RecordWell Data

BZA-SD Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Apr 1, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – SITE DESIGN PUBLIC COMMENT APRIL 1, 2026 A meeting of the B ZA-SD will be held on Wednesday, April 1, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bza-sd. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 The following applications will be considered: A. Review of Minutes and Deferred Applications from Previously Advertised BZA-SD Agendas 2. Murraywood Rd. Johns Island | Council District 3 | TMS# 312-00-00-071, 657 & 330 | Zoned: DR-6/SR-1 Request variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 6 grand trees. Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 3 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 10 grand trees. Owner: Southeastern Recapitalization Group, LLC Applicant: Earthsource Engineering 7 Comments Submitted: • Shirley Stowe, 2910 Sweetleaf Lane, Johns Island, SC 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 28, 2026 2:02 PM As a resident of Whitney Lakes, I am opposed to the Variances requested regarding the 53% encroachment of the grand trees. Paving over the roots of these trees will ultimately kill them. 19 grand trees may be impacted if this variance is allowed, most are healthy Grade A and B assets that currently handle our island’s drainage and heat. The developer’s choice of density (100 units) over tree preservation clearly is an example of lack of environmental consideration for the project. Choosing slightly fewer units would save these trees. I respectfully request opposition to the variances requested and hope we can save these trees that are so critical to our infrastructure. • Sam Pagano, Johns Island Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 29, 2026 7:07 AM It’s sort of BS the city denied my request for removal of a tree with roots growing into my slab foundation “because there’s no damage YET” but you’ll tear down a bunch in Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | April 1, 2026 Page 2 the forest to build new homes. Have a spine and hold developers accountable to the same rules you enforce upon individuals. It’s getting embarrassing. • Jessica Snyder, 2860 Sweetleaf Lane, Johns Island, SC 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 29, 2026 12:45 PM I am a resident of the Whitney Lakes community and I respectfully submit this comment in opposition to the requested variances and special exceptions associated with Agenda Item B3- Murraywood Rd-Johns Island. This request must be evaluated under both Section 54-924 (variance criteria) and Sections 54-327 and 54-329 (tree protection and removal standards). Based on the materials provided, the application does not meet these required standards. 1. The Applicant Has Not Demonstrated a Qualifying Hardship (Sec. 54-924) Under Section 54-924, a variance may only be granted where an extraordinary and unique condition of the property creates an unnecessary hardship. The presence of grand trees is not an extraordinary condition, it is a defining and expected characteristic of Johns Island. The hardship described by the applicant arises from the proposed site layout and density, not from the land itself. As such: The hardship is self-created, and It does not justify the granting of a variance under the ordinance. 2. Reasonable Use of the Property Is Not Denied (Section 54- 924) This requires a showing that strict application of the ordinance would unreasonably restrict or prohibit use of the property. That standard is not met here. The parcel can clearly be developed for residential use consistent with its zoning. The inability to achieve a 100-unit layout does not constitute a denial of reasonable use. A redesigned plan such as reduced density or modified building placement would allow development while complying with tree protection requirements. 3. The Requested Relief Is Not the Minimum Necessary (Sec. 54-924) The ordinance requires that any variance granted be the minimum necessary. However, the application proposes: A. Removal of multiple grand trees, including healthy specimens B. Significant encroachments into the required protection areas of others. Under Section 54- 330(b)(2), encroachment into the protected area of grand trees is only appropriate where it will not adversely affect the tree or where impacts can be effectively mitigated. Encroachments approaching or exceeding 30–50% of the critical root zone raise serious concerns that these trees cannot be preserved in a meaningful or sustainable way. Such impacts are inconsistent with the intent of the ordinance and suggest the design has not been minimized to the least intrusive alternative. 4. Failure to Meet Standards for Grand Tree Removal (Sec. 54-329) Under Section 54-329(b): Removal of grand trees requires a variance or special exception, and The Board must find that no reasonable or economically feasible alternative exists. Additionally, for certain trees, removal must be justified by\either: A. Poor health, B. Conflict with essential infrastructure, or C. Lack of viable alternatives. The materials provided do not demonstrate that alternative site designs such as reduced unit count, reconfigured roadways, or adjusted building footprints have been fully exhausted. Removal of healthy grand trees to accommodate a preferred layout or density does not meet the standard of “no reasonable alternative.” 5. The Proposal Conflicts with the Intent of the Tree Protection Ordinance (Sec. 54-325) Section 54-325 clearly establishes that the purpose of the ordinance is to protect trees by regulating their removal and damage. This proposal involves: A. Removal of multiple grand trees, and B. Significant disturbance to others through encroachment. While mitigation plantings are required under Section 54-331, they do not replace the environmental, structural, and aesthetic value of mature grand trees, particularly in the near or medium term. Approving this level of impact would undermine the stated intent of the ordinance. 6. Substantial Detriment to Public Good and District Character (Sec. 54-924) The removal and degradation of a significant number of grand trees will: A. Reduce canopy coverage, B. Impact stormwater absorption and drainage, C. Alter the established character of Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | April 1, 2026 Page 3 the SR-1/DR-6 district. These impacts constitute a substantial detriment to the public good, which the Board must consider under Section 54-924. The Board may only grant a variance if all required findings under Section 54-924 can be affirmatively made, and if the standards of Sections 54-327 and 54-329 are satisfied. Based on the information provided: 1. The hardship is not unique and appears self-created, 2. Reasonable use of the property is not denied, 3. The requested relief is not the minimum necessary, and 4. The proposal conflicts with the intent and requirements of the Tree Protection Ordinance. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board deny the requested variances and special exceptions and require a revised plan that better complies with the City’s tree protection standards. • Jon Burgess, 2860 Sweetleaf Lane Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 29, 2026 12:50 PM Hello, I am a resident of Whitney Lakes and wanted to share my concerns about the request for tree removal and variances in Agenda Item B3. One of the things that makes this neighborhood so special is the mature tree canopy. These grand trees aren’t just part of the landscape, they provide shade, help with drainage, and contribute to the overall character of our community. It’s difficult to see a plan that would remove several of them and significantly impact others. Especially healthy grade A and B trees. I understand development is part of growth, but it seems like this plan is pushing the limits of the site in a way that comes at the expense of these healthy trees. It feels like there may be opportunities to adjust the layout or reduce density so that more of the existing trees can be preserved. From what I’ve read in the ordinance, these types of variances are meant for situations where there aren’t other reasonable options. I’m not convinced that’s the case here. I respectfully ask the Board to take a close look at whether this request truly meets those standards and to consider requiring a plan that better preserves the trees that make Whitney Lakes such a beautiful place to live. • Anna Messinger, 2928 Sugarberry Lane, Johns Island Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 30, 2026 11:12 AM I respectfully urge the Zoning Board to deny the requested variance to remove protected trees for this development. These trees are not only an essential part of our neighborhood’s natural beauty, but MORE IMPORTANTLY play a critical role in supporting the local ecosystem—providing habitat for wildlife, improving air quality, mitigating stormwater runoff and flooding, and helping reduce urban heat. Granting a variance of this scale sets a concerning precedent that weakens existing protections and prioritizes short-term development over long-term environmental sustainability. Additionally, allowing reduced setbacks for impervious construction near the bases of these trees significantly increases the likelihood that even “retained” mature trees will be damaged or killed over time due to root disturbance, soil compaction, and restricted water infiltration. Our community’s character and environmental health are deeply tied to these mature trees, which cannot be quickly or meaningfully replaced once removed. Thoughtful development and environmental stewardship are not mutually exclusive, and I strongly encourage the Board to require a plan that preserves these protected trees and respects the intent of existing ordinances. Thank you for your consideration. • Zac Viscidi, 59 Cypress St Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 30, 2026 8:07 PM The request to remove 9 grand trees on Rural Johns Island should not be granted without concessions from the developer. Every grand tree removed has an impact, Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | April 1, 2026 Page 4 and the city has been green lighting their removal in far too many instances. Developers who wish to remove these trees ought to be required to make serious contributions to our public spaces and the preservation of our shared green spaces. • Janet Boggs, 2958 Sweetleaf Lane, Johns Island, SC Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 31, 2026 8:32 AM Please do not approve the removal of grand trees. 53.6% Encroachment: They want to pave over half the roots of a healthy Grade B Live Oak (#38). This will ultimately kill the tree. 19 grand Trees may be Impacted: Most are healthy Grade A and B assets that currently handle our island's drainage and heat. The "Density" Choice: The developer is choosing 100 units over tree preservation. A "reasonable design" with slightly fewer units would save these grand trees. B. New Applications 1. 943 Portabella Ln. Bayview Farms | Council District 12 | TMS# 428-14-00-068 | Zoned: DR-6 Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 1 grand tree. Owner: Denis and Liz Chirles Applicant: Jen Proctor, Copper Roof Property Mgmt., LLC No Comments Submitted 2. 404 Tanner Trl. Parrot Point | Council District 12 | TMS# 452-06-00-145 | Zoned: SR-1 Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 2 grand trees. Owner: Andrew & Meredith Kolaski Applicant: Andrew Kolaski No Comments Submitted 3. 35 Stocker Dr. Old Windermere | Council District 11 | TMS# 421-06-00-021 | Zoned: SR-2 Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 1 grand tree. Owner: Michelle & J. Glenn Hammond Applicant: Glenn Hammond No Comments Submitted 4. 1660 Ingram Rd. West Ashley | Council District 9 | TMS# 415-03-00-128 | Zoned: GB Request a variance from Sec 54-347 to allow a reduction in the required 15’ landscape buffer adjacent to Old Towne Rd. Owner: City of Charleston. Applicant: Kimley-Horn No Comments Submitted Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | April 1, 2026 Page 5 5. Forest Acres Cir. Cainhoy | Council District 1 | TMS# 271-00-02-024–026, 069 | Zoned: GP Request a 1-year extension of the Board’s approval to allow the removal of 3 grand trees and a reduced impervious setback near the bases of 5 grand trees on March 6, 2024. Owner: SCT Properties, LLC & TS DI, LLC. Applicant: SeamonWhiteside & Associates No Comments Submitted 6. 1563 Harbor View Rd. James Island | Council District 12 | TMS# 424-10-00-042, 043, 044, 062 Zoned: CT & GO Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 2 grand trees. Owner: The DBA Porter Academy/Porter-Gaud School Applicant: Tom Owenby No Comments Submitted 7. 2051 George Griffith Blvd. James Island | Council District 12 | TMS# 337-00-00-162 | Zoned: PUD Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 3 grand trees. Owner: First Baptist High School Applicant: SeamonWhiteside & Associates No Comments Submitted

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.