2' 10.1' HVAC N 79.9' PROPOSED ADU Scale Project # Date Sheet Name Sheet Project Name & Address Designed By: Crosby Creations Drafting & Design Services, LLC Jodi Crosby 843.514.7354 4770 Hwy 165 Suite D Meggett, SC 29449 www.crosby-creations.com jcrosby@crosby-creations.com Designed Exclusively for: REFER TO GRAPHIC SCALE Copyright: Crosby Creations Drafting & Design Services LLC REVISION DATE: 9/11/2026 1:35:00 PM 4.10 Site CC2653 Gruenloh 7/8/26 30 Pendleton St Charleston, SC Gruenloh 0 40 60 80 20 GRAPHIC SCALE 1" = 20'-0" 1 Site WHEN PRINTED ON 11x17 ZONING INFORMATION: TMS: 463 -07 -02 -068 ZONED: SR2 ACCESORY SETBACKS: REAR 3' SIDES 3' COVERAGE: 50% MAX LOT COVERAGE CALCS: LOT SIZE: EXISTING HOUSE: EXISTING CABANA: PROPOSED ADU: TOTAL: 13,093 SF 2,645 SF 247 SF 600 SF 27% EXISTING EXISTING EXISTING CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 134 Smith St. VARIANCE CASE SUMMARY November 3, 2026 | 5:15pm Case Number: BZA2026-002492 Subject Property: 134 Smith St. / TMS# 460-16-01-098 Zoning District: DR-1 Property Owners: Cornelius Thomas Applicant: Julie O’Connor – American Vernacular Inc. Requested Action: Request Variance from Sec. 54-301 to exceed the maximum lot occupancy to build a detached carport (35% allowed, 38.7% proposed). Project Description: The applicant is requesting a variance from Sec. 54-301 to construct a detached carport which will increase the lot occupancy percentage over the 35% maximum allowed. The proposed carport is comprised of an open air design with six pillars supporting the roof with enough space to accommodate the two required off-street parking spaces. The proposed carport is located entirely behind the home and will not be visible from the public right of way. Case History: On July 18th 2023 the BZA-Z approved a variance request from Sec. 54-301 to allow the construction of a second single-family home on this parcel with a lot occupancy of 47%. Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-301 Height, area and setback regulations The setbacks for the DR-1 Zoning District are as follows: Front: Not required Rear: 3’ South/West: 9’ North/East: 3’ Total Side Setbacks: 15’ Maximum Lot Coverage: 35% Variance Test/ Findings of Fact: The following is excerpted from Section 54-924 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. This test is based on S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-800. A variance may be granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: Applicant Responses: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 134 Smith St. Page 2 See Narrative 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; See Narrative 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and See Narrative 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. See Narrative Narrative: We are requesting a variance for building coverage on this lot. Property is zoned DR-1 with 35% building coverage allowed. We recently returned the historic house to single family and previously received a zoning variance in 2023 for a new dwelling unit on the back of the property. The owners' situation has changed and they would now like to prioritize the open space for a garden and pool and would instead like to add a carport to provide cover for their cars. We are requesting a variance for a total of 38.7% which is significantly less than the 46.9% coverage we were granted in 2023. We meet all setbacks and height restrictions. We have attached a lot coverage graphic. We calculated 41 properties in the vicinity and 70% of them have a coverage ratio higher than 35%. In addition, one of our immediate neighbors is an apartment complex and a close neighbor is Ashley Hall School. This neighborhood has a variety of uses and the addition of the building coverage will not be a detriment, particularly because the single family use will be maintained. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6- 29-800) Staff Recommendation: Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: Staff are recommending approval of the variance request in accordance with the boards previous approval allowing the increase in lot occupancy. Attachments: • Zoning Map • Site Map • Application Staff Contact: Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov BZA-Z Application (continued) Page 2 of 2 For Variance requests, applicants should list the specific variance(s) being requested and, if possible, explain how the variance test that follows is met (add as an attachment if necessary): _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Variance Test: The Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning is authorized to approve a variance from the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6-29-800) For Special Exception requests, applicants should list the specific approval(s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as § 54-110, § 54-206, or sections in Article 5 (add as an attachment if necessary): _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________________ All approvals of the Board shall remain valid for two (2) years from the approval date, unless extended in accordance with the provisions of Article 9, Part 5 of the zoning ordinance. Applicants may not apply for the same request that has been denied by the Board until a period of six (6) months has lapsed. Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability 2 George Street Charleston, South Carolina 29401 (843) 724-3781 www.charleston-sc.gov/zoning 6/22 We are requesting a variance for building coverage on this lot. Property is zoned DR-1 with 35% building coverage allowed. We recently retured the historic house to single family and previously received a zoning variance in 2023 for a new dwelling unit on the back of the property. The owners' situation has changed and they would now like to prioritize the open space for a garden and pool and would instead like to add a carport to provide cover for their cars. We are requesting a variance for a total of 38.7% which is significantly less than the 46.9% coverage we were granted in 2023. We meet all setbacks and height restrictions. We have attached a lot coverage graphic. We calculated 41 properties in the vicinity and 70% of them have a coverage ratio higher than 35%. In addition, one of our immediate neighbors is an apartment complex and a close neighbor is Ashley Hall School. This neighborhood has a variety of uses and the addition of the building coverage will not be a detriment, particularly because the single family use will be maintained. 0.61' 0.61' 5/8"REBAR &CAP RESET 5/8"REBAR &CAP RESET 5/8" REBARFOUND TRIANGLESCRIBE INCONCRETE 5/8" REBARFOUND ±65' TO WARREN ST. 5/8"REBAR &CAP RESET 5/8"REBAR &CAP RESET 5/8" REBARFOUND TRIANGLESCRIBE INCONCRETE 5/8" REBARFOUND ±65' TO WARREN ST. LOT 2 No. 87 1/2 WARREN ST. TMS 460-16-01-100 WILLIAM TAYLOR & SUSAN H. WILSON No. 132 SMITH ST. TMS 460-16-01-097 FAIRFIELD 132 SMITH ST. LLC LOT 2 No. 87 1/2 WARREN ST.TMS 460-16-01-100WILLIAM TAYLOR & SUSAN H.WILSON LOT 1 / No. 89 WARREN ST. TMS 460-16-01-099 89 WARREN LLC LOT 2 No. 87 1/2 WARREN ST. TMS 460-16-01-100 WILLIAM TAYLOR & SUSAN H. WILSON No. 132 SMITH ST. TMS 460-16-01-097 FAIRFIELD 132 SMITH ST. LLC LOT 2 No. 87 1/2 WARREN ST.TMS 460-16-01-100WILLIAM TAYLOR & SUSAN H.WILSON LOT 1 / No. 89 WARREN ST. TMS 460-16-01-099 89 WARREN LLC 13.63' S14°57'53"E 13.63' S14°57'53"E 42.19' S 17°47'48" E N 74°15'39" E 165.87' S 74°07'38" W 161.17' 42.99'S 24°03'00" E 9’ SIDE SETBACK 3’ SIDE SETBACK 3’ REAR SETBACK 42.19' S 17°47'48" E N 74°15'39" E 165.87' S 74°07'38" W 161.17' 42.99'S 24°03'00" E 9’ SIDE SETBACK 3’ SIDE SETBACK 3’ REAR SETBACK 6,925 Sq.Ft.No. 134 6,925 Sq.Ft.No. 134 5.4 5.2 5.3 5.7 5.8 5.5 5.7 5.85.9 5.4 5.2 5.3 5.7 5.8 5.5 5.7 5.85.9 SMITH STREET (R/W VARIES) SMITH STREET (R/W VARIES) DRAWINGS AND THE DESIGN ARE THEPROPERTY OF THE DESIGNER WHETHERTHE PROJECT FOR WHICH THEY AREPREPARED IS EXECUTED OR NOT.THE DRAWINGS SHALL NOT BE USEDBY THE PROJECT OWNER OR ANYONEELSE FOR ANY OTHER PROJECT.THESE DRAWINGS CANNOT BE CHANGED ORREPRODUCED WITHOUT WRITTENCONSENT OF THE DESIGNER. 134 Smith Street Charleston, South Carolina T002 SITE PLAN SITE PLAN SCALE: 1" = 10' - 0" PROPOSED BUILDING COVERAGE - DR-1 SETBACKS: SIDES 15' TOTAL S/W - 9' N/E - 3' FRONT - 0' REAR - 3' FLOOD ZONE: AE-11 LOT SIZE: 6925 SF BUILDING COVERAGE: HOUSE/PORCHES/ STAIRS: 2100 SF HVAC 25 SF CARPORT 556 SF TOTAL: 2681 SF BUILDING COVERAGE RATIO: 38.7% RATIO ALLOWED: 35% (2423 SF) 8/26/26 DATEISSUES/REVISIONSSCHEMATICS DATE: August 26, 2026 Thomas Carport EXISTING BUILDING COVERAGE - DR-1 SETBACKS: SIDES 15' TOTAL S/W - 9' N/E - 3' FRONT - 0' REAR - 3' FLOOD ZONE: AE-11 LOT SIZE: 6925 SF BUILDING COVERAGE: HOUSE/PORCHES/ STAIRS: 2100 SF HVAC 25 SF TOTAL: 2125 SF BUILDING COVERAGE RATIO: 30.7% RATIO ALLOWED: 35% (2423 SF) DARCHITECTERETSIGERUOSFOETATSTHCAROLINARACHELBEVERLEYBURTONSummerville, SCNo. 8440 151 Sheppard St.CharlestonSouth Carolina29403843-856-4818www.americanvernacular.com A M E R I C A N VERNACULAR ® 20.5' CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 148 ½ Cannon St. VARIANCE CASE SUMMARY November 3, 2026 | 5:15pm Case Number: BZA2026-002493 Subject Property: 148 ½ Cannon St. / TMS# 460-11-04-134 Zoning District: GB Property Owner: Wanda & Eric Poinsette Applicant: John Grosso Requested Action: Request Variance from Sec. 54-317 to provide no off-street parking spaces for a proposed coffee shop (2 required). Project Description: The applicant is requesting a variance from the off-street parking requirements to allow the establishment of a proposed coffee shop. The property is comprised of an attached 300sf commercial unit on its own individual parcel where the building footprint occupies the entire lot area. The property was previously used as a hair salon. Public parking is available within the area both on the street and through public parking garages with the closest being located directly across the street. Case History: Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-317 Required number of off-street parking spaces by land use USE Number of Spaces Required Business, Entertainment and Office - Eating and drinking places; sit down establishments serving food and beverage (on the peninsula) 1 per 100 square feet of inside patron use area (excluding bathrooms) except that for a lot with this use that is more than 150 away from any lot with a residential zoning designation, measured closest point of the lot to closest point of the lot, the number of spaces required for inside patron use area Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 148 ½ Cannon St. Page 2 shall be 1 per 150 square feet (excluding bathrooms), and 1 per 130 square feet of outside patron use area Variance Test/ Findings of Fact: The following is excerpted from Section 54-924 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. This test is based on S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-800. A variance may be granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: Applicant Responses: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; See Narrative 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; See Narrative 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and See Narrative 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. Applicants’ Narrative: See Narrative In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6-29-800) Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 148 ½ Cannon St. Page 3 Staff Recommendation : Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: Staff recommend approval of the variance request due to the footprint of the building occupying the entire lot area creating an extraordinary and exception condition unique to this particular piece of property that restricts its utilization as a commercial use due to the lack of any available space to be used for off-street parking. Attachments: • Zoning Map • Site Map • Application Staff Contact: Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 157 Tradd St. VARIANCE CASE SUMMARY November 3, 2026 | 5:15pm Case Number: BZA2026-002495 Subject Property: 157 Tradd St./ TMS# 457-11-04-134 Zoning District: DR-1 Property Owners: Michael Furlong Applicant: Hadden Powell Requested Action: Request Variance from Sec. 54-301 to build a raised pool with a 4’ south side setback (9’ required). Project Description: The applicant is requesting a variance to build an above-ground pool with a 4’ south side setback. The maximum height of the proposed pool will be 16’’ from grade. The applicant has stated the pool is being constructed as an above-ground pool due to the significant flooding that occurs on this parcel. Unlike in-ground pools which are allowed to encroach within the required setback per Sec. 217.a. above-ground pools must meet the side setback requirements of the base zoning district per Sec. 217.b. Case History: Applicable Sections of Zoning Ordinance: Sec. 54-217. - Pools. In all base zoning districts, a pool may be approved by the Zoning Administrator as an accessory use to a permitted principal use, if the Zoning Administrator finds the following conditions have been met: a. In-ground pools. Pools not elevated above existing grade may be located within building setbacks, critical line buffer setbacks and visual buffer zone setbacks but shall not be located within landscape buffers, critical line buffers or a visual buffer zone. Wall elements on in-ground pools, such as waterfalls, may be located within building setbacks. For in-ground pools with pool sections that are elevated above existing grade, such as spas, the elevated sections shall not encroach into required side setbacks and shall meet rear setback requirements of the base zoning district or 10', whichever is less. b. Above-ground pools. Pools elevated above existing grade shall not encroach into required side setbacks and shall meet rear setback requirements of the base zoning district or 10', whichever is less. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 157 Tradd St. Page 2 Variance Test/ Findings of Fact: The following is excerpted from Section 54-924 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. This test is based on S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-800. A variance may be granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: Applicant Responses: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; The property is located within FEMA Flood Zone AE, with a mapped base flood elevation of 11 feet. In addition to this mapped designation, significant flooding has been observed at the property and surrounding street during storm events. I have personally observed flooding at this location. Supporting photographs document conditions following a summer thunderstorm in June 2026, including flooding affecting the existing residence and driveway at 157 Tradd Street and nearby portions of Tradd Street. These conditions present a practical concern for a pool constructed at existing garden grade, where floodwater could enter the pool and introduce sediment, debris, and contaminants. The proposed modest elevation is intended to reduce this exposure, although it would not eliminate flood risk. The flooding conditions, considered together with the existing residence, property boundaries, and enclosed rear garden, form the physical basis for this request. 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; We recognize that flooding also occurs elsewhere in this portion of Charleston. This request is based on the particular combination of flooding exposure and the existing physical configuration of 157 Tradd Street, rather than neighborhood flooding alone. The submitted site plan documents the relationship among the existing residence, masonry garden enclosure, property boundaries, and proposed pool location. We respectfully ask the Board to consider how these conditions operate together on this parcel to constrain placement of a modest elevated pool. The relief requested is specific to the proposed location and dimensions shown on the submitted plans and should be evaluated in relation to these existing property conditions. 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and Based on the guidance provided by zoning staff, the applicable provisions allow an at-grade pool to encroach into the side setback, while an elevated pool must meet the required setbacks. At this property, constructing the pool at grade would increase its exposure to the flooding conditions that prompted the proposed elevation. Strict application of the 9-foot southwest setback would reduce the area available for the proposed pool within the existing rear garden. We respectfully submit that the interaction between the flooding conditions, existing Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 157 Tradd St. Page 3 garden configuration, and elevated-pool setback requirement unreasonably restricts the practical placement of this residential garden improvement. The requested reduction to 4 feet would allow the pool to be elevated modestly while retaining space for planting between the pool and the southwest property line. The request seeks limited relief to address the existing site conditions. 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. The proposed pool would remain within the existing rear garden, where masonry walls provide substantial visual screening from neighboring properties. The submitted photographs illustrate this existing enclosure. A 4-foot separation would remain between the outermost edge of the pool coping and the southwest property line. This area would accommodate planting and provide an additional landscaped buffer between the pool and the existing masonry wall. The pool's modest footprint and limited elevation would maintain its subordinate relationship to the residence and enclosed garden. The proposal would retain the property's residential use and garden character. Pool equipment, drainage, discharge, and safety measures will be addressed through the applicable review and permitting processes. The design will be coordinated to avoid directing additional runoff or pool discharge onto adjacent properties. Approval of this setback variance would not replace any required floodplain, building, or other applicable approvals. For these reasons, we respectfully submit that the requested relief would not cause substantial detriment to adjacent properties or the public good and would preserve the residential character of the district. Staff Recommendation: Recommends Approval Staff Analysis: Staff are recommending approval of the variance request due to the strict application of the ordinance creating an unreasonable restriction on the utilization of the property. Per the ordinance the pool could be constructed in its proposed location if it were an in-ground pool, however the flooding in the area would render the pool unusable. Additionally the parcels adjacent to the south and rear of 157 Tradd St. have stated the construction of the above-ground pool would not be a detriment to their property nor would the character of the district be harmed. Attachments: • Zoning Map • Site Map • Application Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Staff Report | November 3, 2026 | 157 Tradd St. Page 4 Staff Contact: Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner, swalhahc@charleston-sc.gov BZA-Z Application (continued) Page 2 of 2 For Variance requests, applicants should list the specific variance(s) being requested and, if possible, explain how the variance test that follows is met (add as an attachment if necessary): Variance Test: The Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning is authorized to approve a variance from the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. (SC Code of Laws § 6-29-800) For Special Exception requests, applic ants should list the specific approval(s) being requested and include documentation to demonstrate compliance with the relevant special exception requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, such as § 54-110, § 54-206, or sections in Article 5 (add as an attachment if necessary): All approvals of the Board shall remain valid for two (2) years from the approval date, unless extended in accordance with the provisions of Article 9, Part 5 of the zoning ordinance. Applicants may not apply for the same request that has been denied by the Board until a period of six (6) months has lapsed. 11/23 Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability 2 George Street Charleston, South Carolina 29401 (843) 724-3781 www.charleston-sc.gov/zoning N/A Please see attached file TRADD STREET EXISTING MULTI STORYRESIDENCE EXISTING MULTI STORYRESIDENCE EXISTING MULTI STORYRESIDENCE EX. PALMHVAC EX. CRAPE M. GARBAGE ENC. 0LA-4 BRICK DRIVEWAY WITH STRETCHER BORDERAND HERRINGBONE INLAID PATTERN 0LA-4 BRICK COLUMNS WITH GAS LANTERNS ONFRONT FACADE0LA-4 ARTIFICIAL TURF STRIP CENTERED INDRIVEWAY WITH BRICK STRETCHER BORDER 0LA-4 'HAMPTON' PEBBLE WALKWAY WITH STEELEDGING BORDER 0LA-4 WOOD TRASH ENCLOSURE WITH PEDESTRIANGATE, NOTE: POOL GATE TO MEET POOL CODE 0LA-4 BRICK LANDING WITH STRETCHER BORDERAND HERRINGBONE INLAID PATTERN RAISED POOL, MORE INFORMATION ANDDETAILS ON SHEETS LA-9 AND LA-10 0LA-4BLUESTONE POOL TERRACE, RUNNING BONDPATTERN 0LA-4'HAMPTON' PEBBLE LANDING WITH STEELEDGING BORDER 0LA-4'HAMPTON' PEBBLE WALKWAY WITH BRICKSTRETCHER BORDER AND BRICK STRETCHERINLAID PATTERN 0LA-4RAISED BRICK POND, CENTRAL WATERFEATURE AND DETAILS TBD. NOTE: PLUMBINGAND ELECTRICAL SHALL BE PROVIDED BYCONTRACTOR 0LA-4'HAMPTON' PEBBLE LANDING WITH STEELEDGING BORDER 0LA-4 'HAMPTON' PEBBLE WALKWAY WITH BRICK STRETCHERBORDER AND BRICK STRETCHER INLAID PATTERN 0LA-4 'HAMPTON' PEBBLE WALKWAY WITH BRICKHEADER BORDER 0LA-4BRICK SOLDIER COURSE BORDER 9' SIDE SETBACK 3' REAR SETBACK 3' SIDE SETBACKPOOLEQUP. DRAWN BY: REVISIONS: THE FURLONG-LARSEN RESIDENCE157 TRADD STREETCHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA 29401 05/18/26 HP SCALE: 3/4" = 1' - 0"08'16'24'SHEET: 07/20/26 HP08/08/26 HP 09/06/26 HP LAYOUT PLAN LA-2 LEGEND:BRICK PAVING:STONE PAVING:PEBBLE WALKWAY: GENERAL NOTES FOR ALL WORK:1. ALL WORK SHALL BE DONE IN ACCORDANCE WITH ALL NATIONAL, STATE,AND LOCAL CODES. CONTRACTORS SHALL ACQUIRE AND PAY FOR ALLPERMITS, LICENSES, TAXES, AND FEES REQUIRED. ALL CONTRACTORS SHALLINCLUDE ALL LABOR, MATERIALS, EQUIPMENT, TRANSPORTATION, SERVICES,TOOLS, AND MISCELLANEOUS ITEMS REQUIRED FOR A FULLY COMPLETEPROJECT.2. ALL MATERIALS, WORKMANSHIP, AND EQUIPMENT SHALL BE GUARANTEEDBY CONTRACTORS FOR A MINIMUM OF ONE YEAR FROM THE DATE OF FINALCOMPLETION AND ACCEPTANCE BY THE OWNER.3. CONTRACTORS SHALL VERIFY ALL DIMENSIONS IN THE FIELD PRIOR TOBEGINNING CONSTRUCTION, FABRICATION OR THE ORDERING OF ANYITEMS TO BE USED ON SITE. CONTRACTORS SHALL NOTIFY THE LANDSCAPEARCHITECT OF ANY DISCREPANCIES AT HIS EARLIEST OPPORTUNITY. 4. CONTRACTORS SHALL COORDINATE ALL WORK WITH THE OTHERCONTRACTORS WORKING ON THE SITE.5. ANY DISCREPANCIES BETWEEN DRAWINGS, SHOP DRAWINGS, PRODUCTSAMPLES, AND ACTUAL CONDITIONS SHALL BE REPORTED TO THELANDSCAPE ARCHITECT IMMEDIATELY. CONTRACTORS ARE RESPONSIBLEFOR THE INSPECTION AND SUPERVISION OF ALL THEIR WORKMEN ANDWORK.6. NOTIFY THE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT TO CHECK THE GRADES ANDALIGNMENT OF ALL NEW WALLS AND PAVING PRIOR TO THE BEGINNING OFCONSTRUCTION. EXISTING MULTI STORY HARDSCAPE BEYOND POOL COPING BY LANDSCAPECONTRACTOR; EXCLUDED FROM POOL CONTRACTOR SCOPE.POOL ENTRY STEP: 4'-0" L X 11" W X 8" H. PLASTER FINISH TOMATCH PROPOSED POOL INTERIOR.SWIM-OUT BENCH: RUN FULL LENGTH OF POOL, INTERIOR WALL TO INTERIORWALL, APPROX. 12'-9" L X 18" D. SET 18"-22" BELOW WATERLINE. PLASTER FINISHTO MATCH POOL INTERIOR. POOL FLOOR TILE INLAY:OVERALL TILE INLAY, INCLUDING BORDER, TO BE APPROX. 9'-9" L X 5'-8" W. PROVIDE8" WIDE BORDER USING 8" X 24" BLACK TILE. BORDER TO BEGIN 18" FROM INTERIORPOOL WALLS, EXCEPT AT SWIM-OUT BENCH, WHERE BORDER SHALL BEGINDIRECTLY AT FACE OF BENCH. INTERIOR FIELD TO CONSIST OF 8" X 8" BLACK ANDWHITE TILE IN ALTERNATING CHECKERED PATTERN. EXACT TILE PRODUCT ANDCOLOR SELECTION TBD.POOL PLINTH:PROVIDE RAISED PLINTH AT FOOT OF POOL, WITH FINISHED TOP ELEVATION TOALIGN WITH TOP OF POOL COPING. PLINTH TO HAVE STUCCO-FINISHED WALLS TOMATCH POOL WITH 2" THICK BLUESTONE CAP. INTEGRATE POOL SKIMMER WITHINPLINTH. PROVIDE 12" X 12" BLUESTONE SKIMMER ACCESS LID WITH (8) 3/4" DIA.DRILLED HOLES. OWNER-PROVIDED STATUE TO BE CENTERED ON PLINTH BEHINDSKIMMER ACCESS. PROVIDE (2) 4IN. DRAINS AT POOL FLOOR. DRAIN COLOR/FINISH TO CLOSELYMATCH PROPOSED POOL PLASTER FOR MINIMAL VISUAL CONTRAST. MINIMALSLOPE ON POOL FLOOR TOWARDS RECESSED DRAINS. PROVIDE (6) BRASS DECK JETS, EMBEDDED FLUSH WITH BLUESTONE COPING ANDEVENLY SPACED ALONG LONG SIDES OF POOL. COORDINATE FINAL LOCATIONSWITH COPING JOINTS AND POOL CONSTRUCTION. A'LA-10 ALA-10 BLA-10B'LA-10SWIM-OUT BENCH: RUN FULL LENGTH OF POOL, INTERIOR WALL TO INTERIORWALL, APPROX. 12'-9" L X 18" D. SET 18"-22" BELOW WATERLINE. PLASTER FINISHTO MATCH POOL INTERIOR. 9' SIDE SETBACK 3' REAR SETBACK DRAWN BY: REVISIONS: THE FURLONG-LARSEN RESIDENCE157 TRADD STREETCHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA 29401 05/18/26 HP SHEET: 07/20/26 HP08/08/26 HP 09/06/26 HP POOL LAYOUT LA-9 POOL SUMMARY & GENERAL NOTES:1. POOL HEIGHT: RAISED PLUNGE POOL TO EXTEND 16" ABOVE ADJACENT FINISHED LANDSCAPE GRADE, MEASURED TOTOP OF COPING.2. POOL COPING: PROVIDE 2" THICK BLUESTONE COPING WITH 2" OVERHANG BEYOND BOTH INTERIOR AND EXTERIORFACES OF POOL WALL. SLOPE COPING AS REQUIRED TO DRAIN AWAY FROM POOL WHILE MAINTAINING SPECIFIEDFINISHED ELEVATIONS.3. COPING JOINTS: COORDINATE BLUESTONE COPING JOINT LAYOUT TO PROVIDE CONSISTENT JOINT WIDTHS ANDSYMMETRICAL CONDITIONS AT CORNERS, STEPS, FIXTURES, AND OTHER INTERRUPTIONS.4. EXTERIOR POOL WALL: EXPOSED EXTERIOR FACE OF RAISED POOL WALL TO RECEIVE IVORY BUFF STUCCO FINISH.5. MATERIAL SAMPLES: PROVIDE REPRESENTATIVE BLUESTONE SAMPLE AND IVORY BUFF STUCCO COLOR/TEXTURE SAMPLEFOR OWNER/LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT APPROVAL PRIOR TO FABRICATION OR INSTALLATION.6. POOL INTERIOR FINISH: FINAL POOL INTERIOR PLASTER FINISH AND COLOR TO BE SELECTED AND APPROVED PRIOR TOINSTALLATION.7. GRADE + ELEVATION COORDINATION: COORDINATE POOL WALL CONSTRUCTION, COPING ELEVATIONS, AND ADJACENTFINISHED LANDSCAPE GRADES TO MAINTAIN A CONSISTENT 16" FINISHED HEIGHT AROUND POOL.8. FINISHED DIMENSIONS: ALL DIMENSIONS AND ELEVATIONS SHOWN ARE TO FINISHED SURFACES UNLESS OTHERWISENOTED.9. FIELD VERIFICATION: CONTRACTOR TO VERIFY ALL POOL DIMENSIONS, ELEVATIONS, AND EXISTING FIELD CONDITIONSPRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION. NOTIFY LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT OF ANY DISCREPANCIES PRIOR TO PROCEEDING. 10. POOL COMPONENTS: COORDINATE ALL DRAINS, RETURNS, LIGHTS, JETS, SKIMMERS, PLUMBING, AND OTHER POOLCOMPONENTS WITH THE POOL DESIGN AND ADJACENT LANDSCAPE/HARDSCAPE.11. VISIBLE COMPONENTS: LOCATE ALL VISIBLE POOL FITTINGS, DRAINS, RETURNS, JETS, SKIMMERS, ACCESS PANELS, ANDOTHER COMPONENTS AS SHOWN. WHERE NOT SPECIFICALLY LOCATED, COORDINATE LOCATION WITH LANDSCAPEARCHITECT PRIOR TO INSTALLATION.12. POOL EQUIPMENT: COORDINATE POOL EQUIPMENT LOCATION, PLUMBING ROUTES, ELECTRICAL SERVICE, ANDREQUIRED ACCESS WITH ADJACENT SITE IMPROVEMENTS. EQUIPMENT SHALL NOT CONFLICT WITH PROPOSED LANDSCAPE,HARDSCAPE, OR ARCHITECTURAL ELEMENTS.13. STRUCTURAL + TECHNICAL DESIGN: POOL STRUCTURAL DESIGN, REINFORCEMENT, WATERPROOFING, HYDRAULICS,PLUMBING, ELECTRICAL, AND EQUIPMENT SIZING TO BE PROVIDED AND COORDINATED BY POOL CONTRACTOR ANDAPPROPRIATE LICENSED DESIGN PROFESSIONALS.14. CODES + PERMITS: POOL CONTRACTOR RESPONSIBLE FOR CONSTRUCTION IN ACCORDANCE WITH APPLICABLE CODES,PERMIT REQUIREMENTS, MANUFACTURER REQUIREMENTS, AND APPLICABLE INDUSTRY STANDARDS.15. SHOP DRAWINGS: CONTRACTOR TO PROVIDE SHOP DRAWINGS AND/OR FINAL EQUIPMENT AND COMPONENT LAYOUTSFOR REVIEW PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION WHERE REQUIRED.16, DESIGN INTENT: DO NOT MODIFY DIMENSIONS, ELEVATIONS, MATERIALS, FINISHES, PATTERNS, OR LOCATIONS OFVISIBLE COMPONENTS WITHOUT PRIOR APPROVAL OF LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT.17. DRAWING COORDINATION: REFER TO POOL PLAN, SECTIONS, ELEVATIONS, DETAILS, AND SPECIFICATIONS FORADDITIONAL DIMENSIONS, MATERIALS, FINISHES, AND CONSTRUCTION REQUIREMENTS. CONTRACTOR TO NOTIFYLANDSCAPE ARCHITECT OF CONFLICTS OR DISCREPANCIES PRIOR TO PROCEEDING WITH AFFECTED WORK. SCALE:3/4" = 1'-0"

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.